Top des voitures électriques pour les gros rouleurs professionnels ! — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00A nice and chill video today, Gary.
- 0:02Hello Max, hello everyone.
- 0:03Yes, hello. That’s true
- 0:05actually.
- 0:06Ah,
- 0:06actually. Today, we’re going to ask a
- 0:08question. Which electric professional
- 0:10vehicle should you choose on the market
- 0:11?
- 0:12Is the question answered quickly?
- 0:13The question is not answered quickly.
- 0:15Okay.
- 0:15It’s a video that will concern you.
- 0:17Yes, directly. Or actually,
- 0:18because behind us, we have two cars. We
- 0:20have the BYD, which is a press vehicle,
- 0:22but we especially have the Ioniq 6,
- 0:23which is your professional vehicle that
- 0:24you’re changing next year, so
- 0:25there’s a vehicle choice to be made.
- 0:27Well, exactly. Yeah. Otherwise, uh,
- 0:29being a pedestrian, uh, to test
- 0:30chargers and all that, to go, uh, to
- 0:32roam the roads of France, it’s going
- 0:34to be complicated.
- 0:35Or a gas car,
- 0:36I can take the train. A gas car with a
- 0:38CCS plug. So,
- 0:39yeah, that’s it. A hybrid. Since
- 0:41it’s a bit complicated, today we
- 0:42wanted to go over the models that are
- 0:44eligible for everything like subsidies,
- 0:46the ADEME list, and so on. It’s a bit
- 0:48complicated. It’s a bit of a
- 0:49bureaucratic nightmare;
- 0:50whether it’s for a professional or
- 0:51personal purchase, it’s all a bit
- 0:52complicated, everything regarding
- 0:54bonuses and so on. So today, we’re
- 0:55going to clear that up a little bit.
- 0:56In a nutshell, we’re going to confuse
- 0:58you even more. They were doing fine
- 1:00there. They were calm and all. And then
- 1:02you come along and throw numbers,
- 1:04regulations, and stuff at them. Oh,
- 1:06there! "Oh, why am I watching this
- 1:08video?" No, but precisely, we’re
- 1:11going to go over everything regarding
- 1:13subsidies and bonuses that exist on the
- 1:15French market in 2026, and most
- 1:17importantly, we’ll look at the models
- 1:19. Avoid buying duds.
- 1:22Yeah, is it a bit of a top duds or
- 1:24is it a bit like that? It’s a bit of
- 1:26a top duds
- 1:27or top bangers. Top bangers is better.
- 1:28Yeah, there are top bangers, but there
- 1:30will also be some duds in the mix.
- 1:31Oh yes, definitely.
- 1:32Basically, the ones to get and the ones
- 1:33to avoid.
- 1:33The ones to get and the ones to avoid.
- 1:35For your professional activities.
- 1:36Activities where we drive a lot, we
- 1:38cover many kilometers per
- 1:39often, when you have a company car, it
- 1:40means you have to rack up the miles.
- 1:42Yeah.
- 1:42Exactly. So today, we’re going to
- 1:44guide you a bit, Gary.
- 1:45Yes.
- 1:45We’ll go over the recap. "Go over the
- 1:47recap" doesn’t mean anything.
- 1:48The recap tour. We're going to recap
- 1:50the Zaps.
- 1:51OK.
- 1:51Which exist for pros and individuals in
- 1:53France in 2026.
- 1:54I'm listening.
- 1:55Two heads. Do you know what kind of aid
- 1:57exists?
- 1:57So for aid, is the conversion bonus
- 1:59still around? Test.
- 2:01Well, I don't have it. I don't have it.
- 2:03So
- 2:03no, I don't think that's a thing
- 2:05anymore. I think it's over.
- 2:06The conversion bonus was for scrapping
- 2:08a vehicle. Anyway, let's not talk about
- 2:09that today, I was just teasing you. So,
- 2:11I know there's the bonus.
- 2:13That's right.
- 2:13Exactly. So, the bonus is already for
- 2:16vehicles made in Europe.
- 2:18You have a made-in-Europe super-bonus,
- 2:19actually.
- 2:20Yeah, that's it.
- 2:21But it's a bonus. I mean, it's a bonus
- 2:23within the bonus.
- 2:24It's a bonus within the bonus. And I
- 2:25think there's even another benefit,
- 2:27another gift. If the battery is also
- 2:30produced in Europe.
- 2:31Exactly.
- 2:32Did I cover everything? Is there
- 2:33anything else?
- 2:34Well, basically, you have the "coup de
- 2:36pouce" bonus. So it's the "coup de
- 2:38pouce" bonus. Or
- 2:39you have the made-in-Europe super-bonus
- 2:41. You have the social leasing.
- 2:42Ah yes, social leasing.
- 2:43And then you have aid, everything
- 2:45related to ZFE bonuses and local aid.
- 2:47You know, you can get regional aid,
- 2:48help for individuals, and that all
- 2:50stacks up, actually.
- 2:51It stacks. What's interesting and
- 2:52important is that today we're going to
- 2:53refer to the ADEME list. We
- 2:55don't really have a choice.
