YouTube2Text

The History of Astrology: From Ancient to Modern Times — Transcript

by The Astrology Podcast · 22,848 words · 1,522 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00Hey, my name is Chris Brennan, and you’re  listening to The Astrology Podcast. Today is
  2. 0:04Monday, November 23, 2020, starting at 1:33 PM, in  Denver, Colorado, and this is the 280th episode of
  3. 0:13the show. In this episode, I’m going to be giving  an overview of the history of Western astrology.
  4. 0:21The genesis of this episode is I recently did an  interview with Kirah Taybourn on The Astrology
  5. 0:27Podcast, where she wanted to talk about the  recent revival of traditional astrology that’s
  6. 0:33happened over the past 30 years and to place  it in the context of the history of astrology.
  7. 0:38And it was a really good discussion, I really  enjoyed having it, although it made me realize
  8. 0:43that I’d never given an overview of the history  of astrology on The Astrology Podcast. Even though
  9. 0:48I’ve dealt with little individual topics, little  pieces of the history of astrology or subtopics,
  10. 0:56I’ve never really gone over everything,  so that’s going to be my goal here today.
  11. 1:02All right, so why don’t we jump right into it,  with that said. This is going to be one of those
  12. 1:08long, detailed overviews. So it is an overview,  but I’m also going to get into some detail that’ll
  13. 1:14probably be one of those longer discussions,  but think of this like a class; like a deep
  14. 1:20dive into the history of astrology, especially  for those of you that don’t have any background
  15. 1:25in it and really want to know where it came  from and how astrology in the West got started.
  16. 1:32All right, so here’s my  little slideshow presentation.
  17. 1:36As I said, I’m going to give a broad overview of  the history and transmission of Western astrology.
  18. 1:40I’m going to focus especially on periods of  transmission and synthesis, when astrology
  19. 1:46in the West was transmitted from one culture  to another, which essentially inaugurates a
  20. 1:52new era in the history of astrology  each time, every few hundred years.
  21. 1:57I’m also going to discuss some similarities,
  22. 2:03when some of these transmissions took place and  when there were these revivals of older forms of
  23. 2:08astrology and how that actually compares to now  and how things are very similar in some ways.
  24. 2:15I’m also going to explore the role of tradition  versus innovation, and by the end of this,
  25. 2:19I hope to give you sort of an idea and some  reflections on where things are headed now based
  26. 2:25on the trajectory of astrology over the past 2,000  years–actually 3-or-4,000 years, I should say.
  27. 2:34All right, so our story starts here, in  ancient Mesopotamia, which is the term used
  28. 2:42to refer to the geographical area that roughly  coincides with what is today modern-day Iraq. So
  29. 2:49it’s the area around the Tigris and the Euphrates  Rivers, in between them, and where they converge.
  30. 2:57For all intents and purposes, the  history of Western astrology starts
  31. 3:01here in Mesopotamia about 4,000 years ago,  and what happened is that at some point,
  32. 3:08around 2000 BCE, give or take, the basic premise  of astrology was formulated in Mesopotamia.
  33. 3:17This is a translation from a much later text,  from cuneiform, known as The Diviner’s Manual,
  34. 3:24that was translated by Francesca Rochberg, who’s a  historian who specializes in ancient Mesopotamian
  35. 3:30astrology and astronomy. And this passage of  the translation of this text says, “Sky and
  36. 3:38earth together produce omens each separate not  divided; sky and earth are interconnected. A sign
  37. 3:45which is bad in the sky is bad on earth; [and]  a sign which is bad on earth is bad in the sky.”
  38. 3:55This is basically the fundamental astrological  premise; and what I mean by that is that
  39. 4:01astrology posits that there’s a correlation  between celestial movements and things that
  40. 4:06happen in the sky and earthly events. For  example, in Mesopotamia, one of the things
  41. 4:12that they focused on was if there is an eclipse  in a certain part of the sky and a king dies,
  42. 4:20or if there’s a certain eclipse in a different  part of the sky and there’s a plague or a famine.
  43. 4:26So the notion that, for some reason, celestial  movements can act as signs or omens of the
  44. 4:34events that are either happening on Earth in the  present or that will happen in the future, this is
  45. 4:41part of the premise of astrology that  was really formulated during this time.
  46. 4:47Mundane astrology developed around 1500 BCE.
  47. 4:53There may be evidence that it came together  a little bit earlier, from about 2000 BCE,
  48. 4:59but we definitely have records where the  Mesopotamian astrologers started to write down
  49. 5:06observations of omens and what’s called ‘celestial  omens’, which is basically observations of
  50. 5:13things happening in the sky and what they were  thought to correlate with on Earth. So these omens
  51. 5:18were recorded as conditional statements where  it was put in the framing of ‘if X, then Y’.
  52. 5:27For example, if there is an eclipse in this  part of the sky then the king will die,
  53. 5:32or if there’s an eclipse in this part of  the sky, a foreign enemy will invade the
  54. 5:38country or what have you; so a basic  ‘if this, then this’ type statement.
  55. 5:47The Mesopotamian astrologers began compiling  these omens over the course of centuries on
  56. 5:53these little tiny clay tablets, using a  wedge-shaped language known as cuneiform.
  57. 5:59Eventually, they started amassing hundreds  of them and there would be these libraries,
  58. 6:04which would be part of the collective knowledge  and wisdom of the astrological tradition,
  59. 6:10which would be passed down from generation to  generation and from astrologer to astrologer.
  60. 6:17Eventually, the high point of state-supported  astrology in Mesopotamia occurred during the
  61. 6:23Assyrian Empire, somewhere around 750 BCE.  At this time, astrology was state-supported
  62. 6:33and there were 10 different colleges of  astrologers that were all over Mesopotamia who
  63. 6:38would send the king reports directly on mundane  astrology, about their observations and about
  64. 6:46what they had seen in the sky and what predictions  they were making about what that meant on Earth.
  65. 6:53Astrology during this time was  largely focused on what we call
  66. 6:56mundane astrology, which is when the astrological  omens are taken as indicating things about the
  67. 7:04civilization as a whole or large groups of people,  such as cities and nations. Or in some instances,
  68. 7:13the omens would be interpreted as impacting or  being related to the life of the king, since the
  69. 7:19king was representing the state as a whole to some  extent as the person in charge of the country.
  70. 7:29So mundane astrology was used; it got really  popular by the 8th century BCE, by circa 750 BCE,
  71. 7:37and was being practiced all over the place.
  72. 7:41Eventually, in the 5th century BCE, there was an  important turning point in terms of the history
  73. 7:47of astrology. At this point, the zodiac was  standardized to include 12 signs of exactly
  74. 7:5730 degrees each, which is the basic structure of  the zodiac as we know it today, where it has 12
  75. 8:0530-degree signs. So prior to this, the  zodiac was a collection of different
  76. 8:13constellations that laid on the ecliptic,  and it was broken up into uneven
  77. 8:19sections based on the different sizes of  different constellations and different asterisms.
  78. 8:25But at this point, it gets standardized  to 12 signs of 30 degrees each.
  79. 8:30Right around this time, they also  started producing ephemerides,
  80. 8:33which allow astrologers to look up the positions  of the planets and where they will be far into the
  81. 8:40future or where they were far into the past. So  basically, the Mesopotamians started developing,
  82. 8:46or had developed by this point, an  advanced mathematical astronomy,
  83. 8:51where because of the regular movements of the  planets, you can predict where they’re going.
  84. 8:58If you know enough about their planetary  movements, you can predict where they’re going
  85. 9:03far into the future, and you can also recreate  where they must have been far into the past,
  86. 9:10because those movements are periodic and  predictable. But this is something that took
  87. 9:16centuries to develop. It wasn’t just something  that happened overnight; it required astrologers
  88. 9:22who were also astronomers at the time because  there was an interrelationship. There was no real
  89. 9:28huge distinctions between the subjects; the same  people doing astronomy were the same people doing
  90. 9:34astrology and vice versa. So the astrologers would  literally go out every night and observe the stars
  91. 9:39and observe the movements of the planets and write  them down each night. And over the centuries,
  92. 9:46these observations led the astrologers  and astronomers to be able to develop
  93. 9:50mathematical models to predict the movements  of the planets, so this is kind of a big deal.
  94. 9:58Around this time, a little bit later, the Persian  Empire conquered Mesopotamia around 550 BCE.
  95. 10:06This may have led to some  decentralization of astrology,
  96. 10:10because it’s not long after this point  that astrology stops becoming simply a
  97. 10:16state-supported affair–where the astrologers are  serving the kings directly and astrologers are
  98. 10:23limiting themselves to mundane astrology,  which is predictions for entire cities or
  99. 10:29countries or predictions just for the king as the  representative of the state–but all of a sudden,
  100. 10:35this new concept is introduced, which we refer to  as natal astrology or the concept of birth charts.
  101. 10:44The oldest birth chart dates to 410 BCE, and then  after that point, we start to see birth charts
  102. 10:50appearing more and more frequently over  the course of the next few centuries.
  103. 10:56And these birth charts were relatively simple;
  104. 10:59it was just a list of where the planets were  placed on the day that a person was born, under
  105. 11:07the premise that the placement and the alignment  of the planets at the day of a person’s birth
  106. 11:13will have something to say about the quality  of a person’s life as well as their future.
  107. 11:19So that was the new concept that was  introduced, at least by the 5th century BCE,
  108. 11:24this concept known as known as natal astrology and  this practice of using birth charts in order to
  109. 11:30make predictions about the lives of individuals.  I speculate–I haven’t seen a lot of discussion
  110. 11:37about this–that perhaps it had something to  do with that shift towards the Persian Empire
  111. 11:44and the decentralization of astrology. Maybe  not having as much of a role as it did in the
  112. 11:52Assyrian Empire and other empires in  Mesopotamia where it was state-supported,
  113. 11:56perhaps that was part of the  impetus that led to the shift.
  114. 12:00On the other hand, we also know that it was around  this time that they started producing ephemerides,
  115. 12:04so that means they could look up where  the positions of the planets were
  116. 12:1020 or 30 years ago when a person was born. It  wasn’t until that happened that they really had
  117. 12:15the opportunity to calculate birth charts, other  than just observing the position of the stars
  118. 12:22on the day of a person’s birth. But that’s kind  of tricky because if you’re not there to watch
  119. 12:27it or see it, you may not know where the planets  were, so it involves some mathematical astronomy.
  120. 12:37All right, so there’s the zodiac. Here’s a quote.  This is from Francesca Rochberg’s book, Babylonian
  121. 12:44Horoscopes, which you can find out there and  that collects all of the known, surviving
  122. 12:49birth charts that survived from the Mesopotamian  astrological tradition, from about the
  123. 12:555th century BCE until about the 1st century BC. It  says, “Nisannu, night of the 14th—so it’s listing
  124. 13:06the month and the date–son of Sumu-usur, son  of Sumu-iddina, descendant of Deke, was born.”
  125. 13:16So it’s the person’s name–and who their parents  were–was born. “At that time, the Moon was
  126. 13:23below the pincer of the Scorpion. Jupiter in  Pisces, Venus in Taurus, Saturn in Cancer,
  127. 13:30Mars in Gemini. Mercury, which  had set, was not visible.”
  128. 13:34Then the text breaks off, like many of these  cuneiform tablets, and it says something to the
  129. 13:40effect of–maybe the translator guesses–that  “(Things?) will be propitious for you.”
  130. 13:48And then it goes on and it either starts giving  another birth chart, or it starts listing some
  131. 13:53prediction for the person’s future–I’m not really  clear–and then the text breaks off entirely.
  132. 13:58One of the unfortunate things about studying  the ancient history of astrology is, oftentimes,
  133. 14:02when you get a text, as soon as it  starts getting interesting usually
  134. 14:07the text breaks off, which is the Murphy’s  law of studying ancient astrology, I think.
  135. 14:14Anyway, that’s an example of what a  birth chart was like when we’re talking
  136. 14:18about Mesopotamian birth charts. They were  somewhat basic. They were just presenting,
  137. 14:23as far as we know, the positions of the planets  or calculating what signs they were located in;
  138. 14:28and they may or may not have contained some  basic predictions about the person’s life.
  139. 14:33Although one of the things that Rob Hand pointed  out, in a lecture years ago, and always stuck
  140. 14:40with me was to remember that when we look at these  ancient birth charts that just list the positions
  141. 14:45of the planets, that’s basically is analogous to  a modern birth chart that somebody has gotten from
  142. 14:52a computer program and just printed the chart out  on their printer, on a piece of paper, let’s say.
  143. 14:58So the chart itself just presents the raw data  that you need for the person’s birth chart. It
  144. 15:04calculates the birth chart and where the positions  of the planets were when the person was born,
  145. 15:09but it doesn’t actually tell you much.  Usually, historically, astrologers, in order to
  146. 15:15interpret the birth chart, it involved a  verbal consultation; so there’s an oral or
  147. 15:22verbal exchange between the astrologer and the  client and that’s where the delineation or the
  148. 15:27actual predictions of the future take place. And  it’s not as often that you see interpretations of
  149. 15:34birth charts actually committed to writing, since  it’s something that normally is done verbally.
  150. 15:40You do, however, see instructional texts–textbooks  that the astrologers themselves read and
  151. 15:47write–which instruct students how to interpret a  birth chart or at least the theory of astrology.
  152. 15:52Unfortunately, we don’t have a lot of  those from the late Mesopotamian tradition,
  153. 15:57so there’s a gap in our knowledge in terms  of how a Mesopotamian astrologer would have
  154. 16:02interpreted some of these birth charts, even  though at least a dozen or maybe two dozen
  155. 16:09birth charts survive from the Mesopotamian  tradition. It actually may be a little bit
  156. 16:14more than that, so check out Rochberg’s  book if you want more information.
  157. 16:20All right, so now we have to shift over to Egypt  because, along parallel lines, there were some
  158. 16:29important developments happening in Egypt where  they were developing their own type of astrology.
  159. 16:36Egyptian astrology was based on this  concept known as the ‘decans’, which
  160. 16:42identifies specific fixed stars or specific  asterisms and it breaks them up into
  161. 16:4836 groups or 36 clusters of these  fixed stars or fixed star clusters.
  162. 16:56The Egyptians were very much focused on the rising  and the culmination of certain decans or certain
  163. 17:04fixed stars during different  times, especially at night,
  164. 17:08in order to time different religious rituals;  this is essentially how the decans develop,
  165. 17:17starting from 2000 BCE, as this tool  for telling time and also for timing
  166. 17:26religious rituals especially. And this  is important because it means that while
  167. 17:33the Mesopotamians were primarily focused on the  movement of the ecliptic, which is essentially the
  168. 17:40zodiac, the Egyptians were more focused on what  we call the ‘diurnal rotation’, which is where
  169. 17:46we see every morning the 24-hour cycle of the Sun  rising over the eastern horizon in the morning,
  170. 17:52culminating somewhere around the middle of the  day, and then, eventually, setting at night;
  171. 17:57then, eventually, the entire cycle  repeats itself at sunrise the next day.
  172. 18:03The Egyptian system was focused on that  24-hour cycle of the diurnal rotation,
  173. 18:09but focused on it in terms of identifying the  rising and culminating of different fixed stars;
  174. 18:16these 36 clusters of fixed  stars that we call decans.
  175. 18:21So eventually, at some point, there’s this  text that we have only fragments of that’s
  176. 18:25known as the Salmeschoiniaka. And I have  no idea if I’m pronouncing that right, so
  177. 18:32don’t sue me, but we have fragments of this text  from the later Greek astrological tradition that
  178. 18:38records this tradition associated with the  Egyptians, where they were focusing on the
  179. 18:48rising decan and then they were assigning topics  to each of the decans based on where the decan
  180. 18:55fell relative to the rising decan that was rising  over the eastern horizon at the moment of birth.
  181. 19:02They said the 1st decan signified birth, the  rising decan. Then the 28th decan, which would
  182. 19:08be the culminating decan at what we would call  like the Equal House Midheaven–basically the 90
  183. 19:15degree point from the rising decan–was associated  with livelihood. The 25th decan was said to be
  184. 19:24associated with weakness. The 19th decan, which  is the setting decan opposite to the rising decan
  185. 19:30was associated with injury. The 17th decan was  associated with marriage and the person’s wife.
  186. 19:37The 10th decan was associated with death, and  that’s the decan that would be associated with
  187. 19:42the equal house IC or the lowest point in  the chart, in some sense. And then, finally,
  188. 19:48they called the 8th decan ‘the Door of Hades’,  and it was the place that signified children.
  189. 19:54We don’t know very well the timing of this text  and when it came from basically. We don’t know
  190. 20:03when this text dates to, but we think it dates to  sometime around the 1st century BCE or maybe the
  191. 20:082nd century BCE. So it may represent this stage  where the Egyptians were using the decans to
  192. 20:16create something like a prototype for what  later became the concept of the 12 houses,
  193. 20:22which is where you divide the diurnal  rotation into different sectors,
  194. 20:26and then you start associating or assigning it  topics based on where the signs of the zodiac
  195. 20:32fall relative to the rising sign. In this context,  it’s kind of like whole sign decan houses where
  196. 20:39you’re assigning topics based on where the  decans fall relative to the rising decan,
  197. 20:44but this may have been a precursor to the  type of astrology that came about later.
