The Real Reason We Should Revive Extinct Animals — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Look at this. This is rare footage from
- 0:021933. You see this dog looking animal
- 0:04pacing back and forth in a cage. That's
- 0:06a Tasmanian tiger. One of the very last
- 0:09of its kind. It died in 1936. And the
- 0:12species was ultimately declared extinct.
- 0:15But now scientists are trying to bring
- 0:17them back. And it's not alone. You might
- 0:19have seen headlines about direwolves or
- 0:21woolly mammoths or dodo birds or
- 0:23passenger pigeons or dinosaurs.
- 0:25deextinction has become a new and urgent
- 0:29scientific debate that we should all
- 0:31know about. But when I took a deep dive
- 0:32into what's really going on here, I
- 0:35realized that we're getting this
- 0:36conversation very, very wrong. Because
- 0:39we're on the cusp of a huge genetic
- 0:42breakthrough. But the most huge if true
- 0:44thing happening here isn't actually
- 0:46bringing back extinct animals. It's what
- 0:48this means for all the animals alive
- 0:51today. And very few people seem to know
- 0:54about it.
- 0:55>> Deextinction.
- 0:56>> The extinction.
- 0:57>> Trying to bring back creatures from the
- 0:58past.
- 0:59>> We can do this.
- 0:59>> Resurrect the woolly mammoth.
- 1:01>> Direwolf.
- 1:01>> Tasmanian.
- 1:02>> It sounds like something out of a
- 1:03science fiction movie.
- 1:04>> It's no longer science fiction.
- 1:06>> That's the future.
- 1:09[Music]
- 1:13>> All right. Imagine you're a mad
- 1:15scientist and you want to bring back an
- 1:17extinct animal. Here's the recipe. Step
- 1:19one, choose your animal. like a mammoth.
- 1:22Now, from here, you need to choose one
- 1:23of three paths, and for each, you'll
- 1:25need different ingredients. You could
- 1:27try to take a close- living relative of
- 1:28the animal that you chose and breed a
- 1:30bunch of them together until you get an
- 1:32animal with traits that roughly match
- 1:34the one that you wanted. This is the
- 1:35same basic process that made my dog Thor
- 1:38out of a wolf. But instead of trying to
- 1:40make something new and adorable, you're
- 1:41trying to make something old. It's
- 1:43called back breeding, and it can work.
- 1:44Like with this guy, it's called a quaga.
- 1:46>> I actually have a little uh toy quaga
- 1:49right here. It's a subspecies of zebra
- 1:51native to South Africa.
- 1:52>> They have stripes on the head and neck
- 1:54and the stripes fade away along the
- 1:56body.
- 1:56>> It was hunted to extinction by 1883, but
- 1:59we've already been able to bring a
- 2:01version of it back using back breeding.
- 2:03This is a really exciting approach and
- 2:06it can work for both animals and plants,
- 2:08but it is incredibly slow. It takes many
- 2:12generations of zebra to get there and
- 2:14it's a guessing game. You don't know
- 2:15which genes will appear when and which
- 2:17will go away. In reality,
- 2:19>> it's a cool method that's been done, but
- 2:22probably pretty limited.
- 2:23>> Okay, but how about option two? I
- 2:24remember in Jurassic Park, they pulled
- 2:26dinosaur DNA from blood inside a
- 2:29fossilized mosquito.
- 2:31>> Bingo. Dino DNA.
- 2:34>> And then they cloned the animal based on
- 2:36that DNA.
- 2:37>> It's all part of the miracle of cloning.
- 2:39>> Cool. Let's do that. In real life,
- 2:41though, the ingredients that you need
- 2:42for this method aren't just the extinct
- 2:44animals DNA. You need a whole living
- 2:46cell. Because cloning is actually a very
- 2:48specific scientific technique.
- 2:49>> The long name is sematic cell nuclear
- 2:52transfer. It means removing the nucleus
- 2:55out of an egg cell and replacing it with
- 2:57the nucleus of a body or sematic cell of
- 2:59the animal you want to clone. And then
- 3:01you put that egg with its new nucleus
- 3:03into an animal where it can grow. And
- 3:06this actually works
- 3:09almost.
