Toda la Historia Del Psicoanalisis Freud Jung Lacan — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Hello, good afternoon, everyone.
- 0:02Welcome to another video of The Whole
- 0:03Story, a complete summary of the
- 0:05history of psychoanalysis. We are going
- 0:08to look at the complete work of Sigmund
- 0:10Freud, but also of Carl Jung and
- 0:12Jacques Lacan. So, without further ado,
- 0:16the ambitious but not unachievable goal
- 0:18of this video is for you to leave
- 0:20knowing the whole history of
- 0:22psychoanalysis, or at least everything
- 0:24I know about it. We must clarify, of
- 0:28course, that this will take some time,
- 0:30and since I wanted to do it
- 0:32chronologically, we will review the
- 0:34works of Freud, Jung, and Lacan as they
- 0:36were released, that is, in
- 0:38chronological historical order. But
- 0:41also, since the goal of these videos is
- 0:44educational, I will provide a brief
- 0:46summary of each of them and the
- 0:48psychoanalytic concepts they
- 0:49contributed. Also, here on the screen
- 0:53at the beginning, it will show at what
- 0:54minute each one appears. Without
- 0:57further ado, let's start with Freud,
- 0:59who will take the most time because he
- 1:01is obviously the founder of the
- 1:03discipline. His first studies on
- 1:05psychoanalysis appear at a late age for
- 1:09him, around 40 to 50 years old; for
- 1:11example, in Studies on Hysteria from
- 1:141895, which was done in collaboration
- 1:20with his colleague Josef Breuer, and it
- 1:23analyzes the study of hysterical
- 1:25patients, which was a type of
- 1:27phenomenology typical of his time, in
- 1:30which patients had some kind of
- 1:33inhibition or paralysis in their body,
- 1:36for example: fainting, blindness, or
- 1:38becoming paralyzed, and these were not
- 1:41associated with a somatic symptom; that
- 1:44is, there was no biological explanation
- 1:48for why these women suffered from these
- 1:51symptoms. Therefore, Freud's position
- 1:55is that these symptoms were
- 1:57psychosomatic, that is, they originated
- 1:59in the psyche and in an internal
- 2:01psychic conflict that could be
- 2:03discovered through hypnosis at first,
- 2:06through the cathartic method, but later
- 2:09through free association. Why? This is
- 2:13an evolution in the psychoanalytic
- 2:16method because, in principle, what was
- 2:18discovered through hypnosis did not
- 2:20leave, so to speak, traces in
- 2:22consciousness during the subsequent
- 2:24period, and while the symptoms subsided
- 2:26, they later returned. Therefore, free
- 2:30association, saying everything that
- 2:32comes to your mind without moral,
- 2:34ethical, or rational prejudice, proved
- 2:36to be a more convenient method. Then,
- 2:40what is considered the first
- 2:41psychoanalytic work per se, The
- 2:43Interpretation of Dreams, from 1899,
- 2:471900, basically at the dawn of the
- 2:50century. In it, Sigmund Freud speaks to
- 2:54us of the royal road to the unconscious
- 2:56, which is precisely dreams. Evidently,
- 2:59when you are asleep you are not awake,
- 3:02when you are asleep you are not
- 3:03conscious. On the contrary, reason,
- 3:07which dominates our waking life, so to
- 3:10speak, is resting, and dream images are
- 3:12anything but reasonable. There is a
- 3:17structure there, Freud says, that can
- 3:19be distinguished between the manifest
- 3:21—what we remember of the dream, which
- 3:23perhaps isn't exactly like that because
- 3:26it obviously has to pass through
- 3:27daytime logic—and the latent content,
- 3:29that is, the hidden meaning that
- 3:31underlies dreams. The combination of
- 3:35these elements could account for, uh,
- 3:38what representations or what emotions
- 3:40are found in our unconscious. Here it
- 3:44is important to highlight the concepts
- 3:46of condensation and displacement.
