The Quant Who Studied 700 Yrs Of Price Data: Most Levels Are Noise! THESE Are The 2 Levels To Watch! — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00This quant traded orders big enough to
- 0:02move the market, spent decades
- 0:04researching 700 years of price data and
- 0:07sold what he found to some of the
- 0:09biggest hedge funds on Wall Street. And
- 0:12today you get it here for free.
- 0:14>> One thing that makes my work almost
- 0:16unique is I've looked at the full scale
- 0:19of available data in financial markets
- 0:21all the way back to the Phoenicians. The
- 0:22way that I trade, that's a fundamental
- 0:24principle that has existed as long as
- 0:26we've had financial markets. On the
- 0:28other hand, if I were to decide to
- 0:30compute the Jane Street, now I have a
- 0:31problem because the length of a copper
- 0:34cable, the speed of light through that
- 0:35cable matters. They're co-located. I'm
- 0:37at home. I brought the wrong tool for
- 0:40the job and I can't compute on that time
- 0:42frame.
- 0:42>> Introducing Adam Grimes, former New York
- 0:44Mercantile Exchange and SMB Capital
- 0:47trader, author of The Art and Science of
- 0:50Technical Analysis, and he's written and
- 0:52published institutional research every
- 0:54day for nearly a decade.
- 0:56>> People have been looking at order flow
- 0:57ever since markets went electronic and
- 1:00surely there's information there, but
- 1:01there's also a tremendous amount of
- 1:03deception on the tape. I've been on both
- 1:04sides of that. I've been reading the
- 1:06tape and I've also been the guy trying
- 1:08to screw the people reading the tape. I
- 1:10know the tricks to do that.
- 1:11>> What does that mean, the second part?
- 1:12>> Well, it means that
- 1:15let's talk about Fibonacci specifically.
- 1:16Does the market reverse at that level
- 1:18first of all? That's the question. How
- 1:20would we test that? We draw a bunch of
- 1:21random lines on the chart and we test
- 1:23those random lines against the Fibonacci
- 1:26levels. They should look different. What
- 1:28I have found overwhelmingly, Fibonacci
- 1:31levels are not special. Moving averages
- 1:33are not special. VWAP is not special.
- 1:35They just should look different. And if
- 1:37they don't look different, I don't
- 1:39believe that something can be really
- 1:41significant in the market and also
- 1:43invisible in the data.
- 1:44>> In this episode, Adam reveals exactly
- 1:47what those tricks are, the one holding
- 1:49period where his data says a retail
- 1:51trader has the best chance of winning,
- 1:53and why stacking six confluences on your
- 1:55entry just makes you more confident, not
- 1:58more right.
- 1:59>> We started off talking
- 2:00>> correlation versus causation, signal
- 2:02versus noise, the evolution and alpha
- 2:03decay and where the world is headed. I
- 2:05feel like maybe timeless things would be
- 2:07momentum, volatility, trend and
- 2:08direction. Would this stand the test of
- 2:10time and therefore be better places to
- 2:12build an edge around as opposed to when
- 2:14you open up a technical analysis book
- 2:16and what you may find in there.
- 2:17>> I think I have pretty good data on this.
- 2:19Um
- 2:24>> Adam, so I've been on a US tour right
- 2:26now and I'm I want to say pretty
- 2:27confused.
- 2:28>> Yep.
- 2:29>> And the reason for that and I want to
- 2:30look for greater truth with yourself. We
- 2:31went for dinner last night and you
- 2:33strike me as a very introspective and
- 2:34philosophical person. And then the
- 2:36pursuit for today's conversation is to
- 2:38find the truth when I find successful
- 2:40traders on both sides of of defense,
- 2:43let's say.
- 2:44I have traders that tell me, look, the
- 2:45market is super complicated because you
- 2:47have
- 2:48the smartest people in the world with
- 2:49the best resources and money and
- 2:51everything to like carve out an edge and
- 2:52now it's to the point where you have
- 2:53Jane Streets executing in nanoseconds
- 2:56and it's really difficult and you're
- 2:57always subject to alpha decay so you got
- 2:58to move fast. Then you have the other
- 3:00camp which is also verified made profits
- 3:03which is timeless principles, keep it
- 3:05simple, a trend line and a doji and a
- 3:07trend is enough.
- 3:09And there there are opposite sides so
- 3:10where would you lie? And
- 3:13yeah, what is your beliefs on this topic
- 3:14of alpha decay and just the evolution of
- 3:17the market or do timeless principles
- 3:19edge from the 90s can still exist today?
- 3:22>> Both of those things can be true and I
- 3:23think they are.
- 3:24I think so for
- 3:26decades I've structured my trading
- 3:28around pullbacks and consolidations and
- 3:30trends. And you know, market makes a big
- 3:33move and you know, we can take this
- 3:35apart
- 3:36later, you know, exactly what the forces
- 3:38are behind it. Market makes a big move
- 3:40and then makes a pause and then
- 3:42based on reading how the patterns
- 3:44develop, you find the scales tilt a
- 3:47little bit in the direction of a
- 3:48continued move in that initial
- 3:50direction. So that is a fundamental
- 3:54principle. And you said from the 90s, I
- 3:59would say much deeper, you know, if we
- 4:01go back the entire history of recorded
- 4:04price data, we go back to we have price
- 4:06data from Europe in the Middle Ages. We
- 4:09have barley prices from the 1300s.
- 4:11Uh we have some of those early clay
- 4:14tablets the Phoenicians had were
- 4:16accounting tablets and records of prices
- 4:18for merchants. And academics have
- 4:20reconstructed those prices. And of
- 4:23course, you know, no nobody was keeping
- 4:24tick data then. They would
- 4:27not record daily prices. They would
- 4:29record when big changes happened. But
- 4:31I've inspected those price series. I
- 4:33think that one thing that makes my work
- 4:37almost unique is I've looked at the full
- 4:40scale of available data in financial
- 4:42markets all the way back to the
- 4:43Phoenicians. And I would tell you the
- 4:46way that I trade looking for a market to
- 4:48make a big move, maybe get a little bit
- 4:50ahead of itself, maybe consolidate, make
- 4:53a pullback or flag or whatever we're
- 4:54going to call it, and then make a
- 4:56continued move in that direction. That's
- 4:58a fundamental principle that has existed
- 5:00as long as we've had financial markets.
- 5:03On the other hand,
- 5:04if I were to fire up my computer at home
- 5:08and decide to to compete with Jane
- 5:10Street,
- 5:11now I have a problem because the length
- 5:13of a copper cable, the speed of light
- 5:16through that cable matters. And they're
- 5:18co-located. I'm at home. I'm playing a
- 5:20game where
- 5:23I you know, I I brought the wrong tool
- 5:25for the job and I can't compete on that
- 5:27time frame. So I think both of these
- 5:29things are true. And I also think
- 5:30Alpha's decay. And I think that the
- 5:33specific structure that I built for
- 5:35decades around this pullback
- 5:38I think the way that I was trading at
- 5:4010, 15, 20 years ago I think we're
- 5:43starting to see some shifts in the
- 5:44statistics. And I don't know
- 5:47you know, I I don't know exactly why the
- 5:49market is changing, but it does change.
- 5:51>> Is therefore for me concludes that it
- 5:53matters more what boat you're in not how
- 5:55hard you row with the Warren Buffett
- 5:56quotes where if I'm trying to compete
- 5:58against Jane Street, I'm never going to
- 6:00win. But if I go to the other approach,
- 6:02I have a better chance. What would be a
- 6:04retail independent trader's best chance
- 6:06in the markets?
- 6:08>> I think I've pretty good data on this.
- 6:09Um,
- 6:11and not going to be an exciting sexy
- 6:14answer. It's not going to be day
- 6:15trading. Uh, the best chance
- 6:20I think is a time frame where the fewest
- 6:22people are trying to extract money.
- 6:25The markets, you know, use whatever
- 6:27metaphor you want. The markets are a
- 6:29battle. They're a war.
- 6:31I think they're an ecosystem. I didn't
- 6:32come up with that. Andrew Lowe talks
- 6:34about markets adapting and thinking
- 6:36about different market participants like
- 6:37predator and prey, and they evolve and
- 6:40they change over time. So if you're
- 6:42competing on a very short time frame,
- 6:46you're competing with people who have
- 6:49infrastructure, data that that you do
- 6:52not have. Uh, if you're competing on the
- 6:56longer-term time frame, you're competing
- 6:58with people that have access to
- 7:00fundamental data. If you think you're
- 7:01doing fundamentals at home, well, you're
- 7:03up against firms who are sending
- 7:06analysts to the companies. You know,
- 7:07they're spending time in the factories.
- 7:09They're talking to management. They know
- 7:11what whatever you think you know, you
- 7:13don't know what they know. And And you
- 7:15don't have access to that information.
- 7:17If you think you're trading oil on
- 7:19fundamentals, maybe you are, but do you
- 7:21have access to the data feeds that show
- 7:23you where the tankers are in the ocean,
- 7:25how full they are, when they're Do you
- 7:26Do you
- 7:27Is Is that the game you're going to
- 7:29compete as a trader at home? Probably
- 7:31not.
- 7:32I think a simple concrete answer is
- 7:34looking for holds that are probably a
- 7:36little bit longer than you're going to
- 7:37be inclined for, so not day trades. You
- 7:40do need that overnight risk, but
- 7:41somewhere in the, you know, let's say
- 7:43average holding period two to five days
- 7:45is probably the sweet spot for a retail
- 7:47trader.
- 7:47>> [clears throat]
- 7:48>> You mentioned how there are certain
- 7:49principles that you could trace back to
- 7:51hundreds of years.
- 7:52>> Yep.
- 7:52>> And I would suppose that common
- 7:54denominator between then and now is
- 7:56human emotion.
- 7:57Um,
- 7:58>> Yeah.
- 7:58>> greed, optimism, euphoria, then despair,
- 8:01XYZ, which makes total sense and that
- 8:03would be reflected naturally in price
- 8:05action until you go digital and until
- 8:07you go algorithmic. And now, if I'm not
- 8:09wrong, 85 or 90% of price movements or
- 8:13orders are algorithmically generated or
- 8:16executed.
- 8:17When I see the comments online, it's
- 8:19like, well, yeah, but humans coded it,
- 8:20so it's the emotions are baked in. I'm
- 8:22not quite sure, but nonetheless, does
- 8:24human emotion reflect when the majority
- 8:26of the market is algorithmic?
- 8:28>> So far, yes. So, you know, we're
- 8:30recording at a point in time and the
- 8:33markets may evolve very quickly and I
- 8:35may say things today that look very
- 8:37foolish 5 years from now. So, you know,
- 8:39I will reserve the right to say that I
- 8:40was wrong and sure, I'm going to be
- 8:42wrong in some things, but I think so. I
- 8:44think this argument that people make
- 8:46that
- 8:47algorithms So first of all, many
- 8:50algorithms are are execution algorithms.
- 8:52That's that's all they are. You know,
- 8:54people think like there's some algo that
- 8:56determines price. No, you know, like if
- 8:59if I and you know, I've been this trader
- 9:01where if I need to execute
- 9:04a lot relative to the volume in a
- 9:06market, I will either farm it to a
- 9:08trader who can do it algorithmically or
- 9:10to an algo. And that algo is going to
- 9:12you know, it's going to be benchmarked
- 9:13against VWAP over the time period. But
- 9:16it's the algorithm is just figuring out
- 9:18how to nibble my order without really
- 9:20moving the market because you know, if I
- 9:21push the button, the the market moves.
- 9:24Many algorithms are just that and what
- 9:27they're looking to do is buy when the
- 9:31market is and you know, we can flip for
- 9:33selling, but you know, they're they're
- 9:34looking to extract some minimal value
- 9:37and it's not something that's completely
- 9:40disconnected from the way that humans
- 9:43trade, the way that humans think. And
- 9:45the opportunistic algorithms, if you
- 9:47will, well, what are they looking for?
- 9:50They're looking for in most cases
- 9:51extremes and some kind of mean
- 9:53reversion. That's by and large. So what
- 9:56are they looking for? How do we get to
- 9:58those extremes?
- 9:59Either error or emotion, right? And in
- 10:02financial markets, maybe emotion is
- 10:03error. I don't know. Um
- 10:06so I
- 10:08we are seeing I'm seeing in my
- 10:11quantitative work,
- 10:12uh alphas decaying. I'm seeing the
- 10:14markets change in some fundamental ways.
- 10:16It may be exactly what you're asking
- 10:18about. It may be
- 10:20new kinds of AI driving market action,
- 10:24but I think over the, you know, as the
- 10:26world's been more and more digital going
- 10:28back to the late 80s,
- 10:30I think at least up to this point where
- 10:32we're having this conversation, I think
- 10:34the idea of emotion is still valid.
- 10:36>> It's interesting. You mentioned before
- 10:39if we reached out to you and said, hey,
- 10:41let's do a podcast, you would have said
- 10:43no because I've got a system. It's
- 10:44working. I'm making money and that would
- 10:45be a boring conversation.
- 10:46>> not that interesting, yeah.
- 10:47>> Which sounds more interesting to me, but
- 10:49now we're at a time where you're saying,
- 10:51well, it seems like we're at an
- 10:52inflection point in history where you're
- 10:53sensing change, you're sensing decay,
- 10:55and you're seeing the emergence of
- 10:57quantitative power that maybe reshaping
- 10:59the landscape and you're saying my
- 11:00beliefs today might look foolish in five
- 11:02years. Are we at a
- 11:05inflection point in history right now in
- 11:06the markets?
- 11:07>> I believe we are at an inflection point
- 11:09in history.
- 11:10Full stop.
- 11:13I suspect,
- 11:14you know, in my lifetime I saw the
- 11:17arrival of the internet which changed
- 11:18everything, the internet and email. And
- 11:21I know generations before us saw
- 11:23electricity, industrial revolution.
- 11:25We've seen these major inflection
- 11:28points. I suspect today where it's
- 11:31something that
- 11:32we haven't like this is maybe
- 11:34invention of writing. This is maybe
- 11:36agriculture. This this could be one of
- 11:39those civilization level inflections.
- 11:42And I think there are concerns outside
- 11:45of I have many concerns outside of
- 11:47financial markets, how we navigate this
- 11:49as a species and as a culture and and as
- 11:52humans.
- 11:53>> With the objective I guess today of
- 11:55understanding truths of the market, I'd
- 11:57like to know where I should begin
- 11:58because it seems like you've had a
- 11:59journey in your career of styles of
- 12:01trading, what you use from day trading
- 12:03M1 to where you are now.
