YouTube2Text

The Virgin Suicides by Jeffrey Eugenides Discussion — Transcript

by Caroline Sutphin · 4,372 words · 733 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00Hi guys. Welcome back to my channel. In
  2. 0:03this video, we will be discussing The
  3. 0:05Virgin Suicides by Jeffrey Eugenides,
  4. 0:08which is really a very engrossing,
  5. 0:12beautiful, heartbreaking novel. Um it
  6. 0:16strikes a really interesting balance in
  7. 0:19the tone with the obvious tragedy
  8. 0:22against the
  9. 0:24comic, mundane,
  10. 0:28day-to-day of being a teenager. I also
  11. 0:30found this to be a really quick read. I
  12. 0:32moved through it fast. I really enjoyed
  13. 0:35the prose. It's so specific in its
  14. 0:39world-building, and we get so many
  15. 0:42details about all of the people that
  16. 0:45populate this town. This is my first um
  17. 0:49from Eugenides, but I do have a couple
  18. 0:51more on the shelf that I'm excited to
  19. 0:54get to now. I would say in particular
  20. 0:56the perspective
  21. 0:59of this novel is really adeptly handled.
  22. 1:02The narrator is like this collection of
  23. 1:06boys who are now men that were and are
  24. 1:12obsessed with these Lisbon girls. So,
  25. 1:15we're seeing them many years after their
  26. 1:18deaths, after the glow of youth is gone,
  27. 1:23still really hung up on these girls and
  28. 1:26trying to piece together evidence and
  29. 1:29understand what happened. But what they
  30. 1:32find is the deeper they go, the less
  31. 1:36they understand. The perspective's so
  32. 1:39interesting. It's like one of the
  33. 1:41standout features of this novel because
  34. 1:45it is
  35. 1:47deeply intimate in some ways, and like
  36. 1:50the details and the infatuation that
  37. 1:54they feel, but it's also kind of removed
  38. 1:57because they don't know or understand
  39. 2:00the girls inner lives. They're peeping
  40. 2:03in the windows and they they have all
  41. 2:06this evidence and all of these
  42. 2:09artifacts, but they don't really know
  43. 2:11them. I think that's really key about
  44. 2:15The Virgin Suicides is that the
  45. 2:17questions they have are unanswerable.
  46. 2:20They're probably not even the right
  47. 2:23questions to begin with. Right, before
  48. 2:25we dive in, just a reminder, I don't
  49. 2:27really think of my videos as reviews.
  50. 2:30They are in-depth discussions. I don't
  51. 2:33really think this is a book where it can
  52. 2:35be spoiled since the situation is set up
  53. 2:38right away. But if you care about that,
  54. 2:41you should probably find another video.
  55. 2:49So, let's start with
  56. 2:51the Lisbon family. They have five
  57. 2:55teenage daughters,
  58. 2:57um, a kind of passive father and a
  59. 3:02religious, controlling mother. We see
  60. 3:05that
  61. 3:06the the daughters are vibrant and
  62. 3:10interested in life and seeking out
  63. 3:13experiences,
  64. 3:15but they're being smothered by a
  65. 3:18restrictive environment. So, there's all
  66. 3:20kinds of evidence of them
  67. 3:22fighting against their restraints. Like
  68. 3:25we see this with Lux especially, who's
  69. 3:29like covertly smoking and harboring
  70. 3:32secret crushes and wearing halter tops.
  71. 3:36So, they're already kind of pushing back
  72. 3:38even when things are not quite so bad
  73. 3:43and we see that it gets more and more
  74. 3:45restrictive as time goes on and those
  75. 3:48behaviors get more extreme. We also see
  76. 3:51that it's not as simple as
  77. 3:55the girls rejecting um
  78. 3:58the faith of their parents. We see um
  79. 4:02Bonnie being quite religious and
  80. 4:05praying, and we see
  81. 4:07Mary and Therese really trying to follow
  82. 4:10the rules, but they're clearly longing
  83. 4:13for more freedom, more space to discover
  84. 4:17who they are, to pursue their distinct
  85. 4:21interests, to have
  86. 4:23passion, and to live life, and just to
  87. 4:27have the the head space to grow from
  88. 4:31girls into women. And, that's really
  89. 4:34significant um
  90. 4:36a significant shift from
  91. 4:39the childhood that they maybe had before
  92. 4:41this. The fact that all of these girls
  93. 4:44are teenagers now, and they're
  94. 4:47growing into more independence. This is
  95. 4:51where the trouble starts, where the fear
  96. 4:53comes in for their mother, especially.
