YouTube2Text

The Purely Systematic Wizard Trader · Marsten Parker — Transcript

by Chat With Traders · 11,806 words · 616 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00and I experienced how addictive it could be to  you know just like keep keep wanting to put on
  2. 0:05a trade and and see what happens it's just  like a slot machine really you know you get
  3. 0:10a dopamine hit from the winds and then it makes  you want to just put on another one right away
  4. 0:16markets speculation and risk this is the chat  with Traders [Music] podcast yes that's right
  5. 0:28this is chat with Traders episode 281 hey Traders  this is Tessa what's going on how are things with
  6. 0:34the markets lately for you we'd love to hear your  thoughts share it with us feel free to email us at
  7. 0:40hello chatl traders.com it would be so awesome to  hear from you or even better get on the chat with
  8. 0:46Traders website and leave a voice message after  all we are audio- based and always love to hear
  9. 0:51your actual voices so don't be shy before we  introduce Our Guest today please allow me to
  10. 0:57take a few minutes to do a quick shout out out  to our chat Traders community members for those
  11. 1:03who don't already know recently we made the  difficult decision to close the online chat
  12. 1:08with Traders Community when we launched this  space back in November 2022 we wanted to create
  13. 1:15something truly special and different a home where  listeners of the chat with Traders podcast could
  14. 1:21come together connect share ideas and lift each  other up and we pictured a Vibrant Community of
  15. 1:27Traders and aspiring Traders supporting and  lifting each other up Patrick Petersson Steve
  16. 1:34B A big thank you to you you have been a strong  and positive driving force in the community you're
  17. 1:41not only amazing and talented Traders but you have  also inspired many of us in the trading room and
  18. 1:47outside of the trading room to stay motivated and  continually to learn and improve and building this
  19. 1:54community together has been an incredible journey  and the lessons we've learned will stay with us
  20. 1:59so to everyone who's been part of the Chat With  Traders Community family we hope with all our
  21. 2:06hearts that being here has added value to your  trading Journey no matter how small Moise Barlow
  22. 2:13Tim Marilyn Tiffany Daniel Stu Peter Michaela  Quinn Chad Morad Yen Nuno Thomas Brandon Damiano
  23. 2:22Mr dip and many more of you please forgive me if I  am not calling out all the names but you know who
  24. 2:30you are your presence has meant the world to  us and we're so grateful for every contribution
  25. 2:36every interaction this community has allowed us to  connect with so many of you on a deeper level than
  26. 2:43we ever could have imagined sharing the highs and  the lows the struggles and triumphs that make the
  27. 2:50Journey of trading so unique so keep in touch with  us let us know how you're doing thank you again
  28. 2:56for being a part of this very special experience  and for those who haven't had the chance to be
  29. 3:02part of the chat with Traders Community although  we are closed now who knows we may reopen again in
  30. 3:08the future so make sure you are on our email  distribution so we can keep you posted just
  31. 3:15get on the chat with Traders website thank you  again for allowing me some time to talk about
  32. 3:20the community now I am excited to introduce  a special guest today in speaks with Marsten
  33. 3:29Parker Starting In classical violin and computer  programming Marsten's path took a transformative
  34. 3:37turn when he ventured into trading despite a rocky  start his disciplined algorithmic driven approach
  35. 3:44led to consistent returns earning him recognition  in Jack Schwager's Unknown Market Wizards we get
  36. 3:51to learn about his transition from discretionary  trading to systematic trading and emphasizing the
  37. 3:59importance of statistical analysis over emotional  decision making Marsten used his programming
  38. 4:06skills to create fully automated trading systems  to take advantage of breakouts mean reversion and
  39. 4:13IPO opportunities and other strategies also please  note this recording was made before the sad news
  40. 4:20of Jim Simon's passing ladies and gentlemen we  are so pleased to present Marsten Parker from Mass
  41. 4:29Massachusetts well Marsten welcome to chat with  Traders thank you where you calling from I'm in
  42. 4:39Reading Massachusetts which is about 12 miles  north of Boston yeah it's great to be here I
  43. 4:45actually um had been in touch with Aaron ffield  about 10 years ago during the first days of the
  44. 4:51show and almost came on then but I didn't have  any kind of online presence so I thought no I
  45. 4:56don't think I'll do that so better late than never  yeah well um you you happen to be fortunate enough
  46. 5:03to be the only purely systematic Trader whose  performance over the decades was sufficiently
  47. 5:09Superior to make it into the book unknown Market  Wizards by Jack schagger how did you get known
  48. 5:16to him yeah I mean I I have a feeling there are  probably a lot of systematic Traders with better
  49. 5:22performance but who just uh weren't known to him  or weren't interested in being in a book but uh I
  50. 5:30I was lucky enough to be recommended I didn't know  he was making a new market Wizards book at all or
  51. 5:36or seek to be in the book I had been I'm still a  member of a community online called Stock B which
  52. 5:43I joined in 2013 I think and the the fellow who  runs that Community for deep bond somehow was in
  53. 5:49touch with Jack and was let known that Jack  was looking for people for his new book and
  54. 5:55recommended a couple different people including  me uh the the others who he recommended decline
  55. 6:00to be in the book but I agreed uh so that's how  that happened uh and then of course as as usual
  56. 6:06in Market Wizards I had to send Jack all kinds  of documentation about my track record L luckily
  57. 6:13I had um you know all my old brokerage statements  going back 20 years so um so that was fine uh and
  58. 6:20and as he wrote my stats were really just barely  qualified me but somehow he decided to put me in
  59. 6:29so here I am oh oh great great thanks yeah let's  dive into your background um kind of where did you
  60. 6:35grow up and uh what were your early interests  in life yeah well I grew up here in the Boston
  61. 6:41area as a teenager I had two main interests  uh classical music and specifically violin
  62. 6:48and computer programming uh and they they sort of  competed for my attention throughout high school
  63. 6:53and I ended up deciding to to try to pursue a  career in music and I went to a conservatory in
  64. 6:58New York City and and studied classical violin  but this was the early 80s when the personal
  65. 7:03computers were just being introduced and uh and I  got one and so I ended up spending more and more
  66. 7:10of my time while while in school coding and less  time practicing violin so by by I graduated but
  67. 7:16it was clear that I wanted to go in the computer  Direction by the time I finished so I moved back
  68. 7:21to Boston took a job at a computer store and then  eventually uh found employment at a at a software
  69. 7:28startup uh in 1984 and um yeah worked for that  worked for that company and two other companies
  70. 7:37the third one was called segue software segue  and uh they they ended up going public in 1996 on
  71. 7:46NASDAQ symbol segu and I was one of the earliest  employees so I owned about 4% of the company so
  72. 7:53I had some stock and that that's what got me  interested in trading what kind of um uh job
  73. 7:59you have at the at the software company that I was  I was a software developer software engineer at at
  74. 8:05uh that was my profession from 1984 through 1997  oh wow 13 13 years uh and what kind of software
  75. 8:13did you uh did you write it was it it's I started  out working on a vaac um mini computers and then
  76. 8:23transition to personal computers um software and  it it basically was tools for other Developers
  77. 8:30the first thing I built was was a an editor  for a particular programming language that
  78. 8:35the company offered um for a lot of the latter  part of the career I was involved in building
