YouTube2Text

The Three Deep Desires That Drive Philanthropy, a 3-part video series with Jim Langley. Part 1 — Transcript

by Susan Axelrod · 4,892 words · 759 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:02How can charitable organizations build a
  2. 0:04sustained culture of philanthropy?
  3. 0:07Jim Langley, president of Langley
  4. 0:10Innovations, says, "Speak with your
  5. 0:12donors and listen to what they have to
  6. 0:15share."
  7. 0:16In this video series, Jim shares decades
  8. 0:18of expertise and his commitment to
  9. 0:21helping institutions develop the most
  10. 0:23effective strategies to build broader
  11. 0:26and more lasting communities of support.
  12. 0:29If you're a fundraiser, tune in now.
  13. 0:32Every video with Jim is a master class.
  14. 0:38Hello and welcome.
  15. 0:41I'm Susan Axelrod.
  16. 0:43If you raise money for an institution
  17. 0:46that does good work, this video series
  18. 0:49is for you.
  19. 0:51If you watch all three, you will have a
  20. 0:54transformed understanding that will turn
  21. 0:57fundraising from a chore into an
  22. 0:59opportunity you look forward to.
  23. 1:02Is that possible? Tune in. You'll find
  24. 1:05out that it is.
  25. 1:07As a fundraiser, consultant, coach, and
  26. 1:09trainer myself of 40 years now, a
  27. 1:13program titled The Three Deep Desires
  28. 1:16That Drive Philanthropy, I was sold. I
  29. 1:19can't wait to get into this conversation
  30. 1:21so that you can begin your
  31. 1:23transformation to support the very
  32. 1:25fabric of humanity and society.
  33. 1:29How?
  34. 1:30By learning from one of the best in the
  35. 1:32business today. My guest is Jim Langley,
  36. 1:35president of Langley Innovations, a
  37. 1:37philanthropic consultancy, coaching, and
  38. 1:40training firm that helps clients
  39. 1:42understand the cultural underpinnings of
  40. 1:45philanthropy and the psychology of
  41. 1:47donors and with that knowledge to
  42. 1:50develop the most effective strategies
  43. 1:52and tactics to build broader and more
  44. 1:55lasting communities of vital support for
  45. 1:59your
  46. 2:00mission.
  47. 2:01Jim's team has engaged in extensive
  48. 2:04behavioral research that reveals
  49. 2:06remarkable insight into who gives most
  50. 2:09loyally and generously, why they give,
  51. 2:13and which practices serves as a barrier
  52. 2:16or gateway to greater giving. Not by
  53. 2:19crunching analytics, but by face-to-face
  54. 2:22and telephone interviews with thousands
  55. 2:24of donors across the country.
  56. 2:27Jim believes in deep and extensive
  57. 2:30listening.
  58. 2:31I guess that's why I call him Pastor
  59. 2:34Jim.
  60. 2:36Hello, Jim. Hello, Susan. So good to be
  61. 2:39with you. Thank you for your all your
  62. 2:40kind words.
  63. 2:41It's absolutely my pleasure pleasure and
  64. 2:44of course you know me. I mean everyone.
  65. 2:48I've learned so much from following you
  66. 2:50on LinkedIn, reading your words, and I'm
  67. 2:52delighted to bring this three-part video
  68. 2:55series to light today.
  69. 2:58So, let's get started now. Before we get
  70. 3:02into what the three deep desires that
  71. 3:05drive philanthropy are. I love the
  72. 3:07title. I want to start with a framework
  73. 3:11from your lens and experience. You've
  74. 3:15worked with some of the top institutions
  75. 3:17in North America, certainly. And I want
  76. 3:19to ask you, when you look at the
  77. 3:22industry today, what's the core problem
  78. 3:25you keep seeing? And I want to remind
  79. 3:27you, Jim, when I look down, it's cuz
  80. 3:30I'll be taking notes. Of course. So,
  81. 3:32what's the core problem that you see?
  82. 3:36I think the core problem, Susan, is that
  83. 3:38we're misdiagnosing
  84. 3:40our struggles. We know we're struggling.
  85. 3:42We know certain things that were once
  86. 3:45easier to do are more difficult to do.
  87. 3:48And let me make one share one that is
  88. 3:51very basic. When Luis Diaz and I did a
  89. 3:53state of the development survey
  90. 3:57and listened to thousands of people out
  91. 3:59there, most of them felt that their
  92. 4:01research was good, that their mission
  93. 4:03was good, that their support materials
  94. 4:05were good, right? There were There were
  95. 4:06gradations, but they were largely
  96. 4:08confident in their organizations and in
  97. 4:10themselves. But when we asked, "What's
  98. 4:12the single greatest barrier
  99. 4:14to your greater fundraising success?"
