The Psilocybin Dose That Actually Worked in Studies — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00These two mushrooms weigh exactly the
- 0:02same amount, but one of them could be
- 0:03nearly eight times stronger than the
- 0:05other. This year, scientists in Israel
- 0:07grew 14 types of the most common magic
- 0:09mushrooms side by side in identical
- 0:11conditions. When they measured the
- 0:13active compounds, the strongest had
- 0:15almost eight times more than the
- 0:16weakest, and even mushrooms of the same
- 0:18type from the same batch even didn't
- 0:21match each other. So when somebody tells
- 0:23you to just take a gram or two, they're
- 0:25completely guessing how much is actually
- 0:27in there, and you're the one who has to
- 0:28live with the consequences of that
- 0:30guess. I'm Jack. I spend my life reading
- 0:32psychedelic research and turning it into
- 0:34plain English, and in the next 10
- 0:36minutes, I'll explain what a dose really
- 0:37means, what the big studies are actually
- 0:39using, why microdosing might not be what
- 0:41you think, and the safety points that
- 0:43matter most if you're thinking about
- 0:45trying this yourself. No jargon,
- 0:47straight to the point. Let's go.
- 0:51So imagine I said to you, here's one cup
- 0:53of coffee. Now has that got one shot of
- 0:55espresso in it or two? Is it a big mug
- 0:57of filter or a decaf? One cup tells you
- 1:00how much liquid there is, but it doesn't
- 1:02tell you how much caffeine there is.
- 1:03Grams of mushroom works exactly the same
- 1:05way. Grams tell you how much mushroom
- 1:07you've got, but they don't tell you how
- 1:09much of the active ingredient is
- 1:10actually inside it. That active
- 1:12ingredient is called psilocybin. Your
- 1:14body turns into psilocin, and psilocin
- 1:16is actually what changes how you feel.
- 1:18Scientists measure psilocybin in
- 1:19milligrams, which is a thousandth of a
- 1:21gram. So there are two numbers. Grams is
- 1:24the weight of the mushroom, milligrams
- 1:26is the amount of psilocybin inside it.
- 1:28When you read about a study, it's almost
- 1:30always milligrams, when you hear people
- 1:32talking, it's almost always grams, and
- 1:35that's where the confusion starts. And
- 1:37here's why you can't just convert one
- 1:39into the other. In that 2026 study I
- 1:41mentioned, every mushroom was grown in
- 1:43the same conditions. The weakest type
- 1:45had about 2.6 milligrams of the active
- 1:47compound per gram. The strongest had
- 1:49about 20.7. So the same weight with
- 1:52nearly eight times the strength, and it
- 1:54gets messier. Even mushrooms of the same
- 1:57type grown together typically differed
- 1:59by around to 23% from one mushroom to
- 2:02the next.
- 2:03Then there's how old they are, how they
- 2:05were dried, and how they were stored as
- 2:08psilocybin breaks down over time. So
- 2:10here's the first big lesson of this
- 2:12video. You can't measure doses in grams.
- 2:15So if grams are a guess, what do the
- 2:17scientists do? They skip the mushroom
- 2:19entirely. In trials, people get a
- 2:21caption of pure lab-made psilocybin
- 2:24measured to the milligram. And it's
- 2:26pretty much the only way to know exactly
- 2:28what someone took.
- 2:31Let's look at two of the most important
- 2:33studies because between them they answer
- 2:35a question that everyone asks. Does more
- 2:38mean better? Study one, Johns Hopkins
- 2:402011. Roland Griffiths' team gave 18
- 2:43healthy adults five sessions each a
- 2:45month apart, a placebo and four
- 2:48different doses from small to large, and
- 2:50the doses were scaled to body weight.
- 2:53And here's what they found. The bigger
- 2:54the dose, the stronger the effects. At
- 2:56the smallest dose, about one in 20
- 2:58people had what researchers call a
- 3:00complete mystical experience. At the two
- 3:03biggest doses, it was around half. But
- 3:05that's not the whole story because at
- 3:07those two bigger doses, 39% of people,
- 3:10nearly four in 10, also had moments of
- 3:12extreme fear. They felt trapped or
- 3:15feared that they were losing their mind.
