The Crimes of Elizabeth Holmes | A 10 Billion Dollar Fraud — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00[Music]
- 0:02Elizabeth Holmes was just 19 years old
- 0:05when she dropped out of Stanford
- 0:07University with a dream of creating a
- 0:09company that would revolutionize blood
- 0:11testing
- 0:15our work is in being able to make
- 0:20testing more accessible they did nothing
- 0:22to verify that her scientific claims
- 0:25were true
- 0:26I felt like she was deceiving the public
- 0:31Interline the doctors you're lying The
- 0:33Regulators you're also lying to the
- 0:35public most people would call that fraud
- 0:37as well
- 0:40[Music]
- 0:59the Bahamas were once home to one of the
- 1:03richest men in modern history a 29 year
- 1:06old billionaire Named Sam bankman freed
- 1:09described by one YouTuber as the most
- 1:11generous billionaire in the world fast
- 1:14forward a year and Sam's name is now
- 1:17shrouded in National infamy losing his
- 1:20Billionaire's status when it was
- 1:21discovered his company FTX had been
- 1:24illegally using customer money to invest
- 1:26in worthless cryptocurrency the ordeal
- 1:29led to the collapse of the company that
- 1:31forced Sam to abandon his role as CEO
- 1:34shortly before being arrested at his 200
- 1:38million dollar estate he now faces up to
- 1:41115 years in federal prison for
- 1:44allegedly defrauding countless
- 1:46unassuming investors with the help of
- 1:49his Harry Potter loving ancient Harem
- 1:51obsessed girlfriend what's insane is
- 1:54that up until a few months ago the FTX
- 1:56crypto exchange was lauded as one of the
- 1:59most respected entrusted parts of the
- 2:02crypto industry buying the name rights
- 2:04to the Miami Heat arena securing massive
- 2:07celebrity brand deals and even
- 2:09broadcasting a Super Bowl commercial
- 2:11starring Larry David like I was saying
- 2:14it's FTX it's a safe and easy way to get
- 2:16into crypto
- 2:17yeah I don't think so which all seems to
- 2:20lend Sam and his company more
- 2:22credibility a lot of otherwise very
- 2:24smart and successful people bought into
- 2:27the elaborate fraud Sam was peddling and
- 2:30unfortunately countless Innocence Lost a
- 2:32collective eight billion dollars in what
- 2:35one Court filing described as the
- 2:37biggest corporate failure in American
- 2:39history but the cautionary tale of Sam
- 2:43bankman freed is nothing new in a
- 2:45country where professional con artists
- 2:47accumulate massive net worth by
- 2:49intentionally misleading the general
- 2:51public one name in particular boasts a
- 2:54historic degree of disgrace Elizabeth
- 2:57Holmes Elizabeth Holmes Elizabeth Holmes
- 2:59wants a Silicon Valley Superstar
- 3:01Elizabeth Holmes will spend 11 years
- 3:03behind bars for defrauding investors in
- 3:062014 the healthcare technology giant
- 3:09theranos was valued at a whopping nine
- 3:11billion dollars eclipsing the valuations
- 3:14of both Uber and Spotify at the time
- 3:16with its young 20 something year old
- 3:18founder touted as a Pioneer in Silicon
- 3:21Valley theranos was once considered to
- 3:23be at the cusp of revolutionizing the
- 3:26blood testing industry a healthcare
- 3:28Pioneer is being compared to Visionaries
- 3:30like Bill Gates and Steve Jobs
- 3:32revolutionary Diagnostics company this
- 3:34is a very big deal
- 3:36if you think the story of a young
- 3:38Stanford Dropout overcoming All Odds to
- 3:41spearhead a contemporary medical
- 3:43Revolution is too good to be true that's
- 3:46because it is fairness was a lie one
- 3:50that ended with patients lives in
- 3:52Jeopardy and the company's own Founders
- 3:54Behind Bars join me in revisiting one of
- 3:57the most bizarre and truly mind-boggling
- 3:59medical swindles of all time as we
- 4:02uncover the true intent behind a false
- 4:05promise to save lives and the complex
- 4:07personalities that pushed theranos to
- 4:10the bleeding edge this is the story of
- 4:13Elizabeth Holmes every person should
- 4:15have the ability to get that type of
- 4:17test this is what happens first they
- 4:19think you're crazy then they fight you
- 4:21and then all of a sudden you change the
- 4:22world
- 4:25but before we get too deep here I want
- 4:27to thank today's sponsor guardio guardio
- 4:30is an easy to use browser extension that
- 4:33combats emerging online threats by
- 4:35scanning your browser for malicious
- 4:37activity because browsers played such a
- 4:40huge part in our lives by storing
- 4:42valuable data like passwords banking
- 4:45info and other personal details there's
- 4:47a lot at stake but guardio acts as the
- 4:50first line of defense against phishing
- 4:52attempts malware scam sites and pop-ups
- 4:55even when you shop online you can run
- 4:57into malicious look-alike sites and
- 4:59we'll never know the difference but
- 5:01guardio knows how to identify and block
- 5:03these sites saving you plenty of
- 5:06headaches and money lost down the line
- 5:08upon installing Guardia will run a free
- 5:10security scan to detect existing threats
- 5:13found on your browser this is when you
- 5:15find out if your information is already
- 5:17at risk after completing the scan you'll
- 5:20have a seven day free trial to remove
- 5:21these threats and enable real-time
- 5:24protection they making you aware of
- 5:26dangerous downloads hijacking attempts
- 5:28and malicious extensions before they
- 5:31even have the chance to take hold of
- 5:33sensitive information not to mention
- 5:35guardia's identity monitoring is
- 5:37cross-platform by signing up through
- 5:39mobile you'll get real-time alerts if
- 5:41your data is breached or leaked so that
- 5:43you can take Swift action immediately so
- 5:46what are you waiting for join over 1
- 5:48million people who have already
- 5:49installed today by visiting guard.io
- 5:52jobri or clicking the link in the
- 5:55description below to check out their
- 5:56affordable premium plans starting at
- 5:58just 20 off the usual monthly
- 6:01subscription huge thanks again to
- 6:03guardio for sponsoring this video and
- 6:06providing you and me with a clean and
- 6:08secure browsing experience
- 6:16I grew up spending Summers and the
- 6:20holidays with my uncle
- 6:24I remember his love of crossword puzzles
- 6:27and trying to teach us to play football
- 6:29I remember how much he loved the beach
- 6:34see a world in which
- 6:36no one ever has to say goodbye too soon
- 6:38Elizabeth Ann Holmes was born on
- 6:41February 3rd 1984 in Washington DC raced
- 6:45alongside her younger brother Christian
- 6:47Elizabeth always felt she had big shoes
- 6:49to fill given her family's vast history
- 6:52of accomplishments her great great
- 6:55grandfather for instance was such a
- 6:57masterful surgeon they named a hospital
- 6:59after him in Cincinnati he went on to
- 7:02marry the daughter of a man named
- 7:03Charles Lewis Fleischmann Hungarian
- 7:06immigrant accredited with founding the
- 7:08largest East Empire of the 1800s
