The Last 3 Times This Happened, Stocks Fell Hard — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Even with some mid-term volatility, the
- 0:02S&P is about 4% of its all-time high set
- 0:05[music] last month. The 30-year treasury
- 0:07is hovering around multi-decade highs.
- 0:10The 10-year is just under 5%. [music]
- 0:12Stocks and yields both up at the same
- 0:14time should be an investor's cause for
- 0:16celebration,
- 0:17or maybe not.
- 0:19Because the bond market is telling you
- 0:20something if you know how to listen. And
- 0:23this is what it's saying. Stocks have
- 0:25shrugged off almost everything thrown at
- 0:27them.
- 0:28Wars overseas, inflation that won't come
- 0:30down, interest rates that keep going up.
- 0:33Every time the market dips, buyers rush
- 0:35in like it's a sale.
- 0:36The debt market is telling a completely
- 0:38different story. [music] In early
- 0:40October, the 10-year treasury yield
- 0:42climbed above 5.34%.
- 0:45[music] That's the highest it's been
- 0:46since 2002.
- 0:48And corporate borrowing costs climbed
- 0:50right along with it.
- 0:51The average yield on investment grade
- 0:53corporate bonds, which is what big,
- 0:55healthy American companies pay to borrow
- 0:56on average, went from 5.28% in July to
- 1:00around 5.73% [music]
- 1:02today.
- 1:03If your retirement money sits in an S&P
- 1:05500 index fund, you own the companies
- 1:07paying that rate or possibly [music]
- 1:09more. I've spent more than 20 years in
- 1:11fintech working around banks and
- 1:12financial institutions,
- 1:14and it still took me years to learn to
- 1:16check the bond market before the stock
- 1:18market.
- 1:19The bond market is often called the
- 1:21adult in the room compared to the
- 1:23emotional, speculative stock market
- 1:25because it prices hard math, inflation,
- 1:28and supply and demand fundamentals
- 1:30rather than hype or narratives.
- 1:32Now, a spike in borrowing costs isn't
- 1:34always a bad thing and doesn't always
- 1:36crash stocks. [music] Most of the time,
- 1:38stocks get through it. But when three
- 1:40things line up, it has ended badly every
- 1:43time in the last 30 years. Those three
- 1:45things are stocks priced for perfection,
- 1:48borrowing costs that stay high, and a
- 1:50wall of corporate debt that has to be
- 1:51refinanced.
- 1:53I'll show you the three times this
- 1:54happened, the three times it almost did,
- 1:56and the two numbers to watch to tell if
- 1:58it's starting
- 2:00Start with 2000.
- 2:02By the end of the 1990s, [music]
- 2:03investors were paying more for stocks
- 2:05than at any time in history.
- 2:07The best measure of that is the Shiller
- 2:09CAPE ratio.
- 2:11It compares stock prices to 10 years of
- 2:13average company earnings.
- 2:15In December 1999, it hit an all-time
- 2:17high of 44.
- 2:19Then the Fed went to work.
- 2:21Six rate hikes between June 1999 and May
- 2:242000 took its benchmark rate from 4.75
- 2:28to 6.5%. [music]
- 2:30Cheap money disappeared.
- 2:32Tech companies that had never made a
- 2:34dime burned through their cash and
- 2:36couldn't borrow more.
- 2:38The bubble collapsed.
- 2:402007 [music]
- 2:41played out differently.
- 2:42Treasury rates actually fell,
- 2:45but credit spreads widened
- 2:46significantly.
- 2:47A credit spread is the extra interest a
- 2:49company pays to [music] borrow on top of
- 2:51what the government pays.
- 2:53In the spring and summer of 2007, that
- 2:55extra cost jumped. It started with
- 2:58subprime mortgages and spread across the
- 3:00whole credit market. [music] Lenders
- 3:02didn't know who was going to go under
- 3:03next, so they sat on their cash.
- 3:06Companies had to pay a lot more to
- 3:07borrow even with Treasury rates going
- 3:10down.
- 3:11We all know what happened to stocks
- 3:12beginning in October of that year.
- 3:14Then 2022,
- 3:16inflation hit 9.1%, [music] the highest
- 3:19since 1981.
