The Russian Revolution — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:04It's been a century since the Russian Revolution
- 0:08and the formation of the world's first communist state.
- 0:12How did it happen?
- 0:14How could the mighty Romanov dynasty, which lasted for 300 years,
- 0:18fall to a ragtag group of revolutionaries
- 0:21who brought with them Joseph Stalin and a brutal reign of terror?
- 0:26Lenin understood that it wasn't your numbers that mattered.
- 0:29It wasn't your popular support that mattered.
- 0:32You just paralyze the country by occupying the key points,
- 0:35and then you take over.
- 0:38Revolutions don't happen from the dispossessed and the starving.
- 0:41They happen from the middle class, and that's always been true.
- 0:46At the heart of the Russian Revolution lay a very personal battle
- 0:50between Lenin's Ulyanov family and the royal family,
- 0:54who were determined to retain autocratic rule.
- 1:00The Tsar Knight used to say that Russia likes to feel the whip.
- 1:03There was always the feeling the Tsars had the divine right of kings,
- 1:07that they had a God-given obligation to rule themselves and be autocrats,
- 1:12so there wasn't space for democracy.
- 1:15The disaster that happened to Russia is substantially down to mistakes
- 1:20made by Nicholas II.
- 1:23He is utterly useless.
- 1:26He was a man who shouldn't have been a tsar.
- 1:29He wasn't suited to the onerous task of monarch.
- 1:34The errors made by the Tsar would bring an empire to its knees,
- 1:38but no one could have predicted that Vladimir Lenin would be the man
- 1:42to seize control in the chaos.
- 1:47Lenin understood that power is centered in certain knots,
- 1:51that you take over a railway junction,
- 1:53you take over a telephone exchange, and you've already got a city.
- 1:57Lenin was in a tradition of Russian leadership
- 2:00and was a very strong part of it.
- 2:02It had a profound effect on Russia that we are still feeling now.
- 2:061917, in a sense, recasts the ideological map of Europe
- 2:12as the century progresses the ideological map of the world.
- 2:40March 13th, 1881, St. Petersburg.
- 2:44The Tsar Alexander II is on his way to his armies' military roll call.
- 2:49He's traveling in a bulletproof carriage gifted to him by Napoleon III.
- 2:54It had proved necessary,
- 2:56as the Tsar had faced numerous assassination attempts
- 2:59during his reign.
- 3:03Many people wanted to get rid of the Tsar and his government,
- 3:07but the fact that in the middle of the 19th century,
- 3:09you had two inventions, the revolver and high explosive dynamite,
- 3:14both of which were widespread in Russia,
- 3:16enabled amateurish people to get together and organize an assassination.
- 3:23This is a sustained terrorist campaign.
- 3:26There were multiple attempts on the life of the Tsar,
- 3:28attempts to blow up his carriage.
- 3:30One terrorist,
- 3:31over months working as a carpenter in the Winter Palace,
- 3:35managed to plant a body of explosives that very nearly killed Alexander II.
- 3:41Eleven people were killed, and about 56 were injured.
- 3:44It was one of those moments where he was in the wrong room
- 3:48at the right moment, as it were, and the explosion just missed him.
- 3:55This time, the Tsar would not be so fortunate.
- 4:02Alexander's legs are shredded, and his stomach is cut open by shrapnel.
- 4:07His dying body is carried to the Winter Palace,
- 4:09where his family, the Romanovs,
- 4:11who have ruled Russia for nearly three centuries,
- 4:14are horrified to lay their eyes upon him.
- 4:20He only lasted 90 minutes,
- 4:22and the bomber himself also lasted 90 minutes.
- 4:25His legs were blown off too.
- 4:28The assassination of Alexander II is Russia's 9/11.
- 4:32I've read newspaper reports that come out in the days
- 4:35after the assassination, and they are astonishingly graphic
- 4:39about the physical damage inflicted on Alexander's body.
- 4:42They started talking about the shattered legs
- 4:45and the tendons hanging out and others.
- 4:47What they were describing is this wound
- 4:49that has been inflicted on the body of the state,
- 4:52so the king's two bodies were there.
- 4:58The group responsible for this attack is Narodnaya Volya,
- 5:02which means "The People's Will."
- 5:04The conspirators would be hanged for their crimes,
- 5:07but the movement would continue,
- 5:09and it would soon attract the attention of one Alexander Ulyanov,
- 5:13eldest son of the Ulyanov family and elder brother to Lenin,
- 5:18the man who would eventually eliminate the Romanovs completely.
- 5:22In 1881, The People's Will's predictions did not come to pass.
- 5:27There was no great revolution following the death of Tsar Alexander II.
- 5:32He was succeeded by his son Alexander III, who, upon viewing his dying father,
- 5:37vowed to never let the same fate befall him.
- 5:41Despite the enormous unrest, Russian autocratic rule would continue.
- 5:50Alexander III considered Alexander II way too lenient.
- 5:54He liberated the serfs,
- 5:56so Alexander III decided to come down hard on Russia.
- 6:00He was anyway a very forceful character
- 6:03who used to bend forks and knots at the table,
- 6:06and he could walk through doors without opening them.
- 6:11He was a huge man and undermined his son, unfortunately,
- 6:14by calling him girly when the Tsar was a child.
