The Odyssey Is a Map. Here's Where It Leads. — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Homer's Odyssey is one of the greatest
- 0:02stories ever told. But what if I told
- 0:04you the locations in it are real? I'm
- 0:07Curtis Holland, and I'm an independent
- 0:09historian who studies ancient history,
- 0:11ancient texts, and ancient symbolism
- 0:13through a scientific and first
- 0:14principles lens. And today, we're going
- 0:17to continue our conversation on the
- 0:19Odyssey, specifically the locations of
- 0:21Odysius travel and how they fit into our
- 0:23historical timeline.
- 0:30So, what did Homer actually know? I
- 0:32promised you in our last video that I
- 0:34would discuss the specific locations
- 0:36that he has Odysius travel on his way
- 0:38back from Anatolia to Greece. Now, if
- 0:41you were to take a look at a map,
- 0:43Anatolia, which is modern-day Turkey, is
- 0:46not a 10-year sail from Greece. Yet,
- 0:48Homer has Odysius traveling all across
- 0:50the Mediterranean, facing many trials
- 0:53and tribulations.
- 0:55Some of those are brought about by the
- 0:56gods. Some of those are brought about by
- 0:58Odysius and his men's own hubris. But
- 1:01that begs the question, what's the point
- 1:03of a long drawn out journey for a sale
- 1:06that you could functionally accomplish
- 1:07in days in antiquity? This brings us
- 1:10back to Strao, the author we spoke about
- 1:12in our last video, specifically his
- 1:15first book on geography. In it, he makes
- 1:18the claim that Homer is the first
- 1:19geographer and that each location on
- 1:21this journey encodes to a real place and
- 1:24he goes through them line by line,
- 1:26discussing exactly how he was able to
- 1:29determine where each location was in the
- 1:32real world. And this process becomes his
- 1:34default in assessing ancient myths and
- 1:36texts in order to find the locations as
- 1:38he builds his own geography. And as I
- 1:41mentioned before, Strao became one of,
- 1:43if not the most cited ancient
- 1:44geographers when it comes to modern
- 1:46archaeologists and historians. This
- 1:49means that implicitly the foundational
- 1:51geography of the ancient world, the
- 1:52world we claim to understand now, was
- 1:55built on top of a method employed by the
- 1:57ancient poet Homer. So what is the
- 1:59method? Well, let's do what Strao did.
- 2:02Let's take a look at the book and
- 2:04examine some of the locations of
- 2:06Odysius's journey. Now, I'm not going to
- 2:08include every location in the Odyssey,
- 2:09as that would make this a 1-hour video,
- 2:11but I am going to try to follow the
- 2:13basic order of events and spoilers for a
- 2:163,000-year-old text. If you haven't read
- 2:18it by now, I don't know what to tell
- 2:20you. Let's start with Troy. We've
- 2:22already touched on this. Troy, the city
- 2:24that everyone said was invented right
- 2:26until someone took it seriously and put
- 2:28a shovel in the ground. Real place, real
- 2:30war. The text was right. And that's the
- 2:33starting line. Now, let's see where the
- 2:35voyage goes. One of the first stops in
- 2:37the journey is the lotus eaters. In the
- 2:39poem, Odysius's men eat the lotus fruit
- 2:42and forget everything. They forget home,
- 2:44forget the mission. They just want to
- 2:46stay and eat. That sounds like pure
- 2:48fantasy. Except the lotus eaters weren't
- 2:50invented by Homer. The Greeks called
- 2:52them the Latphagai. They were a real
- 2:54people in a real place. Heroditus,
- 2:57another ancient Greek historian,
- 2:59describes them in his histories. They
- 3:00were living on the Libyan coast, eating
- 3:03a real fruit for which they got their
- 3:05name. The fruit itself has been
- 3:07identified as the wild juju bee, a
- 3:09thorny shrub with a berry sweet like a
- 3:12date that they ate year round and even
- 3:14made wine from. It was a real staple
- 3:16crop for the people living there. But
- 3:18here's the thing, nobody forgets home
- 3:21eating juju bees. However, the Egyptian
- 3:24blue lotus growing in the same corner of
- 3:26the world was known to cause minor
- 3:28psychedelic effects and was widely
- 3:30consumed in antiquity before itself
- 3:32vanishing from the Nile. And Herodotus
- 3:34isn't just passing along legend here.
