The Devil and Karl Marx | Dr. Paul Kengor | EP 455 — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00The only part of the end of the
- 0:01Communist Manifesto anybody remembers is
- 0:03workers of the world unite. We have
- 0:05nothing to lose but our chains. But but
- 0:08if you just go back one paragraph at the
- 0:11end, right? The Communist
- 0:14support every revolutionary movement.
- 0:17The forcible overthrow of all existing
- 0:19conditions. I mean those lines are in
- 0:21the the next two final paragraphs. And
- 0:24that's what really the Manifesto was all
- 0:26about.
- 0:40Hi everybody. I have the privilege of
- 0:43speaking with Paul Kengor today.
- 0:45He's written a book.
- 0:46Many books. One of them is for example
- 0:49The Crusader, Ronald Reagan and the fall
- 0:52of communism. This is going to be made
- 0:53in a into a movie. I just interviewed
- 0:56the lead actor for that movie couple of
- 0:58weeks ago. Um Dennis Quaid. And so
- 1:01that'll be releasing the movie will be
- 1:03releasing at the end of August. Paul is
- 1:05also the editor of the American
- 1:07Spectator and this month's
- 1:09the version has a list of the best
- 1:12conservative
- 1:14colleges in the United States. And so
- 1:15that could be a very helpful list for
- 1:17those of you who are thinking about
- 1:19going to college or who have children
- 1:20who are thinking about going to college.
- 1:22So that's the American Spectator. And so
- 1:25but what we're concentrating on today is
- 1:27actually a different book. The Devil and
- 1:30Karl Marx. And I really like this book
- 1:32not least because it delves into Karl
- 1:35Marx's work as a poet and a playwright.
- 1:38And it sheds light, I think, on the
- 1:41underlying structure of his motivation
- 1:44for the so-called economic theories that
- 1:46he developed later. And so we discuss
- 1:49the Mephistophelian
- 1:52nature of the fantasies the poetic
- 1:55fantasies that Karl Marx developed as a
- 1:57young man and how that ethos
- 2:01that Faustian ethos
- 2:04uh what would you say? Shaped and
- 2:06crafted the murderous doctrine that he
- 2:07developed as a polemicist and a
- 2:10so-called economist. So join us for
- 2:12that.
- 2:14So welcome Paul. I just read your book
- 2:17The Devil and Karl Marx recently. And uh
- 2:20there was
- 2:21a lot of it was striking to me for a
- 2:24couple of
- 2:25reasons.
- 2:26I suppose reasons that are more
- 2:28idiosyncratic to me. There are many
- 2:29reasons that it's of general interest.
- 2:31But so the first one was
- 2:35one of the things I noticed about my
- 2:36students
- 2:39especially the ones that were really
- 2:40searching is that if I gave them free
- 2:42reign to write an essay
- 2:45they'd often
- 2:46either they'd include or want to show me
- 2:49a poem that was relevant to that
- 2:53pursuit. And then my first book Maps of
- 2:56Meaning actually started as about a
- 2:5840-page poem. Wow.
- 3:00Well and so
- 3:01So I know where you're going with this.
- 3:02Okay. Okay. Okay. So well so I studied
- 3:06Jung's analysis of creative thought a
- 3:08lot. And Jung had this notion which I
- 3:11think is right that
- 3:14when we first investigate something
- 3:17that we don't understand we fantasize
- 3:19about it. Right? Which
- 3:22in some way seems so obvious that it
- 3:24hardly needs to be said. But it does
- 3:26need to be said because you fantasize
- 3:28about it or you dream about it or you
- 3:31daydream about it. And what you're doing
- 3:33is you're using what you already have a
- 3:35grip on to get a new grip on this
- 3:38indeterminate object. And that's
- 3:40fantasy. And and so you have it's like
- 3:43you have the dream
- 3:44and then you have the drama. No. You
- 3:48have the drama and then you have the
- 3:49dream. And then you have something like
- 3:51the poem because the a poem is where
- 3:54the dream meets the verbal. And then you
- 3:57can you can differentiate that further
- 4:00so it becomes more and more semantic and
- 4:03more explicit. Now
- 4:06this is a long way of asking you this
- 4:07question. One of the things you took
- 4:09pains to do in this book was to
- 4:11concentrate on some of Marx's work
- 4:14before he was an economist because he
- 4:16wrote drama and he wrote poetry. And so
- 4:19um and your claim in the book is that
- 4:22well we should really be paying
- 4:23attention to some of that early work
- 4:25because it does something like set the
- 4:26frame and sheds light on his motivation
- 4:29and it also sheds light on the story
- 4:32that he was imagining or acting out. So
- 4:34do you can you make some comments about
- 4:36that?
- 4:36Yeah. So this is quite fascinating. I
- 4:38think you should write the next forward.
- 4:41Uh the forward for this one was written
- 4:43by Michael Knowles colleague colleague
- 4:45of yours at Daily Wire. Um yeah. Yeah.
- 4:48So Marx fancied himself a poet.
- 4:51Mhm. I I I mean Marx's secret love was
- 4:54poetry. In fact one of his I think his
- 4:57most important biographer. And this guy
- 4:59has been it's kind of fallen people just
- 5:02don't know about him today. No one had
- 5:03anything against him really but his name
- 5:05was Robert Robert Payne. So he was a
- 5:07British academic, man of letters, the
- 5:10arts, a translator, drama. I mean he was
- 5:13no right-winger. He was probably
- 5:16probably slightly left of center. Mhm.
- 5:18He did a couple um did several works on
- 5:21Marx.
- 5:21Late '60s late '60s early 1970s. Uh
- 5:25published by New York University Press,
- 5:27Simon and Schuster. So you know very
- 5:29credible. And uh he was really the first
- 5:32one to mine Marx's poetry. To go through
- 5:36and and figure it out.
- 5:38How much of it is there? How much
- 5:39poetry?
- 5:39Well well there's quite a bit and and
- 5:41it's it's deeply disturbing stuff. All
- 5:44right? It a lot of it is about the
- 5:46devil. And you know quite literally
- 5:49about the devil. It's chilling, right?
- 5:51Um
- 5:52thus heaven I forfeited. I know it full
- 5:55well. My heart once true to God has
- 5:57chosen for hell. Right right. 1837
- 6:01Yeah. Milton. Yeah. 1837 that one was.
- 6:05It was one of his first published
- 6:06writings. He would have only been 19
- 6:09years old at that time. Um another one
- 6:11so it's called The Player and it was
- 6:131841.
- 6:15And here he puts himself it appears in
- 6:18uh in the form of this kind of mad
- 6:21violinist who's like frenetically
- 6:23maniacally sawing away at the violin and
- 6:27he's summoning up the powers of darkness
- 6:29and he's doing this in front of his love
- 6:31interest. As one does. Yeah. Right. And
- 6:34the love interest um Robert Payne says
- 6:36appears to be
- 6:38um his girl at the time Jenny the girl
- 6:40that he would that he would end up
- 6:42marrying. And he's summoning up the
- 6:44powers of darkness and she's saying why
- 6:45are you doing this to to him? It's like
- 6:47a Faustian bargain. More on Faust and
- 6:49Goethe and Mephistopheles in a moment.
- 6:51But just to sort of set the table for
- 6:53people who are shocked by what I I said
- 6:55about him writing about the devil. Mhm.
- 6:57So here's what he says in The Player.
- 6:58Here's just one stanza.
- 7:00He tells the girl Look now my blood-dark
- 7:03sword shall stab unerringly within thy
- 7:07soul. The hellish vapors rise and fill
- 7:10the brain till I go mad and my heart is
- 7:13utterly changed. See the sword the
- 7:16prince of darkness sold it to me. For he
- 7:19beats the time and gives the signs
- 7:21evermore boldly I play the dance of
- 7:23death. And then he he plays this sort of
- 7:27Faustian bargain. And the but but but
- 7:31but to back up a little bit that's his
- 7:34poetry from from an early age. And
- 7:36Robert Payne
- 7:37so who wrote um the book the Simon and
- 7:39Schuster book the the New York
- 7:40University Press said Marx's first love
- 7:43was poetry. And he fancied himself as
- 7:47aspiring to be nothing less than the
- 7:49Goethe of his age. To write the Faust of
- 7:52his age. And Goethe's Faust of course
- 7:55the the famous character is the
- 7:56Mephistopheles character the devil demon
- 7:59character.
- 8:00And um as you saw in the book many times
- 8:02And Mephistopheles in Faust that's a
- 8:04character I've done a fair bit of study
- 8:06about because well there's there's
- 8:09there's a lot there's a a motif that's
- 8:11repeated both in Faust one and Faust
- 8:13two. So Mephistopheles
- 8:16in Faust is a variant of the the
- 8:18heavenly adversary, right? So he's he
- 8:20opposes being itself. He's and his ethos
- 8:25which
- 8:26Goethe has him state twice is that
- 8:29the suffering that existence
- 8:32the suffering that's a necessary
- 8:34consequence of existence in its finite
- 8:36and limited manifestations or mortal
- 8:39frames let's say. That suffering is so
- 8:42unbearable and so unconscionable that it
- 8:44would be better if existence itself did
- 8:47not exist. So so well so what what what
- 8:51Satan does in in Goethe's
- 8:54conceptualization is make the case that
- 8:58life is so unfair in its fundamental.
- 9:00He's like the anti-natalists the modern
- 9:01anti-natalists that anyone ethical would
- 9:04act in order to bring being itself to a
- 9:07cessation. Right? Now the problem with
- 9:10that seems to be as far as I can tell
- 9:12and this is the problem with
- 9:13anti-natalism one of many problems is
- 9:15that
- 9:17the reason that Mephistopheles is
- 9:19anti-being hypothetically is because of
- 9:22the suffering. But the problem is is if
- 9:24you turn that into a political doctrine
- 9:26right? All you do is multiply the
- 9:28suffering.
- 9:28Yes. Right? Because you become
- 9:30anti-life. And so you might say well I'm
- 9:32working for the cessation of suffering
- 9:34because I'm working for the extinction
- 9:35of consciousness. But if the price you
- 9:37pay for that is the endless
- 9:39multiplication of suffering Marxism.
- 9:42Well well that's the that's the horror
- 9:44well that's partly why I found your book
- 9:45so horrifying is that cuz all that's in
- 9:48principle lurking beneath the surface.
- 9:50Okay. So
- 9:51what what do you what do you make of
- 9:54this conceptually? Now Marx
- 9:57proclaimed himself an atheist.
- 9:59Mhm. Okay, so the first question you
- 10:01might ask is, well, what the hell does
- 10:03an atheist have to do with Satan? Right.
- 10:06Right. Right. Well, so what So, what do
- 10:07you think about that?
- 10:08and and and and by the way, he he had a
- 10:10favorite line from Mephistopheles, which
- 10:13was In fact, they said this was Marx's
- 10:15favorite quote, "Everything that exists
- 10:17Yes, that's the line. Exactly. That's
- 10:19exactly the line.
- 10:20exists deserves to perish.
- 10:21that's repeated. It's in Faust 2, too.
- 10:25That's that's his favorite line. So, if
- 10:26someone were to ask me, "Do you have a
- 10:28favorite quote? Do you have a favorite
- 10:29line?" I may give a scripture verse. I
- 10:30might be not afraid, something like
- 10:32that. But, Marx said, "Ah, yes. Yes,
- 10:34Mephistopheles, you know, Goethe's
- 10:36Faust. Everything that exists deserves
- 10:39to perish."
- 10:40terrifying. Well, it's terrifying
- 10:41because it truly is the case that
- 10:45as the character of Mephistopheles is
- 10:47revealed in Faust, in Faust 1 and 2,
- 10:50that's the apotheosis of his philosophy,
- 10:52right? When you really start to
- 10:54understand who Mephistopheles is, that's
- 10:57the final revelation. He's the He's the
- 10:59foe of everything that exists. Now, the
- 11:01rationalization is because of the
- 11:03suffering. Or, it isn't just the
- 11:05suffering, eh? Because there's a
- 11:07Luciferian pride element.
- 11:09Mephistopheles is opposed to the
- 11:11structure of being also because it
- 11:13doesn't meet his standard.
- 11:15Right.
- 11:15Right.
- 11:16In one of the In one of the poems, Marx
- 11:18shouts in the form of Satan, right? "I
- 11:20shall howl gigantic curses at mankind."
- 11:24And And And Robert Payne says, "Picture
- 11:27Marx standing there in the middle of
- 11:29like a burned-down village, a burnt-down
- 11:32house, the right the raised r a z e d
- 11:35building, and flames all around him. You
- 11:38know, everything that exists deserves to
- 11:39perish, and as if to say, 'Now we can
- 11:41begin, right?' He wants to take
- 11:43everything down. He wants to completely
- 11:45level it." And yet, all of this, going
- 11:48back to your original point, this is
- 11:50what he was writing before he was doing
- 11:52anything on economics.
- 11:53Right. Right.
- 11:54Before he was doing And And And also yet
- 11:56at the same time,
- 11:58uh
- 11:59because I know there might be some Marx
- 12:00biographers who've ignored this. I know
- 12:03that they've ignored it. And they might
- 12:05say, "Well, it's so early. He did this
- 12:07as one of his first published writings,
- 12:091837.
- 12:10He was 19 years old. That's not the real
- 12:13Marx." Well, the one I just read to you,
- 12:14the player, that's 1841. That was the
- 12:17same year that he started with Bruno
- 12:19Bauer at the University of Bonn as
- 12:21professor, uh the archives of atheism,
- 12:23the annals of atheism journal that he
- 12:25started. His His peak of writing was
- 12:27really in the 1840s. I mean, they were
- 12:29writing the Communist Manifesto, 1846,
- 12:321847, released uh February 1848. So,
- 12:35he's This is not that long. What? It's
- 12:36not that long.
- 12:37other thing, too, is that if the if the
- 12:40hypothesis that we described at the
- 12:42beginning of this discussion is true,
- 12:44and I truly believe it is,
- 12:46the
- 12:47like a complex set of ideas comes out of
- 12:50a dream-like matrix, and you could make
- 12:52the case that someone
- 12:54radically shifts their view away from
- 12:56that initial revelation. But, that isn't
- 12:58generally how things work, and I think
- 13:00you need very strong evidence of
- 13:02discontinuity
- 13:03not to accept the default proposition
- 13:06that continuity is the much more likely
- 13:08occurrence. I mean, one of the things I
- 13:10do in
- 13:11in my interviews with
- 13:13the people that I'm fortunate enough to
- 13:14interview,
- 13:15all of whom are accomplished people, is
- 13:18an autobiographical analysis. And
- 13:21it's invariably the case that
- 13:24you can trace the seeds of
- 13:27you can trace who they are to seeds that
- 13:29made themselves manifest very early.
- 13:31Now, you might say, "Well, that's all
- 13:33retrospective memory." But, I don't
- 13:35believe that because one of the things
- 13:37I've noticed in doing that kind of
- 13:38interviewing is that the people who tell
- 13:41the story are shocked themselves at how
- 13:44much of what they still do was there in
- 13:46a nascent form, like even when they were
- 13:48children. And so, no, my sense Marx's
- 13:52father saw that. Yeah, right. Marx Yeah,
- 13:54right. Heinrich Marx in the letter that
- 13:56he wrote to him in 1837.
