This Nobel Prize Winner Has a Really Strange Theory About the Mind — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00This video is sponsored by Factor. Get
- 0:02chef-crafted, ready-to-eat meals
- 0:04delivered straight to your door. Go to
- 0:05factor75.com
- 0:07and use code WONDERFB50 to get 50% off
- 0:10your first Factor box and free breakfast
- 0:12for 1 year.
- 0:14In 2003, J.M. Coetzee was awarded the
- 0:16Nobel Prize in literature. When giving
- 0:19his acceptance speech, he didn't discuss
- 0:21his career, he didn't lecture about
- 0:22culture or politics, he didn't thank
- 0:25anyone, he didn't even really discuss
- 0:27literature.
- 0:29Instead, he gave one of, if not the most
- 0:31unusual Nobel Prize acceptance speeches
- 0:33in history.
- 0:34Following a brief reference to a
- 0:36childhood memory, he proceeded to recite
- 0:38a strange kind of parable. When
- 0:39introducing it, he said,
- 0:41"The piece is called He and His Man or
- 0:44His Man and He.
- 0:45I cannot remember which comes first, He
- 0:48or His Man."
- 0:50This was not a lapse in Coetzee's
- 0:51memory. He knew the name of the story.
- 0:53[music]
- 0:55Fundamentally, we all live two separate
- 0:58lives. One is our direct lived
- 1:00experience. That is, what our bodies and
- 1:03brains encounter, produce, [music] and
- 1:05sense. All that is unconscious or
- 1:07external, but nonetheless real and
- 1:09integral to who we are.
- 1:11The second is our conscious awareness.
- 1:13That is, what our conscious mind
- 1:15observes, comprehends, conceptualizes,
- 1:17and tracks through language, ideas,
- 1:20beliefs, [music] and stories.
- 1:22In Coetzee's speech, he refers to two
- 1:24men, He and His Man.
- 1:27He is an old retired sailor who has
- 1:29moved on from adventure and sea life and
- 1:31now spends almost all of his time alone
- 1:33in his room.
- 1:34His primary interaction with the world
- 1:36and others is through reports that he
- 1:38regularly receives from the character
- 1:40referred to as His Man,
- 1:42an individual who travels around Europe
- 1:43encountering various events and
- 1:45phenomena.
- 1:46It is soon revealed that the retired
- 1:48sailor is Robinson Crusoe, one of the
- 1:50most famous fictional characters in
- 1:52history.
- 1:53This character originated in the 1719
- 1:55novel titled Robinson Crusoe, written by
- 1:58the author Daniel Defoe,
- 2:00in which he is an English sailor who is
- 2:02shipwrecked on a remote island for 28
- 2:04years before finally being rescued.
- 2:07What turns Coetzee's speech from
- 2:09interesting to profound, and perhaps a
- 2:11bit unsettling, is that Crusoe's
- 2:13correspondent, [music] his man, is
- 2:15Daniel Defoe.
- 2:17In other words, Defoe is sending
- 2:18messages to the character he created in
- 2:21the story [music]
- 2:22Coetzee created.
- 2:24In Coetzee's story, Crusoe and Defoe
- 2:26have a strange and ambiguous kind of
- 2:28relationship. On one hand, they seem to
- 2:30know and depend on each other
- 2:31intimately. On the other hand,
- 2:33>> [music]
- 2:34>> they appear to be quite unknown and
- 2:35distant to each other. Neither really
- 2:37know the life of the other directly.
- 2:40Crusoe knows of Defoe's experiences
- 2:41[music] only through his reports, and
- 2:43Defoe seems to know of Crusoe, if at
- 2:45all, only as a kind of receiving entity
- 2:48of his reports.
- 2:49Coetzee says,
- 2:51"How are they to be figured, this man
- 2:52and he?
- 2:53As master [music] and slave? As
- 2:55brothers, twin brothers? As comrades in
- 2:58arms? Or as enemies, foes?
- 3:01What name shall he give this nameless
- 3:02fellow with whom he shares his evenings
- 3:05and sometimes his nights, too, who is
- 3:07absent only in the daytime,
- 3:08>> [music]
- 3:08>> when he, Robin, walks the keys
- 3:10inspecting the new arrivals, and his man
- 3:13gallops about the kingdom making his
- 3:14inspections?"
- 3:18There are many ways one could interpret
- 3:19the premise to such an enigmatic story
- 3:21and character relationship. On a
- 3:23literary level, it seems to possibly be
- 3:25a reflection on the relationship between
- 3:27writer or artist [music]
- 3:28and the characters or things they
- 3:30create. What does a writer or artist do
- 3:32if not report their lived experiences to
- 3:34a kind of entity [music] of reception,
- 3:36their work, their worlds, and their
- 3:38characters?