- 6:18I don't know that the Tsar Nicholas ever emerged
- 6:21from that repression from his father and that sort of undermining.
- 6:25Alexander III had a very bad press.
- 6:28People said stagnation, reaction,
- 6:30and all that was true.
- 6:31On the other hand, Alexander III had some positive aspects.
- 6:35He never declared war on anybody,
- 6:37unlike Alexander II, who was extremely aggressive.
- 6:40He made war on the Turkish Empire and the Chinese.
- 6:43He also listened to his ministers.
- 6:44He may have been a reactionary,
- 6:45but he appointed some very competent ministers.
- 6:48During his reign,
- 6:49Russian railways and Post Offices became one of the best services in Europe.
- 6:53He was a boring man,
- 6:54and he liked the bottle, but there were things to be said for him.
- 6:58It seems counterintuitive,
- 7:00but Russia was a very dynamic society in lots of ways in this period.
- 7:05From its defeat in the Crimean War in the 1850s,
- 7:08it understands that it has to industrialize
- 7:10if it is to remain competitive on the international stage.
- 7:15The defeat in the Crimea at the hands of the French and the British
- 7:18laid bare the fact that Russia was an undeveloped state.
- 7:23Its peasant armies were no match for the Western powers,
- 7:27so if Russia wanted to remain in the game, it needed to industrialize.
- 7:32Russia was modernizing at an extraordinary rate,
- 7:36but its political system remained deeply autocratic,
- 7:39unlike almost all other European nations of the era.
- 7:45Due to the conditions in Russia at the time,
- 7:47normal middle-class families weren't allowed any form
- 7:51of political expression at all.
- 7:53That was the main problem that any normal middle-class family,
- 7:57the son could enter the revolutionary, radical political affair.
- 8:01There is a wave of repression against Russian radicals,
- 8:05oppositionists, and so on.
- 8:07Some of these people were dangerous.
- 8:09Some of these people had plotted to kill the Tsar,
- 8:12members of the imperial family, regional governors, and so on.
- 8:16There was a general paradox that,
- 8:17"A dictatorship, as long as it's strict and severe,"
- 8:20"is safe."
- 8:21"The moment it starts to liberalize,"
- 8:23"it gives an inch, and the people take a yard."
- 8:26"Once the people detect a weakness or a division,"
- 8:29"then the whole thing starts to fall apart."
- 8:35One such person who got caught up in this radical world
- 8:38was Alexander Ulyanov,
- 8:40known to his family as Sasha.
- 8:43He was the eldest son of Ulyanov and the elder brother of Vladimir Lenin.
- 8:51The Ulyanov family was not a typical family.
- 8:55There was a very small cast of civil servants in Russia.
- 8:59The father was a school inspector,
- 9:02and he'd reached the position in the civil service
- 9:04that gave him the rank of a noble.
- 9:06That was a very small percentage of people in Russia,
- 9:09but they weren't that rich.
- 9:11Lenin's elder brother, like Lenin himself, was brilliant and an intellectual.
- 9:14He was covered in gold medals from school and university.
- 9:18He joined a student group, and they decided to make a bomb
- 9:21and attempted to kill Alexander III.
- 9:29The plan was to assassinate Alexander II's heir,
- 9:33Alexander III,
- 9:35when Alexander III would attend a ceremony to commemorate
- 9:40the assassination of his father,
- 9:41and Alexander Ulyanov is the kind of master bomb maker.
- 9:48The People's Will was more of a mystic than an ideological association.
- 9:52Their idea was, "If we bring down the very top,"
- 9:54"they'll all be so terrified that the system will disintegrate"
- 9:58"and there'll be a peasant uprising out of which a new order will arise,"
- 10:02but they had begun to read Marx.
- 10:04The trouble with reading Marx is that, as Marx predicted,
- 10:07the last place there'd be a revolution would be Russia.
- 10:09It was still that romantic idea of,
- 10:12"Kill the Tsar and everything would naturally reform."
- 10:15A bomb that's packed with pieces of metal that have been dipped in strychnine
- 10:20to inflict the maximum number of fatalities is worth remembering.
- 10:24However, the plan was undone by the Okhrana.
- 10:26They had wind of the attempt on the Tsar's life,
- 10:31and the terrorists were arrested and rounded up within a matter of days.
- 10:37They were sentenced to death.
- 10:38Alexander III very generously said,
- 10:41"Those that repent, I will reprieve."
- 10:43"Those that don't repent, I will hang."
- 10:45Sasha said, "That will be going against my principles"
- 10:47"to ask for a reprieve."
- 10:48His mother begged him to.
- 10:50The hanging of Sasha is often seen as what motivated Lenin.
- 10:56Often these things are personal and not political.
- 10:58When his brother was arrested, his mother rushed to the city.
- 11:02Vladimir, the future Lenin,
- 11:04tried to organize transport to get her to the nearest train station,
- 11:07and he traced around bourgeois Simbirsk to try and get someone
- 11:11who would go with his mother.
- 11:13All of them refused,
- 11:15and that changed his entire perspective about bourgeois, liberals,
- 11:18and the other middle class.
- 11:20That was overnight, and from then on, he just abused the liberals,
- 11:25and the way the family was snubbed
- 11:27because this changed him as much as any of the politics.
- 11:35Sasha Ulyanov was hanged on the 20th of May, 1887.
