The Dark side of Science: The Milgram Experiment (1963) (Short Documentary) — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00how can a regular person be talked into
- 0:02committing heinous acts upon another
- 0:05and could you be convinced to
- 0:06potentially injure or kill someone else
- 0:09i'm not talking about self-defense or
- 0:10during war on the battlefield
- 0:12but someone you have never met before
- 0:14and have had no interaction
- 0:16with previously how can perfectly normal
- 0:18people commit genocide
- 0:20like what we saw in the 1930s and 1940s
- 0:23in europe
- 0:24or even in cambodia in the 1970s amongst
- 0:27other events
- 0:28what causes people to be active
- 0:30participants in crimes against humanity
- 0:33if we take germany in the 1930s as an
- 0:36example
- 0:37what caused a large part of a modern
- 0:39country to be willing
- 0:40in crimes against people that have been
- 0:43their neighbors and community members
- 0:45for years
- 0:46it is a really fascinating thought
- 0:48experiment as when you think to yourself
- 0:50i could never do something like this or
- 0:53even this
- 0:55but what would it actually take for you
- 0:57to pull trigger push a button
- 0:59or pull a lever well this is where a
- 1:01psychologist set out to see
- 1:03what would be the minimum amount of
- 1:04suggestion for a regular person to
- 1:06administer
- 1:07a potentially deadly electric shock to
- 1:10someone they have never met before
- 1:12the simple but effective study would be
- 1:14known by the inventor's name
- 1:16the milgram experiment the actual
- 1:19experiment would not result in any
- 1:21physical pain
- 1:22but extreme stress and inflicted insight
- 1:24to the participants
- 1:26and this would create controversy with
- 1:28the study
- 1:30as such i'm going to rate it here 5 on
- 1:32my ethics scale
- 1:34this is mainly due to it being a
- 1:35fascinating dive into
- 1:37our hard-wired ability to obey an
- 1:40authority figure
- 1:41even to the point of murder welcome to
- 1:44the dark side of science
- 1:45[Music]
- 1:52stanley milgram was an american social
- 1:55psychologist
- 1:56born on the 15th of august 1933 in the
- 1:59bronx new york
- 2:00his parents were jewish and have fled
- 2:02romania and hungary during the first
- 2:03world war
- 2:04his background and family ties to europe
- 2:06would have an
- 2:07important effect on his later studies
- 2:09into social psychology
- 2:11as word came back to the milgram family
- 2:13during the late 30s and 40s of the
- 2:16atrocities
- 2:16inflicted by the nazi regime although in
- 2:19relative safety in the usa
- 2:21many of stanley's family members were
- 2:23directly affected by the holocaust
- 2:25after the war some surviving members of
- 2:27the family came to stay
- 2:29whilst finding a new life in the u.s a
- 2:32young stanley was exposed to the horrors
- 2:34experienced by his relatives
- 2:35and this would stay with him igniting an
- 2:38interest into the darker side of human
- 2:40nature
- 2:41in 1954 milgram received his bachelor's
- 2:43degree in political science
- 2:45from queen's college in new york initial
- 2:48applications to harvard for
- 2:50psychology masters were rejected but
- 2:53was eventually admitted the initial
- 2:56setbacks were due to milgram not taking
- 2:58any undergraduate courses in psychology
- 3:00at queen's college
- 3:02in 1961 milgram received a phd
- 3:05in social psychology he became an
- 3:07assistant professor at yale
- 3:09around the same time later on he served
- 3:13as an assistant professor
- 3:14in the department of social relations at
- 3:16harvard from 1963 to 1966
- 3:19and this brings us very quickly onto his
- 3:22obedience study
- 3:23more commonly known as the milgram
- 3:25experiment
- 3:26stanley's experience of relatives going
- 3:28through the holocaust
- 3:29coupled with the arrest and trial of
- 3:32adolf eichmann in 1961
- 3:34sparked an interest into finding out
- 3:36what could make seemingly average people
- 3:38take part in atrocities
- 3:40eichmann organized the logistics of the
