YouTube2Text

The Man Who Calls BS On AI: They’re LYING About AI, 2027 Is When It All Breaks! | Ed Zitron — Transcript

by The Diary Of A CEO · 31,429 words · 4,989 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00I think generative AI is at its heart a
  2. 0:02con. And seeing these ultra-rich,
  3. 0:04ultra-powerful people lie through their
  4. 0:07Turns my stomach. The word con is a
  5. 0:09strong word. Well, what do you call
  6. 0:10something where from the very beginning
  7. 0:12they've sold [music] it in the terms of
  8. 0:14magic, but it's just a half-assed
  9. 0:15machine. They are misleading the entire
  10. 0:17world.
  11. 0:18>> You are the first person that I've
  12. 0:19spoken to that has that opinion.
  13. 0:20>> Well, the fact that this is happening is
  14. 0:22insane, and the fact it's not a scandal
  15. 0:24is insane. And I've been in the tech
  16. 0:26industry for 16 years now, and I love
  17. 0:28technology, and I'm enthusiastic about
  18. 0:29it. But I don't like being misled. And
  19. 0:32this is the largest non-consensual push
  20. 0:35of technology in history.
  21. 0:36>> So, we're going to play a game, Ed. I
  22. 0:37have the things that you consider to be
  23. 0:40myths about the AI industry. Let's play
  24. 0:42it.
  25. 0:43>> The AI industry is creating enormous
  26. 0:45economic growth. No, it's not. All of
  27. 0:46these companies run at a horrifying
  28. 0:48loss. OpenAI lost $20.9 billion last
  29. 0:51year. None of these people can just say,
  30. 0:53"Yeah, we're on the path to making this
  31. 0:54profitable." Because they can't.
  32. 0:55>> Next one.
  33. 0:56>> AI will replace all human jobs. That
  34. 0:58just isn't happening. There's no
  35. 1:00economic data to support it. Next, the
  36. 1:02United States need to spend trillions to
  37. 1:04beat China in the AI race. What's the
  38. 1:06race to do for us to constantly piss our
  39. 1:07pants worrying about China? But people
  40. 1:09keep saying, "What if these models fall
  41. 1:10into the wrong hands?" They're already
  42. 1:12in the wrong hands. Mark Zuckerberg, Sam
  43. 1:14Altman, Dario Amodei.
  44. 1:16>> Mark Zuckerberg says, "We'll continue to
  45. 1:18invest aggressively in infrastructure to
  46. 1:19meet the demand."
  47. 1:20>> God meta is a monstrosity. Makes me
  48. 1:22think of Shrek with Lord Farquaad. Some
  49. 1:24of you may die, but that's a risk I'm
  50. 1:26willing to accept. If only these people
  51. 1:28gave a about poverty or actual
  52. 1:30problems in the world versus, "Are we
  53. 1:31buying enough GPUs?"
  54. 1:33>> If this continues, [music] what does the
  55. 1:35future look like?
  56. 1:41This is super interesting to me. My team
  57. 1:43gave me this report to show me how many
  58. 1:44of you that watch this show subscribe,
  59. 1:46and some of you have told us, according
  60. 1:47to this, that you are unsubscribed from
  61. 1:49the channel randomly. So, favor to ask
  62. 1:51all of you, please could you check right
  63. 1:53now if you've hit the subscribe button.
  64. 1:54If you are a regular viewer of the show
  65. 1:56and you like what we do here. We're
  66. 1:57approaching quite a significant landmark
  67. 1:59on this show in terms of a subscriber
  68. 2:00number. So, if there was one simple,
  69. 2:03free thing that you could do to help us,
  70. 2:05my team, everyone here, to keep this
  71. 2:06show free, to keep it improving year
  72. 2:09over year and week over week, it is just
  73. 2:10to hit that subscribe button and to
  74. 2:12double-check if you've hit it. Only
  75. 2:13thing I'll ever ask of you.
  76. 2:14Do we have a deal?
  77. 2:16If you do it, I'll tell you what I'll
  78. 2:16do. I'll make sure
  79. 2:18every single week, every single month,
  80. 2:20we fight harder and harder and harder
  81. 2:21and harder to bring you the guests and
  82. 2:22conversations that you want to hear.
  83. 2:24I've stayed true to that promise since
  84. 2:25the very beginning of the Diary of a
  85. 2:26CEO, and I will not let you down. Please
  86. 2:29help us. Really appreciate it. Let's get
  87. 2:31on with the show.
  88. 2:33>> [music]
  89. 2:36>> Ed Zitron.
  90. 2:38There are a number of things that you
  91. 2:39believe that a lot of other people don't
  92. 2:41believe.
  93. 2:42>> Right.
  94. 2:42>> You have, I think, a couple of
  95. 2:44controversial opinions, and opinions
  96. 2:46that
  97. 2:47are in contrast to the other guests that
  98. 2:49I've sat here with.
  99. 2:50What exactly are those opinions, Ed?
  100. 2:53>> I think generative AI is at its heart
  101. 2:56con. I don't think it is sold as honest
  102. 2:59software. I think that they overstate
  103. 3:01both what it can do, what it will do,
  104. 3:04and the underlying financials to the
  105. 3:06point that they are misleading the
  106. 3:07entire world, and they're actively
  107. 3:09exploiting the weaknesses in journalism,
  108. 3:11in our economies, and indeed within the
  109. 3:14responsible parties with sell-side
  110. 3:15analysts, governments, and all over the
  111. 3:17shop.
  112. 3:17>> The word con is a strong word.
  113. 3:19>> Yeah, I mean, what do you call something
  114. 3:21where from the very beginning they've
  115. 3:23sold it in the terms of magic, as this
  116. 3:25thing that will replace all jobs, that
  117. 3:27will cure cancers, all these things. And
  118. 3:29when you look at it, it's
  119. 3:31boring cloud software that's extremely
  120. 3:32expensive and unprofitable, and also
  121. 3:35unreliable at its core.
  122. 3:36>> Uh uh people will be asking, "Where are
  123. 3:38you drawing from in terms of your
  124. 3:40references, your personal experiences,
  125. 3:41where were you educated, what you
  126. 3:42studied, what you write about, what you
  127. 3:43do, Ed?"
  128. 3:44>> So, that's the funny thing is people
  129. 3:46say, "Oh, he's not going to finance
  130. 3:47experience. He's not going to take" I've
  131. 3:49been in the tech industry 15, 16 years
  132. 3:51now. In PR, but still had practical
  133. 3:53experience, and I love technology and
  134. 3:55I'm enthusiastic about it. And this
  135. 3:57thing just comes along that everyone is
  136. 3:58telling me is the best thing since
  137. 4:00sliced bread. It can't even do the
  138. 4:01basics. It can't even do search. Well,
  139. 4:03whenever you ask an AI person, well,
  140. 4:05what's your setup? They describe this
  141. 4:07PewDiePie's playhouse thing of like,
  142. 4:09well, you got a harness here and you got
  143. 4:10to use the right prompt. Well, you don't
  144. 4:11want to use that prompt. You want to use
  145. 4:13this prompt here with this model, but
  146. 4:15don't use this model for the beginning,
  147. 4:16but at the end you're going to want to
  148. 4:17use this model.
  149. 4:19And this is meant to be artificial
  150. 4:21intelligence. It's meant to be smart.
  151. 4:23It's meant to be autonomous. It's meant
  152. 4:25to be something that you set and forget.
  153. 4:26We have the sort of six leading AI
  154. 4:28companies on the table here, Anthropic,
  155. 4:30Amazon, Nvidia, Microsoft, OpenAI,
  156. 4:32Google.
  157. 4:33You're saying that their fundamental
  158. 4:35business model is
  159. 4:37a con. Well, their revenues are not
  160. 4:39really coming from AI. Up until fairly
  161. 4:40recently, none of their revenues were
  162. 4:42coming from AI, like dribbles of it.
  163. 4:44Right now, 70% of all AI revenues across
  164. 4:47those three companies are from OpenAI
  165. 4:49and Anthropic. Two unprofitable,
  166. 4:51unsustainable companies that literally
  167. 4:53cannot afford to exist without these
  168. 4:55very same companies giving them money.
  169. 4:57Amazon sent $50 billion to OpenAI this
  170. 5:01year. They sent $5 billion to Anthropic.
  171. 5:03Google sent $10 billion to Anthropic.
  172. 5:06And in the next 3 and 1/2 years, OpenAI
  173. 5:08and Anthropic, based on actual sell-side
  174. 5:10analysts' evaluations, their estimates,
  175. 5:13that inform whether stock is going to go
  176. 5:14up or down after earnings, they're
  177. 5:16expecting 400 or more billion dollars of
  178. 5:20revenue.
  179. 5:2130 or something percent of cloud growth
  180. 5:24just from these two unprofitable
  181. 5:25companies that will need to be given the
  182. 5:26money from somewhere.
  183. 5:28And on top of that, these companies have
  184. 5:30such low respect for the average
  185. 5:33investor, for the analysts, for
  186. 5:34everyone, really, that they don't even
  187. 5:36disclose their AI revenues. The few
  188. 5:38times they deign us worthy, they use
  189. 5:40something called a run rate, an
  190. 5:41annualized run rate, which means well,
  191. 5:43nothing. They never define it. It can
  192. 5:45mean month times 12. It can mean months
  193. 5:48times 13. It can mean last 4 weeks times
  194. 5:5013. It's different every time and they
  195. 5:52never define it and then they sometimes
  196. 5:53just don't mention it. So, you've got
  197. 5:55this big thing that is meant to be the
  198. 5:56biggest, most influential change to
  199. 5:59software ever. And whenever you ask them
  200. 6:01about it, when you say what how much
  201. 6:02you're making from this, they go, "Oh, I
  202. 6:03couldn't possibly say. I'm too shy."
  203. 6:06These are public companies or at least
  204. 6:07the ones that aren't Anthropic and
  205. 6:09OpenAI. When they have good news,
  206. 6:10they'll tell you and when they don't
  207. 6:12tell you something, well, that actually
  208. 6:14speaks volumes.
  209. 6:15>> Have you used these tools, the AI tools,
  210. 6:17Gemini, Anthropic, ChatGPT, etc.? And
  211. 6:21you found no value in them?
  212. 6:22>> There's some value, but it's not There's
  213. 6:24They have spent over a trillion dollars
  214. 6:26in CapEx. What does CapEx mean for you?
  215. 6:28>> Capital expenditures. So, when you are a
  216. 6:30business and you have operating expenses
  217. 6:32like electricity, for example, those
  218. 6:34come right off immediately. Capital
  219. 6:35expenditures are long-term investments
  220. 6:37that are theoretically one-off. So, a
  221. 6:38data center or indeed the GPUs you put
  222. 6:41inside an AI data center.
  223. 6:43>> Okay, so you've got a data center. And
  224. 6:45then you have these GPUs which are like
  225. 6:47computer chips.
  226. 6:48>> So, AI GPUs are much bigger, much more
  227. 6:51power intensive. They take a bunch of
  228. 6:53high bandwidth memory and they because
  229. 6:56of how many of them you need, you need
  230. 6:57thousands of them, tens of thousands,
  231. 6:58hundreds of thousands in some case,
  232. 7:01you need a bunch of power. So, an
  233. 7:03example, OpenAI and Oracle are building
  234. 7:05a data center in Texas, in Abilene,
  235. 7:07Texas. 1.2 gigawatts called Stargate
  236. 7:10Abilene. Within that, with each one of
  237. 7:12the eight buildings, there'll be 50,000
  238. 7:15Nvidia GB200 GPUs. So, city of Bristol
  239. 7:19takes about 700, 800 megawatts of power
  240. 7:22a year, right?
  241. 7:24Well, Stargate Abilene is condensing
  242. 7:26more power than that, 1.2 gigawatts,
  243. 7:28into a space around 1,172
  244. 7:31times smaller. City of Bristol is about
  245. 7:331.2 billion square feet. Stargate
  246. 7:35Abilene is about 998,000.
  247. 7:38So, you're condensing all of this power,
  248. 7:40all of this money, all of this labor,
  249. 7:41into this one spot. And all of these
  250. 7:44data centers cost billions of dollars.
  251. 7:46All of these companies other than
  252. 7:47Microsoft are now into take out debt.
  253. 7:49And the thing is, they've spent over a
  254. 7:51trillion dollars so far, and they want
  255. 7:52to spend another trillion dollars next
  256. 7:54year. And for what? To make tens of
  257. 7:56billions of dollars, most of which comes
  258. 7:58from two unprofitable companies,
  259. 8:00Anthropic and OpenAI.
  260. 8:02>> One of the rebuttal to that would be
  261. 8:03that the adoption, the customer adoption
  262. 8:06of people using OpenAI and Anthropic has
  263. 8:09been absolutely insane. These are the
  264. 8:11fastest-growing products in all of
  265. 8:12history, especially as it relates to
  266. 8:14sort of technology, if we're just
  267. 8:15focusing on technology. They are, you
  268. 8:17know, hundreds and hundreds of millions
  269. 8:19of people, billions of people are using
  270. 8:21these tools every single day for things
  271. 8:23that they have subjectively decided are
  272. 8:26problems they need solving.
  273. 8:27So, you know, money is a lagging
  274. 8:29indicator of value. So, one would argue
  275. 8:32that they're just investing ahead of the
  276. 8:35monetization options.
  277. 8:36>> The first, let's start with this
  278. 8:37adoption.
  279. 8:39Is it honest adoption when you are
  280. 8:41forced to use generative AI when you
  281. 8:43load Google, when you load Google Docs,
  282. 8:45Gemini screams in your ear. When you
  283. 8:47load Word, Copilot's bugging you. When
  284. 8:49you use Amazon, whatever ruthless AI is,
  285. 8:52wants to has opinions on what socks
  286. 8:54you're buying.
  287. 8:55This is the largest non-consensual push
  288. 8:58of technology in history. ChatGPT, for
  289. 9:00example, every single media outlet has
  290. 9:02been screaming about this for 3 years.
  291. 9:05They've been saying this will take your
  292. 9:06job. You must use this. If you don't use
  293. 9:08this, you're going to be falling behind.
  294. 9:10So, people are using it because they've
  295. 9:12been told to use it constantly, and
  296. 9:14they're using it like search
  297. 9:15phenomenally. And that's partly because
  298. 9:17Google fell behind search, and also
  299. 9:18because it's better ingesting queries
  300. 9:20sometimes. Sometimes, if you use a
  301. 9:22generative search, it's like a trolling
  302. 9:24vessel. It's not very good at specifics.
  303. 9:25But if you're like, does this thing
  304. 9:27exist? Has this person ever said
  305. 9:28anything like this? It'll still probably
  306. 9:30get it wrong, but it'll scour the ocean
  307. 9:32for you. Nevertheless, that's not worth
  308. 9:34a trillion dollars. None of it is. The
  309. 9:36amount of money being sunk into this
  310. 9:40is just incomparable to anything. Real
  311. 9:42wise, it blows everything out of the
  312. 9:43water because
  313. 9:45there is no post-bubble story even for
  314. 9:48this. AI GPU is not useful for other
  315. 9:50things, either. There's It's a
  316. 9:53directionless egregore of capitalism,
  317. 9:55this
  318. 9:56headless beast that lumbers around
  319. 9:59desperate to seek out growth everywhere
  320. 10:01in the hopes that if it harasses people
  321. 10:03and scares people and demonizes labor
  322. 10:07enough
  323. 10:08people will be forced to use it.
  324. 10:10>> The The reason I I pause is because I
  325. 10:12just I think about my own company.
  326. 10:14Obviously, everybody thinks about their
  327. 10:15own personal situation. So, you have
  328. 10:16people listening now that don't use any
  329. 10:17AI tools, then you'll have people that
  330. 10:20are using it for everything from coding
  331. 10:22new software tools to everything they
  332. 10:24write to, you know, images, whatever.
  333. 10:26And when you look at the the stats
  334. 10:27around enterprise adoption, it says 88%
  335. 10:29of organizations regularly use AI at
  336. 10:31least once for one particular business
  337. 10:34function. And I'd say in our company,
  338. 10:3695% of people use one of these AI tools
  339. 10:40like Anthropic or ChatGPT or Gemini
  340. 10:42every day.
  341. 10:43>> Right.
  342. 10:43>> And that exists on some kind of spectrum
  343. 10:45of like the super users that are using
  344. 10:47it probably, you know, every hour of
  345. 10:49every day for almost everything to, you
  346. 10:52know, someone maybe hiring the executive
  347. 10:54team that's using it less because their
  348. 10:55job doesn't require of it as much.
  349. 10:57>> Right.
  350. 10:58>> And when you look out into the world at,
  351. 11:00you know,
  352. 11:01at how the world is changing from a
  353. 11:03content perspective if we're looking at
  354. 11:04generative AI, it is obvious that
  355. 11:07these tools are being widely adopted.
  356. 11:09Part of the symptom is the AI slop you
  357. 11:11see all over the internet.
  358. 11:12>> Right.
  359. 11:13>> So, I I don't know
  360. 11:14this this this idea that it's not being
  361. 11:17used I struggle with.
  362. 11:19>> It's being used. Here's the thing with
  363. 11:21the slop. Before we had AI slop, we had
  364. 11:24SEO slop because Google incentivized
  365. 11:27doing the lowest common denominator that
  366. 11:28would rank well in search. And that's a
  367. 11:30whole story about how they pulled back
  368. 11:31spam guards, thanks to Prabhakar
  369. 11:33Raghavan, which we can get into,
  370. 11:35where they made the internet worse by
  371. 11:36allowing worse content to rank higher.
  372. 11:39It's why we have when you used to
  373. 11:40Google, oh, best washing machine,
  374. 11:43there's 11 different horrible blogs that
  375. 11:45read like somebody got a concussion.
  376. 11:47They are built to rank rather than be
  377. 11:49read by humans or built to be good made
  378. 11:51good.
  379. 11:52So, AI helps weaponize that at scale.
  380. 11:55Yeah, you can make a bunch of generic
  381. 11:57slop. We've had slop for years. We've
  382. 11:59just found a slop machine. But then also
  383. 12:01there's the problem of cost. So, when
  384. 12:03you use AI services, you burn tokens.
  385. 12:05And it's per million tokens.
  386. 12:07>> What's a token?
  387. 12:08>> So, it's around 3/4 of a word.
  388. 12:10So, so it's characters.
  389. 12:12>> So, the AI companies have a currency in
  390. 12:14which they charge you like a taxi in New
  391. 12:16York has a meter.
  392. 12:17>> Yeah.
  393. 12:17>> And they call it tokens.
  394. 12:19>> Yeah.
  395. 12:20>> And every word, let's just say for ease
  396. 12:22it's a word. You're paying per word.
  397. 12:24>> a word, yeah. And it's per million
  398. 12:25tokens. So, you'll be charged per
  399. 12:27million input tokens, the stuff you're
  400. 12:29feeding into it, like a document or a
  401. 12:31bunch base. And the output tokens are
  402. 12:33both the stuff it spits out at the end,
  403. 12:35but also when it thinks. So, okay,
  404. 12:37you've asked me to give you the best
  405. 12:39restaurants in this area of New York. I
  406. 12:41should find the best restaurants in New
  407. 12:42York. All of that's output tokens as
  408. 12:43well.
  409. 12:44>> Mhm.
  410. 12:44>> However, when you're paying for a
  411. 12:46monthly service, you don't see any of
  412. 12:48that. All that put all that crap to the
  413. 12:49side. They just have rate limits. So,
  414. 12:51you can use them a certain amount and
  415. 12:53then when you run out, but they kind of
  416. 12:54obfuscate what that was. Now,
  417. 12:56someone recently found semi-analysis
  418. 12:57actually found this, a big analyst
  419. 12:59group, they found that on a $200 a month
  420. 13:02ChatGPT subscription, you can burn
  421. 13:04$14,000
  422. 13:06worth of tokens.
  423. 13:08And on Anthropic's, you can burn $8,000
  424. 13:10for
  425. 13:12200 bucks.
  426. 13:13That is how most And then even on the 20
  427. 13:15buck a month service, you can burn $400.
  428. 13:17Now, most people don't realize that.
  429. 13:19Most people have no idea what AI costs.
  430. 13:22Most people just think, oh, it's 20
  431. 13:23bucks a month. No, all of these
  432. 13:25companies run at a horrifying loss. Open
  433. 13:28AI lost $20.9 billion last year because
  434. 13:31people can burn as many tokens as they
  435. 13:32want. And when they tried to move
  436. 13:35everybody on the enterprise side, so
  437. 13:36companies bigger than 150, onto actually
  438. 13:39paying the cost of AI in around March of
  439. 13:422026, to quote Sam Altman, they said
  440. 13:44people have a big problem with it. I
  441. 13:46think it's a huge issue, which is not
  442. 13:48really what the
  443. 13:49heir apparent of tech's history is meant
  444. 13:52to be saying, but the point is
  445. 13:53enterprises immediately started freaking
  446. 13:55out. Uber burned through their entire
  447. 13:57annual token budget in 3 months. So,
  448. 14:00suddenly, after everyone's saying AI is
  449. 14:02the most productive thing ever, it's
  450. 14:03amazing, it's changing everything, the
  451. 14:05moment people actually had to pay for
  452. 14:06it, they go,
  453. 14:07>> [snorts]
  454. 14:08>> Oof, I don't know, actually. Um, maybe
  455. 14:10it's it's obviously we all love it. It's
  456. 14:12all great, right?
  457. 14:14But it's costing too much, so we now
  458. 14:16need to reduce the cost because people
  459. 14:17just dumping stuff into it, being like,
  460. 14:19what do I do here? And getting whatever
  461. 14:21the median is out because that's what
  462. 14:23these things do. They provide the median
  463. 14:25answer.
  464. 14:26>> So, essentially, someone like me who's a
  465. 14:28power user of these tools,
  466. 14:30I could be costing Anthropic or Open AI
  467. 14:33a thousand dollars, but they're only
  468. 14:35charging me a hundred dollars, let's
  469. 14:37say. So, they are having to subsidize
  470. 14:39nine hundred dollars of my usage because
  471. 14:41of the electricity costs and the costs
  472. 14:43at their data centers. And so, your
  473. 14:45assertion here is that that is
  474. 14:46unsustainable.
  475. 14:47>> Yes. And just to be clear, they're
  476. 14:49probably not one-for-one dollar. It
  477. 14:50might be 34. We don't We don't know. I
  478. 14:52think it's unprofitable. These companies
  479. 14:54don't disclose them. Even in their
  480. 14:55audited financials, they play funny
  481. 14:57games with how they categorize things.
  482. 14:58But, nevertheless, yes.
  483. 15:00And on top of that, the way that you
  484. 15:02stand up inference, which is the thing
  485. 15:04that creates the output within these
  486. 15:06data centers,
  487. 15:07you're not just saying, "Okay, turn the
  488. 15:09inference machine on, let's go." You are
  489. 15:12standing up the GPUs necessary to take
  490. 15:14in the demand. And if you buy too much,
  491. 15:17you've wasted the money. You have You
  492. 15:19have to pay for the hourly GPU use
  493. 15:20regardless. If you buy too few, your
  494. 15:23customers can't use it. They get pissed
  495. 15:24off at you. They cancel. They go with
  496. 15:25someone else. But nevertheless, yeah,
  497. 15:27they would get demand selling $20 or $40
  498. 15:30for a dollar. And that's what these
  499. 15:31services do. And really, the simplest
  500. 15:33way to explain it is they were actually
  501. 15:35profitable if they were actually just
  502. 15:37they believed that these services were
  503. 15:38worthwhile and that they were worthy of
  504. 15:40the cost, they'd charge it. Regular
  505. 15:42people wouldn't be able to get a monthly
  506. 15:44subscription. They just be paying what
  507. 15:47it's worth. Unless, of course, there was
  508. 15:49an economic problem. And it's very
  509. 15:50simple.
  510. 15:52You pay when you use an LLM regardless
  511. 15:55of whether you get what you want. When
  512. 15:56these things hallucinate, say you're
  513. 15:58doing something with you're coding
  514. 15:59something and they
  515. 16:00go through a code base and they up
  516. 16:02a bunch of stuff and they break a bunch
  517. 16:03of stuff. You're paying for that. You're
  518. 16:04paying for it whether it works or not.
  519. 16:06Unless, of course, you're using one of
  520. 16:07these subscriptions.
  521. 16:08>> I think that the really interesting
  522. 16:10point is
  523. 16:11are they spending ahead of the value
  524. 16:15showing up,
  525. 16:17which is I imagine what they would
  526. 16:18argue, or are they spending all of this
  527. 16:21money and subsidizing all of their users
  528. 16:24in a way that's unsustainable and that
  529. 16:26will never be justified? Like doesn't
  530. 16:28you know, cuz you think back through the
  531. 16:29history of technology, you often get
  532. 16:31people
  533. 16:32losing money to grab market share.
  534. 16:34>> Right.
  535. 16:35>> And they're also focusing on bringing
  536. 16:37the costs down
  537. 16:39and making it more profitable for them
  538. 16:41as well. But they can't afford to under
  539. 16:43invest.
  540. 16:44>> If they were bringing the cost down,
  541. 16:46they would have brought the cost down,
  542. 16:47which they have not. It seems to be
  543. 16:49getting more expensive. In fact,
  544. 16:51everyone inference providers don't seem
  545. 16:52to be profitable. Even the companies
  546. 16:54renting out GPUs don't seem to be
  547. 16:56profitable. I imagine that it wasn't
  548. 16:58like they started out and they were
  549. 17:00like, "Shit, this is unprofitable at the
  550. 17:01beginning. We know it. Screw it. We'll
  551. 17:03keep doing it anyway. We'll screw I
  552. 17:04don't think it's some big conspiracy.
  553. 17:06They probably thought at some point,
  554. 17:08"Yeah, this will go profitable. The
  555. 17:10chips will catch up. Customers will pay
  556. 17:12for the overwhelming value." Because you
  557. 17:13don't know in 2023 where it's going to
  558. 17:15be in 2026. You assume it's going to go
  559. 17:17up. That's the nature of venture
  560. 17:18capital.
  561. 17:19They should have stopped in like 2024
  562. 17:21when OpenAI lost over $5 billion. They
  563. 17:24should have been like, "Yep, this is not
  564. 17:25going to work." But they kept going
  565. 17:27because it helped number go up so much.
  566. 17:30It helped stock values pump. It helped
  567. 17:32everyone pump. It helped Nvidia pump,
  568. 17:34Microsoft, everyone. And not from the
  569. 17:36revenues. Because here's the funny thing
  570. 17:38about Google, Microsoft, and Amazon.
  571. 17:40People for years have been saying their
  572. 17:43AI bets have paid off. Wow, their AI
  573. 17:45bets have paid off. As these companies
  574. 17:46refuse to say how much they're making
  575. 17:48from AI. But because their existing
  576. 17:50businesses continue to grow and did so,
  577. 17:52by the way, through price increases,
  578. 17:54changes to how Google and Meta
  579. 17:56uh did advertising. Amazon bumped up
  580. 17:59prices and changed how they did
  581. 18:00Actually, Amazon started a remarkable ad
  582. 18:02business during this whole time as well.
  583. 18:04And the selling through Amazon platform.
  584. 18:05Anyway, nothing to do with AI. But
  585. 18:07because number go up, cuz revenue go up,
  586. 18:09everyone
  587. 18:10it's AI. Because these companies
  588. 18:11wouldn't spend a trillion dollars for
  589. 18:13for no reason. For right?
  590. 18:15Except in fiscal year 2026, which just
  591. 18:18ended for Microsoft. Annoying, I know.
  592. 18:20They made, total according to Bloomberg,
  593. 18:23about 34.33 billion dollars. 24.1
  594. 18:26billion dollars of that was from OpenAI.
  595. 18:28So that leaves them with about 10
  596. 18:30billion dollars in a year when they
  597. 18:31spent 115 billion on capital
  598. 18:33expenditures and intend to spend 175
  599. 18:36billion next year.
  600. 18:37The math does not make sense. I imagine
  601. 18:40their plan was, "Okay, this is just
  602. 18:41going to get exponentially more valuable
  603. 18:43and then at some point the costs will be
  604. 18:45outpaced by the return."
  605. 18:47Problem is that large language models
  606. 18:49need a bunch of money to train them.
  607. 18:50They need constant data flows through.
  608. 18:52They need customized data. It's just
  609. 18:54this big expensive monster. And when you
  610. 18:57try and talk to people about it, and you
  611. 18:59try and say, "Hey look, this is really
  612. 19:01bad. Nvidia has
  613. 19:03sold There's 215.9
  614. 19:06billion dollars in the last fiscal year
  615. 19:07with the GPUs mostly.
  616. 19:10And you try and go, "Yeah, that's the
  617. 19:11support like
  618. 19:13$22 billion dollars revenue total in the
  619. 19:16entire world outside of these two
  620. 19:18companies that literally require money
  621. 19:20being fed into them sometimes by Nvidia
  622. 19:22to keep alive.
  623. 19:24When you tell people that they go,
  624. 19:25"Well, companies just lose money,
  625. 19:26right?" Companies because we have this
  626. 19:28quote Ed Elson from Property Markets, we
  627. 19:30have this cult-like worship of the
  628. 19:32wealthy. Where we think that someone
  629. 19:34wouldn't spend all this money for no
  630. 19:35reason, right? Because reconciling with
  631. 19:37that, with this idea that
  632. 19:40the ultra-wealthy, the ultra-powerful
  633. 19:42didn't get there through big brains,
  634. 19:45they didn't get there through
  635. 19:47anything other than luck and opportunity
  636. 19:49sermon, getting an MBA perhaps with the
  637. 19:51right people, that they just got there
  638. 19:53because they're regular people and they
  639. 19:55just happen to be in the right place at
  640. 19:56the right time. Reconciling with that
  641. 19:57and realizing that the world is not
  642. 19:58controlled by people like a meritocracy
  643. 20:01is kind of grim. So, it's easy to be
  644. 20:02like,
  645. 20:03"No, they're not making a mistake. I
  646. 20:05must be missing something." And that's
  647. 20:07what they want.
  648. 20:08>> So, I you know, I think back through the
  649. 20:09history of technological breakthroughs
  650. 20:11and I think about I mean, you can look
  651. 20:13at different industries and one of my
  652. 20:14favorite books on this subject is The
  653. 20:16Innovator's Dilemma.
  654. 20:17>> I've read it.
  655. 20:17>> And one of the things it talks about is
  656. 20:19how the
  657. 20:20the innovation that ends up taking out
  658. 20:22or transforming an industry
  659. 20:25often starts worse, doesn't make
  660. 20:28economic sense, none of your customers
  661. 20:30are asking for it. And this is typically
  662. 20:31why we end up ignoring it. So, like,
  663. 20:33you've got horse and carriages in the
  664. 20:341800s.
  665. 20:35>> Mhm.
  666. 20:36>> Amazing form of transport according to
  667. 20:37the 1800s, you know, people of the
  668. 20:391800s. And then you have this thing
  669. 20:40called cars come along. Now, the problem
  670. 20:42with cars is they broke down all the
  671. 20:43time. It's kind of like AI hallucinates
  672. 20:45now. Um they were more expensive and the
  673. 20:47the economics of it didn't make sense.
  674. 20:48You might as well walk than buy a car.
  675. 20:50There was a law at the time that meant
  676. 20:52you had to walk in front of it with a
  677. 20:53red flag and wave and someone had to get
  678. 20:55to employ someone to walk in front of it
  679. 20:56waving a red flag. Obviously, it's
  680. 20:58worse. It's like a worse solution.
  681. 21:00However,
  682. 21:01these things that are disruptive
  683. 21:02innovations, they have a higher ceiling
  684. 21:05of growth and so they eventually
  685. 21:07overtake the horse.
