YouTube2Text

The Risk Factors Nvidia Forgot to Mention — Transcript

by Patrick Boyle · 5,553 words · 838 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00Nvidia has begun its search for a new
  2. 0:02chief executive. And I've always
  3. 0:04believed that you should dress for the
  4. 0:06job that you want. So, this is my new
  5. 0:09look. I'm told that the board will be
  6. 0:11considering both internal and external
  7. 0:14applicants. If you haven't been
  8. 0:16following the news, Jensen Hong, who
  9. 0:18co-founded Nvidia in a Denny's
  10. 0:20restaurant in 1993, and who is the only
  11. 0:24boss that the company has ever had,
  12. 0:26resigned on Thursday. This all started
  13. 0:29in late October when the New York Times
  14. 0:32reported that US intelligence agencies
  15. 0:35believe a Chinese citizen named Alice
  16. 0:37Wong, no relation, who had grown close
  17. 0:40to Jensen, was passing information to
  18. 0:43Beijing. A week later, the Times
  19. 0:46reported that she had been recruited by
  20. 0:49China's main spy agency. Nvidia said his
  21. 0:53interactions with her were not unusual
  22. 0:56or unexpected. On November 8th, Jensen
  23. 1:00admitted to an affair. On Wednesday, the
  24. 1:03Times reported a second affair with an
  25. 1:05Nvidia executive who reported directly
  26. 1:08to him. The board met late into the
  27. 1:11night, and on Thursday morning, he was
  28. 1:13gone. A few hours later, Reuters
  29. 1:16reported a third relationship with
  30. 1:18another Nvidia employee. Although by
  31. 1:21that point it was mostly of interest to
  32. 1:23historians.
  33. 1:25China denies the spying allegations and
  34. 1:28so far nobody has been charged with any
  35. 1:30crimes. But since the first New York
  36. 1:33Times story in late October, Nvidia
  37. 1:36stock has fallen by more than 20%. A
  38. 1:39company worth $4 trillion at the center
  39. 1:42of the entire AI boom has just lost the
  40. 1:46only boss it ever had. And it turns out
  41. 1:49that it had no plan for what happens
  42. 1:51next. And that's before we get to the
  43. 1:5450,000 chips that nobody can account for
  44. 1:57or the fact that Nvidia had become the
  45. 2:00central bank of the AI industry. Now,
  46. 2:03every public company has to include a
  47. 2:06section in its filings called risk
  48. 2:08factors, a list of all of the things
  49. 2:10that could go wrong. This is a legal
  50. 2:13requirement. The SEC's rules say that
  51. 2:16the list should cover the risks that are
  52. 2:18material to that particular company and
  53. 2:21that they have to be disclosed in plain
  54. 2:23English, a language that the lawyers
  55. 2:26don't speak. In practice, they try to
  56. 2:29list every possible outcome up to and
  57. 2:31including asteroid strikes partially to
  58. 2:34inform investors, but mostly so that if
  59. 2:37an asteroid does hit, nobody can say
  60. 2:40that they weren't warned. The rules even
  61. 2:42set aside a section at the end called
  62. 2:45general risk factors for the really
  63. 2:47generic ones that could apply to any
  64. 2:50company, which I assume is where the
  65. 2:52asteroid strike bit goes. Some companies
  66. 2:55are surprisingly straightforward. As the
  67. 2:58FT's editorial board pointed out,
  68. 3:01SpaceX's perspectus says that if Elon
  69. 3:03Musk were to leave, there's no assurance
  70. 3:06that it could find a suitable
  71. 3:08replacement in a timely manner or at
  72. 3:11all, which is honest of them. Nvidia's
  73. 3:14lawyers haven't been idle either. In
  74. 3:17August, as the FT noted, Nvidia added a
  75. 3:20warning that its growing pile of loan
  76. 3:22guarantees and investment commitments
  77. 3:25could expose us to financial
  78. 3:27counterparty and execution risks. So,
  79. 3:30somebody is keeping these disclosures up
  80. 3:33to date. But given the events of the
  81. 3:36last two weeks, it does seem like they
  82. 3:38missed a few. The FT's Lex column
  83. 3:41suggested this week that companies
  84. 3:43should be a lot more precise in their
  85. 3:45risk factors about how much their
  86. 3:48founders actually matter. So, in the
  87. 3:51spirit of being helpful, I've drafted
  88. 3:53some of the risk factors that Nvidia
  89. 3:56appears to have left out. I'll bring
  90. 3:58them up as we go through this story
  91. 4:00written in the plain English that the
  92. 4:02SEC requires so that whoever ends up
  93. 4:05running the world's most valuable chip
  94. 4:08company can paste them straight into the
  95. 4:10next filing. It's the least I can do.
  96. 4:13Before we dig into that though, a quick
  97. 4:15word from this week's video sponsor,
  98. 4:17Plaude. My best ideas don't often come
  99. 4:20to me when I'm sitting at my desk. They
  100. 4:23show up on a walk in the car or halfway
  101. 4:26through doing something else entirely.
  102. 4:28And by the time I find a pen and paper,
  103. 4:30they can be gone. That's what the plot
  104. 4:32note pin S is for. It's a tiny wearable
  105. 4:35AI noteaker that you can clip onto your
  106. 4:38jacket, wear on a lanyard, or put on
  107. 4:40your wrist. When a thought hits, I press
  108. 4:42the button and just say it out loud. If
  109. 4:45I ramble before landing on the good
  110. 4:47part, a quick press flags that moment.