- 12:06A lot of traders begin at strategies and
- 12:08and that would be like broad schools of
- 12:09thought whereas Elliot wave theory,
- 12:11Wyckoff theory, smart money concepts,
- 12:13and Fibonacci support resistance, and
- 12:15then you'd try and
- 12:17put that to fit into the market. The
- 12:19other approach would be the I guess more
- 12:21algorithmic approach, which is
- 12:23past price could predict future price,
- 12:25and as a result, I'm just going to go
- 12:27through data to find things.
- 12:29Most people start at the other side,
- 12:31which is schools of thought because it
- 12:33feels more approachable.
- 12:34But nonetheless, the ones that do or
- 12:36don't work When I think of let's say a
- 12:38Fibonacci,
- 12:39is there something magical about a
- 12:40Fibonacci level that ends up as as a
- 12:43rejection point, or is it kind of like a
- 12:45bell curve and you have these areas of
- 12:47increased probability? I don't know.
- 12:49But what I'm more concerned myself with
- 12:51is this a correlation or causation? Does
- 12:53the market reverse because of the
- 12:55Fibonacci or this nicely reflects a
- 12:57reversal point? If I could start to
- 12:59think in first principles and start to
- 13:00think in causation,
- 13:02where would I begin?
- 13:04>> So
- 13:06the way you framed that, this is
- 13:08another way to rephrase this is the
- 13:10self-fulfilling prophecy. Is the
- 13:12Fibonacci level, moving average, VWAP,
- 13:15whatever we're talking about, a
- 13:17self-fulfilling prophecy?
- 13:19My answer to that I do care deeply about
- 13:22the truth. We're going to come back to
- 13:23that. But my answer to is it a
- 13:25self-fulfilling prophecy is
- 13:27I don't think I care. What I want to
- 13:30know first of all is and let's talk
- 13:32about Fibonacci specifically,
- 13:34I want to know
- 13:36does the market reverse at that level,
- 13:37first of all? That's the question.
- 13:40So how would we test that?
- 13:44How how it it it's not so easy. How how
- 13:46would we structure a test?
- 13:47>> my first concern would be how do I
- 13:49separate let's say a broken clock where
- 13:51my watch is stuck at 6:00. It's correct
- 13:52twice a day, 6:00 and 6:00 p.m. The rest
- 13:54of the time is wrong. But the times is
- 13:56correct. If I give if I attribute
- 13:58meaning to it, I'm attributing
- 14:00meaning to noise. So I'd have to
- 14:02separate signal from noise.
- 14:05I'll pass it back to you and help me
- 14:06navigate that one.
- 14:07>> Well, there's also And then there's also
- 14:10the
- 14:11cognitive issue that you're going to
- 14:13remember things that look and feel
- 14:15significant. You know, if if you look at
- 14:17your watch and it says 6:00 00 and then
- 14:20you look at it again, it says 7:00 and
- 14:22you're like, oh, you know, I looked at
- 14:24my clock. So you and you know that's
- 14:26meaningless, but it's a it's a data
- 14:28point that jumps out. Uh so the question
- 14:31is
- 14:34if I understand what you're saying, I
- 14:36have a Fibonacci level.
- 14:38First of all, let's define what we think
- 14:40should happen. Price should reverse more
- 14:42from the Fibonacci level. Is that is
- 14:43that what we're saying? Uh because we do
- 14:47kind of need to think around the corners
- 14:49because that's one possibility. Another
- 14:51possibility is maybe price is drawn to
- 14:53the Fibonacci level. Maybe price engages
- 14:57like you know, that could be another way
- 14:58to think about it. Uh but regardless,
- 15:00both of those
- 15:02your question is how do I know it's not
- 15:03the stopped clock being right twice a
- 15:05day, right? Um there's a very simple
- 15:08technique for that
- 15:10which is we draw a bunch of random lines
- 15:12on the chart
- 15:13and we test those random lines against
- 15:16the Fibonacci levels. And this is a
- 15:20you know, it's funny. Uh
- 15:22I didn't have a quantitative background
- 15:24and I didn't know how to test any of
- 15:27this stuff. When I when I started
- 15:29trading out of college, I was a
- 15:30musician. I had no math classes in my
- 15:33pocket. Uh so I had to teach myself
- 15:35everything. And then
- 15:37you know, initially you get very excited
- 15:40because you see things that make money.
- 15:41Uh for instance, it's quite easy to
- 15:44develop a system that buys stocks that
- 15:46makes money because stocks on average go
- 15:49up over time, right? So in fact, if you
- 15:51develop a system where you're buying
- 15:53stocks and doesn't make money
- 15:55that may be very interesting to me today
- 15:57because maybe you found an edge. But the
- 15:59question is, am I just getting the index
- 16:01drift or am or am I getting am I getting
- 16:04alpha you know,
- 16:05we we know what we're talking about
- 16:06here. Are we getting alpha? So what you
- 16:08can do is test against these dummy
- 16:11levels. And I wouldn't even you know,
- 16:14with the Fibonacci level
- 16:16I wouldn't even say
- 16:19I wouldn't even define the bounce. It
- 16:20would be enough for me initially to say,
- 16:22I have my interactions with Fibonacci
- 16:25levels. And what happens after those. I
- 16:27would go through and I would look every
- 16:29time we touch a level and then, you
- 16:32know, you you ask me, well, do you
- 16:33really need to touch it? And I say,
- 16:34okay, we can put a little band around
- 16:36it, whatever. Every time we get close to
- 16:38a level,
- 16:39let's look what happens going forward.
- 16:42And then because we're doing a lot of
- 16:43tests, let's also test exact engagements
- 16:45and we have a bunch of levels and you
- 16:47know, should we test 50%? It's not
- 16:49really a Fibonacci level, but the
- 16:50Fibonacci traders use it. Uh we should
- 16:52talk about Fibonacci and sacred
- 16:53geometry. It's a, you know, entirely
- 16:56separate topic. But sticking on the
- 16:57tests now,
- 16:59so we look at what happens. We look at
- 17:01the outcomes from those engagements and
- 17:03then we look at the outcomes from the
- 17:04random lines. And they should look
- 17:08different.
- 17:09And of course, you know, one one of the
- 17:11we have to use the right kind of
- 17:13statistics because if you look closely
- 17:14enough, you'll see differences where
- 17:16there aren't differences. So we have to
- 17:18understand the variability. But what I
- 17:20have found overwhelmingly, and this is
- 17:24this is where people probably start
- 17:25throwing things at the screen or are
- 17:27spiking their phone on the ground,
- 17:30all of these things that people think
- 17:32were Fibonacci levels are not special.
- 17:35Moving averages are not special. VWAP is
- 17:38not special. Simple test of a moving
- 17:40average, by the way, you want to tell me
- 17:41a 50 period or 200 period moving average
- 17:44is special. Fine. Let's test your 200
- 17:46period. Test it against 210 and 109, you
- 17:49know. And again, they just should look
- 17:51different. And if they don't look
- 17:53different,
- 17:55I don't believe that something can be
- 17:57really significant in the market and
- 17:59also invisible in the data. It might be
- 18:02hard to see. It might be subtle. It
- 18:03might be slight and it might not show
- 18:06up. You know, I don't know. Like you you
- 18:09told me you think price bounces off a
- 18:10Fibonacci level. Maybe it does. Maybe it
- 18:13accelerates through a level. Our tests
- 18:14would have found that. Maybe after the
- 18:17level volatility gets smaller. Our tests
- 18:19would have seen that because we're
- 18:20looking all we're saying is, you know,
- 18:22we're saying I don't know. I'm very
- 18:24naive. I have these two sets of
- 18:26distributions, which are the, you know,
- 18:28forward distributions. Let me look and
- 18:30see if they look different. So that's
- 18:31the test.
- 18:33>> I love to express this conversation
- 18:34towards It seems like you've done this
- 18:36test that you're describing today on
- 18:37Fibonacci and you probably done it on
- 18:39everything else, trend lines and support
- 18:41resistance, XYZ.
- 18:42What What conclusions did you derive?
- 18:44>> Uh there are no with very few
- 18:47exceptions. And you want to know I I'll
- 18:49tell you where some of them are. With
- 18:51very few exceptions, there are no
- 18:52special levels. Uh in general, the from
- 18:56a quantitative perspective, the and it
- 18:59it varies according to asset class a
- 19:01little bit. Uh for instance, stock
- 19:04indexes have a natural tendency for mean
- 19:07reversion.
- 19:08All markets have mean reversion. Stock
- 19:09indexes tend to have a little bit more.
- 19:12Interest rate sensitive instruments, FX,
- 19:15you know, bond futures, uh
- 19:17less mean reversion, more continuation.
- 19:20So if I had to if if you told me uh a
- 19:23market went down a lot today
- 19:27and you're going to buy it on the close,
- 19:28if you tell me it's a stock index
- 19:30or it's a currency, you have a different
- 19:33probability of having a profitable
- 19:34trade. You have much better chance of
- 19:35making money on the stock index. So one
- 19:38thing we will see is if you're looking
- 19:40at moves down to moving averages in
- 19:42stock indexes, they naturally bounce.
- 19:45But guess what? So do our random lines,
- 19:47too. Uh you also can I've run tests
- 19:51where, you know, I said we should test
- 19:53the 200 against the 210 and the 190. Uh
- 19:57we also should test it against a move
- 19:59How about a moving average that changes
- 20:01its period every every bar?
- 20:04So today it's a 90 period. Tomorrow it's
- 20:06130 130 period. So it's it's a
- 20:09meaningless line on the chart.
- 20:11>> This is where I get confused because I
- 20:13have conversation with certain
- 20:14individuals, including recently, where
- 20:16he broke down elements of his edge. He
- 20:18was like, yeah, one of my models is like
- 20:20once we're above the the 200 moving
- 20:22average, if we have three down days, uh
- 20:24going to do X. I'm like, anything else?
- 20:27And they're like, no, that's it. And
- 20:28then I speak to another person. He's
- 20:29like, yeah, I just wait for a EMA cross.
- 20:32I wait for a trend line top or I wait
- 20:34for a breakout. I was like, oh, do you
- 20:35wait for the test? Do you use a
- 20:36Fibonacci? Do you use a Do you like No,
- 20:38just a breakout. I was like, anything
- 20:39more? Nothing. And I And then I have the
- 20:41other side of the camp and we have
- 20:42really deep technical conversations down
- 20:44to M1, down to the philosophical side
- 20:46that we're touching upon. How can these
- 20:48both coexist? Which is back to the
- 20:50original question.
- 20:50>> Okay, they can both coexist in a few
- 20:52ways. So
- 20:54going back to the general behavior of
- 20:56stock markets, when stock markets are
- 20:58significantly off their highs,
- 21:01which would put you under the 200 day
- 21:02moving average. And the 200 day moving
- 21:04average is not a magical line in the
- 21:05sand, but in general
- 21:07with stock indexes or individual stocks,
- 21:10if you're under the 200 day moving
- 21:11average, you're going to see a different
- 21:13kind of behavior. You're going to see a
- 21:15um
- 21:17in the more recent data, you see more
- 21:18volatility.
- 21:20And this again, this is not true in
- 21:22currencies because there's not really an
- 21:24up and down. It depends, you know, what
- 21:26what you're weighing it against. Um
- 21:29but with stocks,
- 21:31under the 200 day moving average, you
- 21:33will see different kinds of behavior.
- 21:36Doesn't It doesn't mean the 200 day
- 21:37moving average itself is magical, but it
- 21:39does mean that when you're off of that
- 21:41high and maybe uh
- 21:43you know, if you're using in a
- 21:45systematic approach, you're using the
- 21:47200 day moving average. Well, you have
- 21:48to use something. And you're capturing
- 21:51this aspect of behavior. Maybe it could
- 21:52be a 200 day median, which is actually
- 21:55quite you know, computationally is a
- 21:57little bit more expensive to compute
- 21:59every day. Um maybe you could just look
- 22:01at where you are in the yearly range or
- 22:03something like that or how far you
- 22:04You're going to get a similar effect.
- 22:06The
- 22:07>> Th- This is down to the self-fulfilling
- 22:08idea that there's nothing magical about
- 22:10the moving average, but generally people
- 22:12would be behaving in a certain way below
- 22:13it.
- 22:14>> It's not It's not even that, you know, I
- 22:15I would be perfectly happy. Our test of
- 22:17Fibonacci levels, which I promise you,
- 22:21shows no difference with the with the
- 22:23Fibonacci level. If they were
- 22:25self-fulfilling prophecy, we would see
- 22:28the difference. We would see the action
- 22:29there. And then I would be quite
- 22:31comfortable telling you,
- 22:32I don't really care why it's I don't I I
- 22:35can't know why it's doing that, but it
- 22:37does that. And I see it in the data. I
- 22:39don't even see it in the data. If the
- 22:41200-day if funds were buying at the
- 22:4450-day or the 200-day or you know the
- 22:46nonsense that that people say, you would
- 22:48see it at those averages. You do not see
- 22:51it at those averages. Now that can be
- 22:52true and it can also be true that when
- 22:55stock indexes are significantly off
- 22:57their highs, you see a different kind of
- 22:58behavior primarily with respect to
- 23:00volatility. I don't think there is a
- 23:04strong directional edge,
- 23:07but there is you you you'll have more
- 23:10volatile events under the historically
- 23:12at least under the 200-day moving
- 23:13average.
- 23:13>> what I personally done I'm with you. I'm
- 23:15on the same page and I like to avoid
- 23:17looking at things that are correlated
- 23:19like a head and shoulder pattern. I
- 23:20don't know what that means and it could
- 23:21work but it is signal versus noise. I
- 23:23don't know if it's statistically
- 23:24relevant. Same for Fibonacci, same for
- 23:25trend line, support resistance, X Y, the
- 23:26list goes on.
- 23:28But I do like to think in in terms of
- 23:30causation. What could cause the market
- 23:32to move? And I find it
- 23:34as as as time goes on or as I'm
- 23:36projecting into further time horizons, I
- 23:39guess the crystal ball gets a bit hazy.
- 23:40So I think it becomes harder to predict.
- 23:42Naturally as a result of that I'm doing
- 23:44these days of the last decade what you
- 23:46were initially doing and I moved away
- 23:48from which is I like to be on the M 1. I
- 23:49like to be on shorter time horizons
- 23:51because I think the causation
- 23:53edge exists there. And what in the
- 23:56language I think of is supply and demand
- 23:58surely has to be causative. Market
- 24:00impact of large institutions can create
- 24:02a small causative event. Now I don't
- 24:04know if that's going to lead to a full
- 24:06move, but it might give a reaction. So I
- 24:08like to think in these terms. Am I on a
- 24:10better line than or a better direction
- 24:12in the industry than someone who is
- 24:13looking at Fibonacci and trend lines and
- 24:15these generic things?