- 3:48Condensation means that multiple
- 3:51representations, images, or ideas merge
- 3:54into one. And displacement means that
- 3:58something more important is shifted
- 4:00onto something less relevant. In "The
- 4:12Psychopathology of Everyday Life" of
- 4:141901, Freud gives us an account of how
- 4:23many seemingly trivial everyday
- 4:25phenomena, such as lapses, slips of the
- 4:28tongue, or calling one name instead of
- 4:31another, are not mere coincidences;
- 4:33that is, it is not just something that
- 4:36happens by accident, but can be the
- 4:39expression of repressed desires,
- 4:41internal conflicts, or unprocessed
- 4:44emotions; it can precisely be a sign of
- 4:48what is found in the unconscious. In "
- 4:54Three Essays on the Theory of Sexuality
- 4:56" of 1905, Freud sets out his theory on
- 4:58human sexuality: that sexuality is not
- 5:01something purely reproductive; that is,
- 5:03it does not only fulfill the function
- 5:06of species reproduction, but, in the
- 5:08human case, it has to do with the
- 5:10experiences undergone by people and
- 5:12their own desire. Obviously, there is a
- 5:16development of sexuality that Freud
- 5:19believes starts in childhood and
- 5:21evolves during adolescence and
- 5:23adulthood. Freud considers that
- 5:27sexuality is a broad phenomenon that is
- 5:29not only related to reproduction, but
- 5:31to the pursuit of pleasure and the
- 5:33avoidance of unpleasure. In Three
- 5:38Essays, we have the development of the
- 5:41theory of psychosexual development of
- 5:43the libido, in which he explains that
- 5:46it goes through different stages in
- 5:49which the child partially experiences
- 5:52that pleasure; that is, the drive is
- 5:54fixed on a part of their body.
- 5:59Obviously, this is also associated with
- 6:01the development of the Oedipus complex,
- 6:03a fundamental theory for psychoanalysis
- 6:05. According to psychoanalysis, between
- 6:09the ages of three and six, the child
- 6:11falls in love with one of their parents
- 6:14and considers the other as their rival
- 6:16for the love of that parent. This is
- 6:20called the Oedipus complex because, as
- 6:22you know, it is based on the tragedy of
- 6:25Oedipus. For Freud, this conflict is
- 6:28fundamental to the formation of
- 6:30personality, and how the Oedipus is
- 6:32accepted or resolved—that is, this
- 6:34impossibility of fulfillment, the
- 6:36prohibition of incest—is how the
- 6:38child will be introduced into cultural
- 6:40norms and values, and precisely into
- 6:42the symbolic order. There is also a
- 6:47theory of the development of the libido
- 6:49. For Freud, libido is not the same
- 6:53thing as, shall we say, instinct.
- 6:56Animals have instincts, which are fixed
- 6:58: the reproductive instinct, the
- 7:00shelter instinct, the feeding instinct.
- 7:04In contrast, in human beings, the
- 7:06libido can develop. The libido, while
- 7:10having a somatic component—that is,
- 7:12it originates in the body—finds its
- 7:14realization outside of it; that is, in
- 7:17an object upon which the libido can be
- 7:19deposited, and that object is
- 7:21contingent. Let's say that, shaped by
- 7:26early experiences of satisfaction, the
- 7:28human being will desire, and will
- 7:30desire in a particular way, not like
- 7:32everyone else, but rather it will
- 7:34obviously be something subjective. We
- 7:38are obviously already talking about the
- 7:40first topography. According to the
- 7:42first topography, Freud describes the
- 7:44psychic apparatus as having a conscious
- 7:46part, which is what we might call
- 7:48thoughts; but, in reality, it is a
- 7:50system that, so to speak, processes or
- 7:52makes decisions regarding stimuli
- 7:53coming from both the outside, from
- 7:55reality, and from the inside, from the
- 7:57body. We have a preconscious aspect,
- 8:01which is exactly what lies just below
- 8:03consciousness. These are all the
- 8:05motions or representations that are not
- 8:07currently conscious, but are
- 8:09susceptible to becoming conscious, for
- 8:10example, memory and so on. You are not
- 8:13currently thinking about your phone
- 8:15number, but when you want to, you can
- 8:17recall it. And then there is an
- 8:19unconscious aspect, which is not
- 8:21susceptible to becoming conscious. That
- 8:24is to say, this is unconscious in a
- 8:26dynamic sense, not in a merely
- 8:28descriptive sense. In the unconscious,
- 8:32according to Freud, one would obviously
- 8:34find repressed desires, impulses, and
- 8:37precisely traumas. Everything that was
- 8:41expelled from consciousness for being
- 8:43too problematic or difficult to deal
- 8:45with at that moment. In "Jokes and
- 8:50Their Relation to the Unconscious" from
- 8:521905, Freud tells us that a joke does
- 8:54not only have a social function or a
- 8:57comedic function to make others laugh,
- 8:59but that every joke hides a sort of
- 9:01truth deep down. That is to say, it is
- 9:05the release of certain psychic drives
- 9:07—of these internal conflicts and
- 9:09repressed desires—through humor.
