The Dark Side of Frugal Living (I’m done ignoring it) — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Imagine spending months, probably even
- 0:03years, just saving up a lot of money to
- 0:06get the things that you want, right? And
- 0:08then, you feel guilty when it's time to
- 0:11actually buy them. Back then, I honestly
- 0:14thought the hardest thing about frugal
- 0:17living would be to stop spending, but
- 0:19girl, listen. It turns out that the
- 0:21hardest part for me, especially, is
- 0:24learning when it is okay to spend, okay?
- 0:27When spending is actually okay. So, yes,
- 0:30my savings, that was technically
- 0:32growing, but on the other side, was my
- 0:36life even getting any better? And that's
- 0:39the dark side of frugal living that I'm
- 0:41just I'm just I'm just done ignoring it,
- 0:44okay? So, in this video, I'm going to go
- 0:47into details of all the dark side of
- 0:50frugal living that I've actually
- 0:52experienced in my life. And we're going
- 0:55to start off strong, girl, okay? Because
- 0:57one of the hardest things that I've
- 1:00encountered with living is I save up so
- 1:03much money to purchase things that I can
- 1:05actually afford, but I feel guilty
- 1:09purchasing them. So, a few weeks ago, I
- 1:11decided, "Listen, I got to get back on
- 1:13my fitness journey, okay? And I want to
- 1:17work out to as you guys know, I want to
- 1:19lose some weight, all this baby fat I
- 1:22got on me, okay?" And I decided I need
- 1:25to get some more comfortable workout
- 1:27shoes because the one that I've been
- 1:29wearing for like the past year and a
- 1:31half, it's a little bit worn, right? To
- 1:34be honest, was it absolutely a necessary
- 1:37purchase at the time? No, I could
- 1:39probably push it another 3 months, but
- 1:42looking back when I was in the store, I
- 1:45was thinking, "Do I really really need
- 1:48this workout shoes right now?" Even
- 1:50after buying the workout shoes, I
- 1:52considered returning them. And the truth
- 1:55is, I wasn't even short on money. Money
- 1:58was not the issue at this point, okay?
- 2:01I just felt guilty spending a lot of
- 2:04money on myself, and girl, the shoes,
- 2:05they were 60 bucks, okay? The thing
- 2:08about me is I
- 2:11>> [sighs]
- 2:11>> I lot of the expensive stuff,
- 2:13unfortunately, that I have, they were
- 2:14either gifted from my significant other
- 2:17or from a family member. I grew up in a
- 2:20third world country, for those who are
- 2:21new here, I grew up in Jamaica, and it's
- 2:25such a privilege to have certain things
- 2:29like basic running water. At my house, I
- 2:33had running water, but at my
- 2:35grandparents' house, whenever I went to
- 2:37visit for the summer, I would have to go
- 2:40to the river to do the laundry, okay? I
- 2:44would have to go to the river to get
- 2:45enough water to take a bath. Like, it
- 2:48was that challenging for me when I was
- 2:51living in Jamaica. And so, that kind of
- 2:54put me in a mindset where I shouldn't
- 2:57take little things for granted, and so,
- 3:00that's where this entire frugal living
- 3:03journey started for me. So, yeah, I feel
- 3:06like that's the part of frugal living
- 3:08that no one really talks about. Like,
- 3:10you get so used to telling yourself no
- 3:14because you don't want to take money or
- 3:16the little things you have for granted,
- 3:18but like, I need to really take a step
- 3:22back and let go off that.
- 3:25I wouldn't say childhood trauma, but
- 3:27that rough patch that I had growing up
- 3:29as a kid because I feel like it has a
- 3:32lot to do with my frugality. Okay, so,
- 3:34the second dark side of frugal living is
- 3:38the fact that if I wanted to save up
- 3:40some money, let's say my goal is
- 3:42$10,000, right? And I save up that
- 3:45$10,000.
- 3:47When I get to that $10,000, girl, like,
- 3:50I'm going to push it, and I'm going to
- 3:51ask myself, "Hey, maybe I can get to
- 3:5412,000 before the end of the year?"
