Transfer Pricing Isn't Optional — Why Many Businesses Still Miss It — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:03Welcome back to Let's Talk Tax. I'm Dave
- 0:05McGuire. In today's episode, we're
- 0:07exploring transfer pricing.
- 0:08Why businesses overlook it and how their
- 0:10CPAs can help.
- 0:12Joining us is John Badoor from McGuire
- 0:14Sossel's Global Business Services team.
- 0:16Welcome, John.
- 0:17>> Glad to be here.
- 0:18>> So, John, as businesses grow
- 0:21and we think about transfer pricing.
- 0:23Now,
- 0:24I think one of the areas we
- 0:26talk about it a lot is as they're
- 0:27growing internationally in cross-border
- 0:29transactions.
- 0:31And actually right before this, you were
- 0:32pointing out it's not always just about
- 0:34cross-border transactions, but that
- 0:36transfer pricing is needed. Can you
- 0:37expand on that? Give me a little context
- 0:39what you mean.
- 0:41>> When we have a company that has, you
- 0:43know, multiple locations even
- 0:46domestically here in the US.
- 0:48And when they have a cross-border
- 0:50transaction, let's say the group
- 0:52headquarters is providing the
- 0:53administrative and back office services
- 0:55for the group and how that expense
- 0:58allocation should work for each state,
- 1:00its subsidiary that the
- 1:02parent company owns.
- 1:04That is within the lines of transfer
- 1:06pricing and we see that more and more in
- 1:08the past, I'm going to say 12 months.
- 1:11That domestic companies are seeking to
- 1:13get their intercompany benchmarking
- 1:16done.
- 1:17>> Now,
- 1:18I'm going to take a step back before we
- 1:19really dive into it. So, obviously,
- 1:23you're kind of the expert in transfer
- 1:25pricing sitting here.
- 1:26And we're going to have people watching
- 1:28that have differing knowledges. So,
- 1:30just give me a basic idea. What is
- 1:32transfer pricing? Why is it important?
- 1:35And and kind of take a step back and
- 1:38pretend I have no business
- 1:41experience at all.
- 1:42What is transfer pricing and why is it
- 1:44needed?
- 1:45>> Transfer pricing is the
- 1:47method to justify intercompany
- 1:50transactions and benchmark those
- 1:52intercompany transactions according to
- 1:53the
- 1:54third-party data available on, you know,
- 1:58on the market. And it's crucially
- 2:01important, and the reason for that is
- 2:04that's how you allocate your, you know,
- 2:06expenses, your profits, and it directly
- 2:09impacts the bottom line. And if you're
- 2:13IRS, and if you, you know, if there's a
- 2:16company here,
- 2:17let's say
- 2:19you you would want that company to have
- 2:21as much income as possible for you to
- 2:24tax that
- 2:25>> Mhm.
- 2:25>> firm. And transfer pricing basically
- 2:28provides the guidelines and the
- 2:30benchmark for what the net income should
- 2:33be according to, you know, functions,
- 2:35assets, and risk analysis for the group
- 2:37and participants of the transaction.
- 2:40>> So, just kind of me thinking about it in
- 2:42my simplified mind here. So, I've got a
- 2:45US company pay taxes in the US.
- 2:48I've got operations somewhere overseas.
- 2:51Maybe that's doing my engineering, but
- 2:53then I'm doing my manufacturing
- 2:54somewhere else, and then I'm bringing
- 2:56the products back.
- 2:57Really, the transfer pricing study is
- 2:58just to make sure that I'm charging each
- 3:00different organization correctly so that
- 3:03the US knows how much income I can get
- 3:04taxed on?
- 3:05>> Correct. Third-party and external
- 3:07example,
- 3:09more likely than not, and if everything
- 3:11is to be, you know, according to the
- 3:13standards, the in a transaction,
- 3:17a the the company that assumes the most
- 3:19risk, has the IP and intangibles that's
- 3:23contributing uniquely to the group's
- 3:25profitability and revenue and whatnot,
- 3:28you would expect that company to
- 3:31have the most amount of, you know,
- 3:33profits.
- 3:34>> Mhm.
- 3:34>> And
- 3:36that's a simplified and a high-level
- 3:37example, but there are certain cases,
- 3:40and even if, you know, large companies
- 3:42such as Caterpillar, which we have a
- 3:44blog that I wrote on online, that a 2017
- 3:48case that they were shifting around 40%
- 3:51of their net income to Switzerland,
- 3:53whereas they had
- 3:55you know, 5% of their workforce in
- 3:57Switzerland. And obviously, IRS took an
- 3:59issue with that approach. So, that is a
- 4:01high-level example, but that's what
- 4:03transfer pricing determines.
