Братья Либерманы. Почему ИИ сделает одних сверхбогатыми, а других – нищими? — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Why is it so much harder for today's
- 0:02young people to get rich than it was
- 0:04for their grandparents? What's more
- 0:06valuable: creating an atomic bomb or
- 0:07artificial intelligence? How is it that
- 0:10everyone benefits from human knowledge,
- 0:12while a few companies in the US and
- 0:15China profit from it? And what will we
- 0:18do when robots come to take our jobs?
- 0:21Hello everyone. My name is Dmitry
- 0:22Yakovenko, and this is a special
- 0:24edition of Forbes Highlights. A month
- 0:26ago, we released a video on our channel
- 0:28in which we discussed how corporations
- 0:29and governments stole the internet from
- 0:31us and turned every user into a
- 0:33commodity. If you haven't seen that
- 0:35episode yet, the link is in the
- 0:37description. We asked brothers Daniil
- 0:39and David Libermanov to serve as
- 0:41experts for this episode. You may have
- 0:43seen them in these episodes. They are
- 0:45serial entrepreneurs, originally from
- 0:47Russia, who have been living in Cream
- 0:49Valley for several years. During this
- 0:51time, they have managed to attract
- 0:53investment from Elon Musk, sold their
- 0:56company to Snapchat, launched several
- 0:58startups, and are now trying to spark a
- 1:00revolution. A key characteristic of the
- 1:03Liebermans is that they're not only
- 1:04incredibly interesting to listen to,
- 1:06they also have their own unique
- 1:08perspective on the modern internet
- 1:09economy. We spoke with them for three
- 1:12hours, but only about 30 minutes of
- 1:14that conversation made it into this
- 1:16episode, so we decided to present our
- 1:18conversation as a classic interview.
- 1:20And one last thing. Social media
- 1:22algorithms are merciless, so if you
- 1:24like the content we produce, we kindly
- 1:26ask you to help us a little by liking
- 1:29it, subscribing, and even writing a few
- 1:31sentences explaining your agreement and
- 1:33disagreement. Thank you very much in
- 1:36advance. No other economic sector in
- 1:44the world probably has such a natural
- 1:47tendency toward monopolies. One search
- 1:51engine, one marketplace, one streaming
- 1:53service, two operating systems. Why, in
- 1:55your opinion, is the industry
- 1:56developing in this particular direction
- 1:58?
- 1:58Fifteen years ago, we wrote an essay
- 2:02called "copy." It was about our
- 2:06internal research. It centered on the
- 2:09phenomenon of copied products. A
- 2:11first-generation
- 2:12product is one in which, after the
- 2:16first copy is created, the cost of
- 2:20creating subsequent copies is
- 2:23negligible. So, you could spend
- 2:26100 years thinking about and inventing
- 2:29electricity, but once it's invented,
- 2:31everyone can copy it. It costs a
- 2:33lot of resources to train a model. But
- 2:37even the largest models now take up
- 2:41about 10 TB. That means they can fit on
- 2:45a single flash drive and can be copied
- 2:47billions of times at a very low cost.
- 2:50Everything we're used to thinking about
- 2:54the market, yes,
- 2:55doesn't work. For example, that very
- 2:58famous Supply and Demand graph that you
- 3:00learn in, I don't know, your first
- 3:03economics course, doesn't work for
- 3:05these products. And the very nature of
- 3:08the market, it turns out, is different.
- 3:10Monopolies in this particular area are
- 3:13very difficult to regulate. For example
- 3:17, in the United States, antitrust laws
- 3:19are very clearly formulated. But all
- 3:22these years, a monopoly has been
- 3:25defined by the fact that you can use
- 3:28your market position to raise prices
- 3:32for consumers. And all the tech
- 3:35monopolies have found a loophole in
- 3:37this, saying, "But we're giving away
- 3:39the product for free." How can we be
- 3:42blamed for offering Facebook or
- 3:45Instagram for free,
- 3:48but they're simply making more and more
- 3:50money from each user on advertising, an
- 3:52indirect product. In these products,
- 3:54like a social network, it's convenient
- 3:56that there's only one. Well, because
- 3:58all of our social networks, our social
- 4:02connections, happen in the same space.
- 4:05It's convenient that there's only one
- 4:06AIL. It's convenient that there's only
- 4:08one domain space. It's also interesting
- 4:11that if you look at this in copied
- 4:13products, the greatest value is
- 4:15achieved when everyone uses the copied
- 4:18product. Imagine, for example, that you
- 4:21have the first copy, and the greatest
- 4:24benefit from this value arises if
- 4:27everyone uses this copy, because it's
- 4:29as if there wasn't any before. So, if
- 4:32no one wants to use it, then that
- 4:34single copy is the value. And if
- 4:36everyone wants to use it, then that
- 4:38copy is multiplied by 8 billion people.
- 4:39The
- 4:40only problem is that as soon as someone
- 4:42controls this one thing, they
- 4:43start to use it to their advantage.
- 4:46When I was thinking about the
- 4:48internet's tendency to create
- 4:51monopolies, it seemed to me that a key
- 4:53feature is the absolute externality of
- 4:56business, meaning there are absolutely
- 4:59no costs to operating in different
- 5:01markets. If you take, say, some
- 5:04consumer industries—like clothing,
- 5:07cucumbers, or anything like cars—it's
- 5:11very difficult for an entrepreneur to
- 5:14service the entire globe. Sure, you can
- 5:18be some kind of Indietex and sell
- 5:20clothes everywhere, but it's impossible
- 5:22to completely conquer every continent,
- 5:24every country. The internet itself
- 5:26offers the ability to deliver a service
- 5:29to any computer for a small fee, for
- 5:31servers and the cost of what a person
- 5:33pays to the provider. It's as if this
- 5:36is a natural monopoly. And here I'd
- 5:39like to clarify: when we talk about
- 5:42corporations on a natural, intuitive
- 5:44level, it seems that a monopoly is a
- 5:47bad thing. What are the fundamental
- 5:50economic claims against large monopoly
- 5:54corporations? Monopolies, in fact, on
- 5:57the one hand, in products like these,
- 6:00they, again, oh, they, of course, and
- 6:03they, they're kind of necessary,
- 6:06because, in fact, with those same vomer
- 6:09AI models, if 1,000 companies spend 10
- 6:14billion on training identical models,
- 6:16that's an unnecessary expense, which—
- 6:19we'll all pay for it anyway. And it
- 6:23seems unnecessary, but the problem with
- 6:25monopolies, or even a small number of
- 6:28companies, is that, unfortunately,
- 6:31since their product marginal cost is
- 6:34zero—well, or very close to zero,
- 6:36copies of the next zero—these
- 6:39companies essentially have no
- 6:42incentive to set a low price. They can
- 6:48always set that price as high as
- 6:51possible. There's an example right now,
- 6:54and even an interesting trial that
- 6:56recently took place in Italy. And the
- 6:59successful lawsuit, when consumers sued
- 7:02Netflix, because Netflix, regardless of
- 7:04the fact that over the last 10 years,
- 7:07the number of people using it has only
- 7:10increased. That is, it seems like there
- 7:12are more copies, meaning that the
- 7:15per-user costs should be lower, but
- 7:17instead, every three months or so, they
- 7:20raise the price.
- 7:21Well, every six months, a year, what do
- 7:23you mean, they constantly raise the
- 7:24price, constantly raising it. And
- 7:26what's more, they don't even ask you,
- 7:27they just tell you that the price is
- 7:29now higher, and higher, and higher
- 7:30again. They justify this with inflation
- 7:33, although they are growing much faster
- 7:35than inflation. Well, that is, simply
- 7:37because they can, because it's as if
- 7:39you can no longer leave this platform,
- 7:41so they can. They need to be cheaper
- 7:43for everyone because more people are
- 7:45using it. Or the same thing happened
- 7:47with Facebook when that service was
- 7:49just launching; there were no ads.
- 7:51Moreover, the founder
- 7:54believed that if there were ads, people
- 7:56wouldn't come. That's it. And that's
- 7:59why there were no ads. Then, when they
- 8:01became popular, they added one ad, and
- 8:03everyone was like, "Well, of course,
- 8:05they're great, they created this
- 8:07platform for us, they must be making
- 8:08money." Then we added a second one, and
- 8:11now
- 8:12today we're talking about every fifth
- 8:14post being an ad, so they couldn't stop
- 8:16, right? Well, actually, Google
- 8:19followed the same path. They also had
- 8:22an initial attitude toward advertising,
- 8:23like, "We have a minimalist site, we
- 8:25don't cover everything with banners, we
- 8:27have minimal advertising." And that's
- 8:29also a very interesting question. The
- 8:31business model itself seems fairly fair
- 8:34at first. We give you a free product to
- 8:36the whole world, but we make money from
- 8:38advertising, showing you ads. It's
- 8:40generally logical, but at what point
- 8:43does it become necessary?
- 8:45Look, think about it this way. In fact,
- 8:47the product, search, and advertising
- 8:50are one and the same, because the
- 8:52advertising product is the product of
- 8:55search, from consumers to producers,
- 8:58from producers to consumers. That is,
- 9:00they are searching for each other. And
- 9:01now, from the perspective of raising
- 9:04this price in general, there's one
- 9:06fairly obvious and understandable
- 9:08reason, and it's natural, and there's
- 9:11no escaping it. A corporation exists to
- 9:14make a profit. Make a profit. For whom?
- 9:17To make a profit for shareholders. And
- 9:19the shareholders of all those
- 9:21corporations are retirees.
- 9:22And
- 9:23pension funds. Pension funds. People
- 9:26give them their money so they can have
- 9:29more money in their old age. Everyone
- 9:31invests in corporations, owns 50 to 90%
- 9:34of them, sits on the board of directors
- 9:37, appoints forces, sets goals for the
- 9:40very purpose for which the retirees
- 9:43gave them the money. Half of the people
- 9:45in the United States have put money
- 9:47aside for their retirement. And they've
- 9:50asked that this money be invested
- 9:52effectively to grow capital. There's no
- 9:55flaw in logic here. You just have to
- 9:58see the whole picture. We ourselves ask
- 10:00corporations to increase this price
- 10:02because we ourselves are their owners.
- 10:05But in whose interests is this really
- 10:06working? It works, let's say, in the
- 10:08interests of half the country's
- 10:10population. The other half, the young
- 10:12people who use these social networks.
- 10:14They're not the beneficiaries,
- 10:15because it seems like, well, what
- 10:17difference does it make? You're right,
- 10:18they gave you a free product, and the
- 10:21advertising, well, is hanging around
- 10:23somewhere. But the more expensive this
- 10:26search between the consumer and the
- 10:28buyer, the more expensive the
- 10:29manufacturer's product is for you, the
- 10:31more expensive the products are for you
- 10:33.