- 9:11Therefore, they would be fully
- 9:12constituted. For Freud, these are the
- 9:15manifestations of the unconscious; as
- 9:17you know, the royal road, which is the
- 9:19dream, and everyday manifestations like
- 9:22lapses, slips, saying one proper name
- 9:24instead of another, or failing to
- 9:26remember a proper name. And in this
- 9:28particular case, the joke. In Totem and
- 9:39Taboo from 1913, what is called
- 9:41Freudian metapsychology begins, that is
- 9:43, how Freud explains structural aspects
- 9:45of culture through psychoanalysis. For
- 9:51example, he speculates that initially,
- 9:53human organizations or groups were
- 9:55organized as primitive hordes, just
- 9:57like other primates, where a single
- 10:00alpha male would be the possessor of
- 10:02all the females, to which a limit had
- 10:04been placed. His organized sons, since
- 10:09they could not face the father alone,
- 10:11would gather in a kind of conspiracy
- 10:14against him and defeat him all together
- 10:16, incorporating him in order to absorb
- 10:19his strength. In this way, the totem,
- 10:23meaning the prohibition, the symbol
- 10:25that inspires care and fear, would be
- 10:28precisely the paternal law of not
- 10:30touching the females of the clan, which
- 10:32through guilt would be internalized in
- 10:35this group or band of brothers, making
- 10:37it so you cannot touch the females of
- 10:39the clan and establishing the need for
- 10:42alliance with other clans. In short,
- 10:45the same thing Lévi-Strauss describes,
- 10:47which is how the first human
- 10:49communities were formed beyond the clan
- 10:51or herd group. In On Narcissism from
- 10:571914, Freud talks about how narcissism
- 10:59is a key stage in the development of
- 11:02the psyche. There is a primary
- 11:05narcissism, which refers to the fact
- 11:07that initially, energy is completely
- 11:09directed toward oneself. And a
- 11:12secondary narcissism that occurs when
- 11:14that energy previously directed toward
- 11:16external objects is withdrawn back onto
- 11:18the ego as a response to trauma or
- 11:20frustrations. We must mention then that
- 11:23for Freud, psychic energy or libido is
- 11:25divided into two, one that is egoic,
- 11:27which is what could be called
- 11:29narcissistic. There must always be a
- 11:32quantum of energy in the ego to sustain
- 11:34it, self-esteem, or self-perception or
- 11:36conception of oneself, the "self," as
- 11:38the North Americans would say. And
- 11:43there is an object-libidinal energy,
- 11:45that is, one that has to be deposited
- 11:47outside the ego; it is what leads you,
- 11:49motivates you, or moves you to desire
- 11:52external things or the like, whether
- 11:54they be material objects, distinctions,
- 11:56a title, etcetera. We must clarify that
- 12:01this introductory study on narcissism
- 12:03is notable because it is the first time
- 12:05the term narcissistic is used in a
- 12:07non-pathological way. A narcissist
- 12:11isn't necessarily someone suffering
- 12:13from a narcissistic disorder, as would
- 12:16be defined today, but rather anyone who
- 12:19obviously has a buffer, a hint, or a
- 12:22protection of their ego or self-concept
- 12:24. Obviously, there is a normal
- 12:27narcissism, which we all have, and then
- 12:29there is pathological narcissism. In "
- 12:38Beyond the Pleasure Principle" from
- 12:401920, Freud begins to suspect that what
- 12:42he had described as the psychic
- 12:44apparatus—that elementary principle
- 12:47known as the pleasure principle, which
- 12:49governed psychic functions—seeking