  97. 4:56There's this one
  98. 4:58small detail about these happy family
  99. 5:02photos and evidence of vacations and
  100. 5:06things that they did together
  101. 5:08um when they were younger. The photos
  102. 5:10virtually cease about the time Therese
  103. 5:13turned 12. And, that's kind of the end
  104. 5:16of their
  105. 5:17happiness in their family. And, I think
  106. 5:20that's evidence of
  107. 5:22Mr. and Mrs. Lisbon having a lot of
  108. 5:25fear, fear of their daughters being
  109. 5:29corrupted, that their
  110. 5:31belief in Christianity is really rooted
  111. 5:33in that fear. They're afraid of all the
  112. 5:35things that
  113. 5:37puberty brings, of growing independence,
  114. 5:40of more temptations to sin,
  115. 5:44of sexuality, all of the ways that life
  116. 5:48becomes more complicated for teenage
  117. 5:51girls. Um,
  118. 5:53they're
  119. 5:54afraid of the world that their daughters
  120. 5:57live in and who they're becoming, their
  121. 6:01inability to control that. Well, the
  122. 6:03book opens with Cecilia's
  123. 6:07suicide attempts. Uh, she is the
  124. 6:09youngest of the Lisbon girls. We see
  125. 6:12that Mr. and Mrs. Lisbon are just
  126. 6:16completely debilitated by the horror of
  127. 6:18this. Um, we don't see them ever get
  128. 6:22over it and the fact that they couldn't
  129. 6:26prevent it, that they couldn't predict
  130. 6:28it, really dictates the next year of
  131. 6:33their family's life. So, after the first
  132. 6:36attempt, there is kind of an interesting
  133. 6:39period that shows kind of the contrast
  134. 6:42of how it could be, where following
  135. 6:45doctor's advice, they loosen the rules a
  136. 6:48little bit. They let out the leash. You
  137. 6:51know, that they need social outlets.
  138. 6:54They need opportunities to interact with
  139. 6:57boys. They need to be able to do the
  140. 7:00things other girls their age are doing.
  141. 7:04This whole period, um, Mrs. Lisbon is
  142. 7:07very skeptical of, so you can kind of
  143. 7:10see it's doomed to come to an end from
  144. 7:13the start. But, what's interesting about
  145. 7:16that time period and the months after
  146. 7:21Cecilia's death, when they aren't on
  147. 7:24complete lockdown and they're still
  148. 7:27going to school, there are signs that
  149. 7:31the other four Lisbon girls are
  150. 7:33beginning to heal from what happened, to
  151. 7:37recover from
  152. 7:39the grief of losing their sister. And
  153. 7:42that time and returning to school and
  154. 7:46returning to their lives is
  155. 7:48helping them. We noticed the change,
  156. 7:50too. The girls seemed less tired.
  157. 7:53In class, they stared out the window
  158. 7:55less, raised their hands more, spoke up.
  159. 7:59They momentarily forgot the stigma
  160. 8:01attached to them and took part again in
  161. 8:03school activities. Like it goes on to
  162. 8:05describe how each of the girls are kind
  163. 8:08of coming back to life for a painfully
  164. 8:12brief moment. There was some
  165. 8:15resiliency being shown, and they were
  166. 8:19looking to their futures. So, we see
  167. 8:22there's not a clear line connecting
  168. 8:25Cecilia's death to the other four
  169. 8:29sisters. They hadn't given up on life at
  170. 8:33that point. You see as it's
  171. 8:36the parents who are stuck, who from that
  172. 8:40moment literally never clean their home
  173. 8:44again or fix a broken thing. They're the
  174. 8:47ones who completely stop living. All
  175. 8:50they have left is that fear, that fear
  176. 8:54of the outside world and what it will do
  177. 8:58to their other daughters, cuz they
  178. 9:00believe that what happened to Cecilia
  179. 9:03was a corruption from outside. They
  180. 9:07can't believe that it came from their
  181. 9:09own home or came from inside of Cecilia.
