Transference Focused Psychotherapy & Personality Disorders with Dr. Otto Kernberg — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00All right, I'm here with Dr. Odo
- 0:02Kernburgg. He is a psychiatrist born in
- 0:06Vienna,
- 0:07Austria, immigrated to Chile,
- 0:09subsequently came to America and is the
- 0:12founder of Transference Focus therapy
- 0:16and was instrumental in our
- 0:18understanding of things like borderline
- 0:20level of organization. We're going to
- 0:22have a discussion today about his life,
- 0:26about the things that he uh wrote and
- 0:29ideas that he came up with and the
- 0:31evolution of it. So, welcome to the
- 0:33podcast. I know you were born in
- 0:35Austria, Vienna in 1928
- 0:39and um you fled Nazi occupied Austria
- 0:44with your family to Chile. Tell me a
- 0:46little bit about that. Uh
- 0:48[Music]
- 0:49well I was um nine years and a half. Uh
- 0:56the Hitler
- 0:58invaded March 1938 and I left with my
- 1:03parents on July 16,
- 1:071939. My father didn't want to leave.
- 1:11He happened to be an Austrian monarchist
- 1:15and he believed all of this was going
- 1:17just passing by. Hitler was a transitory
- 1:20phenomenon. He had
- 1:22a strong belief in in in Austria
- 1:26Austrian survival. My
- 1:29mother had paranoid features.
- 1:33She was frightened to death with the
- 1:36invasion, the
- 1:38Anel.
- 1:40And then after Crystal
- 1:43Knight, which in Vienna occurred on
- 1:45December 10, 19
- 1:4838, she convinced my father that we had
- 1:51to leave. And so we got the visa to
- 1:54Chile. And of course, I didn't know
- 1:57anything. They didn't I'm an only child.
- 2:00That was nine years and a half about.
- 2:03And um on July
- 2:0616th, 1939, she told me, "Pack
- 2:10everything, all toys that you have into
- 2:13this suitcase. We're leaving this
- 2:15afternoon, and you are not supposed to
- 2:17tell a word to anybody." And by then, I
- 2:21was already acutely aware of the danger.
- 2:24And and so that's
- 2:27how we left. I spent one year and a half
- 2:32under the
- 2:33Nazis and it was a bad a bad experience.
- 2:39um violent anti-semitism
- 2:43naturally and
- 2:46um all Jewish kids were expelled from
- 2:49schools, put into Jewish Jewish
- 2:53schools, forbidden to go to movies,
- 2:58parks,
- 3:00uh everywhere.
- 3:03um Jews and dogs
- 3:08forbidden. So um although I was a child,
- 3:12I I got the feeling for
- 3:15it.
- 3:17Um, one day I was walking with my mother
- 3:20on the street and and SR man that was
- 3:25Hitler's lower
- 3:27military guards, the SR in contrast to
- 3:31the SS.
- 3:34Um, forced my mother to wash the street,
- 3:38the pavement. And so my mother was
- 3:43washing the pavement and the crowd
- 3:45gathered making fun of us and I was
- 3:47standing there. I mean this kind of bad
- 3:51experiences and that
- 3:53was before the war started. The war
- 3:59started I
- 4:01think October 1, 1939.
- 4:06So we um just managed to escape in time
- 4:09because after that the border was
- 4:11closed and the rest of my family all
- 4:15ended up in the concentration camps and
- 4:19they had except one cousin who managed
- 4:21to escape within to England with the
- 4:24children's transport and then to the
- 4:26United States.
- 4:28That's uh and um we spent then six
- 4:32months in Italy before finally being the
- 4:36visa came and we immigrated to Chile
- 4:39where I lived for more than 20 years
- 4:42before coming to the United States.
- 4:45First of all, thank you Dr. Karnberg for
- 4:46sharing and I
- 4:48appreciate you you being so um honest
- 4:51with us about just that experience. I I
- 4:54can imagine in part how awful that
- 4:57was. Seeing the violent anti-semitism,
- 5:00the just
- 5:02degrading awful things that you saw,
- 5:05including signs like Jews and dogs not
- 5:09welcome, degrading images of your mother
- 5:12that probably still linger there. And um
- 5:16watching watching her clean the pavement
- 5:20and I I imagine it was a huge loss to
- 5:24have to leave all of a sudden further
- 5:26loss
- 5:27through the the war hearing about the
- 5:30concentration camps and the rest of your
- 5:32family that were stuck there. Um and I
- 5:36appreciate you sharing today. I wonder
- 5:38if you could tell me a bit more about
- 5:40some of these formative experiences that
- 5:43you had in Chile, some of the mentors
- 5:46that guided you towards becoming a
- 5:48therapist. Well, um I studied medicine
- 5:53in
- 5:55Chile and um was fascinated by the
- 5:59psychiatry professor Ignasio Mati
- 6:02Blanco who was trained in England. The
- 6:07He was originally a neurologist trained
- 6:10in psychonaris by the clinian school in
- 6:14London and he started the psychonolytic
- 6:17society
- 6:19and training institute in
- 6:22Chile. He was a very outstanding man
- 6:26and became a personal ideal.
- 6:31Um I was interested actually in
- 6:34psychonaris since adolescence. I had
- 6:37read Freud and in immigration to
- 6:41Chile, I came under the influence of
- 6:45Yian Union analyst and by the time I
- 6:49entered medical school, I was was
- 6:52already interested in psychoanalysis and
- 6:55within psychiatry. Then that culminated
- 6:59and I decided to study psychonalaris in
- 7:04in Chile under the leadership of Ignasio
- 7:08Mativano
- 7:09and graduated there and before
- 7:14I came to the United States with the
- 7:18Rockefeller Foundation
- 7:20fellowship to study research in
- 7:23psychotherapy. I was interested in
- 7:25psychotherapy. was it effective or not
- 7:28and uh did my first research efforts in
- 7:31Chile and then came to the United States
- 7:34spent a year at Johns Hopkins with the
- 7:38Jerome Frank and his research group on
- 7:41psychotherapy and then at the Minga
- 7:43Foundation in Topeka Kansas
- 7:47where I mean in between I went to Chile
- 7:50did all the teaching that I had
- 7:51committed myself to the Rockefeller
- 7:53Foundation who gave me the fellowship
- 7:56So I fulfilled my obligation with the
- 7:58Rockefeller Foundation and then returned
- 8:01to the United States to participate in
- 8:04the psychotherapy research of the
- 8:06Manning Foundation, a huge project that
- 8:10[Music]
- 8:11um I participated in several ways until
- 8:16I
- 8:18became the director of it after Robert
- 8:22Wallerstein who was the leader.
- 8:25left as professor of
- 8:27psychiatry in San
- 8:30Francisco. So
- 8:33at during my work at the Manning
- 8:37Foundation, I was there for about 12
- 8:39years.
- 8:41I became
- 8:43interested in
- 8:45um learned all I could about the
- 8:49diagnosis and treatment of severe
- 8:51personality disorders.
- 8:54And
- 8:55[Music]
- 8:57um within the mening up project then I
- 9:03developed my own
- 9:05interest in studying
- 9:08outcome comparing patients who were
- 9:11treated in supportive
- 9:13psychotherapy
- 9:14in expressive or analytic psychotherapy
- 9:17and
- 9:19psychoanalysis and um came to the
- 9:22conclusion ution that patients with
- 9:26severe personality disorder, the
- 9:29so-called
- 9:32borderline, patients who fell in between
- 9:34neurosis and
- 9:36psychosis, really responded best to a
- 9:42treatment that was a well structured
- 9:46psychotherapy, not standard
- 9:48psychoanalysis, nor the usual supportive
- 9:51psychotherapy.
