YouTube2Text

The Open Coalition on Compliance Carbon Markets: One Year of Cooperation — Transcript

by UNFCCC Global Climate Action · 7,640 words · 1,290 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00And don't forget the whole of the WTO
  2. 0:02trading system, what we heard from the
  3. 0:04colleague from UNEP on trade finance and
  4. 0:07climate finance, they're all there. And
  5. 0:10as much as this room tends to talk about
  6. 0:12reducing fragmentation
  7. 0:14of policies and measures, I think we
  8. 0:16also need to think about reducing
  9. 0:18fragmentation of solutions. So
  10. 0:21let's work towards that.
  11. 0:24>> Okay, very quickly,
  12. 0:27the question Marcus on law, I agree
  13. 0:30completely. The first thing that test
  14. 0:32has started with to attack the trade and
  15. 0:35climate nexus was to explore the
  16. 0:38principles in international law from
  17. 0:40both law worlds, climate and trade. What
  18. 0:44are the principles that should
  19. 0:46potentially guide the discussion? And we
  20. 0:47have this in a publication. And I think
  21. 0:50more work potentially needs to be done
  22. 0:52on this law nexus. And then
  23. 0:56Annie, I just wanted to say that
  24. 0:59the discussions on interoperability
  25. 1:01are rising so much in the space with
  26. 1:03different
  27. 1:05with a lot of different institutions now
  28. 1:08tackling the issue. So I have a question
  29. 1:11for you is that how is all this how do
  30. 1:14you see all this linking? But also one
  31. 1:16of the things that I see from the work
  32. 1:18that you're doing is that sometimes they
  33. 1:20always say that interoperability can be
  34. 1:22more practical when taken to a sector.
  35. 1:25So I would like to see how this will
  36. 1:27apply in the steel and iron sector in
  37. 1:30order to learn more about how can we
  38. 1:32potentially take that down take that up
  39. 1:35to a more broader spectrum. Thank you.
  40. 1:37>> Thank you so much everyone. Thank you
  41. 1:39for the panelists. Please join me in
  42. 1:41thanking them.
  43. 1:44We're running out of time, but clearly
  44. 1:46there needs to be more dialogue between
  45. 1:48the trade and the climate folks and the
  46. 1:50rest of the line ministries.
  47. 1:52We have the spaces to do so. Let's use
  48. 1:55them and let's make sure we all work
  49. 1:58together to ensure the investment is to
  50. 2:00developing countries and the MSMEs in
  51. 2:01these countries so they can do the
  52. 2:03transition and it's in in a just way.
  53. 2:05Thank you so much.
  54. 4:01>> The
  55. 6:34>> three
  56. 8:44>> Hello, hello.
  57. 8:45Just to let you know we are about to
  58. 8:47start, just organizing here. So in some
  59. 8:50minutes, few minutes we're going to be
  60. 8:51starting.
  61. 11:17>> Good morning.
  62. 11:20Good morning. Thank you everyone for
  63. 11:21coming. So we are beginning at the
  64. 11:23session.
  65. 11:24We are here today to celebrate
  66. 11:27to celebrate together with you the first
  67. 11:29anniversary of the Open Coalition on
  68. 11:31Compliance Carbon Markets.
  69. 11:34One year of cooperation, a shared agenda
  70. 11:36for the future. And I'm very happy to
  71. 11:39introduce our wonderful panel this
  72. 11:42morning.
  73. 11:43Ms. Diana
  74. 11:45She's Director for International
  75. 11:47Relations and Finance at the DG CLIMA at
  76. 11:50the European Commission.
  77. 11:52We have also Mr.
  78. 11:55I'm trying my best to make the right
  79. 11:57pronunciation in Chinese. I hope I did
  80. 11:59it good.
  81. 12:01He's Director General for the Department
  82. 12:05of Climate Change at the Ministry of
  83. 12:06Ecology and Environment of China.
  84. 12:09We also have Vice Minister Christina
  85. 12:12Hays. She is the
  86. 12:14uh Vice Minister for uh Carbon Markets
  87. 12:16at the Secretariat of Carbon Markets at
  88. 12:19the Ministry of Finance of Brazil.
  89. 12:21Um and I'm happy to to be the moderator
  90. 12:24for this session today. My name is Karen
  91. 12:25Vargas.
  92. 12:27I head for uh
  93. 12:28climate emissions at the Secretariat of
  94. 12:32Carbon Markets in the Ministry of
  95. 12:33Finance of Brazil.
  96. 12:35But before we begin the panel, I would
  97. 12:37like to invite Kaan Morali on behalf of
  98. 12:40the COP 31 presidency to make a brief uh
  99. 12:43speech opening remarks. Thank you.
  100. 12:49>> Thank you very much. Uh
  101. 12:51distinguished
  102. 12:52coalition representatives, esteemed
  103. 12:53participants.
  104. 12:55First of all, it is a great pleasure to
  105. 12:57welcome you all on behalf of Turkey
  106. 12:59and the COP 31 presidency.
  107. 13:02First of all, I would like to thank the
  108. 13:04uh organizing this panel and the for the
  109. 13:07also for one year
  110. 13:10as a chair and the co-chair roles to
  111. 13:12Brazil, China, and the
  112. 13:14European Union.
  113. 13:16Also, I am pleased to join you today as
  114. 13:19we reflect on the coalition's progress
  115. 13:22over the past year and discuss
  116. 13:23opportunities for future cooperation.
  117. 13:27Today, one of the main challenges in
  118. 13:29global climate action is how to turn our
  119. 13:31goals into effective implementation.
  120. 13:35Important progress has been made towards
  121. 13:37the shared goals of the Paris Agreement.
  122. 13:40However, achieving these goals requires
  123. 13:42countries to strengthen their policy
  124. 13:44tools and improve their capacity to
  125. 13:47implement climate action and deepen
  126. 13:50international cooperation.
  127. 13:53The action agenda provides an important
  128. 13:56framework for supporting climate
  129. 13:58commitments with concrete actions,
  130. 14:00bringing different actors together
  131. 14:03around shared goals and achieving
  132. 14:05stronger results through cooperation.
  133. 14:09In this context, we believe that
  134. 14:11initiatives which respond to common
  135. 14:13needs and connect political dialogue
  136. 14:15with technical cooperation are
  137. 14:18particularly valuable.
  138. 14:20The open coalition on compliance carbon
  139. 14:23markets is an important example
  140. 14:26of this approach in the field of carbon
  141. 14:28pricing.
  142. 14:30Esteemed participants, carbon markets
  143. 14:32play an important role in integrating
  144. 14:35emissions reductions efforts into
  145. 14:37economic activities and encouraging low
  146. 14:41carbon investments.
  147. 14:43Developing regulatory frameworks,
  148. 14:45establishing reliable monitoring and
  149. 14:47verification system,
  150. 14:49strengthening the institution capacity
  151. 14:51is very important tools to achieve
  152. 14:54especially for the
  153. 14:57good data quality in this system.
  154. 15:01Yes, this is one of the most important
  155. 15:04opportunities offered by the coalition.
  156. 15:07By sharing knowledge, by respecting
  157. 15:09national policy choices and regularity
  158. 15:11independence,
  159. 15:12countries can learn from each other and
  160. 15:15build stronger capacity to address
  161. 15:18similar challenges.
