The Winners and Losers Of The English Civil War | History Of Warfare | Timeline — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:09Throughout the quiet shires and peaceful
- 0:11towns of 17th century England, a long
- 0:14period of blissful prosperity had
- 0:16stretched unbroken from the time of
- 0:18Henry the VIII through Queen Elizabeth's
- 0:20long rule and throughout the reign of
- 0:23King James I.
- 0:24But in the year of our Lord 1639,
- 0:27there began an unparalleled series of
- 0:29events which led to an armed conflict in
- 0:32the three kingdoms of Britain.
- 0:35Although it is generally known as the
- 0:37English Civil War, the causes lay in
- 0:39Scotland and by the time the wars ended
- 0:4220 years later, men had died on
- 0:45battlefields as far apart as Caithness
- 0:47and Cornwall and from Flanders to
- 0:50Virginia.
- 1:32When asked to describe the sequence of
- 1:34events on the battlefield at Waterloo,
- 1:36the Duke of Wellington remarked that one
- 1:38could no more chronicle all of the
- 1:40events of a battle than one could hope
- 1:41to record all the events at a ball.
- 1:45Although the Duke was referring to the
- 1:46difficulty in pinpointing the interplay
- 1:48of cause and effect among thousands of
- 1:50men on a single field, he could easily
- 1:53have been referring to the complex
- 1:54interaction of the various factors which
- 1:57lead to war itself.
- 1:59Seldom, if ever, can the outbreak of war
- 2:02be ascribed to a single cause.
- 2:05Despite the seemingly endless list of
- 2:07conflicts throughout history,
- 2:09the decision to take up arms against
- 2:11another country is not one made lightly.
- 2:14To fight against one's fellow countrymen
- 2:17is an even more tragic act which needs
- 2:19greater provocation than a simple call
- 2:22to arms against a foreign foe.
- 2:25The causes of the war which led
- 2:27Englishmen to take up arms against other
- 2:29Englishmen in a bitter conflict in 1642
- 2:32stemmed from the disruptive process of
- 2:34evolution.
- 2:36In this case, the evolution of the
- 2:38church and constitution
- 2:41from a medieval society to one more
- 2:43suited to a modern nation-state.
- 2:48The pace of progress during the long
- 2:50peace of the 17th century had imposed
- 2:52intolerable strains on the feudal
- 2:54structures by which the people were
- 2:56governed and their religious worship
- 2:58controlled.
- 3:00In the fields of art, science, theology
- 3:02and commerce, old boundaries were
- 3:04constantly being pushed back.
- 3:07The process of Renaissance, the
- 3:08rediscovery which had dragged Europe out
- 3:11of the Middle Ages, was by now complete
- 3:14and England was a peaceful, prosperous
- 3:16nation.
- 3:18More new discoveries and advances in
- 3:20trade created an increasingly successful
- 3:23and sophisticated society and many
- 3:25Englishmen felt this new society needed
- 3:28new forms of government and religious
- 3:30worship.
- 3:32Among those who sought change, the
- 3:34precise nature of what this new society
- 3:36needed had yet to be defined.
- 3:39Throughout the nation, there was a
- 3:40heated debate on matters of government
- 3:42and religion which would eventually
- 3:44polarize into two distinct parties.
- 3:47But as yet, that process was still in
- 3:49its infancy.
- 3:51For some Englishmen, constitutional
- 3:53change was uppermost.
- 3:55For the mass of the population,
- 3:56religious reform mattered most.
- 3:59To others, greater freedom of trade was
- 4:01the great issue of the day.
- 4:04The issues which concerned each of these
- 4:06groups were not entirely separate
- 4:08matters and there was some overlap
- 4:09between them. But any move towards
- 4:12reform would inevitably come into
- 4:13collision with the person of the king,
- 4:16Charles I.
- 4:18King Charles was a man of great
- 4:20principle and conviction, but he was a
- 4:22man totally opposed to the kind of
- 4:24change to which large sections of his
- 4:26people were gravitating.
- 4:28Charles' father, James VI of Scotland,
- 4:31had ascended the empty throne of England
- 4:33left by the childless Elizabeth I
- 4:35and so became both James VI of Scotland
- 4:38and James I of England.
- 4:41Charles was therefore the second king to
- 4:42rule both kingdoms of Scotland and
- 4:44England,
- 4:45which were still separate countries in
- 4:47every legal and economic sense.
- 4:50Although he was born in Scotland and
- 4:52spoke with a trace of the Scots accent
- 4:54which he had inherited from his father,
- 4:56Charles largely turned his back on that
- 4:58country.
- 4:59Discover the past with exclusive history
- 5:01documentaries from History Hit and
- 5:03uncover the secrets of some of the most
- 5:05famous people and events in history.
- 5:07History Hit brings you the stories that
- 5:09shaped the world through exclusive
- 5:11documentaries from the world's top
- 5:13historians. Travel with us to the bloody
- 5:16Battle of Stalingrad or uncover the
- 5:18lives of the people who called Pompeii
- 5:20home. We also aim to bring you the
- 5:22stories and legends that shaped our
- 5:25world through our award-winning podcast
- 5:27network. Sign up now for a free trial
- 5:29and Timeline fans get 50% off their
- 5:32first 3 months. Just be sure to use the
- 5:34code Timeline at checkout.
- 5:37His slight speech impediment meant that
- 5:39he lacked a certain presence,
- 5:41but this was more than made up for by
- 5:43his earnest, sincere faith and the
- 5:45serious manner in which he accepted the
- 5:47burden of kingship.
- 5:50Charles was studious, dedicated and
- 5:53absolutely resolute in any cause in
- 5:55which he firmly believed.
- 5:57He was particularly staunch in his
- 5:59desire to uphold the ancient laws and
- 6:01structures of England as he interpreted
- 6:04them.
- 6:06Charles distrusted parliaments
- 6:08absolutely
- 6:10and had in fact governed the country for
- 6:11long periods without recourse to a
- 6:13parliament.
- 6:15At that time, parliament was not an
- 6:17essential requirement for the government
- 6:19of England.
- 6:20However, Charles' failure to call one
- 6:22meant that there was no effective
- 6:24platform for national debate. So the
- 6:26unrest fermenting beneath the surface of
- 6:29English society had no real outlet.
- 6:32This was to have disastrous consequences
- 6:34for Charles when he was eventually
- 6:36forced by events to recall parliament.
- 6:39A good king acknowledges himself
- 6:43ordained by God for his people.
- 6:47He receives from God the burden of
- 6:50government for which he must be
- 6:52accountable.
- 6:54But a king must rule his people like a
- 6:57father and like a father, his authority
- 7:01is founded on the immutable decree of
- 7:04almighty God.
- 7:06His subjects must therefore respect the
- 7:08sovereign like a father.
- 7:11I alone must answer to
- 7:14God for our exercise of the authority he
- 7:17has vested in me.
- 7:19It is for me to decide how our nation is
- 7:22to be
- 7:22governed, how my subjects are to be
- 7:25ruled and above all, how the church
- 7:29shall be established under the rule of
- 7:31law.
- 7:33These are the divine rights of kings and
- 7:35are ordained by the almighty.
- 7:38It is not the place of the subject to
- 7:40question the royal prerogative.
- 7:43I shall endeavor to uphold the liberties
- 7:45of the country, but my authority is
- 7:47absolute and may not be questioned.
- 7:51You may rest assured that I have no
- 7:53other intention but to honor
- 7:55God and procure the
- 7:57good of my people.
- 8:00Because the king and his party
- 8:02represented a common obstacle to change
- 8:04in the main spheres where many of his
- 8:06subjects demanded reform, inevitably,
- 8:09the king's supporters would come to be
- 8:10viewed as the common enemy for those who
- 8:12sought to change society in some way or
- 8:15another.
- 8:16Even his severest opponents stopped
- 8:18short of actual hostility to the king's
- 8:20person.
- 8:21They were in dispute not with the king,
- 8:23but with his evil counselors.
- 8:26Chief among them was Charles' close
- 8:28friend and confidant, Thomas Wentworth,
- 8:31Earl of Strafford.
- 8:34Eventually, the various groups seeking
- 8:35change would coalesce from a range of
- 8:37separate interests into a single party
- 8:39directly opposed to the king's party,
- 8:42but this process took some time and in
- 8:44order to understand how the
- 8:45parliamentarians, as they would later be
- 8:47known, could draw a unified strength
- 8:50from a range of disparate groups, one
- 8:52would first need to look closer at the
- 8:54great issues of the day.
- 8:58Viewed from an increasingly secular
- 9:00society where the influence of the
- 9:01church wanes with every year that
- 9:03passes, it is barely possible for us to
- 9:05understand the fundamental role which
- 9:08religion occupied in 17th century life.
- 9:12English society at that time was
- 9:13profoundly and sincerely religious.
- 9:16People attended church and felt the
- 9:18influence of God in everyday events.
- 9:21They were also intensely concerned with
- 9:23the form and manner in which his worship
- 9:26was observed.
- 9:28The English were overwhelmingly
- 9:30Protestant. They accepted the reformed
- 9:32Protestant doctrine which Martin Luther
- 9:34had eloquently expounded at the dawn of
- 9:37the Reformation.
- 9:39As there was no reference in the Bible
- 9:40to a pope, most Englishmen would not
- 9:43therefore recognize papal authority, nor
- 9:45would they indulge in the more elaborate
- 9:47Catholic rituals for which there was no
- 9:49apparent justification in the Bible.
- 9:53The predominance of ritual was and still
- 9:55is an intrinsic part of the Catholic
- 9:58religion, which was vilified and loathed
- 10:01with an unforgiving passion in 17th
- 10:03century England.
- 10:06However, if the English people were
- 10:07agreed on the aspects of religion which
- 10:09they would not accept, there was still
- 10:11considerable discussion as to what was
- 10:13the correct form of worship in a
- 10:14reformed Protestant church.
- 10:18Many Englishmen favored the adoption of
- 10:20the Scottish Presbyterian system, which
- 10:22was based on the Calvinist model of a
- 10:24reformed church organized into
- 10:26presbyteries with each parish controlled
- 10:28by elders and the clergy working
- 10:30together.
- 10:32Others were Baptists who sought the
- 10:35freedom to worship God in the manner
- 10:36they saw fit.
- 10:38Others still felt that a Protestant
- 10:40church had no place for bishops or
- 10:42archbishops and clamored for their
- 10:44removal.
- 10:46Supporters of these and a number of
- 10:48other groups became generally known as
- 10:50Puritans
- 10:51and despite their many differences, they
- 10:53did share one thing in common.
- 10:56King Charles would not yield to any of
- 10:59their requests for change unless they
- 11:01fitted precisely with his own view of
- 11:03how the church should be governed.
- 11:07The Church of England as presided over
- 11:08by Charles was rigidly and efficiently
- 11:11organized, but under Archbishop William
- 11:14Laud, many practices were reintroduced
- 11:17which the people associated with
- 11:18Catholicism.