  111. 4:50The Plaude app turns it all into clean,
  112. 4:52searchable notes with a to-do list and
  113. 4:55even a mind map of how your ideas
  114. 4:57connect. Weeks later, I can ask Plaude,
  115. 5:00"What was that idea I had about?" and it
  116. 5:02pulls it straight up. The thinking is
  117. 5:05still mine. Plaude just makes sure that
  118. 5:07I don't lose it. If you'd prefer not to
  119. 5:09wear anything, the Plaude Note Pro does
  120. 5:12the same job from the back of your
  121. 5:13phone. It supports both in-person
  122. 5:16conversations and phone calls. My
  123. 5:18favorite use is taking this thing on a
  124. 5:20walk without my cell phone and just
  125. 5:23talking and thinking out loud. It's
  126. 5:25credit card sized and runs for up to 50
  127. 5:27hours on a single charge. What's more,
  128. 5:30everything syncs to the desktop app,
  129. 5:32too, so it's all there when I'm back at
  130. 5:34my computer. Your notes stay private,
  131. 5:37too. Plaude is compliant with GDPR,
  132. 5:40HIPPA, and SOCK, too. It comes with a
  133. 5:4230-day free return policy, so you can
  134. 5:45try it and see for yourself. Click or
  135. 5:48scan and use the code PE boil at
  136. 5:50checkout for up to 22% off your order.
  137. 5:53So, how does the boss of a company that
  138. 5:56makes up roughly 7% of the S&P 500, end
  139. 6:00up in this position? Well, the woman at
  140. 6:03the center of the story, Alice Huang,
  141. 6:05reportedly started out as a journalist
  142. 6:08at CCTV, China's state broadcaster. Now
  143. 6:12in most countries CCTV is something that
  144. 6:14watches you but in China you can also
  145. 6:17watch it. Then she worked for a few
  146. 6:20years in finance and in 2023 took
  147. 6:23control of Mega Speed a Singapore
  148. 6:26offshoot of a Chinese video game company
  149. 6:29which she turned into an AI cloud
  150. 6:31provider that went on to buy billions of
  151. 6:34dollars worth of Nvidia chips. Around
  152. 6:37the same time, she started calling
  153. 6:38herself Alice Wong, the Cantonese
  154. 6:41spelling of the same surname. As the FT
  155. 6:44points out, Chinese business people
  156. 6:46sometimes do this so that their names
  157. 6:48don't turn up when someone searches
  158. 6:50English language company records. She
  159. 6:53and Jensen were photographed together
  160. 6:55several times from 2024 onwards in
  161. 6:59Taipei, Hong Kong, and California, often
  162. 7:02with other AI executives. This spring, a
  163. 7:05classified memo put together under the
  164. 7:08supervision of Secretary of State Marco
  165. 7:10Rubio concluded that China's main spy
  166. 7:14agency had recruited her to keep tabs on
  167. 7:17Jensen and on American chip technology.
  168. 7:20In May, according to the New York Times,
  169. 7:23Rubio briefed the president on the
  170. 7:26intelligence shortly before Jensen
  171. 7:28joined him on Air Force One for a trip
  172. 7:30to Beijing. So, the intelligence
  173. 7:33briefing and the subject of the
  174. 7:35intelligence briefing both ended up on
  175. 7:38the same plane. The president has since
  176. 7:40said that Jensen told him that he didn't
  177. 7:43know she was a spy and if he had known
  178. 7:46she wouldn't have been a very good spy,
  179. 7:48right? But we'll come back to who in
  180. 7:52Washington knew what a little later. The
  181. 7:55AI industry is well aware that it is a
  182. 7:58target. According to the Wall Street
  183. 8:00Journal, Open AI trains its staff to
  184. 8:03watch out for honeypotss, spies who use
  185. 8:06romance to get close to a target. And it
  186. 8:09illustrates the risk with a story about
  187. 8:11a US diplomat in Russia. First, the spy
  188. 8:14sent a blonde woman to his hotel room
  189. 8:16with champagne. When he declined, they
  190. 8:18sent a red head. When that didn't work,
  191. 8:21they sent a young man. Classic AB
  192. 8:24testing. intelligence services were
  193. 8:27optimizing conversion rates long before
  194. 8:29Silicon Valley. Now, what interests me
  195. 8:32about these allegations is how Nvidia
  196. 8:35handled them because its reassurance
  197. 8:37machine was running at full speed. When
  198. 8:41the New York Times first reported the
  199. 8:43story on October 29th, Nvidia said that
  200. 8:46Jensen's interactions with Ms. Wong were
  201. 8:49not unusual or unexpected and that
  202. 8:52Jensen talks with thousands of customer
  203. 8:54executives every year, which is
  204. 8:57reasonable, but most of us managed to
  205. 9:00meet our clients without any of them
  206. 9:01becoming the subject of a classified
  207. 9:04memo. Jensen told Bloomberg that it was
  208. 9:07all completely normal and not unusual.