- 7:11revolutionizing baking forever so yes
- 7:14Elizabeth Holmes's great great great
- 7:17grandfather is basically the reason
- 7:19bread can be mass produced and eaten
- 7:21today the more you know I guess While
- 7:24most of the yeast Fortune may have been
- 7:26spent on the extravagant lifestyles of
- 7:29her great grandfather and grandfather
- 7:31over the course of two generations
- 7:33enough was still left over for Elizabeth
- 7:36you enjoy a pretty comfortable
- 7:37upbringing her father Christian Holmes
- 7:40IV was a vice president that the once
- 7:43bustling Energy company in Ron and her
- 7:45mother Noel doused worked as a staffer
- 7:48on various congressional committees
- 7:50aiding U.S representatives on issues
- 7:52from defense to foreign policy her
- 7:55mother's familial history isn't without
- 7:57success either with Noel's father both
- 7:59planning and carrying out this shift
- 8:01from a draft-based military to an
- 8:04all-volunteer force in the U.S by the
- 8:061970s according to journalist John Kerry
- 8:09Roo Elizabeth's ancestry has even been
- 8:12traced back to the Marshall Lewis
- 8:14Nicholas devout a French military
- 8:16commander ranked among one of Napoleon's
- 8:19finest generals with such an array of
- 8:21accomplishments coursing throughout the
- 8:23family tree Elizabeth grew up with
- 8:26Monumental expectations when her family
- 8:28asked what she wanted to do when she
- 8:30grew up she'd responded I want to be a
- 8:33billionaire written off is the
- 8:34unrealistic imaginary nation of a child
- 8:37back then this was a goal that would be
- 8:39realized a few decades later Elizabeth
- 8:42telling the New Yorker in 2014 I grew up
- 8:45with these stories about greatness and
- 8:47people deciding not to spend their lives
- 8:49on something purposeful and what happens
- 8:52to them when they make that choice the
- 8:54impact on character and quality of life
- 8:57I've always believed that when people
- 9:00find
- 9:01what they're truly passionate about
- 9:04they can build
- 9:07great things various family members have
- 9:10since shined a light on Elizabeth's
- 9:12competitive side being known as a
- 9:14ruthless Monopoly player as a child and
- 9:17throwing fits when she lost to the
- 9:19extent that she apparently ran directly
- 9:21through a screen door more than once
- 9:24regardless Elizabeth's ambition drove
- 9:27her to design detailed inventions in her
- 9:29notebook which later translated to
- 9:31achieving huge success in school even
- 9:33when I'm in her sleep schedule and
- 9:35social life may suffer her inability to
- 9:38maintain a tight Social Circle as a
- 9:40child was only exacerbated by having to
- 9:43get up and move cross-country once her
- 9:45father's job was dissolved along with
- 9:47the entirety of Enron after an
- 9:49accounting fraud Scandal tore the
- 9:51company apart crazyo history repeats
- 9:54itself this led to her father working a
- 9:56myriad of jobs across various government
- 9:58agencies moving Elizabeth from DC to
- 10:01Houston Texas where she'd attend high
- 10:03school at St John's this is where she'd
- 10:05really sharpen her neck for business
- 10:07becoming interested in technology
- 10:09Elizabeth claimed in an interview with
- 10:11Fortune magazine that as a student she
- 10:14kicked off her first ever business by
- 10:16selling C plus plus compliers to
- 10:18universities in China eventually
- 10:21studying Mandarin and even getting the
- 10:23opportunity to attend Stanford's summer
- 10:25Mandarin program as a high school
- 10:27student which was pretty rare by the
- 10:29time graduation rolled around Elizabeth
- 10:31and her family had already established
- 10:34enough connections at Stanford that
- 10:35attempting the Ivy League school seemed
- 10:38like a no-brainer being accepted in 2002
- 10:41Elizabeth carried a goal of obtaining a
- 10:43degree in chemical engineering knowing
- 10:46she wanted to change the world finding
- 10:49her true calling just a few short
- 10:51semesters later and saws is becoming
- 10:55more aggressive the number of victims
- 10:57expected to Triple within weeks we are
- 10:59truly in the middle of the evolution of
- 11:01an epidemic in early 2003 the viral
- 11:04respiratory illness SARS was first
- 11:07identified in China before ripping
- 11:09across over two dozen countries in what
- 11:12would become a global Health epidemic
- 11:14that spanned the next year and a half it
- 11:16was here during the summer between her
- 11:18freshman and sophomore years at Stanford
- 11:21that Elizabeth Holmes worked at the
- 11:22genome Institute of Singapore during the
- 11:25fight against SARS by conducting
- 11:27traditional nasal swab testing by
- 11:30working with patients up close Elizabeth
- 11:32determined this wasn't always the most
- 11:34ideal method and immediately began
- 11:36dreaming up other ways to ensure the
- 11:39comfort and convenience of anyone in
- 11:41need of a test she began working on the
- 11:43concept for an alternative immediately
- 11:45upon her return to California where she
- 11:47sketched up the design for a small
- 11:49wearable arm patch that would both
- 11:51diagnose and treat various illnesses see
- 11:55being at Stanford exposed her to what's
- 11:57known as lab on its ship technology
- 11:59which is inc.com puts it enables diverse
- 12:02results to be extracted from a minuscule
- 12:04amount of liquid on a microchip now if
- 12:07you're like me and only have a fifth
- 12:09grade understanding of science and
- 12:10chemistry at best that's okay not all of
- 12:13this matters the important thing to know
- 12:15here is that Elizabeth's overarching
- 12:17goal throughout all of her work in the
- 12:19field relied on her desire to make tiny
- 12:22technology work on Tiny minuscule
- 12:24samples which apparently is incredibly
- 12:27hard to do Elizabeth's patch would
- 12:29ideally detect a virus in a patient and
- 12:32treat it with the appropriate antibiotic
- 12:34in doses that were adjusted according to
- 12:37variables in the patient's blood and to
- 12:39update doctors wirelessly something that
- 12:42was considered challenging but not
- 12:44impossible at least according to
- 12:46Stanford's then dean of engineering
- 12:48Channing Robertson who claimed it was
- 12:50not only bold but also remarkable in
- 12:52terms of its engineering and scientific
- 12:55Integrity see Robertson may have been
- 12:57sold but not everyone at Stanford was as
- 13:00optimistic about Elizabeth's new idea in
- 13:03fact when she approached professor of
- 13:04medicine Phyllis Gardner with her
- 13:06proposed Gardner fired back with a dose
- 13:09of reality bluntly stating that she
- 13:11didn't think her idea was going to work
- 13:13according to her a tiny patch that could
- 13:16diagnose and begin treating a patient's
- 13:18ailment defied the laws of physics and
- 13:21practically it wasn't anything other
- 13:22than a work of fiction but this didn't
- 13:25stop Elizabeth from filing a patent and