- 11:20The lighting of candles, the burning of
- 11:22incense, making the sign of the cross,
- 11:25bowing at the name of Jesus, images of
- 11:27the Virgin Mary, surplices and vestments
- 11:30for the clergy had all made a return to
- 11:32the Anglican church during Charles's
- 11:34reign.
- 11:36Many were now officially recognized as a
- 11:38part of the prescribed service for the
- 11:40Church of England.
- 11:42Naturally, the Puritans with their
- 11:44desire for an even more stern form of
- 11:46Protestant worship were outraged by
- 11:48these changes.
- 11:50In an age where a man's religious
- 11:51conscience could lead him to endure any
- 11:53form of suffering
- 11:55to defend the particular religion which
- 11:56he believed in,
- 11:57there were many who were prepared to die
- 11:59in the fight against what they saw as
- 12:01the return of papacy.
- 12:05When the time did eventually come to
- 12:06fight, more than half of the king's
- 12:08subjects could be said to be of a
- 12:09Puritan persuasion to some degree or
- 12:11other.
- 12:13But although religion was a major factor
- 12:15in the escalation of national unrest, it
- 12:17was economic issues which would finally
- 12:20plunge the country into civil war.
- 12:22Once again, however, religion would play
- 12:25its part.
- 12:28Not content with imposing a rigid form
- 12:30of worship on the Church of England,
- 12:32Charles wished to extend this to the
- 12:34Church of Scotland.
- 12:36In doing so, he committed a fatal error.
- 12:38Charles attempted to impose a new Book
- 12:40of Common Prayer on the Church of
- 12:42Scotland.
- 12:44From its first introduction, there were
- 12:45riots and unrest culminating in the
- 12:48famous incident where a stool was thrown
- 12:50at the first bishop to introduce the new
- 12:52form of worship.
- 12:54It seemed as if the whole Scots nation
- 12:56was incensed and they signed a national
- 12:59covenant in defense of their own
- 13:00fiercely Protestant religion, which led
- 13:03them into open conflict with the king.
- 13:07The wars of 1639 and 1640 became known
- 13:10as the Bishops' War as the Scots had
- 13:12once again thrown out the bishops who
- 13:14had been reimposed upon them by James I
- 13:17using great skill 30 years before.
- 13:21The outcome of these two short and
- 13:23relatively bloodless wars proved to be
- 13:25an unmitigated military disaster for
- 13:27King Charles.
- 13:29The victorious Scots army easily
- 13:30defeated the English forces hastily
- 13:32thrown against them at the Battle of
- 13:34Newburn and then marched on to occupy
- 13:36Newcastle.
- 13:39Militarily, the Bishops' War had been a
- 13:41shambles, but worse still for Charles
- 13:44was the economic cost of waging war.
- 13:47For 11 years, he had been governing the
- 13:49country without recourse to Parliament.
- 13:52Charles mistrusted Parliament and
- 13:54whenever possible sought to rule the
- 13:55country without one.
- 13:57In order to raise the money to govern
- 13:58the country, he had twisted and
- 14:00manipulated the laws governing taxation
- 14:03and the sovereign's right to grant
- 14:04monopolies.
- 14:06In so doing, he had created huge unrest
- 14:08among the merchant classes.
- 14:10They objected to royal monopolies being
- 14:12granted on, among other things, the
- 14:15manufacture of soap and salt.
- 14:17The reintroduction and extension of
- 14:19dormant taxes like ship money
- 14:21further fanned the flames of revolt.
- 14:24Forced to call a Parliament so that it
- 14:27could vote him the funds to finance his
- 14:28Scottish wars, Charles found that he had
- 14:30unleashed a pent-up force which would
- 14:33not easily be contained.
- 14:36The Parliament of 1639 refused to vote
- 14:38Charles any funds until its own
- 14:41grievances had first been dealt with.
- 14:44In a fury, Charles dismissed this
- 14:46short-lived Parliament.
- 14:48However, he was soon forced to call
- 14:49another, the so-called Long Parliament
- 14:52of 1640, which was even more hostile in
- 14:55its demands.
- 14:58Parliament presented King Charles with a
- 14:59list of grievances which became known as
- 15:01the Grand Remonstrance
- 15:03and further challenged the authority of
- 15:05royal control by claiming that
- 15:06Parliament, not the king, should have
- 15:09the right to raise and control the army.
- 15:12In 1641, Ireland had exploded into
- 15:15rebellion,
- 15:16so the question of who controlled the
- 15:17armed forces was more pressing than
- 15:19ever.
- 15:23Under the able leadership of John Pym,
- 15:25the Long Parliament increasingly used
- 15:27this and other arguments to bring into
- 15:29question Charles's right and his
- 15:31personal suitability to govern.
- 15:34Using great political skill, Pym had
- 15:37Charles's great friend and adviser
- 15:39Strafford tried and executed.
- 15:42Charles, always hostile towards his
- 15:44parliaments, gradually lost patience and
- 15:47decided to act with force if necessary.
- 15:51The two factions finally came to an
- 15:53all-out declaration of war
- 15:55after a failed attempt by Charles to
- 15:57seize the leaders of the party acting in
- 15:59opposition to him.
- 16:01With his failure to arrest the five
- 16:03members, Pym, Hollis, Hampden, Haselrig,
- 16:07and Strode, the king had played his last
- 16:09card.
- 16:11He had attempted to overrule the rights
- 16:13and privileges of Parliament by a coup
- 16:15d'état.
- 16:16The London mob took to the streets
- 16:18backing Parliament and there was no
- 16:20turning back.
- 16:23Unrest in society now took the form of
- 16:26increasingly open conflict.
- 16:29Soon, riots and brawls became more
- 16:31serious and the first shots were fired
- 16:33in anger.
- 16:35Faced with the outright hostility of the
- 16:37Commons and the populace of London, the
- 16:40king fled north to York.
- 16:42From there, he attempted to seize arms
- 16:44and ammunition stored at Hull, but was
- 16:46refused entry on St. George's Day, 1642.
- 16:51Desperately short of arms and
- 16:53ammunition, Charles spent the next four
- 16:55months gathering the beginnings of an
- 16:56army.
- 16:58When he felt strong enough, he raised
- 17:00his standard at Nottingham and the
- 17:01genteel pretenses were cast aside.
- 17:05Civil war had begun in earnest.
- 17:09There's no doubt that the
- 17:10parliamentarian Earl of Essex began the
- 17:12recruiting game much earlier than the
- 17:14king.
- 17:15Robert Devereux, Earl of Essex, went
- 17:17into the Eastern Association counties to
- 17:19the east and south of London and began
- 17:21to build quite a substantial army.
- 17:24And when the king began to take this
- 17:25seriously in August, really Parliament
- 17:27had a great considerable head start in
- 17:29that in the numbers game anyway.
- 17:32Even when he did begin to recruit,
- 17:34having raised his standard at Nottingham
- 17:36in late August of 1642,
- 17:38the king was very disappointed by the
- 17:40initial reaction there.
- 17:423,000 militia had been paraded for his
- 17:45delectation on that occasion, but
- 17:47despite the best harangues of the king
- 17:49and his ministers and friends and so
- 17:50forth, only 300 agreed to take service.
- 17:54And the king had to be content with
- 17:55this, disarmed the remainder, and put
- 17:57all their weapons into his wagons, and
- 17:59moved away hoping to get a bigger army
- 18:01somewhere else. But at the very start,
- 18:03there's no doubt some parliamentarians
- 18:05were discussing whether the king would
- 18:07have the ability to raise an army
- 18:09considering the feeling in the country
- 18:11as a whole. But in fact, he was going to
- 18:12do so.
- 18:15Parliament had easily managed to raise
- 18:17the more sizable army.
- 18:19A large part of these men were drawn
- 18:21from the regiments which had been
- 18:22recruited to suppress the rebellion in
- 18:24Ireland.
- 18:25London was then a hotbed of Puritanism
- 18:28and large numbers of Londoners therefore
- 18:30joined the army and the popular Earl of
- 18:32Essex was appointed to command it.
- 18:35Unfortunately, he was to prove a more
- 18:37able politician than a soldier.
- 18:41The king's army was always smaller than
- 18:43that of Parliament and many were very
- 18:45poorly armed being described by one
- 18:47contemporary as poor Welsh vermin.
- 18:52The infantry regiments of both sides
- 18:54were made up of two quite different
- 18:56types of soldier,
- 18:57musketeers and pikemen.
- 19:00In action, the pikemen were grouped
- 19:01together in the center of each battalion
- 19:04forming a forest of pike shafts with a
- 19:06wing of musketeers on each side.
- 19:10The musketeers were mainly armed with
- 19:11matchlock muskets.
- 19:14These were simple muzzle-loading weapons
- 19:16with a slow-burning fuse or match which
- 19:18was used to fire them.
- 19:20An experienced soldier could load and
- 19:22fire within 30 seconds, but there were
- 19:24few enough of those when the war began.
- 19:28In order to load his musket, the soldier
- 19:30had first to level it waist high and
- 19:33pour some gunpowder into the flash pan
- 19:35at the bottom of the barrel.
- 19:37He then placed the butt of his musket on
- 19:39the ground and poured the main powder
- 19:41charge down it
- 19:43followed by the musket ball and some
- 19:44wadding.
- 19:46After ramming down with his scouring
- 19:48stick, the soldier had to look to his
- 19:50match.
- 19:51At this time, the widespread
- 19:53introduction of the flintlock still lay
- 19:55in the future, and muskets were actually
- 19:57fired by a lighted match being plunged
- 20:00into the gunpowder in the pan.
- 20:03Once loaded, the musketeer therefore
- 20:05needed to fix his match to the lock of
- 20:07his musket
- 20:08and make sure that it was burning
- 20:10properly.
- 20:11He was now ready to fire.
- 20:17Because it took so long to fire and
- 20:19reload a musket,
- 20:20regiments were drawn up six deep, and
- 20:23only one rank fired at a time.
- 20:25The first rank would fire their
- 20:27inaccurate muskets in the general
- 20:28direction of the enemy, aiming as best
- 20:30they could,
- 20:31then move smartly to the rear to reload,
- 20:34while the second rank moved up into
- 20:35their place.
- 20:37By the time all the ranks had fired, the
- 20:39first one would have finished the
- 20:40cumbersome reloading process and would
- 20:43have moved back up to the front, ready
- 20:44to start the cycle afresh.
- 20:48For every two musketeers in the
- 20:50regiment, there would ideally be one
- 20:52pikeman.
- 20:53The pikemen had once been the more
- 20:55important element of an infantry
- 20:56regiment and had formed 2/3 of the
- 20:59regiments in Elizabeth's time,
- 21:01but by the time of the Civil War, they
- 21:02were in decline, eclipsed by the more
- 21:05versatile and deadly musketeers.
