The Insulin & Glucose Doctor: This Will Strip Your Fat Faster Than Anything! — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00When we're looking at smoking versus
- 0:01vaping, vaping is probably worse in
- 0:03terms of the damage to the airway and
- 0:05the insulin resistance that comes from
- 0:07it. But this gets worse because we know
- 0:09that insulin resistance is the core for
- 0:10most chronic diseases that are killing
- 0:12us. And there's a handful of other
- 0:13lifestyle habits that's contributing to
- 0:14it.
- 0:15That's horrifying. So tell me
- 0:17everything.
- 0:18Dr. Benjamin Bikman is a leading
- 0:19metabolic scientist. His research
- 0:21focuses on the hidden epidemic of
- 0:22insulin resistance and its devastating
- 0:24consequences.
- 0:25And by regaining control of your insulin
- 0:26levels, he says you can regain control
- 0:28of your life.
- 0:28Insulin is a hormone that affects
- 0:30literally every single cell of the body.
- 0:32But if those cells become insulin
- 0:33resistant, you start to spread the
- 0:35disease. For example, they call
- 0:36Alzheimer's insulin resistance of the
- 0:38brain. And even the most common forms of
- 0:39infertility, erectile dysfunction, and
- 0:41PCOS, insulin resistance is a heavy
- 0:43contributor. Now, 88% of adults in the
- 0:45US have some degree of insulin
- 0:47resistance. And people hear this and
- 0:49think America is just fat and
- 0:50metabolically sick. But we're not
- 0:52actually the worst country when it comes
- 0:53to this. And part of it is because of
- 0:55how different ethnicities store fat. And
- 0:57I'll come back to that. But there's two
- 0:58roads to insulin resistance. So there's
- 1:00the fast lane, and I could make you
- 1:01insulin resistant in 6 hours with either
- 1:03of these common three things. But if I
- 1:05removed them, your resistance would go
- 1:06away just as quickly. Now, the slow
- 1:08lane, that's a problem. And there's
- 1:10certain lifestyle habits and problems
- 1:11with our diet that are massively
- 1:13contributing to slow insulin resistance.
- 1:15Now, thankfully, this can be resolved
- 1:16through four pillars, which are very
- 1:18simple.
- 1:18We'll get into that. But why don't we
- 1:20just cycle this off and just take his
- 1:21Ozempic?
- 1:22Well, because people may not know about
- 1:23the negative side effects. For example,
- 1:2540% of the weight that people are losing
- 1:27on these drugs is coming from
- 1:29Highly
- 1:32I have been forced into a bet with my
- 1:34team. We're about to hit 10 million
- 1:36subscribers on YouTube, which is our
- 1:37biggest milestone ever, thanks to all of
- 1:39you. And we want to have a massive party
- 1:41for the people that have worked on this
- 1:42show for years behind the scenes. So,
- 1:44they said to me, "Steve, for every new
- 1:46subscriber we get in the next 30 days,
- 1:48can $1 be given to our celebration fund
- 1:52for the entire team?" And I've agreed to
- 1:54the bet. So, if you want to say thank
- 1:56you to the team behind the scenes at
- 1:57Diabetes Canada, all you've got to do is
- 1:59hit the subscribe button. So, actually,
- 2:01this is the first time I'm going to tell
- 2:02you not to subscribe because it might
- 2:05end up costing me AN AWFUL
- 2:19BENJAMIN,
- 2:22WHAT IS THE MISSION THAT YOU'RE ON?
- 2:24My mission is to help people appreciate
- 2:28that much of chronic disease
- 2:30we look at them as these siloed
- 2:32individual distinct disorders with
- 2:34totally distinct origins, and yet much
- 2:37of them
- 2:38uh share a common core. It's as if
- 2:41they're branches growing from the same
- 2:42tree. And the conventional clinical care
- 2:46will look at these branches and give
- 2:48someone a prescription for a medication,
- 2:50which is only going to prune the branch
- 2:52back a little bit, never actually
- 2:54solving the problem.
- 2:56It can just grow right back. And so, we
- 2:59can look at most of these chronic
- 3:01diseases that are killing us globally
- 3:04and and then say, "Okay, there are in
- 3:06fact some simple lifestyle changes that
- 3:09can be implemented that will help reduce
- 3:11the risk of not only one or two, but all
- 3:13of the top killers from things like
- 3:15Alzheimer's disease to
- 3:17uh heart disease to type 2 diabetes to
- 3:20uh liver failure or fatty liver disease.
- 3:22All of them share a common metabolic
- 3:25core. That's my mission.
- 3:27And what is that common metabolic core?
- 3:30Yeah, it's a little-known problem called
- 3:31insulin resistance.
- 3:33In fact, when I first started
- 3:37this topic, I stumbled on one paper
- 3:40that documented how when fat tissue is
- 3:43growing, it increases the risk of type 2
- 3:47diabetes. That wasn't a concept in the
- 3:48early 2000s that was is getting a lot of
- 3:50attention.
- 3:51Diabesity, this kind of dual epidemic of
- 3:54wherever we see obesity, we see more
- 3:56type 2 diabetes. And this manuscript
- 3:58outlined
- 4:00something that was to me a revelation at
- 4:01the time. It was so fascinating where
- 4:04when fat tissue is growing, it starts
- 4:06releasing pro-inflammatory proteins.
- 4:09That inflammation caused a problem
- 4:11called insulin resistance.
- 4:14And then that got me into this realm of
- 4:16understanding that other tissues of the
- 4:19body as they become insulin resistant,
- 4:21then you start to spread the chronic
- 4:23disease.
- 4:24And and essentially
- 4:26coming to the conclusion that something
- 4:29like hypertension, high blood pressure,
- 4:31which is the most common cardiovascular
- 4:33problem and the main contributor to
- 4:35heart disease.
- 4:36Well, insulin resistance is the main
- 4:38cause of hypertension. Um they call
- 4:41Alzheimer's disease type 3 diabetes or
- 4:43more accurately um insulin resistance of
- 4:46the brain. Even the most common forms of
- 4:48infertility in men, it's erectile
- 4:50dysfunction. Well, that's because of
- 4:52insulin resistance of the blood vessels.
- 4:54In women, the most common form of
- 4:56infertility is polycystic ovary syndrome
- 4:58or PCOS. That's because of the insulin
- 5:01resistance affecting her ovaries and the
- 5:03ability to produce the proper sex
- 5:04hormones.
- 5:05I guess the really important question
- 5:07here is what is insulin resistance? And
- 5:10can you explain this to me like I'm a
- 5:1210-year-old because
- 5:13for sure. Insulin resistance is it's
- 5:15kind of a it's a disorder that has two
- 5:18parts. It's like a coin with two sides
- 5:20that as much as we think of we we think
- 5:22of one side just because we hear the
- 5:24word insulin resistance, but there's
- 5:26another part to it that I need to that
- 5:28is very important. So,
- 5:30insulin first of all is a hormone that
- 5:32we make from the pancreas, a long kind
- 5:35of gland tucked underneath the stomach.
- 5:37And the pancreas is a very busy organ.
- 5:39It makes a lot of different hormones. It
- 5:42makes hormones that come into the blood.
- 5:43It also makes enzymes that go into the
- 5:45the into the intestines to help digest
- 5:47food. But among the hormones that are
- 5:50being released into the blood is
- 5:52insulin. Now, in the person with type 1
- 5:55diabetes, their immune system has
- 5:57destroyed their beta cells. So, they
- 5:59don't make insulin anymore. That's why
- 6:02for a person with type 1 diabetes,
- 6:03insulin is a life-saving therapy. You're
- 6:06giving them what they're not making
- 6:07anymore. But for everybody else,
- 6:10we have beta cells and they're releasing
- 6:12insulin when they need to.
- 6:14Now, usually the main stimulus
- 6:17the main reason the beta cell is
- 6:19releasing the insulin is because blood
- 6:21glucose levels go up.
- 6:22So, I eat sugar.
- 6:23You eat sugar or not even something as
- 6:25obvious as sugar, but bread or or
- 6:28crackers.
- 6:29White rice.
- 6:29Chips. Oh, yes. Yes. So, basically
- 6:32anything that falls into the family of a
- 6:34carbohydrate. So, if the earth grows it,
- 6:36that's a carbohydrate. Um if it's a
- 6:39plant, it's a carbohydrate. Maybe that's
- 6:40a better way of describing it. And so,
- 6:42it's going to have starches and sugars,
- 6:44which all this kind of falls into this
- 6:46family of carbohydrate. Depending on how
- 6:49much starch or sugars that it has, then
- 6:52that will result in a bigger or a
- 6:54smaller blood glucose or blood sugar
- 6:56response.
- 6:58But then, if blood sugar is too high for
- 7:00too long, that becomes very harmful to
- 7:02the body. So, insulin comes in
- 7:04um and helps lower the blood glucose.
- 7:06And then, having done its job, insulin
- 7:08comes back down.
- 7:09So, insulin comes out like a taxi and
- 7:11transports all the glucose in my blood
- 7:15to various places around the body to
- 7:17store them.
- 7:17Perfect. Perfect. Yeah,
- 7:19Yeah, that's right. It's that's you can
- 7:20say look at it's a shuttle. It's a taxi
- 7:22saying, "Hey, glucose, come on in. I'm
- 7:24dropping you off at the muscle." So,
- 7:26mostly, just as an interesting tangent
- 7:28of insulin before I finish answering
- 7:30insulin resistance,
- 7:32insulin will open the doors for blood
- 7:35sugar to come in and drive the taxi in,
- 7:38mostly at the muscle and the fat.
- 7:41Muscle and fat tissue need insulin to
- 7:43come and bring the sugar in via taxi.
- 7:47However, other tissues and and the brain
- 7:50a little bit as well. Other tissues will
- 7:52still respond to insulin, but they don't
- 7:55need insulin to tell it what to do with
- 7:57the sugar. It just takes it in. But even
- 7:59on those like the liver for example,
- 8:02if the liver sees sugar driving by in a
- 8:04taxi, it just opens the doors and lets
- 8:06it in. It doesn't need insulin to come
- 8:08and tell it to let the sugar in.
- 8:10However, even at the liver and other
- 8:13every other cell has a similar degree of
- 8:15this.
- 8:16The liver doesn't know what to do with
- 8:18it.
- 8:19So, this is back to something I'd
- 8:20mentioned earlier where insulin's
- 8:22thematic effect of the entire body is to
- 8:25tell the body what to do with energy in
- 8:27all of its forms as as these kind of
- 8:30caloric rich molecules. What to do with
- 8:32lactate, what to do with ketones, what
- 8:34to do with fats or glucose, what to do
- 8:36with pro- amino acids. So, insulin will
- 8:39tell the body what to do with all of
- 8:40those things. But again, it's most
- 8:42famous effect is to control blood sugar.
- 8:46And that's not wrong because it's most
- 8:49powerful activator is blood sugar. So,
- 8:52with all of that in mind,
- 8:54insulin resistance is two problems
- 8:56wrapped into one. The one problem is the
- 8:58most obvious one, which is that insulin
- 9:01isn't working as well as it used to. So,
- 9:02back to the analogy of the taxis
- 9:05dropping off sugar,
- 9:06if the muscle tissue has become insulin
- 9:09resistant, insulin is coming and trying
- 9:12to pull the sugar-loaded taxi into the
- 9:14muscle, but the muscle's not listening.
- 9:16So, say that again. So, the
- 9:17Yeah.
- 9:18Insulin's coming past with the glucose
- 9:21inside it.
- 9:22Well, not not technically. Yeah, but
- 9:24just to sort of go with your metaphor.
- 9:26But maybe to use another one, insulin
- 9:28comes and knocks on the doors. It's like
- 9:30the bouncer
- 9:31Yeah.
- 9:31at the door. It's coming and knocking on
- 9:33the door of the muscle saying, "Hey
- 9:35muscle, I've got some sugar that wants
- 9:36to come in.
- 9:37Mhm.
- 9:38And normally the muscle will say, oh
- 9:39yeah, sure, okay, open up the doors and
- 9:41let the sugar come in.
- 9:42When the muscle is insulin resistant,
- 9:44the bouncer is knocking. Maybe there's
- 9:46even I'm almost getting ahead of myself,
- 9:48but
- 9:49one bouncer maybe two or three bouncers
- 9:51pounding on the doors of the muscle
- 9:53cell, but the muscle cell's not
- 9:55listening. It's become deaf.
- 9:57That's the insulin resistance of what we
- 9:59call insulin resistance, where some of
- 10:01insulin's effects, like helping lower
- 10:04blood sugar, it's not working very well
- 10:06anymore. And the muscle is just an
- 10:08obvious example because there's so much
- 10:10of it. You know, it is the biggest
- 10:12tissue on the average individual.
- 10:14Someone who's very obese perhaps now has
- 10:15more fat tissue, but even people who are
- 10:18overweight, most of us is muscle. So,
- 10:20that's a good it's a good tissue to look
- 10:22at. So, part of insulin resistance is
- 10:26that of all the things insulin's trying
- 10:27to do,
- 10:29including lower blood sugar, it doesn't
- 10:31do it quite as well as it used to. Some
- 10:33of the cells or tissues of the body have
- 10:35become deaf to insulin's demands.
- 10:39Now, however, at the same time that's
- 10:41happening,
- 10:42insulin levels are higher. And that is
- 10:45really important. Um and I'll I'll
- 10:47mention an example in just a moment that
- 10:49highlights the difference between the
- 10:51two, but we have to consider anytime we
- 10:54talk about insulin resistance, we think
- 10:56of two things happening
- 10:57um in concert. One, insulin isn't
- 11:00working quite as well as it used to in
- 11:02various places of the body.
- 11:04At the same time, insulin levels are
- 11:07higher. And that kind of takes us back
- 11:09to the um the muscle cell, where I'd
- 11:12mentioned getting a little ahead of
- 11:13myself, that a bouncer is knocking on
- 11:16the door,
- 11:17and once upon a time the muscle cell
- 11:18would hear that one polite knock from
- 11:20that one bouncer or one molecule of
- 11:23insulin, if you will, and it would open
- 11:25the door and let the glucose or the
- 11:26blood sugar come in. But now the muscle
- 11:28cell
- 11:29um the the the bouncer insulin's
- 11:31knocking on the door, but the muscle
- 11:33doesn't listen. It's resistant.
- 11:35And so, the body has adapted, and it
- 11:38learns, "Okay, well, if one bouncer
- 11:40wasn't enough, let's send an angry mob
- 11:43of bouncers." And then the glucose the
- 11:46muscle will start to open the door. And
- 11:48and and indeed it can. So, those two
- 11:50problems go together. On one hand,
- 11:52insulin isn't working as well as it used
- 11:54to. That's what gives it the name
- 11:55insulin resistance.
- 11:57But there's another part that is equally
- 11:59present, which is that blood insulin
- 12:01levels are higher. Now, there's
- 12:04um earlier at the outset of the
- 12:05conversation, I mentioned that even
- 12:07infertility has an origin has has some
- 12:11degree of um
- 12:13development because of insulin
- 12:14resistance.
- 12:15And it's a perfect example of both of
- 12:18these parts of insulin resistance, where
- 12:20in some instances insulin isn't working
- 12:22very well, always with insulin
- 12:24resistance blood insulin levels are
- 12:26higher. So, for example,
- 12:28erectile dysfunction is the most common
- 12:31form of male infertility. In fact,
- 12:34its connection to insulin resistance is
- 12:36so strong that just a few years ago I I
- 12:39was so struck by a title of a paper that
- 12:40had just been published, which stated
- 12:43something like, "Is erectile dysfunction
- 12:45the earliest manifestation of insulin
- 12:49resistance in otherwise young healthy
- 12:51men?" Now, what is the connection? It's
- 12:53because in a normal erectile function,
- 12:56in order for the man to have normal
- 12:58erectile function, he has to experience
- 13:00a pretty dramatic increase in the size
- 13:03of the blood vessels in his body. The
- 13:05blood vessels expand, that increases
- 13:07blood flow, and then he has normal
- 13:08function.
- 13:10Part of that signal that tells the blood
- 13:12vessels that it's time to expand is
- 13:14actually insulin. And so, this is what I
- 13:17said earlier, where insulin does so many
- 13:19things in the body, and we only think of
- 13:21it as being relevant to glucose, and
- 13:23that's not fair. Insulin does a a of
- 13:25stuff. Again, including telling blood
- 13:28vessels to expand. Now, unfortunately,
- 13:30in the case of this
- 13:32this unfortunate man,
- 13:34his blood vessels become insulin
- 13:36resistant. So, now it's insulin coming
- 13:38and knocking on the doors of the blood
- 13:40vessels saying, "Hey, it's time to
- 13:41expand and increase blood flow."
- 13:44But, the blood vessels don't respond.
- 13:45They don't listen. So, they stay
- 13:47constricted, blood flow stays
- 13:49insufficient, and thus he has erectile
- 13:52dysfunction.
- 13:53Now, I don't want to be insulin
- 13:54resistant.
- 13:55No. No one does. No one does.
- 13:57So, so tell me how it happens.
- 13:59Yeah, right. Yeah, so the origins are so
- 14:01important because it helps us understand
- 14:02why we've gotten into the situation we
- 14:04are, where it's the most common problem
- 14:06worldwide. There are two pathways to
- 14:09insulin resistance. So,
- 14:11two two roads to get to the same
- 14:13destination. Again, the destination
- 14:15being insulin resistance. There's the
- 14:17fast lane, which I call fast insulin
- 14:20resistance, and it actually has three
- 14:21lanes, which I'll describe in a moment.
- 14:24Then, there's the slow insulin
- 14:25resistance, which is a more it takes a
- 14:28little longer to get there, but at the
- 14:30same time it takes a little longer to
- 14:31get away from it. So, I'll start with
- 14:33fast insulin resistance because the slow
- 14:36one ends up getting a little excitingly
- 14:38complicated, but in a cool way.
- 14:41So, with fast insulin resistance, there
- 14:43are three things that I could take you
- 14:45to a clinical lab, and I could make you
- 14:47insulin resistant in 6 hours with either
- 14:50of these three things. But, as quickly
- 14:53as it settles in, if I remove those
- 14:55things, your insulin resistance would go
- 14:58away. So, these are fast causes, and
- 15:00they're fast resolution.
- 15:02They are stress
- 15:05is a is a primary cause of fast insulin
- 15:07resistance.
- 15:09So, too is inflammation.
- 15:12And then lastly, and this is going to
- 15:14sound somewhat paradoxical, too much
- 15:16insulin is also a cause, and I'll end
- 15:19with that one because I think it's the
- 15:20most important. Then transition to slow
- 15:22insulin resistance. So, anytime the body
- 15:25is experiencing too much stress, it will
- 15:27very quickly become insulin resistant.
- 15:29Now, as a professor who teaches
- 15:31endocrinology, no surprise, I define
- 15:35stress in the context of hormones. And
- 15:38there are two primary stress hormones,
- 15:39cortisol and what we call in the US
- 15:42epinephrine or in the UK adrenaline.
- 15:45Those are the two stress hormones. Now,
- 15:47those hormones are very distinct. They
- 15:50have almost nothing in common. But like
- 15:52when you are feeling a little stressed,
- 15:55it's both of those, especially
- 15:56adrenaline {slash} epinephrine, that are
- 15:58making you feel a little jittery. It's
- 16:00making your heart beat a little faster.
- 16:02You're a little more alert. Um that all
- 16:05starts to play into a stress response.
- 16:08But what those two hormones have in
- 16:10common
- 16:11is that they both want blood glucose
- 16:13levels to climb.
- 16:14It's kind of their way of saying, "Hey,
- 16:16we don't really know what's going on
- 16:18right now, but we want to be ready to
- 16:19run away." Or that's the fight or flight
- 16:21kind of aspect to stress. And so they
- 16:24want to push blood glucose levels up,
- 16:26and they do very well.
- 16:27That, of course, puts them at odds with
- 16:29the hormone insulin.
- 16:31Cuz these two, epinephrine or adrenaline
- 16:33and cortisol, the two stress hormones,
- 16:35they're pushing glucose up, insulin
- 16:38wants to push it down. So, the more of
- 16:40the body is has those stress hormones
- 16:43elevated because of, say, sleep
- 16:45deprivation, that's a very effective way
- 16:47to increase cortisol, or they are taking
- 16:50too much drinking too much caffeine,
- 16:53that is a way to increase epinephrine
- 16:55quite strongly. If both of those signals
- 16:57are too incessant, or the you know, they
- 17:00they continue to be present and climb,
- 17:02then insulin has to work harder and
- 17:04harder. And then we have insulin
- 17:06resistance. So, stress is a cause of
- 17:09insulin resistance. But then next is
- 17:11inflammation.
- 17:13You you know, you you and I were
- 17:14commenting about earlier about how,
- 17:17"Boy, there's a cold going around.
- 17:18People it's flu season. Even then, if a
- 17:21person were wearing a continuous glucose
- 17:23monitor on the back of their arm,
- 17:25measuring their glucose levels, they
- 17:27would see their glucose levels are much
- 17:29much higher like significantly higher
- 17:32during the time that they're struggling
- 17:34with this infection. That is a
- 17:36reflection of insulin resistance.
- 17:38Insulin's having a harder time keeping
- 17:40the blood glucose levels in check.
- 17:43Anytime inflammation is up, insulin
- 17:45resistance will be up as well. Even in
- 17:48things like autoimmune diseases, there
- 17:50are reports in humans that document the
- 17:52degree to which someone has say active
- 17:55rheumatoid arthritis. Their their joints
- 17:57are achy and because of of an autoimmune
- 18:00attacking of the joints,
- 18:02they will note on some days, like every
- 18:05autoimmune disease, there is an ebb and
- 18:07a flow. Some days it's good, some days
- 18:10it's bad. And on the bad days, if you
- 18:13measure their insulin resistance, it is
- 18:15absolutely locked with the degree to
- 18:18which their immune system is turned on
- 18:20or off or higher or lower. So,
- 18:22inflammation is another cause. And then
- 18:24the last one of the fast lane of insulin
- 18:26resistance is too much insulin itself.
- 18:29Now, the astute listener will realize
- 18:32the kind of circular thing I've just
- 18:34presented by invoking high insulin as a
- 18:36cause of insulin resistance because they
- 18:38will also think, "But wait a minute,
- 18:40Ben. You just said that high insulin is
- 18:42also a consequence of insulin
- 18:44resistance." That, you know, back to the
- 18:46bouncer knocking on the the the door of
- 18:48the muscle cell, if one bouncer wasn't
- 18:51enough or one molecule of insulin wasn't
- 18:53enough, the body will say, "Okay, well,
- 18:55let's send 10 molecules of insulin."
- 18:58So, high insulin is both a consequence
- 19:01of insulin resistance, but it's also a
- 19:03cause. And this is reflective of a
- 19:07fundamental principle in all of biology
- 19:11that if there is too much of a stimulus,
- 19:14a cell, if it's capable, will try to
- 19:17become resistant to that stimulus. This
- 19:20would be like a funny analogy of in in
- 19:23in my in the Bickman home, my darling
- 19:25wife is home with the children. That is
- 19:28what she wants to do. She She is
- 19:30full-time mom. When I'm home, and I try
- 19:33to be home as much as I can, it's funny
- 19:35for me to note the difference in how
- 19:36quickly we each respond to our children.
- 19:38I will hear my child saying, "Mom. Mom.
- 19:42Mom."
- 19:43And she's not responding. Mom has heard
- 19:46this for so much that she's become kind
- 19:48of selectively deaf to when my children
- 19:51are demanding her attention. I'm not as
- 19:53around my children quite as much cuz I'm
- 19:55working during the day. And so when I
- 19:57hear that, it's a very fresh signal to
- 20:00me. I've not heard it so much that I've
- 20:01become deaf to it. And so I will respond
- 20:05even though I'm in the other room
- 20:06because I'm so much more sensitive to
- 20:09the clamoring for attention.
- 20:11This is like the body in response to
- 20:13insulin. If there is always insulin,
- 20:16it's always going up, always going up,
- 20:19the body will start to say the muscle
- 20:20cell will start to say, "Boy, insulin,
- 20:22you are knocking on my door all the
- 20:24time. This is getting old. I'm not
- 20:26responding anymore. I'm not going to
- 20:28listen as much as I was before." So in
- 20:30that sense,
- 20:32insulin, too much insulin becomes a
- 20:34cause of insulin resistance. And back to
- 20:36what I said earlier, I could take you
- 20:37into the lab, start infusing you with
- 20:40just a little drip of insulin to
- 20:41increase your insulin, and over just a
- 20:43few hours, you would become demonstrably
- 20:46less sensitive to it than you were
- 20:49before we started. But again, as I would
- 20:51take that away, give your body a few
- 20:53hours, and it's back to normal. In every
- 20:55one of those instances, it's a fast
- 20:57onset, and it's also a fast solution if
- 21:00we can take it away.
- 21:01If we can take it away, but if we can't
- 21:02take it away, does it become sort of
- 21:04chronic?
- 21:05Yes, so that especially all of these can
- 21:07contribute to a more lingering insulin
- 21:10resistance, but especially insulin.
- 21:12Where I focus on that one the most
- 21:14because of not only its relevance to the
- 21:16slow lane, but also just how present it
- 21:20is where 70% of all calories globally
- 21:24are carbohydrates. And now, perhaps with
- 21:27the best of intentions, our experts are
- 21:29telling us that we should be eating six
- 21:31times a day.
- 21:32And so, we
- 21:34eat we wake up in the morning, insulin
- 21:37has finally been coming down while we've
- 21:38been fasting overnight. Insulin gets to
- 21:41take a little bit of a break. We're
- 21:42fasting. Then we break that fast by
- 21:44eating breakfast. And in the UK as it is
- 21:47in the US, by and large, this is going
- 21:49to be a very starchy sugary breakfast.
- 21:52It's toast with some jam or a cereal or
- 21:55it's bagels.
- 21:57That is going to be that is almost pure
- 21:58glucose. And so, what do we do? We wake
- 22:01up, we eat breakfast, we spike our blood
- 22:03sugar levels, and insulin has to come
- 22:05up.
- 22:06Insulin will take longer to come down
- 22:08than the blood sugar will.