  162. 15:21Here, we believe that coalition's
  163. 15:23importance within the COP 31 action
  164. 15:25agenda goes beyond its role as a
  165. 15:27platform for cooperation on compliance
  166. 15:31carbon markets.
  167. 15:32By working together, we can turn our
  168. 15:35shared goals into real and lasting
  169. 15:37results.
  170. 15:39Also, strengthening cooperation among
  171. 15:41the existing initiatives also a
  172. 15:44important issue for us.
  173. 15:47It is particularly important that
  174. 15:48developing countries to bring their
  175. 15:52implementation challenges, priorities
  176. 15:54and experiences into the coalition's
  177. 15:57work.
  178. 15:58We believe that these elements can help
  179. 16:00strengthening the coalition's connection
  180. 16:02with the action agenda in the coming
  181. 16:05years.
  182. 16:07By saying this, I would like to thank
  183. 16:09all of you participants and the I wish a
  184. 16:11good panel to all of you and I hope you
  185. 16:14are enjoying time in Antalya. Thank you
  186. 16:16very much.
  187. 16:25>> Thank you very much, Kaan.
  188. 16:27Let's turn to the panel now. And as we
  189. 16:30are celebrating the first anniversary of
  190. 16:32the Open Coalition, which was initiated
  191. 16:35in Belém at COP 30, I would like to
  192. 16:38invite Vice Minister Cristina Heath to
  193. 16:40guide us a little bit about what is the
  194. 16:42coalition, what why it was created, and
  195. 16:45what it's aiming aiming to achieve. So
  196. 16:48Cristina, please.
  197. 16:51>> Thank you, Kaan.
  198. 16:53Good morning. Thank you all for coming,
  199. 16:56especially my dear partners here,
  200. 16:59colleagues
  201. 17:02We are all here representing the chairs
  202. 17:05of the Open Coalition on Compliance
  203. 17:07Carbon Markets. I want to thank also the
  204. 17:10presidency of COP 31, Mr. Kaan, for your
  205. 17:15words, for your kindness, for arranging
  206. 17:17this spot for us, and also for
  207. 17:21yes, giving us this light so that we can
  208. 17:24present the the OCCCM. We can decide if
  209. 17:28we're going to call it OCCCM or OCCCM.
  210. 17:31We still don't have an acronym.
  211. 17:34But yes, we are celebrating one year of
  212. 17:37this idea that came up some few weeks
  213. 17:41before
  214. 17:42COP 30 in Belém, right? So at that
  215. 17:46point, Brazil was
  216. 17:49had approved a a law on carbon pricing
  217. 17:52on ETS, emission trade system. And we
  218. 17:56knew that we had a huge challenge ahead
  219. 17:59of us to implement it to implement the
  220. 18:02domestic market, but we all we wanted to
  221. 18:05implement it already
  222. 18:07connected with interoperability
  223. 18:10with other systems, other carbon pricing
  224. 18:13mechanisms of other countries. And so
  225. 18:18we wanted to promote this cooperation
  226. 18:21precisely related to compliance carbon
  227. 18:24markets. We know that there were already
  228. 18:26some initiatives. We had the Climate
  229. 18:29Club, we had the Coalition to Grow
  230. 18:31Carbon Markets, we had IETA, we had ICAP
  231. 18:35and others and regional initiatives.
  232. 18:37Some are related to voluntary carbon
  233. 18:39markets, others are related to
  234. 18:41compliance carbon markets.
  235. 18:43But the the greatest achievements of
  236. 18:47these uh this initiative, I would say
  237. 18:50are at least three.
  238. 18:52First,
  239. 18:53uh it is an open coalition and this idea
  240. 18:57came from COP 30 presidency and with the
  241. 19:01super support we worked together, the
  242. 19:04Ministry of Finance and the Ministry of
  243. 19:07Foreign Relations and the COP 30
  244. 19:10presidency, we said no, it's opened. We
  245. 19:13need to have a smaller group to advance
  246. 19:17in this topic and it was not in the
  247. 19:19negotiation track of uh the Paris
  248. 19:22Agreement and we need to talk about that
  249. 19:24and we we had the action agenda of COP
  250. 19:2730 that was for those kind of things
  251. 19:30that needed to speed up. So we came with
  252. 19:33this
  253. 19:34uh this solution as it was called, an
  254. 19:37activation group
  255. 19:38related to
  256. 19:40promote this interoperability between
  257. 19:43compliance carbon markets in an open
  258. 19:45manner.
  259. 19:46And then we had already discussed about
  260. 19:50this with the European colleagues by the
  261. 19:53beginning of the year, actually in
  262. 19:55February 2025
  263. 19:57uh the European delegation came to the
  264. 20:00Ministry of Finance with
  265. 20:02a one idea related to carbon pricing
  266. 20:04mechanisms because also our Minister
  267. 20:07Fernando Haddad
  268. 20:09told publicly during the New York
  269. 20:11Climate Week in 2024 that he wanted to
  270. 20:14promote this
  271. 20:15uh this
  272. 20:17bridges between carbon market
  273. 20:19mechanisms. So then later we had the
  274. 20:22chance to to meet the the Chinese
  275. 20:25delegation in the pre-copy event in
  276. 20:28Brasília. We were already talking to
  277. 20:30many countries and we had events, we had
  278. 20:32the meetings of the activation group.
  279. 20:35But then when when the Chinese
  280. 20:38colleagues said, well,
  281. 20:40carbon markets are a priority for us.
  282. 20:44It's part of the ecological civilization
  283. 20:46transformation.
  284. 20:48It is a path to decarbonize the economy,
  285. 20:51but also to promote innovation in
  286. 20:54technology. I think that when the three
  287. 20:57of us decided to to lead the initiative,
  288. 21:01then we
  289. 21:03built so that's my second time point, a
  290. 21:06unique triangulation. I don't know if
  291. 21:08this word exists.
  292. 21:10Uh one union of
  293. 21:13countries that are very relevant in in
  294. 21:17its regions and with big economies and
  295. 21:21big populations.
  296. 21:23And in the case of Brazil, although we
  297. 21:25are smaller
  298. 21:26in terms of like
  299. 21:28the size of the economy and the
  300. 21:29population, we have this
  301. 21:33endowment related to natural resources
  302. 21:36and the big potential to be one of the
  303. 21:39major carbon credit supplier, if not the
  304. 21:42the major carbon credit supplier.