- 12:52pleasure and avoiding pain, is not the
- 12:54only reality in what we could call
- 12:56human phenomenology. This came from
- 13:02cases of veterans returning from the
- 13:05Great War who experienced nightmares
- 13:07where they would relive everything they
- 13:11had endured, all this anguish, which
- 13:13served no purpose, since waking up in
- 13:16renewed terror clearly wouldn't help
- 13:19the person's psychic apparatus. So,
- 13:24Freud begins to theorize that there is
- 13:27a principle beyond the pleasure
- 13:29principle, which is the principle of
- 13:31Thanatos or the death drive, and he
- 13:34begins to describe two types of drives
- 13:37that would no longer be just sexual
- 13:39drives, but the life drive and the
- 13:42death drive. According to these
- 13:47concepts, the life drive would be any
- 13:49movement of desire that leads you to
- 13:52obtain benefits such as the
- 13:54satisfaction of your basic needs, but
- 13:56also honors, prestige, social pride,
- 13:59and the fulfillment of love or desire.
- 14:04In contrast, Thanatos would be the
- 14:06opposing drive or the death drive,
- 14:08which would lead you to seek the peace
- 14:10of the grave—that is, a prior state
- 14:12in which you no longer needed anything
- 14:14and would not need anything again,
- 14:16namely, the inanimate state. Just as
- 14:20one, when thirsty, desires to drink
- 14:23some liquid to return to the state
- 14:25before being thirsty. This would be the
- 14:29death drive: seeking a moment in which
- 14:32nothing bothers or disturbs you anymore
- 14:35. In "Group Psychology and the Analysis
- 14:39of the Ego" from 1921—and I must
- 14:41clarify, I’m going to make a very
- 14:42narcissistic clarification—there is a
- 14:44video on the channel for each and every
- 14:46one of these texts. If you have to
- 14:49study any of these texts in particular,
- 14:51obviously I am only providing a very
- 14:52brief overview, but if you want a more
- 14:54extensive summary, just type the
- 14:56channel name "Resúmenes en Telequia"
- 14:57followed by the text's name, and it
- 14:59will appear in the YouTube search. "
- 15:02Group Psychology and the Analysis of
- 15:04the Ego" is a treatise on
- 15:05metapsychology, just like "Totem and
- 15:07Taboo." Freud attempts to explain what
- 15:10binds human masses together, that is,
- 15:13why we can remain united and
- 15:14collaborate with one another. There
- 15:18were various hypotheses, such as the
- 15:20mass mind, the hive mind, the contagion
- 15:23theory, and so on. None of these
- 15:27satisfy Freud, and he postulates that
- 15:30what keeps us united is a sort of
- 15:33libidinal structure; we deposit into
- 15:36the leader, group, mass, or ideal of
- 15:38this group part of our own ego-ideal,
- 15:41that is, part of our dreams,
- 15:44motivations, desires, and aspirations.
- 15:48And therefore, that keeps us united to
- 15:50all the other people who belong to that
- 15:52mass. Think about it: what is it that
- 15:55unites you with your college classmates
- 15:57, your fellow believers, or your fellow
- 15:59political party members? It is not
- 16:02every single characteristic of theirs,
- 16:04because each will have artistic,
- 16:06intellectual, and all sorts of
- 16:08completely diverse, different, and
- 16:11varied tastes. What unites you with
- 16:14that person is the motive for which you
- 16:16are in the group and the ideal that is
- 16:18shared. Therefore, the libido or the
- 16:22erotic, what has to do with the life
- 16:25drive, would be what unites the mass.