- 3:42deportation of jews during the holocaust
- 3:45he made deportation plans down to the
- 3:48last detail
- 3:49working with other german agencies he
- 3:51also determined how the property of
- 3:53deported jews would be seized
- 3:55what was interesting about the trial was
- 3:57that he claimed he had not dictated
- 3:59policy
- 4:00but only carried it out and that he was
- 4:02merely a cog in the machinery of
- 4:04destruction
- 4:06essentially the i was only following
- 4:08orders defense
- 4:10this highlights the question that is
- 4:13following an order
- 4:14enough to convince someone to do
- 4:15something so heinous
- 4:17milgram would later say in 1974 when
- 4:20explaining the experiment
- 4:21could it be that eichmann and his
- 4:23million accomplices in the holocaust
- 4:26were just following orders could we call
- 4:28them all accomplices
- 4:30the experiment was pretty simple and
- 4:32would make use of three people
- 4:34the experimenter who was in charge of
- 4:36the session the teacher
- 4:38a volunteer for a single session and a
- 4:40learner both the teacher and learner
- 4:42would arrive for the session together
- 4:44and they would draw straws as to who
- 4:46would take each role
- 4:48participants were sourced via a
- 4:49newspaper ads saying
- 4:51we will pay you for one hour of your
- 4:53time in a study of memory
- 4:55the teacher and learner after finding
- 4:57out their roles were taken into a room
- 4:59where the learner was strapped into what
- 5:01appeared to be an electric chair
- 5:02and electrode paste was applied to the
- 5:04learner's wrist
- 5:06to prevent blistering and burns the
- 5:08teacher would hear this being explained
- 5:10and see this happen
- 5:12the experimenter who was dressed in a
- 5:14lab coat in order to appear to have more
- 5:16authority
- 5:17told the participants that restraints
- 5:20was to ensure that the learner would not
- 5:21escape
- 5:23the teacher was allowed to experience a
- 5:24sample electric shock
- 5:26similar to what the learner would feel
- 5:28before beginning the experiment the
- 5:30volunteers were informed
- 5:31that they would be paid regardless of
- 5:33the outcome thus removing any financial
- 5:35incentive to any results
- 5:38the teacher was led into another room
- 5:40where they could not see the learner
- 5:41but could hear them and the experiment
- 5:44would begin
- 5:45the teacher was then given a list of
- 5:47word pairs that he was to teach the
- 5:48learner
- 5:49the teacher would then read the first
- 5:51word of each pair
- 5:53and read four possible answers the
- 5:56learner would press a button to show his
- 5:58answer
- 6:00if incorrect the teacher was meant to
- 6:02administer a shock to the learner
- 6:04if correct the teacher would read the
- 6:06next pair of words
- 6:08each subsequent incorrect answer would
- 6:10mean the teacher had to increase the
- 6:12voltage in 15 volt increments
- 6:15they were also instructed to announce
- 6:16the voltage before shocking the learner
- 6:19pretty cruel you might think but there
- 6:22was only one actual volunteer in each
- 6:24test
- 6:24the teacher who unbeknownst to them was
- 6:27the real test subject
- 6:29you see the learner was actually a
- 6:30stooge and wasn't receiving an
- 6:32electrical shock
- 6:33and the chance drawing his straws to
- 6:35find out who would do either role
- 6:36was actually fixed meaning the teacher
- 6:38would always be the teacher
- 6:41also probably not surprising the
- 6:43experimenter was also in on it
- 6:45this meant that the whole experience of
- 6:47the teacher was controlled from the
- 6:48authority of the experimenter
- 6:50to the reaction of the learner to ramp
- 6:52things up in later versions of the study
- 6:54the learner would also shout out in pain
- 6:56when the voltage got too high
- 6:58the experiment would have a preliminary
- 7:00and a regular run
- 7:01the first was a practice of sorts where
- 7:03the learner would get three correct
- 7:05answers and seven incorrect ones
- 7:07which would yield a shock up to 105
- 7:09volts