  209. 9:11Inside the company, Nvidia's general
  210. 9:13council, Tim Teter, who according to the
  211. 9:16FT wears a leather jacket to work just
  212. 9:19like Jensen's, which I'm told is very
  213. 9:22good for your career prospects at
  214. 9:24Nvidia, told colleagues that the affair
  215. 9:27claims were wrong and that the people
  216. 9:29behind those rumors were just laundering
  217. 9:32salacious gossip. Then on Friday the
  218. 9:356th, the FT reported that US
  219. 9:38intelligence believed the relationship
  220. 9:40had been a romantic one. According to
  221. 9:43Bloomberg, Teter went to Jensen's house
  222. 9:46to ask him about it and Jensen
  223. 9:48confessed. So the gossip had been
  224. 9:51laundered and it came out clean. On
  225. 9:54Sunday, Jensen emailed the entire
  226. 9:57company to say that he had been
  227. 9:59unfaithful to his wife. On Tuesday,
  228. 10:01according to the FT, he gathered his
  229. 10:04team to plan his next big keynote speech
  230. 10:07and told them that it's going to be the
  231. 10:09best one ever. By Thursday, he was gone
  232. 10:13and we'll never get to hear that speech.
  233. 10:16The thing is that as far as securities
  234. 10:19law is concerned, a CEO's love life is
  235. 10:21his own business. As Anne Lipton, a
  236. 10:24corporate law professor at the
  237. 10:25University of Colorado, told CNN, "You
  238. 10:28can have as many affairs with Chinese
  239. 10:30spies as you want under federal law. You
  240. 10:33just can't lie about it." Which means
  241. 10:36that every one of those reassuring
  242. 10:38statements is possibly now being read
  243. 10:40very carefully by shareholder lawyers.
  244. 10:43By Monday morning, at least one law firm
  245. 10:46had already announced that it was
  246. 10:48investigating claims on behalf of Nvidia
  247. 10:51investors. As Matt Lavine would tell
  248. 10:53you, everything is securities fraud. So
  249. 10:57risk factor number one, our chief
  250. 11:00executives extracurricular activities
  251. 11:02may become the subject of classified
  252. 11:04intelligence memos. Statements made by
  253. 11:07the company about these activities
  254. 11:09should not be relied upon and may have a
  255. 11:12useful life of approximately 10 days.
  256. 11:16Every company should probably add that
  257. 11:18one to their filings. Now, it's worth
  258. 11:21remembering that none of this has been
  259. 11:23proven. Alice Hang hasn't been charged
  260. 11:26with anything and China denies the
  261. 11:28spying allegations. But for Nvidia,
  262. 11:32there are two very different stories
  263. 11:34here. If she was a spy, then the boss of
  264. 11:37America's most strategically important
  265. 11:39company spent years getting close to a
  266. 11:42Chinese intelligence asset, which is
  267. 11:44extremely embarrassing. If she was just
  268. 11:47a smuggler, it's a lot less
  269. 11:49embarrassing, but potentially a lot more
  270. 11:52expensive because then the question
  271. 11:54becomes how billions of dollars worth of
  272. 11:56Nvidia chips ended up in China. So, how
  273. 12:00did a Singaporean shell company manage
  274. 12:03to buy billions of dollars worth of
  275. 12:05export restricted American hardware? And
  276. 12:08whose job was it to stop it? Well, the
  277. 12:11rules said that the most advanced chips
  278. 12:13couldn't go to China. They didn't say
  279. 12:16that China couldn't come to the chips.
  280. 12:19Mega Speed's data centers were mostly in
  281. 12:22Malaysia, right next door to Singapore,
  282. 12:24and it rented the computing power out to
  283. 12:27Chinese customers, most notably Alibaba.
  284. 12:31That kind of offshore rental arrangement
  285. 12:33is totally legal. The Biden
  286. 12:36administration wrote a rule to restrict
  287. 12:38it which was due to take effect in May
  288. 12:402025 and the Trump administration
  289. 12:43cancelled it before it came into effect.
  290. 12:46The loophole managed to outlive two
  291. 12:48administrations which in its own way is
  292. 12:51a kind of bipartisanship.
  293. 12:53Mega Speed's ownership is a little hard
  294. 12:56to follow. Alice Wang took control of it
  295. 12:59in 2023 and then it was sold to a
  296. 13:02company owned by a Singaporean national.
  297. 13:05As Bloomberg's Mckenzie Hawkins
  298. 13:07explained it, Mega Speed is 100%
  299. 13:10Singapore owned but by a shell. 4 days
  300. 13:14after that sale, Nvidia made it an
  301. 13:17official cloud partner which comes with
  302. 13:19preferred access to the most sought
  303. 13:21after hardware on the planet. At the end
  304. 13:24of 2023, according to Bloomberg, Mega
  305. 13:28Speed had about $5.7 million in the
  306. 13:31bank. Over the next 2 years, it imported
  307. 13:35more than $4.6 billion worth of Nvidia
  308. 13:38hardware. So, where did the money come
  309. 13:41from? Part of the answer is Alibaba,
  310. 13:45which advanced Mega Speed money with
  311. 13:47Mega Speed's entire Malaysian business
  312. 13:50put up as collateral. Where did the rest
  313. 13:52come from? Well, that's still an open
  314. 13:54question. But remember that word
  315. 13:57collateral. It comes back later. This
  316. 14:00all brings us to the question of whose
  317. 14:03job it was to check. When Washington
  318. 14:05grew concerned that Mega Speed might be
  319. 14:08passing chips onto China, it asked
  320. 14:10Nvidia to go and have a look. Nvidia
  321. 14:13visited its data centers and reported
  322. 14:16back that the hardware was all accounted
  323. 14:18for. But when Hawkins and her colleagues
  324. 14:21at Bloomberg compared Nvidia numbers
  325. 14:24with Malaysian and Indonesian trade
  326. 14:27records, they found that about 50,000
  327. 14:30chips were missing. Now, there's always
  328. 14:33a slight problem with asking a salesman
  329. 14:35to audit one of his own customers.