- 13:58And that was um
- 13:59not long, probably Well, it In that
- 14:03letter, he talks about the disorder in
- 14:05Marx's life. And I know And I know you
- 14:07write a lot about order, including in
- 14:09your most recent book. And the Marx was
- 14:12all about tearing down the traditional
- 14:14order. In fact In fact, um he he said he
- 14:18and Engels wrote in the Communist
- 14:19Manifesto, "Communism represents the
- 14:22most radical rupture in traditional
- 14:24relations." Right, the most radical
- 14:26conceivable disruption. Right. So, it's
- 14:29not not just the family. The most
- 14:31radical, right?
- 14:32And And the one word
- 14:34Yeah, that was the goal. And the one
- 14:35word, well, two words that jump out of
- 14:38the Communist Manifesto, all of Marx and
- 14:40Engels' writings, two, criticism. And
- 14:42Marx wrote to Arnold Ruge in 1843,
- 14:45called for the ruthless criticism of
- 14:47everything that exists.
- 14:48Right. Right. Same thing. No, and by the
- 14:50way, not just You know, people thinking
- 14:52about this, not just for the ruthless
- 14:53criticism of uh the bad things in
- 14:56society, right? Of of that malady or
- 15:00this ill. The ruthless criticism of
- 15:02everything
- 15:04that exists.
- 15:05Yeah. And the other word that they that
- 15:07they use all the time is abolition,
- 15:09abolish. They want to abolish
- 15:11everything, right? Um
- 15:13Communism Communism calls for the
- 15:17abolition of the present state of
- 15:19things, they said in the manifesto. So,
- 15:22after they talk about the entire theory
- 15:24of the Communist may be summed up in a
- 15:26single sentence, "Abolition of private
- 15:27property." All right, so that's gone.
- 15:30Abolition of capital. Yeah. In the
- 15:32manifesto, they write, "Abolition of the
- 15:35family." Exclamation mark. Even the most
- 15:37radical flare-up of this infamous
- 15:39proposal of the Communist. So, we've got
- 15:41capital, property, family,
- 15:43um present state of things, entire
- 15:45societies. I mean, it just It It's
- 15:48complete Mhm. Uh so, one person said to
- 15:50me, "It's nihilism, right?" But, in the
- 15:52sense
- 15:54he has kind of a nihilist
- 15:54It's worship of destruction. Exactly.
- 15:57different. Nihilism is you don't care.
- 15:59Right. Right. Right. Right. No, no, this
- 16:01is way different. No, no, that If If
- 16:03he's an avid devotee of Mephistopheles,
- 16:06it's active destruction. And you don't
- 16:09want to underestimate the the the fact
- 16:12that a poetic line takes root in
- 16:15someone's soul, especially when it's
- 16:17produced by someone as profound as
- 16:19Faust. Like, that that's not nothing.
- 16:22That That really means that Marx
- 16:24identified the central spirit of
- 16:27Mephistopheles. He pulled out the
- 16:28central message, and that stuck in his
- 16:31memory, right? And then Okay, so let's
- 16:34Stuck in his memory and integrated into
- 16:35his worldview. And And into into what he
- 16:38loved doing the most, writing poetry.
- 16:40So, it So, it's really fully, deeply a
- 16:43part of him. And um
- 16:45Yeah, it it's uh Well, you also You also
- 16:48talk in the book a fair bit about the
- 16:51sordid details of his private life. I
- 16:53mean,
- 16:54Marx was also, by all accounts,
- 16:57a person who was filthy in every way,
- 17:00essentially, that you could be filthy,
- 17:02like literally, because his personal
- 17:04hygiene habits were detestable, to say
- 17:06the least. But, he also lived in a Well,
- 17:08you're a better You're better at
- 17:10explaining this than me. So, do you want
- 17:11to walk people through that?
- 17:12And I would I would circle this back to
- 17:14the point of disorder.
- 17:15So, so
- 17:16So, it is a totally disordered personal
- 17:18lifestyle.
- 17:19Um the the His father noticed it when
- 17:21Marx was in college. And then when Marx
- 17:23got married, his life was a wreck. Um
- 17:26and and both his mother and his wife
- 17:28both expressed the wish that Karl would
- 17:30Karl would start earning some capital,
- 17:32right? Rather than just writing about
- 17:33it. They The family had to beg for money
- 17:36all the time, everywhere that they went.
- 17:38The So, first they got the money from
- 17:40Karl's father, all right?
- 17:42And then when he died, and by the way,
- 17:44Marx didn't attend the funeral of his
- 17:46father. Some biographers have said
- 17:49that's because it was out of spite
- 17:50against his father. Another biographer
- 17:52says biographer says he just couldn't
- 17:54make it there, maybe because of the
- 17:56weather, I don't know. But But, he
- 17:58didn't go to the funeral of his father.
- 18:00He was interested in his father's money.
- 18:02And the the one letter that I quote from
- 18:03his father, the father's like, "Okay,
- 18:05here's what you really want. I will give
- 18:07you the money for whatever whatever
- 18:08whatever." So, he clearly knows that the
- 18:10son wants money. After the father died,
- 18:13he went to visit his mother, who he
- 18:16wasn't close to at all. He was at least
- 18:17a little close to the father. And the
- 18:19goal was to get money from from the old
- 18:21lady. And he writes a letter back to
- 18:23Jenny, his wife, ahead of time,
- 18:25basically reporting that, "Well, I
- 18:27really didn't get much money out of the
- 18:29old lady, but she did agree to burn up
- 18:32the IOUs."
- 18:33So, in other words, success, right? I at
- 18:36least got her to do that. And then Jenny
- 18:38would go begging to her relatives. And
- 18:40in one case
- 18:41Well, she was from a rich family,
- 18:43correct?
- 18:43Yeah, fairly well-off family, and that
- 18:45family eventually got to the point of
- 18:47tough love. They had to cut her off as
- 18:49well. And both um
- 18:51her family and also Marx's wider family
- 18:54all knew that when Jenny or Marx came
- 18:55knocking on the door, it was because
- 18:57they wanted money.
- 18:58Right. So, they lived in economic
- 19:00disarray. Economic disarray and to the
- 19:02point where Jenny's family got to the
- 19:04point where they said, "Okay, look, we
- 19:07know that you and Karl have all these
- 19:08kids.
- 19:09We know that you need money. These are
- 19:11our grandchildren. We feel bad for you.
- 19:14Jenny, we can't give you any more money.
- 19:15We We just We just We can't do it." So,
- 19:18the family lends to the Marx family the
- 19:21family nursemaid. Now, this is a woman
- 19:23named Helene Demuth, who was called
- 19:25Lenchen, so the nickname was Lenchen.
- 19:27She grew up with Jenny. So, Jenny's
- 19:30parents say, "Okay, we will We will lend
- 19:32you Lenchen to help the family out
- 19:35rather than giving you more money." So,
- 19:37Lenchen basically hears Karl Marx,
- 19:39champion of the proletariat, the working
- 19:41class, right? Doesn't pay her a dime.
- 19:44Never gives her any money. Yeah, well,
- 19:46that sets the stage for the later
- 19:47Communist revolutions. Well, that's
- 19:49right. In fact, really what he's
- 19:51Big tech companies enrich themselves by
- 19:53taking your personal data. They grab
- 19:55your web history, email metadata, and
- 19:57video searches to create a detailed
- 19:59profile on you, and then they sell that
- 20:00off to the highest bidder. Companies
- 20:03aren't just selling products anymore,
- 20:04they're selling you. To protect your
- 20:06identity and data from these tech
- 20:08giants, I recommend using ExpressVPN
- 20:10every time you go online. Think about
- 20:13all the websites you visit. Everything
- 20:14you do and say online is tracked using
- 20:16your public IP address, which allows
- 20:18them to uniquely map your activity and
- 20:20know your location. ExpressVPN makes you
- 20:23anonymous online by camouflaging your IP
- 20:25address and replacing it with a
- 20:27different secure IP of your choice.
- 20:29ExpressVPN also encrypts all of your
- 20:31data to protect it from hackers and
- 20:33anyone else who might try to spy on you.
- 20:35What I like most about ExpressVPN though
- 20:37is how easy it is to use. Just download
- 20:40the app on your phone or computer, tap
- 20:41one button, and you're protected. So, if
- 20:44you're like me and you believe your
- 20:45internet data belongs to you, then
- 20:47ExpressVPN is the answer. Protect your
- 20:50online data today by visiting
- 20:52expressvpn.com/jordan.
- 20:54e x p r e s s vpn.com/jordan,
- 20:59and you can get an extra 3 months free.
- 21:01That's expressvpn.com/jordan.
- 21:06Well, that's right. In fact, really what
- 21:08he's developing is kind of the ideal
- 21:10world that he wants for himself, which
- 21:12is that other people will pay for him to
- 21:13do whatever he does, and the library,
- 21:15the writing, the research. So, at one
- 21:18point, Marx has sex with Lenchen behind
- 21:22Jenny's back, and she got pregnant. Now,
- 21:25Robert Payne says that he thinks that
- 21:27the sex might have been non-consensual,
- 21:30that it could have been rape, but I
- 21:31don't know how he would know that. But
- 21:33either way,
- 21:34Lenchen got pregnant. Marx refused to
- 21:36admit that the child was his. Everybody
- 21:38knew the child was his. Jenny knew it.
- 21:40In fact, Jenny was crushed. I mean, her
- 21:42heart was broken. She never really
- 21:43forgave her husband for this. The The
- 21:46child Friedrich Engels steps up. Now,
- 21:49the Marx family gets most of their money
- 21:51at this point from Engels. Engels
- 21:53becomes the Marx family's sugar daddy. I
- 21:56mean, he's not just just a partner with
- 21:58Marx. Engels inherited all this money
- 22:00from his from his wealthy industrialist
- 22:02father's inheritance, and so he
- 22:03subsidizes not just Karl, but the Marx
- 22:06family. So, Engels, who doesn't believe
- 22:08in marriage, all right, these guys were
- 22:10against marriage long before anybody
- 22:13else was. Engels has various women that
- 22:15he shacks up with, which in that day is
- 22:17really unusual. I mean, that was
- 22:19scandalous. You didn't live with a woman
- 22:20that you weren't married to. And a lot
- 22:22of these women wanted Engels, you know,
- 22:24Friedrich to marry them, make honest
- 22:25women out of them. One of them
- 22:28Um one of them died, and uh
- 22:31Engels was really crushed by it, really
- 22:33broken-hearted. Marx writes him a
- 22:35letter, and he kind of acknowledges
- 22:37Engels' loss in the first couple
- 22:38sentences, and then he gets straight to
- 22:40the point of asking for more for more
- 22:41money. Engels just raged back in a
- 22:44letter. "Even my bourgeois bourgeois
- 22:47friends showed more compassion and
- 22:49interest and interest than you did." But
- 22:51uh but the point of Lenchen. So, Engels
- 22:53doesn't care about his reputation.
- 22:55Everyone knows he doesn't believe in
- 22:57marriage. So, he steps forward. Helen
- 22:59Demuth Lenchen gives birth to this baby
- 23:01boy, and Engels says,
- 23:04"I'll accept paternity. Let's Let's give
- 23:07him the name Friedrich." So, the son is
- 23:10known as Freddy.
- 23:11Marx never acknowledges his existence,
- 23:14never acknowledges that it's his kid, of
- 23:16course never gives him a penny, just
- 23:18like he never gave a penny to Lenchen.
- 23:21Um and by the way, that poor kid,
- 23:22Freddy, ended up surviving all the Marx
- 23:24family. Um Marx of the six kids he and
- 23:28Jenny had, four of them died before they
- 23:31did, he and Jenny. And then the two
- 23:34girls that survived both committed
- 23:36suicide in suicide pacts with their
- 23:40husbands, and by drinking poison. And as
- 23:43you notice in the Marx poetry, a
- 23:45recurring theme in all of his poetry is
- 23:48about the couples coming together, the
- 23:50one the pale maiden, which sounds like a
- 23:53late-night B-movie horror flick, this
- 23:55pale maiden. You know, she drinks
- 23:57hemlock, she commits suicide. Lovers
- 23:59committing suicide in suicide pacts.
- 24:01That's how Marx's two daughters died.
- 24:03But but the but the family it was a
- 24:06complete wreck. The household where the
- 24:08house was in complete disarray. There
- 24:10were German police reports
- 24:12from 1848 1849 on how one of them says
- 24:16uh "Trying to take a seat in the in the
- 24:19Marx household is a dangerous
- 24:21enterprise" or something like that,
- 24:23because the chair could break from under
- 24:24you. Um it was it was dirty. The
- 24:27landlords would kick them out. The
- 24:29landlords would would cut off the heat.
- 24:31Marx um suffered from boils, carbuncles,
- 24:35which um Paul Johnson, the late British
- 24:38historian, said, "You know, people don't
- 24:40consider this, but Das Kapital is kind
- 24:42of this long, agonizing, painful to read
- 24:44work. Marx's carbuncles on his bottom
- 24:47were at their worst when he was writing
- 24:48Das Kapital."
- 24:50Um he had them on his on his private
- 24:52parts, on his penis, to the point where
- 24:54they would
- 24:56sometimes set him in, you know, into
- 24:57these
- 24:59into outbursts of rage. He wrote one
- 25:02letter to Engels, he said, "I have this
- 25:04boil between my upper lip and my nose.
- 25:06It's like the devil has been hurling
- 25:09excrement at me." Used the word s h i t.
- 25:12Uh but but he suffered, and the doctors
- 25:14tried to figure out Wait, why is Why
- 25:17does Marx have all these boils and
- 25:19carbuncles? No one else in that home
- 25:20seems to have them. Well, the answer is
- 25:22he wouldn't bathe. The guy refused to
- 25:24bathe. Mao Zedong refused to bathe. Um a
- 25:27lot of some of these communists were
- 25:28like this. But he was a very disordered
- 25:31individual at so many different areas of
- 25:34his life.
- 25:35Even his research, we could probably
- 25:36talk about this later. You and I are
- 25:38both PhDs. We've done academic social
- 25:39science research.
- 25:41Uh Marx never went into the field or the
- 25:43factory. I mean, he wrote about the
- 25:45proletariat from uh from the vantage
- 25:49from the
- 25:50from the library, from a from a desk,
- 25:52from a desk in the library in London or
- 25:55or at his home. He never actually did
- 25:57real field research. And if you read the
- 25:59Communist Manifesto,
- 26:01it is not the work of an economist. It
- 26:04is more like a polemic. It's more like a
- 26:07philosophical statement. Um
- 26:10he said once, "The The revolution that
- 26:13began in the brain of the monk" that
- 26:16would be Martin Luther. He says this in
- 26:17"The Opium of the Masses" essay. Um
- 26:20"will now begin in the brain of the
- 26:22philosopher." So, he really fancies
- 26:24himself a philosopher and a poet. A poet
- 26:28above all. He's really not an economist.
- 26:30If Yeah, well, that was probably Well,
- 26:32that was probably an accurate
- 26:33self-characterization, because yeah, his
- 26:36work
- 26:37really I know there are economists
- 26:39who've fallen under his sway, let's say,
- 26:41but his work really served the purpose
- 26:44of motivational doctrine, right? So,
- 26:48the typical writings of an economist
- 26:51aren't taken up by the masses as a
- 26:55rallying point, right? But
- 26:58poetry and philosophy can be taken up as
- 27:02a rallying point. And so, And that's
- 27:04what this book does, right? I mean, if
- 27:06you read if you actually read the
- 27:07Communist Manifesto, which most young
- 27:09people who say, "Well, if you read the
- 27:11Communist Manifesto, it's a pretty good
- 27:13book. It talks about sharing." They
- 27:14haven't read it. They haven't read it.