- 22:10It will wait in the blood to make sure
- 22:11that all the blood sugar has gone back
- 22:13to normal. So, depending on how much
- 22:15carbohydrate we ate for breakfast, it
- 22:17could take our insulin levels three or
- 22:19even four hours to come back down to
- 22:21normal. Long before it's had a chance to
- 22:23come back down to normal, we've had a
- 22:25mid-morning snack, of course. We need to
- 22:27go get a sugary coffee and another bagel
- 22:30or something. And so, after just a
- 22:32couple hours, we do it again. And once
- 22:35again, before insulin has had a chance
- 22:37to come back down, we have a starchy
- 22:39carbohydrate-heavy lunch, then an
- 22:41afternoon snack, and then a
- 22:43carbohydrate-heavy dinner, and then of
- 22:44course we have to have an evening snack
- 22:46before we go to bed. So, the average
- 22:48individual is spending every waking
- 22:50moment in a state of elevated insulin.
- 22:53And thus, the signal never really goes
- 22:55away because they they never give
- 22:57themselves a break. But one of the
- 22:59consequences of that I mentioned, which
- 23:01is that it directly causes insulin
- 23:03resistance.
- 23:04But, when insulin is high,
- 23:07it starts to have a signal on the fat
- 23:09cell. And that then brings us to the
- 23:11slow insulin resistance, where you have
- 23:14something happening in the fat tissue
- 23:16that begins to set the stage for insulin
- 23:18resistance in the entire body. And it
- 23:20takes longer to settle in, but it takes
- 23:22also longer to go away. That's why I
- 23:24call this one slow insulin resistance.
- 23:27Now, in the case of insulin,
- 23:29most people So, the the the the key with
- 23:32the
- 23:33Yeah, I'll explain it this way first.
- 23:34So, the most relevant feature with fat
- 23:36tissue contributing to insulin
- 23:38resistance is the size of each fat cell.
- 23:41When we typically think of fat, we would
- 23:43maybe say, "Okay, Steve has um I'll do
- 23:47this in kilos for the UK audience. Steve
- 23:49has 10 kilos of fat on your entire body.
- 23:51That's probably too much for you. Ben
- 23:53has 20 kilos.
- 23:56And yet, it's possible that I'm
- 23:59healthier metabolically than you.
- 24:01Um and that's because it's not the mass
- 24:04of fat that matters most. It's the size
- 24:06of the fat cell that matters. This is
- 24:08why women, despite universally being
- 24:11fatter than her male counterparts, are
- 24:13healthier with regards to insulin
- 24:15resistance and every single metabolic
- 24:17problem. It's because women, as a result
- 24:19of her particular sex hormones, have
- 24:22more fat cells, but they're smaller. So,
- 24:24she has more fat, but smaller fat cells.
- 24:27And small fat cells are healthy, insulin
- 24:31sensitive, anti-inflammatory
- 24:33fat cells.
- 24:35The but the bigger the fat cell gets,
- 24:37the more it initiates a cascade of
- 24:39events or a series of events that
- 24:41creates insulin resistance.
- 24:43Am I right in thinking we have the same
- 24:44amount of fat cells for our whole life,
- 24:46pretty much?
- 24:47That's really, really safe assumption
- 24:49for most people. Yeah, for most people
- 24:51the a fat cell um sometimes students
- 24:53will hear that fat cells are immortal.
- 24:55That is not true.
- 24:57But, they're long-lived. Fat cells will
- 24:59live about 10 years. And so, typically,
- 25:02by the time you if you think of if you
- 25:03look at a newborn, during infancy,
- 25:06childhood, and puberty, the number of
- 25:08fat cells is going up up up up up. Once
- 25:11they finish puberty, so mid to late
- 25:14teens for a young woman, late teens or
- 25:16even early 20s for a young man, usually
- 25:19at that point the number of fat cells
- 25:20they have is going to be very static.
- 25:22This is something people don't really
- 25:23understand, and I actually need to
- 25:24discover it from doing this podcast and
- 25:26speaking to so many experts about this,
- 25:28that
- 25:29we pretty much, especially as an adult,
- 25:30have the same amount of fat cells,
- 25:32really regardless of what we eat.
- 25:34Yes.
- 25:34And it's actually just the fat cells we
- 25:36have shrinking
- 25:38Or growing.
- 25:38or expanding.
- 25:39Exactly. That's exactly right. Now,
- 25:42there are differences across
- 25:43makes liposuction a pretty bad
- 25:46idea.
- 25:47it in fact, it makes things worse.
- 25:49Please, let's make sure we come back to
- 25:50that.
- 25:50Okay, I'll write that on my list.
- 25:51Because it really becomes the person
- 25:54ends up their vanity ends up really
- 25:56ruining their their their future
- 25:59metabolic outcomes.
- 26:00But, there are differences across
- 26:02ethnicity. Like um this is a little
- 26:04oversimplified, but not much. On one
- 26:06end, you'd have Caucasians, kind of
- 26:08northern European Caucasians. On the
- 26:10other wind end, you'd have East Asians,
- 26:12like uh Chinese, Japanese, uh Korean
- 26:15East Asians.
- 26:16And And then, if you look at that same
- 26:18spectrum of people making fat cells
- 26:20through their life,
- 26:22an East Asian will be making fat cells
- 26:24and then stop right about here.
- 26:26About sort of
- 26:27So, very few fat cells, relatively
- 26:29speaking, across all the ethnicities.
- 26:31They have very few fat cells. A
- 26:33Caucasian on the other end of the
- 26:34spectrum,
- 26:36they went way higher.
- 26:38And so, this guy, let's say American Ben
- 26:41versus Chinese Ben, overly simplified,
- 26:43but but here we are. Um
- 26:45so much of fat mass isn't the number of
- 26:49fat cells, even though American Ben has
- 26:50more, it's the size of the fat cell. So,
- 26:53I could be the same percent body fat
- 26:57really as Chinese Ben,
- 26:59um but that would just be because my fat
- 27:01cells were just that much smaller. But
- 27:03this is the problem then.
- 27:05If you have
- 27:07let's say American Ben and Chinese Ben
- 27:09both gained 10 kilos of pure fat over
- 27:12the next 10 years. Very easily done.
- 27:14Most people do that quite often.
- 27:16Caucasian Ben just doesn't look as good
- 27:19in his speedo.
- 27:20Um which is a pasty Caucasian, he's not
- 27:22going to look particularly good in that
- 27:23speedo anyway. But I'm just indulging a
- 27:25little more than I was before, but
- 27:27otherwise I'm healthy. My blood pressure
- 27:28is fine, my blood sugar is fine,
- 27:30everything is normal.
- 27:32Put that same 10 kilos of fat on Chinese
- 27:34Ben,
- 27:36hypertension, type 2 diabetes, fatty
- 27:38liver disease, infertility.
- 27:41Um and that is because Chinese Ben had
- 27:44fewer fat cells to start with. And so
- 27:46those fat cells, as the body was told to
- 27:49store fat, those fat cells were getting
- 27:51much, much bigger, much sooner.
- 27:53And the fat fat cell
- 27:56promotes insulin resistance very, very
- 27:59readily. And so that logically moves
- 28:01into this the question of what makes fat
- 28:03cells grow?
- 28:05And it is
- 28:06two essential variables that we only
- 28:09ever look at calories.
- 28:10And yet, if you take a person with type
- 28:121 diabetes
- 28:14and say, "I want you to eat 10,000
- 28:16calories, but don't give yourself your
- 28:19insulin injection." They cannot gain
- 28:22weight. It is It is literally impossible
- 28:25for the type 1 diabetic to get fat if
- 28:28they are skipping their insulin
- 28:29injections. In fact, this is so known
- 28:32that if you take Let's imagine a young
- 28:33woman who would maybe have more pressure
- 28:35to be thin than her male counterpart,
- 28:38although it's happening more in males,
- 28:39too.
- 28:40Imagine a young girl who gets diagnosed
- 28:42with type 1 diabetes at the age of 13 or
- 28:4414. Very impressionable time. She's very
- 28:47worried about how how she looks and how
- 28:49thin she is.
- 28:51She learns that wait a minute, I can eat
- 28:55whatever I want and all I have to do is
- 28:57not inject my insulin and I'll be as
- 28:59skinny as I want and it works. It works
- 29:01so well that it's actually a formal
- 29:03eating disorder called diabulimia.
- 29:06So this the fact that this exists is
- 29:08absolute proof
- 29:10that the growing and the shrinking of
- 29:11the fat cell is more complicated than
- 29:13just calories being high or low.
- 29:15Because like I had said earlier when I
- 29:17talked about hormones, hormones are a
- 29:19way for the bot for the very tissues of
- 29:21the body to know what it ought to do
- 29:23with energy.
- 29:24And so a fat cell will have energy all
- 29:27around it and if it doesn't have insulin
- 29:29to tell it what to do, it won't do
- 29:31anything with it. And or maybe to make
- 29:33this more direct back home in my lab
- 29:37my students my students are growing fat
- 29:39cells in Petri dishes. These fat cells
- 29:41are swimming in a little sea of
- 29:43calories, lots of glucose, lots of fats
- 29:46and yet they stay really small
- 29:49until we add insulin. The moment we add
- 29:52insulin into that little Petri dish, if
- 29:54we check those cells 4 hours later,
- 29:56they're immediately fatter. If we check
- 29:58them 4 hours later, they're fatter
- 30:00still.
- 30:01Now they know what to do with the energy
- 30:03they have. So with slow insulin
- 30:06resistance
- 30:07it develops when fat cells get really
- 30:09really big. It's like a because they
- 30:12have to tell insulin, insulin you
- 30:13continue you you are telling me to keep
- 30:15growing, I can't keep growing. I'm so
- 30:18big that I'm going to pop. I mean
- 30:20literally the fat cell can get so big
- 30:21that it degrades its membrane. It's like
- 30:23a water balloon that a naughty little
- 30:25boy has overfilled and it's about to
- 30:27burst.
- 30:28The fat cell doesn't want to burst and
- 30:30so it tells insulin, insulin you are
- 30:32trying to make me grow. You're telling
- 30:34me to grow. I can't listen anymore. I'm
- 30:37becoming insulin resistant to stop
- 30:39growing.
- 30:40So insulin makes you fat?
- 30:41Oh very much. Now, if you So, so I A
- 30:44moment ago I said that the big fat cell
- 30:46has two variables. You must have both.
- 30:48You must have both a signal to tell the
- 30:51fat cell to get big, which is insulin.
- 30:53It is the There's no other signal that
- 30:54can do it. You can in a human just
- 30:57simply take away the insulin, like type
- 30:591 diabetes. It doesn't matter any other
- 31:01hormone in the body, it does not matter.
- 31:03They cannot get fat. They could Again,
- 31:06they can eat thousand They could eat
- 31:0910,000 calories of chocolate cake. They
- 31:11cannot get fat. Not only can they not
- 31:13get fat, they can't hold on to their
- 31:14fat. Cuz if there's no insulin to tell
- 31:17the fat cell to hold on to it or get
- 31:18big, it has to shrink. It's breaking
- 31:21down its fat. So, the body goes into
- 31:23such a dramatic fat burning state in the
- 31:26absence of insulin that keeping fat
- 31:28becomes impossible. So, the insulin
- 31:30signal's necessary to tell the fat cell
- 31:32what to do.
- 31:34But, the fat cell will say, "Okay,
- 31:35insulin, you're high. You're telling me
- 31:37to grow, but what am I going to grow
- 31:39with?" That's where the calories come
- 31:41in. Now, the fat cell will say, "Hey,
- 31:44fats and glucose in the blood, insulin
- 31:47has told me to get big, and so I need to
- 31:48pull you in to help me grow. You're
- 31:51going to give me the bulk."
- 31:53And if you have one without the other,
- 31:55it is death.
- 31:56So, if I'm eating 2,000 calories and I
- 31:59have a different insulin sensitivity to
- 32:02you. Say we both eat 2,000 calories
- 32:04and I'm insulin resistant, doesn't that
- 32:07mean that I will
- 32:09You'll store more as fat.
- 32:11Oh, okay.
- 32:11Yeah. Yeah, so so your body now it would
- 32:14partly depend on There are people where
- 32:17you you if your if all of your fat cells
- 32:19had reached its maximum point, then
- 32:20you're done. You're not going to gain
- 32:22more fat. You're just going to become
- 32:23more and more and more insulin
- 32:24resistant.
- 32:25Okay, fine.
- 32:26So, you kind of start limiting yourself.
- 32:27But, there are studies in humans to show
- 32:30that if you give humans isocaloric diet
- 32:33meals, so the exact same number of
- 32:35calories,
- 32:37but they in the same amount of protein,
- 32:39but you differ those meals based on the
- 32:41amount of carbs to the amount of fat.
- 32:44So, let's say two meals, exact same
- 32:46calories, 2,000 calories, or that's in
- 32:48one meal, that's too high. 1,000
- 32:49calories in one meal.
- 32:51One version of this is the conventional
- 32:54way of eating, which is lower fat,
- 32:56higher carb.
- 32:58The other meal, same number of calories,
- 33:01but it's lower carb, higher fat.
- 33:04This lower carb, higher fat version will
- 33:07have a lower insulin response,
- 33:11and they they will store less fat from
- 33:13that meal. And their meta- And someone
- 33:15would say, "Well, where do the calories
- 33:16go?"
- 33:17You can't this it's the laws of
- 33:19thermodynamics. You can't destroy
- 33:21energy. The metabolic rate will go up.
- 33:24So, when insulin is low, if you have
- 33:26someone going a full day eating the same
- 33:28number of calories, but lower carb
- 33:31calories, their metabolic rate will be
- 33:33almost 300 calories higher in that day.
- 33:35And metabolic rate is the
- 33:37the total amount of energy that it just
- 33:39costs you and I to just live.
- 33:40Okay. So,
- 33:41It was going through the day. But that's
- 33:42But that's a significant amount. Like,
- 33:44if you and I were to go exercise and
- 33:45say, "Let's go burn 300 calories." We
- 33:47got to be on the stair stepper for an
- 33:49hour or something. So, it's 300
- 33:51calories, but at the same time,
- 33:53if your insulin is low,
- 33:56you're burning so much fat that you
- 33:57start making ketones. And I I don't
- 33:59intend to get onto that topic quite yet,
- 34:01but suffice it to say,
- 34:03every molecule of a ketone has a has a
- 34:05caloric load roughly similar to glucose.
- 34:08And one of the And And what the body
- 34:11when it starts making a lot of ketones,
- 34:12it starts eliminating the ketones. So,
- 34:15every time someone is breathing out
- 34:17ketones, they're literally breathing out
- 34:19calories.
- 34:20Or they're urinating, and they're
- 34:21urinating out ketones if they have
- 34:23higher ketones in their blood. They're
- 34:25urinating out calories, because ketones
- 34:27have energy.
- 34:29And so, this is the way that if insulin
- 34:31is low, it becomes impossible for the
- 34:33body to hold on to its energy. It is so
- 34:36determined to spend energy that it will
- 34:38both increase metabolic rate, and it
- 34:40will make the energy, the calories be
- 34:42wasted in the breath and in the urine,
- 34:46and and in the form of ketones because
- 34:48ketones have calories. Ketones are
- 34:50energy. Now we're just dumping them out
- 34:52into the universe.
- 34:53It's worth, before we talk about how to
- 34:56keep my
- 34:57insulin levels low so that I can benefit
- 35:00from all the health benefits we've
- 35:01talked about, it's probably also worth
- 35:02just spending a little bit of time
- 35:03trying to understand the evolutionary
- 35:05basis of insulin resistance.
- 35:07There are some theories that are very
- 35:09interesting that attempt to explain why
- 35:12is it that we became so fantastically
- 35:14different from let's say our closest
- 35:16animal relatives, other primates like
- 35:18chimpanzees or or apes.
- 35:20What was the difference that had us
- 35:22become so different than them? One of
- 35:25the leading theories is a is a theory
- 35:27called the expensive tissue hypothesis.
- 35:31And it actually does have something to
- 35:32do with ketones.
- 35:34In the expensive tissue hypothesis, as
- 35:37the theory goes,
- 35:38our earlier ancestors deviated in this
- 35:42kind of animal family line because we
- 35:44started eating more meat. We started
- 35:47eating food that was so nutritious, so
- 35:50nutrient dense, so loaded with good
- 35:52calories and all of the fats and
- 35:54proteins that we need, that it allowed
- 35:57two very distinct changes to occur in us
- 36:00compared to other primates. One, our
- 36:03intestines became significantly shorter.
- 36:06So if you compare the human digestive
- 36:07tract to any other
- 36:09primate animal, if if we are a primate,
- 36:12um then if you look at the intestines,
- 36:14they're fantastically different,
- 36:16particularly the large intestine or the
- 36:18colon. Because
- 36:21our ancestors, as the theory goes, began
- 36:23eating meat, we didn't need the the as
- 36:25much. Um and
- 36:27the colon is a place for food to
- 36:29ferment.
- 36:30And so, if you're eating a lot of plant
- 36:32matter, like other primates do, you need
- 36:34a much, much larger colon.
- 36:37So, we started eating food that was so
- 36:38nutrient-dense, our colon shrunk
- 36:41considerably. We didn't need to waste
- 36:42energy on a big, busy colon. At the same
- 36:46time, as we were eating food that was so
- 36:48nutrient-dense and so loaded with good
- 36:50fat,
- 36:52it allowed us to have more time to be
- 36:54curious and explore. And so, at the same
- 36:56time our intestines were shrinking,
- 36:58because we didn't need them to be so
- 36:59big, our brain was growing.
- 37:02And and it's because it had so much
- 37:03nutrition,
- 37:05including ketones. So, ketones are
- 37:08an extraordinary fuel for the brain. In
- 37:10fact, one of the reasons why a baby that
- 37:13is born premature
- 37:15will be more likely to have learning
- 37:17disorders later in life, is because
- 37:19premature baby didn't have time to get
- 37:21very fat.
- 37:23And fat baby is healthy baby. And fat
- 37:27baby gets into ketosis.
- 37:29Let's say you and I were to to fast
- 37:31straight for 2 days.
- 37:33If you took a 6-month-old baby, that
- 37:35baby would be in a deeper state of
- 37:37ketosis in 2 hours than you and I would
- 37:40be in 2 days.
- 37:41Because the baby is burning so much of
- 37:43its beautiful chubby fat, and the more
- 37:45the body burns fat, the more it makes
- 37:47ketones. And the tissue of the body that
- 37:50appears to benefit the most
- 37:53in response to ketones is the brain. The
- 37:55brain, the moment ketones hit the blood
- 37:58stream, the brain immediately starts
- 37:59taking in ketones for a fuel. Very
- 38:02often, I have students who have had a
- 38:04professor, perhaps with the best of
- 38:06intentions, but ignorant nonetheless,
- 38:08tell the student that the brain the main
- 38:11fuel for the brain is glucose, that the
- 38:13brain prefers glucose. And I show them
- 38:15just one or two papers to prove that
- 38:17wrong immediately.
- 38:19And it is reflected in in in this idea
- 38:22which
- 38:23if if to use some convenient UK units,
- 38:26if blood glucose is 5 millimolar, that's
- 38:28a concentration, a way of measuring an
- 38:30amount of of something.
- 38:32Blood glucose may be 5 millimolar or 80
- 38:34mg per deciliter for the American
- 38:37audience. Um that would be a normal
- 38:39glucose. And if you and I were to fast
- 38:41for 24 or so hours, we may get up to
- 38:43about 1 millimolar of of ketones. And
- 38:47yet even then, the brain has already
- 38:49switched to get the majority of its
- 38:51energy from the ketone.
- 38:54And so don't tell me that in this
- 38:56dynamic the brain prefers this one
- 38:57because this one's five times higher
- 38:59than this one. And even in that
- 39:01scenario, the brain is already getting
- 39:03more than half of its energy from the
- 39:05ketone. So all of this is my long-winded
- 39:08way of saying, when we look at the
- 39:09principles of evolution, one of the
- 39:11leading theories is this idea that we
- 39:13began eating essentially a meat-heavy
- 39:15diet that again is so nutritious that it
- 39:18allowed our brains to grow. Maybe one
- 39:20final point on this, although it is a
- 39:22bit of a barbed comment,
- 39:24people may find this somewhat amusing or
- 39:26disappointing or frustrating, the title
- 39:29of a book just published which is that
- 39:31vegetarians have smaller brains.
- 39:33This is seen in humans that the less a
- 39:36human eats meat,
- 39:39then the smaller the brain becomes. The
- 39:41brain is so dependent on the nutrient
- 39:43density that comes from animal-sourced
- 39:45foods that it will suffer
- 39:47um when it doesn't get them.
- 39:50Interesting. I mean, that's a
- 39:51controversial thing to say.
- 39:52It is, and you can cut it out.
- 39:54But it really is it's a real thing. And
- 39:56why does depression go up so much when
- 39:58people stop eating animal-sourced foods?
- 40:00It's because you are depriving the brain
- 40:02of what it needs.
- 40:03What is it exactly you're depriving the
- 40:05brain of in that situation?
- 40:06Yeah. Yeah. So at least among other
- 40:08things, at least it would be the the
- 40:09essential omega-3 fats.
- 40:12So there are three omega-3s, and you
- 40:13humans can only we can only get one from
- 40:15plants, but it's one that the humans
- 40:17don't use. We need the other two, and
- 40:19they only come from animal source foods.
- 40:21And you could supplement.
- 40:22Absolutely.
- 40:23Right. I mean, that's what I was
- 40:24Yeah, you can, but but that that So, the
- 40:27the solution in that regard is the vegan
- 40:29must be educated enough to know what
- 40:30they're deficient in, and then wealthy
- 40:33enough to afford the supplements to make
- 40:34up for it.
- 40:36So, is that the the only evolutionary
- 40:39sort of hypothesis towards why we
- 40:41develop this insulin resistance?
- 40:43Mm. Oh, yeah. In fact, it's funny that
- 40:45you bring the question up again because
- 40:46I realized I didn't quite answer it that
- 40:48way. So, insulin resistance, why would
- 40:50it exist at all? It would probably be a
- 40:53way for the body to know when it was
- 40:55needed to hold on to energy a little
- 40:57better.
- 40:58So, now Now, I say that now, and and
- 41:01someone would think, well, but you just
- 41:03why would I want to hold on to energy in
- 41:05a way where it's causing hypertension
- 41:07and Alzheimer's disease and increasing
- 41:08the risk of heart disease?
- 41:10Not all versions of insulin resistance
- 41:13are negative. So, there is um there is
- 41:17what all the insulin resistance that you
- 41:19and I have been talking about is
- 41:20pathological insulin resistance, or
- 41:22harmful insulin resistance. Insulin
- 41:25resistance that serves no good purpose,
- 41:27and it's making us sick.
- 41:29However, there is insulin resistance in
- 41:32human development, which is
- 41:34physiological, or helpful. It's supposed
- 41:36to happen. And that is the two P's of
- 41:40physiological insulin resistance,
- 41:41puberty
- 41:43and pregnancy. Because in both of those
- 41:45instances, as we outlined earlier, when
- 41:47the body's insulin resistant, insulin is
- 41:49high.
- 41:50That's not always bad, because insulin
- 41:53wants things to grow.
- 41:55It is like a fertilizer in the body.
- 41:57Now, sometimes it's misplaced, and
- 41:59results in problems, like increasing the
- 42:01risk of cancer, for example.
- 42:03But in other instances, if you have a
- 42:04young child who needs some explosive
- 42:06growth during puberty,
- 42:08well, then that's really helpful.
- 42:10Insulin's telling the body to store more
- 42:12energy, to build up tissues, including
- 42:14muscle and bone, but also including fat.
- 42:17So, in pregnancy, insulin's playing a
- 42:19role in growing the placenta.
- 42:21is.
- 42:21The breasts.
- 42:22Yes, so in the woman, after she's
- 42:24finished puberty, the only other time of
- 42:26growth she'll ever have will be
- 42:27pregnancy. And and so, those are the two
- 42:30instances where the body has become
- 42:31insulin resistant to take advantage of
- 42:34the heightened scenario where it can
- 42:35grow.
- 42:36Because the woman's body needs to more
- 42:38fat.
- 42:38goodness, yes. Yes, so her body not only
- 42:40needs to grow tissue mass, like the
- 42:42uterus has to get much bigger. She has
- 42:44to grow a placenta. She also needs to
- 42:46become a little insulin resistant to
- 42:48give a little more glucose to her baby,
- 42:50because she is after all now living for
- 42:52two people. And so, as she as her body
- 42:55becomes insulin resistant, it actually
- 42:57facilitates the growth of the baby a
- 42:59little more rapidly. But as you noted,
- 43:01it helps her store more fat, and
- 43:03progesterone is another hormone that
- 43:05even accelerates that process.
- 43:08But basically, it's the her way of her
- 43:11body's way of saying,
- 43:12"Hey, I am committing to growing another
- 43:15human, and it's going to be
- 43:17metabolically very demanding, and so I'm
- 43:19going to have as much extra fat or much
- 43:22as much extra energy as I can in order
- 43:24to ensure that if there's any sort of
- 43:27scarcity in food that happens during the
- 43:29course of the pregnancy, I'll have
- 43:31enough energy to get through it all. And
- 43:33then maybe I'll even have enough to
- 43:35continue to feed the baby with lactation
- 43:38after the baby's born."
- 43:39What is gestational diabetes?
- 43:41Yeah, it's a great question. Gestational
- 43:43diabetes is essentially type 2 diabetes
- 43:46of pregnancy. So, it's perfectly timed
- 43:49question because
- 43:51if you look at the average woman um who
- 43:53is very healthy, very insulin sensitive
- 43:55at the beginning of her pregnancy. So,
- 43:57glucose is normal and insulin is normal.
- 44:01Over the course of her pregnancy,
- 44:03she stays normal healthy pregnant woman,
- 44:06which is to say she has physiological
- 44:08insulin resistance. She doesn't get
- 44:10diagnosed with gestational diabetes
- 44:12though, which means her glucose is
- 44:13normal. But to keep her glucose normal
- 44:16because she is insulin resistant, but
- 44:18for a purpose to help her body grow, her
- 44:20insulin levels are high. And then the
- 44:22glucose is still in a normal range. And
- 44:25then in some women, especially if she
- 44:28has a family history of type 2 diabetes,
- 44:30the insulin resistance goes too far.
- 44:33Now, she has high insulin, like all
- 44:35pregnant women do, but she's not able to
- 44:37keep her glucose levels in check.
- 44:40So, if I'm eating loads and loads of
- 44:42sugar throughout pregnancy,
- 44:43That will compound the problem.
- 44:45Absolutely. So, then she will go from
- 44:47the normal insulin resistance of
- 44:48pregnancy into the insulin resistance of
- 44:51diabetes. So, it really is like type 2
- 44:53diabetes, but a microcosm of it, a mini
- 44:56version that was really instigated or
- 44:59initiated because of the pregnancy
- 45:00combined with a bit of a genetic
- 45:02predisposition combined with her eating
- 45:04the worst possible way.