  305. 21:44So this union, I think this
  306. 21:48this decision to work together to invite
  307. 21:51more countries and also observers was
  308. 21:54very very nice. And then the third
  309. 21:57point, the third difficulty also to
  310. 22:00to establish the coalition was to find
  311. 22:02the right scope,
  312. 22:05which would be the scope of the
  313. 22:07coalition that could differentiate it
  314. 22:10related to the others. And then we said,
  315. 22:13okay, this is a political
  316. 22:16forum to take decisions, to set the
  317. 22:18priorities. But the priorities regarding
  318. 22:21technical issues. And the issues are
  319. 22:25related to methodologies in the end like
  320. 22:28to how to design ETS systems, how how to
  321. 22:32account carbon, carbon accounting, how
  322. 22:35to
  323. 22:36uh to to design MRV also criteria and
  324. 22:39offsets usage. So when we decide to talk
  325. 22:42about those uh those technical points, I
  326. 22:45think that we made a difference because
  327. 22:47it was really clear the aim of the open
  328. 22:50coalition. And then finally uh President
  329. 22:54Lula
  330. 22:55invited all countries to join the the
  331. 22:59declaration. At that point in COP Belém,
  332. 23:02we had more than 20 uh
  333. 23:05uh
  334. 23:06uh countries or jurisdictions endorsing
  335. 23:08the declaration which which was saying
  336. 23:11that we needed to work towards
  337. 23:13building the open coalition. So we had a
  338. 23:16very nice meeting. Many of you were
  339. 23:18there. It was a historical moment. And
  340. 23:22after that
  341. 23:23along the year we established the
  342. 23:25governance and the work plan and here we
  343. 23:27are. That's the that's our little story
  344. 23:31from my point of view.
  345. 23:33>> Thank you very much Cristina. Now fast
  346. 23:36forward from Belém to Antalya.
  347. 23:39According to your views, what are some
  348. 23:40of the main achievements of the
  349. 23:42coalition over this past year?
  350. 23:47>> Yes, and so
  351. 23:50the main achievement is also always the
  352. 23:52group, right? So now we have
  353. 23:5411 members, more members will join us.
  354. 23:58We have more than 20 observers and I
  355. 24:01believe that the power is cooperation.
  356. 24:04The coalition strengthens
  357. 24:07multilateralism
  358. 24:08and the climate world governance in the
  359. 24:12sense that
  360. 24:13it is aimed to for us to work together,
  361. 24:17to exchange experiences, to also build
  362. 24:20capabilities for those countries and
  363. 24:23regions that are
  364. 24:24developing their own domestic carbon
  365. 24:27markets. And so that the biggest
  366. 24:30achievement for me is always the
  367. 24:32cooperation and the group,
  368. 24:34but that has a very clear work plan.
  369. 24:39So the work plan that was approved in
  370. 24:42Wuhan in September in China is
  371. 24:46straightforward. We have work five work
  372. 24:49streams on the topics that I already
  373. 24:51said. So to to
  374. 24:56build compatibility between
  375. 24:59ETS design, on criteria,
  376. 25:02MRV criteria, offsets, carbon
  377. 25:05accounting, and also to build up the
  378. 25:07permanent secretariat, right? So these
  379. 25:10are the the four work streams. And now
  380. 25:14we we will be approving here in Antalya
  381. 25:18the day after tomorrow
  382. 25:20the the priorities. So the authorities
  383. 25:22will be
  384. 25:24will be saying, well, these and that are
  385. 25:25our priorities. And along the next year,
  386. 25:29we have a clear
  387. 25:31workflow
  388. 25:32to
  389. 25:33to make those priorities done. So I
  390. 25:37think that next year we'll be in COP
  391. 25:40announcing the achievements in terms of
  392. 25:45building documents and reflections and
  393. 25:49studies and research related to those
  394. 25:52priorities. So for me,
  395. 25:54the UN and the the possibility of mutual
  396. 25:58understanding is the biggest
  397. 26:00achievement.
  398. 26:02>> Thank you very much, Christina. So
  399. 26:05Christina has highlighted the importance
  400. 26:06of the coalition in bringing all of us
  401. 26:09together,
  402. 26:10but together for a purpose, right?
  403. 26:13Embracing the policy dialogue with a
  404. 26:15practical cooperation on carbon markets
  405. 26:17and building greater interoperability or
  406. 26:20convergence amongst our markets
  407. 26:22in the coming years.
  408. 26:24I invite DG
  409. 26:28Let me turn to you, DG,
  410. 26:31on to to to to give us
  411. 26:34some more thoughts on how countries can
  412. 26:37learn from each other and share
  413. 26:39experiences in a practical way while
  414. 26:42recognizing that many of our countries
  415. 26:44are coming from different backgrounds,
  416. 26:46they are coming from different levels of
  417. 26:48experience and stages in implementing
  418. 26:50our carbon markets. So could you please
  419. 26:53share your views on this and also if I
  420. 26:56may looking ahead,
  421. 26:58what are some of the concrete ways that
  422. 27:00we can work together and support each
  423. 27:02other?
  424. 27:04>> Thank Karina and
  425. 27:07thank you Vice Minister Christina and
  426. 27:10Diana for joining and also well thanks
  427. 27:13for the distinguished delegates present
  428. 27:15here
  429. 27:16and
  430. 27:18Vice Minister Christina has just gave us
  431. 27:20reflection where we came from and where
  432. 27:23we are now and for this coalition itself
  433. 27:27we can see the value and also I believe
  434. 27:31just not only for us as members
  435. 27:35we
  436. 27:36cherish and understand the value but
  437. 27:39also for so many observers and more is
  438. 27:42coming to join for this coalition. So
  439. 27:45this is self-evident that for the value
  440. 27:48of the coalition itself
  441. 27:50and I like to start from such kind of
  442. 27:54you see give me the question that is how
  443. 27:56could we learn from each other and
  444. 27:59especially you see for
  445. 28:01understanding each other and
  446. 28:03specifically understand outset Vice
  447. 28:06Minister has mentioned that is a value
  448. 28:09for this platform for this coalition is
  449. 28:11for trust.
  450. 28:13The trust for us we can have better
  451. 28:14understanding and also to specially from
  452. 28:17different perspective specifically you
  453. 28:20see for the coalition has been very
  454. 28:22clear that is we are not supposed to
  455. 28:24seek for one size for all. We are not
  456. 28:27supposed to say okay to impose whatever
  457. 28:30standards, methodologies. So that is
  458. 28:33from different circumstance from
  459. 28:35different national conditions.
  460. 28:38We are not supposed to I mean
  461. 28:41interoperability that's not mean that is
  462. 28:43we have to cut your size and fit this
  463. 28:47whatever specification. So
  464. 28:50we just have whatever our market our own
  465. 28:53market and our own operability. And I'd
  466. 28:57like to just to say for this kind of
  467. 29:00maybe a such kind of analogy that is
  468. 29:04all the members we just form such kind
  469. 29:08of music band.
  470. 29:10And you see we are supposed to have such
  471. 29:12kind of symphony or whatever such kind
  472. 29:16of performance. And for the observers we
  473. 29:19ask you
  474. 29:21to be tolerant and give us whatever
  475. 29:24whatever advice
  476. 29:26and to be to be kind because the market
  477. 29:28itself you see specifically for some
  478. 29:31countries especially even for China you
  479. 29:33see a compliance market up to now five
  480. 29:36years
  481. 29:37history or five years old but still it's
  482. 29:41just kind of
  483. 29:42like a baby still working and different
  484. 29:45from for example for European market you
  485. 29:48see you have more than 20 years. So
  486. 29:51that's what we have said that is
  487. 29:53we are very humble we have been learning
  488. 29:55from you from your market. So this is
  489. 29:58something that is learning
  490. 30:01by doing and also learning from each
  491. 30:04other. This is something very specific.
  492. 30:07And again you see
  493. 30:08for the market itself for China's market
  494. 30:12I could see I'm not trying to blow on
  495. 30:14trumpet just because our size so big.