  198. 20:52All right, so the next development in our story  is the conquests of Alexander the Great, where
  199. 21:02there was this Macedonian named Alexander,  he was the son of a Macedonian king,
  200. 21:10and he took over his father’s empire after his  father was assassinated. Alexander took an army
  201. 21:18of Macedonians and Greeks–basically people that  spoke Greek and had Greek culture–and they stormed
  202. 21:25out of southern Europe into Asia Minor, into  modern-day Turkey, and they launched a war with
  203. 21:34the Persian Empire, which had been dominating the  Mediterranean for the past couple of centuries.
  204. 21:42So Alexander’s army storms out of southern Europe,  it goes through Turkey, it goes down and sweeps
  205. 21:47through Egypt, which was under Persian control  up to that point; they conquer Egypt, then they
  206. 21:54turn around and go back and conquer Mesopotamia.  And then Alexander’s army goes all the way over
  207. 22:02through modern-day Iran, all the way over into the  western-most portions of India before, eventually,
  208. 22:09he’s forced to turn back. He returns to  Mesopotamia, to Babylon, which is now
  209. 22:16under Greek control, and then promptly dies under  mysterious circumstances at a pretty young age.
  210. 22:25What’s important about this is the two main  areas that we were talking about earlier,
  211. 22:31Mesopotamia and Egypt, are suddenly both  under the control of Greek-speaking rulers,
  212. 22:38and this inaugurates or this launches a period  called the Hellenistic age or the Hellenistic
  213. 22:44period, which is usually thought to begin with  the conquest of Alexander and go on for several
  214. 22:51centuries until about the 1st century BCE, when  the very last Greek-speaking ruler of Egypt is
  215. 23:01overthrown by the Roman Empire, and then  the Roman Empire becomes big at that point.
  216. 23:07What’s important for our purposes  is just that, all of a sudden, Egypt
  217. 23:10and Mesopotamia are under the control of  Greek-speaking rulers, and it increases
  218. 23:15trade and commerce and interactions  between those two areas. All of a sudden,
  219. 23:20Greek becomes the lingua franca of  the ancient world, where everybody
  220. 23:26is speaking Greek and everybody knows how to  speak Greek and uses it, especially for, not
  221. 23:32just trade and commerce, but also for scientific  and religious and philosophical writings. Even if
  222. 23:40that was not the person’s primary language,  it became sort of like English today.
  223. 23:46Even if English isn’t your native language, due to  the internet and due to the exporting of American
  224. 23:55culture and other things like that, English has  become a standard language that’s common to speak
  225. 24:00around the world, and allows people to interact  a little bit more and cultures to intermingle a
  226. 24:07little bit more and for exchanges to happen than  it might otherwise. This is kind of what happened
  227. 24:13in the ancient world, especially in Mesopotamia  and Egypt after the conquests of Alexander.
  228. 24:21All right, so something important starts to happen  at this point, which is that there starts to
  229. 24:27be exchanges that start happening between the  astrologers in Mesopotamia and Egypt, and the
  230. 24:35earlier astrological traditions from Mesopotamian  and Egypt start being synthesized, at least by 300
  231. 24:40BCE, where we start seeing the zodiac appearing  and being merged with the Egyptian decans, in
  232. 24:50Egyptian temples at this time, and we start seeing  the zodiac appearing in Egyptian temples. That’s
  233. 24:59kind of an important development because, all of  a sudden, it indicates that the astrologers were
  234. 25:03exchanging information and their traditions were  starting to interact in a really significant way.
  235. 25:11So eventually, this reaches a really crucial but  somewhat mysterious turning point around 100 BCE,
  236. 25:19when we see the emergence, over the course of the  next century—basically, in the 1st century BCE–of
  237. 25:26what we now call today Hellenistic astrology.  And Hellenistic astrology is a type of astrology
  238. 25:37that emerged during the Hellenistic period after  the conquests of Alexander. It came out of Egypt,
  239. 25:43but Egypt was under the control of Greek-speaking  rulers at the time, a dynasty that was started by
  240. 25:49one of Alexander’s generals named Ptolemy, who  installed himself as the king or the pharaoh
  241. 25:58in Egypt; and then there was a long dynasty of  rulers that came after that that spoke Greek. This
  242. 26:04is also when we get the founding of the famous  Library of Alexandria and other things like that.
  243. 26:10One of the things that comes about after a century  or two of that is this new system of astrology
  244. 26:17kind of appears out of nowhere to some extent, and  it represents the establishment of the ‘fourfold
  245. 26:25system’ of astrology that we still use today that  uses the planets and most of the things that we
  246. 26:32associate with the planets today; the signs  of the zodiac and most of the qualities that
  247. 26:36we still associate with the signs of the zodiac  today; the concept of the 12 houses and most of
  248. 26:42the basic meanings of the houses that we still use  today; and the concept of aspects, which is the
  249. 26:48fourth major piece of the system,  which was introduced at that time;
  250. 26:53and for the most part, the core of it is still  essentially the same today 2,000 years later.
  251. 27:02The emergence of Hellenistic astrology represents  the introduction of all of the basic concepts
  252. 27:08of Western astrology, or most of the basic  core concepts that we still use to this day;
  253. 27:14it partially represents a synthesis of the earlier  Mesopotamian and Egyptian astrological traditions,
  254. 27:21and it also partially represents, at the same  time, some new innovations and some new techniques
  255. 27:27that don’t appear to have existed prior to  that point. So it’s this interesting and weird
  256. 27:34balance between inheriting the old traditions  and synthesizing them together with some new
  257. 27:40innovations that are being introduced around that  time, which is a thing that we’ll see come up
  258. 27:48over and over again in the history of  astrology over the next several centuries.
  259. 27:55All right, so what seems to have happened is  they took the 12 signs of the zodiac, which is
  260. 28:01the movement of the planets along the ecliptic,  and they started to merge it with the concept
  261. 28:07of the 36 decans, and especially the idea of  looking at the rising and the culminating decan.
  262. 28:13So this basically represents looking at two  different frameworks: one of them is the
  263. 28:17movement of the planets along the ecliptic–you  could conceptualize that as moving against the
  264. 28:24backdrop of the constellations–versus  the 24-hour cycle of the movement of
  265. 28:30the planets in the diurnal rotation, which is  just how the Sun rises and culminates and sets
  266. 28:37each day, and then it repeats that cycle the next  day and the day after that and so on and so forth.
  267. 28:43The other planets do the same thing. At some  point, during the day, the planet Saturn will
  268. 28:51rise over the eastern horizon, and at some point  during the day, Saturn will culminate overhead,
  269. 28:56and at some point, Saturn will set over  the western horizon, but it will do it
  270. 29:01at different times in the day, depending on  where it is in its cycle than the Sun does.
  271. 29:09So what happened during the Hellenistic tradition  was the merging of these two different frames of
  272. 29:17reference, and once you do that, you start  seeing in the Egyptian temples the decans
  273. 29:24being overlaid on top of the zodiac, so that  the decans become 10-degree subdivisions,
  274. 29:31or 36 10-degree subdivisions of the signs of the  zodiac, so that there’s three decans in each sign.
  275. 29:39For example, the first 10 degrees of Cancer  is a decan, the second degrees of Cancer
  276. 29:46is the second decan, and then the third 10  degrees of Cancer is the third decan, so that
  277. 29:52the 30 degrees of the sign of Cancer are divided  evenly between these three 10-degree decans.
  278. 30:00Eventually, at some point during  the Hellenistic tradition,
  279. 30:03once the decans and the zodiac were merged,  they then started paying attention to the
  280. 30:11rising decan or the decan that was rising over  the eastern horizon at the moment of birth and
  281. 30:17treating that as important, just like they had  previously been paying attention to the rising
  282. 30:23and culminating decans in the earlier Egyptian  tradition. Once they started transferring that
  283. 30:31and looking at the decans as a sort of subdivision  of the zodiac, and looking at what decan was
  284. 30:36rising and then numbering them from there, that  naturally led to looking at the entire rising
  285. 30:45zodiacal sign and treating that as important to  the person who was born at that moment in time.
  286. 30:53What that eventually led to at some point,  in a text attributed to Hermes Trismegistus,
  287. 31:01was this idea of looking at the rising  zodiacal sign or the sign of the zodiac
  288. 31:09that was rising at the moment a person was born  and then saying that the entirety of that sign
  289. 31:16would represent the 1st house, or what we call  the 1st house of the native. And then the rest
  290. 31:22of the signs were numbered in zodiacal order from  there, so that after the rising decan, which is
  291. 31:28the 1st house; the sign after that, which is Leo,  if Cancer was rising, would become the 2nd house;
  292. 31:35Virgo, which is the 3rd sign from the rising sign  becomes the 3rd house, and so on and so forth.
  293. 31:40This is what’s known today in modern times as the  whole sign house system. And you can kind of see
  294. 31:47how that system then would have developed out of  what was initially a ‘whole decan’ house system in
  295. 31:55the earlier Mesopotamian tradition going back to  that mysterious text known as the Salmeschoiniaka.
  296. 32:04So the concept of whole sign houses is introduced  at this point, but what’s weird is that there were
  297. 32:09also a bunch of other very core concepts that  also seem to have been introduced suddenly at
  298. 32:17this time. And what’s interesting about it is  they are often introduced within the context of,
  299. 32:23or they seem to have these underlying conceptual  or theoretical constructs or frameworks underlying
  300. 32:31them. One of the things that was introduced was  the rulership scheme, that certain planets rule
  301. 32:38different signs of the zodiac, and another  scheme that was introduced was the idea that
  302. 32:43certain planets are associated with one of the 12  houses. The conceptual constructs underlying these
  303. 32:51new ideas are two diagrams that we know as the  Thema Mundi and the ‘planetary joys’ scheme;
  304. 33:01so I want to talk about those two  schemes for just a few minutes.
  305. 33:06The Thema Mundi is often introduced  and is said to be like the birth chart
  306. 33:11for the birth of the world or the birth of the  cosmos, and Firmicus Maternus, in the 4th century,
  307. 33:17tells us that it was a teaching tool  that was used to explain the rationale
  308. 33:22for the rulership of the signs of the zodiac. So  the Thema Mundi was said to have the Ascendant
  309. 33:29rising–so the Ascendant in Cancer–and the Moon in  Cancer in the 1st whole sign house. Then the Sun
  310. 33:36was said to be in the 2nd house in Leo, Mercury  was said to be in the 3rd house in Virgo, Venus
  311. 33:42in the 4th house in Libra, Mars in Scorpio,  Jupiter in Sagittarius, and Saturn in Capricorn.
  312. 33:51So it sets up this interesting  scheme where the Sun is assigned to,
  313. 33:57in one hermetic text, 15 degrees of Leo because  that’s the very height and the very middle of the
  314. 34:04summer in the Northern Hemisphere when  the Sun is at the height of its power;
  315. 34:10the days are long and hot. The Sun, which is a  fiery and hot celestial body, is said to be at
  316. 34:20the peak of its influence at that time, at 15 Leo;  and then the rest of the planets are assigned,
  317. 34:26flanking out in zodiacal order, based on their  relative speed and distance from the Sun.
  318. 34:31Mercury, which can never get more than one sign  away from the Sun before it turns retrograde,
  319. 34:36is assigned to Virgo; and then Venus, which  can never get more than two signs away from
  320. 34:41the Sun before it turns retrograde, is assigned  to Libra. Mars is the next furthest and slowest
  321. 34:49planet out, so it gets assigned to  the next sign, which is Scorpio.
  322. 34:53Then Jupiter is assigned to Sagittarius as  the next furthest planet; and then, finally,
  323. 34:58Saturn is assigned to Capricorn. Saturn is the  furthest and the slowest of the visible planets,
  324. 35:04and Capricorn is the furthest sign from the  starting point, which was Cancer and Leo.
  325. 35:10So this provides the conceptual basis for the  planetary rulership scheme, or at least half
  326. 35:18of the rulerships, and then what happens is the  rest of the sign rulers are assigned by creating
  327. 35:24a mirror image of the Thema Mundi  where the other planets are assigned,
  328. 35:29flanking out from the Moon in reverse or opposite  zodiacal order, first, starting with Mercury,
  329. 35:36which is assigned to Gemini, which is the next  sign after the Moon, which is already signed to
  330. 35:41Cancer. Then Venus is assigned to Taurus; Mars is  assigned to Aries; Jupiter is assigned to Pisces;
  331. 35:48and finally, Saturn is assigned to Aquarius. This  creates the traditional rulership scheme, which
  332. 35:56is a symmetrical rulership scheme that’s divided  between the Sun and Moon axis and Cancer and Leo,
  333. 36:02and then assigns each of the visible planets to  two signs, flanking out from the Sun and Moon.
  334. 36:08From the traditional rulership scheme, we  also get some of the qualities of the basic
  335. 36:13natures of the aspects. For example, if you draw  aspect lines from the two luminaries, the Sun in
  336. 36:20Leo and the Moon in Cancer, to Venus–which is  in Libra–and Taurus, then you get a sextile;
  337. 36:29and Venus is the lesser of the two benefics, and  the sextile is said to be the weaker of the two
  338. 36:34positive or easy aspects. Then if you draw  lines to Mars, you end up with the square;
  339. 36:40Mars is the lesser malefic, and the square is  the easier of the two hard or difficult aspects.
  340. 36:46The trine goes from the Sun in Leo to  Jupiter in Sagittarius and from the
  341. 36:52Moon in Cancer to Jupiter in Pisces. The  trine is said to be the easier of the two
  342. 36:59easy aspects or the more  positive of the two easy aspects;
  343. 37:03and Jupiter is said to be the greater benefit.  And then Saturn, which is the greater malefic,
  344. 37:08is configured by opposition to the Sun and  Moon; and the opposition is said to be the more
  345. 37:14difficult of the two hard aspects. So from this,  we’re already getting, not just the rulership
  346. 37:20scheme, but from the rulership scheme, we’re  also deriving the basic natures of the aspects.
  347. 37:26So all these concepts are starting to intertwine  and be interlocked in this really weird way.
  348. 37:33So then when you take the idea of  aspects, and you have the idea of
  349. 37:37planets either aspecting  signs or not aspecting signs,
  350. 37:42it leads to this concept–when you superimpose that  on the concept of the houses–where they said that
  351. 37:49any of the 12 houses that aspect the rising  sign–since the rising sign is the primary sign of
  352. 37:57the 1st house that signifies the person  who was born at that time, the native–then
  353. 38:02any houses that aspect the rising sign are going  to be positive or supportive of the native,
  354. 38:08and any houses that don’t aspect the rising  sign are going to potentially be negative
  355. 38:12or indicate things that are not supportive  of the native who was born at that time.
  356. 38:17This is why, even today, the houses  that aspect the rising sign–the 1st,
  357. 38:233rd, 4th, 5th, 7th, 9th, 10th, and 11th–are  generally associated with positive topics such as
  358. 38:30siblings, parents, children, partners travel,  career, and friends, whereas the houses that
  359. 38:38don’t aspect the rising sign–the 2nd, 6th, 8th,  and 12th–tend to be associated with more negative
  360. 38:46things, especially the 6th with illness, the 8th  with death, and the 12th with loss; so part of
  361. 38:52the reason for those significations of the houses  is because of this underlying conceptual model.
  362. 39:00The other conceptual model that I mentioned  is the ‘planetary joys’ scheme, where you
  363. 39:05have the 12 houses and then each of the seven  visible traditional planets is assigned to one
  364. 39:10of the houses. So Mercury is assigned to the 1st  house, the Moon is assigned to the 3rd, Venus to
  365. 39:18the 5th, Mars to the 6th, the Sun to the 9th,  Jupiter to the 11th, and Saturn to the 12th.
  366. 39:25So my friend, Ben Dykes, and I made a discovery  back in 2012 that the ‘planetary joys’ scheme
  367. 39:33actually provides a similar conceptual rationale  as the Thema Mundi does for the signs of the
  368. 39:40zodiac, but the ‘planetary joys’ scheme does  the same thing for the 12 houses, where some
  369. 39:46of the basic significations of the houses  were derived from the ‘planetary joys’ scheme
  370. 39:51and there were also other conceptual structures  that were derived from this scheme as well.
  371. 39:59There’s actually a lot of really interesting  things about this. Some of the names of the houses
  372. 40:04were derived from the ‘planetary joys’ scheme.  So the 9th house in Hellenistic astrology was
  373. 40:10called the ‘place of god’, and it was opposite  to the ‘place of goddess’; and that’s why the
  374. 40:15Sun has its joy in the 9th and the Moon in  the 3rd. The 5th was called ‘good fortune’,
  375. 40:20and it was opposite to the 11th house of ‘good  spirit’, which is the opposition between Venus
  376. 40:28in the 5th and Jupiter in the 11th. And then the  6th place was called the ‘place of bad fortune’,
  377. 40:34and it was opposite to Saturn, which is called  the ‘place of bad spirit’. Finally, Mercury,
  378. 40:40which has its joy in the 1st house, is called  the ‘helm’, as well as the ‘hour-marker’.