  182. 9:14They have no understanding of
  183. 9:16the
  184. 9:18the mental health issues that maybe
  185. 9:20Cecilia had within herself. So, on that
  186. 9:23fateful homecoming night, when Lux
  187. 9:26misses curfew,
  188. 9:28they completely lock down. They take
  189. 9:30away
  190. 9:32any freedom the girls had, any
  191. 9:35opportunity to interact with people
  192. 9:38outside of their home. They don't go to
  193. 9:40school, either. They are really
  194. 9:42imprisoned in this house that their
  195. 9:45parents believe to be the only safe
  196. 9:48place. And that's the fatal
  197. 9:51misunderstanding,
  198. 9:53that belief they have that the problems
  199. 9:55are coming from the outside and not
  200. 9:58understanding the
  201. 10:00the pain that is inside of their
  202. 10:03daughters and only intensified by being
  203. 10:07trapped in this home.
  204. 10:14So, part of what we see, our narrators,
  205. 10:17these
  206. 10:18boys, now men, what they're doing is
  207. 10:22correcting the record on what happened
  208. 10:26and why, or at least attempting to.
  209. 10:28Because there is kind of a
  210. 10:30sanitized, accepted narrative of what
  211. 10:34happened in this community. And it
  212. 10:37becomes a kind of
  213. 10:40story that feels different from the
  214. 10:42reality. And the existence of this story
  215. 10:47and the way people just kind of accept
  216. 10:49it and move on,
  217. 10:51exposes an ugliness in American
  218. 10:55suburbia, a
  219. 10:58desire to kind of
  220. 11:00gloss over anything dark or sad or
  221. 11:04difficult. We see
  222. 11:07the adults in this world trying to tie
  223. 11:10this up in a bow and forget about it.
  224. 11:12You know, we see, um,
  225. 11:14these like media vultures kind of
  226. 11:16descending on this story, which is
  227. 11:20disturbing and exploitative for obvious
  228. 11:23reasons. But, it's more disturbing how
  229. 11:26the narrative of it infects people in
  230. 11:30this community, like people who lived it
  231. 11:33or actually knew the girls, how
  232. 11:36their perspective is warped by this kind
  233. 11:40of need to have an answer. Even our
  234. 11:42parents seem to agree more and more with
  235. 11:45the television version of things.
  236. 11:48Listening to the reporters and the
  237. 11:49entities as though they could tell us
  238. 11:51the truth about our own lives. They need
  239. 11:55this
  240. 11:56sanitation, this explanation, because
  241. 12:00that's the way they can say,
  242. 12:03"Well, it will never happen to me,
  243. 12:05because this was their specific
  244. 12:07situation. My teenager doesn't um harbor
  245. 12:11something awful. The teenager in my life
  246. 12:15doesn't have a secret inner self that I
  247. 12:18don't know." It's also all kind of in
  248. 12:20the service of maintaining norms, um
  249. 12:25which feels very
  250. 12:27American suburbia. The idea of teenage
  251. 12:31suicide kind of becomes a
  252. 12:33a campaign of something that they're
  253. 12:36they're fighting against just so they
  254. 12:38can kind of feel like they're doing
  255. 12:39something. There's an interesting note
  256. 12:41that before that was their focus,
  257. 12:45the powers that be in this community
  258. 12:48were really focused on maintaining the
  259. 12:52whiteness of their neighborhood and the
  260. 12:55segregation of
  261. 12:58the suburbs in like
  262. 13:00subtle and insidious ways. Putting these
  263. 13:05kind of community actions in the same
  264. 13:09category and in the same understanding
  265. 13:12of like the focus of what their town is
  266. 13:14doing, it shows how
  267. 13:16empty the the town's campaign for
  268. 13:20wellness is. You know, the total lack of
  269. 13:25honest exploration of what's going on,
  270. 13:28um the kind of petty shallowness of it,
  271. 13:33this need for control, like just adults
  272. 13:37trying to control their kids so they
  273. 13:39don't have to worry about this. Two
  274. 13:41sides of the same coin here. And they do
  275. 13:45all these
  276. 13:46things to address this crisis in their
  277. 13:49community and the school. The Lisbon
  278. 13:52girls, stranded in separate homerooms,
  279. 13:55declined to play or kept asking to be
  280. 13:57excused to go to the bathroom.