- 21:09Fewer and fewer of them now wore the
- 21:11armor shown in the elegantly illustrated
- 21:13drill books, but they still had an
- 21:15important role to play, especially in
- 21:17using their long pikes to fend off enemy
- 21:19cavalry.
- 21:21They could also be called upon to
- 21:23deliver the decisive blow by moving
- 21:25forward with their pikes leveled at the
- 21:27charge.
- 21:28Usually, the threat of coming to grips
- 21:30with the pike was enough to cause one
- 21:32side or the other to break and run.
- 21:34But if both parties were resolute, it
- 21:36came to push of pike, with both parties
- 21:39contending locked in mortal combat, as
- 21:42one observer put it, like bulls trying
- 21:44to bear each other down.
- 21:48Cavalry were of two kinds,
- 21:50the heavy cuirassier, clad in armor from
- 21:52head to toe like medieval knights,
- 21:55and the light cavalryman called
- 21:56arquebusier, who wore only helmets and
- 21:59either a breastplate or a heavy buff
- 22:02leather coat.
- 22:04The cuirassier were intended to charge
- 22:05home,
- 22:06while the arquebusier were skirmishers,
- 22:09trained to fight with firearms rather
- 22:11than close with the sword.
- 22:14In the England of 1642, both the armor
- 22:17for cuirassier and horses fit to bear
- 22:19them were hard to find.
- 22:21But Prince Rupert, the king's flamboyant
- 22:23young nephew, appointed to command the
- 22:25Royalist company, ignored convention and
- 22:28trained his lightly armed troopers to
- 22:30charge home as if they were cuirassier.
- 22:34No such stroke of imagination was to be
- 22:36seen on the other side.
- 22:38Parliament could muster only three
- 22:40troops of cuirassier,
- 22:41but the rest of her cavalry were trained
- 22:43to rely on their firearms rather than
- 22:45the sword.
- 22:48Artillery was invaluable in sieges, but
- 22:51seldom played a decisive part in the
- 22:53battles, since cannon were generally too
- 22:55heavy to move easily and too slow to
- 22:57reload.
- 22:59The cannon of the period fired
- 23:01cannonballs, smooth projectiles, which
- 23:04were not designed to explode, but rather
- 23:06to cause horrific injury by the violence
- 23:08of their passage, tearing off arms and
- 23:10legs as they passed through the massed
- 23:12ranks of men.
- 23:14Although they were cumbersome and
- 23:15inefficient, no army of the period was
- 23:18considered complete without at least a
- 23:19few guns.
- 23:24On the 23rd of September, detachments of
- 23:26both armies met each other by accident
- 23:28at Powick Bridge, outside Worcester.
- 23:31Neither side had realized that the other
- 23:33was close at hand,
- 23:34but the Royalists were the first to
- 23:36recover from the shock of discovery, and
- 23:38in the short fight which followed,
- 23:40Prince Rupert's Cavaliers were
- 23:41victorious.
- 23:43Of itself, the skirmish was
- 23:44insignificant,
- 23:46but it began the myth that the Cavalier
- 23:48horse were invincible,
- 23:50a myth which the Parliamentarians would
- 23:51need some time to destroy.
- 23:55A month later at Edgehill, in the Vale
- 23:57of the Red Horse in Warwickshire, the
- 23:59first major battle of the Civil War was
- 24:01fought.
- 24:03As the Roundheads could not be tempted
- 24:04to attack the favorable Royalist
- 24:06positions on the hill itself, the king's
- 24:08men moved off the hill and were drawn up
- 24:10on the forward slope looking from Radway
- 24:13towards the village of Kineton.
- 24:16The king's nephew, Prince Rupert,
- 24:17commanded the cavalry on the right wing,
- 24:20and Lord Wilmot, a professional soldier
- 24:22turned courtier, commanded the left.
- 24:25In the center, the infantry formed five
- 24:27brigades, with three in the front line
- 24:30and the two others in support.
- 24:32The dragoons were deployed on the flanks
- 24:33of the cavalry.
- 24:36In total, the Royalists fielded nearly
- 24:383,000 cavalry, 1,000 dragoons, and just
- 24:41over 10,000 infantry.
- 24:44The Earl of Essex's army, waiting for
- 24:47them at the foot of the hill, was drawn
- 24:48up in much the same way.
- 24:51The Parliamentarians had 12,000
- 24:53infantry, but less than 3,000 cavalry
- 24:56and dragoons.
- 24:58As a commander, Essex was to develop an
- 24:59unfortunate reputation for allowing his
- 25:01opponent to interpose between him and
- 25:03his home base.
- 25:05The Edgehill campaign was the first
- 25:07example of this dangerous tendency.
- 25:10Essex's army therefore formed up with
- 25:13the Royalist army between him and his
- 25:15base at London.
- 25:18A major defeat in the battle would
- 25:19therefore have been doubly disastrous.
- 25:22A battle had not been expected, and many
- 25:24of Essex's soldiers were scattered in
- 25:26farms and villages where they had been
- 25:28finding shelter from the cold October
- 25:30nights.
- 25:32At first, it looked as though the
- 25:33Cavaliers might end the war in an
- 25:34afternoon.
- 25:36Led by the fiery Prince Rupert, the
- 25:38Royalist cavalry swept all before them.
- 25:41As the Royalists advanced upon the
- 25:42Parliamentary cavalry, the Roundheads
- 25:45who opened fire with their carbines
- 25:47expected the Royalists to respond in
- 25:48kind.
- 25:50Instead, the Cavaliers came on at a
- 25:52furious charge, and the
- 25:53Parliamentarians, panicking, fled away,
- 25:56pursued clear of the battlefield by the
- 25:58jubilant Cavaliers who thought they won.
- 26:02Rupert's men cut down the fugitives,
- 26:04many of whom they pursued for 7 miles,
- 26:07and then began plundering the
- 26:08Parliamentary baggage train.
- 26:11Had the victorious Cavaliers returned to
- 26:13the field, they would have seen the
- 26:14Parliamentary infantry rally and hold
- 26:17the king's army to a bloody stalemate on
- 26:19the battlefield.
- 26:21The presence of the Royalist cavalry
- 26:22would have won the day,
- 26:24but their indiscipline in pursuing the
- 26:26fleeing Parliamentary cavalry too far
- 26:28allowed the infantry of Parliament to
- 26:30save the day.
- 26:31By their dogged persistence, they were
- 26:33able to hold the Royalists to a draw,
- 26:36but at a very high cost.
- 26:39After a bitterly cold night, Essex
- 26:41abandoned the battlefield to the king
- 26:43and retired northwards to the safety of
- 26:45Warwick Castle,
- 26:46leaving the way clear for the king to
- 26:48march on London.
- 26:50The impetuous Prince Rupert was all for
- 26:51making a dash with his cavalry to occupy
- 26:53London before Essex could reach the city
- 26:55with the battered remains of his army.
- 26:58However, the king prevaricated in the
- 27:00hope of a peaceful settlement, and the
- 27:02greatest opportunity of the war to
- 27:04capture the Parliamentary stronghold was
- 27:06lost.
- 27:09By November, Essex had regained London,
- 27:11and the forces of the king and
- 27:12Parliament were joined in some
- 27:14indecisive fighting around Brentford and
- 27:16Hounslow to the west of London.
- 27:19One of those who joined the king's
- 27:21forces at this time was a young Welshman
- 27:23named John Gwyn.
- 27:27Myself and five comrades repaired from
- 27:29the court of Richmond to the king's
- 27:31royal army, which we met accidentally
- 27:33that morning upon Hounslow Heath.
- 27:35We had no sooner joined with that old
- 27:37acquaintance, Sir George Boothby, but we
- 27:39marched up to the enemy, engaged them,
- 27:41and made them retreat into Brentford,
- 27:44and from thence to the open fields.
- 27:46After fighting, we advanced up to push
- 27:48of pike and the butt end of musket,
- 27:50which proved so fatal to Hollis and his
- 27:52butchers and dyers that day,
- 27:54that a great abundance of them were
- 27:55killed and taken prisoner, besides those
- 27:57drowned in their attempt to escape by
- 27:59leaping into the river.
- 28:01No soldier or an impartial man could say
- 28:04that we could have advanced further
- 28:06towards London than we did,
- 28:08because of the thick enclosures with
- 28:10strong hedges and ditches which were
- 28:11lined with men standing shoulder to
- 28:14shoulder by one another.
- 28:16On the common road were planted their
- 28:17artillery with defensible works about
- 28:19them,
- 28:20so that we could not approach any
- 28:22nearer.
- 28:23As we were at such a great disadvantage,
- 28:25the king withdrew and marched from
- 28:27Hampton Court, where, for my further
- 28:29encouragement, I had the care of the
- 28:32regiment's colors conferred upon me in
- 28:34the hope that I would go on with as much
- 28:36resolution as I had begun.
- 28:40The Parliamentarians mustered at Turnham
- 28:42Green to defend London were too numerous
- 28:44for his exhausted army, and the king
- 28:46reluctantly withdrew to Oxford for the
- 28:48winter, there to establish his court.
- 28:51For the next 4 years, the university
- 28:53city was to be the Royalist capital.
- 28:58As luck would have it, the winters of
- 29:00the early 1640s were particularly
- 29:02severe, with unnaturally heavy and
- 29:04prolonged falls of snow.
- 29:07With a sudden thaw, the primitive roads
- 29:10of 17th century England quickly turned
- 29:12into muddy quagmires, which made
- 29:14movement impossible.
- 29:16Winter was therefore a time for small
- 29:18engagements between detachments and
- 29:20garrisons, while the main field armies
- 29:22waited for the spring and dry roads.
- 29:26All around the country, garrisons were
- 29:28attacked, convoys were ambushed, and
- 29:31there was a constant seesaw of raid and
- 29:33counter-raid.
- 29:36As the two sides sought to improve their
- 29:38positions for the coming campaign
- 29:39season, Northumberland and Durham were
- 29:42already held for the king, and the
- 29:44Royalists were pushing southwards into
- 29:45the Vale of York.
- 29:47On the other side of the Pennines,
- 29:49Cumberland and Westmorland were for the
- 29:51King, but in Lancashire, the issue was
- 29:53still in some doubt.
- 29:55Wales was dominated by Royalists, and
- 29:58most of East Anglia was Parliamentarian.
- 30:01In the south, Sir William Waller
- 30:02captured Winchester from its Cavalier
- 30:04garrison shortly before Christmas, while
- 30:06in the West Country, his old friend and
- 30:09future opponent, Sir Ralph Hopton, had
- 30:11secured Cornwall and the southwest for
- 30:13King Charles.
- 30:16In the all-important Thames Valley and
- 30:18in the Midlands, there was some
- 30:19jockeying for position as both sides
- 30:21prepared for the real war in the spring.
- 30:25There is some contention amongst serious
- 30:27historians on the Civil War as to
- 30:29whether you can speak of a Royal
- 30:30strategy for the year 1642 at all.
- 30:34Some like to mention the famous triple
- 30:36advance upon London.