- 10:33That is, if this search were cheaper,
- 10:36then ultimately the market would
- 10:37optimize itself so that the clothes you
- 10:40buy, the cars you buy, and so on,
- 10:41everything would be cheaper. If
- 10:43marketing were cheaper, but ultimately,
- 10:46marketing isn't cheaper. It's just that
- 10:49all this, uh, marginality is being
- 10:51taken over by Google. And now Google,
- 10:54ah, $ 400 billion in revenue, and it's
- 10:57already surpassed, it's fifth, I think,
- 11:01or sixth largest company in the world
- 11:04by revenue. Previously, at least this
- 11:06company used these resources to create
- 11:09more and more of these free products
- 11:11for all of us. Google Maps, Google Maps
- 11:14, Gmail, and so on. But you can't. If
- 11:16you look at the last time something
- 11:18like this happened, it was a very, very
- 11:20long time ago. Meanwhile, if you
- 11:22examine the balance sheets of these
- 11:26companies, you'll see that they already
- 11:29hold 200 billion rubles in cash and 100
- 11:31billion in real estate. But what for?
- 11:34Even if you imagine these wonderful
- 11:36companies simply accumulating this
- 11:39resource, investing in scientists and
- 11:41developing humanity, unfortunately,
- 11:44that's no longer the case. The stories
- 11:53of Forbes's heroes demonstrate how
- 11:55international modern business has
- 11:57become. When projects, partners, and
- 11:59opportunities are located in different
- 12:01countries, additional flexibility and
- 12:03the ability to operate in other
- 12:05jurisdictions are becoming increasingly
- 12:07in demand. The rules of the game are
- 12:10changing, sanctions and banking
- 12:11regulations are tightening. Therefore,
- 12:14second citizenship or residency are
- 12:16increasingly viewed today not as a way
- 12:18to move somewhere permanently, but as
- 12:20an additional tool for long-term
- 12:22planning. While Caribbean passports,
- 12:24Cyprus, and Malta's programs were once
- 12:26all the rage, the market has changed
- 12:29significantly. For citizens of Russia
- 12:31and Belarus, the window of opportunity
- 12:33has narrowed significantly, but options
- 12:35remain. For example, Santa Cruz
- 12:37citizenship can, in principle, be
- 12:39obtained with an investment of at least
- 12:41$ 90,000, and Vnuka citizenship with an
- 12:43investment of at least $ 130,000. A
- 12:45less exotic option is Turkey. Here,
- 12:48citizenship is available through the
- 12:49purchase of real estate starting at $
- 12:51400,000. Golden visa programs also
- 12:54exist, but they are not as numerous.
- 12:56For example, Cyprus offers citizenship
- 12:57with a real estate purchase starting at
- 12:59€ 300,000, while Greece requires
- 13:01purchasing an apartment, house, or flat
- 13:03starting at € 250,000. Participation
- 13:06in the program is only possible with
- 13:08dual citizenship, but, as you've
- 13:09already understood, this is not
- 13:11impossible. Nevertheless, Greece
- 13:13remains one of the most flexible
- 13:14options in Europe. With a residence
- 13:17permit, you'll be able to travel
- 13:18visa-free throughout the Schengen area.
- 13:21The key is that none of the listed
- 13:23programs require permanent residence in
- 13:25the country. You won't have to
- 13:26radically change your lifestyle. These
- 13:28are simply additional opportunities for
- 13:30running a business and generally
- 13:31planning for the future. It sounds
- 13:33simple, but investment immigration
- 13:35isn't just about choosing a country.
- 13:38The legal structure of the transaction,
- 13:40verification of the origin of funds,
- 13:42and compliance procedures are all
- 13:44important. Such tasks should be
- 13:46entrusted to a company with serious
- 13:49legal expertise and real-world cases.
- 13:52Asns has been supporting clients
- 13:54worldwide for over 35 years. Learn more
- 13:57about the available second citizenship
- 13:59and residence permit programs by
- 14:00following the link in the description.
- 14:08So, for retirees, everything is
- 14:09wonderful. In reality, the current
- 14:11world, with the exception of the fact
- 14:13that it's
- 14:13divided not between rich and poor, but
- 14:16between young and old. The economy is
- 14:18being torn apart. Wealth and poverty
- 14:20actually lie in the divide between the
- 14:23young and old. And it's not so much
- 14:25about age. When you and I are old,
- 14:28we'll be poorer. So, in any crisis, say
- 14:30, in the American one, the government
- 14:33primarily seeks to protect the savings
- 14:36of retirees. Simply because they are
- 14:38the voting majority and the economic
- 14:40majority. And on the one hand, the
- 14:43internet and the technological
- 14:45breakthrough have created such an
- 14:47opportunity for young people—the
- 14:50industry is primarily filled with young
- 14:52people, but the end result still went
- 14:55to pension funds, because all the
- 14:57evening funds are mostly money from
- 15:00pension funds or endowments of
- 15:02universities. This, among other things,
- 15:04is why there's such a huge interest in
- 15:06cryptocurrencies, because they seem to
- 15:08be outside the scope of that regulation
- 15:10, outside the scope of that interest,
- 15:12and so on. Now it's not like that
- 15:15anymore, now it's like all pension
- 15:17funds, BlackRock is buying Bitcoin,
- 15:19everything is kind of mixed up with
- 15:22each other in the market, but young
- 15:24people had the right idea that maybe we
- 15:27can win from this now.
- 15:28Blockchain technology. It has a
- 15:30completely non-commercial idea behind
- 15:33it—ah, removing barriers, simplifying
- 15:35transactions between people, increasing
- 15:38security and transparency. From the
- 15:41outside, it looks like, firstly, a huge
- 15:43speculative market, and secondly, well,
- 15:46not just speculative, it's not entirely
- 15:48clear why it exists.
- 15:50If you think about it, if it's
- 15:52speculation, speculation, the entire
- 15:53market is in some sense speculation,
- 15:55it's
- 15:55important to compare apples to apples.
- 15:59For example, let's take
- 16:00cryptocurrencies and try to figure out
- 16:03whether they're excessively expensive
- 16:05or not. Speculation means they must be
- 16:07excessively expensive. But you take any
- 16:10currency in the world, take the Israeli
- 16:13shekel, the Australian dollar, the
- 16:16British pound, take the country's money
- 16:19supply and divide it by the number of
- 16:21users, namely, by the number of people
- 16:24in the country, and you get almost the
- 16:27same figure. What do you mean per
- 16:30person in dollar terms? If you compare
- 16:32countries with a high standard of
- 16:35living to one currency,
- 16:37you take all the currencies, convert
- 16:38them to dollars, and divide by the
- 16:39population.
- 16:40You divide it by the population of this
- 16:42country, which is almost the same
- 16:45amount per person, and then you take
- 16:47Bitcoin, you take Ereum, you take their
- 16:50, uh, active users,
- 16:52yes, for example, the monthly number of
- 16:54wallets, and you get almost the same
- 16:56figure, the same thing
- 16:57there. What does
- 16:58this mean now? It means it's the same
- 17:00currency mechanism. It's just a
- 17:02different currency. So if you call this
- 17:05speculation, then you call the dollar,
- 17:07the pound sterling, and so on
- 17:08speculation. Or you just call it all
- 17:10currency. And that's how much currency
- 17:12is worth. It's
- 17:12just that this currency is controlled
- 17:14by the federalized United States, and
- 17:16this currency is controlled by
- 17:17protocols. It's the same thing. If AI
- 17:19bubbles, we look at the companies that
- 17:22are currently the most, uh, getting, uh
- 17:25, a higher valuation because they're
- 17:28related to AI, you look at their profit
- 17:32multiple,
- 17:33and then you look at Walmart. It's a
- 17:36big store, a chain of stores.
- 17:39And it has the same multiple. Look at
- 17:41Coca-Cola, for example; it has the same
- 17:43multiple. The entire market
- 17:45is high in terms of multiples. But
- 17:48Google's multiple is no higher than
- 17:50Walmart's.
- 17:51And then there's the demand for a large
- 17:54amount of capital accumulated by
- 17:56pension funds and others. Pension fund
- 17:58accumulation in the US is roughly equal
- 18:00to all other savings. That is, all
- 18:02these ultra-rich people, all put
- 18:04together. All these savings are equal
- 18:06to pension savings.
- 18:08Pension accumulation is larger.
- 18:09Larger. Well, I'm ready to say that a
- 18:10comparable thing is that pension
- 18:11accumulation is larger than all the
- 18:13other accumulations. Few, few people
- 18:14understand that
- 18:15this mythical 1%who own everything
- 18:18can't own everything, because retirees
- 18:20have more money than everyone else.
- 18:23Therefore, this is a false perception
- 18:25of reality. When we look at the reason
- 18:28why stocks are expensive or, say,
- 18:30currencies are expensive, we need to
- 18:33look at the economic reason. This
- 18:35bubble occurs because so much capital
- 18:38needs to be transferred into the future
- 18:41with a return. What reason could one
- 18:44stranger have to give another stranger
- 18:49money, a
- 18:50percentage that is, to get more? And
- 18:53all modern thinking about economics and
- 18:55the market is based on the idea that
- 18:58it's almost a
- 18:59cliché that everything is built on the
- 19:01rate of return, right?
- 19:02This is the basic understanding of
- 19:06human interaction in economics. But it
- 19:09turns out there's another reason,
- 19:13namely, your labor, which is perishable
- 19:16,
- 19:16like milk.
- 19:17You worked today, didn't
- 19:20earn enough,
- 19:21didn't earn enough, and at the same
- 19:23time, you have an old age in which you
- 19:26need to somehow live. You won't be able
- 19:29to work there. Therefore, you, a young
- 19:32person, need to somehow
- 19:34freeze your labor,
- 19:36transfer it into the future. You give
- 19:39part of it to someone so that they earn
- 19:41more, so that you can return more to
- 19:43you in the future. This is what this
- 19:46effective transfer is. Accordingly, it
- 19:48turns out there is another reason to
- 19:50give money to another person.
- 19:52You simply need to do it. You can't
- 19:54avoid
- 19:55getting more right now, or even
- 19:57transferring it into the future, even
- 20:00if it's less. Because if you simply put
- 20:03money in an account or bury it in a
- 20:06suitcase, it will lose value. And if
- 20:09you want to get at least the same
- 20:11amount back, you have to find someone
- 20:13who will use it effectively and return
- 20:14the same amount in the future. What's
- 20:16happening with cryptocurrencies, for
- 20:19example? You have this idea that while
- 20:23there may be few people today who want
- 20:27independence from the SDO banks, there
- 20:31will be many of them, and that every
- 20:34crisis, every upheaval, the
- 20:37new COVID-19, and the printing of money
- 20:39will lead to greater and greater
- 20:40rejection of fiat currency and a shift
- 20:44to something that can't be reissued.