- 11:46Lenin entered the underground revolutionary movements
- 11:49following the path laid out by his brother.
- 11:52Just like Sasha,
- 11:53Lenin would be tracked by the Russian Empire's secret police,
- 11:56the Okhrana.
- 11:59Every country had a spy organization,
- 12:02but Russia was the first one that had an entire massive organization
- 12:07to suppress dissent wherever they seem to find it.
- 12:10They had vast operation to open people's mail.
- 12:14The Russian secret police had their agents everywhere.
- 12:18It not only had departments in St. Petersburg, Moscow,
- 12:21and most of the main cities.
- 12:22It had a French department as well,
- 12:25keeping an eye on the exiles.
- 12:27The Okhrana always kept an eye on them, tailing them around Europe.
- 12:32You had to stay one move ahead,
- 12:34so he spent 16 years effectively going from one bolthole to another,
- 12:39always one step ahead of the secret police.
- 12:42One of the biggest influences on Lenin before he read Marx
- 12:46was a novel by a guy called Nikolai Chernyshevsky
- 12:49called "What is to be done?"
- 12:51It's a pretty lousy novel,
- 12:53but the hero is a selfless, devoted revolutionary
- 12:56who gives himself up to the cause.
- 12:58He walks 20 miles a day, does 150 press-ups,
- 13:02and abstains from alcohol.
- 13:05He modeled himself on this character quite deliberately.
- 13:08Lenin always said this book, which he'd read one summer five times,
- 13:12influenced him more than anything by Marx.
- 13:15Lenin was forced to cover his tracks as he traveled around the country,
- 13:19trying his best to avoid the attention of the authorities.
- 13:22At the same time, Nicholas, the heir to the throne,
- 13:25was also on his travels around the Russian Empire and beyond.
- 13:30It was a voyage of great fanfare, but it came to a shocking end in Japan.
- 13:42His father tried to give him some responsibility.
- 13:44He decided it wouldn't hurt to put him in charge of the Trans-Siberian Railway.
- 13:49He crossed Siberia, went all the way to Vladivostok,
- 13:51and then was sent on a mission to Japan,
- 13:54which ended disastrously because Nicholas was suddenly attacked
- 13:58by a Japanese policeman,
- 14:01Tsuda Sanzō,
- 14:02who took out his saber and slashed him in the head.
- 14:06It did quite a considerable amount of damage.
- 14:08Honestly, as far as I could see, it was a bit of a one-off.
- 14:10I didn't feel that it was a movement among the Japanese against the Tsar,
- 14:15whom the Japanese themselves were horrified by.
- 14:17Japan had only been open to Europeans for about 35 years,
- 14:20and there was a general xenophobic suspicion.
- 14:23This Japanese policeman thought of himself as a samurai defending Japanese honor.
- 14:27Nicholas took it very well.
- 14:28He just stood there smoking.
- 14:30He even refused to sit down to be bandaged,
- 14:32but a large part of his skull had been cut out.
- 14:35He suffered from headaches ever afterward.
- 14:38It may well have prejudiced him against the Japanese,
- 14:41because after that, in his correspondence, he refers to the Japanese as macaques,
- 14:45as monkeys.
- 14:46He became convinced that they were inferior to the Russians
- 14:49and therefore could easily be conquered in any future war.
- 14:55The Ōtsu Incident may have been a near miss
- 14:58for the Romanov family,
- 15:00but it was a foreboding of things to come.
- 15:06Just a couple of years later,
- 15:07Tsar Alexander III would suddenly fall ill.
- 15:11He passed away at the age of just 49,
- 15:14leaving behind his thoroughly unprepared son Nicholas
- 15:18to inherit the throne.
- 15:22Alexander died fairly unexpectedly of kidney disease
- 15:27when he was still in his 40s.
- 15:29Nicholas had expected to have another 20 years
- 15:33to prepare for this onerous responsibility of ruling this enormous empire.
- 15:38The problem was the succession.
- 15:40This is the problem with the hereditary monarchy.
- 15:42The monarch has to die at the right time.
- 15:45When Alexander III died and was only 49,
- 15:48his minister said it was a pity he didn't die much earlier,
- 15:51so we had a boy Tsar who couldn't make any decisions
- 15:53for at least ten years or much later,
- 15:56so that Nicholas could have grown up a bit.
- 15:59Nicholas was always somewhat infantile.
- 16:02He was terrified when his father died,
- 16:05at the prospect of having to take on so much responsibility,
- 16:10for which he had really received very little training.
- 16:15Just a week after his father's burial, Nicholas married Alix of Hesse,
- 16:20a German princess who would become Tsarina Alexandra.
- 16:24Her background would prove challenging for the Romanov family
- 16:27during World War One.
- 16:29Nicholas's enormous problems as monarch started far sooner than that.
- 16:34In fact, from the day of his coronation, he was off to a dreadful start.
- 16:47At his coronation in Moscow in 1896,
- 16:51there was a big park called Khodynka in western Moscow,
- 16:54and the government had arranged for coronation mugs
- 16:57and little bags of goodies to be given out.
- 17:03The fencing and the gates were all wrong,
- 17:05and so when the crowds pressed to receive their goods,
- 17:07there was a terrible crush.
- 17:11Some 1500 people died, and that was a terrible tragedy.