  686. 21:09And I when I think about that analogy in
  687. 21:10the context of all of this, I go,
  688. 21:12"Okay, it's imperfect at the at the
  689. 21:14moment. The economic models aren't
  690. 21:16perfectly ironed out. They're still
  691. 21:18figuring out how to make it cheaper, the
  692. 21:20infrastructure, etc. But as if you think
  693. 21:22about the rate of improvement versus
  694. 21:24other, you know,
  695. 21:26let's say coding, how much could I train
  696. 21:28a human coder to improve and to increase
  697. 21:31their output versus an AI agent? One
  698. 21:33would go, if you just imagine any rate
  699. 21:35of improvement in these AI tools,
  700. 21:37at some point, if you just imagine a 5%
  701. 21:39rate of improvement per month, at some
  702. 21:42point, it's
  703. 21:43you know, and then you imagine a 5%
  704. 21:44reduction in cost, which is what we did
  705. 21:46with the internet, what we did with
  706. 21:47cars.
  707. 21:48>> Yeah, but that's Moore's Law.
  708. 21:49>> Moore's Law is a theory, and Moore's Law
  709. 21:50is not with GPUs. So, let me let me
  710. 21:53actually explain. So, Nvidia.
  711. 21:55Nvidia invented, I think it was in the
  712. 21:562000s, they put out something called
  713. 21:57CUDA, which is the underlying software
  714. 22:00library and the way to run software on
  715. 22:02GPUs. Took them some a decade or more to
  716. 22:06make it something where they you could
  717. 22:07do data analytics, one of the early
  718. 22:09things, mapper and such. And then when
  719. 22:11AI came along, they'd had lots of
  720. 22:12experience with it. But nevertheless,
  721. 22:13this company has got more money, more
  722. 22:16attention,
  723. 22:18more geniuses behind them, more people
  724. 22:20focused on making their things more
  725. 22:22efficient than anyone could ever ask
  726. 22:24for.
  727. 22:24>> And Nvidia, for anyone that doesn't
  728. 22:25know, makes the chips.
  729. 22:27>> They So, and that CUDA thing I
  730. 22:29mentioned, they were the ones with CUDA,
  731. 22:30and CUDA allowed generative AI to grow.
  732. 22:32>> Okay, so they're they're chips.
  733. 22:34>> Chips, yes.
  734. 22:34>> And chips are needed. Those are the
  735. 22:35things that go into the data centers.
  736. 22:37>> chips are the ones where you can run AI
  737. 22:39software on it. So, the training runs
  738. 22:41and also the inference. Now, here's the
  739. 22:43thing. The the car example.
  740. 22:45Back then, you didn't have pretty much
  741. 22:48every mathematician and scientist going
  742. 22:49into the car industry. You didn't have
  743. 22:51the combined world's governments never
  744. 22:53shutting up about this. And by the way,
  745. 22:55giving them credit early. Since 2023,
  746. 22:59they've been saying this is inevitable.
  747. 23:00Even what you said, 5% improvement, I
  748. 23:03don't even know how you'd measure that
  749. 23:04because a junior software engineer can
  750. 23:06still experience things and learn things
  751. 23:09from context, from how people deal with
  752. 23:11problems. And the way that people deal
  753. 23:13with problems is not as simple as
  754. 23:14looking at the code or reading some
  755. 23:16emails. It's context you get from
  756. 23:17speaking to a person. It's being in
  757. 23:19different environments. And there may
  758. 23:22There are uses for LLMs in coding. I
  759. 23:24don't dispute that. But even saying 5%
  760. 23:27better, what does that mean? Is it
  761. 23:28better at Rust? Is it better at C++?
  762. 23:30>> productivity. So just like, yeah,
  763. 23:32shipped If we did it in the context of
  764. 23:34coding, it would be like shipped code.
  765. 23:36>> That's the thing. That would be like,
  766. 23:37he's the best writer in the world cuz
  767. 23:39his newsletter is really long. That's an
  768. 23:41insane way of valuing it. With coding,
  769. 23:43it would be I mean, it's even difficult
  770. 23:45to evaluate because it's Is the software
  771. 23:48out there better? Is actually a great
  772. 23:49way of evaluating it. And I would say
  773. 23:51uniformly not. I would say the standard
  774. 23:54of software across Google, Microsoft,
  775. 23:56Amazon, Meta especially. God, Meta is a
  776. 23:58monstrosity. Is worse. GitHub GitHub
  777. 24:02Someone posted on Twitter earlier today,
  778. 24:04we should get a notification when GitHub
  779. 24:05is up rather than when it's down because
  780. 24:07that would be more reliable. Microsoft
  781. 24:09is one of the largest companies in the
  782. 24:10world and they can barely wipe their own
  783. 24:11ass when it comes to GitHub.
  784. 24:13The quality of software is going down.
  785. 24:15Weirdly enough, as more people use LLMs
  786. 24:18and more businesses demand, and I really
  787. 24:20do mean demand, that people use these
  788. 24:22services.
  789. 24:23>> So on this point of If we go back to
  790. 24:24this horse and carriage and car analogy,
  791. 24:27say that we're at whatever point today.
  792. 24:29If you imagine any rate of improvement
  793. 24:31in the technology, which we have seen
  794. 24:33since ChatGPT came out.
  795. 24:34>> Sure.
  796. 24:34>> I remember when ChatGPT came out and I
  797. 24:35was in Asia and I was there showing it
  798. 24:37to my fiance. I was like, look, he can
  799. 24:38do this. And it was hallucinating once
  800. 24:40in a while and getting things wrong. I
  801. 24:41actually don't have that experience
  802. 24:43anymore. I have moments where I believe
  803. 24:46its reasoning is weak,
  804. 24:48but I don't have outright hallucinations
  805. 24:50anymore.
  806. 24:51>> See that? I I disagree.
  807. 24:54>> So give me an example of a what you
  808. 24:55define as a hallucination.
  809. 24:56>> Okay, great one. So I have a Bloomberg
  810. 24:57terminal. Yeah. The very useful thing
  811. 24:59they have on there is Ask B. So, when
  812. 25:01you do a Bloomberg inquiry to like look
  813. 25:02up what we think Nvidia's revenue is
  814. 25:05going to be next quarter, it runs
  815. 25:07something called BQL, which is its own
  816. 25:08programming language. Now, instead of
  817. 25:10having to learn that, you can just type
  818. 25:13into Ask B and it will generate it and
  819. 25:14run it for you. And so, you get pulled
  820. 25:16up and you know where the data is coming
  821. 25:17from. It deals with hallucinations very
  822. 25:18well. The other day, I was like, "You
  823. 25:20know what? Get a little spicy. I'm going
  824. 25:22to look up the growth rate of stocks of
  825. 25:25Microsoft, Google, Meta, and Amazon over
  826. 25:28the course of 5 years, I think it was."
  827. 25:29>> Yeah.
  828. 25:30>> And I was about to I was copy-pasted it
  829. 25:32over to something, looked at it in
  830. 25:33Excel. I was about to I was writing the
  831. 25:35newsletter. I went, "Microsoft stock's
  832. 25:37never been $575 a stock."
  833. 25:41You know what? When it's a cute little
  834. 25:42thing like, "Oh, it's a stock price."
  835. 25:44and I kind of caught it, it was no harm,
  836. 25:45no foul. That's fine.
  837. 25:47But when you're talking about, I don't
  838. 25:48know, like a
  839. 25:49transcribing tool for a doctor or a
  840. 25:52financial model that a hedge fund is
  841. 25:53dependent on,
  842. 25:55at that point, it becomes a little more
  843. 25:57dangerous.
  844. 25:59And the thing is, a hallucination with a
  845. 26:01software
  846. 26:02package, for example, you're refactoring
  847. 26:04a code base and it leaves a door open
  848. 26:06security-wise, or it just breaks
  849. 26:08something, and you, I don't know, maybe
  850. 26:10you've been vibe coding for 6 months.
  851. 26:12You haven't really been coding with your
  852. 26:13own hands for a while. You've maybe
  853. 26:14forgotten a few things. You have this
  854. 26:16slop to look for. You have to
  855. 26:17know what I'm not doing it.
  856. 26:19And so, the problem has become
  857. 26:21multiplicative. And I don't really know
  858. 26:23how you train them out of that, and
  859. 26:25they've certainly not succeeded. So, on
  860. 26:28one hand, they have got better, but one
  861. 26:31of the main ways they evaluate them
  862. 26:32getting better are benchmarks that are
  863. 26:34adjusted specifically for large language
  864. 26:36models, cuz you can't just have them do
  865. 26:39tasks. They've got better at that. They
  866. 26:41found some tasks they can have them do
  867. 26:42on. But even them, like Meta, m e t a.
  868. 26:45They have this thing where it's like,
  869. 26:46"Check out this chart. Look how much
  870. 26:47better it's getting at running tasks.
  871. 26:48Wow, it can go for an hour." And then
  872. 26:50you look at it, and it's like, "Yeah,
  873. 26:51and successfully completing them 50% of
  874. 26:53the time.
  875. 26:54>> They they have a hallucination
  876. 26:55leaderboard and it really focuses on
  877. 26:57basic tasks and it shows that the
  878. 26:58four-year trend according to historical
  879. 27:00data from the Fictoria hallucination
  880. 27:03leaderboard shows that hallucination
  881. 27:05rates on simple summarization tasks have
  882. 27:07plummeted from around 21% 21.8% 4 years
  883. 27:11ago down to 0.7%
  884. 27:14roughly on today's top frontier models
  885. 27:16like Gemini and ChatGPT. Again, the
  886. 27:19point of nuance here is that these are
  887. 27:21on simple tasks which is kind of what
  888. 27:23I've experienced. I've experienced it on
  889. 27:24day-to-day things that hallucinates
  890. 27:25less. Again, rate of improvement
  891. 27:27thinking. So, if I just imagine
  892. 27:30the trajectory to continue,
  893. 27:32there is going to become a time where
  894. 27:33hallucinations become rarer than they
  895. 27:35are today increasingly. And also I'd say
  896. 27:38is when I think about other
  897. 27:39technologies, there's two more points.
  898. 27:41Other technologies at their inception
  899. 27:42when they first came to the world like
  900. 27:44the internet also had technical
  901. 27:46difficulties. I remember growing up with
  902. 27:48dial-up modems and I couldn't go on the
  903. 27:50phone at the same time as going on the
  904. 27:51internet. I'd have to stop RuneScape
  905. 27:53upstairs to go on the phone. And you
  906. 27:55thought that this is crap this is crap
  907. 27:56technology crap all the
  908. 27:57>> What? I don't know, mate. I loved it.
  909. 27:59>> Yeah, I know. You It felt like magic and
  910. 28:01then in hindsight you go, wow, I now
  911. 28:03have Starlink and 5G internet from my
  912. 28:05phone. It's unbelievable. You couldn't
  913. 28:07leave the house with internet before.
  914. 28:09And that's what I mean by the rate of
  915. 28:10improvement thinking. I'd say the last
  916. 28:12point is we often compare
  917. 28:15AI to perfection,
  918. 28:17>> right?
  919. 28:18>> whereas that's not actually the
  920. 28:19alternative.
  921. 28:20In the working world, like if I wanted
  922. 28:22to do let's say a simple writing task,
  923. 28:25I'm I should compare AI to my
  924. 28:27alternative alternative way of doing
  925. 28:29that simple writing task which is both
  926. 28:31measured in my time,
  927. 28:33right? And my ability to hallucinate as
  928. 28:34a person who doesn't know everything.
  929. 28:37At all if I'm hiring someone,
  930. 28:39an intern who might also be prone to
  931. 28:41hallucination or have gaps in their
  932. 28:43knowledge.
  933. 28:44So, it's not actually like we're
  934. 28:45comparing we should compare AI to
  935. 28:46perfection. it's AI to the other
  936. 28:48alternatives. And if someone
  937. 28:49hallucinates 0.7% of the time, but knows
  938. 28:52way more and is faster, maybe on a net
  939. 28:56basis that's a good trade. Maybe I
  940. 28:58should use AI.
  941. 28:58>> So, let's start with an example. Someone
  942. 29:01I love dearly, Matt Hughes, my editor.
  943. 29:03He's He's a side of Liverpool, wonderful
  944. 29:05guy.
  945. 29:06I don't pay Matt Hughes because he knows
  946. 29:08everything. I pay him because he has
  947. 29:10incredible context and a ton of
  948. 29:12knowledge and is willing to expand it
  949. 29:14and work with me. And moral support,
  950. 29:16he's a great editor, but he's also
  951. 29:18someone who gets into the guts of it and
  952. 29:20has the experiences of it. He's a
  953. 29:22decorated tech journalist. And on top of
  954. 29:24that, a wonderful loving being with
  955. 29:27empathy and joy in his heart for the
  956. 29:29stuff he loves and absolute
  957. 29:30venom for the people he hates. That's
  958. 29:32the I can't get that from a large
  959. 29:33language model. But on top of that, I
  960. 29:35don't I push back on just the assumption
  961. 29:37that
  962. 29:38when you say knows everything, what good
  963. 29:40is something that knows everything when
  964. 29:42it sometimes doesn't know anything? When
  965. 29:43it sometimes and on The thing is, are
  966. 29:45you really paying an intern for
  967. 29:47something basic? Are you really going to
  968. 29:49them and saying, "Yeah, can you look up
  969. 29:51what the date is?" No, you're doing that
  970. 29:52on Google. Whatever the task is, you are
  971. 29:55trying to also train an intern. The
  972. 29:57point of an intern is to train them and
  973. 29:59turn them in take them out of Pinocchio
  974. 30:00status.
  975. 30:02But it's also An intern learns. An
  976. 30:03intern gets context. An intern learns
  977. 30:05your habits. Learns your
  978. 30:06>> gets context and learns.
  979. 30:07>> No, it doesn't.
  980. 30:08>> And AI doesn't learn.
  981. 30:09>> I mean, it doesn't. The way it learns is
  982. 30:11you create a giant Claude the MD file
  983. 30:14that it sometimes doesn't read,
  984. 30:15sometimes does read. You create a
  985. 30:17harness, you put It's like It's
  986. 30:18Pee-wee's breakfast machine from
  987. 30:20Pee-wee's Playhouse. You have to do all
  988. 30:21these contrivances to mitigate the
  989. 30:24hallucinations and even then at the end,
  990. 30:26how much effort have you put in?
  991. 30:28>> But so okay, this is an extreme
  992. 30:29simplified example. If I went on my
  993. 30:31Claude now and said, "What's my dog's my
  994. 30:32dog's name?"
  995. 30:33>> Uh-huh.
  996. 30:33>> It would know my dog's name.
  997. 30:35>> Jesus Christ, this This company raised
  998. 30:3695 billion dollars this year.
  999. 30:39>> I'm using an extreme simplified example
  1000. 30:40to show that it can remember things from
  1001. 30:42the past. Obviously, it knows much more
  1002. 30:44complex things as well, but I just use
  1003. 30:46that as an example. So, we we we accept
  1004. 30:48the fact that it can it does have memory
  1005. 30:50of the past.
  1006. 30:51>> It has files it can access that have
  1007. 30:52stuff on it, but that's
  1008. 30:54>> Yeah.
  1009. 30:54>> not the same as memory. And it's also
  1010. 30:56just Okay, so it remembers your dog's
  1011. 30:58name. It might remember your habits. It
  1012. 31:00might be able to read things you've said
  1013. 31:01before.
  1014. 31:02>> Yeah.
  1015. 31:03>> Does it know your moods? Does it know
  1016. 31:05what's going on in the world around it?
  1017. 31:06Does it have good days and bad days? Is
  1018. 31:08it there for you? Because it's just a
  1019. 31:09text machine. And the thing is
  1020. 31:12the intern example.
  1021. 31:14An intern is something that can grow.
  1022. 31:16It's something that you invest in.
  1023. 31:17That's not something you do through
  1024. 31:18feeding files and text to it. The way
  1025. 31:21that we store memories ourselves, the
  1026. 31:23way in which we accrue experiences is a
  1027. 31:26a maelstrom of emotion and feelings and
  1028. 31:30facts.
  1029. 31:30>> Completely different. So,
  1030. 31:31I think there's two things here. There's
  1031. 31:33the process in which something happens,
  1032. 31:35and then there's the output.
  1033. 31:36>> Uh-huh.
  1034. 31:37>> So, the process you were describing the
  1035. 31:38process of how a human does memory.
  1036. 31:40>> Right.
  1037. 31:40>> The way that an AI does memory is
  1038. 31:42different, but the thing that people
  1039. 31:45care about is there value in the output.
  1040. 31:47I.e., you know, if I dump all of my
  1041. 31:49files into Claude, I don't really care
  1042. 31:51how it processes it as long as when I
  1043. 31:53ask it
  1044. 31:54"What's my revenue?" it has the number.
  1045. 31:56And one could say the same thing about
  1046. 31:57training someone. You could say you
  1047. 31:59teach them, you put lots of effort into
  1048. 32:00them, you give them lots of context, you
  1049. 32:02you educate them and give them
  1050. 32:04experiences, and then you might come and
  1051. 32:05say to them, "By the way, what's my
  1052. 32:07revenue?" Now, the processes are
  1053. 32:08entirely different, but the outcome is
  1054. 32:10what I care about. Do they know the
  1055. 32:11revenue number when I ask them?
  1056. 32:13And so, I think that's the part that we
  1057. 32:14sometimes get lost in. We get we, you
  1058. 32:16know, cuz I have I've heard this debate
  1059. 32:17about like can AI be creative?
  1060. 32:19>> Right.
  1061. 32:19>> I think like the way to answer that
  1062. 32:21question is like it's about the output.
  1063. 32:23When I ask it to do a creative thing,
  1064. 32:25does it give me the answer? Not is the
  1065. 32:27process the same as a human process.
  1066. 32:29Cuz actually, no no who cares what the
  1067. 32:31People care about they pay for the
  1068. 32:33outcome, the product.
  1069. 32:34>> I actually disagree about the process
  1070. 32:37because
  1071. 32:38Matt Levine, for example.
  1072. 32:39>> Your editor.
  1073. 32:40>> Yeah. Yeah. Watching him go down a
  1074. 32:42rabbit hole and being there with him and
  1075. 32:44actually vice versa, him doing the same
  1076. 32:45thing. We wrote these Well, I mean, we
  1077. 32:48were working on the research. I ended up
  1078. 32:49sitting there for like the
  1079. 32:51day-long session of writing 11,000 words
  1080. 32:53and he he had given me a bunch of notes.
  1081. 32:55It was actually just Even describing
  1082. 32:57that process, I feel so happy cuz it was
  1083. 32:59like us being like, "I can't believe how
  1084. 33:01these Jesus Christ, they can't do
  1085. 33:03They're just like the
  1086. 33:04misanthropy of just the horrible cynical
  1087. 33:07people of asset managers like
  1088. 33:08Blackstone, just learning about them and
  1089. 33:10being like, "It can't be this." and
  1090. 33:11having a back and forth with him. That
  1091. 33:13is fundamentally different because we
  1092. 33:15were both learning together and the
  1093. 33:16learning process was as much about
  1094. 33:18creating the output as the output
  1095. 33:20itself. When you learn something, you're
  1096. 33:21not creating the average, which really
  1097. 33:24is what these things do, of the
  1098. 33:26documents it could find. You're not
  1099. 33:28getting particularly novel outputs. If I
  1100. 33:31needed a generic slop output, sure, but
  1101. 33:34I've I've used some of the higher-end
  1102. 33:36LLM harness machines that the hedge
  1103. 33:39funds use and they all get the same
  1104. 33:40shite. It's all the same the same
  1105. 33:42generic reports, the same "Oh, we
  1106. 33:44noticed this analysis." Things that you
  1107. 33:45can find on any kind of AI slop out
  1108. 33:47there.
  1109. 33:48>> What you described to me there, what I
  1110. 33:49heard anyway, is there's two points of
  1111. 33:51value you're getting from your time with
  1112. 33:52that. I mean, I mean, there's many more,
  1113. 33:54but you said you're you're learning and
  1114. 33:56then you're getting this book edited
  1115. 33:58blog blog You're getting a blog edited,
  1116. 34:00which is the output, and you're getting
  1117. 34:02learning and you're also really getting
  1118. 34:03connection and all these other things.
  1119. 34:05>> But when I come to when people sort of
  1120. 34:06think about the value of AI, of course
  1121. 34:08they could use it to learn, but in the
  1122. 34:09example I gave of like repeat my revenue
  1123. 34:11number back to me or do this number, I
  1124. 34:13am I just care about the output. I could
  1125. 34:14use it to learn.
  1126. 34:15>> What if What if What if the What if the
  1127. 34:16revenue number was wrong once? You
  1128. 34:18should have defined deterministic ways
  1129. 34:21of knowing those numbers. You should not
  1130. 34:23rely on them. Even with the terminal
  1131. 34:24running BQL, which I trust, I will
  1132. 34:27double triple treble-check everything
  1133. 34:29just to be sure. Partly because also the
  1134. 34:31process of learning for me, I don't want
  1135. 34:33just to report I
  1136. 34:35go like that. I want something that I
  1137. 34:36fully understand and also understand the
  1138. 34:38context around it.
  1139. 34:40I don't think that LLMs do that and I
  1140. 34:42just don't see them getting better in a
  1141. 34:45way that does that because it's
  1142. 34:48it's just not what they do. And also,
  1143. 34:50there's the other problem of
  1144. 34:51the more detailed the report, the more
  1145. 34:52likely there are things to be wrong with
  1146. 34:54it. If you are with Matt Hughes, for
  1147. 34:56example, I can trust he's got it right.
  1148. 34:58I can trust he understood and I can
  1149. 35:00trust that I can have a back and forth
  1150. 35:01with him that will inform me if I've
  1151. 35:03missed something. I can read the stuff
  1152. 35:05that he's read and actually trust him
  1153. 35:08because there's a big trust part as
  1154. 35:09well.
  1155. 35:10>> What is the basis of your trust in Matt?
  1156. 35:12Could it be his historical performance?
  1157. 35:16>> I mean, yes.
  1158. 35:17>> Okay.
  1159. 35:17>> And also, the fact we've learned half of
  1160. 35:19this stuff together.
  1161. 35:20>> But but tenure tenure doesn't
  1162. 35:22necessarily There's probably people you
  1163. 35:23know for 15 years who you also don't
  1164. 35:24trust.
  1165. 35:25>> Yes.
  1166. 35:25>> So, I think I was trying to figure out
  1167. 35:26like what is the what is the thing
  1168. 35:27that's causing humans to trust another
  1169. 35:29thing and I guess it would be continual
  1170. 35:31delivery of a commitment made of sorts.
  1171. 35:34And so, with Claude, for example, on
  1172. 35:37simple tasks as we've seen from the
  1173. 35:38hallucination leaderboard, it
  1174. 35:40continually delivers for people and
  1175. 35:42that's why we've seen the fastest
  1176. 35:44>> that what that board says?
  1177. 35:45>> Well, it's it's saying like is it
  1178. 35:47getting it wrong? Is it hallucinating?
  1179. 35:48>> On simple tasks.
  1180. 35:49>> Simple tasks, yeah.
  1181. 35:50>> How are those defined?
  1182. 35:51>> I don't know.
  1183. 35:51>> That's the thing though because this is
  1184. 35:53actually a very very illustrative thing
  1185. 35:55of the AI industry.
  1186. 35:56They are the what about is masters. They
  1187. 35:59have like, well, look, we've got this
  1188. 36:01we've got this benchmark that says we're
  1189. 36:02good at this and look, the number's
  1190. 36:04higher. What's the number mean? Uh uh
  1191. 36:06uh you know. What's that mean? And I'm
  1192. 36:07not using this as a critic against you.
  1193. 36:09It's
  1194. 36:10when you can't give a direct answer, you
  1195. 36:12give a side answer. When you as the LLM
  1196. 36:14industry want to prove your worth, you
  1197. 36:16can't just be like, just use the
  1198. 36:18product. When the first iPhone came out,
  1199. 36:20I was at Penn State at the time. Ooh, I
  1200. 36:22felt like the apes at the beginning of
  1201. 36:242001. I was like, visual
  1202. 36:26voicemail. It was immediate and I showed
  1203. 36:28it to tech friends, I showed it to the
  1204. 36:30most normal people in the world and
  1205. 36:32everyone was like, "Holy this is
  1206. 36:33They were on Razors, they were on Nokia
  1207. 36:353210s. It was obvious the value. Amazon
  1208. 36:38Web Services, same deal.
  1209. 36:39>> It wasn't obvious though.
  1210. 36:40>> Yes, it was. I mean, I bought it
  1211. 36:42>> To you. To you it was.
  1212. 36:43>> It was and I also showed it to a bunch
  1213. 36:45of people because I'm aware that I have
  1214. 36:46bias when I just look at gadgets.
  1215. 36:48>> But I remember the famous Steve Ballmer
  1216. 36:50who was the CEO of Microsoft interview
  1217. 36:53where he is told about the iPhone and he
  1218. 36:56bursts out laughing.
  1219. 36:59>> [laughter]
  1220. 37:00>> $500? Fully subsidized with a plan? I
  1221. 37:03said, "That is the most expensive phone
  1222. 37:05in the world and it doesn't appeal to
  1223. 37:07business customers because it doesn't
  1224. 37:09have a keyboard which makes it not a
  1225. 37:11very good email machine. You can get a
  1226. 37:13Motorola Q phone now for $99. It's a
  1227. 37:17very capable machine. It'll do music,
  1228. 37:20it'll do internet, it'll do email, it'll
  1229. 37:22do instant messaging. So, I I kind of
  1230. 37:25look at that and I say, "Well, I like
  1231. 37:27our strategy. I like it a lot."
  1232. 37:30>> He burst out laughing, mocking it.
  1233. 37:31>> Because it was so disruptive, it was way
  1234. 37:34more expensive and it was a way
  1235. 37:36different. No keyboard.
  1236. 37:37>> Well, phones used to be insanely
  1237. 37:39expensive and the carriers would cover
  1238. 37:40them but you had to sign a long
  1239. 37:41contract. You were still spending 500
  1240. 37:43bucks but the thing I'm getting at is
  1241. 37:44you didn't have to explain to someone
  1242. 37:46what you Perhaps you'd have to get past
  1243. 37:47the cost part but you could just be
  1244. 37:49like, "Look how good this is." And then
  1245. 37:50once the app was the iPhone 3G with the
  1246. 37:52App Store, people were like, "Oh
  1247. 37:54this could actually change things."
  1248. 37:55Mobile web, even though it was a
  1249. 37:57monstrosity, it was so bad at first.
  1250. 37:59Even then you could get your emails, you
  1251. 38:01could just look at them. Point is
  1252. 38:02Blackberries were also expensive and
  1253. 38:03were still actually kind of cool but the
  1254. 38:05way they worked was not like consumer
  1255. 38:07software. They didn't have the classic
  1256. 38:08GUI. iPhones felt like that. It felt
  1257. 38:10like an a cell phone designed even like
  1258. 38:13a computer. It was obvious. It was
  1259. 38:15obvious in the beginning. Everyone I was
  1260. 38:17I was staying at the go in the center of
  1261. 38:19Pennsylvania at the time and everyone I
  1262. 38:20showed it to was like, "Wow, this is
  1263. 38:21incredible." That to me is the obvious
  1264. 38:24thing. With AI to this day, when you're
  1265. 38:27like, "Okay, why is it so amazing?"
  1266. 38:28People still dither. People are still
  1267. 38:30like, "Yeah, you can't run a business
  1268. 38:32fully with it without this
  1269. 38:34weird system of pulleys and levers and
  1270. 38:37such." And
  1271. 38:37>> But what How come then when you look at
  1272. 38:39the stats around ChatGPT's growth, 100
  1273. 38:42million active users in just the first
  1274. 38:4560 days after launching? For comparison,
  1275. 38:47TikTok took 9 months, Instagram took 2.5
  1276. 38:49years, and the internet itself, the
  1277. 38:51World Wide Web, took roughly 7 years to
  1278. 38:53reach that scale. Over 60% of the US
  1279. 38:55adults are integrated into AI tools in
  1280. 38:57their daily and regular routines within
  1281. 39:003 years of the launch, reaching up 40%
  1282. 39:02of the population. And that same
  1283. 39:04milestone took the internet 5 years, and
  1284. 39:06personal computers nearly 12.
  1285. 39:08>> Okay. So, like this is the I think this
  1286. 39:10is the part that's giving me dissonance,
  1287. 39:11is like when I showed my fiance ChatGPT,
  1288. 39:14okay, it wasn't really [clears throat]
  1289. 39:14work.
  1290. 39:15But as a sole entrepreneur who English
  1291. 39:18isn't her first language, who has to
  1292. 39:20write lots of text, lots of copy, and
  1293. 39:22generate lots of images, and was paying
  1294. 39:23a graphic designer to help her make
  1295. 39:25certain images that she, you know,
  1296. 39:26couldn't make herself because she
  1297. 39:28doesn't have the skills,
  1298. 39:30she would describe it as being
  1299. 39:32transformative for her business.
  1300. 39:35What I'm hearing from you is that it's
  1301. 39:37not transformative, and there's no value
  1302. 39:38in it for people.
  1303. 39:39>> But she If she was actually not she
  1304. 39:40would say transformative.
  1305. 39:42>> It would she pay the per million token
  1306. 39:44rate? Would she pay the actual rate? Cuz
  1307. 39:46that's the thing.
  1308. 39:46>> If this was sold at its honest cost,
  1309. 39:49>> Yeah.
  1310. 39:49>> I would actually if And people were
  1311. 39:50reacting like that, and they were paying
  1312. 39:52two, three, four dollars every time they
  1313. 39:53did something, and they were genuinely
  1314. 39:54happy, then there might be an argument.
  1315. 39:56>> the What would be the honest cost if
  1316. 39:58they weren't subsidized?
  1317. 39:59>> per million token cost, the actual API
  1318. 40:01cost they should charge.
  1319. 40:02>> Do you know how much that is relative to
  1320. 40:03>> Oh, god, it depends. It depends on the
  1321. 40:05model. But there's
  1322. 40:07actually kind of a point I want to make
  1323. 40:09about the thing you said about the
  1324. 40:10internet earlier. So, when I first got
  1325. 40:12on the internet, a 33.4 kilobits a
  1326. 40:14second modem,
  1327. 40:16even back then I was like, "Fuck, if
  1328. 40:17this was faster."
  1329. 40:19And that was like immediate, just like,
  1330. 40:21"If this was faster." Cuz it was slow.
  1331. 40:22You're going like Happy Puppy or
  1332. 40:24something. Download take all bloody day
  1333. 40:26waiting for shareware to download.
  1334. 40:28Immediately, you're like, "If I could do
  1335. 40:29this faster, it'd be better." And even
  1336. 40:30back then, I'm like, "Man, you could
  1337. 40:32probably do video camera stuff with
  1338. 40:33this." Stuff that eventually happened.
  1339. 40:35And actually, there's this guy called
  1340. 40:36Jim Cavallo from Goldman Sachs. In a
  1341. 40:38report he did in 2024, it was GenAI too
  1342. 40:41much spend for not enough return.
  1343. 40:42Paraphrasing there. And he made the
  1344. 40:43point that in the run-up to the iPhone,
  1345. 40:46there was thousands of presentations
  1346. 40:48that when GSM radios get smaller, when
  1347. 40:50Bluetooth radios get smaller, when Wi-Fi
  1348. 40:52radios get smaller, it is inevitable
  1349. 40:54that we will get something like this.