- 13:27hiring Stanford lab students to build
- 13:29the Prototype putting together this
- 13:31semblance of a small company with the
- 13:33help of Robertson Elizabeth soon
- 13:35realized she was spending more time
- 13:37pitching her brilliant idea to venture
- 13:40capitalists than actually the attending
- 13:43school but I wasn't going to any classes
- 13:46and I was spending all of my time
- 13:47talking to VCS and so then logistically
- 13:50it just seemed like a waste of money
- 13:51after just a year and a half of trying
- 13:54to juggle grades into getting a medical
- 13:56startup off the ground Elizabeth dropped
- 13:59out of Stanford in March of 2004
- 14:01breaking up with her boyfriend to focus
- 14:03more on work and putting what was left
- 14:05of her tuition money toward the dream of
- 14:08changing Diagnostics forever in other
- 14:11words at the beginning of the end for
- 14:13Elizabeth Holmes
- 14:15hurry down from
- 14:18here
- 14:23Elizabeth officially founded what would
- 14:26become theranos in 2003 at just 19 years
- 14:30old at the time it was called real-time
- 14:32cures which was written as real-time
- 14:34curses on the company's early paychecks
- 14:37thanks to an unfortunate typo really
- 14:39seemed Elizabeth was foreshadowing
- 14:41something there in the beginning the
- 14:42company operated out of the basement of
- 14:44a college house before upgrading to an
- 14:46office on the edge of East Palo Alto
- 14:49which Elizabeth discovered wasn't the
- 14:51best part of town after her car windows
- 14:53were apparently shot out showing up to
- 14:56work with glass shards still in her hair
- 14:58one day but these circumstances did
- 15:00little to deter her from taking the
- 15:02first step in making her idealistic
- 15:05technology a reality
- 15:08phrasing money as the case with every
- 15:11startup a good handful of willing
- 15:13investors was crucial for getting
- 15:15anything concrete's off the ground
- 15:17luckily Elizabeth prided herself on a
- 15:20dazzling pitch by painting a grandiose
- 15:22picture of what the world could look
- 15:24like with the help of her technology
- 15:26Elizabeth emphasized how her company had
- 15:29the potential to change the entire way
- 15:32we fight and diagnose diseases without
- 15:34delving too far into how the technology
- 15:37actually worked on a practical level her
- 15:40strategy was to talk up a big game and
- 15:42kind of hope the rest just fell into
- 15:44place along the way the details didn't
- 15:46matter especially not to the people she
- 15:49was trying to win over who weren't
- 15:51exactly the most knowledgeable on
- 15:52medical science
- 15:54[Music]
- 15:56her first wave of investors was
- 15:58described as more of a grab bag of
- 16:00random entrepreneurs who didn't want to
- 16:02miss out on what was being depicted as
- 16:05the next big thing for healthcare
- 16:07Elizabeth's technology was meant to be
- 16:09used by everyone after all ideally
- 16:11cutting out the need to be tested for
- 16:13illnesses in a lab altogether combine
- 16:15that utopian concept with the Charisma
- 16:18and charm that Elizabeth was said to
- 16:20have espoused and suddenly people wanted
- 16:22in specifically a family friend named
- 16:25Tim Draper who made a fortune from his
- 16:27early investments in unicorn companies
- 16:29like Hotmail Tesla and Skype did he know
- 16:32anything about the inner workings of
- 16:34Medical Laboratory Testing no but he
- 16:37along with many other Rich investors
- 16:39didn't want to risk fomo the fear of
- 16:42missing out can be a popular incentive
- 16:44to capitalize on these opportunities as
- 16:47early as possible it's what led him to
- 16:49cut Elizabeth a check for one million
- 16:51dollars on the spot and allowed theranos
- 16:54to raise six million dollars in venture
- 16:56backing by the end of 2004 a brand name
- 16:59Elizabeth derived from combining the
- 17:01words therapy and diagnosis of course
- 17:04not everyone bought her lackluster pitch
- 17:06especially not those in the medical
- 17:08field when one venture capitalist firm
- 17:11known for their Investments and you know
- 17:13Medical Technology it tried to pressing
- 17:16Elizabeth on the specifics of her device
- 17:18during a pitch the young CEO found
- 17:21herself unable to answer basic questions
- 17:24cutting the meeting short when she
- 17:25stormed out of the room if we were to
- 17:28use Elizabeth's own words the way her
- 17:30technology worked was that quote a
- 17:32chemistry is performed so that a
- 17:34chemical reaction occurs and generates a
- 17:37signal from the chemical interaction
- 17:38with the sample which is translated into
- 17:41a result which is then reviewed by
- 17:43certified laboratory Personnel if that
- 17:46doesn't sound like me trying to BS my
- 17:49way through a mandatory writing
- 17:50assignment my sophomore year of
- 17:52chemistry I don't know what it does the
- 17:54people who knew anything about what she
- 17:55was trying to do rarely fell for her
- 17:58charm whereas those with little to no
- 18:00prior knowledge of healthcare were the
- 18:02ones to jump on board one of Tim
- 18:04Draper's Associates telling inc.com you
- 18:07hear a lot about young entrepreneurs who
- 18:09come in with a certain confidence Holmes
- 18:11had 10 times that one drop of blood two
- 18:15drops of blood 50 tests 50 tests two
- 18:18drops of blood from your fingers yes
- 18:20and it worked beautifully well the
- 18:23investors remained content blinded by
- 18:25the hype of a new company they didn't
- 18:27know and a product they didn't
- 18:29understand theranosis chemists and
- 18:31Engineers lost more confidence by the
- 18:34day maybe the theropatch wasn't
- 18:36impossible but inventing a wearable
- 18:38device that could do everything
- 18:40Elizabeth wanted it to would pose
- 18:42significant logistical problems for the
- 18:45time being a theranos decided to focus
- 18:47on just the Diagnostics part but even
- 18:50that opened the door for challenges that
- 18:52weren't helped By Elizabeth's rigid
- 18:54expectations she ultimately wanted it to
- 18:57run dozens of tests at once which meant
- 19:00it needed to incorporate more equipment
- 19:02and thus needed to be bigger than
- 19:04something you could simply wear on your
- 19:06arm because of that the idea for a patch
- 19:08was sort of discarded and replaced with
- 19:11a new prototype dubbed the theranos 1.0
- 19:14an erratic boxy machine that relied
- 19:16heavily on microfluidics and
- 19:18biochemistry the theranos 1.0 used a
- 19:22cartridge and reader system that wasn't
- 19:24exactly in line with her original idea
- 19:27but still gave the company something to
- 19:29wheel out during demonstrations to allow
- 19:32more potential investors even if the
- 19:34device didn't actually work ever really
- 19:39[Music]
- 19:41theranos employees told us they were
- 19:44instructed to Stage fake demonstrations
- 19:46for investors in 2006 Elizabeth and her
- 19:50team made the trip out to Switzerland to