- 30:38Newcastle's army from the north,
- 30:41Hopton's from the southwest, and of
- 30:43course the King's from the Midlands.
- 30:44Three prongs descending upon the center
- 30:47of parliamentary control, and of course
- 30:49had London been taken out at that time
- 30:51and Parliament with it, there is no
- 30:53doubt the war would have come to an end
- 30:54in 1642.
- 30:57But in fact, after the Battle of
- 30:58Edgehill, the King who combined
- 31:00indecisiveness in his character with a
- 31:03great deal of stubbornness, a fatal
- 31:05combination as it was going to prove
- 31:07before the end of the First Civil War,
- 31:09the King would not release Prince Rupert
- 31:11and his cavalry for a dash on London,
- 31:14although in fact there was very little
- 31:15between them and the capital, perhaps a
- 31:17few trained bands, but as they would
- 31:19find at Turnham Green, that was nothing
- 31:21to be worrying about. But the
- 31:23opportunity was lost and with it
- 31:25effectively, Charles's chance of winning
- 31:27the war.
- 31:29As the campaign season of 1643 opened,
- 31:32the King at first appeared to have the
- 31:34initiative, but his army was crippled by
- 31:36a serious shortage of arms and
- 31:37ammunition.
- 31:39In some regiments, there were actually
- 31:40more pikemen than musketeers, which
- 31:42meant that the Royalists would have to
- 31:44rely on brute strength rather than
- 31:46firepower in battle.
- 31:48At the end of February, the Queen, who
- 31:50had gone to Holland to pawn the Crown
- 31:52Jewels and buy arms with the proceeds,
- 31:54landed at Bridlington in Yorkshire and
- 31:56prepared a great convoy to convey the
- 31:58arms to Oxford.
- 32:01To cover this vital arms shipment,
- 32:03Prince Rupert moved into the Midlands
- 32:05and stormed the defenses of Birmingham
- 32:07on the 3rd of April and took Lichfield
- 32:10after a short siege on the 21st.
- 32:13Emboldened by his absence, however,
- 32:15Essex struck west and laid siege to
- 32:17Reading.
- 32:19Rupert returned in great haste, but both
- 32:21he and the King were powerless to
- 32:23prevent the garrison surrender on the
- 32:2527th of April.
- 32:27Sir Arthur Aston, the governor, received
- 32:29a letter upon the castle hill guard.
- 32:31Looking about him, said, "Are there none
- 32:34that I may safely communicate the
- 32:36contents of my letter unto?"
- 32:38Then arose from his chair, opened his
- 32:40letter, and went out of door to peruse
- 32:43it. When, as his history fate would have
- 32:45it, it scarce a minute to look it over
- 32:48before a cannon shot came through the
- 32:50guardhouse and knocked off the tiles
- 32:52from the roof.
- 32:53One fell upon his head and sunk him
- 32:55almost through the ground before Colonel
- 32:57Lunsford and another officer caught him
- 33:00by both hands,
- 33:01held him up, brought him into the
- 33:03guardhouse, put him into his chair, and
- 33:06presently he laid his hand upon his head
- 33:08under his cap, and faintly said, "My
- 33:11head's whole, I thank God."
- 33:14And spoke no more thereat that time, but
- 33:17immediately was carried away to his
- 33:18house in the town, where during the rest
- 33:21of the siege, he was speechless.
- 33:23A short time after, the garrison was
- 33:25surrendered,
- 33:27but they broke their conditions with us
- 33:28and plundered us sorely.
- 33:31Now that the issue of Reading had been
- 33:33decided, the two main field armies
- 33:36withdrew to their old positions,
- 33:38watching each other warily.
- 33:40The Roundhead army was crippled by a
- 33:42typhus epidemic, the first of many to
- 33:44sweep the three kingdoms in the army's
- 33:46wake.
- 33:50To break the deadlock, a major victory
- 33:52was required, which could alter the
- 33:54delicate balance in favor of one side or
- 33:56the other.
- 33:57The main chance fell to the Royalists.
- 34:00Sir Ralph Hopton, the Royalist leader in
- 34:03the west, defeated Sir William Waller,
- 34:05who in former days had been a close
- 34:07friend, at Lansdown Hill outside Bath on
- 34:10the 5th of July.
- 34:13Hopton's victorious western Cavaliers
- 34:15then moved to finally destroy Waller's
- 34:17army on Roundway Down on the 13th of
- 34:20July, 1643.
- 34:24The tragedy of a civil war can be
- 34:25clearly seen in the surviving letters
- 34:27between Hopton and Waller when two old
- 34:30friends found themselves on different
- 34:32sides of a bitter conflict.
- 34:39To my noble friend, Sir Ralph Hopton.
- 34:43My affections to you are so unchangeable
- 34:46that hostility itself cannot violate my
- 34:48friendship to your person.
- 34:50That great God, the searcher of my
- 34:53heart, knows with what a sad sense I go
- 34:56up to this service
- 34:57and with what perfect hatred I go upon
- 35:00this war without an enemy.
- 35:03We are both upon the stage and must act
- 35:06those parts that are assigned to us in
- 35:07this tragedy.
- 35:09Let us do it in a way of honor
- 35:12without personal animosity.
- 35:15Your affectionate friend, William
- 35:17Waller.
- 35:20Despite the friendship between their
- 35:21leaders, the war between the two armies
- 35:23in the west was vigorously pursued.
- 35:27Buoyed up by Hopton's success, the
- 35:29Royalists moved swiftly.
- 35:31A second arms convoy arrived in Oxford 2
- 35:33days later,
- 35:34leaving a scattering of garrisons to
- 35:36mask the main Roundhead army, the
- 35:38Royalists marched on Bristol.
- 35:42The city's hastily constructed earth
- 35:44defenses were rather too extensive for
- 35:46the small garrison, and they proved
- 35:48incapable of repelling a furious
- 35:50Royalist assault on the 26th of July.
- 35:54The storming of the defenses of the city
- 35:55of Bristol was to prove one of the most
- 35:57savage days fighting of the whole war.
- 36:08Royalist casualties were high.
- 36:14The dead lay piled high on the ramparts.
- 36:18As gallant gentlemen as ever drew sword
- 36:21lay upon that ground
- 36:23like so many rotten sheep.
- 36:27Although the losses were high, the gain
- 36:30to the Royalist cause, however, was
- 36:31incalculable.
- 36:33Bristol was the second city in the
- 36:35kingdom,
- 36:36a major port with sufficient ships in it
- 36:38to form the nucleus of a Royalist fleet.
- 36:41Less spectacularly, but no less
- 36:43importantly, the city also had factories
- 36:46capable of turning out hundreds of
- 36:48muskets a week, which were greatly
- 36:50welcomed by the undersupplied Royalists.
- 36:53By the end of the war, most Royalist
- 36:55infantry regiments were wholly armed
- 36:57with muskets and had abandoned pikes
- 36:59entirely.
- 37:03With Bristol secure, some of the King's
- 37:05advisers advocated turning back on
- 37:07London.
- 37:08If the city fell, it would mean the end
- 37:10of the war, but Charles again hesitated,
- 37:13and instead it was decided to first
- 37:15capture Gloucester, the last remaining
- 37:17major parliamentary stronghold in the
- 37:19west.
- 37:20It was unlikely to be able to hold out
- 37:22for very long, and in the meantime, the
- 37:24King's shattered western army could be
- 37:26reorganized and refitted at Bristol.
- 37:29The combined Royalist armies would then
- 37:31advance on London with their rear
- 37:33secure.
- 37:36The governor, Colonel Massey, confounded
- 37:38the King's army by holding out.
- 37:41Sickened by the losses at Bristol,
- 37:43Charles would not permit the city to be
- 37:45stormed,
- 37:46preferring instead to starve the
- 37:48defenders into submission.
- 37:50The Earl of Essex was therefore able to
- 37:52assemble a relief force from London
- 37:54by filling out his typhus-ravaged ranks
- 37:57with several regiments of militia from
- 37:59the London trained bands.
- 38:02On the 4th of September, with the
- 38:03garrison down to a single barrel of
- 38:05powder, Essex raised the siege of
- 38:08Gloucester.
- 38:09But once again, the Earl allowed the
- 38:10Royalist army to get between him and his
- 38:12base of London.
- 38:14The King was able to force Essex to
- 38:15fight him on ground of his choosing.
- 38:18The two forces met at Newbury.
- 38:20John Gwyn was present at the battle.
- 38:24It was at the siege of Gloucester where
- 38:25we would probably have captured the
- 38:27town, but a great glut of rain fell,
- 38:29flooding our works, and we were forced
- 38:31to remove the next day. When we drew
- 38:34off, it proved to be a most miserable,
- 38:36tempestuous, rainy weather, so few could
- 38:39take rest on the hills where they were.
- 38:42At Newbury, we beat the enemy from the
- 38:44town's end to the top of the hill by the
- 38:46heath. A wing of Essex, his horse moving
- 38:49gently towards us, made us leave our
- 38:51execution upon the enemy and retreat
- 38:54into the next field. There were several
- 38:56gaps to get to it, but not near my way.
- 38:59With the colors in my hand, I jumped
- 39:01over the hedge and the ditch, otherwise
- 39:04I would have died by a multitude of
- 39:05hands. We kept this field until midnight
- 39:08and until some intelligence came that
- 39:10Essex was marching away with a great
- 39:12part of his army and that he would bury
- 39:15a great many of his great guns.
- 39:17Near unto this field upon the heath lay
- 39:19a whole file of men six deep with their
- 39:22heads all struck off with one cannon
- 39:24shot of ours.
- 39:27With Reading recaptured and an
- 39:29indecisive outcome from the Newbury
- 39:31battle,
- 39:32the winter of 1643 closed in on another
- 39:35stalemate.
- 39:36Neither side, it seemed, was strong
- 39:38enough to win the war without outside
- 39:40help.
- 39:41So both parties earnestly set about the
- 39:43business of securing outside
- 39:45intervention.
- 39:48Frustrated in his attempts to bring in a
- 39:50French army, a ceasefire with the Irish
- 39:52rebels allowed the king to ship home
- 39:54thousands of troops and to form a new
- 39:57army in Cheshire and North Wales.
- 40:00But, it was to prove a short-lived hope.
- 40:02This new army was defeated and dispersed
- 40:05at Nantwich in January 1644.
- 40:10The parliamentarians were to be more
- 40:11successful in their search for help.
- 40:13A few days before the battle at
- 40:15Nantwich, the Scots had come to
- 40:17Parliament's aid and crossed the border
- 40:19near Berwick with a mighty army of some
- 40:2120,000 men.
- 40:23Suddenly, the whole complexion of the
- 40:25war was altered.
- 40:27Well, I think there's no doubt that had
- 40:28the Scots 20,000 men which they brought
- 40:31over into England at this juncture been
- 40:33put straight into effective action, it
- 40:36would have been very hard for the king's
- 40:37cause to survive in the north of
- 40:39England.