  1350. 40:56And then he said that there is no such
  1351. 40:59path that AI there was no roadmap to AI
  1352. 41:02becoming this thing that they promised.
  1353. 41:04And I must be clear. If these companies
  1354. 41:06had gone out there and they're like,
  1355. 41:07"Yeah, this is interesting cloud
  1356. 41:09software. It's generative. It's really
  1357. 41:10expensive. We're not sure if we can
  1358. 41:13fully not trust it." Not in the ooh, I'm
  1359. 41:15scared way. I mean, just like, "We're
  1360. 41:17not sure that this is going to be a
  1361. 41:19disruptive, world-changing thing. It has
  1362. 41:21potential, but we're going to go slow.
  1363. 41:23It's really expensive. This is an R&D
  1364. 41:25effort. We're not going to expose
  1365. 41:26consumers to it." And actually be like
  1366. 41:28call them like, I don't know, language
  1367. 41:30models. And no, no generative AI stuff.
  1368. 41:33Just being Not even call it cuz it isn't
  1369. 41:35AI. It's not autonomous. It's not smart.
  1370. 41:37I actually might respect it. But this is
  1371. 41:39not They've gone out there since 2023
  1372. 41:42and said, it was 2022, "This is the best
  1373. 41:44thing since sliced bread. This is
  1374. 41:45changing everything. This is going to do
  1375. 41:47all your work. This is going to take
  1376. 41:48your job. You're going to talk to Bing
  1377. 41:50and it's going to tell you to leave your
  1378. 41:51wife." All of these crazy things.
  1379. 41:53And what's funny is when the writer
  1380. 41:56Kevin Roose, I think it was. Um, he was
  1381. 41:58speaking to Kevin Scott, the CTO of
  1382. 41:59Microsoft, about it. And Kevin Scott
  1383. 42:01goes, "You know, I'm just glad we're
  1384. 42:02having this conversation." Instead of
  1385. 42:03being like, "Settle down, Beavis. It's a
  1386. 42:06website. The website told you something.
  1387. 42:08It's just LLMs." They talked it up. And
  1388. 42:10that's because everyone is talking about
  1389. 42:12what they wish this was, rather than
  1390. 42:14talking about what it can actually do.
  1391. 42:16This makes it scary to people,
  1392. 42:18deliberately so.
  1393. 42:19It makes it environmentally destructive.
  1394. 42:21Look at the gas turbines poisoning black
  1395. 42:22neighborhoods. I think it's in
  1396. 42:23Louisiana. It's one of Musk's data
  1397. 42:25centers. Look at the incredible energy
  1398. 42:27draws. It is raising power bills. And
  1399. 42:30also, it is creating inflation across
  1400. 42:33all consumer electronics because of the
  1401. 42:34massive RAM
  1402. 42:35>> Do you know what's interesting? I almost
  1403. 42:37feel like
  1404. 42:39so much of what you're saying is true.
  1405. 42:41And also, it can be true that this
  1406. 42:45technology is going to profoundly change
  1407. 42:47the world.
  1408. 42:48And I think like you know, I think back
  1409. 42:50to the early days of the internet is
  1410. 42:52maybe the closest analogy we have of
  1411. 42:54you know, in the dot-com bubble. You
  1412. 42:55know, you wrote this great essay.
  1413. 42:56>> Yeah, yes, yes.
  1414. 42:57>> Which I found really funny. Um
  1415. 42:59especially the name, the rot economy.
  1416. 43:02And you talked about the rot-com bubble.
  1417. 43:04>> Yes.
  1418. 43:04>> Talking about how AI is uh
  1419. 43:07less value than people think.
  1420. 43:08>> Mhm.
  1421. 43:09>> And in that in the sort of dot-com
  1422. 43:11bubble, what you saw is huge hype,
  1423. 43:13people overselling the capabilities of
  1424. 43:15their websites and what they were
  1425. 43:16building. But in the wake of the dot-com
  1426. 43:20bubble, yes, 90% of stuff went to zero,
  1427. 43:23but you had generational companies born
  1428. 43:26that changed the world.
  1429. 43:27>> Right.
  1430. 43:27>> And so I I do I kind of And that's what
  1431. 43:30bubbles do, right? But that huge hype,
  1432. 43:32over investment, investors get crazy
  1433. 43:34delusional, they think it's everything's
  1434. 43:36going to change. At the same time, you
  1435. 43:38do have skeptics
  1436. 43:40in these moments. The the dot-com bubble
  1437. 43:42had I mean, the internet itself had the
  1438. 43:43biggest skeptics. In 1998, Nobel Prize
  1439. 43:46winning economist Paul Krugman said, "By
  1440. 43:502005 or so, it will become clear that
  1441. 43:52the internet's impact on the economy has
  1442. 43:53been no greater than the fax machine."
  1443. 43:56In 1995, astrophysicist Clifford Stoll
  1444. 43:59famously I wrote about this in my book,
  1445. 44:01wrote famously in Newsweek,
  1446. 44:03"Do our computer pundits lack all common
  1447. 44:05sense? The truth is, no online database
  1448. 44:08will replace your daily newspaper. No
  1449. 44:10CD-ROM can take the place of a competent
  1450. 44:12teacher. Commerce and businesses will
  1451. 44:14shift from offices and malls to networks
  1452. 44:16and modems. Baloney. So, how come my
  1453. 44:19local mall does a roaring business and
  1454. 44:22the cyber mall gets zero business? And
  1455. 44:24I'll give you one more from Krugman, who
  1456. 44:26is the award-winning economist.
  1457. 44:29He said, "The growth of the internet
  1458. 44:30will slow drastically as it becomes
  1459. 44:32apparent most people have nothing to say
  1460. 44:34to each other."
  1461. 44:35>> That's
  1462. 44:37That That may actually be the worst one
  1463. 44:38of those
  1464. 44:39Like the Hang around any bar in Middle
  1465. 44:42America. Honestly, the best
  1466. 44:43conversation.
  1467. 44:44>> But it's just all It's all the same
  1468. 44:45thing.
  1469. 44:45>> I actually So, Clifford Stoll actually,
  1470. 44:47his piece was interesting cuz that There
  1471. 44:49were some boner points in it. But he
  1472. 44:50made points about how like an
  1473. 44:51overwhelming amount of bad information
  1474. 44:53out there is bad for society. He's
  1475. 44:54completely right. Saying how online
  1476. 44:56education would not be a great
  1477. 44:58replacement for regular education. I
  1478. 45:00think we've seen that. But there is an
  1479. 45:02economic difference that's vastly
  1480. 45:05completely different. So, dot-com bubble
  1481. 45:07was actually two bubbles. There was the
  1482. 45:08website bubble, which was just trash on
  1483. 45:10trash on trash. It was just like I think
  1484. 45:12what was it? Excite at home bought a
  1485. 45:15e-greeting card company for like a
  1486. 45:17billion dollars. It was insane crap
  1487. 45:18happening. That was so small. The big
  1488. 45:22thing that people are thinking about is
  1489. 45:23the dark fiber.
  1490. 45:24>> Dark fiber?
  1491. 45:25>> It Dark fiber was all of the wires that
  1492. 45:27put in the ground thinking, "We're going
  1493. 45:29to have all this demand for internet."
  1494. 45:30And it turned out that demand for
  1495. 45:32internet, I think the analyst estimate
  1496. 45:35was it was doubling every 90 days when
  1497. 45:37it was doing that every 6 to 12 months,
  1498. 45:39maybe maybe longer. And just thus there
  1499. 45:42was a massive overbuild of fiber optic
  1500. 45:43cable and indeed the transmission
  1501. 45:46stations and such to simplifying to
  1502. 45:48bring that to people's houses. And there
  1503. 45:50was the assumption that well, that would
  1504. 45:52all get lit up and people would want it
  1505. 45:53immediately. Didn't really happen. Now,
  1506. 45:55the post dot-com bubble thing people say
  1507. 45:57is, "Well, but after that, there was
  1508. 45:58demand for the internet."
  1509. 46:00That's the thing, though. That's very
  1510. 46:03to demand for generative AI. Right now,
  1511. 46:05the demand we have for generative AI is
  1512. 46:07predominantly subsidized. Just Let's
  1513. 46:09start there.
  1514. 46:10>> Yeah.
  1515. 46:10>> Predominantly subsidized, and most
  1516. 46:11people experiencing it are not paying
  1517. 46:13the real cost.
  1518. 46:14>> I agree.
  1519. 46:15>> On top of that, we already have all of
  1520. 46:18the possible marketing in the world. We
  1521. 46:20have the largest, most disingenuous
  1522. 46:22marketing campaign in the history of man
  1523. 46:25pushing this up the hill. We have the
  1524. 46:27apex predator of cloud software,
  1525. 46:30Microsoft. They can only get
  1526. 46:31single-digit billions from selling AI
  1527. 46:34software. And Christ almighty, outside
  1528. 46:37of OpenAI and Anthropic, who better get
  1529. 46:38$22 billion.
  1530. 46:40And the thing is, $22 billion is a large
  1531. 46:42amount to you and me. It's not a large
  1532. 46:44amount of money when you spent a
  1533. 46:45trillion-plus dollars, when you have
  1534. 46:47Anthropic and OpenAI with $1.1 trillion
  1535. 46:49worth of cloud commitments. And on top
  1536. 46:51of that,
  1537. 46:52how does this turn into a post.com
  1538. 46:54bubble thing? A data center built today
  1539. 46:57is going to be as expensive to run in
  1540. 46:582050 as it is today.
  1541. 47:01Unless there's some breakthrough in
  1542. 47:02electricity, but again,
  1543. 47:04that's not happening with AI. AI is not
  1544. 47:06doing that. Unless there's some
  1545. 47:07breakthrough in GPU technology, but we
  1546. 47:09already have Broadcom, Nvidia, etched.
  1547. 47:12We have every major chip company, ARM,
  1548. 47:15trying to do something about this. And
  1549. 47:17no one seems to magically be able to
  1550. 47:18make this profitable or indeed even less
  1551. 47:21costly. Even Nvidia, with Vera Rubin,
  1552. 47:24their more expensive new GPU system,
  1553. 47:26even then they're like, "Yeah, 10x more
  1554. 47:28efficient. It's a more dollars per
  1555. 47:30megawatt." They're all coy about it.
  1556. 47:31They don't just say, "Yeah, we worked
  1557. 47:33with OpenAI and Anthropic, and we found
  1558. 47:35it reduced their cost by 50%." Easiest
  1559. 47:37thing in the world if it was true. And
  1560. 47:38that's because it's not happening. And
  1561. 47:41this isn't a case where
  1562. 47:42>> So, you're saying there's not going to
  1563. 47:43be the demand for
  1564. 47:45Let's say let's, you know, there's
  1565. 47:46different types of AI, generative AI. We
  1566. 47:49>> Yeah, and actually that's a good point
  1567. 47:50to make. The reason they use the term
  1568. 47:52artificial intelligence is so everyone
  1569. 47:54would lump everything into it. They
  1570. 47:56would [clears throat] lump protein
  1571. 47:57folding, nothing to do with LLM's.
  1572. 47:59Robotics, not LLM's.
  1573. 48:01Autonomous weapons, even horrible as
  1574. 48:02they are, not LLM's because you couldn't
  1575. 48:04trust them.
  1576. 48:05But they've mushed everything into AI so
  1577. 48:07that when you say, "Well, AI can't."
  1578. 48:09They'll go, "Um
  1579. 48:11um sir, you forgot to give us homework.
  1580. 48:12And also, AI it's working on curing
  1581. 48:15cancer." When it's just like, "No,
  1582. 48:16that's not LLM's. Stop giving them
  1583. 48:18credit." So
  1584. 48:19>> though is they all need GPUs or at least
  1585. 48:21GPUs.
  1586. 48:21>> and that's the funny thing. All those
  1587. 48:23data centers that we're building, all of
  1588. 48:25them are for just generative AI. They're
  1589. 48:27not for all of the other stuff. They're
  1590. 48:30not for the cool AI has been
  1591. 48:32around for a long time. Google a lot of
  1592. 48:34the good stuff that comes out of Google
  1593. 48:36from the search side is AI, but
  1594. 48:38pre-generative.
  1595. 48:39>> would you run uh the the type of AI that
  1596. 48:42sits in a robot, let's say one of the
  1597. 48:44Optimus robots, if you didn't have a
  1598. 48:46GPU?
  1599. 48:47>> So, Metic. Metic is this cleaning robot,
  1600. 48:49for example. That thing is not got a
  1601. 48:51little GPU in it.
  1602. 48:52What it has and may indeed have used
  1603. 48:55some GPUs, but nowhere near as many as
  1604. 48:58they need for generative AI to run the
  1605. 49:00data feed training data into it so it's
  1606. 49:02able to clean a house. But when the
  1607. 49:03little bugger's going around cleaning my
  1608. 49:04floor, turdsley I call him, goes around
  1609. 49:06what mopping my floor, it's not like
  1610. 49:08burning money the whole time. But when
  1611. 49:11it comes to these massive amount of data
  1612. 49:12centers site line climate said in
  1613. 49:14February there's 190 gigawatts of data
  1614. 49:16centers under in planning, don't know
  1615. 49:18about under construction.
  1616. 49:20That works out at about 12 million a
  1617. 49:21megawatt, that's what like 1.6 trillion
  1618. 49:24to 3 trillion dollars a year in annual
  1619. 49:25demand you'd need for that. We don't
  1620. 49:27even have 130 billion dollars worth of
  1621. 49:29annual demand. And people say, "Well, it
  1622. 49:31will grow." How? When most of the demand
  1623. 49:33is coming from Amazon feeding money to
  1624. 49:36Open AI and Anthropic, Microsoft feeding
  1625. 49:38money to Open AI and Anthropic, Google
  1626. 49:40feeding money to Open AI and Anthro
  1627. 49:42Well, Google hasn't fed it to Open AI
  1628. 49:44yet, but they're a pretty big customer,
  1629. 49:45billions of dollars. The con side is
  1630. 49:47that
  1631. 49:48we are building these effigies to
  1632. 49:50capitalism, these giant GPU data
  1633. 49:52centers, and people are being told,
  1634. 49:54"Well, it's for AI." You know, the thing
  1635. 49:57that's done all this other stuff that's
  1636. 49:58unrelated. Or the worst thing I've seen
  1637. 50:00is like, "Oh, you don't like you like
  1638. 50:02online banking. Well, you do like data
  1639. 50:03centers." There's a big difference
  1640. 50:04between a data center for regular
  1641. 50:06non-GPU compute for standing up a server
  1642. 50:08or a content delivery system like Akamai
  1643. 50:10or something that brings the website to
  1644. 50:12you, or how Meta runs Facebook.
  1645. 50:15That is not the same. It takes way less
  1646. 50:17power, mostly CPU-driven, compared to
  1647. 50:19these giant GPU data centers that are
  1648. 50:21for one thing.
  1649. 50:22One thing only.
  1650. 50:23>> But I was doing the the research of
  1651. 50:25looking at some of these notes here. It
  1652. 50:26It does say that for tougher types of AI
  1653. 50:29systems designed to solve concrete
  1654. 50:30physics, biology, and spatial problems,
  1655. 50:32they require some of the most intense
  1656. 50:34data center infrastructure on the
  1657. 50:36planet. AI systems like DeepMind's
  1658. 50:38AlphaFold, the protein folding company,
  1659. 50:41used for genomic sequencing and climate
  1660. 50:43forecasting, etc., run on
  1661. 50:45high-performance computing clusters.
  1662. 50:47These require immense precision and
  1663. 50:48continuous heavy compute in data
  1664. 50:50centers.
  1665. 50:51>> Yeah.
  1666. 50:51>> Training the brains for self-driving
  1667. 50:52cars requires billions of miles of
  1668. 50:56simulated physics environments. The AI
  1669. 50:59isn't generating text. It's learning to
  1670. 51:01navigate 3D spaces and gravity and
  1671. 51:03relies on data centers.
  1672. 51:04>> Right.
  1673. 51:05>> And the thing is, those data centers,
  1674. 51:07they might have GPUs in them. We had
  1675. 51:08GPUs used for this HPC, the
  1676. 51:12high-performance computing, before
  1677. 51:13generative AI. And yeah, that's how AI's
  1678. 51:15been trained before. That's how Tesla
  1679. 51:17did it. I believe they've had their own
  1680. 51:19data centers when it comes to training
  1681. 51:21the autopilot system for better or for
  1682. 51:22worse.
  1683. 51:23>> That's how we've done it before.
  1684. 51:24>> Again, that is not why we're building
  1685. 51:26these data centers. These data centers
  1686. 51:28are being built to sell to AI generative
  1687. 51:31AI companies to either train systems or
  1688. 51:33run inference.
  1689. 51:35These things are being built in this
  1690. 51:36brainless way
  1691. 51:38where it's just, "Well, actually, maybe
  1692. 51:40this is a good way of illustrating the
  1693. 51:42con."
  1694. 51:43Because everyone saw
  1695. 51:45Google, Microsoft, Amazon, and Meta
  1696. 51:48give Nvidia over
  1697. 51:51call it 800 selling billion dollars.
  1698. 51:54Because everyone saw that, they went,
  1699. 51:55"Well, they wouldn't do that for no
  1700. 51:56reason." They went, "We got to build
  1701. 51:58more of these things. There must be all
  1702. 51:59this demand." Even though the demand
  1703. 52:0270% or more of all that demand comes
  1704. 52:05from these two companies who are funded
  1705. 52:06by these three companies. And that's the
  1706. 52:08funny thing.
  1707. 52:10The reason that they don't want to break
  1708. 52:11out their AI revenues is because it
  1709. 52:13would become alarmingly obvious
  1710. 52:16that this was the case. It turns out
  1711. 52:17that the only real big customers, cuz
  1712. 52:20it's not like they're building a few
  1713. 52:21data centers, they're building
  1714. 52:24trillion plus revenue potential they
  1715. 52:26believe they'll get. Speculative.
  1716. 52:28Entirely speculative.
  1717. 52:29They're building it because they saw the
  1718. 52:31biggest companies in the world buy a
  1719. 52:32bunch of GPUs and they said, "I want in
  1720. 52:34on that." They must have diverse
  1721. 52:36customers, right? They wouldn't just
  1722. 52:37have two unprofitable fail sons that
  1723. 52:39they're propping up with
  1724. 52:41Christ, they've raised 217 billion
  1725. 52:43dollars just in 2026.
  1726. 52:46>> So, we know that some of the biggest
  1727. 52:49companies in the world are using AI,
  1728. 52:51generative AI, to write a lot of their
  1729. 52:52code.
  1730. 52:53>> Mhm.
  1731. 52:53>> That is a great productivity gain for
  1732. 52:55those companies, right? I mean, have you
  1733. 52:57used Google or Facebook or Instagram or
  1734. 53:00GitHub recently? Because they are
  1735. 53:03catastrophically worse. Amazon Web
  1736. 53:04Services went down multiple times
  1737. 53:06because of their AI coding tool.
  1738. 53:08>> How How is How is Google worse?
  1739. 53:09>> Well, I'll tell the story of a real
  1740. 53:11guy called Prabhakar Raghavan,
  1741. 53:13previously one of the heads of ads
  1742. 53:15Google. In 2019, Google called something
  1743. 53:17called a code yellow, which is when they
  1744. 53:19said, "We've got a problem." And it was
  1745. 53:21material weakness in query numbers,
  1746. 53:24which means the amount of times that
  1747. 53:25people were searching on Google Search.
  1748. 53:27Guy called Ben Gomes, internal to
  1749. 53:29Google, then the head of Google Search,
  1750. 53:30says,
  1751. 53:31"Wait a minute. To increase this number
  1752. 53:33of using Google more,
  1753. 53:34>> Mhm.
  1754. 53:35>> we're going to have to Well, I mean, you
  1755. 53:37What you're suggesting would mean we
  1756. 53:38give worse answers because if someone
  1757. 53:40got the answer quickly, that would
  1758. 53:41reduce the amount of queries, right? And
  1759. 53:43people at Google, the Shashi Thakur was
  1760. 53:46another engineer was saying, "Yeah, can
  1761. 53:47we please tell Sundar this? Because this
  1762. 53:49doesn't seem good. We can't just
  1763. 53:51increase the amount of queries. That
  1764. 53:53would just mean that people would have
  1765. 53:54to search more, which make the product
  1766. 53:55worse."
  1767. 53:56>> But but it would make them more money,
  1768. 53:57you're saying?
  1769. 53:58>> Yes. And it would cause you to show them
  1770. 53:59more ads. So, if you were spending more
  1771. 54:01time on Google cuz Google's what
  1772. 54:03>> But is this linked to AI doing code?
  1773. 54:04>> I'll get there.
  1774. 54:06So,
  1775. 54:07this is The problem is is that this guy
  1776. 54:09called Prabhakar Raghavan, who's the
  1777. 54:11head of ads at the time, was pushing
  1778. 54:12pushing and saying, "No, we need to make
  1779. 54:14more queries happen. Going to make it
  1780. 54:15happen." Nick Fox, who was there as
  1781. 54:17well, I believe he's actually taken over
  1782. 54:18Google Search, said, "Going to make them
  1783. 54:19go up. This is our new reality."
  1784. 54:22Sometime in early 2020, Prabhakar
  1785. 54:24Raghavan takes over Google Search. From
  1786. 54:26then, and this is This is what I
  1787. 54:28believe. Can't prove it. If you go and
  1788. 54:30look around the various SEO sites, such
  1789. 54:32as Journal and the various forums,
  1790. 54:34Google stripped back a lot of the
  1791. 54:36suppression of spammy sites so that
  1792. 54:38people would be on Google more.
  1793. 54:40And then over the course of time, Google
  1794. 54:43wanted to create more queries, and
  1795. 54:44Google Search became much worse. It's
  1796. 54:46why people always do like plus Reddit or
  1797. 54:48from Reddit or what have you. It's
  1798. 54:50because the actual underlying search
  1799. 54:51results of Google had got worse. And
  1800. 54:53then generative AI came along. And
  1801. 54:55Prabhakar, wouldn't you know it, gets
  1802. 54:57put around part of Gemini. And Google
  1803. 54:59also was having trouble getting people
  1804. 55:01back on Google. And what did they think
  1805. 55:03they'd do? Well, everyone's
  1806. 55:04talking about this AI thing.
  1807. 55:06We'll just put it right at the top so
  1808. 55:08people have to stay at Google. And
  1809. 55:09actually, they'll use it more because
  1810. 55:11instead of searching websites and doing
  1811. 55:13that annoying thing where they click
  1812. 55:14away from Google, they'll just only use
  1813. 55:16Google. Instead of generating answers,
  1814. 55:19by which I mean giving you search
  1815. 55:20results you click through, now Google is
  1816. 55:22the answer. Is it right? God no. It
  1817. 55:24might tell you to eat rocks. Might eat
  1818. 55:26poisonous mushrooms. Maybe it'll give
  1819. 55:27you a little few links you could click
  1820. 55:29through. But the ideal situation was
  1821. 55:31that AI was the ultimate form of
  1822. 55:33Google's evil, which were
  1823. 55:35>> But I'm saying here I'm saying here but
  1824. 55:36that's not the fact that coders could
  1825. 55:39code on Google that's made Google worse.
  1826. 55:40That's human decisions have made it
  1827. 55:42worse.
  1828. 55:42>> Yes, and then there's the instability of
  1829. 55:44Google's platform, which is actually I
  1830. 55:46should have probably labeled that a
  1831. 55:47problem across the whole tech industry.
  1832. 55:49>> Okay, so you're saying that that you're
  1833. 55:50saying Google is going down more?
  1834. 55:52>> Yes, Google is less stable. Google Docs
  1835. 55:55is a bug fest right now and has been for
  1836. 55:57a while. Google Sheets, same deal. And
  1837. 55:59the thing is, you're right. I'm being a
  1838. 56:01little unfair. This is everyone. It's
  1839. 56:02the same with Microsoft. It's the same
  1840. 56:04with Amazon. It's the same across the
  1841. 56:05>> How do we quantify that outside of
  1842. 56:07anecdotes? Like is there a way to
  1843. 56:09>> You're right. I mean GitHub downtime is
  1844. 56:11the best example. Amazon Web Services
  1845. 56:13went down like two or three times this
  1846. 56:14year because of AI tools.
  1847. 56:17And honestly, you're right. It's kind of
  1848. 56:19hard to quantify outside of anecdotes,
  1849. 56:21but I challenge anyone listening to
  1850. 56:23this. Go and use a website these days
  1851. 56:24and tell me how well it works. Tell me
  1852. 56:26how buggy it is. Tell me how many
  1853. 56:27problems even with my iPhone, the
  1854. 56:30supposed best UX in town. Even the
  1855. 56:32iPhone is a flipping mess these days.
  1856. 56:35>> Okay, so the research says
  1857. 56:38the short answer is yes. Tech downtime
  1858. 56:41and software outages have demonstrably
  1859. 56:43increased over the last few years and
  1860. 56:45industry data points directly to the
  1861. 56:46explosion of AI-assisted coding as a
  1862. 56:48primary culprit. The problem is hitting
  1863. 56:50the tech industry from two entirely
  1864. 56:52different directions. The code itself is
  1865. 56:54getting buggier and the sheer volume of
  1866. 56:56AI activity is literally crashing the
  1867. 56:58underlying infrastructure.
  1868. 57:00>> Interesting.
  1869. 57:01>> Yeah, that's because GitHub people are
  1870. 57:03just writing a bunch of code, pushing
  1871. 57:04it. And thus there's just more code on
  1872. 57:07there.
  1873. 57:08>> That's interesting.
  1874. 57:09>> Yeah, it's it's a real mess as well
  1875. 57:10because
  1876. 57:12open source is at this problem as well
  1877. 57:14because it's well-meaning people.
  1878. 57:15They're like, "Oh, I learned a bit of
  1879. 57:16code with an LLM. I'm going to go out
  1880. 57:18and do some stuff. I'm going to make
  1881. 57:19this project better." And these people
  1882. 57:20barely understand what they're shipping.
  1883. 57:22Or maybe they understand a bit of code
  1884. 57:24and they say, "Oh, Dunning-Kruger this
  1885. 57:26I'm going to I'm just like
  1886. 57:28I can understand some of this." And now
  1887. 57:29the code's all written and they just
  1888. 57:30push it right now. So GitHub is flooded
  1889. 57:32with AI code.
  1890. 57:33>> This sounds like it's making humans
  1891. 57:35complacent.
  1892. 57:37>> It is.
  1893. 57:37>> Because we're going, "Okay, look, I'll
  1894. 57:39let it write the the code for the last
  1895. 57:41100 lines, and it was broadly right. So,
  1896. 57:43the next 100 lines, I won't check them
  1897. 57:45as much."
  1898. 57:45>> Yeah, yeah, yeah.
  1899. 57:46>> And that's human nature is to get sort
  1900. 57:49of to take shortcuts, to spend less
  1901. 57:51energy on an activity if you can.
  1902. 57:53>> Right, but the AI is still making the
  1903. 57:55mistake and we're still making all the
  1904. 57:56promises of the AI. That's the thing.
  1905. 57:58This thing is meant to be this
  1906. 58:00autonomous perfect You say it can't be
  1907. 58:02perfect. I don't know. Based on what Sam
  1908. 58:04Altman has been saying for the last few
  1909. 58:06years, clammy Sammy's been promising the
  1910. 58:07world saying this will replace software
  1911. 58:09engineers. Dario Amodei, Wario himself
  1912. 58:12has been saying, "Oh, yeah, 50% of
  1913. 58:15white-collar labor is going to go away
  1914. 58:17in the next few years." These people are
  1915. 58:19promising the world. Again, if they were
  1916. 58:21saying it would be smaller and they were
  1917. 58:22like, "Yeah, it does have issues and we
  1918. 58:25must be None of this, "Oh, what if it
  1919. 58:27wakes up and it's super powerful." Just
  1920. 58:29like, "Yeah, it's probabilistic. It's
  1921. 58:31going to make mistakes. And if you don't
  1922. 58:33know what you're doing, you don't really
  1923. 58:34know what you're looking at, you're
  1924. 58:35going to miss those mistakes, and it's
  1925. 58:36going to get multiplicatively worse as
  1926. 58:39you go when you don't know what you're
  1927. 58:40doing." So, yeah, human nature is part
  1928. 58:42of it.
  1929. 58:44But so is the marketing, so are the
  1930. 58:45promises.
  1931. 58:47>> One of the smartest things a business
  1932. 58:49can do is build like a bigger company
  1933. 58:52without actually hiring like one. But
  1934. 58:54the problem we will face is that most
  1935. 58:55companies don't have every skill in
  1936. 58:57house. So, when I look at the businesses
  1937. 58:59seeing real success today, the
  1938. 59:01consistent pattern with all of them is
  1939. 59:03how quickly they move. They bring in
  1940. 59:05specialists with skills in emerging
  1941. 59:06areas to keep themselves ahead. Even in
  1942. 59:08our company, we spent the last year
  1943. 59:10pulling in talent across areas like AI
  1944. 59:12native strategy, no-code builds, and
  1945. 59:15product workflows. And we find this
  1946. 59:16talent through our long-time partner,
  1947. 59:17Fiverr Pro. Their premium service only
  1948. 59:20shows you vetted talent, so you've
  1949. 59:22always got the safeguard that anyone you
  1950. 59:25pull in to help you with a complex
  1951. 59:27project has the skills that you're after
  1952. 59:29and will deliver to the same high
  1953. 59:31standards as your internal team. And
  1954. 59:33most importantly, they'll keep up with
  1955. 59:34the pace. It's a simple strategy, but it
  1956. 59:36lets us stay agile without compromising
  1957. 59:38on quality. So, if you need these kind
  1958. 59:39of skills in your business, head to
  1959. 59:41pro.fiverr.com to find pioneering talent
  1960. 59:44to fill your business's gaps. That's
  1961. 59:45pro.fiverr.com.
  1962. 59:48You know the little traditional SIM card
  1963. 59:49that goes inside of our phones? They
  1964. 59:51haven't changed at all since they were
  1965. 59:53invented in the '90s. You have this
  1966. 59:55physical piece of plastic that means
  1967. 59:57you're locked into one carrier, one
  1968. 59:59network, and the second you cross a
  1969. 1:00:01border, that carrier can start charging
  1970. 1:00:03you whatever they want. But, there are
  1971. 1:00:05alternatives, and today's sponsor,
  1972. 1:00:07Selly, is one of them. It's an eSIM app
  1973. 1:00:10that gives you a safe and secure data
  1974. 1:00:12connection in over 200 destinations. All
  1975. 1:00:15of their eSIMs have built-in
  1976. 1:00:16cybersecurity, which is great if you're
  1977. 1:00:18traveling for work and looking at
  1978. 1:00:19confidential material. I've been using
  1979. 1:00:21Selly whenever I travel because the
  1980. 1:00:23connection is always reliable, and it
  1981. 1:00:25saves me a ton of roaming fees. It also
  1982. 1:00:27means I don't have to deal with all of
  1983. 1:00:29the faff that surrounds sorting out a
  1984. 1:00:31SIM everywhere I go. If you want to give
  1985. 1:00:33it a try, download the Selly app from
  1986. 1:00:35the App Store now and scan the QR code
  1987. 1:00:37on screen. And if you want 15% off your
  1988. 1:00:39first purchase, use my code d o a c when
  1989. 1:00:44you get to check out. That's d o a c for
  1990. 1:00:4715% off.
  1991. 1:00:49Keep that to yourself.
  1992. 1:00:50My My car that drives itself, that is AI
  1993. 1:00:53technology.
  1994. 1:00:54>> Yes.