- 3:36He's talking about a real people group,
- 3:38one the Greeks actually knew and met and
- 3:40had established trade relationships
- 3:41with. Fly the Elder, another ancient
- 3:44historian, puts them in the exact same
- 3:45region centuries later. And Strao gives
- 3:48you that location exactly, an island
- 3:51called Menanix, which is now called
- 3:53Derba off the coast of North Africa in
- 3:55the Gulf of Gabes. And so notice what we
- 3:58have. You have a real people in a real
- 4:01place eating a real fruit on a real
- 4:04coastline that you can go to today. And
- 4:07that's how mythology works. Tell a real
- 4:10story and embellish it a little bit to
- 4:12make it interesting. Now, hold on to the
- 4:14Gulf of Gabes. We're going to be coming
- 4:16back to it next. The island home of the
- 4:19Cyclops, the oneeyed maneating giant
- 4:22Polyphimis, who traps Odysius in his
- 4:25cave. And of course, this is the story
- 4:27everyone remembers. And it's also the
- 4:29part that sounds the most made up. So,
- 4:31what do we do with this? Well, let's
- 4:33start with the text. Because Homer
- 4:35doesn't hand you a fairy tale island. He
- 4:37hands you sailing directions. A harbor
- 4:40that you can run a ship straight into
- 4:42without tying it off. A freshwater
- 4:44spring at the head of it. A soft,
- 4:47well-watered meadow, a wooded island
- 4:50full of wild goats lying just offshore.
- 4:53And that doesn't read like literary
- 4:55invention. It reads like a real
- 4:57coastline that someone actually saw. So
- 5:00where is it?
- 5:01>> Well, Strao puts it in southeast Sicily,
- 5:04the country around Mount Etna and
- 5:06Leantini. Real geography. And in the
- 5:09same breath, he locates another people
- 5:10group right next door, the Lreonians.
- 5:14The cannibals who smashed Odysius's
- 5:16fleet with boulders. And Strao isn't
- 5:19reaching here. He's drawing on real
- 5:21ancient scholarship from the time.
- 5:23Thusidities, a hard-nured Greek
- 5:25historian known for intentionally
- 5:27stripping myth out of his own history,
- 5:29was writing 400 years before Strao even
- 5:31got a hold of this story. In it, he
- 5:33makes the claim that the Cyclops and the
- 5:35Legonians are real people groups, not
- 5:37monsters, and they're the oldest
- 5:39occupying the island. Now, he does say
- 5:42that he cannot vouch for who they were
- 5:44culturally or specifically, but the
- 5:47placement's already ancient even in his
- 5:49time. So, here's Strao's claims. two
- 5:52hostile populations in a real Sicilian
- 5:55territory. The kind of coast a Greek
- 5:57sailor had every reason to avoid. A sort
- 6:00of Bronze Age North Sentinel island. And
- 6:03that tracks as the late Bronze Age was
- 6:05known to have many people groups
- 6:07actively hostile to foreigners. Homer
- 6:10just takes the extra step and turns them
- 6:11into giants, embellishes the encounter,
- 6:13and keeps the real history underneath.
- 6:16Now, that's all fine and dandy, I hear
- 6:18you say, but here's the question. What
- 6:20about the one eye? Well, here we find
- 6:23Homer's not immune to literary
- 6:24borrowing. He turns to the north to a
- 6:27people group called the Aramispians.
- 6:30This was a Cythian legend of a people
- 6:32group known to have one eye recorded in
- 6:34a poem by Aristius called the Aramaspia.
- 6:37The Greeks had really creative names for
- 6:39their poetry. And Strao's read is that
- 6:42Homer borrowed the oneeyed motif, a
- 6:46oneeyed people that the Greeks already
- 6:47knew and mapped it into a real hostile
- 6:50people in Sicily. And it works because
- 6:52that legend is already wellnown. The
- 6:55audience hears one eye and immediately
- 6:57understands the type of people they're
- 6:59dealing with. Homer isn't building a
- 7:01monster from scratch. He's using
- 7:03shortorthhand his listeners already had.