- 4:05>> How often do companies need it? When
- 4:07when do you see that a transfer pricing
- 4:09is needed? Is it obviously
- 4:12your example you just gave, that's a big
- 4:13multinational company. A lot of the
- 4:15people we deal with, and I know a lot of
- 4:16the people you're dealing with
- 4:18aren't of that size. How do we determine
- 4:20when it's needed?
- 4:21>> This question has been asked almost any
- 4:23client that we assist in transfer
- 4:25pricing, and we give them two answers.
- 4:28One of them is the book answer, and the
- 4:29book answer is IRS does not have a
- 4:32material threshold. If you have a single
- 4:35dollar of intercompany transaction,
- 4:38which you're reporting this by the way
- 4:39on your 5471 form and 5472 form,
- 4:43uh you're required to update every year.
- 4:46And every third year you redo the you
- 4:48reconstruct the whole study.
- 4:51Our answer to our clients that we work
- 4:53with is to have more like a common sense
- 4:56approach. What we do is we touch base on
- 4:59the
- 5:00anniversary of our delivery of the study
- 5:02with the client,
- 5:04and we want to understand if there had
- 5:06been any significant changes to the
- 5:08operations, to the what the functions
- 5:11that, you know, entities involved doing,
- 5:14and you know, assets moved or whatnot.
- 5:17And if there's nothing changed,
- 5:19we tell them that, "Okay, I think
- 5:22this is again, this is the book answer,
- 5:24but
- 5:25for the common sense approach, we can
- 5:27maybe
- 5:28defer for another year. We don't want
- 5:30this to turn into a uh burden on the
- 5:34taxpayers."
- 5:35>> So, you said that that if there's a
- 5:375471, 5472 type situation, that's what
- 5:40triggers it.
- 5:42Is there a compliance risk for not
- 5:45having filing those forms, and then but
- 5:47I never bothered to do the transfer
- 5:48pricing. What's my risk there? Why why
- 5:50would that be important?
- 5:51>> So there are countries right now, Canada
- 5:53just joined this uh group in terms of
- 5:56basically requiring to have a transfer
- 5:59pricing study and submitting it with
- 6:01your updated return in Canadian tax
- 6:03form. There's a box that you check that
- 6:05that says that you have a uh updated
- 6:07transfer pricing study. Mexico does not
- 6:10accept your tax return unless you have
- 6:12you know, a transfer pricing study that
- 6:14you're submitting with the tax return.
- 6:16That's an exposure and you know, there
- 6:18are other countries like Finland, like
- 6:20Sweden in the Europe as well that they
- 6:22have this [clears throat] type of
- 6:23practices that if you don't have the
- 6:25transfer pricing study, your tax return
- 6:27might not be accepted.
- 6:28>> Is that a growing thing? So that's
- 6:29recent in I think you said Canada and
- 6:32Mex- So that's not that's not always
- 6:34been the case?
- 6:35>> That had not been the case and this has
- 6:38been a growing trend that we were able
- 6:41to see when we're while we're working
- 6:43with different, you know, countries and
- 6:46like I said, Canada US will join at some
- 6:49point.
- 6:49>> So you you think the US will eventually
- 6:51have some type of requirement to include
- 6:54the transfer pricing study?
- 6:56>> Absolutely. So in 5471
- 6:59there's a schedule called schedule M
- 7:00that you, you know, the taxpayer reports
- 7:03the intercompany transactions within the
- 7:05within the group and 5472 form uh part
- 7:09four uh you
- 7:12disclose the intercompany transactions.
- 7:15There's going to be a time and I don't
- 7:17know when. I'm
- 7:19I'm assuming it's going to be soon with
- 7:20all the artificial intelligence uh usage
- 7:23and whatnot, but there's going to be a
- 7:25point that they're going to be sending
- 7:27these automatically uh generated notices
- 7:31when you have a number in your 5471
- 7:33schedule.
- 7:34>> So right now I'm supposed to have it,
- 7:36but they don't require it to be shown.
- 7:38You're thinking in the future it's going
- 7:39to be required to be shown.
- 7:41>> Correct. That creates a confusion
- 7:43sometimes with the clients that we work
- 7:45with that they're required to have it on
- 7:47hand, but you don't have to submit it.
- 7:49It's
- 7:50interesting
- 7:51rule.
- 7:52>> Yeah.
- 7:53Now,
- 7:54with transfer pricing studies, so is it
- 7:56just merely a compliance risk or there
- 7:59is there planning that can go into it?