- 24:16>> I think so. I mean if you're trading on
- 24:18the 1-minute chart,
- 24:20one of the other things that will test
- 24:22out well which you're probably aware of,
- 24:24previous day's high and low,
- 24:26that's a real thing.
- 24:27And if we
- 24:30you can test this very easily. You can
- 24:32do the test we were talking about, look
- 24:33at engagements of the high and low,
- 24:36look at random lines, throw your
- 24:37Fibonacci levels in there, and what
- 24:39you're going to see is that one of these
- 24:41things is different than the other. The
- 24:43high and low looks different than the
- 24:45Fibonacci and looks, you know,
- 24:47it's non-random behavior there. So I I
- 24:51think you're correct there. I, you know,
- 24:53as humans we we tell stories, right?
- 24:55We're we're we're we're our
- 24:58culture is tied all of our cultures are
- 25:02tied together by the stories we tell.
- 25:04And we tell these stories about
- 25:05ourselves and we're telling stories here
- 25:06today.
- 25:08And there's something that's very
- 25:09appealing about that. And as somebody
- 25:11who's done a decent amount of spiritual
- 25:14exploration, stories are important to
- 25:16me, but
- 25:17as a
- 25:19quantitative trader, I know the market
- 25:22is, you know, the story I would tell you
- 25:24about the market is the market is
- 25:26very fickle. The market the the market
- 25:28can change
- 25:30can can be
- 25:32making me feel one way and then it can
- 25:35change very quickly. So I know that I
- 25:36can't get very attached to my stories.
- 25:39I
- 25:42you know, there's also at any point in
- 25:43the market there's so many different
- 25:45influences and different people trading
- 25:47that I don't think I have
- 25:50you know, in
- 25:51in full humility I don't think I I can
- 25:53understand those influences, but I will
- 25:55also tell you I find the Wyckoff
- 25:58framework very useful. I know it's naive
- 26:01and
- 26:02the viewers
- 26:04where you think about these big buyers
- 26:06and big sellers driving the market. They
- 26:08may not even be real, but you can think
- 26:10what are buyers trying to do at this
- 26:12point? What are sellers trying to do at
- 26:14this point? And if you use those
- 26:16frameworks, even if these stories are
- 26:18completely fictitious, we're still
- 26:21saying something about
- 26:23the reality that has some any of the
- 26:26story can be useful. Like when
- 26:29when people in a previous culture told a
- 26:31story about a goddess that went into the
- 26:34underworld so all the plants died and
- 26:36the winter and then you would know when
- 26:37to replant.
- 26:39I don't think they thought that was real
- 26:40or not but it guided their decisions for
- 26:43how how they planned to get through the
- 26:45winter and when the spring came and I
- 26:48think this this goes back to the
- 26:49question you asked before should you
- 26:51start where should you start should you
- 26:53start analyzing data quantitatively or
- 26:56should you start kind of trying to wrap
- 26:58your arms around the market.
- 27:00I would say start trying to wrap your
- 27:02arms around the market but you know that
- 27:03that's my bias because I think at heart
- 27:07despite all the quantitative work I'm an
- 27:09artist I'm a musician you know I'm I'm a
- 27:11weird person because
- 27:13this quantitative side but I also have
- 27:16this holistic artistic approach and I
- 27:19think study study patterns
- 27:24trade you know like
- 27:25you learn don't lose much money keep
- 27:28keep your losses small but you can do
- 27:30all of the theoretical trading you know
- 27:33reading and back testing and it all
- 27:36changes when you get in the market and
- 27:37the market punches you in the face and
- 27:39you oh okay they there's something
- 27:41there.
- 27:41>> You mentioned that that Wyckoff could be
- 27:43a little bit naive but even looking at
- 27:45it comparing it to the other things
- 27:47we've spoken about that one still makes
- 27:48sense to me maybe not the stories maybe
- 27:50not the labels and the the UTAD and the
- 27:53LPSY and all these let's say acronyms we
- 27:55give to it but the philosophy of
- 27:58institutional buyers loading up that's a
- 28:00cause it's like an elastic band I'm
- 28:01pulling it back if I let go surely it
- 28:03should
- 28:04it's a cause and effect relationship so
- 28:06that makes more sense to me.
- 28:07>> What are they trying to do in the
- 28:09deception in the market?
- 28:10>> naturally there's going to be a lot of
- 28:12nuance to it like not every buyer is
- 28:14equal someone is a speculator someone is
- 28:15a utilizer of the currency some people
- 28:18is trying to hold for long term someone
- 28:19short term someone's weak handed XYZ so
- 28:21it does get nuanced of course but the
- 28:22general principle of I want to trade in
- 28:25the market from causative perspectives
- 28:27accumulation fuels causative what other
- 28:29things could fuel causative and again
- 28:32avoiding just storytelling which could
- 28:34be guiding but I don't want to get into
- 28:36that because that can um yeah, it can it
- 28:38can just get a bit weird.
- 28:38>> podcast, right? That's because it's a
- 28:39little weird.
- 28:41Um
- 28:42I think this framework is very useful
- 28:43too. And I think, particularly as a
- 28:46discretionary trader,
- 28:48when you
- 28:50you do all of the analysis and it still
- 28:52comes down to you making a decision. And
- 28:55I find that my decisions are best
- 28:58motivated by understanding what I think
- 29:00these groups of people are trying to do.
- 29:02If I think I see, you know, okay, buyers
- 29:04are
- 29:06you said accumulating here, and I think
- 29:07that's a word that in some way, you
- 29:09know, it's overused, but you know, if I
- 29:11keep seeing that the market keeps
- 29:12getting depressed on this time frame uh
- 29:15like there's buying there. There's some
- 29:16and
- 29:17how much do I trust it? I don't know. I
- 29:19can't really trust anything that much,
- 29:21but it's something that is happening.
- 29:22There's somebody there that is buying.
- 29:24And then like you said, you know, what
- 29:26happens when you move into you move
- 29:28above a resistance level um
- 29:31and all of a sudden there's not the
- 29:32selling pressure to meet that and then
- 29:34the market moves. And you saw it because
- 29:36you saw the positioning beforehand. Or,
- 29:38you know, if you're living in an
- 29:40intraday world, you know, you see you
- 29:42keep coming back to the high of the day
- 29:45and you can't really back off from it
- 29:47and you go dull and dead and quiet at
- 29:49the high of the day, that's telling you
- 29:51something. You know, the they're they're
- 29:53not letting it back off much. So buyers
- 29:55I think that
- 29:57whether or not this is actually a thing,
- 29:59it is for a discretionary trader a
- 30:00powerful tool for understanding price
- 30:02action.
- 30:03>> We started off talking about correlation
- 30:04versus causation, storytelling versus
- 30:06signal versus noise, and then also with
- 30:09the evolution and alpha decay and where
- 30:11the world is headed.
- 30:12I feel like maybe timeless things would
- 30:14be momentum, uh volatility, uh trend and
- 30:17direction. These I suppose would always
- 30:19be baked in.
- 30:19>> Add mean reversion.
- 30:21>> Add mean reversion, yes. Would would
- 30:22this stand the test of time and
- 30:24therefore be better places to build an
- 30:26edge around as opposed to when you open
- 30:28up a technical analysis book and what
- 30:29you may find in there.
- 30:30>> I think so, but I think if you open up a
- 30:33good tech and you know, not to talk my
- 30:35book, but if you up my book, my book is
- 30:37going to be centered around momentum and
- 30:39mean reversion, and the patterns are an
- 30:41expression of that. So I think, you
- 30:44know,
- 30:45barring our weird like
- 30:47civilizational financial market ending
- 30:49discussion earlier, which was pretty
- 30:51weird, as long as there are functioning
- 30:53financial markets, these forces of mean
- 30:55reversion and momentum will continue to
- 30:57play. I can't imagine financial markets
- 30:59where they will not play out, but they
- 31:01may play out in ways that mean the
- 31:03specific patterns, the ways we trade
- 31:05them don't necessarily work. So we may
- 31:07need but
- 31:09I don't
- 31:10and there are some other principles,
- 31:12right? We should talk about options
- 31:13traders doing things with volatility,
- 31:15doing things with time. There are things
- 31:17with relative value. You know, some
- 31:18people will tell you that the only thing
- 31:20that matters is price, you know, only
- 31:22price pays. But there is there are other
- 31:24ways to trade, right? You can set up
- 31:26volatility structures.
- 31:28You
- 31:30these things may
- 31:32it's kind of a level of sophistication
- 31:34up from trading chart patterns.
- 31:37It's going to be there some way, you
- 31:39know, and we may
- 31:41I I could imagine a world where the
- 31:43chart patterns are so heavily arbed, but
- 31:46they don't arb the volatility out of
- 31:48relative relationships. So, you know,
- 31:50there's something to be done with
- 31:51spreads perhaps.
- 31:54>> We spoke about dinner last night that
- 31:56the topic of the industry or the
- 31:58buzzword in the industry right now seems
- 32:00to be this year is all about order flow
- 32:02in the retail lens. A lot of influencers
- 32:04are popping up talking about it and it
- 32:05just seems to be everyone's looking for
- 32:07holy grail, mine's not working, let me
- 32:09strategy hop and and try this one out.
- 32:11However, it doesn't feel like the other
- 32:13ones in the past that I've seen where
- 32:14it's just storytelling and something
- 32:15repackaged. It feels like something that
- 32:17could be causal where
- 32:19I'm looking for big orders to come in.
- 32:21This could be institutional for prints
- 32:23and naturally self-fulfilling. If a
- 32:24large institution steps in, price should
- 32:26at least move a bit in that direction.
- 32:28Is there any merit to
- 32:30linking price action to order flow
- 32:32behind it?
- 32:33>> I think so, yes, but
- 32:35where I would
- 32:36where where I would take issue with this
- 32:38is with it being new, because this is
- 32:40this is something, you know, this is
- 32:42this is not new.
- 32:43Uh, volume profile, I
- 32:46I was kind of in the second generation
- 32:49of that. It If I understand correctly,
- 32:51it was first pitched to the floor
- 32:53traders in Chicago who weren't really
- 32:55able to make much with it. So then it
- 32:57moved to a retail marketing. It's been
- 33:00repackaged in, you know, various ways.
- 33:02And then order flow, people have been
- 33:03looking at order flow ever since markets
- 33:05went electronic. And surely there's
- 33:07information there. Uh, I think people do
- 33:11things with order flow that's probably
- 33:12not appropriate and correct. You know,
- 33:14the idea that uh
- 33:17you see somebody
- 33:19made a big transaction at a price. Does
- 33:22that mean they're going to defend it
- 33:23when it comes back? And I You know,
- 33:24that's one It's one of many ways that
- 33:26people think about it. So
- 33:28I
- 33:30I think particularly for scalpers,
- 33:32there's a lot of information there. But
- 33:34there's also a tremendous amount of
- 33:36deception on the tape. You know, you
- 33:38don't see the displayed liquidity. And I
- 33:40know because I've been I've been on both
- 33:42sides of that. I've been reading the
- 33:43tape and I've also been the guy trying
- 33:46to screw the people reading the tape
- 33:47when I'm had to execute a lot of volume
- 33:50in thin stocks. You know, I I I I know
- 33:51the tricks to do that.
- 33:53>> What does that mean, the second part?
- 33:54>> Well, it means that So say say there's a
- 33:56very Just for instance, there's a very
- 33:58thin stock or it could be an option. It
- 34:00could be a currency at a quiet time of
- 34:02the day and there's not much liquidity.
- 34:03The bid ask is very wide. It's not
- 34:05trading very much and you need to do a
- 34:09big order right now. If you just go and
- 34:12start clearing the book, you're going to
- 34:13move it a lot. And instead, what you
- 34:16might do There's all kinds of tricks.
- 34:18You If you have to buy, you know,
- 34:20whatever quantity Let's say you have to
- 34:21buy 20,000, you don't have to put 20,000
- 34:24in the book and let everybody see, hey,
- 34:26you know, uh you you can put in 100, you
- 34:29can put in 200. You can show that. You
- 34:30can ice break the rest. You can Uh,
- 34:33if you're looking to buy, you might put
- 34:35an order in to sell. You might put a big
- 34:37order in to sell way above the market
- 34:39and then people reading the tape will
- 34:41think, oh, there's actually selling
- 34:42pressure there. Uh,
- 34:44you're you know, you're I I got it
- 34:46flipped, but you know, uh,
- 34:48the
- 34:50so a lot of what you see on the tape is
- 34:53by nature deceptive. I don't think you
- 34:55can take it. And then there's of course
- 34:57the argument for looking at the
- 34:59difference between the display, what you
- 35:01see displayed and what you see actually
- 35:02transacted, that you know, the
- 35:04transactions are a level of reality that
- 35:07the displayed theoretical liquidity is
- 35:10not. There's something there. Uh, I
- 35:13I think that the way that I read charts
- 35:16is
- 35:18effectively a kind of tape reading on
- 35:20the chart.
- 35:21You know, and I I think you probably if
- 35:23you're reading a one-minute chart, I
- 35:25think for instance go back to that
- 35:26situation where you're up against the
- 35:27high of the day and imagine you can't
- 35:30really back off from the high of the day
- 35:32and a few times that it's sold off, it
- 35:34leaves long long wicks, long tails.
- 35:37You know that those were probably just
- 35:40quick probes down. So you're reading the
- 35:43tape as you're reading the chart. And
- 35:45the argument the tape readers will make
- 35:46well, you know, the chart's static,
- 35:48you're not seeing what's actually on the
- 35:50tape, but it's leaving the footprint in
- 35:53the same way on the chart sometimes if
- 35:55you know how to read it.
- 35:56>> So what you're basically describing here
- 35:57is essentially what I do and I don't
- 35:59want to make the conversation just about
- 36:00my my beliefs, um, but that 's where I
- 36:02found as a retail trader some edge and
- 36:04when I speak to others, uh, that are
- 36:06able to go into the wise like you are
- 36:07with me today, it seems to be the common
- 36:10answer is as a retail trader the edges
- 36:12seem to lie on the lower time frames on
- 36:13an intraday perspective or scalping.
- 36:15But in the beginning you said day
- 36:17trading is a is the wrong place to begin
- 36:18or you don't like it.
- 36:19>> I
- 36:22I have seen more traders have more
- 36:24success on slightly longer time frames.