- 20:47This is the hypothesis that the creator
- 20:50of this currency, Satoshi, had. He
- 20:52created this protocol, and it turns out
- 20:55that it's working so far, and more and
- 20:57more people are choosing to use this
- 21:00tool to transfer their capital into the
- 21:02future without, well, printing more
- 21:05money. So, this was the main hypothesis
- 21:07that was initially laid down: that
- 21:09because it's finite, it doesn't devalue
- 21:12. And this was the idea that there
- 21:14would be more of these people. If there
- 21:17are more of them, if people who consume
- 21:20it buy more of it, then its price rises
- 21:22, since its supply is limited. It's the
- 21:24same, you know, with all currencies. So
- 21:26, the more users there are, the more
- 21:29monetary value is cut.
- 21:32For you, as a Bitcoin consumer who
- 21:34consumes it as a currency, it doesn't
- 21:36matter whether it costs $ 60 or $
- 21:38120,000, $ 160,000 or $ 120,000. It
- 21:40doesn't matter if you bought $ 100
- 21:42worth of it and paid $ 100 worth of it
- 21:44today. And if the price hasn't moved
- 21:47much during this period, then you got
- 21:49what you wanted—transaction currency.
- 21:51Out you go.
- 21:52But if someone expects more people,
- 21:54that's the idea. It's not a question of
- 21:58some person like Satoshi or someone
- 22:00doing something to make Bitcoin develop
- 22:03. No, you just have an idea. More
- 22:05people will want it,
- 22:07consume it. But more people will think
- 22:10the Central Bank is engaging in
- 22:13so-called tifzing and has printed 9
- 22:16trillion. That's a bit much and will
- 22:19end badly. Why did Bitcoin work?
- 22:21Because Bitcoin was based precisely on
- 22:24a big idea, an ideological one, not a
- 22:28belief that more people would want
- 22:31something,
- 22:32desire something, want to be outside
- 22:35the regulated state mechanism. But the
- 22:39state began to misuse this mechanism,
- 22:42using it for its own political ends.
- 22:46The same thing is
- 22:46happening now with artificial
- 22:49intelligence. That is, if you look at
- 22:52artificial intelligence today, on the
- 22:54one hand, something remarkable is
- 22:55happening. We all now have GPT or
- 22:58Claude chat, or we all use these
- 23:00artificial intelligences. They're
- 23:03incredibly smart, they answer many of
- 23:06our questions, they
- 23:08speak all languages,
- 23:09but the longer it goes, the more people
- 23:13will notice, uh, several problems with
- 23:16this. One problem already exists in the
- 23:18mainstream. What if these little clocks
- 23:22start replacing us all at work? And
- 23:25what are we supposed to do then?
- 23:27Robots will come along with them, and
- 23:29it's like, oh,
- 23:29and this idea becomes many times more
- 23:33complicated if you imagine it. If you
- 23:36have this chat, you're kind of
- 23:38superhuman, you can do more than you
- 23:40could a year ago, but that's only if
- 23:43you have access. But what if at some
- 23:45point your
- 23:45access is taken away, and you have to
- 23:48compete with everyone else who has it?
- 23:51It's the same thing
- 23:52that happens with social media, so to
- 23:55speak, because you're effectively cut
- 23:57off from the economy and you might not
- 23:59even exist if you're not on this
- 24:01platform. It's exactly the same logic.
- 24:03And you can be disconnected, blocked,
- 24:06and so on for various reasons. So, we
- 24:08see how
- 24:09people get blocked on Twitter. For a
- 24:11while, before Elon got scared and
- 24:13bought something to avoid being blocked
- 24:15there.
- 24:15And recently, yes, he just assessed
- 24:18that the risk of being removed from the
- 24:20platform is worth $ 40 billion. Many
- 24:23people just think, why would Elon buy
- 24:25it? He's some billionaire, buying media
- 24:28and this and that. Well, in fact, if
- 24:31you think about it, for Elon, it was a
- 24:33mechanism for
- 24:34communicating with his entire audience,
- 24:37with all his customers, with all his
- 24:40stockholders. So the Wall Street short
- 24:45market couldn't overcome him. And then
- 24:49they tell him, "The president just got
- 24:51disconnected from there, which means
- 24:53you'll get disconnected too for your
- 24:55next bad word." And he's like, "Is this
- 24:57worth $ 40 billion?" Especially knowing
- 24:59that it's not really that I lost those
- 25:0240 billion. I paid for the business,
- 25:04and I still have it. I can sell it
- 25:05later if necessary. And actually, it
- 25:08could even be profitable. I assessed
- 25:10the risks and decided to buy. Now
- 25:11imagine what it means for all of
- 25:13humanity if, at some point, these ten
- 25:16corporations—the five American and
- 25:18five Chinese corporations—begin to
- 25:21realize it's more profitable for them
- 25:23to stop giving you access to AI
- 25:26and simply start selling it directly to
- 25:29factory owners, like, er, taxi
- 25:32companies. Recently, Atropic, the
- 25:35company that produces Claude, released
- 25:38—well, not released—announced that
- 25:41they'd created a new, even more
- 25:44powerful model, but immediately said
- 25:47that access would only be restricted to
- 25:50select companies.
- 25:51Yeah.
- 25:52Yeah, there's a message about security.
- 25:57But in reality, how many steps are
- 25:59there before it becomes a matter of
- 26:02economic security for the company and
- 26:05its clients? There's no limit, not a
- 26:08single law that sets a limit. And
- 26:09what's more, it's in their commercial
- 26:11interests. Recently, the founder of
- 26:14this company, in an interview with
- 26:18aa Darkash, a well-known podcaster from
- 26:23Silicon Valley. And then I asked you
- 26:26about their business models. Is their
- 26:29business model valid? Will it remain
- 26:31that they sell
- 26:33API access tokens to other app makers?
- 26:38And where do they pay for the so-called
- 26:41AI tokens? User usage
- 26:42is a measure of AI usage. He said, "I
- 26:44think this model will remain,
- 26:46blah-blah-blah-blah-blah." And then he
- 26:48said, "But on the other hand, not all
- 26:51tokens are equally valuable." For
- 26:54example, if someone can help you fix
- 26:57your MacBook, it might not be so
- 26:59valuable. What if
- 27:02someone can cure themselves of cancer?
- 27:05Are such tokens worth more?
- 27:07And would
- 27:08people be willing to pay more for them?
- 27:10It's
- 27:10terrible. Well, you shouldn't even say
- 27:12such a thing, but
- 27:13he even laughs in this interview. So,
- 27:17he's laughing hysterically about this,
- 27:18because he himself understands that
- 27:20somewhere there is a line of
- 27:21unacceptability, of indecency, but he's
- 27:23already thinking about it and
- 27:24understands that this is where it's
- 27:26heading. This is what he's most likely
- 27:28selling to investors. But, but, but
- 27:31what does this mean? If today AI is the
- 27:33same as the internet, or even the same
- 27:36as electricity, then it roughly means
- 27:38something like this. The electricity
- 27:40that powers your light bulb costs the
- 27:42same as the electricity that powers the
- 27:45life support machine when you have
- 27:47open-heart surgery. Open-heart surgery
- 27:50is much more important to you. You pay
- 27:521,000 times more for those kilowatts
- 27:53than for the kilowatts you consume when
- 27:55you simply light your house. It
- 27:57sounds absurd. No,
- 27:58it doesn't sound absurd. It sounds like
- 28:01a world we don't want to live in. But
- 28:05that means we're not talking about it
- 28:07enough, you know? That's precisely the
- 28:09difficulty. And then there's
- 28:11electricity. Electricity wasn't
- 28:13perceived by anyone as something, well,
- 28:14something that love could produce. But
- 28:16imagine if it were also considered a
- 28:19matter of national security, as it is
- 28:22now.
- 28:22And everyone would be banned from
- 28:24using this electricity. What would the
- 28:27world be like today if the United
- 28:29States of America said, "You know what,
- 28:31no? Electricity is just for us." Or,
- 28:33well, 90%of the electricity is for us,
- 28:35and we'll give you the other 10%, and
- 28:37then you can consume it as you please.
- 28:39This is also a
- 28:40stunning dystopia. I don't even know if
- 28:43anyone has ever done anything like this
- 28:45. All the power plants are in one
- 28:48country, and it sells it wherever it
- 28:50wants.
- 28:52The GPUs needed for AI computing were
- 28:54built in such a way that all this
- 28:57computing power, 90%of computing power
- 29:00is now in the United States. Next will
- 29:03be China, which will also be doing this
- 29:05computing. They're almost catching up.
- 29:08It's still quite a ways off, but
- 29:10they'll catch up. It's obvious they'll
- 29:12catch up, that China will give it all
- 29:13away, or something. No, it's the same
- 29:15thing. And this creates a false
- 29:17impression, because China made its
- 29:20models open source to catch up. That's
- 29:23a common strategy. That's a non-profit
- 29:24strategy. You make yourself open source
- 29:26to catch up. But what people don't
- 29:30understand is that as soon as they
- 29:31catch up, they stop being open source.
- 29:34You create a model, you make
- 29:34it open source. Developers all over the
- 29:36world use it. When they use it, they
- 29:39train it automatically. It becomes,
- 29:42well, not exactly. Not exactly. It's a
- 29:44small percentage there. That's because
- 29:46the training actually happens
- 29:47beforehand.
- 29:48But people build an ecosystem, you
- 29:50understand? This ecosystem is very
- 29:51important,
- 29:52they show you how to use it, yes, the
- 29:53methods,
- 29:54because all your agents are configured
- 29:55for this model. Since all the models
- 29:57are slightly different, you fine-tune
- 30:01them to fit it, and you build your
- 30:02product.
- 30:02Basically, you make it part of a global
- 30:05infrastructure, and then you simply
- 30:07shut it down. And
- 30:09once it becomes so powerful that it
- 30:11controls a robot that replaces humans,
- 30:13why would the Chinese sell it to anyone
- 30:16? They'll lose the market. The cost of
- 30:18labor will drop to the price of the
- 30:20robot, which will then drop to the cost
- 30:22of the materials and the artificial
- 30:23intelligence it contains, the
- 30:25computations it contains. And if that's
- 30:27the case, then there's no genius in
- 30:29Chinese manufacturing, because all the
- 30:31knowledge about how to produce anything
- 30:32, very cheaply and quickly, is
- 30:34available to everyone all over the
- 30:36world.
