The Role of Quality Measurement in Healthcare — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00hello everyone and welcome to the role
- 0:03of quality measurement in healthcare in
- 0:06this presentation we will cover the
- 0:07state of Healthcare in the United States
- 0:09and then we're going to take a journey
- 0:11through the history of healthcare
- 0:12quality to build a foundation for your
- 0:14future learnings thanks so much for
- 0:16joining us
- 0:18my name is Amanda Ryan and I am the
- 0:21director of education at Pharmacy
- 0:23quality Alliance and I will be your
- 0:25speaker for this presentation
- 0:29the learning objectives for the
- 0:31presentation are listed for you here on
- 0:33the slide but I'll go through them with
- 0:34you briefly as well now at the end of
- 0:37the presentation you'll be able to
- 0:39review some healthcare economics concept
- 0:41Concepts that we will be covering and
- 0:43you'll be able to relate those to
- 0:44healthcare quality you'll also be able
- 0:47to describe the current state of the
- 0:49United States healthcare system and how
- 0:51the ACA or the Affordable Care Act
- 0:53shaped and still does in fact shape that
- 0:55system you'll be able to explain how the
- 0:58current system of U.S Healthcare focuses
- 1:00on quality and will do that by learning
- 1:03about the National Quality strategy and
- 1:05then finally you'll be able to identify
- 1:07the role that quality measures play in
- 1:09delivery of Health Care in the United
- 1:11States
- 1:14and with that let's begin by discussing
- 1:16the state of United States Healthcare
- 1:21this slide shows Healthcare spending as
- 1:24a percentage of GDP over the last 40
- 1:27years or so so from 1980 to 2019 and
- 1:31that's the most recent data that we have
- 1:32available if you look over there on the
- 1:35left at 1980 you can see that compared
- 1:38to a handful of other high income
- 1:40Nations the United States spent a
- 1:42similar amount of money on Health Care
- 1:44however over the last 40 years you can
- 1:47see a pretty significant change all the
- 1:50countries have increased the amount that
- 1:52they're spending on health care but the
- 1:53United States has increased that amount
- 1:55by quite a bit more than the other
- 1:56countries you can see here so bottom
- 1:59line here is we are spending a lot of
- 2:01money on Health Care
- 2:04and then since we spend so much money on
- 2:06Health Care in the United States you
- 2:08would think that should result in higher
- 2:10quality Care
- 2:11however in likely what is not a surprise
- 2:14to you that is not the case in fact when
- 2:17we compare Health Care System
- 2:18performance to other high-income nations
- 2:21we can see that once again the United
- 2:23States is an outlier this time in the
- 2:25opposite direction
- 2:27the United States performance Falls well
- 2:30below the average of other countries and
- 2:32also far below the other two countries
- 2:34that are closest to it in this graphic
- 2:36which are Switzerland and Canada
- 2:39the performance scores here are really
- 2:40pretty comprehensive and they cover
- 2:42multiple domains of Healthcare System
- 2:44performance and they include things like
- 2:46access to care the care process
- 2:49administrative efficiency equity and
- 2:52Health Care outcomes
- 2:54so this is where we are we're spending a
- 2:56lot for not much of a return on that
- 2:59investment there is a significant
- 3:01disparity between the amount that we
- 3:03spend on health care and the quality of
- 3:05that care in the United States
- 3:08so let's think about how to address
- 3:10these issues we need to do that by
- 3:13focusing on increasing the quality of
- 3:15care while reducing the overall cost of
- 3:17care so the two concepts we just covered
- 3:19this can be done by moving from high
- 3:22volume care to high value care so on the
- 3:25graphic on the slide you can see that
- 3:27cost is depicted on the y-axis and
- 3:30quality is depicted on the x-axis high
- 3:33volume care is what has been
- 3:34traditionally delivered in the United
- 3:36States and it is generally higher cost
- 3:38and lower quality well if you move over
- 3:41there to the right you can see high
- 3:43value care which is where we are
- 3:45currently transitioning and that
- 3:47generally is is delivered at lower cost
- 3:49but higher quality so we are looking at
- 3:52a transition here from high value high
- 3:54volume to high volume
- 3:56now we're going to go on a quality
- 3:58Journey where we're going to discuss the
- 4:00history of healthcare quality and
- 4:02provide more context about how we're