  79. 8:42tools to support testing of software so so  our customers would be QA engineers at other
  80. 8:49software companies you know segue main product was  something called Silk test which I think was the
  81. 8:54leading thing in that category for a while uhhuh  and uh did you get a lot of satisfaction from uh
  82. 9:01being a programmer um and I did yeah uh yeah I've  always enjoyed building software and having people
  83. 9:08use the software that I build and so that that  was satisfying yeah so the famous Jim Simmons
  84. 9:15uh he was involved in the in the buyout of the  company you worked at yeah I think he pronounced
  85. 9:21it as Simons he um was that third company segue  software uh he was the chairman of the board and
  86. 9:28the largest investor in that company he um at that  time in the early '90s he he hadn't had you know
  87. 9:35he had some success in his hedge fund business but  not qu not you know nearly as much as he did later
  88. 9:41and he was um or maybe just on the side he he had  a venture capital fund that so he was investing in
  89. 9:48I don't know how many in total probably five or  10 software companies typically and we happen to
  90. 9:53be one of them when the buyout occurred were you  itching to retire at that point or were you imagin
  91. 9:59yourself at just getting another software job no  I mean it wasn't so much a buyout it was it was
  92. 10:04an actual initial public offering so so so I mean  the the company did eventually get bought but that
  93. 10:10was years after I had left um uh so no I wasn't  really itching to to to uh to get bought or to
  94. 10:19do anything I mean it kind of was surprising when  it became a possibility that we could go public we
  95. 10:24were a very small company uh these days it could  not have gone gone public so but yeah it's some
  96. 10:29point the we went public in the spring of 96 and  then several months later there was a fairly major
  97. 10:36correction in the NASDAQ the tech companies were  um were struggling and um I um kind of got got
  98. 10:44tired of of uh working there really and uh and  and I I I just got more and more obsessed with
  99. 10:51watching our stock and and then started buying  books about trading and what getting involved in
  100. 10:57other stocks and dabbling with in strategies and  just kind of thought okay I'm going to leave for
  101. 11:02a while and try this as an experiment you know  I could always go back to that company or get a
  102. 11:07job at a different software company if I wanted  to but then I I did fairly well fairly soon uh
  103. 11:14and the experiment went on for for quite a while  to the point where it was kind of too late to go
  104. 11:19back and get employed again any uh books come  to mind uh that uh influenced you in the early
  105. 11:25stages one of the earlier books I bought was  called trting for a living what's the name of
  106. 11:31that author is that Elder last El yeah Alexander  Elder right right yeah yeah yeah and that I think
  107. 11:37just the very title was influential it just it  didn't occur to me that anybody traded for a
  108. 11:41living until I saw that book and then I thought  oh okay so that was one but also that was just
  109. 11:48the the time when some online resources were first  coming available like there was a site called the
  110. 11:54street.com that I would read and and there was  starting to be some you know early versions of
  111. 11:59kind of like online user groups I think Yahoo  had a whole bunch of user groups so I I would
  112. 12:04participate in some of those oh yeah there was  a site called silicon investor I think that sort
  113. 12:08of like I might have participated in so I don't  know I was getting inputs from all over the place
  114. 12:14and getting interested in in trading so yeah uh  so tell us a little bit about your Early Trades
  115. 12:21your early Big Winners and and losers and how  did they go early on well early on you know I did
  116. 12:27some I opened a broker account and you know had my  restricted shares converted to regular shares so I
  117. 12:33could start to sell them and and have some trading  capital and I just started dabbling in some there
  118. 12:38was some I don't remember where I there must have  been some other earlier book that I read that had
  119. 12:44it was more of a fundamental angle of of like you  know kind of rotational investing based on things
  120. 12:51like PE to growth ratio or stuff like that you  know I found a way to do some scans for things
  121. 12:57like that online Maybe or or with some I think  I had a piece of software on my desktop computer
  122. 13:04called window on Wall Street or something like  that so you know I I would just put on a trade
  123. 13:09because I thought it met some criteria that that I  had heard recommended oh and I was also watching I
  124. 13:14think CNBC was was just kind of getting started at  that time and so I would watch that I remember my
  125. 13:21my first big loser this was in 97 when I was still  employed in trading on the site I I heard on tnbc
  126. 13:30uh what is it Herman Miller company had beat their  earnings expectations so I immediately bought the
  127. 13:36stock like like way larger position I like oh I  they said it was good on cnvc so I better take a
  128. 13:43really large position and and it was one of those  sell the news situations apparently so I remember
  129. 13:49having a couple sleep sleepless nights on that  one so yeah that first year of trading in 97 I I
  130. 13:55think I ended up losing about 50 Grand and then  the end of that year on that basis I said okay
  131. 14:01I'll quit my job and trade for a living um I had  no idea what I was doing well I I was starting to
  132. 14:08get an idea that I could maybe make take a more  systematic approach and I was going of I somehow
  133. 14:12it got included into the the fact that some people  had trading systems and followed them rather
  134. 14:17than just trying to you know make discretionary  decisions and be right about things which clearly
  135. 14:23wasn't working for me I started corresponding with  one person who was sharing some aspects of of his
  136. 14:30trading strategy in a series of articles on the  street.com guy named Gary B Smith and we just kept
  137. 14:35corresponding and became friends and eventually  trading partners and so I I followed his his
  138. 14:41systematic it was mostly systematic there was some  discretion in the selection of which stocks to buy
  139. 14:47or short but then the exits were 100% mechanical  since you were doing this for a living uh did you
  140. 14:55have any expectations as to a targeted annual  income or total return goal I had a general
  141. 15:01concept of and and I remember um corresponding  with with Gary about this and kind of get doing
  142. 15:08a sanity check with him of you know do do you  think I could consistently make 20% a year and
  143. 15:14and he said yeah that should be easy to do I had  about a million of trading Capital so I thought
  144. 15:19if I could consistently make 20% a year you know  even after taxes and be able to have more income
  145. 15:26than I had from my for former job and um and maybe  even you know grow the the account a little bit so
  146. 15:33I I I kind of had a goal of being able to grow my  account five or 10% a year after taxes and living
  147. 15:40expenses which you know now I understand you you  can't really have a have a income type goal from
  148. 15:46trading it doesn't make any sense whatsoever uh  you know you're going to have big swings up and
  149. 15:50down and so on but you know compared to many I  think I was I was in a pretty stable situation
  150. 15:56because I had plenty of trading capital and you  know and I also I I had paid off all of my debts
  151. 16:02like my mortgage and so on when the company went  public so I had no debt plenty of capital so and a
  152. 16:08career I could go back to so it it wasn't a huge  risk at the time I just kind of viewed it as an
  153. 16:14experiment that I was that I was doing and that  book that you mentioned uh trading for a living
  154. 16:20um when I looked into that book it appears to be  a book about discretionary trading did you kind
  155. 16:26of set aside those early books that you got into  uh and then focused more and more on systematizing