- 8:01Now that I know this has to be there, is
- 8:02there any type of planning or anything
- 8:04else I can use this for or is it just I
- 8:07have to have this on my file, so it's a
- 8:09cost?
- 8:10>> So, compliance is a part of it. If I say
- 8:13no, it would it would not be accurate,
- 8:15but in the especially in the last 9 to
- 8:1812 months that we saw a lot of the
- 8:21the clients that we work with they're
- 8:23utilizing it as a strategy cat in terms
- 8:26of cash flow management. So, what
- 8:28happens is when I say cash flow
- 8:29management, we provide a range for the
- 8:32transaction that we're covering. And
- 8:34they can go, you know, within that
- 8:36range, but depending on what they want
- 8:38to accomplish with their cash flow,
- 8:41their corporate goals, and whatnot, we
- 8:43can move from, you know, the 30% let's
- 8:46say to 10% for an intercompany sales of
- 8:49goods depending on what country that you
- 8:52would like to leave the cash more or,
- 8:55you know, less.
- 8:56>> So, sounds like there's some flexibility
- 8:58in how you would do that depending on
- 8:59the country.
- 9:00>> Correct.
- 9:02>> Now,
- 9:03how do other
- 9:05global events influence that? So, I'm
- 9:08assuming it's affected by if I
- 9:10let's say I decide to move operations
- 9:12from
- 9:14Canada to Mexico or Mexico to Europe or
- 9:17or moving things around,
- 9:19does it affect the cost of goods that
- 9:22I'm moving around? Obviously, this year
- 9:24we've had up and down tariffs and other
- 9:26things. Can I affect the charges I
- 9:28charge between the companies to
- 9:31use as a planning tool or is that
- 9:34>> If you move your production, for
- 9:35example, from Canada to
- 9:38somewhere in South America, let's say.
- 9:41Obviously, that that is going to have,
- 9:44you know, a different margin.
- 9:46>> Mhm.
- 9:46>> And the we will be benchmarking
- 9:49according to the geographic location of
- 9:51the entity that will be, you know,
- 9:53manufacturing those goods in your
- 9:54example. And that plays a role how to
- 9:58determine those, you know, the ranges
- 10:01that I I just mentioned about, you know,
- 10:03whether this is North America or South
- 10:06America or whatever the case might be.
- 10:08But that plays in, you know, a 100%.
- 10:11>> As you're going through this, I'm sure
- 10:12you get a little bit of insight as to
- 10:13where it's more expensive to do
- 10:15business, where it's less. So, you
- 10:16probably get some interesting insight as
- 10:18to
- 10:19operations. And when you're reading the
- 10:21newspaper and you hear, "Oh, this
- 10:22company moved their operations to
- 10:25Bangladesh." You might have a little bit
- 10:27more insight as to why than somebody
- 10:29like me that is not.
- 10:31>> I think that's one of the coolest parts
- 10:32of my job that I get to do these
- 10:35benchmarking studies that I get to learn
- 10:38about the clients' businesses, learn
- 10:40about their supply chain, how they
- 10:42operate, what kind of products or
- 10:43services that they provide, but also
- 10:45benchmark those according to their
- 10:47region and compare their margins to what
- 10:49I find on the database and have an
- 10:51understanding of manufacturing
- 10:53businesses in India versus manufacturing
- 10:56businesses in the United States and the
- 10:57margins.
- 10:58>> You used to think that obviously, people
- 11:00had these integrated companies where you
- 11:02would manufacture everything in one
- 11:05building. It seems like more and more
- 11:06companies are just pulling different
- 11:08things from different parts of the world
- 11:09and have massive supply chains to get
- 11:12things done. So, I'm sure these are not
- 11:14getting less complicated.
- 11:15>> No, you you're right. And
- 11:18as the economy of the, you know, global
- 11:21economy becomes more global and you go
- 11:23to different
- 11:25uh
- 11:25different countries for different
- 11:27resources to produce, you know, this
- 11:29cup, let's say. Um
- 11:32the it's it gets more complicated. And
- 11:33it's it it's a we Like I was mentioning,
- 11:36you need to have a uh an analysis of the
- 11:39functions and assets and risk for each
- 11:41entity. So, the more entities involved,
- 11:43it gets more complicated.
- 11:46>> Now, you mentioned earlier that this
- 11:47isn't just always just international,
- 11:49that sometimes companies need this for
- 11:52intercompany transfers either between
- 11:54different states or different business
- 11:55units and other things.