- 2:56We don't really have a choice. And what
- 2:58is ADEME? It's the Agency for
- 2:59Ecological Transition, actually; it's
- 3:01the one that issues the list. So, it's
- 3:03a public body that is independent and
- 3:05under the supervision of the Ministry
- 3:07of Ecological Transition and Energy.
- 3:09There, that way at least we have a
- 3:10little context, it's always interesting
- 3:12,
- 3:12it sets the scene a bit.
- 3:13You should know that it doesn't pay the
- 3:15bonuses directly to the buyer. It
- 3:16calculates the actual carbon footprint
- 3:18of a vehicle sold in France. So it's
- 3:20the one that calculates everything and
- 3:21publishes the official list of eligible
- 3:23vehicles, which is the one we'll be
- 3:25using in this video.
- 3:27So then it's up to fleet managers to
- 3:29sort through based on their preferences
- 3:31and the company's ethics. There are
- 3:33quite a few things that come into play,
- 3:35I think.
- 3:36Well, there are quite a few things. You
- 3:38should know that to unlock the
- 3:39subsidies, you need to get a score out
- 3:41of 80. Do you know what the minimum
- 3:46number of points is to get that famous
- 3:48eco-score label, so a car is eco-scored
- 3:50?
- 3:52Out of 80.
- 3:53It's 80 points.
- 3:54Okay.
- 3:55You have to have a minimum for your car
- 3:57to be eco-scored.
- 3:57Well, I'd say average, 40.
- 3:59No, it's 60 out of 80.
- 4:01Oh, okay.
- 4:02So if you have 50, you're out. Your car
- 4:04isn't eco-scored.
- 4:05Understood.
- 4:05It's quite funny, though. So there are
- 4:07several criteria, you were talking
- 4:08about them. What are the calculation
- 4:10criteria? There's the material
- 4:11footprint, there's battery production.
- 4:13I won't detail the points every time,
- 4:14but there's the energy for assembling
- 4:16the car, the energy that's used. For
- 4:18example, if it's coal, then that ruins
- 4:20your score.
- 4:20There's transport and logistics. If
- 4:22your car is made on the other side of
- 4:24the world, well, your score is ruined.
- 4:26That's why they'll be shipping car
- 4:28parts by electric truck soon.
- 4:30Yes, actually, it's all
- 4:32to lower, well, to increase the score.
- 4:34And there's BMW behind that. They're
- 4:36going to assemble in Hungary if I'm not
- 4:38mistaken. Xpeng is assembling in
- 4:39Austria, MG will assemble in Spain. So
- 4:41we can see that things are happening.
- 4:43There's the weight of the car, we have
- 4:45to be under 2.4 tons.
- 4:46Ah, that's still 2.4 tons for electric
- 4:48vehicles.
- 4:492.4 tons. And there's the vehicle price
- 4:51, of course, it must be less than or
- 4:53equal to € 47,000 excluding options.
- 4:55Okay.
- 4:55Who is this list for? It's important to
- 4:57know.
- 4:58Yeah.
- 4:59For individuals, the goal is to get the
- 5:01bonus, and for professionals, it's
- 5:03about having tax advantages. in kind
- 5:06and that it be fiscally attractive.
- 5:08Exactly, because for example, your
- 5:10employer offers you a list of vehicles.
- 5:12If you want to go for a vehicle that
- 5:13isn't on the list at all, your employer
- 5:15will say "Now, listen Gary, it's not
- 5:16worth it for us."
- 5:17Exactly, it costs way too much.
- 5:19A list of vehicles or maybe a budget.
- 5:21Yeah,
- 5:21it could also be "What is the list of
- 5:23vehicles? Well, let's go over it
- 5:24together. But first of all,
- 5:26do you know who is sponsoring this
- 5:27video? Oh, not at all.
- 5:29You don't know?
- 5:30So, this is the commercial part, where
- 5:32is it?
- 5:32Yeah. Well, this video is not sponsored
- 5:34.
- 5:34Darn. Well, yeah. So, are we telling
- 5:36people to subscribe to the channel?
- 5:38Well, of course, that's the basics.
- 5:39So it's just below, you can subscribe,
- 5:41it's free, you just have to log into
- 5:42your Google account. Two videos per
- 5:43week, Wednesday and Sunday, plus the
- 5:45shorts that I put in the description
- 5:46box.
- 5:46That's fine, there's no call for
- 5:47donations.
- 5:48There's no call for donations. We're
- 5:49not at that point. No, no, no. Just
- 5:52subscribe, it's free, we're not asking
- 5:53for more. So here we go, let's go
- 5:55through the list. So, a little list.
- 5:57We're going to list the vehicles and,
- 5:59every time, give our top and flop.
- 6:00There you go. Keep in mind, some
- 6:02vehicles might be automatically
- 6:04eliminated because, for us, for company
- 6:06car use, it just doesn't fit.
- 6:08That's right.
- 6:08But don't take it the wrong way if you
- 6:10like the vehicle or if you have one,
- 6:12feel free to put it in the comments."
