The Eternal Notre-Dame | FULL DOCUMENTARY — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:01[Music]
- 0:04it was the world's most visited Monument
- 0:06up until April the 15th
- 0:102019 it was on that evening that Flames
- 0:13threatened to destroy
- 0:15it its Spire did however
- 0:18succumb was like a knife in the bag I
- 0:21felt my muscles give
- 0:23away something that never should have
- 0:25happened had just
- 0:28occurred never less the Cathedral of
- 0:31notand Dei is still
- 0:33standing 48 M wide 127 M long with two
- 0:38towers 69 M High which were for a long
- 0:41time the French capital's
- 0:45tallest it's as Monumental as its
- 0:47designer Bishop Maurice duli had hoped
- 0:49it would
- 0:51be the idea of scale is from the very
- 0:55start one of the main considerations of
- 0:57nadan it is huge it is huge for its
- 1:04time the reason this 12th century Gothic
- 1:07Masterpiece resisted the fierce fire was
- 1:09thanks to its original
- 1:11design the builders constructed two
- 1:13gigantic Stone vaults which are still
- 1:15standing 35 M
- 1:17high they were the highest vaults in
- 1:19Europe at the time they were
- 1:21built erecting a 35 met Vault was an
- 1:25Undisputed record for the Western
- 1:28world a bullwark against the ravages of
- 1:31time as symbolized by its colossal
- 1:33foundations dug deep into one of the
- 1:35most unyielding soils of
- 1:39Paris all his vast work was visible but
- 1:43in itself was a masterpiece a hidden
- 1:46Masterpiece in order to guarantee noam's
- 1:48total stability gigantic flying
- 1:50buttresses were added the largest of
- 1:52their kind in the world with a reach of
- 1:5412
- 1:55M these Master Masons were brilliant
- 1:58designers and they they were able to
- 2:00make something so big so strong sit on
- 2:03these sort of spider
- 2:08legs for 800 years the cathedral's
- 2:10wooden framework nicknamed the forest
- 2:13was a structure made from 1200 Oaks and
- 2:15protected the stone until it went up in
- 2:20Flames its only Achilles heal in the
- 2:22event of fire was the oversized Spire
- 2:25erected by V luk in the 19th
- 2:28century it was a massive superstructure
- 2:30made out of 750 tons of wood and Lead
- 2:33weighing the equivalent of three
- 2:35airliners this is the story of how notam
- 2:38was born and how it resisted fire and
- 2:40the test of
- 2:44[Music]
- 2:47time in the eyes of the world it was the
- 2:49Incarnation of medieval architecture and
- 2:51considered changeless and
- 2:58impregnable one of the most horrible
- 3:01things I've ever seen is the Spire
- 3:04collapsing in a blaze into the
- 3:16Nave when the fire got close to the
- 3:19front we began to worry about the hole
- 3:21of the
- 3:24building this world favorite historical
- 3:26monument was wounded to the
- 3:28Core
- 3:37the next morning when we turned on the
- 3:39news it was sort of a relief I mean it
- 3:41wasn't good it was a terrible fire but
- 3:43there was also the feeling that yes the
- 3:45gothic system fireproofing on some level
- 3:48does
- 3:50work an ancient but perfect Gothic
- 3:53system of fireproofing thought up by its
- 3:55Builders more than 8 centuries
- 3:57[Music]
- 3:58ago
- 4:04the big technological innovation in
- 4:05architectural terms was the Vault they
- 4:08were very quick to understand the need
- 4:10to have vaed buildings to limit major
- 4:14damage notam is a feat of pure
- 4:17architectural engineering from the
- 4:18Middle
- 4:19Ages and yet no trace of its Builder
- 4:22intentions
- 4:24remains in order to crack the secrets of
- 4:27its strength you have to make the stones
- 4:29tall and turn back the clock to the
- 4:31middle of the 12th
- 4:32[Music]
- 4:41century
- 4:421160 Paris was a bustling town of 25,000
- 4:47inhabitants it was a town on the rise
- 4:49but it didn't yet have its
- 4:53Cathedral impressive Gothic structures
- 4:56had already been built in law in noo and
- 4:58in s
- 5:02we suddenly have this explosion of of
- 5:04great Cathedrals so that there is not
- 5:06only an enormous amount of wealth uh
- 5:09coming to the cities uh but also the
- 5:12need of the Bishops to have Cathedrals
- 5:14that are in some way representational
- 5:15and worthy of the new status of the
- 5:20town like his peers the ambitious Bishop
- 5:23of Paris Maurice duli wanted a
- 5:26cathedral especially as he had the means
- 5:28to build one
- 5:31the bishop owned a huge amount of land
- 5:33and part of the
- 5:34capital he was an important Lord whose
- 5:36income was amend
- 5:41IM huge income and sacred land right in
- 5:44the middle of Paris on the ilac
- 5:48city there were probably several
- 5:50churches there
- 5:52already the main one being dedicated to
- 5:58santen
- 6:00but it was undoubtedly too small and
- 6:02decrepit for the new bishop of Paris and
- 6:04Maurice D wanted it
- 6:11demolished his ambition was to build a
- 6:13cathedral as good as the Basilica of
- 6:15sandini 10 km to the north of
- 6:20Paris rebuilt between 1130 and 1144 by
- 6:24the Abby suji it was the burial place
- 6:27for the kings of France and help launch
- 6:30the explosion in Gothic
- 6:32architecture all that's left of this
- 6:34frenzy today is the
- 6:37[Music]
- 6:41ambulatory when the people of the Middle
- 6:43Ages discovered the Basilica and the