- 40:41As it was, however, the 7,000 or so
- 40:43troops of the Newcastle were reinforced
- 40:46by 5,000 more a little later on from
- 40:49Ireland and the Lord Byron.
- 40:51Now, this added a new context to the
- 40:53war, in fact. We have the first
- 40:55massacres taking place now because many
- 40:57of these troops from Ireland were
- 41:00Catholics and you had the
- 41:01straightforward confrontation therefore
- 41:04between Catholicism on the one hand and
- 41:06the Presbyterians and Puritan parties on
- 41:08the other. And it was not going to have
- 41:10an ameliorating effect on the war.
- 41:14The appearance of a Scots army in
- 41:16support of Parliament had been feared by
- 41:18the Royalist party for some time.
- 41:21They had long been in discussion on
- 41:22friendly terms with the parliamentary
- 41:24commissioners, but it was not until
- 41:26September 1643 that parliamentarian and
- 41:29Scots commissioners signed the Solemn
- 41:31League and Covenant which bound the
- 41:33Scots to bring in an army on the side of
- 41:35Parliament.
- 41:37It also committed both countries to
- 41:39establishing a common form of worship.
- 41:42The Scots commissioners assumed from the
- 41:44discussion that this would be
- 41:45Presbyterianism
- 41:47according to the example of the best
- 41:49reformed churches.
- 41:51The English, however, added the phrase
- 41:53"according to the word of God",
- 41:56thus making the whole agreement a good
- 41:58deal more ambiguous.
- 42:00The Scots carelessly assumed that this
- 42:02meant that the English would adopt a
- 42:03Presbyterian system of organization of
- 42:05the church like that of Scotland.
- 42:07Ultimately, this misunderstanding would
- 42:10lead to the breakup of their alliance.
- 42:12But, by then the parliamentary forces
- 42:15would have had what they needed from
- 42:16their new allies.
- 42:21The Scots army entering England was
- 42:23opposed by the king's northern army
- 42:25under the fabulously rich Marquess of
- 42:28Newcastle.
- 42:29Newcastle, however, could do little to
- 42:31stop them.
- 42:33All he could spare was a token force to
- 42:35protect his rear
- 42:36while he maintained the fight in
- 42:38Yorkshire against the parliamentary army
- 42:40led by Sir Thomas Fairfax.
- 42:43Only some ill-equipped local militia
- 42:45regiments were left to watch the border
- 42:48and these could only fall back before
- 42:49the invaders.
- 42:51On hearing of this, the Marquess hurried
- 42:53north from Yorkshire through a
- 42:54succession of blizzards and with his
- 42:56main army flung himself into
- 42:58Newcastle-upon-Tyne with just 12 hours
- 43:01to spare before the arrival of the
- 43:03Scots.
- 43:06Taking advantage of Newcastle's
- 43:07difficulties in the north,
- 43:09Fairfax stormed Selby in Yorkshire on
- 43:11the 11th of April.
- 43:14Black Tom, as he was known to his men,
- 43:17was the eldest son of Lord Fairfax.
- 43:19He was a talented soldier who had
- 43:21maintained an unequal fight against
- 43:22Newcastle and his larger Royalist forces
- 43:25since the beginning of the war in 1642.
- 43:29Hearing the news that Fairfax was again
- 43:32in action, Newcastle rushed southwards
- 43:34to secure York.
- 43:36The Scots army left a token force to
- 43:38blockade the remaining northern
- 43:39Royalists in Newcastle-upon-Tyne
- 43:42and moved south to join Fairfax against
- 43:44the Marquess of Newcastle.
- 43:46Meanwhile, the Earl of Manchester
- 43:48brought the Eastern Association army up
- 43:50from Lincolnshire to tighten the net.
- 43:53Newcastle was therefore trapped with his
- 43:55forces in York by three allied armies.
- 44:00In the south, the war was progressing
- 44:02equally badly for the king.
- 44:05Prince Rupert had destroyed a
- 44:06parliamentarian army in a battle outside
- 44:09Newark, but on the 29th of March,
- 44:11Hopton's western Cavaliers were
- 44:13decisively beaten by Sir William Waller
- 44:15at Cheriton in Hampshire,
- 44:18effectively ending any further Royalist
- 44:20threat to London.
- 44:22Not without some misgiving on the part
- 44:24of Charles therefore, Prince Rupert was
- 44:26dispatched north to try and retrieve the
- 44:28situation there.
- 44:31Rupert took few men with him as few
- 44:34could be spared.
- 44:35Instead, he stripped every garrison and
- 44:38press-ganged every stray regiment on the
- 44:40line of march.
- 44:41Rupert's men carried out a series of
- 44:43ferocious attacks on the scattered
- 44:45parliamentarian strongholds in a short
- 44:47campaign marked by the bitterness of the
- 44:49fighting.
- 44:50On the 25th of May, he stormed Stockport
- 44:53and two days later, Bolton.
- 44:56Liverpool was next, stormed on the 11th
- 44:58of June after a short siege, and there
- 45:01Rupert received a letter from the king
- 45:03which he was to carry with him to his
- 45:04dying day.
- 45:06The king's letter to modern ears is
- 45:08confused and unclear.
- 45:11But, when Sir John Culpepper, a royal
- 45:13adviser, was shown the letter,
- 45:15he exclaimed to King Charles,
- 45:17"Before God, you are undone.
- 45:20For on this peremptory order, he will
- 45:22fight whatever comes of it."
- 45:25"If York be lost, I shall esteem my
- 45:27crown little less
- 45:29unless supported by your sudden march to
- 45:31me and miraculous conquest in the south
- 45:34before the effects of their northern
- 45:36power can be found here.
- 45:38But,
- 45:39if York be relieved and you beat the
- 45:42rebels' army of both kingdoms which are
- 45:44before it, then
- 45:46but otherwise not,
- 45:48I may possibly make a shift upon the
- 45:50defensive
- 45:51and to spin out time until you come to
- 45:53assist me.
- 45:55But, if that be either lost
- 45:58or have freed themselves from the sieges
- 46:01or that from want of powder you cannot
- 46:04undertake that work,
- 46:05that you immediately march with your
- 46:07whole strength directly to Worcester and
- 46:10to assist me and my army.
- 46:12Without which
- 46:14or your having relieved York by beating
- 46:16the Scots,
- 46:17all the successes you can afterwards
- 46:19have must infallibly be useless unto
- 46:22me."
- 46:23The letter was highly ambiguous, to say
- 46:26the least.
- 46:27Was it an order to fight or to avoid
- 46:29battle?
- 46:31But, Culpepper was to be proved right.
- 46:34Rupert interpreted it as the order to
- 46:36fight.
- 46:37He decided he must therefore march at
- 46:39once for York and fight when he got
- 46:41there.
- 46:42The allies had warning of his coming and
- 46:44abandoned their siege lines to wait for
- 46:46him on Marston Moor.
- 46:48All day throughout the 1st of July, they
- 46:50waited and waited in vain.
- 46:55Instead of marching straight for the
- 46:57city and engaging an army which
- 46:59outnumbered his own by two to one,
- 47:01Rupert circled around them and relieved
- 47:03York from the north.
- 47:05It was a long day's march, well over 20
- 47:08miles, but while his infantry men flung
- 47:10themselves down exhausted at Tollerton,
- 47:13his cavalry pushed on to enter York
- 47:15itself.
- 47:17Confident of beating Rupert on his own,
- 47:20the allied generals were less sanguine
- 47:22of their chances against Rupert's and
- 47:23Newcastle's armies combined. There was,
- 47:26it seemed, no alternative but to
- 47:28retreat.
- 47:30Despite the weary condition of his men,
- 47:33from his interpretation of the king's
- 47:35strange letter, Rupert was determined to
- 47:37fight.
- 47:39He understood the letter to mean he was
- 47:40to bring the allies to battle and
- 47:42destroy them.
- 47:44Had he succeeded in doing so, he might
- 47:46have won the war in a single afternoon.
- 47:48As it was, he very nearly lost it.
- 47:52Although Rupert was ready to fight, his
- 47:55army was certainly not.
- 47:57Newcastle's army had endured a long
- 47:59siege on short rations.
- 48:01His chief of staff, Lord Ethen, argued
- 48:04that his men needed to rest after the
- 48:05rigors of the siege.
- 48:07Rupert's own infantry were equally
- 48:09wearied by their epic march of the day
- 48:11before.
- 48:12But, the prince would not be denied his
- 48:14chance to come to grips with the three
- 48:15parliamentary armies which faced him.
- 48:18The king's nephew, Prince Rupert of the
- 48:20Rhine, had one great advantage over
- 48:22probably almost all the other generals
- 48:24in the Civil War.
- 48:26And that was he had taken a large part
- 48:28in the 30 Years' War on the continent.
- 48:31Rather mixed fortunes, in fact, he'd
- 48:32been a prisoner of war for 3 years at
- 48:34one stage, but he had experience and
- 48:37used that 3 years' incarceration to
- 48:40study the art of war from all available
- 48:42books of the period and therefore could
- 48:44be set up as being something of an
- 48:46expert.
- 48:48He also was, of course, a very dashing
- 48:50commander in the field. Together with
- 48:53his famous dog Boy, which the
- 48:55parliamentarians began to believe was a
- 48:57familiar of the devil who accompanied
- 48:58him into the field, he cut such a dash
- 49:01on the battlefield that nobody who saw
- 49:04it would ever forget it.
- 49:06But, there was a limitations to the
- 49:08greatness of Prince Rupert.
- 49:11Rupert's greatest drawback as a
- 49:13commander was his total inability to
- 49:16control his horsemen.
- 49:18Now, this is surprising given his his
- 49:20experience on the continent where
- 49:22certainly Gustavus Adolphus and the
- 49:23Swedes had laid great amount of
- 49:25importance on rallying cavalry after the
- 49:28charge.
- 49:29On several times, as after Naseby,
- 49:31you'll find the the Royal cavalry under
- 49:34Rupert leaving the field having defeated
- 49:36their enemy for a very important period.
- 49:39And by the time he had returned to
- 49:40Naseby, for example, the battle, which
- 49:43had been going all King's way until that
- 49:44particular moment, had been lost by the
- 49:47infantry in the center, and Rupert's
- 49:49return was far too late to retrieve the
- 49:50situation.
- 49:52Effectively, therefore, Rupert, time and
- 49:54again, threw away all the cavalry
- 49:56advantage, and the King's army suffered
- 49:59as a consequence.
- 50:02So it was that the allied rearguards,
- 50:04covering the retreat of the
- 50:05parliamentarians across Marston Moor,
- 50:08saw royalist cavalry appear in the early
- 50:11morning haze opposite, and they were
- 50:13soon followed by further infantry
- 50:15regiments.
- 50:16This was clearly no reconnaissance,
- 50:19but the overture to a pitched battle.