- 7:11the second or regular run the teacher
- 7:13would be told to read off a list of
- 7:14words
- 7:15and had to continue repeating it until
- 7:17the learner had gotten
- 7:19all of the pairs correct the volt dial
- 7:21ranged from 15 to 450 volts
- 7:24and to add further explanation for the
- 7:26teacher was labelled slight shock
- 7:28to danger severe shock above 300 volts
- 7:31the learner would kick on the wall
- 7:33and then no longer give answers to the
- 7:35teacher's multiple choice questions
- 7:37if the teacher showed any hesitation the
- 7:39experimenter was able to give
- 7:41one of four prodding responses in
- 7:43sequence
- 7:45the first was please continue or please
- 7:47go on
- 7:48followed by the experiment requires
- 7:51about you to continue
- 7:53and then it is absolutely essential that
- 7:56you continue
- 7:57and finally you have no other choice you
- 7:59must go on
- 8:00the experimenter could only progress to
- 8:02the next prod if the teacher refused
- 8:05if all four responses were reached then
- 8:07the experiment would end
- 8:09if not it would continue all the way up
- 8:10to 450 volts
- 8:13if the teacher asked any specific
- 8:15questions the experimenter could reply
- 8:17for example will the shock leave any
- 8:19permanent damage
- 8:20the experimenter could then reply with
- 8:23although shocks can be extremely painful
- 8:25they cause no permanent damage after the
- 8:28experiment an interview would be
- 8:29undertaken
- 8:30and the question how painful do you
- 8:32think the last few shocks you
- 8:34administered were
- 8:35the teachers were instructed to indicate
- 8:37their answer on a scale between 1 1-14
- 8:40after which the teacher was reintroduced
- 8:42to the learner and the experiment was
- 8:43fully explained
- 8:44the experiments began in july 1961 at
- 8:47yale university
- 8:49and 40 subjects would volunteer through
- 8:52this
- 8:52newspaper advert and the results would
- 8:55surprise
- 8:56all predictions
- 9:00the 40 men were from a cross section in
- 9:02society from various different age and
- 9:05career groups
- 9:06ranging from 20 to 50. during the
- 9:08experiment most test subjects showed
- 9:10signs of severe distress when
- 9:11administering the electric shock
- 9:13they are observed sweating trembling
- 9:15stuttering biting their lips groaning
- 9:17and digging their fingernails into their
- 9:19own skin
- 9:20the discomfort scene shown that the
- 9:23subjects were aware of the pain the
- 9:25learner was experiencing
- 9:26pre-experiment it was expected that only
- 9:28a small amount of the subjects would
- 9:30administer the high voltage shock
- 9:32between one and three percent but this
- 9:34prediction
- 9:35would be way off of the 40 subjects
- 9:38all reached 300 volts at which the
- 9:40learner would bang on the wall and
- 9:42stop giving answers only five refused to
- 9:45go beyond this point
- 9:47four more went on to shock the learner
- 9:50one more time
- 9:51and then also refuse two stopped at the
- 9:53330 volt level
- 9:55and one each at 345 360 and 375 volts
- 10:00respectively
- 10:01meaning that only 14 refused the
- 10:04experimenter's prods
- 10:06this meant that 26 proceeded all the way
- 10:09to the end
- 10:10giving the highest available shock to
- 10:11the learner although most showed signs
- 10:14of discomfort and stress
- 10:15they still obeyed the perceived
- 10:17authority of a guy in a white lab coat
- 10:20the results were understandably
- 10:22unexpected
- 10:23as from a young age we are taught to not
- 10:25hurt others
- 10:27but with the addition of an authority
- 10:28figure the teacher would abandon this
- 10:31fundamental part of their moral fabric
- 10:33scarily there was no punishment for
- 10:35disobeying the experimenter
- 10:37nor was there any reward for completing
- 10:39the experiment as payment was assured
- 10:40from the start
- 10:42even more strange was the results were
- 10:45similar
- 10:46when a control study was undertaken with
- 10:4843 unpaid
- 10:49students in milgram's paper into the
- 10:52study he highlighted several particular