- 17:16That night, there was a party at the French embassy,
- 17:20and he didn't want to go to it, but he was persuaded to go to the event.
- 17:24It was forever held against him as deeply insensitive.
- 17:29He had to rely on his ministers to advise him,
- 17:33but fundamentally, from day one,
- 17:35the job of being Tsar was much agreed and dictated by his wife.
- 17:41She was very entrenched in the concept of autocracy
- 17:45and their divine rights.
- 17:49Nicholas was struggling in his new role as Tsar,
- 17:51but the man who'd eventually replace him as ruler of Russia
- 17:55was in a far worse predicament.
- 17:57Lenin had been captured by the authorities and was charged with sedition.
- 18:02In 1897, he was sent to exile in Siberia for three years,
- 18:06which could often be a far less challenging experience
- 18:09than might at first appear.
- 18:13He isn't quite pleasant either.
- 18:15He had his wife and mother-in-law with him.
- 18:18He had a monthly allowance on which he could keep a cow
- 18:22and a serving maid.
- 18:23He had a maid of 12, whom he paid one ruble a month,
- 18:27and kept her in a cage under the stairs.
- 18:29So much for Bolshevik.
- 18:31Egalitarianism.
- 18:32He writes home, saying that he's ice skating and shooting,
- 18:36and maintains this phenomenal level of correspondence
- 18:41with a conspiratorial network now that stretches across the Russian Empire
- 18:46and beyond to Europe.
- 18:50Once you were there, you were housed quite nicely.
- 18:52In Russia, people never felt prisoners were to be avoided
- 18:56if they're charged with a murder.
- 18:57People used to go to the prisons,
- 18:59at least as people go to the zoo to feed the animals.
- 19:02It was not a bad life.
- 19:05Lenin's exile ended in 1900.
- 19:09He would soon begin his travels across Western Europe,
- 19:12where he would meet other Marxists and dissidents
- 19:14who were planning the downfall of the Russian monarchy.
- 19:17For now, Lenin and these agitators seemed insignificant.
- 19:22There were far more pressing concerns.
- 19:25The Russian Empire was surrounded on two sides by rising military powers.
- 19:29To the west was Kaiser Wilhelm,
- 19:31under whose rule Germany had been unified in 1871.
- 19:35To the east was Emperor Meiji, whose restoration of Japan in 1868
- 19:40had forged another rapidly industrializing state.
- 19:44The first battle would be with Japan in 1904.
- 19:57Few world observers expected an Asian military
- 19:59to challenge a European power at this time.
- 20:02Japan's surprising success in the conflict fueled social unrest throughout Russia,
- 20:08which came to be known as the 1905 Revolution.
- 20:14The Russo-Japanese War was very bad for morale
- 20:18because the Russians were trounced and their fleet was destroyed.
- 20:21That didn't help the Tsar in his bid to be popular.
- 20:26A war being lost was a mixture of embittered soldiers and sailors,
- 20:31whose lives have been just thrown away in a hopeless war against the Japanese.
- 20:35It was an appalling, disgraceful defeat.
- 20:38You come home to find that factories weren't paying properly, and so on.
- 20:42There were shortages, and there was general disarray,
- 20:44and it was an opportunity for disaffected soldiers
- 20:47to organize themselves.
- 20:51The response to the civilian unrest and demands for reform would be brutal.
- 20:57Imperial troops opened fire on the protesters.
- 21:00The events of Bloody Sunday, as it came to be known,
- 21:03would damage Tsar Nicholas' reputation forever.
- 21:10The Bloody Sunday massacre was in some ways typical
- 21:13of Nicholas II's reign,
- 21:16that either he had to have much more sense or he needed a good spin doctor,
- 21:21and he had neither.
- 21:22The revolutionary parties were all caught off guard by 1905.
- 21:26Nobody predicted Bloody Sunday.
- 21:28It's clear that the war is going disastrously with Japan.
- 21:33There was no real sense that Russia had reached a turning point.
- 21:38This was a spontaneous protest that then ended in a bloodbath
- 21:42because the Tsarist authorities attacked the protesters.
- 21:47He wasn't there when the troops opened fire.
- 21:52He just responded very badly.
- 21:54He sensed that he was getting less popular
- 21:57when he became known as Nicholas the Bloody.
- 22:01He spent most of his time at the Alexandra Palace in Tsarskoye Selo,
- 22:06which is about 15 miles away from St. Petersburg.
- 22:10He realized there might be a threat of assassination.
- 22:141905 had been a dreadful year for the Romanovs,
- 22:17but the protest did eventually die down,
- 22:20and, crucially, the Russian armed forces remained loyal to the throne.
- 22:24A peace treaty was declared with Japan,
- 22:27with a deal brokered by US President Teddy Roosevelt.
- 22:31Lenin and his accomplices across Europe, just like everyone else,
- 22:35had been caught completely off guard by the events of 1905.
- 22:39Out of nowhere,
- 22:40it seemed that the revolution they were searching for
- 22:43was occurring spontaneously.
- 22:46In the end, the Tsar remained in power,
- 22:48and although a parliament called the Duma had been set up in response,
- 22:52it was flawed from the beginning.
- 22:54Nicholas had the ability to veto any and all legislation.