  100. 4:17They said, "Getting the first
  101. 4:19appointment." So, isn't it interesting
  102. 4:22that we can talk about all these things,
  103. 4:24AI, all this elaborate research, and the
  104. 4:28average fundraiser is finding it more
  105. 4:30difficult to get the first appointment.
  106. 4:33And it's true. It is more difficult to
  107. 4:35get the first appointment because donors
  108. 4:38are more circumspect, more careful.
  109. 4:40They're screening. They're more acting
  110. 4:42more like foundations. And I would
  111. 4:44submit to you, Susan, that the core
  112. 4:47proposition we should be faced on it
  113. 4:49facing is what are donors really looking
  114. 4:52for as they look across the waterfront
  115. 4:55of giving opportunities, as they ask
  116. 4:58themselves, "Which of these giving
  117. 5:00opportunities correspond with my
  118. 5:01values?" What is it that they're looking
  119. 5:04for? I think if we can get to the heart
  120. 5:07of that and satisfy that, then we start
  121. 5:11to build stronger communities of shared
  122. 5:13purpose. And that is where the focus
  123. 5:16should be. Not on building pipeline, not
  124. 5:19on the mechanics of fundraising, but on
  125. 5:24building stronger communities of shared
  126. 5:26purpose from which giving and
  127. 5:28philanthropy will more naturally flow.
  128. 5:32And the reason we say that with such
  129. 5:33confidence and such conviction is not
  130. 5:36only the research that you've mentioned
  131. 5:38and all the experience behind it,
  132. 5:40but this is where we know philanthropy
  133. 5:43began. We study the history of the
  134. 5:45United States and many other cultures.
  135. 5:47Where does philanthropy begin? When
  136. 5:50neighbor comes alongside neighbor and
  137. 5:53says, "Don't we need to do something
  138. 5:55about better roads, better schools,
  139. 5:57better
  140. 5:59something for our children, something
  141. 6:01better for the elderly?" When neighbor
  142. 6:04came together with neighbor and said,
  143. 6:06"Yes, let's work on this together."
  144. 6:09American philanthropy and philanthropy
  145. 6:10in many parts of the world in an
  146. 6:12organized way was born. And it was those
  147. 6:15powerful shared purposes that made it
  148. 6:18what it is. So, what we should be
  149. 6:21talking about, and I'm so looking
  150. 6:23forward to talking to you about it, is
  151. 6:25well, what happened to cause us to feel
  152. 6:29maybe it wasn't our neighbor who was
  153. 6:32coming alongside us. And maybe what this
  154. 6:34person was asking for wasn't really the
  155. 6:37world that we saw or the world that we
  156. 6:39wanted and wasn't corresponding to our
  157. 6:41hopes and needs. It sounded a little bit
  158. 6:44different. So, what we want to do is get
  159. 6:47back to what I'll call more neighborly
  160. 6:49approach to philanthropy and finding a
  161. 6:52way to tap into donors' deepest desires.
  162. 6:56And then from there, more systematically
  163. 6:59build communities.
  164. 7:02Well, I've done this with you several
  165. 7:04times, Jim, and I already know that our
  166. 7:07next conversation is going to be called
  167. 7:10The Neighborly Approach.