- 36:26Uh, and it it is interesting that you
- 36:29know, we navigated around to basically
- 36:31what you do. Like you know, you you
- 36:33didn't tell me that. I didn't know that
- 36:35it it just just by talking about where
- 36:36the edges are, you have found it in
- 36:38practice and you know, I found it in
- 36:40practice and and theory too. So you you
- 36:43are well aligned. But, uh
- 36:46for me,
- 36:49there was a point where I was I was
- 36:50beyond obsessed with day trading. I
- 36:52would trade the S&Ps. I would do a
- 36:55little bit of music. I would And then I
- 36:56would trade Europe at night. I would get
- 36:58up and I don't know how I slept. Like,
- 37:00you know, I add up the days the hours I
- 37:02and it adds up to more than 24 hours. I
- 37:04did that for a while.
- 37:06And then I realized, you know,
- 37:08it's not really how I want to be a
- 37:09human. We're here. We don't know how
- 37:11long. Like, uh plane could fall through
- 37:14this right now while we're talking,
- 37:15right? It could happen. Uh
- 37:18you you never know the future. I don't
- 37:20want to spend my entire life glued to
- 37:21the screen. And if I'm going to day
- 37:24trade well, and every now and then I get
- 37:27I kind of get a thought, you know, maybe
- 37:29I'd like to day trade again.
- 37:30And my business partner, my wife are
- 37:32like, okay. We we've we've seen this
- 37:34before.
- 37:35>> Mhm.
- 37:35>> Go ahead. Go ahead. Come back and tell
- 37:37me in a few months. And I did it. I'm
- 37:39like, I this is not what I want to do. I
- 37:40hate I I don't want to be glued to the
- 37:42screen 24 hours a day. I don't have to.
- 37:44I can make more money easier, certainly
- 37:48for a unit of my time on a longer time
- 37:50frame. But, I've also I think
- 37:54the
- 37:55everything's good and bad, right?
- 37:56Everything's a double-edged sword. And
- 37:58the advantage of day trading is you get
- 38:01many times at bat. You have to make many
- 38:03many decisions throughout the day. Uh
- 38:05you know, a disciplined day trader on a
- 38:08one-minute chart, you're probably making
- 38:10what on a slow day three trades and
- 38:12maybe up to two dozen on a busy day. Is
- 38:14that roughly where you are?
- 38:16>> So, just to briefly give you context, I
- 38:18suppose it would help. Um I found the
- 38:20sweet spot for me. I don't like look
- 38:22because exactly what you're saying,
- 38:23there is maybe an edge there, but it's
- 38:24at the expense of your time and health
- 38:26and and and everything else. Uh so, what
- 38:29what I like when I started, I was
- 38:30trading many asset classes. I realized I
- 38:32want to focus on two.
- 38:33>> Okay.
- 38:33>> And I [clears throat] I wanted to trade
- 38:34two things that are generally
- 38:35correlated, but they do de-peg at times
- 38:38because I can give meaning to that. So,
- 38:39I ended up trading euro dollar, pound
- 38:41dollar. And I've been doing that
- 38:42probably for six years now exclusively.
- 38:44I'll I'll one to four trades a week. Uh
- 38:46busy periods will get maybe up to 10 a
- 38:48week.
- 38:49>> Okay.
- 38:49>> Um, naturally if I'm in a trend, then I
- 38:51can ride that trend. And what I found
- 38:52the advantages of doing so, because I I
- 38:54get what you're saying. Why don't I just
- 38:56turn that read into a swing position?
- 38:58But I found the benefit is if I can
- 39:00sense price could go and make a lower
- 39:01low in a bearish market, I can find the
- 39:03heightened pockets of reaction, pockets
- 39:06of probability.
- 39:07>> Yeah.
- 39:07>> And instead of me catching one big one
- 39:08to five R, I can catch a few one to
- 39:10threes along the way. So my trading
- 39:12frequency is higher. My win rate is not
- 39:13the best. It floats around 35 to 55.
- 39:16>> Yeah, I don't care about your win rate
- 39:17whatsoever.
- 39:18>> my risk to reward can be one to threes
- 39:20and my rate of return can be higher. And
- 39:22I and I have a good trade frequency, I
- 39:24think. And then I have my A plus setups
- 39:26and my B plus and my C plus XYZ. So I
- 39:28deploy them depending on recent
- 39:30performance and I've architected it that
- 39:32way.
- 39:33Um,
- 39:33>> I guess one of the challenges I would
- 39:34throw out there is should you be doing
- 39:35your C trade, your BC trades at all? Are
- 39:38you better off increasing leverage on
- 39:40your A trades? For many traders, that
- 39:42turns out to be the answer.
- 39:44>> yeah, big debate I have is discretionary
- 39:45sizing. Do I size up on my high
- 39:47conviction plays
- 39:48or do I standardize? I've chosen to
- 39:50standardize and I see the merits in
- 39:51sizing up on on A plus setup.
- 39:54But uh
- 39:55we're talking about risk or exposure to
- 39:56the market. So there's two ways to have
- 39:57great exposure, sizing up on a high
- 39:59conviction or a certain scenarios in the
- 40:01market taking my C plus setup, which has
- 40:03a lower win rate. But if I know it
- 40:06happened to me in September actually,
- 40:07I went through a hot period, not through
- 40:09skill, it's just the distribution of
- 40:11outcomes, a 50% win rate system can have
- 40:14a recent performance of 80% win because
- 40:16it just the wins align and now the
- 40:17losses may may follow. So as a result of
- 40:20that, if I have my
- 40:22trajectory of my expectancy and it's and
- 40:24it's just up into the top right,
- 40:25hopefully. And then I have a period
- 40:27where it overshoots. Now it doesn't mean
- 40:29I've beaten my edge and now I'm going to
- 40:31have a new like superstar edge. It's
- 40:33just I've overperformed. But I realize
- 40:35when the when the market is hot or I'm
- 40:36hot at the moment, I can now add in a
- 40:39little bit more risk through riskier
- 40:41setups, which I wouldn't ordinarily take
- 40:43because my relative recent win rate is
- 40:4580.
- 40:46It should be a 40. So now I can afford
- 40:48to bring it down gradually, and I know
- 40:50I'm calibrating it. So when I start to
- 40:51hit the average of 50 in my last 15
- 40:54trades, get back to my A+ setups. So the
- 40:57as I revert back to my mean of my
- 40:58trajectory of my expectancy,
- 41:00uh I can control when to deploy these
- 41:02higher risk trades.
- 41:04Uh instead of sizing up now, I can
- 41:05actually get uh greater rate of return
- 41:07through greater trade frequency
- 41:09temporarily. That's how I've navigated
- 41:10it. I'd love to hear your thoughts
- 41:12actually. Would I be better off just
- 41:13sizing up on high conviction and having
- 41:15a lower general trade frequency?
- 41:17>> So
- 41:19if on the low side you're doing four
- 41:22trades a week,
- 41:24you're you're kind of
- 41:27tilted toward that longer holding period
- 41:29that I was talking about I think, right?
- 41:31Or are are these are these four short
- 41:33>> I'm trading FX. So it doesn't have the
- 41:35baked in bias, so it doesn't necessarily
- 41:36serve me to just
- 41:38turn it into a long-term hold. So I
- 41:39rarely hold a trade overnight.
- 41:41>> Okay.
- 41:41>> It would be usually a session reaction
- 41:43for my TP1, the average move of a
- 41:45session, and then my usually my TP2 and
- 41:47final TP is average movement of the day.
- 41:49I might leave a runner if I see that
- 41:51there's a long-term trend in play, but
- 41:53generally not.
- 41:54>> I generally find that most traders, you
- 41:57know, this ABC trade book is a common
- 42:00way to think about it. Most traders are
- 42:01better off not doing their B and C
- 42:02trades. They're
- 42:04But what you're describing is exactly If
- 42:07you If your C trades are trades that
- 42:09only happen are more likely to happen in
- 42:12certain market environments that you
- 42:14reach these environments
- 42:15>> That and I define it by lower win rates.
- 42:17Like it it has a 1 to 5 risk reward
- 42:19potential, um but it it has a 40% win
- 42:22rate. I don't want to start with that.
- 42:24>> strike me as a C trade, you know, the
- 42:25the the stats
- 42:26>> It still has an edge, but it's just not
- 42:27as good as the other ones that might
- 42:28appear twice a month where it can give
- 42:30me a 1 to 7 and it can give me a 80 % or
- 42:32not 80 probably around 65% win rate.
- 42:34These are the ones I would love to only
- 42:36focus on, but if I exclusively trade
- 42:37them, my rate of return suffers because
- 42:39I am taking a few trades a month. And if
- 42:42I have a bad month, it just
- 42:44to my personality, I don't like being
- 42:45wrong.
- 42:45>> Sure. Sure. No, I understand that. Um
- 42:49feels to me without like really getting
- 42:51into your numbers like you've probably
- 42:53laid this out in a way that makes sense
- 42:54for you.
- 42:55I would be I would be
- 42:57very hesitant for you to come away from
- 42:59this interview and go make changes based
- 43:00to based on anything that I'm saying
- 43:02because you are you've already asked a
- 43:04lot of the questions that I would ask
- 43:06and you seem to have good answers to
- 43:07them and I think it sounds like you
- 43:09found what's working for you right now.
- 43:12>> The the the interview has kind of
- 43:13flipped a little
- 43:14Let's uh let's put it back into towards
- 43:16yourself. What would your equivalent be
- 43:17of what I've just described of
- 43:19your KPIs, the way you deployed risk,
- 43:21how you built an edge around your
- 43:23temperament, which it seems like a a
- 43:24journey you had after your day trading
- 43:26uh era. What does life look like now in
- 43:28the markets?
- 43:29>> my
- 43:31you know I'm a I'm a person who
- 43:35really feeds off of obsession. If I do
- 43:37something
- 43:39I I I have two speeds, either full stop
- 43:42or full speed ahead.
- 43:43And what I have found with the markets
- 43:46is
- 43:47while I have been involved in trading in
- 43:50the markets, I've gone through periods I
- 43:52haven't been able to maintain for my
- 43:54entire career full focus. I think if I
- 43:57had it would have been very unhealthy.
- 43:58And I have recently been in a period of
- 44:02the major life transition where I
- 44:04haven't been trading quite as much. I
- 44:06haven't been taking as much risk. I've
- 44:07been uh doing more
- 44:11more simple trades, more simple only
- 44:14doing the trades that really jump out
- 44:16and say you know this is a very clear
- 44:18pattern that you have to take. And also
- 44:20to be one thing we maybe should discuss
- 44:22is I don't think the visual prettiness
- 44:25of a chart picture is any
- 44:28judge of its outcome. You know so I used
- 44:29to think that. Some people think that.
- 44:31But if you
- 44:33do a few thousand trades and separate
- 44:35them into
- 44:36patterns that looked really good and
- 44:37ones that don't and again do they does
- 44:39the outcome look different and you know
- 44:40you can do tests like that when you have
- 44:42data.
- 44:43Um
- 44:44now my
- 44:46I think I'm looking at a future because
- 44:48I 'm also thinking you know recently I
- 44:50had my 50th birthday a few years ago and
- 44:52I 'm thinking about how am I going to
- 44:54trade in the future.
- 44:55And it's not going to look like how I
- 44:57traded in my twenties and probably not
- 44:59going to look like how I traded 10 years
- 45:02ago.
- 45:02So my desire is to move into more of a
- 45:08I've always been a discretionary trader
- 45:10that has a quantitative foundation.
- 45:13You know, that I I've asked these kinds
- 45:14of questions, the things that you ask
- 45:16about Fibonacci, things I've had you
- 45:18know, every pattern I trade, if I see a
- 45:21market that makes a big move and then
- 45:23makes a consolidation, is there an edge
- 45:25to buying at the bottom of that
- 45:27consolidation? How can I define that uh
- 45:29if I have and some surprising things
- 45:32work. If I have a trend line, I I draw a
- 45:34trend line and then I draw a parallel
- 45:36trend line, is there an edge to
- 45:38executing against that parallel trend
- 45:40line?
- 45:40There is.
- 45:41>> Okay.
- 45:41>> Why? I don't know. Volatility probably
- 45:44has something to do with random walk
- 45:45volatility, but there is and then the
- 45:49you know, maybe the higher time frame
- 45:50influence of the I I I I do know it's
- 45:52there. It's but it's a you know, issue
- 45:55of shorter time frame mean reversion
- 45:57playing into longer time frame momentum.
- 45:59Uh
- 46:00so that is how I have traded, but I
- 46:03think I'm looking at doing something
- 46:04like more of a weighted alpha kind of
- 46:07approach where and this is actually a
- 46:09loop that we should close. Your question
- 46:10about the 200-day moving average. Um
- 46:14I can
- 46:16for me to have something that I can
- 46:17trade as a standalone, it has to be
- 46:19quite a good edge, right? Uh it has to
- 46:21have a certain expectancy, has to occur
- 46:25often. You know, if if it's a great
- 46:26trade that happens once a year, I might
- 46:28have three bad years trading it, right?
- 46:30You you just don't So you have to have
- 46:31you have all these things that play in
- 46:33to the system that's going to be the
- 46:34system you trade.
- 46:35One of the things you can do as a
- 46:37quantitative trader though and this
- 46:39for discretionary for retail traders
- 46:41this I think this is going to be
- 46:42important because people don't on the
- 46:44retail side typically think about this.
- 46:46I can have
- 46:48a handful of
- 46:50systems edges that kind of suck,
- 46:53but they have a small edge. There's no
- 46:55way I could trade
- 46:56And, you know, I might have
- 47:00It's like this. Uh,
- 47:01let's say you have 50 friends who
- 47:05are kind of good at guessing the
- 47:06direction of the market, but none of
- 47:08them like would really make that much
- 47:09money. You call them up every morning
- 47:12and you say, is the market going to go
- 47:13up or down today? And then you average
- 47:15them.
- 47:17And
- 47:19on days where most of them are telling
- 47:21you the market's going up, you would
- 47:22probably find you had a much stronger
- 47:25signal than you would from any one of
- 47:27those people. If you do it, any one of
- 47:28those people tells you you're not going
- 47:30to make money. But you average them
- 47:32together. This is what happens in a lot
- 47:35of quant trading. You take these alphas,
- 47:37and they have to be legitimate alphas,
- 47:39and you said an important word earlier,
- 47:41they have to be uncorrelated. And the
- 47:43problem is not that many things are
- 47:45truly uncorrelated because let's say I
- 47:48want to trade mean reversion. Great.