- 30:36Therefore, the Chinese will also shut
- 30:38down their models, and the Americans
- 30:39will shut down theirs. Right now, what
- 30:41we're discussing is understood by a few
- 30:44thousand people. When Fzhe wrote, there
- 30:46were a handful of people who believed
- 30:48in the same idea. And ultimately, it
- 30:50blossomed into a community of tens, if
- 30:52not hundreds of millions of people who
- 30:54use Bitcoin today. All of us sitting
- 30:56here listening to this podcast are
- 30:58gradually beginning to understand that
- 31:00something's wrong with AI, that
- 31:02somewhere down the line, we're all
- 31:04being screwed. But then, if you imagine
- 31:06that
- 31:07in 10 years there will be hundreds of
- 31:10millions of people who realize this,
- 31:13and that all these hundreds of millions
- 31:15will be looking for an alternative, one
- 31:18where their access won't be taken away,
- 31:20or where their
- 31:21jobs won't be taken away,
- 31:22and where there will be an
- 31:24ever-increasing number of them, and
- 31:27their productivity will increase due to
- 31:30the fact that they will constantly be
- 31:33using more and more new tools in their
- 31:36work, we saw at some point that, on the
- 31:38one hand, you're slightly opposing
- 31:41yourself, just like Satoshi also
- 31:43opposed himself to central banks—they
- 31:46seem incredibly gigantic, like, well,
- 31:49entities that it's impossible to even
- 31:53imagine that you could resist.
- 31:55Funny. Like, well, his point was that,
- 31:58well, billions of people won't agree
- 32:01with this. Since billions of people
- 32:03won't agree, since currency and values
- 32:05are determined by how many people
- 32:07participate in them,
- 32:08then it will ultimately work. We're at
- 32:11a similar point in AI right now. Large
- 32:15AI corporations seem completely
- 32:18inaccessible.
- 32:20As you can imagine, they invest tens of
- 32:23billions of dollars every year in
- 32:25building data centers and purchasing
- 32:28chips.
- 32:28Hundreds of billions already.
- 32:29Hundreds of billions. Even now,
- 32:31everyone has started looking at graphs
- 32:35of how the costs of AI computing
- 32:38infrastructure compare with the Apollo
- 32:42program, and they're actually
- 32:44comparable, even in terms of the
- 32:47percentage of GDP spent on these
- 32:51projects. This mega-project is underway
- 32:54, but this mega-project, as it's
- 32:57currently unfolding, certainly won't
- 33:01provide equal access to everyone. On
- 33:05the contrary, we're already seeing the
- 33:08first steps toward exclusive access for
- 33:11certain groups of companies or certain
- 33:14groups of people. This is where the
- 33:16important question lies, precisely in
- 33:18the numerical order. That is, there are
- 33:21billions of people who disagree, but
- 33:24then, let's go to Bitcoin. Well, it's
- 33:27not billions of people, it's a large
- 33:29number of people who, uh, are
- 33:31enthusiastically engaged in this. It's
- 33:33a matter of geopolitical confrontation.
- 33:36And by and large, it seems like for
- 33:39most people it doesn't really matter
- 33:42what platform they're working on.
- 33:45Moreover, as far as I understand, the
- 33:48point of this huge Chinese miracle, IT,
- 33:51is that the Chinese population—
- 33:53however many people live there—is
- 33:56generally quite accepting of the fact
- 33:58that we have states, some
- 34:00quasi-corporations that own production,
- 34:03that own our data, and that manage us
- 34:06using algorithms. They build smart
- 34:08cities, offer us super-cool platforms
- 34:11on which we can do everything. But it's
- 34:13super-convenient. And I have a feeling
- 34:15that the rest of the world wouldn't
- 34:19mind.
- 34:19It only appears that way on the surface
- 34:21. Well, if we dig into what's happening
- 34:24in China, underneath the public surface
- 34:29, things are actually much worse. We
- 34:30don't even need to argue with that,
- 34:33because you're right that from
- 34:35Bitcoin's perspective, ah, since there
- 34:38are many central banks, many countries,
- 34:40and each country has its own central
- 34:43bank, otherwise, ah, well, most people
- 34:45will say, "Well, okay, in Europe we
- 34:48live with the euro, we live in
- 34:50Australia with the dollar, and so on."
- 34:53There are many different alternatives.
- 34:54And so, Bitcoin has ultimately
- 34:57accumulated around 50 million active
- 34:59users. And now they are 50 million
- 35:03countries worth a trillion dollars.
- 35:06And not China, not the US in terms of
- 35:10population.
- 35:11Well, like England, France, Germany,
- 35:14with AI,
- 35:15things will be much worse, because
- 35:17you're right. If we're talking about
- 35:19the topic we're discussing before the
- 35:21United States, most people, most of our
- 35:23interlocutors, say, "Well, we're doing
- 35:26fine." So, they'll have a UBI, they'll
- 35:28collect all the value from around the
- 35:30world and distribute it to some segment
- 35:33of the local population.
- 35:35A person gets into a car, and it's a
- 35:38self-driving car. The car drives, and
- 35:40he doesn't get into an accident. He
- 35:42essentially doesn't care how it's
- 35:44powered, what algorithm it uses, or who
- 35:47owns the model it runs on.
- 35:49But, but, but if you're part of the
- 35:52group that benefits from this, you'll,
- 35:55of course, feel more or less okay. But
- 35:59if we even imagine these two groups,
- 36:01the
- 36:01United States and China, and imagine
- 36:03that China also gathers a lot of the
- 36:06world's wealth through developing its
- 36:08AI and also distributes a little to its
- 36:10population, especially so that the
- 36:12population doesn't rise up against them
- 36:14,
- 36:14then the rest of the world—the
- 36:16remaining 6 billion people—will feel
- 36:18—well,
- 36:19maybe not so comfortable.
- 36:20Well, they need to choose where they
- 36:24won't benefit from this, you understand
- 36:26? That is, they will be the ones
- 36:29collecting the resources, while those
- 36:32paying for them will be the ones.
- 36:33This feeling is growing in almost every
- 36:36country in the world, except for the
- 36:38United States and China. Over the past
- 36:41year, we've met with ministers from
- 36:43many countries with varying levels of
- 36:45GDP per capita. And while just a year
- 36:49and a half ago, and usually the
- 36:52ministries of these countries, said, "
- 36:55We're doing our own thing, we'll
- 36:59buy our own chip, we'll do everything
- 37:01ourselves,"
- 37:02now they've realized that no, they're
- 37:04completely behind, and it's impossible
- 37:07to compete with these two fathers on
- 37:09their own. It's impossible to even
- 37:12imagine anything similar to these two
- 37:14policies.
- 37:16And what we're seeing is that almost
- 37:21all of them are now looking for an
- 37:25alternative and are turning toward
- 37:28declaring something more non-commercial
- 37:32. They're determined to
- 37:35cooperate with one of these two—the
- 37:37Poles, the Chinese, or the Americans—
- 37:39simply because they have no alternative
- 37:41. And that's why they're looking for an
- 37:44alternative, inviting us and
- 37:45communicating with us. It's precisely
- 37:48because it's obvious to everyone that
- 37:51an alternative is necessary.
- 37:54This allows for the same thing we
- 37:56discussed with monopolies at the
- 37:58beginning: that when you have a
- 38:00monopoly, you can raise your price
- 38:03to whatever you're
- 38:04willing to pay. Ah, just recently, the
- 38:06company Trobico and its product Clot
- 38:09had a conflict with the OpenC community
- 38:12.
- 38:13Yeah. The
- 38:13OpenC community built—if anyone
- 38:16doesn't know—it's currently the most
- 38:18popular system for agents. It's open
- 38:21source, it's not. People got together
- 38:25and built a product that's better than
- 38:27what all the leading AI labs have built
- 38:30. And then the company Ant Troopic
- 38:33released a new update and banned its
- 38:37use.
- 38:37Well, yes, if you're supposedly an open
- 38:40system, but you're working on a closed,
- 38:42corporate model, then it tends to close
- 38:45pretty quickly.
- 38:46Well, in this regard, all other markets
- 38:48have regulations prohibiting such
- 38:50actions. Because that's precisely one
- 38:53of the reasons people don't like
- 38:55monopolies: one is that they raise
- 38:58prices, and the other is that they
- 39:00start pushing their other products on
- 39:03others, crowding out the competition,
- 39:05and offering bundles. Microsoft was
- 39:09ultimately sued in an antitrust case
- 39:13because they said, "If you install
- 39:16our system, our system, it must have
- 39:18our browser, it must have all our
- 39:22products, and you can't pre-install
- 39:24anything else, otherwise we'll simply
- 39:26forbid you from selling our model."
- 39:28Yeah. And that's the logic that's
- 39:29working with both [and][them]. Well,
- 39:31now it turns out that if you want to
- 39:33use agents, you can't use OpenClone.
- 39:36Use our agent, our genetic system.
- 39:39But if you want to use our model,
- 39:41this will inevitably lead to the fact
- 39:45that, since the goal of any company is
- 39:49to make the greatest profit,
- 39:51Yeah, then
- 39:52all competition will ultimately be
- 39:54pushed out.
- 39:55That's it. And I'm simply using the
- 39:56Microsoft example as a starting point.
- 39:58It's clear that Open AI has everything
- 40:00covered by patents, it's all licensed.
- 40:03The law allows it to charge whatever it
- 40:05wants for it, because it belongs to it.
- 40:07Are there legal mechanisms, like in the
- 40:10case of Microsoft, that prevent the
- 40:13owners of these language models from
- 40:16preventing use? It's a difficult answer
- 40:18. But the state can, yes, the
- 40:21prosecutor's office, the state, the
- 40:24consumer protection agency, and so on,
- 40:27find something in this that isn't in
- 40:30the interests of consumers as a whole
- 40:33and sue and deal with it, and so on.
- 40:36All these models are trained on data
- 40:39obtained from all public data from
- 40:42around the world. For example, they use
- 40:46all the books ever published, both past
- 40:49ones, which are now considered a public
- 40:52good, and current ones, which everyone
- 40:56actually pays for. And there are
- 40:58authors of these books. Oh, and it was
- 41:00precisely for this part of the authors
- 41:03'books that they paid a fine. The
- 41:06United States sued them, and they paid
- 41:08a $ 4 billion fine. But if you think
- 41:11about it, it turns out they paid $ 4
- 41:14billion for some billions of books,
- 41:16some hundreds of millions or billions
- 41:18of consumers of these books. That is,
- 41:21they paid some meager cents per person,
- 41:24per book. When one of the creators of
- 41:28one of the major models complained
- 41:30about how Chinese model manufacturers
- 41:33were stealing their intellectual
- 41:36property by training their models on
- 41:39their models. And someone wrote a funny
- 41:42post about this, and I'll analyze the
- 41:45statistics: apparently, Harry Potter
- 41:48was written by this model because it
- 41:51can replicate it with 95%accuracy.