  496. 30:17And yes indeed.
  497. 30:19You see
  498. 30:20we even for one sector again you see for
  499. 30:23power
  500. 30:25plants so that is
  501. 30:28five billion tons and also you see we
  502. 30:30are supposed right now we have expanded
  503. 30:33to cover additional another three
  504. 30:35sectors Aluminum aluminum and also for
  505. 30:40iron, steel, and also for
  506. 30:44cement.
  507. 30:45So
  508. 30:46it's almost much higher with almost
  509. 30:50eight million eight billion tons of
  510. 30:52carbon dioxide, a 65% of coverage.
  511. 30:57And by the end of next year, we're
  512. 30:59supposed to have more expansion so to
  513. 31:02include in chemical, petrochemical,
  514. 31:05and other heavy industry. So eventually
  515. 31:07for all these kind of major emitters
  516. 31:10will be incorporated in our market. So
  517. 31:13again, you see all market still such
  518. 31:16kind of burgeoning process and also
  519. 31:18we're still trying to learn from from
  520. 31:21your market with Tokyo has been such
  521. 31:24kind of mature market and also so many
  522. 31:26experience for us and also some other
  523. 31:28markets.
  524. 31:30And so that's that's the purpose I
  525. 31:33believe for us to sit together and to
  526. 31:35learn to each other.
  527. 31:37And again, you see
  528. 31:39you see for what the process have been I
  529. 31:42I
  530. 31:44I do believe that is for this coalition
  531. 31:47we are not supposed to be exclusive.
  532. 31:49To be exclusive not only from whatever
  533. 31:53observers, new members. So we are in the
  534. 31:55position to welcome to
  535. 31:58expand this coalition and also to
  536. 32:02strengthen the strengths for our
  537. 32:05understanding, appreciation. But also
  538. 32:08for other processes, you see we have the
  539. 32:13for in Venice in near in Italy, right?
  540. 32:17We have the
  541. 32:18we for each year we have the one week
  542. 32:21for the carbon market Florence, yeah,
  543. 32:24Florence process. And also for us we
  544. 32:27each year we have China Carbon Market
  545. 32:30Conference. So we have still some other
  546. 32:32processes, but that's not mean this is
  547. 32:35this is the only one for us to I mean to
  548. 32:38stop here and also a very close circle.
  549. 32:42So we open and also we are very
  550. 32:45interested and also very enthusiastic to
  551. 32:49learn from other processes and to enrich
  552. 32:53our discussion and to help us understand
  553. 32:56what's
  554. 32:58what's the shortcoming or what kind of
  555. 33:01inefficiency for the market and
  556. 33:03specifically you see for a market itself
  557. 33:06because for for me personally
  558. 33:09I can be very frank with you. I share
  559. 33:11the pressure. I feel the heavy heavy
  560. 33:14burden for developing such kind of
  561. 33:17market not only for you see for our
  562. 33:20experience not only for the expansion
  563. 33:23to cover more sectors but also you see
  564. 33:27we have to ensure the data
  565. 33:31accuracy and to prevent falsification
  566. 33:35you see how could we ensure everything
  567. 33:38on right track
  568. 33:39and we have to
  569. 33:41you see for
  570. 33:44the allowance distribution and what's
  571. 33:47eventually to ensure such kind of
  572. 33:49allowance to be cleared for you see the
  573. 33:53whole process every chain every steps is
  574. 33:56so demanding. So any any change any
  575. 34:00problem it means a disruption
  576. 34:03or even collapse of the market itself
  577. 34:05and also again you see
  578. 34:08at the very beginning we are supposed to
  579. 34:11say how could we have such kind of
  580. 34:12stability and also operability for the
  581. 34:15market itself but still you see how
  582. 34:18could we bring the market into operation
  583. 34:21into full operation it can help
  584. 34:24eventually
  585. 34:25for whatever standards that is what kind
  586. 34:28of control what kind of reduction
  587. 34:31for the
  588. 34:32for the carbon dioxide. So this is the
  589. 34:34major purpose. We have to we have to we
  590. 34:36have to check up that is what kind of
  591. 34:38progress what kind of achievement and in
  592. 34:41this regard, there is quite, quite huge,
  593. 34:44huge work, or huge responsibility for us
  594. 34:47to, for us to shoulder.
  595. 34:49And again, you see
  596. 34:52more, what's more you see we, we take
  597. 34:55ourselves as a little calmer.
  598. 34:58And also I cannot say it's more like a
  599. 35:01students. We are trying to learn, we are
  600. 35:03trying very keen to learn, and also we
  601. 35:06are also in the position to share
  602. 35:10our experience or lessons without any
  603. 35:13reservations. So we are very keen to
  604. 35:15share, to tell you that is what's our
  605. 35:17problem and what's what experience we
  606. 35:20have got.
  607. 35:21And in this regard, we are trying you
  608. 35:24see to have such condescension from
  609. 35:26whatever our practice. We are trying to
  610. 35:28see okay, we for annually we are trying
  611. 35:32to organize such kind south-south
  612. 35:34cooperation and by organizing such kind
  613. 35:37workshops for capacity building, we
  614. 35:40invite the
  615. 35:42some other countries from developing
  616. 35:45countries and to China we can have such
  617. 35:47kind of exchange. And also from whatever
  618. 35:51they are trying to to understand, to
  619. 35:53know so we share with us and also of
  620. 35:55course we also learning from them and to
  621. 35:58help us to
  622. 36:00either overhaul or improve our market.
  623. 36:03So this is very, very important. What
  624. 36:04I'm trying to say for whatever such kind
  625. 36:06experience is not once, is not one
  626. 36:09single way. It's kind of dual, dual
  627. 36:11paths.
  628. 36:12I will stop here.
  629. 36:14Thank you.
  630. 36:20>> Thank you very much
  631. 36:23GG brought the issue of learning
  632. 36:26together which was also emphasized by
  633. 36:28Christina about the importance of mutual
  634. 36:30understanding. I now turn to Diana
  635. 36:35to to tell us a little bit more of how
  636. 36:38we can make this happen in practice
  637. 36:40through knowledge exchange, through
  638. 36:42technical cooperation and other means.
  639. 36:45How can we make this happen? How can we
  640. 36:47bridge the policy dialogue with the
  641. 36:49practical cooperation in the realm of
  642. 36:51the coalition?
  643. 36:56>> Thank you.
  644. 36:57Thank you and good good morning
  645. 37:00everybody and
  646. 37:02it's a pleasure to be here with
  647. 37:06with DG Shia and and with Christina
  648. 37:11that have
  649. 37:12already gone this long stretch of the
  650. 37:14road together with us. So it's it's
  651. 37:16really a pleasure. Last year in Berlin
  652. 37:18we were launching and this year we are
  653. 37:21talking already about the achievement
  654. 37:23about the work that we are doing. So
  655. 37:25this in itself is a lot of progress.