- 3:17And these were screened volunteers in a
- 3:19calm room with trained guides present.
- 3:22One detail I love about this study is
- 3:23that people who started on lower doses
- 3:25and built up seemed to get more lasting
- 3:28benefit than people who started high.
- 3:30Study two, the Compass trial 2022. This
- 3:33was the biggest psilocybin trial of its
- 3:34time, published in the New England
- 3:36Journal of Medicine. 233 people with
- 3:39depression that hadn't responded to
- 3:40other treatments got one dose, either 25
- 3:43mg, 10 mg, or 1 mg, which acted as the
- 3:47comparison. And after three weeks, 37%
- 3:50of the 25 mg group had responded. In the
- 3:5210 mg group, it was just 19%. And in the
- 3:57So the middle dose barely beat the tiny
- 4:00one. But again, there's a cost. Side
- 4:02effects like headaches and nausea were
- 4:03more common at 25 mg and the benefits
- 4:06had started to fade for many people by
- 4:08three months. So does more mean better?
- 4:11Up to a point, the effects do get
- 4:13stronger, but so do the harder moments.
- 4:15And the researchers controlled
- 4:16everything, the exact milligrams, the
- 4:19screening, the room, the guides. And in
- 4:22real life, you can control almost none
- 4:24of that. So which doses have actually
- 4:26shown benefits? Here's the short
- 4:28version. The dose that comes up again
- 4:30and again is 25 mg. It's the amount used
- 4:33in most of the big depression trials. In
- 4:362023, a US trial of 104 people with
- 4:39major depression gave each person either
- 4:4125 mg of psilocybin or a placebo. 6
- 4:44weeks later, 42% of the psilocybin group
- 4:47had a lasting improvement compared with
- 4:4912% on the placebo.
- 4:52And in the last 2 years, two large phase
- 4:54three trials, the final stage before a
- 4:56drug can be approved, both found that 25
- 4:58mg beat placebo for depression that
- 5:00hadn't responded to other treatments.
- 5:02It's a similar story for anxiety. In
- 5:042016, Johns Hopkins gave 51 people with
- 5:07cancer who were struggling with anxiety
- 5:09and depression either a tiny dose or a
- 5:11high one, roughly 22 to 30 mg for an
- 5:14average-sized adults. And 6 months after
- 5:17the high dose, around 80% still had big
- 5:20improvements in their anxiety and mood.
- 5:22But what about when it comes to lower
- 5:23doses? 10 mg is the one that's been
- 5:26tested most. In the first Compass trial,
- 5:28it barely beat the tiny comparison dose,
- 5:31but in their newest larger trial, 10 mg
- 5:33did help, just less than the 25. So
- 5:36roughly speaking, 25 mg is the dose with
- 5:38the strongest evidence behind it. 10 mg
- 5:41has some, but it's weaker. And remember,
- 5:44every one of these people was screened,
- 5:45prepared, and supported by trained
- 5:47guides. Now here's the catch. How many
- 5:50grams of dried mushrooms is 25 mg? Using
- 5:53that 2026 study from earlier, it could
- 5:55be anywhere from 1 g of a strong
- 5:57mushroom to nearly 10 g of a weak one.
- 5:59So that's a tenfold difference. You
- 6:01weigh out the same amount from two
- 6:03different batches and you could be
- 6:04getting half the trial dose from one and
- 6:06four times the trial dose from the
- 6:08other.
- 6:09So that's why if you're seriously
- 6:10considering this, a legal setting where
- 6:12mushrooms are lab tested and the dose is
- 6:15measured is the safest way to do it. At
- 6:18home with mushrooms from who knows
- 6:20where, you just don't have a clue what
- 6:21you're taking. So in those situations
- 6:23I'd recommend starting very low, getting
- 6:25comfortable with the experience, and
- 6:27then only increasing if you see fit from
- 6:29there.