  379. 40:46I don’t want to go into this too much, but what  Ben and I pointed out in a paper that I wrote on
  380. 40:51the ‘planetary joys’ scheme in 2013–which you  can find by just doing a search for my name
  381. 40:57and ‘planetary joys’–is what was happening  is that whoever came up with this scheme
  382. 41:03was distinguishing between the top-half of the  chart–and they were associating it with the solar
  383. 41:09hemisphere, which they were associating with the  concept of the soul, the mind, and the spirit–and
  384. 41:15the bottom-half of the chart, they were  associating with the lunar hemisphere
  385. 41:20and the concepts of fortune, the body, physical  incarnation, and matter, which creates this
  386. 41:27interesting distinction in terms of what  significations you assign to each of the houses,
  387. 41:33if you’re saying that the bottom-half  of the chart indicates bodily things
  388. 41:37and the top-half of the chart indicates things  that pertain to the mind or to the spirit.
  389. 41:45From the ‘planetary joys’ scheme, the  other discovery we made in 2012 is
  390. 41:49that this is also where you get the  origins, the motivating factor for
  391. 41:56the assignment of the four elements to  the signs of the zodiac. Previously,
  392. 42:03it wasn’t known how the signs of the zodiac came  to be associated with the four classical elements
  393. 42:09of Greek philosophy, which are earth,  air, fire, and water. But it turns out
  394. 42:15there’s actually a reason for those assignments  that’s embedded in the ‘planetary joys’ scheme,
  395. 42:21and it has to do with this interesting thing that  I probably shouldn’t go into because I’m already
  396. 42:26making this a little bit longer than I wanted to  by going on a bunch of digressions; so I’ll leave
  397. 42:32you to search for that. Just do a search for ‘the  planetary joys’, ‘Chris Brennan’, and you’ll find
  398. 42:42my paper, which is titled, “The Planetary Joys and  the Origins of the Significations of the Houses
  399. 42:48and Triplicities,” which I published online after  publishing it originally in an ISAR in 2013.
  400. 42:58All right, so we won’t get bogged down in  that. Eventually, through these schemes,
  401. 43:04it led them to develop the basic  significations of the 12 houses.
  402. 43:10While some of these significations that  I’m showing here, for people watching the
  403. 43:13video version, are still the same as they were  2,000 years ago, when this system of 12 houses
  404. 43:20was introduced, some of them have changed, but  for the most part, it’s still pretty standard.
  405. 43:26The 1st house signifies the body and the  spirit; the 2nd house signifies livelihood and
  406. 43:33possessions; the 3rd house signifies siblings and  travels; the 4th house signifies parents and home;
  407. 43:41the 5th house signifies children; the 6th  house indicates injury, illness, and enemies;
  408. 43:48the 7th house signifies marriage, the spouse,
  409. 43:53and partnership in general; the 8th house is  death and inheritance; the 9th house is travel,
  410. 44:02divination, and astrology; the 10th house  is action, reputation, and advancement;
  411. 44:09the 11th house is friends, gifts, and  hopes; and the 12th house in Hellenistic
  412. 44:13astrology is things like suffering,  enemies, weakness, and dangers.
  413. 44:19For the most part, many of those significations,
  414. 44:22they’re introduced 2,000 years ago, but they’ve  stayed relatively consistent with some minor
  415. 44:28changes over time due to the transmission of  astrology over the centuries. But what you have
  416. 44:34to understand is that most of those significations  were introduced relatively quickly, early in
  417. 44:41the late Hellenistic period, and  in the century or two after that.
  418. 44:48All right, so the core of the new system  of astrology, of this fourfold system,
  419. 44:55the first part was the planets, which includes  many of the significations of the planets that
  420. 45:00we still use today, the meanings of the planets,  as well as the concept of benefic versus malefic;
  421. 45:06the concept of sect, which is the  difference between day and night charts;
  422. 45:10also, the concept of attributing gender to the  planets; and the idea of temperaments being
  423. 45:16associated with the planets as well as some other  qualities. In terms of the zodiac, at this time,
  424. 45:23in the Hellenistic tradition, the domicile and  triplicity rulership schemes were introduced,
  425. 45:27so were the classical element schemes of  earth, air, fire, and water. The zodiac also
  426. 45:33attributed the gender of masculine or feminine,  as well as modalities, which is cardinal, fixed,
  427. 45:39and mutable, and the concept of reception  was introduced at this point as well.
  428. 45:45In terms of the houses, we see the  introduction of whole sign houses,
  429. 45:49equal houses, and quadrant houses all pretty early  in the astrological tradition, which I talk about
  430. 45:55in my book titled, Hellenistic Astrology: The  Study of Fate and Fortune. I have a chapter on the
  431. 46:00origins of the different systems of
  432. 46:02house division, but also the significations  of the houses that I was just talking about,
  433. 46:07the ‘planetary joys’ scheme, the concept of  angularity of good and bad houses, as well
  434. 46:12as the concept of ‘lots’, which was a subset of  looking at the significations of different houses.
  435. 46:19Finally, the concept of aspects–there was  a distinction between sign-based aspects as
  436. 46:25well as degree-based aspects. They also introduced  the concept of right- versus left-sided aspects,
  437. 46:31overcoming versus striking with a ray,  aversion, enclosure, and other types of
  438. 46:37aspect doctrine-related concepts were  introduced at this time. So these are
  439. 46:42most of the core things of Western astrology that  persisted for centuries after this point, and even
  440. 46:49though some of these concepts were lost by the  time you get to modern, 20th century astrology,
  441. 46:54for the most part, the core of that  system is still very much intact today.
  442. 47:00All right, so eventually what happens is the  Roman Empire becomes the dominant superpower
  443. 47:07in the Mediterranean in the 1st century BCE, and  it takes over Egypt, which is the birthplace of
  444. 47:14Hellenistic astrology, as well as most of the  areas surrounding the Mediterranean. So the
  445. 47:23Roman Empire culminates and reaches its largest  extent by the 2nd century CE, and this also
  446. 47:31appears to be roughly around the time of the high  point of the practice of Hellenistic astrology.
  447. 47:40Meanwhile, around this time or not long after,  Hellenistic astrology gets transmitted to India
  448. 47:49either, at the earliest, probably by the  2nd century CE or sometime in the next
  449. 47:54few centuries. There were some books on  Hellenistic astrology that went over to
  450. 48:00India that were written in Greek and then  were translated into Sanskrit, and then they
  451. 48:05were merged with the preexisting traditions of  astrology that existed in India up to that point,
  452. 48:11including the 27 sign lunar zodiac known as  the nakshatras. This then created a long and
  453. 48:20flourishing tradition of astrology in India over  the next 2,000 years, all the way up until the
  454. 48:25present time. But it’s important to note that  some of it happened partially as a result of
  455. 48:32this transmission, and again, another interaction  between cultures where astrology written in Greek
  456. 48:39started interacting with astrology that was in  Sanskrit at that point, and it created a new
  457. 48:45tradition, or it created a new system that  then flourished in India after that point.
  458. 48:52There was a similar transmission in the 3rd  century CE or so, where texts written in Greek
  459. 48:59onHellenistic astrology were transmitted to Persia  and translated into the Persian language at that
  460. 49:05time. After this point, the documentation  about Persian astrology is a little spotty
  461. 49:12because of the destruction of a lot of Persian  texts, but they seem to have developed and
  462. 49:17advanced different forms of mundane astrology;  especially the use of Jupiter/Saturn cycles,
  463. 49:23and their conjunctions in different  triplicities, seems to have been really
  464. 49:27developed in the Persian tradition during  this time, from the 3rd century onward.
  465. 49:33This is a diagram which shows the 27 sign
  466. 49:37lunar zodiac known as the nakshatras and how  it interfaces with the 12-sign zodiac from
  467. 49:46the Babylonian and Hellenistic traditions, and  how that gets merged together. Those two systems
  468. 49:54become merged and then they start assigning  planetary rulerships to the different nakshatras,
  469. 50:02which then leads to some interesting timing  systems, like the Vimshottari Dasha system, which
  470. 50:07is a timing technique that’s very popular and very  widely-used in Indian astrology. I did an episode
  471. 50:13of The Astrology Podcast on that with Freedom  Cole just last year. So do a search for that on
  472. 50:20The Astrology Podcast website or YouTube channel  where you can learn more about that technique.
  473. 50:27This is a diagram that just shows–from  the later Renaissance tradition–the
  474. 50:32different Jupiter/Saturn conjunctions. And  what astrologers noticed at some point,
  475. 50:37probably in the Persian tradition, was that the  Jupiter/Saturn conjunctions happen every 20 years,
  476. 50:43but they tend to happen in the same zodiacal  triplicities for these 200-year spans of time.
  477. 50:54We’re about to have one of those shifts later this  year in 2020, where the Jupiter/Saturn conjunction
  478. 51:00is about to take place in Aquarius, which is a  shift into the air triplicity compared to the past
  479. 51:06200 years, where the Jupiter/Saturn conjunctions  tended to take place in the earth signs; so we’re
  480. 51:13having a shift now from 200 years of earth to  about 200 years of air. The ancient Persian
  481. 51:19astrologers started noticing these conjunctions  and used it to group and to divide long
  482. 51:25time spans of history into thousand-year  periods, and they used that to predict the
  483. 51:30rise and fall of different religions and different  dynasties within the context of mundane astrology.
  484. 51:38All right, so eventually we get to the end of the  Hellenistic tradition, where Hellenistic astrology
  485. 51:44kind of peters out or ends, by  the latest, the 7th century CE,
  486. 51:50where for the past couple of centuries, we see  the fall of the Western Roman Empire in Europe;
  487. 51:58so the decline or the fall of the Western  Roman Empire. Astrology stops being practiced,
  488. 52:04for the most part, in Western Europe at this time.  There’s a decrease in learning and literacy during
  489. 52:11this time. Astrologers are not around as much and  not practicing it in an advanced, complicated,
  490. 52:22mathematical form. Additionally, there’s increased  hostility towards astrology from Christianity.
  491. 52:30In the early Roman Empire, astrology  was seen as a type of divination,
  492. 52:34and it was seen as more permissible,  just like other types of divination were
  493. 52:40within a ‘pagan’ context. But then, after the 1st  century CE and the introduction of Christianity,
  494. 52:50Christianity and astrology had a very tense  relationship. And when Christianity becomes
  495. 52:56eventually the dominant religion of the Roman  Empire, it ended up being bad news for astrology,
  496. 53:02just because Christian theologians tended to not  like astrology for different reasons. One of was
  497. 53:09due to the issue of fate and free will and  due to the focus on free will in Christianity,
  498. 53:15whereas astrology had more of a focus towards the  concept of fate due to the premise that you could
  499. 53:22predict a person’s future based on the alignment  of the planets at the moment that they were born;
  500. 53:28so that created a tension  between those two subjects.
  501. 53:31The third thing that contributed to the end of  the Hellenistic tradition was the advent of the
  502. 53:35Arabian Empire. Egypt fell to the Arab armies in  641 CE. The birthplace of Hellenistic astrology,
  503. 53:47Greek had been used as the primary language  in Egypt all the way up to that point,
  504. 53:51but then, all of a sudden, a new culture, with  a new language came in and took over Egypt.
  505. 53:58That was very slowly and gradually put an end  to Greek being the primary language there, and
  506. 54:04astrology, similarly, went into a period of not  being practiced as much in Egypt during that time.
  507. 54:12This is a map from Wikipedia that shows, starting  in the Arabian Peninsula, where modern-day Saudi
  508. 54:18Arabia is, the Islamic Empire started, and then it  started expanding from the 7th and 8th centuries.
  509. 54:29It eventually took over Mesopotamia and took over  the Middle East, all the way to the western-most
  510. 54:36portions of India. It also took over portions  Mesopotamian portions of Turkey, and then,
  511. 54:45eventually, most of North Africa, all the way into  Spain and the Iberian Peninsula, all the way over
  512. 54:53on the top-left. So that, at its height, was the  extent of the Islamic Empire in the 7th and 8th
  513. 55:01centuries; so it was just as massive as Alexander  the Great’s empire and the Roman Empire were
  514. 55:11in different ways, depending on  what century you’re talking about.
  515. 55:18This basically leads to another tradition of  astrology; so we have the end of the Hellenistic
  516. 55:23tradition by the 7th century. And what happens is  that by the 8th and 9th centuries, there is this
  517. 55:31flourishing of science and philosophy that occurs  under the Abbasid dynasty of Islamic rulers,
  518. 55:41who spoke Arabic in the 8th the 9th century.  This dynasty was very favorable towards
  519. 55:49learning and philosophy and science, and also,  astrology. So there was a shift in focus,
  520. 55:59and at one point, the new rulers wanted  to move the capital to this new city,
  521. 56:05which became the city of Baghdad. They  got together a group of astrologers and
  522. 56:10asked them to pick an electional chart for  the founding of this new city that would be
  523. 56:14the new capital of the empire; this chart  actually survives, and it’s set for 762 CE.
  524. 56:25Let me see. Actually, this is the chart itself.  The Baghdad electional chart, it’s preserved by
  525. 56:33a later historian named Al-Biruni, and  he said that it had Sagittarius rising,
  526. 56:38with Jupiter in Sagittarius, the  Sun was in Leo in the 9th house,
  527. 56:43the Moon was in Libra in the 11th house,  and Venus was in Cancer in the 8th house.
  528. 56:51For those looking at the video, you can see  the rest of the placements, but that’s the
  529. 56:55basic electional chart that they  picked for the founding of Baghdad.
  530. 56:59And then what happened is Baghdad flourished for  several centuries and became a center for science
  531. 57:06and philosophy, and also, astrology. At this  time, they set up translation projects in Baghdad
  532. 57:14in order to translate astrological texts from  Greek and Persian and Sanskrit into the language
  533. 57:23of Arabic, which became the new language that  everybody was speaking at this time, just like
  534. 57:30Greek was the common language several centuries  earlier at the birth of Hellenistic astrology.
  535. 57:37So during this time, works of earlier Hellenistic  authors, such as Dorotheus, Vettius Valens,
  536. 57:43Rhetorius, and Ptolemy, were translated, and they  recovered some pieces of the older traditions and
  537. 57:49then synthesized them together with some new  techniques and new things that had developed
  538. 57:57in the interim between the traditions. One  of the things that happened at this time
  539. 58:02that was important in terms of the history  of astrology is that horary astrology gets
  540. 58:07fully established as a full-fledged, fourth  branch of the tradition at this time.
  541. 58:12We do see some earlier references to  horary in the Hellenistic tradition,
  542. 58:17but they’re references in passing, in the  text of Dorotheus. And then, eventually,
  543. 58:23we see a few horary charts that survived from  the 5th century, but we don’t have any full
  544. 58:31textbooks or works on horary astrology from  the Hellenistic tradition for some reason,
  545. 58:36and it’s not referenced very much. For  the most part, natal astrology seems to be
  546. 58:40the primary focus of most of the astrologers in  the Hellenistic tradition. But by the time we
  547. 58:46get to the early Medieval tradition, horary  astrology is a major player at this point,
  548. 58:52and we do see some of the first full-fledged  texts on horary astrology from authors such
  549. 58:57as Masha’allah, Sahl ibn Bishr, and Theophilus  of Odessa; yeah, so that’s really important.
  550. 59:05I should define horary astrology. So horary,  the premise is that you can cast a chart for
  551. 59:12the moment that a client asks an astrologer an  important question that’s important and personally
  552. 59:20relevant and somewhat pressing to them, and that  the chart cast for the moment of the exchange
  553. 59:25of the question will tell you something about  not just the nature of the question itself–that
  554. 59:30the chart will describe the nature of the  question–but that the chart also will describe
  555. 59:35the outcome of the question or what the answer  is to the question just based on looking at
  556. 59:41the chart for that moment. This is important  because we get the establishment of horary.
  557. 59:49Up to this point, we’ve seen Mesopotamian  astrology primarily used in the Mesopotamian
  558. 59:55tradition. Then we see the introduction  of natal astrology using birth charts
  559. 1:00:00in the late Mesopotamian tradition, and that  became the primary technique that was used and
  560. 1:00:06refined and that the Hellenistic astrologers  focused on, birth charts and natal astrology.
  561. 1:00:12We, also, in the Hellenistic tradition, see the  introduction of electional astrology, which is
  562. 1:00:18choosing auspicious moments to begin new ventures  and undertakings under the premise that you can
  563. 1:00:22cast a chart for when you start a new action  or begin a major venture, and that chart will
  564. 1:00:32tell you not just the quality of what you’re  starting at that time, but also its future.
  565. 1:00:36So that’s the founding chart for Baghdad that  we talked about, where the astrologers picked
  566. 1:00:42a chart that they thought would be positive  for the founding of this city. They made
  567. 1:00:47sure that they picked a chart where Jupiter  was in Sagittarius, and they put Jupiter in
  568. 1:00:52the rising sign–so Jupiter in the 1st house–and  considered that to be an auspicious indication for
  569. 1:00:58founding that new city. That’s basically  the concept of electional astrology,
  570. 1:01:02that you can pick out auspicious moments to start  new ventures and undertakings, from very big ones,
  571. 1:01:08like founding a city, to very small ones, like  taking a trip or getting married or what have you;
  572. 1:01:14so that’s basically the premise  of electional astrology.