  656. 37:27And I think I don't need to give a long
  657. 37:30answer to your question because actually
  658. 37:31what Christina said is already covering
  659. 37:33a lot of the ground. The coalition is a
  660. 37:36very powerful diplomatic instrument, a
  661. 37:39very powerful instrument to support the
  662. 37:44uptake of of compliance carbon market or
  663. 37:48carbon pricing by many countries and
  664. 37:51it's been acknowledged that this is an
  665. 37:53extremely powerful instrument to reduce
  666. 37:56greenhouse gases emissions. It has been
  667. 37:59certainly for the European Union where
  668. 38:01the sectors that are subject to the ETS
  669. 38:03are always those decarbonizing
  670. 38:06faster and and
  671. 38:08think it is I don't have to here expand
  672. 38:11about the proven effectiveness of the
  673. 38:15instrument and the coalition is going to
  674. 38:17be for all of us a prime instrument to
  675. 38:21do outreach to other countries and to
  676. 38:23show the advantages of the carbon prices
  677. 38:27but also of course to offer concrete
  678. 38:28cooperation to the countries that to
  679. 38:30want to adopt this means.
  680. 38:32In the European Union the coalition is
  681. 38:36complemented by the bilateral outreach
  682. 38:39that my actually part of the team in DG
  683. 38:41Clima
  684. 38:43that I represent is doing. We have a
  685. 38:46very motivated team that is also the
  686. 38:48team that
  687. 38:49built up this coalition together with
  688. 38:51the partners that is doing outreach to
  689. 38:53different countries and
  690. 38:56to explore the the kind of
  691. 39:00needs that they have and to see how the
  692. 39:02commission
  693. 39:04in conjunction with other the other
  694. 39:06partners including those that
  695. 39:08participate in the coalition can can
  696. 39:10support and can and can help them. And
  697. 39:14this is
  698. 39:16this is at the same time diplomatic
  699. 39:19because we are advancing climate action
  700. 39:21and extremely technical. So to answer
  701. 39:24your question what can the coalition do
  702. 39:26to join the diplomatic and the technical
  703. 39:28I think it's very simple the coalition
  704. 39:29needs to deliver to deliver results and
  705. 39:32to deliver these results it has
  706. 39:34developed
  707. 39:35a very
  708. 39:37big work program during this year that I
  709. 39:39won't repeat because because Christina
  710. 39:42described it
  711. 39:44just before. And the the implementation
  712. 39:48this work program will also be at the
  713. 39:50technical and the political level at the
  714. 39:52same time because there are the working
  715. 39:54groups that will provide the technical
  716. 39:56inputs but there will be the political
  717. 39:58discussions in the high-level meetings
  718. 40:01and the colleagues already have
  719. 40:03mentioned those that we had
  720. 40:05last year in this year in Florence and
  721. 40:08then and then in Wuhan and it's going to
  722. 40:11be another one
  723. 40:12here at COP 31 on on Monday.
  724. 40:16And let me say that the
  725. 40:19strength of this coalition is its
  726. 40:21experience and its diversity. DG Xia was
  727. 40:25talking about
  728. 40:27learning from the European Union because
  729. 40:30we have the longest experience and the
  730. 40:32oldest
  731. 40:33but you have the biggest
  732. 40:35and I think also you are in a very good
  733. 40:37position to advise countries in your
  734. 40:41region and countries with economic
  735. 40:42characteristics which are similar to to
  736. 40:45China's. So to have I think you are
  737. 40:47moving from the one learning to the one
  738. 40:50sharing the experience because your ETS
  739. 40:53is also starting to accumulate a lot of
  740. 40:55experience. And then we have countries
  741. 40:57with emerging ETS which is can be the
  742. 40:59case of of Brazil and as Cristina said,
  743. 41:02the fact that Brazil adopted an ETS was
  744. 41:04the trigger to to the whole discussion
  745. 41:07that that took us here. But we also have
  746. 41:09countries there that are setting up
  747. 41:11carbon taxes
  748. 41:13rather than than an ETS
  749. 41:17and again countries that are quite new
  750. 41:20and want to to learn with others. And we
  751. 41:22come from different continents and we
  752. 41:25have different circumstances. And I
  753. 41:27think that all of this is an incredible
  754. 41:30richness and makes this space really
  755. 41:33useful for the exchanging of best
  756. 41:35practices, for identifying barrier and
  757. 41:39all in all building capacity together.
  758. 41:42So
  759. 41:43at the end of the day what we do what we
  760. 41:46want to do with our domestic compliance
  761. 41:48markets is reduce emissions, is grow the
  762. 41:51economy and is to generate revenues to
  763. 41:54support the decarbonization and the just
  764. 41:56transition. We have different ways of
  765. 41:59organizing all all of this
  766. 42:02but this is why we are here to share our
  767. 42:05experiences and to get better all
  768. 42:07together and also to agree on some
  769. 42:10milestones that all of us I think we'll
  770. 42:11have to put up in place for these
  771. 42:13systems to to function and to make them
  772. 42:16stronger and more effective in
  773. 42:20in addressing in addressing climate
  774. 42:22change. So we want
  775. 42:25we have the aspiration for this
  776. 42:26coalition to be the central point of
  777. 42:29reference on compliance markets and I
  778. 42:30think that we have all the good
  779. 42:34things in place
  780. 42:36to to make this really happen. Thanks.
  781. 42:44>> Thank you very much, Diana.
  782. 42:46In the audience we have many countries
  783. 42:48and organizations who might be willing
  784. 42:50to join the coalition and several others
  785. 42:53were writing members and observers of
  786. 42:55the coalition and doing a lot of work on
  787. 42:58carbon markets.
  788. 42:59Can I Can I
  789. 43:01build on your
  790. 43:03presentation before and ask how these
  791. 43:07countries and organizations can engage
  792. 43:10and and perhaps how the coalition can
  793. 43:11also leverage on much of the work that
  794. 43:14has already been done and take forward
  795. 43:16the discussions and the cooperation in
  796. 43:18carbon markets?
  797. 43:21>> Thanks
  798. 43:22and I will also try to be brief because
  799. 43:23I see that we're running out of time and
  800. 43:25we want to leave some
  801. 43:28some some space for questions. So today
  802. 43:30the coalition has 11 members and twice
  803. 43:34as many observers. It is growing. I
  804. 43:38trust that new members will be announced
  805. 43:40in the in the coming days
  806. 43:42but also we have to
  807. 43:45acknowledge that the space of
  808. 43:48and the entities
  809. 43:50working the space with working on carbon
  810. 43:53markets is already quite quite crowded.
  811. 43:56So we have to work in synergy with
  812. 43:58others that are already there.
  813. 44:00And the good thing is that many of the
  814. 44:02leading players are already
  815. 44:04participating in the coalition. I don't
  816. 44:06want to make all the names because it's
  817. 44:09many and also because Christina already
  818. 44:13already mentioned some of them. So
  819. 44:17I will I will skip that part
  820. 44:20but I think that it's important that we
  821. 44:22have a
  822. 44:24synergy and a complementarity with all
  823. 44:27the organization that are members and
  824. 44:30and observers and that all together the
  825. 44:33members and the observers engage in
  826. 44:35substantial exchanges to
  827. 44:39identify forward-looking solutions that
  828. 44:41then the working groups can propose to
  829. 44:44the the high-level dialogues and at the
  830. 44:47high-level meetings. And regarding the
  831. 44:51possibility to to join as I said before,
  832. 44:54we want this coalition to become a
  833. 44:56central point of of reference. So, we
  834. 44:58want to work with everyone that shares
  835. 45:00the same objective
  836. 45:02of
  837. 45:04establishing effective carbon pricing
  838. 45:06systems. So, the coalition is indeed
  839. 45:09fully open to those countries and
  840. 45:11jurisdictions which have a legal
  841. 45:13framework for domestic carbon pricing in
  842. 45:15place, and we will also consider more
  843. 45:18applications for organization that can
  844. 45:20substantially contribute to delivery
  845. 45:23this this work program.