- 22:59There had been anger and resentment,
- 23:01and they were also losing a war against Japan.
- 23:05That was a big, profound shock to the system.
- 23:07That changed the middle class' view about the political system they had
- 23:12and the autocracy substantially.
- 23:14That was so useless, we could even lose a war against Japan.
- 23:18That had a profound impact.
- 23:20Lenin says, "My generation won't live to see the revolution,"
- 23:24that there is this sense that this was like a one-shot deal,
- 23:28and we blew it.
- 23:29We weren't organized enough.
- 23:30We couldn't give direction and purpose
- 23:33to what was a sort of spontaneous popular uprising.
- 23:37Lenin, even right up to 1917, was quite despairing that revolution,
- 23:42as his vision of revolution was ever going to happen in his lifetime.
- 23:491905 was kind of a dry run for what might come later,
- 23:53but it wasn't planned as a revolution.
- 23:58For now, the Tsar seemed safe.
- 24:01The war had come to an end,
- 24:03and the revolutionary fervor had died down.
- 24:06However, it was not to last.
- 24:08In the next few years,
- 24:09both the Romanov family and the Ulyanov family
- 24:12would be introduced to figures that would prove critical
- 24:15in Russia's future.
- 24:18For Lenin, it was a Georgian named Joseph Jughashvili,
- 24:21later to be known as Stalin.
- 24:24Although upon first appearance, Lenin was unimpressed.
- 24:30Lenin was the leader of that Bolshevik section.
- 24:33He was already the top man, and Stalin was a nobody.
- 24:38At first, Lenin hardly noticed Stalin, but later on in Vienna,
- 24:42he noticed that Stalin was a very useful handyman.
- 24:45Lenin had a rather petrisen view of non-Russians,
- 24:49so he called him this wondrous Georgian.
- 24:51Stalin was regarded as extremely useful.
- 24:54He was also a gofer.
- 24:55He never refused to do anything.
- 24:58He was always happy to kill and rob.
- 25:01He never balked at anything.
- 25:03He could do things physically, such as get into a fight.
- 25:05Lenin admired that about Stalin.
- 25:07He was as tough as anything.
- 25:08He had a quality of intimidating people,
- 25:10and above all, he hardly ever talked, unlike Trotsky.
- 25:13It's why Stalin and Trotsky never got on.
- 25:16Stalin's secret was to appear far less knowledgeable
- 25:19and far less intelligent than he was.
- 25:22He understood a lot of languages.
- 25:24He was an extraordinary judge of character.
- 25:26Stalin's secret was not to find the strongest people to work with him,
- 25:30because the strongest people might want to succeed you.
- 25:32He always chose the Omega male.
- 25:34He had his sort of allies with him,
- 25:36and he knew how to make people feel they needed him.
- 25:40A year later, when they met again,
- 25:42Lenin couldn't remember any of these other names.
- 25:44He didn't even remember meeting him.
- 25:46However, he made himself very useful, specially when they needed to raise money.
- 25:57The Romanovs were also about to come into contact
- 26:00with a mysterious figure from the fringes of the Russian Empire,
- 26:04Rasputin.
- 26:05Tsar Nicholas' only son, Alexei, the heir to the throne,
- 26:09had been diagnosed with hemophilia.
- 26:11The Tsar and Tsarina searched for anyone who could help their ailing son,
- 26:16and Rasputin seemed to be the only figure who was capable of doing so.
- 26:24He met them initially at a tea with the so-called Black Sisters,
- 26:29who were the Montenegrin princesses, Melissa and Anastasia,
- 26:34who had invited him to Melissa's palace at the tea.
- 26:39Then it was several months afterward that Alexei fell and was bleeding badly.
- 26:46They thought of asking Rasputin to try and heal him, and he did.
- 26:52However, the questions always remain as to how he cured him,
- 26:55or even if he did,
- 26:57or whether he just calmed the Tsarina down because she believed he was a man of God.
- 27:02There's also an interesting thing that aspirin was beginning to be used
- 27:06as a painkiller,
- 27:07and Rasputin was always very against medication.
- 27:10He recommended they not use aspirin, and that might have helped.
- 27:17If Alexei had not been a hemophiliac,
- 27:20history could have been quite different because it created such resentment.
- 27:25The invitation of Rasputin into the Imperial family in itself
- 27:31helped bring about the downfall of the dynasty.
- 27:38Rasputin's presence would cause a scandal in Russia.
- 27:42Endless rumors began to spread about the exact nature
- 27:45of his involvement with the Romanovs.
- 27:49First, he was kept a secret.
- 27:51The press was forbidden to mention him,
- 27:53which immediately made people think there was something terrible going on
- 27:56until about 1912 when press restrictions were virtually abolished in Russia.
- 28:00It was impossible to stop the papers from printing everything.
- 28:03Then Rasputin sold papers.
- 28:05The journalists loved him.
- 28:07You could follow him and get all sorts of stories
- 28:09from restaurant owners and prostitutes about his behavior.
- 28:13Police would sell their stories to him.
- 28:15He became a sort of news-making phenomenon.
- 28:19In 1911, there were letters disseminated around by an old friend,
- 28:25which had very passionate notes to Rasputin from the Tsarina.
- 28:31"I kiss you warmly," things like that.
- 28:37Rasputin's presence was bringing the Romanov family reputation to ruins.