- 7:06Odysius and his crew then go on to meet
- 7:08the king Aololis, the wind god, who
- 7:10governs the Aolon Islands. In the poem,
- 7:13he hands Odysius a leather bag with a
- 7:15silver drawstring that contains all of
- 7:17the winds that he would need to find his
- 7:19way back home, which obviously sounds
- 7:22like pure myth, a man who controls the
- 7:24weather. But again, here we see a real
- 7:26place beneath the myth. Aololis governed
- 7:28the Leari Islands, the Aolon archipelago
- 7:32just north of Sicily. The islands still
- 7:34carry that name today, but it's the next
- 7:37part that matters. And Shrao tells you
- 7:39exactly how a man can become a wind god.
- 7:41Aololis taught men how to navigate those
- 7:45waters. The currents there are brutal,
- 7:47and they run with the tides. Getting
- 7:49through alive depends on timing them
- 7:51right, and Aololis knew how to read
- 7:54them. And for that, the locals dubbed
- 7:56him the keeper of the winds. Now, if
- 7:58you're an ancient traveler on the deck
- 8:00of a ship and didn't know any better, a
- 8:02man who can reliably predict the
- 8:04currents in the winds looks like a man
- 8:06who can control them. You see, the bag
- 8:09of winds isn't magic. It's simply the
- 8:11knowledge of how to navigate difficult
- 8:13waters in a boat. And this is exactly
- 8:16the type of information that Strao
- 8:17proposes gets compressed into looking
- 8:19like the knowledge of a god. And that's
- 8:22not a one-off. That's the entire idea of
- 8:25mythic compression. And then here, Strao
- 8:27quotes Paleibius, another ancient Greek
- 8:30historian. He explains that Danish,
- 8:33foundational as one of the first Greek
- 8:34kings, was deified for being the one to
- 8:36find reservoirs of water underneath the
- 8:38city of Argos. And then another king,
- 8:40Atreaus, became deified because he was
- 8:42the one who taught the Greeks that the
- 8:44sun moved in an opposite direction to
- 8:46the stars around the heavens. Both of
- 8:48these two were appointed kings in
- 8:50antiquity per the legend. And both of
- 8:52them were remembered as deified figures
- 8:54in Greek mythology. And here Shabbo
- 8:56makes an even more powerful claim. In
- 8:58every god we worship, we're really
- 9:00honoring the person who discovered
- 9:02something useful. Somebody knows
- 9:04something real. How to read the sea,
- 9:06where the water is, how the sky moves.
- 9:08And across enough generations, the
- 9:10knowledge gets remembered as a person.
- 9:12And that person gets remembered as a
- 9:14god. The myth being the container of
- 9:17forgotten knowledge. However, not every
- 9:20divine character encodes cleanly into
- 9:22real people. Some demonstrate the
- 9:24dangers of real locations. Cersei, the
- 9:27witch who turns Odicius men into pigs,
- 9:30and the sirens, whose song captures the
- 9:33hearts of weary travelers, bewitching
- 9:35them into crashing on the rocks. So,
- 9:37what do these allegorories mean? And
- 9:40it's quite simple. The Mediterranean is
- 9:43dangerous. There are many coastlines
- 9:45that are so beautiful, yet so deadly
- 9:48that sailors would wreck themselves
- 9:50trying to reach them. These characters
- 9:52represent what it feels like to be
- 9:53pulled toward a beautiful coastline
- 9:55after a long time at sea. But
- 9:57unfortunately, without the knowledge of
- 9:58how to traverse these areas, it is often
- 10:01incredibly dangerous. The Greeks placed
- 10:03Cersei's island on the Italian coast at
- 10:06a cape that still carries her name,
- 10:08Monte Cersio. The Sirens had a home,
- 10:10too. A stretch of the Italian coast that
- 10:12the natives called Sarinuse, and an
- 10:14island called Losia, which was named
- 10:17after the Sirens. Anyone who's ever been
- 10:19to the Almalfi coast in Italy knows how
- 10:21beautiful that coastline is. Yet, some
- 10:23of these coastlines are the most
- 10:24perilous in the entire Mediterranean.