  281. 14:00None of the teachers insisted on their
  282. 14:02participating,
  283. 14:04with the result that all the healing was
  284. 14:06done by those of us without wounds. Day
  285. 14:09of grieving that they plan is
  286. 14:13a farce. It doesn't do anything to help
  287. 14:17these girls who actually really need
  288. 14:20help. It just kind of pads the egos of
  289. 14:24those in the community who want to just
  290. 14:26feel like they did something. So, yeah,
  291. 14:29the the kind of comfortable narrative
  292. 14:31that they
  293. 14:33land on in this community is that
  294. 14:37the whole thing comes down to Cecilia.
  295. 14:40So, there's this idea that it was a
  296. 14:45lemmings scenario that Cecilia did this
  297. 14:50and the other sisters followed suit. And
  298. 14:54there was something wrong with Cecilia.
  299. 14:56This theory convinced many people
  300. 14:59because it simplified things.
  301. 15:01Already Cecilia's suicide had assumed in
  302. 15:04retrospect the stature of a long
  303. 15:07prophesied event. Nobody thought it
  304. 15:09shocking anymore, and accepting it as
  305. 15:11first cause removed any need for further
  306. 15:14explanation.
  307. 15:16As Mr. Hutch put it, they made Cecilia
  308. 15:19out to be the bad guy.
  309. 15:21Her suicide from this perspective was
  310. 15:24seen as a kind of disease infecting
  311. 15:26those close at hand. So, Cecilia is
  312. 15:30patient zero in a disease that dies with
  313. 15:35the last of the Lisbon girls. And this
  314. 15:37is a story that they can
  315. 15:39accept, that collapses all of these
  316. 15:43girls into one person, basically. And it
  317. 15:48removes any possibility of
  318. 15:52this affecting their own children. There
  319. 15:55are no hidden unknowns within them.
  320. 15:59Uh they don't have to examine the kind
  321. 16:01of gender depression that all teenage
  322. 16:04girls go through. It's easier to say
  323. 16:06that Cecilia was
  324. 16:09weird and broken
  325. 16:12and she infected her sisters with her
  326. 16:16problem. That's much easier to accept
  327. 16:19than
  328. 16:20the truth, which is that this could have
  329. 16:23been anyone. This could happen to
  330. 16:24anyone. Suicidal ideation is not limited
  331. 16:28to this family.
  332. 16:34So, I'm going to talk a little more
  333. 16:36connected to like the perspective of
  334. 16:38this novel about
  335. 16:40the fantasy and the kind of othering
  336. 16:43that happens between these boys and the
  337. 16:47mysterious Lisbon girls. But first, I
  338. 16:49kind of want to focus on how
  339. 16:51they represent youth to these narrators.
  340. 16:55At the point where these narrators are
  341. 16:58collecting all of this evidence,
  342. 17:00they are older and they're bored with
  343. 17:03their lives. So, this retracing of the
  344. 17:06past in part [clears throat] is about
  345. 17:10recapturing the intensity of their
  346. 17:13youth. And we see that all over the
  347. 17:16imagery and the descriptive work in this
  348. 17:18book.