- 19:52present the theranos 1.0 in front of the
- 19:55global health care company in Novartis
- 19:57if all went well A fairness would secure
- 20:00a lucrative new Investments which they
- 20:02could really use now that they had blown
- 20:04through so much of their initial backing
- 20:06unfortunately though one of the two
- 20:08devices Elizabeth brought with them was
- 20:10malfunctioning the night before the demo
- 20:13while any normal person may have been
- 20:14honest about these flaws and works to
- 20:16fix them before presenting the machine
- 20:18to clients Elizabeth decided to go the
- 20:21insane route calling up her
- 20:22bioinformatics team back in Palo Alto
- 20:25and having them send all the test
- 20:27results before the presentation occurred
- 20:30so at the demo in Switzerland they would
- 20:32obtain a blood sample with a small
- 20:34finger prick and set the cartridge in
- 20:36the machine but as opposed to flashing
- 20:38its usual will error message the machine
- 20:41spit out the fake results from
- 20:42California giving Swiss investors the
- 20:45false impression that their blood was
- 20:47really being tested and the machines
- 20:49actually worked Elizabeth was so excited
- 20:51with the successful demonstration she
- 20:54emailed the entire company saying team
- 20:56we all nailed this one you all did an
- 20:58incredible job making this happen this
- 21:01is the theranos way but when the CFO
- 21:03found out about this he brought it up
- 21:05with Elizabeth at the next meeting
- 21:07saying we've been fooling investors you
- 21:10can't keep doing that to which Elizabeth
- 21:11responded you're not a team player I
- 21:14think you should leave right now he was
- 21:16fired on the spot the theranos way and
- 21:19then to convince investors that they
- 21:21really did have groundbreaking new
- 21:23technology they would stage these demos
- 21:25with not just investors but board
- 21:27members even media members they would
- 21:29prick the visiting vip's finger they
- 21:31would put the blood in the cartridge
- 21:33turn it on you know it start worrying
- 21:35and then they would say oh um it's going
- 21:38to take a little while one of them you
- 21:39come and either visit the lab or
- 21:42go look at what's over here go meet with
- 21:45Elizabeth in her office Elizabeth had
- 21:47proved she wasn't above faking
- 21:49demonstrations to win over the hearts
- 21:51and wallets of clients and frankly lying
- 21:54about the state of your product is
- 21:56hardly an uncommon occurrence in Silicon
- 21:58Valley the reality is plenty of tech
- 22:01entrepreneurs have managed to raise
- 22:02money for their companies by fudging the
- 22:04details a bit but theranos wasn't
- 22:07selling iPads this was being marketed as
- 22:09life-changing medical equipment if it
- 22:12ever became commercially available
- 22:13accurate blood testing is obviously
- 22:16crucial for doctors to know what's wrong
- 22:18with their patients and act accordingly
- 22:20filling a prescription based on a false
- 22:23positive or worse in not informing a
- 22:25patient to the serious ailment carries
- 22:27huge consequences for everyone involved
- 22:30and we've since seen the effects of it
- 22:32without getting too ahead of ourselves
- 22:34here one class action lawsuit filed by
- 22:37the people of Arizona a decade later
- 22:39included a woman who blamed the theranos
- 22:41test for saying she was miscarrying when
- 22:43she was still pregnant another patient
- 22:46received a false positive on their HIV
- 22:48test and another was wrongfully
- 22:50instructed to stop taking her blood
- 22:52thinning medication all as a result of
- 22:54theranos rushing to get what they knew
- 22:57were faulty products out on the market
- 22:59this wasn't something you could be
- 23:00flippant about yet Elizabeth was
- 23:03determined to go commercial as quickly
- 23:05as possible which included using real
- 23:07cancer patients as test subjects back in
- 23:102007 when Elizabeth orchestrated the
- 23:1315-month study for Pfizer that measured
- 23:16how 27 late-stage cancer patients
- 23:19responded to treatment as measured by
- 23:21theranos devices depending on the
- 23:24results theranos was looking at another
- 23:26lucrative partnership with one of the
- 23:28biggest names in medical manufacturing
- 23:31according to one retired Pfizer
- 23:33scientist the results displayed wild
- 23:35variations that theranos couldn't
- 23:37explain not even offer offering a
- 23:39response for two weeks Pfizer ultimately
- 23:42decided against a partnership with
- 23:44theranos after such a poor experience
- 23:46despite theranos calling every six
- 23:48months after that trying to get them to
- 23:50change their mind which I'm surprised
- 23:52didn't work Elizabeth has always had a
- 23:54persuasive charm managing to talk her
- 23:57way out of being removed as CEO in 2008
- 24:00by the board of directors a fate not
- 24:02even Elon Musk could withstand when he
- 24:05was oust from PayPal but by this point
- 24:07she had garnered a reputation for
- 24:09rushing her employees setting
- 24:11unrealistic expectations for their
- 24:13machines ignoring ethical obligations
- 24:15firing anyone who questioned her actions
- 24:18and of course lying to investors and
- 24:20patients about the reliability of their
- 24:22technology but that's not the only thing
- 24:24she was lying about now to the trial of
- 24:27EX theranos executive Sunny bawani
- 24:29prosecutor showed new text message
- 24:31exchanges between balwani and theranos
- 24:34founder Elizabeth Holmes Elizabeth hired
- 24:38a man named Johnny balwani in 2009
- 24:41despite having no prior experience in
- 24:44any scientific field Sunny quickly Rose
- 24:46to the top of the theranos pyramid it
- 24:49was promoted to president and CEO of the
- 24:53company what employees and the board
- 24:55didn't realize though is that sunny and
- 24:57Elizabeth were in a secret relationship
- 25:01thank you for inviting us here for the
- 25:03record my name is sunny balwani born in
- 25:061965 a Ramesh Sunny balwani began his
- 25:10career during the 90s at Microsoft where
- 25:12he claims to have written over a million
- 25:15lines of code which is virtually the
- 25:17impossible given the time frame in 1999
- 25:19he joined a company called
- 25:21commercevid.com and made 40 million
- 25:24dollars after it sold to Commerce one
- 25:26shortly before the.com Bubble Burst
- 25:28being in just the right place at the
- 25:31right time Sunny got lucky with tens of
- 25:34millions to his name he was pursuing his
- 25:36MBA at Berkeley at age 37 when he met
- 25:39Elizabeth Holmes an 18 year old senior
- 25:42in high school while it's uncertain when
- 25:45the two actually began dating they were
- 25:47confirmed to at least be living together
- 25:49by a 2005. joining the company four
- 25:52years later without any investors
- 25:54knowing about the true nature of their
- 25:56relationship which was cold and bizarre