- 27:16It's It's about that thick, okay? The
- 27:18one I have in mind, the 1998 Penguin
- 27:21Classics edition edited by Martin Malia,
- 27:24is 56 pages. But in my Marxism course at
- 27:27Grove City College every every spring
- 27:30semester, we read it. It's only 56
- 27:32pages. It's not long. But but it is a
- 27:35You're right, if it was an economics
- 27:37work or tract, I mean, it would have
- 27:40data, it had information. It wouldn't be
- 27:42anything that could rally anybody,
- 27:44right? But but this is more like um
- 27:47uh like like a Jefferson Declaration of
- 27:49Independence, right? And
- 27:51Except it's aimed at the Mephistophelean
- 27:53Mephistophelean
- 27:55aim, right? Yes, yeah, the
- 27:57It's actually the polar opposite, but in
- 27:59the sense of in the sense of Adams and
- 28:01Franklin saying, "You know, we need a
- 28:03kind of statement here to rally
- 28:04everybody for this. Who can write? That
- 28:07Jefferson's a great writer, right?" 33
- 28:09years old, fantastic writer. You know,
- 28:11"When in the course of human events"
- 28:12just
- 28:13puts it out. And of course, in his case,
- 28:15it's truth and it's inspiring. But when
- 28:17Marx sits down to write, it's just kind
- 28:19of this polemic. The The The Communist
- 28:21Manifesto is kind of a diatribe. It's
- 28:24It's really um there's a lot of anger in
- 28:26there. There's a lot of um
- 28:28catchphrases, kind of revolutionary
- 28:30catchphrases. A guy who could really
- 28:31turn a phrase.
- 28:33I mean, that was Marx. Radical leftists
- 28:34are very good at turning phrases.
- 28:37Gender-affirming care, every stroke of
- 28:39genius. Diversity, equity, and
- 28:41inclusion.
- 28:43Seriously, like they're like once those
- 28:46slogans slogan Do you know what the
- 28:48derivation of the word slogan is?
- 28:50This is so funny. It's comes from the
- 28:52Welsh, two words, sluagh and ghairm.
- 28:56Sluagh is s l u a g h, and ghairm is g h
- 28:59a i r m. Sluagh ghairm, battle cry of
- 29:03the dead.
- 29:04That's what a slogan is. Oh, it's so
- 29:06perfect, right? Cuz it it it it conjures
- 29:09up images of armies of the dead fighting
- 29:12against the living. Yeah, well, that's
- 29:14what a slogan is. Oh, yes. No kidding.
- 29:17He was really good at sloganeering. In
- 29:19fact, to the point where
- 29:21the only part of the end of the
- 29:22Communist Manifesto anybody remembers is
- 29:24"Workers of the world, unite. We have
- 29:27nothing to lose but our chains." But,
- 29:29you know, people just back up
- 29:31to their need" is pretty damn good, too.
- 29:33That's a good one, too.
- 29:33That's a good one.
- 29:34But but if you just go back one
- 29:36paragraph at the end, right? The
- 29:38Communist
- 29:40support every revolutionary movement um
- 29:44uh uh
- 29:45the forcible overthrow of all existing
- 29:47conditions. I mean, those lines are in
- 29:49the the next two final paragraphs. And
- 29:52that's what really the Manifesto was all
- 29:54about.
- 29:55Okay, so let's
- 29:57I want to go get back to a question that
- 29:58we touched on, but didn't fully address.
- 30:01What in the world is an atheist?
- 30:03Absolutely. Why is an atheist toying
- 30:05with not toying with centered on
- 30:09what would you say analysis of and
- 30:11identification with religious tropes?
- 30:14Yeah. Right. Now, he claims atheism, but
- 30:16you don't write a Faust-like poem.
- 30:18Mhm. Mhm.
- 30:20Being in league with Mephistopheles is
- 30:22not technically atheism. Now, you might
- 30:25ask about the relationship between the
- 30:27two, but that's a different question.
- 30:28But so, what do you make of the fact
- 30:30that he was obsessed with these Faustian
- 30:33notions and with ideas of conjuring up
- 30:36the underworld despite his professed
- 30:38atheism? Yeah, but wait, even the phrase
- 30:39from each according to his ability to
- 30:41each according to his needs, that's a
- 30:42that's a twisting of the scripture.
- 30:43Right. Right. Right. But in his case, so
- 30:48yeah, and people have asked me this.
- 30:49They said, "Well, if he had this
- 30:50fascination with the devil,
- 30:53it must have only been in a kind of
- 30:54rebellious sort of way like like Mikhail
- 30:57Yeah, right. Like Mikhail Bakunin.
- 31:00Saul Alinsky in the intro to Rules for
- 31:03Radicals, right? Lest we forget at least
- 31:06an over-the-shoulder acknowledgement to
- 31:08that first of all rebels who won himself
- 31:10his own kingdom. Yeah. Lest we forget.
- 31:13Yeah, no kidding. Yeah, you You don't
- 31:15walk by that sort of statement
- 31:16accidentally. No, definitely not. Well,
- 31:18a lot of people on the left do. They're
- 31:20like, "Well, he's just being Yeah,
- 31:22right. Well, those are the same people
- 31:24who think that Milton's Lucifer is a
- 31:25hero. And And Lots of people thought
- 31:28that.
- 31:28And who give their magazines names like
- 31:30the Jacobin of all things. Why the hell
- 31:33would you name your magazine after a
- 31:35group that guillotined 40,000 people in
- 31:37France in 1793 and 1794? Yeah,
- 31:39absolutely. Well, I've also noticed that
- 31:42I've read a lot of comments by online
- 31:45anonymous trolls, a lot. And I've looked
- 31:48at their names. And there's a sizable
- 31:52minority of the really vicious online
- 31:54trolls who adopt satanic names.
- 31:56Absolutely. Far more than far more than
- 31:59you'd expect. And it's not cute or
- 32:01funny. No. And not in the least. And it
- 32:04sums up the manner in which they deal
- 32:06with the world with much more accuracy
- 32:09than they might imagine when they've had
- 32:12that what would you call it unmitigated
- 32:13gall to dare such a thing. Right. Right.
- 32:15In fact In fact, one one of them, I
- 32:17won't say who it is cuz she could end up
- 32:19watching this, but
- 32:21it's somebody I know the name of the
- 32:22magazine. And her pen name, I won't give
- 32:24the first name, but the last name is
- 32:26Diavolo. Right. Right.
- 32:27A V O L O, which is Italian for devil.
- 32:29Yeah. Right. Yeah. And I mean, what does
- 32:32that tell you? What as
- 32:34nom de plume of all things, Diavolo?
- 32:36Well, it is the question. What does it
- 32:38tell you? Because all people who Well,
- 32:40all the people who picked that would
- 32:41say, "Well, Lucifer is misunderstood
- 32:44because he's just a rebel against
- 32:45tyranny." Right. And so, that's their
- 32:48that's their standard. The devil is
- 32:51misunderstood. He's just a rebel against
- 32:53tyranny.
- 32:53That's how Mikhail Bakunin, who was one
- 32:55of Marx's associates, God and the State.
- 32:57He wrote about Lucifer in this heroic
- 33:00way.
- 33:00Yeah. And he was an atheist. Now, in
- 33:02Marx's case, all right. Um
- 33:05So,
- 33:06he he wasn't an atheist in 1837 when he
- 33:10wrote that first poem, okay?
- 33:12Even in By 1841, was he an atheist?
- 33:15Probably. Let me back up.
- 33:17Well, the question is was he ever an
- 33:19atheist? You know what I mean? Because
- 33:21if he's stated his allegiance to
- 33:23Mephistopheles when he's 19 or 20, and
- 33:26that's actually the motif of his
- 33:28writings, he's never an atheist. He
- 33:30might not be very pleased with the idea
- 33:32of God, but that's not exactly the same
- 33:34thing as being an atheist.
- 33:36And And they also end up putting their
- 33:37faith in Marxism-Leninism in an almost
- 33:39religious-like way. I mean,
- 33:41Ronald Reagan Well, Marxism-Leninism,
- 33:44that religion of theirs. Yeah. Yeah. Um
- 33:46the opium of the intellectuals is what
- 33:48Raymond Aron Aron called it. But But in
- 33:50Marx's case, let me back up a little
- 33:52bit. So, he's born May 5th, 1818
- 33:54in in Trier, Germany. Trier is spelled
- 33:57like Trier, T R I E R. A A very
- 34:00religious city.
- 34:02I mean, like 90% Roman Catholic. The
- 34:05great cathedral of Trier was found
- 34:08founded around the year 320, 330. It was
- 34:12paid for by Saint Helena, the mother of
- 34:15Constantine of all people, right? Oh,
- 34:17really? So, it's that early. Yeah, yeah,
- 34:19exactly. That early. Oh, wow. And so,
- 34:21and by the way, it is also the birth
- 34:23town of Saint Ambrose, who was the the
- 34:27bishop of Milan later who brought
- 34:29Augustine into the faith. So, Ambrose
- 34:32and Marx are both from Trier, Germany of
- 34:35all things. So, you have this cathedral
- 34:37in Trier. Saint Helena is the one that
- 34:39goes to the the Holy Land and brings
- 34:41back all kinds of relics, all right? In
- 34:44fact, she believes that she found the
- 34:45Holy Lance, which is pierced the side of
- 34:49Christ, and that is at the Vatican
- 34:51today. She found, she believes, the
- 34:53Crown of Thorns, which is in Notre Dame.
- 34:55Mhm.
- 34:56She believed that she found the Holy
- 34:58Robe that Jesus wore at the crucifixion
- 35:01that the Roman soldiers cast lots for at
- 35:03the foot of the cross. The Holy Robe is
- 35:06in that cathedral in Trier. By the way,
- 35:08Marx in his 1841
- 35:12poem, The Player, right? Which is
- 35:15actually a play because you you
- 35:16mentioned drama. A lot of these plays
- 35:17are actually dramas as well. His His
- 35:20demonic violinist who's summoning up the
- 35:24powers of darkness. Marx not only wrote
- 35:26the character and the words, he also
- 35:28wrote
- 35:30the the stage, the production, the
- 35:32furniture on the stage, the clothes
- 35:34people would wear. The violinist is
- 35:36wearing the Holy Robe of Christ from the
- 35:38cathedral in Trier while he's summoning
- 35:41up I mean, chilling
- 35:43chilling of all things.
- 35:44there's a letter between Marx and Jenny,
- 35:46whose wife who's an atheist. And at one
- 35:47point, when everyone's coming to town
- 35:49for like the annual sort of festival
- 35:51where people come in to venerate the
- 35:53robe, Jenny's making fun of them. Like,
- 35:55"Oh, these silly people." Right? Um But
- 35:58But But so, in Marx's case, he's born
- 36:00May 5th, 1818 in Trier. He was baptized
- 36:04in 1824.
- 36:06Now, he's he's a Jew. The family he
- 36:08comes from a very Jewish family. Not
- 36:11just in terms of of ethnicity, but
- 36:12Judaism. They are religious Jews.
- 36:14They're Orthodox Jews.
- 36:16A bunch of rabbis in the family.
- 36:19His father
- 36:20had converted to Christianity, to
- 36:22Lutheranism specifically, Heinrich Marx.
- 36:25And some say that he did because of
- 36:26social pressures in Germany in the day,
- 36:29the anti-Semitism. And he perhaps so,
- 36:31maybe.
- 36:32He had an uncle who converted to Roman
- 36:34Catholicism, which most people there did
- 36:36cuz it was like 90% Roman Catholic. But
- 36:38Marx's father converted to Lutheranism.
- 36:40And Marx's father died a believer,
- 36:43right? Probably kind of a more liberal
- 36:45Christian, but he was a Christian. So,
- 36:47Marx converts Marx is baptized 1824. He
- 36:51would have been five or six years old.
- 36:53His mother really didn't want him to.
- 36:55The mother really didn't want to
- 36:56convert. But Marx is a fairly
- 36:59dedicated Christian through his teenage
- 37:02years. And he really doesn't start to
- 37:05change until college. And he came
- 37:07in in particular
- 37:08what happened? Well, he came under the
- 37:10influence It's hard I had a hard time
- 37:13pinning this down. And I don't think
- 37:14there's enough good information. And
- 37:16you'll appreciate this as a fellow
- 37:18academic. So many academics don't give a
- 37:20damn about faith at all. I mean, the the
- 37:23the first biography that I set out to do
- 37:25on Ronald Reagan
- 37:27and I've written I think eight books on
- 37:29Reagan was going to be about him and the
- 37:31end of the Cold War.
- 37:33And I ended up writing a book called God
- 37:35and Ronald Reagan because I found all
- 37:37this stuff on Reagan's faith that no one
- 37:39had talked about.
- 37:39Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. So, look at all
- 37:41this. Look at all this. Look at all
- 37:42these letters he's talking Well, that's
- 37:44particularly relevant in the context of
- 37:45this conversation.
- 37:46Yeah, yeah.
- 37:47Wow, look at this letter to this
- 37:49Methodist minister who's having doubts
- 37:51about Christ's divinity. Reagan's
- 37:52literally using the liar, lord, or
- 37:54lunatic argument of C. S. Lewis, right?
- 37:57So, I kind of picked up on that.
- 37:58But But so many of these biographers
- 38:00ignore faith. So, in Marx's case, I'm
- 38:02one of the only ones who really cared,
- 38:04right? A lot of the Marx biographers are
- 38:06leftists. So, they
- 38:08So, they ignore all of this stuff. I'm
- 38:10getting off track. No, no, that's okay.
- 38:13The first main Marx biographer, Franz
- 38:16Mehring, this would have been over 100
- 38:19years ago, was the first to discover the
- 38:21demonic poetry and plays.
- 38:25And he presented them to Marx's
- 38:26daughter. And he said, "You know,
- 38:30we should this stuff shouldn't see the
- 38:33light of day. I mean, this is this is
- 38:35bad. I mean, this is really damning."
- 38:38And a communist with some integrity, is
- 38:41it David Riazanov? With the Marx-Engels
- 38:43Institute in the 1920s, found all of it
- 38:46and said, "No, for the sake of we we
- 38:48need to put this stuff out there so
- 38:50people know what what Marx believed."
- 38:52So, So, he actually found it, first
- 38:54published it.
- 38:55It's untouched until Robert Payne
- 38:57mentions it late 1960s, early 1970s.
- 38:59Paul Johnson wrote about it in
- 39:01Intellectuals. Pastor Richard Wurmbrand,
- 39:04who was tortured in the Romanian prison
- 39:06of Pitesti, wrote a book called Marx and
- 39:08Satan. He wrote about it. But all the
- 39:11other Marx biographers, they just ignore
- 39:13it. They completely ignore it. So, the
- 39:14long way of saying,
- 39:16how how and why exactly did he become an
- 39:18atheist? What happened between those
- 39:21teenage years and college years that
- 39:23really flipped him? The best that I can
- 39:24determine, he came under the influence
- 39:27of a professor in college named Dr.
- 39:29Fancy that. Yeah, right. Exactly.