  1995. 1:00:55>> I sat here with Dara from Uber, and he
  1996. 1:00:56was saying that I think in a couple of
  1997. 1:00:58years time
  1998. 1:01:01we won't need drivers um
  1999. 1:01:03for Uber because the cars will drive
  2000. 1:01:05themselves, like they'll be fully
  2001. 1:01:06autonomous.
  2002. 1:01:08>> And I think, if I'm not mistaken,
  2003. 1:01:10driving is one of the biggest
  2004. 1:01:12professions on planet Earth.
  2005. 1:01:14So, when you hear people, when you hear
  2006. 1:01:15these CEOs saying that there will be job
  2007. 1:01:17disruption,
  2008. 1:01:18>> Mhm.
  2009. 1:01:19>> you say that they are not telling the
  2010. 1:01:21truth.
  2011. 1:01:22>> Yes, or they're guessing in a way that's
  2012. 1:01:24very good for them. Think about it from
  2013. 1:01:26perspective of Microsoft, Satya Nadella.
  2014. 1:01:28He's not going to be like, "Yeah, we've
  2015. 1:01:29done it. This is going to work, mate."
  2016. 1:01:31Of course, he's going to talk his book
  2017. 1:01:32and he's going to say, "Yeah, this is
  2018. 1:01:34going to replace all workers. It's going
  2019. 1:01:36to be amazing. You you It's going to be
  2020. 1:01:37so powerful." And then he'll change his
  2021. 1:01:39tune and say, "Actually, it's not going
  2022. 1:01:40to replace workers. It'll make them more
  2023. 1:01:41powerful because
  2024. 1:01:43the things aren't catching up." Dara
  2025. 1:01:44Khosrowshahi for example, of course,
  2026. 1:01:46he's going to say, "If this happens,
  2027. 1:01:48then that would be good for Uber because
  2028. 1:01:50Uber would just become
  2029. 1:01:51an autonomous taxi service." There's a
  2030. 1:01:53reason that Waymo's taking I I find
  2031. 1:01:55Waymo fascinating. I think that shit's
  2032. 1:01:56really cool. I think there are
  2033. 1:01:57socio-economic problems that will come
  2034. 1:01:59from it. I think there are actual real
  2035. 1:02:00problems that will emerge. And also,
  2036. 1:02:02>> What kind of problems?
  2037. 1:02:03>> Well, I mean, socio-economically they're
  2038. 1:02:05like you said, one of the largest
  2039. 1:02:07employment centers in the world. I mean,
  2040. 1:02:09just the economics of cabs before apart.
  2041. 1:02:10But again, we are nowhere nowhere
  2042. 1:02:12nowhere near that. We're not even close.
  2043. 1:02:14Waymo has had to do these smallest
  2044. 1:02:16rollouts in the most controlled things
  2045. 1:02:18because the problem with pretty much
  2046. 1:02:19every AI system, but especially driving,
  2047. 1:02:21is not the getting 95% of the way. It's
  2048. 1:02:25those edge cases. It's raining, which is
  2049. 1:02:27a big problem for them in San Francisco.
  2050. 1:02:28It's a kid runs across the road, but
  2051. 1:02:30they're wearing a high-vis thing.
  2052. 1:02:32Does it even notice it's a child?
  2053. 1:02:34>> Again, this is a really interesting but
  2054. 1:02:35very very applicable example of uh the
  2055. 1:02:37right comparison to be made shouldn't be
  2056. 1:02:40autonomous vehicles versus perfection.
  2057. 1:02:42It should be autonomous vehicles versus
  2058. 1:02:43human drivers.
  2059. 1:02:45>> I mean, I don't know if I agree because
  2060. 1:02:47a human driver might make mistakes,
  2061. 1:02:48sure, but
  2062. 1:02:50again, not an expert in autonomous cars.
  2063. 1:02:52Just want to be clear. But if we're
  2064. 1:02:53pushing autonomous cars out there
  2065. 1:02:55willy-nilly and we're not doing so in
  2066. 1:02:57extremely controlled environments, those
  2067. 1:02:59edge cases will multiply and be
  2068. 1:03:01dangerous. Yeah, they might be better at
  2069. 1:03:03human drivers in some ways, but they
  2070. 1:03:04might also I was in Vegas the other day
  2071. 1:03:06and I was in a hotel and I watched a
  2072. 1:03:08bunch of Zoox cars just get
  2073. 1:03:10stuck.
  2074. 1:03:10>> The autonomous cars?
  2075. 1:03:11>> Yeah, yeah, yeah. They they these weird
  2076. 1:03:13boxy things. They just blocked the exit.
  2077. 1:03:15They just all kind of lined up and just
  2078. 1:03:17fell asleep. I saw the same thing
  2079. 1:03:19actually happen outside of a hotel when
  2080. 1:03:20I got out of a Waymo in San Francisco.
  2081. 1:03:22Just stopped at the side and then a
  2082. 1:03:23bunch of cars and then another Waymo got
  2083. 1:03:25stuck behind it. And these are kind of
  2084. 1:03:27These are kind
  2085. 1:03:27>> I've seen some human bad drivers as
  2086. 1:03:28well.
  2087. 1:03:29>> I I agree, but it's just we have control
  2088. 1:03:31over deploying these bad or good
  2089. 1:03:34drivers. We have an ability to roll them
  2090. 1:03:37out slowly, which is exactly what we
  2091. 1:03:39should do. I'm not saying autonomous
  2092. 1:03:40cars are bad. I'm saying we need to be
  2093. 1:03:43so so so careful and treat them
  2094. 1:03:46as guilty until proven
  2095. 1:03:47innocent. Because we can prove And also
  2096. 1:03:50they have people overlooking them. They
  2097. 1:03:51actually have people monitoring the
  2098. 1:03:52routes. It is something they cannot rush
  2099. 1:03:54out and it doesn't seem like they're
  2100. 1:03:55rushing it, which is good. And they're
  2101. 1:03:57not promising the world.
  2102. 1:03:58>> agree. Listen, I I'm a big fan of a big
  2103. 1:04:01fan of taxi drivers generally in in part
  2104. 1:04:02because I spend a lot of time in taxis
  2105. 1:04:03and I think I'm not just getting in
  2106. 1:04:05there because I want to get to from A to
  2107. 1:04:06B. I'm getting in there for lots of
  2108. 1:04:07other reasons.
  2109. 1:04:08>> Yeah.
  2110. 1:04:09>> However, when I look at the stats
  2111. 1:04:11around what is more dangerous,
  2112. 1:04:13>> Uh-huh.
  2113. 1:04:13>> driving myself or having an autonomous
  2114. 1:04:16vehicle drive me, there's a 68% lower
  2115. 1:04:18overall crash involvement rate when
  2116. 1:04:21you're in an an autonomous vehicle.
  2117. 1:04:23>> Uh-huh.
  2118. 1:04:23>> Autonomous vehicles experience roughly
  2119. 1:04:252.1 police-reported crashes per million
  2120. 1:04:27miles compared to humans that are at
  2121. 1:04:29roughly 4.68 per million miles.
  2122. 1:04:31>> Right.
  2123. 1:04:32>> A 55% reduction when you get in an
  2124. 1:04:34autonomous vehicle. And autonomous
  2125. 1:04:35vehicles show an 80 to 81% reduction in
  2126. 1:04:38crashes resulting in injuries versus
  2127. 1:04:41human drivers.
  2128. 1:04:42>> Uh-huh.
  2129. 1:04:42>> So, you're 85% less likely to be
  2130. 1:04:45involved in a single vehicle crash, like
  2131. 1:04:47hitting a wall or a tree, if you're in
  2132. 1:04:49an autonomous vehicle
  2133. 1:04:51versus being driven by
  2134. 1:04:52>> I I agree, but
  2135. 1:04:53>> So, it's safer.
  2136. 1:04:55>> And also that data is What's the sample
  2137. 1:04:58size of human drivers? I mean, we've got
  2138. 1:05:00many many many many many many more years
  2139. 1:05:02of drivers and many many many more years
  2140. 1:05:04of accidents. And also man, does that
  2141. 1:05:06not have anything to do with generative
  2142. 1:05:08AI? If we were just talking about that,
  2143. 1:05:10we're having a different conversation.
  2144. 1:05:12>> the question here was really around job
  2145. 1:05:13disruption. Like, you know, we we look
  2146. 1:05:15across industries and we go driving's a
  2147. 1:05:17massive profession. Is there going to be
  2148. 1:05:18job disruption because cars can now
  2149. 1:05:20drive themselves? If we think about
  2150. 1:05:21white-collar, you know, jobs, you know,
  2151. 1:05:24lawyers and accountants, people sit here
  2152. 1:05:26and they tell me that lawyers and
  2153. 1:05:27accountants will
  2154. 1:05:29the profession, right? I should say some
  2155. 1:05:31of the skills within the profession will
  2156. 1:05:32be relegated to AIs to do.
  2157. 1:05:35>> Here's the thing. Lawyers, for example,
  2158. 1:05:37example, always hearing legal
  2159. 1:05:40partners talking about AI. Never the
  2160. 1:05:42associates. The associates are the ones
  2161. 1:05:44that go out and find the precedent.
  2162. 1:05:46They're the ones that go and do the
  2163. 1:05:47grunt work. They're the ones who are
  2164. 1:05:48pulling motions off the time. The
  2165. 1:05:49partner is the one that might be the
  2166. 1:05:51litigator, it might be the
  2167. 1:05:52client-facing, but the ones that are
  2168. 1:05:54actually doing the day-to-day work, I'm
  2169. 1:05:55not hearing from them. I'm not hearing
  2170. 1:05:57associates being like, "This is
  2171. 1:05:58awesome." I'm hearing a bunch of
  2172. 1:06:00well-paid people that have sat on
  2173. 1:06:03ChatGPT and gone, "Yeah. Yeah, I'm the
  2174. 1:06:05greatest lawyer ever." They're not the
  2175. 1:06:07ones that I want to hear from. The
  2176. 1:06:08actual workers. White-collar labor
  2177. 1:06:10disruption is not happening. OpenAI had
  2178. 1:06:12a study that came out, I think like a
  2179. 1:06:14week ago, that said there was no
  2180. 1:06:15connection between spending on AI tokens
  2181. 1:06:18and revenue per employee. Like, this is
  2182. 1:06:21open and that's the thing.
  2183. 1:06:21>> What does that mean? Could you explain
  2184. 1:06:22that to me?
  2185. 1:06:22>> As in, the more tokens you spend has no
  2186. 1:06:26correlation at all
  2187. 1:06:28with the amount of money you make. It's
  2188. 1:06:29the second report they've put out. The
  2189. 1:06:31other one was like hallucinations are
  2190. 1:06:32mathematically guaranteed. Kind of
  2191. 1:06:34almost It's the one thing I respect
  2192. 1:06:35about that company that occasionally
  2193. 1:06:36they just put out a study that's like,
  2194. 1:06:38"Yeah, shit's going to suck."
  2195. 1:06:40>> [clears throat]
  2196. 1:06:40>> But, the people that are having their
  2197. 1:06:42lives disrupted, work-wise, are art
  2198. 1:06:45directors. It's people Art directors,
  2199. 1:06:47transcribers, translators, who have
  2200. 1:06:50bosses that don't care about the output.
  2201. 1:06:52It's what they consider cheap work. And
  2202. 1:06:54the problem is is those people would
  2203. 1:06:56have automated your work away anyway.
  2204. 1:06:57They would have sold it. They would have
  2205. 1:06:59taken the cheapest They would have sold
  2206. 1:07:00it to the global south. They would have
  2207. 1:07:02taken the shittiest option they could.
  2208. 1:07:03That is something that AI is doing. And
  2209. 1:07:05again, those people are not paying the
  2210. 1:07:06actual cost of AI. They're using a
  2211. 1:07:08subscription. The actual white-collar
  2212. 1:07:11labor force
  2213. 1:07:12might have some things that are slightly
  2214. 1:07:15changing, but there is no evidence of
  2215. 1:07:17like
  2216. 1:07:18productivity gains. In fact, if there
  2217. 1:07:20were, they would be screaming it from
  2218. 1:07:22the rooftops. There was an Oxford
  2219. 1:07:24economic study last year where it's
  2220. 1:07:25like, "Oh, young people are finding less
  2221. 1:07:27jobs because of AI." We actually read
  2222. 1:07:29the study, which multiple journalists
  2223. 1:07:31did not. It was a single line that said,
  2224. 1:07:33"Yeah, we saw some correlation."
  2225. 1:07:35Didn't give a number.
  2226. 1:07:37Didn't actually say what the correlation
  2227. 1:07:38was. We are so conditioned to believe
  2228. 1:07:41that the rich and powerful know what
  2229. 1:07:43they're doing that we internalize these
  2230. 1:07:45narratives about like, "Well, previous
  2231. 1:07:48booms lost a lot of money. Well,
  2232. 1:07:49technology takes time to do stuff." And
  2233. 1:07:51they are intentionally playing on those
  2234. 1:07:54mythologies. They are playing on these
  2235. 1:07:56knowing that journalists, analysts,
  2236. 1:07:58investors
  2237. 1:08:00will believe them. And this is partly
  2238. 1:08:02because our our reality is defined by
  2239. 1:08:04stock prices. Because the stock prices
  2240. 1:08:06of these companies went up, we're like,
  2241. 1:08:08"Oh, look, it must be working, right?"
  2242. 1:08:10>> Both of those things you said were true
  2243. 1:08:11though, right? Like that previous
  2244. 1:08:12technologies didn't make money at the
  2245. 1:08:14start, and you the other one you said
  2246. 1:08:15was um
  2247. 1:08:16they'll get better.
  2248. 1:08:17>> But that's the thing. Okay, because
  2249. 1:08:19another thing got better, this will get
  2250. 1:08:21better?
  2251. 1:08:21>> No, but there's there's got to be
  2252. 1:08:22something that they're saying that is
  2253. 1:08:24fundamentally not true, because those
  2254. 1:08:25are two true statements that okay,
  2255. 1:08:26technology often starts
  2256. 1:08:28>> Okay, I know, I get what you mean. What
  2257. 1:08:29they are fundamentally misleading people
  2258. 1:08:31about is how possible it is.
  2259. 1:08:33>> Okay.
  2260. 1:08:33>> How many actual signs they have. Because
  2261. 1:08:35they don't have the signs. If they had
  2262. 1:08:36the signs
  2263. 1:08:37>> Signs?
  2264. 1:08:37>> As in the signs of this getting cheaper.
  2265. 1:08:39As in the signs of this being able to
  2266. 1:08:41autonomously do work without the Rube
  2267. 1:08:43Goldberg machine. And even then, in a
  2268. 1:08:45reliable way that was making the
  2269. 1:08:47customer more money. Being productive in
  2270. 1:08:49a way you can say with your whole chest
  2271. 1:08:51without a series of asterisks. And
  2272. 1:08:53that's how it is across the board. The
  2273. 1:08:55people
  2274. 1:08:56that are most excited about this
  2275. 1:08:59psychopaths on Twitter in many cases are
  2276. 1:09:01people that I believe
  2277. 1:09:02>> Psychopaths
  2278. 1:09:03>> They are really awesome. I'm sorry.
  2279. 1:09:04There are some people on Twitter because
  2280. 1:09:06the other thing about this is This is
  2281. 1:09:08really unique to the AI industry. I've
  2282. 1:09:09never seen it any other industry outside
  2283. 1:09:11of maybe like sports teams. The
  2284. 1:09:13attachment that some people online have
  2285. 1:09:15to these companies. If you dare dare to
  2286. 1:09:19criticize Anthropic. It's almost this
  2287. 1:09:21religious attachment. Good example was
  2288. 1:09:23this week Bloomberg reported that OpenAI
  2289. 1:09:25was on track to hit $40 billion in
  2290. 1:09:28annualized revenue. Months times 12 4
  2291. 1:09:30weeks times 13. We don't know. They
  2292. 1:09:31don't define it.
  2293. 1:09:33I saw multiple people online going
  2294. 1:09:34actually it's $60 billion. It's actually
  2295. 1:09:36$60 billion. I heard from someone. It is
  2296. 1:09:39like a cult and it's a cult of software
  2297. 1:09:42driven around growth and this idea that
  2298. 1:09:45by backing the right horse you will have
  2299. 1:09:48some grand thing and OpenAI in
  2300. 1:09:51particular and particular Mr. Altman
  2301. 1:09:54They have been fermenting this. That
  2302. 1:09:56Tibo as well at Tibo that one of the
  2303. 1:09:58guys at OpenAI. They ferment this thing
  2304. 1:10:01online. They build this kind of
  2305. 1:10:02parasocial relationship with both the
  2306. 1:10:05large language model themselves and the
  2307. 1:10:06companies. And one's allegiance to the
  2308. 1:10:09companies is so important. It's truly
  2309. 1:10:12vile. If only these people gave a
  2310. 1:10:14about I don't know Medicare for all or
  2311. 1:10:17poverty or thing like actual problems in
  2312. 1:10:19the world versus are we buying enough
  2313. 1:10:21GPUs?
  2314. 1:10:22>> Do you know what's interesting is some
  2315. 1:10:24of what your narrative
  2316. 1:10:26one would argue actually helps them.
  2317. 1:10:29>> How?
  2318. 1:10:29>> Because you know the AI doomers that
  2319. 1:10:31have come here and talk you know some of
  2320. 1:10:32the original founding fathers of AI like
  2321. 1:10:34Geoffrey Hinton have told me that what
  2322. 1:10:37they're building is highly highly
  2323. 1:10:38dangerous and that it will be
  2324. 1:10:40fundamentally disruptive to society. And
  2325. 1:10:43it's interesting because some of the
  2326. 1:10:45CEOs who you've mentioned their
  2327. 1:10:46historical narrative was also by the way
  2328. 1:10:48this is really dangerous.
  2329. 1:10:49>> Yeah.
  2330. 1:10:50>> And there is a significant chance it
  2331. 1:10:51could we could up the the
  2332. 1:10:52planet.
  2333. 1:10:52>> Uh-huh.
  2334. 1:10:53>> And what we've seen is this slow pivot
  2335. 1:10:55away from it which is
  2336. 1:10:56>> Because now they're getting booed and
  2337. 1:10:58they're they're being attacked. Yeah.
  2338. 1:10:59They've been a slow pivot away from it.
  2339. 1:11:01And the pivot almost sounds a little bit
  2340. 1:11:04like your narrative. It now sounds like
  2341. 1:11:06actually now it's not going to change
  2342. 1:11:08anything and you're all going to be
  2343. 1:11:09fine. And it's now it's just not it's
  2344. 1:11:10not it's not dangerous at all.
  2345. 1:11:11>> But that's the funny thing.
  2346. 1:11:13>> And that's why I'm saying like your your
  2347. 1:11:15they I actually think there might be a
  2348. 1:11:17couple PR people at these big AI
  2349. 1:11:18companies thinking thank god for Ed.
  2350. 1:11:20>> Oh, I don't know about that.
  2351. 1:11:21>> some of it some of [laughter] it because
  2352. 1:11:23you're like you're saying actually don't
  2353. 1:11:24worry everything's going to be fine.
  2354. 1:11:26It's not going to take your job. It's
  2355. 1:11:27not going to disrupt the economy. It's
  2356. 1:11:28just a fad. There's no technology. And I
  2357. 1:11:30think they don't think that.
  2358. 1:11:31>> Here's the thing. I think Altman and
  2359. 1:11:33Amodei are some of the most deeply
  2360. 1:11:34corrupt and cynical people in the world.
  2361. 1:11:36I don't Of course they were going to say
  2362. 1:11:37from the it was early 2023. Altman said
  2363. 1:11:40we're a little bit scared about what
  2364. 1:11:42we're creating. Oh, shut up. I'm just I
  2365. 1:11:45hear that and I feel so frustrated
  2366. 1:11:46because I've met so many of these rich
  2367. 1:11:48liars. These people And you know
  2368. 1:11:50why he wants to say that? So you'll
  2369. 1:11:52invest in his company and buy the
  2370. 1:11:54software. So you'll be scared that if
  2371. 1:11:56you don't use AI today, you'll be left
  2372. 1:11:58behind in the future. Which is their
  2373. 1:11:59continual narrative. That if you don't
  2374. 1:12:01get on the train today,
  2375. 1:12:03then you'll be left behind. By the way,
  2376. 1:12:05every single scam and con starts with
  2377. 1:12:07rushing you. Every single trick in
  2378. 1:12:10history begins with saying you must do
  2379. 1:12:12this now. And best piece of advice I
  2380. 1:12:14ever got was if anyone tries to rush you
  2381. 1:12:16and it's not literally a mortal thing
  2382. 1:12:18like you are bleeding or on fire or the
  2383. 1:12:19house is on fire, slow down. And yet all
  2384. 1:12:22of these companies say so scary. And now
  2385. 1:12:25they're talking about slow downs. But
  2386. 1:12:26you ever notice that Amodei and Altman
  2387. 1:12:28they say oh maybe we should slow down
  2388. 1:12:29progress. And then they don't. Right now
  2389. 1:12:32Altman's saying oh we slow down progress
  2390. 1:12:33because we're so delayed. Now they're
  2391. 1:12:35out compute. Now they're doing it. But I
  2392. 1:12:37can guarantee you by the way their PR
  2393. 1:12:38people do not like me. I know for a I
  2394. 1:12:40know I don't think Open AI's PR people
  2395. 1:12:42are super fond of me for
  2396. 1:12:43>> But I bet there's elements of what
  2397. 1:12:44you're saying because you're calming
  2398. 1:12:46people you you are theoretically calming
  2399. 1:12:47down the general public.
  2400. 1:12:49>> And you know what? I hope I am because
  2401. 1:12:51the fear based tactics is horrible.
  2402. 1:12:53These companies don't want that. These
  2403. 1:12:54companies want people scared. I'm 100%
  2404. 1:12:56sure.
  2405. 1:12:58>> I don't I just fundamentally disagree. I
  2406. 1:12:59think it
  2407. 1:13:00>> Can I So, the timelines there and I sit
  2408. 1:13:02here and what I do is I log their quotes
  2409. 1:13:04over time. And I read them out from 2015
  2410. 1:13:08to 2026.
  2411. 1:13:09And the change you see is them going
  2412. 1:13:12from there could be extinction. That's
  2413. 1:13:14the narrative the early narrative. Elon
  2414. 1:13:16said it himself. He says it's the single
  2415. 1:13:17most dangerous thing in the
  2416. 1:13:18>> Elon says a lot of things.
  2417. 1:13:19>> And then you track it over time and it
  2418. 1:13:21evolves to this age of abundance. We're
  2419. 1:13:23all going to have unlimited stuff. And
  2420. 1:13:25then um the the the new slogan at
  2421. 1:13:28ChatGPT is intelligence for everyone. It
  2422. 1:13:30suddenly and all the and and whenever
  2423. 1:13:32Dario comes out and says, "By the way,
  2424. 1:13:34it's really rough and dangerous." They
  2425. 1:13:35attack Dario.
  2426. 1:13:37>> Yeah, that's me.
  2427. 1:13:37>> They hate him.
  2428. 1:13:38>> Yeah, that might
  2429. 1:13:39>> [laughter]
  2430. 1:13:39>> Dario is
  2431. 1:13:40>> They're like, "Dario, shut the up."
  2432. 1:13:41>> Honestly, I I've been saying, "Dario,
  2433. 1:13:43shut the up." for years, but it's
  2434. 1:13:45The thing is, I get your point where
  2435. 1:13:47it's like
  2436. 1:13:47>> I don't think they've changed to calm
  2437. 1:13:49the public down so much as they're
  2438. 1:13:51desperate to not get regulated, which is
  2439. 1:13:53laughable. We don't regulate tech. We
  2440. 1:13:55don't regulate America doesn't
  2441. 1:13:57regulate We are in the We are
  2442. 1:13:59still trapped in the hands of Milton
  2443. 1:14:02Friedman, Margaret Thatcher, and
  2444. 1:14:04Ronald Reagan. We're still stuck in the
  2445. 1:14:06near liberalistic hellscape, which is
  2446. 1:14:09growth at all costs free market
  2447. 1:14:10capitalism. So, no. No one's regulating.
  2448. 1:14:13The regulation of these companies should
  2449. 1:14:15have been, I don't know, breaking up Put
  2450. 1:14:17these bastards aside. Break up these
  2451. 1:14:20>> For sure. We shouldn't have companies
  2452. 1:14:21this big. It makes things worse.
  2453. 1:14:22>> technologies are dangerous.
  2454. 1:14:24>> I mean, they're dangerous, but not in
  2455. 1:14:26the ways they've been warning about.
  2456. 1:14:27>> Less If we think about cyber hacking.
  2457. 1:14:29>> Right. And just be clear, those cyber
  2458. 1:14:31hacking things that happened were not a
  2459. 1:14:33result of They were like, "Break out of
  2460. 1:14:35the sandbox." And then they set the
  2461. 1:14:36sandbox up
  2462. 1:14:38wrong. They set up the server they were
  2463. 1:14:39on wrong.
  2464. 1:14:40>> But I mean, you know, advanced AI models
  2465. 1:14:42could very easily, cuz they can go out
  2466. 1:14:44onto the open internet as agents, they
  2467. 1:14:46could very easily go and look at code
  2468. 1:14:48bases of different websites, find
  2469. 1:14:50vulnerabilities, and exploit those
  2470. 1:14:51vulnerabilities.
  2471. 1:14:52>> Yeah.
  2472. 1:14:52>> And at scale, and arguably, um, at a
  2473. 1:14:55higher intelligence and faster and wider
  2474. 1:14:59than humans a human hacker could
  2475. 1:15:01theoretically. So, that's dangerous.
  2476. 1:15:02>> Well, here's the funny thing.
  2477. 1:15:04We don't know how much compute was spent
  2478. 1:15:06to do the hugging face attack, the open
  2479. 1:15:08AI one. We also do know that they
  2480. 1:15:10improperly set up the server to keep it
  2481. 1:15:11in. They thought they'd turn the
  2482. 1:15:13internet off, and they didn't. That's
  2483. 1:15:15human error, and that's human error in a
  2484. 1:15:16sense that, yeah, they threw about an
  2485. 1:15:19indeterminately large amount of compute.
  2486. 1:15:21This is dangerous, but people keep
  2487. 1:15:22saying we can't let the the Chinese get
  2488. 1:15:25a hold of these models. We couldn't
  2489. 1:15:27possibly, because what if these models
  2490. 1:15:28fall into the wrong hands? They're
  2491. 1:15:30already in the wrong hands. Mark
  2492. 1:15:32Zuckerberg, Sam Altman, Dario Amodei.
  2493. 1:15:34The wrong hands are the hands of those
  2494. 1:15:37who are running these companies. We
  2495. 1:15:38should not be training these models to
  2496. 1:15:41do these things. I don't know why the
  2497. 1:15:42we're doing it, other than they've
  2498. 1:15:44run out of other things they can train
  2499. 1:15:46on. There's a ton. And the fact that
  2500. 1:15:48they can do it is kind of interesting.
  2501. 1:15:49>> But you do it Would you agree that it's
  2502. 1:15:52an intelligence, and I'll call it that,
  2503. 1:15:54you know, you might disagree with that
  2504. 1:15:55terminology, but an intelligence that
  2505. 1:15:57can go out onto the internet and click
  2506. 1:15:59around and take actions is inherently
  2507. 1:16:03there's risks associated with that.
  2508. 1:16:05Well,
  2509. 1:16:06>> the second part I agree with, the risks.
  2510. 1:16:08We've had people running automated
  2511. 1:16:09scripts hacking scripts for a while.
  2512. 1:16:11We've had hackers doing that for years
  2513. 1:16:12and years and years. This is brute
  2514. 1:16:14forcing it with a bunch of compute, and
  2515. 1:16:15yet,
  2516. 1:16:16it is dangerous. These companies are
  2517. 1:16:18doing something dangerous. That is not
  2518. 1:16:21what Geoffrey Hinton et al. have been
  2519. 1:16:23warning about. They've been saying, "Oh,
  2520. 1:16:24these things could destroy society. They
  2521. 1:16:26could manipulate people." When you
  2522. 1:16:27actually look at the underlying thing,
  2523. 1:16:28it's not so much. Geoffrey Hinton, as
  2524. 1:16:30well, talking his book, still got his
  2525. 1:16:32Google stock, I think. And weirdly
  2526. 1:16:33enough, he left Google cuz he was
  2527. 1:16:34worried about the AI there, but then
  2528. 1:16:36immediately made a comment being like,
  2529. 1:16:38"Yeah, actually though, Google's very
  2530. 1:16:39responsible." Strange thing, that. But
  2531. 1:16:41let's get back to the the cybersecurity
  2532. 1:16:43side. I agree, this is dangerous. These
  2533. 1:16:45people should not have access to so much
  2534. 1:16:46compute. They clearly don't know what to
  2535. 1:16:48do with it. There's a really easy way of
  2536. 1:16:50dealing with this. It's not letting them
  2537. 1:16:52use so much compute. It's regulating
  2538. 1:16:54that part out of existence. What if the
  2539. 1:16:55Chinese do it?
  2540. 1:16:57The Chinese are able to distill the
  2541. 1:16:58models.
  2542. 1:16:59And also,
  2543. 1:17:01I don't know, regulate it and stop I I
  2544. 1:17:04feel like with this particular thing as
  2545. 1:17:06well,
  2546. 1:17:08we got to this point and let the genie
  2547. 1:17:09out of the bottle to use an annoying Sam
  2548. 1:17:11Altman term.
  2549. 1:17:13We let this happen because we let these
  2550. 1:17:14companies be unregulated and use as much
  2551. 1:17:16compute as we want. We have these
  2552. 1:17:18enablers allowing them to burn
  2553. 1:17:20as much compute as they want. And also,
  2554. 1:17:22we for all of these dire warnings about
  2555. 1:17:25AI dangers, no one seems to have
  2556. 1:17:27done anything.
  2557. 1:17:28>> Okay, we're going to play a game, Ed.
  2558. 1:17:29>> Let's play it.
  2559. 1:17:30>> On these cards here, I have the things
  2560. 1:17:32that you consider to be myths about the
  2561. 1:17:35AI industry.
  2562. 1:17:36The challenge is I want you to give me
  2563. 1:17:39one sentence.
  2564. 1:17:41on each myth.
  2565. 1:17:42>> Ah, crap.
  2566. 1:17:43>> So, just your first reaction. You're
  2567. 1:17:44going to pick it up, you're going to
  2568. 1:17:45read it, and then you're going to give
  2569. 1:17:46me one sentence on your opinion of that
  2570. 1:17:49um belief.
  2571. 1:17:50>> Okay, let's go.
  2572. 1:17:51>> So,
  2573. 1:17:51>> Let's do this.
  2574. 1:17:56>> What does it say and what and what's
  2575. 1:17:57your one sentence?
  2576. 1:17:58>> It says the the AI industry is creating
  2577. 1:18:00enormous economic growth.
  2578. 1:18:02No, it's not. It's nowhere in the data.
  2579. 1:18:05>> Okay.
  2580. 1:18:05>> [laughter]
  2581. 1:18:06>> Like it's just May I do a second
  2582. 1:18:07sentence?
  2583. 1:18:08>> Go ahead.
  2584. 1:18:09>> Pretty much all of the economics is
  2585. 1:18:10either Nvidia feeding money to its
  2586. 1:18:12companies like CoreWeave or these three
  2587. 1:18:14companies feeding money to these ones to
  2588. 1:18:16spend it with the them.
  2589. 1:18:18>> Okay.
  2590. 1:18:19And what evidence do you have that
  2591. 1:18:20there's it's not causing economic
  2592. 1:18:22growth?
