The myth of the native speaker (with David Crystal) — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00recently I had the pleasure of talking
- 0:03to a legend in the world of the English
- 0:06language David crystal he is a linguist
- 0:12lecturer a broadcaster and he has
- 0:15written or edited over 100 books about
- 0:19language including the cambridge
- 0:22encyclopedia of the english language
- 0:25we talked about language change the myth
- 0:29of the native speaker and why learning a
- 0:33language is part of being human this is
- 0:38an edited version of our interview if
- 0:40you would like to listen to the full
- 0:42version you will find a link down in the
- 0:44description box I hope you enjoy it as a
- 0:48teacher of English is a foreign language
- 0:50a lot of learners encounter teachers who
- 0:53talk about standard English and and I
- 0:58wondered how you feel about this idea of
- 1:00a kind of standard English well start
- 1:03the notion of standard English
- 1:04historically of course is a written
- 1:06English and an attractively a printed
- 1:09English it's it's the kind of English at
- 1:13everybody used when the language was
- 1:14written down and even at the beginning
- 1:18when it's standardized it took 400 years
- 1:20for English to standardize you know it
- 1:22start the movement started around about
- 1:241400 and it was really more or less
- 1:28sorted out by 1800 dr. Johnson in his
- 1:31dictionary for instance represents a
- 1:33very clear picture of how English
- 1:36vocabulary and so on was was
- 1:38standardizing in his day but ironically
- 1:41just at the point at which English was
- 1:43settling down into a standard form in
- 1:45Britain it was beginning to diversify
- 1:47because American English was starting
- 1:50across the pond with Noah Webster and
- 1:53the new nation and run by 1800 of course
- 1:55American English existed as a different
- 1:58standard as an emerging standard
- 1:59differently from British English and
- 2:02then later other educated standards
- 2:05emerged in the written language around
- 2:06the world so one can talk sensibly about
- 2:08you know Australian English and so on
- 2:11very very effectively
- 2:12that the differences are very great you
- 2:14know is still only talking about two or
- 2:16three percent of the language being
- 2:19different between British English and
- 2:21American English it's not a big deal but
- 2:23it's enough to express the different
- 2:25identities of these different countries
- 2:27so standard English is alive and well
- 2:30despite the fact that there's a certain
- 2:32amount of variation in it and when
- 2:34people speak Standard English or try to
- 2:38you know they might learn it in school
- 2:40or you certainly learn it as a foreign
- 2:42language and then once again you get a
- 2:46general consensus that there are certain
- 2:49features of the English sound system
- 2:51that everybody uses otherwise you're
- 2:54going to be unintelligible and then
- 2:55you're gonna get these this you know a
- 2:58few percent of differences like you know
- 3:01I so you might say bath or bath in this
- 3:03country but it'll be bath in America you
- 3:05know that kind of small difference which
- 3:07doesn't usually amount to an
- 3:09intelligibility but it's certainly there
- 3:11so standard English is certainly there
- 3:13despite the fact that there's a certain
- 3:14amount of variation in it so the next
- 3:17question is why have a standard language
- 3:19and the answer to that is to promote
- 3:21intelligibility of nationally and
- 3:24internationally it helps us understand
- 3:27each other and that's one of the two big
- 3:29forces that are driving language the
- 3:31other big force as we mentioned earlier
- 3:33really is the need for identity I have
- 3:36to say Who I am and where I'm from and
- 3:38that produces local accents and dialects
- 3:41both nationally and internationally so
- 3:43it's the tension now between these two
- 3:45forces intelligibility saying let's all
- 3:48speak the same on identity saying no
- 3:51let's be different and it's that kind of
- 3:53tension that is causing well teachers
- 3:57are imagined in various parts of the
- 3:59world a bit of confusion you know
- 4:00quickforce do I allow into my classroom
- 4:03well I think I think maybe well the
- 4:05reason I ask I suppose is because of
- 4:08this general kind of obsession in the