  168. 7:13Yeah, we're going to We're going to be
  169. 7:14talking about that, and that's actually
  170. 7:16how we came to this conversation from a
  171. 7:18generalized conversation interview we
  172. 7:21did recently. And I heard then about
  173. 7:24this teaching construct. So,
  174. 7:27the neighborly approach, gosh, I felt
  175. 7:30those words honestly, Jim. I felt those
  176. 7:32words as you said like neighbor coming
  177. 7:35to neighbor and saying basically, you
  178. 7:38know, "What do you need?" Yes. And in
  179. 7:42the nonprofit or institutional
  180. 7:46setting or structure that has been
  181. 7:48created,
  182. 7:50those words, "What do you need?" are the
  183. 7:53basis of this construct that we're going
  184. 7:55to be talking about and you'll be
  185. 7:57teaching today. Yes. And also, it's part
  186. 8:00of what builds what we call loyalty,
  187. 8:04Yes. longer-term giving because an
  188. 8:07organization would be having these
  189. 8:09conversations with people who have shown
  190. 8:12support, maybe lower-level support over
  191. 8:15a long time. But I know that you talk
  192. 8:18about long-term loyal giving is the
  193. 8:21basis of this. Yes. Yes, and I think we
  194. 8:25have this shared experience that in our
  195. 8:27career, we tried different things when
  196. 8:29we were young. But ultimately, we
  197. 8:32learned to think about what resonated
  198. 8:35first, to first think about that before
  199. 8:37we approached the donor. Or if we didn't
  200. 8:38know, to spend time with the donor to
  201. 8:40suss out what their values and concerns
  202. 8:43were. So, Susan and I eventually evolved
  203. 8:46as a fundraiser. I wasn't coming with a
  204. 8:48pitch, but with a structured listening
  205. 8:51and after listening saying, "Ah,
  206. 8:53if that's what's important to you, did
  207. 8:55you know?" And you see the difference
  208. 8:57between the pitch coming in sort of
  209. 9:00blind with a fervent pitch that may or
  210. 9:02may not land versus a listening
  211. 9:05exercise, hearing what the person thinks
  212. 9:07is important, then bringing back to
  213. 9:10them,
  214. 9:11"Ah, this I think corresponds with what
  215. 9:13you think is important." And every
  216. 9:15organization can do this. It's simply a
  217. 9:18matter of knowing which values you're
  218. 9:21tapping into and how your institutional
  219. 9:24capabilities or aspirations map against
  220. 9:26those. So, it's eminently possible, and
  221. 9:29yet I think for too long we've succumbed
  222. 9:32to this sort of Madison Avenue approach,
  223. 9:34the elevator pitch, the glossy brochure,
  224. 9:37the gala, all those things. They're fun.
  225. 9:39I understand how we went through that
  226. 9:41phase. But what we're seeing is this
  227. 9:44disoriented or disengaged donor or this
  228. 9:48very significant group of donors, many
  229. 9:51of whom have formed DAFs, which show
  230. 9:53charitable intent, but are then quietly
  231. 9:56behind the scenes going, "But where is
  232. 9:59the place where I can find meaningful
  233. 10:02philanthropy, where I can be something
  234. 10:05more than a donor, and feel as if I've
  235. 10:08made a lasting difference?"
  236. 10:10Well, this is one of those times when I
  237. 10:12call the listeners in and say, "Hope
  238. 10:14you're paying attention. Play back 30
  239. 10:17seconds to listen to what Jim just
  240. 10:19said." Because I call that money bags on
  241. 10:21the shelf. Certainly the donor-advised
  242. 10:23funds, that's one of the places it is.
  243. 10:25You just said to us, "People have
  244. 10:27created them." And we know that to the
  245. 10:30tune of hundreds of billions. And uh our
  246. 10:33job is to ask uh
  247. 10:35them, "What is their intention? What is
  248. 10:37their interest? How can we listen to
  249. 10:40them?" And I wanted to say that um you
  250. 10:43just did an if-then statement. You said,
  251. 10:47"Structured listening." Then you said,
  252. 10:50"Ah, if that's what's important to you,
  253. 10:54then did you know?" I love that. That's
  254. 10:58also giving us a clue to what um the
  255. 11:02survey instrument is that we're going to
  256. 11:04talk about later that you devised, but
  257. 11:06we're not going to get there yet. And um
  258. 11:10so, this is such an important
  259. 11:12conversation. You talked about the
  260. 11:14glossy collaterals, the galas, and all
  261. 11:17of that. But also what we got into
  262. 11:20starting in the basically
  263. 11:23late '90s into the 2000s really was the
  264. 11:26metrics and analytics. Yes. And being
  265. 11:30guided more by that than what you're
  266. 11:33talking about here in this entire
  267. 11:36construct of um the framework, what are
  268. 11:40the
  269. 11:41not how many times did you touch me as a
  270. 11:44donor,
  271. 11:45not how many times did I actually hear
  272. 11:47from you,
  273. 11:49which you know, the metric-based data
  274. 11:52that we fundraisers get judged on. But
  275. 11:55um how did I feel from my engagement
  276. 12:00with you? And so, I want to invite you
  277. 12:03to now uh begin to lay out this
  278. 12:07three-part framework that you have
  279. 12:10created, I guess, over decades of
  280. 12:12experience engaging with donors, and
  281. 12:15really is the basis of this three-part
  282. 12:17video series. Good. So,
  283. 12:21as you know, Susan, over a long career,
  284. 12:24you start to gather and analyze a lot of
  285. 12:27information. And if you hope to share
  286. 12:29it, and hope to be helpful to others,
  287. 12:31you can't go on and on and on. So, you
  288. 12:33try to kind of synthesize and
  289. 12:34crystallize what you've learned. So, as
  290. 12:37I synthesized an enormous amount of
  291. 12:39data, and as you said, lots of
  292. 12:41interpersonal interviews that I
  293. 12:43conducted, that my team conducted, that
  294. 12:45we helped other organizations conduct,
  295. 12:47you I started to see patterns emerge.