- 6:46choir they would have noted that light
- 6:48was present everywhere the walls had
- 6:52gone it was just a forest of pillars
- 6:56making it a single space with open Bays
- 6:59and
- 7:00abs it was a radical
- 7:05change this feat was made possible by a
- 7:07structural element which alone was the
- 7:09symbol of Gothic
- 7:10architecture the rib
- 7:13[Music]
- 7:17Vault up to that time if religious
- 7:20buildings had vaults they would have
- 7:22been Barrel
- 7:23vaults heavy tunnel-like forms which
- 7:26exerted a considerable and continuous
- 7:27pressure on the sidewalls
- 7:31if you take a sheet of paper for example
- 7:34and fold it to make a tunnel then you
- 7:36press on the top of the paper you can
- 7:38easily feel the paper presses down on
- 7:40the
- 7:43sides to counteract this pressure the
- 7:46walls were often extremely thick and
- 7:47heavy using up so much material that it
- 7:50was difficult to build them high or to
- 7:52open out the
- 7:57building but by combining two rib vaults
- 8:00the medieval Builders realized that the
- 8:01load could be transmitted downwards to
- 8:03the rows of
- 8:07columns and so they realized that the
- 8:10wall in between was no longer
- 8:13needed being light and using fewer
- 8:15materials rib vaults enabled buildings
- 8:17to gain considerable
- 8:20height and once they were covered by
- 8:22Stone panels the building would be
- 8:24protected from any fire that might break
- 8:26out in the wooden Rafters above
- 8:30[Music]
- 8:31it made great good sense to use them and
- 8:34it had this beautiful aesthetic effect
- 8:36of these diagonal lines crisscrossing
- 8:38across
- 8:41space the old buildings at notredam
- 8:43couldn't begin to compare with
- 8:47that moist Suli wanted his building to
- 8:50have the most impressive rib vating ever
- 8:53constructed in order to make it the
- 8:55reference in Gothic
- 8:58monuments
- 9:03but he needed an exceptional architect
- 9:06to carry this
- 9:07out in the 12th century Architects were
- 9:10very often trained in masonry they were
- 9:13called Master
- 9:14Masons the gothic Master Masons who were
- 9:17working for Suli we don't have their
- 9:22names these people were
- 9:25incredibly thoughtful with their
- 9:27understanding of geometry and
- 9:30engineering they needed someone who
- 9:32could create the cadences the
- 9:34proportions based on simple geometric
- 9:40plans we have no idea who notra Dam's
- 9:42first Master Mason was but Maurice duli
- 9:45more than likely chose the most
- 9:47ambitious and audacious Mason of his
- 9:51time what might we imagine them saying
- 9:53we want a building that is very modern
- 9:55and very upto-date we want something
- 9:58that will also soore above the city and
- 10:00affirm the power of the cathedral what
- 10:03can you do for us Master
- 10:06ma under the watchful eye of moist Su
- 10:09the first Master Mason produced plans
- 10:11for a gigantic
- 10:15Cathedral its scale was
- 10:17exceptional notam would be the largest
- 10:20church in the Paris region measuring 48
- 10:23M wide and 127 M long in France at the
- 10:27time only the Clooney was
- 10:31larger I think the idea of scale is from
- 10:34the very start one of the main
- 10:36considerations of nraam it is huge it is
- 10:40huge for its
- 10:41time I do think it's helpful to think of
- 10:44the cathedral as a Civic stadium in a
- 10:47sense because it's where so many
- 10:49important rituals and ceremonies needed
- 10:52to take place and a small building is
- 10:55actually a safety
- 10:58hazard the extraordinary surface area
- 11:00was matched by its
- 11:03height the interior width of the
- 11:05building required that the vaults rise
- 11:07to 35
- 11:10M making moris DUI's Cathedral the
- 11:14highest vaulted building in the Western
- 11:20World in the west erecting a vault to
- 11:23such a height 35 M was an Undisputed
- 11:26record it was almost Beyond human scale
- 11:29it was a work which could be said to
- 11:30have been Dively created technically it
- 11:32seemed almost beyond
- 11:35belief the Master Mason chose to build
- 11:38six-part rib
- 11:39vaults or sex parites comprised of three
- 11:43arches and three volted panels This
- 11:46strengthened the structure almost
- 11:47certainly reducing the risk of
- 11:49[Music]
- 11:56collapse it's a very brilliant aesthetic
- 11:59choice because it expands the width of
- 12:01the
- 12:02space having a sex partite volt spreads
- 12:06out the distribution of the mass in a
- 12:08very elegant
- 12:14solution the feat of notredam was in
- 12:17having this combination of monumental
- 12:19vaults and remarkably thin walls which
- 12:23happen to be no thicker than those of
- 12:24house manian buildings in
- 12:27Paris
- 12:35in order to ensure the stability of
- 12:36these thin walls the thrust of the
- 12:39vaults had to be counted at a height of
- 12:4035
- 12:42M how was this
- 12:45done the 12th century Master Mason had
- 12:48an audacious
- 12:49solution to build clearly visible
- 12:52exterior
- 12:56butresses butresses are essential like
- 12:59crutches they come to Aid of extremely
- 13:01ambitious
- 13:05monuments what made notam Innovative was
- 13:08choosing butresses from the word go
- 13:10because the gigantic scale of the
- 13:12project required