  573. 1:01:21By the time horary is introduced that  basically gives us the traditional fourfold
  574. 1:01:29system of astrology–or I should say ‘the  four major branches’ of astrology. Earlier,
  575. 1:01:35I talked about the fourfold system of  astrology that’s applied to birth charts,
  576. 1:01:41but what this sets up is the ‘four  traditional branches of astrology’, which are
  577. 1:01:46‘mundane astrology’, which applies to cities  and nations, ‘natal astrology’, which applies
  578. 1:01:52to the birth of individuals, ‘electional  astrology’, which applies to the charts of new
  579. 1:02:00ventures and undertakings, and then, finally,  ‘horary astrology’, which is the astrology of
  580. 1:02:06questions of answering single specific  questions that are posed to an astrologer.
  581. 1:02:14All right, so at this time, in addition  to making horary a full-fledged,
  582. 1:02:22fourth branch of the tradition, there were  also some innovations in the aspect doctrine.
  583. 1:02:28They introduced some concepts that  seemed like they were connected to
  584. 1:02:32some of the new developments in horary astrology,  like the idea of ‘transfer of light’, ‘collection
  585. 1:02:37of light’, and other advanced, somewhat exotic  aspect combinations, which allow astrologers to
  586. 1:02:46answer hoary questions in different ways because  of how approaching query questions is answered.
  587. 1:02:54Additionally, there’s some elaboration  of the Persian mundane astrological
  588. 1:02:58doctrine that involves the Jupiter/Saturn  conjunctions, and we see an increased focus
  589. 1:03:02on things like ingress charts, like the  Aries ingress chart for indications about
  590. 1:03:08what’s going to happen in mundane astrology in  the coming year and other similar ingress charts.
  591. 1:03:15One last thing I should say about the four  traditional branches is that most other
  592. 1:03:22applications of astrology are just  subsets of one of these branches,
  593. 1:03:26or they’re combinations of two or more  of these branches. For example, there’s
  594. 1:03:35‘medical astrology’, which involves sometimes  looking at the birth chart of an individual
  595. 1:03:40to determine their temperament or determining  things like propensity to illness or injuries.
  596. 1:03:49Medical, also, sometimes involves electional  astrology and horary astrology for
  597. 1:03:55diagnosing what is wrong with a person  or diagnosing an illness, for example.
  598. 1:04:01There’s other later types of astrology like  ‘magical astrology’, where astrologers would
  599. 1:04:07make talismans and amulets and sometimes  that’s an application of election astrology.
  600. 1:04:15Even in modern times, there’s things like  ‘business astrology’ or ‘stock market astrology’,
  601. 1:04:22which is just an application or a subset of  mundane astrology, where you’re looking at
  602. 1:04:29outer planet cycles and seeing how that  applies to countries or seeing how that
  603. 1:04:33applies to the stock market; or you’re looking  at the inception chart for businesses to see how
  604. 1:04:39that business chart will do, which is a subset  of electional astrology, and so on and so forth.
  605. 1:04:45So even though astrology’s changed and grown, and  there’s many different applications of it over the
  606. 1:04:49centuries, these four branches are still pretty  standard for the most part today, even if there
  607. 1:05:02are many different subsets of astrology within  them. Even things like ‘relationship astrology’,
  608. 1:05:08for example, is, generally speaking, a subset  of natal astrology, where you have synastry;
  609. 1:05:14where you’re looking at the birth charts of two  individuals and how they overlay on each other;
  610. 1:05:19so that would, again, just be  a subset of natal astrology.
  611. 1:05:23All right, so those are the four branches that  are firmly established by the early Medieval
  612. 1:05:28tradition, in the 8th and 9th centuries. Here’s  a diagram that shows the concept of transfer
  613. 1:05:36of light. Let’s say you’ve got a slow-moving  planet like Jupiter at 15 degrees of Aries
  614. 1:05:43and you have an even slower-moving planet like  Saturn at 9 degrees of Aries; those two planets,
  615. 1:05:49as long as they’re direct-in-motion, would  be separating from each other. But according
  616. 1:05:53to the doctrine of transfer of light, if  there’s a faster-moving planet, like Mercury,
  617. 1:05:57that separates from one of them, like Saturn,  and applies to Jupiter, then it can create a
  618. 1:06:04connection between those two planets, which  becomes necessary in horary questions.
  619. 1:06:10Oftentimes, in horary questions, if your  two primary significators are separating,
  620. 1:06:14it can indicate that the answer to  the question is ‘no’ or negative,
  621. 1:06:18whereas if your two planets are applying  to each other or share some connection,
  622. 1:06:23it indicates that the question is ‘yes’ or is  affirmative. That’s why I think some of these
  623. 1:06:29new aspect doctrine concepts were introduced  by the time of the early Medieval tradition
  624. 1:06:35because of their necessary application in horary  astrology. This may have been a development in
  625. 1:06:42the late Persian tradition that we don’t have a  lot of documentation for, due to a loss of texts.
  626. 1:06:49All right, so eventually we get to late Medieval  astrology or the later Medieval tradition,
  627. 1:06:55where what we know of today as Spain  and the Iberian Peninsula was under
  628. 1:07:04Muslim rule since the 8th century.  But in the 12th century, Europeans
  629. 1:07:11from the northern part of the year Iberian  Peninsula started pushing downwards and started
  630. 1:07:17the Reconquista, the reconquering or taking back  of lands–that previously had been occupied by
  631. 1:07:25Europeans–from the Muslim rulers,  from the 8th century forward.
  632. 1:07:31Let me see if I have a diagram. Yeah. here it is.  So here’s an example where you have some of the
  633. 1:07:38Islamic Empire in Northern Africa, all the  way up into the southernmost portions of
  634. 1:07:43Spain. And then you have these different  European kingdoms that start pushing downwards
  635. 1:07:51and taking land back from the  Islamic rulers at that time.
  636. 1:07:58This is important for our purposes, this shift in  the 12th century, because what happened is when
  637. 1:08:04the Europeans started reconquering some of those  lands in Spain, they ended up getting a hold of
  638. 1:08:16these huge libraries that contained  hundreds and hundreds of Arabic texts,
  639. 1:08:23including scientific and philosophical texts,  but some of these texts covered astrology.
  640. 1:08:31All of a sudden, this spurred a translation  movement, where scholars from all over Europe
  641. 1:08:36started flocking to Spain and started translating  texts from Arabic into other common European
  642. 1:08:44languages at that time, like Latin. So there  was this huge translation movement of hundreds
  643. 1:08:50of astrological texts, which got translated from  Arabic to Latin from the 12th century forward,
  644. 1:08:57and this led to a revival of the practice of  astrology in Europe from the 12th century forward.
  645. 1:09:04Up to this point, astrology had sort of died  out after the fall of the Roman Empire–it
  646. 1:09:12sort of died out in most of Europe–so this  represented a reintroduction of astrology to
  647. 1:09:17Europe at this time; but it was a reintroduction  of it through these Arabic sources. So it was the
  648. 1:09:25type of Arabic astrology that had been created  in the 8th and 9th centuries from translating
  649. 1:09:30other texts from Greek, but also from Sanskrit and  from Persian, and then synthesizing that together
  650. 1:09:40to create a new tradition of astrology  in Arabic, in the 8th and 9th centuries.
  651. 1:09:45And I forgot to mention that the Sanskrit part  of that is interesting. Sanskrit was one of the
  652. 1:09:54texts and one of the traditions that influenced  the early Medieval tradition in the 8th and 9th
  653. 1:09:58centuries. That was astrology from India basically  coming back and then starting to influence the
  654. 1:10:05Western tradition in the early Medieval period.  So it was never just a one-way transmission of
  655. 1:10:12Greek astrology or Western astrology to India,  but also India at different points has influenced
  656. 1:10:18the development of Western astrology as  well through occasional or through periodic
  657. 1:10:23transmissions of astrology from Sanskrit  to the West; Sanskrit texts to the West.
  658. 1:10:32Anyway, this translation movement in the 12th  century led to the revival of astrology in Europe.
  659. 1:10:37There were major universities that were set  up in Europe around this time and forward
  660. 1:10:43that started setting up chairs for astrology;  so there would be a head professor of astrology
  661. 1:10:49in some of the major universities. And medical  astrology especially flourishes during this time,
  662. 1:10:56where the use of different things, like  temperament theory, and the idea that the
  663. 1:11:02planets literally affected or influenced  our bodily temperament in different ways
  664. 1:11:09could be used to treat different ailments and  different issues that might arise as a result of
  665. 1:11:17inflammation or as a result of different  diseases or other things like that.
  666. 1:11:22Astrology became very integral to the practice  of medicine at this time, not just for diagnostic
  667. 1:11:30purposes–where they would sometimes use things  like horary astrology or inceptional or electrical
  668. 1:11:35astrology to diagnose a person’s sickness and  how long it would last and what was causing
  669. 1:11:42it–but they would also do other things  in order to maintain overall health and
  670. 1:11:47wellness as part of a holistic-type approach,  to use a modern term, to health and well-being.
  671. 1:11:56So astrology becomes a big deal in Europe  again from the 12th century forward,
  672. 1:12:02after it’s transmitted back to Europe through  these Arabic sources and translated into Latin.
  673. 1:12:10If we jump forward a century or two, one of the  notable things that happens is the invention
  674. 1:12:17of the printing press in 1440. This ended up  leading to a proliferation of astrological texts,
  675. 1:12:25and in order to understand why that  is, you have to understand that
  676. 1:12:30prior to that century, all texts,  especially astrological texts,
  677. 1:12:36were hand-copied. If you wanted to get a copy of a  book on astrology, a specific book, you would have
  678. 1:12:43to get a scribe who would take one copy of it and  put it next to another copy, and then literally,
  679. 1:12:50with their hand, copy it word-for-word and  sentence-for-sentence until you had a full book.
  680. 1:12:56This is a very time-consuming  and laborious process,
  681. 1:13:00and it’s one of the reasons why we have  only a small percentage of the ancient
  682. 1:13:07astrological texts that were written in the  Roman Empire to survive into modern times.
  683. 1:13:15The transmission of these books on astrology  was kind of spotty just due to this process of,
  684. 1:13:20not just copying books over by hand, but  also sometimes having to translate them
  685. 1:13:24from one language to another, which adds an  additional complication or problem, obviously.
  686. 1:13:33So after the printing press was invented,  one of the things this allowed them to do
  687. 1:13:39was mass-produce astrological texts, and it  led to a proliferation of astrology texts
  688. 1:13:45all over Europe at this time. And what  happened is really interesting because
  689. 1:13:54what they started doing was printing  the Latin translations of earlier Arabic
  690. 1:13:59texts that had been translated  starting in the 12th century.
  691. 1:14:03So when the Europeans started flocking  to Spain and translating those texts from
  692. 1:14:10Arabic to Latin, now all of a sudden, the printing  press was introduced and invented, and they were
  693. 1:14:18looking for what would be the most popular things  that people want to buy. One of those first things
  694. 1:14:25that they really started printing a lot of was the  translations of astrological texts that had been
  695. 1:14:30translated from from Arabic to Latin, so this  leads to a proliferation of astrological texts.
  696. 1:14:37At the same time, the fall of Constantinople,  the last remaining remnant of the Roman Empire,
  697. 1:14:47occurred in 1453, and this led to an exodus  of some of the few remaining Greek texts,
  698. 1:14:55which were then transmitted to Europe  at this time. This led to a revival of
  699. 1:15:02interest in classical learning and philosophy  and culture, including a revival of interest in
  700. 1:15:08Platonism and Hermeticism, and astrology was very  much connected to and intertwined with Hermeticism
  701. 1:15:16in the Greco-Roman tradition; so  that had some impact in terms of
  702. 1:15:22the influence then of astrology  in Europe during the Renaissance.
  703. 1:15:29This is a nice little diagram from Wikipedia  that just shows all of the different towns
  704. 1:15:34that had printing presses when printing  became very major in Europe at that time,
  705. 1:15:41where some of the major centers for printing up  books on printing presses were, and where they’re
  706. 1:15:47clustered around different areas. This is a copy  of the front page of a printed text, where they
  707. 1:15:57typeset and they printed up, using a  printing press, a Latin translation of
  708. 1:16:04an Arabic text from the 8th century, by the  astrologer named Masha’allah. Masha’allah lived in
  709. 1:16:11the late 8th century, let’s say, 775 or so, give  or take. He wrote his text in Arabic around 775,
  710. 1:16:23then it was translated into Latin around the  12th century, and eventually got printed up
  711. 1:16:29several centuries later after the invention  of the printing press in the mid-15th-century.
  712. 1:16:36You can kind of see this leapfrogging of astrology  from culture to culture, and time period to time
  713. 1:16:43period, every time there’s transmissions, and  when there’s new technological advancements,
  714. 1:16:52like the printing press. This can sometimes  lead to this explosion in the proliferation
  715. 1:16:57of astrology as one of the ways that new  technologies are often used by astrologers
  716. 1:17:05or ways that a culture is influenced  by astrology and vice versa.
  717. 1:17:10All right, so eventually, we get to the later part  of the astrological tradition, what I call ‘late
  718. 1:17:17traditional astrology’, where astrology started  to enter a decline in Europe by the 17th century.
  719. 1:17:25The last great flourishing of astrology occurred  in England in the 17th century, where one of the
  720. 1:17:32most important events was the publication of  William Lilly’s book, Christian Astrology, in
  721. 1:17:371647. So this was the first, full English language  textbook on astrology, which is kind of a big deal
  722. 1:17:47in the West, and in terms of  the English-speaking world.
  723. 1:17:50Up to this point, most books, most philosophical  and scientific and astrological works were written
  724. 1:17:58in Latin, which was the common language that was  used in Europe, and it was the common scientific
  725. 1:18:03language that everybody printed important  intellectual works in; but Christian Astrology was
  726. 1:18:11written in English. Lilly wanted to make it more  accessible to people that spoke English and didn’t
  727. 1:18:20necessarily read Latin, so he decided to write it  in English, in his primary language; which is kind
  728. 1:18:25of an interesting and important turning point  in terms of that being the beginning of English
  729. 1:18:30language literature–not literature, but English  language textbooks on astrology. After that point,
  730. 1:18:37other astrologers followed suit and started  writing their textbooks in English as well.
  731. 1:18:45Lilly’s textbook emphasized horary astrology  especially because that seemed to be his
  732. 1:18:49primary practice. Christian Astrology is  broken up into three books: the first book
  733. 1:18:55introduces basic concepts; and then the second  book, right away, jumps into horror astrology
  734. 1:19:02and how to answer specific questions, just based  on the chart cast for the moment of the question;
  735. 1:19:08then eventually, in Book 3 of Christian  Astrology, he does get into natal astrology
  736. 1:19:12and how to interpret birth charts. But it seems  like his primary practice and his primary focus
  737. 1:19:19in Christian Astrology, especially  in terms of the order of importance,
  738. 1:19:23was putting horary first and foremost, by making  that the first subject he jumped into in Book 2.
  739. 1:19:32Lilly’s approach, and the approach of  the other astrologers of this period,
  740. 1:19:35is interesting because it represents a  synthesis of the methods of earlier astrologers,
  741. 1:19:41in addition to some of the new advancements and  developments that occurred in his own time period.
  742. 1:19:49William Lilly drew on authors like Ptolemy,  Claudius Ptolemy, from the 2nd century,
  743. 1:19:54but also Masha’allah from the 8th century, Guido  Bonatti from the 13th century, and Jerome Kardan
  744. 1:20:01from the 15th or 16th century, who’s only a  century or two before Lilly himself. So you
  745. 1:20:08can see in that way that Lilly’s drawing on  the entirety of the astrological tradition,
  746. 1:20:14or at least the pieces of the astrological  tradition that he had access to up to that point.
  747. 1:20:20One of the interesting things though about that is  there was what’s sometimes referred to as a ‘back
  748. 1:20:27to Ptolemy movement’, where there was a tendency  to want to emphasize the older sources or the
  749. 1:20:32oldest source under the premise that the oldest  source was the most authoritative. And for Lilly,
  750. 1:20:40one of the oldest sources, or the  oldest and most authoritative source
  751. 1:20:45available at his disposal was the Tetrabiblos  of Claudius Ptolemy from the 2nd century,
  752. 1:20:52which was a four-book, highly influential  set of books from the Hellenistic tradition.
  753. 1:21:01Sometimes Ptolemy’s work differed from and  conflicted with some of the later Medieval Arabic
  754. 1:21:08authors like Masha’allah or Bonatti. And in cases  where there was a conflict, Lilly would tend to
  755. 1:21:15side with Ptolemy, under the premise that Ptolemy  was the earlier and more authoritative author.
  756. 1:21:21But one of the things that was interesting  about that or ironic about that is that
  757. 1:21:26Ptolemy himself, in the 2nd century, was a bit  of a reformer of astrology, and he introduced
  758. 1:21:32some new techniques and modifications to the  system which set him apart or made him unique
  759. 1:21:41in some ways compared to his contemporaries,  such as Vettius Valens or Dorotheus of Sidon.
  760. 1:21:47And it turns out that some of the Arabic authors  were actually more influenced in some ways by
  761. 1:21:54that other stream of the tradition,  by authors like Dorotheus and Valens,
  762. 1:22:00so that they were in some ways following the  earlier Hellenistic tradition more closely.
  763. 1:22:06But when later authors from the 17th  century, like Lilly, looked back,
  764. 1:22:11they didn’t necessarily have access to Dorotheus  or Valens, so they didn’t realize that the later
  765. 1:22:17Medieval authors were actually being more faithful  to the tradition than they had realized, and
  766. 1:22:24that creates some interesting tensions  in terms of using some of Lilly’s methods
  767. 1:22:30and whether to go with his adoptions of  Ptolemy’s approach or whether to go with
  768. 1:22:35other Hellenistic astrologers that might be  more in line with the later Medieval tradition.