- 3:57And [snorts] it's like I go into this
- 3:59like never-ending cycle, like, I don't
- 4:02know where to stop. I keep putting
- 4:04myself in positions where I'm saying,
- 4:06"Okay, maybe we can extend it to 12,000
- 4:09and when I get to 12,000, maybe I could
- 4:12take a vacation or maybe at that point I
- 4:13can do this." But honestly, looking
- 4:16back, we can still save money and have a
- 4:20balance and, you know, still enjoy life.
- 4:22I don't think it has to be black and
- 4:24white and that's how I looked at frugal
- 4:27living when I just started out. Um
- 4:30today, I don't have that same opinion. I
- 4:34personally think you can still have fun
- 4:36and enjoy life while being on your
- 4:39frugal living journey. Another dark side
- 4:42of frugal living that I've experienced
- 4:44in the past was I used to think that it
- 4:47was frugality, but deep down, it was
- 4:51fear. So, going back to that story that
- 4:53I just told you guys, again, grew up in
- 4:56Jamaica, third world country. We didn't
- 4:58have basic necessities. Well, I didn't
- 5:00have basic necessities at my
- 5:02grandparents' house, like running water.
- 5:04And so, again, that has instilled in my
- 5:08brain that not having enough is bad and
- 5:12that has caused me to hold on tightly to
- 5:15every single thing that I have. And
- 5:18because of that, I noticed that a few
- 5:21years ago I would have a lot of clutter
- 5:25in my house, like I'm talking about
- 5:29if you watched the last video or maybe
- 5:31the one before that, I talked about
- 5:33having a junk drawer in my kitchen,
- 5:35right? I have the belief that you don't
- 5:37really need a junk drawer because I have
- 5:41batteries in my junk drawer and of
- 5:43course, because it's a junk drawer, I
- 5:45couldn't find batteries in there, okay?
- 5:48I could not locate the freaking
- 5:49batteries and as a result, I went ahead
- 5:52and I purchased additional batteries
- 5:54that I already had. Had it been that I
- 5:57was able to organize and declutter that
- 6:00junk drawer, I would have found those
- 6:02batteries, okay? And as simple as that
- 6:05might sound, I kind of like apply this
- 6:07to my everyday life because mentally
- 6:10with less stuff, my brain, it feels more
- 6:13clear. Um I know exactly what I have in
- 6:15my house and what I don't have in my
- 6:17house now. It was more of fear that I
- 6:21was practicing. So, honestly, I feel
- 6:23like I felt more fear than I was
- 6:26actually practicing frugality. Just fear
- 6:29of not having something one day and
- 6:32actually needing it. So, I would just
- 6:34hold on to stuff, have a lot of clutter,
- 6:37and then I can't find anything and I'm
- 6:39still spending money anyway. So,
- 6:41technically,
- 6:43it didn't really make sense, but I know
- 6:45where that's coming from and that has a
- 6:46lot to do with my the way I I grew up.
- 6:50Another dark side of uh you know, frugal
- 6:53living that a lot of people don't talk
- 6:55about is I feel like people in the
- 6:57frugal living community, we sometimes
- 7:00treat our time like it's worth nothing.
- 7:04And I'm going to give you an example of
- 7:06what actually happened to me the other
- 7:08day. So, my son is one a little bit over
- 7:12one years old. So, he stopped using his
- 7:15baby swing, right? And so, I decided,
- 7:18"Okay, I'm going to list this baby swing
- 7:21on OfferUp and Facebook Marketplace for
- 7:2440 bucks." Girl, listen. The amount of
- 7:28messages that I got regarding that baby
- 7:31swing and the amount of time I spent
- 7:33communicating with people about the
- 7:36swing, listing it on Facebook
- 7:38Marketplace, taking additional pictures
- 7:41to send to other people who want
- 7:44the freaking to see the swing from a
- 7:46certain angle.
