YouTube2Text

The Killer Interview S01E12 | Christopher Porco — Transcript

by Eating Show KIMTAN · 13,775 words · 2,017 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00I'm finding it very difficult to
  2. 0:02reconcile what you're here for with the
  3. 0:04person that I'm talking to are you a mad
  4. 0:07axe killer no I I I had nothing to do
  5. 0:10with this my name is Chris bgo I was
  6. 0:13just called by the time Union saying
  7. 0:14that my parents were found dead this
  8. 0:18afternoon um I was wondering if you had
  9. 0:20any information hang on the line for me
  10. 0:22okay thank you to hit someone repeatedly
  11. 0:24with an
  12. 0:25axe that's serious stuff Christopher
  13. 0:29Porco is the most unlikely killer I've
  14. 0:31ever interviewed your father told a
  15. 0:34coworker that he thought you were a
  16. 0:36socium I don't believe he meant it there
  17. 0:38is a a 55-year-old white male down on
  18. 0:41the ground I saw Chris at all stages of
  19. 0:44his life he's unresponsive he's
  20. 0:46unresponsive and as a personal friend of
  21. 0:50the family I believe him to be innocent
  22. 0:54I've been granting one hour with a man
  23. 0:55found guilty of wielding an axe to kill
  24. 0:58his father and his mother there was just
  25. 1:01blood everywhere Blood on the ceiling
  26. 1:04and the bed was just soaked with blood
  27. 1:06you know what bothers me around all this
  28. 1:08you don't really show much remorse here
  29. 1:10you are as a convicted murderer how does
  30. 1:13that make you feel it's kind of a deep
  31. 1:15seething anger that's not really
  32. 1:17expressed dayto day now for the first
  33. 1:19time since his incarceration he's
  34. 1:21speaking out Porco insists he can prove
  35. 1:24he's an innocent man there's no doubt in
  36. 1:28my mind that Christopher Porco
  37. 1:30killed his father it's not our burden to
  38. 1:32demonstrate who did this the point is it
  39. 1:34was not Christopher you know you're
  40. 1:36making me think about this if you're
  41. 1:38guilty then you just played me for the
  42. 1:40last 2 hours but if it wasn't you who
  43. 1:43was it we we certainly have someone in
  44. 1:46mind
  45. 1:49[Applause]
  46. 1:57[Music]
  47. 2:02Christopher thank you for your time
  48. 2:04today what are you hoping to achieve
  49. 2:06from this
  50. 2:07interview well I think it's important to
  51. 2:11try and lay out um facts and information
  52. 2:15that never came to light originally you
  53. 2:17know 15 years ago so figured now was the
  54. 2:21time to kind of begin the process if you
  55. 2:23were innocent you're the victim of one
  56. 2:26of the worst miscarriages of Justice I
  57. 2:27can think of if you guilty you are a a
  58. 2:31Despicable Axe Murderer how do you how
  59. 2:34do you convince me I was convicted
  60. 2:36there's a there's a reason why I was
  61. 2:38convicted it was because the prosecution
  62. 2:41put on a compelling case and in large
  63. 2:44part we didn't do our job or or you were
  64. 2:47convicted because you did
  65. 2:49it I have the luxury of knowing that's
  66. 2:52not
  67. 2:55true in 2005 life seemed pretty good for
  68. 2:5921-year-old Christopher
  69. 3:00porker he was in his junior year as an
  70. 3:03economic major at the University of
  71. 3:05Rochester and a member of the sigma fi
  72. 3:07Epsilon
  73. 3:08fraternity but all that was about to
  74. 3:11change on the morning of November the
  75. 3:1315th when detectives arrived at his
  76. 3:15parents' home 200 M away in
  77. 3:18Albany discovered a scene of
  78. 3:20unimaginable
  79. 3:22Carnage 911 what's the problem there is
  80. 3:25a a 55-year-old white male down on the
  81. 3:28ground the front door was a jar but when
  82. 3:31I did stick my head in immediately I saw
  83. 3:35uh a body laying there his eyes are wide
  84. 3:38open and
  85. 3:40glassy and uh I got to the top of the
  86. 3:42stairs and I saw a female laying
  87. 3:46Crossways in the bed she had these very
  88. 3:49very large hack marks on her forehead
  89. 3:52and her jaw and um I realized she was
  90. 3:56still alive at this moment Porco was 200
  91. 3:59miles away in Rochester where he says he
  92. 4:02was completely unaware of what had
  93. 4:04happened to his parents let's turn to
  94. 4:08the phone call you get telling you that
  95. 4:09your parents have been
  96. 4:12attacked describe that moment it's every
  97. 4:15child's nightmare one of my fraternity
  98. 4:18Brothers came into to where I was and
  99. 4:19told me my phone had been ringing in my
  100. 4:21room I think it was the AL Many Times
  101. 4:24Union and she asked me if I had any
  102. 4:27comment on my parents' murder
  103. 4:30that day that's how you were told yep
  104. 4:33and I kind of fell back into the
  105. 4:36chair and asked her what what she was
  106. 4:39talking about she seemed somewhat
  107. 4:42embarrassed that I didn't know my name
  108. 4:45is Chris poro I was just called by the
  109. 4:47Times Union saying that my parents were
  110. 4:49found dead this afternoon um I was
  111. 4:50wondering if you had any information
  112. 4:52what about are you I'm at school in
  113. 4:54Rochester New York okay you're it's in
  114. 4:57Rochester yes okay hang on the line for
  115. 5:00me okay thank
  116. 5:03you I mean I've heard the tapes of these
  117. 5:06calls yeah what is most striking to me
  118. 5:09is how calm you are you know you've just
  119. 5:12been told that both your parents might
  120. 5:14have been brutally murdered but you're
  121. 5:17responding as if you're ringing up
  122. 5:18because some milk was taken off the
  123. 5:20doorstep I I I don't know if I
  124. 5:23characterize it in that way um by the
  125. 5:25time I made that
  126. 5:26call I didn't believe that anything had
  127. 5:30happened to anybody I knew a few minutes
  128. 5:33later a detective calls Christopher and
  129. 5:35confirms his father is dead and his
  130. 5:37mother is in a critical condition Porco
  131. 5:40is then asked to call back unaware of it
  132. 5:42his conversation is being
  133. 5:44recorded hey Chris yes yeah okay that's
  134. 5:47better I don't have the static anymore
  135. 5:49you going to go right to Aly Med I don't
  136. 5:51know I don't even know where my mom is
  137. 5:53but yeah she is at aling Med okay do you
  138. 5:55know her condition no because I haven't
  139. 5:57talked to her cuz when you get there
  140. 5:59I'll come and see if there's anything I
  141. 6:00can do for you yeah okay thanks once the
  142. 6:04police confirm it why do you stay calm
  143. 6:06I'm not saying you should have been
  144. 6:07hysterical but there's no sense of panic
  145. 6:10there's no sense of fear there's no
  146. 6:13sense of
  147. 6:14turmoil of rising stress or anything
  148. 6:18it's not something that that sinks in
  149. 6:20that
  150. 6:21registers and it it didn't for a long
  151. 6:24period of time it's almost like you're
  152. 6:25kind of floating through interactions
  153. 6:28with people I'm me a syic would say say
  154. 6:30that the reason you were so calm was
  155. 6:33that you already knew that because you
  156. 6:34were the one who had done it sure I
  157. 6:37think that everyone reacts to things
  158. 6:39differently typically I'm not a
  159. 6:42hysterical person to me in my mind I was
  160. 6:45thinking this is not accurate this is
  161. 6:50wrong we were at the hospital and
  162. 6:53Christopher came
  163. 6:55in for lack of a better word I would say
  164. 6:58he was in shock
  165. 7:00and within a few minutes after he got
  166. 7:03there two detectives approached him and
  167. 7:06said we would like to talk with you what
  168. 7:09Christopher doesn't know at this point
  169. 7:11is that detective Bish has already
  170. 7:14spoken to his mother oh she
  171. 7:17coherent did you
  172. 7:20speak
  173. 7:21[Music]
  174. 7:23should your mother was still alive and
  175. 7:25thank God she stayed alive orbe it with
  176. 7:28terrible injuries and they asked whether
  177. 7:31she knew the person who did this I
  178. 7:34looked down at her and I asked her if
  179. 7:36she could hear me and she indicated with
  180. 7:41her head that she nodded up and down yes
  181. 7:43they asked if it was your brother and
  182. 7:45she said no I then said did Christopher
  183. 7:49do this to you and she clearly shook her
  184. 7:52head yes then the immediate aftermath
  185. 7:54your mother not only identified the
  186. 7:57person as being someone she knew
  187. 8:00but specifically nodded twice when she
  188. 8:03was asked if it was you a son there are
  189. 8:06varying I would say descriptions as to
  190. 8:09what
  191. 8:14happened the attack happened upstairs in
  192. 8:17the bedroom but Peter got up and walked
  193. 8:21and trailed that blood himself going
  194. 8:22around the
  195. 8:24house it was one of the most astounding
  196. 8:26things that we heard that he could be
  197. 8:28struck with an axe dying and part of him
  198. 8:31was still trying to get up make the
  199. 8:33coffee get his lunch together do the
  200. 8:36routines you do in the morning before
  201. 8:37you go to work not realizing perhaps
  202. 8:39because of the trauma that he was dying
  203. 8:41which he did probably moments
  204. 8:43later in my mind I just couldn't believe
  205. 8:46that you know number one that this had
  206. 8:49happened number two that you know I was
  207. 8:52looking at the sun for this whole
  208. 8:54thing I'm finding it very difficult to
  209. 8:57reconcile what you're here for with the
  210. 9:00person that I'm talking to I could be
  211. 9:02talking to a regular guy in the bar who
  212. 9:05comes over as a perfectly normal human
  213. 9:07being yet whoever committed this crime
  214. 9:10is not a normal human being I would
  215. 9:12agree with that did you ever imagine
  216. 9:15that you would end up where you are
  217. 9:17today I know I don't think I ever met
  218. 9:20anyone who went to jail until I was in
  219. 9:22jail the porcos were what you would call
  220. 9:25a Norman rockwellian family I mean they
  221. 9:27were really just kind of the epitome
  222. 9:29of the successful middle class very kind
  223. 9:32and loving really nothing to Mar the
  224. 9:35perfect picture Peter Porco was very
  225. 9:38well known in the legal Community as a
  226. 9:40popular law clerk Joan Porco was a was a
  227. 9:43well-known teacher and Christopher Porco
  228. 9:46was not someone who was on anyone's
  229. 9:50radar no violence no abuse no
  230. 9:55reason certainly from their point of
  231. 9:57view no reason that you would feel
  232. 9:59murderous towards them of course not but
  233. 10:02the truth is in the year before the
  234. 10:04attack Peter and Joan Porco are having a
  235. 10:07difficult time with their 21-year-old
  236. 10:09son Christopher the last time that I
  237. 10:11spoke with Peter uh was on the Friday
  238. 10:14before and one of the things that came
  239. 10:16up was the financial problems that Chris
  240. 10:21had created he had forged Peter's
  241. 10:24signature to be a co-signer on a loan I
  242. 10:28paid for a car with a Lo loan that was
  243. 10:30um I signed a a check with my dad's name
  244. 10:33$177,000 to co-sign the loan Christopher
  245. 10:36seems to get off on the idea that he's
  246. 10:38getting over on his parents he likes to
  247. 10:40exploit their trust in the email
  248. 10:43exchanges with your father in particular
  249. 10:45in the run up to what happened it's
  250. 10:48clear that
  251. 10:49your fraudulent Behavior your thieving
  252. 10:52Nature has now extended to the tune of
  253. 10:55tens of thousands of dollars his father
  254. 10:58is calling him out he wants him to come
  255. 11:00home and have a conversation about this
  256. 11:02and basically The Jig Is up the stuff's
  257. 11:05about to hit the fan Christopher Porco
  258. 11:08cannot talk his way out of this one more
  259. 11:10time you had personal animists with your
  260. 11:13parents at the time over the discovery
  261. 11:15about the fraudulent
  262. 11:17Behavior there's an argument that you