  296. 12:51And while there had been studies done
  297. 12:53about what donors wanted, many of them
  298. 12:55were at the tactical level. So, I
  299. 12:58started to say, "But at a deeper level,
  300. 13:01what's a yearning that donors have when
  301. 13:04they consider giving and continuing
  302. 13:06giving to organizations? What are the
  303. 13:08deeper yearnings?" And out of all that
  304. 13:10data, as I thought about it, I started
  305. 13:13to land on three powerful donor desires.
  306. 13:17And I believe they'll stand up to
  307. 13:19scrutiny. And one of the ways that
  308. 13:20they'll stand up to scrutiny, to those
  309. 13:22listening, is as I detail these for you
  310. 13:26and where they come from, with Susan's
  311. 13:27help, ask yourself, whether you're a
  312. 13:31leader of a nonprofit or a fundraiser,
  313. 13:34"Is this not why I got into the
  314. 13:36business, too? Is this not what I want
  315. 13:39for myself?"
  316. 13:41And I think when that realization comes
  317. 13:43to you, you'll realize what a workable
  318. 13:45construct this is. So, the three deep
  319. 13:48donor desires are quite simple. To
  320. 13:51believe, to believe in an organization,
  321. 13:53to believe in its purpose, to believe in
  322. 13:55something that's bigger than ourselves,
  323. 13:58more lasting than our lifetime. To
  324. 14:01believe, to have faith, is incredibly
  325. 14:04important to human beings.
  326. 14:07To belong, to be among kindred spirits,
  327. 14:09to be working toward common goals, as we
  328. 14:12once did in quilting bees, in raising
  329. 14:15barns, in in harvesting livestock, in
  330. 14:18bringing in crops. These were all
  331. 14:20communal activities, and it was from
  332. 14:22these communal activities that we found
  333. 14:25success and support and comfort and
  334. 14:28psychological safety and many of the
  335. 14:30things that we talk about today, because
  336. 14:31we were in community. We as human beings
  337. 14:34want to belong, and we particularly want
  338. 14:37to belong with people who share our
  339. 14:39values and purposes, and we find great
  340. 14:41joy in working toward common goals and
  341. 14:44realizing common goals. And then
  342. 14:47finally, to better. Not just to go
  343. 14:50through processes, to study, to to
  344. 14:53analyze, but ultimately to make
  345. 14:56something better. To say, "I did that,
  346. 14:59or we did that. Look at that. That helps
  347. 15:02current children, or future generations,
  348. 15:05or the elderly." To be able to say, "We
  349. 15:09uh were able to combine our talent and
  350. 15:12our forces for the good of others, and
  351. 15:15that we may benefit from someday
  352. 15:17ourselves, or our children, or our
  353. 15:18grandchildren." This is incredibly
  354. 15:21important to us and powerfully
  355. 15:23motivating to know that we've made
  356. 15:25something better. And if I could, Susan,
  357. 15:28I want to add one
  358. 15:29interesting historical wrinkle to that.
  359. 15:32That while I have studied many people, I
  360. 15:34want to respect people of all ages and
  361. 15:36all generations. I think there's wisdom
  362. 15:39at every level. And I want to share with
  363. 15:42your donors that there was a
  364. 15:43particularly prescient, remarkable,
  365. 15:46I think, 21-year-old
  366. 15:48who said this. That we form these
  367. 15:51associations of shared purposes to not
  368. 15:55only improve our community, but to
  369. 15:58improve ourselves.
  370. 16:00So that in making something better, we
  371. 16:03know it makes us better. And we gain
  372. 16:06conviction and confidence and joy. And
  373. 16:09and that prescient 21-year-old was a
  374. 16:12fellow named Benjamin Franklin, who said
  375. 16:15that about 1750.
  376. 16:18So, this thread, this thread runs
  377. 16:21through our culture, a river of purpose,
  378. 16:25of of shared determination, of shared
  379. 16:27hope, runs through. And I think when we
  380. 16:30tap back in to that source, we will
  381. 16:33revitalize philanthropy and revitalize
  382. 16:36the mission that we hope to advance.