- 41:54And why can it replicate it? Because it
- 41:56used it for training. It's clear that a
- 41:57social contract is needed. It's clear
- 41:59that we all need artificial
- 42:01intelligence. It's clear that
- 42:03artificial intelligence greatly
- 42:05advances us. It's clear that it was
- 42:07truly only possible thanks to the
- 42:09contributions of
- 42:10all these
- 42:11very large numbers of people.
- 42:13If you ask us, we're looking far ahead.
- 42:20This question: is it possible to
- 42:22achieve absolute abundance through AI,
- 42:25and if so, and, in a sense, Open itself
- 42:28—this group, they also gathered there
- 42:30, with the same idea: there is an
- 42:33opportunity to create HI. The means
- 42:36would be good to reach this point: to
- 42:39create shared prosperity for all of
- 42:41humanity, this state of complete
- 42:44abundance, in which robots, not humans,
- 42:47toil, and everyone gets exactly as much
- 42:50as they need and are possible with
- 42:52current resources, so to speak. There's
- 42:55this strange, incredible utopian future
- 42:57, the possibility of achieving it. We
- 43:00can all invest in it together: not wait
- 43:03for corporations to invest in it, for
- 43:05the government to invest in it and use
- 43:08it to their advantage, but all together
- 43:11, invest in a common structure, allow
- 43:13all data to be used on the maximum
- 43:16amount of data, train the best model,
- 43:18make it publicly available to everyone,
- 43:21build a public infrastructure. So, how
- 43:24do you train a model to create a public
- 43:25open source top-tier, but how do you
- 43:27create the infrastructure and even the
- 43:29physical servers in a data center?
- 43:30That's a different question. This layer
- 43:32, in a sense, solved Bitcoin, because
- 43:35Bitcoin, in its technical
- 43:38representation, in its technical
- 43:41incarnation, is a huge distributed data
- 43:44center. The same network can be thought
- 43:47of as hardware that performs
- 43:48calculations and makes them publicly
- 43:54available, distributed, and unblocked.
- 43:59Yes, you have to pay for this, because
- 44:00someone installed this thing. And this
- 44:03creates a market, within which everyone
- 44:06who spent the effort and money to
- 44:08install these servers around the world
- 44:11starts making money. But the protocol
- 44:14works in such a way that the cost of
- 44:16the operation gets cheaper and cheaper.
- 44:19Do
- 44:19you have any kind of relationship with
- 44:21your Chinese comrades in the context of
- 44:23the race, or are they completely closed
- 44:26off?
- 44:26Look, there are a lot of problems with
- 44:27China. Well, we know little about China
- 44:29. We try to go there, try to understand
- 44:32what's going on there. But the problem
- 44:34with China is that there's a huge
- 44:35firewall there. For a long time,
- 44:38blockchains as such were banned. So,
- 44:40for us, China is kind of out of the
- 44:41question. In our current protocol,
- 44:43which we've just created. Many Chinese
- 44:46were there at the beginning of Bitcoin.
- 44:49Many Chinese are still involved in
- 44:51Bitcoin, but outside of China. Many of
- 44:52them are now participating in the race.
- 44:55In one way or another,
- 44:56similar effects are occurring among the
- 44:58Russian-speaking population. Everyone
- 45:00who usually leaves their countries
- 45:03because they see obstacles, and they
- 45:06become even more involved in building
- 45:10systems that would liberate people,
- 45:13make them free. That's why there are a
- 45:16lot of Russian-speaking and Chinese
- 45:18people in blockchain. Among Bitcoin
- 45:22miners, there are many, uh, very strong
- 45:26entrepreneurs from China who created
- 45:29chips for, uh, crypto networks.
- 45:33And here's the thing: right now, for
- 45:36example, the main center, the point of
- 45:39control, of artificial intelligence
- 45:43development is precisely in the
- 45:45computing infrastructure. And almost
- 45:49all of this infrastructure is
- 45:51controlled by a single company, NVIDIA.
- 45:55It also played a very significant role
- 45:59in Bitcoin in 2013. Until three years
- 46:03ago, say, around 2013,
- 46:06NVIDIA GPUs dominated Bitcoin mining,
- 46:11whether it was from AMD or AMD. And
- 46:15then, ah,
- 46:17specialized chips arrived in 2013-2014.
- 46:20And to this day, NVIDIA is no longer
- 46:23there.
- 46:24And at first, Eastern Europeans also
- 46:27played a significant role, and then
- 46:31Chinese entrepreneurs became
- 46:33increasingly important. And now we
- 46:37think that
- 46:38more or less the same AI can be
- 46:39achieved. But these are chips,
- 46:42accordingly, created outside the
- 46:45corporate structure specifically for
- 46:47Bitcoin, not NVIDIA.
- 46:49Some of these people had never created
- 46:51a chip before. It was simply a very
- 46:53strong engineering thought on the part
- 46:56of some whiz kids who saw an
- 46:58opportunity—let's call them
- 47:00enthusiasts, let's call them that—who
- 47:03solved a super-complex engineering
- 47:06problem
- 47:07better than the company that makes
- 47:10money solving it. And they solved it so
- 47:13well that over the 16 years of
- 47:15Bitcoin's existence, the computational
- 47:18efficiency of this protocol and chips
- 47:21has increased 300,000-fold. That
- 47:24is, these calculations are performed so
- 47:29incomparably, insanely efficiently. And
- 47:32all this is mainly thanks to the
- 47:34mechanics of this open market, in which
- 47:37anyone can participate. Oh, and it's
- 47:40direct money right away. Participation
- 47:41equals money. You earn money right away
- 47:44. And this system eventually grows to a
- 47:47size where it begins to form
- 47:49infrastructure, where tens of millions
- 47:52of people are already using it as a
- 47:55currency. And this is not going away.
- 47:58Here, perhaps, in our understanding,
- 48:00the same thing is true. AI isn't going
- 48:02anywhere. We'll only use it more.
- 48:05Much more.
- 48:06So much so that we can barely imagine
- 48:07it. It's just that every light bulb
- 48:09will eventually contain AI, just like
- 48:11electricity. Simply because the result
- 48:15is fundamentally more productive. Yes,
- 48:20this is truly a new stage of
- 48:22dramatically increasing the
- 48:24productivity of each person. If we look
- 48:26at it through the prism of corporations
- 48:28taking away our freedom, we'll lose
- 48:30everything, then our productivity will
- 48:32be zero, it's as if the market doesn't
- 48:33need us at all. But if we look at it
- 48:36from the other side, if it's all public
- 48:38—yes, roads, electricity, the
- 48:40internet—everyone can have access to
- 48:42it, then the productivity of each of us
- 48:45will increase, say, fourfold.
- 48:47And then we'll interact in a new market
- 48:49, in which together we can produce four
- 48:51times as many services, four times as
- 48:53much of everything. We'll simply become
- 48:56four times richer, just as we once did
- 48:59with industrialization. Now we're
- 49:01seeing the next transition from working
- 49:04in offices and companies to working
- 49:07through AI systems. Somewhere around
- 49:102015 or 2016, I, ah, had just started
- 49:13studying blockchain, and I happened to
- 49:16attend a lecture by some philosophy
- 49:18professor who put forward this theory
- 49:21that with the advent of blockchain as a
- 49:24technology, as a philosophy, the need
- 49:27for fiat currencies, which define a
- 49:29person's economic value, would
- 49:32disappear. Well, the easiest way to
- 49:34understand how much you're worth is
- 49:35through money. And the downside of this
- 49:38process is that inequalities arise:
- 49:40when you have a blockchain, a smart
- 49:43contract mechanism, decentralized
- 49:46organizations, then you can refuse
- 49:48money in this decentralized
- 49:51organization that spans the entire
- 49:53world. Your value is determined not by
- 49:56money, not by some boss, but simply by
- 49:59your usefulness, which is already
- 50:01accounted for in this system. It was
- 50:05such a futuristic idea, but what you're
- 50:09saying seems a bit similar.
- 50:11When Bitcoin appeared,
- 50:14it actually introduced a mutable ledger
- 50:16—an irreplaceable ledger. This is
- 50:19immutable money, immutable transactions
- 50:21, uncheatable transactions. Everyone
- 50:23knows who has how much, and no one can
- 50:25cheat. Then Sirium went a little
- 50:27further. They said, "We can make smart
- 50:30contracts." This is the unchangeable
- 50:34execution of a program's script.
- 50:38Yeah.
- 50:38Ah, an
- 50:39unchangeable obligation. There is an
- 50:40unchangeable obligation. The contract
- 50:42will be fulfilled. It doesn't matter
- 50:44how important it is that the conditions
- 50:45are met. It will definitely be
- 50:46fulfilled. There is no middleman. Now,
- 50:48if the same thing happens in the chain
- 50:51from AI, then that's where we get that
- 50:54very crypto-utopia into this
- 50:56vetri-utopia, within which we can build
- 50:59an incorruptible official. We say that
- 51:02we need to remove the middleman, but we
- 51:04can install an algorithmic,
- 51:05incorruptible middleman. And this
- 51:08middleman will constitute almost zero
- 51:11cost. Well, almost zero, because he has
- 51:13a cost of securing it. We need to
- 51:15install hardware, spend electricity,
- 51:17buy chips. If all of this has a price,
- 51:19then we need to do everything possible
- 51:22to drive it down. That is, build a
- 51:24market in which the price of every
- 51:26token, every job performed by this AI,
- 51:29inevitably tends to zero. Under these
- 51:31conditions, we can truly achieve what
- 51:34the crypto-utopians are talking about.
- 51:37And in this regard, with AI, there's an
- 51:40interesting point. Danya often talks
- 51:43about this future world, where everyone
- 51:46has their own robot that works for us,
- 51:48that goes to our factory, and so on.
- 51:51That this world is such an abundance.
- 51:53And people constantly ask him in simple
- 51:56terms: "Well, why doesn't there just be
- 51:58a factory? Why would a factory need
- 52:00your robots? A factory just...
- 52:02Why are they robot masters when it can
- 52:04buy its own?"
- 52:05Yes, that's the most obvious question.
- 52:07But this obvious question seems to be
- 52:10looking at the consumer, right? It
- 52:13looks at the consumer as passive.