- 16:35In The Ego and the Id of 1923, he
- 16:37begins to delve into what will be
- 16:39called the second topography. Here we
- 16:44would have an ego, which represents the
- 16:46conscious and rational part of the mind
- 16:48, our thoughts tasked with dealing with
- 16:50instinctual demands, such as those of
- 16:52the id. I want to, but the id won't let
- 16:57me, as one of Sigmund Freud's patients
- 16:59used to say. The source of repressed
- 17:03desires and unconscious drives, the
- 17:05source of instinct and impulse,
- 17:07everything related to the body and,
- 17:10obviously, the moral restrictions
- 17:12imposed by the superego; the
- 17:13internalization of ethical and social
- 17:16norms, initially through parental
- 17:18figures. So, the ego is pulled, so to
- 17:23speak, between what instinct and the
- 17:26most primitive desire demand you do and
- 17:29what your ethical and moral
- 17:32prohibitions tell you is right or wrong
- 17:35. And apart from that, a third way,
- 17:38which is reality itself. Reality
- 17:40obviously imposes its own limits. This
- 17:43is what would cause internal conflicts.
- 17:47And for Freud, psychoanalysis would be
- 17:49a sort of empowerment of the ego, a
- 17:51conquering ego that must conquer these
- 17:54wild and rugged lands, where the id
- 17:56demands immediate and instinctual
- 17:58satisfaction. And the superego punishes
- 18:03every type of satisfaction with guilt
- 18:06and remorse. So, we would have what is
- 18:13constituted as the second topic, the
- 18:16ego as the rational and conscious
- 18:18aspect, having unconscious and latent
- 18:20aspects, such as its defense and
- 18:22repression mechanisms. The ego expels
- 18:25from consciousness everything it cannot
- 18:26tolerate. The id is fully unconscious,
- 18:30meaning it is what the unconscious
- 18:32would be in the first topic, the
- 18:35reservoir of drive, all that is
- 18:37instinctive and animal, and the
- 18:39superego, which is the incorporation of
- 18:41the laws, morals, and ethics of society
- 18:44and culture, obviously through the
- 18:46Oedipus complex, the prohibitions
- 18:48established initially within the family
- 18:51by the father figure. The superego
- 18:55would also have conscious and
- 18:56unconscious aspects. We would have a
- 19:00conscious superego, which is our mere
- 19:03moral standards, our Jiminy Cricket,
- 19:05and an unconscious superego that
- 19:08represses severely and for which you
- 19:10are never good enough, and everything
- 19:13you do is somehow stained with a tint
- 19:16of sin or wrongness. A tyrannical
- 19:20superego. In Inhibitions, Symptoms and
- 19:25Anxiety from 1926, Freud writes about
- 19:27these three phenomena. Inhibition is a
- 19:30sort of reduction in the functions or
- 19:33capacity of the ego, meaning something
- 19:36you are prevented from carrying out in
- 19:39a normal or standard way. The symptom
- 19:43is a substitute formation that arises
- 19:45as part of this conflict between the
- 19:47ego, the id, and the superego,
- 19:49representing a symbolic realization of
- 19:51repressed desires that often
- 19:53accompanies suffering. The person
- 19:56suffering from a psychic symptom is
- 19:58precisely a way of symbolizing, of
- 20:00metaphorizing that internal conflict.
- 20:04And finally, anxiety is seen as that
- 20:06which would be a signal of preparation
- 20:08against psychic danger, the big
- 20:10difference being that the person who
- 20:13suffers from a symptom or a typical
- 20:15neurotic feels anxiety toward something
- 20:17undefined. It is not towards an
- 20:21imminent, real, and certain danger, but
- 20:23an endless neurotic anxiety. The Future
- 20:34of an Illusion from 1927, another of
- 20:36his metapsychology treatises where he
- 20:39asks what the social function of
- 20:40religion is. Religion is not strictly
- 20:44false, but an illusion or a fantasy. We
- 20:47must incorporate here the concept of
- 20:49fantasy for Freud. For Freud, fantasy
- 20:52is fundamentally protective. Where
- 20:55there is a danger from external reality
- 20:57or internal psychic reality. Fantasy
- 21:00comes to cover up where reality is
- 21:02frustrating, dangerous, or painful.