  383. 16:40Oh my gosh, I I need to just pause here
  384. 16:42and breathe a second. I was uh thinking,
  385. 16:45"Gosh, there's another thing we have in
  386. 16:47common, and that is listening to
  387. 16:50millennials and Gen Z." And when you
  388. 16:52said a 21-year-old, and then you said
  389. 16:55Ben Franklin, I just loved that. But
  390. 16:58honestly, uh I did get chills a bit uh
  391. 17:02to think about that. And you and I are
  392. 17:05people ourselves.
  393. 17:07Uh we do the work, but we've also been
  394. 17:10involved and engaged in our own passion
  395. 17:13projects, uh putting ourselves to the
  396. 17:16task. And that's why uh we can sit here
  397. 17:20and say, uh in the elder wisdom that
  398. 17:22we're sharing today, that we understand
  399. 17:26how it feels to improve ourselves by
  400. 17:29helping to improve our community. Yes.
  401. 17:34We do. We do, Susan. And it's if you
  402. 17:37could pass on one thing about why to
  403. 17:40engage in philanthropy as a donor, as a
  404. 17:42fundraiser, as a nonprofit, is you will
  405. 17:45be better for it, and you will never
  406. 17:48find greater joy than when you know
  407. 17:51you've made a difference in someone
  408. 17:53else's life.
  409. 17:54I mean, you know Jerry Panas, uh who's
  410. 17:57gone now. Um Jerry was my one of my
  411. 18:00early mentors decades ago. He was
  412. 18:04prolific in his output uh of writing and
  413. 18:07speaking and teaching. And I I took that
  414. 18:10and ran with it myself. So, let's uh get
  415. 18:14into now the first part of the
  416. 18:17construct. This is a three-part video
  417. 18:20series. You laid the groundwork for us.
  418. 18:23I just want to add this beautiful
  419. 18:25graphic again, because since the first
  420. 18:28time that I heard you say this in that
  421. 18:31casual interview we did sometime ago,
  422. 18:35I have found uh it's such a simple, deep
  423. 18:39uh framework that I've already been
  424. 18:42sharing it quite extensively, crediting
  425. 18:44you with clients or other people I've
  426. 18:47been in conversation about. And so, this
  427. 18:51uh graphic is just a beautiful, simple
  428. 18:53depiction. We're going to start today
  429. 18:56with the first um
  430. 18:59concept, the first deep desire that
  431. 19:02people have, which is to believe. And I
  432. 19:06really feel like this is um the
  433. 19:08foundation of all of this. And there's a
  434. 19:11lot to say about it. Uh one of the
  435. 19:15things that happened in that
  436. 19:16conversation was we started talking
  437. 19:19because I heard you interviewed in the
  438. 19:21New York Times about the betrayal
  439. 19:23uh of Jeffrey Epstein and the charitable
  440. 19:26institutions and so on. And so, what
  441. 19:30just briefly, what happens when that
  442. 19:32belief is betrayed?
  443. 19:35Yeah, so that's such an important
  444. 19:37question is it it's puncturing, it's
  445. 19:40wounding to the psyche and to the soul,
  446. 19:43because at the heart of human existence,
  447. 19:46what drives us forward,
  448. 19:48even in the face of adversity, extreme
  449. 19:51adversity, is this powerful phenomenon
  450. 19:53called hope. And without hope, we don't
  451. 19:56have civilization. We don't have
  452. 19:58character. We don't have all the
  453. 20:00attributes of life that we find
  454. 20:02valuable. It took people before us and
  455. 20:05in our generation and generations coming
  456. 20:08to believe in something and in the face
  457. 20:11of injustice or difficulty or the lack
  458. 20:14of fairness or the lack of equity or
  459. 20:16even in the belief that no matter where
  460. 20:19we are, something could be done better
  461. 20:21and for the greater good of more people
  462. 20:24is this powerful social force. So, when
  463. 20:28that gets punctured, when we start to
  464. 20:30believe in someone, when we think
  465. 20:33they're doing good work and we find
  466. 20:35they're acting out of base motives and
  467. 20:38they're being selfish or and that even
  468. 20:41something worse than that, taking
  469. 20:43advantage of vulnerable people, it's
  470. 20:45puncturing because it takes away that
  471. 20:48hope. It makes us wonder about
  472. 20:50ourselves. Why did I believe in that
  473. 20:53person? Why was I fooled? Why didn't I
  474. 20:56see that? Now, good people will always
  475. 20:58recover from that and always rally and
  476. 21:00always come back. But, when when
  477. 21:04terrible misdeeds of Epstein are
  478. 21:06revealed and the the fact that other
  479. 21:09people were involved directly and
  480. 21:11indirectly and many of those people were
  481. 21:14powerful and carried very important
  482. 21:17responsibilities,
  483. 21:18it feels like out of our collective
  484. 21:21hope, a gash has been made.