- 25:59as evident by these screenshots of them
- 26:01to Florida I think you are the breeze in
- 26:04my desert for me my water and ocean
- 26:06meant only to be together tiger okay
- 26:10awesome as Elizabeth is second in
- 26:12command Sonny was described by employees
- 26:15as overbearing uncompromising and
- 26:18paranoid when he wasn't spying on
- 26:20people's conversations he was
- 26:21desperately encouraging employees to
- 26:24work long hours even if they weren't
- 26:26being productive the amount of time you
- 26:28spent at work was what made you a good
- 26:31loyal employee he also at once called
- 26:33the cops on a worker who refused to sign
- 26:35an NDA hysterically accusing him of
- 26:38stealing property in his mind in short
- 26:41Sunny was this unqualified rich guy who
- 26:44used his position in theranos to LARP as
- 26:46a dictator because come on it's not like
- 26:48this guy knew anything about chemistry
- 26:50or health care every day he'd pull up to
- 26:52work in his blacked out Lambo and
- 26:54proceed to misunderstand basic
- 26:56scientific terms in front of the entire
- 26:58team mistaking the term end effector for
- 27:01Indo factor a word that doesn't exist
- 27:04needless to say this guy wasn't the
- 27:06smartest meanwhile Elizabeth had
- 27:08commissioned a former Logitech employee
- 27:10Tony Nugent to improve the way blood
- 27:13samples were being handled in the lab
- 27:15with all of the constraints Elizabeth
- 27:16posed Nugent figured automation was the
- 27:19best way to go but since building a
- 27:21robot from scratch is hard he decided to
- 27:24just buy one a three thousand dollar
- 27:26mechanical arm with three degrees of
- 27:28motion that Nugent programmed to mimic
- 27:30the movements of a chemist in a lab
- 27:33working with only 50 microliters of
- 27:36blood this prized machine was later
- 27:38named The Edison being described as an
- 27:408th grade science project by those who
- 27:42had seen it in action one whistleblower
- 27:44later referring to it as a quote piece
- 27:47of crap consisting of six pipette tips
- 27:49that would constantly break off in the
- 27:51middle of tests get stuck in the gears
- 27:54causing the gears to jam up sometimes
- 27:56the tips wouldn't eject so they'd use
- 27:58coat hangers to free up the gears if
- 28:01they didn't just straight up user bare
- 28:03hands subjecting themselves to all kinds
- 28:05of pointy objects and toxic chemicals
- 28:07sure the Edison looked Sleek on the
- 28:10outside but with such a far cry away
- 28:12from Elizabeth's original Vision on the
- 28:15inside on the rare times it did work it
- 28:18only carried out immunoassay tests which
- 28:21only detect drug levels hormone levels
- 28:23and some cancer makers but their scope
- 28:26is limited this meant the Edison could
- 28:28not run the full range of tests
- 28:30Elizabeth had been telling investors
- 28:32it's like she cared more about The
- 28:34Branding than the actual mechanics that
- 28:36you know affect patients well-being
- 28:38theranos has struck a partnership with
- 28:40drugstore chain Walgreens to build
- 28:42thousands of wellness centers it wasn't
- 28:44until the Silicon Valley Boom at the
- 28:47beginning of 2010 the theranos
- 28:49officially reached out to Walgreens
- 28:51touting the productivity of the Edison
- 28:53via email and insisting they had the
- 28:56capability to run any blood test with no
- 28:58more than a few drops of blood fricked
- 29:01from the finger a pitch they knew was a
- 29:04lie but Walgreens didn't know that and
- 29:06became highly interested in doing away
- 29:08with their slower more expensive labs
- 29:11and arranged a meeting almost
- 29:13immediately it was with the help of an
- 29:15enthusiastic Walgreens team member Dr J
- 29:18that an agreement was reached theranos
- 29:20readers would be used in 30 to 90
- 29:23Walgreens stores no later than the
- 29:25middle of 2011. if it worked it could
- 29:28benefit everybody involved it would give
- 29:30patients the opportunity to receive
- 29:32blood tests in under an hour it gave
- 29:34theranos the chance to land another
- 29:36massive partnership and it would let
- 29:38Walgreens make a ton of money Walgreens
- 29:40was moving especially fast in this
- 29:42instance out of fear that theranos would
- 29:45soon be swept up by CVS if they didn't
- 29:47act now plus it helped that Dr J had the
- 29:50ear of the Walgreens CFO who excitedly
- 29:52hopped on board as well to further
- 29:55convince them theranos bragged to
- 29:56Walgreens about its commercially ready
- 29:58lab that could handle 192 blood tests on
- 30:02their own devices had anyone from
- 30:04Walgreens actually been given the chance
- 30:06to explore a said lab however they'd
- 30:08find that it was only an r d lab for
- 30:11research purposes and that half the
- 30:13tests they listed couldn't even be
- 30:14performed on The Edison but Elizabeth
- 30:16and other Top members of theranos
- 30:19repeatedly refused to let anyone from
- 30:21the Walgreens Camp actually see the lab
- 30:25Elizabeth had sooner gifted them an
- 30:27autographed flag than an actual look at
- 30:30their technology and when they finally
- 30:32did conduct a live test on the Edison by
- 30:35pricking the fingers of top Walgreens
- 30:36Executives and making a big show of it
- 30:39they never ended up sending the results
- 30:42it was around this time that a man named
- 30:44Kevin Hunter who had been sent by
- 30:46Walgreens to make sure theranos was on
- 30:47the up and up weren't in a report that
- 30:50the company quote might be overselling
- 30:52or overstating where they are at
- 30:55scientifically with the cartridges and
- 30:57devices but Walgreens still did not want
- 31:00to risk losing out on on such potential
- 31:02one executive telling Hunter we can't
- 31:05not pursue this we can't risk a scenario
- 31:07where CVS has a deal with them in six
- 31:09months and it ends up being real but
- 31:11they weren't the only ones with fomo the
- 31:13supermarket chain Safeway had also been
- 31:16eyeing theranos and ended up signing a
- 31:18deal in 2010 for a 30 million dollar
- 31:20loan and significant overhaul of Safeway
- 31:23stores which included adding brand new
- 31:25Labs where customers to get their blood
- 31:27tested in minutes by this point
- 31:30everything was falling into place
- 31:32theranos had secured two major
- 31:34Distributors raised more Capital funding
- 31:37and seemed to be on a great path to
- 31:39success if things weren't collapsing
- 31:41behind the scenes of course see theranos
- 31:44wanted to go live with a new product
- 31:45they called the mini lab which Elizabeth
- 31:48believed was quote the most important
- 31:51thing Humanity had ever built as the
- 31:54name suggests it was basically a bunch
- 31:56of already existing equipment shrunk
- 31:59down into a tiny little box to put
- 32:01bluntly the mini lab or 4S was a
- 32:04conceptual Nightmare and was still in
- 32:06the very early prototype stages by 2013.