- 9:53That was the fashion at that point. And
- 9:56so I
- 9:58developed a project about an ideal
- 10:01treatment for severe personality
- 10:03disorders and at the same time had to
- 10:06differentiate severe personality
- 10:09disorders from
- 10:11non-cevere and had to deal with the
- 10:16entire diagnostic differentiation within
- 10:19psychiatry in which Ignasio Ignasio Mate
- 10:23Blanco helped me enormously when He
- 10:26learned in Chile that I spoke German. He
- 10:29said I had to read German classical
- 10:32German psychiatry book. I went to the
- 10:36library to get bum and I found out it
- 10:38was 12
- 10:40volumes. I didn't dare to ask him which
- 10:44volume he wanted me to read. And I
- 10:46started all 12 volumes of Bumkant. It
- 10:49gave me a knowledge in classical German
- 10:51psychiatry that helped me enormously
- 10:54together with then of course in the
- 10:57United States I got the American
- 10:58approach to diagnosis. But I became I
- 11:02made myself an expert in differential
- 11:05diagnosis
- 11:07and concluded that um the common
- 11:12features of severe personality disorders
- 11:15was a lack of integration of their
- 11:19concept of self and the lack of
- 11:21integration of their concept of
- 11:24significant others.
- 11:26um what Eric Ericson had described as
- 11:29identity diffusion. I picked up
- 11:32Ericson's concept of identity diffusion,
- 11:36applied it to the differential diagnosis
- 11:39of severe personality
- 11:41disorders and
- 11:43um develop
- 11:47simultaneously view of psychological
- 11:52development depending not on the
- 11:56internalization of representation of
- 12:00significant others.
- 12:01is a kind of mental representation of
- 12:06others from
- 12:08reality.
- 12:09But under the influence of a lecture I
- 12:14heard from Talcon Parsons, a leading
- 12:17sociologist in the United States, I
- 12:20learned that was this internalized are
- 12:23not
- 12:24representation of others but
- 12:27representation of the relationship
- 12:30between self and others. So when we
- 12:33interact with others, we
- 12:37internalize our representation of the
- 12:40other and the self
- 12:42interacting. This explains for example
- 12:46why children who have been physically
- 12:49abused severely
- 12:51abused over years become abusers in
- 12:56turn.
- 12:57We say that they identify with the
- 13:01abuser. Yes. But in a deep sense they
- 13:04have internalized the whole experience
- 13:08and
- 13:09simultaneously internalizing in their
- 13:12mind the representation of abuser and
- 13:16abused
- 13:18and are able then to in order to
- 13:21avoid. So their world becomes a relation
- 13:25between abusers and abused. All
- 13:27relationships are between abusers and
- 13:29abused. And it's better to be the abuser
- 13:33rather than the abused. So they
- 13:36learn role reversals and take on the
- 13:40role of the abuser while the role of the
- 13:44abused is projected onto somebody else.
- 13:47So the internalized relationship with
- 13:51others becomes the guiding principle
- 13:56that organizes habitual behavior what we
- 13:59call character. So the character what we
- 14:04now call
- 14:06personality actually personality is a
- 14:08broader concept that includes cognitive
- 14:11functions and everything else.
- 14:15[Music]
- 14:17character, habitual behavior patterns,
- 14:19but they are the essential part of
- 14:22personality. And so I defined borderline
- 14:28personality organization as
- 14:32those alterations, habitual alterations
- 14:35of the personality that had in common
- 14:39identity diffusion. Mhm. and developed
- 14:44um a
- 14:47clinical instrument, a clinical
- 14:49interview, the so-called structural
- 14:52interview to diagnose
- 14:55identity diffusion and differentiate
- 14:58severe personality disorders from non
- 15:01severe personality disorders. And of
- 15:04course the entire field of personality
- 15:06disorder from
- 15:09ordinary forms of
- 15:12psychosis madness in
- 15:14the usual sense and organic brain
- 15:19syndrome such as mental retardation and
- 15:23dementias. So I linked the specific
- 15:27instruments for diagnosing personality
- 15:30disorders with the general psychiatric
- 15:34diagnostic approach and
- 15:37um placed personality disorder within
- 15:41the general area of psychiatric
- 15:43diagnosis and regarding the treatment as
- 15:47I mentioned to you
- 15:49uh proposed the combination of a psy
- 15:53Psychotherapy under
- 15:56strictly controlled
- 16:00circumstances inspired by
- 16:02psychoanalysis but different from
- 16:05psychoanalysis by modification of
- 16:08psychonalytic instruments or
- 16:11methods and different from supportive
- 16:15forms of
- 16:16psychotherapy. More generally speaking,
- 16:19I would say that transference focused
- 16:22psychotherapy is a psychonalytic
- 16:25psychotherapy, not psychoanalysis
- 16:28proper. Psychonalysis is reserved by
- 16:31patients with less severe neurotic
- 16:34illness. But the severe personality
- 16:38disorders
- 16:39uh that we now call borderline
- 16:42personality
- 16:43organization uh can be treated with
- 16:48transference focused
- 16:49psychotherapy and that's preferable to
- 16:52treat them than to treat them with a
- 16:55supportive approach which may be carried
- 16:59out within a psychonalytic perspective
- 17:01or a cognitive behavioral approach. In
- 17:04general, you can divide treatments into
- 17:07cognitive behavioral ones that are very
- 17:10effective in for some patients in some
- 17:13circumstances in psychoanalytic
- 17:16psychotherapies that are effective with
- 17:19other patients in other circumstances.
- 17:22So
- 17:24I
- 17:25defined this specific psychotherapy
- 17:31um for borderline patients and
- 17:34um this is how uh well my career changed
- 17:40in the middle of this. I became the head
- 17:44of the psychotherapy research project of
- 17:47the maninga foundation but then was
- 17:50appointed director of the maninga
- 17:53hospital. So I some years I was
- 17:58simultaneously medical director of the
- 18:00hospital and director of the research
- 18:01project
- 18:03and then I felt I
- 18:05had nothing more to learn but I felt I
- 18:10needed a learning atmosphere to find
- 18:13different
- 18:15approaches different ways of dealing
- 18:18with psychiatry and psychotherapy.
- 18:21The Manga Foundation seemed to me
- 18:24a more limited place and I accepted
- 18:29invitation to become a professor at
- 18:33Colombia University New York. Went to
- 18:37Colombia where
- 18:41I really began to start out the
- 18:45treatment that I had devised. I was in
- 18:48charge of the the inpatient service for
- 18:51severe personality disorder and I
- 18:54gathered a group of people who after a
- 18:58few years we
- 19:02accepted moving to Cornell and um I
- 19:07became director of Westchester
- 19:11division hospital of the department of
- 19:15psychiatry at Cornell.
- 19:17Well, and uh together with the group we
- 19:20formed the personality disorders
- 19:22institute. And uh 20 years later um
- 19:27after I completed my directorship of the
- 19:31hospital, I dedicated myself exclusively
- 19:35to being the director of the personality
- 19:38disorders institute at Cornell with the
- 19:42help of some
- 19:44distinguished scientist John Clark and
- 19:47the director of our empirical research.
- 19:50Frank Yman's whom you have interviewed
- 19:53who is the director of overall training
- 19:56he's a fantastic
- 19:58psychotherapist and uh there were two or
- 20:02three more people group of six or seven
- 20:06who we
- 20:08first developed the
- 20:11diagnosis more clearly more sharply and
- 20:15described different types of
- 20:18personalities functioning
- 20:20at the borderline level the narcissistic
- 20:25personality, the most important one
- 20:28which we have been studying in great
- 20:30depth. But we also studied the paranoid
- 20:34personality, the schizoid
- 20:37personality,
- 20:40the the
- 20:43infantile or histrionic personality. So
- 20:47we did a a general study of personality
- 20:52disorders, their description and um
- 20:55differentiation into those with normal
- 21:01identity or neurotic personality
- 21:04organization with identity diffusion or
- 21:07borderline personality organization. And
- 21:10those atypical psychotic cases that
- 21:14presented as if they were personality
- 21:16disorders but with a more severe
- 21:19illness, a psychosis is a potential that
- 21:23might blow up or not in different cases.