- 39:31Imagine that. Named Dr. Bruno Bauer,
- 39:34University of Bonn. And he was a
- 39:36professor of theology who was an
- 39:38atheist, right? Imagine that. Just like
- 39:40the colleges today.
- 39:41He's eventually run out of the
- 39:42university, but he and Marx became
- 39:46very tight, very close. Interestingly,
- 39:48too, Bruno Bauer was intensely
- 39:50anti-Semitic.
- 39:51Um so close that they together
- 39:54um so Bauer influences Marx's atheism.
- 39:57They start a journal together called
- 39:59Annals of Atheism, which never gets off
- 40:02the ground, partly because they don't
- 40:03have money to support it. I guess they
- 40:04couldn't find a wealthy atheist
- 40:06socialist who could who could help them
- 40:08out. So they start this archives of uh
- 40:12this Annals of Atheism, and then Bauer's
- 40:15eventually fired from the university.
- 40:18He's pushed out of the university. And
- 40:20he and Marx pulled a couple stunts. In
- 40:22one case, they went to a nearby village
- 40:25on for Palm Sunday and rode in on
- 40:28donkeys together, kind of mocking the
- 40:31entrance of Christ into Jerusalem on
- 40:34Palm Sunday.
- 40:35or imitating, right? Well, you have the
- 40:37same weird dichotomy there with the
- 40:38character in the play that you
- 40:40described. It's like
- 40:41you know, are you mocking or usurping?
- 40:44That's a better a better metaphor, yes,
- 40:46absolutely. Well, because Lucifer I
- 40:49don't like the word channeling that
- 40:50people use today, but that might be what
- 40:51he was doing usurping is good because
- 40:53Lucifer is a usurper, right? I mean,
- 40:55he's the spirit that wants to overthrow
- 40:57everything and put himself at the top.
- 40:59And not just himself, but his intellect
- 41:01specifically. And that's very
- 41:03reminiscent of the way Marx conducted
- 41:04himself in his life, right? Everything
- 41:06around him, including his family, his
- 41:08wife, his friends, everything was
- 41:10sacrificed to the glorification of his
- 41:13intellect, right? In this and like well,
- 41:16and this is exactly what happens in the
- 41:18Faustian bargain, right? I mean, Faust
- 41:19essentially sells his soul to for what?
- 41:24What do you say? Intellectual supremacy,
- 41:26right? Well,
- 41:27there's a good diagnosis for the
- 41:28universities for today, too. But it is
- 41:30the it's the fundamental temptation of
- 41:33the intellect, right? Because it's it is
- 41:35the highest angel in God's heavenly
- 41:37kingdom most capable of going bitterly
- 41:39wrong. And Marx is a great example of
- 41:41that.
- 41:43which is what Alinsky liked about him.
- 41:47Starting a business can be tough, but
- 41:49thanks to Shopify, running your online
- 41:51storefront is easier than ever. Shopify
- 41:53is the global commerce platform that
- 41:55helps you sell at every stage of your
- 41:57business, from the launch your online
- 41:58shop stage all the way to the did we
- 42:00just hit a million orders stage.
- 42:02Shopify's there to help you grow. Our
- 42:04marketing team uses Shopify every day to
- 42:06sell our merchandise, and we love how
- 42:08easy it is to add more items, ship
- 42:10products, and track conversions. Shopify
- 42:12helps you turn browsers into buyers with
- 42:14the internet's best converting checkout,
- 42:16up to 36% better compared to other
- 42:18leading e-commerce platforms. No matter
- 42:20how big you want to grow, Shopify gives
- 42:22you everything you need to take control
- 42:24and take your business to the next
- 42:25level. Sign up for a $1 per month trial
- 42:28period at shopify.com/jbp.
- 42:31Go to shopify.com/jbp
- 42:33now to grow your business, no matter
- 42:35what stage you're in. That's
- 42:36shopify.com/jbp.
- 42:41Think of the
- 42:43arrogance that it requires to be a
- 42:47critic,
- 42:48like a devastating critic of everything.
- 42:50Not in the not in the
- 42:52not in the manner that Descartes
- 42:54questioned. That's not the same thing,
- 42:57right? Questioning is more an admission
- 42:58of your own inadequacy, but that damning
- 43:02critique of everything, like the
- 43:04question is, who the hell do you think
- 43:05you you know, the the kids who shot up
- 43:08the Columbine High School. That's the
- 43:10position they put themselves in. Like
- 43:12their writing, which no one pays any
- 43:14attention to, is absolutely
- 43:15bone-chilling. Like there's no
- 43:18difference between the writing of the
- 43:19more literate of the two and something
- 43:21that you would expect from someone who's
- 43:23manifesting signs of for lack of a
- 43:25better word, possession. It's really
- 43:27chilling stuff. This is independent of
- 43:29your religious belief. Like you can't
- 43:31read what he wrote without the hairs on
- 43:33the back of your neck standing up. And
- 43:36he literally
- 43:38positioned himself as the judge of
- 43:40everything. He believed human life was
- 43:42inadequate. He believed everything
- 43:44should be destroyed. Him and his friend
- 43:45were planning a much more destructive
- 43:48rampage than they managed. And they had
- 43:51fantasies and wrote
- 43:53and wrote
- 43:54about destroying entire cities. They
- 43:56wanted to lay everything waste exactly
- 43:59in that Mephistophelian manner. And you
- 44:01see that in Marx's poetry as well. I
- 44:03mean, I mean, Marx says it I mean, in
- 44:05one case, he's like jury and
- 44:06executioner, right? And I shall howl
- 44:08like a cursed at mankind. And and
- 44:12and the mockery that it's a good point.
- 44:14I mean, because the devil hates to be
- 44:16mocked, but the devil mocks Christ. The
- 44:18devil mocks God, right? And in Marx's
- 44:21case, so they're imitating or mocking
- 44:24the
- 44:25Christ entering Jerusalem. They would go
- 44:27into churches together, he and Bruno
- 44:29Bauer, and laugh and kind of make noise
- 44:32in the pew just to be disrespectful. So
- 44:35he's
- 44:36you know, he he's he's an angry
- 44:39throughout his life, and no one liked
- 44:41him. I I mean, he
- 44:43I can't imagine why. He got along with
- 44:45his own family,
- 44:48you know, his wife I mean, his family
- 44:49tolerated him. Some biographers say that
- 44:52his that he had a great relationship
- 44:54with his daughters, others that he
- 44:55didn't. It's it's amazing two completely
- 44:57diametrically different takes on that.
- 44:59But all the different people who worked
- 45:01with him described him in this like this
- 45:03dictatorial kind of way. And he
- 45:04eventually split with everybody. Mikhail
- 45:07Bakunin,
- 45:09Feuerbach, all these different guys.
- 45:11They would eventually get to the point
- 45:14where Marx is calling him an ape or a
- 45:16baboon. Right, right, right. This is
- 45:18Marx's typical filth and vitriol and
- 45:21bile. This is what he does to everybody.
- 45:23So he eventually got to that point with
- 45:25just about everybody.
- 45:28But but but on your point, right? So
- 45:32when did he become an atheist? So
- 45:34he's there by 1841
- 45:37at that point. And he's 26? At that
- 45:39point, he would have been 23 years
- 45:42old. And
- 45:43I'd love to really see some sort of
- 45:45documentation of exactly how it began to
- 45:47slip away.
- 45:48Right, right. Although you said that
- 45:49this association he had with the
- 45:51professor. Well, that's that's that's in
- 45:53some ways a sufficient explanation. Like
- 45:57not exactly, because it doesn't explain
- 45:59why he would have been attracted to that
- 46:01professor. But you could it's easy to
- 46:03imagine that well, maybe that professor
- 46:04paid a lot of attention to him. I I
- 46:06think so. And the professor's
- 46:07anti-Semitic, and which is odd, of
- 46:09course, and Marx is Jewish, and Marx
- 46:12ends up with some very anti-Semitic
- 46:14statements.
- 46:15He said, "The Israelite faith is
- 46:17repulsive to me."
- 46:19And he has this one statement where he
- 46:21talks about, "In the end, the final
- 46:23emancipation of the emancipation of the"
- 46:25It sounds like something Hitler could
- 46:27have said. I mean, some really
- 46:29disturbing statements about So So the
- 46:31tell me about the emancipation? Yeah, I
- 46:33should get I'll get that exact quote.
- 46:34Okay, okay, okay. I'll get that exact
- 46:36quote.
- 46:37Okay. Okay, so so we don't know Okay, so
- 46:39we have this sense that he identified
- 46:41with Mephistopheles, which is
- 46:43not great. And and that he has a
- 46:45Luciferian intellect, which is also not
- 46:48exactly what you'd hope for. By the way,
- 46:50just for the cameras, I did a piece
- 46:51called
- 46:53Mark Marx on Judaism, Christianity, and
- 46:56Evolution Race. If you look that up, it
- 46:59has it has that quote on the Jewish
- 47:00question.
- 47:01Okay, okay, okay, okay. We don't know
- 47:04why he
- 47:06turned to atheism. These poems that he
- 47:08wrote that were paeans to to
- 47:10Mephistopheles, is that after he becomes
- 47:12an atheist? No, he's writing So the
- 47:14first one was 1837.
- 47:17Wrote another in 1841. He wrote a bunch
- 47:19of them. He did
- 47:21He did a just a chilling play called
- 47:25Oulanem.
- 47:26Um O U L A N E M. And people that are
- 47:30watching this, if they now type into
- 47:31their computer Oulanem, even in Google,
- 47:34it'll pop up, play by Karl Marx. It even
- 47:37has a Wikipedia entry. And uh Let me
- 47:40warn people, you might not want to do
- 47:41this, but if you click the images
- 47:44button, you will see I mean, you will
- 47:46see I mean, there's some satanic stuff
- 47:49up there from like not heavy metal, but
- 47:51like black metal groups. So Oulanem is
- 47:54an anagram for Emmanuel or Manuelo. So
- 47:59Marx takes Emmanuel, which is the name
- 48:01given to Christ or Manuelo, and he flips
- 48:04it into this anagram called Oulanem. And
- 48:07it's this chilling play. The main
- 48:10character is Lucindo, Lucindo, L U C I N
- 48:13D O. And
- 48:16you just can't believe what what what
- 48:17you're reading with with with with this
- 48:20play. So that that was written later in
- 48:22the 1840s. So really the prime of his
- 48:25writing, including the decade when he
- 48:27wrote the Communist Manifesto, is also
- 48:29the same decade when he was writing
- 48:32these these these these poems. And
- 48:35plays. And plays. And plays. And
- 48:37throughout his life, his kids and others
- 48:39would say
- 48:40yeah, he had a favorite line always from
- 48:41Mephistopheles, "Everything that exists
- 48:43deserves to perish." So that remains a
- 48:45part of him through throughout his life.
- 48:48His son, Edgar, has a letter where he
- 48:51addresses his father as my dear devil.
- 48:54Which I don't know, maybe it's playful.
- 48:57I don't know. Although I would never you
- 48:59know, call my dad my dear devil. His
- 49:02wife called him
- 49:04my wicked knave.
- 49:06I I quote Heinrich Heine
- 49:09referring to him as a goblin, "He tried
- 49:12to get take me
- 49:13under his spell."
- 49:15Other cases of where where he's using
- 49:17that kind of language.
- 49:19Um when Engels first met him, he
- 49:22describes him as this dark man from
- 49:26Trier,
- 49:28who hops and leaps and springs on his
- 49:30heels, the the the monster of 10,000
- 49:34devils, he he
- 49:35him. And the
- 49:37And the letter from his father
- 49:39is um
- 49:40which is written in 1837, a year a year
- 49:43before before his before his father
- 49:45died.
- 49:47So, his father writes to him March 2nd,
- 49:501837.
- 49:53Carl, at times my heart delights in
- 49:54thinking of you and your fortune, and
- 49:56yet at times I cannot rid myself of
- 49:59ideas which arouse in me sad forebodings
- 50:02and fear when I am struck as if by
- 50:04lightning by the thought, is your heart
- 50:07in accord with your head, your talents?
- 50:10Has it room for the earthly but gentler
- 50:12sentiments which in this veil of sorrow
- 50:15It's a beautiful letter in many ways.
- 50:17Are essentially consoling for a man of
- 50:19feeling? And then this question from the
- 50:22father of Karl Marx to his
- 50:24to his at this point
- 50:2718-year-old son.
- 50:29And since that heart, Carl, is obviously
- 50:32animated and governed by a demon Mhm.
- 50:36not granted to all men, is that demon
- 50:39heavenly or Faustian? Mhm.
- 50:42Will you ever, and that is not the least
- 50:44painful doubt of my heart, will you ever
- 50:47be capable of truly human domestic
- 50:49happiness?
- 50:51Will, and this doubt has no less
- 50:52tortured me since I have come to love a
- 50:54certain person like my own child, will
- 50:56you ever be capable of imparting
- 50:59happiness to those immediately around
- 51:01you? By the way, the answer was no.
- 51:03Mhm. Right? And that's obviously the
- 51:06father had intimations of that.
- 51:07Yeah, and since that heart is obviously
- 51:10animated and governed by a demon, not
- 51:13granted to all men, is that demon
- 51:16heavenly or Faustian? That's his dad.
- 51:19Yeah. And and there's only so many of
- 51:21those things I think that a sympathetic
- 51:24um Marxist or Marxist biographer can
- 51:26shrug off. I mean, there's just so many
- 51:28statements like that from him and people
- 51:31about him and people who knew him, the
- 51:32loved ones, the
- 51:34a wife, a son, a best friend from
- 51:36Engels, and then the different writings.
- 51:39Woo. Okay, so let's let's let's let's
- 51:41attack this.
- 51:42Now, was he a Satanist, right?
- 51:43Well
- 51:44that is a whole different thing that I
- 51:47can't personally answer.
- 51:50Well, it seems
- 51:52not unreasonable to presuppose that he
- 51:54was a devotee of the Mephistophelian
- 51:56ethos.
- 51:57Yeah, I think that's a Right. So, the
- 51:58question is, you know, what constitutes
- 52:00a Satanist? Well, someone who generates
- 52:02a murderous doctrine. Now, that raises
- 52:04questions. I mean, dead serious about
- 52:06that. Like, the most murderous doctrine
- 52:08ever promoted in the in the roughly
- 52:12Judeo-Christian context by by a large
- 52:15margin. So,
- 52:16I would say it's incumbent on those who
- 52:18would defend him to describe why we
- 52:20wouldn't just assume that. But the like
- 52:23the part of the reason that I was so
- 52:25interested in talking to you was because
- 52:27I felt that what you documented in your
- 52:28book was extraordinarily telling from
- 52:30the psychological perspective because I
- 52:32know how these things work. And it it is
- 52:35not something that can be overlooked
- 52:37that that that that was his favorite
- 52:39quote. Not especially not when you
- 52:41understand
- 52:43Goethe's centrality in the German
- 52:46intellectual tradition. That's like
- 52:48having a favorite quote from
- 52:49Shakespeare, right? And it's it's not
- 52:51any old quote. It's the central credo of
- 52:54Mephistopheles. So, that's
- 52:55extraordinarily telling. Now, okay. Now,
- 52:57I do have another Can Can I give you a
- 52:59quote? Yes. So, Robert Payne, the very
- 53:02serious academic, no right-winger,
- 53:04British man of letters, the guy who
- 53:06really broke this first in his 1968
- 53:08biography of Marx, all right? His
- 53:10chapter where he talks about this stuff
- 53:12is called is called the demons in his
- 53:14Marx biography. Now, he wrote this, and
- 53:17I'm not saying that I endorse this. As
- 53:18an academic, I can't say if this is
- 53:21correct. There were times when Marx
- 53:23seemed to be possessed by demons. That's
- 53:26what Payne wrote.