- 47:49Okay. So
- 47:52a signal might be a certain RSI level,
- 47:55might be a momentum divergence, might be
- 47:57a big standard deviation move down, it
- 47:59might be crossing a Bollinger band, it
- 48:01might be breaking under a five or 10 or
- 48:0320 day high. All of these would be ways
- 48:05that we would measure a big move down,
- 48:07right? They're all highly correlated. So
- 48:10so if I if I think that I I just told
- 48:13you six different ways that I can put in
- 48:14my average alpha, no, I it's it's like
- 48:17me calling the same person six times in
- 48:19the average. So you have to understand,
- 48:23you have to find these edges, and you
- 48:26have to they have to be uncorrelated,
- 48:29you average them together, and you get a
- 48:30much stronger signal than you would from
- 48:31any of them. None of them
- 48:33individually have to be
- 48:36standout.
- 48:38>> I don't know why, but that bothers me
- 48:39from a perspective of
- 48:41why does that work?
- 48:42>> Yep. Well, it's uh
- 48:46I think it has to do with the wisdom of
- 48:47crowds. I don't know if you know that
- 48:49book, but like one of the
- 48:51since we're sitting here in the middle
- 48:52of farmland in America, uh
- 48:56we have these county fairs. And one of
- 48:58the things that happens at these fairs,
- 49:01they would have an animal. They would
- 49:02have, you know, a bull or a pig. And
- 49:05people would
- 49:06put
- 49:07they they would bet on the weight of the
- 49:09animal. If they get the weight right,
- 49:12they get the animal. And what you find
- 49:15is that if you average up all of those
- 49:18guesses, they're actually quite close in
- 49:21most cases to what the animal actually
- 49:22weighs. So what's actually happening
- 49:24there?
- 49:26You have people like me and you know, I
- 49:27assume maybe you who have no idea what
- 49:29they are. So like we're just writing
- 49:30numbers down. My guess is not good. Your
- 49:32guess is not good. But
- 49:35people like us who don't know anything,
- 49:36those guesses are going to average out
- 49:38to kind of zero. And then you have the
- 49:40handful of people who really know what
- 49:41they're looking at, who have intelligent
- 49:43guesses and those actually. So it's kind
- 49:46of like that with the Alphas, you know,
- 49:47the ones that if they're weak working
- 49:51together,
- 49:52the ones that
- 49:54they'll tend to average each other out
- 49:56until several of them point in the same
- 49:57direction.
- 49:58So you can't do this on a discretionary
- 50:00basis to be clear.
- 50:02>> Oh, my question was actually going to be
- 50:05a retail trader listening it might be
- 50:07like, okay, I I I like Fibonacci, but
- 50:09it's not good enough. So let me cross
- 50:10that over with the trend line and an EMA
- 50:12and a doji candle and a head and
- 50:13shoulder pattern. All of a sudden I've
- 50:15got a cocktail of confluences.
- 50:17>> Yeah.
- 50:17>> None of them were necessarily causative
- 50:18or had an edge, but in combination
- 50:21it might be.
- 50:22>> I I don't I've never seen that work. I
- 50:26because first of all, many of those
- 50:27things are correlated, right?
- 50:29The Fibonacci level and the trend line
- 50:31and the EMA and you know, throw a band
- 50:34in there. You've you've moved to a level
- 50:37and those things are probably and are
- 50:39you know, the argument of course is
- 50:40well, if the trend line's at the level,
- 50:41maybe it's more meaningful and you know,
- 50:43we we can test that and look at it.
- 50:46I
- 50:48in the in the discretionary world
- 50:51this is there's also this there's this
- 50:53argument against about should we have
- 50:56confluence and or confirmation. Those
- 50:59are kind of two separate things, right?
- 51:01Do you want to buy in anticipation of
- 51:03the move or sell in anticipation or do
- 51:05you want to wait for the move wait for
- 51:07the train to start moving and then you
- 51:08jump on board. Both of those things work
- 51:12but with the with the confluence
- 51:16people are many times just measuring the
- 51:18same things and they're using things
- 51:19that don't work and is it possible is it
- 51:22possible that something does not work at
- 51:24all and when you put it with something
- 51:27else that then it magically works.
- 51:32Probably not. It it might it might be
- 51:35possible that we have a signal that has
- 51:37no edge and then we put something under
- 51:39it that filters out a bunch of the
- 51:41signals and we have a
- 51:42I haven't really seen that work very
- 51:45reliably. It's theoretically possible,
- 51:46but the key to making this averaged
- 51:49thing work is that all of the each of
- 51:52the pieces has to have an edge
- 51:54separately and they need to be
- 51:56uncorrelated. Most of the things like
- 51:58you know the Fibonacci levels that we're
- 52:00talking about
- 52:01there's not an edge there in the first
- 52:02place.
- 52:03>> you remind me why uncorrelated was
- 52:04necessary because if I'm stacking this
- 52:06EMA, trend line, Fibonacci, da da da,
- 52:08yes they're all correlated telling me
- 52:10the same thing, but that's the point.
- 52:11They are
- 52:12adding additional
- 52:13>> for the you're looking for the
- 52:14correlation and you're assuming the
- 52:15correlation.
- 52:16>> Assuming they are adding odds stacking
- 52:17odds in my favor.
- 52:18>> You're just measuring the same thing a
- 52:20different way.
- 52:21>> Uh-huh.
- 52:21>> You're you're
- 52:23I that that's the argument against it
- 52:25you because everything we look at in the
- 52:27market is you know if if if you really
- 52:31want to blow your mind
- 52:32going back to first principles which is
- 52:34a phrase you said everything we look at
- 52:36in the market is something that's
- 52:39happening in the market, but it's also
- 52:41the structure that we're imposing on the
- 52:43market. It's the way that we're
- 52:44measuring it. Even just a chart you can
- 52:46say no there's no structure Adam. I'm
- 52:48just drawing a line of a like every
- 52:50trade you know a one tick line chart.
- 52:52That's still a structure, right? Because
- 52:54you're still you still have an axis and
- 52:56certainly if we put it into bars or
- 52:58candles
- 52:59we've put a structure around it and then
- 53:01trend
- 53:02you can see everything else right how we
- 53:04measured that. Uh, RSI, trend line,
- 53:07Fibonacci, you're putting structure on
- 53:09it. So you're you're just measuring it
- 53:11and is there that fundamental you know,
- 53:14the market made this move down and then
- 53:16all of these things are going to speak.
- 53:20The you know, the the quantitative thing
- 53:22is see if you have a regression model uh
- 53:25you know, people who have more math than
- 53:27I do understand this intuitively. And if
- 53:29those inputs into the regression model
- 53:30are highly correlated, they make your
- 53:32model look a lot better than it is. They
- 53:34make your confidence in the model, but
- 53:36it's not actually that good because your
- 53:37inputs, it's one of the things you're
- 53:38looking at specifically and most models
- 53:41is you want to see those inputs are not
- 53:42correlated. And in reality, everything's
- 53:44kind of correlated, so you don't you
- 53:46never get to zero.
- 53:48>> Yeah, I guess to visualize it, it's like
- 53:50all these confluences were like Venn
- 53:51diagrams, but you're just adding more
- 53:53circles, but the crossover period is
- 53:55what's relevant. And as opposed to rungs
- 53:58on a ladder, they're not climbing you
- 53:59higher. It's more like the Venn diagram.
- 54:01Okay. I'm I'm also not curious on
- 54:03invalidations because we've spoken about
- 54:05reasons price could do something
- 54:07>> Yeah.
- 54:08>> and confluences and then uh if they're
- 54:10too correlated X, Y, Z,
- 54:12you could you could do this process, but
- 54:14then I guess what would be more relevant
- 54:15is two things that appear optically
- 54:17similar or parameter similar, but you
- 54:20would take one and you wouldn't take the
- 54:21other. What would certain invalidations
- 54:22look like?
- 54:24>> For me, um
- 54:29so understand and we keep talking about
- 54:30buying, maybe we should talk about
- 54:31selling to make it symmetrical, but I'll
- 54:33keep it on buying. If if I'm looking to
- 54:35buy a consolidation,
- 54:37I don't want to see that it makes many
- 54:40probes to the upside and is rejected.
- 54:44So visually, if you're looking at a
- 54:46chart,
- 54:47I don't want that upper boundary to be
- 54:49really ragged. The market makes a swing
- 54:51high and then comes down. I don't like
- 54:54if you're going above that swing high
- 54:56and getting rejected there because
- 54:57there's price we're back to Wyckoff,
- 54:58right? Uh, on the other hand, I'm really
- 55:01happy to see that ragged bottom. You
- 55:03know, I'd like to see the the contained
- 55:05and then it tries to sell off and they
- 55:07buy it right back up. So that kind of
- 55:10asymmetry. It's fine if the bottom
- 55:12smooths too, but I certainly uh if I've
- 55:15been watching for an entry price and a
- 55:18pullback and it breaks out and then
- 55:21fails, in most cases I'm no longer
- 55:23interested. I you know I I have a very
- 55:26easy time killing setups. I I have a you
- 55:30know I can be really excited I don't get
- 55:32excited about anything, but I can be
- 55:32really excited about a setup and then it
- 55:34does something I don't even want to talk
- 55:35It's dead to me. I'm done with it. Um
- 55:38the
- 55:39sometimes it just goes on too long. You
- 55:42know there should be my my thinking and
- 55:44here we're back to stories. My thinking
- 55:46is that
- 55:48if I have identified one of these places
- 55:50there's going to be good continuation
- 55:51there should be some urgency behind it.
- 55:53I I shouldn't see you know if there is
- 55:55if if we're talking about a commodity
- 55:57and there's a supply shortage, I should
- 55:59not see it make a big move up
- 56:01and then just kind of sit sideways for
- 56:02months. That doesn't really say there's
- 56:04any kind of urgency there. Same thing if
- 56:06it's a one minute chart, you know we
- 56:08just just scale it differently. I want
- 56:10to see that there's urgency.
- 56:11>> Does that imply that you got in for a
- 56:13reason, whatever that reason may be, and
- 56:16volume or momentum is necessary and
- 56:18therefore a sense of invalidation is
- 56:19lack of participation in your direction.
- 56:21Would you therefore
- 56:23act upon that in the sense of you're
- 56:24already in a position, you have your
- 56:25parameters of take profit entry and stop
- 56:27loss, price is just around your entry,
- 56:29it's a little bit in profit. Will you
- 56:30say okay upon a kind of time decay this
- 56:33is taking too long long. It could still
- 56:35play out. It's just not happening in the
- 56:37time frames I needed to, but it hasn't
- 56:39invalidated. It hasn't hit my stop. The
- 56:41idea is still there. Would you exit that
- 56:43position?
- 56:43>> Yeah. Yeah, I I would. That that is one
- 56:46of the
- 56:49So you know when I told you that I
- 56:50basically traded the same way for
- 56:52decades
- 56:53trading the basic structure, these kinds
- 56:56of questions exactly how do you manage a
- 56:58trade? How do you get out when it's
- 56:59working? How do you get out when it's
- 57:01not? How do you know when it's not
- 57:02working?
- 57:03What do you do if it's not working and
- 57:04then it's working again you know how do
- 57:05you make These are the kinds of
- 57:06decisions that
- 57:09do evolve and change and there would
- 57:12have been a time uh
- 57:14when I was a day trader, the answer to
- 57:16that question was automatically
- 57:18instantly I'm out. I'm looking for any
- 57:21excuse as a day trader to say the trade
- 57:23is not working, I am done. And you know
- 57:27you you learn this by getting kicked in
- 57:28the head doing doing it the wrong way
- 57:30enough times. As soon as you have a
- 57:32little bit of a a little bit of hope you
- 57:34know a little bit let's just give it a
- 57:35little more time. Sometimes it'll work
- 57:37and you'll remember those times but if
- 57:39you run your stats far more often you
- 57:41need to get out.
- 57:43But on on the daily time frame it has
- 57:46paid to be a little bit stickier and I
- 57:48think this is one of the ways the market
- 57:49has changed in the past
- 57:51>> three years. It's no longer pain to be
- 57:53sticky on the daily time frame if
- 57:55something doesn't look good.
- 57:57Better situation.
- 57:58>> I was I was thinking when to bring up
- 57:59this topic but I feel like you've
- 58:02there's many roads in this conversation
- 58:03that have led to this question.
- 58:05You were talking about the trend line
- 58:06and having a trend line parallel to it
- 58:08and there seems to be something there. I
- 58:09took note of it. You were mentioning how
- 58:11when you get to the range high and
- 58:13you're getting rejection as opposed to
- 58:14movement that would be some sort of
- 58:15invalidation. I took note of that cuz
- 58:17what would that mean? And then when
- 58:18you're talking about okay you got into
- 58:20an you got in for a certain reason but
- 58:21it's not moving as quick as you would
- 58:22need to
- 58:24and you would you would take off you
- 58:25take off the position even though
- 58:26nothing has changed apart from time has
- 58:28elapsed. I took note of that.
- 58:30These things all
- 58:31bring me to
- 58:33I don't know the term for it but it
- 58:34might be a sense of market impact
- 58:37kind of a reflection of order flow where
- 58:39there are moments in the market that are
- 58:40highly reactionary I found. Let's say
- 58:43just to draw a visual
- 58:44there there's grades to it that I have
- 58:46but a high of previous day
- 58:47we could call that some sort of
- 58:49resistance. I've found if price sweeps
- 58:51it pushes higher
- 58:53naturally you invite in breakout traders
- 58:54they're going to look to buy that and
- 58:56then also you take the stops of the
- 58:57people that were holding their cells in
- 58:59that position. So this becomes a high
- 59:00impact or high inflection point. And
- 59:02I've noted that when you sweep it you
- 59:05get a reaction down that might not be
- 59:07for the rest of the day rest of the rest
- 59:08of the month but for a duration it will.
- 59:11>> Yep.
- 59:11>> And that's basically the center of my
- 59:13edge. Now I might be not it's not just
- 59:14high previous day, it could be
- 59:16the high of previous week, it could also
- 59:17be a structural point. There's many
- 59:18levels to it, but that's basically an
- 59:20extension of my edge. And then I've
- 59:22noticed like the bigger zones like a
- 59:24daily high uh sorry
- 59:26let's say a daily impulse, a lower high
- 59:27to lower low. At the extreme of it, if
- 59:29we take that high, it gives a bit of a
- 59:31bigger reaction as opposed to just in
- 59:33New York session you take London's high,
- 59:34which gives a smaller reaction.
- 59:35>> Mhm.
- 59:36>> What is going on here? What what am I
- 59:38describing?
- 59:38>> I think you've like you laid out the
- 59:40dynamics perfectly. That's exactly what
- 59:42happens.
- 59:43>> I mean more of like why is it happening?