  263. 11:19have motivation which was this financial
  264. 11:22Scandal have blown up in your face you
  265. 11:25know you're a Serial fraudster and your
  266. 11:27father's challenging you about this and
  267. 11:29you're lying to him repeatedly refusing
  268. 11:32to take any responsibility for what's
  269. 11:34happened it's
  270. 11:35true Peter Porco insists his son comes
  271. 11:38home and comes clean about his criminal
  272. 11:41Behavior just 10 days later Peter is
  273. 11:44found
  274. 11:45[Music]
  275. 11:46[Applause]
  276. 11:48dead your father told a
  277. 11:51coworker in the week before that he
  278. 11:55thought you were a sociopath yeah why
  279. 11:57would he have said that I don't I don't
  280. 11:59believe he meant it he was exasperated
  281. 12:01at the time because
  282. 12:04he couldn't understand why I was
  283. 12:06behaving that way he was kind of venting
  284. 12:09I think at the time but he did call you
  285. 12:10a sociopath yeah he did what's your
  286. 12:13understanding of what a sociopath
  287. 12:15is basically somebody with no
  288. 12:17emotion somebody incapable of feeling
  289. 12:20guilt remorse empathy yeah I've
  290. 12:22interviewed sociopaths I don't know if
  291. 12:25you are one but certainly the sociopaths
  292. 12:28I've interviewed
  293. 12:29are very capable of putting on a good
  294. 12:32act they're very capable of sounding
  295. 12:34very plausible they tend to be quite
  296. 12:36intelligent they tend to in the
  297. 12:39interview process which we're doing now
  298. 12:41they can be very convincing is
  299. 12:43Christopher Porco so practiced in his
  300. 12:46role playing in his ability to gain
  301. 12:48trust to manipulate to exploit the trust
  302. 12:50of others that he is simply playing the
  303. 12:52role like an academy award-winning actor
  304. 12:55of what he thinks an innocent person
  305. 12:58would behave like
  306. 13:00are you a sociopath no absolutely not um
  307. 13:04are you capable of real emotion I mean
  308. 13:05you didn't show much emotion when you
  309. 13:08were told that your parents have both
  310. 13:09been bludgeoned by a mad axmen well I I
  311. 13:13you say it's down to you not being a
  312. 13:14very emotional person I'm not I mean a
  313. 13:17sociopath is capable of killing people
  314. 13:20and feeling no remorse or guilt or even
  315. 13:23admitting doing it you accept that I
  316. 13:26mean I I know that's possible sure right
  317. 13:29so you accept your behavior at the time
  318. 13:31was
  319. 13:31sociopathic I think it could have been
  320. 13:33interpreted that way a viewer watching
  321. 13:35this will go so he admits he was being
  322. 13:38sociopathic his reaction is quite
  323. 13:40sociopathic and whoever did this was
  324. 13:43probably a sociopath I mean I'm doing
  325. 13:45the mass and it doesn't look great and
  326. 13:46the problem with everything that you've
  327. 13:48been saying to me is this is exactly how
  328. 13:51a sociopath would play me if he was
  329. 13:54trying to persuade me of his innocence
  330. 13:56and he had done it
  331. 14:02the day after the homicide my my son was
  332. 14:05born at Albany Medical Center and that's
  333. 14:07where Joan Porco was undergoing surgery
  334. 14:10at that time she underwent 12 hours of
  335. 14:12surgery when they find Peter dead
  336. 14:14downstairs they go upstairs they find
  337. 14:16his wife Joan who's still in the bed and
  338. 14:19the axe itself was found there at the
  339. 14:20foot of the bed and she was in very very
  340. 14:22bad shaped but still alive and breathing
  341. 14:25remarkably they had a police guard on
  342. 14:27her in part because at that point
  343. 14:30Christopher Porco was a suspect because
  344. 14:32she nodded affirmatively when asked if
  345. 14:35Christopher had done this due to the
  346. 14:38massive head injury sustained by Joan
  347. 14:39Porco prosecutors can't rely on her
  348. 14:42identification alone to convince a jury
  349. 14:45that Christopher is the attacker they
  350. 14:47need to prove he made the 400m round
  351. 14:49trip to his parents' house and back to
  352. 14:51his university in a single
  353. 14:54night one of the points which I think is
  354. 14:56in your favor of this is there's no no
  355. 14:59footage at all that was found of your
  356. 15:01Jeep a very distinctive yellow Jeep
  357. 15:05driving on the throughway at the correct
  358. 15:07time Sunday night into Monday morning
  359. 15:10and they believe you must have stopped
  360. 15:12to refuel at some stage but there's no
  361. 15:13evidence the police spent countless
  362. 15:16hours pulling security camera footage
  363. 15:19from gas stations from places all over
  364. 15:23the capital region the Albany area rest
  365. 15:25stops were checked Dunkin Donuts were
  366. 15:27checked and Not only was there no
  367. 15:29evidence that he ever refueled there was
  368. 15:31no evidence of his presence
  369. 15:34period but the neighbor Marshall gouki
  370. 15:37saw your yellow Jeep in the driveway at
  371. 15:384:00 a.m. I know my car was not there
  372. 15:43why would the neighbor lie B there's
  373. 15:45sort of a backstory with him I know that
  374. 15:48he's
  375. 15:54wrong I had one of my sergeants go to
  376. 15:57meet with the were up the street they
  377. 16:00were aware of the L Jeep because it was
  378. 16:02racing up and down the street during the
  379. 16:04summer and they were upset over it
  380. 16:06because of their kids might get
  381. 16:08hurt he knew it was that particular
  382. 16:10yellow Jeep in the driveway it was very
  383. 16:12fresh in his mind it
  384. 16:15was you have an an individual who was
  385. 16:18aware of what the police suspected one
  386. 16:21of his in-laws worked for the police
  387. 16:23department and um he was in a position
  388. 16:26to help well if he's okay well you've
  389. 16:29certainly been implying that the police
  390. 16:30have been working on a concerted effort
  391. 16:32to discredit you and to persuade
  392. 16:35Witnesses of your guilt mhm you said
  393. 16:38that one of the detectives detective
  394. 16:41ardini had a vested interest in
  395. 16:44disliking you because of something to do
  396. 16:46with his daughters that you dated two of
  397. 16:49his daughters is that right briefly
  398. 16:51dated Christoper had some sort of a
  399. 16:54relationship with one of the detectives
  400. 16:57daughters and and I don't know the
  401. 16:59details of it but whatever it was the
  402. 17:03detective uh did not like Chris him and
  403. 17:06his wife used to take their their dog to
  404. 17:08the veterinarian where I worked and I
  405. 17:10found out later that he had encouraged
  406. 17:13the veterinarians to fire me and that
  407. 17:15was told to me by the
  408. 17:17veterinarians do you think the personal
  409. 17:19animosity he had for you extended to him
  410. 17:22directing Witnesses it's a pretty
  411. 17:24serious allegation to make against the
  412. 17:26detective that he was directing Witness
  413. 17:29es to think that you were guilty and
  414. 17:31therefore they must have seen the yellow
  415. 17:34Jeep rather than them volunteering it I
  416. 17:36I think that his involvement was
  417. 17:40critical no with in all the dealings
  418. 17:43that I had with Detective arween he
  419. 17:45wasn't biased at all he he was
  420. 17:48approaching the investigation as we were
  421. 17:50keeping his uh you know mind open to all
  422. 17:54possibilities but he died right before
  423. 17:57trial he was never were subject to
  424. 17:59cross-
  425. 18:00examination and he is the one that
  426. 18:02secured the statement of John Fallon who
  427. 18:06was one of the toll collectors who
  428. 18:08claimed to remember the yellow
  429. 18:12Jeep how do you explain the the toll
  430. 18:14booth operators he's also believe they
  431. 18:17saw you it's very convenient that you
  432. 18:20have three individuals who remember one
  433. 18:23car to the exclusion of all others and
  434. 18:26it happens to be the car that they're
  435. 18:27being questioned about right but also
  436. 18:30it's very it's very convenient if you're
  437. 18:32you to say that the three people who all
  438. 18:36independently say they saw your car that
  439. 18:39they've all decided for some reason that
  440. 18:42they're going to nail you that they're
  441. 18:44going to pretend they're going to
  442. 18:46pretend they saw your yellow Jeep even
  443. 18:48when it according to you it was never
  444. 18:50there I don't believe it's that simple
  445. 18:52why would they all be so wrong there's a
  446. 18:56lot more information about these
  447. 18:58Witnesses that was not used at trial mhm
  448. 19:01and so you think in each case they're
  449. 19:04discredited I believe they will be yes
  450. 19:07okay absolutely a Shucks let's see if we
  451. 19:09can straighten this out the problem is
  452. 19:12he never sways from that impassive
  453. 19:16storytelling nice guy don't worry we
  454. 19:19come to the next bit in a
  455. 19:21minute how long have we got Chaps at
  456. 19:24first it's very impressive 25 30 minutes
  457. 19:27perfect that's great but after after an
  458. 19:29hour it's really
  459. 19:35suspicious were you aware of that axe
  460. 19:38sure you knew it was there I had split
  461. 19:40with my dad on more than one occasion so
  462. 19:43you knew it was there you knew where it
  463. 19:44was kept yes anybody else I mean it
  464. 19:47wasn't something we really advertised it
  465. 19:50was sitting by the it was right next to
  466. 19:52the door as you came in so it's a small
  467. 19:54number of people that would have known
  468. 19:56it was there before you accept that
  469. 19:59well you're you're assuming that whoever
  470. 20:00did this didn't walk in and see it as
  471. 20:02they walked in no no I'm not making any
  472. 20:04assumptions I'm just saying that the
  473. 20:05number of people who would have known in
  474. 20:07advance oh of course that the axe was
  475. 20:08there was very small that's very true
  476. 20:10yes all the training that we had the
  477. 20:13police have regarding homicide and
  478. 20:17violent crime this type of crime it
  479. 20:20tells us that it's someone close that
  480. 20:22it's not a stranger
  481. 20:24attack the attack on your parents was
  482. 20:28friend
  483. 20:29IED it was
  484. 20:32brutal it's the worst thing you could
  485. 20:34ever do to someone I
  486. 20:36think um
  487. 20:38it's obviously someone who is very
  488. 20:41angry it was a personal thing right it's
  489. 20:44a personal Thing by somebody who hated
  490. 20:48your parents so much they wanted to
  491. 20:50obliterate them I agree I'm not sure
  492. 20:53about hate I I don't know but I know
  493. 20:56anger there's no doubt there was anger
  494. 20:57in what happened
  495. 20:59the fact that whoever did this got out
  496. 21:02without leaving any DNA any blood
  497. 21:04evidence not even fingerprints on the
  498. 21:06acts really shows that it's not a random
  499. 21:09stranger crime detectives are in no
  500. 21:11doubt the Intruder had carefully planned
  501. 21:13and executed the attack some of the
  502. 21:16details of the crime scene were
  503. 21:18surprisingly familiar to them 2 years
  504. 21:21before Peter Porco had reported what
  505. 21:23appeared to be a series of break-ins at
  506. 21:25the house in which two laptops were
  507. 21:28stolen
  508. 21:29when I investigated a couple years prior
  509. 21:31to the homicide investigation the front
  510. 21:33windows were pred open and there was
  511. 21:36this long slit Mark in the cut in the in
  512. 21:39the screen to uh unlock the window and
  513. 21:42get it open when The Hite occurred there
  514. 21:45was a a similar slit in the screen that
  515. 21:49kind of made me think geez you know I
  516. 21:51have seen this before you know we didn't
  517. 21:53learn and get evidence that it was in
  518. 21:56fact Chris Porco who stole Those comp