- 21:05Therefore, that loving father who
- 21:07protects us and loves us all equally
- 21:09would be this sort of illusion of a
- 21:12kind and omnipotent dad who can protect
- 21:14us all. It would be a kind of
- 21:17collective neurosis, says Freud. Now,
- 21:20if at some point science and the
- 21:23development of human cultural activity
- 21:25were to protect us from nature and from
- 21:28other human beings, if we reached an
- 21:31ideal, scientific, and rational society
- 21:34, would religion be necessary, would it
- 21:37survive in some way? "Civilization and
- 21:41Its Discontents" from 1930, another of
- 21:43his important metapsychology treatises,
- 21:45talks about how culture is the
- 21:47prosthesis of the human being. Human
- 21:49beings do not have large claws, wings,
- 21:52or teeth. What protects us from the
- 21:55elements is culture. We can weave our
- 21:59clothes and build our little hut and
- 22:02protect ourselves from what is adverse.
- 22:06With our weapons, our spears, and our
- 22:08arrows, we are more effective hunters
- 22:11than any other. However, culture
- 22:14protects just as it restricts what we
- 22:16have seen as cultural norms; ethics,
- 22:19morality, and sexual repression are
- 22:21also part of the protection from the
- 22:24other great homo homini lupus, the
- 22:26other great wolf of man, which is man
- 22:29himself. Culture protects us both from
- 22:33nature and from other human beings, and
- 22:35therefore this is the paradox. The more
- 22:39it protects us, the more it represses
- 22:41us, and therefore the more we suffer
- 22:43anguish and the greater the discontent
- 22:45that is generated. Well, obviously, in
- 22:48Freud's Victorian society, the
- 22:50prohibitions and cultural norms were
- 22:52much more severe. The more developed a
- 22:54civilization is, the more discontent it
- 22:57will generate. "Moses and Monotheism"
- 23:01from 1939. In this speculative
- 23:05historical treatise, Freud asks himself
- 23:07if Moses was not a prophet of the
- 23:09religion of Aten. You already know that
- 23:12Aten was the solar disk, which was
- 23:15worshipped by the cursed pharaoh
- 23:16Akhenaten and his wife Nefertiti, who
- 23:19were later erased from the history of
- 23:21Egypt. Well, here they wonder if what
- 23:24happened with Moses, who finally
- 23:26disappeared, does not have to do with
- 23:28what had been described in "Totem and
- 23:30Taboo" regarding the assimilation of
- 23:32the father by the primal horde of
- 23:34brothers, and well, a whole issue that
- 23:37has to do with religion, psychoanalysis
- 23:39, and anthropology. And the function of
- 23:42the paternal figure or authority. It is
- 23:46a very interesting treatise, Leandro.
- 23:48Finally, let's move on to Carl Jung.
- 23:52The great difference between Freud's
- 23:54psychoanalysis and Jung's
- 23:55psychoanalysis, which is always
- 23:56mentioned as being the collective
- 23:58unconscious or the individual
- 23:59unconscious, no, that is not it. The
- 24:02great difference between Jung and Freud
- 24:04is that Jung believed in a non-sexual
- 24:06theory of the libido. That is to say,
- 24:10the libido would not be a sexual energy
- 24:13that is born in the body and has as its
- 24:16object a contingent object external to
- 24:18the subject, but rather it would be a
- 24:21sort of energy like prana or chi, or
- 24:24any form of Eastern spiritual energy.
- 24:28What is it that human beings have to,
- 24:32uh, metaphorize or, so to speak,
- 24:35manifest or carry out their desire? It
- 24:38would be a sort of universal energy and
- 24:41not related to the sexual aspect.