- 13:13[Music]
- 13:21them the 12 M long flying besses of
- 13:24notam were the largest in the
- 13:27world
- 13:29they had a double
- 13:30function to transfer the thrust of the
- 13:33vaults from the interior supports to the
- 13:35exterior ground level and secondly to
- 13:38protect the building from the
- 13:41wind it was entirely possible that at 35
- 13:43M High the wind could cause the building
- 13:46to Simply Collapse by exerting
- 13:48unsustainable
- 13:49[Music]
- 13:53pressure if the flying buttresses were
- 13:55to disappear yes notron would still
- 13:57stand but
- 13:59not in a terrible
- 14:03storm the buttresses were originally
- 14:06built for technical reasons but were
- 14:08impressively
- 14:11sculpted their spider-like form is
- 14:13unrivaled
- 14:20elsewhere Maurice duli was insistent
- 14:23that his new cathedral should not just
- 14:25be technologically Innovative but should
- 14:28also go down into
- 14:34history the master Mason's response can
- 14:36be seen in the cathedral's
- 14:38decoration particularly in the Towering
- 14:41antique inspired Columns of the choir
- 14:43and the
- 14:49Nave the idea of the column is an idea
- 14:53about Antiquity and we want to think
- 14:54about Paris wanting to be ancient it
- 14:56wants to emphasize the Roman past the
- 15:00distinguished Roman
- 15:03past as well as these columns which are
- 15:05spread evenly throughout the building
- 15:08the link to the past would be reinforced
- 15:10by dividing the cathedral into five
- 15:14sections a central section and two
- 15:16aisles either side evoke the first
- 15:19pre-christian
- 15:20basilicas but also the Church of santen
- 15:22which notam would
- 15:27replace
- 15:30replicating the five sections was a way
- 15:32of giving a certain substance a certain
- 15:34reverence to the new building this was
- 15:37legitimate because not only did it
- 15:38emulate the past but also it didn't
- 15:40undermine old habits cannons pilgrims
- 15:43worshippers who had known the old
- 15:44Cathedral and who came to the new Nave
- 15:46of notam could find the same areas as in
- 15:49the old
- 15:51building they wouldn't be shocked or
- 15:55upset not dedicated to the vir Virgin
- 15:58Mary was to be the largest Cathedral
- 16:01ever built at the time the Master Mason
- 16:03would have to prove himself to be equal
- 16:05to the grandiose
- 16:10plans he also has to think how on Earth
- 16:14am I going to build this in the
- 16:17constrained territory that I have on the
- 16:22I need to have cart springing Stone I
- 16:25need to have space for the forge and I
- 16:28need to have fire and I need to have
- 16:29sand I need all these materials somehow
- 16:32to congregate at a site it's like
- 16:34planting it
- 16:41ination over 860 years of building work
- 16:45began in the year
- 16:47[Music]
- 16:571160
- 17:08notam required colossal foundations
- 17:11which would be
- 17:14invisible its contemporary the Basilica
- 17:17of sandini can help us understand
- 17:19construction techniques of the Middle
- 17:27Ages
- 17:29you can see here that they used all
- 17:30types of stone sometimes abandoned Stone
- 17:34from
- 17:36quaries you can see traces of old joints
- 17:39there's also cutstone already prepared
- 17:41set and squared
- 17:44off all this vast work was invisible and
- 17:48enabled the mity and beauty of what was
- 17:50to come but in itself was a masterpiece
- 17:54a hidden
- 17:57masterpiece so how was this hidden
- 17:59Masterpiece designed and
- 18:02constructed the building work started in
- 18:04notredam with the
- 18:08choir the first stage was to dig deep
- 18:11enough to find strong enough soil to
- 18:13hold the Colossal amount of stone for
- 18:15the building's
- 18:21foundations the geological conditions of
- 18:23Il weren't
- 18:26favorable they had to keep digging all
- 18:28all the way down to a depth of 9
- 18:36m 9 M down you have to take the height
- 18:39of the key side you can see behind
- 18:42me which is about 6 M and add half the
- 18:47depth again in order to reach the level
- 18:50at which the foundations were
- 18:52laid not only is the level very deep but
- 18:55it's submerged in
- 18:57water
- 18:59every winter the water would rise the
- 19:01soil would be
- 19:02affected and the foundations would
- 19:05become unstable not solid
- 19:07enough there was a huge risk of the land
- 19:10slipping under the cathedral's
- 19:12foundations causing the work to be
- 19:14deformed higher
- 19:17[Music]
- 19:19up to ensure the stability of the
- 19:21foundations in this water loged soil the
- 19:24Master Mason decided to sink huge wooden
- 19:26Stakes deep into the subsoil
- 19:30[Music]
- 19:33sinking poles into the riverbed
- 19:35underneath the
- 19:36foundations was a way of preventing the
- 19:38foundations being washed away and the
- 19:41cathedral being
- 19:43deformed once these Stakes were in place
- 19:46the builders were able to construct the
- 19:47foundations with Limestone and
- 19:51mortar you're going to create a kind of
- 19:53network of Foundations and they're going
- 19:55to look a little bit like a pyramid
- 19:57they're going to be wider at the base
- 19:59and narrower at the top as you rise to
- 20:02ground level at 9 M deep the foundations
- 20:06of notredam had another