- 45:06Does that then impact the future baby?
- 45:08Oh, for sure it does. Yeah. So, think
- 45:10about it's almost like the baby is
- 45:12develop literally developing in a
- 45:14hyperglycemic hyperinsulinemic
- 45:17environment. So, the baby's get the baby
- 45:19gets hardwired
- 45:21to want to continue to exist in a state
- 45:23of high insulin and high glucose after
- 45:25the baby is born. And so, yes, the
- 45:27offspring of mothers who have
- 45:29gestational diabetes are significantly
- 45:32more likely to gain weight and be
- 45:34chubbier or fatter than their
- 45:36counterparts and to later develop type 2
- 45:38diabetes. Yeah, a resounding yes.
- 45:40I read in your book that these infants
- 45:41have a 40%
- 45:43higher chance to be obese and have
- 45:44metabolic complications in their teenage
- 45:46years and beyond.
- 45:47Yes, I mean a significant thing and I I
- 45:49say that with all of the sympathy I can
- 45:51for the mother who may be struggling
- 45:52with this, but it is certainly a
- 45:54motivation for mom to just be mindful of
- 45:58what you're eating.
- 46:00One of the things that that I saw the
- 46:01other day on social media, which I
- 46:03wanted to ask you about, was this. I've
- 46:05got a picture of it here.
- 46:07Um
- 46:08it was someone online that posted this
- 46:10photo, and they said, well, this graph,
- 46:14and they said, we need to figure out
- 46:15what's going on here. Um this is the
- 46:17graph. I'll put it on screen for anybody
- 46:19that's watching, but also it'll be
- 46:20linked in the comments section below.
- 46:22Um it essentially shows that over the
- 46:25last, let's say, 20 years, there's been
- 46:28a really significant rise in cancer
- 46:31amongst women, but when we look at
- 46:33cancer amongst men, it's pretty flat.
- 46:35Mhm.
- 46:35Um and this is cancer incidence by age
- 46:39and gender up to 49 years old.
- 46:42Mhm.
- 46:42And I was wondering if you had any
- 46:43thoughts on why this is happening.
- 46:45Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, a few thoughts come to
- 46:48mind. Um whenever I see these kinds of
- 46:50reports, I always make sure I look
- 46:52firstly at the What are they actually
- 46:53measuring? So, just to set the stage,
- 46:56this is the number of women who are
- 46:57being diagnosed with cancer, so not
- 46:59dying from cancer, but it's going up.
- 47:01So, one one simple explanation, although
- 47:04perhaps the most disappointing, could be
- 47:06that more women are going in for testing
- 47:09younger, and so we're just seeing kind
- 47:11of an artifact of more women are just
- 47:13going in sooner, and they're detecting a
- 47:15problem that they wouldn't have
- 47:16otherwise detected, you know, for 10 or
- 47:1820 years. And which is a good thing. You
- 47:21want to detect cancer as soon as
- 47:22possible. So, that's the boring answer,
- 47:24that it could be a reflection of just
- 47:25more women going in for ultrasounds or
- 47:28MRIs or mammary scans, whereas men don't
- 47:32ever get tested for anything,
- 47:34which is why we die more from
- 47:35everything, possibly. But to give a more
- 47:38exciting answer, this is very, very
- 47:41likely almost entirely driven by breast
- 47:43cancer. Um breast cancer is the main
- 47:45cancer for women um by far. And so, if I
- 47:49had to guess, I bet almost all of this
- 47:51increase in cancer incidence is because
- 47:53of breast cancer. Why might that be
- 47:55going up? I would suggest there's
- 47:57probably a couple instances. One, um
- 48:00although people might not appreciate
- 48:02this, is that one of the best ways for a
- 48:04woman to reduce her risk of breast
- 48:05cancer is actually having babies. It's
- 48:07very well known,
- 48:09um very well documented, that if a woman
- 48:11um has a fam- it has babies and
- 48:13breastfeeds, her risk of um breast
- 48:15cancer goes down.
- 48:17So, yeah, in fact, it's very meaningful.
- 48:19I actually don't know um the reasons for
- 48:21it. It could be the changes in estrogens
- 48:23during lactation phase.
- 48:25I've just I've just actually done a
- 48:26quick search here to I put a picture of
- 48:29that graph into AI and asked it the same
- 48:31question, and it said pretty much what
- 48:32you said. It said, "There's a rising
- 48:34breast cancer incidence according to
- 48:35Cancer Research UK." The other one that
- 48:37it came up with is obesity trends.
- 48:39Oh, yeah. I promise I was going to talk
- 48:41about that. I wouldn't leave that. Yeah.
- 48:43Sorry for interrupting there.
- 48:44No, no, no problem.
- 48:45Uh and then the other one was delayed
- 48:46childbearing.
- 48:47That's what I'm saying.
- 48:48Which is what you were saying.
- 48:49Yeah, so as child rates as childbirth
- 48:51rates are going down, it does increase
- 48:53the risk of breast cancer. Now, as I I'm
- 48:55a cell biologist, right? I like to
- 48:57understand the direct mechanism. And so,
- 48:59as much as I invoke the perhaps lower
- 49:01rates of childbirth among women, I don't
- 49:03know the mechanism, so I'm sort of loath
- 49:05to describe it. The mechanisms I'm very
- 49:07familiar with are the metabolic,
- 49:09um which is if you take a breast tissue
- 49:13that is tumor tissue and compare it to
- 49:16like if you take a breast tumor and
- 49:18compare it to the normal tissue right
- 49:19next to it, like that it would have
- 49:21shared its origins with, the cancer from
- 49:24the breast will have seven times more
- 49:26insulin receptors than the normal breast
- 49:29tissue. So, the idea of this tracking
- 49:32quite nicely with obesity rates going up
- 49:34over the past 20 years, I wouldn't say
- 49:36that it's the obesity per se, but I
- 49:38would say it's the entire metabolic
- 49:40milieu, which is the insulin resistance,
- 49:43that as much as the high insulin is
- 49:44promoting fat cells getting bigger, that
- 49:47high insulin is also accelerating the
- 49:49growth of the tumor cells. Because
- 49:51again, the main one of the main
- 49:53mutations in breast cancer is a
- 49:55sevenfold so a seven times increase in
- 49:58the number of insulin receptors. And
- 50:00insulin wants to tell things to grow. So
- 50:02it's no surprise that almost every tumor
- 50:04that's ever been measured for having
- 50:06insulin receptors will have a lot more.
- 50:09It's basically telling its neighboring
- 50:11cells, "Insulin's going to come by and
- 50:13it's going to tell us all to grow. I
- 50:15want to grow more than you." And that's
- 50:17what cancer is. Cancer is growth,
- 50:18unregulated growth. Insulin tells things
- 50:21to grow. So the connection between
- 50:23obesity with the rising incidence of
- 50:25breast cancer is very, very likely a
- 50:29consequence of the rising incidence of
- 50:31insulin resistance.
- 50:32As you guys know, Whoop is one of my
- 50:34show sponsors. It's also a company that
- 50:36I have invested in and it's one that you
- 50:38guys ask me about a lot. The biggest
- 50:39question I get asked is why I use Whoop
- 50:41over other wearable technology options.
- 50:44And there is a bunch of reasons, but I
- 50:45think it really comes down to the most
- 50:47overlooked yet crucial feature. It's
- 50:49non-invasive nature. When everything in
- 50:52life seems to be competing for my
- 50:53attention, I turn to Whoop because it
- 50:55doesn't have a screen. And Will Ahmed,
- 50:57the CEO who came on this podcast, told
- 51:00me the reason that there's no screen.
- 51:02Because screens equal distraction. So
- 51:04when I'm in meetings or I'm at the gym,
- 51:06my Whoop doesn't demand my attention.
- 51:08It's there in the background constantly
- 51:10pulling data and insights from my body
- 51:11that are ready for when I need them. If
- 51:14you've been thinking about joining
- 51:15Whoop, you can head to
- 51:16join.whoop.com/ceo
- 51:19and try Whoop for 30 days risk-free and
- 51:22zero commitment. That's
- 51:24join.whoop.com/ceo.
- 51:26Let me know how you get on.
- 51:29You know, one of the big subjects you
- 51:30touched on at the start was the was
- 51:32Alzheimer's and dementia.
- 51:34Yes.
- 51:35And I have heard several people on this
- 51:36podcast tell me that they think of
- 51:38Alzheimer's as type three diabetes.
- 51:44Worldwide, there is a new case of
- 51:46dementia every 3.2 seconds.
- 51:49Um it seems like I don't know if this is
- 51:51true, but is Alzheimer's and dementia on
- 51:52the rise?
- 51:53Oh, yes. Yeah, it is. In fact, it went
- 51:55from not being even on the radar to
- 51:57being a top 10 killer.
- 51:59Um now, it's interesting how people even
- 52:01die from Alzheimer's disease. It's a
- 52:02very kind of vague death.
- 52:05But yeah, Alzheimer's disease is one of
- 52:06the top 10 diseases now. Um certainly in
- 52:08the West.
- 52:10Um and and I would argue it's because it
- 52:11has a metabolic origin. Now, one of the
- 52:13interesting things about Alzheimer's
- 52:15disease is we have spent
- 52:18billions of dollars on Alzheimer's
- 52:20research trying to identify the the
- 52:23plaque. So so just to set the stage here
- 52:26so that people listening can appreciate
- 52:28this this paradigm shift that's occurred
- 52:31in Alzheimer's research. Originally, and
- 52:34even in many people still, people
- 52:36thought that Alzheimer's disease is the
- 52:38result of these plaques accumulating in
- 52:40the brain. These kind of little
- 52:41proteinaceous little
- 52:44thick things that are preventing neurons
- 52:45from sending the signals throughout the
- 52:47brain for the brain to think and and and
- 52:49have normal cognition.
- 52:51And and yet, there are those of us and I
- 52:53am proud to say I have long been one of
- 52:55them
- 52:56who has said that the plaque-based
- 52:57theory doesn't make sense. We have had
- 53:00drugs that have been available for human
- 53:02use for years that have effectively
- 53:05reduced plaques in the brain and yet did
- 53:08nothing to improve cognition. So that is
- 53:10an immediate challenge of the
- 53:12plaque-based theory of Alzheimer's. Even
- 53:14further,
- 53:15even beyond older than that evidence,
- 53:18when you would look
- 53:20postmortem or look at tissue donor,
- 53:22people who passed away, you would look
- 53:24at the brains of people who died with
- 53:26confirmed Alzheimer's disease at the
- 53:28time of death
- 53:29and look at the brain of someone who
- 53:31died without any evidence of any
- 53:33cognitive decline or any compromised
- 53:35thinking whatsoever. And you would be
- 53:37just as likely to find plaques in both
- 53:39brains.
- 53:40So the So whether the brain had
- 53:42Alzheimer's disease not, you would still
- 53:43see plaques in the brain. So the whole
- 53:45idea that plaques mattered has long been
- 53:48controversial. And just to put a fine
- 53:50point on it before transitioning to the
- 53:51metabolic origins,
- 53:53about two or three years ago,
- 53:56they found out that the very first
- 53:59published papers that implicated plaque
- 54:02as a cause of Alzheimer's disease were
- 54:04based on fabricated data.
- 54:06So the scientists who published those
- 54:08first reports that led to the entire
- 54:10theory that Alzheimer's disease is
- 54:12plaque-based
- 54:13were called out as fraudulent. And and
- 54:15indeed, all of it was fabricated. So the
- 54:18entire idea that Alzheimer And and we
- 54:20have spent billions of dollars on
- 54:22studies to try to
- 54:23how determine how do plaques cause cause
- 54:26Alzheimer's disease? Why when we reduce
- 54:29plaques, it doesn't appear to help the
- 54:30disease.
- 54:32Because the plaques had nothing to do
- 54:33with it. That's just something that some
- 54:35brains have. Some brains have more of
- 54:37these little specs than other brains,
- 54:38and they don't contribute to Alzheimer's
- 54:40disease at all.
- 54:41Now, what did
- 54:44can what kept rising to the top, and I
- 54:46would hope now is the dominant theory,
- 54:48is that people with Alzheimer's disease
- 54:50almost always have some detectable
- 54:53instance of insulin resistance, if not
- 54:55full-on diabetic type 2 diabetes. Now, I
- 54:58will say personally, I don't like the
- 55:01term type 3 diabetes because it makes it
- 55:03sound
- 55:04like it's a whole new version of
- 55:06diabetes.
- 55:08To say it more succinctly and
- 55:09accurately, it is simply insulin
- 55:11resistance of the brain. And the brain
- 55:14is a very hungry organ.
- 55:16It is in what I teach as as a tri a
- 55:19trinity of high metabolic rate organs.
- 55:22That there are three organs in the body
- 55:24whose metabolic rate is so high that it
- 55:26just really sets it apart from
- 55:27everything else. And the brain is one of
- 55:29them. The brain has a very high
- 55:31metabolic rate. So this is a very hungry
- 55:34organ that that a lot of energy all the
- 55:36time.
- 55:37But the brain is unique in that it
- 55:39primarily will only use two fuel
- 55:41sources, and I've mentioned them, namely
- 55:42glucose and ketones.
- 55:45But glucose in that section of the brain
- 55:48that gets compromised with Alzheimer's
- 55:50disease, the glucose can't just come
- 55:52straight in. It needs someone to open
- 55:54the door for it, and that is insulin, of
- 55:57course, just like we described with the
- 55:59muscle cell.
- 56:00Where in order for the glucose to go
- 56:02into the muscle, insulin had to come and
- 56:04knock on the door, if you will. And then
- 56:06the muscle, being a polite, responsive
- 56:08host, would open and allow the glucose
- 56:09to come in. The brain is similar.
- 56:12That in that section of the brain, it
- 56:14has doors that need insulin. It's locked
- 56:17until insulin comes and opens them. So,
- 56:19even though glucose levels may be high
- 56:21in the blood,
- 56:22like in type 2 diabetes, you would
- 56:24think, "Well, the brain can just get all
- 56:26the glucose it wants." And yet it cannot
- 56:28because it has insulin regulating the
- 56:31entrance of the glucose. And if the
- 56:33brain is insulin resistant, there's not
- 56:35enough glucose coming in. And thus the
- 56:37brain is forced to rely on the only
- 56:39other fuel that it can rely on, namely
- 56:42ketones.
- 56:43But the same person who's eating all the
- 56:45time to keep their blood glucose high
- 56:47all the time has so much insulin in
- 56:49their blood that they're never making
- 56:51enough ketones to fill the gap. You
- 56:53know,
- 56:54mind the gap, and the brain has an
- 56:56energy gap now. And where where the
- 56:59brain needs, you know, an amount of
- 57:01energy, I'm kind of acting it out for
- 57:03those that are watching, but the brain
- 57:04has a certain energy demand that it
- 57:05needs. And if there's a lot of glucose
- 57:08in a healthy insulin-sensitive person,
- 57:10glucose will fill all of that need. But
- 57:12as the brain becomes progressively
- 57:14insulin-resistant, it cannot get all of
- 57:17its energy from glucose. And thus
- 57:19there's an energetic gap.
- 57:21And in the absence of ketones, there's
- 57:23nothing to fill that gap, and the brain
- 57:25says, "Well, I don't have enough energy
- 57:27to keep functioning as well as I did
- 57:28before, so I have to reduce my function,
- 57:31which manifests as a reduction in the
- 57:33ability to think and process. In other
- 57:35words, cognition goes down. But, what's
- 57:38so interesting
- 57:39is I just got finished describing a
- 57:41scenario that scientists refer to as
- 57:43brain glucose hypometabolism,
- 57:47or a reduction in the amount of glucose
- 57:50the brain is using. There are scientists
- 57:52that measured this. We don't in my lab
- 57:54because we don't do these kinds of
- 57:55techniques, but you can actually infuse
- 57:58people with a glucose that you can take
- 57:59pictures of and see how much the brain
- 58:02is taking it in and metabolizing it. In
- 58:04Alzheimer's disease, the brain is not
- 58:06getting as much glucose, so they call
- 58:08that a hypo, or a reduction in
- 58:10metabolism of glucose.
- 58:12And as much as you and I are describing
- 58:14that scenario as relevant for
- 58:15Alzheimer's disease, you can essentially
- 58:17open up the book of neurological
- 58:19disorders and see the same thing.
- 58:21Depression
- 58:22has a brain glucose hypometabolism to
- 58:25it. Migraines have a brain glucose
- 58:27hypometabolism.
- 58:29Epilepsy um and Parkinson's so all of
- 58:32these disorders of the brain, of the
- 58:34central nervous system, the one thing
- 58:36they all have in common is the brain
- 58:38isn't getting enough energy from
- 58:40glucose.
- 58:42And another way of saying that is the
- 58:43one thing all of those seemingly
- 58:45unrelated brain problems have in common
- 58:47is that they all have some degree of
- 58:48insulin resistance. But, then it's no
- 58:50surprise that they all benefit
- 58:53when ketones can swoop in to save the
- 58:55day.
- 58:56Um but that only can happen if the
- 58:59person is giving their body a break from
- 59:01the insulin long enough to actually
- 59:03start making ketones.
- 59:06Really, really interesting on this point
- 59:07about Alzheimer's because I don't think
- 59:09people have spent enough time talking
- 59:10about the link between insulin
- 59:12resistance and Alzheimer's. Um
- 59:15and
- 59:16one of the things I was I was looking at
- 59:18there was how many people with
- 59:20Alzheimer's have meet the criteria for
- 59:22insulin resistance.
- 59:24And some studies have it at 40%. There's
- 59:26a study I found here that has it at 70
- 59:28to 80%.
- 59:30Um which I wanted to cite. Um
- 59:33Exact percentages vary, but one example
- 59:35is a study in the Journal of Neurology
- 59:38in 2011 that found insulin resistance at
- 59:40approximately 40% of individuals with
- 59:42Alzheimer's.
- 59:43Um but another study
- 59:44uh in Alzheimer's patients sometimes
- 59:46found it to be as high as 70 or 80%. For
- 59:48instance, research by Dr. Suzanne de la
- 59:51Monte
- 59:52Mhm.
- 59:53at Brown University has drawn attention
- 59:54to the concept of type 3 diabetes.
- 59:58Yeah, again, I don't love the term, but
- 59:59I appreciate the use of it, which is it
- 1:00:02does suggest a metabolic origin. But
- 1:00:04even you look at those ranges, Stephen,
- 1:00:05you'd say, "Well, one was 40, one was
- 1:00:0780. Boy, what a difference." I suspect a
- 1:00:09lot of that is just how did they measure
- 1:00:11insulin resistance? If they were looking
- 1:00:13at the glucose like so many do, you're
- 1:00:15just going to miss a lot of people.
- 1:00:17Yeah, it's quite hard to
- 1:00:19I think there's different criteria,
- 1:00:20right, for how one defines someone as
- 1:00:22insulin resistant.
- 1:00:23Well, there Yeah, and that's just that's
- 1:00:24right. That's because there's not enough
- 1:00:26training, which is at the beginning of
- 1:00:27the conversation you asked my mission.
- 1:00:29One of my missions is to help people
- 1:00:31learn what to look for.
- 1:00:32What do they need to be looking for?
- 1:00:34Yeah, they need to be looking at
- 1:00:35insulin. So
- 1:00:36Is that easy to measure?
- 1:00:38Well, it is technically easy to measure.
- 1:00:40It's just that we have we don't have
- 1:00:41enough systems in place to allow to
- 1:00:43enable it. Like again,
- 1:00:45if if someone listening in the UK were
- 1:00:48to go to their GP and say, "Can you
- 1:00:50measure my insulin?"
- 1:00:51In many instances, they literally can't
- 1:00:53get it done. The system just isn't in
- 1:00:55place to take it to the lab and and
- 1:00:57measure it. Now, some do. I know some
- 1:00:59physicians in the UK who do so, and they
- 1:01:01have developed their own way of getting
- 1:01:03it done, and they're incredible
- 1:01:05advocates of this whole idea. But it is
- 1:01:07harder in the UK and Canada um where the
- 1:01:11system is such that they have said, out
- 1:01:13of ignorance, but perhaps well-placed or
- 1:01:15or well-intentioned, they will say,
- 1:01:17"Well, insulin isn't a marker that
- 1:01:19matters."
- 1:01:20It is. And if you're measuring insulin
- 1:01:22resistance, just to put things back to
- 1:01:23where we had talked about it earlier,
- 1:01:26many people with insulin resistance have
- 1:01:27normal blood glucose levels. It's the
- 1:01:30insulin that's high. And so, I would say
- 1:01:32if a person can get their insulin
- 1:01:34measured, get it measured. In US units,
- 1:01:37if it is anything above about 10 micro
- 1:01:39units per mil, that's a warning. In UK
- 1:01:42units, if it's anything above about 40
- 1:01:44picomoles, that's a warning. Insulin is
- 1:01:47high, you could have insulin resistance.
- 1:01:50And you could be skinny
- 1:01:52Oh, yes.
- 1:01:52and have insulin resistance.
- 1:01:53Yes, that's especially depending on the
- 1:01:55ethnicity. Like if someone listening to
- 1:01:57this is East Asian and they say, "Well,
- 1:01:59I'm quite thin. I don't have insulin
- 1:02:01resistance." You very well could. Um it
- 1:02:04it depends. Even in in young women, a a
- 1:02:06group out of northern Canada,
- 1:02:09which is of course pretty far north,
- 1:02:11they found that even in young healthy
- 1:02:13weight women with PCOS,
- 1:02:15they if they compared them to their
- 1:02:17identically matched other women without
- 1:02:19PCOS, they were more insulin resistant
- 1:02:22in the other group. So so anyway, that's
- 1:02:24my
- 1:02:25way of saying even if you look at
- 1:02:27yourself and think, "Well, I'm kind of
- 1:02:28lean. I'm not insulin resistant." You
- 1:02:30very well could be.
- 1:02:31Okay, so I've got a friend who's a a
- 1:02:33woman
- 1:02:34Mhm.
- 1:02:34who has PCOS.
- 1:02:36Yeah.
- 1:02:36And one of the things that she often
- 1:02:38says to me is that
- 1:02:39she gains weight easily. Is this true?
- 1:02:42Oh, for sure. And in fact, I wouldn't be
- 1:02:44surprised if she does because the fact
- 1:02:46that she has PCOS is not absolute
- 1:02:49evidence, but very likely evidence that
- 1:02:52she has insulin resistance, which would
- 1:02:54mean at any given moment her insulin is
- 1:02:57at the risk of being a little higher
- 1:02:58than her non-insulin resistant
- 1:03:00counterparts.
- 1:03:01So if she goes and gets the test done,
- 1:03:03I bet her insulin would be high.
- 1:03:05Um and so, all that would mean is which
- 1:03:08is good. I mean, knowledge is power. And
- 1:03:10my hope would be that as someone goes
- 1:03:12and gets their insulin measured, and
- 1:03:13there are a handful of other tests they
- 1:03:15could also look at, but that's the most
- 1:03:17succinct. Then it would be all the more
- 1:03:19impetus or encouragement to say, "Okay,
- 1:03:22I heard I listened to Steven and Ben. I
- 1:03:24really do need to start making some
- 1:03:25changes." And even in PCOS,
- 1:03:28there are reports that document the
- 1:03:31absolute reversal of the disease with
- 1:03:33nothing more than just dietary changes.
- 1:03:36I was looking also at second here cuz we
- 1:03:37mentioned ethnicity a few times and it
- 1:03:39says the research I was looking at says
- 1:03:40that East Asians have East Asians have
- 1:03:43fewer fat cells and they're more
- 1:03:44resistant to obesity-related metabolic
- 1:03:47issues.
- 1:03:48Well, that's second part of that
- 1:03:50statement is not true. They're more
- 1:03:52resistant to obesity,
- 1:03:54but they are like if it's an interesting
- 1:03:56dichotomy cuz
- 1:03:57Right. Okay, I got you.
- 1:03:58Yeah, so they're more you you like to
- 1:03:59find a Japanese man who's as fat as the
- 1:04:02average American, boy, you're going to
- 1:04:03have to look. It's hard. It's hard, but
- 1:04:05to find a Japanese man who has is just
- 1:04:08as much likely to get diabetes, type 2
- 1:04:10diabetes, very easy.
- 1:04:12Africans have
- 1:04:14more fat cells typically?
- 1:04:15Yeah, so so on that ethnicity, if now
- 1:04:18there's a lot of kind of wiggle room
- 1:04:20here, but on one end we'd have
- 1:04:21Caucasians, blacks would be right
- 1:04:24nearby. African ethnicities would be
- 1:04:25quite close
- 1:04:27um to the to the kind of northern
- 1:04:29European ethnicity. And then we would
- 1:04:30move through and and I don't mean to
- 1:04:32miss anyone here, but on the other end
- 1:04:34it would be East Asian and then
- 1:04:36sprinkled through that would be um
- 1:04:39uh
- 1:04:40Latino.
- 1:04:41Latino would be somewhere in the middle
- 1:04:43and Hispanic. And then other Southeast
- 1:04:45Asian and then East Asian kind of on the
- 1:04:47worst end or the least sensitive or the
- 1:04:50most sensitive to their fat. The most
- 1:04:52sensitive to their fat. This actually is
- 1:04:54a concept that has been presented called
- 1:04:56the personal fat threshold, which is
- 1:04:59this really interesting idea born from a
- 1:05:01group in Australia suggesting that
- 1:05:03across every individual body, which of
- 1:05:06course is heavily influenced by both
- 1:05:07ethnicity and sex, like we mentioned
- 1:05:10earlier, a body is going to have a rate
- 1:05:12at which it can store fat in a healthy
- 1:05:15way. And then once that threshold is
- 1:05:17met, any further pressure to store fat
- 1:05:20will start creating insulin resistance.
- 1:05:22And that threshold is essentially
- 1:05:24how big, how many fat cells do you have,
- 1:05:26and how much room do they have. So if
- 1:05:28you have more fat cells, you have a
- 1:05:30higher fat threshold. You can get fatter
- 1:05:32before it starts to hurt you.
- 1:05:34Does your fat distribution also matter
- 1:05:36here? Because
- 1:05:37does.
- 1:05:37different races, this research is
- 1:05:40telling me
- 1:05:41have different fat distribution. It's
- 1:05:43saying that Africans have better fat
- 1:05:45distribution, lower visceral fat, and
- 1:05:48less metabolic risk because of that.