- 6:14Oh, I don't get why you put it as a
- 6:16flop. "" I have it as a company car, it
- 6:18suits me just fine. "" I drive so many
- 6:20miles a year. "That's what's going to
- 6:22interest me.
- 6:22That's it,
- 6:23because that's what will shape our
- 6:24choice.
- 6:25Let's take you as an example, Gary. How
- 6:27many miles a year does Gary drive?
- 6:2940,000.
- 6:3040,000. So we'll use your example. Well
- 6:32, first vehicle on the list, we'll
- 6:33start with the letter A. And at Abarth,
- 6:35you can have the Abarth 500e. And
- 6:37honestly, the Abarth 500e is going to
- 6:38be complicated.
- 6:39Oh no.
- 6:41Cool car for the fun side.
- 6:42Oh yes, but for
- 6:44the weekend, if you have it as a second
- 6:45or third car. It's a treat, right? The
- 6:48500
- 6:48yeah, flop. But we like it a lot. Let's
- 6:50move on. We'll just say a short
- 6:51sentence each time, otherwise the video
- 6:52will last three hours.
- 6:53Yes.
- 6:53Alfa Romeo Junior.
- 6:54No.
- 6:55No.
- 6:55Sorry.
- 6:56Next, let's go.
- 6:57Come on, it's not even worth detailing.
- 6:59No, but honestly,
- 7:01honestly, it's a dressed-up city car,
- 7:03not enough range, not versatile enough.
- 7:05Alpine A290.
- 7:07It's a bit like the Abarth.
- 7:08Yeah, it's pretty much the same issue.
- 7:10Cool little car but,
- 7:11consumption a bit high, range limited,
- 7:13especially in winter, complicated.
- 7:14Company car? No.
- 7:15I was just thinking that.
- 7:17Yes.
- 7:17because later there will be the Renault
- 7:19R5 on the highway at 1, right? They
- 7:20have R5s and I think, since there are
- 7:21charging stations everywhere
- 7:23company vehicle
- 7:23Yeah, but as a company vehicle it could
- 7:25work, you know
- 7:26It could
- 7:27It could work since they are on the 1
- 7:28they
- 7:28are doing the shuttle, there are
- 7:30charging stations.
- 7:31Maybe they have chargers at the depot
- 7:32too.
- 7:33Exactly. So, I was thinking, again,
- 7:36I’m focused on company vehicles,
- 7:38please, on benefits in kind.
- 7:40Yeah, that’s true. That’s true, Q4
- 7:42e-tron in SUV version, in coupe version
- 7:45. Let's go.
- 7:45Yeah, it’s not bad, not a bad choice.
- 7:48I like MB, we often like the budget for
- 7:50it’s a nice ID4. Yes.
- 7:52Actually, the problem with German
- 7:54premium brands is the options list and
- 7:56often the versions that are eligible
- 7:58are very base versions. Yes.
- 8:01And so you end up with an options
- 8:03package, and that will be the case for
- 8:05BMW, Mercedes, and all that, you
- 8:08quickly have to add 10 to 15k in
- 8:10options.
- 8:11Ah, it’s a headache. Even the heated
- 8:13steering wheel is an option, it’s
- 8:14madness.
- 8:15Exactly. So that would be more for a
- 8:17senior manager or project manager.
- 8:18Anyway,
- 8:19that’s it, but it works, we’ve
- 8:20already seen one by the way on
- 8:22BMW, we have the letter B, we’ll have
- 8:25the i1, the X2, the i4 and the new i3.
- 8:28And honestly, I like the range as a
- 8:30company vehicle, even if the
- 8:32it fits well, eh.
- 8:33It fits well because you already have
- 8:36four models, so there are several uses
- 8:38to take into account, even if I'm not
- 8:41too keen on the X1, X2
- 8:43which are a bit limited in the medium
- 8:44term.
- 8:45I find them, I find them lacking in
- 8:47range even if the charging curve isn't
- 8:49too bad, I would rather go for an i4 or
- 8:51an i3. The i4 is aging, it’s going to
- 8:53be released now. Yes,
- 8:55so maybe the i3, especially with the
- 8:57800V and the battery
- 8:59car that we will test soon but see
- 9:01or nice car but expensive nonetheless.
- 9:03Yeah, and you pointed out the X1, X2,
- 9:05they are also at the end of their life
- 9:06because the new GLA has arrived, so
- 9:08thank you, BMW is going to pull out
- 9:09what's good, the X1, X2 are more
- 9:11accessible.
- 9:11Yes, that’s it. These are vehicles,
- 9:13it's really the entry-level BMW. Letter
- 9:15C at Citroën, it’s going to be a bit
- 9:16complicated, we have to be honest.
- 9:18We’ll have the ë-C3, ë-C4, ë-C4X,
- 9:20ë-Berlingo and ë-SpaceTourer. And you
- 9:22, you’ve already had your share of
- 9:24trouble. The ë-C4 as a company car,
- 9:26well, for travel as a loaner car while
- 9:28waiting for the Ioniq I had ordered.
- 9:30You have to admit it’s quite limited.
- 9:31It was super complicated.