  330. 14:38Jensen told Bloomberg TV that the
  331. 14:40company had chased down every single
  332. 14:43concern and found no diversion. And an
  333. 14:47Nvidia spokesperson said that a
  334. 14:49startup's growth plan in a friendly
  335. 14:51nation is an opportunity for America,
  336. 14:54not a red flag to be feared, which is an
  337. 14:58optimistic way of describing a 50,000
  338. 15:00chip discrepancy. As Tracy Aloway
  339. 15:03pointed out on the OddLocks podcast, if
  340. 15:06demand for Nvidia chips is really as
  341. 15:08strong as the company keeps telling us,
  342. 15:11it can afford to be a bit choosy about
  343. 15:13who it sells them to. Nvidia says that
  344. 15:16it put Megape on its internal block list
  345. 15:20in June 2025.
  346. 15:22Five months later, according to
  347. 15:24Malaysian trade records, Mega Speed
  348. 15:26somehow imported 17,544
  349. 15:30of Nvidia's topof the range GB300 chips
  350. 15:34worth about $787 million. And as of this
  351. 15:39week, Bloomberg reports that Mega Speed
  352. 15:42is still listed as an official Nvidia
  353. 15:45cloud provider. Nvidia's block list, it
  354. 15:48seems, works a bit like the unsubscribe
  355. 15:51button on a marketing email. In fairness
  356. 15:54to Nvidia, it says that it asked
  357. 15:57Washington whether it needed to cut Mega
  358. 15:59Speed off and was told no. Now,
  359. 16:02Washington wasn't doing much about Mega
  360. 16:05Speed either. It never made it onto the
  361. 16:07commerce department's trade blacklist
  362. 16:10even though the Pentagon, the State
  363. 16:12Department, and the Treasury were
  364. 16:14reportedly pushing for it. According to
  365. 16:17Axios, Scott Bent asked Commerce
  366. 16:20Secretary Howard Lutnik in the situation
  367. 16:22room why Mega Speed wasn't on the list.
  368. 16:26Commerce denies that this conversation
  369. 16:28took place and Lutnik is reported to
  370. 16:31have worried that new restrictions could
  371. 16:33upset the trade truths with China.
  372. 16:36Nvidia also had a direct line to the top
  373. 16:40of the department. According to
  374. 16:42Bloomberg and the New York Times, in the
  375. 16:44summer of 2025, Tim Teter, our other
  376. 16:48friend in the leather jacket, called
  377. 16:50Jeffrey Kesler, the Commerce Department
  378. 16:53official in charge of export controls,
  379. 16:56to ask about the Mega Speed
  380. 16:57investigation. In the weeks that
  381. 16:59followed, the investigators on the case
  382. 17:02were told that any contact with Nvidia
  383. 17:05had to go through Kesler. And when one
  384. 17:08of them turned down a meeting with
  385. 17:10Teter, he wrote back saying that Kesler
  386. 17:12had given him permission to talk to
  387. 17:14them. So the investigators checked with
  388. 17:18their boss who told them to handle the
  389. 17:20case by the book. They replied 104.
  390. 17:24Thank you. Nvidia says that Teter didn't
  391. 17:28know about the affair at the time. You
  392. 17:31might be wondering how you actually
  393. 17:33smuggle an AI server across a border.
  394. 17:36And if you listen to that OddLots
  395. 17:38episode, you'll know that it isn't a guy
  396. 17:41in a trench coat with chips sewn into
  397. 17:43the lining. As Jensen Hong pointed out,
  398. 17:46while dismissing the idea that smuggling
  399. 17:48was a problem, Nvidia's most advanced
  400. 17:51system, Grace Blackwell, weighs about
  401. 17:54two tons. So, you're not putting that in
  402. 17:56your backpack anytime soon. The reality
  403. 17:59is a lot more bureaucratic and mostly
  404. 18:02involves filling out customs forms
  405. 18:05creatively. In one case where one person
  406. 18:08has already pleaded guilty, restricted
  407. 18:11Nvidia hardware was declared as adapter
  408. 18:14modules. As Hawkins pointed out, that's
  409. 18:17the category for the little thing you
  410. 18:19use to plug your haird dryer into it, a
  411. 18:21foreign wall socket. These ones just
  412. 18:24happen to weigh 2,000 lb. And in March,
  413. 18:27Super Micro's co-founder Wally Liao was
  414. 18:31indicted for allegedly running a $2.5
  415. 18:34billion dollar smuggling operation just
  416. 18:37days after watching Jensen sign Super
  417. 18:40Micro Servers with a gold Sharpie and
  418. 18:42write Super Micro is Super. The case
  419. 18:46against him includes a blurry CCTV image
  420. 18:50of a woman in a Southeast Asian
  421. 18:52warehouse peeling serial number stickers
  422. 18:54off server boxes with a red hair dryer,
  423. 18:58which I suppose is what the adapter
  424. 19:01modules were for. Liao has pleaded not
  425. 19:04guilty. Then there's Mega Speed's own
  426. 19:08investor presentation which showed off
  427. 19:10its largest AI facility located in a
  428. 19:14specific area. The architectural
  429. 19:17rendering turned out to match the Yangy
  430. 19:19River Delta project, a big data center
  431. 19:22in Shanghai whose president is a
  432. 19:25longtime business partner of Alysses.