- 1:05:50Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:05:51Caucasians moderate fat cell quantity,
- 1:05:53more prone to subcutaneous fat
- 1:05:55accumulation, which
- 1:05:55Subcutaneous.
- 1:05:56Which is that's the fat around the
- 1:05:57organs.
- 1:05:58Yeah, so Caucasians and so so let's say
- 1:05:59northern European African, both store
- 1:06:02more of their fat subcutaneously, which
- 1:06:04is the fat just beneath the skin, or the
- 1:06:06fat that you can pinch and jiggle.
- 1:06:08That has an ability to expand more
- 1:06:10because there's nothing really to limit
- 1:06:11it. Um however, the other place for
- 1:06:14people to store fat is their visceral
- 1:06:16adipose, which is the fat that is tucked
- 1:06:18within the abdominal cavity, so tucked
- 1:06:21around the organs. It's sort of
- 1:06:22surrounding the kidneys and the
- 1:06:24intestines and the liver. That is an
- 1:06:26unhealthy place to gain fat, but an East
- 1:06:28Asian, all things equal, is putting much
- 1:06:31more fat there than they are
- 1:06:33subcutaneously. The advantage of
- 1:06:35subcutaneous fat is
- 1:06:37Which is the fat on the outside.
- 1:06:38Yeah, yeah, so the the fat beneath the
- 1:06:40skin. Yeah, the yeah, the loose belly
- 1:06:42fat, the fat that can pinch and jiggle.
- 1:06:44That fat has a greater ability to make
- 1:06:46new fat cells. So as much as earlier you
- 1:06:48and I said fat cells remain static, for
- 1:06:50the most part they do, there's a little
- 1:06:52bit of wiggle room, where it can go up.
- 1:06:54And that's purely subcutaneous.
- 1:06:57And Hispanics have higher fat cell
- 1:06:58quantity, more visceral fat,
- 1:07:00Yes.
- 1:07:01and increased risk of obesity related
- 1:07:03conditions.
- 1:07:03Yes, and so the problem with visceral
- 1:07:04fat is this is such a finite space.
- 1:07:07There's so little room within the core
- 1:07:09of your body that if we allowed those
- 1:07:11fats to multiply, it could theoretically
- 1:07:14start physically compressing on tissues.
- 1:07:16Right.
- 1:07:17And so those fat cells only grow through
- 1:07:20hypertrophy, which is the thing we
- 1:07:22talked about earlier with slow insulin
- 1:07:24resistance. Subcutaneous fat cells are
- 1:07:26more abundant but smaller. Visceral fat
- 1:07:29cells are fewer but much larger. And so
- 1:07:32any ethnicity including Hispanic or
- 1:07:35Asian that promotes relatively more fat
- 1:07:37storage in the visceral space is going
- 1:07:40to suffer from the consequences of that
- 1:07:41fat much sooner. And again, it still
- 1:07:43comes back to size. The bigger the fat
- 1:07:46cell, the sicker the fat cell.
- 1:07:48According to Alzheimer's Disease
- 1:07:49International, the total number of
- 1:07:50people living with dementia globally is
- 1:07:52expected to reach 139 million by 2050,
- 1:07:55which is up from around 55 million in
- 1:07:572020. Which I imagine is in part
- 1:08:01related to people living a bit longer
- 1:08:03than they once did as well.
- 1:08:05Although although over the past few
- 1:08:06years, life expectancy actually turned
- 1:08:07down for the first time in the history
- 1:08:09of modern
- 1:08:11world. So who knows if it will continue
- 1:08:13to go up, but yeah. It could be people
- 1:08:15are living longer. I mean one of the
- 1:08:17effects of modern medicine is that
- 1:08:19people live longer with disease.
- 1:08:22Um Alzheimer's included, but it's
- 1:08:23absolutely a consequence further of our
- 1:08:26overall metabolic milieu that we put
- 1:08:28ourselves in a position where we are
- 1:08:30making our brains insulin resistant and
- 1:08:33thus they're going hungrier and
- 1:08:34hungrier.
- 1:08:35There's a study you talk about
- 1:08:38which you've cited before that shows
- 1:08:39that if you move visceral fat from an
- 1:08:43obese animal to a lean animal, this
- 1:08:45immediately caused insulin resistance.
- 1:08:48Yeah. In the animal that received it.
- 1:08:50Okay.
- 1:08:51Yeah, so just to be clear, if if we took
- 1:08:54what they did in the study just to
- 1:08:55reflect why or that different depots of
- 1:08:58fat are harmful. And so the the human
- 1:09:00body has two distinct fat depots, and
- 1:09:01you and I described them subcutaneous,
- 1:09:04which is the fat beneath the skin, or
- 1:09:05visceral, which is the fat tucked within
- 1:09:07the organs of the abdominal space.
- 1:09:10And if you move subcutaneous fat,
- 1:09:14Which is like the belly fat?
- 1:09:15The belly fat, and and from one animal
- 1:09:17to another, you couldn't do this in
- 1:09:18humans, if you move belly fat, if you
- 1:09:20will, or subcutaneous fat from one
- 1:09:22animal to the other, the animal's very
- 1:09:24healthy. It's no problem. Subcutaneous
- 1:09:26fat is inert. It really is just sort of
- 1:09:29hanging out there and minding its own
- 1:09:30business. But, in that same study, if
- 1:09:32you move the visceral adipose over, now
- 1:09:35all of a sudden that animal that got
- 1:09:37that extra dose of visceral fat is going
- 1:09:39to become sicker. It's going to become
- 1:09:41more insulin resistant and diabetic
- 1:09:43because you've increased its visceral
- 1:09:45fat the amount of fat that it has in
- 1:09:47that space.
- 1:09:48The body wants to limit the amount of
- 1:09:50fat that it has there because if the
- 1:09:52fat, again, if the fat grows too much,
- 1:09:55you can physically start compressing and
- 1:09:57squishing organs that you need to be
- 1:10:00functioning, like the kidneys and the
- 1:10:01intestines.
- 1:10:02Have you seen Bryan Johnson?
- 1:10:04I have. I don't know him personally, but
- 1:10:06You've seen the documentaries and stuff
- 1:10:07made about him and the the work that
- 1:10:09he's doing. What do you make of what
- 1:10:10he's doing to extend his age? Cuz, you
- 1:10:12know, one of the subjects that I think's
- 1:10:13linked to this is the idea of longevity
- 1:10:16and aging, and he's become a bit of a
- 1:10:18poster child for the subject of
- 1:10:19longevity.
- 1:10:20Right, right. Well, I want to address
- 1:10:22this cuz this is a real person, so I
- 1:10:23want to address it very politely and
- 1:10:25diplomatically. I think that I want to
- 1:10:28distinguish the difference between
- 1:10:30longevity research and science, which is
- 1:10:32a very real, living, breathing field,
- 1:10:34and I'm proud to know individuals who
- 1:10:36are longevity scientists, and
- 1:10:38distinguish them from
- 1:10:40um longevity
- 1:10:42you said poster child, so the the gurus
- 1:10:44of longevity, and that's not the same
- 1:10:46thing. So, what I say, I don't mean to
- 1:10:48it to be an indictment of longevity
- 1:10:50research, but I don't mind if people
- 1:10:52hear a bit of an indictment in my voice
- 1:10:55of the modern longevity guru approach.
- 1:10:59So, these individuals, and he is
- 1:11:00certainly the most well-known, they do
- 1:11:03have the advantage of never really
- 1:11:06being able to be proven wrong. You know,
- 1:11:08so there's an inherent problem here.
- 1:11:10But, I will say that the the application
- 1:11:13of
- 1:11:14being a longevity
- 1:11:16expert or not a scientist, but a guru,
- 1:11:19and I don't mean for that to be
- 1:11:20negative, but it does have a bit of a
- 1:11:22negative sound to it, is that you have
- 1:11:24to rely on
- 1:11:26what I would call weak evidence. Now,
- 1:11:28what do I mean by that?
- 1:11:30Uh so, all of the approaches to
- 1:11:32longevity nowadays rely on either
- 1:11:34correlational studies
- 1:11:36or
- 1:11:37basic research or animals and insect
- 1:11:39studies.
- 1:11:40And then extrapolating that results or
- 1:11:42assuming those same results will apply
- 1:11:44to the human. So, let me briefly just
- 1:11:45mention my concerns with correlational
- 1:11:47research.
- 1:11:48So, the longevity guru will say,
- 1:11:51"Correlational evidence suggests that
- 1:11:53people who eat meat
- 1:11:55um die more."
- 1:11:57Well, a correlational study is, by my
- 1:12:00estimation, some of the weakest evidence
- 1:12:03that you can ever generate. A
- 1:12:04correlational study would just have
- 1:12:06someone come to your home and say,
- 1:12:07"Steven, can you please answer this
- 1:12:08survey about what you eat?"
- 1:12:11You answer the survey. You may lie. You
- 1:12:13may not remember.
- 1:12:14You may have things that you don't even
- 1:12:16think about including, like, for
- 1:12:18example, that you're part of a very
- 1:12:20um well-put-together religious
- 1:12:23organization. And I actually used that
- 1:12:24example very deliberately because people
- 1:12:27who are known to be
- 1:12:28part of good tight social circles, like
- 1:12:30a formal religious group, always live
- 1:12:32longer than people who don't. Maybe
- 1:12:34you're really lonely. Loneliness is a
- 1:12:37greater contributor to death than
- 1:12:39cigarette smoking, and it's not even
- 1:12:40close. So, there could be things on that
- 1:12:42survey that you just cannot capture. And
- 1:12:45yet, we end up making a conclusion. And
- 1:12:48so, all of that correlational evidence
- 1:12:50is deeply flawed research. And yet that
- 1:12:53becomes the basis for the longevity guru
- 1:12:55to determine diet.
- 1:12:57So, if I'm trying to extend my
- 1:12:59longevity,
- 1:13:00Yeah.
- 1:13:01trying to live longer,
- 1:13:02then exactly what should I be thinking
- 1:13:04about?
- 1:13:05So, my view on longevity is a metabolic
- 1:13:07view, no surprise. I'm a metabolic
- 1:13:09scientist and I don't mind someone sort
- 1:13:11of smirking at me declaring that or
- 1:13:13admitting it. But, I'm somewhat
- 1:13:15justified.
- 1:13:17Just by way of setting the stage, the
- 1:13:19earliest the birth of the modern
- 1:13:22longevity research
- 1:13:24uh at least if it didn't start, it was
- 1:13:26heavily influenced by the work of a
- 1:13:27woman named Cynthia Cynthia Kenyon.
- 1:13:30K E N Y O N
- 1:13:32Cynthia Kenyon was one of the kind of
- 1:13:35she really did, in my mind, kind of give
- 1:13:37give birth to the modern longevity
- 1:13:39focus.
- 1:13:40What her lab found using an insect
- 1:13:43model,
- 1:13:44and this is again a problem with the
- 1:13:45longevity gurus is that they rely on
- 1:13:47insect data and for example, but it was
- 1:13:50compelling what she found. I think it
- 1:13:51was worms. She found in worms
- 1:13:55that if they restricted the glucose that
- 1:13:57the worms were eating,
- 1:13:59they would live 50% longer or some some
- 1:14:01fantastic increase in the how long the
- 1:14:04animals lived. That kind of gave birth
- 1:14:06to the idea of fasting being beneficial,
- 1:14:09but it also allowed her lab to start
- 1:14:11playing around with some of the genes of
- 1:14:13these little insects. And when they
- 1:14:15started knocking down or under
- 1:14:17expressing some of the genes involved in
- 1:14:20insulin,
- 1:14:22they didn't have to restrict the food,
- 1:14:24the animals just lived longer.
- 1:14:26And so, that touches on this metabolic
- 1:14:29aspect and everyone nowadays is really
- 1:14:31interested in autophagy.
- 1:14:33Autophagy is a term for a cell
- 1:14:36essentially cleaning itself out.
- 1:14:38Which is typically associated with long
- 1:14:39fasting.
- 1:14:40Yeah, that's Yeah, yeah. In fact, yes.
- 1:14:42So, that is partly why fasting has been
- 1:14:44so embraced within the uh longevity
- 1:14:46community. it's because if you can
- 1:14:49promote longevity or autophagy rather,
- 1:14:51if you can promote autophagy, the cell
- 1:14:54keeping itself cleaned out, that is
- 1:14:56thought to be a key contributor to
- 1:14:58longevity. So, autophagy equating to
- 1:15:01longevity. I don't disagree with that. I
- 1:15:03think that probably is a very valid
- 1:15:05view.
- 1:15:06Then, the question comes, well, how can
- 1:15:09I control autophagy?
- 1:15:11Well, there is a humble hormone that
- 1:15:13comes from the pancreas that has a very
- 1:15:15powerful effect on autophagy called
- 1:15:17insulin. So, as much as people are
- 1:15:20fasting, what's the value of fasting in
- 1:15:22reducing autophagy? It's because insulin
- 1:15:24comes down. Now, what becomes
- 1:15:26interesting is what happens if you were
- 1:15:28to put someone allow them to eat
- 1:15:30calories, but the calories are such that
- 1:15:32their insulin is staying low
- 1:15:35and they're making ketones. In other
- 1:15:36words, a ketogenic diet.
- 1:15:38You also enable autophagy. There was a
- 1:15:41very well-done animal study finding that
- 1:15:44they didn't have to restrict calories
- 1:15:46and fast the animals. They could let the
- 1:15:48animals eat as much as they wanted, but
- 1:15:50it was a ketogenic diet. They lived
- 1:15:53significantly longer than their other
- 1:15:55littermates that were eating the normal
- 1:15:57high-carb chow, similar to what humans
- 1:15:59eat nowadays.
- 1:16:01And so, autophagy probably does matter
- 1:16:03for longevity.
- 1:16:05All the more reason to keep your insulin
- 1:16:07in check because insulin is a powerful
- 1:16:09inhibitor of autophagy. So, as much as
- 1:16:12we have longevity gurus who are taking
- 1:16:14thousands of dollars worth of
- 1:16:16supplements,
- 1:16:17I can't help but look at that and think,
- 1:16:19just control your insulin.
- 1:16:21That within every cell, there's this
- 1:16:23battle. There's a yin-yang of growth and
- 1:16:25death or building and breaking to say it
- 1:16:27a little more politely. In fact, that is
- 1:16:30metabolism. The very word metabolism
- 1:16:33encompasses anabolism,
- 1:16:36which is anabolic or building up, and
- 1:16:38catabolism or catabolic, which is
- 1:16:40breaking down.
- 1:16:41The key to a healthy growing living cell
- 1:16:45is this nice ongoing balance of build
- 1:16:47and break, build and break. You have to
- 1:16:50build something up and then modestly
- 1:16:51break it down. And then you build
- 1:16:53somethings up again. And autophagy is a
- 1:16:55very important part of that breaking
- 1:16:57cycle within the cell that hey, it's
- 1:16:59time to get rid of some old parts and
- 1:17:01now we'll rebuild some of that again.
- 1:17:03Now we're going to break down these
- 1:17:04parts and rebuild it. Insulin is the key
- 1:17:07to that process. If insulin stays high
- 1:17:10for too long, you never allow the
- 1:17:12catabolic or the breakdown. This is one
- 1:17:15reason why insulin is so facilitative to
- 1:17:17cancer. Insulin wants things to grow.
- 1:17:19Cancer is a disease of growth. We don't
- 1:17:22ever let the cancer start to break down.
- 1:17:24Insulin won't let it in part.
- 1:17:26You even repeatedly talked about
- 1:17:28ketosis.
- 1:17:29I have.
- 1:17:30Ketones. We'll eventually get there.
- 1:17:31We're kind of teasing the audience a
- 1:17:32little bit.
- 1:17:33Yeah, we are. Yeah. But rightly so. I
- 1:17:34mean, ketones are a very vilified
- 1:17:37misunderstood part of the body. And and
- 1:17:38to my great delight, um it's getting
- 1:17:41it's getting a sort of new appreciation.
- 1:17:43Well, I'm currently on the keto diet as
- 1:17:45well. So, I am incredibly interested to
- 1:17:47understand A, like what's going on in my
- 1:17:49body, but B, I I'm quite compelled by
- 1:17:52both the pros and cons of doing it. And
- 1:17:54I want to talk about the cons and the
- 1:17:55pros.
- 1:17:55Mhm.
- 1:17:56Um because they both exist. One thing
- 1:17:58you say in your book, Why We Get Sick,
- 1:18:00is that the longest living humans are
- 1:18:03also the most insulin sensitive.
- 1:18:05Yeah.
- 1:18:05So, you're telling me that the longest
- 1:18:07living humans are the ones that are able
- 1:18:09to stave off that
- 1:18:10insulin resistance.
- 1:18:11Yes. Yes, so there are
- 1:18:12keep their insulin levels low.
- 1:18:14That's right. Yeah, in fact, most of the
- 1:18:16longevity research
- 1:18:17a sort of a final point on this, um is
- 1:18:19that when you look at these studies that
- 1:18:21look back in time and say, "Okay, what
- 1:18:24is it about these people? What variables
- 1:18:27tend to go along with the longest lived
- 1:18:29humans?" One of them is that their
- 1:18:31insulin sensitive and their blood
- 1:18:32glucose levels are In fact, a very well
- 1:18:34done study just last year out of Sweden.
- 1:18:37I think it was just 1 year ago.
- 1:18:39They looked at all and Sweden is
- 1:18:41meticulous in its in its record keeping,
- 1:18:43which is an advantage. And and a
- 1:18:46fairly homogeneous society, so it kind
- 1:18:48of eliminates some confounding
- 1:18:49variables.
- 1:18:51But they attempted to document what were
- 1:18:53the what were the variables that were
- 1:18:54just the most consistent theme of people
- 1:18:57who lived very long. One of them was
- 1:18:59good glucose control.
- 1:19:01And this next one is very controversial
- 1:19:02because they found that they also the
- 1:19:04longest lived people had high
- 1:19:05cholesterol levels.
- 1:19:07And isn't that funny? It is one of the
- 1:19:09most consistent themes of longevity
- 1:19:11research that the longest lived people
- 1:19:13have higher cholesterol.
- 1:19:15And yet we live in a world that hates
- 1:19:17cholesterol and the moment cholesterol
- 1:19:19goes up we put them on a cholesterol
- 1:19:20lowering medication.
- 1:19:22We could be doing the perfectly wrong
- 1:19:24thing to help these people live longer.
- 1:19:26So, that was and and then low uric acid
- 1:19:28and there's a handful of other little
- 1:19:30variables that fit into this.
- 1:19:31So, they they found that some of the
- 1:19:32longest living humans had high
- 1:19:34cholesterol levels.
- 1:19:35That's right. That's what the Sweden
- 1:19:36study found for example. The paper just
- 1:19:38published a year or so ago. What were
- 1:19:40some of the most consistent themes? They
- 1:19:41had good glucose control and high
- 1:19:44cholesterol.
- 1:19:45I'm a great defender of of cholesterol.
- 1:19:48It is a molecule of life.
- 1:19:53And and so many so much depends on it.
- 1:19:55Mitochondria for example. Mitochondria
- 1:19:57have to have a cholesterol molecule in
- 1:19:59them in order to work. Like the very
- 1:20:01powerhouse of the cell. And the more you
- 1:20:03lower cholesterol through say drug
- 1:20:05interventions, the more you compromise
- 1:20:07the mitochondria.
- 1:20:09Um the sex hormones. All sex hormones
- 1:20:12are built on cholesterol. It's no
- 1:20:14surprise if someone takes a cholesterol
- 1:20:16lowering medication their sex hormones
- 1:20:18go down. This is why some men experience
- 1:20:20such terrible loss of libido because
- 1:20:22he's becoming low testosterone because
- 1:20:24of the war on cholesterol.
- 1:20:26But there's good and bad cholesterol,
- 1:20:27right?
- 1:20:27Well, that's as the story goes, yes. And
- 1:20:30yet I think that's overly simplified.
- 1:20:32Where people will say LDL cholesterol is
- 1:20:34the bad cholesterol.
- 1:20:37And yet, that gets included in these
- 1:20:39studies of longevity. So, I think the
- 1:20:41good and bad aspect of it is not
- 1:20:43entirely fair or accurate. We need LDL.
- 1:20:46And LDL is just as much a component of
- 1:20:48the immune system.
- 1:20:49LDL actually helps the body fight
- 1:20:51infections. So, it's also an unsung hero
- 1:20:53of immunity.
- 1:20:55There was research suggesting that in
- 1:20:56very old age, high cholesterol levels do
- 1:20:58not always correlate with higher
- 1:21:00mortality. And in some studies may even
- 1:21:02be linked to longer life.
- 1:21:05Exactly.
- 1:21:06Which is bizarre.
- 1:21:07Yeah, well, you say that and yet maybe
- 1:21:10our anti-cholesterol view is the bizarre
- 1:21:12one.
- 1:21:12Yeah.
- 1:21:12And so, as a cynic who's very familiar
- 1:21:15with biomedical research, I sometimes
- 1:21:16will look at clinical markers and say,
- 1:21:18"Why are we so obsessed with glucose?
- 1:21:21Why not insulin? Why are we so obsessed
- 1:21:23with cholesterol? Why not triglycerides,
- 1:21:26which is another lipid that can be
- 1:21:27measured that is far more predictive of
- 1:21:29who's going to have a heart attack or
- 1:21:31not?"
- 1:21:32And I think it's because we have chosen
- 1:21:35markers in modern medicine that we have
- 1:21:37well-designed drugs.
- 1:21:40So, it's a really, really good way to
- 1:21:41sell a lot of drugs. So, there's no drug
- 1:21:44that's going to address insulin. So,
- 1:21:45let's not measure it. But, there are
- 1:21:47lots of drugs that will lower glucose.
- 1:21:49So, let's measure glucose because then
- 1:21:51we can diagnose the problem and then we
- 1:21:53can give them a drug and make a lot of
- 1:21:55money. That's a cynical view, but I
- 1:21:56don't think it's unjustified. Similarly
- 1:21:58with cholesterol.
- 1:22:00Why look at LDL when triglycerides,
- 1:22:02another lipid marker, are a much better
- 1:22:05indicator? It's because we don't have a
- 1:22:07drug that effectively lowers
- 1:22:08triglycerides. You can with diet, but we
- 1:22:11do have drugs that very effectively
- 1:22:12lower LDL.
- 1:22:15One thing that really surprised me when
- 1:22:16I was reading your work is
- 1:22:18there was a study done
- 1:22:21in Bulgaria which proved that smoking
- 1:22:23causes insulin resistance in humans by
- 1:22:26having seven healthy non-smokers smoke
- 1:22:29four cigarettes over an hour for 3 days.
- 1:22:32What did they find in that study?
- 1:22:34Yeah, so they found that if you took
- 1:22:35healthy non-smoking people and had them
- 1:22:36start smoking, they became insulin
- 1:22:38resistant. I believe I invoked that
- 1:22:40study in the section where I was talking
- 1:22:42about inflammation.
- 1:22:44Um where when you cigarette smoke that
- 1:22:46elicits there's a lot of junk coming in
- 1:22:49and there's a powerful inflammatory
- 1:22:50response and that contributes to insulin
- 1:22:52resistance.
- 1:22:53Is this vaping as well?
- 1:22:54Oh, so that is a very good question. I
- 1:22:57have in fact published now multiple
- 1:22:59papers with a very good friend and
- 1:23:00colleague who is a lung expert at my
- 1:23:03university, a guy named by the name of
- 1:23:05Paul Reynolds. Paul and I, we have
- 1:23:06published reports together looking at
- 1:23:08cigarette smoking and the inflammatory
- 1:23:10and insulin resistance effects that come
- 1:23:13from that. And now we've even started
- 1:23:15looking at the molecules, the
- 1:23:16hyper-heated
- 1:23:18molecules from vaping and they're
- 1:23:21they're terrible. In fact,
- 1:23:23yes, very similar results. If you were
- 1:23:25to take a comparable amount of the
- 1:23:27chemicals from normal cigarette smoke
- 1:23:29with its filter
- 1:23:31versus vaping, the vaping ones are
- 1:23:33probably worse chemical for chemical.
- 1:23:36In terms of their insulin
- 1:23:38in terms of their inflammatory effect,
- 1:23:40of the damage to the airway and the
- 1:23:42insulin resistance that comes from it.
- 1:23:44That's horrifying.
- 1:23:45It is in part because of just how common
- 1:23:48it's become.
- 1:23:52Does smoking make us fat?
- 1:23:53Uh that's a great question. It doesn't
- 1:23:56because it replaces other interests. So
- 1:23:58if the cigarette smoker ate
- 1:24:01the way everyone else was eating, it
- 1:24:03would.
- 1:24:04But because the cigarette smoke
- 1:24:06satisfies a craving, they have less of
- 1:24:09an interest in food. What's so
- 1:24:10interesting about cigarette smoking is
- 1:24:12again, as I said, you begin to smoke
- 1:24:14other things don't tempt you as much
- 1:24:16like the cookies and the cakes. But one
- 1:24:18of the ways the smoker helps kick the
- 1:24:20habit of cigarette smoking is actually
- 1:24:22eating candy. Like they will literally
- 1:24:24start carrying around little candies in
- 1:24:26their pocket. So that they feel a
- 1:24:28craving for cigarette smoking, they will
- 1:24:29take out a little candy, open it up, and
- 1:24:31pop it in their mouth. And so it's no
- 1:24:33surprise that very commonly when a
- 1:24:35person quits smoking, they gain
- 1:24:37significant weight.
- 1:24:39They end up trading out their
- 1:24:41addictions, if you will. Um and
- 1:24:43unfortunately, in humans, all of the
- 1:24:45study of addictions with food, people
- 1:24:48only manifest an addiction to one type
- 1:24:50of food, and that is carbohydrate.
- 1:24:51There's no evidence of addiction to fats
- 1:24:53or proteins.
- 1:24:54You published a study in 2024, which
- 1:24:56found that exposure to diesel exhaust
- 1:24:59gas was associated with increased fat
- 1:25:02mass, enlarged fat cells, insulin
- 1:25:04resistance, and increased levels of
- 1:25:06inflammation. And that was published in
- 1:25:08the International Journal of Molecular
- 1:25:09Sciences.
- 1:25:10Yeah, that was one of the studies I just
- 1:25:11was referring to with regards to my
- 1:25:13colleague Paul Reynolds. Paul and I, we
- 1:25:15That was one of the papers we published
- 1:25:17looking at these inhaled particulates.