  485. 21:25Is this leadership? Why were so many
  486. 21:27bright, talented people fooled? Why did
  487. 21:30they fall prey to this? Why did they
  488. 21:32turn a blind eye, right? So, it's that
  489. 21:35that really hurts us and further erodes
  490. 21:38trust in institutions and institutional
  491. 21:41leadership. And
  492. 21:42institutions, in the main, when you look
  493. 21:45at the long arc of public opinion, Yeah.
  494. 21:48can't afford any more gashes in their
  495. 21:51credibility and their trust. This has
  496. 21:53been going down for decades and here
  497. 21:55comes another gash.
  498. 21:58You know, Jim, I want to say about this,
  499. 22:00uh everything, you know, civilization
  500. 22:05uh doesn't go on if we don't have hope.
  501. 22:08Actually, when terrible things happen,
  502. 22:11it gives those of us who are conscious,
  503. 22:13aware, alert, responsible, and organized
  504. 22:17uh opportunity.
  505. 22:19And this first part of the three deep
  506. 22:23desires that donors have to believe in
  507. 22:26something, Yeah. Jim, I feel like it's
  508. 22:29opportunity waiting to happen for any
  509. 22:32nonprofit, any fundraiser working with
  510. 22:35donors uh to take the responsibility
  511. 22:38back. Uh we're seeing very intense cuts,
  512. 22:42federal cuts right now.
  513. 22:44>> seeing nonprofits are stretched and um
  514. 22:48and so we're here having this
  515. 22:50conversation to support the fundraisers,
  516. 22:53the nonprofit workers, the institutions
  517. 22:56themselves, which are, as I say,
  518. 22:58protecting the fabric, the very fabric
  519. 23:01of our communities and society.
  520. 23:04And so, we want them to breathe breathe.
  521. 23:07We want them to know we believe in them.
  522. 23:09And they have an opportunity to connect
  523. 23:12with their donors about this particular
  524. 23:15desire. Is that how you see it? I do and
  525. 23:19you you boy, you raised so many points
  526. 23:21there in in a few sentences, Susan,
  527. 23:24about where we are and where to turn.
  528. 23:26And you touched on something that I
  529. 23:28really want to, with your help, further
  530. 23:30elaborate. That
  531. 23:33this notion of hope is so central to
  532. 23:37leadership itself and to coming out of
  533. 23:40difficult and dark moments. And so, you
  534. 23:42talk about cutbacks in federal support,
  535. 23:44support for research, support for
  536. 23:46universities, support for human
  537. 23:48services, all those things that we care
  538. 23:50about, that we know are critical to
  539. 23:51making a better world. And what I worry
  540. 23:54about, Susan, is while I perfectly
  541. 23:57understand it, is outrage, condemnation.
  542. 24:00This is awful. This can't stand.
  543. 24:02All this decrying is understandable,
  544. 24:07but to to share another powerful
  545. 24:09construct that so ties into the one
  546. 24:11we're talking about, what do real
  547. 24:13leaders do? In six words,
  548. 24:17absorb chaos, project calm, give hope.
  549. 24:22That if we're going to help those causes
  550. 24:25and those purposes, we can't just decry,
  551. 24:28we have to say, "It's a shame what
  552. 24:31happened. It's a terrible shame." But,
  553. 24:34here is a ray of hope. Here is a path
  554. 24:37forward. If we just condemn and decry,
  555. 24:40we may feel good about that. We may feel
  556. 24:42victimized and we may enjoy our shared
  557. 24:45victimization like we enjoy all shared
  558. 24:48feelings. I understand it. I don't mean
  559. 24:50to belittle it, but a leader steps in
  560. 24:52and says, "But, we need a legitimate ray
  561. 24:55of hope to get out
  562. 24:57of this descending cycle." We've just
  563. 25:00lost some important societal attributes.
  564. 25:03We're losing talent in this country.
  565. 25:05It's going outside to other countries.
  566. 25:08People are returning home. They're
  567. 25:09finding more advantageous circumstances
  568. 25:12in other cultures. This is not our
  569. 25:14story. This is not our history. So, if
  570. 25:16we have to rally people, then we've got
  571. 25:19to get into that, again, that projection
  572. 25:21of hope.