- 10:26These aren't free floating fairy tales.
- 10:28They're fixed to real places on real
- 10:31maps, the same as every other location
- 10:33on the journey. The danger was real. The
- 10:35poetry is just how you remember it. And
- 10:37while some may say that the names of
- 10:39these locations came from the myth, many
- 10:41of these names were already ancient by
- 10:43the time of the ancient Greek
- 10:44historians. And it's unclear whether or
- 10:46not those names can be attributed
- 10:47specifically to Homer or if they predate
- 10:50his epics. And so now we come to another
- 10:52strange location on the journey, the
- 10:55land of the dead. Odysius sails to the
- 10:57edge of the world to a place of
- 10:59permanent fog and darkness where the sun
- 11:01never shines. And there he speaks with
- 11:04the souls of the dead. The people who
- 11:06live at that dark edge are called the
- 11:08Samrians. And that's Samrian with a C,
- 11:11not Sumerian. Now, the location of the
- 11:14underworld is obviously a myth, but the
- 11:16Samrians were anything but. They were a
- 11:19real people from far north up around the
- 11:22Black Sea, often called the Pontis or
- 11:24the Uxene. And Strao makes a point of
- 11:27this. Homer didn't just know the name of
- 11:29the Samrians. He knew them. Around
- 11:32Homer's lifetime, or perhaps just before
- 11:34it, the Samrians came down out of the
- 11:36north and ravaged their way across the
- 11:38land, all the way into Ionia into the
- 11:40Greek world itself. The Greek chronicers
- 11:43preserve this. This is a real people,
- 11:45hostile and foreign to the Greeks. Their
- 11:48existence also shows up in the records
- 11:49of the Neoasyrian Empire as the Game
- 11:52starting in the late 8th century BC.
- 11:55What's more, there's contemporary
- 11:56correspondence to Sargon II's court
- 11:59reporting that the Samrians had crushed
- 12:01the kingdom of Oratu around 714 BC. So
- 12:05then why does Homer place these people
- 12:07at the gates of Hades? And the answer is
- 12:10rather straightforward because the
- 12:12homeland of the Samrians is the North
- 12:14Caucus region at the edge of the Greek
- 12:16known map. Beyond them are the vast
- 12:18steps of Russia and Asia, uncharted
- 12:21lands and borderline uninhabitable to a
- 12:23Bronze Age population. It was a colder,
- 12:26wetter, and darker climate year round in
- 12:29comparison to the Greek Mediterranean.
- 12:31But perhaps most importantly, these
- 12:33people were alien to the Greeks. They
- 12:35were different. They had different
- 12:36traditions, different customs, and
- 12:38different gods. They were the perfect
- 12:40metaphor for the land of the dead, the
- 12:42land of people functionally living in
- 12:44another world. And that cognitive
- 12:46dissonance was perfect for the motif
- 12:48that Homer was going for. Which brings
- 12:50us to our next location, Sila and
- 12:53Kuribdus, the two monsters guarding a
- 12:55narrow straight. On one side, the
- 12:58six-headed creature reaching out to
- 13:00snatch men off the deck. And on the
- 13:02other side, a whirlpool that swallows
- 13:04ships whole. And by now, you should know
- 13:07where this is going. It's a real
- 13:09straight, the straight of Messina, the
- 13:12narrow gap between Sicily and the
- 13:13Italian mainland. And the danger there
- 13:16is real. This is where the two seas
- 13:19meet. The Tyan on one side and the
- 13:22Ionian on the other. Their tides don't
- 13:24line up. So the water tears through that
- 13:26narrow channel and it reverses twice a
- 13:29day. Now remember that number twice a
- 13:32day. That reversal is what spins up the
- 13:35whirlpools. And that's Caribbdus.
- 13:39The same currents Aololis taught the
- 13:41sailors to read. A genuine
- 13:43shipthreatening whirlpool in the exact
- 13:46spot that Homer puts one. And then
- 13:48there's Silo, the six-headed monster
- 13:51lunging off the rocks to snatch weary
- 13:53travelers. Paleibius, again preserved by
- 13:56Strao, makes the claim that this is a
- 13:58swordfish hunt native to that exact
- 14:00region. And he describes how it's done.