- 21:28So we did we spent the time first on
- 21:32differential diagnostic studies and
- 21:35publications and then set up
- 21:38empirical study comparing
- 21:41uh transference focus
- 21:43psychotherapy with supportive
- 21:47psychotherapy and um with cognitive
- 21:51behavior therapy and confirmed the
- 21:55effectiveness of transference focus
- 21:57psychotherapy both in research carried
- 22:02out in the United States in in New York
- 22:06and then replicated in Europe under the
- 22:10direction of Stefan During, professor of
- 22:14psychonaris in psychiatry at the
- 22:17University of Vienna
- 22:20who gathered internally group that
- 22:24carried
- 22:25out parallel
- 22:28empirical
- 22:30research
- 22:31[Music]
- 22:33in in the German speaking
- 22:37countries and of course now we
- 22:40have groups in in many different
- 22:44countries and are continuing both
- 22:47research
- 22:49uh training and treating
- 22:52patients. Uh that's in a nutshell. Can
- 22:55you I hope I didn't put
- 22:58this into the technical terms. No, no,
- 23:02it's good. Um, can you specifically talk
- 23:05about how in the borderline level of
- 23:09functioning you have identity diffusion
- 23:12and primitive defenses and can you talk
- 23:15about the primitive defenses that you
- 23:17see? How do you identify them? Yes.
- 23:22Um Freud had defined the def the ego
- 23:28defenses against awareness of
- 23:31unconscious conflicts particularly
- 23:34repression and related
- 23:38defenses of
- 23:41suppression, rationalization,
- 23:46intellectualization, reaction formation.
- 23:49um those were unconscious defenses to be
- 23:54discovered in the course of the
- 23:56treatment of psycholytic
- 23:58treatment searching for the unconscious
- 24:01conflicts of these patients. Melanie
- 24:05Klene, who influenced
- 24:09me very importantly in in my psychonetic
- 24:13development,
- 24:15discovered a a group of primitive
- 24:19defenses centering around splitting or
- 24:22primitive dissociation. in which the way
- 24:27to deal with conflicts between love and
- 24:30aggression by sharp splitting of the
- 24:34emotional
- 24:36experience. So it is not a neurotic
- 24:40patient may act lovingly and represses
- 24:43his aggression or he may act
- 24:46aggressively and represses his loving
- 24:49potential. Borderline patients express
- 24:54simultaneously love and aggression but
- 24:57under different emotional
- 25:00conditions and they have memory of when
- 25:03they felt opposite to the way they feel
- 25:06now but they can't but feel can't help
- 25:10it and have to feel now the way they
- 25:12feel now. So when they feel enraged they
- 25:15are all rage then there's no love you
- 25:18when they feel love or love and no rage
- 25:21and they may shift from one to the other
- 25:24rather easily. So that's the mechanism
- 25:27of splitting and it creates chaos in
- 25:31their relationship because they
- 25:34are violent and brus changes of of mood
- 25:39and attitude that creates difficulty
- 25:42with other people who in turn
- 25:45respond to to that chaotic behavior with
- 25:49their own difficulties. And so
- 25:52personality disorders tend to create
- 25:55abnormal interactions with other people
- 25:58and distort all
- 26:00relationships. Um another mechan
- 26:04primitive mechanism is projective
- 26:07identification. Projective
- 26:09identification is a tendency to
- 26:12attribute to the other person what one
- 26:16cannot tolerate at the moment in
- 26:18oneself. So that while you are in a
- 26:21state of idealization, you project your
- 26:25own aggression onto somebody else,
- 26:28attribute somebody else is having
- 26:32aggressive motivation, aggressive
- 26:34behavior and you induce it in him
- 26:39without being aware of it and then try
- 26:41to control it. So projective
- 26:44identification is perception combined
- 26:48with induction, effort and control. And
- 26:52um uh it is the primitive form of what
- 26:57advanced mechanisms show in projection
- 27:01which is
- 27:03attributing
- 27:05something internal to somebody else but
- 27:08without any internal contact anymore
- 27:12with what you are projecting. In
- 27:16projection you just declare the other
- 27:19one is what you are not and you don't
- 27:22feel like that. In projective
- 27:25identification you attribute it to the
- 27:27other one but you know how it feels to
- 27:30feel like the other one and you produce
- 27:33it in the other one and you have to
- 27:35control it. So projective identification
- 27:39is primitive form of projection. Another
- 27:43mechanism is that of a very primitive
- 27:48idealization that um doesn't
- 27:53tolerate
- 27:55an opposite
- 27:59of modifying
- 28:02it with the realization of your own
- 28:06aggression toward the ideal object.
- 28:10uh the
- 28:13idealization or the higher level
- 28:15idealization recognizes one's own
- 28:19limitations. The primitive
- 28:21one there is somebody ideal and you
- 28:25identified with that
- 28:27implicitly become ideal as well. And the
- 28:31wish to omnipotent control the other
- 28:34person. the effort to deny that you've
- 28:39had a feeling or an action that you've
- 28:42had but it no longer exists because of
- 28:46splitting
- 28:47operation. This is the the primitive
- 28:50mechanism. So splitting, projective
- 28:54identification, omnipotent control,
- 28:57denial, these are typical primitive
- 29:00defensive operation and they show in the
- 29:02behavior of people. The advanced
- 29:04mechanism only showing the treatment.
- 29:07Primitive defenses show in the behavior
- 29:10in the habitual behavior of people who
- 29:14use projective identification and
- 29:16splitting and omnipotent control and
- 29:20deny aspects of themselves that have
- 29:22been evident at at other times.
- 29:26And so we can we
- 29:29can diagnose through these
- 29:34behaviors the personality disorder. H
- 29:38how do we diagnose the personality
- 29:40disorder?
- 29:41uh we try to find out how the person is
- 29:46functioning in work and
- 29:51profession, love and
- 29:53sex, social life, family
- 29:57relation, self
- 29:59affirmation and free time interests,
- 30:04hobbies
- 30:05and what we in the structural interview
- 30:10what We ask people
- 30:13mostly how are you doing in your work?
- 30:16Are you happy or not? Are you effective
- 30:19or not? Are you do you get along with
- 30:22other people or not? And we ask the same
- 30:25about their sexual life. Are you happy?
- 30:28Do you have a relationship? When sex
- 30:32becomes
- 30:34complicated, not only because it's a
- 30:36fundamental aspect of life that is in
- 30:42conventional reality is usually
- 30:44suppressed and and highly privileged.
- 30:48But um because it involves implicitly
- 30:54the
- 30:54integration of the erotic
- 30:58dimension, sexual excitement, orgasm
- 31:01sexual behavior with the emotional
- 31:04feelings of love and
- 31:07tenderness. And when we study sexuality,
- 31:11we study the extent to which the erotic
- 31:15and the emotional have been
- 31:18integrated, which is what happens
- 31:22maturely normally. in contrast to
- 31:25conflictual lack of integration by which
- 31:29the erotic and the
- 31:32emotional remain separate and create
- 31:35serious problems in intimate relations.
- 31:38So we try to find out about that. And
- 31:42regarding social life, we find out to
- 31:44what extent a person has friend a social
- 31:49environment that enriches life or feels
- 31:53isolated for whatever reason incapable
- 31:57of establishing things such as social
- 31:59life.
- 32:01To what extent is he able to establish
- 32:04relationship in
- 32:06depth, in friendship, not only in sexual
- 32:10love? Uh or to to what extent is this
- 32:14not possible? And with patients having
- 32:17borderline personality
- 32:19organization, usually they are serious
- 32:22problems in work and profession in love
- 32:26and sex and in their social life, family
- 32:31life such as between parents and
- 32:35children.
- 32:39So the present the careful study of
- 32:44functioning in present life leads to the
- 32:47diagnosis of the personality disorder.
- 32:50Can can you say a little bit more about
- 32:53when someone has this borderline level
- 32:56of
- 32:57organization and their sexual
- 33:00intimacy is um separated from or from
- 33:04more of the erotic side? Like how does
- 33:06that show up? What would a patient be
- 33:08saying to let you know that they've
- 33:11separated those two things? Yeah. First
- 33:14of all, I need
- 33:17to modify what I said that in that there
- 33:21are patients on a higher level of
- 33:24functioning on a neurotic level of
- 33:26functioning who also have such
- 33:29separation between love and sex, namely
- 33:34people with misochistic personality,
- 33:37which is a nonborderline personality
- 33:41disorder. But the borderline
- 33:45personality
- 33:47organization patients have the greatest
- 33:50difficulties. The most typical is
- 33:53presented by the narcissistic
- 33:56personality. Um the most typical cases
- 34:01then uh they have great difficulty for
- 34:05intimate relations. They can't maintain
- 34:07an intimate relation. The men have
- 34:10relation with women for a few months.