  573. 25:23Think about, Susan, all the things, the
  574. 25:25lessons that we've learned in our
  575. 25:27lifetime. Mine is longer than yours, but
  576. 25:29think about what we've learned and think
  577. 25:32about who we admire and it is often
  578. 25:34those people who absorb chaos, project
  579. 25:37calm, and gave hope. Often at great
  580. 25:39personal expense and personal sacrifice,
  581. 25:42but they gave hope and that's what lived
  582. 25:45after them. That's what we were able to
  583. 25:48to latch onto. I think when we sacrifice
  584. 25:51that in the name of condemnation, we
  585. 25:54lose our way and we don't rally enough
  586. 25:56support to secure the resources to
  587. 25:59revive the very things that were so
  588. 26:02upset were taken away from us. So, this
  589. 26:04is the kind of leadership we now need to
  590. 26:06go back
  591. 26:08to where we began and this is what will
  592. 26:11then resonate with donors is the giving
  593. 26:15of legitimate hope, right? Oh, now
  594. 26:19here's someone I can believe in. They're
  595. 26:22telling me the truth. They've got the
  596. 26:24grit to rise from the ashes and the
  597. 26:27difficulty of failure and setback and by
  598. 26:31their
  599. 26:31virtual by their their commitment to
  600. 26:34what they believe in, their courage of
  601. 26:36their convictions, we start to go,
  602. 26:38"Well, maybe I can now believe in this
  603. 26:41person." And the more progress they make
  604. 26:43and the more courage they demonstrate,
  605. 26:46the more we start to believe, "Yes, now
  606. 26:49we've got someone to believe in." Or
  607. 26:52the organization they represent. If we
  608. 26:54can start to see depth in that
  609. 26:56organization, not just one great leader,
  610. 26:58but depth across the organization of
  611. 27:00people who are all committed to that
  612. 27:03mission, whether the janitor or the
  613. 27:05chief executive, if we get exposed to
  614. 27:07that kind of culture, it's
  615. 27:08that's that's who I can believe in
  616. 27:11because it's not just one leader, it's
  617. 27:13not just one mission statement. It's
  618. 27:16it's being lived out in a way there's
  619. 27:18energy to it. There's ongoing purpose to
  620. 27:20it.
  621. 27:21Throughout human history, the greatest
  622. 27:24organizations,
  623. 27:26the ones that we place the most value
  624. 27:28in, the ones that most of us adhere to
  625. 27:31the most for the longest, were the ones
  626. 27:34that legitimized our belief in them
  627. 27:38over and over and over. Wow.
  628. 27:43Jim, we're in such a contained
  629. 27:44environment. I want to stand up and go
  630. 27:46like, "LET'S GO!"
  631. 27:49WE'RE SO contained here in our little
  632. 27:51spaces, but uh in response, I could
  633. 27:54really feel uh what you're saying and I
  634. 27:58want to you know, just like call out uh
  635. 28:02to the leaders today. I know uh you're
  636. 28:06suffering yourselves as the humans you
  637. 28:08are.
  638. 28:09>> Um but, especially the way uh Jim just
  639. 28:12really laid it out, if you go back and
  640. 28:15play the last about 2 minutes, you're
  641. 28:17going to see
  642. 28:19opportunity abounds.
  643. 28:22And uh Jim, this actually um brings us
  644. 28:25uh to the second part of the framework,
  645. 28:28which we're going to talk about in the
  646. 28:29second uh video, the part two of this
  647. 28:32video series, um to belong. Yes.
  648. 28:36And that's what you literally just led
  649. 28:38to. But, before we close here, I wanted
  650. 28:42to invite you to speak about the survey,
  651. 28:45the donor satisfaction survey instrument
  652. 28:49uh that you have that we discussed. What
  653. 28:52it is and how it can be helpful,
  654. 28:54especially in this context.
  655. 28:57>> Well, I thank you for your help in this
  656. 28:59survey, Susan, and it was instrumental
  657. 29:01and I thought incredibly insightful. So,
  658. 29:04we talked about where do we go? What do
  659. 29:06we offer people listening as a concrete
  660. 29:08tool? And that would be to go to your
  661. 29:11service to your donors, to your
  662. 29:14volunteers, to those people who will
  663. 29:16form and strengthen this community of
  664. 29:18shared purpose and check in with them.
  665. 29:21And find out how strongly they believe.
  666. 29:23How strongly do they feel as if they
  667. 29:25belong and people care if they belong?