- 3:39In this, the creator feels as though
- 3:41they are producing a character, story,
- 3:43or [music] world, but in a way, they are
- 3:46sort of already there.
- 3:47That is, the character, story, or world
- 3:50already exists [music] as a kind of
- 3:51nebulous entity of lived experience.
- 3:53They merely increasingly form into
- 3:55semi-tangible structures as they receive
- 3:57more information from the creator's
- 3:58conscious [music] mind. A kind of
- 4:00embodiment of the creator's awareness
- 4:02and experience as they're assembled with
- 4:04words and features. Coetzee writes,
- 4:07"How then has it come about that this
- 4:09man of his, who is a kind of parrot and
- 4:11not much loved, writes as well as or
- 4:13better than his master?
- 4:14>> [music]
- 4:15>> For he wields an able pen, this man of
- 4:17his, no doubt of that.
- 4:19Only when he yields himself up to this
- 4:20man of his do such words come."
- 4:25There's also a deeper interpretation
- 4:27here. The very nature of the mind and
- 4:29consciousness,
- 4:30how we form knowledge and understanding,
- 4:32and how we don't.
- 4:34Whether we write or not, whether we
- 4:36publish or not, each of us are authors.
- 4:39Our self, the conscious observer and
- 4:41narrator of our lives, is the product of
- 4:43our minds' creative work. The stories we
- 4:45tell ourselves about ourselves and the
- 4:47world, the concepts we form, and the
- 4:50beliefs we hold. Our source material,
- 4:52our inspiration, is all of the
- 4:54sensations of the body and brain and
- 4:56their interactions with the external
- 4:57world.
- 4:58Naturally, these two channels,
- 5:00experiencer and observer, are always
- 5:02trying to work together.
- 5:04Both born of and sharing the same
- 5:05fundamental substrate of being, they
- 5:07both operate toward the same shared
- 5:09goals, survival and continuance.
- 5:12On the unconscious experiential level,
- 5:14this is fairly obvious. We automatically
- 5:17try to catch our balance when we trip,
- 5:19move our hand away from something hot or
- 5:21sharp. We blink and breathe
- 5:22automatically. Our heart rate
- 5:24automatically increases
- 5:26>> [music]
- 5:26>> and we become adrenalized when we
- 5:28perceive a threat, and so on.
- 5:30On the conscious observer level, it's
- 5:32slightly less obvious, but still
- 5:34apparent. We attempt to make order,
- 5:36meaning, and rigidity out of our
- 5:37experiences [music]
- 5:38through language, concepts, stories, and
- 5:40beliefs. Our conscious mind attempts to
- 5:42make sense of, tolerates, and
- 5:44rationalize events so that we can best
- 5:46endure and proceed onward.
- 5:49Though the miracle of human
- 5:50consciousness and the degree of our
- 5:51conceptual awareness is perhaps only
- 5:53second to the miracle of existence
- 5:55itself, it is of course deeply limited.
- 5:58We can only comprehend what we can
- 5:59perceive, [music] and we can only
- 6:01perceive what the human brain has
- 6:02evolved to process.
- 6:04Moreover, words and concepts are always
- 6:06merely a proxy, symbols of reality and
- 6:09experience, never the real things.
- 6:12Thus, these two channels of experience
- 6:14don't really understand each other all
- 6:16that well. One is out in the world
- 6:18experiencing a chaos of phenomena, while
- 6:20the other is alone inside its room
- 6:22trying to parse the chaos into clarity.
- 6:26What is left is a kind of dissonance
- 6:27between reality and consciousness.
- 6:31In Coetzee's story, one of the main
- 6:32reports sent back to Crusoe describes
- 6:35what are known as duck decoy systems,
- 6:37elaborate traps constructed to lure wild
- 6:39ducks to be killed for food. Using
- 6:42ponds, nets, channels, and decoy ducks,
- 6:44the configurations are designed to look
- 6:46natural and safe, deceiving the ducks
- 6:48into moving through them until
- 6:50>> [music]
- 6:50>> they become trapped.
- 6:51From the ducks' perspectives, they
- 6:53aren't doing anything odd or unnatural.
- 6:55The traps work because they look
- 6:56completely real and safe to the ducks.
- 6:59They see waterways, food, and other
- 7:01ducks, and they simply follow their
- 7:02instincts of perception.
- 7:04But in the end, the pond is not real,
- 7:07and the ducks become consumed.