- 50:23Frantic orders were sent to recall the
- 50:25retreating allied regiments,
- 50:27but beyond drawing up in order of
- 50:29battle, the royalists made no move to
- 50:31attack.
- 50:33The trouble lay with Newcastle.
- 50:36The northern infantry had mutinied,
- 50:38loudly demanding their arrears of pay,
- 50:40and it was late in the afternoon before
- 50:42an impatient Prince Rupert saw them
- 50:44march onto the moor.
- 50:47The delay had given the parliamentarians
- 50:49the time they needed to recall the three
- 50:51armies.
- 50:52Now they could count on a single force
- 50:54of over 7,000 cavalry and 20,000
- 50:57infantry.
- 50:58On the left were the Eastern Association
- 51:01cavalry, led by one Oliver Cromwell,
- 51:04a lesser known member of parliament, but
- 51:06a gifted commander, who, like Rupert,
- 51:09had grasped that the essence of cavalry
- 51:11fighting was to charge home at the
- 51:13gallop.
- 51:14Although he was not yet the figure he
- 51:16would later become, Cromwell's
- 51:18reputation was growing both on and off
- 51:20the battlefield.
- 51:22His cavalry were already renowned for
- 51:23their fierce courage and excellent
- 51:25discipline.
- 51:27Behind Cromwell's men were a brigade of
- 51:29Scots cavalry under a professional
- 51:31soldier named David Leslie.
- 51:34These Scots were destined to play a
- 51:35crucial role in the battle.
- 51:38In the center stood the combined
- 51:39infantry of the allied armies, commanded
- 51:42by two more Scots professionals,
- 51:44Lawrence Crawford and James Lumsden.
- 51:48On the right wing were Fairfax's cavalry
- 51:50and another Scots brigade.
- 51:53The royalist dispositions left something
- 51:55to be desired.
- 51:56Rupert had intended that his own and
- 51:58Newcastle's army should be drawn up side
- 52:00by side.
- 52:02However, the late appearance of the
- 52:03northern infantry meant that his own men
- 52:05had to be spread thinly across the
- 52:07entire front, while the latecomers
- 52:09eventually grouped together in the rear.
- 52:13Rupert assumed that it was too late in
- 52:14the day to fight. The battle would be
- 52:16fought on the morrow.
- 52:18But the Earl of Leven had other ideas.
- 52:21After all, he reasoned, a summer's
- 52:23evening was as long as a winter's day.
- 52:26No sooner had the royalists begun to
- 52:28relax and cook the evening meal, when
- 52:30under the cover of a brief summer
- 52:32thunderstorm, the parliamentarians
- 52:34surged forward and the battle began.
- 52:37The allies came on at a running march,
- 52:40and in moments all was confusion.
- 52:43The cavaliers were taken completely by
- 52:45surprise.
- 52:46Cromwell's men scattered the cavalry
- 52:48opposite, and in the center, the
- 52:50royalist infantry under Sir Thomas
- 52:52Tyldesley also began to give way before
- 52:55the onslaught.
- 52:56Only Fairfax's cavalry on the right were
- 52:58checked.
- 53:00The royalist left wing defeated
- 53:02Fairfax's northern regiments and carved
- 53:04their way deep into the allied infantry.
- 53:07Led by the Earl of Leven himself,
- 53:09thousands of parliamentarians and Scots
- 53:11fled the field, spreading the word of a
- 53:13royalist victory.
- 53:16At this crucial juncture, Cromwell, too,
- 53:18left the field to have a minor wound
- 53:20attended to.
- 53:22In his absence, the Scots cavalry halted
- 53:25Rupert's cavaliers, then swung round to
- 53:28attack the unsupported royalist
- 53:30infantry.
- 53:31The battle had been stabilized.
- 53:34Cromwell returned and resumed command.
- 53:37But the general allied was to be halted
- 53:39by a brigade of white-coated royalist
- 53:41infantry.
- 53:43Newcastle's northerners had arrived
- 53:45late, but now they were in a strong
- 53:47position and determined not to give
- 53:49ground.
- 54:12THE WHITE COATS REFUSED TO SURRENDER,
- 54:14AND THE Scots took no prisoners.
- 54:17Less than 30 survived.
- 54:20As the white coats went down in bloody
- 54:22ruin, Cromwell drove off the last of the
- 54:24cavaliers, and the day ended with a
- 54:26complete allied victory.
- 54:35MARSTON MOOR WAS THE LARGEST BATTLE ever
- 54:37fought on British soil,
- 54:39but the allies gained very little from
- 54:40their famous victory.
- 54:42York surrendered 2 weeks later, but
- 54:45Newcastle upon Tyne held out until
- 54:46October, and Carlisle until the
- 54:48following June.
- 54:50Only the Earl of Manchester's Eastern
- 54:52Association army was free to turn south,
- 54:55and without it, Parliament might still
- 54:57have lost the war.
- 55:01While Rupert was in the north, the King
- 55:03had been very hard-pressed at Oxford by
- 55:06the combined armies of Essex and Waller.
- 55:09Defeat for the King looked imminent, but
- 55:12then the two generals, who harbored a
- 55:13personal hatred for each other, suddenly
- 55:16parted company.
- 55:18The King at once seized his opportunity
- 55:20to attack each in turn, and defeated
- 55:23Waller's army at Cropredy Bridge in
- 55:24Oxfordshire.
- 55:26Then he pursued the inept Earl of Essex
- 55:28into the royalist West Country,
- 55:30once again interposing his own army
- 55:33between Essex and London.
- 55:35This time there would be no mistakes.
- 55:39In a week-long running battle, the
- 55:41parliamentarians were harried to
- 55:42destruction at Lostwithiel in Cornwall.
- 55:46Most of Essex's cavalry eventually broke
- 55:48out under cover of rain and darkness,
- 55:50and he himself fled in a tiny fishing
- 55:53boat.
- 55:53But his infantry were forced to
- 55:55surrender on the 2nd of September.
- 55:58Marston Moor had been avenged, and no
- 56:00end to the war was in sight.
- 56:03On his return to Oxford from the victory
- 56:05at Lostwithiel, fresh parliamentarian
- 56:08forces sought to trap the King at
- 56:09Newbury, but the royalists fought their
- 56:11way clear in the second battle of
- 56:13Newbury.
- 56:14Angry recriminations followed, and the
- 56:17parliamentarians split into two
- 56:18factions.
- 56:21On the one hand were the Presbyterians
- 56:22and their Scots allies, led by the old
- 56:24generals Essex, Manchester, and Waller.
- 56:28They were sickened by the fighting and
- 56:30ready for peace.
- 56:31The Presbyterians favored the
- 56:33reorganization of the Church of England
- 56:35along the same lines as that of the
- 56:37Church of Scotland.
- 56:38They were also more inclined to make
- 56:40peace with the King.
- 56:42Manchester was the chief spokesman.
- 56:46"I beseech you, let us consider what we
- 56:49do.
- 56:50The King need not care how often he
- 56:52fights.
- 56:53If we fight 100 times and beat him 99,
- 56:57he will be King still.
- 56:59But if he beats us but once, or the last
- 57:02time,
- 57:02we shall be hanged and all our posterity
- 57:05undone."
- 57:09On the other side were the Independents
- 57:11and their champion, Oliver Cromwell.
- 57:14To Manchester, Cromwell had the stern
- 57:16reply,
- 57:17"If this be so, my Lord, why did we take
- 57:20up arms in the first?
- 57:22This is against fighting ever
- 57:23hereafter."
- 57:27On one point, both the Independents and
- 57:29the Presbyterians were agreed.
- 57:31The parliamentarian forces had to be
- 57:33remodeled.
- 57:35The performance of the parliamentary
- 57:36armies in the field was poor.
- 57:39There were too many regiments and too
- 57:40many officers, but all too few soldiers.
- 57:44The solution was to break up the
- 57:45existing units and draft the men into
- 57:47fewer, but larger regiments.
- 57:51Nomination of officers became a trial of
- 57:52strength between the two factions.
- 57:55The Independents won, and Sir Thomas
- 57:57Fairfax was appointed general.
- 57:59But the overriding influence in the army
- 58:02was that of Oliver Cromwell.
- 58:04It's interesting to compare Prince
- 58:06Rupert, all dash and feathers, with
- 58:09Cromwell's attitude to cavalry command.
- 58:12He was much less experienced than
- 58:15Rupert, and indeed, in 1642, was only
- 58:18beginning to raise his very first troop
- 58:20of cavalry in the Eastern Association.
- 58:22But he would emerge during these years
- 58:24as by far the greater cavalry commander
- 58:26of the two, and on the basis of his
- 58:28cavalry command, everything else was
- 58:30going to be built.
- 58:32Why was this so?
- 58:34First of all, he believed in total
- 58:36indoctrination and dedication on the
- 58:39part, at least of his officers, if not
- 58:41of his rank and file. Whereas Rupert, on
- 58:43the other hand, was loyal to his uncle,
- 58:45King Charles I,
- 58:47but really couldn't care a damn about
- 58:48what else was being fought for.
- 58:51Cromwell, on the other hand, of course,
- 58:53was absolutely clear from the beginning
- 58:55what he was after. He'd had this
- 58:57conversion to low church Calvinistic
- 59:00type religion in about 1638, it is
- 59:03thought, and he was ideologically
- 59:05committed to the struggle, and he looked
- 59:07for men of the same type.
- 59:09"Give me a plain fustian captain," he
- 59:12said, "who knows why he fights and loves
- 59:14what he knows."
- 59:16Now, that attitude of dedication to a
- 59:18cause, whether we happen to agree with
- 59:20it or not, is immaterial, contrasts so
- 59:22markedly with the attitude of the
- 59:24cavaliers, who, after all, the wordy
- 59:27word has come into the language to mean
- 59:28somebody who's pretty slap-happy,
- 59:30devil-may-care, but what the hell.
- 59:33There's a contrast there.
- 59:35But passing on from the mere cavalry
- 59:37commander Cromwell, he then emerges as
- 59:40an overall commander-in-chief.
- 59:43This, of course, he owes in large
- 59:44measure to Fairfax, who undoubtedly
- 59:47taught him a great deal of the do's and
- 59:50don'ts of 17th century battlefields.
- 59:53And so, when we get to the time of the
- 59:54Battle of Preston against the Scots, we
- 59:57find that Cromwell, as the overall
- 59:59commander, very cleverly welding
- 1:00:01together his guns, his infantry or foot,
- 1:00:04and his cavalry or horse into a most
- 1:00:06effective fighting team.
- 1:00:08And he is becoming a great general.
- 1:00:11Personally, however, I would not rate
- 1:00:13him as high as say Marlborough or
- 1:00:15Wellington in our English military
- 1:00:17pantheon.
- 1:00:19Why?
- 1:00:20Well, first of all, he was dealing with
- 1:00:22opponents who, on the whole, were
- 1:00:24second-rate. He never had the challenge
- 1:00:26of taking on a major continental
- 1:00:28opponent, for example, brought up in a
- 1:00:30different military tradition, probably
- 1:00:32far more efficient, perhaps, than his
- 1:00:34own army.