- 59:45>> Because you are the market is always
- 59:48probing into areas to see if there's
- 59:51real interest. And I couldn't have said
- 59:54it better than you did. In my first
- 59:56book, I laid out six basic price
- 1:00:00patterns, what you're describing, your
- 1:00:02edge was the first one that I put in the
- 1:00:03book. This idea of penetrating a level
- 1:00:06and then failing. So you know one of the
- 1:00:10things that has happened, markets always
- 1:00:12markets are looking for liquidity.
- 1:00:14Markets want to make trades. They the
- 1:00:17exchange exists to facilitate trade, to
- 1:00:20make trades happen. So markets are
- 1:00:22always looking for places to make
- 1:00:24trades. And the market is if we think of
- 1:00:27the market as a conscious being, the
- 1:00:29market's going to probe above those
- 1:00:31highs and to say is there really buying
- 1:00:33pressure here? Certainly there are there
- 1:00:35are orders, you know I can I know I can
- 1:00:36go get those orders executed because
- 1:00:38people have shorts, they have stops, and
- 1:00:40there are the hopeful breakout traders.
- 1:00:42But how much buying pressure is how do I
- 1:00:44know? Well let's go execute there and
- 1:00:46see. And if there wasn't much, then
- 1:00:48those that those people are going to
- 1:00:50sell uh you know the the hopeful
- 1:00:52breakout traders when their hope is
- 1:00:54gone, they sell and then you kind of get
- 1:00:56this cascade of selling. For me, there's
- 1:00:58also a reaction after that. So you have
- 1:01:01that penetration versus if you have
- 1:01:03acceptance where you where you go up
- 1:01:05above the high and turns out oh there's
- 1:01:08actually real buying pressure here,
- 1:01:10there is continuation. If you have that
- 1:01:12failure scenario,
- 1:01:14then there's
- 1:01:15potentially kind of a second move,
- 1:01:17right? You have you have the failure,
- 1:01:19the market goes back below the high.
- 1:01:21Everybody's like, oh, what happened,
- 1:01:22right? And you sit there for a minute
- 1:01:24and then if more sellers come in, you
- 1:01:26may get another leg down. That's also
- 1:01:28quite uh reliable tradable move
- 1:01:30sometimes. And then of course, you know,
- 1:01:32it's uh
- 1:01:34back to your question about me what I'm
- 1:01:37doing and when I'm in a trade, when I'm
- 1:01:39thinking about a trade, every tick that
- 1:01:41comes in is data.
- 1:01:43And
- 1:01:44I'm analyzing every piece of data that
- 1:01:46comes in. I'm probably analyzing most of
- 1:01:48it wrong, but I'm getting enough right
- 1:01:50to be able to be on the right side of
- 1:01:52the market more often than not. And so,
- 1:01:56you know, the market comes in and now
- 1:01:58it's processing that move and now if the
- 1:02:01market sits near that high, you know,
- 1:02:02now maybe we're sitting you know, you
- 1:02:04can establish a short there against that
- 1:02:06high, but the more time you sit there,
- 1:02:09the probabilities are not really
- 1:02:10favoring that drop. They're favoring
- 1:02:12another trip to this high.
- 1:02:13>> I like what you mentioned before of
- 1:02:14confluence versus confirmation. And I
- 1:02:17I've always toyed with which one is
- 1:02:19better. Around these scenarios, you have
- 1:02:21a liquidity point. Price shoots above
- 1:02:23it. Naturally, this is a dangerous place
- 1:02:25to be because it is by definition an
- 1:02:26inflection point. You could get buyers
- 1:02:28stepping in, it goes up. It could also
- 1:02:29be a rejection point, it goes down. How
- 1:02:31do we know which one? So, there's some
- 1:02:32things you could do to I guess put put
- 1:02:34the odds in your favor, but I I found
- 1:02:36it's a bit more dangerous to enter
- 1:02:37there, but when I see the rejection and
- 1:02:39the sellers are taking strength, whether
- 1:02:40it's defined by a M1 break of structure
- 1:02:42or XYZ parameters, then upon certain
- 1:02:45parameters, I'll then enter the short.
- 1:02:47But the issue is it's hard to know if
- 1:02:48this is is it going to be a sustained
- 1:02:50move, which is why I can't turn that
- 1:02:51into a swing trade even though I'm in a
- 1:02:53bearish market and I found a sell at the
- 1:02:55top. I don't know if I can hold it
- 1:02:57because it could chop around and
- 1:02:58invalidate the next day.
- 1:02:59Uh so, what I've kind of found a
- 1:03:01parameter for me that helps me is I just
- 1:03:03break even super fast. I would just like
- 1:03:05literally as soon as I can. It might tap
- 1:03:07me out here and there. It does happen a
- 1:03:08lot and that is frustrating, but a lot
- 1:03:10of the times I can just take a shot not
- 1:03:13knowing really what's going on, but it
- 1:03:15just if I'm protected, I'm risk free and
- 1:03:16then it happens to play. And uh if I
- 1:03:18look back in my last year, around 30% of
- 1:03:21my profit was trades where I got the
- 1:03:23direction wrong. I was selling and the
- 1:03:25the week ended up bullish, the day ended
- 1:03:26up bullish, but I caught a reaction,
- 1:03:28broke even fast, and let it run to
- 1:03:30targets. So I was wrong, but yet
- 1:03:32captured a profit. Seems weird, but that
- 1:03:34was 30% of my profit for the last year.
- 1:03:36>> that those are my favorite trades to be
- 1:03:37to be wrong and make money. Yeah.
- 1:03:39>> Yes.
- 1:03:40Um I I'm also curious here because yes,
- 1:03:42I'm I'm at a younger or a different
- 1:03:44stage in my life compared to yourself,
- 1:03:45but I also find that finding alpha
- 1:03:47enough or an edge enough is so
- 1:03:49difficult.
- 1:03:50Most people are not in a place of luxury
- 1:03:52or abundance to say, let me pick the
- 1:03:53edge that suits me the most. How have
- 1:03:55you found yourself in a position where
- 1:03:57I don't know how to turn my approach to
- 1:03:59a swing approach and and take it a bit
- 1:04:01more easy. How have you been able to
- 1:04:03reshape an edge that would be
- 1:04:05draining on your time and consuming you
- 1:04:06and your let's say obsessive personality
- 1:04:08that you have to now be like, I'm
- 1:04:09getting older now and I want to be less
- 1:04:11stressed, so I'm going to now turn it
- 1:04:13into a longer time horizon hold. It
- 1:04:15feels like you're just going to be
- 1:04:16looking for a whole new edge and a whole
- 1:04:17new system.
- 1:04:18>> I don't I don't think
- 1:04:21you get to do what you're suggesting. I
- 1:04:23I don't think you get to take your
- 1:04:25specific edge and make it make it a
- 1:04:27longer term hold. So, you know, back to
- 1:04:30kind of themes we run through this
- 1:04:32interview, we're talking about mean
- 1:04:34reversion and momentum. And there are
- 1:04:35traders who trade, broadly speaking,
- 1:04:38mean reversion or in your a mean
- 1:04:39reversion trader.
- 1:04:40In general, and when you say in general,
- 1:04:43you're going to make a lot of bad
- 1:04:44generalizations, but in general, mean
- 1:04:46reversion traders need to take profits
- 1:04:48very quickly.
- 1:04:49As soon as there is money on the table,
- 1:04:51you put it in your pocket and you're
- 1:04:53done. Momentum traders,
- 1:04:55generally speaking, can be a little bit
- 1:04:57stickier, you know, like I'll I'll let
- 1:04:59it ride. I give I give it a little bit
- 1:05:00more time. Um
- 1:05:03you don't get to decide you want to play
- 1:05:07for a bigger move because the another
- 1:05:10way to think about it is every signal
- 1:05:13that we would have and to talk broadly
- 1:05:14in signals,
- 1:05:16I think, and this may not be accurate,
- 1:05:18but I think they have an
- 1:05:21a limited influence over the market.
- 1:05:24Both in terms of time and magnitude. So
- 1:05:26I do not believe yes, we can go back 20
- 1:05:29years and we can find the intraday low
- 1:05:32from the British pound that held for
- 1:05:35years and you can say that was the
- 1:05:37moment that pattern help
- 1:05:39No, it didn't. You know, I I I I don't
- 1:05:41believe that and that's just I guess
- 1:05:43it's a belief. But your
- 1:05:46mean reverting patterns have a
- 1:05:48relatively short duration where they're
- 1:05:50valid because they're going to be
- 1:05:51absorbed. Something happened. Unless of
- 1:05:53course then it cascades into something
- 1:05:55else, but that's a different kind of
- 1:05:56trade. Now you're swing trading the
- 1:05:58momentum to the downside, which is a
- 1:06:00valid trade. You know, somebody can look
- 1:06:03at the trade you take and say, you know,
- 1:06:05that guy it's like, you know, the person
- 1:06:08who's first is the person who gets shot
- 1:06:10a lot of times, right? You don't want to
- 1:06:11be the first guy through the door,
- 1:06:12right? Uh so they'll they'll let you
- 1:06:15take that trade. I'm going to let you
- 1:06:17take that trade. I'll I'll tell you
- 1:06:18that's the kind of trader I am. And then
- 1:06:20when it breaks to the downside again,
- 1:06:23I'm interested in that move. So you've
- 1:06:25taken what I would consider to be a
- 1:06:26higher risk trade. It's actually
- 1:06:28probably a higher probability trade. You
- 1:06:29probably make money on more of those,
- 1:06:31but the way you make money on more of
- 1:06:33those is by taking smaller profits,
- 1:06:35which means you're not playing for a big
- 1:06:36move. You're not playing for a long
- 1:06:37move. So you
- 1:06:40I don't think you get to say I just want
- 1:06:42to hold these trades longer. How how can
- 1:06:43I do that? Yeah, so I mean and I you
- 1:06:46figured that out.
- 1:06:46>> You you kind of spoken in labels of the
- 1:06:49the principles of the market could be
- 1:06:50mean reversion or trending or it could
- 1:06:52be um momentum these orientations.
- 1:06:56How do I know which one I am? Because
- 1:06:58mean reverting and trend it depends on
- 1:07:01the time frame you're looking at. I
- 1:07:03could be trending daily bullish, but hey
- 1:07:05H1 bearish, M15 bullish,
- 1:07:07M1 bearish. Which time frame is the mean
- 1:07:10reverting and trend?
- 1:07:11>> Well, so you this is one very common
- 1:07:15mistake. Uh
- 1:07:18you have a time frame that you trade.
- 1:07:19That's your trading time frame. And
- 1:07:22let's say you get in let's just go back
- 1:07:24to our example. Let's say you get short
- 1:07:28on your one-minute time frame.
- 1:07:30And then it turns into a loss and you're
- 1:07:32holding it and I'm I'm guessing
- 1:07:33viscerally you're like you wouldn't do
- 1:07:35that. So like, you know, you you've
- 1:07:37learned this. But let's say you do that
- 1:07:38because you notice the 15-minute is
- 1:07:41still kind of bearish.
- 1:07:42And then that goes away on the 15-minute
- 1:07:44and you you look at the oh, the hourly.
- 1:07:47I have known more than one trader who
- 1:07:51have entered trades on very low time
- 1:07:54frames and ended up holding losing
- 1:07:56trades for weeks.
- 1:07:57The equivalent of risking a few hundred
- 1:07:59dollars and losing tens of thousands of
- 1:08:02dollars. This this is I call it the time
- 1:08:04frame justification system.
- 1:08:06And the way you avoid it is you say this
- 1:08:09is the time frame I trade. I am in this
- 1:08:12market because of this pattern, because
- 1:08:14of this condition. And when that no
- 1:08:16longer exists, I'm in business being in
- 1:08:18that market. So you
- 1:08:21you could look to develop a separate
- 1:08:22edge on the daily time frame, but you
- 1:08:26really need to stick with your time
- 1:08:28frame. It also has to do
- 1:08:30You want me to like
- 1:08:31>> Go go go go.
- 1:08:32>> It also has to do with how you manage
- 1:08:33the trade because uh we could be in a
- 1:08:36situation where, you know, let's say the
- 1:08:39the the euro goes up and then comes down
- 1:08:42and you you short it and I buy it at the
- 1:08:45exact same time. We both can make money
- 1:08:46on that trade.
- 1:08:47>> Mhm.
- 1:08:48>> You know, you you might be out and I
- 1:08:51might buy more from you and then it goes
- 1:08:53up later and you would have had a losing
- 1:08:54trade, but you had a profitable trade
- 1:08:56because you have your you took your
- 1:08:57shorter profits as a mean-reverting
- 1:08:59trader. Again, very broadly speaking,
- 1:09:01needs to do. And because I was trading
- 1:09:03momentum, I needed to be stickier and I
- 1:09:05gave it more room to run. So it really
- 1:09:07is it's not just what the market does,
- 1:09:10it's you defining what you're going to
- 1:09:12do in response to what the market does.
- 1:09:13>> So you mentioned you should have a time
- 1:09:14frame you select to trade upon.
- 1:09:16Uh
- 1:09:18by trade upon you mean a time frame I
- 1:09:19execute upon? Because I can also do a
- 1:09:22top-down analysis on multiple time
- 1:09:24frames to ideate something and then I
- 1:09:26will always execute on M1.
- 1:09:28Uh should I separate those two things?
- 1:09:30>> I mean you you already do. Where where
- 1:09:32you get in trouble is if you're using
- 1:09:34you know one common frame is you can use
- 1:09:36several higher time frames or you can
- 1:09:39use a higher and a lower time frame. But
- 1:09:42and there are certainly things you can
- 1:09:43do like you have your trading time frame
- 1:09:46and you execute on the lower time frame
- 1:09:48and then you manage it on your trading
- 1:09:50time like though though but you you're
- 1:09:52consistent. You know you're not it's not
- 1:09:55like you're you're trading 15 5 and 1
- 1:09:57minute and then all of a sudden I call
- 1:09:59you up and you're trading on the 2-hour
- 1:10:01chart today. That's a break of
- 1:10:03discipline and that that will get you in
- 1:10:05trouble. So yeah you just and you might
- 1:10:07even you know I could imagine that you
- 1:10:09tell me so most of my trades are on the
- 1:10:111-minute chart but I have this one setup
- 1:10:13that happens a few times a month on the
- 1:10:14hourly chart and then I trade that. But
- 1:10:16the trade is consistent on the time
- 1:10:18frame that you're where you're getting
- 1:10:20trouble is bouncing.
- 1:10:20>> That makes sense to me. I I have with
- 1:10:22time I've found with the style of
- 1:10:24trading I have a top-down analysis
- 1:10:26doesn't serve me because what relevance
- 1:10:28does a monthly trend or a weekly or even
- 1:10:31a daily trend have unless I'm in the
- 1:10:34like the extremes
- 1:10:35>> Yeah.