  846. 45:26But this is of course a two-way street,
  847. 45:28so the countries come to the coalition,
  848. 45:31but also the coalition comes to the
  849. 45:34to interested to interested countries.
  850. 45:37So, we the members of the coalition will
  851. 45:40also help non-members to develop
  852. 45:42approaches to domestic compliance
  853. 45:45markets so that can be suitable for
  854. 45:47them. This is also part of of our work
  855. 45:51program. So,
  856. 45:53we we welcome new members, but we also
  857. 45:56prepare countries that want to become
  858. 45:57members. In my previous intervention, I
  859. 46:00mentioned the the task force that we
  860. 46:02have in the European Commission to
  861. 46:04cooperate with countries.
  862. 46:06The cooperation is not necessarily
  863. 46:08leading to become members of the
  864. 46:10coalition. We could support a country
  865. 46:12that then finally does not want to
  866. 46:14become a member of the coalition. We
  867. 46:16also support some countries that want to
  868. 46:19rather than to put in place domestic
  869. 46:22compliance systems, they want to engage
  870. 46:24in international carbon markets that
  871. 46:26would not make them eligible for the
  872. 46:28coalition, but we do also help these
  873. 46:31countries and we are very interested in
  874. 46:34also strengthening international carbon
  875. 46:36markets, but that's that's another
  876. 46:37chapter. So, yes, the coalition is open
  877. 46:42and and we will support all those that
  878. 46:45are interested in joining us.
  879. 46:48>> Thank you very much. The coalition is
  880. 46:50open and so is the floor is open also
  881. 46:52for interventions from the audience.
  882. 46:55When I was asking the previous
  883. 46:56questions, I already saw many hands up.
  884. 46:59So I'm very happy to see uh interest in
  885. 47:02the work that is being done.
  886. 47:04Uh we still have a few minutes. I would
  887. 47:06invite you uh to
  888. 47:09share
  889. 47:11your experience Yeah, perhaps three to
  890. 47:13four questions. We still have
  891. 47:1510 minutes.
  892. 47:16Uh
  893. 47:17we would like to hear how the coalition
  894. 47:20might make a practical difference for
  895. 47:23your country and organization.
  896. 47:27Please introduce yourself.
  897. 47:29>> My name is Uzamaka. I support public
  898. 47:32sector engagement at the United States
  899. 47:34Department of Agriculture. So there's a
  900. 47:36project for cocoa right now in Nigeria,
  901. 47:39one of the biggest we've had and it
  902. 47:41borders around deforestation free cocoa
  903. 47:44initiative, climate change, and what
  904. 47:46that means around sustainability for
  905. 47:48compliance with EUDR. My question, how
  906. 47:51do you get more people like us in the
  907. 47:52room? Because if you look around,
  908. 47:55it tells a bigger story. So just really
  909. 47:57curious around the efforts being done on
  910. 48:00the on the side. Thank you.
  911. 48:05>> Thank you. My name is Serge. I I would
  912. 48:08like to speak from Cape Verde in Africa
  913. 48:12prospective. So first of all, I would
  914. 48:15like to thank Brazil, the European
  915. 48:17Union, and China for this coalition.
  916. 48:21And I would like to put for priority
  917. 48:25that I wish that the coalition can work
  918. 48:28with looking forward. So first, I think
  919. 48:32some of the panel members have speak
  920. 48:34already about it. The coalition is meant
  921. 48:37to be inclusive. So I want us to think
  922. 48:40about participation. And as African
  923. 48:44country in small island states, I think
  924. 48:47that we want to contribute to shaping
  925. 48:51the market's rules and the methodology.
  926. 48:54So as the markets become
  927. 48:57more connected, I think it's important
  928. 49:00that ours views and the particular
  929. 49:03circumstances also count on those
  930. 49:06approaches. Second, I would like to
  931. 49:08speak about capacity building and
  932. 49:10technology transfer.
  933. 49:12You know, the coalition can definitely
  934. 49:15help the country assess this market
  935. 49:18three training capacity on market
  936. 49:21monitoring accounting system.
  937. 49:24And the third, I would like to speak
  938. 49:26about investment for development. So the
  939. 49:29coalition can connect projects with
  940. 49:32international investors and compliance
  941. 49:34markets. And finally, equity and benefit
  942. 49:39sharing. You know, developing country
  943. 49:41should be partner in creating value.
  944. 49:44That mean protecting environmental
  945. 49:47integrity, respecting natural
  946. 49:49sovereignty, ensuring transparency
  947. 49:53and delivering tangible benefit for host
  948. 49:56economy and community. So these are my
  949. 49:59recommendation for the coalition looking
  950. 50:01for Thank you for your attention.
  951. 50:13>> Davi Bomtempo. I'm the CEO of SBCoP and
  952. 50:18right now
  953. 50:20congratulation for the first year of
  954. 50:24working in progress in the the OP
  955. 50:26coalition.
  956. 50:28So we represents
  957. 50:31123
  958. 50:32chambers of commerce and industry
  959. 50:36and represents around more than 50
  960. 50:40million companies inside the the
  961. 50:42initiative.
  962. 50:43So we are receiving more than 1,400
  963. 50:49projects and many about carbon markets
  964. 50:53and we are working inside the initiative
  965. 50:56in a coalition and some topics like
  966. 51:00offsets and carbon accounting. So I'm
  967. 51:03here just to inform you yeah you can
  968. 51:07count with us in this journey
  969. 51:10and probably I can share with you the
  970. 51:14the achievements, the outcomes and the
  971. 51:16results inside our coalition about
  972. 51:19carbon market. Thank you.
  973. 51:22>> We have one more question and then we
  974. 51:24can come back to the panel.
  975. 51:33Yes and we have
  976. 51:35him and one more question here.
  977. 51:37>> Hi hi there.
  978. 51:38Good morning. Thank you so much. I have
  979. 51:40one question for China.
  980. 51:43You announced during this COP another
  981. 51:45coalition for carbon markets.
  982. 51:47Could you clarify to us the difference
  983. 51:50between them and what do you want to
  984. 51:52achieve with both of them and maybe for
  985. 51:54the panel itself
  986. 51:56for next COP when we gather in Ethiopia
  987. 51:58what should we expect for this coalition
  988. 52:01to have achieved? Thank you very much.
  989. 52:05>> And here last last comment.
  990. 52:16>> Hi. Thank you very much. My name is
  991. 52:18Hasna Modud. I am from Bangladesh.