- 20:10peculiarity just like at sandini parts
- 20:13of old religious buildings demolished to
- 20:15make place for the cathedral were
- 20:18used as with these column
- 20:22bases in those days Stones had power
- 20:27they radiated
- 20:29they were charged with energy like our
- 20:31modern-day batteries to put it simply
- 20:35they transmitted a symbolic
- 20:37force and they bestowed on the walls not
- 20:40only protection but also continuity with
- 20:44ancient
- 20:49buildings the foundations built during
- 20:51the 1160s were one of the main strengths
- 20:53of the
- 20:56cathedral this strength strength was
- 20:58combined with the power of the
- 21:00stone it was present in the Parisian
- 21:03subsoil ready to be picked like ripe
- 21:06[Music]
- 21:08fruit the raw materials necessary were
- 21:11found in the surrounding Hills
- 21:13sedimentary rock deposited 45 million
- 21:16years ago according to the
- 21:18geologists in warm shallow Seas which
- 21:21sound lovely leaving magnificent
- 21:23Limestone typical of the center of the
- 21:26Paris
- 21:27basin
- 21:30the slopes of the river s and its
- 21:32tributaries had Banks of limestone the
- 21:34sin carried them all the way into Paris
- 21:37and thus provided the building site with
- 21:39all its
- 21:42needs even though nadam was built in
- 21:45stone it could not be finished without
- 21:47another material
- 21:50wood wood scaffolding was essential in
- 21:52the building of the
- 21:54cathedral the wood came from forests
- 21:57owned by the bishop
- 22:00brick when we look at a cathedral now we
- 22:03don't think about wood but we would not
- 22:06be able to build a cathedral without
- 22:08vast amounts of wood coming up as a kind
- 22:11of frame all around the stone walls as
- 22:14they emerge from the
- 22:17ground thanks to Wood Stone and the
- 22:20skill of its Builders the cathedral's
- 22:22choir took
- 22:24shape within a few years they'd got as
- 22:27far as the
- 22:28galleries while the builders erected the
- 22:31claries they also started on building
- 22:33the flying buttresses with a 12 M reach
- 22:37these would ensure the stability of the
- 22:39vaults to
- 22:41come building such archers was a
- 22:43technological
- 22:48challenge it must have blown everybody
- 22:51away I mean it was a spectacle in a
- 22:53sense to see these external arches
- 22:56rising up so high to support the walls
- 22:59and the
- 23:02roof once this was completed iron hooks
- 23:05would be inserted into the masonry to
- 23:07reinforce and strengthen the
- 23:09walls but before constructing the vaults
- 23:12the building needed a wooden framework
- 23:14to cover
- 23:15it the first one would be replaced
- 23:18during the following Century but its
- 23:20role was
- 23:23vital it was important to wreck the
- 23:25framework before the vaults because the
- 23:28framework obviously protected the
- 23:29building but also gave it a bulk filled
- 23:32it out to such an extent that the walls
- 23:34were braced and wouldn't move once the
- 23:37framework was up then the materials
- 23:38required for constructing the vaults
- 23:40could be levered up by special
- 23:44mechanisms a tread wheeel Crane or
- 23:47squirrel cage was one of these
- 23:50mechanisms charges of up to several
- 23:52hundred kilos could be lifted by rope
- 23:54and pulley activated by a wheel turned
- 23:57by by two men walking inside the
- 24:01[Music]
- 24:04crane the cage was a motor which along
- 24:07with a rope and a pulley mechanism
- 24:08enabled anything to be lifted up to 100
- 24:11m High the squirrel cages were so
- 24:13important in the Middle Ages that they
- 24:15turned up in illuminated manuscripts
- 24:17such was a pride in the
- 24:21devices the huge wooden Timbers intended
- 24:24to support the Vault arches were almost
- 24:27certainly raised into the cathedral
- 24:28Rafters thanks to a squirrel
- 24:33[Music]
- 24:36cage when those vaults are going up they
- 24:38were the highest in the known world and
- 24:41they were therefore some of the most
- 24:43ambitious building projects in Europe at
- 24:45the time the second stage of the
- 24:47construction of the vaults involved the
- 24:49Masons placing the stones on the Timbers
- 24:51one by one starting with the
- 24:56Keystone the rest of the stones already
- 24:59cut to size were placed afterwards and
- 25:02fixed with
- 25:05[Music]
- 25:07mortar the Keystone is put in place
- 25:10first because its position determines
- 25:12where the center
- 25:13is this then enables the Timbers to be
- 25:16repositioned and the necessary material
- 25:18for the rib Vault can be laid
- 25:22out here they're doing this for the
- 25:25first time so high imagine the impct of
- 25:28this on people walking by and seeing
- 25:30these arches in up in the air and
- 25:33thinking oh my goodness how is this ever
- 25:35going to stand
- 25:37up once the Arches were in place they
- 25:40could be used as a fulcrum to construct
- 25:42the
- 25:43panels the last stage was the most
- 25:46delicate of all when the Timbers were
- 25:49removed this was when the risk of
- 25:51collapse was at its
- 25:53highest however there has never been any
- 25:55recorded trace of any accident involving
- 25:58these record-breaking 35 met High