- 7:48>> [sighs]
- 7:48>> Girl, listen. I spent maybe at least two
- 7:51hours
- 7:53two hours plus, probably three, okay? I
- 7:56spent about that time actually
- 7:58communicating with people, listing
- 8:00things, you know, and I still have not
- 8:03sold the swing. Now, when I compare that
- 8:06to my job as an accountant, the last job
- 8:09that I worked, I would make more than
- 8:12$40 for the hour. And here I am spending
- 8:16two to three hours trying to sell a baby
- 8:18swing
- 8:20for 40 bucks. So, it's like I feel like
- 8:23us in the frugal living community,
- 8:25sometimes we just don't value our time
- 8:29enough. You know what I mean? And I'm at
- 8:32the point where I'm literally just going
- 8:35to donate that swing to someone in the
- 8:39in my chat messages who I know is
- 8:42actually pregnant and would benefit from
- 8:45having that swing for their baby.
- 8:47Another dark side of frugal living is
- 8:51>> [sighs and gasps]
- 8:51>> and I'm guilty of this, girl, okay? We
- 8:54try to make money off of every single
- 8:59hobby. I
- 9:00I don't know about you, but for me, yes,
- 9:02so
- 9:03I recently learned how to make pizza
- 9:06from scratch. And when I say recently,
- 9:08I'm talking about maybe two to three
- 9:10years ago. I know how to make the dough,
- 9:13I know how to experiment with different
- 9:15toppings. Like, when I say good pizza,
- 9:18my family members, they say that I make
- 9:21better pizza than like Papa John's,
- 9:24Domino's. Like, I'm not saying this to
- 9:27brag, okay?
- 9:29But, I believe them and it's true. From
- 9:32the moment they told me that, I've been
- 9:34researching how to start a pizza
- 9:36business. Remember, making pizza has
- 9:39been a hobby for me the past two to
- 9:41three years. I shouldn't be looking into
- 9:44ways to start a pizza business. It's a
- 9:46hobby. And I feel like in the frugal
- 9:49living community, we tend to do that. If
- 9:52we know how to sew, we're trying to
- 9:55capitalize and make money off of that.
- 9:58And in reality, yes, we can do things to
- 10:02make money off of it, but I think we
- 10:04should just try to keep our hobbies our
- 10:06hobbies, okay? Not everything we need to
- 10:08try to make money off of or get rich.
- 10:12Sometimes hobbies just need to stay
- 10:14hobbies. You know, I went on Amazon
- 10:17looking for stack of pizza boxes because
- 10:20I was like, "Hey, I can start selling
- 10:23pizzas now."
- 10:24>> [laughter]
- 10:25>> And maybe in the future I might consider
- 10:28it, who knows, but at this point I don't
- 10:32see myself considering that between now
- 10:34and the next year or two, okay? Like I'm
- 10:38just going to keep that hobby a hobby.
- 10:40And
- 10:42yeah, I think us in the frugal living
- 10:44community, we need to embrace that a
- 10:47little bit because once you turn that
- 10:49hobby into a business, like it's no
- 10:51longer a hobby. It's it's a business.
- 10:53Now, another dark side of frugal living
- 10:56that I've experienced in my life is I
- 10:59was at a point where I would allow
- 11:01myself to do every single thing around
- 11:05the house. I'm talking about there was a
- 11:07point when I was working on my YouTube
- 11:10channel cuz if you guys don't know, I
- 11:12had a another YouTube channel. I'm going
- 11:14to put it up here. I recently hid that
- 11:17channel, but that's not the point of
- 11:19this video, right? So, yeah, I was
- 11:21working on my other YouTube channel. I
- 11:24was working as an accountant. I was a
- 11:27mom, a wife, a daughter, a sister. Like
- 11:31my to-do list was really long every
- 11:35single day. And so, I would try to take
- 11:38on all these tasks and all these roles
- 11:42without paying for help because yeah,
- 11:45I'm frugal.