- 9:32It’s complicated
- 9:33especially
- 9:34in winter.
- 9:35The ë-C5 isn’t there, I’m
- 9:36intrigued now. The ë-C5 for me,
- 9:38honestly, we are in France. For me,
- 9:41it’s the benchmark for company cars
- 9:43for purely French companies.
- 9:44Exactly. I don’t know why it
- 9:46doesn’t appear in the list. Good good
- 9:47for me the ë-C5. Yeah, right. There is
- 9:50indeed one Citroën that is, let’s
- 9:52say, recommendable at Citroën as a
- 9:54company car, and that is the ë-C5. The
- 9:58others, you can write them off.
- 10:01Oh my, painful.
- 10:02I have a memory.
- 10:05The torture. Oh, I don’t want one.
- 10:08Cupra, you can have the Cupra Born and
- 10:10the Cupra Tavascan. Ah, the Tavascan is
- 10:12in it?
- 10:12Yeah, the Tavascan is in it. Cupra is
- 10:14good, you can get it with 77 kWh. So
- 10:16that’s good range for an electric
- 10:18compact. And the Tavascan, MEB platform
- 10:20in a higher segment.
- 10:21Okay. Honestly, both models are
- 10:23not bad.
- 10:24They look good in a fleet with a
- 10:26slightly youthful vibe. Why not?
- 10:29Why not? Letter D. DS Automobiles, DS3
- 10:32E-Tense, DS4 E-Tense. The new one, I
- 10:34imagine the new DS7 and number.
- 10:36Yes, normally the DS number 7 will be
- 10:38in it.
- 10:39There you go. So you basically have the
- 10:41whole DS range, it’s the same issue.
- 10:42We should clarify for those not
- 10:44familiar with all this, Stellantis is
- 10:46the shared platform. So finally,
- 10:47everything we said about the ë-C3,
- 10:49etc., is actually valid for almost all
- 10:52models.
- 10:52Yeah.
- 10:53Well, I would go for, let’s say, the
- 10:55equivalent of the C5, which is the DS
- 10:58number 7. That’s it.
- 10:59Preferably in the big battery version
- 11:01because since the charging curve
- 11:03isn’t great, you might as well be
- 11:04able to do long legs.
- 11:06That’s it. So we go up to 97 kWh, so
- 11:08we exceed, I think, 700 km of range on
- 11:10that.
- 11:11WLTP.
- 11:12WLTP. So that’s actually not bad.
- 11:14Letter F. We go to Fiat and here
- 11:16I thought you were going to say Ferrari
- 11:17. I
- 11:18as a company car, why not? Ferrari...
- 11:20Fiat E-Doblò.
- 11:23Well, at Fiat, you’ll be able to have
- 11:25the Grande Panda, please. Watch out
- 11:27Grande Panda.
- 11:28The 600, the 500E, the E-Doblo and the
- 11:30E-Ulysse, I'll take the E-Ulysse.
- 11:32I have a story about the E-Doblo. Can I
- 11:34tell it here or not?
- 11:35Go ahead, go ahead, please do. Well, I
- 11:37work in the charging industry as you
- 11:39know, and sometimes we can identify
- 11:41vehicles, and actually, the new Ferrari
- 11:43Purosangue is identified as a Fiat
- 11:44E-Doblo. So, there's a little, that's
- 11:46why there's a little smirk regarding
- 11:47the Fiat E-Doblo. Yeah. I'm getting a
- 11:49Fiat E-Doblo as a company car.
- 11:51Ah, that's funny.
- 11:52Yeah, it's quite funny.
- 11:54No, honestly, at Fiat, there's nothing.
- 11:56Well,
- 11:58there's nothing recommendable aside
- 11:59from the Doblo joke, really.
- 12:01Same platform, same sickness. Yeah,
- 12:04sorry Stellantis, but hey, moving on to
- 12:06Ford, we can have the electric Ford
- 12:08Explorer and the electric Ford Capri
- 12:10which are variations like the Tavascan,
- 12:12like the ID.5, ID.4, they're
- 12:14platforms, it's classic, really.
- 12:17It seems it's tailor-made, actually.
- 12:19That's it.
- 12:19That's what's crazy.
- 12:20So at the start, the MEB wasn't great,
- 12:22but now they've improved a lot, we have
- 12:24to be honest. At Ford, you have the
- 12:25Ford tuning, so it's a different tuning
- 12:27than at VW. You like it or you don't,
- 12:29but at least they have a way to
- 12:30differentiate themselves.
- 12:32That's it. At Hyundai. At Hyundai, we
- 12:34can have the electric Kona
- 12:35which are, well, assembled in Europe,
- 12:37which wasn't the case for the Ioniq 6,
- 12:39but I ordered it at the end of, end of,
- 12:41well, end of 2023, beginning of 2024,
- 12:43so it wasn't the same criteria. That's
- 12:46why I drive an Ioniq 6 as a company car
- 12:47. Besides,
- 12:48as a Hyundai expert and absolute fan of
- 12:50Hyundai, in my list, I only have the
- 12:52electric Kona that comes from the Czech
- 12:54Republic. It's not just me, there's
- 12:57only the Kona, there's the Ioniq too,
- 13:00but anyway, in any case, both aren't
- 13:01recommendable today as company cars.