  433. 19:28Half a kilometer away, a company called
  434. 19:31Shanghai Shu Yao was advertising for
  435. 19:35engineers to work on H100's and H200s,
  436. 19:39the band Nvidia chips. Its website was
  437. 19:42almost an exact copy of one of Meg
  438. 19:45Speeds, right down to Megape's name
  439. 19:48appearing in the website source code.
  440. 19:50Did any chips actually make it to
  441. 19:53Shanghai? According to documents that
  442. 19:55Bloomberg reported on this week, the
  443. 19:57answer appears to be yes. A unit of a
  444. 20:00company Alice founded a decade ago
  445. 20:03listed restricted Dell and Super Micro
  446. 20:06Servers installed at that data center as
  447. 20:09collateral for loans in filings with the
  448. 20:11Chinese central bank's credit registry.
  449. 20:14Which means that in Malaysia, the
  450. 20:17business was the collateral for the
  451. 20:19chips. And in Shanghai, the chips were
  452. 20:21the collateral for the business. You'd
  453. 20:24only pledge something like that if you
  454. 20:26were fairly confident that nobody was
  455. 20:28going to come and take it away. To be
  456. 20:31fair to Alice, she gave up her stake in
  457. 20:34that company in 2017. And the filings
  458. 20:37don't show whether she was involved or
  459. 20:40not. Now, what does all of this cost
  460. 20:42Nvidia? So far, the Justice Department
  461. 20:45is investigating Mega Speed, not Nvidia.
  462. 20:49And Megape has categorically denied
  463. 20:52smuggling anything. But as the FT's
  464. 20:55Robert Armstrong put it this week,
  465. 20:57Nvidia will no longer receive the
  466. 20:59benefit of the Dow from Washington.
  467. 21:02Three bipartisan bills are now moving
  468. 21:04through Congress and Commerce is
  469. 21:06reportedly finalizing a rule to close
  470. 21:09the rent the chips from abroad route,
  471. 21:12which means there will be fewer places
  472. 21:14for Nvidia chips to end up. According to
  473. 21:17CNBC, the people moving smuggled chips
  474. 21:20into China have already been told to
  475. 21:23take a break until next week. So, it
  476. 21:26seems that they've been reading the
  477. 21:27news, too. The irony is that this
  478. 21:31scandal hasn't been all bad news for
  479. 21:33Chinese tech. Chinese AI stocks sold off
  480. 21:37on this news, but Chinese chip makers
  481. 21:40like Cambercon rallied by more than 20%
  482. 21:43this week as investors concluded that
  483. 21:46Chinese companies will now have to build
  484. 21:48this stuff themselves. As Tilly Jang, an
  485. 21:52analyst at Gavacol Dragonomics, pointed
  486. 21:54out, the US and Chinese governments both
  487. 21:58agree that US chips should not be used
  488. 22:00in China. It's always good to see two
  489. 22:04global superpowers find common ground.
  490. 22:08So, risk factor number two, our products
  491. 22:11weigh approximately 2 tons and cannot be
  492. 22:14carried in a backpack. They may however
  493. 22:17be declared to customs as adapter
  494. 22:19modules.
  495. 22:21Now, smuggling aside, Nvidia
  496. 22:23shareholders spent the week worrying
  497. 22:26about a much simpler question. What
  498. 22:28happens to a company when its boss
  499. 22:31suddenly isn't there? Some companies are
  500. 22:34remarkably specific about this. Meta's
  501. 22:37annual report warns investors that Mark
  502. 22:40Zuckerberg takes part in combat sports,
  503. 22:43extreme sports, and recreational
  504. 22:45aviation, all of which carry a risk of
  505. 22:48serious injury. Jensen, as far as we
  506. 22:51know, isn't a cage fighter. The risk he
  507. 22:54posed to Nvidia shareholders was a
  508. 22:56different kind. He ran Nvidia with
  509. 22:59around 60 executives reporting directly
  510. 23:02to him, which is far more than the
  511. 23:05typical CEO. And everyone at the company
  512. 23:08was expected to write a regular top five
  513. 23:11things email, which Jensen would dip
  514. 23:13into, reportedly reading around a
  515. 23:16hundred of them a day. By most accounts,
  516. 23:19it worked brilliantly. It's credited
  517. 23:21with helping him spot the AI opportunity
  518. 23:24early. The catch is that it's a system
  519. 23:27with exactly one person at the center
  520. 23:30and there was no succession plan. When
  521. 23:33Apple replaced Tim Cook this year, it
  522. 23:36announced the change in April, spent the
  523. 23:38whole summer on the handover and then
  524. 23:41kept Cook on as chairman just in case.