  156. 16:33your approach yes I pretty much you know i' had  gone through a lot of different books and looking
  157. 16:40for really clues about how to proceed and you know  and I found thing Clues here and there but but
  158. 16:46like you said most of them are about discretionary  there weren't any books there that that said
  159. 16:50You know here here are all the exact rules of a  trading system that that's highly likely to work
  160. 16:55I mean I don't even think I don't know when some  of the first books about Trend following came out
  161. 16:59I don't think that there were many yet back then  there may have been I I pretty much set that aside
  162. 17:05and and adopted the method that Gary Smith was was  using and then gradually tried to systematize that
  163. 17:12method uh in our preall you mentioned that you  hate trading uh why is that yeah I mean I may
  164. 17:20have overstated that some but I I I don't really  have the the person the typical personality of
  165. 17:26a Trader who uh you know who who who is kind of  enjoys placing bets on things or you know likes
  166. 17:33the challenge of of trying to make correct calls  about the direction of things of price going or
  167. 17:39or anything like that I mean I did I do enjoy it  and particularly did early on in terms of the as
  168. 17:45a kind of puzzle of you know how can you come  up with a strategy that that made money in the
  169. 17:50past and more importantly will continue to make  money in the future so I I enjoy the the kind of
  170. 17:56research and of that aspect of it you you know  of testing different strategies trying to come
  171. 18:01up with ideas and so on but the actual process  of trading of you know placing trades and I mean
  172. 18:06I kind of I went down that rabbit hole a little  bit early on I I even spent about a month doing
  173. 18:12very active discretionary day trading in NASDAQ  stocks in 1997 during that losing period And I
  174. 18:19experienced how addictive it could be to you know  just like keep keep wanting to put on a trade and
  175. 18:24and see what happens it's just like a slot machine  really you know you get a dopamine hit from the
  176. 18:28winds and then it makes you want to just put on  another one right away and so you know fortunately
  177. 18:33I was self-aware enough to just to observe myself  in that process and realize that this was going to
  178. 18:39be dangerous slippery slope for me if I continued  in that direction so I I said No at heart I'm very
  179. 18:47conservative you know I'm not interested in in  losing a lot of money and I'm not I'm not the
  180. 18:51kind of person who who will ever make a big bet on  anything do you think that if you had beginner's
  181. 18:56luck uh from the beginning say in 19 97 and had  good gains early on would you have still started
  182. 19:03the process of moving to a systematic approach  um is that kind of in your nature yeah I think
  183. 19:09it's in my nature yeah I mean it you know as I  mentioned that when I started trading with Gary
  184. 19:15we our method was had a discretionary element  in that you know we'd run a scan well not not
  185. 19:22so much run but get get the investors's business  daily newspaper and look at the table of stocks
  186. 19:27that had unusual volume the prior day so we would  go through the charts of those and he would make
  187. 19:33mostly him would make some kind of subjective  Judgment of how the chart looked and kind of
  188. 19:39rank them on that basis for for what are the best  entries to to take and and I tried to grasp that
  189. 19:45what he was doing there and I always found it  sort of arbitrary so right away I wanted to um
  190. 19:50I wanted to be able to test it and I also wanted  to be able to test the exits we were using and
  191. 19:54see if we could come up with better ones for the  given the set of entries we had actually taken
  192. 20:00what different exits would have worked better so  yeah no even if I had succeeded initially with
  193. 20:05the with some of the discretionary type project  I was doing I probably would have written code
  194. 20:10to test it fairly soon as a musician do you  see a link between musical reading and playing
  195. 20:17skills and systematic trading but the things I  learned from from trying to be a violinist you
  196. 20:23know concentration ability to to stay focused  at a task uh which didn't come that easily to
  197. 20:29me but um I worked at it just the discipline of  practicing every day there's there's some there's
  198. 20:35some overlap there you know there's a lot of of  uh structure or you might even say system behind
  199. 20:43behind music uh you know some of which I learned  about in school and so on that you know there
  200. 20:49probably make some some connections there I don't  know if it's super specific yeah so let's dive
  201. 20:54into your early uh algo trading can you share  with us a little bit about about some of your
  202. 20:59early algo strategies well you first started off  as systematic right were you uh manually entering
  203. 21:05in uh your orders or how soon did you actually go  to an algo approach so basically from so I started
  204. 21:14trading with this Gary Smith in 1998 February  1998 and we were trading one pair of strategies
  205. 21:22Bas long and short kind of a symmetrical uh not  exactly symmetrical but uh it's basically bu buing
  206. 21:28breakouts uh with unusual volume or shorting  breakdowns and then setting a bracket like a
  207. 21:34Target and a stop and whichever one gets hit first  and the only thing that was a little unusual about
  208. 21:40that strategy as opposed to classical Trend  following is that the the stop is larger than
  209. 21:45the target you know and and so it had a fairly  High win rate like a 70% win rate I think we were
  210. 21:50using like a 5% uh Target and a 7% stop initially  you know later I I discovered other way to measure
  211. 21:59those things like atrs but um that's what we were  doing initially and I basically traded that that
  212. 22:08exact system those two that one pair of long  and short strategies just with minor variations
  213. 22:14all the way until 2015 I I wasn't doing I wasn't  really doing anything else you know I kept over
  214. 22:21optimizing them and tweaking the parameters the  basic concept was the same so I I I don't think
  215. 22:26all the optimizing and parameter changing I did  really made very much difference I could have
  216. 22:30chosen different parameters and maybe at random  I would have had better results or Worse results
  217. 22:35or or whatever but the basic concept was the same  you're buying breakouts on unusual volume and and
  218. 22:42setting a Target and a stop and I think there was  also a time stop so there's basically three three
  219. 22:47components to the exit so to answer your question  uh when we first started this in '98 we were we
  220. 22:54would actually phone in our orders to a broker  you know there was n even an online platform where
  221. 23:01like interactive brokers is now where you could  actually do that uh Schwab Maybe started to have
  222. 23:07an and TDM a trade that came a year or two later  when we first started there really wasn't much
  223. 23:12uh so we yeah we were using this online broker I  mean it was kind of an agency a small broker in
  224. 23:18New Jersey so we would call in the orders then you  know since we were doing this every day we asked
  225. 23:24if we could email them the orders so we we started  emailing them the orders instead and then I ended
  226. 23:29up you know writing code to generate those emails  so that that was my first automation was actually
  227. 23:36um code that that generated and sent emails to a  human broker who would then do the order entry I
  228. 23:42actually stayed with that broker until 2013 they  were called trade managed capital and earlier than
  229. 23:47that they had been called yamer I think we were  probably their only retail clients and all their
  230. 23:51other clients were hedge funds um but we were  sort of behaving like hedge funds so they took
  231. 23:56us on and so they gave us this software and um  and I changed my code to use that but and then
  232. 24:01in u the 2013 I switched to interactive brokers  just because I was paying too much commissions