- 11:57Why would somebody care between
- 11:59different business units, for example,
- 12:01why they're being charged? Is that is
- 12:03that still a compliance from the IRS's
- 12:05side, or is that more of a internal
- 12:07accounting or a state income tax? What
- 12:10are some of the reasons that we would
- 12:11have to worry about that?
- 12:12>> I think state state income tax planning
- 12:14is a, you know, one of the top reasons
- 12:17why we had done domestic
- 12:20transfer pricing studies. I don't want
- 12:22to say that compliance is not a part of
- 12:24it cuz it is.
- 12:26If an If an organization has, you know,
- 12:29$100 of income, they would prefer to
- 12:32recognize that income at a place where
- 12:35there's no state income tax versus,
- 12:38you know, California or
- 12:40New York,
- 12:41uh where they do have state income tax.
- 12:45>> Are you seeing any of those states
- 12:47increasing their
- 12:49reviews or similar to the IRS? Is there
- 12:51an expectation that at some point in the
- 12:53future they might to make sure people
- 12:55aren't trying to offshore or not
- 12:57offshore in this case, but transfer some
- 12:59of their income down to a lower tax
- 13:02jurisdiction when they're in a higher
- 13:03tax jurisdiction like New York or
- 13:05California?
- 13:06>> E- Especially so, we had done multiple
- 13:08studies
- 13:10with uh we work with clients that had
- 13:12offices in California, but they had
- 13:15recently moved their uh
- 13:17headquarters to like Texas, for example,
- 13:20and they still had operations in
- 13:22California, but they were trying to
- 13:24allocate the income in between those two
- 13:26states, and that becomes crucial in
- 13:27terms of how much state
- 13:29state income tax that they'll be paying.
- 13:32>> Okay.
- 13:33Are there penalties associated with
- 13:34transfer pricing or is it just simply a
- 13:36compliance issue going on or what's
- 13:38what's the risk if I don't have it but
- 13:40my numbers are probably
- 13:42pretty close.
- 13:45>> So, this is interesting because I'm not
- 13:48sure if this is happening in any other
- 13:49tax area that I I have never seen this
- 13:52but how IRS approaches is is let's say
- 13:55you have a management fee that you're
- 13:57paying from you know, a US parent to
- 14:00Irish subsidiary.
- 14:02And
- 14:04let's say we're paying a management fee
- 14:05to the to Ireland and you don't have a
- 14:07transfer pricing study. What IRS does is
- 14:11they will benchmark that transaction for
- 14:14you
- 14:16and they will basically enforce that
- 14:19those margins to be included in your
- 14:23financials and you'll pay taxes on the
- 14:26ones that you know, the income that you
- 14:28didn't pay
- 14:29according to their benchmarking
- 14:32and then there's a 20% additional
- 14:36uh
- 14:37penalty that you would pay.
- 14:38>> Can you argue it at that point or is
- 14:40that once you don't have it they're just
- 14:41going to set it up for you and you're
- 14:44out of luck and or can you take that and
- 14:47argue that in court that hey the IRS
- 14:49benchmark was too high?
- 14:51>> You can
- 14:53but it's still going to be a a
- 14:55challenging process. To begin with you
- 14:57did not have a study in hand. That's not
- 14:58a good start to just to begin with. And
- 15:01once they send you a
- 15:03once they send a taxpayer a notice it
- 15:06they require to have a study in 30 days
- 15:09to be submitted to the IRS but then
- 15:11still they can challenge but at least
- 15:12you're starting when you have a study in
- 15:14hand you're starting at a different
- 15:15point than when you didn't have.
- 15:18>> Well, it's it's it's interesting at the
- 15:19the way you described that
- 15:21um the IRS benchmark if they don't have
- 15:23it. um
- 15:24I know we have a property tax group. It
- 15:26almost sounds like property tax where
- 15:27they're coming in saying, here's the
- 15:29value on your house and if you don't
- 15:32like it, you have to push back a little
- 15:34bit. And that sounds it's always harder
- 15:36to come in from an argumentative than a
- 15:38defensive position.
- 15:39>> Absolutely. And not to mention they're
- 15:41going to try to benchmark that
- 15:42transaction as beneficial as possible
- 15:44for the IRS's purposes and
- 15:47I don't think taxpayers would
- 15:49would like that.
- 15:51Now,
- 15:53do you have any examples of clients
- 15:55where maybe they weren't in compliance
- 15:57with this or you've gone through and and
- 16:00been able to
- 16:01either save them some money by finding
- 16:03things during the transfer pricing or
- 16:04just get them back in compliance after
- 16:06years of uncompliance on the transfer
- 16:08pricing side?