- 13:04There will be the Ioniq 3, but I'm not
- 13:06even sure.
- 13:07Yeah, well, it's not there yet because
- 13:08it's not too available on the market
- 13:10yet.
- 13:10Well, for me at Hyundai, there's
- 13:11nothing recommendable today, really.
- 13:13Although the Kona can do the job, but
- 13:15it's not the best. There's better.
- 13:16The Kona will be renewed, so wait a
- 13:18little if you really like Hyundai.
- 13:19Jeep Avenger, let's forget about it.
- 13:21Is there, is there not the...
- 13:24the Compass. Yeah. Which is a variation
- 13:26, well, of the 3008 or whatever. Well,
- 13:29same here, American company based in
- 13:31France, it just adds to the Ford choice
- 13:33. You can choose the Jeep.
- 13:34What's funny is that once again, my
- 13:36list was pulled but it's not in there.
- 13:38Ah well, that means it's not up to date
- 13:39.
- 13:40The guys at LAAD aren't up to date,
- 13:41it's August, they're on vacation, you
- 13:43know.
- 13:43But don't worry, we're fixing it for
- 13:45you.
- 13:45We're trying to correct it a bit. There
- 13:46might be some omissions, unfortunately.
- 13:48Yeah, like Kia, the list wasn't up to
- 13:49date. I added it. Actually, Kia didn't
- 13:51appear at all. So I'm the one who made
- 13:53Kia appear. Watch out now,
- 13:54I swear it didn't show up.
- 13:57You're a Korean car expert.
- 13:59The channel's Korean expert, with the
- 14:01EV2 and EV4.
- 14:02But the EV2 seems a bit complicated to
- 14:04me
- 14:04starts with the 61 kWh version.
- 14:06The EV4 is great, though.
- 14:08We love the EV4. EV4.
- 14:10Comparable to the Born, actually. In a
- 14:12way.
- 14:12If you want an Italian brand, you want
- 14:14to drive an Italian car.
- 14:15The brand L. Lancia.
- 14:17Lancia.
- 14:17Lancia.
- 14:18For Lancia, what's there? The Ypsilon?
- 14:21No,
- 14:21we'll have uh
- 14:23there might be the Gamma, which is the
- 14:25counterpart from Stellantis to the DS7.
- 14:28That's it.
- 14:30For those who don't like the DS7 design
- 14:32but still like the atmosphere it offers
- 14:34, you can get the Lancia Gamma and
- 14:36drive something original because, in my
- 14:38opinion, they'll sell two of them.
- 14:41Yes, exactly. There will be two fans in
- 14:43France. Uh, we're at the letter M, and
- 14:46under M, what do we have? We have
- 14:48Mercedes.
- 14:48Mercedes. Honestly, look at the videos
- 14:50on the channel, but I think Mercedes
- 14:52has come up with a solid product range.
- 14:54Oh, they have, yeah, they've cast a
- 14:56wide net and they've done a good job.
- 14:58And with good products, a few
- 14:59reliability issues on the early ones,
- 15:01as we saw recently with a GLB.
- 15:03Yes, that's true. That's true.
- 15:05There you go. So keep an eye out,
- 15:07remain cautious. Hoping that between
- 15:11your choice and, let's say, production/
- 15:13delivery, there will be improvements.
- 15:16Which I don't doubt, it is still
- 15:18Mercedes behind it, after all. But yes,
- 15:20there's that.
- 15:21Very good.
- 15:22There it is.
- 15:22Well, we've got everything because
- 15:24what's funny is that the CLA doesn't
- 15:25appear, but it is actually eligible.
- 15:27So we have the CLA, we have the new EQA
- 15:30, the EQB, the EQC.
- 15:31So there will be a new GLA replacing
- 15:33the EQA. Yes, that's true, sorry. Yes,
- 15:35that's true, that's true. But I was
- 15:37thinking of the new GLA, actually, when
- 15:38I said
- 15:38GLB instead of EQB. Yes, but actually
- 15:40those were vehicles that were already
- 15:42eligible, I think. And so now, it's the
- 15:44renewal, right. There is a renewal of
- 15:46the whole range that is effective from
- 15:48the GLA to the GLC, including the
- 15:49sedans.
- 15:50That's right. Well, Mercedes is
- 15:51expensive, so it's going to be
- 15:53complicated. But, for example, for a
- 15:54replacement for the Ioniq 6, would you
- 15:56prefer a GLA or something compared to
- 15:57the X1, for example?
- 15:58It's more practical than that one and
- 16:00maybe more practical than the CLA,
- 16:02which is quite streamlined; I haven't
- 16:04had the shooting brake in my hands yet.
- 16:06Under the letter M, we'll have the Mini
- 16:08Cooper SE, Aceman and Countryman. Only
- 16:10the Countryman
- 16:11Yeah, Countryman, which is the Mini
- 16:13counterpart to the X1.