- 1:25:19The reason I was interested in this
- 1:25:21field of study in the first place
- 1:25:23was just to continue to kill the caloric
- 1:25:26model of obesity. So our And this
- 1:25:29touches on an earlier part of the
- 1:25:30conversation. Overwhelmingly, if you ask
- 1:25:33someone, "Why do we get fat?" Well,
- 1:25:35because you eat more calories than you
- 1:25:36burn. "Why do you lose fat?" Because you
- 1:25:39eat fewer calories. And I have long just
- 1:25:42been frustrated by how naive that view
- 1:25:44is. Yes, energy matters, but again, the
- 1:25:46fat cell must be told what to do with
- 1:25:48the energy that it has. That, of course,
- 1:25:50points an obvious finger at insulin,
- 1:25:52which is the strongest of all signals.
- 1:25:54But what we found in that study is that
- 1:25:56even something as seemingly unrelated as
- 1:25:58diesel exhaust particles,
- 1:26:00mind you, we did not do this study in
- 1:26:01humans.
- 1:26:03Full disclosure, we did the study in
- 1:26:04animals where we could perfectly control
- 1:26:06how much diesel exhaust they're getting.
- 1:26:09Um so we have this mechanism through in
- 1:26:11Paul's lab where you can aerosolize
- 1:26:13these particulates and know exactly how
- 1:26:15how the animals breathing. And then at
- 1:26:16the end of the study, after even though
- 1:26:18they ate the exact same amount of food,
- 1:26:21the animals that were exposed to the
- 1:26:22diesel exhaust particulates had fatter
- 1:26:25fat cells and more insulin resistance
- 1:26:27than the animals that had just been
- 1:26:28breathing normal room air.
- 1:26:30So, what we're breathing in
- 1:26:31theoretically could then be determining
- 1:26:33how fat we're getting.
- 1:26:34Yeah, yeah, in fact yeah yeah this
- 1:26:35evidence would suggest that it goes
- 1:26:37beyond theory. So, our evidence would
- 1:26:39state conclusively that yes, what you
- 1:26:41breathe does matter. Then theoretically
- 1:26:43we would say, well, how much does that
- 1:26:45apply to humans? That is where it would
- 1:26:47get into the realm of theoretical, but
- 1:26:48the evidence certainly suggests yes, the
- 1:26:51very air we breathe matters. And you see
- 1:26:53this at a population level. Look in
- 1:26:55areas where there are Now, there are
- 1:26:57confounding variables here. Here I am
- 1:26:59invoking correlational research and I
- 1:27:00was just criticizing it a moment ago
- 1:27:02with regards to longevity. But you look
- 1:27:04in areas where they have higher
- 1:27:05pollution levels, where the particulates
- 1:27:07are higher in the atmosphere, and those
- 1:27:09same areas are always fatter and more
- 1:27:13diabetic.
- 1:27:14Interesting.
- 1:27:16But of But of course that's
- 1:27:17correlational, so it's hard to say.
- 1:27:19Exactly. Yes, thank you for pointing it
- 1:27:20out. And but again, as much as you and I
- 1:27:23are citing the problem with the
- 1:27:24correlational study there, we need to
- 1:27:26always cite the problem with
- 1:27:27correlational studies when it comes to
- 1:27:28informing nutrition policy. Like, don't
- 1:27:31eat eggs because they cause diabetes,
- 1:27:33but when you actually look at the
- 1:27:34studies, you find nothing of the sort.
- 1:27:36What about other sort of environmental
- 1:27:37toxins and their impact on insulin
- 1:27:40resistance?
- 1:27:40Mhm. Yeah. So, there are the ones that
- 1:27:42you inhale. A handful of inhaled
- 1:27:45particulates will matter. We have shown
- 1:27:47in my lab alone with my with my
- 1:27:49collaborators, diesel exhaust will do
- 1:27:51it, cigarette smoke will do it, and more
- 1:27:53We have a funded grant right now to look
- 1:27:56at the effects of vaping. So, apparently
- 1:27:58stuff we breathe will matter.
- 1:28:01To some unknown degree, things that we
- 1:28:04drink will that are non-caloric. So,
- 1:28:07there can be like people have heard of
- 1:28:09the microplastics.
- 1:28:11Microplastics are things that you can't
- 1:28:13They're so small that you drink them
- 1:28:16and they will absorb through the
- 1:28:17intestine and get into the bloodstream.
- 1:28:19For reasons that are unknown to me at
- 1:28:22the moment, one of the sites where those
- 1:28:24microparticles will go is the fat cells.
- 1:28:27And once there, they will directly
- 1:28:29promote the growth of the fat cells. So,
- 1:28:30that's actual microscopic segments of
- 1:28:33plastic. But separate from that are
- 1:28:35molecules that can come from plastics
- 1:28:37and soaps and detergents like BPA
- 1:28:40or diethylstilbestrol DES. That's
- 1:28:43actually an estrogen mimetic, kind of
- 1:28:46what we referred to earlier with regards
- 1:28:47to other endocrine disruptors. But there
- 1:28:49are other chemicals that a person can
- 1:28:51drink
- 1:28:52um or inhale like I mentioned earlier,
- 1:28:55but that will directly impact the growth
- 1:28:57of fat cells or promote to tell that
- 1:28:59mimic what insulin wanted to do, which
- 1:29:01is tell the fat cell to grow.
- 1:29:04I've invested more than a million pounds
- 1:29:06into this company Perfect Ted, and
- 1:29:07they're also a sponsor of this podcast.
- 1:29:09I switched over to using matcha as my
- 1:29:10dominant energy source, and that's where
- 1:29:13Perfect Ted comes in. They have the
- 1:29:14matcha powders, they have the matcha
- 1:29:16drinks, they have the pods, and all of
- 1:29:18this keeps me focused throughout a very,
- 1:29:19very long recording day, no matter
- 1:29:21what's going on. And their team is
- 1:29:23obsessed with quality, which is why they
- 1:29:25source their ceremonial grade matcha
- 1:29:27from Japan. So, when people say to me
- 1:29:29that they don't like the taste of
- 1:29:30matcha, I'm guessing that they haven't
- 1:29:31tried Perfect Ted. Unlike low-quality
- 1:29:34matcha that has a bitter, grassy taste,
- 1:29:36Perfect Ted is smooth and naturally
- 1:29:38sweet. And without knowing it, you're
- 1:29:39probably a Perfect Ted customer already
- 1:29:41if you're getting your matcha at places
- 1:29:43like Blank Street or Joe & the Juice.
- 1:29:45But now, you can make it yourself at
- 1:29:47home. So, give it a try and we'll see if
- 1:29:49you still don't like matcha. So, here's
- 1:29:51what I'm going to do. I'm going to give
- 1:29:52you 40% off our matcha if you try it
- 1:29:54today. Head to perfectted.com and use
- 1:29:57code Steven 40. Or if you're in a
- 1:29:59supermarket, you can get it at Tesco's
- 1:30:01or Holland & Barrett or in the
- 1:30:02Netherlands at Albert Heijn. And those
- 1:30:04of you in the US, you can get it on
- 1:30:06Amazon.
- 1:30:07As you guys know, Whoop is one of my
- 1:30:09show sponsors. It's also a company that
- 1:30:11I have invested in and it's one that you
- 1:30:13guys ask me about a lot. The biggest
- 1:30:14question I get asked is why use Whoop
- 1:30:16over other wearable technology options
- 1:30:18and there is a bunch of reasons, but I
- 1:30:20think it really comes down to the most
- 1:30:22overlooked yet crucial feature. It's
- 1:30:24non-invasive nature. When everything in
- 1:30:27life seems to be competing for my
- 1:30:28attention, I turn to Whoop because it
- 1:30:30doesn't have a screen. And Will Ahmed,
- 1:30:32the CEO who came on this podcast, told
- 1:30:34me the reason that there's no screen.
- 1:30:36Because screens equal distraction. So,
- 1:30:39when I'm in meetings or I'm at the gym,
- 1:30:40my Whoop doesn't demand my attention.
- 1:30:42It's there in the background constantly
- 1:30:44pulling data and insights from my body
- 1:30:46that are ready for when I need them. If
- 1:30:49you've been thinking about joining
- 1:30:50Whoop, you can head to
- 1:30:51join.whoop.com/ceo
- 1:30:54and try Whoop for 30 days risk-free and
- 1:30:57zero commitment. That's
- 1:30:58join.whoop.com/ceo.
- 1:31:01Let me know how you get on.
- 1:31:04So, let's talk about ketosis and
- 1:31:06ketones.
- 1:31:07Um the diet the keto diet is becoming
- 1:31:10increasingly popular from what I've
- 1:31:12seen. It's actually the diet that I'm on
- 1:31:13at the moment.
- 1:31:16How does that play into everything we've
- 1:31:17talked about?
- 1:31:18Yeah. Yeah, so it it this is an
- 1:31:20opportunity for me to do a little bit of
- 1:31:22um bio nutrient biochemistry or a little
- 1:31:25discussion of metabolism so that people
- 1:31:27appreciate what ketones even are and
- 1:31:29where they come from.
- 1:31:31So, the the entirety of the human body
- 1:31:33is a metabolic hybrid in that the body
- 1:31:36is largely burning fuel from two
- 1:31:38sources. It is burning blood glucose or
- 1:31:41sugar blood sugar or it's burning fat.
- 1:31:45Those are the two main fuels for the
- 1:31:46body my extension. Now, the brain was an
- 1:31:48exception. The brain is glucose or
- 1:31:50ketones and but I'll get to where the
- 1:31:52ketones come from. The rest of the body
- 1:31:55isn't really relying on ketones as much.
- 1:31:57It's fats or glucose
- 1:31:59or blood sugar. Insulin is what decides
- 1:32:02which fuel is used. So, as much as the
- 1:32:04metabolic engine has two fuel sources,
- 1:32:07insulin will decide which one is opened
- 1:32:09and which one is closed. If insulin is
- 1:32:11high, the body is sugar burning. And you
- 1:32:13can measure this in the whole body level
- 1:32:15by measuring the amount of
- 1:32:16oxygen and CO2 that the body is
- 1:32:18producing. Because different
- 1:32:19biochemistry or the burning of the fuels
- 1:32:21will produce a different amount of CO2.
- 1:32:23So, if I'm burning glucose, I might be
- 1:32:25producing more CO2.
- 1:32:27Yes. Yes, so we could hook you up to
- 1:32:29something called an indirect calorimeter
- 1:32:31and measure that your RER, the
- 1:32:33respiratory exchange ratio, the balance
- 1:32:35between CO2 and oxygen, would go higher.
- 1:32:38So, we we increase your insulin, like if
- 1:32:40I infused you with insulin in the next
- 1:32:42few minutes, we would see that your RER
- 1:32:45would go up and we'd say, "Boy, you're
- 1:32:46sugar burning."
- 1:32:47Or we allow insulin to come down and
- 1:32:50then the RER goes down, which is
- 1:32:52reflective of fat burning. So, it's
- 1:32:54insulin that determines whether the body
- 1:32:56is sugar burning or fat burning. Now,
- 1:32:58when insulin has been low for about 16
- 1:33:00or so hours,
- 1:33:03something interesting starts happening
- 1:33:04at the liver.
- 1:33:05So, the liver,
- 1:33:07with insulin being low, is burning a lot
- 1:33:09of fat.
- 1:33:10Including its own fat that the liver can
- 1:33:12store. The liver can store fat, but also
- 1:33:14fat coming from fat cells. Because if
- 1:33:16insulin is low, the fat cells are just
- 1:33:19leaking out fat to be burned by the
- 1:33:21body.
- 1:33:22And because insulin is low, the liver
- 1:33:24keeps burning it.
- 1:33:25And the liver essentially
- 1:33:28burns continues to burn so much fat that
- 1:33:30it it fills its own needs. It meets its
- 1:33:33own needs and says to itself, "Hey, I
- 1:33:35don't need to keep burning fat. I have
- 1:33:37all the energy I need. I'm I'm doing
- 1:33:40great." But it can't stop burning fat
- 1:33:43because insulin is low. And if insulin
- 1:33:45stays low, fat burning keeps going. And
- 1:33:47so,
- 1:33:48Because the body doesn't have enough
- 1:33:49glucose.
- 1:33:50Well, it's acting Yes, so in this sense,
- 1:33:52it's doing it to help replace the
- 1:33:54glucose that isn't coming in. That's
- 1:33:55what value of the ketone. So, as the
- 1:33:57liver is continuing to burn fat, it
- 1:33:59essentially gets to a point of fat
- 1:34:01burning where it's burning more fat than
- 1:34:03it needs.
- 1:34:04And that excess, if you will, is what
- 1:34:06becomes ketones. So, ketones are kind of
- 1:34:09a metabolic release valve for the liver
- 1:34:12cell to say, "I I can't I don't know
- 1:34:14what to do with all this fat burning.
- 1:34:15Okay, I know what I'm going to do.
- 1:34:17There's not a lot of glucose coming in.
- 1:34:19And so, the brain may start to get
- 1:34:21hungry. So, I'm going to start making
- 1:34:23ketones."
- 1:34:24And so, ketones are nothing more than a
- 1:34:27product of a lot of fat burning. And
- 1:34:30anyone who even fasts for 24 hours, you
- 1:34:32wake up that next morning, you're in
- 1:34:34some degree of ketosis. Lest anyone
- 1:34:37think it's an extreme thing. People are
- 1:34:39going in and out of ketosis ideally
- 1:34:42often. Now, why do I say ideally? It's
- 1:34:44because ketones are, as we've already
- 1:34:46outlined, perhaps the best fuel for the
- 1:34:48brain. The brain thrives on ketones. You
- 1:34:51can take a person
- 1:34:53with early stage Alzheimer's disease and
- 1:34:56have them go through a series of
- 1:34:57cognitive tests and they do horribly on
- 1:34:59them. Like one example is you ask the
- 1:35:02patient with Alzheimer's to draw the
- 1:35:04face of an analog clock,
- 1:35:06a circle with 1 2 through 12 and then
- 1:35:08some hands on it. And it is utter chaos.
- 1:35:12This is published reports. You then put
- 1:35:14them into ketosis,
- 1:35:16ask them, "Can you please draw the face
- 1:35:18of a clock?" It's still sloppy, but it
- 1:35:20is absolutely the face of a clock. You
- 1:35:23ask them, when they're not in ketosis,
- 1:35:25to try to tie their shoelaces, they
- 1:35:26can't think through the puzzle of tying
- 1:35:29the shoelaces. Ask them to do it again
- 1:35:31when they're in ketosis, all of a sudden
- 1:35:33they can tie their shoelaces. More than
- 1:35:35that, they can get themselves dressed.
- 1:35:37All of these are published case reports.
- 1:35:39It's just my long-winded way of saying
- 1:35:41the brain thrives when it has ketones as
- 1:35:45a fuel source. But, the benefits don't
- 1:35:47stop there. My lab published a report
- 1:35:50finding that when humans were in
- 1:35:52ketosis, which is just a term for
- 1:35:53ketones being elevated,
- 1:35:55we pulled out small pieces of belly fat
- 1:35:58and measured the metabolic rate of that
- 1:36:00belly fat. And we found that in ketosis,
- 1:36:03the metabolic rate of that belly fat was
- 1:36:05three times higher than when the people
- 1:36:08were not in ketosis.
- 1:36:09What does that mean?
- 1:36:10Yeah, so that means that the fat was
- 1:36:12suddenly behaving in a much more
- 1:36:14energetic way. That fat tissue has a
- 1:36:16very low metabolic rate. And then all of
- 1:36:18a sudden when the ketones came into
- 1:36:20them, they started getting much more
- 1:36:22active and they started burning more
- 1:36:24energy. Which is going to be very
- 1:36:25helpful for someone who wants to lose
- 1:36:28fat. If your fat cells now have a three
- 1:36:30times higher metabolic rate, that means
- 1:36:33that the fat cells are starting to act a
- 1:36:34little bit more like your muscle cells.
- 1:36:37And they're just burning more energy.
- 1:36:38So does that mean that I'm going to lose
- 1:36:40fat faster? What does that mean?
- 1:36:41absolutely. And that is what happens.
- 1:36:43There are very well-done controlled
- 1:36:45studies to show that if you control for
- 1:36:47all calories, when a human is in
- 1:36:49ketosis, the metabolic rate goes up.
- 1:36:52Your body Your whole body is just
- 1:36:53burning more.
- 1:36:54Um it it it's just everything's kind of
- 1:36:56been turned on a little more. The the
- 1:36:57the the furnace of the metabolism has
- 1:36:59just been it's you have a little more
- 1:37:01fuel kind of stoking the fire.
- 1:37:04So ketones will increase metabolic rate
- 1:37:05of fat tissue. We found a paper that we
- 1:37:08published documenting how we took muscle
- 1:37:11cells and kind of insulted the muscle
- 1:37:13cells to determine how tough the muscle
- 1:37:15cells were.
- 1:37:17When we incubated the muscle cells with
- 1:37:19ketones, they were much more resistant
- 1:37:21to injury.
- 1:37:23So the ketones act to protect muscle
- 1:37:25tissue.
- 1:37:27And in a way that is reflective of a
- 1:37:28function of ketones. Ketones are a
- 1:37:31defender of muscle.
- 1:37:33Ketones are basically the way to tell
- 1:37:34the brain, saying, "Brain, you think you
- 1:37:37need a lot of glucose.
- 1:37:38And if you don't get enough glucose, you
- 1:37:40would start stripping the protein from
- 1:37:42muscle to turn it into glucose. But I'm
- 1:37:45here as a ketone, so you can eat me
- 1:37:47instead and not and leave the muscle
- 1:37:50alone. So we published again a direct
- 1:37:52report finding that ketones actually
- 1:37:54make muscle more resistant to injury.
- 1:37:56And this could be why you're seeing more
- 1:37:58and more elite athletes using ketones as
- 1:38:01an actual
- 1:38:02ergogenic aid or like a supplement to
- 1:38:04help them better be better. So my
- 1:38:06university at BYU, just this year, our
- 1:38:09men's and women's cross country team
- 1:38:11took the national championships, the
- 1:38:13best college runners in the nation,
- 1:38:15pretty impressive. One of the things
- 1:38:17they do is they take these ketone drinks
- 1:38:20before they train and before they they
- 1:38:22race. Some more and more of the Tour de
- 1:38:24France teams
- 1:38:26take ketone supplements because it is
- 1:38:28just another fuel.
- 1:38:30It is something that the body can burn.
- 1:38:32The that we always say, well, if once
- 1:38:34you start running out of glucose, you're
- 1:38:36going to bonk or you're going to hit the
- 1:38:37wall. Well, what if you don't really use
- 1:38:39glucose because you're burning a lot of
- 1:38:41fat and a lot of ketones instead and
- 1:38:43that keeps your glucose kind of
- 1:38:44untouched. You're not You're not relying
- 1:38:47on the glu- And we see this in humans.
- 1:38:49If there's an a human that has adapted
- 1:38:51to a ketogenic diet, they burn fat at a
- 1:38:55higher rate than was ever thought
- 1:38:56humanly possible. That that fat is
- 1:38:59basically fueling all of their muscle
- 1:39:01movement during the exercise session
- 1:39:04rather than relying predominantly on
- 1:39:05glucose. The body has adapted. It's
- 1:39:08burning fat for fuel and when available,
- 1:39:10it's burning ketones for fuel and it's
- 1:39:12leaving the muscle as sort of a last
- 1:39:14resort when it really needs a big kick.
- 1:39:16I've seen these keto drinks. They're
- 1:39:18little They're almost like little shots.
- 1:39:20Well, there's a bunch of different
- 1:39:21types. If you look at the spectrum of
- 1:39:23ketones, you on one end you have the
- 1:39:25cheapest, most readily available,
- 1:39:27although less effective, called ketone
- 1:39:29salts, where it takes a molecule of
- 1:39:31ketone and binds it to a mineral like
- 1:39:32calcium or magnesium.
- 1:39:34Um not as effective and it's a lot of
- 1:39:37minerals, so people will find that they
- 1:39:38might get a lot of plaque on their
- 1:39:39teeth, maybe increased risk of kidney
- 1:39:42stones, so comes with some consequences.
- 1:39:44Then you have the ketone ester, which
- 1:39:46often comes in shots.
- 1:39:47Yeah.
- 1:39:48Then you have the bioidentical
- 1:39:50BHB or the bioidentical ketone. One
- 1:39:52company, which is original ketone, um
- 1:39:55they make it. Now, these ones are more
- 1:39:57effective. You take a little bit of
- 1:39:58these and you will get an increase in
- 1:40:00ketones. They're a little more
- 1:40:01expensive, too.
- 1:40:02But as the space is becoming more
- 1:40:03competitive, the price is coming down.
- 1:40:05And what exactly does it do? So if I
- 1:40:07took a shot of bioidentical ketone
- 1:40:10drink,
- 1:40:10Mhm.
- 1:40:11what would go on in my body and how
- 1:40:12would I
- 1:40:13how would that impact my cognitive
- 1:40:15performance or
- 1:40:16athletic performance?
- 1:40:17Yeah. Yeah. So it would result So you're
- 1:40:20drinking it in, you're immediately
- 1:40:21absorbing it from your gut.
- 1:40:23Yeah.
- 1:40:23So if you were not in ketosis, let's say
- 1:40:25you had and I'm not encouraging people
- 1:40:27to do this. You would just have eaten
- 1:40:29two bagels and a cup of sugary coffee.
- 1:40:31You're no ketones, undetectable cuz
- 1:40:34insulin has come up, it's inhibited
- 1:40:35ketone production. And then you drink a
- 1:40:38shot of the ketone, within an hour we
- 1:40:40would detect your ketones. They would
- 1:40:41have gone up maybe to 1 millimolar,
- 1:40:42which is a pretty significant bump.
- 1:40:44Yeah.
- 1:40:44And they're capable of that kind of
- 1:40:45movement. And maybe you do so because
- 1:40:47you're thinking I really need to be
- 1:40:48sharp right now.
- 1:40:49Would that make me sharper?
- 1:40:51Well, that's where we have to speculate.
- 1:40:53There's no
- 1:40:54I My lab published animal evidence
- 1:40:56suggesting that yes, indeed, it makes
- 1:40:58you sharper. That we had these animals
- 1:41:00navigate mazes and recognize objects.
- 1:41:02And when the animals were on a ketogenic
- 1:41:04diet, they were much sharper. They were
- 1:41:06much quickly, much better at solving
- 1:41:08problems and remembering solutions to
- 1:41:11previous problems.
- 1:41:12It's one of the I asked this in
- 1:41:14particular because
- 1:41:16as my team know cuz I've said it to them
- 1:41:17a lot over the last couple of weeks
- 1:41:18since I've been on the keto diet and
- 1:41:20I've been literally
- 1:41:21pricking my finger to check
- 1:41:23Yeah.
- 1:41:24Yeah.
- 1:41:24my keto levels and the highest I've
- 1:41:26gotten to is like 2.5.
- 1:41:27Which is high.
- 1:41:28Is it high?
- 1:41:29That's not problematic.
- 1:41:30Right.
- 1:41:31that is just proof positive that you're
- 1:41:33in ketosis, which itself is proof
- 1:41:34positive that you're burning a lot of
- 1:41:36fat
- 1:41:36Yeah.
- 1:41:37and three that your insulin levels are
- 1:41:38low.
- 1:41:39Fat dropped off my body like I've never
- 1:41:40seen in my life.
- 1:41:41Exactly.
- 1:41:42Yeah, it's crazy.
- 1:41:43So the power there is
- 1:41:44like if you'll allow me to kind of
- 1:41:46springboard off of that comment
- 1:41:49the power of So So if someone is
- 1:41:51listening to this and they're thinking,
- 1:41:52"Okay, I need to shrink my fat cells."
- 1:41:54Yeah.
- 1:41:54Unfortunately, they don't realize that
- 1:41:56there's two variables to what caused
- 1:41:58their fat cells to grow in the first
- 1:41:59place. They have no awareness of the
- 1:42:01value of insulin in this in this um um
- 1:42:04formula. All they do is pay attention to
- 1:42:06the calories. And so the average
- 1:42:08individual is looking down the road of
- 1:42:10this fat cell shrinking journey and
- 1:42:12they're thinking, "Okay, what I have to
- 1:42:14do is just cut my calories." And what do
- 1:42:17they do to cut their calories? They do
- 1:42:18the exact wrong thing.
- 1:42:20And before I even answer that, let me
- 1:42:22just present the scenario. Let's imagine
- 1:42:24that Steven and I everyone listening is
- 1:42:26invited. Steven and I are hosting a
- 1:42:27buffet. We have the world's best chefs.
- 1:42:30It is going to be a table filled with
- 1:42:32the most delicious food you can imagine.
- 1:42:34You're In our invitation, we say, "Come
- 1:42:36hungry cuz you're going to want to try a
- 1:42:38little bit of everything." Everyone
- 1:42:40listening, ask yourselves what would you
- 1:42:42do to come as hungry as possible. You'd
- 1:42:44probably do two things. Or think, "How
- 1:42:47did you go to your Thanksgiving or
- 1:42:49your your Christmas dinner as hungry as
- 1:42:51possible?" You would eat a little less
- 1:42:54in some period of time before the event
- 1:42:56and you would exercise a little more.
- 1:42:58And it would work. You would be very
- 1:43:00hungry.
- 1:43:01That's why the traditional advice given
- 1:43:03for weight loss doesn't work because we
- 1:43:05tell people, "Eat less, exercise more."
- 1:43:08Sure, you may be lose a little bit of
- 1:43:09weight in the short term, but all that
- 1:43:11does, you've given them the perfect
- 1:43:13recipe to promote hunger. And hunger
- 1:43:15always wins.
- 1:43:16As a good example uh in the US, we have
- 1:43:19a game show. Maybe there was some
- 1:43:20version of this in the UK called The
- 1:43:21Biggest Loser.
- 1:43:23It was essentially who can lose the most
- 1:43:24weight. And it was through a punishing
- 1:43:27regiment of caloric restriction. Eat
- 1:43:29less, exercise more. That is like the
- 1:43:31perfect embodiment of that approach.
- 1:43:33They were starving and they were
- 1:43:35exercising to insane degrees. And oh my
- 1:43:38goodness, did they lose a lot of weight?
- 1:43:40And yet you never see them again.
- 1:43:41They don't do a reunion tour 5 years or
- 1:43:4410 years later because they gained it
- 1:43:45all back.
- 1:43:47Do Do you know they gain it all back?