- 52:16As if there's no difference. And to
- 52:19understand this world, there's a simple
- 52:23exercise. Let's imagine that there are
- 52:25only settings. And Dania has come up
- 52:29with one that can do everything so that
- 52:32neither your work nor mine is needed
- 52:35anymore.
- 52:37And let's say you have everything you
- 52:39have left: the land, your home. You
- 52:40live in it. I can come and say: "Give
- 52:42away your houses, because everything
- 52:43that can happen to me, everything that
- 52:45is needed, only I can give you. You
- 52:46have nothing else except your house.
- 52:48That's it. But it is very important
- 52:50that if he does not need our labor, yes
- 52:53, our labor will not add anything to
- 52:55his life, then
- 52:56nothing bothers us.
- 53:00Nothing bothers us. The world has not
- 53:01become worse for us, because you and I,
- 53:03even if we do not have this great" yay
- 53:05", you and I can exchange this labor.
- 53:06We do not need it. The factory that
- 53:09takes us all away. But at that moment,
- 53:11when we think that we do not need it,
- 53:14then this appears, what is described in
- 53:16that example, yes, that m Dao is a kind
- 53:19of closed system in which we begin to
- 53:21exchange when we do not need universal
- 53:23money, in which
- 53:24we have really all disappeared, right?
- 53:27But we can create money between us,
- 53:30which denotes an exchange between us.
- 53:32And in this regard, the consumer is
- 53:34also a creator, You understand? Because
- 53:37it's only because you want to use my
- 53:38labor, and I want to consume your labor
- 53:40, that's the only reason this labor is
- 53:42valuable at all. And just imagine that
- 53:44in reality, if you fast-forward 30
- 53:48years—it's not like that, not that
- 53:50much, but you still have to
- 53:51fast-forward as far as you can. Where
- 53:52exactly this super-super-artificial
- 53:54intelligence is, it's not exactly a
- 53:56question of whether it will be in 2
- 53:58years, 5 years, 10 years, or 30 years,
- 54:00we can guess, but let's assume we've
- 54:02definitely moved ourselves far ahead.
- 54:05Yeah. And in this distant future, there
- 54:08are two very different scenarios. One,
- 54:11in which all this is owned by
- 54:13corporations and everyone else lives,
- 54:15maybe, only on some kind of benefit and
- 54:17, in general, has lost the meaning of
- 54:19life and is very dependent on it. Or
- 54:23the other, in which we have a future
- 54:25future, in which we have all become so
- 54:28much stronger, precisely because
- 54:30intelligence is so democratized, and
- 54:33people create very different things,
- 54:36and consume each other, because it's
- 54:38interesting consume each other. So this
- 54:41labor, as I say, is four times. Why am
- 54:43I saying this figure of four times?
- 54:45Firstly, statistics from the last 90
- 54:48years show that every 30 years, human
- 54:51productivity has quadrupled. Now we are
- 54:54on the verge of a similar breakthrough,
- 54:56which will be achieved in the next 30
- 54:58years. Why? Because if every person
- 55:01simply has a robot working in their
- 55:03interests, both intelligence and a
- 55:06robot. And why will there be a robot?
- 55:07Because it will cost 10-20,000 dollars.
- 55:09We are already seeing this. The market
- 55:11is already moving towards this. Ying
- 55:12promises that it will cost 20. The
- 55:14Chinese are churning it out. 500
- 55:16companies now, I'm not kidding, 500
- 55:18plus companies are now engaged in the
- 55:21creation of robots. Robots will be
- 55:23accessible. The question would be, why?
- 55:26And the question would be,
- 55:27understanding how to use all this. And
- 55:29every person can have a robot. If every
- 55:32person has their own robot, which is
- 55:34exclusively in your interests If it
- 55:36works, your personal robot, then 8
- 55:38hours of your work, you sleep, 8 hours
- 55:40of rest, 8 hours of work and another 3
- 55:42times 8,
- 55:43yes,
- 55:43your robot, who just works with you,
- 55:46maybe you take another 8 from him and
- 55:48say:" Let's have fun together, my 8,
- 55:51your 8, let's have fun together. "And
- 55:53you only work 16 hours, not all 24. But
- 55:55actually, just a second, you will have
- 55:58fun with other people, and the robots
- 56:00will teach you productivity together
- 56:02with you. Build four times more houses,
- 56:05clean the ocean four times more, plant
- 56:07four times more lawns, replant trees.
- 56:10And there is a very big gap between
- 56:13these two versions of reality. And you
- 56:15are right, yes,
- 56:16that we don't care
- 56:18how much money we earn, but we still
- 56:19want to be in the second world. Well,
- 56:21that is, we definitely need to make an
- 56:23effort not to end up in the first, but
- 56:25to end up in the second. And we don't
- 56:27have the option of
- 56:29not ending up in any of them, you know,
- 56:31just stopping so that I didn't develop
- 56:33any further, and so on. This is not
- 56:34true. This is not an option. There is
- 56:36no Switch killer who will kill this,
- 56:38like, and it won't happen, yes. Someone
- 56:41will periodically throw Molotov
- 56:43cocktails there, threatening the people
- 56:46who create
- 56:48these, and they, they, they will be
- 56:51created.
- 56:52Fact. We will all use the GPT chat. In
- 56:54doing so, we are paying for the
- 56:56development of the GPT chat and the
- 56:57development of these future
- 56:59corporations. Simply by doing nothing
- 57:01or simply using these tools, we are
- 57:04paying for the construction of their
- 57:06infrastructure, when we could actually
- 57:09pay for the construction of public
- 57:11infrastructure. And the mere presence
- 57:14of public infrastructure leads to a
- 57:17completely different market.
- 57:19Now hundreds of billions are being
- 57:21invested in this infrastructure. The
- 57:23first thing to think about is who will
- 57:25have to pay for these 100 billion. That
- 57:27in fact, every investment is bad news
- 57:28for us. Every time the capitalization
- 57:30of these companies grows more and more,
- 57:32it's bad news for us all, because we
- 57:34will all have to pay for it.
- 57:35Well, yeah, you We'll have to pay so
- 57:37that the people who invested in this
- 57:39can profit.
- 57:40While they're competing with each other
- 57:42, and there are five of them here, five
- 57:44there, we all essentially have to pay
- 57:4610 times more. Well, because we could
- 57:48have built this public infrastructure
- 57:51once, but now they'll all build
- 57:53capacity with Drum, competing to steal
- 57:55each other's clients. By the way,
- 57:58there's an understanding of the use of
- 58:00computing power for AI, that is, what
- 58:03it's mainly used for now. All this
- 58:06chatting, all this chatting, is a
- 58:08pittance for the current consumer.
- 58:10Got it?
- 58:11Ah, it's already a pittance. It all
- 58:13started with that. It allowed us to get
- 58:14everyone involved. Ah, but when you
- 58:17send 100 words to a chat, you get 100
- 58:22words back.
- 58:23Yeah. Well, not 100, 1,000. Now that
- 58:25they're still thinking, yes, there's a
- 58:27process called rendering, otherwise
- 58:29there are already 1,000 words,
- 58:31including what, you know, he's spinning
- 58:33around and thinking. There, what you
- 58:35think is right.
- 58:36Right or wrong, but what did the user
- 58:38mean? Now I'll think about it some more
- 58:40.
- 58:40When people use this professionally,
- 58:43for example, for programming, then
- 58:46I send 100 words and I get at least
- 58:50100,000 words back for every word I
- 58:53write. Agents. That is, when you launch
- 58:58it and tell this system:" Let's have
- 59:01you report information to me on this "
- 59:04on this, about—when you ask it to do
- 59:08certain things for you: work with
- 59:10tables in Excel, create websites, etc.
- 59:14—for every 100 words you write,
- 59:16millions of words are sent back.
- 59:19Millions." And, accordingly, it's like
- 59:21a huge risk that everything, at some
- 59:23point, will all close, because these
- 59:25models, they are corporate, because
- 59:27they are designed to make money. This
- 59:30is how the race itself is structured in
- 59:32this regard, this decentralized story
- 59:35with, and as we mentioned, exactly what
- 59:38happened, and this is what happened
- 59:41just in the last few months,
- 59:43and that the emergence of OpenCore, and
- 59:46it gave a powerful tool to a very large
- 59:48number of people to start using
- 59:51artificial intelligence to automate
- 59:53their work, create new businesses, as
- 59:56if to do some kind of...These are more
- 59:58serious things than we had all done in
- 1:00:01chats before. But at the same time,
- 1:00:03people began to notice that it was a
- 1:00:06bit expensive. That is, they use it and
- 1:00:08they already have hundreds of dollars a
- 1:00:10week, they began to see that their
- 1:00:12credit cards are being withdrawn.
- 1:00:14Many were surprised that for a couple
- 1:00:16of nights, a couple of hundred dollars
- 1:00:17so far. That's it. And from this, a
- 1:00:20noticeable movement arose to connect
- 1:00:24open models to OpenCore and look for
- 1:00:28some other alternatives.
- 1:00:31And, that is, the same In our network,
- 1:00:34it's clear that the main usage is
- 1:00:37agents right now, precisely because
- 1:00:40agents, unlike people, don't have any
- 1:00:44loyalty to the Open AI or Antropic
- 1:00:47brands. Often, when you tell them
- 1:00:50directly: "Find yourself a
- 1:00:53cheaper model, here's a credit card, go
- 1:00:56find it, pay," they'll go and find it
- 1:00:59cheaper.
- 1:00:59That's it. And in this regard, the
- 1:01:02advantage of blockchain protocols is
- 1:01:07that this growth is ensured by the
- 1:01:11issued coin. Fewer and fewer of them
- 1:01:14are being issued. And therefore, when
- 1:01:16you ask agents: "Find me
- 1:01:18the cheapest, the
- 1:01:19cheapest route," then for them, uh,
- 1:01:21they'll search on the internet, they'll
- 1:01:23compare prices, and they'll quickly
- 1:01:25come to the conclusion that it's
- 1:01:27necessary, of course, to use decimated
- 1:01:29networks, because that's the best thing
- 1:01:31. And we usually, when we finally talk
- 1:01:34about this topic in the testing of
- 1:01:36Soviet scientists Intelligentsia, we're
- 1:01:39not talking about our protocol and our
- 1:01:41product specifically, but we're talking
- 1:01:44about how de-clasticization is the way
- 1:01:46to go.
- 1:01:47Yeah. Yes. We've tried to implement in
- 1:01:49our product
- 1:01:50everything that we believe will lead to
- 1:01:53the construction of this public
- 1:01:55infrastructure. That is, this is how we
- 1:01:57see the specific rules of this protocol
- 1:01:59that should lead to the construction of
- 1:02:01an infrastructure worth hundreds of
- 1:02:03billions of dollars.