  233. 24:07basically with the others people and the and and  the slippages were getting worse they they had
  234. 24:13been giving us I think very good fills um early on  but the slippages were getting worse and decided
  235. 24:20to change to interact to Brokers um and then you  know coincidentally I went kind of went through a
  236. 24:25rough patch for the next several years but I don't  think it was because I change Brokers I think it
  237. 24:29was because the strategies were were winding down  and not working as well anymore uh so to be clear
  238. 24:35for or what since 1999 2000 era till 2014 or so I  mean a good long stretch that you were doing two
  239. 24:44basic strategies correct yeah or really two sides  of one strategy you might say two sides of one
  240. 24:50strategy so let's dive into that uh a little bit  more what um so you're on one side you're buying
  241. 24:56breakouts on volume like dou basically I mean what  in the early days when we would do the scanning
  242. 25:05you know every day after the market closed after  data was available so you're basically scanning
  243. 25:10you know all all common us Common Stocks that  meet like like a liquidity criteria price and
  244. 25:16liquidity filters uh for um yeah kind of three  things that you know unusual volume like at least
  245. 25:23two times average or three times average volume  a significant move you know not like like up 5
  246. 25:29cents on two times average volume but you know  up several percent uh in one day and then the
  247. 25:37pro pre prior to that it should not have already  been overbought so you know ideally it's it's
  248. 25:42like a flat congestion area and then a breakout  from there um so that's the basic setup I it's
  249. 25:47probably the most well-known breakout setup in the  universe um there's nothing original about it I
  250. 25:52think Gary got it he started by reading the works  of William O'Neal uh how to make money in stock
  251. 25:58and basically took the can slim method discarded  all the fundamentals and changed the profit Target
  252. 26:03from 20% to 5% and that was about it so that's  essentially what we were running and then he he
  253. 26:08added the short side which O'Neal wasn't doing  any shorting and hadn't even published any his
  254. 26:14book about shorting yet back then so those I  think the most Innovative thing was was that
  255. 26:18Gary had added the short side which where where  he was looking for kind of a an even more big
  256. 26:24breakdown he used to describe it as like it should  look like you just broke your arm and it was
  257. 26:29dangling so the the the criteria for entering  shorts was more stringent and required a greater
  258. 26:37gap down on heavier volum yeah basically he was  looking for for um for really a visible Gap and
  259. 26:44the way he used to say is that the stock  should look broken most of these entries
  260. 26:48would be after a negative earning surprise  or a negative earnings pre-announcement I
  261. 26:53mean that was typically in those days you  know that was the news that would lead to
  262. 26:57that P pattern yeah and how long did you uh  typically hold these uh positions both long
  263. 27:03and short did you have targets when you get out  yes yes we it's the moment we play you initially
  264. 27:09we would we would basically place an order  to buy or short at the open at Market with
  265. 27:15an attached bracket of a Target and a stop  order you know whichever comes first so you
  266. 27:21know one cancels the other kind of situation  um and those would be calculated in advance as
  267. 27:28as um you know 5% favorable or 7% adverse so in  the case of a long it would be 5% up and 7% down
  268. 27:38vice versa for the shorts and that was it and  then you just leave them alone until they hit
  269. 27:43one or the other which would typically be in those  days uh anywhere from that same day to a week or
  270. 27:51two later but Mo mostly it was within a few days I  mean it doesn't it doesn't take that long for a a
  271. 27:58that just had an unusual move on unusual volume  to move another 5% one way or the other so so
  272. 28:05yeah it's it it was really a a few days was the  average holding period maybe three four days
  273. 28:12what were your thoughts about uh holding it for a  relatively short amount of time um you know given
  274. 28:17the old adage the trend is your friend and uh did  you have a kind of a reasoning for um no let's get
  275. 28:23out early earlier than than normal yeah I mean our  reasoning was that we want to be in what is moving
  276. 28:31right now and that that keeps changing every day  or every few days you know whereas if you buy a
  277. 28:37breakout and then just hold it until some longer  term stop is hit you know you might be tying up
  278. 28:42your money in that one stock for a long time  some of which it's not really going anywhere
  279. 28:47Gary's philosophy that I adopted is is that you  your capital is sort of like inventory and you
  280. 28:52want to just keep turning it over and putting it  in where the action is you know within reason uh I
  281. 28:58in those days that kind of time frame was about  as small as you could get you know without trading
  282. 29:03costs totally overtaking because remember back  then um stocks were still priced in fractions
  283. 29:09and the tick size was 1/8 of a dollar uh which is  pretty large spread and then and the commissions
  284. 29:15were were like I mean if we were trading one  or 2,000 share Lots the commission would be
  285. 29:21you know 50 or $60 per roundtrip trade so yeah  that's pricey so you know so there was kind of
  286. 29:28a sweet spot where um 500 to a th000 roundtrip  trades per year you know was was workable Gary
  287. 29:35was less conservative than me so that that year  1998 our first year of trading together he made
  288. 29:3980% and I made 50% it was a good good year for  us uh you mentioned in a previous interview that
  289. 29:47you like to have large numbers of Trades to be  statistically significant do you tweak your system
  290. 29:53so that it will generate a likely minimum  number of Trades per year um you mentioned
  291. 29:58I think 500 or a thousand trades per year is  that kind of The Sweet Spot to be statistically
  292. 30:03I mean if I look at a back test I want to see you  know thousands of Trades to to believe that that
  293. 30:09there's there's an edge to it I mean if if if you  see a back test that only produces 50 trades you
  294. 30:14know and there's one or two outliers in there it  doesn't really tell you anything about the rules
  295. 30:17that that led to those trades so that's what I I  was typically looking for yeah yeah again there's
  296. 30:23kind of well it depends on on what data you have I  mean I've I've generally always worked with daily
  297. 30:28bars that kind of 500 to 1,000 round trips a year  uh holding for a few days is kind of as as low as
  298. 30:35you can go with daily bars I mean obviously you  can't really model intraday trading on daily on
  299. 30:39daily bars or even um even a a day trading there's  one day trading strategy you can where where
  300. 30:46you enter with a limit order and exit with Moc  other than that how how time consuming is coding
  301. 30:53everything yourself is it I imagine it's a big  upfront investment but uh later on how much time
  302. 30:58do you spend both in the early stages and later  on I don't know how I've I've probably spent many
  303. 31:03many thousands of hours on on the coding but it's  not like I'm starting from scratch every time I
  304. 31:09have a a trading idea I mean I from the beginning  I built a general purpose back testing program and
  305. 31:15then later a general purpose automation program  uh most of that time it was in in Excel but um
  306. 31:21but now I have a standall program so so now I  mean given the software that I have if I want
  307. 31:26to test a new idea it I can do it in a few minutes  and and if I want to start trading a new strategy
  308. 31:32I can do it with very little additional coding  because I have the infrastructure but yeah early
  309. 31:39on I mean it it just kind of evolved there wasn't  some big task I had to complete before I could
  310. 31:44trade systematically you know it it gradually  evolved from Mostly manual to to semi systematic