- 6:31Now a lot of my viewers ask me about
- 6:33microdosing, taking a tiny amount, too
- 6:36small to really feel, every few days.
- 6:39People say it helps their mood, their
- 6:40focus, their anxiety, and I believe them
- 6:43because I microdose regularly and I
- 6:45notice those same benefits.
- 6:47But here's a study that changed how I
- 6:48think about it. In 2021 a team at
- 6:51Imperial College London here in the UK
- 6:54ran a study on 191 people who were
- 6:56already microdosing. Most were using
- 6:58LSD, but about a quarter were using
- 7:01mushrooms. Now the problem with studying
- 7:02microdosing or psychedelics in general
- 7:05is that if you know you've taken it, you
- 7:07expect to feel better. So the team gave
- 7:09everyone instructions to blind
- 7:10themselves. People put their real
- 7:12microdoses into opaque capsules, made
- 7:15identical empty ones, mixed them into
- 7:17envelopes with QR codes, and shuffled
- 7:19them. For four weeks nobody knew which
- 7:22they were taking. And the results, both
- 7:24groups got better. Mood, well-being,
- 7:26anxiety all improved, but the people
- 7:29taking the empty capsules improved just
- 7:31as much as the people taking the real
- 7:33thing, and the people scored higher on
- 7:35the days they believed they'd taken a
- 7:36real dose, whether they had or not. Now
- 7:39to be fair, this wasn't a perfect lab
- 7:41trial and everyone in it already
- 7:42believed in microdosing, but it's the
- 7:44largest placebo-controlled microdosing
- 7:46study done so far, and it suggests that
- 7:48a lot of the benefits come from
- 7:50expectation and not the actual mushroom.
- 7:53I'll be honest, I'm pretty certain there
- 7:55is more to it than that and perhaps
- 7:56we've just been unable to study or
- 7:58measure the effects accurately enough.
- 8:00The studies can only look at what's
- 8:01measurable in a lab setting, so they use
- 8:03standardized cognitive tests, subjective
- 8:06mood questionnaires, and reaction time
- 8:07tasks, which are all useful scientific
- 8:10tools, but they're also very reductive.
- 8:12Flow states, the thing that I notice
- 8:14most when I microdose, are notoriously
- 8:16hard to capture in controlled settings.
- 8:18Flow emerges in dynamic, unpredictable
- 8:20contexts, like when you're improvising
- 8:22in conversation or responding to the
- 8:25spontaneity of a football match or
- 8:27expressing a creative idea. And you
- 8:29can't really test for that with a
- 8:30computer task showing letters in
- 8:32sequence.
- 8:33But even if the placebo does play a
- 8:35role, which I'm sure it does, I don't
- 8:37think that's bad news either. It just
- 8:39shows how important it can be to believe
- 8:41in something, to have a ritual or
- 8:43routine around it, and why having the
- 8:45intention of looking after yourself
- 8:47matters so much.
- 8:50So why does the same dose hit people
- 8:52differently? People like to think a gram
- 8:54is a gram, but we've already seen that
- 8:56this isn't true because the strength of
- 8:58the mushroom can vary hugely. And even
- 9:00if you had two identical doses, they'd
- 9:02still land differently in different
- 9:04people. Your mindset, your body, where
- 9:06you are, who you're with, and countless
- 9:08other things all change the experience.
- 9:11Even with the exact same milligrams,
- 9:13researchers see huge differences between
- 9:15people. So with that in mind, what
- 9:16actually changes the experience beyond
- 9:18the dose itself? First, your mindset
- 9:21going in. Scientists call this set, and
- 9:23it's about if you're calm or anxious or
- 9:26rested or exhausted. Second, your
- 9:28surroundings or setting. A peaceful room
- 9:31with someone you trust is a completely
- 9:33different world from a busy party or out
- 9:35in public.
- 9:36Third, your body.