- 28:42However, in 1913,
- 28:43a chance to repair some of the damage seemed possible.
- 28:47That year marked 300 years of Romanov rule,
- 28:50and huge tercentenary celebrations were planned
- 28:53that would hopefully boost public morale.
- 28:56However, yet another assassination attempt would soon undo everything.
- 29:12Archduke Franz Ferdinand was gunned down in Sarajevo.
- 29:17World War One was about to begin.
- 29:19Russia's failure against the Japanese nearly brought an end to Nicholas' rule.
- 29:24He would not survive a defeat against the Germans.
- 29:31Considering that the Germans already had the British and the French
- 29:34to cope with,
- 29:35with their enormous empires of Indians, Algerians, and so on,
- 29:39and that very soon the Americans would come into the war,
- 29:42you would have thought Russia would have had a hope.
- 29:44The Russian army was a peculiar army, and the officers were enthusiastic,
- 29:48but the soldiers were not.
- 29:50Many of the soldiers had been part of the defeated army.
- 29:54Most of them had nothing against the Germans whatsoever.
- 29:57They didn't see them as an enemy.
- 30:00The corruption in the civilian area was that no boots and rifles were produced,
- 30:06so soldiers were told to go in
- 30:08and pick the first rifle and pair of boots off the corpse in front of them.
- 30:12There were desertions, murdered officers, and so on.
- 30:19I think that it was generally considered a disaster
- 30:22when he decided to take over the troops
- 30:25and get rid of Grand Duke Nicholas, who was probably a very good general.
- 30:29He was certainly a more imposing figure than the Tsar.
- 30:33That did leave the Tsarina and Rasputin in charge.
- 30:39The war was an absolute disaster for Russia.
- 30:42An autocrat has got to be judged on the autocrat's decision,
- 30:46and it was a disastrous decision.
- 30:48A bigger decision was,
- 30:50he put himself in charge of the military strategy,
- 30:54which was a terrible mistake
- 30:56because once it goes wrong, he's the only one you can blame.
- 30:59There was a stalemate on the Eastern Front.
- 31:02The Germans had already occupied large tracts of Russia.
- 31:05There was no will among the army to carry it on.
- 31:09Desertions were on a massive scale.
- 31:11There was almost no way for Russian victory.
- 31:17The winter of 1916 not only saw the chill of inevitable defeat for the Russian army,
- 31:23but it also saw a shocking and painful loss for the Romanovs.
- 31:30Certain members of their extended family would not tolerate Rasputin's influence
- 31:35over the Tsar and Tsarina any longer.
- 31:40There was growing resentment within the Romanov family
- 31:44and among the relatives who were appalled
- 31:48at Alexandra's close relationship with Rasputin
- 31:51because they believed all the gossip as well.
- 31:53It reached a point where they said,
- 31:55"Not only have we got to get rid of Rasputin,"
- 31:58"this evil, Machiavellian influence."
- 32:01"We've got to get rid of her and lock her up in a nunnery."
- 32:04She was causing a lot of trouble.
- 32:07It was the aristocrats who felt that Rasputin
- 32:11was bringing the whole Romanov name down.
- 32:14One of the problems here was,
- 32:17nobody knew why Rasputin was always going to court,
- 32:20and it was to cure the boy Alexei.
- 32:24However, because nobody knew that Alexei was ill,
- 32:27nobody could tell the aristocrats why he was still being welcomed at court.
- 32:31Rasputin was blamed for being a German agent.
- 32:35They were convinced he was advising the Tsar to make peace,
- 32:38at least with the Germans,
- 32:40so a conspiracy was formed with the connivance of many people
- 32:43in the government.
- 32:45Two of the assassins both left quite detailed memoirs
- 32:49and descriptions of the killing.
- 32:51There were quite a few discrepancies in both the memoirs.
- 32:54He ended up in a river, but he was tipped over a railing,
- 32:57and he ended up with a lot of wounds on his face and head.
- 33:01Nobody's sure whether it was because he was beaten up
- 33:03or whether they tried to transfer the body.
- 33:07The plotters were incompetent.
- 33:10They didn't know how to handle guns and couldn't even kill him efficiently.
- 33:14Eventually, it took three bullets before they finally killed the poor man.
- 33:19It was an ignominious way to get rid of Rasputin.
- 33:23At the time, they were greeted as national heroes.
- 33:27Everyone thought they'd saved Russia by killing Rasputin.
- 33:39Rasputin's time at court had come to an end in brutal fashion,
- 33:44and it would not be long before the Romanovs themselves
- 33:46would also be seen off in equally bloody circumstances.
- 33:50Just as in 1905, during the disasters of the Russo-Japanese War,
- 33:55civil unrest was about to break out in Russia.
- 33:58The historic city of St. Petersburg would see the beginnings
- 34:01of the February Revolution.
- 34:03It had been renamed Petrograd, literally Peters City, in 1914,
- 34:08as St. Petersburg had been thought to have a Germanic name at a time of war.
- 34:13The new designation did nothing to contain the revolutionary fervor
- 34:17that was unleashed in the city.
- 34:19It soon became so overwhelming
- 34:21that Tsar Nicholas II was forced to step down.
- 34:32He couldn't quite accept how bad the crisis was.
- 34:35He had this passivity and resistance to crisis.