- 1:43:49In fact, a paper published in the US
- 1:43:50from the National Institutes of Health
- 1:43:52documented not only the degree to which
- 1:43:54they gain weight back, but also how it
- 1:43:56almost literally breaks their
- 1:43:58metabolism. That normally a person's
- 1:44:00metabolic rate is connected to their
- 1:44:02body mass. A bigger body has a higher
- 1:44:04metabolic rate. A smaller body has a
- 1:44:07lower metabolic rate. This is just human
- 1:44:09physiology. And no surprise when someone
- 1:44:11loses weight, there's less of body and
- 1:44:13so metabolic rate goes down. As they
- 1:44:15gain weight back, metabolic rate will
- 1:44:17typically go back up as well.
- 1:44:20Except for the contestants in The
- 1:44:21Biggest Loser. They started with a high
- 1:44:23metabolic rate because of a high body
- 1:44:25fat level. They lost a substantial
- 1:44:28amount of weight. No surprise, metabolic
- 1:44:31rate went down substantially. But if
- 1:44:33this is such a dramatic change that as
- 1:44:36they started gaining weight back,
- 1:44:38metabolic rate did not come back with
- 1:44:40it. It stayed lower than it should have.
- 1:44:43Normally it's connected sort of
- 1:44:45one-to-one. Wherever body weight is
- 1:44:47going, metabolic rate is going. Except
- 1:44:49in these people. That method of dramatic
- 1:44:51weight loss through such severe
- 1:44:54restriction, which is based purely on
- 1:44:56the caloric theory of obesity,
- 1:44:58leads to such It leads to significant
- 1:45:00hunger. So no surprise, if a person's
- 1:45:02attempting to shrink their fat cells or
- 1:45:04lose weight,
- 1:45:05if the first step is I'm going to cut my
- 1:45:08calories and they don't address their
- 1:45:09high insulin,
- 1:45:11they're never going to lose weight in
- 1:45:12the long run. They're going to step
- 1:45:14right back to where they were. Because
- 1:45:15if they start cutting calories, but
- 1:45:17insulin is still high,
- 1:45:19that's going to make them very hungry
- 1:45:20because insulin wants to be storing
- 1:45:22energy.
- 1:45:23A A professor from Harvard named David
- 1:45:25Ludwig found this. If you have people
- 1:45:28eating a lower calorie meal that spikes
- 1:45:30their insulin, it makes them much
- 1:45:32hungrier
- 1:45:33than a lower calorie meal that doesn't
- 1:45:35spike insulin. So, that's the key.
- 1:45:37Anyone listening, if you're thinking I
- 1:45:39need to be on a fat cell shrinking
- 1:45:40journey, let the first step of that
- 1:45:43journey be
- 1:45:45I'm going to lower my insulin.
- 1:45:46Which means
- 1:45:47Which means I'm going to control my
- 1:45:48carbohydrates. I'm going to stop eating
- 1:45:51carbohydrates that come from bags and
- 1:45:52boxes with barcodes. And while I am
- 1:45:55restricting those carbohydrates, I'm
- 1:45:57going to focus more on protein and fat.
- 1:46:00So, control carbs, prioritize protein,
- 1:46:04and don't fear the fat that comes with
- 1:46:06those proteins. Fat and protein together
- 1:46:09is a
- 1:46:11a miraculous combination of helping you
- 1:46:13feel full, and it is literally giving
- 1:46:15everything you need.
- 1:46:17There are such things as essential
- 1:46:18proteins. There are such things as
- 1:46:20essential fats. So, focus on those.
- 1:46:23And that will be the key to helping
- 1:46:24insulin come down. Then, as you have
- 1:46:27found, you have and when you're hungry,
- 1:46:29eat. If you're not hungry, don't eat.
- 1:46:31But, what the person will find as
- 1:46:32they're lowering their insulin,
- 1:46:34all while their metabolic rate is going
- 1:46:36up. They're learning how to burn their
- 1:46:38own fat for fuel, because remember the
- 1:46:40metabolic hybrid, that metaphor, that if
- 1:46:43you want to lose fat, you need to burn
- 1:46:44fat. You're not going to lose fat if
- 1:46:46you're always burning glucose. It's fat
- 1:46:48that you need to burn. And as you start
- 1:46:50burning more fat, you realize that it's
- 1:46:53like the hump on a camel. That hump
- 1:46:55exists because it is a big source of fat
- 1:46:58for that animal to be using its own fat
- 1:47:00for energy. We have our own version of
- 1:47:02that. So, where the you think about the
- 1:47:05average individual who's chubby, they
- 1:47:06have hundreds of thousands of calories
- 1:47:09waiting to be burned in those fat cells.
- 1:47:12It's just that their chronically
- 1:47:13elevated insulin is never letting them
- 1:47:15burn it.
- 1:47:16And so, as the person starts making
- 1:47:18these changes in their diet to lower
- 1:47:20insulin, they now can finally start
- 1:47:22relying on their own fat for fuel. So,
- 1:47:24it's no surprise that their hunger
- 1:47:26starts to come down. Let that be the
- 1:47:28natural way in which you're controlling
- 1:47:30your calories. Don't control your
- 1:47:33calories because you're forcing yourself
- 1:47:34to be hungry and eat less.
- 1:47:36Control your calories because you simply
- 1:47:39aren't hungry.
- 1:47:40So, I have to I'll leave it at this with
- 1:47:42my own sort of anecdotal experience. So,
- 1:47:43I every year do a keto diet for usually
- 1:47:46for about 8 weeks.
- 1:47:47Mhm.
- 1:47:48This time it's going to go on for a
- 1:47:50little bit longer. Um the reason in part
- 1:47:52why it's going to go on a little bit
- 1:47:53longer is I just learned more about
- 1:47:54what's going on in my body, and also
- 1:47:57because I podcast now and do a lot of
- 1:47:58speaking on stage and those kinds of
- 1:48:00things, I see tremendous variance in my
- 1:48:02ability for my brain to articulate what
- 1:48:04I want to say.
- 1:48:05way.
- 1:48:06It's like it's absurd. Yes. I I was
- 1:48:08saying this the other night to the the
- 1:48:10team that were with me here in Los
- 1:48:11Angeles, and I tried to say it to so
- 1:48:13many people.
- 1:48:14As someone that can spend 9 hours a day
- 1:48:17trying to think of the next question to
- 1:48:19ask or trying to remember the research
- 1:48:20or on stage in front of a thousand
- 1:48:22people trying to deliver a story or a
- 1:48:25point, I get to see variance which I've
- 1:48:29never been able to explain.
- 1:48:30Yeah.
- 1:48:31Um where some days I'll go up on stage,
- 1:48:33I'll be in a podcast, and it's like my
- 1:48:35brain and my mouth aren't connected. And
- 1:48:36then on other days, specifically when I
- 1:48:38started doing ketosis or having a
- 1:48:41ketogenic diet,
- 1:48:42Mhm.
- 1:48:43it just flows. Yeah. It just flows so
- 1:48:45well. And I was saying to my team, it
- 1:48:46feels like I'm looking at the world like
- 1:48:48this these days. Like I've got this
- 1:48:50intense I probably anyone that can't see
- 1:48:51me, I just stretched my eyes, but like
- 1:48:53I've got this intense focus on the
- 1:48:54world. Um the other thing I've noticed
- 1:48:56with my diet is
- 1:48:58I
- 1:48:59I get hungry, but not like I used to get
- 1:49:01hungry.
- 1:49:02And then very quickly after I start
- 1:49:04eating,
- 1:49:06I stop.
- 1:49:07Mhm.
- 1:49:08I don't seem to be like doing like these
- 1:49:09I used to kind of binge a little bit.
- 1:49:11Yeah.
- 1:49:12I used to have like a longer eating
- 1:49:13sessions. And my hunger goes very
- 1:49:14quickly.
- 1:49:15Um I also found that I didn't have these
- 1:49:18like fluctuating energy levels
- 1:49:19throughout the day. I didn't crash
- 1:49:21anymore. I used to get like slumps.
- 1:49:23Yeah, for sure.
- 1:49:24I don't slump anymore. And then the
- 1:49:26other thing which a lot of people will
- 1:49:27care mostly about is the the fat, so
- 1:49:29like belly fat. I have never seen
- 1:49:31anything that has stripped belly fat off
- 1:49:33me faster. And I'm talking in a matter
- 1:49:36of weeks that I could
- 1:49:37Yeah.
- 1:49:38you know, count on one hand
- 1:49:40Yeah.
- 1:49:40than
- 1:49:42doing the ketogenic diet. And if I I
- 1:49:43could literally show a picture of my
- 1:49:45scales cuz I have these digital scales
- 1:49:47on the screen and it's just trundling
- 1:49:49along and then there's this cliff edge
- 1:49:52where it goes directly down. And it and
- 1:49:55so much so actually that one of my
- 1:49:56concerns with the ketogenic diet is how
- 1:49:58the hell do I keep my muscle?
- 1:50:00Oh, that's a great question.
- 1:50:01Because my girlfriend, to her credit,
- 1:50:03when I did ketosis the first time, she
- 1:50:05was like, "I've never ever seen you look
- 1:50:07like this." When I took my top off.
- 1:50:10But also, it was quite clear that my
- 1:50:13my muscles had got smaller.
- 1:50:14Mhm.
- 1:50:14I was as lean as but my muscles
- 1:50:16were small.
- 1:50:16Yeah.
- 1:50:17So, with I with with caution this time I
- 1:50:19did ketosis again and I've been
- 1:50:21thinking, "How the do I keep my
- 1:50:22muscles?"
- 1:50:22Yeah. Yeah. Okay, so first of all, let
- 1:50:24me just add a hearty amen. I'm an
- 1:50:26advocate of a ketogenic diet, although
- 1:50:28it can be applied differently across
- 1:50:30different people. But I would say anyone
- 1:50:31would benefit from having some modest
- 1:50:33period of time of elevated ketones, at
- 1:50:36least in some portion of the day. Now,
- 1:50:38how do you maintain muscle mass
- 1:50:41in the midst of such obvious weight
- 1:50:42loss?
- 1:50:44I can only speculate. Now, there are
- 1:50:46peer-reviewed studies that I can cite
- 1:50:49which do support the idea that a human
- 1:50:51can be on a ketogenic diet and have a
- 1:50:53total maintenance of muscle and
- 1:50:55strength. That is published. So, we know
- 1:50:57it's possible, although that isn't that
- 1:50:59doesn't seem to be what happened with
- 1:51:01you.
- 1:51:02I would suspect
- 1:51:04that there were two things
- 1:51:07two things happening, possibly. Now, I'm
- 1:51:09speculating here and I'm pretending to
- 1:51:10be your coach or your expert here.
- 1:51:13One
- 1:51:14could have been that you had relatively
- 1:51:16lower energy during your workouts
- 1:51:18because of a slight degree of
- 1:51:19dehydration.
- 1:51:21And then the other one would be
- 1:51:21calories, which I'll come back to in a
- 1:51:23moment. I just wanted to put it out
- 1:51:24there. So, when insulin comes down, one
- 1:51:26of the other one of the many effects in
- 1:51:28the body is that another hormone comes
- 1:51:31down called aldosterone, which is one
- 1:51:34we've never invoked yet. But low insulin
- 1:51:36leads to lower aldosterone. When
- 1:51:38aldosterone comes down, the kidneys
- 1:51:40become much
- 1:51:42uh begin to eliminate salt and water
- 1:51:45much more rapidly. Now, that's not
- 1:51:47problematic,
- 1:51:48but it does mean that a person does have
- 1:51:51to focus more on hydration and salts.
- 1:51:53So, if someone's going on this strategy
- 1:51:56and they exercise fairly often,
- 1:51:58you need to be much more focused on your
- 1:52:00hydration,
- 1:52:02literally drinking more because you will
- 1:52:04be urinating more,
- 1:52:05which is partly why people's blood
- 1:52:07pressure gets so good so quickly.
- 1:52:10And just to
- 1:52:11pause on that point, there if if someone
- 1:52:13is on one or two blood pressure
- 1:52:15medications and they adopt a ketogenic
- 1:52:16diet, they usually have to stop their
- 1:52:18medications within 2 days cuz their
- 1:52:21blood pressure goes to normal so quickly
- 1:52:23that if they stay on the medication,
- 1:52:24they're going too low. So, one could be
- 1:52:27that you were actually working out a
- 1:52:28little less intensely because of the
- 1:52:30dehydration.
- 1:52:32But then two,
- 1:52:33it's possible that you were eating too
- 1:52:36few calories to actually maintain
- 1:52:38muscle. Muscle is a hungry organ. It is
- 1:52:41metabolically expensive for the body to
- 1:52:43keep that muscle on. And as you start to
- 1:52:46get leaner and leaner,
- 1:52:48it gets harder and harder for the body
- 1:52:50to defend that muscle.
- 1:52:51In fact, that's the difference between
- 1:52:53fasting and starvation. The longest
- 1:52:56known evidence of a fast was a man in
- 1:52:58the UK who fasted for 384 days,
- 1:53:02literally not eating or drinking a
- 1:53:03single calorie. He was under medical
- 1:53:05supervision, getting vitamins and
- 1:53:07minerals and water, and he was went to
- 1:53:09live on went on to live a perfectly
- 1:53:11healthy life. Um so, but what was the
- 1:53:14difference? Why was that not starvation?
- 1:53:16Starvation is when you run out of fat.
- 1:53:19So, you might have gotten to the point
- 1:53:21of so lean that you didn't have enough
- 1:53:23fat to burn to make enough ketones to
- 1:53:26fuel the brain. If you don't have enough
- 1:53:28fat to burn to make enough ketones, and
- 1:53:29the brain is saying,
- 1:53:31"All right, well, I wanted to switch to
- 1:53:33ketones so that I could spare the
- 1:53:34glucose,
- 1:53:36but I can't. There's not enough ketones
- 1:53:38here, so I have to rely 100% on
- 1:53:40glucose."
- 1:53:41But, if you're not eating glucose, now
- 1:53:43the body has to start stripping the
- 1:53:44protein from muscle. And then it sends
- 1:53:47those amino acids to the liver, then the
- 1:53:49liver
- 1:53:50is so capable, it will turn those amino
- 1:53:52acids into glucose.
- 1:53:53So, it turns my muscle
- 1:53:54into glucose to feed the brain. So, my
- 1:53:56comment then, getting finally getting to
- 1:53:58my answer is
- 1:54:00in your version of a ketogenic diet,
- 1:54:02with your level of muscle mass, and your
- 1:54:05inherent metabolic rate based on your
- 1:54:06body size and your activity, you
- 1:54:08probably ought to eat more fat.
- 1:54:10I wasn't actually doing the blood test
- 1:54:12at that point.
- 1:54:13Mhm.
- 1:54:14I'm doing it this time around, but I
- 1:54:15wasn't doing the blood test, so I can
- 1:54:16actually see my keto levels.
- 1:54:17Yeah.
- 1:54:18So, maybe I wasn't even in ketosis cuz I
- 1:54:20was coming off
- 1:54:20and you might have been, but it could
- 1:54:22have been that you were simply not
- 1:54:23eating enough calories. That I have to
- 1:54:25So, this is an instance where
- 1:54:27That's what I'm trying to do this time.
- 1:54:28I'm trying to
- 1:54:28more fat. Like every time you're making
- 1:54:30a steak, put butter on there. And when
- 1:54:32you're drinking a cup of coffee, as
- 1:54:33crazy as it sounds, I I drink yerba mate
- 1:54:35every morning, I will put a big dab of
- 1:54:38butter
- 1:54:39In your coffee?
- 1:54:39dab of butter in my tea, and I'm sipping
- 1:54:42on it while the world's still asleep and
- 1:54:44the kids haven't woken up yet. And so, I
- 1:54:45know because I want to keep my muscle,
- 1:54:48as a guy who's almost 50,
- 1:54:50um I I find that when during my strict
- 1:54:53ketogenic phase, and I'm currently in it
- 1:54:55as well, every January I go to kind of a
- 1:54:57carnivore diet, to and I mostly do it to
- 1:55:00one lean down, but also to check any
- 1:55:02addictions and habits. I don't like
- 1:55:04feeling addicted to things.
- 1:55:06And and my wife will comment and even as
- 1:55:08an almost 50-year-old it's fun to see my
- 1:55:10six-pack coming. I don't want to lose my
- 1:55:12mass, my muscle mass because you have to
- 1:55:14work so hard to get it.
- 1:55:16Yeah.
- 1:55:16And what I find is if I increase my fat,
- 1:55:19I always get plenty of protein.
- 1:55:21But if I increase my fat content, I have
- 1:55:23an easier time maintaining my bulk.
- 1:55:26Are there any downsides of following a
- 1:55:27ketogenic diet that we need to be aware
- 1:55:29of?
- 1:55:30The only downside I can articulate, so
- 1:55:32in fact, I didn't even finish because I
- 1:55:34distracted myself mentioning some of the
- 1:55:36benefits of ketones, but ketones are
- 1:55:38further anti-inflammatory.
- 1:55:40Like they directly reduce inflammation
- 1:55:42in the body by inhibiting inflammatory
- 1:55:44processes and they also improve
- 1:55:46antioxidant defenses, so it helps reduce
- 1:55:49oxidative stress. So ketones do have
- 1:55:51benefits that go beyond even what we've
- 1:55:53taken the time to articulate. If there's
- 1:55:55any negative to a ketogenic diet,
- 1:55:59it could be that you start
- 1:56:02you acutely or you temporarily become
- 1:56:05less metabolically flexible. Now that's
- 1:56:08me invoking a term we haven't brought up
- 1:56:10yet, but metabolic flexibility is is a
- 1:56:12term to refer to the body's ability to
- 1:56:15when it eats glucose, to burn glucose.
- 1:56:18When it's not eating glucose,
- 1:56:20it burns fat. So you're shifting between
- 1:56:22the two metabolic fuels that we outlined
- 1:56:24earlier. When someone has been adhering
- 1:56:26to a ketogenic diet for some time,
- 1:56:29it's almost as if their body is stuck in
- 1:56:31fat-burning mode. And that if you and I,
- 1:56:34being in such adapted ketogenic state as
- 1:56:36we are, if we were to go to lunch and
- 1:56:38eat two bagels and a sugary drink,
- 1:56:42it would take us a very long time to
- 1:56:44clear that glucose from our blood.
- 1:56:46Um much longer than otherwise. Like
- 1:56:48let's say we go out with the production
- 1:56:49team, they're eating a normal higher
- 1:56:51carb diet, all things equal, same body
- 1:56:54size, same activity, their glucose
- 1:56:56levels would come up and down in 90
- 1:56:57minutes for
- 1:56:58perhaps. Yours and mine may take 180
- 1:57:01minutes to come back down. So the person
- 1:57:03may say, well gosh Steven and Ben are no
- 1:57:06longer burning glucose very well.
- 1:57:09And that's true in that one moment
- 1:57:11our bodies had almost forgotten what it
- 1:57:14was like to burn a bunch of glucose
- 1:57:15because we had adapted to fat burning.
- 1:57:18So what about the gut microbiome?
- 1:57:20Oh yeah.
- 1:57:21Cuz cuz I told someone who is a
- 1:57:23nutritionist that I was doing a keto
- 1:57:25diet at the moment and they said oh your
- 1:57:27poor gut.
- 1:57:28Ah yes, well what a naive
- 1:57:31thing to say if I may gently reprimand
- 1:57:34your friend. There's no evidence to
- 1:57:36support that there's any harmful change
- 1:57:37in the microbiome. In fact, a paper was
- 1:57:40just published that looked at a man who
- 1:57:42went from a normal omnivorous human diet
- 1:57:44with abundant plant matter to a purely
- 1:57:47carnivorous diet.
- 1:57:48Literally zero carb.
- 1:57:50And they documented precisely no change
- 1:57:53in his microbiome. None whatsoever.
- 1:57:55But is he eating plants?
- 1:57:57No. Well he had been eating plants. So
- 1:58:00the case study was a person eating a
- 1:58:01normal
- 1:58:02diet of of plants and meat. A normal
- 1:58:05omnivore diet. And and then looked at
- 1:58:07the microbiome and then adapted to a
- 1:58:09purely carnivorous diet. Purely meat.
- 1:58:12And the microbiome didn't change at all.
- 1:58:14What's the time period?
- 1:58:15Months I think. The problem with the
- 1:58:17microbiome, the reason I don't take
- 1:58:19microbiome research too seriously as a
- 1:58:22scientist is that it is a big black box.
- 1:58:26You You came from the UK to London to to
- 1:58:30to LA to California. If we took a
- 1:58:32microbiome sample analysis of your time
- 1:58:34in the UK
- 1:58:36now it would be different now. Even
- 1:58:38though you're eating the same but you're
- 1:58:39drinking different water, you're
- 1:58:40breathing different air.
- 1:58:42Things I was just on a plane from Utah
- 1:58:45to California. Give me a day or so I
- 1:58:47would have some sort of shift in my
- 1:58:49microbiome. So the microbiome can change
- 1:58:51in response to all kinds of things.
- 1:58:54The idea that you somehow have decimated
- 1:58:56your microbiome because you aren't
- 1:58:58eating fiber is absolutely false. That
- 1:59:00is That is completely false. Now, there
- 1:59:03might be a change in some of the
- 1:59:05population of your microbiome, more of
- 1:59:07one, less of another, but there's no
- 1:59:09evidence to suggest that's problematic.
- 1:59:11Your microbiome is intact. Those
- 1:59:13bacteria do not die. They're just simply
- 1:59:15metabolizing other things. Maybe they're
- 1:59:17relying more on short-chain fatty acids.
- 1:59:19Maybe they're relying more on amino
- 1:59:20acids. They're not eating as They're not
- 1:59:22eating fiber, but there's still stuff in
- 1:59:25the meat or the eggs that the microbiome
- 1:59:28will eat.
- 1:59:29But if eating lots of plants does give
- 1:59:32me a more diverse gut microbiome, then
- 1:59:34if I stop eating plants, I'm going to
- 1:59:37have a less diverse gut microbiome.
- 1:59:38but Steven,
- 1:59:40but even then there's a bit of an
- 1:59:41assumption built into the question
- 1:59:42because it's Do we know that the
- 1:59:45microbiome will be less diverse? The
- 1:59:46case study I just mentioned found that
- 1:59:48in this one single man, it didn't change
- 1:59:50his microbiome at all. It was the exact
- 1:59:53same populations in all the same
- 1:59:55proportions.
- 1:59:56Because isn't the Aren't the plants like
- 1:59:58feeding the bacteria?
- 2:00:00Yeah, yeah, so the the fiber is. So,
- 2:00:02fiber will, but again,
- 2:00:05it's not That's not the only thing
- 2:00:07bacteria can eat. Bacteria can eat fats.
- 2:00:10Bacteria can eat amino acids. They can
- 2:00:12eat glutamine, for example. They
- 2:00:15They can even meat will have a little
- 2:00:16bit of glucose in it. Where the muscle
- 2:00:19has something called glycogen. And so,
- 2:00:21there's you know, trace amounts of
- 2:00:23glucose in even the meat that you're
- 2:00:24eating. So,
- 2:00:26I do not look at the argument that, you
- 2:00:29know, you're destroying your microbiome.
- 2:00:31That has no That has no scientific
- 2:00:34support. You may be changing your
- 2:00:36microbiome, but who's to say that's a
- 2:00:38bad change? Maybe it's a better change.
- 2:00:40You certainly are feeling better. You're
- 2:00:42thinking better. You're getting leaner.
- 2:00:43Your insulin sensitivity's improved.
- 2:00:45Cognition's improved. I would argue if
- 2:00:47there is a change in your microbiome,
- 2:00:49it's probably one that's for the best.
- 2:00:53And no one can prove that wrong. As much
- 2:00:55as I just stated that comment in a
- 2:00:57speculative fashion, it's speculative
- 2:00:59because there's no evidence. This is why
- 2:01:01I look at the microbiome and just say,
- 2:01:03"Yeah, it appears to matter, but in ways
- 2:01:05that we don't know."
- 2:01:07But the the You agree with the argument
- 2:01:09that if I sat here now and I ate
- 2:01:13a wide range of plants for the next,
- 2:01:16let's say, 6 months, when you analyzed
- 2:01:19my gut microbiome, it would be much more
- 2:01:21diverse.
- 2:01:21I'm not agreeing to that, really. I
- 2:01:23don't know if that's true.
- 2:01:25Um And again, I would cite that one case
- 2:01:28report I just mentioned now, which is
- 2:01:30the a man who did this, they reported
- 2:01:33that the microbiome was identical. That
- 2:01:35there was no significant change.
- 2:01:37But that's just one man, though.
- 2:01:38It was one man. It was a case report.
- 2:01:40Which is not a randomized clinical
- 2:01:42study.
- 2:01:43So, um but even still,
- 2:01:46I I with my speculation uh um
- 2:01:49heavy-handed here, I would say probably
- 2:01:52more plants would result in a more
- 2:01:55diverse
- 2:01:56microbiome.
- 2:01:58But I would say
- 2:02:00But then the next step is a harder one,
- 2:02:02which is is that good or bad? I don't
- 2:02:04know. Maybe all you're doing is
- 2:02:06promoting the growth of bacteria that
- 2:02:08make more gas.
- 2:02:10Because they're fermenting the fiber and
- 2:02:11you just have more flatulence as a
- 2:02:13result of it. People dieticians will
- 2:02:15say, "Well, a diverse microbiome is a
- 2:02:17good microbiome." Well, prove it.
- 2:02:20How do we know that? Like, how can you
- 2:02:22prove that to me as a basic scientist? I
- 2:02:25want to see the hard evidence.
- 2:02:27Because what I can prove is that we can
- 2:02:29take humans who are overweight and
- 2:02:31diabetic and hypertensive eating a
- 2:02:33standard American or global diet and put
- 2:02:36them under a ketogenic diet, which is
- 2:02:38going to be much simpler
- 2:02:40diet, and yet every clinical marker gets
- 2:02:42better. And so, if someone were to say,
- 2:02:44"Yeah, but sure, you reversed your
- 2:02:46diabetes and your hypertension, but your
- 2:02:47poor microbiome." I would say, "Well, I
- 2:02:49don't care about my microbiome. I care
- 2:02:51about the human." And so, if there's
- 2:02:53less diversity, but every single
- 2:02:54clinical marker has gotten better,
- 2:02:56perhaps more diversity is not what we
- 2:02:58want in our bacteria. I'm And I'm
- 2:03:00speculating, but so are the is the
- 2:03:02person who states that.