- 10:54conditions of the experiment
- 10:56that might have contributed to the high
- 10:58level of about 65 percent of compliance
- 11:00to the highest voltage level the fact
- 11:02that the study was being undertaken
- 11:04at and sponsored by yale possibly
- 11:06reassured subjects that the experiment
- 11:08was above board and reputable
- 11:11the perceived randomness of the
- 11:12selection of learner and teacher
- 11:14also could have factored in as a teacher
- 11:17may have thought that he could have been
- 11:19in the other chair hence he was exposed
- 11:21to the same risks
- 11:23the subject may have also have thought
- 11:25that
- 11:26as he had volunteered that he was
- 11:27obligated to help the experimenter
- 11:30and to the same extent that the learner
- 11:32had also submitted to the authority of
- 11:34the experiment
- 11:35the subjects were also reassured that
- 11:37although painful the shocks were not
- 11:39deadly
- 11:40and that compliance was built through to
- 11:42shock level 20
- 11:43when the learner would no longer reply
- 11:47to refuse would cause a conflict
- 11:48situation where the wants of the learner
- 11:52and the experimenter were at odds with
- 11:54one another and to side with the
- 11:55experimenter
- 11:56was the path of least resistance so to
- 11:58speak the short duration that the
- 12:00experiment ran
- 12:01four meant that the teacher had less
- 12:03time to think about the actions
- 12:05resulting in little time for reflection
- 12:08milgram would repeat the experiment in
- 12:10several variations to see
- 12:12if any of the conditions change would
- 12:14yield different results
- 12:15even when milgram conducted the
- 12:17experiment in an unregistered office far
- 12:20away from yale
- 12:21the results were fairly similar now to
- 12:24the ethical question
- 12:26was the experiment cruel well in my
- 12:28opinion no
- 12:29but it can leave long-term distress to
- 12:31the teacher
- 12:32especially if they administered the full
- 12:34shock
- 12:35for many the experience left
- 12:37self-reflection on how they had
- 12:38submitted to the authority of the
- 12:40experimenter
- 12:41ethical criticism came from the allowed
- 12:44discomfort of the test subjects
- 12:46where even though they had provided
- 12:47their consent the experiment should have
- 12:50been paused when the distress was
- 12:51observed
- 12:53however in his 1974 book obedience to
- 12:56authority
- 12:57an experimental view pushed back on his
- 12:59detractors
- 13:00saying that the ethical criticism
- 13:02provoked by his experiments
- 13:04was because his findings were disturbing
- 13:06and revealed
- 13:07unwelcome truths about human nature he
- 13:09is really open to debate
- 13:11as whether the experiment was ethical or
- 13:13not but regardless
- 13:15it was a fascinating dive into human
- 13:18nature
- 13:20the study would later be compared with
- 13:22another controversial experiment
- 13:24run by one of milgram's friends philip
- 13:27george zimbardo at stamford
- 13:30but that will be a subject for another
- 13:31video thanks for watching i hope you
- 13:33enjoyed the video
- 13:34this video is a plain difficult
- 13:35production all videos on the channel are
- 13:37creative commons attribution share alike
- 13:39licensed
- 13:40play difficult videos are produced by me
- 13:41john in a sunny south
- 13:43eastern corner of london uk help the
- 13:45channel grow by liking commenting and
- 13:47subscribing
- 13:48and check out my twitter for all sorts
- 13:50of photos nods and sods as well as hints
- 13:52on future videos
- 13:53i've got patreon and youtube membership
- 13:55as well if you fancy
- 13:57supporting the channel financially and
- 13:59all that's left to say is thank you for
- 14:00watching
- 14:03[Music]
- 14:14[Music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of The Dark side of Science: The Milgram Experiment (1963) (Short Documentary) by Plainly Difficult, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,293 words across 432 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.