  349. 17:19The world of adults is dull and
  350. 17:22lifeless, but when they were young, they
  351. 17:25felt things so strongly and everything
  352. 17:27was vibrant and they were more
  353. 17:31connected. The world has changed. We see
  354. 17:35a lot of comparison about the physical
  355. 17:38environment and what the neighborhood
  356. 17:41looks like. Like,
  357. 17:43there were trees back then and all of
  358. 17:45the trees are gone from the street. The
  359. 17:48very trees the girls had defended in
  360. 17:51their life that made the character of
  361. 17:54the neighborhood is gone. It doesn't
  362. 17:57really snow anymore. People don't know
  363. 18:00their neighbors anymore. The town has
  364. 18:03died. All a reflection of how
  365. 18:06these men feel about what happened to
  366. 18:09their lives. It's not just the suburbs
  367. 18:11that have changed. These boys have
  368. 18:14become men and they're obsessed with the
  369. 18:18girls who never became women. So, I'm
  370. 18:21going to read a couple examples of how
  371. 18:24um the iconic Trip Fontaine
  372. 18:28describes his first love with Lux.
  373. 18:31"Every second is eternal," Trip told us,
  374. 18:35describing how as he sat in his desk,
  375. 18:38the girl in front of him, for no
  376. 18:40apparent reason, had turned around and
  377. 18:42looked at him. He couldn't say she was
  378. 18:45beautiful because all he could see were
  379. 18:46her eyes.
  380. 18:48The rest of her face, the pulpy lips,
  381. 18:51the blonde sideburn fuzz, the nose with
  382. 18:54its candy pink translucent nostrils,
  383. 18:57registered dimly as the two blue eyes
  384. 19:00lifted him on a sea wave and held him
  385. 19:02suspended.
  386. 19:04She was the still point of the turning
  387. 19:06world. He sat next to her in the last
  388. 19:09row, and though he avoided looking at
  389. 19:11her, it was no use.
  390. 19:13With organs of sense he hadn't realized
  391. 19:15he possessed, Trip Fontaine felt Lux
  392. 19:18beside him,
  393. 19:19registered her body temperature,
  394. 19:21heartbeat, respiration rate,
  395. 19:24all the pumping and flow of her body.
  396. 19:26And there's a description of this scene
  397. 19:29following that second quote of
  398. 19:32him slowly and slowly getting closer to
  399. 19:36touching her, to being in contact with
  400. 19:38her for the first time. And just like
  401. 19:40the intensity of that. Really loved
  402. 19:43these moments um that describe the
  403. 19:47the kind of electrified, glowy feeling
  404. 19:50of
  405. 19:51a first love. It's really beautifully
  406. 19:54handled, and I think probably
  407. 19:56familiar. We all remember what it was
  408. 19:58like to be a teenager and take those
  409. 20:02first steps. Trip, whose
  410. 20:05life has turned out kind of sad and
  411. 20:07disappointing,
  412. 20:09he still puts a lot of importance on
  413. 20:13this brief relationship that he had with
  414. 20:16Lux. Not because the relationship was so
  415. 20:20deep where they had some kind of
  416. 20:21soulmate connection. I mean, he didn't
  417. 20:25really know or understand her very well.
  418. 20:29Um but it's important to him because
  419. 20:33it was a love that happened in the
  420. 20:38intensity of his youth. That that kind
  421. 20:41of single-minded obsession with her
  422. 20:44feels good, and when he remembers it, he
  423. 20:48feels young and passionate again. And
  424. 20:53because
  425. 20:54this is his only relationship that never
  426. 20:57had to face the realities of the world.
  427. 21:00And it's the same for narrators,
  428. 21:04they can feel
  429. 21:06their depth of feeling kind of fading
  430. 21:09with age
  431. 21:11and [snorts] they're
  432. 21:12clinging to
  433. 21:14how intensely they felt about those
  434. 21:16girls when they were young. And part of
  435. 21:19the reason why the girls maintain their
  436. 21:22mystery is because
  437. 21:25they never faced adulthood and the
  438. 21:29natural changes that come with that.
  439. 21:31They are frozen in the magic of
  440. 21:35childhood.
  441. 21:36Um they never lost that intensity. They
  442. 21:41describe their adulthood as the
  443. 21:43melancholic remainder of our lives. A
  444. 21:47place the Lisbon girls wisely it began
  445. 21:50to seem never cared to see. That moment
  446. 21:53they're nearly
  447. 21:56jealous of the fact that their lives
  448. 21:59ended cuz in their minds they have
  449. 22:02accepted a broken, flawed world that the
  450. 22:07girls rejected.
