This School Helps Poor Kids Succeed, Teacher Unions Try To Shut It Down — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00this is our largest crew today so many
- 0:05kids from one charter school take
- 0:07advanced placement exams they had to
- 0:09rent space at a Convention
- 0:14Center kids who attend Rich suburban
- 0:16school sometimes pay $500 an hour for
- 0:20tutoring for
- 0:22tests but these kids can't afford that
- 0:26they're mostly from lowincome families
- 0:28they attend a city Charter chain yet
- 0:31they succeed outperforming their peers
- 0:33by a landslide on math test Success
- 0:36Academy kids outperform every school in
- 0:38New York state other Charters are in
- 0:41Blue on this graph government runs
- 0:43schools in Gray success kids also
- 0:45outperform other kids in English that is
- 0:48redefining American public education
- 0:50lame D young is Success Academy's Chief
- 0:52schooling officer our Black and Hispanic
- 0:57students um outperformed their peers by
- 1:00double triple perent in their math by
- 1:03peers you include the rich kids in the
- 1:05suburbs yes but school is boring no it's
- 1:11not when I first checked out this
- 1:13Charter I was amazed that these kids
- 1:16enjoyed School saying subjects like
- 1:18reading were rocking awesome so you guys
- 1:22look forward to going to school in the
- 1:23morning yes it's why lots of parents
- 1:26want to get their kids into Success
- 1:28Academy I watched them line up hoping to
- 1:32get their kids in this line goes on and
- 1:37on go forever goes around the block what
- 1:41do you do when you have thousands of
- 1:43people just a few hundred slots they
- 1:46hold a lottery the winners are happy
- 1:49sadly there are many more losers let
- 1:52mean my name going to come next time
- 1:54yeah next
- 1:58year not today that's so sad today the
- 2:02Lottery's done electronically so we
- 2:04don't get to see the thousands of kids
- 2:07and parents who cry in disappointment
- 2:10the chain wants to offer its magic to
- 2:12more kids but they aren't allowed to New
- 2:16York limits the number of charter
- 2:18schools why because some people hate
- 2:22them y aren now welcome here we will not
- 2:25welcome you here politicians and the
- 2:27teachers union have convinced many
- 2:29people people that charter schools are
- 2:31evil when Progressive Democrats are in
- 2:34charge they shut some Charters down the
- 2:36highest performing school in the state
- 2:38upsetting even media leftists and it's
- 2:41in Harlem is being shut down why shut
- 2:45down a successful school why not give
- 2:48parents more Choice here's a union Vice
- 2:51President we have a lot of choice it's
- 2:53do we need more Choice yes competition's
- 2:57good but the education establishment
- 2:59doesn't doesn't want competition
- 3:01education Advocates say charter schools
- 3:02are not the answer taking away from an
- 3:04already shrinking budget in New York
- 3:06City Public Schools that's completely
- 3:08wrong it is spending on government
- 3:10schools is not shrinking it's increasing
- 3:13despite falling enrollment also Charters
- 3:16like success get half what government
- 3:19run schools get yet with less money
- 3:23success does better why does success
- 3:26succeed cuz we believe children can
- 3:30and that is fund schools don't believe
- 3:32children can no there's low expectations
- 3:35that persist uh unfortunately and even
- 3:39more so after the pandemic at other
- 3:41schools pandemic related learning loss
- 3:43is the new normal but not its success
- 3:46every one of these kids has been
- 3:48accepted by a
- 3:50college here they cheer as friends open
- 3:53their
- 3:58acceptances that doesn't just happen one
- 4:01reason it does is because the school day
- 4:03here is longer kids often stay till 5:00
- 4:06p.m. Charter teachers can be asked to
- 4:08work more than the union would have
- 4:10allowed they told us they don't mind but
- 4:14you're going to burn out why aren't you
- 4:15ticked off that's not an option for us
- 4:18because we kind of have our eye on the
- 4:20prize with these kids now some success
- 4:23parents do pull their kids out because
- 4:25of the extra hours required critics say
- 4:28that raises average test scores for kids
- 4:31who remain probably does but so what
- 4:35high expectations are a good thing for
- 4:37many kids thousands from low-income
- 4:40families now succeed because this
- 4:43Charter chain innovates at most schools
- 4:46the principal sits in the principal's
- 4:48office not a success no they're in the
- 4:51classrooms what are they telling you
- 4:53they're telling me things that I don't
- 4:54see if I don't think of a great question
- 4:57in this in the moment my principal's
- 4:59able to kind of feed that to me we
- 5:00expect not only change but fast change
- 5:03some teachers don't like being watched
- 5:06and criticized no but it's purposeful
- 5:09and they're getting better and when they
- 5:10get better their Scholars do better and
- 5:13they feel as Educators more successful
- 5:16uh and that's what you want most high
- 5:17school students never even take advanced
- 5:19placement tests of those who take them
- 5:22in New York City only half pass but all
- 5:25success kids take the tests and 80% pass
- 5:30we were all pretty nervous about this
- 5:31test it was like oh my god wow I'm
- 5:34really about to take my first AP exam
- 5:36you're a freshman most people don't take
- 5:38that until junior or senior year if then
- 5:41I think that makes me more proud these
- 5:43kids must be miserable they're working
- 5:45all the time why are they miserable
- 5:47they're having fun
- 5:51learning success offers dance and other
- 5:54activities it's not schoolwork all the
- 5:56time chess debate theater music those
- 6:00aren't add-ons those are part of our day
- 6:03this student was surprised that her
- 6:04friend at a government run school had
- 6:06few extracurriculars to put on her
- 6:08college application I was like don't you
- 6:11like have any like leadership positions
- 6:13like you should just go for student
- 6:14council and they didn't have one and I
- 6:16was like that's shocking well you should
- 6:18like make one and they were like oh like
- 6:19my school doesn't do that I was like
- 6:21okay how about like a club and she was
- 6:23like we still don't do that success does
- 6:26make its teachers work harder and longer
- 6:29some quit but so what other teachers
- 6:32like it here and the goal is for kids to
- 6:35succeed and they do I feel like it's
- 6:38unfair that not not everybody gets to
- 6:40get this opportunity if sa doesn't exist
- 6:42then we wouldn't all exist and we
- 6:44wouldn't have all the cool opportunities
- 6:46that we have it's great that the kids
- 6:48here could have a choice and pick a
- 6:50better school all kids should have that
- 6:55choice choice is good in all things you
- 6:59two has millions of channels they're
- 7:01everywhere here competition makes me
- 7:04work harder if you want to help us
- 7:06compete please click that button
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of This School Helps Poor Kids Succeed, Teacher Unions Try To Shut It Down by John Stossel, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,083 words across 161 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.