- 53:28And now this I would at least more
- 53:31endorse.
- 53:32Marx had the devil's view of the world
- 53:35and the devil's malignity. Mhm.
- 53:37Sometimes he seemed to know that he was
- 53:39accomplishing works of evil.
- 53:41I think that gets closer to it. Now, our
- 53:44Pastor Richard Wurmbrand who wrote the
- 53:46famous book Tortured for Christ and was
- 53:48tortured for Christ in Romanian prisons
- 53:50by uh communist captors who were
- 53:52shouting, "I am the devil" while they
- 53:53were torturing him. He did a book called
- 53:55Marx and Satan. He is convinced that
- 53:58Marx was a Satanist and did some things
- 54:00ritualistically that it might have even
- 54:02been satanic, but I can't I can't say
- 54:05that. I can't endorse But you see
- 54:06evidence of that in his writings.
- 54:07I've never seen evidence of that. I've
- 54:09never seen evidence of that.
- 54:10That's right. That's right. In fact,
- 54:12Payne even goes so far as to say
- 54:14Vladimir Lenin, right? There's a
- 54:16statement from Lenin which said,
- 54:18um "When I was a teen, I broke from all
- 54:20religion. I took the cross from my neck
- 54:22and I threw it in the rubbish bin." Mhm.
- 54:25And and Payne has a quote where not
- 54:27Payne, uh Richard Wurmbrand, where I
- 54:29think um I think he believes that Lenin
- 54:31even stomped on it. He says, "Well,
- 54:33that's a satanic ritual." I don't know I
- 54:34don't know that it is or not. But
- 54:36there's another case of Lenin who at
- 54:37least did the work of the devil. I mean,
- 54:39Lenin had uh according to Robert
- 54:42Conquest, W. H. Chamberlain, the first
- 54:44historian of the Russian Revolution,
- 54:46500,000 people were killed from 1917 to
- 54:491923 under Lenin, not even including the
- 54:51Russian Civil War. If that's not the
- 54:53devil's work, I don't know what the hell
- 54:54is, right? But but I think what Payne
- 54:57had said in the latter quote, "The
- 54:59devil's view of the world, the devil's
- 55:00malignity." And at the very least, this
- 55:02identification with kind of devilish
- 55:05like um destruction, right? Tearing
- 55:07everything down, rebelling against the
- 55:09world, everything that exists deserves
- 55:11to perish. Um that at least And then the
- 55:14ideology that he created that just
- 55:17happened to be responsible for the
- 55:19deaths of over 100 million people in the
- 55:2120th century, you know, more than World
- 55:23War I and World War II combined. So,
- 55:26that ideology was pretty hellacious.
- 55:30Mhm. Yeah, yeah, to say the least. Okay,
- 55:33so
- 55:34and I think it's very naive not to
- 55:35assume that
- 55:37the events that we described in Marx's
- 55:38life are not connected. Right.
- 55:41Yeah, right, correct.
- 55:42And that that that his economic
- 55:44polemics were somehow independent of his
- 55:47poetic imagination. It's like obviously
- 55:49they weren't because they wouldn't have
- 55:50had that motivational force. So, they're
- 55:53they were calling on dark forces.
- 55:56Obviously. So, because otherwise they
- 55:59wouldn't have compelled people in that
- 56:00manner, especially not toward the that
- 56:02sort of immense sadistic murderousness
- 56:05and utter destructiveness. And of course
- 56:07get to the hatred of God, which all the
- 56:09communists did. So, all the communists
- 56:11thereafter seek to ban religion, right?
- 56:13Atheists. They're not exactly atheists
- 56:15because they're trying to stomp
- 56:16something out. That's right. It's not
- 56:18just It's not just
- 56:19a neutrality. That's right. It's not a
- 56:21neutrality toward religion. It's not
- 56:23irreligion. It's not separation of
- 56:25church and state. It is militant
- 56:26aggressive atheism. Trotsky and Lenin
- 56:28create the League of the Militant
- 56:30Godless. Right.
- 56:31They ban religion. They have the Moscow
- 56:33church trials. They blow up churches.
- 56:35They jail priests, right? Um you know,
- 56:37the the Solzhenitsyn writes in The Gulag
- 56:39Archipelago, they put nuns in special
- 56:41sections of the Gulag with prostitutes.
- 56:43Yes, right.
- 56:43Right, deemed them of Christ.
- 56:45Lenin said, "All worship of a divinity
- 56:47is a necrophilia. There is nothing more
- 56:50abominable than religion." So, they they
- 56:53don't just try to stop religion. They
- 56:55they want um Pol Pot, the Buddhist monks
- 56:58in Cambodia, to renounce their vows, to
- 57:02marry. It's not enough for them to be
- 57:05quiet. Well, I don't I don't know how
- 57:06you can I don't know how you can
- 57:07separate
- 57:09a
- 57:10militantly anti-religious atheism from
- 57:15from especially say within a Christian
- 57:17context from something approximate
- 57:20satanic
- 57:22ideology because Right.
- 57:24I don't see how I don't see how
- 57:25conceptually that separation is
- 57:27possible. It's one thing to be atheist
- 57:29in the manner that
- 57:31leaves people to go to hell in a
- 57:33handbasket in their own way, but to be
- 57:36actually an enemy of the religious
- 57:39enterprise, that's a whole different
- 57:40thing.
- 57:41It is. So
- 57:42and and that obviously Marx and the
- 57:44communists were obviously that. Clearly,
- 57:46obviously.
- 57:47And and and and and Satan might say, "I
- 57:49don't care if you believe in me or not.
- 57:51You're doing my work, man." Yeah, well,
- 57:53that You're shutting down churches,
- 57:54blowing up churches. It also that also
- 57:56touches on the issue of what it means to
- 57:58believe. Right? And I mean
- 58:02you could imagine someone comparatively
- 58:04harmless who toys with ritualistic
- 58:07satanic activities in a sort of dramatic
- 58:09manner. And then you could imagine
- 58:11someone who tortures nuns and priests
- 58:13and burns down churches, but forgoes any
- 58:16technical affiliation with Satan. I
- 58:18would say that the latter is
- 58:20the Satanist in a much deeper sense than
- 58:22the former. That's Not that what the
- 58:24former's doing is excusable.
- 58:26Yeah, or at least satanic. Yes, right.
- 58:28But but
- 58:29to to to to do what the communists did
- 58:33to the religious enterprise is evidence
- 58:35of something far more militant than a
- 58:37mere atheism. Yes.
- 58:39So, okay. Okay. Now, here's something
- 58:41that was bothering me, too, when I was
- 58:43reading your book. So,
- 58:45one of the things that the radical
- 58:46leftists do
- 58:48that especially and this is sort of in
- 58:50proportion to their
- 58:52what would you say? Their intellectual
- 58:55um
- 58:56arrogance
- 58:57is elevate themselves on moral grounds
- 59:00above the great figures of the past. So,
- 59:04I can hardly stand going into art
- 59:05museums anymore because
- 59:07a typical art museum now, and this is
- 59:09true even of the greatest museums in the
- 59:10West, is a great painting
- 59:12with a a little polemic off to the side
- 59:15written by some art critic who's
- 59:17basically claiming moral superiority
- 59:20over the artist because of their
- 59:21adherence to whatever the current
- 59:23ideological doctrine is. It's sickening.
- 59:26has has has survived for six centuries,
- 59:28we're still looking at Well, but you
- 59:29imagine what a what a great advantage it
- 59:32is to the art critic to be able to claim
- 59:34moral superiority to a truly great man
- 59:37of the past without having to actually
- 59:39have accomplished anything. I mean, what
- 59:41a deal, right? Okay, so but but there
- 59:43but
- 59:45but I would like to be very careful in
- 59:47our conceptualization here because I've
- 59:49thought the same way about um Foucault.
- 59:52Yeah. So Foucault was uh
- 59:55a person rather unpleasant, you might
- 59:57say, in his personal habits. Like
- 59:59seriously unpleasant. And so
- 1:00:02but but here here's here's our
- 1:00:04conundrum.
- 1:00:07In the in the story of Noah
- 1:00:09Noah is described as a man who's good in
- 1:00:12his generation. And it it seems to mean
- 1:00:15something like for his time and place
- 1:00:18he was a good man. And there might be
- 1:00:20men that are so good that their goodness
- 1:00:22transcends their time and place.
- 1:00:24And I think we remember men like that.
- 1:00:26But the typical amount of goodness that
- 1:00:28you could expect from someone is that
- 1:00:30for their time and place they're good.
- 1:00:32Okay, so now the temptation would be for
- 1:00:34us to look back into history to great
- 1:00:37figures of the past and to say
- 1:00:39we understand what wasn't good even if
- 1:00:42we misunderstand it about their time and
- 1:00:44place and then to say, well, those
- 1:00:46people weren't good and we should we are
- 1:00:49now morally superior to them and we can
- 1:00:51remove the detritus from our past. We
- 1:00:53can tear down the statues, for example.
- 1:00:55It's happening in Canada. We're going to
- 1:00:56tear down the statues of John A.
- 1:00:58Macdonald, who was the founding Prime
- 1:01:00Minister of Canada. And we point to his
- 1:01:02inadequacies as a person. Okay, so
- 1:01:04Churchill. Churchill, absolutely.
- 1:01:06Churchill is a great example. And that
- 1:01:08sort of thing is happening all over the
- 1:01:09US. Now
- 1:01:12how do you know
- 1:01:15that
- 1:01:16the leftist
- 1:01:19criticism of your critique would be
- 1:01:20something like has to be something like
- 1:01:23you have to separate the man the works
- 1:01:26from the man.
- 1:01:27Okay. And I have some sympathy for that
- 1:01:31because
- 1:01:32there are
- 1:01:33like Picasso is a good example.
- 1:01:36And Picasso by any
- 1:01:39measure was a remarkable artist and
- 1:01:41unbelievably productive. He produced
- 1:01:43three
- 1:01:44pieces of art a day for 65 years, right?
- 1:01:47I can't remember how many tens of
- 1:01:49thousands of piece it's it's some insane
- 1:01:51number. And and was revolutionary in
- 1:01:53that manner. But but wait, but by the
- 1:01:54way, the left will not separate
- 1:01:57um the accomplishments of the man from
- 1:01:59the personal life of the man when it
- 1:02:00comes to people they don't like.
- 1:02:02Yes, I know. Yes, so
- 1:02:03but how do you how do you how do you
- 1:02:04Okay,
- 1:02:04Okay, but but but how do you how do you
- 1:02:07as an academic
- 1:02:09you can imagine that there should be
- 1:02:11some separation between the products of
- 1:02:14thought and the personality of the
- 1:02:15person. Okay, so
- 1:02:18are you concerned about that in
- 1:02:20relationship to your critique of
- 1:02:22of Marx and Marxism?
- 1:02:24a great question. And and and and and by
- 1:02:26the way, in case we we don't get to it,
- 1:02:28um people should know Marx's views on
- 1:02:31race, especially toward black people.
- 1:02:33I mean, he he had hideous views toward
- 1:02:36black people. All stuff that should get
- 1:02:38him canceled. I don't believe in
- 1:02:39canceling anybody. But the things that
- 1:02:42the left is willing to cancel this or
- 1:02:44that American figure on because of maybe
- 1:02:46a statement about race or somebody owned
- 1:02:47slaves. I mean, what Marx said about
- 1:02:50black people is unbelievable. You'll be
- 1:02:51reading letters in German between Marx
- 1:02:54and Engels and all of a sudden the
- 1:02:56N-word pops up. You know, the American,
- 1:02:58you know, English racial epithet. You
- 1:03:00know, N I G G. It's not like the German
- 1:03:03word for Negro or black. So like, "Whoa,
- 1:03:04look at that." And and they were um in
- 1:03:07fact uh his daughter was married to to
- 1:03:11yeah, to a guy named Paul Lafargue, who
- 1:03:13was who was I guess partly Cuban to some
- 1:03:16degree. And Marx and Engels are sitting
- 1:03:17there trying to figure out in a letter
- 1:03:19deducing with scientific accuracy how
- 1:03:22much N-word blood is in his veins. Is it
- 1:03:251/8? Is it 1/12? And they they called
- 1:03:28him Negrillo, the gorilla. And they made
- 1:03:31fun of him because he was black. And
- 1:03:32there's a letter from Engels to Marx's
- 1:03:34daughter that says something like, "Oh,
- 1:03:35here he's running for office in this
- 1:03:37district in Paris. Well, it contains a
- 1:03:39zoo.
- 1:03:40As as somebody who's
- 1:03:43that should he should be a perfect
- 1:03:44representative of that district being
- 1:03:45somebody who's just what
- 1:03:47closer to closer to the apes and the
- 1:03:50monkeys than we are."
- 1:03:52They they Ferdinand Lassalle, who they
- 1:03:54referred to as the Jewish N-word,
- 1:03:56they're looking at his at his cranial
- 1:03:58capacity and all kinds of So I mean,
- 1:04:00very very racist. If if Patrice Cullors,
- 1:04:03one of the founders of Black Lives
- 1:04:05Matter, who calls herself a Marxist,
- 1:04:07knew what Marx said about race, she'd
- 1:04:08probably call herself, I don't know,
- 1:04:09maybe a communist, but she probably
- 1:04:11shouldn't call herself a Marxist.
- 1:04:13Um but in Marx's case, to get to get to
- 1:04:15your question
- 1:04:15Yeah. Yeah. the the the personal um
- 1:04:19what he believed in his writings and his
- 1:04:21ideas in the world the world that he
- 1:04:22wanted is in fact an extension of his
- 1:04:25personal life. So it's a fascinating
- 1:04:28example of where um what he wanted in
- 1:04:31public um very much is reflective of
- 1:04:34what he believed in private.
- 1:04:35Yeah. Be- because communism, again,
- 1:04:37people read actually sit down and read
- 1:04:40the manifesto, okay? I mean, you they
- 1:04:43they actually call for, you know, the
- 1:04:45forcible overthrow of all existing
- 1:04:48conditions. That's an actual phrase.
- 1:04:51That's in the That's in the next to the
- 1:04:53last paragraph
- 1:04:54the problem is is that for many people
- 1:04:57that wouldn't be shocking. It would
- 1:04:58actually be admirable. Right? Well,
- 1:05:01seriously, because, you know, what what
- 1:05:03we tend to think is that that if the
- 1:05:05excesses of the real revolutionaries
- 1:05:08were revealed that people would be less
- 1:05:11attracted to them. And I'm less
- 1:05:13optimistic about that because if people
- 1:05:16can regard Lucifer himself as an
- 1:05:18admirable rebel, then the overreach of
- 1:05:21the revolutionaries is actually an
- 1:05:22attractive part of their fervor. Right?