- 16:10>> There's a client that we recently worked
- 16:13with. They had a a US entity owned by a
- 16:16Canadian parent.
- 16:18And they had been in existence in the US
- 16:21for 10 plus years. And they never had a
- 16:24taxable income where they're producing
- 16:27$3 million of revenue and every single
- 16:29dime of US company
- 16:32company's profits were being repatriated
- 16:34to Canada with no documentation and or
- 16:37whatnot. So, we we explained them that
- 16:41this is, you know, the operations is
- 16:43happening in in Canada and it it it it's
- 16:46great, but there's a purpose of this
- 16:48entity in the United States which is
- 16:50which is generating $3 million of
- 16:52income. So, we need to have a taxable
- 16:54income. There's a
- 16:56There's a purpose of that entity. And
- 16:58after 10 years, this year is the first
- 17:01year that they are having a compliant
- 17:04tax return that has a taxable income.
- 17:06Yes, they they they are going to be
- 17:07paying some taxes, but
- 17:09again, when you have an entity that
- 17:11serves a purpose, that generates
- 17:13revenue, and has zero cogs, and every
- 17:16dime is repatriated,
- 17:18that's red flag like first class red
- 17:21flag as I would call. Hm.
- 17:23>> Before we kind of conclude this, are
- 17:25there any other examples or or client
- 17:28stories that you want to share?
- 17:31>> We recently assisted one of our alliance
- 17:34firms on an acquisition
- 17:37and we tax diligence was a part of it
- 17:40and transfer pricing was
- 17:42a piece of that part and we did a study
- 17:46to basically confirm the inner company
- 17:48sales of goods was in compliance and the
- 17:51mar- margins that they used were were
- 17:54good.
- 17:54>> Hm.
- 17:55>> And
- 17:56that was a retroactive and proactively
- 17:59we discussed how can we maximize this
- 18:02new, you know, range that we provided
- 18:05according to the new owner's goals and
- 18:07what they want to accomplish, where they
- 18:09want their cash to be and what not. So,
- 18:11there's there's a lot of strategy that
- 18:13we're we're discussed during those
- 18:14meetings.
- 18:16>> Well, it's interesting I think as
- 18:18businesses grow, I think we're seeing
- 18:20the complexities of
- 18:22of the world changing. And I think if
- 18:24one thing taught us over the last couple
- 18:26years is as we've seen these tariffs and
- 18:28everything else,
- 18:29whether you agree with them or disagree
- 18:31with them, it shows how integrated all
- 18:33these businesses are just in
- 18:35international, you've got tentacles kind
- 18:37of everywhere around the world and I
- 18:39think we've learned that.
- 18:41So, it's good to know that there's
- 18:42people like you out there that kind of
- 18:44understand the complexity and can help
- 18:47walk people through this, especially
- 18:50obviously we deal with a lot of CPA
- 18:51firms. Those mid-size CPA firms that may
- 18:53not have an expert uh in on staff like
- 18:56you, knowing that they can call you and
- 18:58ask these questions is probably very
- 19:01uh gratifying to them to know that they
- 19:04can have somebody to lean on in those
- 19:06situations.
- 19:07>> It is and I their clients
- 19:10are very satisfied with the results that
- 19:12they get and I think one of the things
- 19:14that I was able to observe in the past
- 19:1712 months is
- 19:19the
- 19:20clients that we're working with they're
- 19:22they're really happy that we there's an
- 19:24internal benchmark for these
- 19:25transactions, you know, beyond
- 19:27compliance, beyond strategy. They know
- 19:30how they will be recording those
- 19:32intercompany transactions that's not a
- 19:34cost only and it needs to They
- 19:36understand the logic behind it and they
- 19:38were able to apply to their businesses
- 19:40which makes me happy.
- 19:43>> I I appreciate the fact that there are
- 19:45people like you out there, John. Thank
- 19:47you for joining us today and I I think
- 19:49for people that are watching today and
- 19:52curious about how McGuire Sponsel
- 19:54supports it, I know you'd be happy to
- 19:56take phone calls and reach out and work
- 19:58with anybody, but anybody that has any
- 20:00questions about transfer pricing and the
- 20:02complexities within, I would ask them
- 20:05just to reach out and talk to somebody
- 20:07at McGuire Sponsel and we can help them
- 20:08out. But, thank you for joining us
- 20:09today, John.
- 20:10>> Thank you so much for having me.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Transfer Pricing Isn't Optional — Why Many Businesses Still Miss It by Let's Talk Tax Podcast, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,466 words across 572 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.