  519. 21:58computers until we got this homicide
  520. 22:01investigation we learned that Chris
  521. 22:03Porco had eBay accounts we were able to
  522. 22:06trace one of his sales the sale of Janes
  523. 22:09laptop to a kid from uh San Diego
  524. 22:15California and you just took these
  525. 22:17laptops when you were at the home or did
  526. 22:19you break in and when I was
  527. 22:22home yep but you allowed your parents to
  528. 22:24think somebody else had done yes yep I
  529. 22:28mean that is a pretty unsavory thing to
  530. 22:30do to your parents because it makes them
  531. 22:32think they've had absolutely somebody
  532. 22:33intruding in the house
  533. 22:35absolutely to me what I did was
  534. 22:39Despicable and
  535. 22:41wrong and to some people maybe
  536. 22:43unforgivable but the attack on my
  537. 22:48parents is a whole different category of
  538. 22:53[Music]
  539. 22:55horrible there is another piece of
  540. 22:57evidence that seems to point directly
  541. 22:59towards Christopher's guilt Peter and
  542. 23:02Joan PCO had installed a home security
  543. 23:04system after the break-ins on the night
  544. 23:07of the murder that system was
  545. 23:10deactivated now whoever did it broke in
  546. 23:12using the alarm master code that I
  547. 23:15believe was only known to six people
  548. 23:18your parents Uncle John your godmother
  549. 23:21Margaret and you and your brother six of
  550. 23:23you knew that well it's correct that we
  551. 23:25those are the people that knew the code
  552. 23:27right so how could somebody have got
  553. 23:28into the house using the master code if
  554. 23:30it wasn't one of the six people I would
  555. 23:33not say that the person gained entry to
  556. 23:35the house at that time or using a code
  557. 23:40the alarm records show that it was on at
  558. 23:42the time you're saying that was faulty
  559. 23:44no I'm saying that the alarm was turned
  560. 23:47off at 2 something in the morning most
  561. 23:51likely my dad if I had to guess why
  562. 23:54would you do
  563. 23:55that um why would your dad get out of
  564. 23:57bed 2:45 in the morning turn off the
  565. 24:00alarm we don't know I given that they
  566. 24:02believe Intruders have been repeatedly
  567. 24:04breaking in to steal their
  568. 24:07possessions and they've intensified
  569. 24:09security to combat that here's what I
  570. 24:12don't get about what you're saying true
  571. 24:14you want us to think that your father
  572. 24:16gets out of bed at 2:14 a.m. mhm goes
  573. 24:20down and deactivates the alarm to the
  574. 24:22house not withstanding the fact they put
  575. 24:24it there because they believe there's
  576. 24:26somebody constantly breaking in steing
  577. 24:28their possessions what part of that
  578. 24:30makes sense my dad had a habit of
  579. 24:32turning the alarm off and forgetting to
  580. 24:35rearm it that was not something that but
  581. 24:37why would he get out of bed at 214 and
  582. 24:39do it to let the dog out at 214 most
  583. 24:41likely I think that's probably what
  584. 24:43happened yeah he was 11 years old at the
  585. 24:45time and needed to go out sometimes that
  586. 24:49was not unusual we subpoenaed the
  587. 24:51records for the alarm and for months and
  588. 24:54months and months it was the same
  589. 24:56pattern there was never over months and
  590. 24:59months and months of Records never a
  591. 25:01single time when that alarm was
  592. 25:04deactivated in the middle of the night
  593. 25:07just as detectives had noted 2 years
  594. 25:09earlier the screen on the window was
  595. 25:11again cut to allow it to be opened and
  596. 25:13although the alarm had been switched off
  597. 25:15using the master code the killer had
  598. 25:17nevertheless decided to smash up the
  599. 25:19control
  600. 25:21pad Chris Porco set the stage for those
  601. 25:25burglaries in 2002 and 2003 that's the
  602. 25:28exact same thing he did in the homicide
  603. 25:31uh scene so the pad was smashed to make
  604. 25:34it look like a stranger had done that
  605. 25:36but the brains of the alarm system in
  606. 25:38the basement had already registered at
  607. 25:402:14 a.m. that the master code had been
  608. 25:43used to deactivate the
  609. 25:45alarm I'll be honest with you I don't
  610. 25:47know what to think you don't come across
  611. 25:49as a mad ax killer and yet I know that's
  612. 25:52what you're here for I have a sequence
  613. 25:55of events before this happened of you
  614. 25:57being a liar a fraudster treating your
  615. 26:00parents despicably by your own admission
  616. 26:03uh treating them inhumanly making them
  617. 26:05in fear of their lives making them
  618. 26:07bolster security because of intruders
  619. 26:10that didn't exist and I just have to
  620. 26:12look at you as viewers will be and think
  621. 26:15is this guy
  622. 26:16capable of taking an axe in his hand and
  623. 26:20brutally murdering his
  624. 26:23father and then trying to brutally
  625. 26:25murder his mother including axing her in
  626. 26:27the head and face and that's the
  627. 26:30question people will be asking are you
  628. 26:32capable of doing that are you a mad axe
  629. 26:35killer no I I I had nothing to do with
  630. 26:38this but if it wasn't you was
  631. 26:42it I mean was something got pop into
  632. 26:45your head a little bit who would you
  633. 26:50guess why is Christopher Porco doing
  634. 26:53this interview now well he has an appeal
  635. 26:56going he has some lawyers working on it
  636. 26:58he wants a new trial hopefully to have
  637. 27:01his conviction overturned and the
  638. 27:03greatest thing he has going for him is
  639. 27:05the love and support of his mother
  640. 27:08shortly after the horrific attack on
  641. 27:10Joan Porco she recovers Consciousness
  642. 27:12and changes her story she now believes
  643. 27:15her son to be innocent and appeals to
  644. 27:18the court to be merciful at his
  645. 27:20sentencing I understand that the law
  646. 27:23requires you to impose a lengthy thren
  647. 27:26sentence
  648. 27:29however you do have
  649. 27:32discretion and I implore you to use that
  650. 27:35discretion to keep this sentence as
  651. 27:37short as possible please allow
  652. 27:40Christopher the opportunity to obtain
  653. 27:45freedom in my
  654. 27:49lifetime I believe him to be
  655. 27:53innocent what about your mother how
  656. 27:56often does she come and see you she's
  657. 27:58been a number of times we speak almost
  658. 28:01every day um I mean the extraordinary
  659. 28:03thing is your mother says she has no
  660. 28:05recollection at all of what happened
  661. 28:07that night she obviously with the way
  662. 28:10that she responded to questions in the
  663. 28:12Moment by the police that attended
  664. 28:15that's part of the reason that you're
  665. 28:17here convicted but she has defended you
  666. 28:20publicly yes ever since whilst
  667. 28:22acknowledging she has no memory of what
  668. 28:24happened yes she lost her husband
  669. 28:27someone she loved very deeply and was
  670. 28:29very happy with a mother's instinct
  671. 28:32might be in that circumstance that I
  672. 28:34don't want to lose a son as well you
  673. 28:36might do everything in your power to try
  674. 28:39and do that and operate under a form of
  675. 28:42self-denial simply because it's you Su I
  676. 28:45think that's very
  677. 28:47possible I think the biggest mystery of
  678. 28:50this case is whether Joan Porco knows
  679. 28:55that her son attacked her or not you
  680. 28:58know she's my mother no mothers want to
  681. 29:00believe that that son of course I I
  682. 29:02she's my mother she loves me
  683. 29:04unconditionally and I I have no doubt
  684. 29:05that if she believed I had done this she
  685. 29:07would still love me um I mean that's
  686. 29:10extraordinary it is it is she would
  687. 29:13still forgive you you think forgive I
  688. 29:16don't know I I think she would still
  689. 29:18love
  690. 29:20me if Joan were here speaking in my mind
  691. 29:25I think that she would reiterate that
  692. 29:28she is absolutely convinced that
  693. 29:30Christopher is innocent if she doesn't
  694. 29:33want her son to be in prison then she
  695. 29:36might just pretend she doesn't remember
  696. 29:38it's possibility right I I I take some
  697. 29:42offense to that um she's I just say it's
  698. 29:45a possibility she's an honest person she
  699. 29:47would absolutely not lie if she knew um
  700. 29:51there's no doubt that she she does not
  701. 29:53remember has she ever asked you
  702. 29:56Christopher did you do this
  703. 29:59it's a good question I don't believe so
  704. 30:00directly she may have at one point I I
  705. 30:03don't believe so she never asked
  706. 30:06you I'm not sure to be honest with you I
  707. 30:09don't
  708. 30:10know if Christopher Porco can convince
  709. 30:13his mother that he's factually innocent
  710. 30:14it gives him the confidence to believe
  711. 30:16that he might convince you but what I
  712. 30:19see as a psychopath who is exploiting a
  713. 30:22mother's love you come across as
  714. 30:24thoughtful sensitive intelligent
  715. 30:27articulate
  716. 30:29but if you're guilty then you just
  717. 30:31played me for the last 2
  718. 30:33hours here's the other problem I have no
  719. 30:36one else has ever been found there was
  720. 30:38no evidence of anybody else being in the
  721. 30:40property that's not true well who did
  722. 30:43they discover had been there who could
  723. 30:44have done this well there was forensic
  724. 30:46evidence from at least one other person
  725. 30:49and was that person investigated no so
  726. 30:52that person could still be out there
  727. 30:54they
  728. 30:55are you know we have a great system in
  729. 30:58our country it's probably the best in
  730. 31:00the world but it's it's adversarial the
  731. 31:03public still does not know much about
  732. 31:05this case that I feel resembles the
  733. 31:08truth ultimately I have faith in the
  734. 31:11system and my father held so dear and
  735. 31:14I'm confident that with time wrongs will
  736. 31:15be wred and when you say we have a great
  737. 31:18system in this
  738. 31:19country you're sitting here claiming to
  739. 31:22be a completely innocent man it's not
  740. 31:24perfect why would you think it's a great
  741. 31:26system if you've been framed for
  742. 31:27something you didn't do
  743. 31:28I I wouldn't say framed I wrongfully
  744. 31:30convicted but it isn't that the same
  745. 31:32thing Christopher is preparing a new
  746. 31:34appeal with the full support of his
  747. 31:36mother he hopes to prove not only that
  748. 31:38he is Innocent but to reveal who he
  749. 31:41believes committed the
  750. 31:45murder you know you're making me think
  751. 31:47about this but if it wasn't you who was
  752. 31:50it we we certainly have someone in mind
  753. 31:54who is that um it's someone who had a
  754. 31:58personal connection to my father through
  755. 32:01work someone who expressed a lot of
  756. 32:04anger right during this time frame
  757. 32:06through his lawyer who we've spoken to I
  758. 32:09am aware of a direct threat that was
  759. 32:11made to Peter I don't know the details
  760. 32:14of the threat I don't know who made the
  761. 32:16threat but it raised the thought in
  762. 32:19Peter's mind of having a gun in the
  763. 32:22office and you think he did it I had I
  764. 32:26know that he had a motive what was the
  765. 32:28motion um he felt that my father was
  766. 32:31meddling in
  767. 32:33a family court case that involved him
  768. 32:37there may have been other personal
  769. 32:38issues involved that I don't think it's
  770. 32:40appropriate for me to discuss have you
  771. 32:42told the police to investigate this
  772. 32:44other person no why not well they
  773. 32:47wouldn't really be interested in doing
  774. 32:49that right now I find that again I find
  775. 32:51that extraordinary so well you have to