- 24:43Obviously, he doesn't believe solely in
- 24:45an individual unconscious, but believes
- 24:48that the individual unconscious is part
- 24:50of something larger, which is the
- 24:52collective unconscious, shared by all
- 24:55human groups and all cultures of
- 24:57humanity. In fact, he believes in this:
- 25:00he approaches structuralists like
- 25:02Lévi-Strauss and others, that all
- 25:04cultures share similar rites and myths,
- 25:07and that beyond the cultural filling of
- 25:09each one, they share figures he calls
- 25:11archetypes—I don't know, the father,
- 25:14the mother, the warrior, the wise man,
- 25:16etc.—and that this would precisely be
- 25:19the reflection of the existence of the
- 25:21collective unconscious. Just as Freud
- 25:26believed that through dreams one can
- 25:28manage to access the unconscious, in
- 25:30this case also the collective
- 25:32unconscious, and that often we dream of
- 25:35metaphorical figures, for example, a
- 25:37king who could represent our father,
- 25:39because we are precisely dreaming of
- 25:41collective archetypes that are giving
- 25:44us, uh, clues on how to direct our life
- 25:46in major changes or great processes of
- 25:49transformation of the subject. In the
- 25:53same way, the repressed aspect of the
- 25:54unconscious, he will call it the shadow
- 25:56. All this that we do not accept about
- 26:00ourselves, and part of analytical
- 26:02therapy would be precisely to integrate
- 26:05our ego with our shadow, that is, our
- 26:07conscious and rational aspects with our
- 26:10, uh, not-so-bright aspects. Finally, I
- 26:21have the audacity to make a brief
- 26:24introduction to Lacan. Obviously Lacan
- 26:28is super complex, I won't finish him in
- 26:30this video, and this is only what I
- 26:32know of Lacan, which I don't know if
- 26:34it's much or little, but it can serve
- 26:37as a clue for you to have a vague idea
- 26:39of how to approach this author. We are
- 26:44going to look at the mirror stage, the
- 26:46function and field of language in
- 26:48psychoanalysis, obviously the three
- 26:50orders—imaginary, symbolic, and real
- 26:53—and the return to Freud. Be Lacanian
- 26:56if you want, "I am Freudian," said
- 26:58Lacan. For Lacan, the mirror stage is a
- 27:06process by which the child, who in
- 27:08principle was composed of these partial
- 27:11drives that Freud described—the need
- 27:13for shelter through the skin, the
- 27:16desire for satisfaction of hunger
- 27:18through the mouth, the motility of the
- 27:21different limbs—manages to integrate
- 27:24by recognizing their image in the
- 27:26mirror. But this recognition obviously
- 27:29does not happen in a solipsistic way,
- 27:32because the child is a genius and
- 27:34arrives at this discovery, but
- 27:36precisely because the mother stands him
- 27:39in front of the mirror and points and
- 27:41says: "Well, the typical phrases, who
- 27:44is that beautiful baby?". That baby is
- 27:47you, and so on. In this way, the
- 27:50perception generates an experience of
- 27:53alienation in which the child manages
- 27:55to integrate all these partial drives
- 27:57projected onto this external image,
- 28:00thus constituting the order of the
- 28:02imaginary. Therefore, we have three
- 28:09orders for Lacan. What for Freud would
- 28:11be superego, ego, in Lacan would be the
- 28:18imaginary, symbolic, and real. The
- 28:21imaginary is precisely what we have
- 28:23just described, our relationships with
- 28:26our images, identifications, and
- 28:27fantasies that make up the ego, that is
- 28:30, the phantasm. This that we have
- 28:32discussed, what is protective when
- 28:35reality is frustrating and limiting,
- 28:37this would make up the person's self or
- 28:39ego. Then the symbolic, when one
- 28:43accepts the norms and provisions of
- 28:46society through the Oedipus complex, it
- 28:48would be formed through a network of
- 28:51structures of symbols, laws, and norms
- 28:53that have to do with culture. And this
- 28:57is structured by language, social and
- 28:59cultural norms introjected through the
- 29:01Name of the Father. Name of the Father,
- 29:05because at some point the mother will
- 29:07stop looking at the baby in that
- 29:09undefined and perfect dyad and will
- 29:11begin to name the father. And well,
- 29:14finally the real, that which remains
- 29:17outside the symbolic order and the
- 29:19imaginary order. That is to say, there
- 29:22remains a remnant of meaning that can
- 29:23never be put into words. The unsaid,
- 29:26the never said. Trying to describe the
- 29:30real order would be absurd because it
- 29:32is like that Lovecraft meme describing
- 29:35an indescribable creature. Anything I
- 29:38might say about the real remains
- 29:40outside the field or the order of the
- 29:43real. But to give you an idea, it is
- 29:46that which cannot be put into words.