- 16:14That's it. Complicated.
- 16:16You have to like Mini, I guess.
- 16:17Yeah, you have to like Mini, but it has
- 16:19a nice look, at least.
- 16:20Not really recommendable. No. Nissan,
- 16:22letter N. Nissan Ariya and the Townstar
- 16:25EV.
- 16:26Well, you really caught me off guard
- 16:28with the Ariya. I didn't think it was
- 16:30eligible.
- 16:30Well, it is indeed eligible, the Ariya,
- 16:32funny, right?
- 16:33Wow! Okay, it's not made in Japan. Okay
- 16:36,
- 16:36in any case, it's on the list,
- 16:37apparently.
- 16:38The Ariya is on the list and maybe the
- 16:40next Leaf.
- 16:40Yes. Well, new Leaf, we can update. So
- 16:43update.
- 16:44Yeah. Update.
- 16:45It's the people working at ADEME. Wait,
- 16:47what did he say?
- 16:48Yeah. No, but wait, I have to check
- 16:50that.
- 16:50It's ridiculous that the list isn't up
- 16:51to date like this.
- 16:52There is still a
- 16:53there are a lot of new things that have
- 16:55arrived here and that are arriving this
- 16:56fall. Opel, well, Opel, the group:
- 16:58Corsa, Mokka, Astra, Frontera, Combo
- 17:01Electric, and Zafira Electric. So
- 17:03basically just about the whole Opel
- 17:05range.
- 17:05Ah, for me, there's only one that's
- 17:07recommendable, the Grandland.
- 17:08The Grandland, yeah.
- 17:09The Grandland, same with two battery
- 17:11ranges. I think there's even a specific
- 17:1480-something kWh battery.
- 17:15That's it. There's a slight variation
- 17:17on the Opel that we don't have
- 17:18elsewhere.
- 17:19It's made in Germany
- 17:20just to stay with the medium, you know.
- 17:22There you go. Not a bad car you tested
- 17:24on the channel a little while ago.
- 17:25No, it’s not bad, and honestly, the
- 17:27ergonomics are good if you do a lot of
- 17:28driving, actually. The seat ergonomics.
- 17:30Yeah.
- 17:31And the cabin, like the 3008, like the
- 17:33Citroën.
- 17:34What I noted
- 17:34is really very good ergonomics.
- 17:36Yeah. If you don't like the e-C 5, you
- 17:38can get this.
- 17:39Exactly. Peugeot e-208, e-2008, e-308,
- 17:423008, 5008, Rifter, Traveller.
- 17:45Nice lineup.
- 17:46Nice lineup. Same, honestly, the 3008,
- 17:485008, it can do the job.
- 17:505008, honestly, a good choice for
- 17:52rather large families.
- 17:54Yes,
- 17:54like if you have three or four kids,
- 17:567 seats,
- 17:57bam.
- 17:57E-5008.
- 17:58E-5008.
- 17:59Renault?
- 18:00Yes.
- 18:00Renault 5, Scenic, Megane which just
- 18:02got a restyle. Twingo, Kangoo. Doesn't
- 18:05a Twingo sound good as a company car?
- 18:07A Twingo as a company car, you know.
- 18:09Well, I work in charging, I go around
- 18:11to the chargers, so what's the problem?
- 18:13Ah,
- 18:13that's good, that would be, that would
- 18:15you'll be waiting a long time.
- 18:17Uh, no, well, look, we have to see what
- 18:19the latest Megane is worth with its 67
- 18:22kWh LFP battery.
- 18:23We might recommend the Scenic and
- 18:24Megane. Scenic, Megane, that could be
- 18:27not bad, more than, but the Scenic,
- 18:29well, the 87.
- 18:30By the way, I have a colleague who has
- 18:32an 87 Scenic. Now here, an outsider,
- 18:34almost a brand that’s killing it
- 18:36right now. Well, no, not an outsider,
- 18:38Skoda.
- 18:39Skoda. They’re well-established in
- 18:40fleets, huh.
- 18:41They’re really well-established. We
- 18:42have the Elroq, Enyaq, and Enyaq Coupé
- 18:44, which to this day are on the list.
- 18:46But we can add the Epiq and the Epiq.
- 18:47Yes, the Epiq that just arrived.
- 18:49Exactly, so in fact, we have a great
- 18:51MEB platform lineup, and honestly, with
- 18:53Skoda, we really have the practical
- 18:55side, price, design, we have the
- 18:56price-to-performance-to-option ratio,
- 18:58it gets the job done. It’s not ugly,
- 19:00it works well.
- 19:02What would you say about driving a
- 19:03Smart? Because Smart, with the#1 and#3,
- 19:06are present on the list.
- 19:07Now here, I didn't know that, and you
- 19:09surprise me.
- 19:10Well, you see? Now, it is written,
- 19:12though, subject to European assembly,
- 19:14supply, etc., so there might be some
- 19:15conditions, so it might be coming.
- 19:17But
- 19:17it might be on the way.
- 19:19Smart#1 and#3 are present on the list.
- 19:21For me, you know what the problem is
- 19:23with the hashtag 3, the trunk is tiny,
- 19:26so I can't recommend it.