- 14:02A lookout posted on the cliff. Two man
- 14:04boats, one to row and one with a barbed
- 14:07spear. Something waiting at the rock
- 14:09lunging out to seize prey from the sea.
- 14:12And the thing from the sea is the
- 14:13swordfish. And the monster is the men
- 14:15hunting it. And swordfish hunting is one
- 14:17of the most dangerous kinds of fishing
- 14:19in the ancient world. They often
- 14:22compared it to hunting boar and Homer
- 14:25turned that fishing ground into a
- 14:26monster so that both monsters decode to
- 14:30real things at one real place. But
- 14:32here's an interesting control. Homer
- 14:35says Kuribdus turns three times a day.
- 14:38In reality, the straight of Msina only
- 14:40has a tide two times a day. And Strao
- 14:42flags it as he's been to the straight of
- 14:44Msina and counted it. So this is a good
- 14:47question. How do we know that this is
- 14:49the location that Homer meant? And the
- 14:52answer to that is incredibly simple and
- 14:53rather mundane because there's no place
- 14:55on Earth where the tide rises three
- 14:57times a day. It's not the tides that
- 14:59anchor that location. It's the rest of
- 15:01the textual clues that give you
- 15:03everything else. The straight is real.
- 15:06The whirlpool is real. The rock is real.
- 15:08The swordfish hunt is real. The only
- 15:10thing that's off is a single number. And
- 15:12that's the tell of mythic compression.
- 15:15You see the structure of that
- 15:17independently identifying everything
- 15:18else and mislabeling one number. That's
- 15:21not what literary invention looks like.
- 15:23That's what memory looks like. And
- 15:26that's Shabbo's whole argument. If Homer
- 15:28had invented Sila and Kuribdus, then
- 15:31there's zero reason why the rest of the
- 15:32data would match so cleanly with just
- 15:35the tides being off. Which brings us to
- 15:38our last location. The one Strao
- 15:40couldn't solve. Oijia, the island at the
- 15:43center of the sea where the sea goddess
- 15:45Calypso keeps Odysius prisoner for seven
- 15:48years until he's finally allowed to go
- 15:50home. Up until this point, all of these
- 15:52locations had been identified and
- 15:54accounted for by the ancient historians.
- 15:57But this one, Straa reads as pointing
- 16:00out somewhere past the edge of the known
- 16:02world. He believes it's out in the open
- 16:04ocean beyond where anyone lives.
- 16:07Actually, that sounds a little bit like
- 16:10another mythical island.
- 16:13But here we run into a problem. And so
- 16:14Strao turned to Paleibius again, who did
- 16:17the most honest thing any scholar can
- 16:19do. He ran the numbers. Odysius builds a
- 16:22raft and sails for 17 days to get to the
- 16:25islands of the Fiatans. Based on the
- 16:27location of the Fiatians, the distance
- 16:30to the Atlantic Ocean could not be
- 16:32covered in that time horizon. In
- 16:34calculating the distance between the
- 16:36fiat and the Atlantic Ocean, the numbers
- 16:38rule it out. So Strao stops. He doesn't
- 16:41force it. He sets Oja down in his own
- 16:44words as something that should be
- 16:46neither examined too rigorously nor
- 16:48dismissed as groundless. Meaning it's
- 16:50pointing at something real, but we can't
- 16:53quite place it. But we have the
- 16:55advantage of 2,000 years of hindsight on
- 16:57our side. So let's see if we could do
- 16:59what Strao couldn't. Let's attempt to
- 17:01find this using first principles and see
- 17:03if we can boldly assert a new
- 17:05hypothesis. Let's start with the text
- 17:07because Homer gives you more than a
- 17:09story here. He gives you the heading.
- 17:11The first clue is that when Calypso lets
- 17:13Odysius go, she tells him exactly where
- 17:15to steer. Keep the great bear, the one
- 17:18constellation that never sets on your
- 17:20left. Be sure to watch the Pleades and
- 17:23watch Bootees. Those constellations
- 17:26never set because they're in the north.