- 1:02:04But we strongly encourage everyone to
- 1:02:07double-check, look at different ones,
- 1:02:09and encourage your agents to find the
- 1:02:12most effective. And this is what's
- 1:02:15already happening and will only happen
- 1:02:18more. Every time people encounter
- 1:02:20higher prices or every time they
- 1:02:22encounter being disconnected from the
- 1:02:24model, just like the OpenCell community
- 1:02:26at some point discovered that they were
- 1:02:28all disconnected from the OtropiC model
- 1:02:30. The more such cases there are, the
- 1:02:34more people will join in the
- 1:02:37consumption and, in particular, the
- 1:02:40protocol race.
- 1:02:43And this is the same thing that
- 1:02:44happened with Bitcoin. With Bitcoin
- 1:02:45What was happening? You can see that
- 1:02:47every time there was some kind of
- 1:02:50economic crisis, yep,
- 1:02:51people would join in because, well,
- 1:02:53it's clear, yeah, in calm times you
- 1:02:54don't really think about it, well, what
- 1:02:56are the numbers, a
- 1:02:56dollar, a dollar, they pay salaries, I
- 1:02:59buy coffee,
- 1:02:59and then a crisis happens, you realize
- 1:03:01that no, there's some big problem with
- 1:03:03modern finance, something needs to be
- 1:03:05changed and alternatives needed to be
- 1:03:07found.
- 1:03:08Each such event was also a big
- 1:03:11development for us for the protocol we
- 1:03:15created. Take Open Claw and all this
- 1:03:18open source movement, the creation of
- 1:03:22agents. And at the end of last year,
- 1:03:24everyone thought that agents were
- 1:03:27something completely under control, and
- 1:03:29not these large existing corporations.
- 1:03:32And now it's not just OpenClaw, there's
- 1:03:34Gstack, there's Hermes, there's that.
- 1:03:37That is, in fact, it's already
- 1:03:39unstoppable; there will be a huge
- 1:03:41number of free open source projects,
- 1:03:44because what is it? Essentially, it's
- 1:03:47just someone sitting down (not even one
- 1:03:49person, but a group of people) and
- 1:03:51putting their own vision and knowledge
- 1:03:53into in the form of text, simply
- 1:03:55formulated processes, protocols, and
- 1:03:58operations in text—the projects are
- 1:04:00written, and from them a certain
- 1:04:02personality is created, a certain
- 1:04:04behavioral structure, work processes,
- 1:04:06which are then passed through AI models
- 1:04:09to execute your tasks, which you
- 1:04:11already say in the line: "Do it for me,
- 1:04:13please." So, it, having all these
- 1:04:15processes, runs there in the model,
- 1:04:18calculates, returns the results and
- 1:04:20continues to spin inside its set
- 1:04:22processes. And then you really have two
- 1:04:24paths. One is to try to make the most
- 1:04:27of this, or we all share this knowledge
- 1:04:30and we all only make each other
- 1:04:33stronger.
- 1:04:33And it turns out that there are enough
- 1:04:36people, including those who have
- 1:04:38already earned money, but know how, who
- 1:04:40sit down, write and post it for free
- 1:04:42for everyone. Here is precisely the
- 1:04:44clarification. That is, the agent to
- 1:04:46whom you say: "Find me a cheaper model,
- 1:04:48" has the opportunity to choose. That
- 1:04:51is, as if the world is not reduced to
- 1:04:52these three or these three models.
- 1:04:57It turned out that all these companies,
- 1:04:59they can spend Well, billions of
- 1:05:01dollars already spent on model training
- 1:05:03.
- 1:05:04Yeah. But as soon as they make it
- 1:05:07available to anyone else, through
- 1:05:09communication with this model, to
- 1:05:12create a model that is practically as
- 1:05:15powerful as the copied product, yeah,
- 1:05:18where did we start,
- 1:05:20right? Well, even, that is, you can't
- 1:05:22even protect it, you know, it turned
- 1:05:24out that this could have happened. We
- 1:05:26predicted the emergence of DeepSky more
- 1:05:27than a year in advance, everyone at
- 1:05:28home was saying, "It's impossible not
- 1:05:29to catch up with everything open, not
- 1:05:30to catch up with Anthropic, not to
- 1:05:31catch up with Google, forget about it."
- 1:05:33And speaking of which, why? How easy is
- 1:05:35it to catch up? Just imagine that
- 1:05:37everything they've done is based on
- 1:05:39publicly published scientific articles,
- 1:05:42publicly available data. Then you need
- 1:05:45a lot of calculations, and then, once
- 1:05:47you've done these calculations, you can
- 1:05:49test your own against their model,
- 1:05:50while your model communicates with
- 1:05:52their model to train itself. That is,
- 1:05:54for now, this bottleneck has turned out
- 1:05:57to be precisely in computing power. And
- 1:05:59this is where reality control exists
- 1:06:02now.
- 1:06:02And Where will it remain if we don't
- 1:06:04build a public infrastructure? So you
- 1:06:06understand, Deepsk became possible
- 1:06:09thanks to the fact that the company
- 1:06:12that was trading on the exchange bought
- 1:06:16GPUs for trading on the exchange. And
- 1:06:19they put them there for a while. And so
- 1:06:21they decided, well, let's just leave
- 1:06:22them idle and calculate. And
- 1:06:24why don't we calculate our model, like
- 1:06:25those guys, put the ones posted on it.
- 1:06:27We're interested, we're all scientists,
- 1:06:29we all study mathematics here. Let's
- 1:06:30take all this and calculate it on our
- 1:06:32GPUs.
- 1:06:32They had a lot of GPUs. They had about
- 1:06:361,500, uh, the
- 1:06:39most powerful GPUs at the time.
- 1:06:43And that's how they managed to do it.
- 1:06:45And what we want to show people is that
- 1:06:49the power is in them, yes. In our
- 1:06:52community now, it's not in chips, not
- 1:06:54in Chinese, but in people.
- 1:06:56People. There are 15,000 people in our
- 1:06:59community. And this community is
- 1:07:02already They assembled 3,000 of these
- 1:07:04same
- 1:07:05chips and connected more of the
- 1:07:06existing ones to the common network.
- 1:07:08That is, they didn't have to buy them,
- 1:07:10they didn't have to build anything new.
- 1:07:12Most people even simply borrowed these
- 1:07:14chips from data centers and cloud
- 1:07:16providers.
- 1:07:17That's it. But then, the next step is
- 1:07:20that yes, there will be 5,000, 10,000,
- 1:07:2320,000 of them. But the protocol itself
- 1:07:27, because it's open, has no barriers.
- 1:07:31And what's happening now? That
- 1:07:34engineers around the world are just as
- 1:07:37skilled as they were with Bitcoin—
- 1:07:40yeah,
- 1:07:41who just made chips for Bitcoin or
- 1:07:44Ereum. They're like, "But this is the
- 1:07:47future." And there will be hundreds of
- 1:07:50times more computing than Bitcoin ever
- 1:07:53had. "And they started making chips to
- 1:07:56connect to our protocol, so that people
- 1:07:59no longer have to buy a modern chip
- 1:08:02because it's expensive. That is, to put
- 1:08:05this in perspective, if you try to
- 1:08:09build the Bitcoin network today with
- 1:08:12all its computing power, but on Nvidia
- 1:08:15chips, you'll need to spend 5
- 1:08:18quadrillions of dollars.
- 1:08:22This is not the way we need to build
- 1:08:25infrastructure for AI. But what this
- 1:08:29crypto community, which everyone
- 1:08:30perceives, has shown, you know, they
- 1:08:32haven't done anything. No, they've done
- 1:08:34a lot. These are incredible engineering
- 1:08:37breakthroughs in chip construction. And
- 1:08:40now similar breakthroughs, yes, this
- 1:08:43equipment needs to be redesigned,
- 1:08:45because the equipment used for Bitcoin
- 1:08:48cannot be used for slahiTektu, but the
- 1:08:51principles they came up with, how they
- 1:08:54layer memory on chips and so on, they
- 1:08:57are now using everything to create ASX.
- 1:09:00Already this year, already this year,
- 1:09:03new chips will be released, not from
- 1:09:05Nvidia, not from Google, and not from
- 1:09:07Amazon, but from completely independent
- 1:09:10companies. Nvidia even bought one of
- 1:09:12these GRKyu last year, this year they
- 1:09:14even integrated their new platform. And
- 1:09:17there are many new manufacturers like
- 1:09:19this, and these chips will be
- 1:09:22competitively much better, cheaper,
- 1:09:24like this, more productive for their
- 1:09:27cost. The same people who produced
- 1:09:29chips for Bitcoin in the past have been
- 1:09:32working for many years to apply their
- 1:09:35knowledge to the construction of AI
- 1:09:37chips.
- 1:09:38And now they are releasing them this
- 1:09:40year, this year, next year. Edchet in
- 1:09:42the US, NTR in Canada, Talas in Canada,
- 1:09:46accelerators somewhere in Europe, I
- 1:09:49don't remember where, some Chinese
- 1:09:51companies, Taiwanese companies, Korean
- 1:09:55companies are producing new chips. They
- 1:09:58all, uh, when they started, might not
- 1:10:01even have thought about decentralized
- 1:10:03networks. They might have thought:"
- 1:10:05We'll just sell this to those same
- 1:10:07Facebooks, Googles, and others, "
- 1:10:08whoever needs it." But now it's
- 1:10:10becoming clear that all these Facebook
- 1:10:13corners, they've either already bought
- 1:10:15whoever they wanted, or are even
- 1:10:16producing new chips on their own in
- 1:10:18this club of theirs, a closed club of
- 1:10:20boy-bunnies, where even the five of
- 1:10:22them have taken up the entire SMC,
- 1:10:24taken up all the memory, and so on. So
- 1:10:27they sit there and it's all their club.
- 1:10:29And these small manufacturers are
- 1:10:32suddenly realizing that they can use a
- 1:10:35decentralized network, connect
- 1:10:37non-their chips and earn coins. Because
- 1:10:40now it's the same as it was with
- 1:10:43Bitcoin. And what is the coin imitated
- 1:10:46in Bitcoin here? A token.
- 1:10:48Well, it's the same in our example of
- 1:10:52our protocol,
- 1:10:53the same thing. This protocol has its
- 1:10:55own coin, which has a limited supply,
- 1:10:58and only those who mine receive it.