- 9:38Your size, what you've eaten, what
- 9:40medications you take. And there's more
- 9:42on that in a minute because it's
- 9:43especially important for older viewers.
- 9:45And fourth, experience. Remember the
- 9:47Hopkins study? In it, people who built
- 9:49up gradually seemed to do better than
- 9:51those who started big. And one more
- 9:53thing that often surprises people is
- 9:55that you might think a smaller amount is
- 9:57always the gentler option, but
- 9:59therapists who run legal sessions often
- 10:01say the in-between experiences can be
- 10:03the hardest. The effects are strong
- 10:05enough to stir up emotions and memories,
- 10:07but your thinking mind is still fully
- 10:08switched on, trying to stay in control,
- 10:11and that tug of war can feel really
- 10:12uncomfortable. So the honest answer to
- 10:15what will this dose do to me
- 10:17is that nobody can tell you, not me, not
- 10:20a doctor, not a chart.
- 10:24Now a lot of dosing advice we'll skip
- 10:26this next part, but it's the part that I
- 10:27most want you to hear because if you're
- 10:29over say 60 or 70, the risks aren't the
- 10:32same as for a 25 year old. Number one,
- 10:35your heart and blood pressure.
- 10:37Psilocybin pushes up your blood pressure
- 10:39and your heart rate while it's working.
- 10:41In the Hopkins study, at the highest
- 10:43dose, four of 18 healthy volunteers had
- 10:46rises big enough that staff had to
- 10:47monitor them more closely. A 2023 review
- 10:50of psychedelic therapy for older adults
- 10:52found healthy older people seem to face
- 10:54similar risks to younger ones, but
- 10:57almost all trial volunteers are
- 10:58carefully screened. Very few are over 65
- 11:02and we know very little about people
- 11:03with heart disease or several long-term
- 11:06conditions. Two, lithium. This one is
- 11:08serious. Researchers at Johns Hopkins
- 11:10looked at 62 online reports of people
- 11:13who'd combined a psychedelic with
- 11:15lithium. Nearly half described a seizure
- 11:18and almost four in 10 needed medical
- 11:19help. Now that's from online reports,
- 11:21not a trial, but the signal was so
- 11:23strong that researchers flagged it as a
- 11:25real risk. So if you take lithium, this
- 11:27is not one to experiment with. Number
- 11:29three, antidepressants. Now this is more
- 11:31mixed than most people think. A 2022
- 11:33Swiss study gave healthy volunteers two
- 11:35weeks of an antidepressant before
- 11:37psilocybin. Now it didn't weaken the
- 11:39overall experience and it actually
- 11:41reduced anxiety and the rise in blood
- 11:43pressure, but that was short-term use in
- 11:45healthy people and some long-term
- 11:47antidepressant users say that they feel
- 11:49less effects. The danger is people
- 11:51stopping their medication suddenly or
- 11:53taking more mushrooms to make up for it.
- 11:56So please don't do either without
- 11:57talking to your doctor. Four, your
- 11:59mental health history. Trials exclude
- 12:01people with bipolar disorder or a
- 12:03personal or family history of psychosis
- 12:06as psychedelics can trigger serious
- 12:08episodes in people who are vulnerable.
- 12:10Five, falls and confusion. Psilocybin
- 12:13affects balance and coordination and you
- 12:15can lose track of time and where you
- 12:16are. This is one reason why trials
- 12:18always have someone sober in the room.
- 12:20One last thing, in most of the world,
- 12:22including the UK and most of the US,
- 12:25psilocybin mushrooms are still illegal.
- 12:27A few states like Oregon and Colorado
- 12:30now allow it in licensed supervised
- 12:32settings. So I'm not telling you what to
- 12:33do, I'm telling you what the science
- 12:35says so that whatever you decide, you
- 12:37decide with as much reliable information
- 12:39as possible.
- 12:42So what do you actually do with all
- 12:44this?