- 4:04moving from high volume to the high
- 4:06value care that we talked about a few
- 4:08moments ago
- 4:09this will lead us at the end to the
- 4:12value equation which will be helpful for
- 4:14you to use as you learn and understand
- 4:16more about Healthcare quality
- 4:20we are going to begin our journey back
- 4:22in 1999 so as you can see we've been
- 4:25talking about Healthcare quality for
- 4:27quite some time now and in 1999 The
- 4:30Institute of medicine released the first
- 4:32of two seminal reports on Health Care
- 4:34Quality
- 4:35the first report was entitled to Ayers
- 4:38human building a safer Health System
- 4:40this report highlighted that medical
- 4:43errors are a common and serious problem
- 4:45in health care in fact it showed that
- 4:48between forty four thousand and ninety
- 4:51eight thousand Americans die every year
- 4:53in hospitals due to preventable medical
- 4:55errors
- 4:57the report also emphasizes that medical
- 4:59errors are not simply the result of
- 5:01individual shortcomings and this is
- 5:03something that's very important to
- 5:05remember as we talk about Healthcare
- 5:06quality but these errors are actually a
- 5:09result of systematic systematic issues
- 5:11within the Health Care system and to
- 5:14address this we need a comprehensive and
- 5:16systematic approach to improve patient
- 5:18safety
- 5:20the second report which was released in
- 5:222001 is called crossing the quality
- 5:24Chasm this report highlights that safety
- 5:27issues are not just confined to
- 5:29hospitals as you would expect and that
- 5:32Americans are not receiving the care
- 5:33that they should be
- 5:35it also identifies and recommends
- 5:37improvements in six dimensions of
- 5:39Healthcare in the United States and
- 5:41those include patient safety care
- 5:44Effectiveness patient-centeredness
- 5:46timeliness hair efficiency and equity
- 5:49and much like to air as human this
- 5:52report emphasizes that the Health Care
- 5:54System must be transformed in order to
- 5:56deliver high quality safe and effective
- 5:59care to patients
- 6:02continuing now on our journey in 2006
- 6:06John Whittington and Tom Nolan from The
- 6:08Institute for healthcare Improvement
- 6:10developed what is called the triple aim
- 6:13the triple aim allows us to clarify that
- 6:16systematic approach that we just talked
- 6:18about that's required to improve Health
- 6:20Care Quality it contains as the name
- 6:23suggests three aims which are the
- 6:25experience of care population health and
- 6:28per capita cost so once again you do see
- 6:31both elements of quality and cost within
- 6:33the triple aim
- 6:34while crossing the quality Chasm did
- 6:37focus on the individual experience of
- 6:39receiving Health Care the triple aim
- 6:41actually went beyond this the individual
- 6:44experience of care as you can see there
- 6:46on the bottom left is one part of the
- 6:48triple aim but also included is
- 6:51population health and that addresses
- 6:53reasons individuals seek care in the
- 6:55first place and things that happen
- 6:57outside of healthcare including social
- 6:59determinants of health and then of
- 7:02course as we said the third part of the
- 7:03triple aim is per capita cost
- 7:06improving the U.S health care System Inc
- 7:09requires a simultaneous focus on all
- 7:11three of these aims and focus on all of
- 7:14these simultaneously does reinforce each
- 7:17of the others we need all three aims to
- 7:19get where we're going and in addition to
- 7:22that it's important to recognize that no
- 7:24one entity can be entirely responsible
- 7:26for the Triple aim and also by extension
- 7:29no one entity can possibly be
- 7:31responsible for Health Care Quality
- 7:33so this is a call for all of us to work
- 7:36together in pursuit of high quality
- 7:38Health Care
- 7:41after the triple aim was designed some
- 7:43thought leaders advocated for adding a
- 7:46fourth aim to address healthcare
- 7:47provider burnout or Health Equity
- 7:50and then following that in 2022 ihi CEO
- 7:55cater mate and colleagues advocated for
- 7:57What's called the quintuple aim which
- 8:00includes both Workforce well-being and
- 8:02advancing Health Equity
- 8:04they believe that achieving high quality
- 8:06care for all cannot be realized without
- 8:08these additional aims the quintuple aim
- 8:11represents a more holistic approach and
- 8:14also a more comprehensive approach to
- 8:16healthcare quality and also provides a
- 8:18framework for thinking about how to
- 8:20improve the quality of care while also
- 8:22addressing broader social determinants
- 8:24of health and well-being of healthcare