- 34:14That's all they tolerate before the
- 34:17relationship goes up in
- 34:19smoke. So they
- 34:21replace the lack of intimacy of love
- 34:26with freedom in sex. So you find men and
- 34:30the same thing holds for women. Men get
- 34:34involved with many women have great
- 34:37sexual relation and infatuation that
- 34:39lasts for weeks or a few months. Then
- 34:42they get bored, fed up, end of
- 34:45relationship on with the next. So that
- 34:49sex determines the capacity to maintain
- 34:55brief repetitive relationships without
- 34:59the capacity for relation in depth. On
- 35:02the other hand, they may maintain a very
- 35:05dependent relationship with one woman
- 35:08who has a kind of a motherly
- 35:11function with whom they have no sexual
- 35:14interest but are very dependent and
- 35:17exploitive.
- 35:19So they may be married men who act like
- 35:23children who are
- 35:26exploitive to women who tolerate that
- 35:29while they have the sexual pleasure with
- 35:32a number of women. That would be one
- 35:34way. Uh another possibility is
- 35:40uh
- 35:41that they have a full sexual relation
- 35:46but in which there is an alternation
- 35:49between intense aggression and rejection
- 35:53and then reounter
- 35:56uh sex permits them to reounter the
- 36:00relationship in which there is depth and
- 36:04dependency in contrast. to narcissistic
- 36:07personality. The ordinary
- 36:09non-narcissistic borderline patient is
- 36:12capable of maintaining long-term
- 36:15relationships. But within each of them
- 36:17chaos in which love and aggression shift
- 36:22rapidly and create chronic couple
- 36:27conflicts. Of course, there are some
- 36:30patients with a total inhibition of
- 36:34their sexual impulses in which there
- 36:37has been too much aggression in very
- 36:40early development to permit eroticism or
- 36:43develop or the strictly rigid
- 36:48excessively rigid education has kind of
- 36:51severely inhibited their sexual behavior
- 36:55or forced it
- 36:58into remaining at the level of infantile
- 37:04sexuality. Sexual life begin with birth.
- 37:08What we now know is that children if you
- 37:11leave if you leave babies alone in the
- 37:14sense you don't forbid sexual behavior
- 37:17they start masturbating in the second
- 37:20half of the first year of life and
- 37:22during the second year of life boys and
- 37:25girls
- 37:26masturbate girls in
- 37:29general tend to end this first
- 37:33masturbation phase around age three
- 37:37around age three but re-establish it
- 37:42later at age five or six. Boys tend to
- 37:46if not forbidden tend to masturbate all
- 37:48through until adulthood. Masturbation is
- 37:52a normal sexual
- 37:54activity when there's no other sexual
- 37:57outlet. And we have learned that it's a
- 38:00normal aspects of infantile
- 38:04psychology has taken us
- 38:08Sigman Freud and 100 years later to this
- 38:12slowly sinking in
- 38:15um even in
- 38:17the in the modern forms of the various
- 38:23western religions masturbation is no
- 38:27longer a major sin. Uh and
- 38:31so science has been able to modify our
- 38:36attitude towards sexuality. Mhm. But in
- 38:41general then in borderline personality
- 38:44organization either sexuality is
- 38:48combined so much with aggression that
- 38:51chronic chaotic conflict prevent a good
- 38:55sexual relationship. a stable one with
- 38:58stable love, stable sexual
- 39:02erotic gratification, excitement. Uh as
- 39:07an alternative to not being able, a
- 39:12woman may be sexually excited and
- 39:15orgasing with one man totally
- 39:19irres nonresponses to another one. So
- 39:23there may be sharp way
- 39:26of div splitting or division
- 39:30within the erotic
- 39:33life.
- 39:35Um I don't know whether I've answered
- 39:38your question. Do do you see with the
- 39:41narcissism specifically more of the
- 39:43sadism in the sexuality or is it is it
- 39:46specific to a certain personality type?
- 39:48How do you see that play out in in your
- 39:51in the work that you've done? We all
- 39:54have a potential for love and for
- 39:57aggression. That's
- 39:59universal. Usually love wins over
- 40:03aggression. From babyhood on who have
- 40:06more experience of good relation than
- 40:09bad ones. But of course they are
- 40:11traumatized children whose life has
- 40:14mostly bad experiences.
- 40:17there everything goes
- 40:20wrong under ordinary circumstances. We
- 40:24use aggression
- 40:27constructively by
- 40:29self-affirmation by endurance by
- 40:33defending ourselves realistically.
- 40:36And and aggression also enters sexuality
- 40:40in the sense
- 40:43that from the beginning of life there is
- 40:46a pleasure in penetrating and being
- 40:51penetrated that already has an erotic
- 40:54quality.
- 40:56The there is an erotic quality in in
- 41:00biting, in being bitten, in
- 41:04um in fusing lovingly with the other by
- 41:09touching skin as well as feeling that
- 41:12one penetrates the body of the other or
- 41:15is being penetrated.
- 41:19So the erotic impulses show from the
- 41:24beginning of life in uh the capacity to
- 41:29experience sexual
- 41:31excitement and to the erotic pleasure in
- 41:37watching one's partner the baby watching
- 41:42mother and mother watching the baby
- 41:45which is the origin of why ism or sexual
- 41:50pleasure with seeing the sexually
- 41:54prohibited part of
- 41:56others and exhibitionism which is the
- 41:59opposite the erotic pleasure in showing
- 42:03one's forbidden parts to other to excite
- 42:06them. In
- 42:08masochism, the slight pleasure in mild
- 42:14pain that is part of sexual
- 42:18excitement and sadistic pleasure in
- 42:22inducing pain in the other which is part
- 42:26of sexual excitement when it is within a
- 42:30dominant loving atmosphere and signals
- 42:34the erotic pleasure of mutual fuel.
- 42:38losing. When there's an excessive degree
- 42:41of
- 42:42aggression, then these
- 42:45tendencies become dominant and create
- 42:49problems.
- 42:51And the most important problem is that
- 42:55excessive aggression makes ordinary
- 42:58sexual intercourse dangerous
- 43:02uh dangerous to penetrate, dangerous to
- 43:05be penetrated.
- 43:08And uh so one remains with a childlike
- 43:12equivalence of
- 43:14masturbation,
- 43:16virism,
- 43:19exhibitionism,
- 43:21[Music]
- 43:22fetishism. We call them perversion or
- 43:27paraphilas when they become
- 43:31indispensable preludes to sexual
- 43:33intercourse. when the individual only
- 43:36acquires the security of sexual
- 43:39excitement and orgasm after having
- 43:42fulfilled these
- 43:45pre-genital early
- 43:47[Music]
- 43:48erotic desires. So, so perversions are
- 43:53really sexual inhibitions of the
- 43:56ordinary sexual behavior.
- 44:00retreat from it into the infantile
- 44:03equivalence.
- 44:06Normal sexual relation however includes
- 44:10all those infantile components. So a
- 44:12couple that has a good mature sexual
- 44:17relationship may have games and plays
- 44:20and fantasies and activities of a
- 44:23misoistic sadistic as
- 44:26exhibitionistic varistic heterosexual
- 44:29and homosexual quality and a
- 44:33propomosexuality and
- 44:34heterosexuality
- 44:36unconsciousness. We have both
- 44:39tendencies although usually one clearly
- 44:42predominates in most cases. But there
- 44:46are persons who of course who maintain
- 44:51both homosexual and heterosexual
- 44:54impulses of various degrees. So
- 44:58sexuality becomes complicated is has
- 45:02been accentuated in recent fashions and
- 45:06political movements.
- 45:09One one thing that I really loved about
- 45:12the when I read the transference focused
- 45:15therapy articles is when they looked at
- 45:18reflective function before and after
- 45:21transference focus therapy. And I think
- 45:24transferred focus therapy is one of the
- 45:26only therapies that has shown an
- 45:29improvement in reflective
- 45:32function. Um reflective function being
- 45:35measured by the adult attachment
- 45:37interview. Phone was the main uh
- 45:40originator of that manual.
- 45:43Um, do you have any thoughts on why
- 45:47transference focus therapy increases
- 45:49reflective function where things like
- 45:51dialectical behavioral therapy did not
- 45:53show any change in reflective function?
