YouTube2Text

Theories of Global Stratification: Crash Course Sociology #28 — Transcript

by CrashCourse · 2,125 words · 125 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00For much of human history, all of the societies on Earth were poor.
  2. 0:03Poverty was the norm for everyone.
  3. 0:05But obviously, that’s not the case anymore.
  4. 0:07Just as you find stratification among socioeconomic classes within a society, like the United States,
  5. 0:12across the world you also see a pattern of global stratification, with inequalities in wealth and power between societies.
  6. 0:19So what made some parts of the world develop faster, economically speaking, than others?
  7. 0:24[Theme Music]
  8. 0:35How you explain the differences in socioeconomic status among the world’s societies depends, of course, on which paradigm you’re using to view the world.
  9. 0:42One of the two main explanations for global stratification is modernization theory, and it comes from the structural-functionalist approach.
  10. 0:49This theory frames global stratification as a function of technological and cultural differences between nations.
  11. 0:55And it specifically pinpoints two historical events that contributed to Western Europe developing at a faster rate than much of the rest of the world.
  12. 1:02The first event is known as the Columbian Exchange.
  13. 1:04This refers to the spread of goods, technology, education, and diseases between the Americas and Europe after Columbus’s so-called discovery of the Americas.
  14. 1:13And if you wanna learn more about that, we did a whole World History episode about it.
  15. 1:16This exchange worked out pretty well for the European countries.
  16. 1:19They gained agricultural staples like potatoes and tomatoes, which contributed to population growth,
  17. 1:24and provided new opportunities for trade, while also strengthening the power of the merchant class.
  18. 1:29But the Columbian Exchange worked out much less well for Native Americans, whose populations were ravaged by the diseases brought from Europe.
  19. 1:36It’s estimated that in the 150 years following Columbus’ first trip, over 80% of the Native American population died due to diseases such as smallpox and measles.
  20. 1:44The second historical event is the Industrial Revolution in the 18th and 19th century.
  21. 1:49We’ve mentioned this before, and there are a couple World History episodes that you can check out for more detail,
  22. 1:53but this is when new technologies like steam power and mechanization allowed countries to replace human labor with machines and increase productivity.
  23. 2:02The Industrial Revolution at first only benefited the wealthy in Western countries.
  24. 2:07But industrial technology was so productive that it gradually began to improve standards of living for everyone.
  25. 2:12Countries that industrialized in the 18th and 19th century saw massive improvements in their standards of living.
  26. 2:17And countries that didn’t industrialize lagged behind.
  27. 2:20The thing to note here is that Modernization Theory rests on the idea that affluence could have happened to anyone.
  28. 2:25But of course, it didn’t.
  29. 2:26So why didn’t the Industrial Revolution take hold everywhere?
  30. 2:29Well, modernization theory argues that the tension between tradition and technological change is the biggest barrier to growth.
  31. 2:35A society that’s more steeped in family systems and traditions may be less willing to adopt new technologies, and the new social systems that often accompany them.
  32. 2:43Why did Europe modernize?
  33. 2:45The answer goes back to Max Weber’s ideas about the Protestant work ethic.
  34. 2:48The Protestant Reformation primed Europe to take on a progress-oriented way of life,
  35. 2:53in which financial success was a sign of personal virtue, and individualism replaced communalism.
  36. 2:59This is the perfect breeding ground for modernization.
  37. 3:01And according to American economist Walt Rostow, modernization in the West took place – as it always tends to – in four stages:
  38. 3:08First, the Traditional Stage refers to societies that are structured around small, local communities with production typically getting done in family settings.
  39. 3:17Because these societies have limited resources and technology, most of their time is spent laboring to produce food, which creates a strict social hierarchy.
  40. 3:25Think Feudal Europe or early Chinese Dynasties.
  41. 3:28Tradition rules how a society functions: What your parents do is what their parents did, and what you’ll do when you grow up too.
  42. 3:35But as people begin to move beyond doing what’s always been done, a society moves into Rostow’s second stage, the Take-off Stage.
  43. 3:42Here, people begin to use their individual talents to produce things beyond the necessities, and this innovation creates new markets for trade.
  44. 3:50In turn, greater individualism takes hold, and social status is more closely linked with material wealth.