  769. 1:22:42I mention this just because it’s an interesting  precedent, an interesting lesson from history,
  770. 1:22:48when we’re drawing on older sources. Sometimes  we don’t have the full vantage point or the full
  771. 1:22:55bird’s eye view because only a  few texts survive from any era,
  772. 1:23:02and so, all you can do is do your best to assess  what some of those earlier traditions were.
  773. 1:23:08But even once you do that, your perspective  is still going to be somewhat limited based on
  774. 1:23:14whatever texts survived from that era and what you  have at your disposal to work with, in terms of
  775. 1:23:20inheriting the texts and the techniques  from the earlier astrological traditions.
  776. 1:23:27All right, so at this point, from the 17th  century onward, we enter a period called
  777. 1:23:34the–it’s not usually called this–but you  might call it the ‘Astrological Recession’,
  778. 1:23:39where astrology goes into a decline, especially  in the West, in the English-speaking world in
  779. 1:23:45particular; but also in Europe, in general, due  to a mixture of different social and scientific
  780. 1:23:53and religious changes. So one part of that is the  scientific revolution and some of the advancements
  781. 1:24:01that occurred in astronomy, for example, which  overthrew and disproved Ptolemy’s cosmology.
  782. 1:24:09Part of what happened is that Ptolemy’s text–this  is almost a whole separate episode unto itself.
  783. 1:24:15But Ptolemy, as I said, in the 2nd century,  he was a scientist and a polymath who wrote
  784. 1:24:22major works on several different fields, including  astronomy, astrology, geography, harmonics;
  785. 1:24:32pretty much, you name it, Ptolemy wrote a text  on it if it was like a major scientific field.
  786. 1:24:39And with his astrological texts, he tried to
  787. 1:24:42situate astrology and to reform it a little bit  to make it look a little bit more acceptable from
  788. 1:24:50a natural or what we might  call a scientific standpoint
  789. 1:24:54by conceptualizing it as working as a result of  the planets influencing somehow life on Earth.
  790. 1:25:02Prior to that time, astrology was primarily  conceptualized as a form of divination, where the
  791. 1:25:09planets were seen to indicate things about, let’s  say, a person’s birth chart or a person’s life
  792. 1:25:15by acting as signs or omens of the future  without necessarily causing those events in
  793. 1:25:20the person’s life to happen, but Ptolemy tried to  reconceptualize it as more of a causal science.
  794. 1:25:28On the one hand, that was a somewhat positive  thing because it allowed astrology to survive
  795. 1:25:34some of the attacks that then started to  ramp up on it from Christianity, where
  796. 1:25:40the Christian Church basically tried to  stamp out astrology as a form of pagan
  797. 1:25:48learning and divination and started connecting  it with magic and other practices like that.
  798. 1:25:54But some forms of astrology, which were  conceptualized as natural or just working
  799. 1:26:01as part of the natural world just like  the weather, were seen as acceptable;
  800. 1:26:06and this is partially what allowed astrology to  survive the Middle Ages and the Medieval period,
  801. 1:26:12and then, eventually, to make a comeback in Europe  and hit a high point during the Renaissance.
  802. 1:26:18But the downside is that Ptolemy’s  model was based on a certain cosmology
  803. 1:26:24that placed the Earth at the center of the  cosmos. After some of the discoveries that
  804. 1:26:30occurred in the scientific revolution showed  that the Sun is actually the center of our
  805. 1:26:35solar system and the Earth revolves around it,  that threw off Ptolemy’s cosmology and made it
  806. 1:26:41questionable, which then had a sort of  domino effect in questioning and disproving
  807. 1:26:50some of his other models that were based on  it, including his rationale for astrology.
  808. 1:26:55So to make a long story short, that’s  one part of what happened that led to
  809. 1:27:00the Astrological Recession and  a decline in astrology in Europe
  810. 1:27:06and the West, from the 17th through the 19th  centuries. In reality, there were a lot of
  811. 1:27:11other cultural and religious and social issues  that were going on during that time as well.
  812. 1:27:17The decline of astrology is not simply the result  of the scientific revolution, and it wasn’t
  813. 1:27:22really a result of astrology being disproved  at this time, which is a common misconception.
  814. 1:27:31Scientists didn’t just come out of nowhere in  the 17th century and do statistical tests on
  815. 1:27:36astrology; in fact, statistical tests of astrology  didn’t really start until the 20th century. So
  816. 1:27:42it’s not that science disproved astrology in the  17th century, it’s just that there was this major
  817. 1:27:47shift and some of those scientific and religious  and cultural and conceptual shifts ended up having
  818. 1:27:56a negative effect on astrology and astrology fell  out of favor, especially with intellectuals. So
  819. 1:28:03astrology disappears from the universities during  this time and stops being taught there and is no
  820. 1:28:10longer seen as a legitimate subject or legitimate  form of wisdom or information or what have you.
  821. 1:28:19Astrology only survives at this time,  from the 17th and the 19th centuries,
  822. 1:28:23for the most part through the form of popular  almanacs, which were low-level astrology
  823. 1:28:31that continued to survive and be popular  in a minor sense during that time.
  824. 1:28:37But for the most part, this was after the heyday  of astrology, during the Renaissance in Europe,
  825. 1:28:44and there were not as many astrologers practicing  and not as many astrological textbooks that were
  826. 1:28:50being produced during this period, from the 17th  through the 19th centuries; even though there were
  827. 1:28:56still some, the practice was greatly reduced and  went into a low point for a couple of centuries.
  828. 1:29:04Eventually, we get to the rebirth  of astrology in the 20th century and
  829. 1:29:12part of the contributing factor was, again,  another change in culture, where there was this–in
  830. 1:29:17the mid-19th century–growth of spiritualism  and eventually the Theosophical Society;
  831. 1:29:25and the beginning of what we know of today as  the modern-day, New age movement began in the
  832. 1:29:32mid-to-late 19th century and then really  took off by the early 20th century.
  833. 1:29:38This was a period where people became more open  to and it became more fashionable to talk about
  834. 1:29:45things like karma and reincarnation and ghosts  and the afterlife and spirits and talking with
  835. 1:29:54spirits and different things like that. So it was  a whole period where interest in paranormal and
  836. 1:30:02occult topics suddenly became trendy or came into  vogue again and astrology was one of the things,
  837. 1:30:12as a side effect of that, led to a renewed  public interest in astrology basically.
  838. 1:30:20In the English-speaking world, there  was an astrologer named Alan Leo
  839. 1:30:24who’s often credited with instigating the  revival–or at least having a major role
  840. 1:30:30in impacting the revival of astrology at  that time and making it more accessible–by
  841. 1:30:35setting up different astrological  associations, and also, especially because of
  842. 1:30:40his publication of a bunch of books on astrology  that helped to popularize the subject in English;
  843. 1:30:46some of those books were also translated  into other European languages, which had some
  844. 1:30:50impact on spurring a revival to some extent  in other languages across Europe as well.
  845. 1:30:57Alan Leo was a Theosophist, so his books not  just incorporated Theosophical and New Age ideas,
  846. 1:31:06but also through the major publishing arm of  the Theosophical Society, that allowed him
  847. 1:31:13to have a huge reach across the world and have  his books reach a lot more people than it would
  848. 1:31:19have otherwise; and that’s part of the reason  why he’s credited with instigating or at least
  849. 1:31:24contributing to the revival, even though there  were other astrologers around that time that were
  850. 1:31:28writing books and participating in organizations  and magazines and other publications as well.
  851. 1:31:35So Alan Leo sought to simplify the system  and make it easier to learn because he found
  852. 1:31:40it to be very complicated when he first started  learning it as a student. Part of his goal was to
  853. 1:31:45break it down and simplify it just to make it  easier for new students to take up the subject
  854. 1:31:51because he was very passionate about it and  he wanted to share that with lots of people.
  855. 1:31:57He also had a greater focus on character  analysis, and we start seeing a shift in
  856. 1:32:01astrology–in the early 20th century that goes  through and accelerates throughout the 20th
  857. 1:32:06century–from astrology being more about prediction  in traditional astrology to eventually being more
  858. 1:32:13about character analysis. And then, later, after  the birth of depth psychology in the 20th century,
  859. 1:32:21it eventually became very much focused on  psychological analysis and introspection as well,
  860. 1:32:28but this is something that we already see going  really heavily with Alan Leo and his focus on
  861. 1:32:34character analysis; he liked to repeat  the phrase, “Character is destiny.”
  862. 1:32:42Also, at this time, astrology largely becomes  associated with the New Age movement and New Age
  863. 1:32:52concepts like karma and reincarnation and other  fringe topics like that or other philosophical
  864. 1:32:58topics that were being mixed together to form  a new philosophy of some sort. I don’t want to
  865. 1:33:05go on a whole digression about what the New Age  movement was; that’s a whole topic into itself.
  866. 1:33:12All right, so in modern astrology,
  867. 1:33:16there’s a few developments that we need to  talk about in the 20th century. First, we see
  868. 1:33:21the introduction or at least the popularization  of Sun-sign astrology from the 1930s forward.
  869. 1:33:30In newspapers and magazines, they start  to present astrological columns that focus
  870. 1:33:39on the 12 signs of the zodiac, where you’re  supposed to be able to look at it just based on
  871. 1:33:45knowing your birth date. You only have to know  your birth date because that will tell you roughly
  872. 1:33:49what your Sun sign is, and whatever the position  of your Sun is in the 12 signs of the zodiac,
  873. 1:33:55that becomes your sign and then you’re able  to read a forecast for that specific sign.
  874. 1:34:01This wasn’t as common of a concept prior to  the 20th century. If you go back and look
  875. 1:34:09at the Hellenistic texts, when they talk about  ‘your sign’–or other traditional texts–they’re
  876. 1:34:15usually talking about your rising sign, and  that’s supposed to be the most personal part
  877. 1:34:20in the chart that has more to do with your  personality or personal characteristics,
  878. 1:34:24whereas what happens in the 20th century is  that part of the popularization of astrology
  879. 1:34:31was a shift towards Sun signs. So that gets  going from the 1930s onwards and then becomes
  880. 1:34:38extremely popular and helps to repopularize  astrology in the public consciousness.
  881. 1:34:44Additionally, there were some astrologers that  continued the push towards character analysis
  882. 1:34:50that was initiated by Alan Leo and other  astrologers around that time period.
  883. 1:34:56Another astrologer, a few decades  later, Dane Rudhyar, in the 1930s,
  884. 1:35:01starts bringing in concepts that are  being introduced from depth psychology,
  885. 1:35:07and in particular, he starts incorporating, from  a very early stage, the work of the psychologist
  886. 1:35:12Carl Jung into astrology. One of his first  books was titled, The Astrology of Personality.
  887. 1:35:22I did a whole episode on Dane Rudhyar with Chet  Zdrowski at one point, so you can check that out
  888. 1:35:29if you’d like to learn more about that.  And I also did a whole episode on the
  889. 1:35:33revival of astrology in modern times  with Nicholas Campion at one point,
  890. 1:35:38so you can check that episode  out for more about that as well.
  891. 1:35:42But anyways, this really accelerates this push  towards a tendency to focus on internal states
  892. 1:35:50in 20th century astrology, and astrology shifts so  that it becomes more of a tool for psychological
  893. 1:35:57analysis and counseling rather than something  that is strictly predictive or deterministic or
  894. 1:36:05fatalistic or what have you. Increasingly, 20th  century astrology starts to differentiate itself
  895. 1:36:11from the earlier traditions, which it starts  conceptualizing as more fatalistic and a lot of
  896. 1:36:18the excitement starts being about depth psychology  and the integration of astrology and psychology.
  897. 1:36:26Additionally, in the 20th century, or at  least by the 20th century, we see the real
  898. 1:36:29incorporation of outer planets which have been  around. Uranus and Neptune were discovered over
  899. 1:36:36the previous two centuries, but eventually,  in the 1930s, there’s the discovery of Pluto;
  900. 1:36:42and then other bodies, including different  asteroids start being discovered as well,
  901. 1:36:50and from the 1980s forward, there’s a huge  push to integrate things like asteroids.
  902. 1:36:56By that time, the outer planets had been fully  integrated into astrology and were even starting
  903. 1:37:02to replace some of the traditional planetary  rulers as rulers of the signs of the zodiac.
  904. 1:37:10Uranus, in modern astrology, in 20th century  astrology, came to replace Saturn as the ruler
  905. 1:37:16of Aquarius; Neptune came to replace Jupiter  as the ruler of Pisces; and some astrologers
  906. 1:37:24eventually assigned Pluto to the sign of Scorpio.  So this represented for the first time in almost
  907. 1:37:322,000 years, a major overhaul and change to the  fundamental makeup of the astrological system
  908. 1:37:39where the rulership scheme itself started  being tinkered with by modern astrologers.
  909. 1:37:46In general, one of my feelings or one  of my impressions about modern astrology
  910. 1:37:51in the 20th century is that there was this  emphasis on innovation rather than tradition.
  911. 1:37:58In some instances, this was deliberate; in some  instances, it was just the thing to do and was
  912. 1:38:05more unconscious. But there seems to have been an  emphasis on inventing new techniques and coming up
  913. 1:38:11with the next big thing rather than just passing  on the tradition and copying it over slavishly;
  914. 1:38:21there was more of an emphasis on innovation  as part of one of the things that seems
  915. 1:38:26somewhat characteristic about 20th century  astrology. This led to a great flourishing
  916. 1:38:32and proliferation of many new techniques  and new ideas in 20th century astrology,
  917. 1:38:37in addition to the new things that were happening  just as a result of new discoveries–like new outer
  918. 1:38:43planets being discovered–necessarily causing  the astrologers to start changing the system.
  919. 1:38:50There was in the 1960s a large influx of younger  astrologers that came in partially due to the
  920. 1:38:56counterculture movement in America, for example,  the hippies and different cultural groups like
  921. 1:39:04that. There seemed to be an influx of astrologers  into the community at that time in the 1960s
  922. 1:39:11and ‘70s, in the US. Linda Goodman published  her book–what’s it called–Sun Signs in 1968,
  923. 1:39:20and it sold some ridiculous amount, like millions  of copies; it became a high watermark in terms of
  924. 1:39:31the perception of astrology in public culture,  where everybody knew what their Sun sign was.
  925. 1:39:38Astrology became mainstream once again after  not being mainstream for several centuries,
  926. 1:39:46but the way in which astrology was mainstream was  different in the 20th century compared to earlier
  927. 1:39:52due to this shift in emphasis towards character  analysis and the shift towards Sun-sign astrology.
  928. 1:40:00Additionally, in the second-half, and especially,  the fourth quarter of the 20th century,
  929. 1:40:09the rise of computers and personal computers  and then eventually the Internet made it easier
  930. 1:40:15to calculate charts. You didn’t have to know  how to do all of the math by hand. Instead,
  931. 1:40:23you could get a chart calculated  in a matter of seconds rather than
  932. 1:40:27the period of time that it would take, up  to that point, to calculate it by hand.
  933. 1:40:32This is kind of a big deal because for centuries,  up to this point, in order to calculate a birth
  934. 1:40:41chart, you needed to know the underlying astronomy  and the underlying math in order to be able to
  935. 1:40:47do it. You would have to have an ephemeris, which  would tell you the planetary positions in the past
  936. 1:40:55for every day and every year covering the time  period where you wanted to look up somebody’s
  937. 1:41:01birth chart of the day they were born, and  you’d also have to use other tables in order
  938. 1:41:07to calculate the houses or in order to calculate  what time zone was in effect to know what part
  939. 1:41:14of the day and what the rising degree was so  you could calculate the Ascendant correctly.
  940. 1:41:19It was kind of an involved process to calculate  a birth chart and it created a barrier to entry,
  941. 1:41:28where you had to at least be able to do  the basic mathematics involved and have
  942. 1:41:32the basic reference books in order to be able to  calculate a birth chart and then interpret it.
  943. 1:41:37So in the past few decades, first,  with the rise of personal computers,
  944. 1:41:43and then more recently, with the rise of websites  that will calculate birth charts for you, or even
  945. 1:41:50nowadays, mobile phone apps, anybody can calculate  a birth chart. All you need to know is your birth
  946. 1:41:56date, birthplace, and birth time and you can  get a chart calculated in a matter of seconds.
  947. 1:42:02That lowered the barrier to entry  and made it so that anybody can do
  948. 1:42:07the complex mathematical calculations  of astrology relatively easily.
  949. 1:42:13This is an interesting shift compared to  previous centuries, where for many centuries,
  950. 1:42:19the astrologers were also astronomers, and the  astrologers were sometimes mathematicians or
  951. 1:42:25people that were capable of doing the advanced  calculations that were necessary in order to
  952. 1:42:31calculate a birth chart, like Johannes Kepler,  or Claudius Ptolemy, or other famous astronomical
  953. 1:42:39figures who were also astrologers. Nowadays,  that’s changed just due to the advent of
  954. 1:42:45computers, and that’s an interesting thing that  we’re still getting used to in our culture–what
  955. 1:42:50sort of implications that has for the practice  of astrology and its prevalence around the world.