- 3:09>> People tried this in the early 2000s
- 3:12with an extinct species called the
- 3:14bukardo. These animals are so cool. But
- 3:17by 2000, there was only one Bicardo
- 3:20left. But luckily, this was 4 years
- 3:22after Dolly the sheep was famously
- 3:24successfully cloned. So, in an attempt
- 3:26to save the species, some quick-thinking
- 3:28biologists put tissue samples from the
- 3:30remaining Bicardo in storage. And then
- 3:31they were able to take the nucleus from
- 3:33those cells and put them into the cells
- 3:35of domestic goat hybrids. And in 2003, a
- 3:38baby Bicardo was born. Unfortunately,
- 3:41their first clone that was born had a
- 3:44malformed lung and didn't survive. Um,
- 3:47this hasn't been tried again.
- 3:48>> So, we are able to clone animals when we
- 3:51have living cells, which is wild. But
- 3:54unlike the bicardo, nobody carefully
- 3:56preserved the whole cells of a mammoth.
- 3:58The biggest challenge is needing those
- 4:00living cells in the first place. Because
- 4:02it turns out that cells have a shelf
- 4:04life. Once an animal dies, their cells
- 4:06are typically pretty shortlived, dying
- 4:08off within hours or days. But freezing
- 4:11can dramatically slow this process,
- 4:13which is why there's been hope that
- 4:14animals found preserved in ice, like
- 4:16this 40,000-year-old baby mammoth, might
- 4:20have some usable cells. But so far, no
- 4:22revivable cells have been found. So
- 4:25cloning is hard. But we've got one more
- 4:27option, and this one is by far the most
- 4:30popular.
- 4:30>> For the 99.99%
- 4:33of extinct species, we have to use the
- 4:35third method, gene editing. If you
- 4:38imagine DNA as a group of blocks, each
- 4:40block here could represent a gene. Like
- 4:42this one tells me the shape of the
- 4:43skull, and this one tells me ear size,
- 4:45and maybe this one tells me thick woolly
- 4:47coat. And then stacked together, they
- 4:49give me the instructions for how to
- 4:50build this specific animal. The
- 4:52challenge is like living cells have a
- 4:54shelf life. So does DNA. Once an animal
- 4:56dies, the DNA in its cells starts to
- 4:59break down into tinier and tinier and
- 5:01tinier fragments until eventually
- 5:03there's nothing left. That's why right
- 5:04now we can't bring back animals that
- 5:06went extinct too long ago, like the
- 5:08dinosaurs. Too much time has passed and
- 5:10their DNA is way too fragmented. But if
- 5:12we use an animal that died off fairly
- 5:14recently or was frozen in just the right
- 5:16way, scientists can figure out what some
- 5:18of those key missing pieces are and
- 5:20replicate this stack of blocks in
- 5:22another animal. This is gene editing.
- 5:24You compare the stack of DNA blocks of
- 5:26the extinct animal with the blocks of a
- 5:28close living relative to see where the
- 5:30two are different and edit the DNA in
- 5:32the living relative. So, it resembles
- 5:34the DNA in the extinct one. This is what
- 5:36they're trying to do with woolly
- 5:38mammoths and direwolves,
- 5:41but they won't be exactly like the
- 5:44extinct animal. In fact, people online
- 5:46were really quick to point out that
- 5:47these actually aren't really direwolves
- 5:50at all. It's better to think of them as
- 5:52genetically modified greywolves. But the
- 5:54thing is, that was intentional.