- 26:01vaults the construction of the Vault
- 26:03started with the positioning of the
- 26:05Arches and then that of the panels above
- 26:08them they were
- 26:10gigantic covering almost 100 square
- 26:15[Music]
- 26:17m in spite of their relative thinness
- 26:20between 20 to 30 cm noam's vaults proved
- 26:24to be incredibly efficient during the
- 26:25fire of April the 15th 201
- 26:2919 they bear witness to the genius of
- 26:31their medieval Builders protecting the
- 26:34major part of the cathedral not only
- 26:36from the Flames but from the thousands
- 26:38of liters of water used to put out the
- 26:40fire from
- 26:48[Music]
- 26:51above
- 26:531177 the cathedral choir was consecrated
- 26:56just 17 years after after the work had
- 26:58been instigated by Mor
- 27:03duli since it was closed off from the
- 27:05rest of the construction it was able to
- 27:07house a whole set of sacred relics from
- 27:09the Paris
- 27:10[Music]
- 27:15sea objects that had belonged to Saints
- 27:18or fragments of their bodies revered by
- 27:23worshippers you can think of the relics
- 27:25as the presence of the sacred on Earth I
- 27:28like to think of sacred relics as a as
- 27:31the battery that powers the machine of a
- 27:33sacred
- 27:36building amongst these relics a strand
- 27:39of hair supposedly belonging to the
- 27:40Virgin Mary a stone that had been used
- 27:43to lapidate
- 27:47Sten or an arm that allegedly belonged
- 27:49to Andrew the
- 27:52apostle so we're talking about an
- 27:54arsenal of holy weapons they to protect
- 27:57not just the community of the dean and
- 27:59his chapter and the bishop and his power
- 28:01but the whole city of
- 28:05[Music]
- 28:19Paris April the 15th 2019 the wooden
- 28:22frame and roof of notam caught fire
- 28:2612200 Oak beams Nick named the forest a
- 28:29forest fire the cathedral's weak
- 28:34point and yet despite the apparent
- 28:36fragility the frame was robust and
- 28:40[Music]
- 28:46indispensable the weight of the frame
- 28:48held everything together without this
- 28:50pressure point the sidewalls of the
- 28:52cathedral would have had to withstand
- 28:54the thrust of the vaults on the inside
- 28:57and the thrust of the buttresses on the
- 28:59outside not necessarily everywhere only
- 29:02at certain
- 29:03points so the weight of the whole frame
- 29:06ensured the adherence of the hole and
- 29:08prevented the walls undergoing too much
- 29:14strain the frame was a real plus point
- 29:16for the safety of the
- 29:20cathedral we knew that if ever there was
- 29:22a problem with fire then the frame would
- 29:25indeed burn but it would save the
- 29:27building that's part of its DNA built
- 29:30into its design by the Master Masons of
- 29:33the 12th and 13th
- 29:36centuries the forest of notredam was
- 29:38designed to self-destruct in the event
- 29:40of
- 29:41fire it no longer exists but it was
- 29:44identical to the frame of the Cathedral
- 29:45of notam of Ruan one of the most perfect
- 29:48examples of its
- 29:49[Music]
- 29:53time the best techniques could be found
- 29:56in gu as well in most wooden frames in
- 29:59the Kingdom at the
- 30:00time everything was coordinated between
- 30:03the Master Mason and the master
- 30:05Carpenter there was an overall
- 30:11design Notre Dam's wooden frame had
- 30:13already been rebuilt
- 30:16once why did the cathedral's Master
- 30:19Mason and the Carpenters decide on this
- 30:23structure and how can we explain its
- 30:25resilience for eight centuries
- 30:28the answers to these questions can be
- 30:30found in what happened during the night
- 30:31of August the 14th
- 30:411218 on the eve of the holy day of the
- 30:43Assumption of the Virgin Mary thieves
- 30:46broke into the premises of noam's
- 30:53cannons One Source identifies one of
- 30:56these thieves as an Englishman um they
- 30:59crept up into the upper parts of the
- 31:02cathedral and tried to sort of Levy
- 31:06themselves down to steal these sacred uh
- 31:10lurgical vestments and vessels in the
- 31:12night and something went wrong a
- 31:15Candlestick of some sort was knocked
- 31:17over and the choir caught
- 31:22fire notam caught fire for the first
- 31:24time in its
- 31:26history
- 31:28we don't really know the full
- 31:30consequences of this fire but it helped
- 31:32to launch a huge campaign of new work
- 31:35during the
- 31:411220s during the same period the
- 31:44construction of the Cathedral of shat
- 31:46was coming to an
- 31:48end it had enormous Windows whereas
- 31:51notredam
- 31:53didn't and then all of a sudden notredam
- 31:56apparently changing modernizing and
- 32:03upgrading you can imagine the sort of
- 32:05site meeting with the Master Mason with
- 32:07the Stone Cutters and the other Artisans
- 32:09saying just give us the order we've been
- 32:12to Shar seen what they've done there we
- 32:15can do
- 32:18better doing better meant letting more
- 32:21light in by opening noam's Windows A new
- 32:24challenge for the medieval builders
- 32:28it meant modifying the
- 32:30roof and completely rebuilding the
- 32:33wooden
- 32:34frame it was a Structure which was over
- 32:37100 m long 10 m High 13 M wide and
- 32:41worryingly
- 32:43[Music]
- 32:45unstable a wooden frame has a major
- 32:47impact on the stability of a building as
