The Overlooked Photo of Neil Armstrong on the Moon — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00This photograph was taken on the moon in
- 0:02July 1969.
- 0:04The astronaut in the shadows was
- 0:06publicly identified as Neil Armstrong in
- 0:081987.
- 0:10Look closer at the base of the lunar
- 0:11module. Next to an equipment bay called
- 0:14the mesa, there is an astronaut at work.
- 0:16That is Neil Armstrong. He is packing
- 0:19the bulk sample. Clear [snorts] still
- 0:21photographs of Armstrong on the lunar
- 0:23surface are rare. NASA's catalog
- 0:25describes this frame as one of the few
- 0:27that show him there. So why are there so
- 0:30few? Who was holding the camera? And how
- 0:32was this frame publicly identified in
- 0:341987?
- 0:37The moonwalk lasted about two and a half
- 0:39hours from the moment the hatch opened
- 0:41to the moment it closed again. For
- 0:43ordinary color still photographs outside
- 0:45the lunar module, the astronauts used
- 0:47one Hasselblad camera during the
- 0:49moonwalk. In the plan written in June
- 0:511969, the Hasselblad is the camera that
- 0:55will enable the CDR, the commander, to
- 0:57take still color photographs. Separate
- 1:00systems recorded live television and 16
- 1:03mm film. A stereo close-up camera was
- 1:05intended for the lunar soil, not
- 1:07portraits. In the 1980s, Apollo
- 1:10historian David Compton told researcher
- 1:12Keith Wilson that the commander was
- 1:14scheduled to photograph the lunar module
- 1:16pilot and the reverse was not planned.
- 1:19The commander was Armstrong. The lunar
- 1:21module pilot was Buzz Aldrin. The
- 1:24surface operations plan fits that
- 1:25description.
- 1:27Armstrong was to photograph Aldrin
- 1:28coming down the ladder while Aldrin,
- 1:30still inside, filmed Armstrong's first
- 1:33activities with the 16 mm camera.
- 1:36But the camera did not stay with
- 1:38Armstrong the whole time. At one point,
- 1:40he set the Hasselblad down on the mesa.
- 1:43A little later, Aldrin picked it up from
- 1:44there. People who later studied the
- 1:46television footage noted that Armstrong
- 1:48did not hand the camera to Aldrin at
- 1:50that moment. With the camera, Aldrin
- 1:53photographed his boot and his boot print
- 1:55in the lunar soil. During a review in
- 1:571991, he remembered that he was the one
- 2:00took them. Then, standing west of the
- 2:02ladder, he began a panorama. Frames 5881
- 2:05through 5889 make up that pan. 5890 and
- 2:095891 were taken after he moved closer to
- 2:13a double crater. Frame by frame, the
- 2:15view turns. And in frame 5886, there is
- 2:19the lunar module and Armstrong beside
- 2:21it.
- 2:22For that frame, Aldrin was holding the
- 2:24camera and the commander was in the
- 2:25picture.
- 2:27So why did this frame take so long to be
- 2:29publicly linked to Armstrong? NASA's
- 2:32NSSDC catalog notes that Armstrong took
- 2:35most of the photographs on the moon.
- 2:37That helps explain why so many
- 2:38Hasselblad frames show Aldrin instead.
- 2:41In one of them, Armstrong appears only
- 2:43as a small reflection in Aldrin's gold
- 2:45visor. We looked at that detail in a
- 2:47separate short. The record had another
- 2:49problem. According to the Apollo Lunar
- 2:52Surface Journal, mistakes in identifying
- 2:54who was speaking in the original
- 2:55transcript made it look as if Armstrong
- 2:58took many pictures that Aldrin actually
- 3:00took. Researcher Keith Wilson later
- 3:02described what he was told by NASA's
- 3:04Johnson Space Center. According to
- 3:06Wilson 's account, JSC Public Affairs
- 3:08told him that no still photo of
- 3:10Armstrong on the moon existed because
- 3:12Aldrin had never had the camera. Wilson
- 3:15also described a phone call that, by his
- 3:17account, Brian Duff of NASA Public
- 3:19Affairs made to Armstrong in the Lunar
- 3:21Receiving Laboratory [music] after the
- 3:22flight.