- 4:10world of foreign language teaching with
- 4:14everything you do should be modeled on
- 4:17the kind of native speaker now you know
- 4:20like a native speaker accent ladies
- 4:22speaker grammar and that's history for
- 4:25me yeah
- 4:26that has gone out of the window with the
- 4:28dodo I mean I know there are people
- 4:30around the world who will still maintain
- 4:32it but it's a myth there was never a
- 4:35native speaker in the sense of somebody
- 4:39who hasn't been influenced by some sort
- 4:42of local variation here and there all
- 4:45sorts of mixed accents people especially
- 4:47these days people moving about the
- 4:49country and accommodating to the accent
- 4:51of the place in which they find
- 4:52themselves
- 4:53all this kind of variation is there
- 4:56remember that RP was only ever spoken by
- 4:59about that most in its history 5% of the
- 5:02speakers of England
- 5:04remember not Wales or Scotland or
- 5:06Ireland and these days it's probably
- 5:08round about 2% of the population and
- 5:11even RP of course has changed its
- 5:14character so it's no longer the very
- 5:16very posh far back kind of accent that
- 5:19we heard you know a few decades ago but
- 5:22go around the english-speaking world now
- 5:24and look at the majority of speakers who
- 5:26are out there and try listening for RP
- 5:30and see how often you find it you know
- 5:32you can stand at the corner of Oxford
- 5:33Street and I did this once for a BBC
- 5:35programme and made notes about the
- 5:37accents I heard as they passed by you
- 5:40know I could wait for ages it's like
- 5:41London buses you know before one turns
- 5:43up before an RP accent turned up and
- 5:45when when one does turn up my wife
- 5:48Hilary and I often turn to each other
- 5:49and say hey RP lives there were so
- 5:52pleased to hear it you know because it's
- 5:54so rare so what preparing our students
- 5:57for you know in terms of listening
- 6:00comprehension they have got to be made
- 6:02aware of the fact that English is now
- 6:05multiple in its accent or might add you
- 6:08kated English now I'm not talking about
- 6:10you know people who don't have an
- 6:11educated background people you want to
- 6:13identify with as a learner and unmixed
- 6:17accents and and modified RP accents and
- 6:21all sorts of things American tinged
- 6:23accents and accents themselves of course
- 6:25all of these things are now absolutely
- 6:27belong so from a comprehension point of
- 6:30view you've got to introduce students to
- 6:32this kind of variation otherwise they're
- 6:34going to be living in a fool's paradise
- 6:35from a production point of view of
- 6:38course
- 6:39think necessarily changes if you're used
- 6:43to teaching RP and all your materials
- 6:46are in RP and that's your lobbying your
- 6:49life then by all means teach our Peter
- 6:51students or produce it's a perfectly
- 6:53reasonable accent you know just because
- 6:55it happens to be not so common as it
- 6:58used to be doesn't mean to say it's not
- 7:00got a value it still has and it'll still
- 7:02be heard especially on the radio so
- 7:05there's a difference here I think
- 7:06between production and comprehension
- 7:07just just to just rewind just very
- 7:10slightly because I know that there are
- 7:12some teachers out there who feel like
- 7:14and I'm not one of them but they feel
- 7:16like well we need to have this this
- 7:19native speaker model because if we don't
- 7:22if we don't have this like you know
- 7:25perfect sort of accent and the grammar
- 7:28like native speakers then what we will
- 7:30do is we will allow chaos chaos will not
- 7:33happen if the teaching has been good I
- 7:34mean one aims for intelligibility always
- 7:37the question then is does a local accent
- 7:40interfere with intelligibility and if it
- 7:43does then the student has not yet learnt
- 7:45the English language and the teaching
- 7:47has gone horribly wrong somewhere but
- 7:49let's assume now that we've got somebody
- 7:51who is pretty fluent in English but has
- 7:54got a pretty strong accent - Spanish
- 7:57accent Portuguese accent French accent
- 7:59or whatever as long as that person is
- 8:02intelligible to me I have no problem
- 8:05with that whatsoever in fact the
- 8:08intelligibility drive is present so now
- 8:11it's the identity drive that I'm
- 8:13fascinated by I love to hear English