- 34:40He had to be driven to abdicate, and he finally did.
- 34:44However, the Tsarina always believed that had she been with him,
- 34:47she would have been able to dissuade him from abdicating.
- 34:52He hoped he was doing a grand gesture to save Russia,
- 34:57so it was done out of a genuine love of the country.
- 35:05With Nicholas having vacated the throne,
- 35:07a power vacuum was created in Russia with two major factions in Petrograd
- 35:12fighting for control.
- 35:14On one side was a council of workers and soldiers
- 35:17known as the Petrograd Soviet,
- 35:19which soon counted Leon Trotsky as a member.
- 35:22On the other side was the Russian Provisional Government,
- 35:25which had been quickly established by ministers who'd served under the Tsar.
- 35:29They would move the Romanov family to Siberia for safekeeping,
- 35:33but soon nowhere in Russia would be safe.
- 35:39The Provisional Government represents a vision of a liberal Russia,
- 35:44where you'd have a community of citizens who are given equal rights,
- 35:49but you enshrine a liberal order based around representative government.
- 35:54The Soviet represents a very different kind of Russia.
- 35:59The Provisional Government made a halfhearted attempt
- 36:02to continue with the war,
- 36:04but because it couldn't come to a decision,
- 36:06it couldn't get the economy going,
- 36:07it couldn't satisfy even the housewives of bread, and so on.
- 36:11There was more and more dissatisfaction.
- 36:13Lenin was in Zurich at the time.
- 36:14Someone entered his room in his lodging house and said,
- 36:17"Have you heard? There was a revolution."
- 36:19At first, he didn't believe it, then he did,
- 36:21and he wanted to get back to Russia as soon as possible.
- 36:24From the moment the war started, Lenin was totally against the war.
- 36:29His line was,
- 36:30"Better that this country should lose,"
- 36:33"the better that Kaiser-ism wins, then Tsarism continues."
- 36:37He was saying his own country should lose the war.
- 36:45Lenin was in a difficult situation.
- 36:48To get from Switzerland to Russia,
- 36:50to take advantage of the February Revolution,
- 36:52he would have to travel through Germany, with whom his country was at war.
- 36:57A complicated deal would have to be brokered.
- 37:03I would say it wasn't Lenin who made his move.
- 37:05It was the German high command that made the move.
- 37:07He'd been offered inducements from the Germans
- 37:11that offered him money, and he'd always refused it.
- 37:15Now, he was less scrupulous.
- 37:18He agreed to the famous sealed train through Germany,
- 37:22and from the German's point of view,
- 37:23it seemed like a perfectly reasonable tactic.
- 37:27Lenin didn't make the deal.
- 37:29Lenin never got his hands dirty.
- 37:31Lenin never directly did something that might be politically damaging.
- 37:37The deal to get him and his cohort of followers back to Russia
- 37:42when the revolution broke was negotiated by intermediaries.
- 37:47He had to go on this tortuous journey up through Germany,
- 37:50across to Sweden, all the way up through Sweden to Finland,
- 37:53and down.
- 37:55That train deposited Lenin at the Finland Station
- 37:58in St. Petersburg.
- 38:00Now, if the Provisional Government had had the sense to turn up
- 38:04with a small group of people to meet him and arrest him on the spot,
- 38:07that was it, but they couldn't get to it.
- 38:09They were incredibly inefficient.
- 38:11Lenin was genius.
- 38:12When he arrived at the Finland Station and gave a speech from the armored car,
- 38:16he called for all power to the Soviets.
- 38:20That was not a call for direct democracy rather than representative democracy.
- 38:25That was a call for this much more brutal, exclusive vision
- 38:31of a revolutionary future in which everyone who was on top before
- 38:36would now be at the bottom.
- 38:37The dual power system meant that everything had to be agreed
- 38:40by the Soviet and the Provisional Government,
- 38:43which led to paralysis.
- 38:46Lenin was very, very good at using this.
- 38:48He was incredibly skilled at the black arts and propaganda,
- 38:52and he used it rather brilliantly.
- 38:54He loved the revolution, this part of the revolution.
- 38:57The Bolsheviks did nearly overplay their hand.
- 39:00In the July days,
- 39:01they tried to stage an uprising in Petrograd,
- 39:05and it was crushed.
- 39:07In the middle of July, Lenin was charged with treason.
- 39:11There was information that came out about money
- 39:14that the Bolsheviks accepted from the Germans.
- 39:18He was under arrest and escaped to Finland,
- 39:21and he was out of the country for quite a lot of the war.
- 39:25He then came back and insisted, "There is no power in this country."
- 39:29"Let's take over the railway station and the post offices, and power is ours."
- 39:33"It's there for the taking. Take it from the street."
- 39:36"We can do it."
- 39:51Lenin's belief in the profound weakness of the Provisional Government
- 39:55would prove justified.
- 39:57Russia's October Revolution had begun,
- 39:59and the Bolsheviks' attempted coup d'état would spark a civil war
- 40:03that would last until 1922.
- 40:08Without Lenin, there would be no abolish of revolution,
- 40:11and there wouldn't have been any second revolution.
- 40:14He pushed and pushed and pushed his party members with him.
- 40:18They were very, very reluctant because they were scared of being shot
- 40:22or that that wouldn't work.