- 32:50it creates pressure points and a great
- 32:52deal of thrust
- 32:53points pressure points carried chiefly
- 32:56to the side by
- 32:59Rafters Rafters are the very long beams
- 33:02of wood that support the roof
- 33:04covering they carry the weight to the
- 33:08outside it's important to have joists at
- 33:11the base which are pieces of wood
- 33:13linking the rafters and which will
- 33:15reduce the spread of the
- 33:17frame if the whole device is not solid
- 33:20enough the frame will push down onto the
- 33:22ston workor and the section could
- 33:25collapse
- 33:28the main problem with the first frame
- 33:29was that the vaults were inside the
- 33:33frame this prevented adding any joists
- 33:36which would prevent the spread of the
- 33:37frame how could this mistake be
- 33:40rectified the only solution was to build
- 33:42the wall higher and enable the new frame
- 33:45to have horizontal joists fitted in
- 33:48order to stabilize the overall
- 33:51structure other elements were added to
- 33:53share the load exerted by the large mass
- 33:55of wood and to reinforce
- 34:01it the only material that could be used
- 34:04in this consolidation plan was the most
- 34:06noble of
- 34:07woods
- 34:10Oak Oakwood has an exceptional
- 34:12elasticity mechanical resistance and an
- 34:14extraordinary durability what we're
- 34:16concerned with is a consistency between
- 34:18the part of the tree which is cut in the
- 34:20piece of wood that is produced since
- 34:22each tree provides a single piece of
- 34:24wood one tree produces a single piece of
- 34:27wood so the trees have to be not only
- 34:29solid but
- 34:32enormous the joist span the roof
- 34:35triangle horizontally and cross the
- 34:37whole
- 34:38building so for a Nave with a width of
- 34:4013 M the joist must be 50 cm longer at
- 34:45each end and thus tree trunks of at
- 34:47least 14 M are
- 34:53necessary it's estimated that between
- 34:551,000 and 2,00 th000 Oaks were required
- 34:58to construct the wooden frame of
- 35:00nraam where did they find such tall
- 35:02trees and in such
- 35:05[Music]
- 35:09quantities the medieval solution was to
- 35:12be found in a long forgotten
- 35:16technique trees were clearcut and the
- 35:19stumps were allowed to grow again so
- 35:22Forest could spring up again and keep
- 35:23producing
- 35:25wood this knowhow enable trees to grow
- 35:28quicker higher thinner and straighter as
- 35:32they sort out the
- 35:33light after 50 to 60 years the wood was
- 35:36perfectly ready for the building of
- 35:37Cathedral frames and could be cut
- 35:40down this clever technique reduced the
- 35:42area that needed to be
- 35:45deforested the scientists estimate that
- 35:47only 3 to four hectar of forests were
- 35:49required to build Notre Dam's
- 35:52frame this is the equivalent to three
- 35:54times the area of the Cathedral Square
- 35:59the Carpenters worked with axes on the
- 36:01young freshly cut wood which made the
- 36:03jobs of squaring and right angling much
- 36:09[Music]
- 36:12easier the squaring followed the natural
- 36:14lines of the wood giving it an
- 36:17unbeatable
- 36:21solidity if you follow my finger you can
- 36:24see that the fiber has stayed intact
- 36:29these pieces of wood have remained in
- 36:30exactly the same shape as they grew and
- 36:32so they cannot be
- 36:35[Music]
- 36:37deformed all these pieces of wood which
- 36:40ensured the solidity of the frame were
- 36:42then assembled on a platform above the
- 36:51vaults The Forest of notam was completed
- 36:54during the
- 36:551220s and protected the building from
- 36:58bad weather for eight
- 37:00centuries it's a mark of its Flawless
- 37:06resistance it also supported the
- 37:08Striking lead roof the Steep slender
- 37:12structure visible to
- 37:15[Music]
- 37:16all the roof covering could be seen for
- 37:20miles for a long time it was covered in
- 37:22Gold
- 37:25Leaf this made it gleam in the Sun but
- 37:29it also Shone out in
- 37:32[Music]
- 37:34Moonlight once the Monumental roof had
- 37:36been completed all that was left was to
- 37:39complete the towers of the
- 37:42cathedral these huge Towers became the
- 37:44face of
- 37:46notam at 69 M high they became the
- 37:49tallest buildings in
- 37:52Paris the function of these two towers
- 37:55isn't just aesthetic the Towers can be
- 37:57cited from miles and miles away but they
- 37:59can also be heard so it's important to
- 38:02remember that these aren't just visible
- 38:05signs of power they're ways of
- 38:07transmitting the power of nrom through
- 38:10sound
- 38:13too noam's Towers were erected during
- 38:16the Decades of 1230 and
- 38:201240 it wasn't until the construction of
- 38:22the Eiffel Tower 650 years later in 1889
- 38:26that any building superseded
- 38:29[Music]
- 38:31them when the towers were completed the
- 38:34whole of notam was finally ready to
- 38:36welcome its faithful almost 70 years
- 38:39after it was
- 38:43started however more work was deemed
- 38:47[Music]
- 38:55necessary
- 39:01April the 15th 2019 7:45
- 39:09p.m. one of the most horrible things
- 39:11I've ever seen is the Spire collapsing
- 39:14in a blaze into the
- 39:20[Applause]
- 39:24Nave if you stud
- 39:27Gothic
- 39:28architecture that's the last thing you