  668. 29:28And how much are we providing in terms
  669. 29:30of evidence of the bettering that's
  670. 29:32being done or have we gotten caught up
  671. 29:35in the wrong things? So, what you helped
  672. 29:38design, while I sort of provided the
  673. 29:40basic framework, is a very simple
  674. 29:43instrument that gets right to the heart
  675. 29:46of the matter, that donors would be
  676. 29:48complimented if you asked them to fill
  677. 29:50out because it shows caring for them.
  678. 29:53And that when presented with this, it's
  679. 29:55easy to fill out. I think it would be
  680. 29:57enjoyable to fill out because all of a
  681. 29:59sudden this organization is allowing me
  682. 30:01to speak to my values, to what I think
  683. 30:03the relationship is and what could be.
  684. 30:06And so I think you're going to get
  685. 30:07donors complimented. I think you're
  686. 30:08going to get them responding to it and
  687. 30:10feeling grateful for the opportunity.
  688. 30:12And as an organization, you're going to
  689. 30:14create a baseline
  690. 30:16of how many donors believe at what
  691. 30:18level, 1 to 5 or 1 to 10. How strong are
  692. 30:20those beliefs? How strongly do they feel
  693. 30:23as if they belong, 1 to 5, 1 to 10,
  694. 30:25whatever scale you want. And how
  695. 30:27strongly do they feel they're with by
  696. 30:29giving to you and through you, time,
  697. 30:31talent, and treasure, are they making
  698. 30:33something better?
  699. 30:34Then you've got a baseline. And then
  700. 30:37every year you can run a similar survey
  701. 30:39and you can see for yourselves and
  702. 30:40announce to your board, "Look, here's
  703. 30:43where we started, believe, belong,
  704. 30:44better, and we're inching up here. And
  705. 30:47because we've listened to donors and
  706. 30:49better understand these desires, with
  707. 30:52every passing year we're strengthening
  708. 30:55the believe, belong, better paradigm and
  709. 30:58we're getting closer and closer to being
  710. 31:01an ever more healthy community of shared
  711. 31:04purpose. I promise everyone here, and I
  712. 31:07think Susan, you know intuitively, if we
  713. 31:09do those things, albeit albeit
  714. 31:13imperfectly,
  715. 31:14philanthropy will flow more naturally,
  716. 31:17more spontaneously, more joyously.
  717. 31:22I I'm the example of that. I taught my
  718. 31:24own fundraising method to the person I
  719. 31:27co-founded an organization with. And
  720. 31:30guess what happened? She uses it on me
  721. 31:32and I give more. I mean, when you
  722. 31:35when you believe in something, when you
  723. 31:38believe in a mission, and this survey is
  724. 31:40so good because it's in a little bit in
  725. 31:43the feeling space, it's showing your
  726. 31:45donors that you care about them and that
  727. 31:49you're willing to listen to them. And
  728. 31:51so, when you can feel your giving, that
  729. 31:54is the best. And the way you feel your
  730. 31:57giving is to believe in something. So,
  731. 32:00Jim, we're going to bring it to a close
  732. 32:02here and now. How can people find you?
  733. 32:05The best way to find me is at
  734. 32:07[email protected]. That's my
  735. 32:09email. But I also post regularly on
  736. 32:11LinkedIn. And I I'll produce a weekly
  737. 32:14newsletter, which I hope starts
  738. 32:16important conversations. That's how I
  739. 32:18see what we're doing. So, in any of
  740. 32:19those venues, I ask you to not only join
  741. 32:22the conversation, but contribute
  742. 32:24contribute to the conversation so that
  743. 32:26we can all learn from each other and
  744. 32:28create a body of knowledge that will
  745. 32:30help all nonprofits that want to access
  746. 32:33it.
  747. 32:34I mean, honestly, I can't say how much I
  748. 32:37love following following you on
  749. 32:38LinkedIn. You know me, if I don't agree
  750. 32:42with something or part of something,
  751. 32:43I'll say it. And other people you've
  752. 32:46brought to you also do. There's
  753. 32:48conversation. There may be challenge.
  754. 32:50It's okay. We may not agree. And so, I
  755. 32:54really love that this engaged community
  756. 32:58you've created on LinkedIn.
  757. 33:00Wonderful. Thank you, Susan. All right.
  758. 33:03I'll see you next time. Take care.
  759. 33:04>> All right. Thank you.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of The Three Deep Desires That Drive Philanthropy, a 3-part video series with Jim Langley. Part 1 by Susan Axelrod, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,892 words across 759 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.