- 8:16spoken with a Spanish accent or accents
- 8:19because of course the variety of Spanish
- 8:22accents is really quite extraordinary
- 8:24especially in South America I love to
- 8:26hear English spoken with the French
- 8:28accent why but not just because it's
- 8:30delightful but because it helps me
- 8:32identify who the speaker is that they
- 8:35are French fine well that that's what I
- 8:37need to know in order to develop a kind
- 8:40of sense of balance between us in having
- 8:44a conversation in my
- 8:46one type of person who needs to speak RP
- 8:49perfectly like a native speaker so that
- 8:52they cannot be identified as a foreigner
- 8:54and they are spies to be a spy you will
- 8:59probably need to have that kind of
- 9:02disappearing act in your accent but
- 9:04apart from them I don't any reason
- 9:07whatsoever to aim to become identical to
- 9:11a native speaker
- 9:12they are learner's are not native
- 9:15speakers they are foreigners and I'm the
- 9:17same if I if I'm learning French or
- 9:20Spanish or whatever language I've learnt
- 9:21over the years then so long as I'm
- 9:24intelligible I don't want to say I don't
- 9:26to be a French person or a Spanish
- 9:28person I want to be me and I want my
- 9:31accent to reflect that and to let other
- 9:33people know it and so that kind of
- 9:36climate of increasing acceptance
- 9:38tolerance and increasingly respect for
- 9:42different actions I think it's becoming
- 9:44increasingly the norm
- 9:46although recognizing that there is still
- 9:48it's still a great deal of
- 9:49conservativism out there no I mean look
- 9:51I totally agree but I also know that
- 9:53there are teachers out there who are
- 9:55saying well you know we can't just have
- 9:57people speaking with a Spanish or French
- 9:59accents because you know we need it's
- 10:02it's that whole kind of for me it's a
- 10:04very almost colonialism kind of attitude
- 10:08about you know homogenizing the the
- 10:12language and the people who speak it
- 10:14yeah people have people have to realize
- 10:16that that there is no such thing as
- 10:18homogeneity in in language there is
- 10:20always variation and as long as the
- 10:23variation doesn't get in the way of
- 10:24intelligibility then it has to be
- 10:27respected first and then fostered really
- 10:31because these are markers of identity
- 10:34and you know the difference between
- 10:36intelligibility and identity is not just
- 10:38an intellectual difference
- 10:39intelligibility is full ahead
- 10:41identity is full of heart you know who
- 10:44you are which community you belong to
- 10:47which community you're proud to belong
- 10:49to you you you want to foster that at
- 10:52the same time of course as needing to be
- 10:55understood and understand other people
- 10:58who belong to the same
- 10:59community know that the really
- 11:01disastrous thing in the attitude that
- 11:04you've mentioned is that in many
- 11:06language teaching schools around the
- 11:07world I understand if you're a native
- 11:10speaker of a language you get paid more
- 11:13even if you are not it is speaker of
- 11:16language even though the non-native
- 11:17speaker of the language may know more
- 11:20about the English language than the
- 11:21native speaker does and if you ask me
- 11:24who I want to be taught by do I want to
- 11:26be taught by a native speaker doesn't
- 11:28know one end of grammar from the other
- 11:30or by a non-native speaker who is very
- 11:33familiar with English grammar and knows
- 11:34how to teach it I know who I'm voting
- 11:36for every time you know my experience
- 11:38again is with with a lot of foreign
- 11:40learners and and you know learning a
- 11:43learning a language any language is
- 11:44really really difficult and it takes a
- 11:46really long time in fact I believe you
- 11:49yourself you've described learning the
- 11:51language as AI climbing a mountain well
- 11:53let me first of all say that the
- 11:55metaphor of the mountain when I used it
- 11:58to talked about vocabulary being the
- 12:01Everest of language it was vocabulary I
- 12:03was thinking of more than anything else
- 12:05not pronunciation not grammar those
- 12:08aren't mountains really you know and
- 12:10when you think about it if you're
- 12:12learning English that are depending on
- 12:14the accent 4044 sounds that you have to
- 12:17learn well that's not a big deal really