- 45:57Because
- 46:00transference transference focused
- 46:03psychotherapy permits the full
- 46:07expression of a
- 46:09conflict in its positive and negative
- 46:13aspects. Patients who develop a negative
- 46:17transference, we don't try to reduce it.
- 46:21To the contrary, we try for the patient
- 46:24to experience fully
- 46:27the negative transference in in terms of
- 46:31identifying with the hostility of the
- 46:35object
- 46:37and the self as victim and then with the
- 46:40hostility of the self and the object as
- 46:43victim. In other words, we try to
- 46:46familiarize the patient to make him
- 46:49accept the extreme of his
- 46:53reaction to then confront him with the
- 46:57opposite extreme that we also tolerate
- 47:01of the intensity of loving and erotic
- 47:04impulses to the
- 47:06therapist.
- 47:07both is doer and
- 47:11recipient of of love. So that by
- 47:16permitting the full expression of the
- 47:19extremes of love and aggression, we
- 47:24facilitate the interpretive integration
- 47:28of them and permit the patient to
- 47:32tolerate the simultaneous contradictory
- 47:37impulses part of normal human
- 47:41ambivalence. And the patient then is
- 47:45able to see that yes he has an ideal
- 47:49view of himself as a very nice person
- 47:52but in in part of him is also a nasty
- 47:55person and introspection or
- 47:59insight consists in the capacity of an
- 48:03integrated view of all potential that
- 48:06one
- 48:07has in contrast to remain
- 48:10splitting to in into a false idealized
- 48:16version completely separate from all
- 48:19aggression. So
- 48:22selfreflection signifies a realistic way
- 48:25of assessing one in one's strength and
- 48:28weaknesses good and bad aspects is a
- 48:32it's a mature distance from
- 48:36oneself is acting in any concrete
- 48:39interaction. So, a lot of people do not
- 48:44like the idea that we all have
- 48:47aggression, right? And what I'm hearing
- 48:51from you is that you
- 48:53really allow the patient to feel the
- 48:56full weight of their
- 48:59aggressiveness. And um that's very
- 49:02different than like trying to give them
- 49:05coping strategies or trying to tell
- 49:08them, "No, you're not really aggressive.
- 49:10you're not really angry. So like give me
- 49:13some examples or help me understand
- 49:16uh how you might help
- 49:19someone tolerate their own aggression.
- 49:22Take a marital
- 49:24conflict.
- 49:25[Music]
- 49:27Um a
- 49:29woman hates her man because he has been
- 49:34um treating her badly during breakfast.
- 49:39has not been coming home, has forgotten
- 49:43something
- 49:44important, gets enraged at him. Uh he in
- 49:48turn gets
- 49:50enraged defending himself. They are in
- 49:53the middle of a big fight, but at the
- 49:56same time they both have a
- 49:59consciousness that they love each other
- 50:02and that fight is going to end in a in a
- 50:06good way into a good relationship. They
- 50:09have no doubts about that. They
- 50:13tolerate bad momentary interaction with
- 50:17a deep conviction of the consistency of
- 50:21a dominant love. In contrast to to
- 50:25another couple who when they are enraged
- 50:28they feel this is the end. I'm walking
- 50:30out of this. I don't want to see that
- 50:33man ever again or that woman never
- 50:35again. So the uh the the
- 50:40the
- 50:42tolerance of one's fighting mood when
- 50:46one is
- 50:47angry with the consciousness of the
- 50:50permanent of the deep
- 50:52relationship that transcends the
- 50:55momentary one. That is what
- 50:59characterizes
- 51:00self-reflectiveness. the capacity to see
- 51:04one's overall relationship rather than
- 51:07being victim of a certain mood and then
- 51:11having the sense that there's no other
- 51:14possibility as that particular
- 51:18mood.
- 51:19Uh a man gets enraged at the way his
- 51:26wife is treating the children and um
- 51:30gets so enraged you say you do this once
- 51:34again I walk out and he's ready to walk
- 51:36out and then drop the relationship. So
- 51:40there is an
- 51:41intolerance
- 51:43of the bad unavoidable bad aspects of of
- 51:48any relationship of daily
- 51:50life. Tolerance of
- 51:53ambivalence is really what marks
- 51:56self-reflectiveness.
- 51:59what Kleinian psychonalysis calls the
- 52:03depressive
- 52:04position, which is the sense of the
- 52:08potential for sadness, for treating
- 52:12badly people one really
- 52:15loves. All of us have moments in which
- 52:19we don't treat those we love well.
- 52:24It takes a baby
- 52:28um a year or two to realize that the
- 52:33mother that he hates when he hates her
- 52:36is the same mother that he loves when he
- 52:39loves her and eventually has the
- 52:42capacity of feeling depressed when he's
- 52:46angry at the mother that he loves and is
- 52:50sad over losing the mother that he loves
- 52:52because he's so angry. That is an
- 52:56indication of mature reflection. The
- 52:59capacity for reaction with
- 53:03sadness about one's own reaction and the
- 53:07awareness that one has a different
- 53:13general a different general relationship
- 53:16with somebody with one is in a momentary
- 53:21mood very different from the usual
- 53:24habitual one. A person who tends to
- 53:30be kind of rough
- 53:32and acting superior with subordinates
- 53:36has a kind of inappropriate
- 53:39grandiosity. May recognize that he has
- 53:42that tendency and
- 53:44uh accept that he has problem in the way
- 53:48he treats others that he has to correct
- 53:51and uh that becomes part of his
- 53:54personality.
- 53:55watching out uh what he knows are
- 54:00problems in his own tendencies that in
- 54:02that indicates
- 54:06self-reflection. The general intention
- 54:09how we should behave with others
- 54:12controls the immediate behavior even if
- 54:15it's very different of what his general
- 54:17attitude is. M this is what what we mean
- 54:21by an integrated view of self
- 54:27and an integrated view of others.
- 54:31Um I mean a man comes home with a
- 54:34serious mind and his wife thinks oh he
- 54:37doesn't love me
- 54:40anymore. That's then he comes home with
- 54:43a friendly face. Ah he loves me. She
- 54:47doesn't have the capacity to know that
- 54:49he loves her whether he's in a good mood
- 54:51or a bad
- 54:52mood. The integration of his present
- 54:56mood into his general relation with her
- 55:00indicates maturity. Integration of the
- 55:04object representation.
- 55:06So integration of self representation
- 55:09and integration of object
- 55:12representation mark
- 55:14normality, normal identity and capacity
- 55:19for refractiveness. And we develop that
- 55:22throughout the treatment that tends to
- 55:25resolve primitive defensive operations,
- 55:28normalize identity and uh therefore
- 55:32normalize the capacity of dealing with
- 55:35the major task of work and profession,
- 55:39love and
- 55:40sex, social life and one's own
- 55:44creativity. Tell me about your thoughts
- 55:46on
- 55:47envy and how someone with um maybe more
- 55:52narcissistic
- 55:54uh borderline level functioning how envy
- 55:57shows up for them versus maybe normal
- 56:00people.
- 56:02A very good question. Um uh envy is a is
- 56:08a
- 56:10normal aggressive
- 56:13affect with very specific
- 56:16characteristics. It is anger at somebody
- 56:20who has something that we want and we
- 56:23don't
- 56:23have. So we want something that we don't
- 56:27have and are angry at whoever has it
- 56:32when we
- 56:34don't.
- 56:35Um it is a normal way in which a baby
- 56:40sees another baby has a toy is that he
- 56:43he wants to have that toy and gets angry
- 56:47if he doesn't get that toy or something
- 56:50exactly like it. Um so it is a human em
- 56:55emotion that is one of the negative
- 56:58aspects of our potential that normally
- 57:01we have we tolerate it doesn't control
- 57:04our
- 57:05lives with narcissistic personality the
- 57:08problem is
- 57:10they present very intense aggression
- 57:15that takes the form of envy. Usually the
- 57:19cause of that is a lack of
- 57:23loving sufficiently loving
- 57:26relationship in very very early life in
- 57:31the first two or three years of life.
- 57:35When one feels
- 57:37loved, one feels one
- 57:40internalizes a good
- 57:42representation of others and feels
- 57:45fulfilled by the people who have been
- 57:49good to one. If one doesn't have any of
- 57:52this, there's a sense of emptiness and
- 57:54one gets
- 57:57painful the painful observer that other
- 58:00people feel so good about their relation
- 58:03with others while we feel so bad.