  525. 23:44As the economist put it, Nvidia's
  526. 23:47succession plan lasted 4 days.
  527. 23:50Bloomberg's Beth Cowat made an
  528. 23:52interesting point about this. Founders
  529. 23:55like Steve Jobs and Jeff Bezos seemed
  530. 23:58irreplaceable, but their companies did
  531. 24:00just fine without them because they'd
  532. 24:03spent years building businesses that
  533. 24:05could carry on without them. Jensen, she
  534. 24:08argues, built Nvidia around himself. As
  535. 24:11a Harvard Business School professor told
  536. 24:14her, "The difference between a cult and
  537. 24:16a religion is that one outlasts the
  538. 24:19other." So, how much was Jensen actually
  539. 24:22worth to Nvidia? Robert Armstrong at the
  540. 24:25FT looked at it from the market side. He
  541. 24:28borrowed an idea from baseball called
  542. 24:30wins over replacement, which measures
  543. 24:33how much better a player is than whoever
  544. 24:36you could get in to replace them. Since
  545. 24:39the scandal broke, Nvidia has lost about
  546. 24:42$1.1 trillion in market value. And as
  547. 24:45Armstrong wrote, it's absurd to suggest
  548. 24:48Hang's wins over replacement came
  549. 24:51anywhere near $1.1 trillion. Steve Jobs
  550. 24:55defined Apple even more than Jensen Hong
  551. 24:57defined Nvidia. And Apple has added
  552. 25:00almost $5 trillion in value since he
  553. 25:03died. So, the market isn't really
  554. 25:06mourning the loss of Jensen's talent.
  555. 25:09It's pricing in the damage. Governments
  556. 25:12now have a reason to distrust Nvidia.
  557. 25:15Customers have even more reason to hedge
  558. 25:17their bets with its competitors. And
  559. 25:20whoever runs it next will spend a lot of
  560. 25:23their time on repairs. And as Armstrong
  561. 25:26says, if you add all of that up, you
  562. 25:29might get to something like $1.1
  563. 25:31trillion worth of damage. All of this is
  564. 25:34supposed to be the board's problem.
  565. 25:37Shareholders elect a board of directors
  566. 25:39to hire, supervise, and when necessary,
  567. 25:42fire the CEO on their behalf. An
  568. 25:45executive recruiter told Bloomberg that
  569. 25:48the board of every big company should be
  570. 25:50able to answer three questions on an
  571. 25:52ordinary Tuesday morning. If the CEO
  572. 25:56doesn't come in on Wednesday, who are
  573. 25:58the three people who could step in? What
  574. 26:00are we paying them to stay? And who do
  575. 26:03we call to replace them if we lose them?
  576. 26:05As he pointed out, Nvidia had 33 years
  577. 26:09to prepare for this. So, who was on this
  578. 26:13board? Nvidia's directors have been
  579. 26:15there for about 15 years on average,
  580. 26:18which is roughly double the S&P 500
  581. 26:21average. None of them is a current or
  582. 26:24former S&P 500 CEO. They do however
  583. 26:28include a former pro- football marketer
  584. 26:31and a former president of Taco Bell.
  585. 26:35Both are demanding and highly skilled
  586. 26:37jobs, but they don't necessarily prepare
  587. 26:40you for understanding semiconductors or
  588. 26:43for overseeing export controls on the
  589. 26:46technology that people in Washington now
  590. 26:48compare to the Manhattan project. James
  591. 26:51Drury, whose firm ranks the
  592. 26:54effectiveness of corporate boards, put
  593. 26:56Nvidia 609th out of about 650 companies
  594. 27:01and told Bloomberg that it was a
  595. 27:03pathetic board. Nvidia doesn't even have
  596. 27:06an official chief compliance officer.
  597. 27:09The job is done unofficially by the
  598. 27:12general counsel at a company that sells
  599. 27:15one of the most heavily export
  600. 27:16controlled products in the world. Then
  601. 27:19there's the family. Jensen's daughter
  602. 27:22and son both work at Nvidia, as does his
  603. 27:26daughter's husband. Their pay shows up
  604. 27:28in the company's proxy statement because
  605. 27:31SEC rules require companies to disclose
  606. 27:34any transactions worth more than
  607. 27:37$120,000
  608. 27:38with an executive's immediate family. In
  609. 27:41the last fiscal year, his daughter
  610. 27:43earned about $1.2 $2 million and his son
  611. 27:47about $1.3 million. Nvidia says they
  612. 27:50don't report to him and I'm not going to
  613. 27:53comment on how good they are at their
  614. 27:55jobs. The point is that when a
  615. 27:58founders's family is given senior roles,
  616. 28:00you need a board that's strong enough to
  617. 28:03push back when necessary. and his
  618. 28:06son-in-law now helps run Nvidia's
  619. 28:09program of financial guarantees for its
  620. 28:12customers, which we'll come back to
  621. 28:14shortly. For most of its history, Nvidia
  622. 28:17didn't even have a chair of the board at
  623. 28:20all. According to its proxy filings,
  624. 28:22this ensured that each member has an
  625. 28:25equal voice in the affairs and
  626. 28:27management of Nvidia, which in practice
  627. 28:30means that nobody's voice was quite as
  628. 28:33equal as Jensen's. This week, the board
  629. 28:36finally appointed its first ever chair.