- 32:10almost three whole years after theranos
- 32:13had originally planned to launch with
- 32:15Walgreens they had nothing to show but
- 32:17by that point Walgreens couldn't wait
- 32:19any longer the partnership was going to
- 32:22fall through if theranos didn't go live
- 32:24with something theranos needed access to
- 32:28patients and Walgreens made that happen
- 32:30by opening wellness centers inside its
- 32:33stores
- 32:34theranos received their first real blast
- 32:37of national recognition from The Wall
- 32:39Street Journal with a headline that
- 32:41praised Elizabeth for her breakthrough
- 32:43of instant diagnosis the 2013 article
- 32:46made therano sound to be the solution to
- 32:48painful slow and expensive blood testing
- 32:51serving as a resounding endorsement of
- 32:54Elizabeth other than its quite
- 32:56unflattering illustration I have to say
- 32:58the journal would not decide how the
- 33:00company's devices could quote automate
- 33:02and miniaturize more than a thousand
- 33:04laboratory tests from routine blood work
- 33:06to Advanced genetic analysis using a
- 33:10simple finger stick to draw a few
- 33:12droplets of blood from the capillaries
- 33:14at the end of your hand the blood would
- 33:16be placed into a vile Elizabeth dubbed
- 33:19the Nano Tanner which could hold a blood
- 33:21sample no bigger than the size of a
- 33:23raindrop you'd have your results almost
- 33:25instantaneously she promised just a few
- 33:28days after the article theranos set the
- 33:30mini lab aside to launch the Edison and
- 33:33select Walgreens stores along with their
- 33:35own website after a decade in stealth
- 33:38mode Elizabeth had finally publicized
- 33:41her life-saving technology that she
- 33:43insisted was a godsend for society and
- 33:46for about the next year and a half
- 33:48that's what everyone else thought too
- 33:51Elizabeth home is part of the news time
- 33:54100 list just out Elizabeth Holmes from
- 33:56theranos Elizabeth for example she has
- 33:59become wildly popular among those bucks
- 34:01who follow things like this appearing on
- 34:03the covers of Forbes Fortune tea and ink
- 34:06magazine in one illustrious cover story
- 34:09after another I guess these magazines
- 34:11just can't get enough of Rich frauds but
- 34:13at the time it was hard to deny how
- 34:15inspiring her journey was here was this
- 34:18female College Dropout who had worked 10
- 34:21years building one of the biggest
- 34:23companies in a male dominated industry
- 34:25wired called her achievements
- 34:27mind-blowing the New Yorker gave her a
- 34:29glowing profile and Time magazine named
- 34:32her among the top 100 most influential
- 34:35people in the world she was being
- 34:37compared to the likes of Bill Gates Mark
- 34:40Zuckerberg and especially her own
- 34:42personal role model Steve Jobs Elizabeth
- 34:45had idolized the Apple Foundry since the
- 34:47early days of her career and worked
- 34:49tirelessly to match his product activity
- 34:51and creative Outlook right down to her
- 34:54wardrobe sporting jobs as signature
- 34:57black turtleneck every day adopting a
- 34:59similar diet hiring security detail
- 35:02snatching up former Apple employees to
- 35:05work at theranos and even commissioning
- 35:07his advertising agency to make their
- 35:10commercials
- 35:11I've always followed a challenge and I
- 35:13think the reason I got into engineering
- 35:15was because I looked at it and I said
- 35:16that looks hard it's so empowering and
- 35:19Powerful to to be a part of a company
- 35:21created by a woman who is so incredibly
- 35:24intelligent and also nurturing next to
- 35:27every glass ceiling there's an iron lady
- 35:28she even referred to her technology as
- 35:32the iPod of healthcare everyone knew
- 35:34Elizabeth was obsessed with Steve Jobs
- 35:36in fact when his biography came out
- 35:38those at theranos who were also reading
- 35:41it could tell what part of the book she
- 35:43was at by the way she was talking and
- 35:45behaving that's how much she ripped this
- 35:47guy off maintaining a particular image
- 35:49became her top priority it's almost like
- 35:52she got so swept up in the hype of being
- 35:54a media darling that she forgot that her
- 35:56technology was a practical failure
- 35:58behind the scenes as far as the public
- 36:00was concerned theranos was the new Apple
- 36:03by this point their board of directors
- 36:05consisted of former Secretary of States
- 36:08Henry Kissinger future Secretary of
- 36:10Defense Jim Mattis Wells Fargo CEO
- 36:13Richard kovich [ __ ] man Richard kavoked
- 36:17hang on kavachovich kavachovich former
- 36:20Secretary of Defense William Perry
- 36:22former CDC director William foage and
- 36:25another former Secretary of State George
- 36:28Schultz who served under President
- 36:30Ronald Reagan during the Iran Contra and
- 36:33Cold War you know she's got the probably
- 36:34one of the most impressive Boards of any
- 36:36startup with Henry Kissinger and former
- 36:38Secretary of State George Schultz I
- 36:40talked to Henry Kissinger who said she
- 36:41is iron willed about getting this done
- 36:43such a powerful board of directors was
- 36:46practically unheard of and offered a new
- 36:48level of legitimacy to what theranos
- 36:50claims to be doing to top it all off
- 36:52Elizabeth managed to raise more than 700
- 36:55million dollars of capital funding
- 36:57thanks to the help of colossal investors
- 37:00including Fox News owner Rupert Murdoch
- 37:03oracle's Larry Ellison future Secretary
- 37:05of Education Betsy DeVos and the Walton
- 37:08family of Walmart inflating the value of
- 37:11theranos to nearly 10 billion dollars at
- 37:14its Zenith with Elizabeth owning half
- 37:16the company in 2015 this officially
- 37:19brought her personal net worth to an
- 37:22estimated 4.5 billion dollars the
- 37:25youngest billionaire in the world
- 37:28is that heady when you hear that
- 37:31you know it's it's not what matters
- 37:33um what matters is how well we do in
- 37:37trying to make people's lives better
- 37:38that's that's why I'm doing this that's
- 37:40why I work the way that I work and
- 37:42that's why I love what I'm doing so much
- 37:44at that point theranos had made it to
- 37:47the top of the mountain Elizabeth was
- 37:49doing TED Talks being invited to speak
- 37:51at various institutions and could barely
- 37:53walk down the street without being sworn
- 37:55by ravenous young fans who admired her
- 37:58more importantly she was also cozying up
- 38:00with the Obama Administration in a move
- 38:02that some wondered was a calculated ploy
- 38:05to avoid potential regulatory scrutiny
- 38:08down the line after all schmoozing the
- 38:10most powerful individuals in the country
- 38:12had seemed to work in shielding her for