- 58:07So envy becomes a a very strong
- 58:15motivation because basically we don't
- 58:19feel the internalization of love that
- 58:23others
- 58:24have and envy then grows to the extent
- 58:30that whatever we like and don't have
- 58:35enraged es
- 58:38us. It destroys our relationship because
- 58:42whomever we could love and be friendly
- 58:46with turns out to have things that we
- 58:48don't have to give to begin with the
- 58:52very capacity to love.
- 58:54So the weight and envy is very gives one
- 58:59a painful sense of lacking of
- 59:03emptiness and the way
- 59:06to fight it off is to devalue what one
- 59:18environ response to our behavior from
- 59:22others. We feel very happy that others
- 59:26love us and we see it as a gift. In
- 59:30other words, normally we have a feeling
- 59:33of gratitude for love that we get.
- 59:38Envious person lack their capacity of
- 59:42gratitude
- 59:44because what they get gives them a sense
- 59:48what they didn't
- 59:50have. It reminds them of what they
- 59:53didn't have which colors what they get.
- 59:57They happy that they get it but they
- 59:59don't have that feeling of happiness
- 1:00:02with the happiness that the other feels
- 1:00:06in giving them something.
- 1:00:09Uh so envy tends to spoil what one envys
- 1:00:15which means that narcissistic
- 1:00:17personality fall in love with the woman
- 1:00:21unconsciously hate what they admire in
- 1:00:24her from her physical appearance to her
- 1:00:27capacity to her potential. And so
- 1:00:31unconsciously they tend to devaluate and
- 1:00:34that makes this woman indifferent and
- 1:00:38boring and they have to drop her. So
- 1:00:41unconscious envy the defenses the
- 1:00:45defense against it by devaluation is
- 1:00:48what motivates the sexual promiscuity of
- 1:00:51narcissistic personalities.
- 1:00:54The counterpart of envy is a an
- 1:00:58unconscious destruction of the values
- 1:01:01that others have and that one
- 1:01:05doesn't. Students with a narcissistic
- 1:01:10personality can learn only what they
- 1:01:13feel they learn because they take over
- 1:01:17what others know. They incorporate the
- 1:01:20knowledge from other. That's a kind of
- 1:01:24it's like stealing from
- 1:01:27other makes them feel good. But when
- 1:01:30they have to
- 1:01:32acknowledge that they depend on the
- 1:01:35other, it spoils it because then envy is
- 1:01:39unavoidable. Narcissistic personalities
- 1:01:42can learn from what they learn by what
- 1:01:45they feel they are learning by
- 1:01:47themselves without anybody giving them
- 1:01:50anything. They take it from others but
- 1:01:53they can't read a book. They can't learn
- 1:01:55from a book because they have to there's
- 1:01:57independent knowledge from them and they
- 1:02:00resent it.
- 1:02:03So you find very intelligent people who
- 1:02:06can't read a book or or spoil their own
- 1:02:10capacity of interest in a certain field.
- 1:02:15So
- 1:02:16envy tends to ruin the capacity to
- 1:02:22absorb good things, establish good
- 1:02:25relationship in in the worst case
- 1:02:28scenario. One cannot enjoy anything
- 1:02:31except being
- 1:02:33admired which is recognizing of one's
- 1:02:37greatness by the others. And in one of
- 1:02:41the predisposition to the narcissistic
- 1:02:45personality are parents who really don't
- 1:02:48love the children but they are happy
- 1:02:51with ad admirable things that children
- 1:02:54have that others admire. The child the
- 1:02:57parent the narcissistic parent uses the
- 1:03:01child is something great
- 1:03:04that look what beautiful children I
- 1:03:07have. So they admire their child but
- 1:03:10they don't love it.
- 1:03:13So when the when love is replaced by
- 1:03:16admiration is the only source of what
- 1:03:20love one receives it fosters
- 1:03:22narcissistic
- 1:03:24personality. One has no hope for love.
- 1:03:28Only when others admire one one can feel
- 1:03:31good about oneself.
- 1:03:34So the psychopathology of envy is very
- 1:03:38damaging
- 1:03:41and a major issue in the treatment that
- 1:03:45one solves by analyzing all its causes
- 1:03:49and consequences.
- 1:03:52You you mentioned uh histrionic
- 1:03:57personality before. Do you do you see
- 1:03:59this on the the borderline level of
- 1:04:01functioning or more the neurotic or
- 1:04:03both? There is a confusion in the
- 1:04:05literature about this.
- 1:04:09Uh there exists a high level personality
- 1:04:13disorder, the hysterical personality
- 1:04:17disorder with which has normal identity
- 1:04:21and then the main problem is sexual
- 1:04:26inhibition and efforts to overcome the
- 1:04:29sexual inhibition by various means.
- 1:04:32Sexuality is a great problem. They act
- 1:04:35quite maturely except when it comes to
- 1:04:38sex when they become quite
- 1:04:41childish.
- 1:04:43Now because politically hysterical
- 1:04:48personality usually went together with
- 1:04:51an attack of women because the
- 1:04:53impression was that only women had
- 1:04:56hysterical personality which is false.
- 1:04:59Men also present hysterical
- 1:05:03personalities. The official
- 1:05:05classification of
- 1:05:07personality disorders called it
- 1:05:10histrionic personality disorder. told to
- 1:05:13take it away from its political
- 1:05:16implication. And the histrionic
- 1:05:18personality
- 1:05:20disorder in the official classification
- 1:05:23covers both the
- 1:05:25hysterical and the histrionic in a
- 1:05:29strict sense equivalent to the infantile
- 1:05:33personality which
- 1:05:36are are patients who have sexual
- 1:05:40difficulties. but part of a general
- 1:05:43severe personality disorder with
- 1:05:46identity
- 1:05:48diffusion. So that the histrionic
- 1:05:51personality how it is used generally
- 1:05:54refers to a broad spectrum. Most of them
- 1:05:57are really have borderline personality
- 1:06:01organization when in fact a
- 1:06:05subgroup is part of a higher level
- 1:06:08neurotic
- 1:06:10organization. How do we make that
- 1:06:14differentiation? The histrionic
- 1:06:16personality disorder is childlike or
- 1:06:20infantile in all aspects of life.
- 1:06:24work, profession, school, love, sex,
- 1:06:27social life, and
- 1:06:31uh is part of this childlike
- 1:06:35regression. Feelings are expressed
- 1:06:38through behavior more than
- 1:06:42verbally. And the exaggeration of
- 1:06:46behavior is what from the outside looks
- 1:06:50at theatric theatricality.
- 1:06:54an
- 1:06:55exaggeration
- 1:06:59theatrical exaggerated behavior which
- 1:07:02has an infantile quality to it and is
- 1:07:06important aspects of those personality
- 1:07:09disorders. Histrionic
- 1:07:13means
- 1:07:15a behavioral
- 1:07:17exaggeration of real feelings one has
- 1:07:21and conveys a sense of
- 1:07:24artificiality in contrast to the
- 1:07:27expression of real feelings in a
- 1:07:30profound sense.
- 1:07:32So these are patients who give the
- 1:07:35feeling that they exaggerate that they
- 1:07:39do theater with what they feel to
- 1:07:42impress
- 1:07:43others as if it were a profound in lack
- 1:07:48of sincerity, lack of
- 1:07:51honesty when it is really part of a
- 1:07:54general
- 1:07:56childlike regression to childlike
- 1:07:59communication of affect. M
- 1:08:04so the histrionic personality are
- 1:08:07personalities with childlike behavior in
- 1:08:11all their interaction that may
- 1:08:14include sexual inhibition but very often
- 1:08:18surprisingly doesn't so often the
- 1:08:21histrionic personality on a boral level
- 1:08:25are freer sexually than the hysterical
- 1:08:28personality on a neurotic level because
- 1:08:31The hysterical personality using the
- 1:08:34mechanism of
- 1:08:36repression inhibits totally the sexual
- 1:08:39response while the borderline
- 1:08:42personality by the splitting mechanism
- 1:08:46is able to have great sex with one
- 1:08:48partners and zero with others. So in a
- 1:08:52strange way, borderline patients may be
- 1:08:56freer often
- 1:08:58sexually than higher level neurotic
- 1:09:02patients. The main problem is in the
- 1:09:04relationship with others. And of course,
- 1:09:08borderline patients who on top of all
- 1:09:10their problems have an extremely severe
- 1:09:14sexual inhibition with zero capacity for
- 1:09:18any sexual excitement or
- 1:09:21enjoyment constitute the most serious
- 1:09:26part most serious part of sexual
- 1:09:29inhibition that don't that requires
- 1:09:33long-term treatment.