- 3:20The Fed raised its rate from a quarter
- 3:22of a percent to 4.5% in a single year,
- 3:26its fastest tightening since the 1980s.
- 3:29At the end of 2021, a big healthy
- 3:31company could borrow at about 2%. By
- 3:34late 2022, it was paying over [music]
- 3:366%,
- 3:37three times the cost.
- 3:39Stocks took the hit and tech took it
- 3:41hardest.
- 3:42In January 2022, investors were paying
- 3:4521 times next year's expected earnings
- 3:47for the S&P 500.
- 3:50By September, they'd only pay 15.
- 3:52And profit estimates actually went
- 3:54[music] up over that stretch. Same
- 3:56profits, lower price. Three different
- 3:59causes,
- 4:00same result.
- 4:02In every one of these cycles, the shock
- 4:03showed up in the bond market well before
- 4:05stocks rolled over.
- 4:07And in all three of these cycles, the
- 4:08three conditions were in place. Stocks
- 4:10were expensive going in.
- 4:12Borrowing costs stayed high, and
- 4:14companies had to keep borrowing at the
- 4:16new rates.
- 4:17But let's look at three other times when
- 4:19borrowing costs also spiked, [music]
- 4:211994, 2013, at 2023.
- 4:26And stocks survived all three. In 1994
- 4:29and 2013, stocks were cheap going in.
- 4:32The Shiller CAPE was around 21 in both
- 4:34years. [music] In 2023, the 10-year hit
- 4:375% in October.
- 4:398 weeks later, it was back below 4%.
- 4:42The higher borrowing costs never had
- 4:44time to reach corporate profits. [music]
- 4:46None of those years had all three
- 4:47conditions.
- 4:49Today, we've got all three.
- 4:51The Shiller CAPE is near 40, nearly
- 4:53double 1994 and 2013, and just four
- 4:56[music] points below the dot com peak.
- 4:59Borrowing costs are rising, and
- 5:00companies need to refinance and keep
- 5:02borrowing.
- 5:04So why are borrowing costs going up now?
- 5:06Three reasons. First, the Fed is hiking
- 5:09again.
- 5:10It raised rates in September and
- 5:12signaled at least one more hike this
- 5:14year.
- 5:15Markets now put the odds of a December
- 5:16hike at near 100%.
- 5:19And markets are betting the Fed won't be
- 5:21done after that.
- 5:22Just like in 2000 and in 2022, the Fed
- 5:26is raising rates into a market that's
- 5:27already stretched.
- 5:29Inflation is what's forcing the Fed's
- 5:30hand.
- 5:31That's why I put together a free
- 5:33inflation scoreboard, seven key
- 5:35inflation indicators I track every
- 5:37month. [music] First link in the
- 5:39description.
- 5:40Second, the government is borrowing on a
- 5:42massive scale.
- 5:44The deficit [music] for this fiscal year
- 5:45is about $2.1 trillion.
- 5:48Every dollar of that has to [music] be
- 5:49borrowed. And when a 10-year Treasury
- 5:51pays close to 5% with no risk, why would
- 5:54anyone lend to a company for less?
- 5:56They won't.
- 5:57So every company that needs money has to
- 5:59offer a higher rate than the government
- 6:01just to get in the door. The government
- 6:03sets the floor.
- 6:04Everyone has to bid above it.
- 6:07Third, and this is the big change, the
- 6:09largest tech companies have become
- 6:11consistent borrowers.
- 6:13The handful of giant companies building
- 6:15AI data centers used to pay for
- 6:17everything out of their own cash. They
- 6:19didn't need to borrow.
- 6:21In 2024, they issued about 17 billion in
- 6:24debt.
- 6:25This year, Goldman Sachs expects about
- 6:27250 billion. [music] Next year, a record
- 6:30420 billion.
- 6:32From 17 billion dollars to 420 billion
- 6:34in three years, almost [music] 25 times
- 6:37as much. The companies that used to be
- 6:39the safest cash machines in the market
- 6:41are now some of its biggest borrowers.
- 6:43And they're borrowing at today's rates.
- 6:46Now, there's a popular argument that
- 6:48none of this matters. It goes like this.
- 6:51Tech earnings are expanding at an
- 6:52incredible rate.