  2593. 1:18:23>> Just to be clear, other than the spend
  2594. 1:18:25on semiconductors, so the speculative
  2595. 1:18:27investment in GPUs and data center
  2596. 1:18:29infrastructure, that's happening. But,
  2597. 1:18:31as far as like spend on AI goes, barely
  2598. 1:18:33cracking a hundred billion dollars, and
  2599. 1:18:35most of that is just these two running
  2600. 1:18:37their services and paying these three
  2601. 1:18:39companies Oracle, Huawei, and others.
  2602. 1:18:41>> But a hundred billion dollars is a lot
  2603. 1:18:43of money for a relatively new
  2604. 1:18:44technology.
  2605. 1:18:45>> Not when you've spent three hundred
  2606. 1:18:46billion dollars in equity funding and
  2607. 1:18:49if we're going with just these three, I
  2608. 1:18:51think six hundred billion dollars in
  2609. 1:18:52capital expenditures.
  2610. 1:18:53>> Yeah, I get that. That means it's not
  2611. 1:18:54profitable, but the hundred billion is
  2612. 1:18:57an expression of consumer demand.
  2613. 1:18:58>> When the compute is mostly driven by
  2614. 1:19:00subscriptions that subsidized, no, it's
  2615. 1:19:02not. When you're giving someone twenty
  2616. 1:19:03dollars or forty dollars for a dollar,
  2617. 1:19:05they are going to use it more. If this
  2618. 1:19:07was all on a per million token basis,
  2619. 1:19:08we'd have a different conversation.
  2620. 1:19:10>> Fine. Cool. Next one.
  2621. 1:19:13The United States need to spend
  2622. 1:19:15trillions to beat China in the AI race.
  2623. 1:19:19Let's see.
  2624. 1:19:21What AI race?
  2625. 1:19:22That's actually That's actually my
  2626. 1:19:25point. It's what AI race is there? Is it
  2627. 1:19:27to make big scary LLMs? They They did
  2628. 1:19:30that already. Without the Nvidia GPUs.
  2629. 1:19:32By the way, they've got Blackwell GPUs.
  2630. 1:19:33Kakashi and Just Taro, two amazing
  2631. 1:19:35analysts I love. They've been on this
  2632. 1:19:37for years. It's like
  2633. 1:19:38China's already had Nvidia GPUs that
  2634. 1:19:40they're not meant to have for years. But
  2635. 1:19:42also, to do what? They already got the
  2636. 1:19:44LLMs. What What's the race to do? To
  2637. 1:19:46make us spend more money than them? For
  2638. 1:19:47us to constantly piss our pants worrying
  2639. 1:19:49about China? Because they won if that's
  2640. 1:19:51the case.
  2641. 1:19:53Myth number three, AI will replace all
  2642. 1:19:56human jobs.
  2643. 1:19:58That just isn't happening. There's no
  2644. 1:19:59economic data to support it.
  2645. 1:20:02>> Will it replace some jobs?
  2646. 1:20:04>> I mean, it's replace some contract labor
  2647. 1:20:06that would otherwise be replaced with
  2648. 1:20:07cheap labor out in the global south.
  2649. 1:20:09It's a digital globalization that sense,
  2650. 1:20:11but
  2651. 1:20:13all jobs, most jobs, a lot of jobs, no.
  2652. 1:20:16>> What about robotics?
  2653. 1:20:17>> Robotics is not what we're talking
  2654. 1:20:19about. Robotics is a very different
  2655. 1:20:20thing. And even then,
  2656. 1:20:21>> Robotics will be powered by AI.
  2657. 1:20:23>> I mean, yes, but there are tons of
  2658. 1:20:24different kinds of AI. We're talking
  2659. 1:20:25explicitly about generative AI, and
  2660. 1:20:27that's what I This is for my myth
  2661. 1:20:28busters piece. It was definitely about
  2662. 1:20:30generative AI.
  2663. 1:20:31>> Okay, but what about robotics? Like the
  2664. 1:20:33thing is the Optimus robot that Elon's
  2665. 1:20:35working on at Tesla.
  2666. 1:20:36>> The one where even in the demo of the
  2667. 1:20:38hand, he still like they had to have a
  2668. 1:20:40guy controlling it. It wasn't doing that
  2669. 1:20:42autonomously. Here's the thing. If they
  2670. 1:20:44can
  2671. 1:20:45beat all these challenges, yeah,
  2672. 1:20:46robotics would be really cool. I don't
  2673. 1:20:48know how long that's That's one I'd
  2674. 1:20:49actually be willing to believe in a
  2675. 1:20:52couple decades.
  2676. 1:20:53>> Have you seen them try them Chinese
  2677. 1:20:54robots? I know you've seen them Chinese
  2678. 1:20:56>> What's it called? The one that can dance
  2679. 1:20:58and that, but they can't really do human
  2680. 1:21:00things.
  2681. 1:21:01>> Well, it's just it is pretty
  2682. 1:21:02mind-blowing.
  2683. 1:21:03>> It's robotics are cool. I like
  2684. 1:21:06I'm not going to pretend I don't think
  2685. 1:21:07robots are cool. I wish they were
  2686. 1:21:08building robots and actually doing cool
  2687. 1:21:11I wish the tech industry still
  2688. 1:21:12made fun stuff and interesting stuff.
  2689. 1:21:14Instead we get these large
  2690. 1:21:15language models.
  2691. 1:21:16>> But with AI plus robotics is an You
  2692. 1:21:19know, I I was in San Francisco and I
  2693. 1:21:21went to this massive incubator there.
  2694. 1:21:23And when I'd gone there 3 years earlier,
  2695. 1:21:25it was all software startups. And when I
  2696. 1:21:27went back 3 years later, it was all
  2697. 1:21:29these robots startups. And I remember
  2698. 1:21:30saying to the founder of the incubator,
  2699. 1:21:31I was like, "Why is everything robots
  2700. 1:21:33now?" There was this one robot where it
  2701. 1:21:35was just the arm and it had a frying pan
  2702. 1:21:37on it.
  2703. 1:21:37>> Yeah.
  2704. 1:21:38>> And its whole thing is it cooks for you.
  2705. 1:21:39Yeah. So it was it was showing me it
  2706. 1:21:41cooking, whatever. And he goes, "Well,
  2707. 1:21:42you know the arm? He goes the the
  2708. 1:21:44hardware part, the physical parts,
  2709. 1:21:47that's always been fairly cheap." Yeah.
  2710. 1:21:48He goes, "The expensive part was the
  2711. 1:21:50intelligence. And now that's come down
  2712. 1:21:52to pennies. So what you're seeing is
  2713. 1:21:53this explosion in the robotics industry
  2714. 1:21:55cuz robotics is a function of
  2715. 1:21:56intelligence plus hardware. We've always
  2716. 1:21:58had the
  2717. 1:21:58>> And a ton of data though as well. Like
  2718. 1:22:00data is very expensive.
  2719. 1:22:02>> Yeah.
  2720. 1:22:03>> The thing is cybercabs rolled out real
  2721. 1:22:05slow. It's going to take a long time. It
  2722. 1:22:07could be a threat. If they do a robot
  2723. 1:22:10that could replace a human job, sure it
  2724. 1:22:11could. But that human jobs are
  2725. 1:22:13multifaceted. Human jobs change with
  2726. 1:22:15environments and also a lot of human
  2727. 1:22:17jobs that you might think of like I
  2728. 1:22:19don't know, dishwashing robot for
  2729. 1:22:20example.
  2730. 1:22:21>> Yeah.
  2731. 1:22:22>> Some guy at a restaurant isn't paying
  2732. 1:22:2410, 20 grand for a robot to replace the
  2733. 1:22:26job that they're already not paying
  2734. 1:22:27enough for.
  2735. 1:22:29The point is, yeah, it could if you can
  2736. 1:22:31replace the jobs. That is not what we're
  2737. 1:22:33talking about with this.
  2738. 1:22:34>> Yeah, I I just I just I ask these
  2739. 1:22:36questions not because I'm trying to be
  2740. 1:22:37like
  2741. 1:22:38I actually I'm trying to form my own
  2742. 1:22:39opinion on these things and I I do
  2743. 1:22:43think, you know, as it's written there,
  2744. 1:22:45it says AI will replace all human jobs.
  2745. 1:22:48Obviously not. Obviously that's
  2746. 1:22:50But I'm I'm trying to figure out if the
  2747. 1:22:51truth is somewhere in the middle. That
  2748. 1:22:53there's a certain type of job which
  2749. 1:22:55actually humans probably shouldn't have
  2750. 1:22:57ever been doing really.
  2751. 1:22:58Um if you think back through history,
  2752. 1:22:59there was someone's job just to sit in
  2753. 1:23:01an elevator and press the buttons.
  2754. 1:23:02>> Right.
  2755. 1:23:03>> example of a job that humans probably
  2756. 1:23:04shouldn't have been doing. And as
  2757. 1:23:05technology gets more advanced, it takes
  2758. 1:23:07on a lot of that
  2759. 1:23:09sort of automated monotonous stuff.
  2760. 1:23:11>> Right. The thing is
  2761. 1:23:13with this particular thing that I know
  2762. 1:23:15that this is from, it's a specific blog
  2763. 1:23:16I wrote. I was explicitly talking about
  2764. 1:23:18generative AI though. I was explicitly
  2765. 1:23:19[clears throat] talking about people
  2766. 1:23:20when they say this, they're referring to
  2767. 1:23:22that.
  2768. 1:23:23>> So, you're not talking about agentic AI
  2769. 1:23:24with
  2770. 1:23:25>> Agentic AI is LLMs. Agentic AI is just a
  2771. 1:23:27fancy way of saying an LLM talking to
  2772. 1:23:29another LLM with a harness on top. That
  2773. 1:23:31is still LLMs. Agentic AI is one of the
  2774. 1:23:33big the bigger lies they tell. It's like
  2775. 1:23:35when you hear agent, you're meant to
  2776. 1:23:36think autonomous AI can do what you
  2777. 1:23:38want. It's still LLMs. It's still LLMs
  2778. 1:23:40talking to other LLMs doing what LLMs
  2779. 1:23:42>> Yeah.
  2780. 1:23:42>> taking screenshots and putting them in
  2781. 1:23:43LLMs and stuff.
  2782. 1:23:44>> Oh god, yeah.
  2783. 1:23:45>> Okay, but but you know, I could I could
  2784. 1:23:47make the case that
  2785. 1:23:49I'm just thinking about my personal
  2786. 1:23:50usage. I definitely use agents to do
  2787. 1:23:53things that I would have previously
  2788. 1:23:55asked people to do. It's not to say that
  2789. 1:23:56I didn't I still don't hire cuz we're
  2790. 1:23:57hiring like crazy.
  2791. 1:23:58>> Yeah.
  2792. 1:23:59>> And I still in that particular function
  2793. 1:24:00I'm thinking about like the chief of
  2794. 1:24:02staff role.
  2795. 1:24:03So, my chief of staff would have triaged
  2796. 1:24:05all of my inboxes previously and put
  2797. 1:24:06them somewhere
  2798. 1:24:08and told me about them or maybe once
  2799. 1:24:09upon a time showed me a piece of paper
  2800. 1:24:10back in the day, I guess. Now, my chief
  2801. 1:24:12of staff is no longer doing that job.
  2802. 1:24:14>> Do you still have a chief of staff
  2803. 1:24:15though?
  2804. 1:24:16>> And this is what I'm saying, they're
  2805. 1:24:16doing other things.
  2806. 1:24:18>> Right. But the thing is, again, what you
  2807. 1:24:20were describing is
  2808. 1:24:22fairly basic automation. I don't know
  2809. 1:24:23what the tasks are, Tristram.
  2810. 1:24:25>> basic even
  2811. 1:24:26>> They spent a trillion dollars on
  2812. 1:24:27triaging email. Like, that's the the
  2813. 1:24:29promise is if they'd spent 10 billion
  2814. 1:24:31dollars and this was much smaller and
  2815. 1:24:32you're like, "Oh, cool. Cool software.
  2816. 1:24:34Yay." A lot of the things that people
  2817. 1:24:35are impressed with are like script stuff
  2818. 1:24:36as well. It's just LLMs doing Python.
  2819. 1:24:38You should be impressed by Python code.
  2820. 1:24:40Python's incredible. You can scrape
  2821. 1:24:42websites, you can download It's
  2822. 1:24:43awesome.
  2823. 1:24:44But, the point I'm making is
  2824. 1:24:46none of this would be anywhere near as
  2825. 1:24:48much of a problem if they didn't ask for
  2826. 1:24:50all of the attention, all of the money,
  2827. 1:24:51and promise the world. It's their
  2828. 1:24:53promises that are the problem and the
  2829. 1:24:55journalists who went along with it and
  2830. 1:24:56the analysts and the Twitter people who
  2831. 1:24:57went along with this saying that this
  2832. 1:24:59would change everything and replace
  2833. 1:25:00everything and leaving the realm of
  2834. 1:25:02reality.
  2835. 1:25:03>> Is there any technological innovation
  2836. 1:25:05through history that was really, really
  2837. 1:25:07game-changing where that didn't happen?
  2838. 1:25:10>> I mean
  2839. 1:25:12the internet.
  2840. 1:25:13>> I mean, people over-promised that.
  2841. 1:25:15>> I mean, they over-promised on the
  2842. 1:25:16businesses, but I've read through a
  2843. 1:25:18great many pieces about the early
  2844. 1:25:20internet. A lot of people were
  2845. 1:25:22excited but hesitant. They were worried
  2846. 1:25:25that there was not enough demand, but
  2847. 1:25:27they were still like, "Oh, yeah. This
  2848. 1:25:29could have potential ramifications if it
  2849. 1:25:31happened." People were not super
  2850. 1:25:33negative about the internet. A lot of
  2851. 1:25:35the skeptics were saying, "We're worried
  2852. 1:25:36about an overload of bad information."
  2853. 1:25:38Look at where we are. A lot of people
  2854. 1:25:40were worried about the social
  2855. 1:25:41consequences of everyone talking online,
  2856. 1:25:43which they were correct about. With the
  2857. 1:25:45economic things, they were specifically
  2858. 1:25:46talking about like the Globe, which I
  2859. 1:25:48think made hundreds of thousands of
  2860. 1:25:49dollars and had like a
  2861. 1:25:51think a billion-dollar market cap. They
  2862. 1:25:53were talking
  2863. 1:25:54>> Yeah, there was massive hype in the
  2864. 1:25:55dot-com era.
  2865. 1:25:56>> I read a lot of those stories. The hype
  2866. 1:25:57was nowhere near You didn't have
  2867. 1:25:59articles everywhere that was saying
  2868. 1:26:01"If you don't get online, you'll be left
  2869. 1:26:02behind." You didn't have professional
  2870. 1:26:05consequences. Nick Srnicek mentioned his
  2871. 1:26:07blog earlier. He described the thing
  2872. 1:26:08global AI assisting global
  2873. 1:26:10decision-making, where he said that you
  2874. 1:26:12have
  2875. 1:26:13businesses you work at where if you
  2876. 1:26:16don't say that you're more productive
  2877. 1:26:17with AI, whether or not it's true is
  2878. 1:26:19irrelevant, you have professional
  2879. 1:26:21consequences, you can get fired. There
  2880. 1:26:23are people having to AI wash their jobs
  2881. 1:26:25by saying AI did it. Otherwise, their
  2882. 1:26:27bosses, who don't do
  2883. 1:26:29will get mad at them. This did not
  2884. 1:26:32happen with the internet. It was not
  2885. 1:26:34present. And part of the thing is social
  2886. 1:26:35media was not like it is today. The kind
  2887. 1:26:38of uh was it decentralization of media
  2888. 1:26:41in general has caused this as well.
  2889. 1:26:43And also the fact that day trading
  2890. 1:26:45there's so many different things that
  2891. 1:26:46are different. It's crazy.
  2892. 1:26:47>> I I do I do think AI is different from
  2893. 1:26:50the internet in part if you just
  2894. 1:26:51measured it on the speed of adoption.
  2895. 1:26:53Especially if we can just think about
  2896. 1:26:54generative AI and AI is also
  2897. 1:26:55>> But but the the the the adoption of the
  2898. 1:26:57internet required physical connections
  2899. 1:26:59to your house. The adoption of
  2900. 1:27:01generative AI involves having a web
  2901. 1:27:02browser. It took a vast amount of effort
  2902. 1:27:05to bring internet to people. Even with
  2903. 1:27:07dial-up connections, it still required
  2904. 1:27:08the distribution.
  2905. 1:27:09>> why it was so slow and there was less,
  2906. 1:27:12you know, there was less hype than AI. I
  2907. 1:27:13do agree that there's way more hype. And
  2908. 1:27:15we are again, going back to this point
  2909. 1:27:16that we're clustering AI in this big
  2910. 1:27:19category of lots of different things. It
  2911. 1:27:21was generative AI. It's generative AI,
  2912. 1:27:23there's like real-world AI.
  2913. 1:27:24>> AI is explicitly what I'm talking about
  2914. 1:27:26here. When bosses are saying you need to
  2915. 1:27:28use AI, they're not saying I need you to
  2916. 1:27:29go and buy a Unibeam robot. They're
  2917. 1:27:31saying use LLMs so that I And that's the
  2918. 1:27:34thing. I have this theory that era of
  2919. 1:27:35the business idiot where it's like we
  2920. 1:27:37are ruled by people that don't do work
  2921. 1:27:39cuz nobody who actually does a bunch of
  2922. 1:27:40work, who really is productive, is
  2923. 1:27:43harassing someone who works to them for
  2924. 1:27:45not being productive enough. They're not
  2925. 1:27:47They don't have the time. They're doing
  2926. 1:27:48work. Someone who's sitting there with
  2927. 1:27:50the ingratiation machine that's telling
  2928. 1:27:52them that every beautiful idea out of
  2929. 1:27:53their messy little skull is amazing.
  2930. 1:27:56Yeah, they're going, "Damn, this thing
  2931. 1:27:57says I'm a genius. Why are you not using
  2932. 1:27:59the genius machine to do more work?" And
  2933. 1:28:01yeah, if you're a boss that goes to
  2934. 1:28:03lunch, leaves lunch, and sometimes reads
  2935. 1:28:05your emails, LLMs are magic.
  2936. 1:28:06>> I do you know one of the most compelling
  2937. 1:28:08arguments I have for the over-hype of AI
  2938. 1:28:12in a world where everybody has access to
  2939. 1:28:14these tools, whatever the tools
  2940. 1:28:15[clears throat] can do would largely be
  2941. 1:28:18commoditized. And what the tools can't
  2942. 1:28:20do, which one could say is the human
  2943. 1:28:23taste judgment, you could say it's
  2944. 1:28:25people skills, whatever you want to say,
  2945. 1:28:27is now going to be the valuable thing
  2946. 1:28:29because the scarce and the hard becomes
  2947. 1:28:31the most valuable through history. And
  2948. 1:28:34the commoditized becomes the least
  2949. 1:28:35valuable. So, the very nature that we're
  2950. 1:28:37commoditizing the generation of content
  2951. 1:28:39or whatever you want to call it code,
  2952. 1:28:41means that's actually not where the
  2953. 1:28:42value will accrue as for the user.
  2954. 1:28:45And actually, if you think about what it
  2955. 1:28:47takes to now make something that is
  2956. 1:28:49objectively great, if an AI can do it,
  2957. 1:28:54then it's not the the great thing is not
  2958. 1:28:56a value. So, so I think a lot I've been
  2959. 1:28:58thinking a lot actually about how
  2960. 1:29:01how do you
  2961. 1:29:02avoid the temptation of slopification of
  2962. 1:29:05the things you make, the value you put
  2963. 1:29:06into the world? It's very simple example
  2964. 1:29:08that people will be able to relate to.
  2965. 1:29:10If you use ChatGPT or Anthropic, you
  2966. 1:29:12know, Claude to make your LinkedIn
  2967. 1:29:14posts, let's say,
  2968. 1:29:16they will be LinkedIn posts because
  2969. 1:29:18everybody else is using them. And
  2970. 1:29:19actually, a great LinkedIn post now is
  2971. 1:29:21someone who doesn't use them and makes
  2972. 1:29:22something that's like irreplaceably
  2973. 1:29:24human and
  2974. 1:29:26deeper and more personal, N of 1, lived
  2975. 1:29:30experience.
  2976. 1:29:31>> Yeah.
  2977. 1:29:32>> All these things that AI can't do. And I
  2978. 1:29:34think that's a compelling argument that
  2979. 1:29:35actually the commodity tools produce
  2980. 1:29:38commodity outcomes.
  2981. 1:29:39>> So, everyone has access to these things
  2982. 1:29:40and what's changed? Like really, like
  2983. 1:29:42what
  2984. 1:29:42>> The slopification of stuff.
  2985. 1:29:43>> We've We've got a bunch of slop, but
  2986. 1:29:45these people were half-assing their jobs
  2987. 1:29:46before. It's just a half-assery machine.
  2988. 1:29:49And it's just It's It's the thing It's
  2989. 1:29:51what I'm talking about with the slop
  2990. 1:29:52blocks. It's like It's a Yeah, people
  2991. 1:29:54that gave you dog before have now
  2992. 1:29:56got the dog machine to pump out dog
  2993. 1:29:58It's So, there's a guy called Carl
  2994. 1:30:00Brown, internet box, awesome guy, great
  2995. 1:30:02software engineer. He He said I might
  2996. 1:30:05have said this earlier, so it makes the
  2997. 1:30:06easy things easy, the hard harder. When
  2998. 1:30:07you know you're doing a really distinct
  2999. 1:30:09small script for something and it can
  3000. 1:30:10pop that out, it's awesome. I used
  3001. 1:30:13Claude the other day for something
  3002. 1:30:14useful. My kid loves Minecraft. I was
  3003. 1:30:16trying to fix a broken mod cuz
  3004. 1:30:18he loves his Wither Storm. It's awesome.
  3005. 1:30:20And it still took me half an hour and
  3006. 1:30:22kept getting things wrong. What do you
  3007. 1:30:24use AI for? Generative AI. I really
  3008. 1:30:25don't. I You don't use it. With
  3009. 1:30:27Bloomberg Terminal, I use Ask B, which
  3010. 1:30:29is just when it's like requesting the
  3011. 1:30:31consensus analyst estimates for Nvidia.
  3012. 1:30:33But otherwise, you don't use it.
  3013. 1:30:34>> No.
  3014. 1:30:35>> So, how do you know it's bad?
  3015. 1:30:36>> I've used it. I've put it through its
  3016. 1:30:37paces. I've used it to try and do
  3017. 1:30:39financial models and found one error and
  3018. 1:30:40immediately be like, "Ah." I've never
  3019. 1:30:42been particularly impressed. The one
  3020. 1:30:44thing I will defend it on is it's really
  3021. 1:30:46good for like tech support. Like I have
  3022. 1:30:48this thing called Synergy in my New York
  3023. 1:30:50New York place I go to. I have this
  3024. 1:30:51monitor where I have a MacBook and a PC
  3025. 1:30:53laptop. And this thing Synergy for using
  3026. 1:30:55the same mouse and keyboard.
  3027. 1:30:57Dropping a giant
  3028. 1:30:59troubleshooting log into this thing and
  3029. 1:31:01going, "What's wrong?" And it going,
  3030. 1:31:03"This is wrong." Yeah, super useful. Is
  3031. 1:31:05that trillion-dollar nut? Is that a
  3032. 1:31:06two-trillion-dollar company? No. Pretty
  3033. 1:31:08easy.
  3034. 1:31:08>> Better than Google, though, right?
  3035. 1:31:10Better than Google, though.
  3036. 1:31:10>> I mean, yeah. Remember to use Google
  3037. 1:31:13Search still?
  3038. 1:31:13>> I try. I have to push the crap
  3039. 1:31:16out of the way and scroll.
  3040. 1:31:17>> I can't remember the last time I did a
  3041. 1:31:20Google search. Christ, I find myself
  3042. 1:31:21using Bing sometimes.
  3043. 1:31:23>> I know. I hate saying it, too. But I
  3044. 1:31:25have to scroll past the AI crap cuz I
  3045. 1:31:27want the good stuff. I want the I want
  3046. 1:31:29the actual links to stuff so that I can
  3047. 1:31:31read the thing and go
  3048. 1:31:32>> But you can ask
  3049. 1:31:34the AI to give you the links.
  3050. 1:31:35>> Yeah, and it doesn't do a particularly
  3051. 1:31:37good job. Like my
  3052. 1:31:38>> Say Say that the other day, my iPad
  3053. 1:31:40wasn't turning on and it was doing this
  3054. 1:31:41funny little thing on the screen. You
  3055. 1:31:43think that it's better to type that into
  3056. 1:31:45Google than
  3057. 1:31:45>> Oh, no. I must be clear. That may be the
  3058. 1:31:48only LLM use case I defend. The
  3059. 1:31:50troubleshooting thing is awesome for it.
  3060. 1:31:51I will It's the the one weakness I have.
  3061. 1:31:53It's like genuinely being able to drop a
  3062. 1:31:55log into it. That's awesome. Again, that
  3063. 1:31:58is not what they're selling it as.
  3064. 1:32:00They're not selling it as a useful
  3065. 1:32:01little tool. They're selling it as the
  3066. 1:32:04uh software, as the thing that will
  3067. 1:32:06change everything, that will replace all
  3068. 1:32:08jobs, that will do this and that. It's
  3069. 1:32:10not like they sold it as a quirky bit of
  3070. 1:32:12software.
  3071. 1:32:12>> No, you are all right. They are, you
  3072. 1:32:13know, telling us that it is going to
  3073. 1:32:15replace everything. But, funnily enough,
  3074. 1:32:16the critics are saying that as well.
  3075. 1:32:18>> Which one? I mean I mean
  3076. 1:32:20>> like, the Geoffrey Hintons of the world.
  3077. 1:32:21You know, even people that have left the
  3078. 1:32:23safety team in ChatGPT who have who have
  3079. 1:32:25who have who have sat here with the the
  3080. 1:32:26these are critics that are that are
  3081. 1:32:28warning of the impacts it's going to
  3082. 1:32:30have on the world.
  3083. 1:32:31>> Sweet, all these critics also have a
  3084. 1:32:33vested interest in AI doing well,
  3085. 1:32:35though. Daniel Former, OpenAI guy, AI
  3086. 1:32:372027, written with the Star Codex guy
  3087. 1:32:39that was nothing more than badly written
  3088. 1:32:41science fiction that he's already had to
  3089. 1:32:43walk back.
  3090. 1:32:44>> could have made more money by staying at
  3091. 1:32:45ChatGPT.
  3092. 1:32:47>> Could he?
  3093. 1:32:48>> I mean, looks like it.
  3094. 1:32:49>> If he had options early
  3095. 1:32:51>> It sticking around would have made him
  3096. 1:32:52>> Did he lose the options? How much did he
  3097. 1:32:54>> You can't You're not saying that they're
  3098. 1:32:55they're being critical
  3099. 1:32:57>> They're not critical of the companies
  3100. 1:32:59themselves. They're not critical of the
  3101. 1:33:00stealing. They're not critical of the
  3102. 1:33:01environmental damage. They're not
  3103. 1:33:03critical of the fact that you cannot
  3104. 1:33:04rely on the answers. They're critical of
  3105. 1:33:06this big scary boogeyman out in the
  3106. 1:33:09future
  3107. 1:33:10where it's like, oh, I'm scared of when
  3108. 1:33:12this becomes so powerful, and everyone
  3109. 1:33:14should talk to me about how scary and
  3110. 1:33:15powerful it is. They're not saying,
  3111. 1:33:17"Hey, here are the harms today. Here are
  3112. 1:33:18the things we're actually looking at
  3113. 1:33:20today. Here are the social problems of
  3114. 1:33:22having this automated way of spewing out
  3115. 1:33:25slop, of filling our feeds with crap, of
  3116. 1:33:28having information that will pop up that
  3117. 1:33:30is presented even with the little
  3118. 1:33:31disclaimer thing of saying, 'Yeah,
  3119. 1:33:33sometimes this gets wrong.' So, in
  3120. 1:33:34the tiniest words possible." They don't
  3121. 1:33:37talk about the fact that these things
  3122. 1:33:39are trained on stealing millions of
  3123. 1:33:41people's work.
  3124. 1:33:41>> But, on that last point where you say
  3125. 1:33:43that it's going to get progressively
  3126. 1:33:44more intelligent, and when it does, it
  3127. 1:33:45will be a danger.
  3128. 1:33:46>> Yeah.
  3129. 1:33:47>> Would you agree with the statement that
  3130. 1:33:49artificial intelligence has gotten more
  3131. 1:33:51intelligent
  3132. 1:33:53if you measure it based on any sort of
  3133. 1:33:55measure of intelligence one might use?
  3134. 1:33:57>> It's got better on the test that are
  3135. 1:33:59rigged for the models, it's got better
  3136. 1:34:00at tests where you can train for the
  3137. 1:34:02test.
  3138. 1:34:03>> Okay, so it's got better at
  3139. 1:34:04>> It's got better at tests that they're
  3140. 1:34:05intentionally trained for. So,
  3141. 1:34:07>> If you logged the rate of improvement on
  3142. 1:34:10a graph, it would look something like
  3143. 1:34:12this.
  3144. 1:34:13>> Right.
  3145. 1:34:14>> in terms of what it's capable of doing.
  3146. 1:34:16>> Oh, that's
  3147. 1:34:17>> There we go.
  3148. 1:34:18>> Yeah, cuz it's not It's not got new
  3149. 1:34:20features. You'll notice that outside of
  3150. 1:34:22OpenAI and Anthropic, the va
  3151. 1:34:24>> When you remove the coding startups,
  3152. 1:34:26there's basically no successful AI
  3153. 1:34:28startup company.
  3154. 1:34:29>> So, we agree that it's got better, it's
  3155. 1:34:31got more capable
  3156. 1:34:34at doing things.
  3157. 1:34:35>> Yeah,
  3158. 1:34:35>> Okay, fine.
  3159. 1:34:36>> Over time, AI has got more capable. If
  3160. 1:34:38we imagine that trajectory will
  3161. 1:34:41continue, it will get more capable.
  3162. 1:34:43Then at some point it does cross, you
  3163. 1:34:46know,
  3164. 1:34:47this is what they say to me, it crosses
  3165. 1:34:48human intelligence. And at such time,
  3166. 1:34:51will it not start to do
  3167. 1:34:53some of the jobs that people are doing
  3168. 1:34:54today?
  3169. 1:34:55>> Outside of software engineering. Remove
  3170. 1:34:56software cuz I will concede software
  3171. 1:34:58engineering has got better at that.
  3172. 1:34:59>> Outside of software engineering,
  3173. 1:35:01>> Yeah.
  3174. 1:35:01>> where?
  3175. 1:35:02>> So, the chief of staff things, the
  3176. 1:35:03admin.
  3177. 1:35:04>> Okay, so it's got better at admin.
  3178. 1:35:05>> Video generation, photo generation,
  3179. 1:35:08text generation, uh theoretically,
  3180. 1:35:10coding.
  3181. 1:35:11>> Right, but
  3182. 1:35:12>> And then I'd say agentic workflows.
  3183. 1:35:14>> What is an agentic workflow?
  3184. 1:35:15>> So, automated workflows is where you're
  3185. 1:35:17doing the same I mean, a good example is
  3186. 1:35:20looking at the back-end data of the
  3187. 1:35:21Darvis CEO.
  3188. 1:35:22>> Summarizing.
  3189. 1:35:23>> Looking at all of the data, ingesting
  3190. 1:35:24all of it, going on the internet and
  3191. 1:35:25searching who that is.
  3192. 1:35:26>> Uh-huh.
  3193. 1:35:26>> Looking at every interview you've ever
  3194. 1:35:28done ever.