- 1:10:35>> and most of the time I'm in no man's
- 1:10:36land. How's that going to affect my
- 1:10:37London session tomorrow? Uh so I've
- 1:10:39avoided it and and I'm basically between
- 1:10:41M15 and M1. Is there any merit in
- 1:10:43thinking in this way?
- 1:10:44>> That's where I've evolved over the
- 1:10:45years. I most of my trading
- 1:10:48So I got to be careful here because I
- 1:10:49tell you most of my trading is on one
- 1:10:51time frame but what I'm doing when I
- 1:10:53look at that one time frame chart I'm
- 1:10:55visualizing the higher time frame. So I
- 1:10:57don't think there's anything wrong with
- 1:10:58you seeing the structure on the higher
- 1:10:59time frame. And I suppose you know
- 1:11:02you're aware of levels on the higher
- 1:11:03time frame that I may miss and if you're
- 1:11:05coming into an important monthly level
- 1:11:07that I might not see on my 1-minute
- 1:11:09chart might be good to know that. Like
- 1:11:10you know I I understand that argument.
- 1:11:12But I think in general uh people add
- 1:11:16pieces of complexity and it doesn't
- 1:11:18necessarily add to to better results. I
- 1:11:21I almost always have if I'm trading on
- 1:11:23the daily time frame I'll have the
- 1:11:24weekly time frame there but
- 1:11:26I'm
- 1:11:27my attention's on the daily. I I I'm
- 1:11:29trading one chart, one time frame.
- 1:11:31>> Back to that scenario we said where we
- 1:11:33we probe a high and we're looking for
- 1:11:34sellers to get in to then to then see a
- 1:11:36rejection.
- 1:11:37The word we used was liquidity. Do we
- 1:11:39see sellers liquidity and and lack of
- 1:11:41buyers liquidity?
- 1:11:42I I've had this conversation with a few
- 1:11:44people and they say to me, well,
- 1:11:46there's liquidity everywhere in the
- 1:11:47market literally every point, every pip,
- 1:11:49every tick there is liquidity.
- 1:11:50Will there be zones of heightened
- 1:11:52liquidity such as a previous day's high?
- 1:11:54And does heightened liquidity equal
- 1:11:56better opportunity or does it kind of
- 1:11:57also cancel out?
- 1:12:01>> Giving
- 1:12:02caveat of this answer, this is not my
- 1:12:03specialization. I don't know for sure.
- 1:12:06Yeah, there's liquidity at every point,
- 1:12:07but there's a varying amount of
- 1:12:09liquidity. What is liquidity? It's not
- 1:12:11just resting orders. It's people being
- 1:12:13willing to execute there and you
- 1:12:14certainly could revisit a level very
- 1:12:16quickly based on what price does and
- 1:12:18liquidity is completely It's constantly
- 1:12:19changing, right?
- 1:12:21I think that ultimately
- 1:12:23all of our edge comes from these shifts
- 1:12:26in liquidity. That That's what it is.
- 1:12:28And you know, then maybe we're back to
- 1:12:30your order book question. Maybe people
- 1:12:32are able to access that and understand
- 1:12:34that in a way that I'm not really
- 1:12:36looking at.
- 1:12:37But I I think it all does come I mean,
- 1:12:39we're using liquidity which sounds like
- 1:12:41a big fancy word, but really what it
- 1:12:43means is just people being willing to
- 1:12:44transact at a price and people You know,
- 1:12:46there's always a buy order for every
- 1:12:48sell order, but you know, what urgency
- 1:12:51is what what motivation is behind those?
- 1:12:52That's really the question.
- 1:12:54>> As you mentioned to yourself of you're
- 1:12:55evolve ever evolving,
- 1:12:57I feel like I've reached a a bit of a
- 1:12:59ceiling and I know what the next step
- 1:13:00would be. I just have a skill gap which
- 1:13:03is
- 1:13:04I do try to trade mechanical around
- 1:13:06parameters and it is objective. I don't
- 1:13:07trade intuition or gut feelings or
- 1:13:10anything like that.
- 1:13:11So therefore it would serve me to take
- 1:13:12it algorithmic and and quantitative and
- 1:13:15make it systematize and let's say even
- 1:13:17eradicate human error by just having it
- 1:13:19automated. I just don't really know how
- 1:13:21to
- 1:13:22you self-taught. So maybe you could shed
- 1:13:24some light again especially in the AI
- 1:13:25era how I myself and many others
- 1:13:27listening could take that step.
- 1:13:30>> Well, let me tell you a bad
- 1:13:31>> thing to do with AI first. So this and
- 1:13:33I'm seeing a lot of this. The bad thing
- 1:13:35you do with AI is you go to your AI of
- 1:13:39choice and you say what is the edge in
- 1:13:42this pattern? Buy or find a
- 1:13:45find a trading system that works for you
- 1:13:48know what concept should I I don't think
- 1:13:50at this point maybe this will change I
- 1:13:51don't think AI is really good at that
- 1:13:53ideation level.
- 1:13:55I also would not trust an AI to say you
- 1:13:59know we're talking the stats behind your
- 1:14:01trade you know if the Euro takes out the
- 1:14:03one minute at in this time window during
- 1:14:05the day against these sessions
- 1:14:08you know what are the stats after that?
- 1:14:10I would if you asked AI I would have
- 1:14:12zero confidence in that answer. What I
- 1:14:14have done so I have a quantitative
- 1:14:18framework that I've driven for years
- 1:14:19that was you know written in MATLAB and
- 1:14:22Python and R and I am now driving it
- 1:14:26with AI. So I'm having conversations
- 1:14:28with AI I'm asking these kinds of
- 1:14:30questions but the AI is not answering
- 1:14:33the questions the AI is driving my code
- 1:14:36yeah but what it means is because I'm a
- 1:14:38I'm a pretty shitty programmer to be
- 1:14:40honest I I don't have to actually
- 1:14:43program the system
- 1:14:45figure out how to you know program the
- 1:14:48levels.
- 1:14:49I can tell the AI what I want it can
- 1:14:51kick it back visual confirmation I can
- 1:14:53look at a few hundred charts and say
- 1:14:55yeah that 's right you know let's tweak
- 1:14:57this and then I can run the test but
- 1:14:59it's coming from my code driven by AI.
- 1:15:02I think anybody can do something like
- 1:15:04that but I think you have to kind of and
- 1:15:06it sound you know I know it sounds
- 1:15:07daunting but you can develop your own
- 1:15:09framework that's going to be much more
- 1:15:11valuable than asking AI for the answer.
- 1:15:13>> I've spoken to a variety of guests on
- 1:15:15the show and a unanimous common
- 1:15:17denominator between all of them is the
- 1:15:18emphasis they put on data and actually
- 1:15:20knowing the inner workings and the
- 1:15:22insights of your edge and your
- 1:15:23performance. That 's why I'm proud to
- 1:15:24bring a partner of the show TradeZella
- 1:15:26the number one journaling back testing
- 1:15:28and all-in-one insights experience
- 1:15:30created by traders for traders. What
- 1:15:32TradeZella really gives you is deep
- 1:15:33insights about your trading that would
- 1:15:35ordinarily not be visible, whether it's
- 1:15:36through understanding your trade types
- 1:15:38and playbooks or even insights powered
- 1:15:40by artificial intelligence through Zella
- 1:15:41AI. Whether you trade forex, futures,
- 1:15:43cryptos, the stock market, it all
- 1:15:45seamlessly connects to TradeZella, so
- 1:15:47there is no additional work. You've seen
- 1:15:48me reference it dozens of times and all
- 1:15:50of the benefits I've had in my trading
- 1:15:52from the insights I've found from my
- 1:15:53TradeZella. So join myself and thousands
- 1:15:55of other viewers of the show, you'll get
- 1:15:57the best discount using the link in the
- 1:15:58description or code TOT for Titans of
- 1:16:01Tomorrow. So the reasons I would want to
- 1:16:02go on this path and and I could hire
- 1:16:05someone or whatever the answer would be.
- 1:16:06But anyway, the reason I would do it is
- 1:16:08to seek a certain advantage and the
- 1:16:09advantage would be I guess an element of
- 1:16:11buying back a bit of time.
- 1:16:13The advantage would be when human error
- 1:16:15comes in that could be eradicated. Even
- 1:16:16to this day it does happen from time to
- 1:16:18time.
- 1:16:19And then also
- 1:16:21performance related of like if I'm
- 1:16:23traveling right now I just don't trade
- 1:16:24because I'm in different time zones and
- 1:16:25I can't really do it. But I could in
- 1:16:27theory have it still running and check
- 1:16:28up on upon it. So these would be the
- 1:16:30benefits I would pursue.
- 1:16:32But now you are also
- 1:16:34algorithmic and mechanical and
- 1:16:35objective, but also discretionary. And
- 1:16:38it feels like then you would remove the
- 1:16:40said benefits that I'm looking for by
- 1:16:41being discretionary in in the mix.
- 1:16:43>> So there's several ways to do it. One of
- 1:16:45the classic ways to do it
- 1:16:49would be to have and I think this could
- 1:16:50be done pretty easily for what you're
- 1:16:53looking to do.
- 1:16:54Have your entry be automatic and then
- 1:16:56you manage the exit.
- 1:16:59So so the code takes the entry and then
- 1:17:02you have a position. Now the problem is
- 1:17:04if you're not at the screen, if you're
- 1:17:05not paying attention, then
- 1:17:08you know then then you have an issue.
- 1:17:11The
- 1:17:12there there are many ways to
- 1:17:15intertwine discretion and systematic,
- 1:17:18discretionary trading and systematic
- 1:17:19trading. And I know most of the you talk
- 1:17:21to systematic traders who tell you they
- 1:17:23have no discretion.
- 1:17:24That's not true because you still you
- 1:17:27decided what to test. You decided this
- 1:17:30is the word related to discretion,
- 1:17:32right? You decided what to trade. You
- 1:17:34decided what kind of risk to trade and
- 1:17:36you're going to decide when the thing
- 1:17:38stops working, when to turn it off. So
- 1:17:40there is absolutely an element of
- 1:17:42discretion. Uh, we can't have we we
- 1:17:45can't be purely systematic. You can't be
- 1:17:47pure Maybe someone can. I've never seen
- 1:17:49it. A purely discretionary trader would
- 1:17:52have none of what we're discussing. They
- 1:17:53would have no plan. They would look at
- 1:17:55the chart. They say I'm going to
- 1:17:56sell it there, buy it there, and then
- 1:17:58you know they're just making
- 1:18:00That person over time, they're going to
- 1:18:02accumulate experience, and they're going
- 1:18:04to accumulate a system around their If
- 1:18:08they're successful, they're going to
- 1:18:09have some systematic elements to their
- 1:18:11to their discretion.
- 1:18:13I
- 1:18:14would suspect for you the if
- 1:18:18it does not remove the part of you being
- 1:18:20at the screen, but I also don't think
- 1:18:22you can trade the time frame you're
- 1:18:23going to trade without you being at the
- 1:18:25screen. Uh, but that idea about having
- 1:18:28the entry and then you managing the
- 1:18:30exits and of course when we program the
- 1:18:32entry, we'll also program some exits,
- 1:18:34right? So one of the things that we need
- 1:18:38to do whenever we start meddling with a
- 1:18:40systematic approach, we need to analyze
- 1:18:43our discretionary inputs and see is it
- 1:18:45adding anything. And I've seen this. You
- 1:18:47know, I mean I've I've traded some
- 1:18:49systematic approaches in the past, and I
- 1:18:51found on balance my discretionary input
- 1:18:54is actually helpful, but I'm monitoring
- 1:18:56it, and I know, and I can I can quantify
- 1:18:59the alpha contribution of my discretion
- 1:19:03over just letting the system run. Also
- 1:19:05has to do with the kinds of systems. If
- 1:19:08we're trading a system that's based
- 1:19:09around the kinds of patterns that we're
- 1:19:11talking about, it would be somewhat
- 1:19:13similar to discretionary trader.
- 1:19:15I think I have valid input as a
- 1:19:17discretionary trader, but the the weird
- 1:19:20averaged alpha approach, I probably
- 1:19:22don't have any valid discretionary input
- 1:19:24there, I would assume.
- 1:19:25>> Is time of day of execution relevant to
- 1:19:27you?
- 1:19:28>> Yeah, I mean it this goes back to
- 1:19:30liquidity, right? Because uh
- 1:19:32the most liquid market can be completely
- 1:19:36dull and dead for hours and hours out of
- 1:19:38the day. Uh there's certainly are
- 1:19:40intraday edges that are very time frame
- 1:19:43specific.
- 1:19:44Uh you can
- 1:19:46if people want to start doing
- 1:19:47quantitative research, you can you you
- 1:19:50can start chopping the day up into hours
- 1:19:52or half hours and asking, you know, hey,
- 1:19:54what if we make a new high in this half
- 1:19:56hour? Is that different than making it?
- 1:19:57And the answer is yes. So it it matters
- 1:20:00quite a lot. And this is why I'm sure
- 1:20:02you've talked to day traders who only
- 1:20:04trade a few hours a day. They've carved
- 1:20:06their edge and you know I mean maybe
- 1:20:08this is you too. You've carved your edge
- 1:20:09out of a specific window when specific
- 1:20:11things are happening and absolutely that
- 1:20:13matters.
- 1:20:14>> Yeah, in the end trading 24 hours a day
- 1:20:16would be chaotic. So it ends up being 2
- 1:20:18hours a day for me. But I don't know if
- 1:20:20I found anything specific that would
- 1:20:22benefit me or because there are times
- 1:20:23that I I'm seeing the exact same pattern
- 1:20:25if if I'm to call it. Signatures of
- 1:20:27price that I'm interested in happening
- 1:20:28at a London Open, I take it. Happening 3
- 1:20:31hours later in my no man's
- 1:20:33no man's land time time frame,
- 1:20:35I won't take it. And I don't know if I
- 1:20:37improve the odds because I just I'm
- 1:20:39susceptible to less opportunities,
- 1:20:41therefore less losses, or is that
- 1:20:43actually a heightened statistical skew
- 1:20:44in my 1 2 hour window that I have?
- 1:20:46>> I would think that could be tested. I
- 1:20:48mean if you want to if you want to send
- 1:20:49me some I can I can throw it into my
- 1:20:51research process and take a look at it.
- 1:20:52>> on that offer. That sounds fun. Um in
- 1:20:54fact, what would be the best way for me
- 1:20:56to approach all of this if I want to
- 1:20:58become a little bit more quantitative?