- 7:09Coetzee writes,
- 7:11"By these representations, which are
- 7:13made all in duck language, they, the
- 7:15decoy ducks or duckoys, draw together
- 7:18vast numbers of fowl and, so to say,
- 7:21kidnap them.
- 7:22They guide them back across the seas
- 7:23from Holland and Germany and settle them
- 7:25down in their decoy ponds on the fens of
- 7:27Lincolnshire, chattering and gabbling to
- 7:29them all the time in their own language,
- 7:32telling them these are the ponds they
- 7:33told them of, where they shall live
- 7:35safely and securely."
- 7:38Of course, we aren't ducks, but the
- 7:40distance between the abilities of our
- 7:42perception and the true nature of
- 7:44reality is likely inconceivably further
- 7:46than the distance between us and ducks.
- 7:49Like the ducks in the decoy systems, we
- 7:52don't misunderstand reality because
- 7:53we're foolish or irrational or doing
- 7:55anything unnatural. We misunderstand
- 7:57reality because nature deceives us.
- 8:00Reality to us is a human decoy system
- 8:03constructed out of human language. And
- 8:06yet its truth is entirely beyond human
- 8:08language.
- 8:10This interpretation maps fairly cleanly
- 8:13onto several philosophical theories and
- 8:14schools of thought. What is known as
- 8:16transcendental idealism, originally
- 8:18founded by 18th century philosopher
- 8:20Immanuel Kant, argues that, in simple
- 8:22terms, human knowledge is forever
- 8:24limited to the appearances of things.
- 8:26That is, we can never access the world
- 8:28that exists outside of human perception.
- 8:31The thing in itself.
- 8:33Reality.
- 8:34What we perceive is inextricably shaped
- 8:36by the a priori structures of the human
- 8:38mind.
- 8:3919th century philosopher Arthur
- 8:40Schopenhauer argued in his masterwork,
- 8:43The World as Will and Representation,
- 8:45the world is fundamentally divided into
- 8:47two components.
- 8:48The will,
- 8:49>> [music]
- 8:49>> which is the unified underlying
- 8:50substrate of reality that endlessly
- 8:52strives to sustain and express itself,
- 8:55and representation, which is how the
- 8:57world, or the expressions of the will,
- 8:59appears to consciousness.
- 9:01According to Schopenhauer, we can never
- 9:02directly access the true reality of
- 9:04things except through bodily sensations.
- 9:07The body gives us a kind of access point
- 9:09to the will, a direct subjective
- 9:11correspondent sending us reports.
- 9:14But when trying to interpret and
- 9:15transcribe these reports into [music]
- 9:16concepts and words, we move away from
- 9:18the will and into representation,
- 9:21a distortion.
- 9:22Schopenhauer writes,
- 9:24"The world is my representation. This is
- 9:26a truth valid with reference to every
- 9:28living and knowing being, although man
- 9:30alone can bring it into reflective
- 9:32abstract consciousness.
- 9:34It then becomes clear and [music]
- 9:35certain to him that he does not know a
- 9:36sun and an earth, but only an eye that
- 9:39sees a sun and a hand [music] that feels
- 9:40an earth. That the world around him is
- 9:42there only as representation. In other
- 9:45words, only in reference to another
- 9:46thing,
- 9:47>> [music]
- 9:47>> namely that which represents.
- 9:49And this is himself.
- 9:51Everything that exists for knowledge and
- 9:53hence the whole of this world is only
- 9:54object in relation to the subject,
- 9:57perception of the perceiver.
- 9:59In a word, representation.
- 10:02Likewise, the philosophy of Taoism
- 10:05suggests that the observing self,
- 10:06experiencing self, and external world
- 10:09are all inseparable in a state of
- 10:10constant flux, carried out by what is
- 10:13referred to as the Tao, the true
- 10:15underlying unified nature of reality.
- 10:18But as such, the Tao exists solely
- 10:20beyond concepts and language. It cannot
- 10:22be named or understood. Ideas and terms,
- 10:25including the Tao itself, can only
- 10:27gesture in its direction. Reality in
- 10:29this case isn't exactly a trap, but
- 10:32trying to comprehend and categorize it
- 10:34is.
- 10:35We must rather flow with it, letting go
- 10:37of rigidity, explanations, and
- 10:39certainties.
- 10:40The opening verse of the Tao Te Ching
- 10:41reads,
- 10:43"The Tao that can be spoken is not the
- 10:44eternal Tao.
- 10:46The name that can be named is not the
- 10:47eternal name.
- 10:49The nameless is the origin of heaven and
- 10:51earth. The named is the mother of myriad
- 10:53things.
- 10:54Thus, constantly without desire, one
- 10:57observes its essence.