  992. 52:21I am so thrilled to be in this COP. I
  993. 52:24have attended at least four five COPs in
  994. 52:26the past and this is beyond my
  995. 52:29expectation. Thank you Turkey and I
  996. 52:32think it is very overwhelming for all of
  997. 52:34us who have been here. It just I had to
  998. 52:37put this word in. Particularly China's
  999. 52:40very proactive role in this COP is
  1000. 52:43amazing because China has always been a
  1001. 52:46closed country for us and has always had
  1002. 52:50been a part of groups. But here in this
  1003. 52:53particular climate change conference I
  1004. 52:55see no grouping excepting
  1005. 52:58excepting that you know countries like
  1006. 53:01us like in Bangladesh and elsewhere in
  1007. 53:04small countries They are suffering
  1008. 53:06mostly due to climate change, but
  1009. 53:09they are yet to
  1010. 53:12get any not money or
  1011. 53:15recognition. They are yet to get
  1012. 53:17recognition
  1013. 53:18that we are not contributing to climate
  1014. 53:21change, but we are asking for damage
  1015. 53:25as well as for the service we are paying
  1016. 53:28free. The for example, the Sundarban
  1017. 53:31forest in Bangladesh and oceans without
  1018. 53:35any frontier. You know, these quiet
  1019. 53:37areas are contributing so much to
  1020. 53:41climate change and I wish United Nations
  1021. 53:44will recognize recognize them and stop
  1022. 53:47the piracy on high seas. Thank you very
  1023. 53:50much again.
  1024. 53:52>> Thank you very much for all the the the
  1025. 53:54comments and the questions. I'll turn
  1026. 53:56back to the panel
  1027. 53:58to react or make your closing remarks
  1028. 54:01and what are the main takeaways from our
  1029. 54:03conversation today and also what we
  1030. 54:06heard from the audience.
  1031. 54:09>> Thank you very much the audience, all
  1032. 54:11the interventions and questions. I think
  1033. 54:14the idea is not really to answer
  1034. 54:16question but make a general statement. I
  1035. 54:18agree with you, madam.
  1036. 54:21It's a great COP. It's so beautiful to
  1037. 54:23see the advancement and the progress and
  1038. 54:27yes, all countries like here to engage
  1039. 54:30in the against climate change and try to
  1040. 54:34avoid fragmentation and build up
  1041. 54:38multilateralism,
  1042. 54:39knowing that we have common but
  1043. 54:41differentiated responsibilities, right?
  1044. 54:44And so this open coalition aims to
  1045. 54:49contribute to
  1046. 54:51set the carbon pricing in every
  1047. 54:55jurisdiction that wants to do so
  1048. 54:58because this is one of the main
  1049. 55:00instruments to mitigate.
  1050. 55:03And as the road map
  1051. 55:07for transitioning away from fossil fuels
  1052. 55:09show with carbon pricing and with
  1053. 55:12investments in R&D related to clean
  1054. 55:16technologies we can avoid the increase
  1055. 55:20of the temperature according to the
  1056. 55:22estimation in 0.6 degrees so until 2100
  1057. 55:27instead of the
  1058. 55:29increasing the temperature of 2.5
  1059. 55:32degrees the estimations of the the
  1060. 55:35researchers of LSE says that with clean
  1061. 55:38investments
  1062. 55:39investments in clean technologies and
  1063. 55:41carbon pricing the temperature would
  1064. 55:44increase 1.9 and this means a huge
  1065. 55:49avoidance of catastrophes that really
  1066. 55:53is achieving the poor
  1067. 55:56and the more vulnerable communities and
  1068. 55:59we all want to avoid this and we really
  1069. 56:02need to work together against this so
  1070. 56:06answering the question on what we want
  1071. 56:08to to have achieved until until Ethiopia
  1072. 56:11next year
  1073. 56:13the idea is yes we gonna start
  1074. 56:17tackling the methodological issues
  1075. 56:19related to MRV systems to carbon
  1076. 56:21accounting and to offsets because they
  1077. 56:25will improve and enlarge the investment
  1078. 56:30and trade flows and we know that in the
  1079. 56:33end carbon pricing is not only about
  1080. 56:37environmental and climate dimensions but
  1081. 56:39especially about financial economic and
  1082. 56:43social dimensions so we want that this
  1083. 56:45initiative help countries and the world
  1084. 56:49to invest more to trade more to develop
  1085. 56:53and to have actually a sustainable
  1086. 56:56development and reach the sustainable
  1087. 56:59development goals because we are always
  1088. 57:02fighting to to achieve the sustainable
  1089. 57:04development goals.
  1090. 57:10>> Well if I may actually
  1091. 57:12it seems specifically some questions
  1092. 57:15posing to China. I'd like to
  1093. 57:17first maybe to the lady over there. You
  1094. 57:20see
  1095. 57:22I share your concern of of course for
  1096. 57:24such kind of anxiety or such kind of
  1097. 57:26urgency of climate change. I believe
  1098. 57:28that's the purpose or that's why we are
  1099. 57:30here.
  1100. 57:31And specifically you see there's no one
  1101. 57:33delegation is quiet and because I'm I'm
  1102. 57:36also a negotiator so I can stand what's
  1103. 57:39what's going on. And everyone's speaking
  1104. 57:42up. Everyone has been talking to each
  1105. 57:44other so
  1106. 57:45closely and so I cannot say fiercely but
  1107. 57:48very hitting it of course. So we have
  1108. 57:50very very close such kind of
  1109. 57:51coordination, discussion, negotiation
  1110. 57:55and I believe all of us are right here
  1111. 57:57trying to contribute to the purpose of
  1112. 57:59Paris agreement, to the purpose of the
  1113. 58:02convention itself. And still again you
  1114. 58:04see for whatever we are talking for
  1115. 58:06whatever such kind of obligation, for
  1116. 58:08whatever such kind of mitigation,
  1117. 58:10adaptation, funding whatever. So we're
  1118. 58:13not starting
  1119. 58:14from scratch or from vacuum.
  1120. 58:17Christina, you have mentioned very
  1121. 58:19clearly that is we have the CBDR, we
  1122. 58:21have the RC, we have we have the
  1123. 58:23convention, we have the Paris agreement.
  1124. 58:24So let's implement, let's follow the
  1125. 58:27whatever has set out in the I mean for
  1126. 58:31the convention for the Paris agreement.
  1127. 58:34And specifically if I can go further for
  1128. 58:36China's contribution
  1129. 58:38there's a long list. Specifically I like
  1130. 58:40to say that is for the provision of
  1131. 58:42China's green products for the solar for
  1132. 58:46the
  1133. 58:47panel whatever. So there is a research
  1134. 58:50by seeing our product our export has
  1135. 58:53helped the world to reduce emission more
  1136. 58:56than four billion carbon dioxide. So
  1137. 58:59it's a very huge number. I mean of
  1138. 59:02course it's not only for China making
  1139. 59:03contribution I have to see why I have to
  1140. 59:05recognize other contributions.
  1141. 59:08Specifically you see
  1142. 59:09all of us as
  1143. 59:11have to see. So we're not supposed to
  1144. 59:13see whatever one is quiet and another is
  1145. 59:15not.
  1146. 59:17Specifically you see right here, we come
  1147. 59:19here, we're trying to contribute all of
  1148. 59:21us.
  1149. 59:22And come to the question that is for the
  1150. 59:25Chinese initiative
  1151. 59:27uh we have launched or announced uh
  1152. 59:29this week.