  776. 32:53understand when this information became
  777. 32:55known to us yeah it was in the past
  778. 32:57several years years hang on I just need
  779. 33:00to understand why if you were told
  780. 33:02several years ago that there was
  781. 33:05somebody that may have done this to your
  782. 33:07parents who's still there and you know
  783. 33:10who it is we do but you wouldn't even
  784. 33:13tell the police we we that's part of the
  785. 33:15the process yeah but you're stretching
  786. 33:17my credulity
  787. 33:18here secondly why would you not put it
  788. 33:21in your extremely lengthy
  789. 33:24detailed process of appeal um
  790. 33:28I'm sensitive about publicly accusing an
  791. 33:31individual of murder without having
  792. 33:34pretty conclusive evidence that he's
  793. 33:37responsible um you know this person I
  794. 33:40I've never met him you know who it is
  795. 33:43Christopher doesn't want to publicly
  796. 33:44name this person who was the partner of
  797. 33:47one of Peter Porker's work colleagues we
  798. 33:49took that name to the
  799. 33:52police did you ever investigate the
  800. 33:56name I never even heard that name don't
  801. 34:00remember honestly
  802. 34:03sorry nothing comes to mind no it
  803. 34:06honestly
  804. 34:07doesn't sorry if there was a direct
  805. 34:10threat against Peter and we were aware
  806. 34:12of that that would have been pursued and
  807. 34:13investigated nothing nothing even
  808. 34:16remotely pointed toward this being
  809. 34:19anyone other than
  810. 34:21Chris like we discussed earlier it's
  811. 34:24very clear there was anger behind this I
  812. 34:27think this was a a an intentional act by
  813. 34:29someone who
  814. 34:30knew you know who they were after and
  815. 34:32what they were doing so you didn't put
  816. 34:35this man's name in your appeal document
  817. 34:39not yet do you intend
  818. 34:43to hopefully at some
  819. 34:46point trust me if you think somebody
  820. 34:48else has gotten away with the murder of
  821. 34:50your parents you want everyone to know
  822. 34:52their name but he's polite he's like I
  823. 34:53don't I don't want to I know what it's
  824. 34:55like to be falsely accused I want to
  825. 34:57take care of his due process rights and
  826. 34:59not name him because this person does
  827. 35:01not exist do we have a person in mind
  828. 35:05yes we do did that name just come out of
  829. 35:08The Ether no it did not but like I said
  830. 35:11it's not our burden to demonstrate who
  831. 35:13did this the point is is it was not
  832. 35:16Christopher here's my problem with this
  833. 35:19I'll be honest with you I don't know
  834. 35:20what to think you're very convincing
  835. 35:22you're very
  836. 35:24plausible you're intelligent as I've
  837. 35:26said before you clearly know all the
  838. 35:29details of the case you've had lived it
  839. 35:31for you had 15 years to talk it through
  840. 35:34I also understand from your appeal and
  841. 35:37the detail of the appeal that there are
  842. 35:39lots of questions that remain unanswered
  843. 35:41about this there definitely
  844. 35:44are Christopher it's been a fascinating
  845. 35:46interview yeah um thank you I honestly
  846. 35:50don't know what to
  847. 35:52think thank you for your time thank you
  848. 35:55I appreciate it
  849. 35:58[Applause]
  850. 36:00as you've discovered we want to be fair
  851. 36:01and open-minded about this well that's
  852. 36:03all I that's all I really want yeah
  853. 36:04we're just about trying to get to the I
  854. 36:06think it's important to recognize that
  855. 36:07there's a reason why I got convicted and
  856. 36:10it's not an easy thing to kind of look
  857. 36:12in the mirror and say like you're
  858. 36:14[ __ ] you know Christopher Porco is
  859. 36:16obviously highly intelligent he's got no
  860. 36:19record of violence and the questions I
  861. 36:23have to ask myself are two really one is
  862. 36:26he smart enough to covered his tracks if
  863. 36:29he did do this because there's hardly
  864. 36:31any evidence leing him to his crime I
  865. 36:33think he is he definitely is smart
  866. 36:36enough to have done that secondly is
  867. 36:38someone like him capable of taking an
  868. 36:41Axe and attacking his parents as they
  869. 36:44lay in bed that's the question I can't
  870. 36:47answer I still don't know
  871. 36:57[Music]
  872. 37:09I'm Emily compano as a lawyer I've spent
  873. 37:12many hours with convicted felons inside
  874. 37:15the walls of Prisons those are
  875. 37:17conversations and experiences you never
  876. 37:20forget now Piers Morgan is joining me
  877. 37:23here in a slightly less intense
  878. 37:25environment to take you inside the
  879. 37:28killer
  880. 37:31interview Christopher Porco you've
  881. 37:34called him the most unlikely killer
  882. 37:36you've ever interviewed tell us why the
  883. 37:39most Killers I've interviewed over the
  884. 37:41years they they're quite rough they're
  885. 37:44obviously dangerous people you can tell
  886. 37:47they have a look they have a manner they
  887. 37:50have a way about them where you just
  888. 37:53feel Menace exuding from their every
  889. 37:56poor PCO isn't like that he's calm he's
  890. 38:01intelligent he is extraordinarily normal
  891. 38:05to meet and to interview he's softly
  892. 38:08spoken he's not overly emotional he's
  893. 38:12not stupid he's a bright guy and you put
  894. 38:15it all together and you think is it
  895. 38:17really conceivable that somebody like
  896. 38:20this would go to his own parents bedroom
  897. 38:25with an
  898. 38:26axe and
  899. 38:28murder one and nearly murder the other
  900. 38:30and that was the bit for me which I
  901. 38:32found very hard to to definitively prove
  902. 38:37because the evidence against him is all
  903. 38:40circumstantial there's nothing actually
  904. 38:42forensic which Nails him and so you
  905. 38:46couple the kind of person he is with
  906. 38:49that and it doesn't quite add up
  907. 38:52honestly I did not think I was looking
  908. 38:54at a murderer nothing about him said I'm
  909. 38:58a Savage axe killer let alone of his own
  910. 39:03parents and it's a fascinating story
  911. 39:06because it obviously killed his father
  912. 39:09he's convicted of killing his father his
  913. 39:12mother survived and she believes
  914. 39:15him she thinks he's completely innocent
  915. 39:19so there you have a situation where he's
  916. 39:21convicted of taking an axe to his own
  917. 39:23mother and she survived but she believes
  918. 39:27him
  919. 39:27thinks he's been completely set up could
  920. 39:30never never ever hurt her and again you
  921. 39:34think if she's that
  922. 39:36sure did
  923. 39:38he what was your first impression of him
  924. 39:41and did that change ever my first
  925. 39:44impression was my last
  926. 39:46impression he can't have done this
  927. 39:48honestly he was just polite he was calm
  928. 39:53he
  929. 39:53was nothing like any prisoner I'd seen
  930. 39:56inside of Max from security prison in
  931. 39:58America nothing about him said to me
  932. 40:02he's a mad ax man now I know from
  933. 40:06criminal history there are people that
  934. 40:09do Despicable things who look and sound
  935. 40:11exactly like Christopher porker so I'm
  936. 40:13not completely deluded to the
  937. 40:16possibility he might have done it but
  938. 40:18when you add the lack of any real
  939. 40:20forensic evidence proving that he did it
  940. 40:23everything is circumstantial and some of
  941. 40:25it's quite compell in
  942. 40:28circumstantial you know he did steal
  943. 40:30things from his parents' home he did
  944. 40:33know how the locks worked etc etc
  945. 40:35there's lots of things you could point
  946. 40:36to and say yeah I mean look you all the
  947. 40:40prison officers afterwards I said to
  948. 40:43them what do you think I can't make my
  949. 40:45money well oh he did it he did it they
  950. 40:47were sure I wasn't so
  951. 40:50sure and he said to me they had his
  952. 40:54defense team had found another suspect
  953. 40:57I'll be very interested to see how that
  954. 40:59investigation plays out because it might
  955. 41:03be he's the victim as I said to him of a
  956. 41:05terrible miscarriage of justice and what
  957. 41:07a miscarriage that would be do you feel
  958. 41:10that you are a good detector if someone
  959. 41:12is lying I think as a a journalist of 30
  960. 41:15odd years I've always thought
  961. 41:17journalists lawyers and police
  962. 41:21detectives are all have a similar skill
  963. 41:24set you're a lawyer I'm a journalist we
  964. 41:27know detectives it's all the same kind
  965. 41:30of thing right you're going down the
  966. 41:32same process and you encounter a lot of
  967. 41:34good liars and your lie ometer if you
  968. 41:37like gets ever more finely tuned so I
  969. 41:41think I can normally tell a good liar
  970. 41:43pretty
  971. 41:44quickly and in his case he was very
  972. 41:48consistent in his story he was very
  973. 41:51emphatic he never lost his temper like
  974. 41:54some of them do with me he never hung
  975. 41:57himself on
  976. 41:59details now he's highly intelligent so
  977. 42:02whether he just had prepared for it in
  978. 42:05such a minuscule way that he could be
  979. 42:08that plausible or he genuinely didn't do
  980. 42:12it you mentioned earlier the Menace that
  981. 42:15you can feel emanating from Killers do
  982. 42:19the packages change or do the packages
  983. 42:22all look the same they can come in any
  984. 42:25packages for all I know you could be a
  985. 42:27terrible serial killer I'm not and you
  986. 42:30can tell I'm not no but it's it's you
  987. 42:32know in a way I'm joking but I'm also
  988. 42:35making the point that it it can be
  989. 42:36anybody in my experience of interviewing
  990. 42:39really bad people they can come in all
  991. 42:42walks of life they can come in all from
  992. 42:44any kind of societal class any form of
  993. 42:48intelligence very intelligent very
  994. 42:50stupid you know very well off very poor
  995. 42:54there's no real connecting Force that
  996. 42:57links Killers if you're in a gang that's
  997. 43:00different you know crimes of passion I
  998. 43:02always Park to one side too because in a
  999. 43:04crime of passion they tend to be
  1000. 43:06instantaneous and full of regret
  1001. 43:08afterwards these are different these
  1002. 43:10killers I interviewed particularly the
  1003. 43:12serial killers it's a methodical
  1004. 43:14systematic destruction of other human
  1005. 43:16beings and um it's they're fascinating
  1006. 43:23[Music]
  1007. 43:56do you still feel homicidal urges no
  1008. 44:00never well if you push my trigger you're
  1009. 44:04you're
  1010. 44:04done Robert spahalski is a serial killer
  1011. 44:07unlike any I've encountered before I
  1012. 44:10mean what you're saying is if I press
  1013. 44:11the wrong trigger with you in this
  1014. 44:12interview absolutely you might feel
  1015. 44:14homicidal
  1016. 44:16absolutely he's a psychotic a soulless
  1017. 44:19human being spahi he's like a lightning
  1018. 44:22bolt that you can't see coming his
  1019. 44:25crimes made him notorious I'm told
  1020. 44:27spahalski can be volatile but he's also
  1021. 44:30unique the prototypical serial killer
  1022. 44:33kills strangers but he killed people
  1023. 44:35that he knew she was making fun of him
  1024. 44:38so he lost it and he uh he choked her to
  1025. 44:45death that's really strange and it's not
  1026. 44:48a one-off like a domestic this kept
  1027. 44:50happening and happening and happening he
  1028. 44:53said that um that he saw her as a demon
  1029. 44:56coming after him so he found something
  1030. 44:59that he could strangle her with and put
  1031. 45:01her out of her misery I've been given
  1032. 45:03one hour spahi to try and understand a
  1033. 45:06serial killer who murders only those
  1034. 45:08he's closest to I did not kill her and