- 6:54Yields are high because the government
- 6:56is flooding the market with bonds, not
- 6:57because companies are in trouble.
- 6:59So this time is different, and there's
- 7:01real evidence behind it.
- 7:03S&P 500 earnings grew over 31% last
- 7:06quarter. That's the third quarter in a
- 7:08row above 25%.
- 7:10And that extra interest the most
- 7:12creditworthy companies pay on top of
- 7:14Treasuries is near the low end of where
- 7:16it's been for the past three years.
- 7:18Lenders aren't worried about getting
- 7:20paid back.
- 7:21So the argument says, relax. [music]
- 7:23Companies are strong. This is a
- 7:25government problem.
- 7:26Two problems with that argument.
- 7:28First, that earnings growth is highly
- 7:30concentrated. Strip out the big dogs and
- 7:33the bottom 493 S&P companies [music]
- 7:36have median earnings growth much closer
- 7:38to mid to high single digits.
- 7:41Second, a company's balance sheet
- 7:42doesn't care why rates went up.
- 7:44A 6% interest rate takes the same
- 7:47dollars out of earnings, whether it's
- 7:48caused by inflation, government
- 7:50borrowing, or fear of default.
- 7:53Picture a company that borrowed a
- 7:55billion dollars at 2.5%.
- 7:57It pays 25 million dollars a year in
- 7:59interest.
- 8:01When that debt comes due and it
- 8:02refinances at 6%, it [music] pays 60
- 8:04million dollars.
- 8:06If the company is borrowing fresh, it
- 8:07pays that same 6%. [music]
- 8:09That extra $35 million comes straight
- 8:12out of profit every year until the debt
- 8:14is paid off. [music] The reason rates
- 8:16went up doesn't change the bill. A
- 8:18higher cost of borrowing squeezes profit
- 8:20margins, [music]
- 8:21no matter what story management tells on
- 8:23the earnings call.
- 8:24So if borrowing costs are this high, why
- 8:26haven't stocks felt it yet? [music]
- 8:28Because most big companies aren't paying
- 8:30today's rates, not yet. And the ones
- 8:32that are just started. In 2020 and
- 8:35[music] in 2021 money was nearly free
- 8:38and companies borrowed as much as they
- 8:39could.
- 8:40Today, 32% of all investment grade
- 8:43[music] corporate bonds and 55% of junk
- 8:45bonds were issued in those two years.
- 8:47[music]
- 8:48Companies locked in rates of 2 to 3% for
- 8:50years, but the pain is already showing
- 8:53up where balance sheets couldn't lock in
- 8:54cheap long-term paper. In the public
- 8:57markets, that burden falls squarely on
- 8:59small and mid-cap stocks.
- 9:01In the Russell 2000, roughly 40% of all
- 9:04debt is floating rate or matures in the
- 9:06near term compared to under 15% for the
- 9:09S&P 500. Nearly 40% of these companies
- 9:13earn less than twice what they owe in
- 9:14annual interest [music] and almost a
- 9:16third generate no net earnings at all.
- 9:19Not much room for anything to go wrong.
- 9:21The largest companies are protected for
- 9:23now. Most of their debt is fixed rate
- 9:25and it comes due a little at a time, but
- 9:28that cheap debt doesn't last forever.
- 9:30It comes due on a fixed schedule [music]
- 9:32and the weaker borrowers get hit first.
- 9:35US companies outside the financial
- 9:36sector have $539 [music]
- 9:38billion in investment grade debt coming
- 9:41due this year.
- 9:42514 billion in 2027, 449 billion in
- 9:472028. For the riskier companies, the
- 9:49ones with junk ratings, the wall peaks
- 9:52at 1.1 trillion coming due in 2028.
- 9:56When debt borrowed at 2 or 3% rolls
- 9:58over, it rolls into today's rates.
- 9:59[music] Right now, investment grade
- 10:01companies pay about 5.7%.
- 10:04The weakest investment grade companies
- 10:06pay closer [music] to six.
- 10:07For a a of borrowers, the interest bill
- 10:10and it sticks around.
- 10:12That higher interest expense sits on the
- 10:13income statement for the life of the new
- 10:15bond or until they can refinance.
- 10:18The biggest companies have a different
- 10:19problem. Their risk isn't old debt
- 10:22coming due. It's the new debt they're
- 10:24piling on right now at today's rates to
- 10:26pay for AI.