  45. 3:55Next, nations begin what Rostow called the Drive to Technological Maturity, in which technological growth of the earlier periods begins to bear fruit,
  46. 4:03in the form of population growth, reductions in absolute poverty levels, and more diverse job opportunities.
  47. 4:09Nations in this phase typically begin to push for social change along with economic change,
  48. 4:14like implementing basic schooling for everyone, and developing more democratic political systems.
  49. 4:18The last stage is known as High Mass Consumption – when your country is big enough that production becomes more about wants than needs.
  50. 4:25Many of these countries put social support systems in place to insure that all of their citizens have access to basic necessities.
  51. 4:32So, the TL; DR version of Modernization Theory is that if you invest capital in better technologies,
  52. 4:37they’ll eventually raise production enough that there will be more wealth to go around, and overall well-being will go up.
  53. 4:43And rich countries can help other countries that are still growing by exporting their new technologies in things like agriculture, machinery, and information technology, as well as providing foreign aid.
  54. 4:53But critics of Modernization Theory argue that in many ways, it’s just a new name for the idea that capitalism is the only way for a country to develop.
  55. 5:00These critics point out that, even as technology has improved throughout the world, a lot of countries have been left behind.
  56. 5:06And they argue that Modernization Theory sweeps a lot of historical factors under the rug when it explains European and North American progress.
  57. 5:12Countries like the US and the UK industrialized from a position of global strength, during a period when there were no laws against slavery or concerns about natural resource depletion.
  58. 5:20And some critics also point out that Rostow’s markers are inherently Eurocentric, putting an emphasis on economic progress.
  59. 5:26But that isn’t necessarily the only standard to aspire to.
  60. 5:30After all, economic progress often includes downsides, like the environmental damage done by industrialization and the exploitation of cheap or free labor.
  61. 5:38Finally, critics of modernization theory also see it as blaming the victim.
  62. 5:41In this view, the theory essentially blames poor countries for not being willing to accept change,
  63. 5:46putting the fault on their cultural values and traditions, rather than acknowledging that outside forces might be holding back those countries.
  64. 5:54This is where the second theory of global stratification comes in.
  65. 5:57Rather than focusing on what poor countries are doing wrong, Dependency Theory theory focuses on how poor countries have been wronged by richer nations.
  66. 6:04This model stems from the paradigm of conflict theory, and it argues that the prospects of both wealthy and poor countries are inextricably linked.
  67. 6:11This theory argues that in a world of finite resources, we can’t understand why rich nations are rich without realizing that those riches came at the expense of another country being poor.
  68. 6:19In this view, global stratification starts with colonialism – and it’s where we’ll start today’s Thought Bubble.
  69. 6:24Starting in the 1500s, European explorers spread throughout the Americas, Africa, and Asia, claiming lands for Europe.
  70. 6:30At one point, Great Britain’s empire covered about one-fourth of the world.
  71. 6:33The United States, which began as colonies themselves, soon sprawled out through North America
  72. 6:39and took control of Haiti, Puerto Rico, Guam, the Philippines, the Hawaiian Islands, and parts of Panama and Cuba.
  73. 6:45With colonialism came exploitation of both natural and human resources.
  74. 6:49The transatlantic slave trade followed a triangular route between Africa, the American and Caribbean colonies, and Europe.
  75. 6:55Guns and factory-made goods were sent to Africa in exchange for slaves, who were sent to the colonies to produce goods like cotton and tobacco, which were then sent back to Europe.
  76. 7:04As the slave trade died down in the mid-19th century, the point of colonialism came to be less about human resources and more about natural resources.
  77. 7:12But the colonial model kept going strong.
  78. 7:14In 1870, only 10% of Africa was colonized.
  79. 7:17But by 1940, only Ethiopia and Liberia were not colonized.
  80. 7:22Under colonial regimes, European countries took control of land and raw materials to funnel wealth back to the West.
  81. 7:28Most colonies lasted until the 1960s, and the last British colony, Hong Kong, was finally granted independence in 1997.
  82. 7:36Thanks Thought Bubble.
  83. 7:37This history of colonialization is what inspired American sociologist Immanuel Wallerstein’s model of what he called the Capitalist World Economy.
  84. 7:44Wallerstein described high-income nations as the “core” of the world economy.
  85. 7:49This core is the manufacturing base of the planet, where resources funnel in, to become the technology and wealth enjoyed by the Western world today.