  956. 1:43:00Later, in the 20th century, we start to  see the revival of traditional astrology,
  957. 1:43:06and the context for this development is that there  weren’t a lot of texts from the earlier tradition
  958. 1:43:12that were available to modern astrologers  in the 20th century until very recently.
  959. 1:43:21Part of this is just due to  availability–the texts not being available
  960. 1:43:28or not being widely available in print  form because they weren’t kept in print.
  961. 1:43:33The other thing is that in order to read some  of the old texts from, let’s say, the Medieval
  962. 1:43:39tradition or the Hellenistic tradition, or  even the ancient Mesopotamian tradition,
  963. 1:43:46you have to have special language skills  in order to be able to read those texts.
  964. 1:43:51You have to know Latin to read some of the  Renaissance texts, or you have to know Arabic
  965. 1:43:57in order to read some of the early Medieval texts,  or you have to know ancient Greek in order to read
  966. 1:44:03some of the Hellenistic texts, or you have to know  cuneiform in order to read some of the ancient
  967. 1:44:08Mesopotamian texts, and if you don’t have those  special language skills, like most astrologers
  968. 1:44:14don’t or didn’t in the 20th century, then you’re  just out of luck; so that’s one thing; even when
  969. 1:44:23certain texts were available, astrologers couldn’t  read them. Also, prior to the 20th century,
  970. 1:44:28a lot of these texts weren’t readily available;  they were just lying around in Europe, in
  971. 1:44:35handwritten manuscripts, waiting to be translated  and waiting to be collected and put together.
  972. 1:44:41So two things happened. One thing that happened  is that there was a group of scholars in Europe
  973. 1:44:46that got together and decided to collect  all of the ancient Greek astrological texts
  974. 1:44:52that survived in the early 20th century.  They decided to create a catalog for them
  975. 1:44:58and started putting them together, publishing  them in modern printed book form for academic
  976. 1:45:05purposes because they wanted to study them  within the context of ancient cultures.
  977. 1:45:14They didn’t believe in astrology or think that the  astrological content was valuable in it of itself;
  978. 1:45:21instead, they just thought studying  the history of astrology would tell
  979. 1:45:25you something about ancient cultures and would  help you get an additional vantage point that
  980. 1:45:30was valuable from that perspective because,  typically, when astrologers do delineations for
  981. 1:45:35clients, they’re also describing  something about their worldview
  982. 1:45:38and something about how their  culture is perceived at the time.
  983. 1:45:44Basically, there was this rise in this  movement in academia to study ancient
  984. 1:45:49astrology as part of the history of science and  as part of the history of of Western culture;
  985. 1:45:56that was an important development  in academia, but it was happening
  986. 1:45:59independent of the astrological community,  and astrologers, for the most part,
  987. 1:46:03were not paying attention to what the academics  were doing; but then, by the 1980s and 1990s,
  988. 1:46:11astrologers started to get interested in  going back and studying the history of ancient
  989. 1:46:16astrology and studying the older astrological  tradition from prior to the 20th century.
  990. 1:46:22One example of this was Robert Zoller, who  wrote a book on the Arabic Parts in 1981,
  991. 1:46:28which was based largely on his study of the texts  of the 13th century astrologer, Guido Bonatti,
  992. 1:46:35who Zoller had read because he learned Latin in  college. So Zoller got a printed version of the
  993. 1:46:43text, and then he was able to read parts  of Bonatti by translating it for himself
  994. 1:46:48and then started to practice some of the  techniques that he learned from that 16th century,
  995. 1:46:53late Medieval text. But for the most part, Zoller  was kind of on his own in being one of the lone
  996. 1:47:00people in the US that was studying and trying  to promote traditional astrology at that time.
  997. 1:47:06Over in the UK, there was a revival of traditional  astrology that centered around horary astrology
  998. 1:47:13and especially around the work of William  Lilly from the 17th century, who wrote the
  999. 1:47:19earliest English textbook on astrology.  There was a push to reprint, and eventually,
  1000. 1:47:28through Regulus Publications, they ended up  reprinting the original textbook of William
  1001. 1:47:34Lilly in the mid-to-late-1980s. This  led to a sudden flourishing of interest
  1002. 1:47:41in practicing older methods of  astrology–especially horary,
  1003. 1:47:46based on Lilly and some of his  contemporaries–that developed a
  1004. 1:47:51lot of steam and got a lot of energy starting  in the late 1980s and throughout the 1990s.
  1005. 1:47:58At the same time, the historian and astrologer,  James Holden published a paper on whole sign
  1006. 1:48:05houses in 1982; the title of this paper–and  you can find it online on my website–is called
  1007. 1:48:12Ancient House Division by James Holden. He was the  first astrologer and historian to point out the
  1008. 1:48:19use of whole sign houses in the early Western  astrological tradition in 1982, and he also
  1009. 1:48:26translated and started publishing astrological  works, like the book of Abu Ali Al-Khayyat,
  1010. 1:48:34which Holden published a translation of in 1988  through the American Federation of Astrologers.
  1011. 1:48:40So Holden studied classics in college, and he  actually did his master’s thesis on William Lilly
  1012. 1:48:48and his work. And Holden had been translating  texts from Greek and Latin for himself,
  1013. 1:48:54privately, from the 1950s forward, but he’d never  published them. He had a whole separate career as
  1014. 1:49:02an electrician or something for several decades  before he retired from that in the 1980s,
  1015. 1:49:07and he became the research director of  the American Federation of Astrologers.
  1016. 1:49:12But the AFA, or the American Federation  of Astrologers, wasn’t very popular
  1017. 1:49:19in the 1980s and ‘90s. There was some sort of  split that occurred with the younger generation
  1018. 1:49:26of astrologers in the 1970s and 80s, where a  lot of that generation that came in the ‘60s
  1019. 1:49:32split away from the AFA and set up their own  separate organizations, such as the National
  1020. 1:49:38Council for Geocosmic Research, the International  Society for Astrological Research, and the
  1021. 1:49:44Association for Astrological Networking. So as a  result of that, Holden’s work wasn’t as well known
  1022. 1:49:52as it could have been otherwise, even though he  was translating texts and publishing some of them.
  1023. 1:49:58Eventually, in 1992-1993, a group of people got  together and founded the Project Hindsight/ARHAT
  1024. 1:50:09Translation Project, where they started  translating ancient astrological texts from
  1025. 1:50:15Greek and Latin–and maybe one or two other  languages–into English, and they started
  1026. 1:50:21publishing them; they were entirely funded  by the astrological community at that time.
  1027. 1:50:29So this started a revival and a great  flourishing of interest in older forms
  1028. 1:50:35of astrology, where for the first time in  centuries, astrologers were able to go back
  1029. 1:50:40and read some of the oldest astrological texts in  Greek and Latin from the Hellenistic and Medieval
  1030. 1:50:45traditions in their own language, in English, in  a modern language, which is a pretty big deal.
  1031. 1:50:53The main focal point of activity for this  translation project was especially between
  1032. 1:50:591992 and 1998, where they published something like  two dozen translations or preliminary translations
  1033. 1:51:09of some of these ancient astrological texts from  Greek and Latin; and this translation project
  1034. 1:51:14was primarily headed up by the astrologers,  Robert Schmidt, Robert Hand, and Robert Zoller.
  1035. 1:51:24Unfortunately, most of the activity was  confined to that translation project,
  1036. 1:51:28in terms of their output to the 1990s; that’s when  the majority of their translations were produced.
  1037. 1:51:36But then ‘the three Roberts’, during the  course of the project, ended up splitting up,
  1038. 1:51:42so that the project itself didn’t  complete its goal of translating
  1039. 1:51:48all of the ancient astrological texts  which it had originally set out to do.
  1040. 1:51:54Interestingly, around this time, in the late 1980s  and early 1990s, important to note there was also
  1041. 1:52:01a sudden surge in interest in the practice  of Indian astrology in the West at this time,
  1042. 1:52:08and one of the first organizations which  was dedicated to promoting Indian astrology
  1043. 1:52:16and its practice in the West, in America,  was founded. The Council of Vedic Astrology
  1044. 1:52:22was founded in the early 1990s, around the  same time that all this is taking place.
  1045. 1:52:26So part of the traditional revival was not just  a revival of interest in older forms of Western
  1046. 1:52:32astrology, but also a revival, a sudden surge  in interest in studying Vedic astrology as well,
  1047. 1:52:40which represented a 2,000-year-old  tradition that had been practiced
  1048. 1:52:44continually in India up to that point. The  Indian tradition had a much more continuous
  1049. 1:52:51tradition over the past 2,000  years than we’ve had in the West
  1050. 1:52:55because there weren’t as many starts  and stops and breaks in the tradition.
  1051. 1:53:01Due to its integration with Hinduism and  integration with religious doctrines and culture,
  1052. 1:53:10astrology continued to be permissible in India  over the past 2,000 years, while it fell out
  1053. 1:53:16of favor in Europe and in the West. So as a result  of that, some practices in Indian astrology today,
  1054. 1:53:24in modern times, are actually much more similar  to how Western astrology was practiced in
  1055. 1:53:29ancient times in the West than modern Western  astrology is, at least in the 20th century,
  1056. 1:53:35to ancient Western astrology, so that’s  another interesting piece of that.
  1057. 1:53:40And finally, as a result of all of these different  translation projects–not just from Project
  1058. 1:53:48Hindsight, which was one of the main things in the  1990s; there’s been other translators and other
  1059. 1:53:55groups that have produced translations–now  there are dozens of translations available
  1060. 1:54:03from many different astrological traditions  from the past 4,000 years that are available for
  1061. 1:54:09astrologers to study. This is a really unique  time in history because it means there’s more
  1062. 1:54:15translations that are available now  from different traditions of astrology
  1063. 1:54:19than have been available at any other time  in history, which puts us at a very unique
  1064. 1:54:26nexus in terms of the timeline  in the history of astrology.
  1065. 1:54:31One of the side notes that I want to mention at  this point is the Uranus-Neptune conjunctions;
  1066. 1:54:39the planets Uranus and Neptune form a  conjunction approximately every 172 years.
  1067. 1:54:49One of the things that I noticed  that was really interesting is when I
  1068. 1:54:53lived at Project Hindsight–I studied there  for just over two years, from 2005 until 2007.
  1069. 1:55:07One of the things I was always really  curious about was what was going on
  1070. 1:55:11in 1992 and 1993 when this translation project was  started because it wasn’t just that translation
  1071. 1:55:19project; also, the revival of of traditional  astrology in the UK had turned into a full-blown
  1072. 1:55:26thing at that point and there was a lot of  excitement surrounding traditional astrology.
  1073. 1:55:31There was the founding of the American College  of Vedic Astrology around 1992-1993 as well,
  1074. 1:55:37and there was also the foundation of Kepler  College, which was an attempt in the West to
  1075. 1:55:43create a school for astrologers and to bring  astrology back into academia, in some sense.
  1076. 1:55:51So there was a lot of stuff going on around  1992-1993, especially with the revival of
  1077. 1:55:56ancient wisdom, and I was curious what was  going on astrologically and if there’s anything
  1078. 1:56:03that coincided with that, that sort of  stood out. One of the things that I noticed
  1079. 1:56:09was that there was this conjunction–this  somewhat rare conjunction–of outer planets
  1080. 1:56:14between Uranus-Neptune that occurred in 1992  and 1993, right when all of this was going on.
  1081. 1:56:22I thought that that was curious, and I  decided to look back and see what had happened
  1082. 1:56:28at other times in the history of astrology  when Uranus-Neptune conjunctions occurred.
  1083. 1:56:33And what was weird is I started noticing that at  the start of many of these major traditions of
  1084. 1:56:39astrology, especially at the point where there was  a transmission of older forms of astrology which
  1085. 1:56:45were then merged with whatever the prevailing  astrological tradition was at that time,
  1086. 1:56:50there would often be a Uranus-Neptune conjunction.
  1087. 1:56:54That’s been the subject of other talks. Sometimes  I go through the different Uranus-Neptune
  1088. 1:57:02conjunctions, but just to give you an idea, there  was a Uranus-Neptune conjunction in 61 and 62 BCE,
  1089. 1:57:11which roughly coincides with the emergence  of the Hellenistic astrological tradition.
  1090. 1:57:17There was another conjunction in 794/795 CE,  which was when Masha’allah and some of the
  1091. 1:57:26early Arabic authors were writing in Baghdad,  and they started their translation project
  1092. 1:57:33in Baghdad in order to translate texts from Greek  and Sanskrit and Persian into Arabic. That was in
  1093. 1:57:40Baghdad, under the House of Wisdom, that  translation project; so there was a Uranus-Neptune
  1094. 1:57:46conjunction that perfectly coincided with the  start of the Medieval astrological tradition.
  1095. 1:57:51Then right in the middle of the  12th century translation movement,
  1096. 1:57:57there was a Uranus-Neptune conjunction  from 1135 through 1137 CE; so right in
  1097. 1:58:04the middle of that huge movement of scholars  who were flocking from all over Europe to Spain
  1098. 1:58:10to translate texts from Arabic to Latin,  there was a Uranus-Neptune conjunction.
  1099. 1:58:14And remember, when William Lilly published  Christian Astrology in 1647, that was within
  1100. 1:58:23two or three years of another Uranus-Neptune  conjunction, which occurred between 1649 and 1650.
  1101. 1:58:31So these are actually just a few of them. The  full version of this lecture I’ve given at
  1102. 1:58:38different points over the past 15 years–2006  was the first time I gave this lecture–and I
  1103. 1:58:46integrated the Uranus-Neptune conjunctions  throughout it. I didn’t want to make that the
  1104. 1:58:50focal point of this lecture, but I still wanted  to include something as a side note about that
  1105. 1:58:56because I think that it really helps to  contextualize the current period of transmission
  1106. 1:59:01and synthesis that we’re going through now;  where just like in history, periodically,
  1107. 1:59:08this revival of older forms of astrology are  transmitted and recovered and then synthesized
  1108. 1:59:14with whatever the prevailing approaches  to astrology are at that time,
  1109. 1:59:18and it ends up creating a new astrology that then  becomes the standard over the next century or two.
  1110. 1:59:26When you break down the  astrological traditions–this
  1111. 1:59:29isn’t a complete breakdown–we have, let’s say,  the high point of Mesopotamian state-supported
  1112. 1:59:35astrology in the 8th century under the Assyrian  Empire in Mesopotamia; then we have the birth
  1113. 1:59:43and the introduction of natal astrology  in the 5th century BCE in Mesopotamia.
  1114. 1:59:48We have the birth of Hellenistic astrology and the  birth of the four-fold system that uses planets,
  1115. 1:59:55signs, houses, and aspects in the 1st century BCE.  Then we have–this is a little bit more rough–the
  1116. 2:00:03Indian and Persian traditions; we have that  transmission of Hellenistic astrology to India,
  1117. 2:00:08into Persia, at least by the 3rd  century or possibly a little bit later.
  1118. 2:00:13Then in the 8th century, we have the  beginning of the Medieval Arabic tradition.
  1119. 2:00:19In the 12th century, we have the Medieval Latin  tradition, which flourishes as a result of
  1120. 2:00:25translating texts from Arabic into Latin. Then we  have the 15th century Renaissance tradition, which
  1121. 2:00:34really gets going after the invention  of the printing press; and then the
  1122. 2:00:3817th century English tradition, starting with  William Lilly and some of his contemporaries,
  1123. 2:00:44at the very end of traditional astrology  before its decline. And then, finally,
  1124. 2:00:49we have 20th century modern astrology,  especially starting with William Leo, being
  1125. 2:00:56fully reconceptualized by astrologers such as Dane  Rudhyar, and then reaching its peak in especially
  1126. 2:01:03the last quarter of the 20th century; so that  pretty much brings us to where we are today.
  1127. 2:01:10So I wanted to have one quick little  reference where, roughly speaking,
  1128. 2:01:15these are the astrological traditions, or  you could break them down into five eras.
  1129. 2:01:23On The Astrology Podcast, when I  refer to ‘Mesopotamian astrology’,
  1130. 2:01:27I’m talking about the type of astrology that  was practiced in Mesopotamia from roughly
  1131. 2:01:332000 BCE until about 100 BCE. When we’re  talking about ‘Hellenistic astrology’,
  1132. 2:01:39we’re talking about the type of astrology  that was practiced in the Mediterranean
  1133. 2:01:44region between the 1st century, roughly 100 BCE,  and 650 CE; that’s the Hellenistic tradition.
  1134. 2:01:54When we talk about ‘Medieval astrology’,  we’re talking about the type of astrology
  1135. 2:01:59that was practiced between roughly 750 CE and  about 1300 or so CE. And that tradition in and
  1136. 2:02:09of itself can sometimes be divided into the  early Medieval tradition, which is in Arabic
  1137. 2:02:15in the late Medieval tradition, which tends  to be more in Latin; but generally speaking,
  1138. 2:02:19they’re so close most of the time that they’re  treated as a group, as just Medieval astrology.