- 40:24There wasn't one particular spark that week or that month that led it.
- 40:28It was Lenin saying, "This is our chance."
- 40:31Lenin's regime is a government that was born in war,
- 40:34so it's helpful to think about the period, I think from 1914 to 1921,
- 40:39as one of continuous warfare.
- 40:41The Bolshevik Party at the beginning of 1917
- 40:43was about 20,000 people.
- 40:45By the end of the Civil War, it was about 1.3 million.
- 40:48Most of the new recruits were men whose formative administrative experience
- 40:54had been in the Army.
- 40:55They were militarized in their psychology.
- 41:01The actual revolution in Russia initially was very much in Petrograd
- 41:05and, of course, Moscow.
- 41:07The way it took hold across rural Russia was very anarchic and violent.
- 41:14There were horrific scenes of peasants rampaging across estates,
- 41:20burning the manor houses down, slaughtering the occupants,
- 41:24and killing all the cattle owned by the landowners.
- 41:28It was very savage.
- 41:30The resistance took too long because most of the army and the navy
- 41:33were so demoralized, that they came over to the Bolshevik side.
- 41:37They were very happy to go around the hospital shooting ministers.
- 41:41There was a general murderous feeling about the government,
- 41:43which Lenin just released.
- 41:51Lenin was quickly becoming the most powerful man in Russia.
- 41:55He'd agreed to an end to the war with Germany
- 41:57with the treaty of Brest-Litovsk,
- 42:00and his new secret police commenced a strategy of violent repression
- 42:04that would become known as the Red Terror.
- 42:10The now-deposed Romanov family was being held in safekeeping
- 42:13by the Provisional Government.
- 42:15Attempts had been made to send them into exile,
- 42:18but the efforts were to no avail.
- 42:20Soon, the Tsar, his wife and children, and his last remaining staff
- 42:24were captured by the Bolshevik forces and sent to a Yakaterinburg,
- 42:29where they were kept in strict isolation.
- 42:37At around midnight on July 17th, 1918,
- 42:40the family was awoken and escorted into the basement of the house.
- 42:53This all-powerful dynasty had authorized the execution of Sasha Ulyanov,
- 42:59Lenin's elder brother,
- 43:01but now the tables had been turned, and the Romanovs were no more.
- 43:09The tragedy is that they had 11 assassins for 11 people to be shot.
- 43:16When it came to it, I think the assassins were quite drunk
- 43:19and nobody wanted to shoot the children, so they shot the Tsar and Tsarina first.
- 43:26The children had the most horrifying death you could ever imagine or inflict,
- 43:31and that was brought about by the loving parents,
- 43:35just indirectly over the years.
- 43:38Who could have imagined that those innocent children
- 43:41would be murdered?
- 43:42This was why it was so horrifying when it happened.
- 43:47No one ever imagined those children would be so cruelly murdered.
- 43:52There was no paper trail,
- 43:53but we know it would never have happened without Lenin agreeing to it.
- 43:57No one was going to kill the Romanovs without Lenin saying so.
- 44:07Nicholas II's mother, the Dowager Empress, was able to escape the carnage on a ship
- 44:12leaving from the Crimea along with other members
- 44:15of the extended Romanov family.
- 44:17However, the dynasty that ruled Russia for over three centuries
- 44:21had come to a vicious end.
- 44:23By 1922, the civil war in the country had also reached its conclusion,
- 44:28with the Bolsheviks victorious and a new Soviet Union established.
- 44:34Lenin began cementing power as soon as he started.
- 44:37His organization was so good he had the common soldiers and sailors
- 44:41and, above all, had the secret police.
- 44:43He had Trotsky, who I think was the real genius
- 44:46to take a whole lot of disillusioned deserters,
- 44:48who then create a Red Army,
- 44:50which was one of the most brilliant armies in the world.
- 44:52With Trotsky's military genius and Lenin's organization and subversion,
- 44:57I think he consolidated all the time.
- 45:01He used terror.
- 45:04Not only that, but he was very good at lying.
- 45:07He was very skilled in building majorities and building groups who were loyal to him.
- 45:12After the revolution, people said,
- 45:14"Yes, we need a republican."
- 45:15"We need the Constitution, but we still need a firm Tsar as well."
- 45:21They wanted the two.
- 45:22They couldn't quite dissociate themselves.
- 45:26It was this idea,
- 45:27"The protective, all-embracing Tsar who looked after the nation."
- 45:32There was always going to be this tendency toward the abuse of power
- 45:36because the party acknowledged no checks at all on its own behavior.
- 45:40There was no independent judiciary and press.
- 45:42There was no political opposition.
- 45:45There was always going to be this tendency toward a degeneration
- 45:49into ever more absolute power.
- 45:54Lenin would not hold on to this new position for long.
- 45:58He suffered a debilitating series of strokes
- 46:01and died on 21st January, 1924.
- 46:06Joseph Dzhugashvili, now known as Joseph Stalin,
- 46:09saw an opportunity laid out before him.
- 46:13The Russian Revolution of 1917 changed the world forever.
- 46:18The Romanovs had been usurped and the largest country on earth
- 46:22was a communist state.
- 46:23The man who had become the most powerful dictator in history
- 46:27was now cementing his position.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of The Russian Revolution by Best Documentary, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,612 words across 771 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.