- 38:14most doubters if she could ever become
- 38:16Pals with the president of the United
- 38:18States she may just be unstoppable so in
- 38:21July 2015 when then Vice President Joe
- 38:24Biden planned to visit theranos's
- 38:27California facility Elizabeth was
- 38:29determined to do everything she could to
- 38:31make a great impression which included
- 38:34staging an entire fake lab with fake
- 38:37equipment instead of taking Biden on a
- 38:39tour of their actual workplace Elizabeth
- 38:42and sunny cobbled together in erroneous
- 38:45display of defunct equipment that if
- 38:47anyone had tried using wouldn't actually
- 38:49do anything the entire event was nothing
- 38:52more than a pathetic theatrical display
- 38:54to impress the country and it worked the
- 38:58meeting ended with Biden making it
- 39:00apparent that he along with the entire
- 39:02Administration saw Elizabeth Holmes as a
- 39:06leading figure in the medicine World a
- 39:09much hyped Silicon Valley startup had a
- 39:11special visitor today we mentioned
- 39:12earlier in this newscast Vice President
- 39:14Joe Biden spending time at theranos it
- 39:17wants to shake up the health care
- 39:18industry it's made some progress so far
- 39:21and today got a big boost though if the
- 39:24people praising her actually knew what
- 39:26was going on behind closed doors they
- 39:29discovered that Elizabeth's Edison
- 39:31device could only test for about 15 of
- 39:34the 240 illnesses they advertised on
- 39:38their menu as it was later found out
- 39:39that theranos had been conducting the
- 39:41vast majority authority of its tests on
- 39:44other companies machines secretly buying
- 39:47commercial analyzers from Simon's in
- 39:49bulk as opposed to actually using the
- 39:51product they insisted would change the
- 39:54world the truth was the Edison was a
- 39:56piece of garbage pushing some employees
- 39:59to the point of quitting when they could
- 40:00no longer cope with the fact that these
- 40:02broken machines were being used on real
- 40:05life patients culminating with a
- 40:07concerned whistleblower at theranos
- 40:09reaching out to Federal Regulators
- 40:11rumors began to spread that the company
- 40:13was obscuring test results deleting
- 40:16outliers that would have caused the
- 40:17Edison to fail quality control checks
- 40:20which is not just unethical but highly
- 40:22illegal that whistleblower was Tyler
- 40:25Schultz the grandson of board member
- 40:27George Schultz who at that point had
- 40:29taken Elizabeth in as a close family
- 40:31friend in fact Tyler only applied at
- 40:34theranos when he ran into Elizabeth that
- 40:36his grandfather is home being hired to
- 40:38work in their protein engineering lab in
- 40:402013 what Tyler witnessed missed it
- 40:43theranos was far from the Utopia he had
- 40:45seen her spew to investors describing
- 40:48the blockades and locked doors that
- 40:51sprawled throughout its headquarters
- 40:53Tyler Maines tamed that many who worked
- 40:55at the company had never actually seen
- 40:58their own blood testing machines there
- 41:00was a list of words he wasn't allowed to
- 41:02say when describing his job to people
- 41:04and the morale was basically in the
- 41:06toilet probably because the amazing
- 41:08invention that had been hyped up to the
- 41:10entire world was just a pipette in a box
- 41:13which barely worked as it was when it
- 41:16often malfunctioned Tyler says he
- 41:18witnessed employees shoving their entire
- 41:20hands into the box even when highly
- 41:23dangerous chemicals like potassium
- 41:25cyanide were still inside I was told
- 41:28when I was working with it to be
- 41:29extremely careful because it was what
- 41:31Hitler used to kill himself then an
- 41:34engineer goes in and reaches in with his
- 41:36bare hands and you're just like no
- 41:38evidently theranos took lab safety about
- 41:41as seriously as it took quality control
- 41:43the company puts speed above anything
- 41:46else according to several key Witnesses
- 41:48including Erica Chung another major
- 41:51whistleblower who later testified
- 41:52against Elizabeth in court she argued
- 41:55the machines were never recalibrated
- 41:57because quote that would take days and
- 42:00with the lack of breaks employees were
- 42:02made to sleep in their cars while they
- 42:04waited Erica even kept a tally of all
- 42:07the times the tech failed quality
- 42:09control checks and when she'd put up
- 42:11error report sheets by the machines
- 42:13they'd just be taken down people didn't
- 42:15want to actually know the number of
- 42:17times that we were having issues because
- 42:19they were starting to realize we were
- 42:21having them so frequently she stated
- 42:23employees were heavily pressured into
- 42:25lying to doctors and Regulators out of
- 42:27fear of getting fired or sued by the
- 42:30company this cost such a massive problem
- 42:32that people were leaving in droves
- 42:34creating a high turnover rate that
- 42:37resulted in a lab director being
- 42:38replaced by a [ __ ] dermatologist at
- 42:41one point employee were a secretly
- 42:43forwarding emails from their theranos
- 42:45account to their personal ones so they
- 42:47could clear their name if the time ever
- 42:49came for a federal investigation that's
- 42:51how it's Shady all of this was Elizabeth
- 42:53and sunny were so freakishly paranoid
- 42:56about people going to authorities that
- 42:58they monitored all employee interactions
- 43:01by prohibiting various departments from
- 43:03speaking to each other as you can
- 43:05imagine hampering communication between
- 43:07the engineering team and chemistry lab
- 43:10made a working together to create a
- 43:12revolutionary medical device
- 43:14unreasonably difficult in court it was
- 43:16even revealed that two theranos lab
- 43:18directors both in charge of the same lab
- 43:21weren't even aware of each other's
- 43:23existence until the trial each
- 43:25department was required to go directly
- 43:27to the top when they had a question or
- 43:30concern Elizabeth made sure that she was
- 43:32the only one who knew what was happening
- 43:35in all departments and as she intended
- 43:37to keep it that way in the name of
- 43:39proprietary information and Trade
- 43:41Secrets which was really just code for
- 43:44her not wanting to listen to any
- 43:45potential concerns writing off worried
- 43:48employees is just vicious detractors if
- 43:50she didn't fire you on the spot she'd
- 43:53threatened to or at least see to it that
- 43:55you were ostracized from the rest of the
- 43:57company making sure you were rightfully
- 43:59punished for challenging the company's
- 44:01Vision long time theranos Chief
- 44:04scientist Ian Gibbons had indicated to
- 44:06his wife these problems from the very