  1139. 2:02:26Then there’s what I call ‘Renaissance astrology’.  There’s not really a good name for this tradition;
  1140. 2:02:31I know some people call it ‘late modern  astrology’, or ‘early modern astrology’
  1141. 2:02:38is sometimes the term used for  William Lilly’s type of astrology. But
  1142. 2:02:42if you were to do like we did with the  Medieval tradition and try to group it
  1143. 2:02:46more together to make a distinct unit, then  what I’m calling Renaissance astrology would
  1144. 2:02:51be the type of astrology practiced in Europe  between 1400 CE and 1700 CE; it’s roughly what
  1145. 2:03:07we might call the Renaissance tradition. And  then, finally, there’s ‘modern astrology’,
  1146. 2:03:11which is the type of astrology practiced in  the West between roughly 1900 and 2000 CE.
  1147. 2:03:19So that brings us to where we are now, where we’re  in the early 21st century or still in the first
  1148. 2:03:25quarter of the 21st century, and I don’t really  have a name for what this tradition is going to be
  1149. 2:03:31called. 20th century astrology tended to be called  ‘modern astrology’, but astrology is already
  1150. 2:03:40starting to change a lot compared to what was  practiced even just a few decades ago because of
  1151. 2:03:48the revival of all of these different older forms  of astrology that are now being introduced into
  1152. 2:03:53the mainstream, and it’s having some interesting  effects on the astrological tradition already.
  1153. 2:03:58For example, through even simple technical things  like the rediscovery of whole sign houses as a
  1154. 2:04:05form of house division, that’s already become,  over the past decade or two, one of the most
  1155. 2:04:11popular forms of house division; whereas prior  to its rediscovery by James Holden in the 1980s,
  1156. 2:04:18and then subsequently Robert Hand and Robert  Schmidt in the 1990s independently, it wasn’t
  1157. 2:04:23known about as a form of house division prior to  that time. So that’s a pretty radical shift to
  1158. 2:04:28go from not a form of house division anyone’s  using in the West in the early 20th century
  1159. 2:04:36to suddenly it being the second-most popular  form of house division by this point in 2020.
  1160. 2:04:44Sometimes these revivals are already  changing astrology significantly,
  1161. 2:04:48and we’re going to have at some  point a question about what to call
  1162. 2:04:52whatever new tradition emerges at this time  from the synthesis of all of these different
  1163. 2:04:57modern and ancient traditions that’s  starting to go on as they intermingle.
  1164. 2:05:03In general, I did want to mention something  here about the value of studying tradition, and
  1165. 2:05:09not just from a technical standpoint, but  also from a historical standpoint. Part of
  1166. 2:05:16the purpose of studying the history of astrology  is understanding how astrology itself developed,
  1167. 2:05:23and this can tell you where the  techniques came from and how they
  1168. 2:05:28were originally developed, which is important  from a conceptual and a practical standpoint.
  1169. 2:05:33It can also result in us rediscovering techniques  that otherwise had been lost, such as techniques
  1170. 2:05:40like whole sign houses, which I just mentioned;  but there’s other techniques like sect.
  1171. 2:05:44There’s techniques like the ‘Arabic Part to  the Lots’ that have been reintegrated into the
  1172. 2:05:50tradition. There’s techniques like the ‘time-lord’  techniques. Also, there’s some techniques like
  1173. 2:05:55horary astrology, which was still practiced  in the 20th century, but then there was the
  1174. 2:06:01rediscovery of traditional-style hoary astrology  from William Lilly and earlier authors, which was
  1175. 2:06:06a little bit different than how horary had been  practiced up to that point in the 20th century.
  1176. 2:06:11So sometimes it can take us back  to the roots in a sense and let us
  1177. 2:06:16get a different perspective on earlier  versions of the astrological tradition,
  1178. 2:06:20which sometimes are different than  how we experience the tradition today.
  1179. 2:06:27Sometimes going back and studying the history of  astrology or studying the older traditions can
  1180. 2:06:33help us to understand techniques  that we still use today,
  1181. 2:06:37for example, where the significations of  the houses come from. There’s some ancient
  1182. 2:06:46techniques like ‘annual profections’ that help us  to enhance certain techniques that we still use,
  1183. 2:06:52like the concept of transits, where you can use  annual profections to identify which transits are
  1184. 2:06:59going to be more important and which transits  are going to be less important to a person
  1185. 2:07:03in the upcoming year; which can have a very  useful, filtering effect on using that technique.
  1186. 2:07:11Additionally, sometimes when we study  the history of ancient astrology and
  1187. 2:07:15the astrological tradition in general, it can  give us a clear insight into the conceptual
  1188. 2:07:21and philosophical basis of the astrological  tradition. So there’s some things that we do
  1189. 2:07:28that we just take for granted, but we don’t  know why we do that. We don’t know where that
  1190. 2:07:32technique came from or how anybody came up with  it, but we just use it as part of the tradition,
  1191. 2:07:37or at least until recently  that’s how it’s been done.
  1192. 2:07:41But going back and studying some of these ancient  texts, in some instances, has actually given us
  1193. 2:07:46greater insight into why certain techniques and  how certain techniques were developed, which is
  1194. 2:07:52incredibly useful and puts you on a much more  certain footing about deciding which techniques
  1195. 2:07:57you want to use and which techniques you don’t  want to use; or which techniques have a more
  1196. 2:08:04solid conceptual or philosophical or practical  basis versus which techniques may not have as
  1197. 2:08:11solid of a basis and that can be useful in  different ways for practicing astrologers.
  1198. 2:08:18Finally, going back and reviving the traditions  can reconnect us with the empirical traditions of
  1199. 2:08:24astrology, where astrologers have been practicing  this subject for thousands of years and have
  1200. 2:08:29been writing down their observations  and their experiences for centuries.
  1201. 2:08:36Having access to the collected wisdom of  centuries’ worth and hundreds and thousands
  1202. 2:08:43of lifetimes’ worth of astrologers observing  the stars and seeing what happened in terms
  1203. 2:08:50of those movements correlating with earthly  events can only help us in terms of enhancing
  1204. 2:08:57our ability to practice astrology today,  by letting us not have to reinvent things
  1205. 2:09:04from a blank slate. We can take on some of the  useful observations that our predecessors have
  1206. 2:09:12made in order to give us a shortcut instead of  just having to invent everything from scratch.
  1207. 2:09:20I feel like that’s important because  I feel like that’s one of the things
  1208. 2:09:23that was almost like a skipped step in modern  astrology with the push towards innovation and
  1209. 2:09:31breaking out on your own in order to explore new  vistas, which is important and was a necessary and
  1210. 2:09:39useful and helpful thing. So don’t get me wrong.  I think that break in the 20th century that modern
  1211. 2:09:46astrology had from the ancient traditions allowed  us to introduce new things and explore new vistas
  1212. 2:09:55that we might not have introduced otherwise or  explored otherwise, and I think that was actually
  1213. 2:09:59very important and valuable and should be honored  and many of those innovations should be retained.
  1214. 2:10:07Not having access to the ancient astrological  tradition meant sometimes reinventing the wheel,
  1215. 2:10:14and sometimes there were pieces from the older  traditions that were perfectly valid and useful
  1216. 2:10:18that we simply didn’t know about because we  didn’t have access to them. But now that we do
  1217. 2:10:23again through these translations of ancient texts,  there’s no reason not to take some of those things
  1218. 2:10:29into account or not to draw on and partake in  some of the wisdom from those ancient traditions.
  1219. 2:10:38The upshot here and what I think I’ve shown at  this point is that astrology is going through
  1220. 2:10:43another one of its periodic periods  of transmission and synthesis.
  1221. 2:10:49One of the things I wasn’t able to show as  well here–because this was not as much of a
  1222. 2:10:54technical lecture as much as it was  just a broad overview–is every time
  1223. 2:10:59astrology is transmitted to a new language  or to a new culture, it changes in some way.
  1224. 2:11:06So while our goal needs to be to  go back and look at the ancient
  1225. 2:11:10traditions, study and understand and  reconstruct them as best as we can,
  1226. 2:11:16in some ways, there may be instances where we  misunderstand or misinterpret certain things,
  1227. 2:11:22and that in and of itself will cause changes and  deviations in the tradition; so that’s one source
  1228. 2:11:28of periodic changes in the tradition, just  misunderstandings. Another cause for changes
  1229. 2:11:35is just receiving two different or multiple  traditions at once and sometimes having to
  1230. 2:11:40make a choice between them when they go in  different directions. So that’s another reason why
  1231. 2:11:48there’s changes that sometimes happen when there  are these revivals of older forms of astrology.
  1232. 2:11:55So what’s happening now and what will happen  is that a new type of astrology will emerge,
  1233. 2:12:01and one of the things that I think is important  and would be good for us to talk about is
  1234. 2:12:06what are some of the best things from each of  the ancient astrological traditions that each
  1235. 2:12:11ancient and modern tradition has to contribute  to any future synthesis. What are some of the
  1236. 2:12:16best pieces that were good innovations that would  be worth continuing or passing on to the future?
  1237. 2:12:24Obviously, we’re not all going to agree on  what was the best piece of each tradition
  1238. 2:12:31that should be passed on, but it’s still  an interesting dialogue to have because
  1239. 2:12:36some pieces of the tradition always inevitably  get passed on and some pieces of the tradition
  1240. 2:12:42sometimes get lost or set aside for different  reasons–and some of those reasons are good and
  1241. 2:12:47some of those reasons are not as good–but  to whatever extent we can have a conscious
  1242. 2:12:52discussion about that today,  I think it would be useful.
  1243. 2:12:56Traditionalism doesn’t require the rejection of  every aspect of modern astrology. And one of the
  1244. 2:13:02things that I’ve tried to say continuously  on The Astrology Podcast and I tried to end
  1245. 2:13:11the last chapter of my book with a  rejection of fundamentalism because
  1246. 2:13:15I generally think we should try to avoid  astrological fundamentalism of any sort.
  1247. 2:13:21It’s okay for people to have preferences for  different traditions or different techniques
  1248. 2:13:26or different approaches, and we have to  make room for people to be able to advocate
  1249. 2:13:32for the techniques or the approaches or  the traditions that they prefer and that
  1250. 2:13:37they want to show their love for and share with  other people so there has to be room for that.
  1251. 2:13:44But we also want to be careful that in going back  and digging up some of these different traditions
  1252. 2:13:50that it doesn’t lead to a sort of  fundamentalism in terms of saying
  1253. 2:13:54that my approach to astrology is  the best, and if you don’t practice
  1254. 2:13:59that approach to astrology that you’re an idiot  or you’re a bad astrologer or something like that.
  1255. 2:14:06While that’s a tendency that can sometimes happen  or that some astrologers have, some astrologers,
  1256. 2:14:18for example, like Rob Hand talk about astrology as  a language and different traditions of astrology
  1257. 2:14:25being like speaking different languages. If you’re  comparing two languages, like English and French,
  1258. 2:14:34they’re just different languages and  different ways of talking. It doesn’t make one
  1259. 2:14:38better or worse, but instead, they’re just  different ways of doing similar things.
  1260. 2:14:44So to some extent, I think astrology is like  that and it would be more productive if we,
  1261. 2:14:49in comparing the traditions,  tried to focus more on
  1262. 2:14:53what we like about different aspects  of them rather than the things that we
  1263. 2:14:57dislike about different aspects of them to  whatever extent we can in order to encourage
  1264. 2:15:05inclusivity, realizing that there’s many  different ways to practice astrology
  1265. 2:15:11both historically, in ancient  times, as well as in modern times.
  1266. 2:15:16To try to stamp out certain types of astrology is  almost like an attempt to erase that diversity.
  1267. 2:15:24Instead of attempting to erase that diversity, I  think it would be better to embrace it in some way
  1268. 2:15:30by looking at it as something that’s interesting;  that astrology can be practiced in different ways
  1269. 2:15:36rather than something that’s somehow  negative, if that makes sense
  1270. 2:15:42This is something I’ve been  thinking about for a while:
  1271. 2:15:44What are the contributions of each  tradition? This is not a comprehensive list;
  1272. 2:15:47it’s just some of my offhand thoughts about some  of the things that I find interesting about the
  1273. 2:15:53different traditions that they could contribute  if you were trying to synthesize them together.
  1274. 2:15:57From the Mesopotamian astrological tradition,  I really like and appreciate and think is
  1275. 2:16:02important is their ‘observational astrology’,  where they had a much closer connection to
  1276. 2:16:08actually looking at the sky and
  1277. 2:16:10observing the movements of  the planets and the stars
  1278. 2:16:14with the naked eye and on their own–not  always relying on books or relying on
  1279. 2:16:22computers or what have you–to calculate the  positions of the planets. They were going out each
  1280. 2:16:27night and they were looking and had a personal  relationship with the stars and with the sky.
  1281. 2:16:35That approach to observational astrology I think  is very important and something that we can draw
  1282. 2:16:40on and learn from in terms of studying the  Mesopotamian tradition. They also had a very
  1283. 2:16:45close connection with ‘omenology’ and with the  relationship between astrology and other types
  1284. 2:16:52of divination. Understanding astrology within the  context of other types of divination, in terms
  1285. 2:17:00of reflecting on how astrology works and how to  conceptualize and use it, would be very useful.
  1286. 2:17:09From Hellenistic astrology, since that’s of  course my primary tradition, I think we can learn
  1287. 2:17:15things like understanding the core technical  structure of the system, since many of the core
  1288. 2:17:19techniques that we use in Western astrology  over the past 2,000 years really fully came
  1289. 2:17:25together around that time. We can also recover a  lot of lost interpretive distinctions, like sect,
  1290. 2:17:33overcoming, which is an aspect doctrine thing,  as well as concepts like whole sign houses that
  1291. 2:17:40I’ve already mentioned. There’s also some advanced  timing techniques such as the time-lord systems,
  1292. 2:17:45which includes things like annual profections, but  also other more advanced time-lord techniques such
  1293. 2:17:50as zodiac releasing that I think are useful things  that we can recover from Hellenistic astrology.
  1294. 2:17:56From Indian astrology, we can recover  something about the sidereal framework.
  1295. 2:18:04Even if one isn’t switching to the sidereal  zodiac but looking at the nakshatras and their
  1296. 2:18:09connection with the fixed stars, bringing that  framework back into Western astrology in some form
  1297. 2:18:16may be useful and important. In Indian astrology,  they also have other things like the dasha
  1298. 2:18:22systems, which is a continuous tradition of  basically the Indian version of the time-lord
  1299. 2:18:28systems using their framework. And the  way that the Indian astrologers use the
  1300. 2:18:33dasha systems could tell us a lot about how  Western astrologers could use some of these
  1301. 2:18:39techniques, like time-lords, now that  they’re being revived in modern times.
  1302. 2:18:45From the Medieval tradition, there’s a lot  of great techniques for mundane astrology
  1303. 2:18:50using the Jupiter-Saturn cycle, as well as other  world cycles and other mundane techniques, like
  1304. 2:18:56Aries ingress charts and other types of ingress  charts, so there’s some very good mundane stuff.
  1305. 2:19:03There’s also some great stuff from  medical astrology and temperament
  1306. 2:19:07theory that really got going in the Medieval  tradition and really started to be refined
  1307. 2:19:12at that point, which is useful for  character analysis, but also for
  1308. 2:19:18different applications of astrology in  a medical context in different ways.
  1309. 2:19:24From the Renaissance tradition, it really  became the high point of certain types of
  1310. 2:19:31refinements in horary astrology and the practice  of horary astrology after inheriting it and
  1311. 2:19:36synthesizing it from the previous tradition, and  there’s much more extensive textbooks on horary
  1312. 2:19:43astrology that survive from, for example, William  Lilly compared to some of the earlier Medieval
  1313. 2:19:49authors. There’s also some interesting stuff from  Renaissance astrology from works, like Marsilio
  1314. 2:19:55Ficino, on sympathetic magic and different  ways that astrology can be conceptualized
  1315. 2:20:01in a magical context that’s interesting  and potentially useful in modern times.
  1316. 2:20:07And then, finally, from modern astrology,  things like psychology and counseling are super
  1317. 2:20:12interesting and useful skills for astrologers,  especially when you’re practicing natal astrology,
  1318. 2:20:18which involves talking to people about their lives  and about their future and potentially about their
  1319. 2:20:23fate; and there’s some things where even though  an astrologer can say something, it doesn’t
  1320. 2:20:29necessarily mean that they always should. I think  there’s a lot of great insights and advancements
  1321. 2:20:35that were made in modern psychological astrology  and counseling astrology that are useful things
  1322. 2:20:40for traditional astrologers to take into  account and integrate into their practice.
  1323. 2:20:45Additionally, I think some of the developments  with other celestial bodies being incorporated
  1324. 2:20:50into modern astrology were useful advancements,  like the integration of the outer planets Uranus,
  1325. 2:20:56Neptune, and Pluto. There is going to be an  issue where so many additional planetary bodies,
  1326. 2:21:04like minor planets or asteroids or other things,  have been discovered and are continuing to be
  1327. 2:21:09discovered and will be discovered in the future  that there’s going to be an issue of where to
  1328. 2:21:14draw the line in terms of how many bodies  you want to integrate into your practice.
  1329. 2:21:19Each astrologer will have to draw the line
  1330. 2:21:22in a different place to some extent and some  of that will be somewhat arbitrary or somewhat
  1331. 2:21:30unique to each practitioner based on their own  interests and philosophy and everything else,
  1332. 2:21:36but I think there are interesting things from  some of these new astronomical discoveries that
  1333. 2:21:41could be incorporated into astrology without doing  too much violence to the astrological tradition.