  1035. 45:11the people I did Kill they didn't suffer
  1036. 45:13how can I believe you I don't care if
  1037. 45:15you do you now
  1038. 45:18[Music]
  1039. 45:19[Applause]
  1040. 45:28the chances of somebody walking in as
  1041. 45:31Infamous as Robert spahalski admitting
  1042. 45:34to murder are the same as winning a
  1043. 45:37lottery during the '90s Bowski
  1044. 45:40terrorized his neighborhood in Rochester
  1045. 45:41Upstate New York killing friends
  1046. 45:44neighbors and even lovers for almost 15
  1047. 45:47years he played a game of cat and mouse
  1048. 45:48for detectives but they could never
  1049. 45:50catch him until one morning in November
  1050. 45:532005 when Robert spahalski did something
  1051. 45:56unheard heard of he turned himself in
  1052. 45:59it's November the 8th um I'm working in
  1053. 46:02the homicide unit and it's an average
  1054. 46:04day for me I'm coming in the front doors
  1055. 46:06of the public safety building I walk in
  1056. 46:09and I look towards the headquarters desk
  1057. 46:12and we see a male white standing there
  1058. 46:14he looked Shaggy he looked like a street
  1059. 46:16person possibly a crack addict when I
  1060. 46:19first see him I I noticed the big
  1061. 46:21forehead and and the shy hair and he
  1062. 46:26looks like an old oldtime Hipp beat and
  1063. 46:29Glenn and I look at each other and do a
  1064. 46:32double take at him and realize although
  1065. 46:34we hadn't seen him in years it was him
  1066. 46:37and whatever he's saying is likely to be
  1067. 46:39true he said it was his friend it's
  1068. 46:41someone he got high with and that he
  1069. 46:43doesn't remember but he was dead and
  1070. 46:46everything changed right at that
  1071. 46:50moment in 2005 you walked into a police
  1072. 46:54station and you confessed absolutely to
  1073. 46:58all four murders that you were convicted
  1074. 47:00of and you knew all your victims which
  1075. 47:03again is unusual these were people some
  1076. 47:06cases they were personal relationships
  1077. 47:08you were having absolutely I know
  1078. 47:11previously you've tried to say you don't
  1079. 47:14want to be known as a serial killer okay
  1080. 47:16yeah why in my my mind's definition a
  1081. 47:19serial killer is something that's
  1082. 47:20predatory it's premeditation the people
  1083. 47:23I kill it wasn't predatory and it wasn't
  1084. 47:25premeditation when the those people died
  1085. 47:27that day I didn't wake up I think I'm
  1086. 47:29going to kill this person today my
  1087. 47:31killings were not like that sir I didn't
  1088. 47:32even know they were going to happen and
  1089. 47:35the reason I'm doing this interview with
  1090. 47:36you cuz I don't want to be seen as a
  1091. 47:39serial killer I don't want to be I but
  1092. 47:42Robert that's what you are I know but I
  1093. 47:43didn't mean it tool there nothing you
  1094. 47:45can do about that but you can't you
  1095. 47:46can't tell the world you're not a serial
  1096. 47:49killer when you have killed multiple
  1097. 47:51people you are obviously a Serial then
  1098. 47:54what I'm here is trying to say is why I
  1099. 47:56killed those people it's not about how I
  1100. 47:57kill it's
  1101. 47:59why unlike other serial killers that
  1102. 48:02I've interviewed who pick on random
  1103. 48:03strangers they don't know and kill them
  1104. 48:06spahalski picked on people he did know
  1105. 48:08people he cared about perhaps even
  1106. 48:12loved this is uh Lake Avenue in the city
  1107. 48:15of Rochester we're going to head over to
  1108. 48:18the uh address where Adrien Berger's
  1109. 48:22body was found in the apartment that she
  1110. 48:23lived in at the time of her death and
  1111. 48:25that was uh July of
  1112. 48:301991 Adrien burer She Was Your onoff
  1113. 48:33Girlfriend yes for one year now you
  1114. 48:36admit to killing her absolutely do sir
  1115. 48:38did you love this person well not in
  1116. 48:40love with her but I cared for her she
  1117. 48:42was a friend of mine absolutely this was
  1118. 48:44uh where Adrien burer lived at the time
  1119. 48:46of her uh
  1120. 48:48death uh when we arrived at the scene it
  1121. 48:50was a hot uh humid July day uh there
  1122. 48:54were several flies attached to the
  1123. 48:56window both inside and out of the
  1124. 48:58residence so at that point we realized
  1125. 49:01that she had probably been there a while
  1126. 49:03or at least decomposed
  1127. 49:06fast it was the the dog days of summer
  1128. 49:09I'll tell you that you know her body was
  1129. 49:11parabol actually they couldn't determine
  1130. 49:14whether she was a male or female she was
  1131. 49:16so deteriorated from you know Decay
  1132. 49:19Robert is absolutely Lucky in this case
  1133. 49:22it was the fact that they couldn't tell
  1134. 49:23for sure that she'd been murdered that
  1135. 49:26let him off the
  1136. 49:31hook why did you kill someone who you
  1137. 49:34had a relationship but it was compulsive
  1138. 49:36I didn't think about killing her I just
  1139. 49:37wrapped my hands around her throw and
  1140. 49:38strangle her to death it was it was like
  1141. 49:40when when I was doing it I was it was
  1142. 49:42like you when you turn the TV off
  1143. 49:43there's that little white Little Dot you
  1144. 49:45see in the middle of TV well that's what
  1145. 49:47I was experiencing when I was taking her
  1146. 49:48gift of life that's all I remember and I
  1147. 49:51also remember thinking this has taken
  1148. 49:53too
  1149. 49:54long during his confession he said that
  1150. 49:57uh they were on the couch and they were
  1151. 49:59attempting to have sex together but he
  1152. 50:03remained flaccid he couldn't get in
  1153. 50:05Direction and that she was making fun of
  1154. 50:07him so um he lost it he got snapped he
  1155. 50:12got very angry and he uh he choked her
  1156. 50:15to
  1157. 50:17death your explanation for that is you
  1158. 50:21completely lost control
  1159. 50:23absolutely absolutely had she done
  1160. 50:26anything
  1161. 50:27to Warrant her death well to a friend of
  1162. 50:30mine yeah she ripped up a $330,000 CH of
  1163. 50:33my friends she threw pain all over the
  1164. 50:35lady's house she was a terrorist so uh
  1165. 50:38um I think me on a subconscious level I
  1166. 50:40wanted to uh re resolve that problem
  1167. 50:43with my with my friend you see that but
  1168. 50:45that suggests Robert that you did give
  1169. 50:47it some pre-thought why that suggests
  1170. 50:49that your motivation for killing it was
  1171. 50:51what she'd done to your friend well I
  1172. 50:53think that doesn't sound to me if you
  1173. 50:54don't mind me saying it doesn't sound to
  1174. 50:56me like a spontaneous out of nowhere it
  1175. 50:59was when I killed her psychosis it
  1176. 51:00sounds like you wanted to punish her
  1177. 51:02well on a subconscious level absolutely
  1178. 51:05but on the conscious level I didn't
  1179. 51:07experience those type of thoughts at all
  1180. 51:09and I want you to understand that so I'm
  1181. 51:13try I'm trying to understand that's what
  1182. 51:14I'm saying so if it what motivated me to
  1183. 51:16kill her on that compulsive level it was
  1184. 51:18because I that subconscious programming
  1185. 51:21in my mind of how she violated my friend
  1186. 51:23all right but that's the only thing I
  1187. 51:24had against her if if that's the reason
  1188. 51:27why I actually killed
  1189. 51:28her during the interview process he
  1190. 51:32actually said to me it's not like a go
  1191. 51:34around killing people all the time is as
  1192. 51:36bizarre as anything anyone's ever said
  1193. 51:37to me in my police career this is
  1194. 51:40someone you've had an onoff relationship
  1195. 51:42with for a year did you have any
  1196. 51:44feelings of guilt or remorse no nothing
  1197. 51:47at all never thought about it again sir
  1198. 51:50you never gave her any more thought no
  1199. 51:52not really when you think about it now
  1200. 51:54because I'm asking you what do you think
  1201. 51:56still don't what do you think about her
  1202. 51:57now nothing it's like she didn't
  1203. 52:01exist you have no thoughts about her at
  1204. 52:03all no no right I'm being honest with
  1205. 52:05you I don't have a conscience sir right
  1206. 52:09do I feel remorse no I can
  1207. 52:11intellectualize guilt I can
  1208. 52:13intellectualize remorse but am I
  1209. 52:15actually feeling it
  1210. 52:17no see that that's extraordinary to
  1211. 52:19listen to absolutely it is not a great
  1212. 52:21thing sir I want to be normal just like
  1213. 52:24all you people but my life has been
  1214. 52:26anything but normal so is Bowski a
  1215. 52:29product of where he grew up or was he
  1216. 52:30born this way a ticking Time Bomb
  1217. 52:33predisposed to killed the answer to that
  1218. 52:36may lie here in the farmlands of Elmyra
  1219. 52:39New York when you don't have a con you
  1220. 52:41don't think about the repercussions
  1221. 52:42right you just want the part chop you
  1222. 52:43don't care how you got
  1223. 52:45[Applause]
  1224. 52:52it there is a serious drug problem in
  1225. 52:54the city of Rochester in the 19
  1226. 52:571980s crack cocaine is an
  1227. 53:00epidemic and people wanting to sell
  1228. 53:03crack cocaine are killing each other
  1229. 53:05over the right to
  1230. 53:06Turf by the mid 80s Robert spahalski is
  1231. 53:09a regular face on the Mean Street to
  1232. 53:11Rochester Upstate New
  1233. 53:13York I lived in a very violent World sir
  1234. 53:17I was a hardcore crack addict for 15
  1235. 53:18years and addictions always controlled
  1236. 53:21my life and my
  1237. 53:23thinking I first heard of spsky during
  1238. 53:26the late 80s he was kind of a um Jack of
  1239. 53:29all trades type guy an opportunist he
  1240. 53:31was involved in Street crimes burglaries
  1241. 53:34uh drugs drug dealing um male
  1242. 53:39prostitution watchest was perhaps the
  1243. 53:41ideal playground for a killer like
  1244. 53:44spahalski but where his story began
  1245. 53:46could not be any more
  1246. 53:49[Music]
  1247. 53:51different I mean the Curious Thing to me
  1248. 53:53is unlike most serial killers I've
  1249. 53:56interviewed where normally there's a
  1250. 53:57pattern in their lives of abuse at some
  1251. 53:59stage physical or sexual has driven them
  1252. 54:02to be the way they are there's the Ping
  1253. 54:06upbringing terrible parents you had none
  1254. 54:09of that none of that when all things go
  1255. 54:10bad in my life period I go back to my
  1256. 54:13childhood cuz that's where I feel the
  1257. 54:14love so tell me about the early years
  1258. 54:16and what life was like for you life was
  1259. 54:19like was was great U my father uh owned
  1260. 54:22his own business a grocery store uh we
  1261. 54:25own 40 acres of land a nice Farmhouse
  1262. 54:28could uh deer hunt we could fish so um I
  1263. 54:31never went without
  1264. 54:32lacking um was it a loving household
  1265. 54:36absolutely both parents yeah um I love
  1266. 54:39my mother as far much as I thought I
  1267. 54:40could she was loving to you absolutely
  1268. 54:43she was a ger what values did your
  1269. 54:45parents try and instill in you honesty
  1270. 54:49not to be hostile be
  1271. 54:51open-minded um all all all the positive
  1272. 54:55things but you Liv the opposite life a
  1273. 54:58life of dishonesty and I don't
  1274. 54:59understand that part of it I don't it's
  1275. 55:01like there I'm I'm possessed with a
  1276. 55:03different person in me um it's like a Dr
  1277. 55:05Jacko Dr High type thing I I don't I
  1278. 55:07can't explain
  1279. 55:13it spahalski also admitted to another
  1280. 55:16crime that happened back in 1991 in
  1281. 55:19Webster the murder of 40-year-old
  1282. 55:21Charles Grande spahalski told police he
  1283. 55:23used to run a male escort service and
  1284. 55:25that's how he met Grande Grande Charles
  1285. 55:27Chuck Grande yes he was 40 uh he was