- 1:00:35Although it is true, of course, that the
- 1:00:36Battle of the Dunes was fought
- 1:00:39with by parts of his army very
- 1:00:40effectively without his presence, yet I
- 1:00:43feel our first of men, as he is often
- 1:00:46described as being, was possibly a
- 1:00:48figure of military importance who might
- 1:00:51come third after both Marlborough and
- 1:00:53Wellington, certainly ahead of
- 1:00:54Montgomery, however, in our military
- 1:00:57list of great commanders.
- 1:01:01The cavalry for the New Model Army were
- 1:01:03easy to find. They were generally better
- 1:01:06provided for than the infantry, who
- 1:01:08waded knee-deep through mud and shivered
- 1:01:10under hedgerows at night.
- 1:01:12Far fewer cavalrymen deserted or died
- 1:01:15from the dysentery, exposure, or want,
- 1:01:18which had so thinned the ranks of the
- 1:01:20infantry.
- 1:01:21Most of the old cavalry regiments were
- 1:01:23simply transferred directly into the New
- 1:01:25Model Army.
- 1:01:28The infantry were a different matter.
- 1:01:30One of their more charitable officers
- 1:01:32described them as arrant scum.
- 1:01:36The frequent gaps in the ranks had to be
- 1:01:37filled with unwilling conscripts, who
- 1:01:40promptly deserted at the first
- 1:01:41opportunity.
- 1:01:43By 1645, the whole country was war-weary
- 1:01:46and infantry recruits almost impossible
- 1:01:49to find.
- 1:01:51On the 30th of May, 1645, the King's
- 1:01:54last field army, breaking out from
- 1:01:56Oxford, stormed Leicester, and
- 1:01:58Parliament sent its New Army northwards
- 1:02:00to seek the decisive battle, which would
- 1:02:02end the war.
- 1:02:05With no clear overall strategy, the
- 1:02:07Royalists had little option but to
- 1:02:09oblige, and both armies met at Naseby in
- 1:02:12Northamptonshire on the 14th of June,
- 1:02:141645.
- 1:02:18This surviving contemporary map shows
- 1:02:20the dispositions of the army. Numbers
- 1:02:22were unequal. The King's army, commanded
- 1:02:25by Prince Rupert, had dwindled to 5,500
- 1:02:28cavalry and about 4,500 infantry.
- 1:02:32Sir Thomas Fairfax mustered 6,000
- 1:02:34cavalry, but had no fewer than 6,500
- 1:02:37infantry and 1,000 dragoons.
- 1:02:40The disparity of forces should have been
- 1:02:42enough to ensure a comfortable victory
- 1:02:44for parliamentary forces.
- 1:02:47The Royalist army marshaled itself on
- 1:02:49Dust Hill, 2 miles north of Naseby
- 1:02:52village.
- 1:02:53As usual, the infantry stood in the
- 1:02:55center, flanked by the two wings of
- 1:02:57cavalry.
- 1:02:59The New Model Army drew up 1,000 yards
- 1:03:02to the south, on the other side of the
- 1:03:03valley.
- 1:03:05They differed from the Royalists in two
- 1:03:07respects.
- 1:03:08Most stood behind the crest of Mill Hill
- 1:03:11and could not, therefore, be seen by
- 1:03:12Rupert's men.
- 1:03:14More importantly, the right wing of the
- 1:03:16cavalry, led by Oliver Cromwell, had
- 1:03:19three lines of regiments and very
- 1:03:21heavily outnumbered the Cavaliers
- 1:03:23opposite.
- 1:03:26Confident of his men, Rupert ignored the
- 1:03:29disparity in numbers and ordered an
- 1:03:31immediate assault.
- 1:03:33Rupert's men swept down the hill,
- 1:03:35ignoring the Parliamentarian dragoons in
- 1:03:37the hedgerows.
- 1:03:38First into action was Prince Rupert
- 1:03:40himself.
- 1:03:41Leading the Royalist right wing, his men
- 1:03:44crashed into his opponents' numbers and,
- 1:03:46after a brief fight, drove them clean
- 1:03:48off the field.
- 1:03:50Despite the superior numbers ranged
- 1:03:52against them, the Royalist infantry,
- 1:03:54too, came on with great spirit.
- 1:03:57They mounted the crest of Mill Hill,
- 1:03:59poured a single volley into the
- 1:04:00Parliamentarians, and then fell on with
- 1:04:02swords and musket butts.
- 1:04:04The Roundheads' first line dissolved
- 1:04:06into a mass of panic-stricken fugitives
- 1:04:09and fell back upon the reserves in the
- 1:04:10second line.
- 1:04:12Not even a despairing counterattack by
- 1:04:14the few cavalry squadrons left unscathed
- 1:04:17by Prince Rupert's charge could stop the
- 1:04:19Royalists.
- 1:04:21Fairfax's second line of infantry held
- 1:04:23on grimly, but Royalist reinforcements
- 1:04:25were moving up and the Roundhead
- 1:04:27infantry looked ready to crack.
- 1:04:30It was Cromwell who saved the day.
- 1:04:32With the first charge, his division
- 1:04:33broke the Royalist cavalry opposite him.
- 1:04:36Unlike Prince Rupert, Oliver Cromwell
- 1:04:38did not allow his men to waste time in
- 1:04:40chasing the fugitives.
- 1:04:42Instead, seeing the disaster looming in
- 1:04:44the center, he turned his
- 1:04:46well-disciplined men inwards to attack
- 1:04:48the Royalist infantry from behind.
- 1:04:51Now surrounded, most of the Royalist
- 1:04:53infantry surrendered,
- 1:04:55though a few held out stoutly for a
- 1:04:56time.
- 1:04:58Thinking that the Royalists had gained
- 1:05:00the victory, Prince Rupert, meanwhile,
- 1:05:02had pushed as far south as the
- 1:05:04Parliamentarian baggage train.
- 1:05:06His men stopped to pillage the train,
- 1:05:08but were discouraged by Parliamentarian
- 1:05:10guards.
- 1:05:11Rupert returned to find the battle over,
- 1:05:14won not by the Royalists, as he
- 1:05:16expected, but by the Roundheads,
- 1:05:18who had captured all of the King's
- 1:05:20artillery, put his cavalry to route, and
- 1:05:23destroyed his infantry.
- 1:05:26In the Royalist camp, the wives and
- 1:05:28children of the King's Irish and Welsh
- 1:05:31awaited the outcome of the battle.
- 1:05:33The first signs of defeat came when the
- 1:05:36surviving infantry fled through the camp
- 1:05:38with the victorious Parliamentarians in
- 1:05:40pursuit.
- 1:05:41When they reached the Royalist tents, a
- 1:05:43fearful massacre ensued.
- 1:05:48Many of the Royalist regiments had
- 1:05:50served in the Irish wars.
- 1:05:52The soldiers had Irish wives and
- 1:05:54girlfriends, and now over 100 women died
- 1:05:57in a senseless orgy of killing.
- 1:06:00Afterwards, it was lamely claimed that
- 1:06:02they were Catholics and that many had
- 1:06:04long knives.
- 1:06:07The defeat of the King's army at Naseby
- 1:06:10signaled the end of the last major
- 1:06:12Royalist army.
- 1:06:13In a series of sieges and smaller
- 1:06:15affairs, the war dragged on for another
- 1:06:17year after the Battle of Naseby.
- 1:06:21Fairfax marched next into the West
- 1:06:23Country and cleared it of Royalists in a
- 1:06:25brisk campaign.
- 1:06:27Everywhere, war-weariness was apparent.
- 1:06:30Many garrisons held out stubbornly.
- 1:06:33Others surrendered with indecent haste.
- 1:06:36The King was now powerless.
- 1:06:38Without the veteran infantry lost at
- 1:06:40Naseby, he could do nothing.
- 1:06:43Scotland gave him some cause to hope for
- 1:06:45a while.
- 1:06:46The Marquess of Montrose led a Royalist
- 1:06:48uprising there, which came tantalizingly
- 1:06:51close to victory, but this brief spark,
- 1:06:53too, was extinguished.
- 1:06:55David Leslie utterly destroyed the army
- 1:06:57of Montrose at Philiphaugh, near
- 1:06:59Selkirk, on the 12th of September,
- 1:07:02and the King's last hope was gone.
- 1:07:06At length, even Charles recognized his
- 1:07:08plight
- 1:07:09and surrendered himself to the Scots
- 1:07:11army besieging outside Newark on the 5th
- 1:07:13of May, 1646.
- 1:07:16He seems to have had some thought of
- 1:07:17persuading them to support him,
- 1:07:20but their first act was to compel him to
- 1:07:22order the surrender of his remaining
- 1:07:23fortresses.
- 1:07:25With that, the war should have been
- 1:07:27over,
- 1:07:28but the King, even now, refused to admit
- 1:07:30defeat, and the Scots went home, leaving
- 1:07:33the King in Parliamentarian custody.
- 1:07:37Two years of intrigue, plots, and
- 1:07:39counter-intrigue followed.
- 1:07:42Even although Charles was now
- 1:07:43effectively a prisoner of Parliament, a
- 1:07:45settlement was deferred time and time
- 1:07:47again as the King tried to play one
- 1:07:50faction off against the other.
- 1:07:52Charles is shown here in this
- 1:07:54contemporary pamphlet negotiating with
- 1:07:56the parliamentary commissioners.
- 1:08:00His army may have been defeated, but he
- 1:08:02was King still, even though he was now
- 1:08:04effectively a prisoner, here with his
- 1:08:07jailer, Colonel Hammond.
- 1:08:09The Presbyterians were disposed to
- 1:08:11accommodate him, but the
- 1:08:12Independent-dominated army became
- 1:08:14increasingly impatient with Charles.
- 1:08:17Concerned over its increasing power,
- 1:08:19Parliament tried to have the army
- 1:08:21disbanded, but the move failed.
- 1:08:23The army, along with its new champion,
- 1:08:26Oliver Cromwell, would have the last
- 1:08:28say.
- 1:08:30Meanwhile, the King had concluded a
- 1:08:32secret alliance with some of the more
- 1:08:34moderate Scots.
- 1:08:36Royalist agents were also secretly
- 1:08:38prepared for a great uprising in England
- 1:08:40to coincide with another Scots invasion,
- 1:08:43this time on the side of the King.
- 1:08:46On the 23rd of March, 1648, the garrison
- 1:08:49of Pembroke declared for the King in the
- 1:08:51rather naive belief that he would settle
- 1:08:54their arrears of pay.
- 1:08:57Cromwell was at once sent to deal with
- 1:08:59them, but a month later, more Royalist
- 1:09:01rebels seized Berwick and Carlisle,
- 1:09:04opening the way for the arrival of the
- 1:09:05Scottish army into England, now marching
- 1:09:07to the aid of the King.