  630. 28:39His name is Harvey Jones. He's been on
  631. 28:42Nvidia's board since 1993. He mentored
  632. 28:45Jensen when he was a 30-year-old CEO,
  633. 28:48and he owns more than a billion dollars
  634. 28:50worth of Nvidia stock. To top it off,
  635. 28:53last year, Nvidia invested $2 billion in
  636. 28:57Syopsis, the company that Jones used to
  637. 29:00run. So, if you were hoping for a fresh
  638. 29:03pair of eyes, that's not what you get.
  639. 29:06These are the same eyes. They've just
  640. 29:08been given a new chair. And now that
  641. 29:11board has an awkward problem when they
  642. 29:13investigate Huang. As Anne Lipton told
  643. 29:16CNN, the worse things they uncover, the
  644. 29:19more they're opening the company and
  645. 29:21Huang up to shareholder fraud lawsuits.
  646. 29:25So risk factor number three, we depend
  647. 29:29on the continued services of our founder
  648. 29:31who has approximately 60 direct reports
  649. 29:34and no designated successor. Our board
  650. 29:37has been meaning to look into this since
  651. 29:401993.
  652. 29:42Now a badly put together board is one
  653. 29:45thing. The bigger worry for the stock
  654. 29:47market is that the AI industry has just
  655. 29:49lost the man at the center of its
  656. 29:52financing. Nvidia sold the shovels for
  657. 29:55the AI gold rush, but over the last two
  658. 29:57years, it also financed the miners,
  659. 30:00backed their loans, and signed their
  660. 30:02leases. According to the FT, Nvidia had
  661. 30:05committed $124 billion to equity
  662. 30:08investments by the end of July and was
  663. 30:11doing a new deal roughly every 2 and 1/2
  664. 30:14days. As the FT's due diligence
  665. 30:16newsletter put it, Nvidia had become the
  666. 30:19central bank of AI. In the 1870s, the
  667. 30:23economist Walter Badget set out the
  668. 30:26classic rule for central banks in a
  669. 30:28crisis, which is usually summed up as
  670. 30:31lend freely against good collateral at a
  671. 30:34penalty rate. Jensen's version was a
  672. 30:37little bit different. Lend freely to the
  673. 30:40people buying your chips at whatever
  674. 30:42terms keep them buying. In central
  675. 30:44banking terms, Jensen was a dove. The
  676. 30:47Mario Draggy of the AI boom, willing to
  677. 30:51do whatever it takes. His chief
  678. 30:54financial officer, Colette Cres, was the
  679. 30:56hawk. According to the Wall Street
  680. 30:58Journal, when Nvidia started offering
  681. 31:01credit support to Upstart Cloud
  682. 31:03providers in exchange for a share of
  683. 31:05their revenue, a program that his
  684. 31:07son-in-law helped run, Crest asked
  685. 31:10awkward questions about how to choose
  686. 31:12the deals, how to value the guarantees,
  687. 31:15and what the return would be. Then in
  688. 31:18July, the Journal reported that Nvidia
  689. 31:21was considering a $250 billion backs
  690. 31:24stop for OpenAI's giant data center in
  691. 31:27Ohio. The next day, Nvidia stock fell by
  692. 31:315%, wiping out about $250 billion of
  693. 31:35market value. So, the market priced that
  694. 31:39one at roughly one for one. Crest
  695. 31:43reworked the deal and cut Nvidia's
  696. 31:45initial commitment in half. Jensen was
  697. 31:48reportedly not impressed. At a meeting
  698. 31:51in August, he interrupted her
  699. 31:53presentation to call her a deer in the
  700. 31:55headlights and complained that she was a
  701. 31:59reporting CFO rather than someone who
  702. 32:01could help him set strategy, which is an
  703. 32:04odd way to describe the person who was
  704. 32:07busy cutting your exposure to the
  705. 32:09biggest data center deal in history in
  706. 32:11half. Within weeks, though, Nvidia was
  707. 32:14moving in her direction. According to
  708. 32:17the journal, Nvidia paused some of its
  709. 32:20credit support deals and told cloud
  710. 32:22companies that new ones would now need
  711. 32:25sign off from senior management and the
  712. 32:27board. And in October at a conference in
  713. 32:30Berlin, Jensen told a table of cloud
  714. 32:33computing CEOs, some of his biggest
  715. 32:36customers, about a soup seller he'd once
  716. 32:39found in Japan with a long queue
  717. 32:41outside. When Jensen asked for a second
  718. 32:44bowl, the soupman said no because he had
  719. 32:47too many other customers waiting. The
  720. 32:50soupman, Jensen explained, didn't sell
  721. 32:52all of his soup to one or two customers.
  722. 32:55He kept his prices high and his
  723. 32:57customers varied. He's a better
  724. 32:59businessman than all of you. Jensen
  725. 33:02reportedly told them, "You are not
  726. 33:05establishing the value of my products."