- 29:49Suppose death, the afterlife, the
- 29:52orgasm, and so on, different orders
- 29:54that are inaccessible to the
- 29:57subjectivity or phenomenology of the
- 30:00human being. For Lacan, the Oedipus
- 30:05complex has three stages. In the first
- 30:07moment, the child lives an exclusive
- 30:09relationship of desire with the mother.
- 30:11He completes the mother and the mother
- 30:13feels completed by him. It is a sort of
- 30:15dyad without the presence of the father
- 30:17. In a second stage, the figure and the
- 30:20name of the father appear as a symbolic
- 30:22instance of prohibition and separation
- 30:24so the child does not remain
- 30:25introjected by the mother. This is the
- 30:28big difference between Freud and Lacan.
- 30:30Freud believed that the father
- 30:31prohibited the child from being with
- 30:33the mother. For Lacan, the father
- 30:36represents the prohibitive stance of
- 30:38culture and the symbolic order,
- 30:40forbidding two things: the child from
- 30:42being with the mother, and the mother
- 30:44from believing she is complete through
- 30:46the child. And obviously, the third
- 30:49stage is the internalization of the
- 30:51paternal function, accepting the norms
- 30:52of the symbolic order that govern
- 30:54desire. In his Tokyo lecture. This is
- 31:00the text I recommend; if anyone is
- 31:02truly interested in understanding Lacan
- 31:04by reading him directly, Lacan tries to
- 31:06explain himself to an audience that
- 31:08isn't strictly psychoanalytic and isn't
- 31:10strictly Western either. So, it is the
- 31:14first time Lacan tries to be clear. He
- 31:17talks about why we use the term "
- 31:18analysand" rather than "patient,"
- 31:20because the patient is not a passive
- 31:22subject, but an active subject in the
- 31:24psychoanalytic experience. And through
- 31:28metaphor and metonymy, he tries to make
- 31:30the unconscious conscious; that is, he
- 31:33tries to bring what is in the
- 31:35structural order of the unconscious
- 31:37language into consciousness through
- 31:40free association, and he fundamentally
- 31:42talks about the essential role that
- 31:45language plays in Lacanian
- 31:46psychoanalysis. Function and field of
- 31:50language. Another fundamental text in
- 31:53which this norm is established, which
- 31:55says that the unconscious is structured
- 31:57like a language. If I have to simplify
- 32:01it tremendously for those who know
- 32:03Peirce, everything would be a sign. The
- 32:07same applies to Lacan’s structural
- 32:09reading. The symptom is a sign of
- 32:13something that must be read and
- 32:14interpreted, but not by the
- 32:15psychoanalyst; rather, precisely by the
- 32:17patient. Well, so much for our very
- 32:22brief, curious, and chaotic review. I
- 32:24hope I haven't made too many conceptual
- 32:26errors. I just wanted to give you a
- 32:29rough overview, or tell you from what
- 32:31I've heard, what psychoanalysis is
- 32:33based on its main exponents. If you
- 32:37liked it, this was very costly in
- 32:39psychic and cognitive terms; it has
- 32:41been exhausting. So if you appreciate
- 32:44it, if you reward me with a like, by
- 32:46sharing it with all your colleagues and
- 32:47friends from college or your classmates
- 32:49and friends who want to learn about
- 32:51psychoanalysis. Yeah.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Toda la Historia Del Psicoanalisis Freud Jung Lacan by Resumenes Entelekia, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,572 words across 740 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.