- 10:28Meta sold bonds to build AI
- 10:29infrastructure last year and earlier
- 10:31this year at 5.55% to 6.45%. [music]
- 10:36Those bonds now trade between 7.25% and
- 10:397.41%.
- 10:42Investors are demanding more to hold
- 10:43them.
- 10:44And when Meta returned to the bond
- 10:46market recently, investors demanded
- 10:48yields from 5.85% to 7.53%. [music]
- 10:52So how do we know when this stops being
- 10:54a debt problem and starts being a your
- 10:56401k problem?
- 10:58Two things to watch.
- 11:00First, the ICE BofA US [music] Corporate
- 11:03Index Effective Yield.
- 11:05It's around 5.7% while I'm writing this.
- 11:08If it breaks above 6.15%,
- 11:11the 2023 peak and stays there, corporate
- 11:14borrowing costs are at a 17-year high
- 11:16and still climbing while trillions in
- 11:18cheap debt is coming due and the big
- 11:20boys are still borrowing.
- 11:22That's your first warning.
- 11:24Second, once that happens, watch
- 11:26earnings season.
- 11:28If sales are still growing at double
- 11:29digits but earnings per share slow
- 11:31[music] to low single digits, the higher
- 11:33interest bills are eating into profits.
- 11:36When that shows [music] up, lower stock
- 11:38prices are likely to follow.
- 11:40And don't forget depreciation.
- 11:42When companies spend hundreds of
- 11:43billions on data centers and short-lived
- 11:45GPUs, accounting rules force them
- 11:48[music] to expense that hardware against
- 11:49profits over just a few years.
- 11:52That creates an unavoidable recurring
- 11:54hit to earnings per share, compounding
- 11:56their higher interest bills [music]
- 11:57whether the new technology pays off or
- 11:59not.
- 12:00Right now, that warning hasn't appeared.
- 12:03Last quarter, S&P 500 sales grew over
- 12:0614% while earnings grew over 31. Profits
- 12:10are still growing more than twice as
- 12:11fast as sales. But that's the gap to
- 12:14watch.
- 12:15When it turns, [music]
- 12:16the bond market's warning has reached
- 12:17stocks. And to be fair, here's what
- 12:20would [music] break this whole setup.
- 12:22If the 10-year falls back below 4% like
- 12:24it did in 2023 [music] and corporate
- 12:26yields fall with it, the higher costs
- 12:28never reach profits.
- 12:30But I'm not going to hold my breath.
- 12:33Nobody can time the stock market down to
- 12:34the month,
- 12:35but debt is different.
- 12:37Every corporate bond has a maturity date
- 12:39written into the contract. Those dates
- 12:41don't move because the market is in a
- 12:43good mood. Those dates [music] are
- 12:44fixed.
- 12:45The debt schedule says the pressure
- 12:46builds through 2027.
- 12:49The maturity wall comes due.
- 12:51The new AI debt keeps piling up at
- 12:52today's rates, and interest costs eat
- 12:55further into profit margins every
- 12:56quarter.
- 12:57So go back to where we started. [music]
- 12:59Stocks are near record highs. Long-term
- 13:02yields are near their highest since
- 13:042002.
- 13:05That's not a celebration. That's the
- 13:07setup. [music]
- 13:08If most of your retirement money is in
- 13:09stocks, you don't have to predict the
- 13:11crash.
- 13:12You need two numbers.
- 13:14The corporate bond yield and the gap
- 13:16between sales growth and earnings
- 13:18growth. Check them every quarter.
- 13:19[music]
- 13:20You can't time the exact month, but you
- 13:22can watch the borrowing cost climb, and
- 13:24it's climbing now, and keep the momentum
- 13:26going.
- 13:27Watch the global debt crisis has
- 13:29arrived. Ordinary people will get rich.
- 13:32It's on your screen. If this changed how
- 13:35you view the bond market, subscribe.
- 13:37Remember, this isn't personal financial
- 13:39advice. It's education [music] so you
- 13:41can build your own plan. See you in the
- 13:43next video.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of The Last 3 Times This Happened, Stocks Fell Hard by Clearly Finance, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,289 words across 407 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.