- 39:30ever want to
- 39:32see it was one of those moments I think
- 39:35that all of us who s will never
- 39:38[Music]
- 39:39forget the collapse of the Spy of
- 39:42notredam was met with Universal
- 39:45horror it wasn't just a gigantic
- 39:48Monument that had collapsed but a symbol
- 39:50too an architectural feat measuring 93 m
- 39:55tall the this neogothic Colossus
- 39:58weighing 500 tons of lead and 250 tons
- 40:01of wood gave notredam its unmistakable
- 40:14flare the collapse of the Spire brought
- 40:16about the building's worst ever
- 40:20damage taking with it parts of the
- 40:22vaults above the Nave and the transp
- 40:25Crossing
- 40:31it was the weak point of the cathedral
- 40:32in the event of
- 40:35fire and yet its designers had been the
- 40:37saviors of notredam at the
- 40:39time by consolidating it enabling it to
- 40:43last for
- 40:44[Music]
- 40:52centuries
- 40:541843 for 500 years the cathedral had had
- 40:58pride of place in the center of
- 41:00Paris the proud building hadn't
- 41:02succumbed to flames but the onslaughts
- 41:05of time and human
- 41:08activity the statues of biblical Kings
- 41:11had been vandalized and destroyed during
- 41:13the French
- 41:14[Music]
- 41:16Revolution many of the stones were
- 41:18fractured in other words cracked either
- 41:21by extreme cold or other
- 41:24conditions to such an extent
- 41:26that the structure was
- 41:29weakened the roof was in terrible
- 41:32condition that meant water was
- 41:33infiltrating into the vaults uh the
- 41:36building had been essentially abandoned
- 41:38for some 60
- 41:43years above all notam had had one of its
- 41:47limbs
- 41:48amputated its medieval Spire built
- 41:50during the middle of the 13th
- 41:53century it was a wooden and Lead
- 41:55construction reach reaching a height of
- 41:5678
- 41:59M it had become dangerous for the
- 42:01building and was dismantled between 1786
- 42:04and
- 42:071792 it was down to a weakness in the
- 42:10structure it had shown signs of fatigue
- 42:13as had many medieval
- 42:17spires the cathedral had to be
- 42:20saved and it was thanks to the novel
- 42:24notand written by Victor hug
- 42:28go the novel was so popular at the time
- 42:31that the whole of France rallied to save
- 42:34the
- 42:35cathedral Victor Hugo helped bridge to
- 42:38the popular imagination the importance
- 42:40of the Middle Ages for the identity of
- 42:43France identity of Paris in particular
- 42:46and so it's one of those wonderful
- 42:48examples when the written word when a
- 42:50novel changes
- 42:53[Music]
- 42:55history
- 42:58in
- 42:581843 two architects specialized in the
- 43:01restoration of medieval monuments
- 43:03volunteered to help restore the grand
- 43:05dam to its previous
- 43:10[Music]
- 43:13Glory there was Jean batist lus who was
- 43:16experienced and thorough but also the
- 43:18hugely talented workaholic 29-year-old
- 43:21uren VI
- 43:25luk he had Boundless Energy had traveled
- 43:29extensively Drew extremely
- 43:32quickly and was capable of assimilating
- 43:35pages of encyclopedic
- 43:38knowledge while continuing to run big
- 43:41building
- 43:42[Music]
- 43:45projects vuk described himself as
- 43:48belonging to the living and the
- 43:51dead he believed himself to be the
- 43:53successor of medieval builders because
- 43:56he felt medieval and he communicated
- 43:58with those from the Middle
- 44:04Ages with State support Jean Baptist lus
- 44:08and Eren vuk delved into the history and
- 44:11the structure of the
- 44:12monument they inspected every weakness
- 44:15noted every defect and proposed a
- 44:18complete restoration
- 44:25project
- 44:28their Monumental work is archived and
- 44:31can be found just outside of Paris at
- 44:33the media library of architecture and
- 44:34Heritage in chanton
- 44:42Leon the archives are exceptional both
- 44:44in quantity and
- 44:49quality here are four drawings from the
- 44:521843 competition signed by both V Duke
- 44:56and Jean Baptist lus in them we can see
- 45:00the grand project to restore the Western
- 45:02facade including the gallery of the
- 45:04statues of Kings the restoration of all
- 45:07the sculpted decorations that had been
- 45:09set a light During the Revolution and
- 45:11also Aspire designed by both Architects
- 45:13similar to the one that had been built
- 45:15in the Middle
- 45:18[Music]
- 45:20Ages the archives attest to the Colossal
- 45:23work undertaken by the two architects
- 45:26and then by Vi luk alone after the
- 45:28Unexpected death of lassus in
- 45:331857 old Stones were replaced flying
- 45:37buttresses
- 45:39replaced reconstruction of the sculpted
- 45:41decorations with the creation of dozens
- 45:43of gargoyles and Shima each designed
- 45:46individually by the
- 45:48architect such as the famous
- 45:54stricks
- 45:59it's almost as if V luk had given the
- 46:02cathedral an extra Touch of soul to such
- 46:05an extent that today the STS and the
- 46:09Gargoyles Define Neutra
- 46:11Dam more than the figure of the building
- 46:15[Music]
- 46:16itself not only did vuk give notam more
- 46:21depth but he also strengthened it
- 46:23ensuring its
- 46:24stability
- 46:27his major architectural stroke was the
- 46:28rebuilding of the