- 1:21:00Would it be
- 1:21:01upload price action to to something and
- 1:21:03then just start conversing through AI?
- 1:21:05Or would it be here's my last 100
- 1:21:06trades, feed it in and then ask
- 1:21:08questions?
- 1:21:09>> I think I think both of those are valid
- 1:21:11approaches. I think also there's
- 1:21:12something to be said for
- 1:21:15constructing what I would consider to be
- 1:21:17kind of
- 1:21:19a
- 1:21:22I don't have a word for it.
- 1:21:24So we're talking
- 1:21:26the kind of quantitative analysis we're
- 1:21:27talking about is one thing. There's also
- 1:21:28a way which we haven't really discussed
- 1:21:30of coming with a specific rule set,
- 1:21:32right? So um you know I 'm looking for
- 1:21:36price to be below the 200 day moving
- 1:21:37average and then to cross above the the
- 1:21:39five the three crosses above the day
- 1:21:42average and I take a buy with a stock.
- 1:21:44You know, so you and you've talked a lot
- 1:21:46of people probably who do this. That's
- 1:21:47certainly valid way to
- 1:21:50to solve the puzzle.
- 1:21:52I think there's some value in doing that
- 1:21:54because you will learn how so I would
- 1:21:57try to I would try to structure a system
- 1:21:59like that.
- 1:22:01And you know
- 1:22:02I I gave one example, but for you it
- 1:22:05might be the rule might be in this time
- 1:22:07window
- 1:22:09if the market goes above this level and
- 1:22:11is back below it and I don't if you back
- 1:22:13below it in 1 minute or you know
- 1:22:14whatever that's that's a variable you
- 1:22:16can look at. You know, I'll get short
- 1:22:18here. My stop will be at or beyond that
- 1:22:21previous high. My profit target is here.
- 1:22:24If I don't have a profit in 15 minutes I
- 1:22:26get out of the you know and those are
- 1:22:28all variables and things. There there
- 1:22:29would be a lot of value for you, I
- 1:22:32think, in taking what you're doing on a
- 1:22:34discretionary basis and putting it into
- 1:22:37a clean rule set like that and then
- 1:22:39seeing it run and then going back and
- 1:22:42you know so one of the thing it's very
- 1:22:43easy to push the button and let the
- 1:22:45system run. What you also need to do, I
- 1:22:48think this this is how this is how I
- 1:22:49learned a lot is go back and look at the
- 1:22:51specific executions. And you got to look
- 1:22:54at a lot of them. You you know you need
- 1:22:56to you
- 1:22:58don't go and look at three trades and
- 1:22:59say well those looked stupid. I wouldn't
- 1:23:01have done those. You know we're talking
- 1:23:03dozens of trades and you know if you've
- 1:23:05done a back test hundreds it takes a lot
- 1:23:07of time. You have to be
- 1:23:09a not normal person to to to want to do
- 1:23:11that. And if you are normal it will make
- 1:23:13you a not normal.
- 1:23:15But you know you're going through and
- 1:23:16you're looking at hundreds of these and
- 1:23:17you and you can take some notes, but
- 1:23:19you're also building some this is how
- 1:23:21how we build intuition is seeing
- 1:23:23patterns, right? And seeing occurrences.
- 1:23:26And then you'll think about making them
- 1:23:28my I've had cases where I've tried to
- 1:23:30systemize approaches exactly what I'm
- 1:23:33explaining here and I was not
- 1:23:34successful. I was doing something on a
- 1:23:37discretionary basis and I went through
- 1:23:39iterations of this
- 1:23:41or
- 1:23:42approach with it
- 1:23:43couldn't could not systemize, but it
- 1:23:45made my discretionary trading better
- 1:23:47because it made me look at a lot of
- 1:23:48patterns. It made me look at a lot of
- 1:23:50outcomes. It made me think about what
- 1:23:52exactly was contributing to the edge.
- 1:23:54And, you know, so the system development
- 1:23:56was a failure, but I made money from it.
- 1:23:58And that's that's like having a making
- 1:23:59money on a losing trade.
- 1:24:01>> Exactly.
- 1:24:01>> good.
- 1:24:02>> I'm curious if overfitting, which is I
- 1:24:04mean, yesterday's conversation I had, it
- 1:24:05seemed like a big topic.
- 1:24:07>> It's a big topic.
- 1:24:08>> But I I don't know if it's like a
- 1:24:09problem that most people won't encounter
- 1:24:11or is something actually problematic.
- 1:24:13>> It's a problem in that kind of in that
- 1:24:16kind of development very specific
- 1:24:18because uh
- 1:24:20what are what are the variables? Okay,
- 1:24:21so we're talking about a time window.
- 1:24:24We're talking about a certain
- 1:24:25penetration Sorry. Certain penetration
- 1:24:27through the high.
- 1:24:28Uh we're talking about where you put
- 1:24:30your profit target and then and there's
- 1:24:31others. But
- 1:24:33what you could do is test every
- 1:24:34combination of those.
- 1:24:35And
- 1:24:37some of those will work.
- 1:24:39You know, if we're testing random levels
- 1:24:42back to our Fibonacci discussion, some
- 1:24:44of those random levels are going to
- 1:24:45work. There there there's going to be
- 1:24:47non-random action. You may know, you
- 1:24:49know, statistically if you do a bunch of
- 1:24:51tests, you can't just look at the
- 1:24:52p-value. You have to adjust for the fact
- 1:24:54I did a bunch of tests. I did 20 tests.
- 1:24:56Therefore, there's a probability at a
- 1:24:5895% that one of those is going to look
- 1:24:59good, right? So you you have to I think
- 1:25:03this is where a lot of those kinds of
- 1:25:04system developers get in trouble is
- 1:25:07they'll do all of these tests and then
- 1:25:09it is massively overfitted. And there
- 1:25:11are ways to overcome that, right? Like
- 1:25:13if I see if you tell me you tested this
- 1:25:15grid of five variables and you found
- 1:25:18some magical combination that worked and
- 1:25:20all the others look like garbage and one
- 1:25:23works, I don't think you have anything.
- 1:25:25But if there's kind of a plateau where a
- 1:25:27lot of things work, you might have
- 1:25:29something. The gold standard is to do
- 1:25:33your development and hold out an out of
- 1:25:35sample and then test that. Most people
- 1:25:37don't do that right because the problem
- 1:25:39with out of sample is how many times can
- 1:25:40you do the out of sample?
- 1:25:44So if you're doing your system
- 1:25:46development and then you're like, let me
- 1:25:47just look at this on my you you've
- 1:25:49completely invalidated your test. Most
- 1:25:50people the outside of you know real
- 1:25:54quant firms don't have the discipline to
- 1:25:56do all of the system development which
- 1:25:58may take weeks and weeks and weeks and
- 1:26:00then to run it on the out of sample
- 1:26:01which answers to some extent what if I
- 1:26:04had traded this over the past year, six
- 1:26:06months or whatever if you see
- 1:26:08persistence there. You can do a cheap
- 1:26:10out of sample
- 1:26:12uh all of my tests I also look at like
- 1:26:15uh I call them temporal quantize. So you
- 1:26:17know I'm I 'm slicing whatever data that
- 1:26:20I'm looking at into periods and I want
- 1:26:23to see some persistence. If it only
- 1:26:24looks good if I'm testing 10 years and
- 1:26:27only looks good in two and a half of
- 1:26:28those it's probably not great.
- 1:26:31>> We also spoke about the beginning of
- 1:26:32alpha decay. So if I'm going through all
- 1:26:34this in sample out of sample testing
- 1:26:36and then I start to deploy it is there
- 1:26:38any degradation rate you found of of
- 1:26:41alpha decaying and therefore an edge an
- 1:26:43edge has a certain shelf life?
- 1:26:45>> I think so. Yeah.
- 1:26:46>> What what is that
- 1:26:47you know
- 1:26:47>> It it varies but it's it's varies it's
- 1:26:49real and it seems to go in one direction
- 1:26:52and it's not it's not the direction you
- 1:26:53want. It's it's not the answer you want.
- 1:26:55Uh I think you can greatly accelerate
- 1:26:58alpha decay by publishing.
- 1:27:00>> Mm.
- 1:27:00>> So tell people about it. Uh
- 1:27:02one of the
- 1:27:04absolute standards is you know there's
- 1:27:07tons of academic papers that have real
- 1:27:08alphas published.
- 1:27:10Uh there are books that have real and
- 1:27:12there's also lots of books that don't
- 1:27:13have alphas. They say they do but they
- 1:27:15don't. Uh but what you will find is that
- 1:27:18those alphas that were good at one point
- 1:27:20in time
- 1:27:21invariably they they've degraded since
- 1:27:23publication.
- 1:27:25And this goes back to our discussion
- 1:27:26about this doesn't mean that you can't
- 1:27:29that I can't trade the pullback that you
- 1:27:31can't trade the tests through that level
- 1:27:34but how we trade it today may degrade
- 1:27:37and we may need to modify that. You know
- 1:27:39you may need to change your change what
- 1:27:42the penetration looks like, change what
- 1:27:43the action after you know the the any of
- 1:27:45these variables may need some adjustment
- 1:27:48and I think as a discretionary trader,
- 1:27:52when you're in touch with the data,
- 1:27:54you're going to do some of those
- 1:27:55adjustments automatically. And that goes
- 1:27:57back to where I said, you know, I tell
- 1:27:59you I've traded the same way for
- 1:28:00decades. It's a lie because I modified
- 1:28:03the subtle things around it, sometimes
- 1:28:05without even knowing. You know, I I
- 1:28:07don't even know I'm doing something
- 1:28:08different until I go back and look at a
- 1:28:10different period. I look, oh, my stops
- 1:28:11are in quite a different place now. And
- 1:28:14you know, I evolved with the market. And
- 1:28:15that's the advantage of discretionary
- 1:28:17trading.
- 1:28:17>> Right at the beginning, on your own
- 1:28:18admission, you said your intuition sucks
- 1:28:20and in fact I should do the opposite of
- 1:28:21your intuition and I would make money.
- 1:28:23Um
- 1:28:24you you mentioned intuition is kind of
- 1:28:26like your subconscious picking up on
- 1:28:27patterns.
- 1:28:28>> Maybe.
- 1:28:28>> Uh so that feels like some sort of
- 1:28:31advantage. But anyhow, the question is
- 1:28:33if you are optimizing through quant
- 1:28:36through probabilities and you have a
- 1:28:37quantitative approach and you say your
- 1:28:39intuition sucks, what's the purpose of
- 1:28:41discretion?
- 1:28:43>> I
- 1:28:45there are patterns that I can trade. And
- 1:28:48I don't I don't think it's the same
- 1:28:49thing as intuition. I think if I
- 1:28:51identify a pattern like the pattern
- 1:28:53you've described to me,
- 1:28:55if I can identify that pattern on a
- 1:28:56chart, I might not be able to quantify
- 1:28:58it.
- 1:28:59I might not be able to explain it to
- 1:29:01code in a way that I could execute, but
- 1:29:04I can see it on a chart, I can trade it
- 1:29:07on a chart. In fact, it might be quite
- 1:29:09easy for me, but if I describe it in
- 1:29:11code, what I'm going to find is I'll
- 1:29:12describe that, but I'll also describe
- 1:29:15four examples that aren't actually the
- 1:29:17thing. So there is some degree of
- 1:29:19filtering. Maybe if I were a better
- 1:29:21programmer, maybe you know, some of the
- 1:29:24modeling tools now I did quite a bit of
- 1:29:27work many, many years ago with
- 1:29:30was working with a group of of
- 1:29:32engineers who were looking at the
- 1:29:34algorithms that radars use to a radar
- 1:29:37from an airplane looking down at another
- 1:29:40airplane,
- 1:29:41everything's just reflected back to the
- 1:29:43radar. You you may know this or you
- 1:29:45many of your listeners do, uh you get a
- 1:29:47lot of ground clutter. So it's not the
- 1:29:50simplest thing to pull. So there are
- 1:29:52algorithms, of course, that process
- 1:29:54that. So they were looking at those
- 1:29:56kinds of algorithms, which also had
- 1:29:57found use in speech recognition, and
- 1:30:00they were trying to apply those kinds of
- 1:30:02algorithms to my discretionary pattern
- 1:30:04recognition.
- 1:30:05It's an interesting project. We spent a
- 1:30:06lot of time on it.
- 1:30:08Zero Zero result from it.
- 1:30:11I think, you know, maybe some of the
- 1:30:12modeling tools are a little bit more
- 1:30:14sophisticated now. Maybe you could show
- 1:30:17the right kind of training environment.
- 1:30:19This is a pattern. This is not a
- 1:30:21pattern. And then it will see things. It
- 1:30:23could maybe tell us things about our
- 1:30:24perception. We don't know.
- 1:30:25>> And I feel like we could have another
- 1:30:27like 10-hour conversation. So I think
- 1:30:29the best way for me to end is asking
- 1:30:31you,
- 1:30:32is there anything I should have asked
- 1:30:33you today?
- 1:30:36>> I think we did a really good job to pat
- 1:30:38ourselves on the back staying focused
- 1:30:40because there were a lot of things that
- 1:30:41we could have talked about and there are
- 1:30:42I think that
- 1:30:44one of the
- 1:30:46things that is occupying a lot of my
- 1:30:48thought at this point in my life is
- 1:30:51thinking about life outside of markets
- 1:30:53and thinking about, you know, how do you
- 1:30:57how do you interact with the markets
- 1:30:59responsibly with the degree let's say
- 1:31:02focus because it's a nice word, but we
- 1:31:04really mean single-minded crazy
- 1:31:06obsession
- 1:31:07while also being a good human and also
- 1:31:10enjoying the time that we're alive. And
- 1:31:12I think that crosses into many other
- 1:31:15questions that we can talk about
- 1:31:16meditation and spiritual practice and
- 1:31:18art and the meaning and the meaning of
- 1:31:20everything and
- 1:31:22I mean we could talk about knowledge and
- 1:31:24you know what we know and how we know it
- 1:31:26and how sure we are with I think that's
- 1:31:28actually
- 1:31:29set maybe that's a separate interview
- 1:31:31sometime. I think we did a good job
- 1:31:32staying on track today.
- 1:31:33>> Yeah, it was a very colorful
- 1:31:34conversation with a lot of wisdom and
- 1:31:35lessons. I thoroughly enjoyed it. Thank
- 1:31:37you for the opportunity.
- 1:31:37>> I enjoyed it too. Thank you.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of The Quant Who Studied 700 Yrs Of Price Data: Most Levels Are Noise! THESE Are The 2 Levels To Watch! by Titans Of Tomorrow, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 18,623 words across 2,802 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.