- 3:23Duff asked, "Neil, this is Brian. When
- 3:26did you give the camera to Buzz?"
- 3:28Armstrong answered, "I never did."
- 3:30Wilson's explanation was that Armstrong
- 3:32had answered literally. He had not
- 3:34handed the camera to Aldrin. He had set
- 3:37it on the mesa where Aldrin picked it
- 3:38up.
- 3:40In July 1986, Keith Wilson wrote to
- 3:43David Compton, then the official Apollo
- 3:45historian at the Johnson Space Center,
- 3:47asking why there seemed to be no still
- 3:49photographs of Armstrong from the
- 3:51moonwalk. Compton described the camera
- 3:53arrangement we heard earlier. According
- 3:55to Wilson, Compton at that time believed
- 3:58that no still photo of Armstrong
- 3:59existed. Wilson then contacted
- 4:02Armstrong's office. Late in 1986, he was
- 4:05told that Armstrong believed the photo
- 4:07of himself lay between frames 5875
- 4:10and 5901. According to Wilson, in May
- 4:131987, after studying a copy of the
- 4:16Apollo 11 70 mm photographic catalog
- 4:19sent by Lee Saegesser of the NASA
- 4:21History Office, Armstrong confirmed to
- 4:23him that frame 5886 was the one. Wilson
- 4:27later wrote that his first public note
- 4:28appeared in the letters column of Space
- 4:30[music] Flight Magazine in August 1987.
- 4:33The photograph itself followed in the
- 4:35December 1987 issue. Another researcher,
- 4:38H. J. P. Arnold, reached the same
- 4:40conclusion independently and published
- 4:42his own article in Space Flight.
- 4:45In 1991, Armstrong and Aldrin went
- 4:48through the mission photographs with
- 4:49Eric Jones, the editor of the Apollo
- 4:51Lunar Surface Journal.
- 4:53They agreed that frame 5886 shows Neil
- 4:56at the mesa.
- 4:57Armstrong said, as I've continually told
- 5:00people, but the problem was that NASA
- 5:02kept putting out that there weren't any
- 5:04pictures of me.
- 5:05He said he did not think NASA had asked
- 5:07either him or Aldrin.
- 5:09That is Armstrong's own later
- 5:10description of NASA's position, not a
- 5:13quotation from a NASA document.
- 5:15Later in the review, while tracing how
- 5:17Armstrong regained the camera before
- 5:19frame 5923, Aldrin asked, did we set it
- 5:22down somewhere? Did we ever do that in
- 5:24transferring it? Armstrong replied, I
- 5:27don't remember.
- 5:2822 years later, they could not be sure
- 5:31how that transfer had happened.
- 5:33Armstrong is not missing from the record
- 5:36of the moon walk. On live television,
- 5:38mission control told him, Neil, we can
- 5:40see you coming down the ladder now. At
- 5:43one point, Houston even asked to get
- 5:45both astronauts into the television
- 5:46camera's field of view for the
- 5:48president's call. The television record
- 5:50was incomplete too. Geologist Lee Silver
- 5:53later recalled a stretch of about seven
- 5:55or eight minutes when you couldn't see
- 5:57Neil as Armstrong collected samples
- 5:59outside the camera's view. The 16 mm
- 6:02film shot from the lunar module shows
- 6:04him at work, at one point with a scoop
- 6:06in his hand. [music] And there's the
- 6:08reflection in Aldrin's visor. On
- 6:10television, on film, and in a
- 6:13reflection, he is there. In the color
- 6:15still photographs from the Hasselblad,
- 6:17clear frames of him are rare.
- 6:20So look again at the first photograph,
- 6:22the lunar module, the equipment bay, and
- 6:25in the shadow beside it, Neil Armstrong
- 6:27packing the bulk sample while Aldrin
- 6:29held the camera. It was taken in 1969.
- 6:33It was publicly identified in 1987.
- 6:36It was in the record all along.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of The Overlooked Photo of Neil Armstrong on the Moon by Look Closer Mysteries, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,094 words across 178 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.