- 19:27Exactly. And why wouldn't we recommend
- 19:29it? Well, even if the design and so on
- 19:31can be nice, we have the practical
- 19:33aspect and especially the ADAS
- 19:34lane-keeping aspect.
- 19:36It must have evolved since our last
- 19:37test, right?
- 19:38Yeah, but it's still a Chinese car, and
- 19:40the Chinese ones are still pretty bad.
- 19:42In there, the software behind it is a
- 19:43bit complicated, huh? It does the job,
- 19:45it works, but it's not as well
- 19:47integrated as in a European car.
- 19:48Yeah. So if you want a Smart as a
- 19:50company car, good luck.
- 19:51That's it, clearly there's
- 19:52it won't necessarily be in the policy
- 19:54of the fleets, I think.
- 19:56Letter T. T for Tesla.
- 19:57T for Tesla. We'll have the Model Y,
- 19:59only the versions produced in the
- 20:01Berlin Gigafactory.
- 20:02Oh yes, yes, I have the same, I have
- 20:04colleagues in Teslas, including two in
- 20:07Model Ys, huh. I'm not surprised.
- 20:09There are a huge number of them. It's a
- 20:10bit like Skoda, a lot of vehicles. And
- 20:14when you want a vehicle, let's say
- 20:16where you don't want to worry about
- 20:18charging, that has space inside, that
- 20:20is still, let's say, well-equipped
- 20:21relative to the price, the Model Y is
- 20:23almost a must-have.
- 20:26But I don't like it.
- 20:27Yeah, that'll be a matter of preference
- 20:28.
- 20:29I don't want one.
- 20:29Yeah, you don't want one. But factually
- 20:31, in terms of purely being an electric
- 20:33car, it's still pretty good. But Tesla
- 20:35still needs a technical update. There
- 20:37are two brands left.
- 20:38Well yeah, they have a big one, huh.
- 20:39Volkswagen.
- 20:40Well, ID 3, 4, 5, 7, and Buzz.
- 20:43Volkswagen. Yeah, they apply too, huh.
- 20:45Maybe the ID3 Neo as well, it's not up
- 20:47to date, but there you go.
- 20:48Yes, I think so. ID3 Neo.
- 20:50So we'll be able to recommend just
- 20:51about everything to you. The ID3, get
- 20:52it with the big 77 battery.
- 20:53Yes.
- 20:54Uh, the ID3 Neo, I tested it recently,
- 20:56it's really good.
- 20:57New ID4 that's coming out.
- 20:58New ID4.
- 20:59OK. New ID7 that just arrived. Yes,
- 21:02which is
- 21:02on the list
- 21:03which is on Gary's short list to
- 21:05replace the Ioniq 6. His list. That's
- 21:07it.
- 21:07There you go.
- 21:08To be continued.
- 21:08I'm spoiling it a bit, but the ID7 in
- 21:10the Tourer version, sir.
- 21:12Yeah, that's pretty good. We'll talk
- 21:14about it again. And Volvo EX40, EC40,
- 21:16EX30, we'll have the EX60.
- 21:20Yeah.
- 21:20Which actually isn't in the—Ah,
- 21:22though it's not above the price points.
- 21:25Volvo bothers me because I actually
- 21:27love the brand, I love the stuff, but
- 21:28they are currently renewing their
- 21:30entire lineup. Logic dictates you have
- 21:35the EX30, EX40, EC40, and then
- 21:37obviously the EX60. Yes, but that's too
- 21:41expensive.
- 21:42Or maybe it's too expensive. Yeah.
- 21:44Which might be excluded because of the
- 21:46price. But maybe, I’ve heard talk of
- 21:50an EX50 coming, and I was hoping for an
- 21:53ES60, a sedan or an electric V60 wagon.
- 21:57An EV60, in a way. Unfortunately,
- 21:59it’s hypothetical; we don’t know.
- 22:01That’s it. And quite high-end pricing
- 22:03. And you should know that it will only
- 22:05be versions produced in the Ghent plant
- 22:06, because they produce the EX, well, in
- 22:08Belgium...
- 22:09There is a plant in Ghent and there is
- 22:10a plant near Gothenburg, I think, in
- 22:12Sweden.
- 22:13Yeah. So that’s still pretty good.
- 22:14I’m quite surprised. We were talking
- 22:16about Volvo, but there’s no Polestar
- 22:17on the list, you see.
- 22:18That might be coming eventually. Yeah.
- 22:20Polestar isn't there, for me. I’ve
- 22:22heard rumors that there could be an
- 22:23entry for Polestar and Zeekr in Ghent.
- 22:26All right.
- 22:26There you go. So maybe there will also
- 22:28be the letter Z from...
- 22:29Yes. Since here we stop at V. There are
- 22:31other brands, obviously; Chinese brands
- 22:33aren't included. We can see that they
- 22:35are pushing European brands.
- 22:36Ah, well, it’s very much geared
- 22:38toward Franco-European production, in
- 22:40any case. Like an Atto 3, the EV, we
- 22:42put it behind, but...