  3195. 1:35:29>> Uh-huh. This is summarizing and
  3196. 1:35:31generating.
  3197. 1:35:32>> Making a little model on, you know, the
  3198. 1:35:33things people want to know from Ed.
  3199. 1:35:35>> Uh-huh.
  3200. 1:35:35>> Producing a report, sending that to my
  3201. 1:35:37inbox.
  3202. 1:35:37>> Uh-huh.
  3203. 1:35:37>> Me getting a 20, 30, 40, 50-page report
  3204. 1:35:39on Ed before he arrives.
  3205. 1:35:41>> This is all basically the same thing
  3206. 1:35:42it's been doing for years, though. It's
  3207. 1:35:44It's not really new capabilities.
  3208. 1:35:45>> Research, it's it's
  3209. 1:35:46>> It's still the
  3210. 1:35:48>> It's still the same thing. They've had
  3211. 1:35:49web search for years. They've had report
  3212. 1:35:51generation for years. Well, we couldn't
  3213. 1:35:52generate
  3214. 1:35:54high-quality videos that are like
  3215. 1:35:56indistinguishable from cameras. See
  3216. 1:35:58dance and these ones that look like
  3217. 1:36:00movies.
  3218. 1:36:01>> I mean, they
  3219. 1:36:01>> are incredible.
  3220. 1:36:02So, I'm saying the point I'm trying to
  3221. 1:36:03make is that if we imagine that over the
  3222. 1:36:05last 10 years there has been a rate of
  3223. 1:36:06improvement in terms of capabilities and
  3224. 1:36:08output and quality. We've seen
  3225. 1:36:10hallucinations drop, we've seen the
  3226. 1:36:12models get more quote-unquote
  3227. 1:36:13intelligent, get better at, you know, if
  3228. 1:36:15you did it give it an IQ test, it's
  3229. 1:36:17getting higher scores than it was 10
  3230. 1:36:18years ago. We agree that there's been a
  3231. 1:36:20upward motion of improvement.
  3232. 1:36:21>> This is pretty much how machine learning
  3233. 1:36:22goes when you feed it more data.
  3234. 1:36:24>> Exactly, and you put more compute behind
  3235. 1:36:25it. So, if this continues,
  3236. 1:36:29what does the future look like? So, the
  3237. 1:36:32rebuttal I was expecting to hear is that
  3238. 1:36:33it won't continue.
  3239. 1:36:34>> And I actually don't think it I think
  3240. 1:36:36that there are hard limits that we're
  3241. 1:36:38going to hit.
  3242. 1:36:38>> Okay, so you do believe in that there's
  3243. 1:36:40a hard limit somewhere.
  3244. 1:36:41>> kind of already hit the diminishing
  3245. 1:36:43returns level because
  3246. 1:36:45for example, video generation, which is,
  3247. 1:36:47by the way, far less than American
  3248. 1:36:49concern anymore. Open AI has shut down
  3249. 1:36:51Sora. I think you can still use the API,
  3250. 1:36:53but nevertheless,
  3251. 1:36:55look at the look around you with the
  3252. 1:36:56amount of stuff and the crew you need to
  3253. 1:36:57get a shot. People think that movies are
  3254. 1:36:59just shot by shot by shot and they just
  3255. 1:37:00magically happen. When you've got my my
  3256. 1:37:02wonderful girlfriend of first ADs, so
  3257. 1:37:05assistant directors, you've got gaffers,
  3258. 1:37:06you've got lighters, and also simulating
  3259. 1:37:09light is insanely difficult. There are
  3260. 1:37:11so many magical things that happen in
  3261. 1:37:13creating visual images that yeah, you
  3262. 1:37:15could create a 1-minute long thing that
  3263. 1:37:16might fool someone. How do you
  3264. 1:37:18practically turn that into a movie?
  3265. 1:37:19Because that movie I forget what the
  3266. 1:37:21name is. There's a movie that claimed it
  3267. 1:37:23aired at Can. It didn't. No one It aired
  3268. 1:37:26in the city of Can during the Can Film
  3269. 1:37:28Festival. It was not at the film
  3270. 1:37:29festival.
  3271. 1:37:30When it comes to the practical creation
  3272. 1:37:31of actual things at the end of it versus
  3273. 1:37:33magic tricks, the actual practical
  3274. 1:37:35outcomes are not there. The reason I
  3275. 1:37:36keep coming back to the capabilities
  3276. 1:37:38thing for the example is yeah, they can
  3277. 1:37:39do better at tests, do better at you
  3278. 1:37:42number go up. When it comes to can this
  3279. 1:37:44actually do two tasks that you can rely
  3280. 1:37:46on it?
  3281. 1:37:47You can rely on it for summaries. You
  3282. 1:37:48can rely on it for generations. The
  3283. 1:37:50things it was doing it's getting
  3284. 1:37:52linearly-ish better at. But again,
  3285. 1:37:55there's a ceiling to that. Like, okay,
  3286. 1:37:57so it gets really good at research. What
  3287. 1:37:58does that actually mean? You've already
  3288. 1:38:00kind of got the automation there. What
  3289. 1:38:02is the next step of that? Because
  3290. 1:38:03training it to be more autonomous, for
  3291. 1:38:04example, that's not something that comes
  3292. 1:38:06from training data. That is actually a
  3293. 1:38:07new
  3294. 1:38:09Gary Marcus a neuro-symbolic. You need
  3295. 1:38:11as you need to build a structure around
  3296. 1:38:12the AI to make it work. And even then,
  3297. 1:38:15doesn't fix the pro So you're
  3298. 1:38:16>> So you're saying that there will become
  3299. 1:38:17a point where the rate of improvement
  3300. 1:38:20will plateau?
  3301. 1:38:21>> there.
  3302. 1:38:21>> And stop.
  3303. 1:38:22>> We've already hit that dimension. Gary
  3304. 1:38:23Marcus said this in 2022 as well.
  3305. 1:38:25>> You know, there's lots of people
  3306. 1:38:26listening now that like they've had
  3307. 1:38:28their workflows completely transformed
  3308. 1:38:30by these tools.
  3309. 1:38:31>> Have they? They'll be be Yeah, they
  3310. 1:38:33will. Yeah, the thing is, first of all,
  3311. 1:38:35every single one of them, did you pay
  3312. 1:38:37for the tokens? That's the thing. Did
  3313. 1:38:38you pay for the tokens? And also,
  3314. 1:38:40how many tokens did you burn? But
  3315. 1:38:41putting all that aside, what workflows?
  3316. 1:38:43Because if it's yeah, I did a bunch of
  3317. 1:38:44web scraping or web searches, I'm just
  3318. 1:38:46not impressed. Did you make an entire
  3319. 1:38:48movie? No, you didn't. Is it
  3320. 1:38:51speeding up your coding? Yeah, I believe
  3321. 1:38:52that. I've heard that from multiple
  3322. 1:38:54people. But again,
  3323. 1:38:56how much can you trust this
  3324. 1:38:57>> I think what I was getting at is,
  3325. 1:38:59you know, when in the moment of any
  3326. 1:39:01technological innovation,
  3327. 1:39:03people they extrapolate linearly or they
  3328. 1:39:07view it as a static state. I mean, they
  3329. 1:39:09think today is going to look like
  3330. 1:39:10tomorrow. Or they think it's going to
  3331. 1:39:11get better in the sort of straight line.
  3332. 1:39:13But what we end up seeing a lot of the
  3333. 1:39:14time is this exponential improvement.
  3334. 1:39:16>> All of the innovations we're talking
  3335. 1:39:18about with you with like with computer
  3336. 1:39:20and all that with fast processors, those
  3337. 1:39:21are hardware breakthroughs. The hardware
  3338. 1:39:23breakthrough companies don't seem to be
  3339. 1:39:25fixing the LLM problems. Despite the all
  3340. 1:39:28the king's horses, all the king's men
  3341. 1:39:29were what? 9 10 generations of TPUs from
  3342. 1:39:32Google now. Broadcom's building stuff
  3343. 1:39:34with Open AI, their jalapeno chip. And
  3344. 1:39:36yet none of these people can just say,
  3345. 1:39:38"Yeah, we're on the path to making this
  3346. 1:39:39profitable." Because they can't. If we
  3347. 1:39:41fix the environmental problems and the
  3348. 1:39:43profitability situation, maybe I'd be
  3349. 1:39:45more generous with this stuff. But they
  3350. 1:39:47don't seem to be able to and you talk
  3351. 1:39:50about these improvements in
  3352. 1:39:51capabilities,
  3353. 1:39:53there's a certain point at which I'm
  3354. 1:39:54saying, "Okay, can it do even a tenth of
  3355. 1:39:57the stuff they're promising?" Sam Altman
  3356. 1:39:59the other week was saying it's
  3357. 1:40:00going to be a you know, like 6 months
  3358. 1:40:02we'll be like a genie that you can ask
  3359. 1:40:03wishes for from this like motherfucker's
  3360. 1:40:06never watched Aladdin. What's he talking
  3361. 1:40:07about? Like
  3362. 1:40:08Also, the the genie was charming.
  3363. 1:40:10Anyway, long story short,
  3364. 1:40:13the promises do not line up with the
  3365. 1:40:14capabilities or the capability
  3366. 1:40:15improvements. An exponential improvement
  3367. 1:40:18in software and software performance is
  3368. 1:40:22always a result of direct hardware
  3369. 1:40:24improvement. We have all the gifted
  3370. 1:40:26mathematicians, all the gifted software
  3371. 1:40:28engineers, all the gifted hardware
  3372. 1:40:29engineers.
  3373. 1:40:31And where are we? Trillion plus dollars
  3374. 1:40:33in with
  3375. 1:40:34the future great financial crisis and
  3376. 1:40:36the world's greatest marketing psyop.
  3377. 1:40:38>> I just think in the future
  3378. 1:40:39>> I do think that all of the devices and
  3379. 1:40:41the computers we use and the physical
  3380. 1:40:43items in our world will be more
  3381. 1:40:44intelligent.
  3382. 1:40:45>> I mean, sure, but is that LLMs?
  3383. 1:40:47>> And that'll be powered by the underlying
  3384. 1:40:49AI infrastructure. It'll be the data
  3385. 1:40:52centers data centers. It'll be energy
  3386. 1:40:53coming down.
  3387. 1:40:54>> How does a
  3388. 1:40:55GPU full data center translate to
  3389. 1:41:00a Nikon camera that can I don't know
  3390. 1:41:03even what you'd think think it could
  3391. 1:41:05like because what is the thing we're
  3392. 1:41:06talking about here? Because the idea
  3393. 1:41:08that devices will get smarter, sure, I
  3394. 1:41:11can see that that's a very broad
  3395. 1:41:12statement. I can see it happening. It's
  3396. 1:41:13already kind of happening. What does
  3397. 1:41:15that have to do with the data centers?
  3398. 1:41:16Because these data centers again are not
  3399. 1:41:18being built to make your consumer
  3400. 1:41:20electronics smarter. They're not being
  3401. 1:41:22built for anything other than
  3402. 1:41:24speculating on the ability to capture
  3403. 1:41:26demand for generative AI services.
  3404. 1:41:27>> But it's not just generative AI. We went
  3405. 1:41:29through that.
  3406. 1:41:29>> It is No, but those data centers, they
  3407. 1:41:31are being built for generative AI. They
  3408. 1:41:32are not being built for anything else.
  3409. 1:41:34>> Would Do consider generative AI to be
  3410. 1:41:37the fact that on Meta's earnings call
  3411. 1:41:38like a couple of weeks ago, Mark
  3412. 1:41:40Zuckerberg said the big breakthrough
  3413. 1:41:41we've had which has resulted in 15 basis
  3414. 1:41:43points of increased retention, I believe
  3415. 1:41:46he was referring to Instagram, is that
  3416. 1:41:48we now take anything you post on social
  3417. 1:41:50media and we run it through an AI to get
  3418. 1:41:53full context of what it is and because
  3419. 1:41:55we can see guy sat in front of me called
  3420. 1:41:57Ed with blue shirt and coffee, we now
  3421. 1:42:01can train AI to serve whoever wants blue
  3422. 1:42:04shirt Ed with coffee to the right user
  3423. 1:42:07which means people are retained longer
  3424. 1:42:08because
  3425. 1:42:09>> Isn't 15 basis points like 0.15%?
  3426. 1:42:11>> so small but it makes a difference at
  3427. 1:42:12scale.
  3428. 1:42:13It makes a big difference at scale.
  3429. 1:42:15>> Yeah, but 100 and something billion
  3430. 1:42:16dollars in and the best you've got is
  3431. 1:42:180.15%?
  3432. 1:42:19>> If If he could be fired, I mean how much
  3433. 1:42:22of a difference because
  3434. 1:42:24there's a reason he's saying basis
  3435. 1:42:26points versus dollars.
  3436. 1:42:28Because think about it like this. If
  3437. 1:42:30Mark Zuckerberg was I take your point
  3438. 1:42:32about scale.
  3439. 1:42:32>> No, I'm saying the point I was making
  3440. 1:42:34was that that is another application of
  3441. 1:42:37these data centers cuz it needs a data
  3442. 1:42:39center that is driving revenues but also
  3443. 1:42:43that's not that's outside of us thinking
  3444. 1:42:45about just generating a data center.
  3445. 1:42:47>> and that's generate the gem there
  3446. 1:42:48generative model.
  3447. 1:42:49>> Muse.
  3448. 1:42:50>> It was it Oh, Muse Spark is their LLM.
  3449. 1:42:52Gem is their generative model. Well,
  3450. 1:42:54Muse
  3451. 1:42:55then then that's them doing the weird
  3452. 1:42:57thing where it's like on Instagram and
  3453. 1:42:58it's like Dave the cat, why is Dave the
  3454. 1:43:00cat suffering? Like it's the weird
  3455. 1:43:01pop-up things. Meta is God damn
  3456. 1:43:04that company sucks. Like every time I
  3457. 1:43:06think about how they've ruined that
  3458. 1:43:07product but that's the thing though,
  3459. 1:43:08again, why can't he just say with his
  3460. 1:43:10whole chest we've made a couple billion?
  3461. 1:43:12Why can't he say that? Because he isn't
  3462. 1:43:14because there's not actually a way of
  3463. 1:43:15going I spent all this money, I spent 14
  3464. 1:43:18billion god damn dollars on scale. I
  3465. 1:43:20hired Alexander Wong and I made this
  3466. 1:43:22much. They can't It gets back to a very
  3467. 1:43:24simple point of hey, if it was going
  3468. 1:43:27well, you'd tell me how well it was
  3469. 1:43:29going rather than
  3470. 1:43:31I don't know, doing this weird rain
  3471. 1:43:32dance where you're like, "Well, if we
  3472. 1:43:34move all the pieces around in 3 years,
  3473. 1:43:36theoretically this will happen."
  3474. 1:43:39>> I've done almost 700 interviews with
  3475. 1:43:41some of the most interesting people in
  3476. 1:43:43the world. And one of the things you
  3477. 1:43:44learn, which is unexpected, is that
  3478. 1:43:46vulnerability is the doorway to
  3479. 1:43:48connection. And after sitting here for
  3480. 1:43:502-3 hours with a guest, I feel a deep
  3481. 1:43:53sense of connection to them. And as they
  3482. 1:43:55leave, what I get them to do is to write
  3483. 1:43:57a question in the diary of a CEO. We've
  3484. 1:44:01taken all of the questions from the
  3485. 1:44:02Diary of a CEO. We have put the question
  3486. 1:44:06here on this card with the name of the
  3487. 1:44:08person that wrote it. So, you can sit at
  3488. 1:44:10home, as I do with my fiance, and my
  3489. 1:44:12colleagues at work, and other people in
  3490. 1:44:14my life, whenever we get a minute, we
  3491. 1:44:16play the Diary of a CEO conversation
  3492. 1:44:18cards. And it is incredible what
  3493. 1:44:21happens. These are great if you're in a
  3494. 1:44:23romantic relationship, and you want to
  3495. 1:44:24connect your partner more. These are
  3496. 1:44:26also great if you're in a team, and you
  3497. 1:44:28want to bond your team together. And I
  3498. 1:44:30have to say, they're also great for
  3499. 1:44:31families that want to learn more about
  3500. 1:44:32each other, and that need a good excuse
  3501. 1:44:34to spend some time in a digital world in
  3502. 1:44:37the analog environment, connecting human
  3503. 1:44:40to human. It is remarkable what the
  3504. 1:44:42right question at the right time can do.
  3505. 1:44:45Go to the diary.com,
  3506. 1:44:48and you can get these conversation cards
  3507. 1:44:50right now.
  3508. 1:44:51There should be a button just down below
  3509. 1:44:53here. And if it says subscribe, you're
  3510. 1:44:55already subscribed. If it says
  3511. 1:44:56subscribe-a, that means you're not yet.
  3512. 1:44:59And if you're not subscribed, please
  3513. 1:45:00could you do us a favor and hit that
  3514. 1:45:01button. It helps to show more than you
  3515. 1:45:02know. And according to the algorithm,
  3516. 1:45:04you're someone that watches our show,
  3517. 1:45:06but you haven't yet hit that button.
  3518. 1:45:07Thank you so much.
  3519. 1:45:09>> I do think you're accurate and right
  3520. 1:45:10when you talk about the fact that
  3521. 1:45:12there's a lot of like Is the word
  3522. 1:45:13fugazi? Yeah. Where like there's a lot
  3523. 1:45:15of people that have spent a lot of
  3524. 1:45:16money, and they kind of shouldn't have
  3525. 1:45:17spent it, and they up. And now
  3526. 1:45:19they're thinking, "Shit, like we spent
  3527. 1:45:20all this invested money." Kind of like
  3528. 1:45:22the metaverse was a bit of a
  3529. 1:45:23>> Oh my god. That was a bit of a joke.
  3530. 1:45:24>> That's so weird. Lot of money spent, we
  3531. 1:45:26kind of thought this dream was coming of
  3532. 1:45:28this one I shouldn't say dream cuz it's
  3533. 1:45:29not a dream that I've had.
  3534. 1:45:30>> A dream that they had.
  3535. 1:45:31>> Yeah, this sort of virtual world and
  3536. 1:45:33actually it never transpired and there's
  3537. 1:45:34there's no sign that it will in the near
  3538. 1:45:36term. AI and the dot-com boom
  3539. 1:45:40in this regard are the same. NFTs were
  3540. 1:45:41the same.
  3541. 1:45:43>> Right.
  3542. 1:45:43>> So, crypto one could argue that a lot of
  3543. 1:45:44the crypto industry was the same.
  3544. 1:45:46>> It's way that is inflated by the media.
  3545. 1:45:48The difference is the reason the
  3546. 1:45:50metaverse and NFTs didn't escape this
  3547. 1:45:52was they weren't stocks to speculate on.
  3548. 1:45:55They weren't big companies that you
  3549. 1:45:56could invest in. They had rec- record
  3550. 1:45:58earnings in 2021. There was a bunch of
  3551. 1:46:00money flowing in the system thanks to
  3552. 1:46:01post-COVID, uh the PRDC that basically
  3553. 1:46:04government federal money flowed in to
  3554. 1:46:06the banks. There was a bunch of easy
  3555. 1:46:07money, zero interest for the era. Money
  3556. 1:46:10was easy to find. Then after that, there
  3557. 1:46:11was the hangover. Growth started to slow
  3558. 1:46:13down dramatically. This is actually my
  3559. 1:46:15rock combo bubble theory, which is they
  3560. 1:46:16don't have any hypergrowth ideas
  3561. 1:46:18anymore. So, suddenly they started
  3562. 1:46:21buying GPUs. When they bought GPUs,
  3563. 1:46:23people went they're doing AI.
  3564. 1:46:25Oh, we better buy the stock and the
  3565. 1:46:27stocks went on an incredible run. Meta's
  3566. 1:46:28like several hundred percent growth. In
  3567. 1:46:30the last few years, their stock has
  3568. 1:46:31grown like hundreds of percent despite
  3569. 1:46:33zero proof. And because the media was
  3570. 1:46:36just saying, "Yeah,
  3571. 1:46:38Meta's revenue's growing cuz of AI,
  3572. 1:46:40right? Microsoft's revenue's growing cuz
  3573. 1:46:42of AI, right?" The fugazi you're talking
  3574. 1:46:44about was the fact that everyone just
  3575. 1:46:45gave them credit in advance. And now
  3576. 1:46:47we're kind of getting to the point where
  3577. 1:46:48it's like, "Hey,
  3578. 1:46:50you didn't spend that trillion dollars
  3579. 1:46:51for no reason, did you Sacha?" Amy Amy
  3580. 1:46:54heard just going to take him out back,
  3581. 1:46:55send him to the glue factory or
  3582. 1:46:57something? Like
  3583. 1:46:57>> I do think there's overspending. I I
  3584. 1:46:59want to concede that point. I do think
  3585. 1:47:00there's
  3586. 1:47:00>> Dramatic.
  3587. 1:47:01>> Yeah, no, I do think there is. And I
  3588. 1:47:02think the reason why there's
  3589. 1:47:04overspending and is I think there is
  3590. 1:47:07something here.
  3591. 1:47:08>> And what?
  3592. 1:47:09>> In terms of like I think there is prac-
  3593. 1:47:11practical uses for this technology. And
  3594. 1:47:14I think when people realize that through
  3595. 1:47:16history, they go crazy cuz they want to
  3596. 1:47:18be the person that owns the opportunity.
  3597. 1:47:20going
  3598. 1:47:20>> honest. I just I fundamentally don't
  3599. 1:47:22agree.
  3600. 1:47:22>> You don't agree with which part?
  3601. 1:47:24>> I don't agree that this that the
  3602. 1:47:25speculation is a result of actual
  3603. 1:47:27demand. I don't believe it's a spec I
  3604. 1:47:28don't think private credit is sinking
  3605. 1:47:30conscious of billions of dollars into AI
  3606. 1:47:32because of actual demand. They are doing
  3607. 1:47:33it because they saw the biggest
  3608. 1:47:34companies in the world building data
  3609. 1:47:35centers making a ton of money from two
  3610. 1:47:37companies they feed money and went I
  3611. 1:47:39want some of that money.
  3612. 1:47:40>> I'm saying that I do think there is
  3613. 1:47:42value in the underlying technology. I
  3614. 1:47:44think that and so I think I'm not saying
  3615. 1:47:46how much value.
  3616. 1:47:47>> Right.
  3617. 1:47:48>> Okay, I get I actually I get you meaning
  3618. 1:47:50that.
  3619. 1:47:50>> That's fair.
  3620. 1:47:50>> I'm not saying it's proportionate to the
  3621. 1:47:52investment. All I'm saying is that do
  3622. 1:47:54you know what it's like? It's like I
  3623. 1:47:55mean if I take your example, the raw
  3624. 1:47:57economy essay that you wrote. Say that
  3625. 1:47:58you're on a desert island and then
  3626. 1:48:00someone says they found a banana tree.
  3627. 1:48:02>> Right.
  3628. 1:48:03>> And there's
  3629. 1:48:04there's 10,000 people on the island.
  3630. 1:48:06>> Okay.
  3631. 1:48:07>> They are going to stampede
  3632. 1:48:10towards where they think the banana tree
  3633. 1:48:11is. They are going to claw each
  3634. 1:48:14other to pieces and if if your essay
  3635. 1:48:16here is right that there was desperation
  3636. 1:48:17cuz they hadn't found an innovation in a
  3637. 1:48:19while. Maybe that explains it. Maybe
  3638. 1:48:21there is a bit of value here.
  3639. 1:48:22>> Right.
  3640. 1:48:23>> And they're stampeding
  3641. 1:48:25and killing each other and making
  3642. 1:48:26irrational decisions like hungry people
  3643. 1:48:28would.
  3644. 1:48:28>> I actually think we're then we actually
  3645. 1:48:30agree. That is actually my point which
  3646. 1:48:32is these three companies in meta, their
  3647. 1:48:34main business lines are running out of
  3648. 1:48:36growth. There's only so much they can
  3649. 1:48:37grow and indeed in the next three and a
  3650. 1:48:38half years analysts think that these two
  3651. 1:48:40bastards these two open AI and Anthropic
  3652. 1:48:42are going to spend over 400 billion
  3653. 1:48:44dollars on these people alone.
  3654. 1:48:45>> Microsoft
  3655. 1:48:46>> Google and Amazon and the crazy thing is
  3656. 1:48:48is that's a large part of their future
  3657. 1:48:50growth and if this money isn't spent
  3658. 1:48:52their growth slows down.
  3659. 1:48:53>> Okay.
  3660. 1:48:53>> So your point about the bananas, I
  3661. 1:48:55actually agree. That is the raw comb
  3662. 1:48:56bubble. It's they don't have a new thing
  3663. 1:48:57and they're desperate and indeed they
  3664. 1:49:00got rewarded for buying the GPUs. They
  3665. 1:49:02got when they bought these goddamn GPUs
  3666. 1:49:04from Nvidia, all the markets went rock
  3667. 1:49:07hard overnight. They loved it. There
  3668. 1:49:09were stories about how they were sending
  3669. 1:49:10armored cars with the GPUs to Microsoft
  3670. 1:49:12to make sure Microsoft got the GPUs and
  3671. 1:49:15so everyone saw all that money flowing
  3672. 1:49:16in even though they never disclosed
  3673. 1:49:18their AI revenues. They saw the
  3674. 1:49:19expenditures and they went
  3675. 1:49:21"Well, I want to do what these people
  3676. 1:49:22are doing. I want to get a little of
  3677. 1:49:24that money, don't I?"
  3678. 1:49:25>> I think the area where we have a slight
  3679. 1:49:27disagreement is that I think the
  3680. 1:49:29underlying technology has a lot more
  3681. 1:49:31promise over the long term than you do.
  3682. 1:49:34>> So the thing I want to push back on
  3683. 1:49:36there is
  3684. 1:49:37to have progress with AI
  3685. 1:49:40>> Yeah.
  3686. 1:49:41>> taking it in a vacuum. To have progress
  3687. 1:49:42for these two companies to keep going,
  3688. 1:49:45to keep progressing, they need to spend
  3689. 1:49:47tens of billions of dollars a year on
  3690. 1:49:49training.
  3691. 1:49:50>> Uh-huh.
  3692. 1:49:50>> The only way that that can happen is if
  3693. 1:49:52these companies and venture capitalists
  3694. 1:49:54and private credit firms and Nvidia keep
  3695. 1:49:56circulating money to them. So the
  3696. 1:49:58progress
  3697. 1:49:59>> Yeah.
  3698. 1:49:59>> that we've got so far is entirely a
  3699. 1:50:01result of this circular system. So it
  3700. 1:50:03means that
  3701. 1:50:04>> Circular? You talked about VCs there.
  3702. 1:50:06>> Venture capitalists who are, by the way,
  3703. 1:50:08>> Investors.
  3704. 1:50:09>> the majority of the funding that OpenAI
  3705. 1:50:11got in the last 6 months came from
  3706. 1:50:13SoftBank, Nvidia, and Amazon.
  3707. 1:50:15>> Okay.
  3708. 1:50:16>> Yeah.
  3709. 1:50:16>> So
  3710. 1:50:17>> Just the point is is you're talking
  3711. 1:50:18about progress continuing. Progress in
  3712. 1:50:21LLMs can only continue as long as the
  3713. 1:50:23money keeps flowing. Once the money Once
  3714. 1:50:26the money stops flowing, the progress
  3715. 1:50:28stops, which means
  3716. 1:50:28>> But isn't that most like early like
  3717. 1:50:30Spotify didn't make money for 20 years?
  3718. 1:50:31>> Spotify didn't lose 20.9 billion dollars
  3719. 1:50:33in 1 year. They didn't need to raise 217
  3720. 1:50:36billion dollars in the space of 6
  3721. 1:50:38months.
  3722. 1:50:38>> Yeah, and like Uber's another example.
  3723. 1:50:39>> 33 billion dollars since inception
  3724. 1:50:41before it became a messy kind of
  3725. 1:50:43profitable. Amazon Web Services between
  3726. 1:50:442003 and 2015 when it became profitable,
  3727. 1:50:4729.7 billion dollars.
  3728. 1:50:48>> They've spent
  3729. 1:50:49>> Yeah, that's the total capital
  3730. 1:50:51expenditures and that's not just Amazon
  3731. 1:50:52Web Services, that's the entire
  3732. 1:50:54logistics operation, normalized for
  3733. 1:50:55inflation.
  3734. 1:50:56>> So they all lost money for a long period
  3735. 1:50:58of time is the TLDR.
  3736. 1:50:59>> Yes, but the amount of money they lost
  3737. 1:51:01is
  3738. 1:51:03completely
  3739. 1:51:05just magnitudes different on a level
  3740. 1:51:07where these three companies
  3741. 1:51:09>> Can I argue then that the that's because
  3742. 1:51:11the potential of intelligence permeates
  3743. 1:51:14everything. Whereas Amazon at the time
  3744. 1:51:16was like selling books.
  3745. 1:51:17>> No.
  3746. 1:51:17>> That was That was bringing retail
  3747. 1:51:19online.
  3748. 1:51:19>> When Amazon Web Services grew, it was
  3749. 1:51:21great.
  3750. 1:51:21>> Oh, Amazon Web Services.
  3751. 1:51:22>> Amazon Web Services. So, Amazon Cloud.
  3752. 1:51:24With Amazon Web Services, the reason I
  3753. 1:51:25bring that up, I'm going to repeat
  3754. 1:51:26something, but it's really important.
  3755. 1:51:272003 it was founded. And it was founded
  3756. 1:51:30mostly because Amazon as a growing
  3757. 1:51:32online store needed hardcore
  3758. 1:51:33infrastructure.
  3759. 1:51:352006 I think is when they turned it
  3760. 1:51:37client-facing. I may be wrong on the
  3761. 1:51:38dates there, but 2015
  3762. 1:51:40>> is the year it became profitable.
  3763. 1:51:41>> Yeah.
  3764. 1:51:41>> The total capital expenditures
  3765. 1:51:43normalized for inflation were $29.7
  3766. 1:51:45billion across that 12-year period.
  3767. 1:51:48>> Yeah.
  3768. 1:51:48>> And yeah, it lost money, but
  3769. 1:51:51if we speak cold economics here,
  3770. 1:51:53Amazon
  3771. 1:51:55didn't have to go into the They were
  3772. 1:51:56unprofitable in a in a way, but their
  3773. 1:51:58margins actually started improving cuz
  3774. 1:51:59AWS was a very margin-heavy business. It
  3775. 1:52:01was great.
  3776. 1:52:02>> Yeah.
  3777. 1:52:03>> These These two, Google,
  3778. 1:52:05cash flow negative. Amazon, cash flow
  3779. 1:52:07negative. These businesses, the reason
  3780. 1:52:09you liked software businesses, was they
  3781. 1:52:11are meant to be
  3782. 1:52:13cash-heavy, asset-light. These
  3783. 1:52:16companies, along with Meta, have added
  3784. 1:52:18more than $700 billion
  3785. 1:52:20of new property, plants, and equipment,
  3786. 1:52:22so assets, data centers, GPUs in the
  3787. 1:52:25last 4 years. They have gone from being
  3788. 1:52:27these cash machines to these cash
  3789. 1:52:30furnaces.
  3790. 1:52:31>> You said a second ago this can only
  3791. 1:52:33continue if investors continue to
  3792. 1:52:35invest.
  3793. 1:52:35>> Yes.