- 1:09:35Do you want to talk about borderline
- 1:09:37level of functioning with the paranoid
- 1:09:40personality type? Like what what is kind
- 1:09:42of like the thing that is most common
- 1:09:45with that group?
- 1:09:47Paranoid
- 1:09:50personalities are using the mechanism of
- 1:09:54projective
- 1:09:55identification as a dominant mechanism.
- 1:09:59They are part of borderline personality
- 1:10:02organization with intense aggression
- 1:10:06that they attribute to
- 1:10:08others. Uh because of that mechanism
- 1:10:12meaning that they are hyper sensitive to
- 1:10:15anything that can be interpreted as a
- 1:10:19negative attitude toward them. They are
- 1:10:21suspicious that others behavior
- 1:10:24indicates
- 1:10:26hostility to the
- 1:10:29person hostility or the effort to uh to
- 1:10:36disguise or hide hostility.
- 1:10:39At the same time, they tend to be very
- 1:10:42aggressive because they have excessive
- 1:10:45aggression and they tend to use
- 1:10:49omnipotent control efforts to control
- 1:10:52the other person whom they see is
- 1:10:56dominated by aggression toward them. So
- 1:10:58the combination of aggressive
- 1:11:04behavior,
- 1:11:06hyper
- 1:11:09suspiciousness and um efforts of
- 1:11:13sadistic control of others are the main
- 1:11:16characteristics of the paranoid
- 1:11:18personality. And and you touched on um
- 1:11:22schizoid a little bit. Schizoid with
- 1:11:25borderline level of functioning. Yeah.
- 1:11:27Um the the skitsoid personality uses
- 1:11:32predominantly the mechanism of
- 1:11:35splitting in effort to avoid conflicts
- 1:11:41by
- 1:11:44such generalized splitting of the
- 1:11:48expression of all a effects that it is
- 1:11:52as if they had no
- 1:11:54affects. there is a kind of a
- 1:11:56fragmentation of a effect as if extreme
- 1:12:00forms of
- 1:12:03splitting. Uh so they fragment both
- 1:12:08their aggressive
- 1:12:11affects and um
- 1:12:15uh withdraw from contacts in order not
- 1:12:19to be tempted to become aggressive.
- 1:12:24And um
- 1:12:26they fragment
- 1:12:29the view of themselves as aggressive to
- 1:12:32avoid
- 1:12:35it. And
- 1:12:37um
- 1:12:39sometimes they show a very sharp
- 1:12:43perception of others because they are so
- 1:12:46suspicious and so
- 1:12:48observant. Nothing escapes them. They
- 1:12:51are very good in spite of the identity
- 1:12:54diffusion
- 1:12:56to know exactly what to expect from
- 1:13:00others but about self they have a
- 1:13:03complete
- 1:13:06confusion because of the fragmentation
- 1:13:09of all affective experience. So the
- 1:13:14identity diffusion shows in
- 1:13:17sharp description of others while they
- 1:13:21look an integrated view of them. It's
- 1:13:25they see the wood, they see the trees
- 1:13:28but they don't see the wood.
- 1:13:33um and
- 1:13:35um and they withdraw
- 1:13:39protectively from avoiding aggressive
- 1:13:42interaction with others. They are in
- 1:13:45they look as if they didn't need
- 1:13:50affect effective relation and love.
- 1:13:53That's a mistake. They do need love but
- 1:13:57they are afraid that uh their own
- 1:14:01aggression will destroy the effective
- 1:14:04potential of a good relation with
- 1:14:06significant others.
- 1:14:09So the with
- 1:14:11withdrawal protects them
- 1:14:14from direct search for love and to the
- 1:14:19contrary one has they have to do a
- 1:14:22tremendous effort to be able to express
- 1:14:27any close relationship with others. So
- 1:14:32their relationships are distant.
- 1:14:36the a effect is
- 1:14:38dispersed. So it's hard for them to know
- 1:14:43what they really want. And they are
- 1:14:47ignorant of their own deep need for love
- 1:14:52that they have to reject out of fear of
- 1:14:56being
- 1:14:58rejected. And so there is
- 1:15:02hyper alertness to what's going
- 1:15:06on but without the aggression of the
- 1:15:11paranoid personality
- 1:15:15social withdrawal rather than omnipotent
- 1:15:18control and and a sense of
- 1:15:23uncomfort and loneliness and distance in
- 1:15:27group situations.
- 1:15:29So a sense of
- 1:15:31loneliness, confusion about the
- 1:15:34self, not clear awareness of their need
- 1:15:38of significant
- 1:15:40others and their capturing of the great
- 1:15:45details of the personality of others
- 1:15:48without really putting it together into
- 1:15:51an integrated view. These are the main
- 1:15:54characteristics of the skitsoid
- 1:15:57personality and the so-called schizoid
- 1:16:00schizotypical is just a more severe form
- 1:16:04of that except that in the
- 1:16:08schizotypal there is a genetic stronger
- 1:16:12genetic
- 1:16:14hereditary disposition than in the
- 1:16:17schizoid personality.
- 1:16:19What role does fantasy play for
- 1:16:21schizotiple and schizoid?
- 1:16:24In withdrawing from immediate social
- 1:16:27reality for the reasons that I
- 1:16:29mentioned, they replace their
- 1:16:32interaction with others by an intense
- 1:16:35fantasy life. They find in their intense
- 1:16:39fantasy life an expression of their need
- 1:16:42of relating to others. So they are
- 1:16:46particularly prone to to create their
- 1:16:50own internal world gratifying their
- 1:16:53needs because they don't dare to express
- 1:16:57it in external reality out of the fear
- 1:17:01of their own aggression. How about
- 1:17:03someone who's classically borderline
- 1:17:05personality disorder? Do you how do you
- 1:17:08make of their their intense fear of
- 1:17:12disconnection of of the withdrawal of
- 1:17:15the other? Because the
- 1:17:19splitting operation
- 1:17:23uh and the activation of intense
- 1:17:28aggression toward people whom they love.
- 1:17:32They project the aggression and any real
- 1:17:37frustration creates an exaggerated
- 1:17:40reaction. They are afraid of being left,
- 1:17:44of being dropped, of being abandoned
- 1:17:48because they see others with the intense
- 1:17:52aggression that they can't tolerate in
- 1:17:55themselves.
- 1:17:58So they
- 1:18:01take one way to solve the dilemma
- 1:18:04between love and aggression is to look
- 1:18:08for an ideal relation with the other is
- 1:18:12a protection against the feared
- 1:18:14aggressive rejection by the other. So
- 1:18:17they become very dependent and
- 1:18:20intolerable of being separate. that that
- 1:18:24intolerance of separation has to do with
- 1:18:27the fact that any separation is
- 1:18:29immediately translated into a sense of
- 1:18:32an aggressive
- 1:18:34rejection of the patient. What do you
- 1:18:37think of most therapists who come into
- 1:18:40practice? Do you find them more of the
- 1:18:42depressive personality type or what kind
- 1:18:46of range have you seen?
- 1:18:48Well, I've had a long professional life
- 1:18:52and I've seen I've seen I
- 1:18:57think a
- 1:18:59very broad spectrum of patients. Yes, I
- 1:19:04believe I've seen probably most patients
- 1:19:07described in the literature.
- 1:19:11Is is there a commonality of of the
- 1:19:13helper of the person that wants to help?