  311. 31:50to I think I started being fully automated from  my Excel VBA code uh at the beginning of 2000
  312. 31:58I don't think I've placed a manual trade order  since since 1999 let's go back to the kind of
  313. 32:04the timeline of you used um your first system  until how long did you use your very first system
  314. 32:11without ma making major modifications to it I was  always tweaking it so it's everything just kind
  315. 32:18of you know gradually evolved I mean in in so  so we had that very good year in '98 99 I was I
  316. 32:27I was really getting much more system systematized  I was I had become disillusioned with the chart
  317. 32:35judgment process with our eyes and and you know  wanted to make rules for for what the data should
  318. 32:40look like so I kept changing those rules and um  you know ended up having a fairly mediocre year
  319. 32:46in 1999 which is unusual because most Traders  had a fabulous year in that year uh except for
  320. 32:52ones who were exclusively short I I went back and  looked at all the times I had changed the rules
  321. 32:57and realized I would have done better off leaving  them how they were at the start of the year so I
  322. 33:01made this resolution of okay going into 2000 I'm  going to trade one set of rules all year and not
  323. 33:06change it all year and and I actually did that  and as it happened I had had my best year yet so
  324. 33:13that worked well um after that I had many periods  where I where I would frequently tweak things you
  325. 33:19fallen into I think everybody's susceptible to  this when you're in a draw down you say well how
  326. 33:25could I have avoided this draw down or made it  less severe and you find some rules that would
  327. 33:29have made it less severe and you put them in place  I mean I was totally naive I didn't know anything
  328. 33:33about overfitting or whatever I just did that and  um you know sometimes it it helped and sometimes
  329. 33:39it didn't my usual process would be okay I'm in a  draw down let's retest and let's see if I can come
  330. 33:45up with a new idea that would have made the draw  down better or would have made recent performance
  331. 33:49better and put that in and then there were a  couple times when I couldn't find any parameters
  332. 33:54that would have done better and then I thought oh  shoot look the whole approach it's broken now so
  333. 33:59what do I do one of those was was actually you  know I said I had this great year in 2000 and
  334. 34:04so of course I kept running the same rules going  into 2001 and I immediately had a 20% draw down
  335. 34:10within the first month and I'd never had a draw  down that large before so that that caused me to
  336. 34:17you know stop for a little while and re-evaluate  and I ended up putting something in place that was
  337. 34:22fairly similar but I I think I changed to um that  I would get a real time data service and enter my
  338. 34:29um do my entries before the close rather than  at the next open because in back testing I had
  339. 34:36figured out that would have done a lot better  uh recently uh so I made that change and then
  340. 34:42I I did an analogous thing when things stopped  working again in in 2005 of of um switching to uh
  341. 34:50to getting in even earlier so I would I would look  starting about five minutes after the open for the
  342. 34:56stocks that seem to be making big moves on unusual  volume and and buy them then so I ran it that way
  343. 35:01and that that did did well in O 06 and ' 07 were  my NE my other two best years besides 2000 and um
  344. 35:09and even and 08 was okay 09 10 was quite good 11  12 2012 basically the the short side when we got
  345. 35:18into that to that decade especially after starting  2013 the short side completely failed and um prior
  346. 35:28to that more than half of my total profit was  from the short side you know if if I had just been
  347. 35:33trading my long side all that time I wouldn't have  even beat the market at all like you know I would
  348. 35:38have been better off buying and holding uh long  and then just shorting against it but I I didn't
  349. 35:43know that maybe not in ' 08 but other than that  yeah I see why do you think the the short side was
  350. 35:50hurt in 2012 what what was it about the markets  that uh made that year different oh I I think uh
  351. 35:58more and more other Traders started uh adopting  the you know buy the dip uh approach B basically
  352. 36:04me you know short-term meaner version became a  very popular strategy so uh so the kind of sharp
  353. 36:12breakdown pattern that was my short entry signal  became a long entry signal for many Traders um
  354. 36:18oh wow so so yeah they they would so that's what  I kept seeing you know I would I would be end up
  355. 36:23shorting it near the low and uh and then having it  go against me uh you know more and more often you
  356. 36:30know it wasn't like I suddenly got all these huge  losses it just um you know the stats eroded the
  357. 36:38the the win rate got lower and the average loss  got got larger than you know than the average win
  358. 36:44and so on uh that that's what typically happens  this uh by the uh btfd by the DI phenomenon um
  359. 36:52did this phenomenon exist that is a technical  term btfd yeah uh did this phenomenon exist in
  360. 36:59other roaring uh bull markets of the past or was  it an additional Nuance of that particular Market
  361. 37:06oh I think it I think it became it was a fairly  new thing that started in in that around 2012
  362. 37:132013 um I don't remember I mean of course prior to  that there were you know value investors who who
  363. 37:21were you know would know what what stocks they  wanted to own and wait for them to to be cheap
  364. 37:27in order to buy them so so in a in a longer  time trading time frame you might say uh sure
  365. 37:35di di buying has always been part you know Buy Low  sell High that's that's always been part of the uh
  366. 37:40the investment landscape but I think it became a  popular short-term trading strategy mostly after
  367. 37:48um maybe even in 08 I mean I I ended up uh you  know adding mean reversion to to what I do in
  368. 37:572014 and when I did the back testing I found that  even the long side would have done great in in 08
  369. 38:05the the long dip buying so I think it was going on  for a while but it probably reached some critical
  370. 38:10mass where where my my particular um shorting  setup didn't just stopped working but I don't know
  371. 38:18really you you you never can know exactly why you  don't you don't know who else is doing what in the
  372. 38:23market so best you can do is guess why something  doesn't work are there any objective or subtle
  373. 38:30indicators that start to appear when a strategy  has stopped working no it's a it's very hard to
  374. 38:37um pin that down it's really more of a more of a  judgment call yeah I that's where where I'm I'm
  375. 38:44discretionary is in strategy level decisions I I  still have uh in in the back testing software that
  376. 38:51I sell I I include um at one of my many example  scripts is the the long essentially the long and
  377. 38:57short strategy that I traded from the late '90s  through the mid 2000 like till after 2012 and um
  378. 39:04yeah and it you can see when you run that back  test all the way back to the 90s that how it did
  379. 39:09very well uh and then went flat for a long time  and and then it mysteriously did really well in
  380. 39:152022 when most other short-term stock trading  strategies did poorly so you just you never
  381. 39:21know when something is is going to start working  or or stop working really it's it's it's it's a
  382. 39:27call so my understanding is that you uh added a  mean reversion strategy uh to your repertoire of
  383. 39:34uh tool yeah I became aware of that concept uh  in that stock be Forum that I was a member of
  384. 39:42uh 2013 2014 um and did a lot of research and  back testing of it I think I also was aware of
  385. 39:50uh or became aware of the writing of Larry Connors  who who's probably Connor and Caesar Alvarez are
  386. 39:57the people who have done the most publishing on  the on the topic of short-term mean reversion
  387. 40:01yeah I I found some strategies I liked and and  uh so in 2014 I divided my capital in two and