  1286. 55:31someone you met on the bar scene he was
  1287. 55:33a sexual partner was that in your
  1288. 55:36existence as a male prostitute yes he
  1289. 55:38was paying you for sex
  1290. 55:43yes Charles uh is my brother and um we
  1291. 55:48were growing up I always called him
  1292. 55:51Chuck Charles Grande was
  1293. 55:54bisexual he was a l landscaper from
  1294. 55:58Rochester uh lived in the town of
  1295. 56:00Webster Chuck was so much fun to be
  1296. 56:03around um he was everyone's favorite
  1297. 56:06mine my mom my dad and because it's just
  1298. 56:10his personality was just you just if you
  1299. 56:15knew him you loved
  1300. 56:16him well that day the reason he died
  1301. 56:19because that was 1991 and he called my
  1302. 56:23phone number and when he called that
  1303. 56:24number he that was he won the lottery to
  1304. 56:27die that day and he won the lottery to
  1305. 56:29die to die that day uh that I was
  1306. 56:33mentally fixated at that stage I was not
  1307. 56:37it wasn't a compulsive thing it was
  1308. 56:39fixating on homicide and it wasn't
  1309. 56:41particularly with
  1310. 56:43him how did you kill him with a hammer
  1311. 56:47yeah one blow well well the first one
  1312. 56:50kind of glanced off on and shocked him
  1313. 56:52for a minute but the second blow put him
  1314. 56:54down forever
  1315. 56:57after I killed him I was completely
  1316. 56:58naked and I let up a cigarette and I
  1317. 57:00sitting on his naked bag smoking a
  1318. 57:02cigarette thinking about I don't
  1319. 57:03remember that's how far gone I was there
  1320. 57:06um I forget what I was thinking but uh
  1321. 57:10um was I in reality
  1322. 57:12no during the the time that we spoke
  1323. 57:15with him he gives specific details that
  1324. 57:17no one else would have known um he said
  1325. 57:20that he turned up the thermostat uh to
  1326. 57:22throw the police off and the medical
  1327. 57:24examiner off to show that the body may
  1328. 57:27have been there
  1329. 57:29longer um that was just a um that was an
  1330. 57:33aging Burger type thing uh because you'd
  1331. 57:36seen from your previous victim yes
  1332. 57:37absolutely heat would decompose the body
  1333. 57:40absolutely I was
  1334. 57:41there um I out of all the homicides he
  1335. 57:45his his bothers me the most why because
  1336. 57:48there there was a former premeditation
  1337. 57:50and his death um because I did
  1338. 57:54specifically go there with a hammer so
  1339. 57:56that's premeditation so I feel Bartly
  1340. 57:59even though I was in in a fixated even
  1341. 58:01though I was in a cycle mode of
  1342. 58:04homicidal fixation I still felt guilty
  1343. 58:06because I still had presence of Mind of
  1344. 58:09knowing I Hadar that hammer I mean again
  1345. 58:10I would say just hearing this from you
  1346. 58:13yes that both with Adrien berer and with
  1347. 58:15Charles Grande in both cases it seems
  1348. 58:17there was a premeditated feeling that
  1349. 58:20you were having to do something bad to
  1350. 58:23somebody neither of them seemed like
  1351. 58:25completely
  1352. 58:26spontaneous acts of violence it's been
  1353. 58:29in your head simmering absolutely sir
  1354. 58:31ready to blow
  1355. 58:33absolutely absolutely
  1356. 58:36no I guess never really thought about it
  1357. 58:4020 years before Charles Grande was
  1358. 58:42bludgeon to death with a hammer A store
  1359. 58:44owner in Elmyra was murdered the exact
  1360. 58:47same way and the killer sp's twin
  1361. 58:51brother Steven
  1362. 58:57[Music]
  1363. 59:03do you still feel homicidal urges no
  1364. 59:07never well if you push my trigger you're
  1365. 59:10you're done um but you see that if I
  1366. 59:14feel friend right but that in itself
  1367. 59:16that's normal that that's
  1368. 59:17self-preservation if it's not about
  1369. 59:18self-preservation I don't feel h a
  1370. 59:20satellite officer but what you just said
  1371. 59:23I mean that sends a chill down my spine
  1372. 59:25frankly
  1373. 59:27I mean what you're saying is if I press
  1374. 59:28the wrong trigger with you in this
  1375. 59:30interview absolutely you might feel
  1376. 59:31homicidal absolutely it's called genetic
  1377. 59:34sir called genetics my twin I were born
  1378. 59:37with Killer Instinct
  1379. 59:38[Music]
  1380. 59:40sir the spahalski brothers are that rare
  1381. 59:43thing in the annals of crime twins both
  1382. 59:46murderers who've killed
  1383. 59:49separately yet their five siblings went
  1384. 59:51on to lead completely normal lives what
  1385. 59:55was it that made the these twins
  1386. 59:58Killers have you been able to work out
  1387. 1:00:01why you think that you and your twin
  1388. 1:00:03brother went down One path and your
  1389. 1:00:05siblings another absolutely um
  1390. 1:00:08genetically my twin I were were born
  1391. 1:00:10without a conscience from day one when I
  1392. 1:00:12dropped my my mother's birth canal I
  1393. 1:00:15I've always been the epitome of social
  1394. 1:00:17dysfunction the spahalski came to BU
  1395. 1:00:21attention probably around
  1396. 1:00:241970 um they're a little hard to tell
  1397. 1:00:27apart you essentially juvenile
  1398. 1:00:29delinquents it was a
  1399. 1:00:32competition outdoing one another but was
  1400. 1:00:35a social misdirection what how we were
  1401. 1:00:37behaving absolutely was Sir right and we
  1402. 1:00:39were painting the balls with a lot of
  1403. 1:00:40people out there to satisfy oural rushes
  1404. 1:00:45were you surprised when Steven he was
  1405. 1:00:47just 16 at the time when he killed
  1406. 1:00:50Ronald Ripley no
  1407. 1:00:56Steven for reasons that are unclear
  1408. 1:00:59picks up a hammer and hits him over the
  1409. 1:01:01head uh victim falls down the stairs to
  1410. 1:01:04the foot of the stairs stevenh pounces
  1411. 1:01:07on him turns him over and stabs him
  1412. 1:01:09until he's
  1413. 1:01:10dead but he hit him over the head with a
  1414. 1:01:13hammer yes he did he then stabbed him in
  1415. 1:01:15a frenzy stabbing 40 50 times it only 13
  1416. 1:01:19times only 13 yeah I mean you say only
  1417. 1:01:2213 but take a knife and stab a human
  1418. 1:01:24being 13 times to me yes is an
  1419. 1:01:29unthinkable thing to do absolutely you
  1420. 1:01:31seem to think it was reasonable I'm
  1421. 1:01:33going to be honest with you well
  1422. 1:01:35resolved his way and now just all right
  1423. 1:01:38you kill him good for you again I don't
  1424. 1:01:40have a conscience sir I mean people who
  1425. 1:01:43don't have a conscience tend to be
  1426. 1:01:45categorized as either sociopaths or
  1427. 1:01:48Psychopaths well I am considered a
  1428. 1:01:50sociopathic psychopath because I don't
  1429. 1:01:52have a
  1430. 1:01:54conscience very often in layman's terms
  1431. 1:01:56we say that sociopaths are made very
  1432. 1:01:58often by lives of childhood abuse but
  1433. 1:02:01psychopaths are born then I believe that
  1434. 1:02:03he could be the rare example of the
  1435. 1:02:06innate Bad
  1436. 1:02:08Seed there are two peas in a pod they're
  1437. 1:02:11they got the same chromosomes whatever
  1438. 1:02:14and they just don't have that social
  1439. 1:02:17control how did you feel when you
  1440. 1:02:19learned that your brother several years
  1441. 1:02:21ago had died your twin
  1442. 1:02:23brother I felt relieved because uh I
  1443. 1:02:26think he's in a better place like me he
  1444. 1:02:29never had a chance in uh to function
  1445. 1:02:31we're not we're not functionable I I
  1446. 1:02:34mean I can function in society but not
  1447. 1:02:36in the way you people genuinely do did
  1448. 1:02:39you love your twin brother
  1449. 1:02:41absolutely but you say you're not
  1450. 1:02:43capable of a conscience either of you
  1451. 1:02:46and yet you were capable you think of
  1452. 1:02:48love I don't experience the emotional
  1453. 1:02:50death you would feel through love on
  1454. 1:02:52being lost and something like that when
  1455. 1:02:54my father's father died my grandfather I
  1456. 1:02:57laughed my balls off at his funeral cuz
  1457. 1:02:59I knocked on his forehead it was rock
  1458. 1:03:00hard we thought that was hilarious right
  1459. 1:03:03as your kid it was no there was open pun
  1460. 1:03:04casket yeah AB you actually yes you
  1461. 1:03:07found it funny that his for was yeah I
  1462. 1:03:10wasn't expecting that he feel that their
  1463. 1:03:11hardness you know and you burst out
  1464. 1:03:13laughing absolutely my father was pissed
  1465. 1:03:15off about that almost surprised it's his
  1466. 1:03:16father yeah it's pretty disrespectful
  1467. 1:03:19yeah yeah well I wasn't thinking like
  1468. 1:03:21that it was automatic you know automatic
  1469. 1:03:22you know kiss like that I guess
  1470. 1:03:25[Music]
  1471. 1:03:30yeah the first time we ever saw him in
  1472. 1:03:33person I felt like I was looking
  1473. 1:03:36at a monster and he turned around he
  1474. 1:03:40looked at my husband and I and he said
  1475. 1:03:42you want to tell me why you keep looking
  1476. 1:03:45at
  1477. 1:03:46me between 1991 and 2005 there appears
  1478. 1:03:50to have been a 14-year Gap in which
  1479. 1:03:52Robert spahalski didn't kill anybody the
  1480. 1:03:55reason
  1481. 1:03:56a woman called Christine Gonzalez I
  1482. 1:03:58wrapped my arms around her and looked
  1483. 1:04:00her in the eyes did you ever tell her
  1484. 1:04:03that you loved her yeah cuz I knew I
  1485. 1:04:06would never see her again
  1486. 1:04:15sir I saw Robert spahalski on the street
  1487. 1:04:19many times when I was a uniform officer
  1488. 1:04:21and would roll my window down and say
  1489. 1:04:24than to him not necess very
  1490. 1:04:26pleasant if Bowski is a natural-born
  1491. 1:04:29killer as he claims could he really
  1492. 1:04:31resist the urge to kill for 14 years
  1493. 1:04:35between 1991 and 2005 there appears to
  1494. 1:04:38have been a 14-year Gap in which you
  1495. 1:04:40didn't kill anybody which seems unusual
  1496. 1:04:45given that you
  1497. 1:04:46killed so soon after a previous death
  1498. 1:04:50before why was that well I think in part
  1499. 1:04:53is he had a good girlfriend uh that I
  1500. 1:04:56felt responsible for Christine Gonzalez
  1501. 1:04:58yes uh I how did you meet her um I I was
  1502. 1:05:02uh at that time I was mansion in a bunch
  1503. 1:05:04of apartments for a realtor and she was
  1504. 1:05:08I rented her apartment and uh nice one
  1505. 1:05:10in the back what a PanAm view of the
  1506. 1:05:12gorge and that's how I met her and were
  1507. 1:05:15you in love with
  1508. 1:05:17her um I loved her but I I've never been
  1509. 1:05:21romantically in love with any woman
  1510. 1:05:22which I regret I mean I had feelings for
  1511. 1:05:24but not uh not deep like the kind of
  1512. 1:05:27relationship I we really like did you
  1513. 1:05:29ever tell her that you loved her yeah
  1514. 1:05:32and she did you yes Christine and her
  1515. 1:05:36kids uh they they're very fond memories
  1516. 1:05:39of him apparently when he was not being
  1517. 1:05:42a psycho
  1518. 1:05:44killer she had three young grandchildren
  1519. 1:05:47yes she did and you became quite close
  1520. 1:05:49to them yeah absolutely in fact they
  1521. 1:05:50knew you as Uncle boo boo yeah they were
  1522. 1:05:53my social anchors and that's I think
  1523. 1:05:55kept me from um going out there and
  1524. 1:05:58hurting other people yeah were you
  1525. 1:06:00capable of genuine emotion towards kid
  1526. 1:06:02absolutely I T them kids fishing uh
  1527. 1:06:05blowing up propane tanks uh riding bikes
  1528. 1:06:09I was a good Mentor toward those
  1529. 1:06:13kids yeah he's definitely creepy you
  1530. 1:06:16know he's six he's like what 64 or
  1531. 1:06:18something like
  1532. 1:06:20that but I never felt that you know he
  1533. 1:06:24would try to harm any any of us for any
  1534. 1:06:27reason do you miss that world that you
  1535. 1:06:30had in those years yes absolutely you