- 1:05:25Cuz you cuz you're hypothesizing
- 1:05:27something like an overarching reason
- 1:05:30that you could just appeal to by by
- 1:05:32contrast and that that would do the
- 1:05:34trick. It's like it isn't it isn't
- 1:05:36uh
- 1:05:37I think that the degree to which, for
- 1:05:40example, the real radical protesters
- 1:05:42that are burning down cities aren't
- 1:05:43aiming at burning down the city is
- 1:05:45highly questionable. Yes, so to actually
- 1:05:48go down and to go down into the village
- 1:05:50square and just rip down the statue,
- 1:05:54to go up and down the California coast
- 1:05:56to all the missions that were founded by
- 1:05:58Saint Junípero Serra, who by the way was
- 1:06:01canonized by Pope Francis of all people,
- 1:06:03right? To go to every single mission and
- 1:06:05tear them down, right? Every single So
- 1:06:07what are you tearing down?
- 1:06:08Yeah, right? Do you even know who this
- 1:06:09guy And what are you trying to put in
- 1:06:10place of certainly you?
- 1:06:14Sleep is the foundation for our mental
- 1:06:16and physical health. In other words,
- 1:06:17you've got to have a consistent
- 1:06:18nighttime routine to function at your
- 1:06:20best. But if you're struggling with
- 1:06:21sleep, then you've got to check out
- 1:06:23Beam. Beam isn't your run-of-the-mill
- 1:06:24sleep aid. It's a concoction carefully
- 1:06:26crafted to help you rest without the
- 1:06:27grogginess that often accompanies other
- 1:06:29sleep remedies. A bunch of us here at
- 1:06:31the Daily Wire count on Beam's Dream
- 1:06:32Powder to knock us out and sleep better
- 1:06:34through the night so we can show up
- 1:06:36ready for work the next day. Just mix
- 1:06:38Beam Dream into hot water or milk, stir
- 1:06:40or froth, and then enjoy before bedtime.
- 1:06:42Then wake up feeling refreshed without
- 1:06:44the next day grogginess caused by other
- 1:06:45sleep products. Dream contains a
- 1:06:47powerful all-natural blend of reishi,
- 1:06:49magnesium, L-theanine, apigenin, and
- 1:06:51melatonin to help you fall asleep, stay
- 1:06:53asleep, and wake up refreshed. And with
- 1:06:55it now being available in delicious
- 1:06:56flavors like cinnamon cocoa, chocolate
- 1:06:58peanut butter, and mint chip better
- 1:07:00sleep has never tasted better. And
- 1:07:02today, listeners of this show can get a
- 1:07:03special discount on Beam's Dream Powder.
- 1:07:05Get up to 40% off for a limited time
- 1:07:07when you go to shopbeam.com/peterson
- 1:07:10and use code Peterson at checkout.
- 1:07:11That's shopbeam.com/peterson
- 1:07:15and use code Peterson for up to 40% off.
- 1:07:19And and in many cases, they seem to be
- 1:07:22tearing down for the sake of tearing
- 1:07:23down.
- 1:07:24Yes, absolutely.
- 1:07:24And and so this quote from Marx would go
- 1:07:26right into this. This is in the next to
- 1:07:28the last paragraph of the manifesto.
- 1:07:30Uh they, the communists, openly declare
- 1:07:34This is an amazing statement. That their
- 1:07:36ends can be attained only by the
- 1:07:39forcible overthrow of all existing
- 1:07:42social conditions. So their ends can be
- 1:07:45attained only only by the forcible
- 1:07:49overthrow of all existing social
- 1:07:51conditions. And by the way, I I don't
- 1:07:53even know Find me a leftist who wants to
- 1:07:56overthrow absolutely everything. I mean,
- 1:07:59certainly there you know, you can name
- 1:08:00some things you'd like to keep, right?
- 1:08:03This This guy wanted everything to be
- 1:08:06Well, it's well, it's worse than that.
- 1:08:07So it's worse than that.
- 1:08:08just about spreading the wealth and
- 1:08:09redistributing. This is about forcibly
- 1:08:11overthrowing everything. Well, there's
- 1:08:13two elements of that three elements of
- 1:08:15that are that are appalling, right? And
- 1:08:17it's difficult to differentiate
- 1:08:19the one that's most appalling. First,
- 1:08:21that it's everything, right? So it's
- 1:08:23it's it's it's like a parody of
- 1:08:24omniscience and omnipresence and
- 1:08:27omnipotence. It's everything. Okay.
- 1:08:29Second it's
- 1:08:32So it's everything.
- 1:08:35Two, let's go for two.
- 1:08:37It's also not a consequence of a
- 1:08:39critique. Right? And it's not
- 1:08:42invitational.
- 1:08:43Right? It's forcible. So so so not only
- 1:08:46do you have the worship of destruction
- 1:08:48utter destruction, you have the worship
- 1:08:51of power. Right? Now, you remember in in
- 1:08:54when Christ is out in the desert
- 1:08:56and tempted by Satan after the 40 days
- 1:08:59of of isolation after the baptism
- 1:09:02that the third temptation of Satan,
- 1:09:05which is I would say the ultimate
- 1:09:08temptation, is one of power.
- 1:09:10Right? Now, it's very interesting.
- 1:09:12of this.
- 1:09:13Right right, it's
- 1:09:14straightforward power. And that's the
- 1:09:17temptation that Moses falls prey to
- 1:09:19continually in his work as
- 1:09:21the Exodus leader as well. It's why he
- 1:09:23doesn't get into the promised land. Like
- 1:09:25there's a very strict and it's something
- 1:09:28that Christ himself forswears utterly.
- 1:09:31No force. No force. Regardless of the
- 1:09:34provocation. Now, what you have here in
- 1:09:37this doctrine that you just described is
- 1:09:38not only the desire for universal
- 1:09:41destruction which, as you pointed out,
- 1:09:43is
- 1:09:45part and parcel of Marxist celebration
- 1:09:47of Goethe's
- 1:09:50Mephistophelean
- 1:09:52doctrine, but also allied with worship
- 1:09:55of power itself. Because otherwise, why
- 1:09:57the forcible? Because he could have
- 1:09:58written the overthrow of everything. And
- 1:10:00that could happen at the level of idea.
- 1:10:02And of course Or even the phrase the
- 1:10:04end, right? It can only be attained with
- 1:10:08with the end of
- 1:10:10but no, they want the forcible
- 1:10:12overthrow. Which which begs the
- 1:10:13question. Okay, so so what is it that
- 1:10:16you want? Do you want the end state
- 1:10:18where everything's razed to the ground
- 1:10:19so that you have a new beginning? Or do
- 1:10:21you want all the absolutely satanic
- 1:10:25pleasure of the act of forcible
- 1:10:27destruction? And I would say
- 1:10:29if you spend any time at all analyzing
- 1:10:32the history of
- 1:10:34Stalinist Soviet Union, including the
- 1:10:36Leninist period, for all for for that
- 1:10:38matter, what you see fundamentally is
- 1:10:42a celebration of
- 1:10:44sadistic devastation. Right? That's the
- 1:10:46fundamental ethos. That's the
- 1:10:48fundamental goal. Now, the flag-waving
- 1:10:50about the new utopia that's going to be
- 1:10:53created in the future, that's all cover
- 1:10:55story. That's all camouflage. The actual
- 1:10:57worship is
- 1:10:58because the things that happened in
- 1:11:01those communist countries are so
- 1:11:03appalling
- 1:11:04well, that people won't pay any
- 1:11:05attention to them because they're too
- 1:11:07much to even contemplate. Right? And so,
- 1:11:10no one wants to know anything about
- 1:11:12them. But, it seems to me that
- 1:11:15the point of dancing
- 1:11:18naked and triumphantly in the smoking
- 1:11:21ruins Yeah.
- 1:11:22That's fundamentally the point. And if
- 1:11:24you happen to
- 1:11:25be jumping up and down on the bodies of
- 1:11:27your enemies and the and the toppled
- 1:11:29statues of your culture
- 1:11:31so much the better. And and wondering
- 1:11:34how it goes how the personal matters
- 1:11:36with like the public, right? Okay, the
- 1:11:38he the end of his manifesto calls for
- 1:11:42the forcible overthrow of everything
- 1:11:43that exists. So, that's an actual policy
- 1:11:46prescription at the end, right? We're
- 1:11:48going to forcibly overthrow everything
- 1:11:50that exists. And as we saw in the
- 1:11:51private, that's what he believes in his
- 1:11:53life in the poetry. So, you see it in
- 1:11:56the poetry. So, you see one one directly
- 1:11:58leads to the other. His his hatred of
- 1:12:00religion, right? Communism begins where
- 1:12:02atheism begins. The
- 1:12:04the famous line, the opiate of the
- 1:12:06masses, right? That full quote, a lot of
- 1:12:09people I've heard people say from time
- 1:12:10to time, "Well, I kind of see what he's
- 1:12:12getting at there. Religion can be like a
- 1:12:14sort of drug for people, maybe like a
- 1:12:17placebo, maybe like a crutch." But if
- 1:12:20you read that whole line,
- 1:12:23religion is the sigh of the oppressed
- 1:12:25creature. It is um it is the heart of a
- 1:12:29heartless world. It is the soul of
- 1:12:31soulless conditions. It is the opium of
- 1:12:35the people. And then Lenin picked that
- 1:12:37up and said, "Yeah, like Marx said,
- 1:12:39religion is the opium of the masses. It
- 1:12:41is a kind of spiritual booze. It is
- 1:12:45medieval mildew. There is nothing more
- 1:12:48abominable than religion. And so, what
- 1:12:50does that mean? Damn it, that means
- 1:12:52we're going to shut down the churches,
- 1:12:54right? And we're going to put them in
- 1:12:55jail and we're going to be an officially
- 1:12:58atheistic country. We're going to create
- 1:12:59a league of the militant godless. You're
- 1:13:01not going to be allowed to to be a
- 1:13:03religious person. So, so the private
- 1:13:05thoughts are actually being implemented
- 1:13:07and enacted enacted out.
- 1:13:09Well, the other thing, too, about that
- 1:13:10phrase is it's actually a lie. And it's
- 1:13:14a lie in two ways. So, there's a
- 1:13:16Canadian philosopher, Taylor
- 1:13:18who wrote about this in a book he wrote
- 1:13:20on identity. And he pointed out that
- 1:13:24the medieval fear of hell
- 1:13:27was at least the equal of the medieval
- 1:13:30fear of death. Okay, so that begs a
- 1:13:32question. It's like, if your religion is
- 1:13:36an opium
- 1:13:38then why isn't it just all smiley faces
- 1:13:40and and fun? Right? Why why Well, hell
- 1:13:43is a really good start. It's like, and
- 1:13:45you know, the cynics might say, "Well,
- 1:13:47hell is a convenient place to put those
- 1:13:49you hate." But that's you have to be
- 1:13:51cynical and naive and stupid to come up
- 1:13:54with that theory because
- 1:13:56you're a fool if you think that the fear
- 1:13:58of hell was anything but real among
- 1:14:02the believers in those periods of time
- 1:14:04where the reality of hell was amplified.
- 1:14:07They were terrified of that. Right? And
- 1:14:09so,
- 1:14:10what are you going to do? You're going
- 1:14:11to do something convoluted like, "Well,
- 1:14:13you have to leave in the opium with a
- 1:14:15bit of terror so that it becomes
- 1:14:17believable enough to be a soporific."
- 1:14:20It's like, "Hey, man, your theory's
- 1:14:22getting a little convoluted at that
- 1:14:23point." It's like
- 1:14:25why bother with hell? And so, that to me
- 1:14:28and it's the same with the Freudian
- 1:14:29critique, you know, that
- 1:14:31it's a form of immaturity and
- 1:14:33over-reliance on a benevolent father.
- 1:14:35It's like, "Well, the father isn't all
- 1:14:36benevolent. There's hell. And so, you
- 1:14:38better watch your step." And and part of
- 1:14:41that is implemented by terror. And then
- 1:14:44there's more to it than And and Jesus
- 1:14:46said, "You want to follow me, pick up
- 1:14:47your cross."
- 1:14:47Well, that's the next thing. It's like,
- 1:14:49"Okay, so we have Christ the happy face
- 1:14:52God who asks people only to believe that
- 1:14:56everything is good and there's no price
- 1:14:58to be paid for that." No, that's not
- 1:15:00that's exactly that that couldn't be a
- 1:15:02bigger lie because there isn't a larger
- 1:15:05sacrifice that is possible than the one
- 1:15:08that
- 1:15:09the founder of Christianity required of
- 1:15:11himself and his followers. There's
- 1:15:13nothing in that in the least that's
- 1:15:15opiate. Now, you might say, "Well, the
- 1:15:17happy thought that you go to heaven when
- 1:15:18you die is the opiate." It's like
- 1:15:22well, wait a second.
- 1:15:23First of all, that only happens if
- 1:15:25you've actually lived a good life and
- 1:15:28the cost of not doing that is well, now
- 1:15:30we're back to the hell problem. So, I
- 1:15:32don't buy the
- 1:15:34the Freudian interpretation that it's
- 1:15:37all, you know, immature dependence on
- 1:15:39the heavenly father, so to speak. And I
- 1:15:41certainly don't buy the Marxist doctrine
- 1:15:43that there's anything about it that's
- 1:15:44opiate. Now, you could say
- 1:15:47any any naive person and any person
- 1:15:50looking for unearned security could take
- 1:15:54any doctrine and use it as a security
- 1:15:57blanket. And I think there's some truth
- 1:15:58in that, but boy, if you don't think
- 1:16:00that applies to radical leftism as much
- 1:16:02as it applies to Christianity
- 1:16:04far more than it applies to
- 1:16:06Christianity, you're not thinking in the
- 1:16:08least. I mean, what you see with the
- 1:16:10radical leftists on campus now is that
- 1:16:12they make the presumption that all the
- 1:16:14leftist theorizing is predicated on an
- 1:16:17admirable compassion. It's like, "Well,
- 1:16:19if you want an opiate, there's one."
- 1:16:21Right. Hypersimplification,
- 1:16:23pathological hypersimplification that's
- 1:16:25morally self-serving and and dangerous
- 1:16:27beyond belief. Right. Right.
- 1:16:29So, And and Marx said, I was just
- 1:16:31looking for the quote right now and I
- 1:16:32couldn't find it. But but one of his
- 1:16:34criticisms of Christianity later was he
- 1:16:37said it preaches
- 1:16:39cowardice,
- 1:16:40self-contempt, self-abasement,
- 1:16:43self-sacrifice. It's like, "Well, yeah."
- 1:16:46It well, I don't know if it preaches
- 1:16:47cowardice, but but it but it preaches
- 1:16:49self-sacrifice.
- 1:16:50Those things don't go in the same
- 1:16:51category.
- 1:16:52No, they certainly don't.
- 1:16:53what Christ did. He didn't lack courage,
- 1:16:56right? And and but but for Marx, it was
- 1:16:58about the self, selfishness. And and in
- 1:17:02fact, that that moment where
- 1:17:04the devil is tempting Christ, right? And
- 1:17:07and and Christ says them, "Man does not
- 1:17:09live on bread alone."
- 1:17:10Yes, yes, yes. The Marxists actually act
- 1:17:13as if man does live on bread alone.
- 1:17:15Precisely.