- 1:19:16maybe maybe of the person where there
- 1:19:18was a role reversal early on in their
- 1:19:20childhood where they were the ones who
- 1:19:22were like the family therapist even at a
- 1:19:24very young age. Where do those people
- 1:19:26fit in your sort of I I think that
- 1:19:30um therapists may have many reasons for
- 1:19:35becoming a therapist. Very often uh
- 1:19:39persons who have had strong personal
- 1:19:42problems that they have overcome then
- 1:19:45want to become
- 1:19:47therapists out of an experience of
- 1:19:49gratitude and identification with the
- 1:19:52people who help
- 1:19:54them. Some people are looking for
- 1:19:56solution of their own problems in
- 1:19:59helping others.
- 1:20:02[Music]
- 1:20:04For some people, it is a source of
- 1:20:08great
- 1:20:10gratification to have a profession that
- 1:20:15helps
- 1:20:16others
- 1:20:17and there go all the motivations for
- 1:20:21medical
- 1:20:23professions, nursing, psychology
- 1:20:27uh including that of psychotherapist
- 1:20:32uh interested in the psychological
- 1:20:35functioning of self and others and how
- 1:20:38to modify it. There are some people who
- 1:20:41become
- 1:20:44psychotherapists secondary to their
- 1:20:46interests in neurobiology in the
- 1:20:49functioning of the
- 1:20:53brain. Uh
- 1:20:57sometimes
- 1:21:00psychotherapists have the unconscious
- 1:21:02motivation of
- 1:21:04um helping
- 1:21:07others out of the situation in which the
- 1:21:11therapist had been in the
- 1:21:16past broadening the effect of of his
- 1:21:20treatment. And um one thing that was
- 1:21:24important for me was uh that sense of
- 1:21:29being able to change one's way of
- 1:21:32behavior. I had ways of behaving I was
- 1:21:35not happy with and I had difficulty
- 1:21:39changing and I wanted to know how much
- 1:21:43change can one obtain in self and in
- 1:21:46others. M that drew me to get into a
- 1:21:50personal psychonalysis first and then
- 1:21:54became interested in psychotherapy in
- 1:21:56general.
- 1:21:58And and how much did you change?
- 1:22:01I I changed
- 1:22:03significantly. I changed significantly.
- 1:22:06I had two personal analysis. So I had
- 1:22:11people helping me and um and I
- 1:22:15had the luck of great
- 1:22:19teachers really an unusual luck with
- 1:22:24met number of the leaders of the field
- 1:22:28with some of them became real friends
- 1:22:30[Music]
- 1:22:31and that was very important. I owe a
- 1:22:36great
- 1:22:36deal uh to people such
- 1:22:41as Ad
- 1:22:44Jacobson and
- 1:22:45[Music]
- 1:22:47um Andre
- 1:22:49Green and Betty
- 1:22:52Joseph and many others. But it it sounds
- 1:22:56like you were also a great student
- 1:22:58because when he gives when he tells you
- 1:23:01to read the book, you read the 12
- 1:23:03volumes. sounds like you which
- 1:23:07it's an unusual unusual student to come
- 1:23:09back and said I I read the 12 volumes
- 1:23:13I admired him greatly
- 1:23:15and and it was worth it. It I learned
- 1:23:19the scriptive
- 1:23:20psychiatry more than most psychiatrist
- 1:23:24of my generation. It helped me to become
- 1:23:28very
- 1:23:29observant about small issues of
- 1:23:32behavior. It really was a I got a
- 1:23:36specialized training.
- 1:23:40What would you
- 1:23:41say is something that you feel a lot of
- 1:23:44therapists don't understand that you
- 1:23:46wish they would understand at this
- 1:23:48point? It's very difficult
- 1:23:52to generalize. I
- 1:23:56um my experience is mainly with
- 1:24:00psychonamic psychotherapists is I have
- 1:24:03limited experience of working with the
- 1:24:06cognitive behavior
- 1:24:08therapists although I do have some and
- 1:24:12I'm very impressed by what some
- 1:24:15cognitive behavior therapy can
- 1:24:17achieve but for psychonalytic
- 1:24:21psychotherapist I think the most
- 1:24:24important issue is
- 1:24:27um first of all comfort
- 1:24:32with one's own aggression.
- 1:24:36Therapists have to be comfortable with
- 1:24:38their own aggression, not having to act
- 1:24:42it out nor being afraid of it. That's
- 1:24:46one important issue.
- 1:24:49One of course a crucial issue is having
- 1:24:52a real interest in people and getting to
- 1:24:54know about people being curious about
- 1:24:59how how other people are
- 1:25:02functioning. There are many
- 1:25:05therapists who don't pay sufficient
- 1:25:07attention to
- 1:25:09that. Then I think psychotherapists need
- 1:25:12to have a great s a great common sense.
- 1:25:16Uh psychotherapy starts where common
- 1:25:19sense ends. And uh in order to deal with
- 1:25:24the subtlety of com conflicts, one has
- 1:25:28to have first a good hold of solid
- 1:25:34reality. I think that therapist can come
- 1:25:37from many direction. They can come from
- 1:25:39a very intuitive emotional direction or
- 1:25:43a very intellectual ones and they have
- 1:25:46to learn to complement what comes
- 1:25:50natural with what they have to learn.
- 1:25:53The very intellectual one have to learn
- 1:25:57about expression of emotions and the
- 1:26:01most emotional intuitive one have to
- 1:26:05learn how to formulate things
- 1:26:08cognitively a a really a a strong wish
- 1:26:12to help other people. I think these are
- 1:26:17the most important ingredients.
- 1:26:20Yeah, that's good.
- 1:26:22Well, as we kind of I I I don't want to
- 1:26:25take too much of your time today and um
- 1:26:27I could I I I feel like almost a part
- 1:26:30two is necessary to to hash out some
- 1:26:32more of these ideas, but um or part 10
- 1:26:35or part 11, but I'm I'm curious as we've
- 1:26:39talked today
- 1:26:41um if any lingering ideas are going
- 1:26:45through your mind that you haven't had
- 1:26:47adequate time to express. I think
- 1:26:51the the great goal of treatment are to
- 1:26:55help people to become more
- 1:26:59effectively
- 1:27:02self-affirmative and at the same time
- 1:27:04more capable to develop relationship in
- 1:27:08depth with
- 1:27:09others. These are two basic issues of
- 1:27:14normal
- 1:27:15functioning to take care of one's
- 1:27:18relations with
- 1:27:20others and to take care of oneself in a
- 1:27:23reasonable
- 1:27:26way. Acquire full responsibility for
- 1:27:30one's behavior in one's life. One one
- 1:27:34more one more question. Yes. What
- 1:27:37was do you do you feel like there's any
- 1:27:40room to explore the thing that you were
- 1:27:42doing before you did the psychoanalysis
- 1:27:45two times that you wanted to change and
- 1:27:48did you actually feel it changed?
- 1:27:52Are you asking me whether I was
- 1:27:54considering some other profession? No,
- 1:27:57no, no, no. You you said earlier there
- 1:28:01was something about yourself that you
- 1:28:04wanted to change through through
- 1:28:06psychoanalysis.
- 1:28:08Do you is there anything else you would
- 1:28:10be willing to share about that publicly?
- 1:28:14Uh well I I don't want to share too many
- 1:28:19personal issues but
- 1:28:21um I used to be
- 1:28:24quite
- 1:28:27obsessive
- 1:28:29excessively intellectual and I have
- 1:28:32become much freer with my emotions.
- 1:28:36Well I I thank you for that and thank
- 1:28:39you for coming on. I've really enjoyed
- 1:28:40my time talking to you Dr. Kernburgg.
- 1:28:43It's a it's a
- 1:28:44pleasure and uh I I'm I'm very grateful
- 1:28:49for for your your many uh articles and
- 1:28:53books and
- 1:28:56um there was just a
- 1:28:57recent biography that was written about
- 1:28:59you. I think uh Yman's wrote it in part
- 1:29:04that I apprec I've appreciated and um I
- 1:29:08know my the people that have been
- 1:29:09listening to my podcast for a while have
- 1:29:11been grateful for his expertise and I'm
- 1:29:13sure they'll be grateful for you coming
- 1:29:14on today. So, thank you so much. You're
- 1:29:17most welcome. It's been has been a
- 1:29:19pleasure. I'm glad it worked
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Transference Focused Psychotherapy & Personality Disorders with Dr. Otto Kernberg by Psychiatry & Psychotherapy, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 8,933 words across 1,668 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.