- 5:56Scientists are choosing which exact
- 5:58traits to manipulate to get the outcomes
- 5:59that they want. and they want to do it
- 6:01by making the least amount of edits
- 6:03possible. I asked the scientist in
- 6:05charge of the direwolf project why I'm
- 6:07thinking about deextinction and I'm also
- 6:09thinking about animal welfare. Every
- 6:10time we change the sequence of DNA in a
- 6:12genetic background, there's a risk that
- 6:15something happens that we didn't
- 6:16predict. I want healthy animals in the
- 6:18end. Therefore, my goal is the fewest
- 6:21number of changes necessary to
- 6:22de-extinct those important
- 6:25characteristics. So deextinction might
- 6:27have a branding problem because people
- 6:29on one side are looking at the literal
- 6:31definition and saying that's not
- 6:33de-extinction and they're right that's
- 6:35not the exact animal. But then on the
- 6:37other side of this you have scientists
- 6:38who are saying bringing back exact
- 6:40replicas isn't really the point. They're
- 6:42not trying to deextinct the exact
- 6:45animal. They're trying to deextinct what
- 6:48the animal did. In the end the whole
- 6:51direwolf or not direwolf debate doesn't
- 6:53really matter. Branding them this way
- 6:55makes for a good headline, but it's not
- 6:58technically accurate. And while the
- 6:59effort to bring back a version of a
- 7:01direwolf or a woolly mammoth is totally
- 7:03cool, I think it's a distraction from
- 7:06what is the real huge, if true, use of
- 7:10this technology. But first, let me show
- 7:12you something. This new phone case is
- 7:14special. It's not just that it's built
- 7:15with insane impact resistance and
- 7:17durability, or that it has a lifetime
- 7:19warranty against yellowing. Those things
- 7:21are important, but what's even more
- 7:22important is their mission to tackle
- 7:24plastic waste. Every year, 19 to 23
- 7:28million tons of plastic waste leaks into
- 7:31lakes and rivers and oceans. First, they
- 7:33plan to become plastic neutral. So, they
- 7:35built a closed loop model. The phone
- 7:37cases are 100% recyclable. You can send
- 7:40back your old phone case and they break
- 7:41it down and repurpose it into a brand
- 7:43new one, giving it a second or third or
- 7:45more life. It's even got a QR code on
- 7:48the inside so you can track the
- 7:49product's life cycle. But what they
- 7:51really wanted was to tackle all plastic
- 7:53waste, not just modern plastic, but also
- 7:55legacy and future plastic, too. What if
- 7:58you could take plastic waste out of the
- 8:00ocean, and then use or upcycle it?
- 8:03That's exactly what they do. They've
- 8:05built a solar powered floating platform
- 8:07that uses water jets to create pressure
- 8:09differences that guide floating garbage
- 8:11into its collection area. It's like a
- 8:13robot vacuum for ocean cleanup. This is
- 8:16new. They're testing it right now, but
- 8:18it's the kind of effort that I find
- 8:19really optimistic. Protecting your phone
- 8:21and protecting oceans, too. If you want
- 8:23to check it out, use the code cleo for
- 8:2510% off at the link in my description.
- 8:28There have been five times in the
- 8:30history of Earth where over 75% of all
- 8:32life was lost. And many scientists say
- 8:34we're going through a sixth right now.
- 8:36And while prior mass extinctions were
- 8:37caused by natural disasters, this one
- 8:40seems to be caused by us. But hang on,
- 8:42even if you don't care about animals and
- 8:44biodiversity, this sucks for us. This
- 8:47has huge impacts on our food and our
- 8:48homes and everything we rely on to
- 8:50survive. And here's the optimistic part.
- 8:52The same tools that we've been talking
- 8:54about to bring back extinct animals can
- 8:56also be used to help animals not go
- 8:58extinct in the first place. This is the
- 9:00part that got me most excited, and this
- 9:02is what I don't see enough people
- 9:03talking about. It's called genetic
- 9:05rescue. Meet the blackfooted ferret.
- 9:07This adorable little guy is in need of
- 9:09genetic rescue because
- 9:11>> every living blackfooted ferret alive
- 9:13today are first cousins.
- 9:15>> Yikes.
- 9:17This little guy nearly went extinct in
- 9:191979. Because of humans, the population
- 9:21crashed. But fortunately, they've
- 9:23started to come back. The problem now is
- 9:26that this new group of blackfooted
- 9:27ferrets,
- 9:28>> it has really, really low diversity.