- 46:31Spire VI luk and lus had initially
- 46:34imagined the Spire as a simple copy of
- 46:36the medieval
- 46:37one but after lass's death in 1857 V luk
- 46:42gave free reign to his imagination and
- 46:44designed an exaggeratedly large
- 46:47Spire it is part of a whole kind of
- 46:50aesthetic system that is simply about
- 46:53beauty about beauty and spectacle and
- 46:59profoundly powerful
- 47:03architecture although it was the heart
- 47:05of the Industrial Revolution vo luk
- 47:08intended to replicate the medieval
- 47:10[Music]
- 47:14Spire it would be covered in lead but
- 47:16built out of wood just as in the Middle
- 47:21Ages the Spire was an integral part of
- 47:24the hall and so it was inconceivable to
- 47:27use anything else but oak
- 47:30wood there was also an archaeological
- 47:33challenge which involved the renewal and
- 47:35invigoration of ancient knowhow in
- 47:38particular the skills of
- 47:43carpentry in order to meet the challenge
- 47:45of building at a height of 40
- 47:48m vuk needed the help of an exceptional
- 47:51Carpenter who was also an expert in
- 47:54scaffolding
- 47:57he called Upon A Certain bullu who was
- 47:59considered the best man for the
- 48:02[Music]
- 48:05job so we engaged a remarkable
- 48:08Carpenter someone who knew how to put up
- 48:11scaffolding and had experimented with
- 48:14and improved wood Scaffolding in
- 48:20particular the Spy that they designed
- 48:23ended up being 93 m High which was more
- 48:26than 20 M higher than the medieval
- 48:29[Music]
- 48:33one it would be a work of folly
- 48:36embellishing the cathedral in spite of
- 48:38the RIS of the
- 48:40monument work started in
- 48:43[Music]
- 48:471858 vuk Spire was so big that in the
- 48:51event of fire serious damage to the
- 48:54vaults couldn't be avoided
- 48:59he nevertheless took the risk that if it
- 49:01caught fire there was a very good chance
- 49:03of it burning down but he created it to
- 49:06some extent to last
- 49:08[Applause]
- 49:12forever vuk and bulu together created a
- 49:15slender aerial
- 49:18structure it was both solid and
- 49:20extremely
- 49:21[Music]
- 49:24heavy it weighed 750
- 49:29tons its Chief structural element was a
- 49:32huge wooden pinion braced by the rest of
- 49:34the
- 49:38framework the structure was supported by
- 49:41four oblique arms which themselves were
- 49:43caner levered on each of the transcept
- 49:45crossing columns the largest in the
- 49:47[Music]
- 49:52cathedral vuk counteracted this coloss
- 49:55weight by consolidating the transp
- 49:59[Music]
- 50:00stonework while doing this he
- 50:02surprisingly came across the original
- 50:04High Windows of notam which he proceeded
- 50:07to restore
- 50:09[Music]
- 50:13identically josing a 12th century
- 50:15element with a 13th century element was
- 50:18a pure architectural idea and an
- 50:20educational
- 50:24one the restation was informative but as
- 50:27an act of consolidation it helped him to
- 50:30build
- 50:35further when the work was completed the
- 50:37Spy was assembled and raised
- 50:41up it was inaugurated on August the 15th
- 50:49[Music]
- 50:541859 it's completion marks the last
- 50:56great phase of work on
- 51:00[Music]
- 51:10notam 160 years later the worst came to
- 51:15pass a gigantic bulk of burnt wood and
- 51:18molten lead crashed down onto the top
- 51:20part of the
- 51:24building even though the fire has deeply
- 51:27scarred the cathedral it has
- 51:29nevertheless revealed its strength and
- 51:33Ingenuity it Bears witness to each
- 51:36Gothic era across eight
- 51:38centuries it remains our proud
- 51:44Heritage what makes a cathedral like
- 51:47notam so vitally
- 51:48important is a combination of all the
- 51:51knowhow and skills involved in building
- 51:54it
- 51:57it's exactly these types of skills and
- 51:59techniques that need to be passed on
- 52:02that's what nutam can teach us
- 52:05today in July 2020 the French
- 52:08authorities decided to rebuild an
- 52:10identical wooden
- 52:12frame this is a fitting homage to the
- 52:15Carpenters of the Middle
- 52:19Ages we have all the wood necessary to
- 52:22rebuild the frame the French Forest are
- 52:24full o we have the know how to use axes
- 52:28to square the
- 52:30wood moreover this is the best way of
- 52:34guaranteeing its
- 52:38durability notam will always be
- 52:42indestructible not withstanding its new
- 52:44Spire which will be recreated in wood
- 52:46and Lead according to V Luke's original
- 52:52plans the Flesh of luk is a spectacular
- 52:57structure it was visible all around the
- 53:00cathedral and of such great Beauty so
- 53:02there's every reason to maintain the
- 53:05appearance of the cathedral as it was
- 53:09before is the cathedral stuck in the
- 53:11past if so it's not just any old past
- 53:16because if notam is still standing today
- 53:18it's down to the men and women who
- 53:20thought it up the first time and who
- 53:22thought it up again to those who built
- 53:24it and to those who will rebuild
- 53:27[Music]
- 53:37it
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of The Eternal Notre-Dame | FULL DOCUMENTARY by SLICE Full Doc, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,210 words across 1,114 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.