- 8:26providers
- 8:29now back to our Healthcare journey and
- 8:32we're going to go to 2010 when we're
- 8:34going to and now we're going to talk
- 8:35about the patient protection and
- 8:37Affordable Care Act which is also known
- 8:39as the ACA or Obamacare in 2010 the ACA
- 8:43became law
- 8:44the ACA did create significant changes
- 8:47to the U.S Health Care system in a
- 8:48number of ways and while we will not be
- 8:51able to cover all the provisions of the
- 8:52ACA here we will cover a few of them now
- 8:55as part of the ACA Medicaid was expanded
- 8:58which increased the number of low-income
- 9:00individuals who are eligible for the
- 9:03program
- 9:04the ACA also created a health insurance
- 9:06Marketplace which allows people to shop
- 9:09for insurance online
- 9:11subsidies were also provided to assist
- 9:13in the affordability of insurance
- 9:14coverage
- 9:15the ACA also included a number of
- 9:18insurance reforms these included
- 9:20requirements to offer Insurance
- 9:22regardless of pre-existing conditions
- 9:24and coverage for certain types of care
- 9:26including preventative care
- 9:28the ACA also contained mandates for
- 9:31individuals to have health insurance
- 9:33coverage and also mandates for many
- 9:35employers to offer health insurance
- 9:40Medicaid expansion raised the
- 9:42eligibility floor to 138 percent of the
- 9:46federal poverty level however the
- 9:48expansion of Medicaid was effectively
- 9:50optional for States and not all states
- 9:53chose to expand Medicaid
- 9:55here you can see a map that shows which
- 9:57states opted to expand Medicaid and this
- 9:59is current as of November 2022 the navy
- 10:02blue states have chosen to expand
- 10:04Medicaid and the orange states have not
- 10:06expanded it South Dakota is the one
- 10:09state you can see here in light blue and
- 10:11they are scheduled to implement their
- 10:13expansion on July 1st 2023.
- 10:18the health insurance Marketplace
- 10:20provided a new option for people to shop
- 10:22for health insurance individuals can
- 10:25choose the amount of coverage that they
- 10:27need and likewise if not buy insurance
- 10:29that they don't need and they can also
- 10:31comparison shop among different plans
- 10:33additional financial assistance was also
- 10:36introduced to help with affordability of
- 10:38health insurance
- 10:41multiple Insurance reforms were included
- 10:44in the ACA some expanded access to
- 10:47insurance and they included those
- 10:49individual and employer mandates that I
- 10:51referenced earlier as well as Provisions
- 10:53allowing young adults to stay on their
- 10:55parents Insurance until they are 26.
- 10:58other reforms increase consumer
- 11:00protections by reducing denials based on
- 11:03pre-existing conditions as well as
- 11:06prohibitions against certain
- 11:07unreasonable premium increases and
- 11:10canceling of insurance coverage
- 11:13in addition to the provisions that we've
- 11:15already covered the ACA also had a
- 11:17significant focus on quality
- 11:19for example the National Quality
- 11:21strategy or nqs was created under the
- 11:24ACA
- 11:25it was a strategy to guide not only
- 11:27local but also State and National
- 11:29efforts to improve quality of care
- 11:32the nqs focuses on six priorities that
- 11:36address Americans most common health
- 11:38care concerns you can see those six
- 11:40priorities here we'll talk about just a
- 11:42sampling of them now if you start over
- 11:44there on the left you can see in the
- 11:46First Column refers to making care safer
- 11:48by reducing harm caused by the delivery
- 11:51of care so this sounds very much like
- 11:53those two iom reports that we referenced
- 11:56from early in the 2000s and 1999. in the
- 12:00middle you can see a strategy around
- 12:03promoting effective coordination and
- 12:05communication of care that's something
- 12:07we've been working on for quite some
- 12:08time and we continue to face challenges
- 12:11in that area especially as new digital
- 12:14Communications are introduced and we
- 12:16have new ways to communicate with one
- 12:17another in various forms and then
- 12:20finally over there on the right you can
- 12:22see a dollar sign so once again we are
- 12:25thinking of high value care and when we
- 12:27do that we have different elements of
- 12:29quality that play into it but cost is
- 12:31also part of the Asian
- 12:33so now that we've been talking about
- 12:35various elements of quality you may be
- 12:37asking yourself about how we track
- 12:39meaningful change on the priorities that
- 12:42we just discussed and other elements of