- 9:30Very small gene pool.
- 9:31>> Scientists call this the bottleneck
- 9:33effect. If your group doesn't have
- 9:34enough genetic variety, you're
- 9:36vulnerable to things like disease and
- 9:38weird genetic mutations. This is a
- 9:40problem facing dozens of species whose
- 9:42populations put them at risk for genetic
- 9:44bottlenecking. But today, scientists are
- 9:47exploring gene editing to create more
- 9:50genetic diversity in some of those
- 9:52groups.
- 9:52>> We can take DNA from a museum stuffed
- 9:55animal from a 100 years ago, sequence
- 9:57its DNA, and then edit it into living
- 10:00blackfooted ferrets.
- 10:02One way to get diversity back, which we
- 10:04are working on.
- 10:05>> Another great example of using minimal
- 10:06gene editing to save a species, is this
- 10:10little guy, the northern qu from
- 10:12Australia. Look how cute he is. But
- 10:14they're expected to be extinct in the
- 10:15wild within the next 10 years because of
- 10:18this guy, this toad. This is the cane
- 10:20toad, and it's an invasive species. It's
- 10:22got a deadly toxin on its skin. So what
- 10:25happens is
- 10:25>> so our carnivorous little qual will eat
- 10:28the cane toad and they die instantly
- 10:30from that toxin.
- 10:31>> But scientists found that it's just one
- 10:33single letter of genetic code that makes
- 10:35them either die from eating a cane toad
- 10:37or completely resistant. Just one
- 10:40letter. So they're working on a way to
- 10:42introduce that one change into the
- 10:44population and make coals that are able
- 10:46to eat cane toads without dying, saving
- 10:48an entire species. In theory, you could
- 10:51do a lot of this. Not just making key
- 10:52animals poison resistant, but also
- 10:54disease resistant or heat resistant.
- 10:56There are projects to do this on coral
- 10:58reefs. Huge if true. But then why are we
- 11:02trying to deextinct animals at all? That
- 11:06brings us back to the Tasmanian tiger.
- 11:08Humans hunted these tigers until there
- 11:10were none left in the wild. But they
- 11:11didn't understand what would happen
- 11:13next. Without the tiger, Tasmania lost
- 11:15its only apex predator, a keystone
- 11:17species, meaning it has a huge impact on
- 11:19its ecosystem. And without them,
- 11:21>> there's been an explosion of walabeees
- 11:23and kangaroos there. They're eating all
- 11:25the shrubs, they're eating all the
- 11:26bushes, you know, that's impacting the
- 11:28bird populations. It's changing the
- 11:30landscape,
- 11:30>> which means that now other species are
- 11:32at risk, like the Tasmanian devil.
- 11:34>> They developed this incredibly strange
- 11:36disease, and it's actually like a cancer
- 11:38tumor that grows on their face, and they
- 11:40spread it from animal to animal. Apex
- 11:42predators used to reduce diseases like
- 11:44this. By eating sick members of the
- 11:46population by killing all the Tasmanian
- 11:49tigers, we created a butterfly effect
- 11:51that's rippling through the food chain
- 11:52to this day. So, some are proposing
- 11:55>> the only way we'll ever be able to bring
- 11:56that ecosystem back into balance is to
- 11:58put the Tasmanian tiger back into it.
- 12:01>> Tasmania is an island cut off from other
- 12:03natural predators. And many scientists
- 12:05agree that there's no other living
- 12:06species that could replace what the
- 12:08thyloine could do here. But could we
- 12:11actually do this? Well, they're
- 12:12following the recipe. They've identified
- 12:14the animal. They've sequenced the DNA.
- 12:17As for close relatives, this is the
- 12:19closest living animal to the thyloine.
- 12:20Their genetic makeup is 99.9%
- 12:23identical.
- 12:24>> And then you just edit that.1% where
- 12:27they're different. And that will turn
- 12:28that then into a Tasmanian tiger or a
- 12:32thyloine cell.