- 12:19it might take you a while to get your
- 12:21tongue around them but you know any
- 12:23anybody can handle that number of sounds
- 12:25within a reasonably short period of time
- 12:27when you get onto grammar leaving aside
- 12:30some of the most sophisticated forms of
- 12:32grammar you might get in literary
- 12:33expression or very advanced scientific
- 12:35language or what have you
- 12:37we're only talking about what you know I
- 12:40did the index to the big quirk grammar
- 12:42the comprehensive grammar of the English
- 12:44language when you count up all the
- 12:46points about grammar that are in that
- 12:48big book there are about 3,500 of them
- 12:51so that might seem like a lot to a
- 12:53beginner but come on 3,500 points you
- 12:57can handle that over a period of four or
- 12:59five years or something and most of them
- 13:02you'll get in the first year but oak
- 13:05Abbe you Larry
- 13:06Wow now we are talking about an Everest
- 13:09because how many words are there in the
- 13:11English language well nobody knows but
- 13:12you know
- 13:13two million probably far more than that
- 13:15and you're competent average native
- 13:18speaker adult will have a vocabulary of
- 13:21about you know fifty sixty thousand
- 13:23words something of that order of
- 13:25magnitude
- 13:26well that is a task and I remember very
- 13:30well from my own learning of foreign
- 13:31languages you know I could handle the
- 13:33pronunciation and the grammar to a
- 13:35reasonable extent quite quickly but the
- 13:38vocabulary that is the killer you know
- 13:41how do you get all that under your belt
- 13:43and that to my mind is the the biggest
- 13:47problem when people get to that
- 13:48intermediate stage they've they've they
- 13:51can do conversations now very well you
- 13:53know they've got a pretty solid command
- 13:55of grammar they've got the pronunciation
- 13:58pretty well they can even probably write
- 14:00it and spell it reasonably well - who
- 14:02knows but the vocabulary you just think
- 14:04oh no I mean I just don't know these
- 14:06words that are coming up and that can be
- 14:11the slippery slope into depression it
- 14:14seems to me and so now here's the
- 14:17interesting point Christian at least it
- 14:19seems to me so what we need now is good
- 14:22techniques for teaching vocabulary and
- 14:26where are they you know where are the
- 14:28good vocabulary teaching materials piles
- 14:32of grammar teaching materials all over
- 14:34the place pronunciation materials
- 14:35everywhere but vocabulary often still I
- 14:39observe in classrooms or read new
- 14:42textbooks and the chapter-by-chapter
- 14:44organization is you know to do with a
- 14:47grammatical point and at the end it says
- 14:50here's the vocabulary you need in order
- 14:52to understand this chapter learn that
- 14:54off by heart you know and you have to
- 14:56you sort of learn this set of words that
- 14:58turned up in the chapter there's no
- 15:00structural approach to vocabulary a kind
- 15:03of semantic structural approach is very
- 15:05definitely needed now I do see some
- 15:07signs of this happening at an academic
- 15:10level and in applied linguistics but
- 15:12when you get down to the classroom I
- 15:14mean you tell me I mean is there a good
- 15:17structured vocabulary graded thing that
- 15:20would take you all the way through for
- 15:22that intermediate period I don't know of
- 15:24one what would you say
- 15:26a to people who you know to people who
- 15:30really really want to learn a language
- 15:32but they're lacking motivation like what
- 15:35is like a really great reason or some
- 15:37great reasons to learn language well a
- 15:39whole cluster of things I suppose the
- 15:43fact that we are living in a
- 15:45multilingual and multicultural world and
- 15:48you know fight fire mountains because
- 15:51they're there these languages are there
- 15:54so if you're curious about the nature of
- 15:56the planet and what it means to be human
- 15:58then you've got to very quickly start
- 16:01addressing the question of why why are
- 16:04all these differences there it's a
- 16:07matter of temperament partly some people
- 16:09are only interested in similarities but
- 16:12I for one and I think perhaps I'm in the
- 16:14majority are interested in differences I
- 16:16don't spend my whole life just talking