- 17:28Which means in order to keep them on
- 17:29your left, the direction of travel must
- 17:32be east. And he is to follow that
- 17:34heading until the mountains of the
- 17:36fatians rise from the sea. And we
- 17:38actually know where the fatians are.
- 17:40It's the island called otherwise known
- 17:42as Corfu in modern-day western Greece.
- 17:45So all we need to do is take that
- 17:46sailing heading and run it backwards. A
- 17:49sailing raft in antiquity could travel
- 17:50anywhere from 1.5 to 2 knots which
- 17:53equates to about 1100 to,500 km over the
- 17:57course of 17 days. That doesn't get you
- 17:59to the Atlantic Ocean, but it does get
- 18:01you into the southern Mediterranean. And
- 18:04there are several good candidates that
- 18:06fall into that range. You have the
- 18:07islands of Corsica in Sardinia. You have
- 18:10Sicily. You have Malta and Goo, the
- 18:13sister island to Malta. And many of
- 18:15these locations had been debated
- 18:16throughout antiquity. Kamachis, one of
- 18:19the most learned men in the ancient
- 18:21world and the prime scholar who
- 18:23cataloged and organized the entire
- 18:25library of Alexandria, looked at this
- 18:27same problem 2,300 years ago and said
- 18:29Calypso's island was indeed Gooo. But
- 18:32here's the big problem, and again, it's
- 18:34context. Calypso's island was meant to
- 18:37be hidden. It was mythical. It was
- 18:39beyond the mortal veil. It was a place
- 18:42that was not well traveled. And every
- 18:44single one of these locations was well
- 18:46known in Homer's time. But that's
- 18:49actually where modern research and
- 18:50findings come into play because maybe
- 18:53there's a third option. And for that, we
- 18:55need to go to Tunisia. Remember when I
- 18:57said the Gulf of Gabes? Look at where
- 18:59this is. This falls right into the
- 19:02location that we just calculated. But
- 19:04not only that, Heroditus places many of
- 19:07his most ancient people groups right
- 19:09next to the lotus eaters in that same
- 19:11location. Diodoris also makes the claim
- 19:14that the locals there believe they had
- 19:16the oldest mythology that accounted for
- 19:18all of both the Greek and the Egyptian
- 19:20gods. And finally, Appalonius of Roads,
- 19:23a former head librarian at the library
- 19:25of Alexandria, places Jason and the
- 19:27Argonauts in that exact region. In the
- 19:29fourth book of the Argonautica,
- 19:31Appalonius places Jason and the
- 19:33Argonauts in Libya, specifically in a
- 19:35lake, Lake Tronis. Lake Trtonis has
- 19:38often been believed to be the Chhat
- 19:40Eljared in Tunisia, a ancient paleo lake
- 19:43that is now a salt flat. What's more,
- 19:46Talmé in his geographies gives precise
- 19:48coordinates that within his system map
- 19:50to the exact location in Tunisia where
- 19:53the Chhat El Jared sits today. And in
- 19:56the Argonautica, Jason and the Argonauts
- 19:58sail this same vector that Calypso gives
- 20:00Odysius in order to get back to Greece,
- 20:03which coincidentally was a real ancient
- 20:05seaway based on how the currents travel
- 20:07in that region. And now we must consider
- 20:09the next unit of analysis, the names,
- 20:11because Homer doesn't choose these names
- 20:13by accident. Ojisia, the word means
- 20:17primeval, the oldest from the dawn of
- 20:20the world. The word itself is tied to
- 20:22ojis, a king before the ducalian flood.
- 20:24And the old writers often used ojigian
- 20:27to mean anything in the ancient world
- 20:29that they couldn't name. And then
- 20:31there's the goddess Calypso from the
- 20:33Greek Calypto to mean to cover, to
- 20:35conceal, to hide. And the ancient
- 20:37lexicon is actually sharper than that.