- 10:58Constantly with desire, one observes its
- 11:01manifestations.
- 11:02These two emerge together, but differ in
- 11:04[music] name.
- 11:05The unity is said to be the mystery,
- 11:07mystery of mysteries,
- 11:08>> [music]
- 11:09>> the door to all wonders."
- 11:11In the end, Coetzee seems to possibly be
- 11:14representing a similar kind of inability
- 11:16to comprehend the world and define the
- 11:17self through a sequence of character
- 11:19relationships.
- 11:20Robinson Crusoe's relationship with his
- 11:22creator, Daniel Defoe, and Crusoe and
- 11:24Defoe's relationship with Coetzee, who,
- 11:27in this story, is sort of their creator.
- 11:30In this web of fiction weaved out of
- 11:32experience, it isn't obvious what and
- 11:34who is real, if anything.
- 11:39Referring back to Kochi's introduction
- 11:40to his story, when he says, "The piece
- 11:43is called he and his man, or his man and
- 11:45he. I cannot remember which comes first,
- 11:48he or his man."
- 11:50There is something subtle, yet deeply
- 11:52important in this preface that seems to
- 11:54cleanly summarize the authorship problem
- 11:57of identity and truth.
- 11:59We imagine we are the author of our
- 12:00thoughts and selves, but we are
- 12:02characters being written by the reports
- 12:04of forces we barely understand or have
- 12:06access [music] to.
- 12:07We are both a character being written
- 12:09and the author of the character in the
- 12:10same story. [music]
- 12:12We are not solely the observing mind, we
- 12:14are not solely the experiencing body,
- 12:16and we are not the external world.
- 12:18We are the sum total of all of it, all
- 12:20in constant motion.
- 12:22We are each [music] an expression of the
- 12:23will, the Tao, a universal awareness,
- 12:27or the universe itself, whichever word
- 12:29or concept you like.
- 12:31Because in the end, whichever word or
- 12:33concept you like,
- 12:34is irrelevant.
- 12:38Of course, what is relevant to
- 12:40continuing on and flowing with reality
- 12:42is eating. Ironically, despite eating
- 12:44being one of the most basic and
- 12:46fundamental aspects of our condition,
- 12:48getting and preparing good quality, good
- 12:49tasting meals can be extremely
- 12:51time-consuming and inconvenient. This
- 12:53video's sponsor, Factor, [music] helps
- 12:55solve that exact problem.
- 12:57Personally, I'm not big into cooking,
- 12:59and I'm someone who tries to prioritize
- 13:00time and focus as well as I can.
- 13:03Shopping and cooking are just not often
- 13:04at the top of that list, if I can avoid
- 13:06them.
- 13:07>> [music]
- 13:07>> The problem is, of course, alternatives
- 13:09can be junk food or expensive meals out,
- 13:12but Factor makes it so I can both reduce
- 13:14time shopping and cooking without
- 13:16compromising on taste [music] or
- 13:17nutrition. Factor's meals are made with
- 13:19real ingredients, have balanced macros,
- 13:22and come with at least two vegetables
- 13:23per meal, which makes the challenge
- 13:25[music] of maintaining a balanced diet
- 13:26much easier to overcome.
- 13:28The meals are ready to eat, so no
- 13:30planning, prep, or clean up. Just open,
- 13:32heat if needed, and eat. [music]
- 13:34I absolutely love the Monterey spinach
- 13:36chicken I recently had, which was ready
- 13:38in minutes. Particularly this time of
- 13:40year, when I'm trying to maintain work
- 13:41while enjoying the summer, Factor helps
- 13:44me eat well with real food while
- 13:46reducing stress and time [music] in a
- 13:47way that is one of those things you
- 13:49notice actually improves your life. 97%
- 13:52of people say Factor helps them live a
- 13:53healthier life, and 92% say it makes
- 13:56their life [music] less stressful. I'm
- 13:57certainly one of them. Head to
- 13:59factor75.com
- 14:00or click the link below and use code
- 14:02WONDERFB50 to get 50% off your first
- 14:05Factor box, plus free breakfast [music]
- 14:07for 1 year. That's code WONDERFB50 at
- 14:10factor75.com
- 14:12to get 50% off, plus free breakfast for
- 14:141 year. Offer only valid for new Factor
- 14:16customers with the code and qualifying
- 14:19auto-renewing subscription purchase.
- 14:20[music]
- 14:22And of course, as always, thank you so
- 14:24much for watching in general,
- 14:26and see you next video.
- 14:33>> [music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of This Nobel Prize Winner Has a Really Strange Theory About the Mind by Pursuit of Wonder, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,502 words across 446 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.