  388. 40:08kept running my old strategies in half and my new  meanor version strategies in the other half the
  389. 40:14uh the old strategies were flat and the meaner  version half had a very good year so then in
  390. 40:192015 I just decided to abandon the old ones and  put everything in in this long and short meanor
  391. 40:25version strategy pair that I had built and I had  a great start to that year and then a really nasty
  392. 40:31draw down what what what was the cause of the uh  the draw down and what was the cattle was it the
  393. 40:36mean reversion part of your strategy that well I  was only by so from the start of 2015 I was just
  394. 40:42running long long and short meanor version with  all with my whole account so and so each position
  395. 40:47was 10% of my account no I take it back I was  still trading fixed shares not fixed percentage
  396. 40:54then but but it was it was on average around that  size 10 to 15 really I mean all it takes for the
  397. 41:02in a typical mean reversion strategy you're buying  you're catching a falling knife you know you're
  398. 41:07buying a stock that's dropping or shorting a  stock that's ripping higher you know you've
  399. 41:11based on some calculations that that it's already  overbought or already oversold vice versa and if
  400. 41:18you try to put uh stops in those strategies they  don't work at all you you basically have to rely
  401. 41:24on on on the stats of you know if you if you take  a th trades and that are overbought in this way
  402. 41:32you know on average you'll make money uh but but  every now and then you'll you'll take a larger
  403. 41:39loss and and you you just manage that by keeping  your position sizes small enough so that so that
  404. 41:44even if you know a stock went down like 50% more  from where you bought it you know you might only
  405. 41:50have a two or three% Draw down on your account and  that would be that would only happen once or twice
  406. 41:54a year so so the draw Downs in those strategies  happen when there's some typically there's some
  407. 42:00kind of Market event going on where where you get  you know serial correlation of those bad trades so
  408. 42:06you you got several significant losers in a row  and and that's what happened uh in the second
  409. 42:13half of 2015 especially in August I mean you the  the market was was very bad in the in August 2015
  410. 42:21that's when you had your big draw down yeah it had  started I think it might have started in June or
  411. 42:26July a lot of it is random I mean I I think I had  one chunk of the draw down in um June there was
  412. 42:34one where I was shorting Chinese stocks that were  ripping there was one where I was buying biotech
  413. 42:42stocks that were plunging after um oh I think  like Hillary Clinton was running for president
  414. 42:47and made some announcement that she was going to  crack down on the pharmaceutical industry and the
  415. 42:50whole biotech sector fell apart and but I kept  buying the dip because that's what my rules said
  416. 42:55to do so basically when you when you have some  something like that where there's a a news-based
  417. 43:00catalyst or or a you know a um Feeding Frenzy like  the like the mem stock craze that happened later
  418. 43:08uh you just end up having too many large losers  next to each other uh you know whereas when you
  419. 43:13back test that kind of strategy the the large you  see some large outlier losses but they're spread
  420. 43:19out most typically and so the stats still look  really good but then in real life when they happen
  421. 43:25one after the other you you and and then when you  have several periods like that interspersed with
  422. 43:31flat periods you know it all adds up to a to a  significant draw down so my I mean starting my
  423. 43:37draw down had started in mid 2012 when my that was  my Equity High uh the summer of 2012 all the way
  424. 43:46and it you know I had some recovery periods and  then some further losses and then some recovery
  425. 43:50periods so basically My Equity was in a downtrend  from mid 2012 all the way until 2015 and added up
  426. 43:58to about 45% total draw down wow in that period  yeah curious how much does does a strategy have to
  427. 44:06erode in performance over time before you look  to tweak the system or just dump it entirely
  428. 44:13I pretty much always said a 20% draw down is my  kind of system stop or my off switch where where
  429. 44:19I'll at least pause if not stop for a while and  re-evaluate and you know then it's I mean then
  430. 44:25that happened several times during that period and  then at some point you you either say uh okay well
  431. 44:31I I think I've got a new idea that'll do better so  I'm going to restart but of course you're not back
  432. 44:37you you can't wait till you get back to an equity  high before restarting by definition because you
  433. 44:42have to be trading to get back to an equity high  so um so so at some point you just have to keep
  434. 44:49you know at any given point you either believe you  have something that's going to work and go back
  435. 44:55in or or you throw in the towel and say I'm done  forever um which I I thought I had done that in
  436. 45:022016 and I I I stopped for three months actually  and but then you I I've got all this software all
  437. 45:10these tools all this experience you know just see  what I can do put put more Conservative Strategies
  438. 45:17with fewer parameters in place and so that's  how you got out of the 45% draw down is is to uh
  439. 45:23simplify your system H right simplify make make it  more uh take take smaller positions and diversify
  440. 45:31more you know I had just been trading the two Meer  systems but then I went back and add it you know
  441. 45:38they my old breakout systems were still no good  but but I found a new long breakout system by
  442. 45:43narrowing the universe to recent IPOs which ended  up being my best performing strategy for the next
  443. 45:48several years um and then um and added a a new  I did go back to something like my old shorting
  444. 45:55strategy but with some with some differences uh  in particular I rather than just buy shorting on
  445. 46:03the breakdown I I I shorted on a little rebound  after the breakdown um to get a bit bit of a
  446. 46:08better price Advantage so so those four together  are kind of like my core four strategies that I'm
  447. 46:14that I'm still running and that they did Mo you  know mostly well since then do you program any of
  448. 46:20your systems to avoid either highly shorted stocks  or any of the meme stocks and how do you screen uh
  449. 46:26these out of your system if you do want to avoid  them I do have some I yeah I have a well I have
  450. 46:33a upper volatility filter actually use it on both  sides uh which which I mean there's a couple ways
  451. 46:41to approach that I mean one way is to to restrict  your trading to a to a narrow a narrower Universe
  452. 46:48like the you know the constituents of a major  index for example so some people do that um I've
  453. 46:53always found I can get better stats by having my  universe be all publicly traded us Common Stocks
  454. 47:01and then applying a liquidity filter the main  difference between this universe and say the
  455. 47:05Russell 3000 is that that the the broader universe  will include a lot of adrs so it's actually you're
  456. 47:11actually getting a lot of uh foreign stocks  uh you know hence my issue with Chinese names
  457. 47:17that I had mentioned earlier so oh shoot I've  sort of lost my thread of thought now what what
  458. 47:22did you ask me oh yeah yeah so the meme so a few  years ago we had the the mem stock M stocks right
  459. 47:28so so my volatility filter helps I mean I did I  did take a bit of a hit when that first started
  460. 47:34I remember luckily I I avoided GameStop but I  think bbby uh and maybe AMC I you know I had
  461. 47:41some some significant losing trades in a couple  of those um at the same time my my IPO strategy
  462. 47:48was was on fire so it kind of canceled out like I  didn't notice those big losses quite as much as I
  463. 47:53would have they didn't cause an overall account  drw down but but that strategy was definitely
  464. 47:59doing poorly and and I was you know aware of what  was going on and with the mem stock craze because