  86. 7:56Low-income countries, meanwhile, are what Wallerstein called the “periphery”, whose natural resources and labor support the wealthier countries,
  87. 8:03first as colonies and now by working for multinational corporations under neocolonialism.
  88. 8:07Middle-income countries, such as India or Brazil, are considered the semi-periphery, due to their closer ties to the global economic core.
  89. 8:14In Wallerstein’s model, the periphery remains economically dependent on the core in a number of ways, which tend to reinforce each other.
  90. 8:20First, poor nations tend to have few resources to export to rich countries.
  91. 8:25But corporations can buy these raw materials cheaply and then process and sell them in richer nations.
  92. 8:30As a result, the profits tend to bypass the poor countries.
  93. 8:34Poor countries are also more likely to lack industrial capacity, so they have to import expensive manufactured goods from richer nations.
  94. 8:41And all of these unequal trade patterns lead to poor nations owing lots of money to richer nations,
  95. 8:46creating debt that makes it hard to invest in their own development.
  96. 8:49So, under Dependency Theory, the problem is not that there isn’t enough global wealth; it’s that we don’t distribute it well.
  97. 8:55But just as Modernization Theory had its critics, so does Dependency Theory.
  98. 8:58Critics argue that the world economy isn’t a zero-sum game – one country getting richer doesn’t mean other countries get poorer.
  99. 9:06And innovation and technological growth can spill over to other countries, improving all nations’ well-being, not just the rich.
  100. 9:12Also, colonialism certainly left scars, but it isn’t enough, on its own, to explain today’s economic disparities.
  101. 9:18Some of the poorest countries in Africa, like Ethiopia, were never colonized and had very little contact with richer nations.
  102. 9:24Likewise, some former colonies, like Singapore and Sri Lanka, now have flourishing economies.
  103. 9:29In direct contrast to what Dependency Theory predicts, most evidence suggests that, nowadays, foreign investment by richer nations helps, not hurts, poorer countries.
  104. 9:38Dependency Theory is also very narrowly focused.
  105. 9:40It points the finger at the capitalist market system as the sole cause of stratification,
  106. 9:45ignoring the role that things like culture and political regimes play in impoverishing countries.
  107. 9:49There’s also no solution to global poverty that comes out of dependency theory –
  108. 9:53most dependency theorists just urge poor nations to cease all contact with rich nations or argue for a kind of global socialism.
  109. 10:00But these ideas don’t acknowledge the reality of the modern world economy –
  110. 10:04making them not very useful for combating the very real, very pressing problem of global poverty.
  111. 10:09The growth of the world economy and expansion of world trade has coincided with rising standards of living worldwide,
  112. 10:15with even the poorest nations almost tripling in the last century.
  113. 10:18But with increased trade between countries, trade agreements such as the North American Free Trade Agreement
  114. 10:23have become a major point of debate, pitting the benefits of free trade against the costs to jobs within a country’s borders.
  115. 10:30Questions about how to deal with global stratification are certainly far from settled, but I can leave you with some good news: it’s getting better.
  116. 10:37The share of people globally living on less than $1.25 per day has more than halved since 1981, going from 52% to 22% as of 2008.
  117. 10:47Today we learned about two theories of global stratification.
  118. 10:50First, we discussed modernization theory and Walt Rostow’s Four Stages of Modernization.
  119. 10:55We then talked about dependency theory, the legacy of colonialism, and Immanuel Wallerstein’s Capitalist World Economy Model.
  120. 11:01Crash Course Sociology is filmed in the Dr. Cheryl C. Kinney Studio in Missoula, MT, and it's made with the help of all these nice people.
  121. 11:07Our Animation Team is Thought Cafe and Crash Course is made with Adobe Creative Cloud.
  122. 11:11If you'd like to keep Crash Course free for everyone, forever, you can support the series at Patreon,
  123. 11:16a crowdfunding platform that allows you to support the content you love.
  124. 11:19Speaking of Patreon, we'd like to thank all of our patrons in general, and we'd like to specifically thank our Headmaster of Learning Ben Holden-Crowther.
  125. 11:26Thank you so much for your support.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Theories of Global Stratification: Crash Course Sociology #28 by CrashCourse, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,125 words across 125 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.