- 11:47So, that means I'm just going to burn
- 11:49myself out and get exhausted, right? And
- 11:52so, I took a step back and I'm like,
- 11:54"You know what? I have to focus on what
- 11:56matters most to me." You know,
- 11:59eventually over the years I resigned
- 12:02from that accounting job and now I'm a
- 12:05stay-at-home mom with my kids. And in
- 12:09addition to that, I also pair pay for
- 12:12child care services even though I'm a
- 12:14stay at home mom. Again, if you watched
- 12:16the last video, I go into details about
- 12:19this, but just to cut everything short,
- 12:22I don't want to repeat myself over and
- 12:24over. I must, you know, moving forward,
- 12:28pay for services that are going to help
- 12:31me to not feel so exhausted. I think
- 12:34it's worth it because for me, frugal
- 12:36living is more of spending less on the
- 12:40things that mean less to you and then
- 12:43spending more on things that really
- 12:45matters to you. That's going to improve
- 12:47your quality of life. That's going to,
- 12:51you know, make you have a better quality
- 12:52life, make things easier for you. And
- 12:55that's where I stand on frugal living.
- 12:58For me, frugal living is not about being
- 13:00cheap and stingy and making things
- 13:03harder for yourself, okay? It's just
- 13:06taking away from one area so you can put
- 13:09it in another area so you can have a
- 13:11better quality life and that's how I see
- 13:13it. Now, another dark side of frugal
- 13:16living is I made spending depict my
- 13:21entire existence on this planet. Like,
- 13:24here's what I mean, okay? It it
- 13:27determine like how much of of life I was
- 13:30actually enjoying. So, here's an
- 13:32example. So, let's say a friend would
- 13:35invite me somewhere, maybe to a dinner
- 13:37or a restaurant because, okay, it's
- 13:39girls' night. And I would be like,
- 13:42"Okay, cool. Where are we going?" And
- 13:44the moment they mention the restaurant
- 13:46that we're going to, I would [snorts] go
- 13:49online and look up the prices before I
- 13:52even agree. And if the price was too
- 13:54high, girl, I'm going to say either I am
- 13:57sick or I got other stuff to do or I'm
- 13:59just tired, okay? One of the three.
- 14:02>> [laughter]
- 14:04>> I hope none of my friends are watching
- 14:05this though, but seriously, that's what
- 14:09would usually happen. I feel like
- 14:11looking back at that point, I could have
- 14:15just had an honest conversation.
- 14:17That restaurant is not in my budget, as
- 14:20simple as that. Or I could have at least
- 14:24suggested another fun activity that was
- 14:27less expensive or possibly even free.
- 14:31Because at the end of the day, we don't
- 14:34want to just be friends with people who
- 14:37can't really understand our financial
- 14:39circumstances, right? And again, that
- 14:42would be another way to kind of weed out
- 14:45or get rid of
- 14:47people in our lives that are not
- 14:49supposed to be in our lives. And so,
- 14:51looking back, I wish I've done that more
- 14:54instead of canceling or making up an
- 14:56excuse. I should have just made a
- 15:00different suggestion or just say, "Hey,
- 15:02not in my budget." Yeah, so suggesting a
- 15:05more affordable alternative would have
- 15:07been a better choice than actually just
- 15:09completely withdrawing from the activity
- 15:13or going out with, you know, with people
- 15:15that mean a lot to me. Because it's more
- 15:18about the connection than going out to
- 15:21spend
- 15:22a few thousand or a few hundred dollars.
- 15:24More about the connection with the
- 15:25person you're going out with. At least
- 15:27that's how I look at it. Another dark
- 15:30side of frugal living that I've
- 15:32experienced is I felt like I've made my
- 15:36entire identity frugal living. So,
- 15:40um what I mean by this is if I made a
- 15:44pretty expensive purchase that I feel is
- 15:47worth it, I felt like I've betrayed the
- 15:50frugal living community because a lot of
- 15:53people in the frugal living community
- 15:55probably would not have bought this
- 15:57piece. Here's an example. When my
- 16:00husband and I, when we closed on our
- 16:02home, we installed a water filtration
- 16:05system in our entire house. And it did
- 16:08cost a lot of money. But I know a lot of
- 16:11people would be like, "Okay, a water
- 16:14filtration system is not a necessity."
- 16:17And so, instead of putting that in, you
- 16:20could have done you know, you could have
- 16:22done without it. But, in our opinion,
- 16:26we really needed it. And for us, that
- 16:29was a valid purchase. But, when friends
- 16:32and family come to my house, they're
- 16:33like, "Oh, you have a
- 16:36you have soft water and a whole
- 16:38filtration system in your house?"