- 1:17:16And and they they believe that if you
- 1:17:17solve the economic problem, if you solve
- 1:17:20the class problem, I mean, that's the
- 1:17:22key to your utopia right there. It it's
- 1:17:24it's Augustine said, "We have a
- 1:17:26God-shaped vacuum in in each of us,
- 1:17:29right?" But he didn't say we have a
- 1:17:30dollar-shaped vacuum in each of us. But
- 1:17:32the communists, they act as if we have a
- 1:17:34dollar-shaped
- 1:17:34Yeah, I know. That's that's one of the
- 1:17:35other things that's so perverse about
- 1:17:37the communists is that although
- 1:17:39hypothetically they're anti-capitalist,
- 1:17:41they believe that there's an economic
- 1:17:43solution to every problem. They are so
- 1:17:45perverse.
- 1:17:46So, yeah, so the communists and the
- 1:17:47leftists will say all the time, "Oh, you
- 1:17:49capitalists, all you guys care about
- 1:17:51money." No, Karl Marx, all you care
- 1:17:53about is money.
- 1:17:54Yeah. I mean, all you care about is the
- 1:17:56is the material world. It's like they're
- 1:17:58fashioning their golden calf out of
- 1:18:00money and capital. They just think that
- 1:18:02if you redistribute wealth, if you can
- 1:18:04level the classes, if everybody has
- 1:18:06equal income, right? That that that's
- 1:18:09your key to utopia. Right. They think
- 1:18:11man does live by bread alone.
- 1:18:12Yes, definitely. But but we don't,
- 1:18:15right? So, their alpha and omega is the
- 1:18:17economic problem.
- 1:18:21Pope Benedict the 16th said, "The you
- 1:18:24know, the the the the problem with the
- 1:18:26communists is not that communism failed
- 1:18:28even so much economically, though it
- 1:18:30did, philosophically, though it did, but
- 1:18:32anthropologically. They failed to
- 1:18:34understand human nature. They failed to
- 1:18:37understand people. And to just think
- 1:18:39that and they put it this this
- 1:18:42simplistically in the Communist
- 1:18:43Manifesto." People say all the time,
- 1:18:45"Give me a Give me a one-sentence
- 1:18:46definition of communism." Okay, that's
- 1:18:49easy cuz Marx and Engels did it. They
- 1:18:51said the entire communist theory or
- 1:18:53program may be summed up in the single
- 1:18:55sentence. Four words, "Abolition of
- 1:18:58private property." Abolition of private
- 1:19:00property. They think that
- 1:19:03if if you could abolish private
- 1:19:04property, that you this is the beginning
- 1:19:06of the key to your utopia of all things.
- 1:19:08And that the utopian utopia is entirely
- 1:19:10materialistic. So, one of the things
- 1:19:12that I found particularly striking about
- 1:19:15Dostoevsky, especially in Notes from
- 1:19:18Underground, is he
- 1:19:19Speaking of the devils and demons, yeah.
- 1:19:20Yeah, well, right, absolutely. He
- 1:19:23He put his finger on the fundamental
- 1:19:25flaw in the communist doctrine
- 1:19:28before I think it was probably even
- 1:19:30expressed by Marx, at least popularly
- 1:19:32expressed. I don't exactly know when
- 1:19:33Notes from Underground was written, but
- 1:19:35I don't believe that Mark that
- 1:19:37Dostoevsky had any direct knowledge of
- 1:19:39Marx at that point. Now, I'm not certain
- 1:19:42of that. It doesn't matter cuz the ideas
- 1:19:43were in the air anyways, right? Yeah,
- 1:19:45they were. So so but but
- 1:19:47one of the things that Dostoevsky points
- 1:19:49out in the Notes from Underground, which
- 1:19:51is so brilliant, is that like he has
- 1:19:53this bitter resentful underground
- 1:19:55character point out that if you did
- 1:19:58provide human beings with the
- 1:20:00materialist utopia that Marx
- 1:20:04promoted
- 1:20:05so that Dostoevsky says so that they had
- 1:20:08nothing to do but lie in warm pools of
- 1:20:11bubbling water and eat cakes and busy
- 1:20:15themselves with the continuation of the
- 1:20:17species that the people so
- 1:20:21benefited would
- 1:20:24promptly go insane enough to smash it
- 1:20:26all to bits just to have something
- 1:20:27interesting to do. Now, he phrases it
- 1:20:30more bitterly because he he phrases it
- 1:20:32as a form of ingratitude, but there's a
- 1:20:33point there. Then the point is that it
- 1:20:35is the point that man does not live
- 1:20:37Right. by bread alone. That Dostoevsky
- 1:20:41from from the mouth of God, right?
- 1:20:42Right right. Well, Dostoevsky understood
- 1:20:44that we were built for something more
- 1:20:46than infantile satiation, right? And
- 1:20:48more than more for more than hedonistic
- 1:20:51satiation. And I would say the Marxists
- 1:20:54ally very nicely with the infantile
- 1:20:57hedonists because both of them presume
- 1:20:59that the mere satiation of desire would
- 1:21:02suffice to bring about the utopia.
- 1:21:05right. Right right right. Okay. Okay.
- 1:21:07And um
- 1:21:08maybe this is a kind of sharp departure.
- 1:21:11Look where the Marxists today are,
- 1:21:13right? A lot of the Marxists today are
- 1:21:15not even bothering with class or
- 1:21:17economics, but they've gone into the
- 1:21:19area of culture. They've gone into
- 1:21:21gender. They've they've they've gone
- 1:21:23into race, right? And they A lot of the
- 1:21:26Marxists today, if you go to the website
- 1:21:28of People's World, which is the
- 1:21:30successor to the Daily Worker that and
- 1:21:33you go to the about section, they have a
- 1:21:35call there not for factory workers, not
- 1:21:38for coal miners. I mean, the West
- 1:21:41Virginia coal miners are voting for
- 1:21:42Trump, right? Not for steel workers. You
- 1:21:45know, my hometown of Pittsburgh, steel
- 1:21:47workers are probably largely MAGA
- 1:21:49people. A lot of those guys are
- 1:21:51blue-collar union guys. They have a call
- 1:21:53for culture workers. So, they're looking
- 1:21:56They've gone from the factory floor to
- 1:21:58the classroom.
- 1:22:00And and so the modern Marxists
- 1:22:03knowing that the world of the Communist
- 1:22:05Manifesto and the Industrial Revolution
- 1:22:06of the 1840s is just completely gone. I
- 1:22:09mean, that book, by the way,
- 1:22:11is archaic. I mean, it's written for
- 1:22:141840s France and Germany and
- 1:22:17and Britain. Yeah, I mean, that world
- 1:22:19doesn't even exist anymore. So, a lot of
- 1:22:21today's Marxists have taken the Marxist
- 1:22:23superstructure of oppressed versus
- 1:22:25oppressor, right?
- 1:22:27And they said, "Okay, it's no longer the
- 1:22:30the the oppressive bourgeoisie and the
- 1:22:32oppressed proletariat." The and the
- 1:22:34proletariat would be the oppressed
- 1:22:35group. That would be the victim class
- 1:22:37and also the redeemer class,
- 1:22:40by the stripes of the proletariat you
- 1:22:42were healed, right? They would usher in
- 1:22:44the revolution. So, instead people don't
- 1:22:47I mean, what young people today even
- 1:22:49know what the word proletariat or
- 1:22:50bourgeoisie mean?
- 1:22:52They've taken the oppressed oppressor
- 1:22:54model and they've applied it to issues
- 1:22:56like race. And exactly and and so the so
- 1:22:59the oppressor, and this is the most
- 1:23:01simplistic infantile thing anybody could
- 1:23:03do, the race-based critical race
- 1:23:05theorists, to take human beings who are
- 1:23:09I mean, you know, do I've done my DNA
- 1:23:11ancestry.com, my family is just they're
- 1:23:14all over the place in terms of their
- 1:23:16DNA, right?
- 1:23:18So, boil people down in America in the
- 1:23:212020s as, "Okay, two categories, black,
- 1:23:24white." Right. How do you do that? I
- 1:23:26mean, my youngest son, who's adopted, is
- 1:23:28is black. Um actually, his mother's
- 1:23:31white, his father's black, um so is
- 1:23:33Obama. So, he's he'd be considered
- 1:23:35black, right? But if you do his DNA
- 1:23:37test, he's all over the place. But the
- 1:23:39modern critical race theorist is going
- 1:23:41to say white, oppressor black,
- 1:23:44oppressed.
- 1:23:45Yeah. And they're going to hammer you
- 1:23:47into one of those two categories. Which
- 1:23:49Martin Luther King Jr. said, "No, we're
- 1:23:51to be judged by the content of our
- 1:23:52character, not the color of our skin."
- 1:23:54Um CRT, which I I interviewed David
- 1:23:56Garrow, the King biographer, about this.
- 1:23:59And he said CRT predates King. King was
- 1:24:02shot in April 1968. So, he didn't talk
- 1:24:04about CRT, but he would have been
- 1:24:06totally against any kind of race-based
- 1:24:08classification of human beings. So, the
- 1:24:10modern group is is hammering you into
- 1:24:12one of these two categories, oppressed
- 1:24:14versus oppressor. So, the new oppressed
- 1:24:17group will be blacks and they need to
- 1:24:19have their consciousness raised. They
- 1:24:21need to know that they are the oppressed
- 1:24:23group. Um they will usher in the
- 1:24:25redemption. They're also the redeemer
- 1:24:26class.
- 1:24:28And try telling somebody like Oprah
- 1:24:29Winfrey or Kobe Bryant that they're
- 1:24:31oppressed just because they're black. I
- 1:24:34mean, how racist is that? Whereas the
- 1:24:36white homeless guy that he's the
- 1:24:38oppressor because he's white is an
- 1:24:40unbelievably ridiculous infantile absurd
- 1:24:44racist separation of human beings into
- 1:24:46opposing hostile camps. And by the way,
- 1:24:48it divides people. And back to Marx,
- 1:24:50this is what Marx and Engels did with
- 1:24:52with class.
- 1:24:53Yeah. Well, so you said that that took
- 1:24:55us that took us a field and I don't
- 1:24:57think it did because tell me what you
- 1:24:59think about this because this ties maybe
- 1:25:01the close of our discussion to the
- 1:25:03beginning because we talked about
- 1:25:05essentially theological matters in
- 1:25:07relationship to Marx's fantasizing.
- 1:25:09Okay, so imagine that there's
- 1:25:12there's a theological element to Marx
- 1:25:14that can be
- 1:25:16traced all the way back to the story of
- 1:25:18Cain and Abel cuz Cain and Abel is the
- 1:25:20first victim victimizer narrative.
- 1:25:23Right? And Cain feels that he's the
- 1:25:25victim of Abel. And he is driven by a
- 1:25:29bitter resentment.
- 1:25:30way, envy, which is what Marxism is all
- 1:25:32about.
- 1:25:32Absolutely. And he becomes extremely
- 1:25:34hostile. Okay, so imagine
- 1:25:36imagine that Marxism is essentially a
- 1:25:39retelling of the story of Cain and Abel
- 1:25:42with Cain as the protagonist. Okay, so
- 1:25:44now so once you get that, then you can
- 1:25:46see what's happened with the modern
- 1:25:48meta-Marxists because
- 1:25:50we might think
- 1:25:53being slightly older, we might think
- 1:25:55that the core doctrine of Marxism is
- 1:25:57economic inequality, but it's not. The
- 1:26:00core doctrine is victim victimizer. Now,
- 1:26:03what Marx said was the prime dimension
- 1:26:06of victim victimizer is economic. Now, I
- 1:26:10think, and this is partly why Marxism
- 1:26:12was powerful
- 1:26:13if you have to pick a victim victimizer
- 1:26:15narrative, the most powerful one is
- 1:26:18economic.
- 1:26:19But let's just leave that aside. Now,
- 1:26:21you said, "Well, we no longer have the
- 1:26:22dark satanic mills, so the economic
- 1:26:24story isn't playing out as well."
- 1:26:27But the victim victimizer narrative,
- 1:26:29that's still alive. And what the I think
- 1:26:31of
- 1:26:32the new postmodern leftism as a
- 1:26:35metastasized Marxism because it's the
- 1:26:38victim victimizer narrative that's now
- 1:26:40multidimensional. You can take any way
- 1:26:43you can possibly categorize human beings
- 1:26:45that divides them into groups and you
- 1:26:48can take that dichotomous dimension and
- 1:26:51you can say victim victimizer. So, now
- 1:26:54you explain everything, right? Then you
- 1:26:56can say so you can explain everything.
- 1:26:58You got no more work to do cognitively.
- 1:27:00You can learn that in 10 minutes, right?
- 1:27:02But then there's an additional advantage
- 1:27:04and this is also endemic to Marxism.
- 1:27:06Imagine that you have two problems to
- 1:27:08solve in the world. One is to understand
- 1:27:10it and the other is to figure out how to
- 1:27:12conduct yourself in it. Okay, well, the
- 1:27:14victim victimizer narrative gives you
- 1:27:15both because
- 1:27:17not only have you now a complete causal
- 1:27:19explanation, everything can be
- 1:27:21understood in terms of power because
- 1:27:23that's the victim
- 1:27:24victimizer story, but goodness merely
- 1:27:28requires that you identify with the
- 1:27:30victim. Right right. So, it solves your
- 1:27:32moral problem, too. Right? And so
- 1:27:34exactly. And so what we have is
- 1:27:37the spectacle of the modern universities
- 1:27:40uh
- 1:27:41what would you say? Promulgating this
- 1:27:42meta-Marxism, metastatic Marxism, where
- 1:27:45they've fragmented the oppressor
- 1:27:48oppressor narrative into multiple
- 1:27:50dimensions.
- 1:27:50Even if they don't know it's Marxist.
- 1:27:52Exactly. Exactly. Well, and it's not if
- 1:27:55it's a retelling of the Cain and Abel
- 1:27:56story, it's deeper than Marxism, right?
- 1:27:58Marxism would then become a variant of
- 1:28:00something even deeper. And I think what
- 1:28:03is deeper is the victim victimizer
- 1:28:05narrative, that way of construing the
- 1:28:06world. And that is a way of like the
- 1:28:08postmodernists, especially people like
- 1:28:10Foucault.
- 1:28:11It's all about power.
- 1:28:14Life can be unpredictable, but a good
- 1:28:16life insurance plan gives your family a
- 1:28:18financial safety net to protect against
- 1:28:20some of the unknowns. Policygenius is
- 1:28:22the country's leading online insurance
- 1:28:23marketplace. It makes choosing the right
- 1:28:25policy for your family easy and quick.
- 1:28:27With Policygenius, you can find life
- 1:28:29insurance policies that start at just
- 1:28:31$292 per year for $1 million of
- 1:28:34coverage. Some options offer same-day
- 1:28:35approval and avoid unnecessary medical
- 1:28:38exams. Maybe you already have a life
- 1:28:39insurance policy through work, but that
- 1:28:41might not offer enough protection for
- 1:28:43your family's needs and it may not
- 1:28:44follow you if you leave your job. You
- 1:28:46need a backup plan. Policygenius has
- 1:28:49licensed agents who can help you find
- 1:28:50the best fit for your needs. When they
- 1:28:52make it this easy, there's no excuse not
- 1:28:54to do it. Policygenius works for you,
- 1:28:56not the insurance companies. That means
- 1:28:57they're not incentivized to recommend
- 1:28:59one insurer over another, so you can
- 1:29:01trust their guidance. Get peace of mind
- 1:29:03by finding the right life insurance with
- 1:29:04Policygenius. Head to
- 1:29:06policygenius.com/jordan
- 1:29:07or click the link in the description to
- 1:29:09get your free life insurance quotes and
- 1:29:11see how much you could save. That's
- 1:29:13policygenius.com/jordan.