  465. 48:05everybody was so but by that point you know I I  had been marketing my back testing software for a
  466. 48:12while and we had a fairly active Forum so there's  a lot of conversation about it as well and um yeah
  467. 48:18you know we started just the first thing we did  was to just build a an an exclude list in a text
  468. 48:24file of you know we're just not going to trade  these symbols cuz they're the ones that these
  469. 48:28these idiots are buying and um so um so so I did  that the the other thing you can do that I that
  470. 48:36I also do sometimes is look at the broker's like  margin requirements or short borrow rates and and
  471. 48:43just avoid especially you know I figure if if IB  says you need 100% margin or more I mean I've seen
  472. 48:49stocks where they want 400% margin to short it wow  that that's crazy right I mean that tells you that
  473. 48:56risk management people have said this is this is  dangerous so why why would I want to do that so so
  474. 49:03yeah you can that that's another thing you can  do is let the broker give you some clues about
  475. 49:08what's too risky to be be shorting right right  so tell us about your IPO strategy how how does
  476. 49:13that differ from your other strategies it's it's  it's so simple that it's stupid I mean really I
  477. 49:20the idea was to just Well define an IPO as as a  a stock that only has a limited number of of uh
  478. 49:29days in its trading history and then uh buy  it when it closes at a new all-time high um
  479. 49:38you know and then sell it if it has like a one  or two day low you know fairly fairly tight I I
  480. 49:45don't use stop I've never used stop orders in any  of my trading strategies I use stop rules but you
  481. 49:51know on a closing basis basically I just don't  want to be taken out by intraday noise and also
  482. 49:57stop orders have more slippage than any other type  of orders so so yeah I'll get out of the close um
  483. 50:04you you sell out you're saying um so how long  would you when you buy the the IPO it's hitting
  484. 50:10a new high uh how long would you typically hold it  if it's a if it's running you know day after day
  485. 50:16going higher and higher well they really I mean  they they typically are I I I I have a profit
  486. 50:21Target in that strategy as well so I'll hold it  till it hits the target and and then you know it
  487. 50:25might have a day and then make another new high  and then I might buy it again now that strategy
  488. 50:30worked very well um I started it in 2017 and it  worked you know well enough through 2017 18 19 uh
  489. 50:39and then it really hit it out of the park in the  middle of 2020 through the middle of 2021 uh when
  490. 50:46everything was kind of on fire I mean practically  any strategy work during that time period so it's
  491. 50:51not really saying anything but since uh since the  uh end of 2021 it it's just been flat but you know
  492. 51:00I mean a good thing about that approach is when  the when the Market's correcting there there
  493. 51:04are fewer IPOs because companies just cancel their  IPOs so it kind of has a built-in regime filter of
  494. 51:09its own a lot of people focus on on trading IPOs  I'm not sure I mean part of the the success in the
  495. 51:1620 20 and 21 were all the spacks which is kind of  no longer a thing I there there's one I just saw
  496. 51:22the other day threel symbol starting with I where  it got canceled and it dropped like 80% in one day
  497. 51:29uh after a runup anyway yeah it's I think it's  going to be a while before that strategy works I
  498. 51:35mean I'm still running it but it's just been flat  for about two years now it's not doing anything so
  499. 51:40uh going back to your mean reversion strategy uh  does your system differentiate between an earnings
  500. 51:46release gap down on massive volume versus a steady  multi-day drop on above average volume not tied to
  501. 51:53earnings uh would your mean reversion strategy  play a big gap down influenced by volume it it
  502. 52:01would only if the if the stock had already been  falling for several days and then had a big gap
  503. 52:07down it would be then then I might buy it there  um that would be like a capitulation type thing
  504. 52:13but I mean the the the setup I use will typically  not choose anything that was like add a new high
  505. 52:21and then suddenly had a big gap down which which  is my old short setup and th those did work work
  506. 52:26well in um like 2013 and and around there but  but uh I think I don't know they they might work
  507. 52:33well now I I'm not I have no awareness of whether  it's earnings or not I don't I don't pull in any
  508. 52:40news fundamentals earning States whatever I mean  I'm I'm really I'm literally just taking price
  509. 52:46history and and and when price does the thing I'm  looking for it to do then that's my signal so yeah
  510. 52:55clearly uh you know all of my trading strategies  are basically looking for unusual volatility um
  511. 53:03like I said ear you know from from the beginning  we wanted to be in what was moving at any given
  512. 53:08time um and and so clearly I'll get more more  trades during earning season than not during
  513. 53:15earning season but there there's some amount of  earning season every quarter you know the the big
  514. 53:21ones are are are the the usual you know March uh  June and so on but uh I mean April July but some
  515. 53:30many companies are on a offset fiscal year so  you you get a certain clump of earnings every
  516. 53:35month um you mentioned earlier about curve fitting  and optimization what what are the primary kind of
  517. 53:43dangers um one should look out for uh so that they  don't get sucked in by this you know attractive uh
  518. 53:50shiny object well the the number one is don't  even try to build a strategy for one symbol
  519. 53:57Ian there's no way you can build a strategy for a  single symbol without overfitting it in my opinion
  520. 54:05and unless you're talking about very short-term  intraday you know I mean if if you have tick data
  521. 54:12or one minute bars and can go back several years  you know maybe uh you can find something that
  522. 54:19works consistently but um and I had that instinct  from the very beginning was to basically I want
  523. 54:25my sister be modeling a process where I'm scanning  the whole Market every day for for for that day's
  524. 54:32trades so that it's always a different set of  stocks that I'm trading every day I mean if I
  525. 54:37if I look at you know do it like a buy symbol back  test of my of my systems I mean there'll be fairly
  526. 54:42few trades in any one symbol in the course of a  year there'll be hundreds of different symbols
  527. 54:47in total so that's one that's the easiest way  to avoid overfitting is to do portfolio based
  528. 54:52approach not a single single stock approach you  know what I see a lot of people do is is you know
  529. 54:58or like I want to find a strategy that would have  caught the most possible gains out of Tesla in the
  530. 55:03last three years you know or right now you see  people doing that with Bitcoin which is pretty
  531. 55:09dumb because it's not going to keep repeating uh  you know that like that was a thing that happened
  532. 55:14and it's going to be a different a different stock  or or thing next time so avoid that and then other
  533. 55:21than that you know it's just keeping your total  number of parameters or degrees of Freedom as the
  534. 55:27quants would say um small I don't do optimization  for the most part I I'll use the optimizer to to
  535. 55:34uh go over a fairly small set of parameters or  just kind of study how a parameter impacts the
  536. 55:41results but I I don't do the classic thing of run  the optimization over every possible combination
  537. 55:46and find the best stats and choose that one that's  the thing I want to run so basically you avoid
  538. 55:54curve fitting by not curve fitting right right  right so uh I I've read that um back testing the
  539. 56:03issue problems with back testing uh often we back  test a system that will yield much higher returns
  540. 56:09and smaller draw Downs than typically experience  with live trading what is it about that process
  541. 56:16um why why does that happen are we not looking  at enough long enough time frame um for this