- 16:40And we're like, "Yeah."
- 16:43And I feel like I've betrayed those
- 16:46people because they already know that
- 16:48frugal living is my entire identity. So,
- 16:51it's like, technically, I feel like
- 16:53they're thinking, "Why are you spending
- 16:55$10,000 on a water filtration system for
- 16:58your house if you say you're frugal?"
- 17:01But, you know, people just don't
- 17:02understand
- 17:04that frugal living is not just "Don't
- 17:07spend, don't spend, don't spend."
- 17:09>> [snorts]
- 17:09>> You know, again, it's more of reducing a
- 17:13lot in one area that doesn't mean a lot
- 17:16to you, and putting it in other areas.
- 17:19So, meal prepping is something that I
- 17:21do. A lot of people don't like to meal
- 17:23prep, but that's one area I save a lot
- 17:26of money to put that money that I saved
- 17:29in better places that will improve my
- 17:31quality of life. So, I will literally
- 17:34spend one or two days out of the week,
- 17:36and I'll cook, and I'll literally freeze
- 17:39it for when I'm ready. I just throw it
- 17:41in the microwave, and I'm set, okay? And
- 17:44a lot of people they think so, or they
- 17:47think the food is going to come out
- 17:48soggy. They think For me, it works great
- 17:51for my family and I, um, and that's just
- 17:54a quick example of one way I take from
- 17:58one area of my life to apply to other
- 18:01areas that mean a lot more to me. Make
- 18:03sense? I hope so. And another thing that
- 18:06I see going on in the frugal living
- 18:08community that's like, to me, it's the
- 18:11dark side of it, is a lot of the times
- 18:14we're saving, we're making big
- 18:16sacrifices, but we don't know what it's
- 18:18for. We just know we're going to be
- 18:20frugal, and that's it. But, I feel like
- 18:23when you're frugal, you should have a
- 18:25goal at all times. Are you trying to pay
- 18:28off debt? Are you trying to save up
- 18:31money to go on vacation? Are you trying
- 18:34to build an emergency fund? And so,
- 18:37that's one dark side that I feel like a
- 18:39lot of people in the frugal living
- 18:41community must consider. What is your
- 18:44goal? What are you saving up for? Is it
- 18:46because being frugal gives you peace of
- 18:49mind. I feel like with a goal in mind at
- 18:51all times, you're more likely to stick
- 18:54to being frugal than just be like,
- 18:56"Okay, I'm going to be frugal, and
- 18:58that's it." Like, that doesn't work for
- 19:00me, okay? For me, it's to save for
- 19:04retirement so I can retire early cuz,
- 19:06girl,
- 19:07I always say I do not want to be working
- 19:10until I'm 65, okay? Um I want to retire
- 19:13before that, and I also want to have a
- 19:16great quality life. And so, that's the
- 19:19reason I've decided to become really
- 19:23frugal. So, to be quite honest with you,
- 19:26frugal living has helped me a lot. And
- 19:30I'm not going to give it up at all, for
- 19:32no one. But, what I'm going to give up
- 19:34is the fact that I have to be extremely
- 19:36uncomfortable
- 19:38and live in a tent outside to prove that
- 19:42I'm frugal enough to be a part of this
- 19:44frugal living community, you know? You
- 19:46don't have to be uncomfortable 24/7
- 19:50every single day of your life to prove
- 19:52that you're good with money. No, sis.
- 19:54You can actually still be good with
- 19:57money, but you're fairly comfortable in
- 20:00life, and that's that's my approach.
- 20:03Now, if you've ever felt guilty about
- 20:06buying something that you could actually
- 20:08afford, let me know in the comments what
- 20:11that was like, and maybe you want to
- 20:13share what the product is or was. Um
- 20:16yeah, let me know, and I'll be sure to
- 20:18respond because I know I cannot be the
- 20:21only one who has talked herself out of
- 20:23something that was actually really
- 20:26really needed. Not even want, but
- 20:29needed. I'll see you in the next one.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of The Dark Side of Frugal Living (I’m done ignoring it) by Lydia Rose, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,350 words across 467 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.