- 20:39It glosses her name as the one who
- 20:40conceals what is known. She isn't just
- 20:43hiding a man on an island. She's hiding
- 20:45the island's location itself. And she is
- 20:49the daughter of Atlas, the Titan who
- 20:51stands at the western edge of the world
- 20:53and holds up the sky. And ironically
- 20:56enough, the Atlas mountain range covers
- 20:58all of northwestern Africa from Tunisia
- 21:01all the way to the straight of Gibralar,
- 21:03otherwise known as the pillars of
- 21:04Heracles. So, let's line it up. Calypso
- 21:07means to hide, to conceal, the daughter
- 21:09of Atlas, which is the mountains that
- 21:11hold up the western edge of the world,
- 21:13presiding over the location that is the
- 21:15primordial primeval place. So, what
- 21:18could be hidden? Not an island, but the
- 21:21Sahara itself, or at least what it used
- 21:25to be. And we've touched on this before,
- 21:27but during the African human period, the
- 21:29Sahara was green. Rivers, grassland, and
- 21:32water, not oasises. There are multiple
- 21:34peer-reviewed papers that talk about
- 21:36rivers and massive paleo lakes, some
- 21:39large enough to contain islands that
- 21:41sprawled over the entire Sahara Desert.
- 21:43Homer's epic points back to a memory, a
- 21:46memory of a Sahara that was once
- 21:48habitable and a prime location for
- 21:50humans to live. The Greek historians
- 21:52were hunting for an island in the middle
- 21:54of the sea. But that island was never in
- 21:56the sea. It was already hidden
- 21:58underneath the sand of the Sahara. But
- 22:00then following first principles, this
- 22:02actually leaves open another question.
- 22:04The Sahara was already desiccating by
- 22:06the time of Homer, meaning he wouldn't
- 22:08have been able to witness any lakes to
- 22:10attest to them. Which means that if
- 22:12Homer is recording real geography in
- 22:14this story, the knowledge of that
- 22:16geography is older than him. Which means
- 22:19that those who came before him recorded
- 22:21this information for him to preserve.
- 22:24And this [music] is the ultimate purpose
- 22:26of mythology. This is how stories get
- 22:28passed down generation to generation and
- 22:30millennia to millennia. Many of the
- 22:33stories we hear today are echoes of past
- 22:35stories that we've been telling for
- 22:37thousands of years. And as we've shown
- 22:39throughout the conversation, often times
- 22:41these stories are real, pointing at real
- 22:44things, real knowledge, and real
- 22:46locations. Sometimes we just need a bit
- 22:48of modern research data to find the
- 22:51answers. But here's where we need to be
- 22:53disciplined and take one massive step
- 22:55back. Can we say through this little
- 22:57analysis that we found the mythical
- 22:59island of Oijia?
- 23:02No, probably not. But here's the point.
- 23:05The text gives a real heading to a real
- 23:08coast, a real coast with a real
- 23:10geography, real history, and real
- 23:13ancient names that map to the specific
- 23:15motifs that Homer employs. The logic
- 23:18that decoded Odysius's journey at every
- 23:21other stop could still be applied here.
- 23:24And quite possibly the reason it still
- 23:26reads like a fairy tale is because the
- 23:28world it's describing is no longer here.
- 23:31What's changed in our time since Stravo
- 23:33is not that we're more intelligent
- 23:35today. It's that we have access to
- 23:38knowledge that we never had before. The
- 23:42African human period data is little over
- 23:4550 years old. We're still learning about
- 23:48what that means and what the
- 23:49implications for that knowledge are. And
- 23:51as we do, stories from the past that
- 23:53have been written off as pure mythic
- 23:56fantasy are starting to become more and
- 23:59more plausible. And aside from
- 24:01demonstrating that Homer's Odyssey
- 24:04documented real history and real
- 24:06geographical locations, that's the whole
- 24:09point of this video. Schlleman found
- 24:11Troy because he refused to call the text
- 24:13a liar. So, the question I'd carry out
- 24:16of here isn't what did the ancient
- 24:19writers make up. It's what are we still
- 24:22calling fiction that's just waiting to
- 24:25be found? I'm Curtis Holland and I'll
- 24:28see you on the next one.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of The Odyssey Is a Map. Here's Where It Leads. by Curtis Holland | Reviewing the Record, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,280 words across 639 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.