  3794. 1:52:36>> And I was saying I I think that
  3795. 1:52:38investors are used to pumping money into
  3796. 1:52:40things that are burning cash. Your
  3797. 1:52:42rebuttal to me sounds like, "Well, this
  3798. 1:52:43is burning more cash than ever." And
  3799. 1:52:45then so I would say, "Well, is the
  3800. 1:52:47opportunity
  3801. 1:52:48bigger than those other case studies you
  3802. 1:52:51referenced like AWS?" And one would say
  3803. 1:52:54that the opportunity of intelligence
  3804. 1:52:58permeates everything. So, the TAM, the
  3805. 1:53:00total adjustable market, is enormous.
  3806. 1:53:03Maybe the rebuttal back to me is about
  3807. 1:53:05open-source and all these kinds of
  3808. 1:53:06things.
  3809. 1:53:06>> I I actually know you're getting at. So,
  3810. 1:53:08what you were describing there is the
  3811. 1:53:09argument that Satya Nadella or Sam
  3812. 1:53:11Altman would make, that the theoretical
  3813. 1:53:13opportunity of large language models.
  3814. 1:53:15And I could have bought that into
  3815. 1:53:17any 24 from them. When they were like,
  3816. 1:53:19"Oh, we see the opportunity." We've gone
  3817. 1:53:21way past the point at which you can
  3818. 1:53:23rationally argue that LLMs need this
  3819. 1:53:25much money. And when I say the money
  3820. 1:53:27needs to keep flowing, I am talking
  3821. 1:53:29these two comp- OpenAI, just OpenAI.
  3822. 1:53:33Clammy Sam Altman has said, Wall Street
  3823. 1:53:35Journal and Nisa Godizi reported a few
  3824. 1:53:37weeks ago, they plan to spend $750
  3825. 1:53:41billion on compute through 2030. I think
  3826. 1:53:44they're going to be dead before then,
  3827. 1:53:45but $750 billion.
  3828. 1:53:48That is an insane amount of money.
  3829. 1:53:50>> crazy.
  3830. 1:53:51>> [laughter]
  3831. 1:53:51>> A large chunk of that is training. So,
  3832. 1:53:53when I say progress, I mean literally to
  3833. 1:53:55make the models better at stuff requires
  3834. 1:53:57billions of dollars invested just in
  3835. 1:53:58data.
  3836. 1:54:00And also tens of billions of dollars of
  3837. 1:54:02taking that data. And so, training.
  3838. 1:54:04Training's actually a really interesting
  3839. 1:54:05thing because
  3840. 1:54:07when you think of like, well,
  3841. 1:54:09Jake and Troy are my trainers. Well, I
  3842. 1:54:10train with them. I lift with them. I
  3843. 1:54:11have a defined thing. When I do it and I
  3844. 1:54:13eat right, muscles get bigger. They
  3845. 1:54:15would
  3846. 1:54:16And here's the thing, when you train
  3847. 1:54:17with an LLM, you're experimenting. Each
  3848. 1:54:20And this is not actually a hit on the
  3849. 1:54:21companies, because they're still trying
  3850. 1:54:22to work out how to do the thing. Because
  3851. 1:54:25putting aside how I feel like they're
  3852. 1:54:27trying to innovate, I think there are
  3853. 1:54:28people at these companies that actually
  3854. 1:54:29want to do something interesting. It's
  3855. 1:54:31costing too much money. So, once the
  3856. 1:54:32money tap turns off,
  3857. 1:54:34the money won't be there to buy the data
  3858. 1:54:36or to feed the data into the GPUs. Put
  3859. 1:54:38aside all the thoughts I have, just the
  3860. 1:54:40raw capital to get them this far has
  3861. 1:54:42cost increasingly larger amounts of
  3862. 1:54:44money, and increasingly larger amounts
  3863. 1:54:46of training money for training runs that
  3864. 1:54:49sometimes can fail.
  3865. 1:54:50GPT-5 was meant to be this panacea for
  3866. 1:54:53the AI industry. They had at least one
  3867. 1:54:55training run that cost half a billion
  3868. 1:54:57dollars and did nothing. And that's the
  3869. 1:54:59thing.
  3870. 1:55:00If we are thinking about progress in a
  3871. 1:55:02in a vacuum, they need so much more
  3872. 1:55:04money just to maybe get somewhere.
  3873. 1:55:06There's no guarantee. There's never any
  3874. 1:55:07guarantee, but there's a reason that
  3875. 1:55:08Google and Amazon are cash flow negative
  3876. 1:55:10now. There's a reason why Oracle's
  3877. 1:55:11probably going to die
  3878. 1:55:13as a result of OpenAI because Oracle's
  3879. 1:55:15future depends on OpenAI spending $300
  3880. 1:55:18over 5 years.
  3881. 1:55:19>> It's absolutely fascinating because I
  3882. 1:55:21was just reading through a list of
  3883. 1:55:22quotes from the big CEOs of the AI
  3884. 1:55:24companies to see what they would
  3885. 1:55:25rebuttal you.
  3886. 1:55:26>> Yeah.
  3887. 1:55:27>> And they're all basically saying the
  3888. 1:55:29same thing. They're all saying this is
  3889. 1:55:31actual an exact quote from Sundar, who
  3890. 1:55:33is the CEO of Google. He says, "The risk
  3891. 1:55:35of under investing is dramatically
  3892. 1:55:38greater than the risk of over
  3893. 1:55:40investing."
  3894. 1:55:42And you go down you go through this that
  3895. 1:55:44you know but Andy Jassy, CEO of Amazon,
  3896. 1:55:46"We're not investing approximately 200
  3897. 1:55:47billion in CapEx in 2026 on a hunch.
  3898. 1:55:51We're not going to be conservative in
  3899. 1:55:53how we play this. We're investing to be
  3900. 1:55:55the meaningful leader and our future
  3901. 1:55:57business operating income and free cash
  3902. 1:55:59flow will be much larger because of this
  3903. 1:56:02investment." Then Mark Zuckerberg, CEO
  3904. 1:56:04of Meta, says, "We'll continue to invest
  3905. 1:56:06aggressively in infrastructure to meet
  3906. 1:56:08the demand. I'd rather risk building
  3907. 1:56:10capacity before it's needed than being
  3908. 1:56:12late."
  3909. 1:56:13>> I just be thinking of Shrek with Lord
  3910. 1:56:14Farquaad, "Some of you may die, but
  3911. 1:56:17that's a risk I'm willing to accept."
  3912. 1:56:18It's like, "You know, I'm just going to
  3913. 1:56:20spend all this money. You can't fire me
  3914. 1:56:21cuz Mark Zuckerberg can't be fired due
  3915. 1:56:23to the unique board situation he's got
  3916. 1:56:25going." So, yeah, he's just going to
  3917. 1:56:26piss the money away and hope he's right.
  3918. 1:56:28And I know from the people I know at
  3919. 1:56:29Meta, he's not right.
  3920. 1:56:30>> The thing is why might you be wrong?
  3921. 1:56:33>> I mean, this is the thing. The AI people
  3922. 1:56:35who claim this is going to be the
  3923. 1:56:36biggest strongest thing in the world,
  3924. 1:56:37did they ever get that I I mean this
  3925. 1:56:39>> It's a good question.
  3926. 1:56:40>> Because it's like they don't. And the
  3927. 1:56:41thing is what would it take for me to be
  3928. 1:56:43wrong? A bunch of hardware breakthroughs
  3929. 1:56:44that make this profitable. A bunch of
  3930. 1:56:46what question new math because the thing
  3931. 1:56:48is when it comes to being a critic or a
  3932. 1:56:50skeptic, you are put on the hot seat,
  3933. 1:56:52not the people spending a trillion
  3934. 1:56:54dollars, not the people promising the
  3935. 1:56:55world. The the the with a blog
  3936. 1:56:58is the one who's like, "No, no, no."
  3937. 1:56:59>> me. Trust me. If they came here, they'd
  3938. 1:57:01be on the hot seat, too. Trust me.
  3939. 1:57:03>> Oh, they They won't talk to me. Don't
  3940. 1:57:05know why they They
  3941. 1:57:06Don't know It's cuz I call him clammy
  3942. 1:57:07Sammy.
  3943. 1:57:09>> I think it's cuz my guests are quite
  3944. 1:57:10quite critical that I don't think Sam
  3945. 1:57:12Altman wants to come here.
  3946. 1:57:13>> Altman,
  3947. 1:57:14go on Steve Show. Do it. But this is the
  3948. 1:57:15thing, like, of course they're going to
  3949. 1:57:17say that. And also, if they thought they
  3950. 1:57:19were right, I don't think they do
  3951. 1:57:21anymore. If I was in their shoes and I
  3952. 1:57:22thought that this was an existential
  3953. 1:57:24thing, sure. But it gets back to the
  3954. 1:57:25rock con bubble, which is, yeah, this is
  3955. 1:57:27the last thing they've got.
  3956. 1:57:28>> But I really want to know that question.
  3957. 1:57:29It was one of the questions I was really
  3958. 1:57:30excited to ask you, which is, you have a
  3959. 1:57:32different opinion. We said this at the
  3960. 1:57:34top. You have a very different opinion
  3961. 1:57:35from a lot of people. I would categorize
  3962. 1:57:38the the two most popular opinions as
  3963. 1:57:40uh AI is going to hurt everybody and
  3964. 1:57:42it's going to be catastrophic and we
  3965. 1:57:43need to stop. Yeah. The other opinion is
  3966. 1:57:45age of abundance is going to be amazing.
  3967. 1:57:47Let us crack on.
  3968. 1:57:48>> Yeah.
  3969. 1:57:48>> Yours is different from both of those,
  3970. 1:57:50which is,
  3971. 1:57:51as you said in your words, it's a con
  3972. 1:57:53and it's and there's no real underlying
  3973. 1:57:55value in the technology and it's
  3974. 1:57:57overhyped.
  3975. 1:57:57>> Yes.
  3976. 1:57:58>> And there's way too much spending. I
  3977. 1:58:00mean, like, a few people agree on the
  3978. 1:58:01spending part, to be But the other part
  3979. 1:58:02So, with you, it's one of the probably
  3980. 1:58:04the first person that I've spoken to
  3981. 1:58:06that's had this opinion.
  3982. 1:58:07So, how What would it take for you to
  3983. 1:58:10change your mind
  3984. 1:58:12about what you believe here?
  3985. 1:58:14>> There would need to be a hardware
  3986. 1:58:15breakthrough that reduced the cost by
  3987. 1:58:18like a thousand. But it would have to be
  3988. 1:58:19just a dramatic breakthrough that is not
  3989. 1:58:21happening, just to be clear, because
  3990. 1:58:23they've all been trying.
  3991. 1:58:24>> So, what's the cost for you that would
  3992. 1:58:26have to change?
  3993. 1:58:26>> It's the cost, and it's also the data
  3994. 1:58:28centers. I think the way they're
  3995. 1:58:29building the data centers is reckless
  3996. 1:58:30and damaging to communities. The fact
  3997. 1:58:32that you have communities like in
  3998. 1:58:33Violand, New Jersey, where the residents
  3999. 1:58:35like, "I don't want this." But the
  4000. 1:58:36planning boards vote for it because
  4001. 1:58:37they're all I assume having chammy
  4002. 1:58:40lunches with the people doing it. I
  4003. 1:58:42think the use of gas turbines is
  4004. 1:58:44disgraceful. I The water situation, I'm
  4005. 1:58:46not super well read on, so I'm not going
  4006. 1:58:48to wade into it. But the use of gas
  4007. 1:58:49turbines and behind the meter of is
  4008. 1:58:51reckless and damaging to communities.
  4009. 1:58:53The noise that these things make and
  4010. 1:58:54also
  4011. 1:58:56generative AI is this egregious
  4012. 1:58:58pornographic
  4013. 1:59:00demonstration of how unfair the world
  4014. 1:59:02is. Regular people try and get a loan
  4015. 1:59:04for a business, random business they
  4016. 1:59:06want to have a good idea.
  4017. 1:59:07They go to a bank, bank will tell them
  4018. 1:59:08to go themselves. They'll say, "I'm
  4019. 1:59:10not going to give you what you're You're
  4020. 1:59:11going to make a store that sells stuff?
  4021. 1:59:12Screw you."
  4022. 1:59:13You want to build a data center? You
  4023. 1:59:16Jensen Huang will back you. Jensen Huang
  4024. 1:59:17will give you 25% residual value. You
  4025. 1:59:20want to build a regular business that's
  4026. 1:59:22even profitable? you. No, venture
  4027. 1:59:24capitalists won't give you the money.
  4028. 1:59:25Something that's just growing steadily
  4029. 1:59:27but it's profitable? Screw that. No, I
  4030. 1:59:29need 10 100X return. Try and get a
  4031. 1:59:31mortgage. You have to give the bank a
  4032. 1:59:34full colonic. But you want to get money
  4033. 1:59:36for Jensen Huang to buy some GPUs? He'll
  4034. 1:59:38give you a contract. Core Weave's a
  4035. 1:59:39great example. Core a Neo Cloud, which
  4036. 1:59:42is just a company that builds data
  4037. 1:59:43centers and puts GPUs and rent people.
  4038. 1:59:45Nvidia, one of their first investors in
  4039. 1:59:482023, signed a $1.3 billion contract
  4040. 1:59:52to rent back their GPUs from Core Weave
  4041. 1:59:55so that Core Weave go to a bank and go,
  4042. 1:59:56"I've got a customer. Yeah, it's the guy
  4043. 1:59:58I'm buying the GPUs from with the debt
  4044. 2:00:00I'm getting from you."
  4045. 2:00:02If you want to buy GPUs, it's open
  4046. 2:00:03season. If you want to live a regular
  4047. 2:00:05life where you build a regular business
  4048. 2:00:06or buy a house, highest interest rates
  4049. 2:00:09ever. Screw you. Up yours. Yeah, you
  4050. 2:00:12need to show us way more than that. I
  4051. 2:00:13don't trust you regular folks. But if
  4052. 2:00:15you're an unprofitable Neo Cloud,
  4053. 2:00:18you get billions from Jensen. It doesn't
  4054. 2:00:20matter.
  4055. 2:00:21>> It's so interesting. You It's
  4056. 2:00:22interesting because you are the first
  4057. 2:00:24person that I've spoken to that has that
  4058. 2:00:25opinion.
  4059. 2:00:26>> I am pro user. Let's take another myth.
  4060. 2:00:29AI will be conscious.
  4061. 2:00:31>> Mhm.
  4062. 2:00:32>> So,
  4063. 2:00:34superintelligence, artificial general
  4064. 2:00:36intelligence, these are theories.
  4065. 2:00:38Anyone saying this stuff will become
  4066. 2:00:41this is just guessing and does not have
  4067. 2:00:43proof.
  4068. 2:00:44>> Okay.
  4069. 2:00:45>> And that And like that's really it.
  4070. 2:00:46>> Okay.
  4071. 2:00:47Okay, let's take another myth.
  4072. 2:00:50>> AI systems are already blackmailing and
  4073. 2:00:52escaping control. So, this is a really
  4074. 2:00:54specific one. Anthropic, there's
  4075. 2:00:56actually two.
  4076. 2:00:57OpenAI's GPT-3.5
  4077. 2:01:00I realize this is more than a sentence,
  4078. 2:01:01I apologize.
  4079. 2:01:03in their system card. And a bunch of
  4080. 2:01:05media outlets covered this saying that
  4081. 2:01:07OpenAI's model blackmailed a task rabbit
  4082. 2:01:10into solving a capture. What actually
  4083. 2:01:12happened was a
  4084. 2:01:15user of GPT doing the experiment
  4085. 2:01:19got it to generate things to say to a
  4086. 2:01:21task rabbit to make a task rabbit do
  4087. 2:01:23stuff.
  4088. 2:01:24>> rabbit being
  4089. 2:01:24>> As in a person that you rent not even to
  4090. 2:01:27do a capture. It's someone you rent to
  4091. 2:01:28like nail that nail picture up in your
  4092. 2:01:30apartment. It's an insane example. This
  4093. 2:01:32was covered as if these things
  4094. 2:01:33blackmailed someone and and it and they
  4095. 2:01:36specifically said, "Yeah, we prompted it
  4096. 2:01:37to do this." And also, the other note
  4097. 2:01:40was that yeah, AI systems can't do
  4098. 2:01:41autonomous stuff like this. Then there
  4099. 2:01:43was this other one where Anthropic said,
  4100. 2:01:45"Oh, yeah, a model was blackmailing
  4101. 2:01:47someone saying that if you don't do
  4102. 2:01:49this, I'll email proof that you slept
  4103. 2:01:51with someone else other than your wife."
  4104. 2:01:53I think it was. What actually happened
  4105. 2:01:54was Anthropic explicitly trained a model
  4106. 2:01:57to do this and then prompted it to
  4107. 2:01:59blackmail.
  4108. 2:02:00This keeps happening and the media just
  4109. 2:02:03slop slop me up. I don't need no
  4110. 2:02:05thoughts. Put the story in the bag. And
  4111. 2:02:07it's frustrating because it's scarce
  4112. 2:02:10people. Put aside the fact it's wrong,
  4113. 2:02:12it's scary. It's scary to people. People
  4114. 2:02:14living their lives who have to work
  4115. 2:02:16longer hours to make less money and
  4116. 2:02:18their money doesn't go far. And they can
  4117. 2:02:20turn on the news and there's
  4118. 2:02:21some being like, "Yeah, you
  4119. 2:02:22should be terrified. It blackmailed
  4120. 2:02:24someone."
  4121. 2:02:25>> But this is a this is so
  4122. 2:02:26counterintuitive of their interest to
  4123. 2:02:28some degree and they've experienced it
  4124. 2:02:30backfire.
  4125. 2:02:31>> Well, they have now. Like it's it's
  4126. 2:02:33literally backfired.
  4127. 2:02:33>> It's backfired. Er- Eric Schmidt getting
  4128. 2:02:35booed at a commencement speech by 8,000
  4129. 2:02:37people every time he said the word AI.
  4130. 2:02:40But I mean, this is this is I mean,
  4131. 2:02:42they're they're these CEOs are being
  4132. 2:02:43attacked at home.
  4133. 2:02:44>> Yeah, which sucks.
  4134. 2:02:45>> Yeah, which is terrible.
  4135. 2:02:46>> I I must be clear, like, you dislike it
  4136. 2:02:48come don't hurt people.
  4137. 2:02:49>> Yeah, don't don't attack people at home.
  4138. 2:02:51But but the point here is that that
  4139. 2:02:53narrative is backfiring in a big big way
  4140. 2:02:56for them.
  4141. 2:02:56>> don't think they saw it coming. Because
  4142. 2:02:58you have to remember, you mentioned
  4143. 2:03:00regulation earlier. These tech companies
  4144. 2:03:01have been glazed for their entire
  4145. 2:03:04existence. Travis Kalanick's like, "Oh,
  4146. 2:03:06what? People don't like me now?" And
  4147. 2:03:07it's because Uber was a horribly run
  4148. 2:03:09place, and he was kind of a monster.
  4149. 2:03:11Also, tons of articles about how great
  4150. 2:03:12Uber was at the time. The point I'm
  4151. 2:03:14making is these companies are not used
  4152. 2:03:15to push back. They thought what would
  4153. 2:03:17happen, I believe, just guessing. They
  4154. 2:03:19thought they'd do the scary stuff, and
  4155. 2:03:21they would just get floods of money, and
  4156. 2:03:22everyone would just be like, "I kneel
  4157. 2:03:24before you. I'll do whatever you want."
  4158. 2:03:26They didn't expect, I think, what has I
  4159. 2:03:29I agree, this has backfired on them.
  4160. 2:03:31Because they were inarticulate. They're
  4161. 2:03:33disconnected from regular people. Sam
  4162. 2:03:35Altman drives a $5 million car around
  4163. 2:03:38San Francisco. So, that that man's doing
  4164. 2:03:40like 9 mph. It's hilarious. But, these
  4165. 2:03:42people are disconnected from everyone
  4166. 2:03:44else. So, they don't they don't
  4167. 2:03:45experience real problems, so they can't
  4168. 2:03:46build the solutions for them. And they
  4169. 2:03:48think, "Well, if we scare people into
  4170. 2:03:50doing what we want, that'll work,
  4171. 2:03:51right?" It didn't. They This was all of
  4172. 2:03:53this blackmail stuff was an attempt to
  4173. 2:03:55make it mystic. It was a mysticism
  4174. 2:03:57attempt. It was to make it seem like
  4175. 2:03:58this unknowable, impossible to control,
  4176. 2:04:01just this powerful thing. But, we're the
  4177. 2:04:02only ones We are the only Only us. Only
  4178. 2:04:06these two angels could possibly control
  4179. 2:04:09the beast we've created.
  4180. 2:04:10>> This is This is quite a controversial
  4181. 2:04:12statement, but I think that
  4182. 2:04:14for some reason, I trust Dario a little
  4183. 2:04:15bit more
  4184. 2:04:17because I think he's been the most
  4185. 2:04:18balanced in his writing about the risk
  4186. 2:04:21profile.
  4187. 2:04:22>> I
  4188. 2:04:22>> Whereas the others, they they seem to
  4189. 2:04:25kind of move with the wind.
  4190. 2:04:27>> I I
  4191. 2:04:28>> Do you know what I mean?
  4192. 2:04:28>> I get what you mean. But, the reason I
  4193. 2:04:30don't like Dario is Dario was doing the
  4194. 2:04:32scare tactics thing when he worked at
  4195. 2:04:33OpenAI. When GPT-2 came out, he said,
  4196. 2:04:35"It's too scary to release." He's also
  4197. 2:04:38gone on television and given AI
  4198. 2:04:40psychosis to Axios being like, "50% of
  4199. 2:04:43jobs are going to go away because of
  4200. 2:04:44AI." What I respect is the consistency.
  4201. 2:04:48He's now being attacked by them. Good.
  4202. 2:04:51>> Um but the thing is
  4203. 2:04:52>> He is sorry, I mean let me clarify the
  4204. 2:04:54word attack.
  4205. 2:04:55>> Dario
  4206. 2:04:55>> verbally
  4207. 2:04:55>> is being verbally attacked by Silicon
  4208. 2:04:57Valley and you know,
  4209. 2:05:00if Silicon Valley, if powerful people in
  4210. 2:05:02Silicon Valley are attacking someone
  4211. 2:05:03>> 4 months ago he was
  4212. 2:05:05>> wasn't though. They were all saying he
  4213. 2:05:06was the smartest boy ever. But the point
  4214. 2:05:07I want to make there as well is again,
  4215. 2:05:08"Wow, you're so scared of how powerful
  4216. 2:05:10this is. You're so scared of it. It's so
  4217. 2:05:12scary." What are you doing about it? Oh,
  4218. 2:05:13nothing.
  4219. 2:05:14Like he's just like, "What are you
  4220. 2:05:15doing?" Well, we have an alignment team.
  4221. 2:05:17So does every AI lab. Well, I guess
  4222. 2:05:19OpenAI cycles through those really
  4223. 2:05:20quickly. Here's the thing, if I'm Dario
  4224. 2:05:22Amodei and I'm like, "I'm scared of all
  4225. 2:05:24things changing."
  4226. 2:05:26And I thought I had made a thing that
  4227. 2:05:27would eliminate all jobs, I'd be
  4228. 2:05:29terrified. I'd be walking around with
  4229. 2:05:31like like a 10-ton weight on my back.
  4230. 2:05:34The show
  4231. 2:05:35>> the responsibility
  4232. 2:05:36>> The fact he doesn't, the fact he wants
  4233. 2:05:38to be this weird elder statesman that's
  4234. 2:05:39too scared to hold Sam Altman's hand in
  4235. 2:05:41an event just makes me believe that he's
  4236. 2:05:43just saying it because it's convenient
  4237. 2:05:45and he'll wind that back as he kind of
  4238. 2:05:47already has whenever it's convenient for
  4239. 2:05:49him. I think OpenAI and Anthropic are
  4240. 2:05:51basically the same level of bad company.
  4241. 2:05:53I think Anthropic is more cult-like. I
  4242. 2:05:56think
  4243. 2:05:57It's so weird like Jack Clark over
  4244. 2:05:58there, one of the co-founders. That
  4245. 2:05:59fellow used to be at The Register. Used
  4246. 2:06:00to be one of the most critical
  4247. 2:06:01journalists ever. Now he's it's like
  4248. 2:06:03like something took over
  4249. 2:06:05>> over him because they talk of these
  4250. 2:06:06things in these highfalutin terms. But
  4251. 2:06:08then again, maybe the people at
  4252. 2:06:09Anthropic buy their Maybe some of
  4253. 2:06:10the people at OpenAI buy their
  4254. 2:06:12>> So so going back to the central question
  4255. 2:06:13we asked at the top here was
  4256. 2:06:15what would have to be the case for you
  4257. 2:06:16to look back and say, "Do you know what,
  4258. 2:06:17I was wrong in 2026." And you said to me
  4259. 2:06:20it would be mainly that the cost of
  4260. 2:06:23production around AI drops dramatically.
  4261. 2:06:26>> And it would have to also do
  4262. 2:06:28insane amounts of stuff it does it would
  4263. 2:06:30It to be a truly autonomous
  4264. 2:06:32>> have to continue its improvement in
  4265. 2:06:34terms of capability.
  4266. 2:06:36>> It would have to be It would have to be
  4267. 2:06:37indistinguishable from magic. And the
  4268. 2:06:38reason I have these high standards is
  4269. 2:06:40they set them.
  4270. 2:06:41>> Okay, fair enough.
  4271. 2:06:41>> It's interesting as well because all
  4272. 2:06:43these myths and all these conversations,
  4273. 2:06:45it's about technology but it's also it's
  4274. 2:06:47an information war. It's literally
  4275. 2:06:50narrative versus narrative. Everyone
  4276. 2:06:52trying to escape the financials.
  4277. 2:06:54Everyone trying to actually escape what
  4278. 2:06:56the models can do. And the big thing I
  4279. 2:06:58always say about AI boosters is if I
  4280. 2:07:00could regulate them, I'd regulate them
  4281. 2:07:01they can't speak in the future tense
  4282. 2:07:03anymore. Cuz you got to talk about
  4283. 2:07:04today, mate. You get 2 weeks in the
  4284. 2:07:06future max. Because if they were
  4285. 2:07:08constrained to what was happening today
  4286. 2:07:10it they would sound like insane people.
  4287. 2:07:12>> Yeah, I know. I think Yeah, most I guess
  4288. 2:07:14most technology companies would at the
  4289. 2:07:15time. Like Uber would sound insane.
  4290. 2:07:17>> Uber Uber Uber was basically the
  4291. 2:07:19difference
  4292. 2:07:20>> pissing money, they weren't they?
  4293. 2:07:21>> They were pissing money away but the
  4294. 2:07:22unit economics were the same just
  4295. 2:07:24subsidized. So you were still getting a
  4296. 2:07:26service from A to B and paying a much
  4297. 2:07:29lower cost. It wasn't like you paid Uber
  4298. 2:07:32200 uh sorry, 20 bucks a month and you
  4299. 2:07:34could get 500 miles of Uber and then one
  4300. 2:07:36day you started paying by the mile cuz
  4301. 2:07:38that's what's happening with this.
  4302. 2:07:39>> Have they they've they've changed their
  4303. 2:07:40business model for customers like me now
  4304. 2:07:43so that I have to buy credits.
  4305. 2:07:44>> No, so you Well, kind of with
  4306. 2:07:47>> They asked me the other day to buy
  4307. 2:07:47credits.
  4308. 2:07:48>> So with the Anthropic's Fable model,
  4309. 2:07:51with some accounts you have to pay for
  4310. 2:07:52usage. And also adoption of Fable has
  4311. 2:07:55been pretty low because of this cuz of
  4312. 2:07:56the cost. But with enterprises or
  4313. 2:07:58companies over 150 people you have to
  4314. 2:08:01pay by the token now or per million
  4315. 2:08:03token.
  4316. 2:08:03>> I see. So they are moving to a token
  4317. 2:08:04now.
  4318. 2:08:05>> Yeah, but when they did that everyone
  4319. 2:08:06went from being like this is the most
  4320. 2:08:07impressive thing ever to being like
  4321. 2:08:10>> It's so expensive.
  4322. 2:08:10>> It's always uh we've got to control
  4323. 2:08:11these costs. Uber's COO says Andrew
  4324. 2:08:14McDonald, I think he said that it's
  4325. 2:08:16getting hard to justify cuz it's hard to
  4326. 2:08:18connect spending money on tokens to
  4327. 2:08:20actual useful outcomes.
  4328. 2:08:21>> Hmm.
  4329. 2:08:22>> He said the thing. Like he said the
  4330. 2:08:23actual thing I'd be saying and it's
  4331. 2:08:25>> So you we're in an AI bubble.
  4332. 2:08:27>> Yes.
  4333. 2:08:27>> And when will When this AI bubble
  4334. 2:08:29collapses, so much of the economy is
  4335. 2:08:31resting upon it.
  4336. 2:08:33>> Yeah.
  4337. 2:08:33>> It's going to have downstream
  4338. 2:08:35consequences. So, I got two questions
  4339. 2:08:36for you. I guess the first question is,
  4340. 2:08:37are we in an AI bubble? And what happens
  4341. 2:08:39when the bubble pops?
  4342. 2:08:41>> Yes, and it's it depends. So,
  4343. 2:08:45the big thing that people say is, "Oh,
  4344. 2:08:46we'll get bailed out. Donald Trump's
  4345. 2:08:48scared of Donald Trump." Here's the
  4346. 2:08:49problem with this.
  4347. 2:08:51It isn't just an AI bubble, it's the
  4348. 2:08:54Rubicon bubble. So, the AI bubble
  4349. 2:08:56collapsing will probably be this company
  4350. 2:08:58running out of money, OpenAI.
  4351. 2:09:01And the thing is with OpenAI is, they
  4352. 2:09:03were meant to go public this year. And
  4353. 2:09:04now it's been pushed to next year.
  4354. 2:09:06>> Oh, we going to have after they release
  4355. 2:09:07their audited financials. What do I that
  4356. 2:09:09was?
  4357. 2:09:09>> Um but they've delayed to next year.
  4358. 2:09:11Sarah Fryer, the CFO, has now said,
  4359. 2:09:13"Well, they'll do it earlier than 2027
  4360. 2:09:16or 2027." Great answer there.
  4361. 2:09:18>> For anyone that doesn't understand what
  4362. 2:09:19going public means, that means joining
  4363. 2:09:20the stock market. And at such a time
  4364. 2:09:22when you join the stock market, your
  4365. 2:09:23investors can finally sell the equity
  4366. 2:09:27that they got for investing in the
  4367. 2:09:29company when it was private. So, often
  4368. 2:09:31times companies will flirt with the idea
  4369. 2:09:33of we'll go public someday soon because
  4370. 2:09:36investors will have a moment in their
  4371. 2:09:38head where they'll get their money back
  4372. 2:09:40at a return. So, you kind of need to If
  4373. 2:09:43you're in these guys' shoes, you kind of
  4374. 2:09:44need to be flirting with going public or
  4375. 2:09:45investors won't want to invest.
  4376. 2:09:47>> OpenAI up until this point has been a
  4377. 2:09:49private company. And their last funding
  4378. 2:09:51round, they were valued at $865 billion.
  4379. 2:09:55when they tried to go public, New York
  4380. 2:09:57Times' Mike Isaac reported this,
  4381. 2:09:59they tried to list at Well, they wanted
  4382. 2:10:02to go at a set a $1 trillion valuation.
  4383. 2:10:04Apparently, their advisor said, "No,
  4384. 2:10:07don't do that."