- 2:03:04Yes, I'm I'm not aware of um research
- 2:03:07that links the two. Um
- 2:03:10But I mean, I could always have a look,
- 2:03:11but um I would
- 2:03:13I I I was always under the assumption
- 2:03:15that a more diverse microbiome is a
- 2:03:17healthier person.
- 2:03:18I don't know. Yeah, but but do you do
- 2:03:20you feel healthier now?
- 2:03:22Um
- 2:03:23feel healthier. I certainly feel And And
- 2:03:26it's only been a short amount of time,
- 2:03:27so I don't know what what my health
- 2:03:29might look like if I'd done this for
- 2:03:30like 2 years.
- 2:03:32Right, cuz then that could be a really
- 2:03:33sort of deeper change to um
- 2:03:36my whole composition.
- 2:03:38for more than 2 years, and they're
- 2:03:39they're great.
- 2:03:40Because some of the some of the changes
- 2:03:42that occur in our health take time. Now,
- 2:03:45you you show this a lot in your work
- 2:03:46with insulin resistance, that if you're
- 2:03:48insulin resistance for 10 years, your
- 2:03:51brain, I think I read in your work, is
- 2:03:52like
- 2:03:53It ages.
- 2:03:54It ages by an an additional 2 years, is
- 2:03:56that correct?
- 2:03:57accelerates the aging.
- 2:03:58I wonder the same thing with like my gut
- 2:04:00microbiome. If I'm
- 2:04:02if my gut microbiome is not diverse, so
- 2:04:05I have a very sort of narrow diet or,
- 2:04:08you know, I'm not getting I'm not eating
- 2:04:09my plants,
- 2:04:11could it take me a couple of years to
- 2:04:12really understand the the net negative
- 2:04:14impact that has on my overall health?
- 2:04:16It It's entirely possible. Yeah, yeah, I
- 2:04:19would just I would just ask that we be
- 2:04:21careful with the assumptions that if
- 2:04:23there is an an increase in diversity
- 2:04:26with more plant matter,
- 2:04:28that's an if. Um is that change
- 2:04:32beneficial?
- 2:04:33Are the bacteria that we're now
- 2:04:34promoting the growth of, are they better
- 2:04:36for us, or are they just bacteria that
- 2:04:38exist in order to handle more fiber? And
- 2:04:40again, the outcome being that it perhaps
- 2:04:43is just making more gas.
- 2:04:45Um you know, the more plants you eat,
- 2:04:46the more gas you have to produce by
- 2:04:48fermenting more fiber. What if those
- 2:04:49bacteria are only existing to just eat
- 2:04:52the fiber and not actually improve the
- 2:04:54human host at all?
- 2:04:57Psychotosis.
- 2:05:00Possible to live in a It's I think one
- 2:05:02of the important points on ketosis is
- 2:05:04when I do my blood keto test, I
- 2:05:06fluctuate wildly. After I've gone for a
- 2:05:08run, my ketone levels are super high.
- 2:05:10Sometimes later at night, I'm just on
- 2:05:12the verge of ketosis sometimes. Um
- 2:05:15and I think that's interesting because
- 2:05:17we don't have to live in this
- 2:05:18necessarily deep state of ketosis the
- 2:05:21whole time. We can fluctuate uh
- 2:05:23a little bit in
- 2:05:24Yeah.
- 2:05:25Maybe even sometimes drop
- 2:05:26thought on it is that
- 2:05:28a person would benefit from some state
- 2:05:30of ketosis on on a frequent basis. If
- 2:05:33for no other reason than to really give
- 2:05:35the brain a heavy dose of just straight
- 2:05:37energy.
- 2:05:39Um not that everyone needs to be as
- 2:05:40strict as perhaps you and I are being at
- 2:05:42the moment. Um but I would say the more
- 2:05:44a person has a disorder or a disease
- 2:05:46that benefits from ketosis, the more
- 2:05:48than they ought to focus on it. Like if
- 2:05:50someone has type 2 diabetes, if they
- 2:05:52adopt a ketogenic diet, they will be off
- 2:05:54all of their diabetes medications in
- 2:05:55months. All of them.
- 2:05:58Um if someone has epilepsy,
- 2:06:01if they're or migraine headaches, if
- 2:06:02some of the if from 19
- 2:06:04uh 13, I think, was the first published
- 2:06:06report on this. If there's someone who
- 2:06:08suffers from migraines, as long as
- 2:06:10they're in ketosis, they may never have
- 2:06:12another migraine again.
- 2:06:14I mean, it is completely curative or
- 2:06:15preventative for the disorder. Same with
- 2:06:17epilepsy. There many forms of epilepsy.
- 2:06:19So, depending on the person,
- 2:06:21they would benefit from being ketosis
- 2:06:23forever. For everyone else who's just
- 2:06:26sort of a normal individual who wants to
- 2:06:27be lean and keep their brain healthy and
- 2:06:30happy, etc., I would say it's generally
- 2:06:32prudent to just control your carbs, be
- 2:06:35mindful of the type of carbohydrate
- 2:06:36you're eating, and as I said earlier,
- 2:06:38just try to focus on the carbs that
- 2:06:40don't come from bags and boxes with
- 2:06:42barcodes. I'm actually quite liberal in
- 2:06:45my view when it comes to whole fruits
- 2:06:47and vegetables.
- 2:06:48I would say eat them, enjoy them
- 2:06:50liberally, but then also make sure
- 2:06:52you're getting some good protein and fat
- 2:06:54because there's no such thing as an
- 2:06:55essential carbohydrate. That sounds
- 2:06:57controversial, but humans do not need,
- 2:07:00we have no requirement for carbohydrate.
- 2:07:02We do have requirement for fat and
- 2:07:04protein.
- 2:07:05What about artificial sweeteners? It's
- 2:07:07one of the things that I I'm tempted by
- 2:07:11when I'm on a ketosis diet is like the
- 2:07:14soda zeros of the world or the diet
- 2:07:17sodas of the world. What impact does
- 2:07:19that have on my insulin levels, etc.?
- 2:07:20Yeah, yeah, great question. There is
- 2:07:22such a breadth of of diversity when it
- 2:07:25comes to sweeteners, from artificial to
- 2:07:27natural to another rare sugar more and
- 2:07:31more, you know, there's all these random
- 2:07:32I'm not random, but a very broad
- 2:07:35spectrum of molecules that we have
- 2:07:37developed or found that taste like sugar
- 2:07:40but don't have the effect of sugar. So,
- 2:07:42on on the good end are things like that
- 2:07:45have been shown to have no insulin
- 2:07:47effect.
- 2:07:48And so, you know, I appreciate everyone
- 2:07:50listening letting me kind of stay with
- 2:07:51that as my framework
- 2:07:53because people are going to go on and
- 2:07:55criticize all kinds of other things
- 2:07:56about other sweeteners, and that's just
- 2:07:58too broad. That's a topic for a a whole
- 2:08:00book. With regards to just insulin, on
- 2:08:03the good end where they have no effect,
- 2:08:05it would be one as common as aspartame.
- 2:08:07So, like diet drinks, not the zero
- 2:08:10drinks,
- 2:08:11but the diet drinks will have aspartame
- 2:08:13as the sweetener.
- 2:08:14Is there a difference?
- 2:08:15There is a difference, and I'll get to
- 2:08:16that other one in a moment.
- 2:08:18So, I should be having diet instead of
- 2:08:19zero?
- 2:08:19Well, I personally go to diet rather
- 2:08:22than zero, um but that's because
- 2:08:24aspartame is the sole sweetener in the
- 2:08:27zero in the diet rather and it has no
- 2:08:30effect on insulin. So too erythritol
- 2:08:33sorry erythritol is a little right
- 2:08:35around aspartame is generally a good one
- 2:08:37but monk fruit extract stevia and
- 2:08:40especially allulose those are inert when
- 2:08:42it comes to insulin.
- 2:08:44You know allulose stevia monk fruit
- 2:08:46extract
- 2:08:48aspartame no effect erythritol no effect
- 2:08:51but erythritol that ending OL
- 2:08:55is reflective of a class of sweetener
- 2:08:57called a sugar alcohol and that does not
- 2:08:59mean it's alcoholic that just refers to
- 2:09:00the actual chemical structure that puts
- 2:09:02it in the alcohol family. Once you get
- 2:09:05into the sugar alcohols you start to get
- 2:09:07a little problematic.
- 2:09:09Where erythritol is a good one and
- 2:09:11xylitol is generally a good one but then
- 2:09:14you get to things like maltitol and
- 2:09:15mannitol and they do have an insulin
- 2:09:18effect.
- 2:09:18And what what's what kind of foods have
- 2:09:20they some?
- 2:09:20Yeah so often like you can get mannitol
- 2:09:24in like artificially sweetened chocolate
- 2:09:26sometimes for reasons that I don't know.
- 2:09:28I don't know why the food formula that
- 2:09:29puts them in some things and not other
- 2:09:30things. The
- 2:09:32the problem I chuckle because it becomes
- 2:09:34so apparent with some of those
- 2:09:36artificial sweeteners like the sugar
- 2:09:38alcohols is that as you eat them you
- 2:09:41taste it sweet in your mouth
- 2:09:43and it doesn't have any caloric value in
- 2:09:45the body because it stays in the
- 2:09:47intestines.
- 2:09:49And this is something that is largely
- 2:09:51unique to the sugar alcohols where as it
- 2:09:53stays in the intestines it starts
- 2:09:55pulling in water
- 2:09:57from the body which starts to create a
- 2:10:00fairly inconvenient degree of flatulence
- 2:10:02and diarrhea.
- 2:10:04And so a person will know if they've
- 2:10:05eaten too many of those types of
- 2:10:07sweeteners because their intestines will
- 2:10:09tell them so.
- 2:10:11So but also on that spectrum kind of in
- 2:10:13the middle is the one that's in the zero
- 2:10:15drinks which is one called sucralose.
- 2:10:19And while sucralose is generally not a
- 2:10:21problem with insulin It is a sweetener
- 2:10:24that has been shown to cross the
- 2:10:25blood-brain barrier.
- 2:10:27And so the reason I avoid the zero
- 2:10:29drinks and refer or go to the diet
- 2:10:32drinks is that aspartame does no such
- 2:10:34thing. Aspartame just gets divided into
- 2:10:36amino acids. We just digest it and
- 2:10:38absorb amino acids. Sucralose will go
- 2:10:42can cross the blood-brain barrier and I
- 2:10:44don't know what it's doing there, but I
- 2:10:45don't want it there.
- 2:10:47And so I avoid the zero drinks because I
- 2:10:49don't want that sweetener.
- 2:10:52But but personally, um when I'm adhering
- 2:10:55to this diet, a diet soda is my actual
- 2:10:58indulgence where I want something sweet
- 2:11:00um and yet I don't want the metabolic
- 2:11:02effect of it.
- 2:11:04One thing you mentioned earlier which
- 2:11:05I've been thinking a lot about is salt.
- 2:11:07And I think a lot about salt because I
- 2:11:09went to the doctor many years ago and I
- 2:11:10think I was using this like Maggie
- 2:11:11seasoning that I put on my food. And the
- 2:11:14doctor said to me that my salt levels
- 2:11:16were too high.
- 2:11:18And I And then I've heard since then
- 2:11:20from other people that we're actually
- 2:11:21probably not getting enough salt in our
- 2:11:22diet.
- 2:11:23Yeah. So I'm interested to hear that
- 2:11:25your physician would have said your salt
- 2:11:26is too high. That is very rare that that
- 2:11:29gets measured. Not salt sodium I think
- 2:11:31he said. Yep, yep. He could have
- 2:11:32measured sodium and that could have been
- 2:11:33higher. They absolutely could have. It's
- 2:11:34just not common. So salt has
- 2:11:37has earned a terrible reputation because
- 2:11:40of a series of studies that implicated
- 2:11:42salt consumption as a cause of high
- 2:11:44blood pressure.
- 2:11:46And and really briefly, as a as a
- 2:11:49momentary physiology
- 2:11:51that is a real effect. If you and I were
- 2:11:54to go eat salt, our body for the next
- 2:11:56several hours afterwards
- 2:11:58would retain its water in order to
- 2:12:00balance out the salt so that we didn't
- 2:12:02get too salty. So we would retain water
- 2:12:04in order to keep our salt at a normal
- 2:12:06level.
- 2:12:08And so that could be reflected by an
- 2:12:10elevated blood pressure.
- 2:12:12Um however, multiple huge studies have
- 2:12:16found that if you go to a population of
- 2:12:18humans that have high blood pressure and
- 2:12:21you tell them you need to cut your salt
- 2:12:23in order to correct your blood pressure,
- 2:12:25they may at most move their blood
- 2:12:27pressure by one or two points. It has an
- 2:12:29absolutely negligible, irrelevant
- 2:12:32effect.
- 2:12:34Um and it's because salt is not a key
- 2:12:36contributor to blood pressure. It's
- 2:12:37actually insulin resistance. Insulin
- 2:12:39resistance will force the body to hold
- 2:12:41on to salt. Insulin resistance will
- 2:12:43force the blood vessels to be very
- 2:12:44constricted. All of which play together
- 2:12:46to make for a very high blood pressure.
- 2:12:48So, as much as we have been telling the
- 2:12:50world that we should be cutting back
- 2:12:52salt, no, we should have been telling
- 2:12:54them to cut back on what spikes your
- 2:12:55insulin, refined starches and sugars.
- 2:12:58But with regards to salt, it's
- 2:12:59interesting for me to note where did
- 2:13:02that whole view come from?
- 2:13:04Within the United States decades ago,
- 2:13:06there was a study that was published and
- 2:13:09they called it the DASH diet. Dietary
- 2:13:12Approaches to Stop Hypertension, D A S
- 2:13:15H, the DASH diet. And in the DASH diet,
- 2:13:18one of the critical changes was to tell
- 2:13:21people to eat less salt.
- 2:13:25And when they found that when people
- 2:13:26adopt a DASH diet, it's amazing, their
- 2:13:28blood pressure goes down. However,
- 2:13:31unfortunately, they also tell people to
- 2:13:33do lots of other things with the DASH
- 2:13:34diet. Like when they tell someone to go
- 2:13:36on the DASH diet, they also tell them to
- 2:13:38eat less sugar and less refined starches
- 2:13:41and sugars.
- 2:13:42Well, it's possible, indeed, I would say
- 2:13:46it's absolutely the case, that what's
- 2:13:47actually lowering their blood pressure
- 2:13:49isn't that they cut their salt back,
- 2:13:52it's that they were cutting their
- 2:13:52refined starches and sugars back. And
- 2:13:55it's that that had the main effect. And
- 2:13:57the cutting the salt was just some
- 2:13:58innocent bystander. But to put a fine
- 2:14:01point on it, in human studies,
- 2:14:04if you have humans cut back their salt
- 2:14:07considerably, they become insulin
- 2:14:09resistant.
- 2:14:11So, you take a healthy group of humans,
- 2:14:12say you need to eat less salt, and they
- 2:14:15do so. If you measure them a week later,
- 2:14:17while they're adhering to this, they
- 2:14:18will be significantly more insulin
- 2:14:20resistant than before they ever cut back
- 2:14:23their salt. It's one of the ironies of
- 2:14:25the whole scenario where a physician may
- 2:14:28be telling a patient with high blood
- 2:14:29pressure, you need to cut back your
- 2:14:31salt.
- 2:14:32And they end up eating less salt, and
- 2:14:35yet their their blood pressure their
- 2:14:36blood pressure gets worse.
- 2:14:38It's because the main contributor to
- 2:14:40high blood pressure is insulin
- 2:14:41resistance. And by telling them to cut
- 2:14:42back on their salt, you made them more
- 2:14:44insulin resistant. And that whole
- 2:14:46mechanism is because one of insulin's
- 2:14:49many, many effects is to want the body
- 2:14:51to hold on to salt and water.
- 2:14:53And so, if you start cutting your salt,
- 2:14:56all of a sudden insulin says, well,
- 2:14:58there's little salt coming in. I need to
- 2:14:59do what I can to retain whatever salt we
- 2:15:01do have.
- 2:15:02And so, it starts retaining salt and
- 2:15:04water more in order to try to offset the
- 2:15:07lack of salt coming in. And while
- 2:15:09insulin's going higher and higher, the
- 2:15:11body's becoming more and more insulin
- 2:15:13resistant.
- 2:15:14So, salt restriction can cause insulin
- 2:15:17resistance in humans.
- 2:15:19You talk about four pillars to
- 2:15:22eating
- 2:15:23Mhm.
- 2:15:24in your book Why We Get Sick. You
- 2:15:25outline these four essential pillars to
- 2:15:27develop a strategy for maintaining low
- 2:15:29insulin levels and combating insulin
- 2:15:31resistance. What are the four pillars?
- 2:15:34Yes, so when it comes to controlling
- 2:15:36insulin resistance, the key is to manage
- 2:15:38macronutrients.
- 2:15:39And the best way to manage
- 2:15:41macronutrients is going to be a strategy
- 2:15:42that helps lower insulin. Lowering
- 2:15:45insulin is the key to both slow insulin
- 2:15:47resistance and fast insulin resistance.
- 2:15:49So, the more the strategy lowers
- 2:15:51insulin, the more effective it's going
- 2:15:52to be. And there are poor There are four
- 2:15:55pillars. So, the first one, control
- 2:15:57carbohydrates. Second, prioritize
- 2:16:00protein. Third, don't fear fat.
- 2:16:04And then fourth, after the first three
- 2:16:06have been taken care of, four,
- 2:16:08frequently fast.
- 2:16:10So, with the first one, very briefly, by
- 2:16:13control carbohydrates, I mean that it is
- 2:16:15time to focus more on whole fruits and
- 2:16:17vegetables. Eat them, don't drink them.
- 2:16:20And then don't get your carbohydrates
- 2:16:21from bags and boxes with barcodes. That
- 2:16:23the more you're opening up a package and
- 2:16:25getting your chips or your crackers or
- 2:16:27your cereal or your bread, the more
- 2:16:29you're going to be spiking your glucose
- 2:16:30and your insulin.
- 2:16:32Keep that on the shelves at the grocery
- 2:16:34store. Focus on whole fruits and
- 2:16:36vegetables. That's going to be the key
- 2:16:37for number one, control carbs. Now,
- 2:16:40while you're eating fewer carbohydrates,
- 2:16:44you need to eat something. And so,
- 2:16:45prioritize protein. I would say
- 2:16:47particularly animal source protein,
- 2:16:50which is the best source of all of the
- 2:16:52amino acids that humans need. And then
- 2:16:55with those proteins will come fat.
- 2:16:57Don't fear that fat. That's number
- 2:16:59three. Fat is very satiating when
- 2:17:01combined with protein. When fat and
- 2:17:03protein come together, we digest it
- 2:17:05better.
- 2:17:07Sometimes people will find that if they
- 2:17:08just have a scoop of whey protein, it
- 2:17:10can be very upsetting on their stomach.
- 2:17:13It's because we're not supposed to eat
- 2:17:14protein alone. In nature, that never
- 2:17:16happens. In nature, protein always comes
- 2:17:19with fat. That's how we should eat it.
- 2:17:21We digest it better. And human studies
- 2:17:23have shown that when a human eats pure
- 2:17:25protein, there is some degree of muscle
- 2:17:27growth, albeit microscopically
- 2:17:29minuscule. But when we eat protein with
- 2:17:32fat, we have significantly greater
- 2:17:34muscle growth than we do with the
- 2:17:36protein alone. So, that is the three
- 2:17:38pillars that encompass the
- 2:17:40macronutrients or the big parts of our
- 2:17:42diet. But once a person has done that,
- 2:17:45then they are well positioned
- 2:17:48to adopt a strategy, a structured
- 2:17:50strategy of fasting. And that can be
- 2:17:53There are as many ways to fast as there
- 2:17:55are people who want to do it. There's no
- 2:17:57right way or wrong way. My goal by
- 2:18:00invoking that fourth principle, and and
- 2:18:02I do think it should come last once
- 2:18:04you've learned how to eat better food.
- 2:18:06Your your your body has adapted to
- 2:18:08burning its own fat for fuel.
- 2:18:10But it can take it can take intermittent
- 2:18:13fasting where it's one meal of the day.
- 2:18:15You're fasting through it can do where
- 2:18:17people do alternate day fasting. There
- 2:18:19are countless different ways to do it.
- 2:18:21Even if I'm in ketosis?
- 2:18:22Then you don't need to do it as much cuz
- 2:18:24you're already lowering your insulin. So
- 2:18:26if a person's already in ketosis in
- 2:18:28fact, if a person were in ketosis and
- 2:18:30frequently fasting
- 2:18:32depending on how lean they are, it's
- 2:18:33going to become extremely difficult to
- 2:18:35retain muscle.
- 2:18:36Yeah.
- 2:18:37So those are the four pillars. It will
- 2:18:38be an extraordinarily effective way to
- 2:18:41address insulin resistance. But the
- 2:18:42problem as I started when I
- 2:18:45that I mentioned
- 2:18:47is that while these concepts are simple,
- 2:18:49that does not mean they're easy. Because
- 2:18:52humans show addiction addictive
- 2:18:55tendencies to only one macronutrient.
- 2:18:58Not fats, not proteins.
- 2:19:01All of the evidence of the neurobiology
- 2:19:02of addiction in humans points to
- 2:19:04carbohydrates. It And so as much as I
- 2:19:07lay out this simple plan, it can be
- 2:19:09difficult. And this is why
- 2:19:11this self-discipline required is
- 2:19:13difficult enough that it's why people
- 2:19:16find that they have to result in you
- 2:19:18know relying on drugs for these kinds of
- 2:19:20things.
- 2:19:22Physical activity?
- 2:19:24Mhm.
- 2:19:24Exercise?
- 2:19:25Useful for keeping my
- 2:19:28insulin levels in check?
- 2:19:29Yeah. Yeah, I'm really glad you brought
- 2:19:31up exercise. I'm an enormous advocate of
- 2:19:33exercise.
- 2:19:35The best exercise to improve insulin
- 2:19:37sensitivity is the one you'll do. And so
- 2:19:39if someone listening to this is an
- 2:19:4080-year-old grandma
- 2:19:42if she if her form of exercise is
- 2:19:44walking around the street down around
- 2:19:46the block with her girlfriends. But then
- 2:19:48if someone else has the ability to go
- 2:19:50cross-country skiing or CrossFit, do it.
- 2:19:53So the best exercise is the one you'll
- 2:19:54do.
- 2:19:55Now having said that
- 2:19:57the better exercise is the one that
- 2:19:59you'll do that keeps muscle.
- 2:20:01Um muscle-building work is going to be
- 2:20:04minute for minute a more effective way
- 2:20:06of improving insulin sensitivity than
- 2:20:08than any kind of aerobic activity. And
- 2:20:10that's because muscle is the great
- 2:20:12consumer of glucose.
- 2:20:14Um and back to the In fact, not only
- 2:20:17does muscle eat the most glucose from
- 2:20:19the blood, but it's also how it eats the
- 2:20:22glucose when it's exercising. So,
- 2:20:24earlier we talked about how insulin kind
- 2:20:27of comes and knocks on the door of the
- 2:20:28muscle cell. And then the muscle cell
- 2:20:30will open the door and allow the glucose
- 2:20:31to come in, thereby lowering blood
- 2:20:33glucose. Unless the muscle is
- 2:20:35exercising. When a muscle is exercising,
- 2:20:38and I'm kind of mimicking the
- 2:20:40contraction and relaxion relaxation of a
- 2:20:42muscle,
- 2:20:44when the muscle is exercising, it has
- 2:20:46its own way of opening those doors. So,
- 2:20:49there's an insulin-independent
- 2:20:52method where the muscle cell essentially
- 2:20:55tells insulin,
- 2:20:56"Insulin, I know normally I have to wait
- 2:20:58for you to come and open these doors,
- 2:21:00but I'm so hungry during this exercise
- 2:21:02that I'm not going to wait." And so, the
- 2:21:04doors just open. So, the contracting
- 2:21:06muscle has its own way to rush to pull
- 2:21:09the glucose in, which means, of course,
- 2:21:12that a person's going to have an easier
- 2:21:14time controlling their blood glucose,
- 2:21:16which in turn would mean a better time
- 2:21:18controlling insulin. But,
- 2:21:20the more muscle a person has, the easier
- 2:21:23it is.
- 2:21:24And this could be one of the reasons
- 2:21:26why, if you look at longevity
- 2:21:29and look at the markers of muscle
- 2:21:30strength versus the markers of
- 2:21:33cardiovascular aerobic fitness,
- 2:21:36the aerobic fitness markers are terrible
- 2:21:38predictors of longevity. It's muscle and
- 2:21:40strength that predicts longevity for
- 2:21:43multiple reasons, including just the
- 2:21:44very active living and moving, but also
- 2:21:47because if you have more muscle, you're
- 2:21:49going to control your glucose better,
- 2:21:51which means you're going to control your
- 2:21:52insulin better. Then you're back to
- 2:21:54these variables that people use to
- 2:21:55predict or what are the most accurate
- 2:21:58indicators of longevity? It's who has
- 2:22:00the best glucose control. More muscle
- 2:22:02helps that happen.
- 2:22:04There's a big debate around whether we
- 2:22:06should be calorie restricting and
- 2:22:08low-fat diet, whether we should be
- 2:22:10calorie restricting in a moderate fat
- 2:22:12diet, or calorie restricting in a
- 2:22:14low-carb diet.
- 2:22:16What's What's your take on that?
- 2:22:18Yeah, I am unabashedly in favor of
- 2:22:20carbohydrate restriction. Um I I would
- 2:22:22say for two reasons.
- 2:22:24Um that one reason I think that
- 2:22:26carbohydrates should be the
- 2:22:27macronutrient that is most scrutinized
- 2:22:29is because it's the one we eat the most
- 2:22:30of. 70% of all calories consumed
- 2:22:33globally come from carbohydrates.
- 2:22:35That is the one that has the biggest
- 2:22:37insulin effect. For And that's a problem
- 2:22:39for all the reasons we've discussed. But
- 2:22:41two,
- 2:22:43carbohydrates are not essential. Um this
- 2:22:45is controversial. People don't like to
- 2:22:47acknowledge it, but there is literally
- 2:22:49no biological need that humans have for
- 2:22:52carbohydrate. Um the In the United
- 2:22:55States, a report decades ago from the
- 2:22:57Department of Agriculture looking at the
- 2:23:00needs of human nutrition,
- 2:23:03there's a quote there, and I'm not going
- 2:23:04to get it exactly right, but I'll get it
- 2:23:06pretty close.