- 12:44quality well the way that we do that is
- 12:46actually through measurement you're
- 12:48going to learn a lot more about
- 12:49measurement in upcoming sections of this
- 12:52course but for now I'd like to tell you
- 12:54about two measure resources from the
- 12:56centers for Medicare and Medicaid
- 12:58services or CMS
- 13:00the first is Meaningful measures 2.0
- 13:03which was launched in 2022 and it builds
- 13:07on the original meaningful measures
- 13:08initiative from 2017. meaningful
- 13:11measures 2.0 includes a set of goals
- 13:14which are intended to facilitate and
- 13:16move towards value-based care and it
- 13:18targets issues that are probably going
- 13:20to sound very familiar to you and those
- 13:22include patient-centered care safety
- 13:25chronic condition seamless care
- 13:27coordination Equity affordability and
- 13:31efficiency wellness and prevention and
- 13:33Behavioral Health so we're seeing a lot
- 13:35of themes here between the nqs the
- 13:38triple aim and the quintuple aim carried
- 13:40through into the meaningful measures 2.0
- 13:42initiative
- 13:43the initiative also does emphasize the
- 13:46importance of the patient in caregiver
- 13:48voice across CMS programs
- 13:50the second resource and that you can see
- 13:52a screenshot here on the slide of is the
- 13:55measures management system blueprint
- 13:57this provides an overview of quality
- 13:59measure development implementation and
- 14:02maintenance and each section includes
- 14:04information about important steps that
- 14:06are associated with a given stage in the
- 14:09measure life cycle this measure life
- 14:11cycle actually aligns very closely with
- 14:13ours here at pqa which you will learn
- 14:15learn about in more detail soon
- 14:20okay we are almost to the end of our
- 14:23quality journey and for now I'd like to
- 14:25take a moment and introduce you to a
- 14:27sampling of organizations that play a
- 14:29role in healthcare quality
- 14:31you can see organizations here such as
- 14:33the Joint Commission which is
- 14:35responsible for Hospital accreditation
- 14:37and patient safety also there are some
- 14:40measure development developers including
- 14:42ncqa which is responsible for the
- 14:45creation and maintenance of hedis
- 14:46measures as well of course uh pqa which
- 14:49is focused on medication use quality the
- 14:52LeapFrog group is another group here
- 14:54that is on the slide and they are a
- 14:56non-profit who reports Hospital quality
- 14:58and safety data
- 15:00as we wrap up our journey you can use
- 15:02the framework that you see here on this
- 15:04slide to help you think about how all
- 15:06the different pieces are fitting
- 15:08together
- 15:09at the base of this framework our
- 15:10performance measures which help us to
- 15:13assess opportunities to improve quality
- 15:15of care
- 15:16off to the left you can see clinical
- 15:18practice which is both influenced by
- 15:21performance measures and also itself can
- 15:23influence performance measures
- 15:26that's at the next level performance
- 15:28measures are rolled into measurement
- 15:29programs and then finally measurement
- 15:32programs allow us to assess the overall
- 15:34quality of care that an entity provides
- 15:38all right we are now at the end of our
- 15:40quality Journey which is leading us to
- 15:42the value equation as we are closing the
- 15:45door on volume-based care we are opening
- 15:48it to value-based outcomes and the
- 15:50essence of value is captured by the
- 15:53value equation which is value equals
- 15:56quality over cost
- 15:57as we discussed earlier the goal is to
- 16:00provide high quality care that both
- 16:03increases for high value care that both
- 16:05increases quality and while decreasing
- 16:07cost and as some of the early graphs in
- 16:10this presentation showed you we have
- 16:11ample opportunities to do both of these
- 16:14things in the United States
- 16:15we have accomplished a lot in the last
- 16:1820 plus years but there is still much
- 16:20work to be done I hope you enjoyed
- 16:22learning about the state of Healthcare
- 16:24in the United States and that our
- 16:25journey through the history of
- 16:27healthcare quality has built a solid
- 16:28foundation for your future learnings
- 16:30thank you for joining me for the role of
- 16:32quality measurement in healthcare
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of The Role of Quality Measurement in Healthcare by PQA, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,697 words across 434 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.