  1153. 59:31For this one you see for China we have
  1154. 59:33two carbon markets. One is compliance
  1155. 59:35market, another one is voluntary carbon
  1156. 59:37market, that is CCER. And for this
  1157. 59:40coalition is a compliance market. So
  1158. 59:43it's very supplementary. And for that
  1159. 59:46one specifically voluntary carbon
  1160. 59:48market, if I may say in one in one
  1161. 59:52one word several words by saying
  1162. 59:54specifically that is for the
  1163. 59:57not carbon market for our initiative
  1164. 1:00:00that's trying to say
  1165. 1:00:02what is from from the field to your
  1166. 1:00:05table
  1167. 1:00:07or from farm to your table. Specifically
  1168. 1:00:09what kind of provision of our credits.
  1169. 1:00:12So you can understand all the way
  1170. 1:00:15transparent.
  1171. 1:00:16That is for all methodologies and
  1172. 1:00:19boundaries, how could we counting. So
  1173. 1:00:22this all open transparent. So this is
  1174. 1:00:25the way for us to enhance the credit, to
  1175. 1:00:28increase the credibility for this kind
  1176. 1:00:31of credit. So this is some it's not we
  1177. 1:00:34are supposed to set another platform
  1178. 1:00:37just to make a division whatever
  1179. 1:00:39coalition. It's not the case, it's
  1180. 1:00:41supplementary. This is compliance,
  1181. 1:00:43another one is voluntary.
  1182. 1:00:45Thank you.
  1183. 1:00:52>> Thank you very much and
  1184. 1:00:54not not much to say after what the
  1185. 1:00:57colleagues have said. I wanted to answer
  1186. 1:01:00the the points on how to use this
  1187. 1:01:02coalition to support developing
  1188. 1:01:04countries particularly in Africa and
  1189. 1:01:07small islands and and country like
  1190. 1:01:09Bangladesh to achieve the our common
  1191. 1:01:13objectives
  1192. 1:01:14under the Paris agreement and and the
  1193. 1:01:18and grow their economies. The coalition
  1194. 1:01:21is indeed supporting the countries that
  1195. 1:01:24want to set up compliance, domestic
  1196. 1:01:28compliance markets. So it's very
  1197. 1:01:29specific. But as I said at the
  1198. 1:01:31beginning, there are other
  1199. 1:01:35some of the observing members as well as
  1200. 1:01:37the European Commission are offering a
  1201. 1:01:39wider type of cooperation that can
  1202. 1:01:41indeed help the countries that have the
  1203. 1:01:43possibility and the will to enter the
  1204. 1:01:46high carbon markets with high integrity
  1205. 1:01:49to also benefit post from the possible
  1206. 1:01:51financial flows that that come from
  1207. 1:01:53that. So that is
  1208. 1:01:56an offer that is open on on open on our
  1209. 1:01:58side. My colleagues are also in the room
  1210. 1:02:01and then can explain a bit more what
  1211. 1:02:04what it means, but certainly we are open
  1212. 1:02:06to cooperation with Africa and with
  1213. 1:02:08other parts of the world. And I wanted
  1214. 1:02:10to close by
  1215. 1:02:12make picking up one of the points made
  1216. 1:02:14by the colleagues, also by Christina. We
  1217. 1:02:16she reminded us of the CBDR principle of
  1218. 1:02:19of the Paris Agreement. And in fact,
  1219. 1:02:23domestic compliance carbon markets are
  1220. 1:02:26not a one size fits all. This is a very
  1221. 1:02:29important discussion that we had at the
  1222. 1:02:31beginning when we set up the coalition.
  1223. 1:02:34We are not doing this coalition to all
  1224. 1:02:35become the same and to all get to the
  1225. 1:02:38same price per ton of carbon as the
  1226. 1:02:41European Union because if the European
  1227. 1:02:43Union the market sets the price at 80
  1228. 1:02:47Euros or 85 Dollars per ton because
  1229. 1:02:49that's the price for us that is
  1230. 1:02:52necessary to create the incentive to
  1231. 1:02:53decarbonize. This is not the same for
  1232. 1:02:55Brazil, it's not the same for China and
  1233. 1:02:57it can be a different price for, I don't
  1234. 1:02:59know, South Africa or or I'm inventing
  1235. 1:03:03or I'm thinking of other countries that
  1236. 1:03:04have carbon carbon prices or carbon
  1237. 1:03:07taxes.
  1238. 1:03:08For the European Union, this have been
  1239. 1:03:10extremely effective because in the 20
  1240. 1:03:12years of its establishment, it has
  1241. 1:03:14reduced the emissions of 50% and last
  1242. 1:03:19year we managed to the revenues were 43
  1243. 1:03:22billion euros. So it's an very important
  1244. 1:03:25amount that has been reinvested in the
  1245. 1:03:27economy, but others will go at their own
  1246. 1:03:30pace. And what we are discussing in the
  1247. 1:03:32coalition is how our ETS in the same
  1248. 1:03:36diversity, our systems in their
  1249. 1:03:38diversity, they can be all effective and
  1250. 1:03:41they can be all somehow talk to each
  1251. 1:03:44other. So I think this is a very good
  1252. 1:03:47example of how
  1253. 1:03:48the CBDR can work in practice, but we
  1254. 1:03:51are all doing what we can do in our
  1255. 1:03:53systems to get to the same goal, which
  1256. 1:03:55is to decarbonize our economies in
  1257. 1:03:58efficient, effective way and and
  1258. 1:04:01allowing to grow and redistribute
  1259. 1:04:03resources. So
  1260. 1:04:05I just want to thank everybody for this
  1261. 1:04:07the event and the interaction and the
  1262. 1:04:09interest. I see the the room is still
  1263. 1:04:11full at the end of the event. It's a
  1264. 1:04:12very good sign. So thanks a lot and pass
  1265. 1:04:15back the floor to the moderator.
  1266. 1:04:17>> Thank you very much.
  1267. 1:04:19Thank you very much, Diana. And
  1268. 1:04:22we are coming to an end of this panel. I
  1269. 1:04:24would like to thank again for
  1270. 1:04:26and Turkey for hosting this beautiful
  1271. 1:04:29COP and giving us the opportunity to
  1272. 1:04:30share
  1273. 1:04:32the the the work of the Open Coalition
  1274. 1:04:34and Compliance Carbon Markets. Thank you
  1275. 1:04:36very much,
  1276. 1:04:38Also thanks to my wonderful panelists
  1277. 1:04:40and co-chairs for sharing your thoughts
  1278. 1:04:44and especially to all of you for
  1279. 1:04:45celebrating with us this first
  1280. 1:04:47anniversary and looking forward to the
  1281. 1:04:50fourth coming years and the work
  1282. 1:04:52together that we have to do. For those
  1283. 1:04:54interested to learn more about the Open
  1284. 1:04:57Coalition, I invite you to visit our
  1285. 1:04:59website at
  1286. 1:05:02or o
  1287. 1:05:05dot org.
  1288. 1:05:06And looking forward to collaborating
  1289. 1:05:08with all of you. So thank you very much.
  1290. 1:05:29>> Okay, very good.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of The Open Coalition on Compliance Carbon Markets: One Year of Cooperation by UNFCCC Global Climate Action, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,640 words across 1,290 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.