  542. 56:23and is that inherent it it happens because when  you back test you keep trying different things
  543. 56:30and discarding the ones that work less well and  keeping the ones that work better and it after
  544. 56:35do it doesn't take too many iterations of that  before you come up with something that works
  545. 56:39better than is likely to happen in the future  that's kind of inevitable I mean I I just over
  546. 56:44the over the years have learned to assume that my  results going forward are not going to match what
  547. 56:49the back test indicates in fact my rule of thumb  is is half the return and twice the draw down
  548. 56:56uhhuh um so so unless I I'm content with that I I  typically won't run something I mean that rule of
  549. 57:04thumb probably shows that I'm overfitting as well  but I I think there's no way to avoid it I mean
  550. 57:11as soon as you run your second test you you've  begun the overfitting process right right right
  551. 57:20it um is there a way to measure different types  of bull and bare markets with subtle granularity
  552. 57:26so we can have an earlier detection of the  conditions that could cause draw Downs in
  553. 57:31our strategy so that we get you know different we  don't just simply say well this is during a bull
  554. 57:36market or this is during a bare Market well what  type of bull market what type of bare Market how
  555. 57:41did this bull market and bare Market different was  different from past Bull and Bear markets is there
  556. 57:46a way to kind of get that uh unique granularity of  that particular market so that we can understand
  557. 57:54greater what's going on there may be I know that  uh some people have done work in that area I think
  558. 58:00van Tharp had a whole way of classifying different  market regimes like that you know I mean the
  559. 58:06simplest is just a binary Market regime you know  bull or bear like is it above or below the 200 day
  560. 58:11moving average but yeah you can go from there you  can do I think there's like a four-way thing of
  561. 58:19bull with high volatility Bull with low volatility  bear with high volatility bear with low volatility
  562. 58:25uh and there's probably other dimensions you could  add and then and then you have to back test that
  563. 58:30against you know you have to pick a strategy and  try it in each of those regimes and see how it did
  564. 58:35and is that indicative of what will happen in the  future maybe you kind of if you want to use regime
  565. 58:41filtering in in in these kind of systems you have  to kind of decide from the beginning that that's
  566. 58:47what you're going to do start with the regime  filter in place and then put your rules on top
  567. 58:50of it because if you optimize some trading rules  and then try to apply a regime filter it'll always
  568. 58:55almost always make it look course because you've  already kind of accounted for that in the trading
  569. 59:00rules themselves since you were interviewed in  the uh unknown Market Wizards um say 2023 and
  570. 59:08so far in 2024 uh how how have you been how have  you been doing well basically uh you know my my
  571. 59:16last Equity Peak was was the middle of 2021 um  you know I had a bit of a draw down in the or
  572. 59:23end of 2021 and then had a flat year in 2022 and  I had another draw down at the start of 23 and
  573. 59:31and then flat since then I'm up slightly this year  so basically I'm no longer achieving Market wizard
  574. 59:39results in in the last few years but you know  then again there were several years in the in
  575. 59:46the past uh the period That's documented in the  book when my results weren't that great either
  576. 59:52I mean it's he's looking for overall stat over a  long term so but you know the one way to look at
  577. 1:00:00it is I had an extreme outlier period of from mid  2020 through mid 2021 where where I had the best
  578. 1:00:0612month results I've ever had and then and now my  equity's main reverted since then back to its uh
  579. 1:00:13usual Trend kind of kind of 20% average uh so why  do you think uh more Traders don't go systematic
  580. 1:00:23uh are the barriers to entry or learning curve  uh are they high not quite as exciting as for the
  581. 1:00:30Adrenaline Junkies all of those things yeah I mean  it you know it's the the old cliche of finding an
  582. 1:00:37approach to trading that fits your personality I  mean the ones more likely to go systematic or are
  583. 1:00:43the ones who don't care so much about the the  gambling feeling of putting on a trade and and
  584. 1:00:49don't care about you know wanting to be right you  know like your typical Global macro kind of Trad
  585. 1:00:56who who who who likes to do all this analysis  about what's happening in the world and make
  586. 1:00:59the correct call about what stocks bonds and  Golds are going to do and you know gets pleasure
  587. 1:01:05it it sort of comes down to what what gives you  pleasure what makes your dopamine fire probably
  588. 1:01:10so um you know for for me the the actual trading  process of put you know putting on one trade I
  589. 1:01:18don't even care what my individual trades are I  I know I have some positions open right now but
  590. 1:01:23I couldn't tell you what the symbols are I can't  remember I I didn't even look I just I literally
  591. 1:01:28don't care about an individual trait I care about  the stats you know so so what gives me pleasure
  592. 1:01:34is is um finding a strategy that feels robust to  me and has had good stats in the past and then
  593. 1:01:40having putting it on and having it keep working  um over time uh but more than that uh working on
  594. 1:01:47this the back testing software and um you know  improving the software itself actually gives me
  595. 1:01:52more pleasure than anything related to trading so  I've I've kind so part of my results are flat is
  596. 1:01:56I've really been neglecting my own trading system  research recently putting all my focus in working
  597. 1:02:02on my software because I have over 700 users now  who who like to use it and I I just really like
  598. 1:02:08uh you know supporting them and it's kind of  like I'm back in the software business but I'm
  599. 1:02:12still trading too because I have money to invest  and I don't know of another way to do it so I do
  600. 1:02:17it that way and so your trading software uh does  what helps users do back testing it's back testing
  601. 1:02:25yeah back testing tool and then I I also have a an  automation tool that uh you know integrates with
  602. 1:02:31interactive brokers and places the orders that  the software generates for for the strategies
  603. 1:02:38that have been modeled yeah it makes it fairly  easy to to build a system that combines multiple
  604. 1:02:44strategies and um and see what the results would  have been in the past and trade it going forward
  605. 1:02:50yeah so so that's kind of your your passion  currently is the uh working tweaking your software
  606. 1:02:56and and uh communicating with your fellow members  on their strategies and so forth yes for sure yeah
  607. 1:03:03well great well thank you Marsen for coming  on chat with Traders my pleasure thank you
  608. 1:03:08for having me yeah yeah H how can our listeners  uh get in touch with you the my website is mhpr
  609. 1:03:15trading.com uh and so that's where you can you can  find out about my software and actually there's
  610. 1:03:22links to my all the other podcasts I've been on  and one will soon be on there as well uh great
  611. 1:03:28I'm on Twitter also known as X as mars10p that's  M s10p those are the best ways to find me okay
  612. 1:03:38fantastic thanks Marsten thank you you've reached  the end of this episode of chat with Traders but
  613. 1:03:46rest assured there are more episodes loaded with  real Market insight and zero hype on the way soon
  614. 1:03:53so to stay updated with each great new release  subscribe to the podcast and iTunes and we'd
  615. 1:03:59love it if you'd leave a rating and review we'll  catch you next time on chat with Traders [Music]
  616. 1:04:26[Music]

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of The Purely Systematic Wizard Trader · Marsten Parker by Chat With Traders, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 11,806 words across 616 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.