- 22:44Oh, it’s far from being on the list,
- 22:46I think, huh.
- 22:46Very, very far, because that's still
- 22:48waiting.
- 22:49We’re talking about a truly Chinese
- 22:50product here.
- 22:51Well, let's take advantage of it. Is it
- 22:53recommendable? Really, would it be on
- 22:54the list? Is it recommendable?
- 22:56The only thing that saves it is its big
- 22:57battery, frankly.
- 22:58What is a big battery? It’s 500 km
- 23:00WLTP.
- 23:01Yes, we go over 500.
- 23:02Basically, what we can say honestly to
- 23:04generalize is that we are pushing a bit
- 23:06toward the battery. Why? Because you
- 23:08need versatility, and roughly, you need
- 23:10a minimum of 500, 550, or even more km
- 23:13WLTP to have good range, do nice
- 23:15highway legs, all of that.
- 23:16Exactly. And well, among the list, no,
- 23:19there is better than the Atto 3 EV.
- 23:20However, I've had it for over two
- 23:22months now. What I've noticed is that
- 23:24it's quite efficient and it has a large
- 23:26battery. So actually, the range is far
- 23:27from terrible, and I can end up with 50
- 23:29%battery left, allowing me to head back
- 23:31up the coast and so on. You don't have
- 23:33that charging anxiety? So, Gary, to
- 23:35wrap things up and come back to that.
- 23:37BMW i3, the Cupra range, Kia, Mercedes,
- 23:39Renault Scenic, Skoda's whole range,
- 23:41the Model Y, Volkswagen's whole range
- 23:43too, that's pretty much what you could
- 23:45say. The products, as we've seen, are
- 23:47struggling a bit, except for the STLA
- 23:50Medium. Well, thankfully there's this
- 23:54big battery made in Douvrin, which
- 23:56allows for a range of over 400 km
- 23:58between charges. But otherwise,
- 24:02unfortunately, there are very few
- 24:04recommendable models from Stellantis.
- 24:09We said it when we tested the 3008, I
- 24:11think, that this STLA Medium platform
- 24:13is already dated and urgently needs an
- 24:15update.
- 24:17800 V.
- 24:20Because Peugeot is well-positioned for
- 24:22fleet vehicles, and many companies
- 24:23require a Peugeot.
- 24:25Or a French car, a Citroën, a Peugeot,
- 24:27you make it work, or possibly a Renault
- 24:29.
- 24:30Good stuff, good, good stuff.
- 24:32So it's hard to recommend an E-3008,
- 24:34you see, it's not obvious. It's not
- 24:36easy. No,
- 24:37that's life. Even though they are very
- 24:41comfortable cars, overall they're not
- 24:43too bad to drive, even if they are
- 24:45essentially anvils on wheels. Steel
- 24:47hearts.
- 24:48To finish,
- 24:49yes,
- 24:49from the list, we'll each pick the car
- 24:51we choose. OK. So we have to leave with
- 24:54one car.
- 24:55I might be spoiling the secret of the
- 24:57X6 replacement, maybe.
- 24:59Or I'll choose from the list, though
- 25:01you have to look at the terms, but I
- 25:02think I'll choose the BMW i3. We'll
- 25:04have to see the prices and terms, but I
- 25:06might settle for a base model. In terms
- 25:08of versatility, it really appeals to me
- 25:09.
- 25:10With power windows or not?
- 25:11Windows? But yes, it'll be a base i3 or
- 25:14...
- 25:14I'd love to have an i3, but I don't
- 25:15think it's in the budget.
- 25:16It's going to be tight. What do you
- 25:18choose? A vehicle, right?
- 25:19Well, ID.7 Tourer.
- 25:21ID.7 Tourer.
- 25:22Well, yes,
- 25:23that's a funny choice.
- 25:24It's one of the few wagons we have.
- 25:25There is the CLA Shooting Brake but
- 25:27Ah, it's taken
- 25:29and but it's the segment and it's the
- 25:30segment below
- 25:31actually. You wouldn't think so. The
- 25:33CLA is a stretched C-segment vehicle.
- 25:35So it's quite a small vehicle actually,
- 25:37fairly compact, and likewise the price
- 25:40of the options.
- 25:41I mean, I really struggle with that.
- 25:43Stay tuned on the channel, on the chan-
- 25:48nel
- 25:49or not,
- 25:50we'll see. Subscribe to the channel, a
- 25:51big thanks for this video. It was
- 25:53pretty cool. Tell us if you like this
- 25:55type of relaxed, laid-back format
- 25:56where we talk a little bit about models
- 25:58like this.
- 25:58Coffee table here with something in
- 25:59hand. Yes, that's it.
- 26:01A coffee,
- 26:01it's a bit of a pilot format. We could
- 26:03do other tops because there will be
- 26:04quite a few new things coming.
- 26:05Subscribe and, uh, we'll see you in the
- 26:07next video. Alright, see you next time.
- 26:10Alright, bye. M.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Top des voitures électriques pour les gros rouleurs professionnels ! by Max BLD, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,367 words across 954 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.