  1334. 2:21:50Finally, the last thing that I want to talk  about is something that I’ve been thinking
  1335. 2:21:54about for the past few years and that I refer  to as the Hermetic nature of astrology where,
  1336. 2:22:00traditionally, astrology was said to be  ruled by the planet Mercury. Astrologers
  1337. 2:22:06were said to be signified by Mercury  in astrology, in general; for example,
  1338. 2:22:10in the texts of Vettius Valens in the 2nd  century, it was said to signify astrology.
  1339. 2:22:15Part of the reason for this is that astrologers  were thought to be translators in some way who
  1340. 2:22:23could read and translate the speech of the stars;  and that’s actually what astrology means, if you
  1341. 2:22:31translate the word ‘astrology’ literally from  Greek; it means something like ‘star speech’. So
  1342. 2:22:38astrologers in some sense translate this language  that is written in the sky and in the stars for
  1343. 2:22:48individual human beings and relate it to what  the stars have to say about individual lives.
  1344. 2:22:56So one of the issues though with this is  that the mercurial or Hermetic nature of
  1345. 2:23:05astrology–if astrology is truly a Hermetic- or  Mercury-type thing–is that often it means or
  1346. 2:23:14it results in there being dueling approaches to  the same thing, where there can be two different,
  1347. 2:23:24mutually exclusive approaches to the same thing,  but both of those approaches, even though they
  1348. 2:23:29seem mutually exclusive, can potentially  work or have some value in their own right.
  1349. 2:23:36And we see this crop up in a bunch of  different areas in astrology where there are
  1350. 2:23:42these sometimes dueling approaches  to doing the same thing.
  1351. 2:23:47One of these great debates in the astrological  tradition is whether to use the sidereal
  1352. 2:23:52zodiac versus the tropical zodiac, and some  astrologers very adamantly use the tropical
  1353. 2:23:58zodiac and some astrologers very adamantly  say that there’s something valuable to use
  1354. 2:24:03about the sidereal zodiac. So there’s  two, what seem like mutually exclusive
  1355. 2:24:08approaches, but they may have some  independent value in their own right.
  1356. 2:24:16Similarly, the history and the  debates over house division.
  1357. 2:24:21For example, more recently, there’s been debates  about whole sign houses versus quadrant houses.
  1358. 2:24:28Each group thinks that their system works  really well, and so they prefer it and they
  1359. 2:24:33defend it sometimes very aggressively, but there  may be independent value to both of those systems
  1360. 2:24:40rather than it just being something where one is  right and the other is wrong. In other instances,
  1361. 2:24:46there’s debates like the modern versus traditional  rulership scheme, psychology versus event-based
  1362. 2:24:53astrology, or character analysis versus  prediction. There was also a debate since
  1363. 2:25:00the 1990s about whether astrology is science or  whether it’s divination and so on and so forth.
  1364. 2:25:07There’s all of these dueling approaches or  dichotomies–I can’t really think of the right
  1365. 2:25:14word–where there are these mutually exclusive  ways of practicing or conceptualizing astrology,
  1366. 2:25:22where astrologers are often pitted against each  other in thinking that you have to pick one or the
  1367. 2:25:28other and it can’t be both; but in reality, there  could be some validity to both at the same time.
  1368. 2:25:36The sooner astrologers realize that as  part of the basic nature of astrology,
  1369. 2:25:42the sooner we’re going to be able to  reconcile some of those tensions and truly
  1370. 2:25:46understand astrology on its own terms for what  it actually is. So that’s something I wanted to
  1371. 2:25:53end this talk about and have you think about  because it may be important in moving forward,
  1372. 2:25:58as we try to reconcile some of the  different astrological traditions.
  1373. 2:26:04Much of what we have to realize is that  astrology straddles the line between both
  1374. 2:26:09and there may be parts that are true on both  sides as part of the very nature of astrology.
  1375. 2:26:19All right, so in terms of the future, we  are obviously going through another period
  1376. 2:26:25of transmission and re-synthesis.  What’s happening right now is we’re
  1377. 2:26:31starting to combine the modern and the ancient  traditions, so there’s some steps that we need
  1378. 2:26:37to finish and wrap up before that can fully take  place and before that can fully be finished.
  1379. 2:26:43One of those is we need to finish reviving  the tradition by translating the rest of
  1380. 2:26:49the surviving ancient astrological texts because  they haven’t all been translated or revived yet;
  1381. 2:26:55there are some scholars who have done an  amazing job of translating these texts
  1382. 2:27:00in both the astrological and academic  communities over the past few decades.
  1383. 2:27:06There’s been some scholars that have  translated texts, like David Pingree,
  1384. 2:27:10who was an academic that translated a number of  texts or preserved them from ancient languages.
  1385. 2:27:15There’s also astrologers such as James  Holden, Benjamin Dykes, Robert Schmidt,
  1386. 2:27:22Robert Hand, Robert Zoller, or Levante Laszlo–  recently who started a new translation project
  1387. 2:27:28for ancient Greek astrological texts–who are doing  a lot of that important work right now, but we
  1388. 2:27:35need to support some of those efforts either by  contributing to those translation projects, by
  1389. 2:27:42buying those translations, and basically helping  out the people who are translating those texts.
  1390. 2:27:48Alternatively, if you want to learn an ancient  language to help in that translation effort,
  1391. 2:27:54if you have some sort of aptitude  for ancient languages, for example,
  1392. 2:27:58then maybe you, yourself, could take part in  that translation project because there’s still
  1393. 2:28:03lots of work that needs to be done, not just in  translating the texts, but also in reconstructing
  1394. 2:28:09those texts even once we have translations.  Sometimes, even once you have a translation
  1395. 2:28:14of an ancient text, it still takes some work  to understand and interpret it to correctly
  1396. 2:28:22receive the information that the original author  was attempting to convey through their words,
  1397. 2:28:28and sometimes that can be more difficult  than it sounds like it should be.
  1398. 2:28:33So once we do that there’s going to be a new  synthesis of astrology that emerges in our time
  1399. 2:28:39over the next few decades. Part of that is going  to happen organically, just through astrologers
  1400. 2:28:46reading ancient texts and reading modern  texts and intermingling with each other
  1401. 2:28:51and exchanging information. Every time you  put two astrologers in a room together,
  1402. 2:28:56they will start to talk and will start  to exchange tips and exchange views,
  1403. 2:29:03and their views will tend to rub off on each  other, one way or another, and that’s just the
  1404. 2:29:08way it’s always been throughout history  and that’s still the way it is today.
  1405. 2:29:12When there’s other traditions of astrology  that are practicing in close proximity,
  1406. 2:29:17they always start to influence each other  in some way. So some of that’s going to
  1407. 2:29:21happen organically and some of that might also  happen deliberately as a result of astrologers
  1408. 2:29:27going out of their way to create some  sort of synthesis of different traditions,
  1409. 2:29:34by sitting down and deciding and talking  about what are the best parts of astrology
  1410. 2:29:39from each tradition that should be put  together and contributed to the future.
  1411. 2:29:45So I think it’s really important and really  crucial then as part of that process to foster
  1412. 2:29:51dialogue between the astrological traditions. And  we don’t have to agree on everything. It’s okay to
  1413. 2:29:59have debates or arguments and disagreements  sometimes, or sometimes even strong ones,
  1414. 2:30:07but it’s important to stay respectful  because it’s just part of the process.
  1415. 2:30:13There’s not necessarily a reason to personalize  it or to make it something that’s negative;
  1416. 2:30:19instead, it’s something that is just a natural  part of the growth and transmission and the
  1417. 2:30:24evolution of astrology that’s been going on  for centuries and for thousands of years.
  1418. 2:30:32In doing this, we’re all going to be following in  the footsteps of our predecessors who have carried
  1419. 2:30:39out this process for over 4,000 years now. And  I think that’s something that’s reassuring and
  1420. 2:30:47puts us in good company by understanding that,  even though the end result isn’t clear now.
  1421. 2:30:54Nobody knows for sure exactly what the synthesis  is going to be that’s going to come out of this
  1422. 2:30:58time period in the next few decades. We know  at least if we approach it with a sense of
  1423. 2:31:03being humble and honest and eager to do  our best as astrologers in modern times
  1424. 2:31:11that we will be able to pull it off, to some  extent, and contribute something that will then
  1425. 2:31:19outlive us and will live on and eventually will  pass on to our ancestors–not our ancestors,
  1426. 2:31:25but our to whoever it is that takes  over astrology in a century from now,
  1427. 2:31:30or whoever recovers the texts that we’re writing  today, 1,000 years from now, 5,000 years from now,
  1428. 2:31:39or what have you. They’ll be able to, ideally,  look back on us and say that we did a good job
  1429. 2:31:47with the tradition in putting it  together to the best of our abilities
  1430. 2:31:51during this very brief period of  time when it was in our possession.
  1431. 2:31:57So I like to end lectures like this by saying  the catchphrase, “By looking back into the past,
  1432. 2:32:06we can create a better astrology for the future,”  not by going back into the past and staying there,
  1433. 2:32:13but by going back and looking into the past  and taking some of the best techniques from it
  1434. 2:32:17forward and bringing them into our time  and merging them with some of the great
  1435. 2:32:22innovations that have taken place in the past  century. And I think by doing that we will,
  1436. 2:32:28in fact, create a better astrology for  the future, or at least that’s my hope.
  1437. 2:32:34All right, so that’s it for  this lecture on the history of
  1438. 2:32:37Western astrology. There’s a couple of books  that I want to recommend for further reading.
  1439. 2:32:42If you want to learn more about the history  of Western astrology, my favorite book on the
  1440. 2:32:47history of astrology is by James Holden, and it’s  a book titled, A History of Horoscopic Astrology.
  1441. 2:32:54Holden focuses more on talking about individual  astrologers in the astrological tradition
  1442. 2:33:03and giving a history of astrology that’s based  on what were the most important astrologers
  1443. 2:33:07and what were the most important texts at  different points in the history of astrology.
  1444. 2:33:12So it’s almost like a biographical approach to  talking about the different eras of astrology.
  1445. 2:33:19I love that approach. It’s something that  always stuck with me, and my way of dividing
  1446. 2:33:23up astrological history is very much influenced  by his, as you’ll see if you read his book.
  1447. 2:33:30His book is one of the ones that really gave me  a passion for studying the history of astrology,
  1448. 2:33:34so I always recommend his book as one of the  core books that every astrologer should have.
  1449. 2:33:40So check that book out, A History of  Horoscopic Astrology. I also highly recommend
  1450. 2:33:45the two-volume series by Nicholas Campion  titled, A History of Western Astrology,
  1451. 2:33:51where Nick Campion approaches  astrology more from a cultural context.
  1452. 2:33:57He gives a great additional perspective and  a much more detailed perspective in terms of
  1453. 2:34:03the history and philosophy of astrology from  ancient to modern times and how astrology has
  1454. 2:34:12both been influenced by different cultures  at different points and times and what their
  1455. 2:34:16religious and philosophical beliefs  were. Also, Nick Campion talks very
  1456. 2:34:21well about how astrology itself has influenced  different cultures at different points in time
  1457. 2:34:28and what kind of cultural impact  astrology has had in different eras.
  1458. 2:34:34And it’s two volumes. It’s divided into  ancient astrology and then modern astrology,
  1459. 2:34:41but both of those volumes, if you  get that together with Holden’s book,
  1460. 2:34:45are just an amazing overview of the history  of astrology that goes into much more detail
  1461. 2:34:49and much more nuance than I was able to cover  in what is otherwise still a very long lecture.
  1462. 2:34:58Finally, if you want to learn more about ancient  astrology, I would check out my book titled,
  1463. 2:35:02Hellenistic Astrology: The Study of Fate and  Fortune. I have a huge section in the beginning
  1464. 2:35:10dealing with the history of ancient astrology,  as well as a section that talks about the
  1465. 2:35:16transmission of Hellenistic astrology all the way  through to modern times. It was really important
  1466. 2:35:22for me to give a historical backdrop, where  the first-half of my book, or the first-third
  1467. 2:35:29of my book, is just establishing the history of  ancient astrology and trying to document as best
  1468. 2:35:35as I could how Western astrology originally  developed in the in the Hellenistic period.
  1469. 2:35:41And then in the second-half of the book, I go  into the actual techniques of ancient astrology
  1470. 2:35:46and use a bunch of example charts in order  to demonstrate how ancient astrologers
  1471. 2:35:53used and practiced and conceptualized astrology;  but the historical component is very important
  1472. 2:35:59there as well, so I recommend checking  that out if you’d like something that’s
  1473. 2:36:03kind of like a blend between the history  of astrology as well as the practice.
  1474. 2:36:11Let me see. I think that might be it for  this lecture. That is. That is the last
  1475. 2:36:15slide in this lecture. So thank you very much.  This is my website, theastrologypodcast.com.
  1476. 2:36:21If you made it all the way through this lecture,
  1477. 2:36:23this was my brief overview of the history of  astrology. Any one of these traditions, we could
  1478. 2:36:29have sat down and broken it down into a bunch of  different subsections and gone into more detail.
  1479. 2:36:34I hope in giving an overview of these  different traditions that I haven’t
  1480. 2:36:39done a disservice to any of them. I mean, there’s  some that I only touched on very briefly, like the
  1481. 2:36:44history of Indian astrology; that’s something I  hope to go into more detail about at some point.
  1482. 2:36:51Part of my purpose with The Astrology  Podcast and one of the things I’ve
  1483. 2:36:54been doing with it over the past eight  years, since I started it in 2012, is
  1484. 2:36:59if you look through the archives of The Astrology  Podcast, you’re going to find a bunch of episodes
  1485. 2:37:04where I’ve already dealt with a bunch of subtopics  on the history of astrology. I love doing
  1486. 2:37:10historical episodes where we go and do a deep dive  into some of these topics every once in a while.
  1487. 2:37:19Like I said, I’ve done episodes on Dane Rudhyar,  and different modern figures like Dane Rudhyar and
  1488. 2:37:24Alan Leo. I did an episode with Kim Farnell on  Alan Leo last year. I’ve had Nick Campion on to
  1489. 2:37:30talk about the revival of astrology in modern  times. Nina Gryphon and I did an episode on
  1490. 2:37:35William Lilly last year. I’ve just done a ton  of different episodes on different historical
  1491. 2:37:42figures or different historical eras  and topics, so be sure to look through.
  1492. 2:37:46If you go to theastrologypodcast.com/episodes,  you’ll see a concise list of the titles of all
  1493. 2:37:52280 episodes, and you’ll get a sense of what  other ones on the history of astrology you could
  1494. 2:37:58check out in order to go further  into some of these topics.
  1495. 2:38:03All right, I think that’s it. I guess the only  other thing is if you want to learn more about
  1496. 2:38:07ancient astrology, I teach courses on
  1497. 2:38:10Hellenistic astrology. I have an online  course that has lots of lectures like
  1498. 2:38:13this one, where I go into detail, not just  about the history of ancient astrology but
  1499. 2:38:17also about techniques. My main course is my  course called The Hellenistic astrology Course,
  1500. 2:38:24which you can Google, or you can  find out more information about at
  1501. 2:38:27theastrologyschool.com. And I  also teach electional astrology,
  1502. 2:38:32as well as one other course on how to set  up a professional practice as an astrologer.
  1503. 2:38:37So I think that’s it for this episode. Thanks  to everybody for listening or watching this
  1504. 2:38:41episode of The Astrology Podcast. Thanks  to all of the patrons who support my work
  1505. 2:38:45through my page on Patreon, and in return  get early access to new episodes and other
  1506. 2:38:51benefits. I really appreciate you. You’re  the only reason I’m able to keep doing the
  1507. 2:38:56episodes like I do each month at this  rate, so thanks a lot for your support.
  1508. 2:39:01And I guess that’s it for this  episode of The Astrology Podcast,
  1509. 2:39:03so thanks a lot for listening,  and I’ll see you again next time.
  1510. 2:39:08Thanks to all the patrons that supported the  production of this episode of the podcast through
  1511. 2:39:12our page on Patreon. In particular, thanks to  the patrons on our Producers tier, including
  1512. 2:39:17Nate Craddock, Maren Altman, Thomas Miller,  Catherine Conroy, Michelle Merillat, Kristi Moe,
  1513. 2:39:24Ariana Amour, Mandi Rae, Angelic Nambo, and Sumo  Coppock. For more information about how to become
  1514. 2:39:32a patron or have your name listed in the credits,  please visit patreon.com/astrologypodcast.
  1515. 2:39:39Thanks also to our sponsors, including  the Northwest Astrological Conference,
  1516. 2:39:43which is happening online May 27-31, 2021 (for  more information about that, visit norwac.net);
  1517. 2:39:52the ISAR Astrology Conference, which is happening  August 18-22, 2021 (for more information,
  1518. 2:39:59visit isar2020.org); the Honeycomb Collective  Personal Astrological Almanac, which is available
  1519. 2:40:05at honeycomb.co; the Portland School of Astrology,  which you can find out more information about
  1520. 2:40:11at portlandastrology.org; the AstroGold  Astrology App, available at astrogold.io;
  1521. 2:40:18and finally, Solar Fire Astrology  Software, which is available at alab.com.
  1522. 2:40:23You can get a 15% discount on  it by using the promo code AP15.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of The History of Astrology: From Ancient to Modern Times by The Astrology Podcast, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 22,848 words across 1,522 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.