- 12:33>> Wait.1%.
- 12:34That's actually a lot genetically. And
- 12:36that's the bit that's going to take a
- 12:38really, really long time um to get that
- 12:40bit done.
- 12:41>> At this point though, you might be
- 12:42wondering, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa.
- 12:44Did we not learn our lesson from
- 12:45Jurassic Park?
- 12:47What are the consequences of actually
- 12:50doing this? When is it okay to use this
- 12:52technology? And when is it not? In other
- 12:54words, how do we get this right? What
- 12:57happens when you drop a predator back
- 12:59into an environment that hasn't seen it
- 13:00in decades? Well, in this case, it seems
- 13:04like a lot of the animals remember them.
- 13:07>> We made some replica thyloines and we
- 13:09took them out into the bush in Tasmania.
- 13:11We saw that they absolutely without
- 13:14doubt, even though it's been over a
- 13:16hundred years since they were really
- 13:17there. All of those animals remember the
- 13:19thyloine. If there's a fox or a goat,
- 13:21they don't really care. But if they see
- 13:23the thyloine, they are out of it.
- 13:25>> But what about the thyloine's instincts?
- 13:27How would it know to behave right like a
- 13:29predator? How much of an animal is
- 13:31nature versus nurture? There's real
- 13:33debate here.
- 13:34>> I frankly don't think that it will ever
- 13:36happen that we will see thyloines into
- 13:38the wild.
- 13:38>> But advocates for the thyloine would
- 13:40argue
- 13:41>> those behaviors are really hardwired in
- 13:44any animal's brain. The best example of
- 13:46this would be domestic cats. These are a
- 13:48pounce predator animal that have been
- 13:50living in our houses now for hundreds of
- 13:52generations, eating tinned cat food or
- 13:55little crispy biscuits. But if you
- 13:57wiggle a feather in front of them or a
- 13:58mouse runs across the floor, they
- 14:00immediately know that they are a pounce
- 14:02predator and they will pounce and kill
- 14:05and eat that that animal.
- 14:06>> We don't really know until we try. And
- 14:08they're trying. This is all hard, but
- 14:10it's not like we're creating things that
- 14:12are suddenly going to just be released
- 14:14into the wild.
- 14:15>> You would have them in a very large
- 14:16enclosure. you would really study them
- 14:19very very closely and make sure that
- 14:21they have taken on all of the behaviors
- 14:23so that by the time we get a population
- 14:25that we could think about releasing into
- 14:27the wild, we know that they're going to
- 14:28be able to really thrive once again.
- 14:30>> What this all means, best case, is we're
- 14:33still decades away from a wild Tasmanian
- 14:35tiger, but this technology is coming and
- 14:38we need to be part of that conversation
- 14:40right now. It's obviously fun to imagine
- 14:42Jurassic Park or bringing back a
- 14:44direwolf, but as we have this
- 14:47conversation, we got to be careful.
- 14:48We're talking about manipulating
- 14:50billions of years of evolution. There
- 14:52are huge stakes, ethical stakes about
- 14:54using animals as lab experiments,
- 14:56environmental stakes that could
- 14:57accidentally devastate entire
- 14:59ecosystems, and of course, the stakes of
- 15:02not doing absolutely everything we can.
- 15:05To me personally, the most huge, if
- 15:07true, optimistic bit of all of this
- 15:10isn't actually bringing back animals
- 15:12from the past. It's using all of this
- 15:14incredible science and technology to
- 15:17help keep the animals and the world that
- 15:19we live in now healthy.
- 15:21>> I would love people to go away from this
- 15:22and be like, deextinction science is
- 15:25conservation science and we absolutely
- 15:27have to use it.
- 15:28>> We are living in a world that we changed
- 15:30before we understood the consequences.
- 15:32The real debate about de-extinction
- 15:34isn't what's a direwolf. It's what
- 15:36responsibility do we have to the world
- 15:39we created.
- 15:44[Music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of The Real Reason We Should Revive Extinct Animals by Cleo Abram, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,990 words across 464 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.