  4385. 2:10:08That is very bad for a number of
  4386. 2:10:10reasons. One, OpenAI needs perpetual
  4387. 2:10:12amounts of money. They raised $122
  4388. 2:10:14billion this year. Most of it's crossed,
  4389. 2:10:16there's some left, but they are going to
  4390. 2:10:18need to raise at least $100 billion a
  4391. 2:10:20dollars a just to survive. If they can't
  4392. 2:10:22go public, they will have to raise
  4393. 2:10:23another funding round. Problem is, it's
  4394. 2:10:25going to be difficult to raise at even
  4395. 2:10:27the same one they raised at. So, they're
  4396. 2:10:29probably going to have to take a flat,
  4397. 2:10:30so the same amount
  4398. 2:10:31>> They can't go flat.
  4399. 2:10:32>> Exactly. But, they need money. They need
  4400. 2:10:34money so bad. Amazon sent them 35
  4401. 2:10:37billion dollars that was meant to be
  4402. 2:10:38contingent on them going public
  4403. 2:10:40early.
  4404. 2:10:41They did that because they needed the
  4405. 2:10:42money. Now, OpenAI is the kind of
  4406. 2:10:46catastrophe center here because
  4407. 2:10:47Anthropic is likely going to beat it to
  4408. 2:10:49go public, and once Anthropic goes
  4409. 2:10:50public, it'll be borderline impossible
  4410. 2:10:52for OpenAI to do so because Anthropic,
  4411. 2:10:54an unprofitable, unsustainable AI lab,
  4412. 2:10:56but a better business that's growing
  4413. 2:10:58faster than OpenAI's. I believe they
  4414. 2:11:00have a ceiling. They're eventually going
  4415. 2:11:01to face competition, too.
  4416. 2:11:03I think sometime in 2027, things are
  4417. 2:11:05going to start running out of steam
  4418. 2:11:06because the thing I said earlier, the
  4419. 2:11:08only way these models get better is if
  4420. 2:11:09you feed more money, tens of billions of
  4421. 2:11:11dollars into them.
  4422. 2:11:12>> So, you think OpenAI runs out of steam
  4423. 2:11:14in 2027?
  4424. 2:11:15>> I think they're already running out of
  4425. 2:11:16steam, yeah, but I think they run out of
  4426. 2:11:17cash.
  4427. 2:11:18>> You think they run out of cash?
  4428. 2:11:19>> Yes.
  4429. 2:11:20>> And the sequence of events here will be
  4430. 2:11:21they they go out and try and raise
  4431. 2:11:23>> And they have trouble raising another
  4432. 2:11:25round. I think maybe Nvidia props them
  4433. 2:11:27up a little, maybe private credit,
  4434. 2:11:29BlackRock and the like, the ones And the
  4435. 2:11:31reason that private credit is getting
  4436. 2:11:32involved, so asset managers, is because
  4437. 2:11:34they're investing in the data centers,
  4438. 2:11:35and they know this company is most of
  4439. 2:11:37the data center demand.
  4440. 2:11:38>> Okay, so they run out of steam in 2027,
  4441. 2:11:40according to you.
  4442. 2:11:41>> Yep. And maybe they try If they bum rush
  4443. 2:11:42to go public, they're going to have
  4444. 2:11:44worse economics than Anthropic. They're
  4445. 2:11:45going to get savage. It WeWork was a
  4446. 2:11:47great example. Another SoftBank classic.
  4447. 2:11:50Now, I think OpenAI collapses. There are
  4448. 2:11:52many different ways it could happen.
  4449. 2:11:54There are many different ways it could
  4450. 2:11:55end.
  4451. 2:11:56But, the crucial thing is is that there
  4452. 2:11:57are multiple companies that are
  4453. 2:11:59existentially tied to OpenAI. SoftBank,
  4454. 2:12:03one of the largest companies in the
  4455. 2:12:04Japanese stock market, a holding company
  4456. 2:12:06with lots of investments.
  4457. 2:12:07They have on paper
  4458. 2:12:09about 100 billion dollars worth of
  4459. 2:12:10OpenAI stock. If they can't go public,
  4460. 2:12:13they can't do diddly squat with them.
  4461. 2:12:15And so, SoftBank's future, their ability
  4462. 2:12:17to continue paying the people around
  4463. 2:12:19them and existing as a business, relies
  4464. 2:12:21on their ability to continually
  4465. 2:12:23liquidate funds to be to take the things
  4466. 2:12:25they've invested in and have value from
  4467. 2:12:27them, either by selling the stock or
  4468. 2:12:29taking loans out on the stock. If OpenAI
  4469. 2:12:31can't go public, SoftBank can't do that.
  4470. 2:12:33SoftBank probably won't run out of
  4471. 2:12:35money, but we're going to see one of the
  4472. 2:12:36largest holding companies in the world
  4473. 2:12:38become much smaller. We will also see
  4474. 2:12:41Amazon, Google, and Microsoft have to
  4475. 2:12:43restate guidance. They will have to say,
  4476. 2:12:45"Actually, we don't think we're going to
  4477. 2:12:46grow as fast."
  4478. 2:12:48>> And what happens then?
  4479. 2:12:49>> Well, I think we enter a tech
  4480. 2:12:50depression, because the Roku bubble, the
  4481. 2:12:52core of my theory,
  4482. 2:12:54is that they're out of hypergrowth
  4483. 2:12:56ideas, but the market doesn't think so.
  4484. 2:12:58The reason they're so
  4485. 2:12:59maniacally spending is because
  4486. 2:13:02buying AI GPUs allows them to kick the
  4487. 2:13:04can further. It allows them to say,
  4488. 2:13:06"We're still doing something. We're
  4489. 2:13:07working on AI. Don't think too hard."
  4490. 2:13:09And also, their current businesses are
  4491. 2:13:10still growing.
  4492. 2:13:11Their current businesses will eventually
  4493. 2:13:13slow. There's only so many price
  4494. 2:13:15increases, only so many tweaks to ads,
  4495. 2:13:17only so many tweaks to Google search,
  4496. 2:13:19only so only so many ways that Amazon
  4497. 2:13:21can screw merchants.
  4498. 2:13:22>> So, in that tech depression, which you
  4499. 2:13:25think it might be triggered in 2027, is
  4500. 2:13:29that a cascading downstream economic
  4501. 2:13:31depression, because the stock market is
  4502. 2:13:33heavily dependent on these companies?
  4503. 2:13:35The stock market sees a pullback,
  4504. 2:13:37investors stop investing, they get
  4505. 2:13:38panicked.
  4506. 2:13:40>> Yes. I think that because
  4507. 2:13:41>> sort of downstream consequence, the sort
  4508. 2:13:43of domino effect?
  4509. 2:13:44>> There's so much to imagine that it's
  4510. 2:13:46difficult to capture everything, but
  4511. 2:13:48there are a few things that worry me.
  4512. 2:13:49First of all, a ton of American money,
  4513. 2:13:51just regular people's money, retail
  4514. 2:13:53investors, are in these companies, and
  4515. 2:13:54they bought into the Magnificent Seven
  4516. 2:13:56thinking that number go up forever.
  4517. 2:13:58Nvidia is the largest company on the
  4518. 2:14:00Fortune 500 and Nasdaq as well. And like
  4519. 2:14:027 to 8% of the S&P 500,
  4520. 2:14:05that company, when when the bottom falls
  4521. 2:14:07out from Nvidia, and we haven't really
  4522. 2:14:09got into it, but Nvidia is is the most
  4523. 2:14:10circular refinancing, feeding companies
  4524. 2:14:12money so that they can raise debt to buy
  4525. 2:14:14more GPUs.
  4526. 2:14:15I think Nvidia's revenue could go 50 to
  4527. 2:14:1770% down. I think that Nvidia could put
  4528. 2:14:20Nvidia back in 2022 was making
  4529. 2:14:21single-digit billion dollars.
  4530. 2:14:23>> And what happens though? If I'm thinking
  4531. 2:14:24about like Jenny and Dave that are
  4532. 2:14:25watching this right now, and they aren't
  4533. 2:14:27just normal people
  4534. 2:14:29with normal jobs.
  4535. 2:14:30>> People's retirements are going to
  4536. 2:14:31contract severely, and I don't believe
  4537. 2:14:34they're going to return to those values.
  4538. 2:14:35And I think that because so much of the
  4539. 2:14:38value of the S&P 500 and Russell 1000
  4540. 2:14:40index comes from these four companies
  4541. 2:14:42and the rest of the Magnificent Seven,
  4542. 2:14:43so Apple, Tesla, Meta as well.
  4543. 2:14:47And the thing is
  4544. 2:14:48I don't know what happens after that
  4545. 2:14:50because
  4546. 2:14:51venture capital has also like more than
  4547. 2:14:53half of venture capital last year went
  4548. 2:14:54into AI. I think most venture capital
  4549. 2:14:56investments in AI going to zero because
  4550. 2:14:58when it comes to building a company on
  4551. 2:15:00top of an LLM, all of those are
  4552. 2:15:01unprofitable, too.
  4553. 2:15:03And the thing is
  4554. 2:15:04LLM companies have not really been
  4555. 2:15:06acquired. The exception being Cursor
  4556. 2:15:08bought by Elon Musk for the coding side.
  4557. 2:15:10But you have Cognition, which is just
  4558. 2:15:12another LLM company raising a $26
  4559. 2:15:15billion valuation. That means that
  4560. 2:15:16company has to go public cuz who's
  4561. 2:15:18buying a company at $26 billion other
  4562. 2:15:20than Elon Musk? And there were rumors
  4563. 2:15:22that Elon Musk was trying to buy them as
  4564. 2:15:23well. Is Elon Musk just going to pick
  4565. 2:15:25off every
  4566. 2:15:26like LLM company like going to a
  4567. 2:15:27TJ Maxx for AI? Like Jesus Christ.
  4568. 2:15:29>> So, is that a recession you're
  4569. 2:15:30describing?
  4570. 2:15:31>> It is a recession, but it's also a
  4571. 2:15:33depression within people's retirements.
  4572. 2:15:35Like I'm talking about 20, 30, 40% off
  4573. 2:15:38the top of these companies' stock value.
  4574. 2:15:40>> Economic contractions recessions
  4575. 2:15:41consistently lead to job losses and
  4576. 2:15:43rising unemployment. When an economy
  4577. 2:15:44contracts, the mechanism driving job
  4578. 2:15:46losses typically follows a predictable
  4579. 2:15:47sequence.
  4580. 2:15:49Falling demand, consumers and businesses
  4581. 2:15:50spend less money causing revenues across
  4582. 2:15:52most industries to drop. Margin
  4583. 2:15:54compression, with lower revenue and
  4584. 2:15:56often fixed overhead costs like rent or
  4585. 2:15:58debt, corporate profits shrink. And
  4586. 2:15:59lastly, cost-cutting measures to survive
  4587. 2:16:01or protect profit margins, businesses
  4588. 2:16:03freeze hiring, reduce hours, and resort
  4589. 2:16:05to layoffs.
  4590. 2:16:06>> Yes, that's that would all happen, but
  4591. 2:16:08the thing is we're talking about equity
  4592. 2:16:10values dropping and we're talking about
  4593. 2:16:12there not really being a home for that
  4594. 2:16:14value or that money.
  4595. 2:16:16>> [snorts]
  4596. 2:16:16>> So much is riding on these companies,
  4597. 2:16:18but you can't bail it out. You can
  4598. 2:16:21theoretically bail out OpenAI. I don't
  4599. 2:16:22think it happens. You could pump these
  4600. 2:16:24dogs full of money and keep them alive
  4601. 2:16:26for a bit, but at some point they're
  4602. 2:16:27going to have to stop They have between
  4603. 2:16:29these two companies, Anthropic and
  4604. 2:16:30OpenAI,
  4605. 2:16:32you have $1.1 trillion of commitments.
  4606. 2:16:35>> Just OpenAI?
  4607. 2:16:36>> Mhm.
  4608. 2:16:36>> Oracle is building 7.1 gigawatts of data
  4609. 2:16:39centers, so over $400 billion worth.
  4610. 2:16:41Just for OpenAI. There is not a customer
  4611. 2:16:43on Earth and Oracle's revenue has been
  4612. 2:16:45flat last 15 years when you adjust for
  4613. 2:16:47inflation. Without OpenAI, Oracle dies.
  4614. 2:16:50>> So you think OpenAI is going to crash
  4615. 2:16:51and run out of money and that's going to
  4616. 2:16:52cause this domino effect across these
  4617. 2:16:54other big tech companies, which is going
  4618. 2:16:55to impact the stock market and in impact
  4619. 2:16:58the broader economy?
  4620. 2:16:59>> Yes. And also the tens of thousands of
  4621. 2:17:01people that will be laid off from the
  4622. 2:17:02tech sector, but also the venture
  4623. 2:17:03capital thing is significant because
  4624. 2:17:05venture capital has been having one of
  4625. 2:17:07the most historic
  4626. 2:17:10bad runs in history. Since 2018, the
  4627. 2:17:14average return from venture capital at
  4628. 2:17:16total value put in, so the amount of
  4629. 2:17:17money you get back for your dollars
  4630. 2:17:18between 0.8 and 1.21, meaning for every
  4631. 2:17:21dollar you invest get 80 cents to a
  4632. 2:17:23dollar 20.
  4633. 2:17:24>> Paper gains?
  4634. 2:17:25>> Well, no, that's just actual get like
  4635. 2:17:27actual returns. Paper gains they'll give
  4636. 2:17:28you, but even an internal rate return,
  4637. 2:17:30which is a whole separate thing, even
  4638. 2:17:32that's not very happy, but long story
  4639. 2:17:34short, very simple. Venture capital is
  4640. 2:17:36not making money come out. Venture
  4641. 2:17:38capital is not actually providing
  4642. 2:17:40returns.
  4643. 2:17:40>> They're celebrating paper gains.
  4644. 2:17:42>> They're celebrating paper gains.
  4645. 2:17:43>> And they're raising off paper gains.
  4646. 2:17:44>> Uh-huh. And actually
  4647. 2:17:45>> By paper gains I mean just being able to
  4648. 2:17:47say, "Oh, look, the valuation of
  4649. 2:17:48Anthropic went up, so that's
  4650. 2:17:49>> But that's that's what Google and Amazon
  4651. 2:17:51were doing. Google's last quarter, they
  4652. 2:17:53boosted their net profits, profits on
  4653. 2:17:55paper,
  4654. 2:17:56by $99 billion because of the increased
  4655. 2:17:59value of their SpaceX holding and their
  4656. 2:18:00Anthropic holding. And, again,
  4657. 2:18:03the fact that this is happening is
  4658. 2:18:05insane, and the fact it's not a scandal
  4659. 2:18:07is insane, but we live in this culture,
  4660. 2:18:09I guess.
  4661. 2:18:10But, everyone is really benefiting right
  4662. 2:18:13now. It's really that It's that great
  4663. 2:18:14tweet where it's like, "When you're uh
  4664. 2:18:15reaping, it's like, 'Yeah, yeah,
  4665. 2:18:17this rocks.' Sowing, 'Ah, this
  4666. 2:18:18sucks.'" Because right now they're all
  4667. 2:18:20like, "Yeah, all the speculative gains
  4668. 2:18:22are awesome. The paper gains are
  4669. 2:18:23awesome. The theoreticals of Anthropic
  4670. 2:18:25being worth $2 trillion. Wow, the
  4671. 2:18:27articles we could write, the promises we
  4672. 2:18:28can make." Then when the rubber meets
  4673. 2:18:30the road,
  4674. 2:18:32it's going to be pretty rough on them
  4675. 2:18:33because like, the valuation of Amazon,
  4676. 2:18:36Google, Microsoft, and Meta is based on
  4677. 2:18:38this idea that they will grow eternally,
  4678. 2:18:39that they will grow forever.
  4679. 2:18:41If that changes, quoted Ellison from
  4680. 2:18:42Profit Markets again,
  4681. 2:18:44it's this they're all doing Botox right
  4682. 2:18:46now. They're sinking money into it to
  4683. 2:18:47make themselves feel young again, and
  4684. 2:18:48the market believes them. When the
  4685. 2:18:50market doesn't, we're not just talking
  4686. 2:18:51about a depression, I'm talking about
  4687. 2:18:53the market valuing them like airlines,
  4688. 2:18:56and saying, "Yeah, you're real big, and
  4689. 2:18:57you make money off your existing
  4690. 2:18:58products." But, guess what? You don't
  4691. 2:19:01have new You're just going to be
  4692. 2:19:02doing this forever, and we're going to
  4693. 2:19:03value you as such. So, if
  4694. 2:19:06Jenny and Dave sh- should they do
  4695. 2:19:08anything differently? Should they be
  4696. 2:19:09conserving money if there's a recession
  4697. 2:19:11or depression coming? Should they be a
  4698. 2:19:12little bit more conservative? Should
  4699. 2:19:13they I Yes. I actually I actually think
  4700. 2:19:16it's
  4701. 2:19:16I don't know. I don't have money in the
  4702. 2:19:18market. I think it's a casino casino
  4703. 2:19:20pumped up by the media. Should they
  4704. 2:19:21invest in the S&P 500? Should they
  4705. 2:19:23invest in Open AI on Facebook? I I God,
  4706. 2:19:25no. I Honestly, I live in cash right
  4707. 2:19:27now. I I cash. I don't trust the
  4708. 2:19:29market, man. Try and get some gains
  4709. 2:19:32here. I'm like, I'm not comfortable
  4710. 2:19:33giving financial advice, but it's like,
  4711. 2:19:36if you like, it's like you're gambling.
  4712. 2:19:37Okay, be conservative. Things might get
  4713. 2:19:39volatile. Yeah, it really is It's going
  4714. 2:19:41to be act as you would with volatility.
  4715. 2:19:42Take the gains when you've got them.
  4716. 2:19:44Don't sell everything, but be suspicious
  4717. 2:19:47of tech. Like, that's actually the
  4718. 2:19:49biggest thing. It's like, be suspicious
  4719. 2:19:50of what they're promising. If you're
  4720. 2:19:51acting based on their promises, don't
  4721. 2:19:54trust the promises. Trust that they are
  4722. 2:19:56going to say what will make the stock
  4723. 2:19:59run rather than what's actually
  4724. 2:20:01happening and that they will find every
  4725. 2:20:04dodgy way to make you think something is
  4726. 2:20:07happening rather than it's actually
  4727. 2:20:09happening. Annualized run rate, great
  4728. 2:20:10example.
  4729. 2:20:11Microsoft said that they had 38 37
  4730. 2:20:13billion dollars of annualized run rate
  4731. 2:20:15in AI. You hear that, you go
  4732. 2:20:17they made 38 37 billion dollars, right?
  4733. 2:20:20Wow, that's so much.
  4734. 2:20:21Run rate maybe month times 12. They
  4735. 2:20:24don't even define it, but it's built to
  4736. 2:20:26manipulate and they do that because we
  4737. 2:20:28don't have a functional SEC and we don't
  4738. 2:20:30have a media environment that actually
  4739. 2:20:32where skepticism is the priority and
  4740. 2:20:34where protecting the readers is
  4741. 2:20:35necessary. What would they say? They
  4742. 2:20:37would say
  4743. 2:20:38>> uh this technology is going to be so
  4744. 2:20:40great and so transformative that we are
  4745. 2:20:43investing a ton of money
  4746. 2:20:44um in advance of the value and utility
  4747. 2:20:49showing up. That's what they would say.
  4748. 2:20:51>> Right.
  4749. 2:20:52>> And I've heard your rebuttal, but I just
  4750. 2:20:53wanted to express like that.
  4751. 2:20:54>> get that.
  4752. 2:20:55>> I think that's their sentiment. I'm not
  4753. 2:20:56defending them or anything. I'm just
  4754. 2:20:57trying to provide enough like balance to
  4755. 2:21:00see if we can see if we can dance
  4756. 2:21:02between these these two perspectives.
  4757. 2:21:05And a lot of people would say
  4758. 2:21:07that there's going to be a bloodbath
  4759. 2:21:09because they can't all win big in the
  4760. 2:21:11way that they're kind of describing. So
  4761. 2:21:13someone's going to have to lose and when
  4762. 2:21:15one of these players starts to lose big,
  4763. 2:21:16I think it could as you say there could
  4764. 2:21:18be some kind of domino effect or
  4765. 2:21:19contraction.
  4766. 2:21:20>> Yeah, and I think the thing that people
  4767. 2:21:22want to believe is they the dot com
  4768. 2:21:24bubble thing. It's like it worked out
  4769. 2:21:25afterwards because Amazon, Oracle, they
  4770. 2:21:28didn't die after the dot com bubble.
  4771. 2:21:30They're actually fine. This isn't like
  4772. 2:21:32that. They're bigger companies. They
  4773. 2:21:33have bigger promises and even I'm not
  4774. 2:21:36like Oracle I actually think could die.
  4775. 2:21:38RIP Larry. Couldn't happen to a nastier
  4776. 2:21:41man. They'll probably
  4777. 2:21:42>> these people, do you?
  4778. 2:21:43>> No, I actually
  4779. 2:21:45>> No, again, I ask this question purely
  4780. 2:21:46because I want an answer not because I
  4781. 2:21:47agree or disagree. But
  4782. 2:21:49why don't you like these these people?
  4783. 2:21:52>> I don't like being misled and I don't
  4784. 2:21:55think regular people are being misled
  4785. 2:21:56either and I really don't think that the
  4786. 2:21:59average person can get away with
  4787. 2:22:00bullshitting as much as these companies
  4788. 2:22:02do and I don't think the average person
  4789. 2:22:04gets anywhere near the level of
  4790. 2:22:06affordance for failure and lying as
  4791. 2:22:08these companies do and I think there is
  4792. 2:22:10a real economic and human cost to
  4793. 2:22:12allowing these companies to run rampant
  4794. 2:22:14and promise the world and never really
  4795. 2:22:16get called up on it. The tepid nature of
  4796. 2:22:19criticism these days is so frustrating.
  4797. 2:22:21There are some really great critics out
  4798. 2:22:23there like
  4799. 2:22:24they're really great people but it's
  4800. 2:22:25like
  4801. 2:22:27seeing these ultra rich, ultra wealthy,
  4802. 2:22:29ultra powerful people lie through their
  4803. 2:22:31teeth or misstate or whatever it
  4804. 2:22:33people want to call it. It turns my
  4805. 2:22:35stomach and I hate seeing people being
  4806. 2:22:38misled and I feel like I write at such
  4807. 2:22:40length cuz I really want people to see
  4808. 2:22:42why I've come to a conclusion. Am I
  4809. 2:22:43right or am I wrong? I think I am. Of
  4810. 2:22:45course I do.
  4811. 2:22:46But I also
  4812. 2:22:48I just find it loathsome. I find these
  4813. 2:22:50companies don't make good products
  4814. 2:22:52anymore. They don't care about the
  4815. 2:22:53customers.
  4816. 2:22:55And and they treat their customers with
  4817. 2:22:57contempt.
  4818. 2:22:59>> If people want to go read more about
  4819. 2:23:01your work, um you have a great Substack.
  4820. 2:23:03>> Ghost actually. It looks exactly like I
  4821. 2:23:05moved off of Substack in 2024.
  4822. 2:23:06>> Oh, okay. And you also have a podcast
  4823. 2:23:09you do?
  4824. 2:23:09>> Yeah, Better Offline.
  4825. 2:23:10>> Um I'm going to link both of them below.
  4826. 2:23:12So whoever wants to read more, get more
  4827. 2:23:13detail and and follow Ed, I think it's
  4828. 2:23:15I would highly recommend. It's it is
  4829. 2:23:17fascinating. And you know what?
  4830. 2:23:18One of the things people um sometimes
  4831. 2:23:20struggle with when they listen to
  4832. 2:23:21podcasts is you get lots of different
  4833. 2:23:23opinions. And weirdly I think they think
  4834. 2:23:25of Some people assume podcasts are going
  4835. 2:23:26to be like one person saying
  4836. 2:23:28the same thing as the next person and
  4837. 2:23:29then the next person and the next
  4838. 2:23:30person. That is just not the nature of
  4839. 2:23:31information in the world and opinions
  4840. 2:23:33and progress and discussion.
  4841. 2:23:34Uh what what happens is people have
  4842. 2:23:36different opinions and I think my job,
  4843. 2:23:38but also the listeners' job, is to try
  4844. 2:23:39and pass through it and over time
  4845. 2:23:42collect more of these reference points
  4846. 2:23:43from different people
  4847. 2:23:45and and do your own research.
  4848. 2:23:46>> Yeah.
  4849. 2:23:47>> Whether it's on your health or whether
  4850. 2:23:48it's on something like this is to watch
  4851. 2:23:50and do your own research and to learn.
  4852. 2:23:52And I would say also, never believe one
  4853. 2:23:54person. Never believe one particular
  4854. 2:23:56perspective religiously. You know,
  4855. 2:23:58collect a body of evidence and follow
  4856. 2:24:00follow the evidence yourself. But I love
  4857. 2:24:02watching your YouTube because it
  4858. 2:24:05provides a different opinion. And that
  4859. 2:24:08challenges me to think beyond my current
  4860. 2:24:12opinion about what might be possible.
  4861. 2:24:14So, when I've heard you talking about
  4862. 2:24:15how this is an economic bubble, and I've
  4863. 2:24:17heard you talk about the capex spend
  4864. 2:24:20with these big sort of frontier AI labs,
  4865. 2:24:22it really did make me pause for a
  4866. 2:24:24second. And it really did make me
  4867. 2:24:25consider
  4868. 2:24:27that there could be a bit of fugazi
  4869. 2:24:30going on here.
  4870. 2:24:30>> Yeah.
  4871. 2:24:31>> And then it made me reflect on history
  4872. 2:24:32and go, you know, through history
  4873. 2:24:33there's always a bit of fugazi in these
  4874. 2:24:34moments. And
  4875. 2:24:35Oh, that's an interesting take. And
  4876. 2:24:37what's going to happen in 2027, 2028
  4877. 2:24:38when there's a bit of a market pullback?
  4878. 2:24:40And
  4879. 2:24:40So, I highly recommend people go watch
  4880. 2:24:42cuz you do you challenge me to think
  4881. 2:24:43differently.
  4882. 2:24:44>> Yeah.
  4883. 2:24:45>> And we need some of those contrarian
  4884. 2:24:46voices to
  4885. 2:24:47to have honest discussions. So, thank
  4886. 2:24:49you for doing what you do. Really
  4887. 2:24:50appreciate it. And I find you to be a
  4888. 2:24:51very compelling, captivating
  4889. 2:24:53communicator. And I've I feel like I've
  4890. 2:24:54learned a lot today.
  4891. 2:24:55So, I appreciate that. We have a closing
  4892. 2:24:57tradition.
  4893. 2:24:57>> Yeah.
  4894. 2:24:58>> Where the last guest leaves a question
  4895. 2:24:59for the next guest not knowing who
  4896. 2:25:00they're leaving it for. And the question
  4897. 2:25:02left for you is
  4898. 2:25:03given that high-quality relationships
  4899. 2:25:05are important for health and longevity,
  4900. 2:25:07what should we be doing to improve our
  4901. 2:25:09relationships and social connection?
  4902. 2:25:12>> So, this is actually connected to the AI
  4903. 2:25:15bubble.
  4904. 2:25:16>> So, I'm a critic. I'm a skeptic, we'll
  4905. 2:25:18call it.
  4906. 2:25:19I have found that
  4907. 2:25:22showing and appreciating and loving the
  4908. 2:25:24people around you and uplifting them and
  4909. 2:25:26and raising them up as you succeed is
  4910. 2:25:28the way we do that. Your success should
  4911. 2:25:30be everyone around you. It's not
  4912. 2:25:31economic, it's
  4913. 2:25:32talking about Matt Hughes for a while
  4914. 2:25:34made me really happy. This whole thing
  4915. 2:25:37has been at times quite grueling and
  4916. 2:25:38quite negative and quite brutal.
  4917. 2:25:41But the love I've found and the joy I
  4918. 2:25:43found from community and the people
  4919. 2:25:45because even in the in the small groups
  4920. 2:25:48of haters, even like Gary Marcus and so
  4921. 2:25:50the people I talked to Edward Jr., Molly
  4922. 2:25:53White, Brian Merchant. There are so many
  4923. 2:25:54people who have been loving and caring
  4924. 2:25:56and I think
  4925. 2:25:58within especially these very critical
  4926. 2:26:00moments when you're like very much
  4927. 2:26:02dialing in on how negative things are
  4928. 2:26:03and how bad things are.
  4929. 2:26:05Finding the people who
  4930. 2:26:07maybe find it repulsive too. Finding the
  4931. 2:26:09people
  4932. 2:26:10Finding your people who can be and the
  4933. 2:26:12people who will talk to you about it.
  4934. 2:26:13Even like Troy and Jake, my my trainers
  4935. 2:26:15who are so excited about this. Um
  4936. 2:26:17even talk to them about this as
  4937. 2:26:19normal people. Knowing that there are
  4938. 2:26:21people there going through their own
  4939. 2:26:22struggles but also
  4940. 2:26:24to just give you the perspective and
  4941. 2:26:25also remind you that you are human too
  4942. 2:26:28and focus. I know this is kind of a all
  4943. 2:26:29over the place point but it's just it's
  4944. 2:26:31really easy to get hard locked in
  4945. 2:26:33everything in life and to
  4946. 2:26:35kind of get away from why you do things
  4947. 2:26:37and focus too much on the work when the
  4948. 2:26:39most important thing at times is just to
  4949. 2:26:41know there are other people feeling the
  4950. 2:26:42way you do and when I hear from my
  4951. 2:26:44listeners and my readers a lot, the most
  4952. 2:26:45common thing I feel is they feel like
  4953. 2:26:47they have a voice and they feel like
  4954. 2:26:48someone is there for you. And I don't
  4955. 2:26:50think it can be understated how much it
  4956. 2:26:53means when you just reach out to someone
  4957. 2:26:54you love and tell them you love them.
  4958. 2:26:55Tell them their rocks. Say that
  4959. 2:26:57their bangs. Tell everyone you when
  4960. 2:26:59you like an artist or a writer like they
  4961. 2:27:01were a podcast like this, tell them you
  4962. 2:27:03love it. We don't do this enough
  4963. 2:27:06and we need to do it more.
  4964. 2:27:07>> Well, that's a good closing message. So
  4965. 2:27:09if you do have you have enjoyed the
  4966. 2:27:10conversation today with Ed, please do
  4967. 2:27:11let Ed know that you love it down below.
  4968. 2:27:14Um but please do leave your opinions
  4969. 2:27:15down below and I shall read all of them.
  4970. 2:27:17Ed, thank you so much. I'll link to your
  4971. 2:27:18website but also to your YouTube channel
  4972. 2:27:21where people can learn more and I would
  4973. 2:27:22highly recommend you do because it is
  4974. 2:27:24truly fascinating and I think we need
  4975. 2:27:25more voices that are demystifying a lot
  4976. 2:27:27of the figazi in the narrative in this
  4977. 2:27:28moment in time and you're certainly one
  4978. 2:27:30of them. I really enjoyed the
  4979. 2:27:31conversation.
  4980. 2:27:31>> Thank you so much.
  4981. 2:27:32>> YouTube have this new crazy algorithm
  4982. 2:27:34where they know exactly what video you
  4983. 2:27:36would like to watch next based on AI and
  4984. 2:27:38all of your viewing behavior. And the
  4985. 2:27:40algorithm says that this video is the
  4986. 2:27:43perfect video for you. It's different
  4987. 2:27:45for everybody looking right now. Check
  4988. 2:27:47this video out. I bet you you might love
  4989. 2:27:49it.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of The Man Who Calls BS On AI: They’re LYING About AI, 2027 Is When It All Breaks! | Ed Zitron by The Diary Of A CEO, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 31,429 words across 4,989 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.