  451. 22:13But this
  452. 22:15thesis that the girls were somehow
  453. 22:18omniscient and knew that the future was
  454. 22:21going to be so grim and therefore opted
  455. 22:25out of it
  456. 22:26um kind of like everything that the boys
  457. 22:30decide, every conclusion that they come
  458. 22:32to
  459. 22:33is flawed because it's not really
  460. 22:36understanding the girls. Everything that
  461. 22:39they
  462. 22:40think about, every piece of evidence
  463. 22:42they find
  464. 22:43centers them and their experience of the
  465. 22:48girls. The conception that boys and men
  466. 22:52have of them
  467. 22:53is the perspective they cannot get away
  468. 22:56from.
  469. 22:57Not who the girls actually are. And we
  470. 23:00see this
  471. 23:02all over this novel that the the
  472. 23:04fantasy, the idea of the Lisbon girls is
  473. 23:09clashing with reality. And even as they
  474. 23:13see the evidence and they understand
  475. 23:16that that's clouding their ability to
  476. 23:20see what actually happened. They've
  477. 23:22othered the girls so much that it's
  478. 23:27impossible for them to see. And you
  479. 23:30know, that's the same way that
  480. 23:32men and boys other all women and girls
  481. 23:39as
  482. 23:40incomprehensible,
  483. 23:42fantasy, mythical beings.
  484. 23:45A way of thinking that makes it
  485. 23:48impossible for them to understand their
  486. 23:51humanity. We see their first discovery
  487. 23:55that is in contrast to their idea of
  488. 23:58them is that these five girls are
  489. 24:01actually individuals. They're not just a
  490. 24:05magical mass of blondes. Um, they have
  491. 24:09their own interests and passions and
  492. 24:11personalities. They've got opinions and
  493. 24:14dreams just like anybody else. You know,
  494. 24:17that realization comes at
  495. 24:20this ill-fated party for Cecilia. And
  496. 24:23they come again in the simple and
  497. 24:27obvious way
  498. 24:29every time they actually talk to the
  499. 24:31girls and spend any time with them.
  500. 24:35Though those authentic moments of
  501. 24:37actually
  502. 24:39knowing the girls are very limited and
  503. 24:44small pieces of
  504. 24:46this
  505. 24:47world that they have built around them.
  506. 24:51The reality squashes the fantasy of the
  507. 24:54girls bit by bit. Like this interesting
  508. 24:58realization on the homecoming night,
  509. 25:02something like this revelation came over
  510. 25:04the boys.
  511. 25:06"They weren't all that different from my
  512. 25:08sister." Kevin Head said. So their
  513. 25:11romantic fantasies are not true and also
  514. 25:15the invention of them as kind of broken
  515. 25:19or mad from what has happened to them is
  516. 25:22also not true.
  517. 25:24They are teenage girls like other
  518. 25:26teenage girls, which if they think about
  519. 25:29that too hard is kind of a scary
  520. 25:32realization that they are very much like
  521. 25:36all the other girls they know. So I
  522. 25:38think what we are seeing here is if they
  523. 25:41had had more time with the Lisbon girls,
  524. 25:44more actual experiences interacting with
  525. 25:47them,
  526. 25:48the fantasy would have continued to die
  527. 25:52bit by bit and be supplanted by reality,
  528. 25:55but there wasn't more time. The sisters
  529. 25:59were
  530. 26:00frozen [snorts]
  531. 26:02in this time and place where they were
  532. 26:07mysterious. The fantasy of what they are
  533. 26:10is never
  534. 26:11tempered by age or wisdom. They are
  535. 26:16forever mythic, forever the dream girls.
  536. 26:19And with this view of them, I think
  537. 26:22these men take a strange kind of
  538. 26:25ownership over them. They have
  539. 26:29all of these things that belonged to the
  540. 26:32girls, really intimate things like
  541. 26:35Cecilia's diary, for example. You
  542. 26:38reading it, it just struck me as so
  543. 26:42invasive. Like what right do they have
  544. 26:45to own Cecilia's private thoughts or
  545. 26:50anything intimate from these girls that
  546. 26:52they don't know. And this is an area
  547. 26:55where I think they are not self-aware
  548. 26:58that part of what they're doing is
  549. 27:01fueled by this desire to capture and
  550. 27:04hold and own the girls. This entitlement
  551. 27:08they feel towards them because they have
  552. 27:11been in love and obsessed with them for
  553. 27:15the longest.