  1536. 1:06:33know you had a loving relationship with
  1537. 1:06:35a woman that do I miss that yeah clearly
  1538. 1:06:37you cared about I uh I I grew up to be
  1539. 1:06:39My Own Worst Enemy I flaunted my my life
  1540. 1:06:42took life for granted why I did that I
  1541. 1:06:45don't know um spah House's life with
  1542. 1:06:48Christine Gonzalez he says stopped him
  1543. 1:06:50from killing but on the night of
  1544. 1:06:52November the 4th 2005 that repulsion to
  1545. 1:06:56murder returned you then killed Vivian
  1546. 1:06:59irari irari who was a close friend very
  1547. 1:07:02good friend of your your love Christine
  1548. 1:07:06Gonzalez absolutely um you described her
  1549. 1:07:08as being like a sister to you absolutely
  1550. 1:07:11did you have any previous no ill will
  1551. 1:07:13towards no I love that lady to death I
  1552. 1:07:16would never hurt that lady but I still
  1553. 1:07:17ended up killing
  1554. 1:07:19her the night before he turned himself
  1555. 1:07:23in I was at his door knocking on his
  1556. 1:07:25door
  1557. 1:07:26asking them where's my mother no one's
  1558. 1:07:29talked to her all weekend where is she
  1559. 1:07:33and he said I haven't seen her since
  1560. 1:07:36Friday I remember Robert saying they
  1561. 1:07:39were smoking crack and that at some
  1562. 1:07:41point he looked at viven and she was no
  1563. 1:07:44longer his friend
  1564. 1:07:46Vivien he said that he had smoked much
  1565. 1:07:49crack that her face changed and she
  1566. 1:07:51looked like a
  1567. 1:07:53demon what I experienced with when I
  1568. 1:07:55killed Vivian irari is a it's like time
  1569. 1:07:58suspended itself into slow motion and
  1570. 1:08:02you it wasn't in a positive way it's
  1571. 1:08:04like the universe was breaking up or
  1572. 1:08:08something it was weird it was very
  1573. 1:08:15[Applause]
  1574. 1:08:20soar initially he he bludgeons Vivian
  1575. 1:08:24and then to complete the ACT he
  1576. 1:08:27strangles her and he actually put um a
  1577. 1:08:29ligature around her neck and then he
  1578. 1:08:30used a garat which tightens it down and
  1579. 1:08:33that was still on her body when I
  1580. 1:08:35located her in the
  1581. 1:08:36basement had I ever uh had a case like
  1582. 1:08:40that never before and never
  1583. 1:08:43since once you realized You' killed her
  1584. 1:08:46this person that you loved like a sister
  1585. 1:08:49did you have any feeling afterwards no
  1586. 1:08:52with mental illness that's just
  1587. 1:08:54collateral damage Catal damage it's
  1588. 1:08:57chilling I know but when she came to my
  1589. 1:08:59house that day I wasn't thinking about
  1590. 1:09:00killing her but she still ended up dead
  1591. 1:09:03because I developed a compulsive
  1592. 1:09:04homicidal psychosis what triggered me to
  1593. 1:09:07kill her I have no idea it's a mental
  1594. 1:09:10illness our argument was yeah there was
  1595. 1:09:13the devil the devil was was that little
  1596. 1:09:15white rock that that he smokes up every
  1597. 1:09:18hour on the hour when we asked the
  1598. 1:09:21question are the drugs what made Robert
  1599. 1:09:23spahalski commit these murders the
  1600. 1:09:25bottom line is the drugs are a perfect
  1601. 1:09:27excuse especially with his mental
  1602. 1:09:29illness for that impulsivity to reign
  1603. 1:09:32supreme when Christine realized you
  1604. 1:09:35confessed to killing her best friend how
  1605. 1:09:36did she react I have no idea I never
  1606. 1:09:38seen her from the day I turned myself
  1607. 1:09:40and I walk you never saw her again no
  1608. 1:09:42before I turned myself in I walked her
  1609. 1:09:44to work I wrapped my arms around her and
  1610. 1:09:46looked her in the eyes and says honey I
  1611. 1:09:49love you no matter what happens I love
  1612. 1:09:51you she looked at me in a quizzical way
  1613. 1:09:53and I just walked away from her I looked
  1614. 1:09:56at her one last time and never seen her
  1615. 1:09:58against her cuz I didn't want Christine
  1616. 1:09:59to see your best friend being carried
  1617. 1:10:01out of that house which is my primary
  1618. 1:10:04concern this is why basically I turned
  1619. 1:10:06myself in when he kisses Christina on
  1620. 1:10:10the cheek and says I love you he is
  1621. 1:10:13emulating normaly not to say he really
  1622. 1:10:15is ethical or he feels remorse or regret
  1623. 1:10:18but he feels like this is
  1624. 1:10:20something that a good person would do
  1625. 1:10:23and he owes it to Christine because she
  1626. 1:10:24has believed in him like nobody else for
  1627. 1:10:2714 years um I I painted myself into a
  1628. 1:10:30corner when I killed somebody in my own
  1629. 1:10:32house could I get rid of Vivian IR AR's
  1630. 1:10:34DNA her blood all over the place no so I
  1631. 1:10:37turned myself in shut myself down before
  1632. 1:10:39I did something
  1633. 1:10:40stupid on that day spahalski confessed
  1634. 1:10:43to not one but four murders including
  1635. 1:10:46Adrien burer Charles Grande and his
  1636. 1:10:48neighbor Marine
  1637. 1:10:50Armstrong but now he's changing his
  1638. 1:10:53story I just thought that Marine
  1639. 1:10:55Armstrong even a death she was a very
  1640. 1:10:57beautiful loal woman I did not kill
  1641. 1:11:00morine Armstrong sir I did
  1642. 1:11:07not ever since last November when Robert
  1643. 1:11:09spahalski walked into Rochester Police
  1644. 1:11:11Headquarters and confessed to killing
  1645. 1:11:13four people we've heard all about him
  1646. 1:11:15including his description by some media
  1647. 1:11:17as a serial
  1648. 1:11:19killer he certainly did not want that uh
  1649. 1:11:23the stigma of being labeled the serial
  1650. 1:11:25kill
  1651. 1:11:26that's not the company he wanted to keep
  1652. 1:11:28krie Patterson's niece Lorraine
  1653. 1:11:30Armstrong was spolsky's first victim do
  1654. 1:11:32you think there's anything inside that
  1655. 1:11:34man a soul a heart anything no there's
  1656. 1:11:36nothing inside of him whether spahalski
  1657. 1:11:39likes it or Not by killing three or more
  1658. 1:11:41people on separate occasions he is by
  1659. 1:11:44the FBI's definition a serial
  1660. 1:11:48killer it's been over a decade since
  1661. 1:11:50bajowski confessed to those four murders
  1662. 1:11:53including his neighbor Marine armr
  1663. 1:11:55strong but now he's telling me it was
  1664. 1:11:57all lies did I know her did she live
  1665. 1:12:00across the street from me yes did I kill
  1666. 1:12:03her no I was never in her dwelling but
  1667. 1:12:05why would you have admitted when you
  1668. 1:12:07made your confessions well they walked
  1669. 1:12:09me those detectives walked me into that
  1670. 1:12:13one Marine Armstrong was a uh uh single
  1671. 1:12:17female uh
  1672. 1:12:19African-American she was involved in uh
  1673. 1:12:22prostitution and
  1674. 1:12:24narcotics Robert spahalski at the time
  1675. 1:12:26lived uh right across the street in a
  1676. 1:12:28large apartment building um it was uh
  1677. 1:12:31New Year's Eve and he said he went over
  1678. 1:12:34there to use drugs with her and um I
  1679. 1:12:37have sex with
  1680. 1:12:38her he caught her taking money from him
  1681. 1:12:43and he became violent they were already
  1682. 1:12:45high and uh he strangled
  1683. 1:12:49her I just took the bullet for her death
  1684. 1:12:52so that her mother after 15 years of of
  1685. 1:12:55not having any closure I gave her
  1686. 1:12:57spiritual closure and social closure
  1687. 1:12:59saying yes I killed your daughter but I
  1688. 1:13:01didn't trust me but you gave
  1689. 1:13:03details which only the killer would have
  1690. 1:13:05known how can I believe you I don't care
  1691. 1:13:08if you do you don't I'm I'm sure you
  1692. 1:13:10don't I'm just saying how can
  1693. 1:13:15I he mentioned that he had taken a cord
  1694. 1:13:19and wrapped it around her neck I says
  1695. 1:13:22well was there anything on the cord or
  1696. 1:13:24was it just a plane cord he says well it
  1697. 1:13:26was uh it was attached to an
  1698. 1:13:29iron that is certainly something only a
  1699. 1:13:32person responsible for that crime would
  1700. 1:13:34have
  1701. 1:13:36known Roberts spahalski now says that he
  1702. 1:13:40didn't actually kill morine Armstrong I
  1703. 1:13:42think this is because he doesn't want to
  1704. 1:13:45be tagged a serial killer but you can't
  1705. 1:13:49you can't come close to believing
  1706. 1:13:51him when I opened up that that that can
  1707. 1:13:53of worms with Marine armr taking the
  1708. 1:13:55bullet for that I was profiled and I
  1709. 1:13:58made a big mistake I did because the FBI
  1710. 1:14:01profiled me as uh killing uh prostitutes
  1711. 1:14:04like Marine Armstrong I never killed a
  1712. 1:14:06prostitute in my life I was a prostitute
  1713. 1:14:08back in those years as a male escort
  1714. 1:14:11bisexually but anyway yes I am a serial
  1715. 1:14:14killer because I did Kill multiple times
  1716. 1:14:16but I do not enjoy killing people and
  1717. 1:14:18the people I did
  1718. 1:14:20Kill they didn't suffer sir it wasn't
  1719. 1:14:22about torture sex money nothing it was
  1720. 1:14:24just spontaneous you're
  1721. 1:14:27dead how many people are lucky to be
  1722. 1:14:30alive without even realizing it because
  1723. 1:14:33you may have come close to having that
  1724. 1:14:35feeling about them I wasn't out of
  1725. 1:14:37control like that sir you you were
  1726. 1:14:39completely out of control with the
  1727. 1:14:40murders you committed absolutely
  1728. 1:14:42absolutely so my my question really is
  1729. 1:14:44how many other times have you felt like
  1730. 1:14:46that and had a thought about somebody
  1731. 1:14:49and then not executed The Killing I
  1732. 1:14:52don't know I have a lot of blackouts
  1733. 1:14:54because of
  1734. 1:14:55um it it takes us tall ler you must have
  1735. 1:14:59had other homicidal thoughts oh probably
  1736. 1:15:03did amongst many troubling aspects of
  1737. 1:15:06this case one in particular I find hard
  1738. 1:15:08to believe that 14-year Gap M spahalski
  1739. 1:15:12says he resisted that compulsion to kill
  1740. 1:15:15it doesn't seem plausible does it you
  1741. 1:15:17clearly were capable of extreme violence
  1742. 1:15:20taking people's lives and not really
  1743. 1:15:21caring yes it has to be possible that
  1744. 1:15:24you took other lives I just want to ask
  1745. 1:15:27you one more time did you take other
  1746. 1:15:29lives we don't know about absolutely
  1747. 1:15:32not and if you had you would tell me yes
  1748. 1:15:35sir there's one there's one picture I
  1749. 1:15:37just want to show
  1750. 1:15:38[Music]
  1751. 1:15:45you my
  1752. 1:15:47mother
  1753. 1:15:49was completely
  1754. 1:15:52heartbroken when Chuck died
  1755. 1:15:55I don't know if she want to live
  1756. 1:15:57anymore I seek
  1757. 1:16:00Comfort because of
  1758. 1:16:03uh like how good you felt with your mom
  1759. 1:16:07you only get
  1760. 1:16:10one so yeah oh see
  1761. 1:16:13Comfort he doesn't deserve to live I
  1762. 1:16:16would
  1763. 1:16:18say no I don't I don't think I'd be
  1764. 1:16:21happy when he dies cuz it's just a sad
  1765. 1:16:27person do you get any visitors here I
  1766. 1:16:30got one good friend that I knew up back
  1767. 1:16:32in the day from 50 something years ago
  1768. 1:16:35she's come into my life and uh she helps
  1769. 1:16:38me with money packages uh on
  1770. 1:16:40conversation why because she knows
  1771. 1:16:43what's in my heart she's know she knows
  1772. 1:16:45that whatever I did it was because the
  1773. 1:16:48drugs are something she believes that
  1774. 1:16:51underneath all this absolutely sir
  1775. 1:16:52there's a good heart She Believes In Me
  1776. 1:16:54absolutely and do you believe there's a
  1777. 1:16:56good heart underneath it absolutely but
  1778. 1:16:58if you had a good heart Robert you would
  1779. 1:17:00be capable of looking back on the