- 1:09:10Worse news was to come for Cromwell. At
- 1:09:12the end of May, a Royalist revolt broke
- 1:09:14out in Kent, and the navy mutinied and
- 1:09:17declared for the King.
- 1:09:19Although the Scots were to support the
- 1:09:21Royalist uprising and come to the aid of
- 1:09:23the King, they were delayed by fierce
- 1:09:25opposition at home until the beginning
- 1:09:27of July.
- 1:09:28By that time, it was too late.
- 1:09:32Fairfax had defeated the Kentish rebels
- 1:09:34at Maidstone in June 1648, and he
- 1:09:36pursued the fugitives north across the
- 1:09:39Thames and besieged them in Colchester.
- 1:09:42Pembroke surrendered to Cromwell on the
- 1:09:4411th of August.
- 1:09:46Only 3 days later, the Scots at last
- 1:09:48crossed the border.
- 1:09:50There was not a moment to lose.
- 1:09:52Marching hard, Cromwell joined General
- 1:09:54Lambert at Wetherby, then turned
- 1:09:56westwards again across the Pennines to
- 1:09:58pursue the Scottish army marching
- 1:10:00southwards on London.
- 1:10:03By this time, the Scots had reached
- 1:10:04Preston, but on the 17th of August,
- 1:10:07Cromwell's men defeated the English
- 1:10:09royalist forces allied to the Scots
- 1:10:11outside the town.
- 1:10:13Over the next 2 days, the Scots army,
- 1:10:15now in considerable disorder, continued
- 1:10:18to push south in driving rain, while
- 1:10:20Cromwell's men snapped at their heels.
- 1:10:23On the 19th, abandoned by their cavalry,
- 1:10:26the Scottish infantry turned at bay
- 1:10:28outside Warrington.
- 1:10:31"We held them in some dispute," wrote
- 1:10:33Cromwell afterwards, "till our army came
- 1:10:36up,
- 1:10:36they maintaining the pass with great
- 1:10:38resolution for many hours.
- 1:10:41Ours and theirs coming to push of pike
- 1:10:43and very close charges."
- 1:10:46Eventually, the Scots ran out of
- 1:10:48ammunition and fell back into
- 1:10:49Warrington.
- 1:10:50There was some talk of fortifying the
- 1:10:52town, but without ammunition, it was
- 1:10:54hopeless. Next day, they surrendered.
- 1:10:58A week later, Fairfax's men flaunted the
- 1:11:00banners taken from the Scots army before
- 1:11:02the walls of Colchester.
- 1:11:04The defenders now realized that no
- 1:11:06relief could now be expected, so they
- 1:11:08surrendered on the 28th of August, 1648.
- 1:11:13The Second Civil War was over,
- 1:11:15and it was time for a reckoning with the
- 1:11:17king.
- 1:11:20The events of Colchester and Preston
- 1:11:22proved to be Charles's final undoing.
- 1:11:25It was clear to all that with his
- 1:11:27various intrigues, the king had played a
- 1:11:29significant part in plunging the country
- 1:11:31once more into civil war.
- 1:11:34But it was what to do now which was the
- 1:11:36unanswerable question.
- 1:11:39The role of the king lay at the very
- 1:11:41heart of the causes of the war, and the
- 1:11:43dilemma was now greater than ever.
- 1:11:46The parliamentary party had embarked
- 1:11:48upon the Civil War earnestly believing
- 1:11:50that they fought for God and Parliament
- 1:11:52against the king's evil counselors.
- 1:11:55They genuinely believed that they were
- 1:11:57at war not with the king himself, but
- 1:11:59with the malignant party which advised
- 1:12:01him.
- 1:12:02Now, the awful truth was becoming
- 1:12:04abundantly clear.
- 1:12:06His armies may have been defeated, but
- 1:12:08even in defeat, Charles Stuart, the man,
- 1:12:11was still the king,
- 1:12:12and he embodied all that went with that
- 1:12:14office.
- 1:12:17King Charles was a man who would not
- 1:12:18yield his personal position.
- 1:12:20He still clung to principles which he
- 1:12:22had taken to the field to protect in
- 1:12:241642.
- 1:12:27The great constitutional issues,
- 1:12:29therefore, still remained unsolved. No
- 1:12:32one had intended that it should end this
- 1:12:34way, but among the victorious
- 1:12:36Roundheads, the uncomfortable
- 1:12:37realization gradually dawned that the
- 1:12:39only lasting solution lay in the drastic
- 1:12:42step of abolishing the monarchy and the
- 1:12:45execution of the sovereign.
- 1:12:47As yet, no one had dared to voice such a
- 1:12:49treacherous solution.
- 1:12:51It fell to Oliver Cromwell to grasp that
- 1:12:54poisoned chalice.
- 1:12:57"We shall cut off the head of the king
- 1:12:59with the crown upon it."
- 1:13:02But even Cromwell had supported all of
- 1:13:04the attempts to find a mutually
- 1:13:06acceptable way forward which would
- 1:13:07accommodate both the dignity of the
- 1:13:09king's position and the wishes of
- 1:13:11Parliament.
- 1:13:12However, the role of the king in
- 1:13:14bringing about the Second Civil War
- 1:13:16convinced that God-fearing man that
- 1:13:18there was no other solution.
- 1:13:21Cromwell, therefore, decided that
- 1:13:23Charles would face trial for his life.
- 1:13:26Cromwell knew that no lasting peace
- 1:13:28could be found while Charles Stuart,
- 1:13:30that man of blood, still lived.
- 1:13:33However,
- 1:13:35even the most Puritan lawyers declared
- 1:13:37the trial illegal.
- 1:13:39Of the 135 commissioners selected by
- 1:13:41Cromwell to try Charles, only 68
- 1:13:44appeared when the trial opened.
- 1:13:47Turning to consider the whole matter of
- 1:13:48the trial of King Charles I, we have to
- 1:13:51establish whether it was legal or not.
- 1:13:53Well, in a single word, that word is no.
- 1:13:56It was not legal.
- 1:13:58There was no precedent whatsoever,
- 1:14:00either in our unwritten or such parts of
- 1:14:02our written constitution as then
- 1:14:03existed, to allow a king to be killed by
- 1:14:07his subjects for supposed uh
- 1:14:10uh acts of treason against his own
- 1:14:12people,
- 1:14:13as the parliamentary court tried to
- 1:14:15establish.
- 1:14:16So, King Charles I was perfectly in
- 1:14:18order and absolutely correct to first of
- 1:14:20all deny the charge's legality and
- 1:14:23secondly to refuse to recognize the
- 1:14:25court which was setting to try him.
- 1:14:28But Cromwell, remember, was determined
- 1:14:29to try to solve the problem of the
- 1:14:32future of the coal country,
- 1:14:34and he believed he could not do that
- 1:14:36while the king still lived. Ironically,
- 1:14:39Oliver Cromwell became far more of a
- 1:14:41tyrant in the end than Charles I. He had
- 1:14:43to rule
- 1:14:45He had to rule when he had had his big
- 1:14:47arguments with Parliament through the
- 1:14:48army, the rule of the major generals and
- 1:14:51so forth, which had a major effect right
- 1:14:53down to the present day on the
- 1:14:55constitutional position of the army
- 1:14:57within the British realm.
- 1:14:59He was offered the crown twice, but very
- 1:15:02wisely refused it. But as Lord
- 1:15:04Protector, he had in fact far more power
- 1:15:07than Charles I had ever exerted.
- 1:15:10All his life, Charles had cut a rather
- 1:15:11reticent figure, not at all aided by his
- 1:15:14slight speech impediment.
- 1:15:16His trial was to be the finest hour of
- 1:15:18his life.
- 1:15:19His stammer miraculously left him, and
- 1:15:22he won new admiration and respect from
- 1:15:24among even his most bitter opponents by
- 1:15:26his steadfast and dignified defense of
- 1:15:29his position.
- 1:15:31After his first eloquent speech in his
- 1:15:33own defense, in which he refused to
- 1:15:35recognize the authority of the court,
- 1:15:38Charles was not allowed to speak again.
- 1:15:40And it was soon obvious that the trial
- 1:15:42was nothing more than a charade by which
- 1:15:45Cromwell hoped to give the dubious
- 1:15:46proceedings an air of legality.
- 1:15:49I would know
- 1:15:51by what authority,
- 1:15:53and I mean lawful authority, I am to be
- 1:15:56tried.
- 1:15:58There are many unlawful authorities in
- 1:16:00the world, such as thieves and robbers
- 1:16:02on the highway, which have the same
- 1:16:04authority as this assembly.
- 1:16:08Do not forget that I am your sovereign
- 1:16:11king, ordained by God to rule his
- 1:16:14people.
- 1:16:15By that authority, I stand more for the
- 1:16:17liberty of my people than any that come
- 1:16:20here to be my pretended judges.
- 1:16:24You have shown no lawful authority to
- 1:16:26satisfy any reasonable man.
- 1:16:29If I am not suffered to speak, what
- 1:16:31justice shall my people have?
- 1:16:34But however eloquent his defense may
- 1:16:36have been, as Cromwell had intended,
- 1:16:39Charles was sentenced to death by
- 1:16:40beheading.
- 1:16:42In order to prevent any public
- 1:16:44groundswell of support for Charles, the
- 1:16:46sentence was to be carried out the day
- 1:16:48after the signature of his death
- 1:16:49warrant, January the 30th, 1649.
- 1:16:55Typically of Charles, that unhappy
- 1:16:56sovereign went to meet his cruel fate
- 1:16:59still espousing his unshakeable belief
- 1:17:01that it was the divine right of kings to
- 1:17:03rule
- 1:17:04and that of his subjects to be governed.
- 1:17:08His implacable adherence to this
- 1:17:10principle had been the root cause of the
- 1:17:12wars, and Charles would carry that
- 1:17:14belief with him to the grave.
- 1:17:17In his last speech on Earth, he once
- 1:17:19again returned to the principles for
- 1:17:21which he had fought
- 1:17:22and lost.
- 1:17:24For the people, truly I desire this
- 1:17:27liberty and freedom as much as anybody,
- 1:17:30but that freedom and liberty does not
- 1:17:32extend to them having a share in
- 1:17:34government.
- 1:17:36The process of government is not their
- 1:17:38affair.
- 1:17:39A subject and sovereign are clearly
- 1:17:41different things.
- 1:17:44If I had given way for our ancient laws
- 1:17:46to be changed in an arbitrary way
- 1:17:48according to the power of the sword,
- 1:17:51I need not have come here.
- 1:17:54I tell you, therefore,
- 1:17:56I am the martyr of the people.
- 1:17:59I die a Christian according to the
- 1:18:01profession of the Church of England as I
- 1:18:03found it left me by my father.
- 1:18:07I will say no more.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of The Winners and Losers Of The English Civil War | History Of Warfare | Timeline by Timeline - World History Documentaries, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 11,925 words across 2,088 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.