- 2:23:08It stated in this document that the
- 2:23:09lower limit of carbohydrate consumption
- 2:23:11in humans is zero.
- 2:23:14In other words, there is no such thing
- 2:23:16as an essential carbohydrate. Now, I'm
- 2:23:17not saying, "Well, then let's not eat
- 2:23:19any of them." No. But I am saying, "Why
- 2:23:22is that the one we focus the most on as
- 2:23:2570% of all calories globally are coming
- 2:23:28from that one?" You're telling me that
- 2:23:29we Most of what we eat comes from what
- 2:23:31we don't need. Why not put the focus on
- 2:23:34the things we do need? There are such
- 2:23:36things as essential fatty acids. Let's
- 2:23:38eat fat. There are such things as
- 2:23:40essential amino acids. So, let's eat
- 2:23:42protein and make sure we get what we
- 2:23:44need. And then, on any remainder of the
- 2:23:47plate, we can get some other things that
- 2:23:49we want to nibble on, like plants.
- 2:23:51Why don't we just cycle this off and
- 2:23:53just take a Zempic then?
- 2:23:54Ah, yeah, great question. So, the the I
- 2:23:57have a I have kept my finger on the
- 2:23:59pulse of the whole field of gut-derived
- 2:24:02hormones, which is what we talk about
- 2:24:03with these weight-loss drugs, almost
- 2:24:05since their beginning. My dissertation
- 2:24:07work was in a lab, one of the first
- 2:24:09funded labs to look at these drugs,
- 2:24:11although in the context of diabetes, and
- 2:24:14then it's blossomed into the context in
- 2:24:16the use of obesity. This This is the
- 2:24:19class of drug, GLP-1 receptor agonist.
- 2:24:21First of all, what is GLP-1? GLP-1 is a
- 2:24:24hormone that we all make from our guts.
- 2:24:27Our small intestine will make GLP-1.
- 2:24:30We're making it all the time to varying
- 2:24:31degrees. Some things we eat will result
- 2:24:34in a higher GLP-1, sometimes it'll be a
- 2:24:37lower GLP-1. Like, for example, a paper
- 2:24:39just published a few months ago found
- 2:24:41that if you have people eat the exact
- 2:24:43same meal of calories, but lower carb or
- 2:24:46higher carb, the lower carb version of
- 2:24:48the meal will increase GLP-1 three times
- 2:24:51higher in the blood than the high carb
- 2:24:53version of the meal.
- 2:24:54Which means that they'll feel
- 2:24:56Yeah, so then the What So, what's the
- 2:24:57point? Who cares about GLP-1? One of
- 2:24:59GLP-1's main effects is to tell the
- 2:25:01brain that we're full.
- 2:25:03Okay, so more GLP-1 means
- 2:25:05More satiety. Yeah, yeah, more GLP-1,
- 2:25:06less hunger, which is very impactful.
- 2:25:09In fact, I would be remiss if I didn't
- 2:25:11mention a study that was published in
- 2:25:13humans a while ago. They took obese
- 2:25:16humans and lean humans
- 2:25:18and had them eat fat
- 2:25:20and found that like pure fat, and they
- 2:25:22found that the GLP-1 response was the
- 2:25:23same. Whether you were lean or obese,
- 2:25:26you had the same amount of GLP-1. That
- 2:25:28would suggest that whether you're lean
- 2:25:30or obese,
- 2:25:31both of your brains in both of these
- 2:25:33populations will have the fat and have
- 2:25:35the same sense of I'm full.
- 2:25:38It would cuz it was matched with GLP-1.
- 2:25:40However, when they had these same groups
- 2:25:43eat pure carbohydrate,
- 2:25:45the lean group had a robust GLP-1
- 2:25:48response. Big GLP-1. In other words,
- 2:25:50they would eat the carbohydrate and say,
- 2:25:53"I'm full."
- 2:25:54Cuz GLP-1 would tell them so. However,
- 2:25:56in the obese group, they ate that exact
- 2:25:58same amount of carbohydrate and they had
- 2:26:00an almost negligible GLP-1 effect.
- 2:26:03They were still hungry.
- 2:26:03In other words, they would eat the same
- 2:26:05amount of carbohydrate as their lean
- 2:26:06counterpart and then just say, "Okay,
- 2:26:08what's next? I'm still hungry." And so,
- 2:26:11it is prudent to focus on GLP-1. GLP-1
- 2:26:14is a powerful hormone that does have an
- 2:26:17effect on human health.
- 2:26:19What I feel inclined to comment on is
- 2:26:22the negative side effects because the
- 2:26:24only thing we hear about is social media
- 2:26:26influencers extolling the benefits.
- 2:26:28And hey, I'm on this weight loss drug
- 2:26:30and I've lost 50 lb.
- 2:26:32Someone has to be the voice that says,
- 2:26:34"Yeah, but what about this?" And there
- 2:26:36are some significant
- 2:26:38but what abouts when it comes to these
- 2:26:41um weight loss drugs. One of them
- 2:26:44is the loss of muscle mass or lean mass.
- 2:26:46You've mentioned a couple papers from
- 2:26:48the New England Journal of Medicine. A
- 2:26:49paper a couple years ago from what was
- 2:26:52called the Step 5 trials looking at
- 2:26:53these drugs.
- 2:26:55They found that for every 6 lb of fat a
- 2:26:58person was losing on these drugs,
- 2:27:01they were losing 4 lb of fat-free mass
- 2:27:04or lean mass.
- 2:27:05So, 40% of the weight they were losing
- 2:27:08uh on these drugs is coming from lean
- 2:27:11mass, like including muscle and bone.
- 2:27:14So, there are now case reports of young
- 2:27:16healthy women who are overweight who go
- 2:27:18on the drug for some period of time and
- 2:27:20after they get diagnosed with
- 2:27:21osteoporosis
- 2:27:23where they have eroded their bone
- 2:27:25health. They're losing lean mass. So
- 2:27:27again,
- 2:27:27They've eroded that bone health.
- 2:27:29Yeah, so 40% of the weight that people
- 2:27:32are losing on these drugs
- 2:27:34appears to at these high doses is coming
- 2:27:35from lean mass. So, fat-free mass
- 2:27:38including muscle and bone. The reason I
- 2:27:40find that so troubling
- 2:27:42is that in the UK at 2 years on the drug
- 2:27:4669% of people get off the drug.
- 2:27:50They don't want to be on it anymore. And
- 2:27:52now imagine this individual. Imagine if
- 2:27:54you will a 60-year-old woman
- 2:27:56who's been on the drug. I take that age
- 2:27:58and that sex on on purpose because it's
- 2:28:00so hard for her to to grow new muscle
- 2:28:03and bone. Let's say she's been on this
- 2:28:05drug for a year and she's lost 20 kilos.
- 2:28:09Well, 40% of that will have come from
- 2:28:12her lean mass and 60% of it came from
- 2:28:15her fat. And then when she gets off the
- 2:28:17drug
- 2:28:18now all of a sudden her lean mass, her
- 2:28:21muscle and bone, that's never coming
- 2:28:22back. The muscle and bone that she has
- 2:28:24lost is gone forever probably at that
- 2:28:27age
- 2:28:27because we can't at after the age of 60,
- 2:28:30good luck developing new muscle and
- 2:28:31bone. But what can come back rapidly is
- 2:28:35the fat mass.
- 2:28:36And so at 2 years
- 2:28:38she decides to get off the drug, which
- 2:28:40again about 70% of people do, they're
- 2:28:42going to gain that fat back. But they're
- 2:28:44not going to gain their muscle and bone
- 2:28:47back. That is a significant loss that
- 2:28:49may be depending on their age gone
- 2:28:52forever.
- 2:28:53I was scrolling on Twitter the other day
- 2:28:55and I saw a video go viral, which is now
- 2:28:59being reported in a bunch of news
- 2:29:01publications. It was yesterday that I
- 2:29:03saw um this video go viral. And I'm
- 2:29:05going to play this video to you. It's
- 2:29:07from a singer called Avery.
- 2:29:10And she talks about her experience with
- 2:29:12Ozempic.
- 2:29:13I just left the doctor's office. I went
- 2:29:16to get a checkup
- 2:29:17because I've been off of the Ozempic for
- 2:29:192 months now and I just wanted to see
- 2:29:22my body was in better condition, if
- 2:29:23there were any permanent damages. Kind
- 2:29:26of in shock right now because I wasn't
- 2:29:28expecting this.
- 2:29:30But um I guess Ozempic
- 2:29:33can cause bone density loss. And I
- 2:29:36didn't think that that would happen to
- 2:29:38me because
- 2:29:40I was only on it for a year.
- 2:29:42Um but I have significant bone loss. I
- 2:29:45have osteoporosis
- 2:29:47and um
- 2:29:48osteopenia. So, there are There's like
- 2:29:51several of them that I have.
- 2:29:53I wasn't expecting that.
- 2:29:55But, that's what happens if you um
- 2:29:59if you use Ozempic
- 2:30:01uh for weight loss and you lose too much
- 2:30:03weight.
- 2:30:03Yeah, I wonder.
- 2:30:04She's so lean.
- 2:30:06I wouldn't be surprised if she had it
- 2:30:08even worse than normal because we see it
- 2:30:11has become I don't mean to suggest this
- 2:30:13is the case for her.
- 2:30:15But, you do see people using these
- 2:30:17weight loss drugs who are already very
- 2:30:19lean.
- 2:30:20I mean, I've got a picture of her here.
- 2:30:22And she does look incredibly lean
- 2:30:24already.
- 2:30:24But, see this is what people are doing.
- 2:30:26They're basically using it to facilitate
- 2:30:28an eating disorder in the people who are
- 2:30:30lean. Um this has become so common that
- 2:30:32there are complaints saying that you
- 2:30:34know, lean healthy people are getting
- 2:30:35the prescription and people who are
- 2:30:37obese and diabetic aren't because of
- 2:30:39shortages.
- 2:30:40The more the the leaner I've seen this.
- 2:30:43I know someone personally who is already
- 2:30:46a perfectly lean healthy woman
- 2:30:48and then she now looks sickly.
- 2:30:50Um and
- 2:30:51what caused it? Well, she wasn't lean
- 2:30:54enough.
- 2:30:55And when you take enough of that drug
- 2:30:57that you just have no more hunger
- 2:31:00because of how it's acting at your
- 2:31:01brain, you do just stop eating. And the
- 2:31:03malnutrition at least in part is going
- 2:31:05to cause a loss of lean mass.
- 2:31:08Um but that also
- 2:31:10play it it it is even further
- 2:31:13exacerbated by the mental health
- 2:31:15problems. Where There was a paper
- 2:31:16recently published with the use of these
- 2:31:18drugs finding that people when they
- 2:31:20begin the drug, their risk of suicidal
- 2:31:23thoughts doubles. It It up by over 100%.
- 2:31:26and their risk of major depression
- 2:31:28triples.
- 2:31:30And this so as much as we talk about
- 2:31:32these drugs and we say
- 2:31:34the drug helps you control your
- 2:31:36cravings.
- 2:31:38What it's hap- what it's doing is
- 2:31:40perhaps reducing your craving for
- 2:31:43everything. That while you are eating
- 2:31:44less food, which is resulting in the
- 2:31:46weight loss, you also are not interested
- 2:31:49as much in exercise as you used to be,
- 2:31:50which is going to make it even easier
- 2:31:52for you to lose your muscle and bone.
- 2:31:54You're also less interested in hobbies
- 2:31:56like going to play pickleball with your
- 2:31:58friends or going out and drinking with
- 2:32:00the boys. Um so there is this kind of
- 2:32:03what's reflected across all of their
- 2:32:05interests is that their cravings for
- 2:32:08everything starts to
- 2:32:09decline.
- 2:32:10In the case of that girl who mentioned
- 2:32:12that Avery, I've just seen she's
- 2:32:13uploaded a post that says, "Thanks, my
- 2:32:15record label told me I was fat. They
- 2:32:17dropped me. I got addicted to Ozempic."
- 2:32:20I got addicted to Ozempic and now as a
- 2:32:21result I have osteoporosis and my bones
- 2:32:24are as as fragile as wafer cookies.
- 2:32:27Yeah, it's heartbreaking. Um so now that
- 2:32:30Obviously, you know, these are claims
- 2:32:32that she's alleging. Now we don't know
- 2:32:33the full picture of her health and there
- 2:32:35might be something more.
- 2:32:36But we do know
- 2:32:38based on that one report that 40% of
- 2:32:40weight loss is coming from fat-free mass
- 2:32:41and so it isn't people's best interest
- 2:32:43to be mindful of that tendency and that
- 2:32:45if they're going to explore the use of
- 2:32:47the drug to do so responsibly. And and I
- 2:32:49want to mention that um kind of caveat
- 2:32:53or angle to everything because I don't
- 2:32:55want someone listening to me thinking
- 2:32:57"All right, Ben says I should never
- 2:32:58touch this and it is uniformly evil and
- 2:33:01bad." I'm not saying that. I find that I
- 2:33:03have to speak a little more boldly about
- 2:33:06the negative consequences because nobody
- 2:33:08talks about them. What would she have
- 2:33:09done if she knew about them, for
- 2:33:11example? No one knows about these kinds
- 2:33:13of negatives because people want to
- 2:33:14sweep them under the rug. Now, I believe
- 2:33:18there is a use case for these drugs,
- 2:33:21although different from how it's being
- 2:33:22used currently, in my mind, the best use
- 2:33:25of these drugs is to help someone learn
- 2:33:27how to control their carbohydrate
- 2:33:29addiction because it will help you
- 2:33:31control your addiction. Sweet cravings
- 2:33:34goes down significantly within 6 months
- 2:33:37of the person taking the drug.
- 2:33:39So, I think in addition to getting
- 2:33:41proper education, and if I may be so
- 2:33:44bold, I would say it's those pillars I
- 2:33:45mentioned earlier. Control
- 2:33:47carbohydrates, prioritize protein, and
- 2:33:49don't fear fat. All the more reason
- 2:33:52prioritize protein and fat to help
- 2:33:53preserve your muscle and bone.
- 2:33:56Muscle and bone are not made of
- 2:33:57carbohydrate. They're made of mus- of
- 2:33:59protein and fat. Eat protein and fat.
- 2:34:02Lift weights to keep any of that lean
- 2:34:04mass you can. Keep the integrity of your
- 2:34:06bones intact. But, take advantage of the
- 2:34:09drug helping reduce your cravings for
- 2:34:11sweet things especially.
- 2:34:13I would say find the lowest effective
- 2:34:16dose you can where you are able with a
- 2:34:18little bit of self- discipline where
- 2:34:20you're not assigning all of the
- 2:34:22self-discipline to the syringe that
- 2:34:23you're going to inject into your tummy.
- 2:34:25There is value in learning to deny
- 2:34:28yourself something you know you
- 2:34:29shouldn't be doing. There's life lessons
- 2:34:31to learn there. And so, enough of the
- 2:34:34drug that makes it a little easier for
- 2:34:36you
- 2:34:37to overcome your carbohydrate addiction.
- 2:34:40At the same time,
- 2:34:41you're learning how to eat well. You're
- 2:34:43learning how to eat properly by managing
- 2:34:45your macronutrients and lifting weights.
- 2:34:48And then over time, ideally I would say,
- 2:34:51you find that you are able to reduce the
- 2:34:53dose of the drug and then eventually get
- 2:34:55off of it entirely.
- 2:34:56It's worth saying that I I did also
- 2:34:58search to see if there was a link
- 2:34:59between Ozempic and bone density, and
- 2:35:01there was no
- 2:35:03clear link in the studies that have been
- 2:35:05done. I I don't know whether there's
- 2:35:06been a lot of studies done. It says in
- 2:35:08the studies and reviews semaglutide
- 2:35:09generally shows no harmful effect on
- 2:35:10bone mineral density, although rapid
- 2:35:12weight loss itself can sometimes affect
- 2:35:14bone health.
- 2:35:15Yeah, so I actually think it's an
- 2:35:16artifact. That's a term that we would
- 2:35:18use as a scientist to say that it's it's
- 2:35:20an it's an effect that's happening
- 2:35:22without being a main effect. So, I don't
- 2:35:24believe the GLP-1 drug is attacking the
- 2:35:26bone.
- 2:35:27Yeah.
- 2:35:27I think it's because the person has just
- 2:35:29stopped eating and stopped moving.
- 2:35:31Remember what I said earlier, people
- 2:35:33find that they're just less interested
- 2:35:35in doing stuff like going to the gym,
- 2:35:38for example. Um and so that is probably
- 2:35:41combining where a little bit of
- 2:35:42malnutrition
- 2:35:44combined with a little less physical
- 2:35:46activity means you're accelerating some
- 2:35:48lean mass loss.
- 2:35:50One of the things that this podcast has
- 2:35:52taught me is that liposuction
- 2:35:54is
- 2:35:56dangerous.
- 2:35:57Do you agree with that statement?
- 2:35:59I do. From a metabolic perspective, I
- 2:36:01absolutely do. Um liposuction is not
- 2:36:04dangerous to fit into the clothes you
- 2:36:06want to wear, but it's deeply
- 2:36:08problematic for metabolic health. And
- 2:36:10that's because, as a reminder, it's not
- 2:36:12the mass of fat we have that matters
- 2:36:14most when it comes to metabolic health.
- 2:36:16It's the size of our fat cells. So,
- 2:36:18let's imagine an individual who has more
- 2:36:21fat than they want in some particular
- 2:36:22part of the body.
- 2:36:24The best way to help reduce that fat is
- 2:36:28to shrink your fat cells. So, that's
- 2:36:29very important for people to realize.
- 2:36:31When you lose weight, you're not killing
- 2:36:33fat cells. You're not You're not getting
- 2:36:35rid of them. You're shrinking them.
- 2:36:37And small fat cells are very healthy fat
- 2:36:40cells. They are literally
- 2:36:41anti-inflammatory. They're releasing
- 2:36:43hormones that fight inflammation in the
- 2:36:45body, and they're very
- 2:36:47insulin-sensitive, which helps the body,
- 2:36:48by extension, be very insulin-sensitive.
- 2:36:51So, very healthy. Small fat cells are
- 2:36:53healthy fat cells. The problem with
- 2:36:55liposuction is that you are going in,
- 2:36:57and rather than shrinking the fat cells,
- 2:36:59you are sucking them out.
- 2:37:01Now, let's say, like a study that was
- 2:37:03done in the US in women,
- 2:37:06they found that when women had
- 2:37:08liposuction from their buttocks and hips
- 2:37:10area,
- 2:37:11um which is where most women gain their
- 2:37:13weight, which is because of sex hormones
- 2:37:15telling her body to store that weight
- 2:37:16there,
- 2:37:17they may look at that fat on their
- 2:37:19buttocks and hips and say, "There's more
- 2:37:20than I want. I'm going to suck it out."
- 2:37:23So, they do. But, they don't change
- 2:37:25their habits. So, they're still eating
- 2:37:27the same way they were before.
- 2:37:29Essentially, now they have fewer fat
- 2:37:31cells, but the body wants to store that
- 2:37:34same amount of fat based on how they're
- 2:37:37eating. In other words, there's enough
- 2:37:38insulin telling the body to store a
- 2:37:40certain amount of fat and there's enough
- 2:37:42calories to fuel that fat storage.
- 2:37:45But, the the fat would be saying, "Hey,
- 2:37:48we don't have all these fat cells in the
- 2:37:49buttocks and hips like we used to. Let's
- 2:37:51go somewhere else." And so, it's no
- 2:37:53surprise that over the ensuing years
- 2:37:55after she's had liposuction, not only
- 2:37:57does she not experience any improvement
- 2:37:59in any health marker. Nothing gets
- 2:38:02better with regards to her health.
- 2:38:04And that is again reflective of the fact
- 2:38:06that it's the size of the fat cell that
- 2:38:07matters. Maybe she has lost 10 kilos of
- 2:38:10fat. That might be a little much for
- 2:38:11liposuction. 6 kilos.
- 2:38:14And you would say, "Well, you have 6
- 2:38:16kilos of less fat. Clearly, you're
- 2:38:18healthier." And yet, they're not at all.
- 2:38:20Nothing has gotten better. And then, if
- 2:38:22you follow them over the years, they
- 2:38:24cannot gain that fat back on their
- 2:38:27buttocks and hips because it was
- 2:38:28literally sucked out and adults have a
- 2:38:30hard time making new fat cells. So, it's
- 2:38:33no surprise that they start storing more
- 2:38:35fat in an area that wasn't sucked out,
- 2:38:38namely their belly. And so, a woman
- 2:38:40who's gone through liposuction, yes, she
- 2:38:42will have lost fat by liposuction at her
- 2:38:45buttocks and hips. But, if she doesn't
- 2:38:47change her lifestyle habits, the body
- 2:38:49will take those 6 kilos and say, "Well,
- 2:38:51I need to store those now somewhere else
- 2:38:53because you're eating in a way that
- 2:38:55makes me want to store that much fat."
- 2:38:57And so, her remaining fat cells that are
- 2:38:59intact get bigger and store a bigger
- 2:39:01burden. And so, over time, it's no
- 2:39:04surprise that health outcomes can start
- 2:39:06to get worse.
- 2:39:07By having fewer fat cells, she's
- 2:39:09increasing the burden that the remaining
- 2:39:12fat cells have to carry. Not only does
- 2:39:14that result in a a change in where she's
- 2:39:16storing fat, namely storing more on her
- 2:39:18abdomen,
- 2:39:19but all the fat cells will get bigger.
- 2:39:22And thus, metabolic health can get
- 2:39:24worse.
- 2:39:25We have a closing tradition on this
- 2:39:27podcast where the last guest leaves the
- 2:39:29last question for the next guest, not
- 2:39:30knowing who they're leaving it for. And
- 2:39:32the question that's been left for you,
- 2:39:33Ben, is who in your life gave you a
- 2:39:35chance or believed in you when no one
- 2:39:37else did?
- 2:39:40What a fun question.
- 2:39:42Um thank you.
- 2:39:43Um
- 2:39:45probably my wife.
- 2:39:47Uh frankly, I just adore her. I think
- 2:39:50about So, when we were newlyweds, uh we
- 2:39:53got married quite young, if you'll allow
- 2:39:54me to be a little personal for a moment.
- 2:39:56We both really wanted a family. We knew
- 2:40:00that we wanted to be m- uh mom and dad.
- 2:40:04And she really wanted to be uh a at-home
- 2:40:06mom, just full-time mom.
- 2:40:08Which I loved. I benefited. My mother,
- 2:40:11um who died when I was quite young, she
- 2:40:13was a full-time mom. And most of my
- 2:40:15memories come from her being home. When
- 2:40:19I would come home from lunch or I had a
- 2:40:20tummy ache and she would come pick me
- 2:40:22up. And I I mean, I think I thank God
- 2:40:24for my for my mother, of course, but
- 2:40:26also for the time I had with her because
- 2:40:29I had so little.
- 2:40:30Um and we both really wanted
- 2:40:33Cheryl to be able to be full-time mom.
- 2:40:35Mom is just that special.
- 2:40:37That meant, as a young newly married
- 2:40:40husband, I was anticipating a future
- 2:40:43where I would be the sole provider for
- 2:40:45the family.
- 2:40:46And it was very daunting, uh very um
- 2:40:51scary for me as a 23-year-old. That's
- 2:40:53how old I was when we got married. And I
- 2:40:55worried, how am I going to provide for
- 2:40:58my family? And And would look at the
- 2:41:00trust that my beautiful wife had in me
- 2:41:03and I felt inadequate. And I I have
- 2:41:06moments where I remember young Ben in
- 2:41:09his early 20s as a newlywed and how
- 2:41:12scared I was and how my wife's ongoing
- 2:41:16devotion
- 2:41:17put us in a position where I both make a
- 2:41:20wonderful amount of money to provide for
- 2:41:22the family and help secure our future
- 2:41:24and then at the same time still have a
- 2:41:26schedule that lets me be really home, to
- 2:41:28go home early and help one of our
- 2:41:30daughters with her homeschooling, which
- 2:41:31I do, to always not go into work until
- 2:41:34I've made breakfast for the kids and
- 2:41:36we've had some family time.
- 2:41:38So, um much of all of it is just this
- 2:41:42the support of my wife because at any
- 2:41:44moment if she would have said, "No, I'm
- 2:41:46done. You got to go get a job right
- 2:41:47now."
- 2:41:49I would have.
- 2:41:50I I love her and respect her enough and
- 2:41:52even rely on her insight that I would
- 2:41:53have done it.
- 2:41:55But she just really believed that,
- 2:41:57"Okay, Ben, you're not dumb.
- 2:41:59I didn't marry you for your looks. I
- 2:42:01think you've got something. I'm going to
- 2:42:02trust you." And that trust was it was
- 2:42:05both humbling and scary but also very
- 2:42:07empowering. And it's given us a
- 2:42:09beautiful life.
- 2:42:11Ben, thank you. It's been truly
- 2:42:12eye-opening and you've answered so many
- 2:42:14of the questions that I've had for so so
- 2:42:15long, especially as it relates to
- 2:42:16ketosis and the broader link between
- 2:42:19insulin, infertility, pregnancy, PCOS,
- 2:42:23all of these kinds of things which are
- 2:42:24topics of conversation amongst my
- 2:42:26friends and people that I love. Ben,
- 2:42:27thank you.
- 2:42:28My pleasure. Thank you.
- 2:42:33Isn't this cool? Every single
- 2:42:35conversation I have here on the Diary of
- 2:42:36a CEO, at the very end of it you'll know
- 2:42:38I ask the guest to leave a question in
- 2:42:42the Diary of a CEO. And what we've done
- 2:42:45is we turned every single question
- 2:42:47written in the Diary of a CEO into these
- 2:42:49conversation cards that you can play at
- 2:42:52home. So, you've got every guest we've
- 2:42:54ever had, their question, and on the
- 2:42:57back of it, if you scan that QR code,
- 2:43:00you get to watch the person who answered
- 2:43:03that question. We're finally revealing
- 2:43:06all of the questions and the people that
- 2:43:09answered the question. The brand new
- 2:43:11version two updated conversation cards
- 2:43:14are out right now at the
- 2:43:16conversationcards.com.
- 2:43:18They've sold out twice instantaneously,
- 2:43:20so if you are interested in getting hold
- 2:43:21of some limited edition conversation
- 2:43:23cards, I really, really recommend acting
- 2:43:25quickly.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of The Insulin & Glucose Doctor: This Will Strip Your Fat Faster Than Anything! by The Diary Of A CEO, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 30,209 words across 4,824 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.