- 1:29:18And and they're and they're always in
- 1:29:20search um this kind of modern post
- 1:29:22market whatever. They're always in
- 1:29:23search for the next victim group. Right?
- 1:29:25That that that's the key. Who's the next
- 1:29:27victim class? And once you're in that
- 1:29:28group, you you that group has to be
- 1:29:31taught to hate the other group. I I I
- 1:29:33mean to to for them to know that they
- 1:29:35are a victim because of that group.
- 1:29:37Yes, that's right. That's right.
- 1:29:38And and and if you don't get that, if
- 1:29:39you don't understand that, you need your
- 1:29:41consciousness or this is where the
- 1:29:42university
- 1:29:42a traitor. to teach you That's right.
- 1:29:44And if And if you're in the oppressor
- 1:29:46group and you don't realize you're an
- 1:29:47oppressor, right? Um you might be in
- 1:29:49that class you say, "Well, you know, I
- 1:29:51was brought up actually in a multiracial
- 1:29:53family. We've got adopted kids." And we
- 1:29:56we uh as I know no no no no, you've got
- 1:29:58to understand your skin color defines
- 1:30:01you and puts you in that camp, right?
- 1:30:03You are the oppressed. Or your sexual or
- 1:30:06your gender. I mean, what could be worse
- 1:30:07than a simple as you know, male female,
- 1:30:10right? Gender Marxist. Yeah. Uh but but
- 1:30:12that that's unfortunately where the
- 1:30:14Marxism comes in.
- 1:30:15dimensions of oppression, too, which is
- 1:30:17very convenient if you want to
- 1:30:19rationalize the power narrative and you
- 1:30:21also want to claim moral virtue without
- 1:30:23doing any work.
- 1:30:23That's right.
- 1:30:24I'm on the side of the victims. It's
- 1:30:25like, "Really? Are you? Really now?
- 1:30:28You're really on the side of the
- 1:30:29victims?" And you're sure you've got the
- 1:30:31victims properly identified? And they're
- 1:30:33only victims?
- 1:30:34And they're in a power position, too.
- 1:30:36They're in the They're in the position
- 1:30:37to define who's the victim and who's
- 1:30:39not. And those are always people during
- 1:30:41the revolution that are going to be in
- 1:30:42charge. It's what Lenin called the
- 1:30:43vanguard, right? And in What Is to Be
- 1:30:45Done? in 1902, he's he's said what's
- 1:30:48needed here is a cadre of
- 1:30:49revolutionaries, kind of educated elites
- 1:30:52who can run this whole thing. Mhm. Who
- 1:30:54can who can who can run the project and
- 1:30:57tell you when you've gone from feudalism
- 1:30:59to capitalism to socialism to communism,
- 1:31:02right?
- 1:31:02They're the same ones that tell you when
- 1:31:03it's new time time for a new pride flag
- 1:31:05now.
- 1:31:06That's right. That's right. Seems to be
- 1:31:07about every week.
- 1:31:08That's right. They're the managers. And
- 1:31:09and and and you stop and say, "You know,
- 1:31:11I don't get this. Everybody's supposed
- 1:31:13to be equal in wealth, but Castro, I
- 1:31:16mean, doctors, janitors, baseball
- 1:31:18players, custodians all get $120 a year
- 1:31:21in Cuba. Castro's worth a billion
- 1:31:23dollars, right? Look at the dachas in
- 1:31:25the Black Sea that all the communist
- 1:31:26apparatchiks have in the Soviet Soviet
- 1:31:28Union. Look at the Kims. Look how Look
- 1:31:30how much money they Well, you have to
- 1:31:31understand for them, they're the rulers,
- 1:31:34right? The Marxism, the communism is for
- 1:31:37the ruled, not the rulers. It's for the
- 1:31:39masses, not the masters, right? It's for
- 1:31:41all of you idiots. Well, there's also no
- 1:31:44evidence technically from the economic
- 1:31:46perspective that the communist communist
- 1:31:48governments had any impact whatsoever on
- 1:31:50inequality. Oh, yeah. No. Other than
- 1:31:52making everybody equally poor.
- 1:31:54Well, well, that's the thing is there
- 1:31:55was less to go around, right? So, they
- 1:31:57were very good at suppressing the
- 1:31:59benefits of capital, but were able to
- 1:32:02address inequality not at all Yes, by
- 1:32:04Well, and by destruction, but they were
- 1:32:06not able to address inequality at all.
- 1:32:08No. No. No, they they They nationalized
- 1:32:10everything including uh poverty. Yeah.
- 1:32:14Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Okay, so what Let's
- 1:32:17close with this a more personal
- 1:32:18reflection.
- 1:32:21Your book about Marx is
- 1:32:24a rather personal analysis of Marx.
- 1:32:27And that makes it as you pointed out
- 1:32:30somewhat unique, especially in its
- 1:32:31concentration on
- 1:32:33his motivations, let's say, and his
- 1:32:35poetic motivations, his revelatory
- 1:32:37motivations.
- 1:32:38What has that done to you
- 1:32:41personally in your understanding of Marx
- 1:32:43and let's say also your understanding of
- 1:32:45the world? Cuz there's a very strange
- 1:32:48theological dimension to your analysis
- 1:32:50of Marx. Okay, so So, was that
- 1:32:52theological dimension there before you
- 1:32:55wrote this book? Partly, I suppose.
- 1:32:56Well, yeah, I think I think it probably
- 1:32:58was already there. I mean, I've always
- 1:33:00thought, Jordan, that um
- 1:33:02when people ask me uh
- 1:33:04"How did communism catch on, right?"
- 1:33:07Uh even Well, fir- first of all, it's
- 1:33:09never voted into power and if it is,
- 1:33:11they don't they they don't stand for
- 1:33:12another election, right? I mean, Fidel
- 1:33:14Castro called for democracy and free and
- 1:33:16fair elections in 1959, right? And it
- 1:33:19never actually had them, right? The Kims
- 1:33:21don't put themselves themselves up for
- 1:33:23for for election. But the the What's the
- 1:33:27rational reason why anybody if you just
- 1:33:29read the Communist Manifesto, it's so
- 1:33:31clear that this is
- 1:33:33completely impractical. It can't
- 1:33:35possibly work. Uh I think there I think
- 1:33:38there's almost a kind of a diabolical
- 1:33:41explanation for this. You know, Ro-
- 1:33:43Ronald Reagan said um in in in the in
- 1:33:46the grand destiny of humanity, we are
- 1:33:49not matters of mere material
- 1:33:51computation, right? When great forces
- 1:33:54are are on the foot in the world, we
- 1:33:56learn that we are spirits, not animals,
- 1:33:58right? Um the the
- 1:34:02I think there's almost a spiritual
- 1:34:04explanation behind this.
- 1:34:06So, you think
- 1:34:06It doesn't It doesn't make mere rational
- 1:34:09sense
- 1:34:10that this idea could have ever been
- 1:34:12fostered or caught on. It I I think
- 1:34:15there's a diabolical explanation of
- 1:34:17course behind it. Right. Right. So, you
- 1:34:19basically you basically believe that the
- 1:34:21Marxist phenomena cannot be understood
- 1:34:24outside an overarching religious
- 1:34:26interpretative framework.
- 1:34:27And and and we
- 1:34:28I think that's right.
- 1:34:29And we haven't mentioned the very
- 1:34:30opening words of the Manifesto, "A
- 1:34:32specter is haunting
- 1:34:34the specter of communism."
- 1:34:36Yeah, and it says, "All the old allies
- 1:34:39of Europe
- 1:34:40Pope and Tsar, Metternich and Guizot,
- 1:34:42German and French French radicals and
- 1:34:45German spies have entered into a holy
- 1:34:47alliance to exorcise the specter."
- 1:34:50Yeah. Marx and Engels open the book with
- 1:34:53with a paragraph describing it as a
- 1:34:55specter, a demonic specter that needs
- 1:34:58exorcise. Yeah. Now again, I I the Well,
- 1:35:00they're being playful with words.
- 1:35:02Yeah, right. No, there's too much of
- 1:35:04this. There's too much of this.
- 1:35:06Uh there's something deeper and darker
- 1:35:08going on.
- 1:35:08joke contains a seed of the truth. Well,
- 1:35:11in in my experience, for what it's
- 1:35:13worth,
- 1:35:14it was the horrors of communism that
- 1:35:17motivated me to think much more deeply
- 1:35:19about religious matters. Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:35:21if you if you familiarize yourself with
- 1:35:24the hell of the communist regimes, you
- 1:35:28end up at a level of analysis, I think,
- 1:35:30that you you can't avoid. At a level of
- 1:35:32analysis that demands that you account
- 1:35:35for an evil that profound. Right. Yeah,
- 1:35:37I was at I was an agnostic in college
- 1:35:40and close to being an atheist and
- 1:35:43studying this stuff. And the end of the
- 1:35:45Cold War is part of what pulled me out
- 1:35:47of that pit. Uh because you really do
- 1:35:50look at it and you say, "This is This
- 1:35:53seems demonic. This seems diabolical."
- 1:35:56Yeah. The you know, another quote from
- 1:35:58Reagan, uh "This isn't a matter of
- 1:36:00rockets and economics. This is This is a
- 1:36:02something of the spiritual order." And
- 1:36:04there's something deeper, darker
- 1:36:07Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:36:08No, I think I I I can't see how you can
- 1:36:11be I also think that that's a motif
- 1:36:13that's expressed
- 1:36:13founder which is Karl Marx. Yeah, right.
- 1:36:16Right. Right. I think that there's a
- 1:36:17reflection in that of the
- 1:36:20dragon-treasure dichotomy. You know, we
- 1:36:22know from time immemorial that you go
- 1:36:26searching for treasure where the dragons
- 1:36:28are. Mhm. And there isn't a dragon
- 1:36:30that's more terrifying than the dragon
- 1:36:34that's the spirit of malevolence itself.
- 1:36:36And you cannot study communism without
- 1:36:40encountering the spirit of malevolence.
- 1:36:42And then the treasure that lurks there
- 1:36:45is something like a recognition that the
- 1:36:47overarching religious framework is
- 1:36:49actually necessary to conceptualize the
- 1:36:51problem properly and probably to offer
- 1:36:54something approximating a solution.
- 1:36:56That's right. Like a genuine solution.
- 1:36:58Yeah, I I think You think that's right?
- 1:36:59that's exactly right. Yeah, there's um
- 1:37:02there's a church encyclical Divini
- 1:37:04Redemptoris from 19
- 1:37:05uh 37 by Pius XI and and they described
- 1:37:09it as a satanic scourge orchestrated by
- 1:37:13the sons of darkness. I mean, the the
- 1:37:15the church then came to that conclusion
- 1:37:17that they believed that everything that
- 1:37:19the communists wanted and said and wrote
- 1:37:21in their books can only be interpreted
- 1:37:24in this really dark demonic sense. What
- 1:37:26do the liberation theologians think of
- 1:37:28that?
- 1:37:28they're they're nuts. I mean, they're um
- 1:37:31Yeah, they're powerful nuts. They are
- 1:37:33still. And
- 1:37:35even someone like Pope Francis
- 1:37:37said in December 2013, he said the
- 1:37:39Marxist ideology is wrong.
- 1:37:42Uh but have that having been said, he's
- 1:37:45not a very good anti-communist.
- 1:37:47Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:37:48Right? I mean, he's
- 1:37:48Well, it's a it's a very powerfully
- 1:37:50contaminated force and its tendrils are
- 1:37:52everywhere and they're not necessarily
- 1:37:54that easy to identify.
- 1:37:56That's exactly right.
- 1:37:57Especially if you don't really want to
- 1:37:58look. Yeah, and if you tell somebody,
- 1:38:00you know, what you're engaging in there
- 1:38:01could be a form of Marxism applied to
- 1:38:03culture, Frankfurt School, Antonio
- 1:38:05Gramsci, cultural hegemony, founders of
- 1:38:08the Frankfurt School, Max Horkheimer,
- 1:38:10Theodor Adorno wrote about the culture
- 1:38:11industry and the dialectic of
- 1:38:13enlightenment. You know, this is a kind
- 1:38:14of Marxism applied to culture. They go
- 1:38:16look up cultural Marxism, it pops up
- 1:38:18anti-Semitic conspiracy theory. So, they
- 1:38:20go, "Well, what's that?" Right? But but
- 1:38:22but you know, it's it's it it's it's to
- 1:38:24the point where it's infiltrated things
- 1:38:26where people engaging in the framework
- 1:38:29or metanarrative or Marxist
- 1:38:30superstructure on gender, race, culture,
- 1:38:33whatever, often don't even know that
- 1:38:34they're guilty of it, which they're, you
- 1:38:36know, credit to them, they don't know
- 1:38:38it, but it's it's so seeped in to the
- 1:38:41culture at large that yeah, that's what
- 1:38:43we're dealing with.
- 1:38:45All right, sir. Hey, this is great.
- 1:38:46Thanks so much.
- 1:38:46Thank you very much. Yeah. Well, there
- 1:38:48were many other things, too, that we
- 1:38:49could have talked about, too. I would
- 1:38:50have liked to have talked about your
- 1:38:51work on Reagan and your other books as
- 1:38:53well, but we may save that for a further
- 1:38:55discussion. This was worth the devotion
- 1:38:58of 90 minutes to, I would say, just this
- 1:39:00topic. So, I'm very glad that we did it.
- 1:39:02Me, too. I'm glad, too. Yeah. And for
- 1:39:04everybody watching and listening on the
- 1:39:06YouTube side, we're very happy for your
- 1:39:08time and attention as well. And to the
- 1:39:09film crew here, we're at the Museum of
- 1:39:11the Bible, which is a very appropriate
- 1:39:13place to be having this discussion in
- 1:39:15Washington, D.C. Uh
- 1:39:17that's a museum whose work I did a
- 1:39:20documentary on for the Daily Wire, which
- 1:39:22I think is quite a successful
- 1:39:23documentary and was a great joy to
- 1:39:25actually produce. And it's a great
- 1:39:27museum. So, if you ever do come happen
- 1:39:28to come to D.C., um go check it out.
- 1:39:31It's
- 1:39:32it's uh
- 1:39:34it's the kind of place that can help you
- 1:39:36understand a lot more deeply the
- 1:39:37relationship between at minimum the
- 1:39:39relationship between the fact of the
- 1:39:41Bible and the fact of literacy itself in
- 1:39:45its worldwide distribution, because
- 1:39:46those two things are very integrally
- 1:39:48associated. And that's a
- 1:39:50underappreciated contribution of
- 1:39:53Christianity and Protestantism to the
- 1:39:55world. So, anyways, thanks to the Museum
- 1:39:58of the Bible for hosting us today. And
- 1:40:00uh
- 1:40:00I'm going to continue this discussion
- 1:40:02for another half an hour on the Daily
- 1:40:03Wire side. And
- 1:40:05what we'll talk about is what I often
- 1:40:06talk about on that
- 1:40:08in that additional half an hour, which
- 1:40:10which is the development of the
- 1:40:11interests that underlie
- 1:40:14this
- 1:40:15this body of work devoted not least to
- 1:40:17the catastrophe of Marxism and
- 1:40:19Communism. So, join us there.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of The Devil and Karl Marx | Dr. Paul Kengor | EP 455 by Jordan B Peterson, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 17,466 words across 2,798 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.