- 12:45If you're on any regular medication, the
- 12:47first step is a conversation with your
- 12:48doctor or a trained medical professional
- 12:51about interactions. And you don't have
- 12:53to tell them your plans, you can just
- 12:54ask what's known about your medication
- 12:56and psychedelics. If you want reliable,
- 12:59judgment-free information, harm
- 13:01reduction services exist exactly for
- 13:03this. In the US, Fireside Project runs a
- 13:06free confidential psychedelic peer
- 13:08support line. You can call or text on 62
- 13:11Fireside, whether you're in the middle
- 13:13of an experience or trying to make sense
- 13:15from one already gone. Dance Safe offers
- 13:18drug checking kits and plain English
- 13:20safety information, and TripSit has
- 13:22volunteers you can chat to online. If
- 13:24you're drawn to this for your mental
- 13:26health, there are now some legal routes
- 13:28and they will come with the things that
- 13:29trials have, screening, tested products,
- 13:32and trained support. In the US, Oregon
- 13:34and Colorado run licensed programs where
- 13:37adults over 21 can have a supervised
- 13:39psilocybin session with a trained
- 13:40facilitator, no prescription needed. New
- 13:43Mexico has passed a medical psilocybin
- 13:45law too, though its program isn't
- 13:47expected to open until the end of 2027.
- 13:50Just know that psilocybin is still
- 13:51illegal under federal law even in those
- 13:53states. Outside the US, Australia let
- 13:56specially authorized psychiatrists
- 13:58prescribe psilocybin for
- 13:59treatment-resistant depression. Since
- 14:01January this year, doctors in the Czech
- 14:03Republic can prescribe it for certain
- 14:04mental health conditions, and
- 14:06Switzerland allows it case by case. Then
- 14:08there are places that are legal for
- 14:10different reasons. In the Netherlands,
- 14:12magic truffles are sold legally in
- 14:13shops, and in Jamaica, mushrooms were
- 14:16never banned, so retreats operate
- 14:18openly. Now, not all of them come with
- 14:20medical screening, so the safety points
- 14:22from earlier matter even more. And
- 14:24clinical trials are still recruiting in
- 14:26the US and the UK, and that's one route
- 14:28where you reliably get a measured dose,
- 14:30proper screening, and trained support
- 14:32for free.
- 14:33And if you want help with the part that
- 14:34matters most, which is getting ready
- 14:36mentally and making sense of an
- 14:37experience afterwards, I've put
- 14:39everything I've learned into my
- 14:41psychedelic prep and integration guide.
- 14:43I've also added a full section on legal
- 14:45access, which countries and states allow
- 14:48it, how each route works, plus links to
- 14:50trusted retreats and university trials
- 14:52that are recruiting right now. So if
- 14:54you're wondering where you could do this
- 14:55legally and safely, it's all in one
- 14:57place and it's linked below. So if you
- 14:59remember one thing from this video, make
- 15:01it this. A gram is not a dose. The same
- 15:04weight can be eight times stronger, and
- 15:06the same dose can hit two people
- 15:08completely differently. The studies show
- 15:10bigger doses bring stronger experiences
- 15:13and also more hard moments, too.
- 15:15Microdosing may not have the scientific
- 15:17proof, but anecdotal evidence and my
- 15:19personal experience says there's more to
- 15:20it than placebo. And if you're older,
- 15:23your heart health, your overall health,
- 15:25and your medication status matter more
- 15:28than any number on a scale. And now I
- 15:30want to hear from you. If you've had any
- 15:32experiences with mushrooms, whether last
- 15:34year or 50 years ago, what surprised you
- 15:37the most? Tell me in the comments cuz I
- 15:39read every one. And if this helped you
- 15:41understand something that might have
- 15:42confused you before, please subscribe. I
- 15:45make videos like this often, turning new
- 15:47psychedelic research into plain English.
- 15:49I also send a weekly newsletter covering
- 15:51the latest psychedelic research, which
- 15:52you can sign up to via the link in the
- 15:54description. Cheers, and I'll see you in
- 15:56the next one.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of The Psilocybin Dose That Actually Worked in Studies by Mushies, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,949 words across 452 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.