  727. 33:08Now, this is a bold thing to say to the
  728. 33:10people who were buying your products
  729. 33:12partially with your money. So, the
  730. 33:15financing tap was already being turned
  731. 33:18down and now the dove has gone and the
  732. 33:21hawk is running the bank. That doesn't
  733. 33:24mean that the money stopped. Crest has
  734. 33:27publicly defended the deals. We know
  735. 33:29some will call this circular financing,
  736. 33:32she said in August. We see it
  737. 33:34differently, but it probably means that
  738. 33:37it gets a lot harder to borrow. Neocloud
  739. 33:41stocks like Core Wee fell sharply this
  740. 33:44week. Anthropic, on the other hand,
  741. 33:46doesn't look short of friends. Reuters
  742. 33:49reported this morning that its IPO is
  743. 33:51about six times overs subscribed with or
  744. 33:54without Nvidia's 10 billion.
  745. 33:57We'll learn a lot more on Tuesday when
  746. 34:00Crest reports Nvidia's earnings for the
  747. 34:03first time as chief executive.
  748. 34:05So risk factor number four, we are the
  749. 34:09lender of last resort and central bank
  750. 34:11to the AI industry. We've just replaced
  751. 34:14our governor. There is an irony in all
  752. 34:17of this. For the last few years, we've
  753. 34:20been warned that AI might one day slip
  754. 34:22beyond human control. and billionaires
  755. 34:24have spent a lot of time on podcasts
  756. 34:27arguing about the risks of misaligned
  757. 34:29algorithms. Rather, less time has been
  758. 34:32spent on misaligned executives. As the
  759. 34:35FT's editorial board put it this week,
  760. 34:38one important safeguard against
  761. 34:40autonomous AI models and agents running
  762. 34:43a mock is to involve people in their
  763. 34:45design, operation, and oversight. The
  764. 34:48Nvidia case, they wrote, makes clear the
  765. 34:51risk that senior humans in the loop can
  766. 34:54themselves become a dangerous liability.
  767. 34:57So far, the AI has behaved itself
  768. 35:00perfectly.
  769. 35:02Jensen has worn a black leather
  770. 35:05motorcycle jacket for at least 20 years.
  771. 35:07He told a CBS reporter that he always
  772. 35:10dresses the same because it removes
  773. 35:12three to four decisions from his day.
  774. 35:15>> Why do you adhere to the uniform?
  775. 35:17Because you don't, you know, black is
  776. 35:19the the absence of choice
  777. 35:21and and um it's nice to wear the same
  778. 35:24thing every day because because uh no
  779. 35:26surprises.
  780. 35:27>> No surprises.
  781. 35:27>> It all fits the same way, feels the same
  782. 35:30way.
  783. 35:30>> It's true.
  784. 35:31>> Yeah. Go focus on something else. That's
  785. 35:33one decision made, you know,
  786. 35:34>> one less thing to deal with.
  787. 35:35>> Yeah. For everybody else, they probably
  788. 35:36have to make three or four decisions. I
  789. 35:38took that off my plate. It's fantastic.
  790. 35:40>> It helps keep yourself focused on what
  791. 35:43matters.
  792. 35:43>> The moment I wake up, I could be
  793. 35:44thinking about important things. One of
  794. 35:46the jackets sold at Sabes this summer
  795. 35:49for $960,000.
  796. 35:52And a lot of other tech bosses have
  797. 35:54adopted the look, too. The die workear
  798. 35:57men'sswear rider Derek Guy points out
  799. 36:00that the black leather jacket started
  800. 36:02out as riding gear and became a symbol
  801. 36:05of rebellion in the 1950s. Think Marlon
  802. 36:09Brando in the Wild One. In Silicon
  803. 36:12Valley, you can't wear a suit. Instead,
  804. 36:14the very rich dress in the clothes of
  805. 36:17people with a lot less money, which as
  806. 36:19Paul Facel pointed out in his book,
  807. 36:21Class back in the 1980s, is a very
  808. 36:25American habit. A billionaire in a biker
  809. 36:27jacket gets to look like an outsider
  810. 36:30while sitting at the very center of
  811. 36:32power, which is also why I've spent this
  812. 36:35video dressed for Jensen's old job. The
  813. 36:39look is still tied to the idea that you
  814. 36:42have a motorcycle. In the Clash song,
  815. 36:45This Is England, Joe Strummer sings, I
  816. 36:48got my motorcycle jacket, but I'm
  817. 36:50walking all the time. The punks had
  818. 36:53every right to the jacket. They just
  819. 36:55couldn't afford the bike. Tech CEOs have
  820. 36:58the opposite problem. They can afford
  821. 37:00the bike and the designer version of the
  822. 37:02jacket that costs almost $9,000.
  823. 37:05What they can't buy is the credibility
  824. 37:08that's supposed to come with it. You can
  825. 37:10tell because the jackets always look
  826. 37:12brand new. This one has actually been on
  827. 37:16a motorcycle. I've been riding for about
  828. 37:1820 years and it has armor in the
  829. 37:20shoulders because it's built on the
  830. 37:23assumption that at some point something
  831. 37:25could actually go wrong, which is more
  832. 37:28planning than Nvidia's board managed. If
  833. 37:31you found this video interesting, you
  834. 37:33should watch my video on the Doomsday
  835. 37:35cult inside Open AI next. Don't forget
  836. 37:38to check out our sponsor, Plaude, using
  837. 37:40the link in the video description. See
  838. 37:43you in the next video. Bye.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of The Risk Factors Nvidia Forgot to Mention by Patrick Boyle, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,553 words across 838 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.