  554. 27:21So, I think we have a bit of a
  555. 27:25which came first, chicken or the egg
  556. 27:28situation here.
  557. 27:30The girls are unknowable to them because
  558. 27:34they see them through this lens of
  559. 27:36fantasy,
  560. 27:37but the fantasy and the mystery is
  561. 27:40possible because of everything they
  562. 27:42don't know. A cycle they're trapped in
  563. 27:45forever because so much is left unknown
  564. 27:48by their deaths. Iconic bit of dialogue
  565. 27:52that was also in the movie is probably
  566. 27:55the thing that people know most about
  567. 27:58this book. It's that when the doctor
  568. 28:00kind of has this unserious tone with
  569. 28:03Cecilia, like, "You're so young. You
  570. 28:05don't even know what life is. Why would
  571. 28:08you have done this?" And Cecilia says,
  572. 28:12"Obviously, doctor, you've never been a
  573. 28:1413-year-old girl." The experience of the
  574. 28:17Lisbon girls and all girls who go
  575. 28:21through adolescence
  576. 28:23is inherently unknowable to our
  577. 28:27narrators. They're
  578. 28:29incapable of understanding it, no matter
  579. 28:32how hard they try.
  580. 28:34They can't see the forest through the
  581. 28:35trees. My edition of this book has an
  582. 28:39introduction by Emma Cline,
  583. 28:41and she points out how this idea is
  584. 28:46literalized by the boys using their
  585. 28:49telescope to look through the windows
  586. 28:52and that
  587. 28:53they can use their telescope to look at
  588. 28:56the stars in the heavens and see things
  589. 28:58so clearly.
  590. 29:00But when they point it into the girls'
  591. 29:01rooms, it's so close-up that it doesn't
  592. 29:05make any sense. They can't figure out
  593. 29:06what they're looking at. They're
  594. 29:08drowning in details and artifacts, but
  595. 29:12they can't piece together the big
  596. 29:14picture. Cecilia's diary maybe gets them
  597. 29:17the closest. We felt the imprisonment of
  598. 29:20being a girl, the way it made your mind
  599. 29:22active and dreamy, and how you ended up
  600. 29:25knowing which colors went together. But
  601. 29:28it doesn't get them close enough to
  602. 29:31answer their question, which is why
  603. 29:35couldn't we save them? Why couldn't we
  604. 29:37fulfill this fantasy they had to save
  605. 29:40them? And I think
  606. 29:42the girls are aware that they have this
  607. 29:45fantasy based on the ending. They
  608. 29:48bring them there. They make them
  609. 29:51witnesses to their ends to show them
  610. 29:56that
  611. 29:57they don't know them. They They can't be
  612. 29:59saved by them because they don't know
  613. 30:01them. The white knight fantasy that
  614. 30:05brings them to the house on that night
  615. 30:08is entirely built in their own heads. I
  616. 30:11want to point out
  617. 30:13um
  618. 30:14something that I wonder if I would have
  619. 30:16even noticed if I had read this when I
  620. 30:20was younger.
  621. 30:21Um
  622. 30:22I spent some time in this book imagining
  623. 30:25what it would have felt like to read
  624. 30:26this when I was a teenager, but I think
  625. 30:29I saw in this book something that felt
  626. 30:32really deeply important about the girls.
  627. 30:34Just that
  628. 30:36there was something that
  629. 30:38could have saved them. And if anybody
  630. 30:41had been paying attention, they might
  631. 30:44have been able to prevent this from
  632. 30:46happening. But it's something that our
  633. 30:48narrators
  634. 30:50still haven't learned fully because
  635. 30:52they're still kind of indulging their
  636. 30:55fantasies. I think the tragic thing that
  637. 30:59they don't see, that their parents don't
  638. 31:02see, that the people in this community
  639. 31:04don't see is
  640. 31:07what the girls are craving, what they
  641. 31:10need.