- 16:19to the people I know who have exactly
- 16:21the same background as me I want to find
- 16:24out about the diversity that really will
- 16:27give me an insight on what it means to
- 16:29be human
- 16:29there are something like 6,000 languages
- 16:31in the world I'd look to study all of
- 16:34them because each one has an individual
- 16:36insight into the nature of the human
- 16:37condition no other language has got and
- 16:41the more I learn another language not
- 16:43the fluency level necessarily mind you
- 16:45know just enough to get a sense of what
- 16:48it's like what it's about how the people
- 16:50think in it and so on then this
- 16:53illuminates me and my language more than
- 16:55anything else so there's all those
- 16:57theoretical sort of reasons and then
- 17:00there are the practical reasons of
- 17:01course so I'm trying to sell you some
- 17:03goods and I know your language or at
- 17:06least a bit and you've gone about I for
- 17:09me because I know your language whereas
- 17:10if I say I want to sell you some goods
- 17:12but you've got to learn English mate
- 17:13sorry III just can't be bothered to
- 17:17learn your language you're going to buy
- 17:18my goods now all that sort of economic
- 17:21kind of argument is increasingly
- 17:23important in this day and age there is
- 17:25two other reasons you know there are a
- 17:27host of other reasons as well and what
- 17:30people need is the two crucial things
- 17:33motivation which I've been talking about
- 17:35but the other big factor is opportunity
- 17:39and that is much trickier and by
- 17:42opportunity I mean you know it's got to
- 17:45be there in the educational system it's
- 17:47got to be there in the cultural system
- 17:49people not far more people would be
- 17:52learning foreign languages in this
- 17:54country and I guess it's the same in
- 17:56many others if if foreign language
- 17:59learning was given the the national
- 18:05respect that it needs and my national
- 18:07respect I mean things like prizes you
- 18:11know if you're a physicist you want the
- 18:13Nobel Prize don't you if you're a
- 18:14literature you want the Nobel Prize why
- 18:17as I know Nobel Prize for languages why
- 18:20are there no internationally recognized
- 18:23crises at that level there's a Templeton
- 18:26Prize for progress in religion why isn't
- 18:29there a Templeton type prize for
- 18:31progress in languages why have languages
- 18:33be left off the agenda here why didn't
- 18:35Nobel ignore languages so much this
- 18:38puzzles me greatly and it seems to me
- 18:41that if we could build into our
- 18:44international society criteria like that
- 18:49date prizes language days there are some
- 18:53of those we do have some international
- 18:54language days mother tongue language day
- 18:56for example but even so lingua Pax has a
- 18:59little prize for instance there are a
- 19:01few things around but nothing major and
- 19:04that's the sort of perspective within
- 19:06which people would say Oh
- 19:08learning a language is not just useful
- 19:10for me because I might sell some goods
- 19:11I'm not just useful for me because I
- 19:14might learn something about other
- 19:17languages which will illuminate me no
- 19:19it's because language learning is valued
- 19:22by society at an international level
- 19:25it's starting to happen at an endangered
- 19:28language level people are realizing that
- 19:30of those 6,000 languages half of them
- 19:33are so seriously endangered they're
- 19:35going to die out in the course of the
- 19:37present century and this is beginning to
- 19:38worry people and people starting to do
- 19:40something about it but I'm not just
- 19:42talking about endangered languages here
- 19:44I'm talking about all the languages of
- 19:46the world it's that kind of
- 19:47international value we need to see
- 19:49present and it's still there's still a
- 19:51long way off from that so that would
- 19:53help enormous Lee I think again thank
- 19:55you very much for your time well I
- 19:57appreciate it
- 19:57well it's pleasure all power to you I've
- 20:01been busy filling pages I've been busy
- 20:10[Music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of The myth of the native speaker (with David Crystal) by Canguro English, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,401 words across 496 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.