  1780. 1:17:03terrible crimes you've committed right
  1781. 1:17:05and expressing genuine remorse and guilt
  1782. 1:17:08and you'd apologize how many times can
  1783. 1:17:10you kick yourself and ask doing that in
  1784. 1:17:12your life peers how many times do I have
  1785. 1:17:15to do that for the rest of
  1786. 1:17:17Eternity in our minds there's no doubt
  1787. 1:17:20that he has committed more murders
  1788. 1:17:22specifically we're very convinced that
  1789. 1:17:24he murdered Hortense
  1790. 1:17:26greatart as we see in the police world I
  1791. 1:17:29liked him for that case a
  1792. 1:17:31lot this is uh Hortense great heart I
  1793. 1:17:35know you know who she is you remember
  1794. 1:17:37her yes she was a downstairs neighbor of
  1795. 1:17:41yours you knew her
  1796. 1:17:43well not really I've seen her around she
  1797. 1:17:46Liv right downstairs from me in 2003 she
  1798. 1:17:49was strangled yes in the way that you
  1799. 1:17:51strangled the two women that you do
  1800. 1:17:53admit killing
  1801. 1:17:55the thermostat was turned up which is
  1802. 1:17:58what you did I don't believe that it was
  1803. 1:18:00a summer day well the thermostat was
  1804. 1:18:02turned up there were just too many um
  1805. 1:18:06similarities he lived in the same
  1806. 1:18:08building she was strangled and then
  1807. 1:18:11there's uh the
  1808. 1:18:13thermostat and that is why the
  1809. 1:18:15police strongly believe that you must
  1810. 1:18:18have been the one who killed her because
  1811. 1:18:20he strangled her and the thermostat was
  1812. 1:18:22turned off that's what they believe yes
  1813. 1:18:24abolutely did you kill her no I'm just
  1814. 1:18:26being profile that's
  1815. 1:18:30all we promised him that the DA's office
  1816. 1:18:33had no interest in charging him with any
  1817. 1:18:35more crimes that he was locked in and
  1818. 1:18:37locked down forever and uh he wouldn't
  1819. 1:18:40admit to it I don't know why you could
  1820. 1:18:42give Comfort to the family of hent
  1821. 1:18:45greatart yes if you did kill her you
  1822. 1:18:48could give them Comfort now in just
  1823. 1:18:50admitting it yes absolutely can it
  1824. 1:18:52wouldn't change your life but it would
  1825. 1:18:54dramatically
  1826. 1:18:55change theirs it would give them some
  1827. 1:18:57closure absolutely but I can't I can't
  1828. 1:19:00provide that to
  1829. 1:19:01her at
  1830. 1:19:03[Music]
  1831. 1:19:09all Robert spahalski even if he killed
  1832. 1:19:12Hortense greatart is not going to admit
  1833. 1:19:14to it because he gets nothing out of
  1834. 1:19:18it it's also possible that he may have
  1835. 1:19:21selective Amnesia and simply not
  1836. 1:19:24remember it he may get flashes that come
  1837. 1:19:26back and haunt him but he's never really
  1838. 1:19:29sure if they're just kind of LSD
  1839. 1:19:31flashbacks or whether he really did them
  1840. 1:19:33so why confess to something that he's
  1841. 1:19:35not sure about
  1842. 1:19:36himself finally for all the relatives of
  1843. 1:19:40those people you did Kill yes this is a
  1844. 1:19:43chance for you to say something to them
  1845. 1:19:45yes what would you like to say I would
  1846. 1:19:47say that I'm very sorry that I
  1847. 1:19:49devastated their lives that I took their
  1848. 1:19:51loved ones lives I did not mean to
  1849. 1:19:54mental defect they di anybody that I
  1850. 1:19:57killed died relatively quick with no
  1851. 1:20:01pain that's what I want them to know sir
  1852. 1:20:05yes but it wasn't out of disrespect or
  1853. 1:20:08or or or because I got off on killing
  1854. 1:20:10them it wasn't about that thank you for
  1855. 1:20:12your time yes sir thank you I I
  1856. 1:20:15appreciate you you're more dimensional
  1857. 1:20:17than these other interviews I've had
  1858. 1:20:18what sir more dimensional you've gotten
  1859. 1:20:21more deeper you're the kind of person
  1860. 1:20:23I've wanted to talk to about these
  1861. 1:20:24deeper issues am I insane most likely
  1862. 1:20:27but not but not insane where I don't
  1863. 1:20:29know where I am right
  1864. 1:20:31understand it was quite unsettling
  1865. 1:20:33interview particularly when very early
  1866. 1:20:36on he almost put a threat down you press
  1867. 1:20:41the wrong trigger point and I won't be
  1868. 1:20:43responsible for what happens I've never
  1869. 1:20:45had that in any interview I've done with
  1870. 1:20:47any criminal and unlike other serial
  1871. 1:20:49killers I've interviewed who pick on
  1872. 1:20:52random people they don't know and kill
  1873. 1:20:54them
  1874. 1:20:55he only picked on people he cared about
  1875. 1:20:58or even perhaps in his own way loved and
  1876. 1:21:01that's what makes him so unique and so
  1877. 1:21:13dangerous I'm Emily compano as a lawyer
  1878. 1:21:17I've spent many hours with convicted
  1879. 1:21:19felons inside the walls of Prisons those
  1880. 1:21:21are conversations and experiences you
  1881. 1:21:24never forget now Piers Morgan is joining
  1882. 1:21:27me here in a slightly less intense
  1883. 1:21:30environment to take you inside the
  1884. 1:21:32killer
  1885. 1:21:37interview when I was a young attorney
  1886. 1:21:40the first time that I interviewed a
  1887. 1:21:43convicted felon inside prison I'll never
  1888. 1:21:47forget uh when the security guard
  1889. 1:21:49started walking out and shut the door I
  1890. 1:21:51turned to him and I said wait you're
  1891. 1:21:52leaving and he said yeah
  1892. 1:21:55what was it like for you when those
  1893. 1:21:57doors shut look there were some people
  1894. 1:22:00interviewed in this series Robert
  1895. 1:22:01spahalski would be one uh where I was
  1896. 1:22:04warned he'd broken out of handcuffs with
  1897. 1:22:06his own bare hands and I should be
  1898. 1:22:09careful about angering
  1899. 1:22:11him and there's a good reason for that
  1900. 1:22:14because in a Flash he killed people so
  1901. 1:22:18he threatened you and there were no
  1902. 1:22:20handcuffs so what did that feel like it
  1903. 1:22:23felt intimidating
  1904. 1:22:25I mean that was probably the most
  1905. 1:22:26intimidated I've ever felt interviewing
  1906. 1:22:29any inmate ever because I knew he was
  1907. 1:22:32capable of on a whim even to people that
  1908. 1:22:36he was very close to girlfriends friends
  1909. 1:22:39of long standing on a on a whim on the
  1910. 1:22:44toss of a dime he could be explosively
  1911. 1:22:47violent and then he would have no
  1912. 1:22:49remorse he had no remorse this wasn't
  1913. 1:22:52some guy just killing random people in
  1914. 1:22:54the tree which some of these killers are
  1915. 1:22:57this was somebody killing people he knew
  1916. 1:23:00but just because one day he woke up and
  1917. 1:23:01they annoyed him and I said you know
  1918. 1:23:04should I be concerned and it's a really
  1919. 1:23:06quite unsettling exchange when he sort
  1920. 1:23:10of explained that if I was to trigger in
  1921. 1:23:12the wrong way then yeah yeah it was
  1922. 1:23:16pretty clear what he was getting at that
  1923. 1:23:18you know I should be careful and I was
  1924. 1:23:21careful I'm not stupid and he's a very
  1925. 1:23:25big guy capable of explosive extreme
  1926. 1:23:29violence and I'd already been warned by
  1927. 1:23:31one of the prison officers be careful
  1928. 1:23:33with this
  1929. 1:23:34one there's a difference between anxiety
  1930. 1:23:38and fear did you feel fear ever I would
  1931. 1:23:42say more adrenaline I I don't think I
  1932. 1:23:45was fearful I was wary I do remember
  1933. 1:23:48after that a long drive back to New York
  1934. 1:23:50City about 5 hours from upstate and I do
  1935. 1:23:54remember when I got back to my hotel
  1936. 1:23:57feeling really weird and I had a long
  1937. 1:24:00shower and I glugged a little bit too
  1938. 1:24:03much wine a little too quickly and I
  1939. 1:24:06felt very unsettled the most unsettled
  1940. 1:24:08I've ever felt after an interview he
  1941. 1:24:11really did quite disturb me we saw your
  1942. 1:24:14audio guy taking his microphone off what
  1943. 1:24:17did your crew think of this you know we
  1944. 1:24:19all came away afterwards and it was
  1945. 1:24:21during the co pandemic so we wore masks
  1946. 1:24:23we sh added a kind of surreal feel to it
  1947. 1:24:26anyway made it all feel a little bit
  1948. 1:24:28creepier it was quite a small room so it
  1949. 1:24:30got very intense the interview and
  1950. 1:24:33afterwards I remember my my uh top
  1951. 1:24:36producer just said to me wow and I went
  1952. 1:24:40yeah and we walked away and we were like
  1953. 1:24:43that was just incredible but it was
  1954. 1:24:45because the atmosphere was
  1955. 1:24:48charged he was throughout the entire
  1956. 1:24:51exchange for over an hour radiating a a
  1957. 1:24:56menace which I found quite intimidating
  1958. 1:24:59why do you think he cared so much about
  1959. 1:25:01being labeled a serial
  1960. 1:25:03killer he was strangely concerned about
  1961. 1:25:07how he was
  1962. 1:25:10labeled And yet when I really pushed him
  1963. 1:25:12about how did he feel about these
  1964. 1:25:14victims who he had brutally murdered he
  1965. 1:25:17felt nothing did nothing so in a way he
  1966. 1:25:21was a psychopath sociopath I mean
  1967. 1:25:24there's not a lot of difference between
  1968. 1:25:25the two things but it means really
  1969. 1:25:26they're not capable of normal human
  1970. 1:25:28emotion if you or I killed somebody in a
  1971. 1:25:31moment of explosive rage we probably
  1972. 1:25:33regret it for the rest of our lives and
  1973. 1:25:35we would feel awful afterwards he felt
  1974. 1:25:38nothing even in the immediate aftermath
  1975. 1:25:40surrounded by Blood and Mayhem from his
  1976. 1:25:44murderous barbaric Behavior he felt
  1977. 1:25:47nothing never looked back and that that
  1978. 1:25:50to me added to the sense of danger about
  1979. 1:25:53him because somebody that can do that
  1980. 1:25:56and feel nothing about the victims at
  1981. 1:25:59all and has never given them another
  1982. 1:26:01moment's thought till I've asked him
  1983. 1:26:03about them that's scary why then
  1984. 1:26:06suddenly do you think he turned himself
  1985. 1:26:08in I I don't know why he turned himself
  1986. 1:26:10in and he wasn't really particularly
  1987. 1:26:13plausible in his own version of why he'd
  1988. 1:26:15done it other than he just decided to do
  1989. 1:26:18it I mean he was he wasn't a guy that
  1990. 1:26:21thinks like a normal human brain anyway
  1991. 1:26:24so I think almost everything he did was
  1992. 1:26:27kind of
  1993. 1:26:28inexplicable uh
  1994. 1:26:29including randomly turning himself in
  1995. 1:26:33there was no real reason he should have
  1996. 1:26:35done that other than he did it no real
  1997. 1:26:37reason he should have killed the people
  1998. 1:26:39he killed other than he just woke up one
  1999. 1:26:41day and felt like it literally do you
  2000. 1:26:44accept that as certainly not
  2001. 1:26:46justification but as his reason for do
  2002. 1:26:49you feel satisfied as a journalist or as
  2003. 1:26:51a human that while that explanation is
  2004. 1:26:53woefully inadequate and of course never
  2005. 1:26:56acceptable it's his reason and
  2006. 1:26:59therefore Case Closed what I've learned
  2007. 1:27:01about Psychopaths and I think he is one
  2008. 1:27:04is they are medically wired in a way
  2009. 1:27:09chemically wired really in a way that
  2010. 1:27:11doesn't allow them to feel normal human
  2011. 1:27:14emotion and once you know that about
  2012. 1:27:17somebody the rest is more explicable
  2013. 1:27:20because he's one of those guys he is to
  2014. 1:27:23void
  2015. 1:27:24of normal human
  2016. 1:27:30[Music]
  2017. 1:27:53emotion for

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of The Killer Interview S01E12 | Christopher Porco by Eating Show KIMTAN, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 13,775 words across 2,017 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.