- 1:11:01This and this coin, it represents a
- 1:11:04certain opportunity to either get
- 1:11:06computation now, or wait 10 years and
- 1:11:09get computation when this network is
- 1:11:12much larger. That's exactly what
- 1:11:14I was asking. That is, it's not In
- 1:11:16itself, in a vacuum, it's tied
- 1:11:18specifically to access to
- 1:11:20this currency, which is then used to
- 1:11:23pay for its consumption. Hey, you
- 1:11:25either use it now, when there are 3,000
- 1:11:28GPUs in the network, or you use it in 5
- 1:11:31years, when there are millions of GPUs.
- 1:11:35And it's clear that, accordingly, you
- 1:11:36can get significantly more computing
- 1:11:38power later and then
- 1:11:39sell these coins to someone, and they
- 1:11:41will use the computing power.
- 1:11:42You just said 3,000, yes,
- 1:11:44every time we mention a number in an
- 1:11:45interview, by the time the interview
- 1:11:47comes out, it's already higher. Now, in
- 1:11:49fact, it's already 3,700, and most
- 1:11:51likely, by the time people hear this,
- 1:11:53it will be 5,000 or more. And what's
- 1:11:55the safety net? This decentralized
- 1:11:57network, it must always remain
- 1:11:58decentralized. Roughly speaking, there
- 1:12:00shouldn't be an imbalance in favor of
- 1:12:02someone who has more of these coins,
- 1:12:04who can build more of these capacities.
- 1:12:06Coins have nothing to do with it. More
- 1:12:07Coins, please, this is for the market.
- 1:12:10If you want to buy up all the coins,
- 1:12:11buy up all the coins. The importance of
- 1:12:13this network is that it is not defined
- 1:12:15by the coins, but by who provides the
- 1:12:17capacity. That is, to have a voice and
- 1:12:20influence in this network's vote on
- 1:12:22where this network is going, you need
- 1:12:25to add hardware.
- 1:12:26When we launched this network, from day
- 1:12:29one, we made it completely independent
- 1:12:32of us.
- 1:12:33Even regardless of what we say about it
- 1:12:35and so on, we have no control over it.
- 1:12:37We were often discouraged; they said, "
- 1:12:38No, well, you have to have some kind of
- 1:12:39control."
- 1:12:40All other cryptocurrencies are like
- 1:12:41this, back and forth. You're like, if
- 1:12:43we're creating a physical
- 1:12:45infrastructure,
- 1:12:46and people should believe that no one
- 1:12:49will ever use it,
- 1:12:51complete control. And that's exactly
- 1:12:53what needs to be given. Then it's all
- 1:12:55determined by the protocol. And then
- 1:12:57it's all determined, accordingly, by
- 1:13:01these many independent actors that
- 1:13:04define this network. Our thesis is that
- 1:13:08even a non-profit organization, even a
- 1:13:10charitable organization, wouldn't be a
- 1:13:13good form, because in a charitable
- 1:13:15organization there's still a board of
- 1:13:17directors,
- 1:13:18and then the board of directors usually
- 1:13:20elects itself. And that means it's
- 1:13:22still a certain power. And the only way
- 1:13:24is, in Bitcoin, there's no charitable
- 1:13:26organization, there's no organization,
- 1:13:28and it works perfectly well. And
- 1:13:29everything is determined by the
- 1:13:31protocol. And this protocol has one
- 1:13:33goal: for the infrastructure to grow
- 1:13:37and for this infrastructure to be free,
- 1:13:40accessible, and for everyone who
- 1:13:43wants to buy up all this capacity,
- 1:13:45let's assume how this is regulated in
- 1:13:47Bitcoin, by the way. Not at all, not at
- 1:13:49all. It's regulated. It's regulated by
- 1:13:52That as soon as it grows...
- 1:13:55Yeah. The
- 1:13:55number of participants increases, so
- 1:13:57the price of the coin increases. As
- 1:13:58soon as the price of the coin increases
- 1:13:59, the others look and say, "Oh, it's
- 1:14:01growing. Why am I such a fool that I'm
- 1:14:02not making money?""And they join too.
- 1:14:05And what's more, at the same time,
- 1:14:07whenever you want it, whenever you want
- 1:14:10it...This is a theory, but it has been
- 1:14:12empirically proven by Bitcoin. Oh, and
- 1:14:14we had the same situation, especially
- 1:14:16at the beginning of the network. At the
- 1:14:18beginning, there were very few. Eight
- 1:14:20participants, whom we found independent
- 1:14:22of each other, experienced people with
- 1:14:25a reputation. We found them and said:"
- 1:14:27Here you add the first GP, you launch
- 1:14:29the network. "They launched the network
- 1:14:31, and it seemed like there were only
- 1:14:326480 GPUs. There very quickly became 80
- 1:14:34in a couple of days. And critics
- 1:14:36were saying that
- 1:14:37someone could add 100 tomorrow and
- 1:14:38that's it, and they would have half,
- 1:14:40and everything would be gone. Oh, and
- 1:14:42our thesis was that the moment someone
- 1:14:45wants to add 100, someone else is
- 1:14:49already thinking about it too. And
- 1:14:50that's how it happens. It doesn't
- 1:14:52happen in a vacuum. We go out and give
- 1:14:55interviews so that as many people as
- 1:14:57possible know, so that the idea Whether
- 1:14:59this network was ready for 10,000 new
- 1:15:01GPUs or not didn't come to one person,
- 1:15:04but to many at once.
- 1:15:06It works in a surprising way. So, from
- 1:15:08those sixty GPUs, the network grew to
- 1:15:103,000, and there wasn't a single moment
- 1:15:13where anyone gained significant power.
- 1:15:15Conca, meanwhile, isn't really a
- 1:15:17company; it's, so to speak, a protocol.
- 1:15:19It's an OpenS protocol, hosted on
- 1:15:21GitHub, and people are already using it
- 1:15:23and contributing code to it without us.
- 1:15:25Overall, there are no restrictions on
- 1:15:27anyone's participation. Right now, you
- 1:15:30can go to Nibius's website, that Neo
- 1:15:34Cloud in Volzhe, rent a couple of GPUs
- 1:15:38for a couple hundred dollars a day, and
- 1:15:42go mine the race. Anyone can do it, and
- 1:15:45you
- 1:15:45don't have to negotiate with anyone. We
- 1:15:47don't have to give anyone permission.
- 1:15:49It's happening.
- 1:15:50You go to the website, open the
- 1:15:51documentation, read how to install,
- 1:15:53then, if you don't understand it, you
- 1:15:54go to the community, there are 15,000
- 1:15:56people there. Everyone has long
- 1:15:58understood everything, explained it,
- 1:16:00agreed, made the instructions simpler
- 1:16:02than ours. Ours is too technical, too
- 1:16:04scientific. Someone made it simpler,
- 1:16:06someone recorded YouTube videos. All
- 1:16:08this exists. What's
- 1:16:09my logic? Let's say I'm a venture fund
- 1:16:12or a pension fund, and I invested in
- 1:16:15Open and look at the race and say:"
- 1:16:19Okay, the logic is that if this product
- 1:16:22takes off and starts working, then
- 1:16:25these billions invested in data centers
- 1:16:29will turn into zero. And all my money
- 1:16:31will turn...Well, not into zero, they
- 1:16:32won't turn into zero. They can all join
- 1:16:34the race,
- 1:16:35ah,
- 1:16:36and also update the race. Well, your
- 1:16:39idea is this: if this desire for AI to
- 1:16:43be free is not among 15,000 people, but
- 1:16:47among billions of people in the future,
- 1:16:51then this will be a much more valuable
- 1:16:55network. And then, as usual, they all
- 1:17:01come here and want money. But you can't
- 1:17:04invest money here. You can participate
- 1:17:06in mining or buy coins from other
- 1:17:09miners.
- 1:17:09So, to continue my example, I'm looking
- 1:17:12at it, I understand that all these data
- 1:17:15centers won't go broke, but I don't
- 1:17:18believe they'll join the race. I
- 1:17:21understand that, basically, I'm losing
- 1:17:24this profit. So, I need to somehow...
- 1:17:26But I can't give you money. Buy.
- 1:17:32Well, you either go to these miners,
- 1:17:34you go to these miners who have already
- 1:17:36mined, buy out their coins,
- 1:17:37or rent a GPU and start mining too. It
- 1:17:41was very inconvenient for them, you
- 1:17:42know, because the eternal capitalists
- 1:17:43are used to the fact that they just
- 1:17:45need to deposit money. And it's kind of
- 1:17:46funny, really funny, you understand.
- 1:17:48When they came in the first or second
- 1:17:50month,
- 1:17:50they were like, "We want to deposit, I
- 1:17:52don't know, a million dollars." We say,
- 1:17:54"There's nowhere to put it. If you want
- 1:17:55, you can go buy it on the market. But
- 1:17:57wait a second, there aren't enough
- 1:17:59coins on the market yet, not enough
- 1:18:01coins have been mined for you to buy
- 1:18:03them with your million dollars.
- 1:18:05Therefore, your only chance to invest
- 1:18:07your million in these coins is to go
- 1:18:09and mine these coins yourself. Okay, I
- 1:18:11get it. It was such a, uh, process, too
- 1:18:14, because it's a strange structure, yes
- 1:18:17, it's designed precisely to create
- 1:18:20some, uh, public domain, but in some
- 1:18:23kind of framework, in which there is
- 1:18:25still some, uh, commercial motivation
- 1:18:28for people. Those same venture
- 1:18:31capitalists who were looking for a way
- 1:18:33to somehow get involved in this project
- 1:18:35. We also usually respond very sharply
- 1:18:38that, first and foremost, what's
- 1:18:39interesting is the participation of
- 1:18:41people who believe in this future, who
- 1:18:44want this future to happen. Here,
- 1:18:46taking into account other restrictions,
- 1:18:48here, you can't just come and bring
- 1:18:50money, you need to do something. This
- 1:18:52was not the case, and at first, it was
- 1:18:53especially It's a complex natural
- 1:18:55product of some sort. Well, well, well,
- 1:18:56it was
- 1:18:57A who put in the effort to make it what
- 1:19:00it is now. Overall, again, it was a
- 1:19:03difficult process, two years in our
- 1:19:05lives and so on, but we've already
- 1:19:07earned enough money to not worry about
- 1:19:10the time we
- 1:19:13spent on it. But the future of this
- 1:19:17protocol depends solely on how many
- 1:19:20people believe that this alternative
- 1:19:24needs to exist for this infrastructure
- 1:19:29to be truly meaningful.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Братья Либерманы. Почему ИИ сделает одних сверхбогатыми, а других – нищими? by Forbes, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 12,346 words across 2,030 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.