  642. 31:11Simple human connection. All they want
  643. 31:15is to
  644. 31:16experience the world and experience
  645. 31:19people and just
  646. 31:21live in a world where there is
  647. 31:23possibility
  648. 31:25and agency
  649. 31:27and opportunities to meet their social
  650. 31:31needs. The The simplicity of that is
  651. 31:34really
  652. 31:35heartbreaking that it's just this simple
  653. 31:38human thing um that nobody could give
  654. 31:42them. So, the whole homecoming night is
  655. 31:45so important or very revealing part of
  656. 31:49this book and a real turning point where
  657. 31:52things go south for the girls. You know,
  658. 31:55they managed to get these dates and
  659. 31:59their parents allow them to go. One of
  660. 32:01the dates asks Mary,
  661. 32:04"Are you having a good time?"
  662. 32:06"I'm having the best time of my life,"
  663. 32:08she said.
  664. 32:10She was telling the truth. Never before
  665. 32:12had the Lisbon girls looked so cheerful,
  666. 32:15mixed so much, or talked so freely. With
  667. 32:18just this tiny little bit of freedom and
  668. 32:22opportunity to
  669. 32:23connect with their peers and have some
  670. 32:26fun, this is literally the best night of
  671. 32:30their lives. And it shows how isolated
  672. 32:34their lives have been otherwise. And we
  673. 32:36see
  674. 32:38so many times in this book, they are
  675. 32:43reaching out. They want to be
  676. 32:46understood, but nobody's listening. And
  677. 32:49I think that's kind of the essential
  678. 32:51tragedy here is that
  679. 32:54no one actually sees them or listens to
  680. 32:58them. They only see the reflection of
  681. 33:01themselves or the ideas they've put upon
  682. 33:05them. And if they had just
  683. 33:07accepted those moments when the girls
  684. 33:10tried to connect, maybe this wouldn't
  685. 33:12have happened. Everyone is
  686. 33:16culpable. We're coming to the end here.
  687. 33:18I want to
  688. 33:20just look at what the girls say when
  689. 33:23they're trying to save the tree in their
  690. 33:26yard. So, the the town is cutting down
  691. 33:29these trees because they're infected
  692. 33:31with these beetles. Trees says,
  693. 33:35"These trees are ancient. They have
  694. 33:37evolutionary strategies to deal with
  695. 33:39beetles.
  696. 33:41Why don't you just leave it up to
  697. 33:42nature?"
  698. 33:44"If we left it up up to nature, there'd
  699. 33:46be no trees left."
  700. 33:49"That's what it's going to be like
  701. 33:50anyway," said Lux. And now, reading that
  702. 33:53part, I
  703. 33:55wondered if
  704. 33:57the way they see the trees and that
  705. 34:01the trees could heal themselves, if
  706. 34:04that's
  707. 34:06true of the girls as well. But if they
  708. 34:08had been
  709. 34:10left alone and kind of allowed to be
  710. 34:13their natural selves and continue in the
  711. 34:16world as they had been,
  712. 34:18if they would have healed from the loss
  713. 34:21of Cecilia. You know, what
  714. 34:23would have become of them if their
  715. 34:25parents hadn't intervened so harshly.
  716. 34:29And I I think there was evidence that
  717. 34:32that might have happened, that they
  718. 34:34might have been okay if they had just
  719. 34:37been allowed to be girls and seek out
  720. 34:41the things that they are interested in
  721. 34:44and interact with their peers. This book
  722. 34:47definitely leaves you with a lot to
  723. 34:49think about there. Yeah, I mean, I'm
  724. 34:52always partial to stories that are
  725. 34:56serious about the hearts and minds of
  726. 34:59girls. This is definitely a big part of
  727. 35:02that canon. While I could talk for a
  728. 35:05long time about this book, I'm sure
  729. 35:07there's a lot of things I didn't include
  730. 35:09in this video, so please share your
  731. 35:11thoughts and thanks for watching. I'll
  732. 35:13see you next time.
  733. 35:15Bye.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of The Virgin Suicides by Jeffrey Eugenides Discussion by Caroline Sutphin, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,372 words across 733 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.