- 44:08beginning as he had been with the
- 44:10company since 2005. being an
- 44:12accomplished inventor himself with over
- 44:1560 patents to his name Ian did not take
- 44:18his craft lightly and began to notice
- 44:20serious problems with the way the
- 44:22company was run as his wife later told
- 44:25CBS he started talking to me about all
- 44:27these Investments all the money that the
- 44:29company was bringing in and he told me
- 44:31that he couldn't imagine why people were
- 44:33giving the company any money because
- 44:35there was no invention there was nothing
- 44:37there adding Elizabeth lives about
- 44:40everything after racing these concern
- 44:42times with Elizabeth and board member
- 44:43Channing Robertson Ian was fired rehired
- 44:47and demoted all within a couple hours
- 44:49working at a lesser rank than before
- 44:52Ian's a passion for the company dwindled
- 44:55significantly over the next few years
- 44:57and it didn't help that he was also
- 44:59showing signs of depression in the
- 45:01meantime when he was eventually issued a
- 45:03court subpoena in an unrelated patent
- 45:05dispute against Elizabeth Ian became it
- 45:08terrified the testifying against his
- 45:10boss would breach the terms of his NDA
- 45:12and result in losing his job the day
- 45:15before he was set to testify Ian
- 45:17overdosed on Tylenol and died in the
- 45:20hospital a few days later when his wife
- 45:22Rachelle notified Elizabeth of Ian's
- 45:25passing she received no call back simply
- 45:28acknowledging the death of a top
- 45:30scientist who had been with the company
- 45:31from the very beginning was not on
- 45:33Elizabeth's agenda and instead Rachelle
- 45:36got nothing other than an office manager
- 45:38calling back and asking her to return
- 45:40Ian's company property work resumed like
- 45:43clockwork with Elizabeth pretending like
- 45:46nothing had happened to this day
- 45:48Rachelle is convinced her husband would
- 45:50still be alive had he not gone to work
- 45:53at theranos I think of it every day I
- 45:56mean
- 45:57I think of it all the time
- 45:59do you believe that if Ian
- 46:02had not gone to work for theranos that
- 46:04he would be oh yeah for sure no question
- 46:06many ex-employees can attest to the fact
- 46:09that Elizabeth and sunny created a
- 46:11culture of hostility at theranos but
- 46:14their intimidation tactics could only go
- 46:16so far doing little to deter Tyler
- 46:18Schultz from speaking with an
- 46:20investigative journalist by the name of
- 46:22John Kerry Roo a man who had spent
- 46:24nearly that entire year carefully
- 46:27crafting a series of articles for the
- 46:29Wall Street Journal exposing theranos
- 46:31for who they really were by interviewing
- 46:33countless employees and doctors Kerry
- 46:36Roo confirmed that the vast majority of
- 46:39tests were not being conducted on
- 46:41theranos equipment but instead other
- 46:43commercial testers due to how unreliable
- 46:46the Edison truly was in fact most
- 46:49theranos testing centers were using
- 46:51blood from the arm the exact method
- 46:54theranos set out to destroy the way
- 46:56their system worked included drawing
- 46:59blood the traditional way in the clinic
- 47:01then since using blood samples via FedEx
- 47:04truck to their California Lab where
- 47:06they'd be tested either by humans or
- 47:09Siemens analyzers but hardly any of it
- 47:12was being done on the Edison's
- 47:14themselves because he reached out to
- 47:16Elizabeth for comment before the story
- 47:19was released she knew it was coming and
- 47:21had already deployed her legal muscle
- 47:23David boyes who began strong arming
- 47:25whistleblowers David boys rocketed to
- 47:28National Fame by defending presidential
- 47:30candidate Al Gore in the 2000 election
- 47:32recount successfully arguing to overturn
- 47:35California's homophobic proposition a
- 47:37grilling Bill Gates in a suit against
- 47:39Microsoft and defending yeah boys has a
- 47:44pretty textured background to say the
- 47:46least and Elizabeth was paying him in
- 47:48Company stock which meant he also sat on
- 47:51the board of directors in a possible
- 47:52conflict of interest that she used to
- 47:55her Advantage he was more than
- 47:56financially obligated to see the
- 47:59survival of the company by any means
- 48:01necessary so he had no problem running
- 48:03up Hefty legal bills for whistleblowers
- 48:06which almost made Tyler's parents sell
- 48:08their house but that was of little
- 48:10concern to Elizabeth by the time October
- 48:132015 rolled around
- 48:16[Music]
- 48:17as soon as the first few articles
- 48:20dropped Elizabeth Holmes put herself
- 48:22directly in the line of fire instead of
- 48:25canceling an upcoming conference with
- 48:27the Wall Street Journal in Laguna Beach
- 48:29she used the event to hit back at her
- 48:31detractors and double down on her
- 48:33company's practices you've said that the
- 48:36journal's reporting has been erroneous
- 48:38and grounded in faceless assertions she
- 48:41expressed concern for the misinformation
- 48:44she claimed to have been spread by the
- 48:46journal and denied accusations that
- 48:48theranos was using commercially
- 48:50available equipment for its tests she
- 48:52asserted that their full commitment to
- 48:54transparency was evident by their
- 48:56willingness to voluntarily seek FDA
- 48:59approval but didn't acknowledge that
- 49:01theranos had been operating in sort of a
- 49:03gray Zone where because their tests were
- 49:06considered lab developed the FDA had
- 49:08little to no oversight as The Verge put
- 49:11it if a test is designed by and used in
- 49:14a single lab that lab is allowed to sell
- 49:17and advertise the test without the FDA
- 49:19sign off it's a dangerous loophole that
- 49:22still lingers to this day overall
- 49:25Elizabeth made it clear that she wasn't
- 49:27about to back down in the face of
- 49:29journalistic scrutiny maintaining her
- 49:31innocence even a safe way and Walgreens
- 49:33pulled back over the coming months
- 49:35Safeway unable to turn any kind of
- 49:38profit at all after already sinking 350
- 49:41million dollars into building on-site
- 49:43theranos clinics and their stores
- 49:45dissolved their partnership before they
- 49:47could even get their hands on any
- 49:49devices Walgreens announced it would no
- 49:51longer be sending tests to theranos's
- 49:53California lab and suspended all
- 49:56theranos services at its Palo Alto
- 49:58location following a letter from CMS
- 50:01stating theranos's lab had failed to
- 50:03comply with Federal standards to an
- 50:06extent that put patients lives in
- 50:08immediate Jeopardy giving theranos 10
- 50:10days to fix things or else Elizabeth and
- 50:13sunny would risk being banned from
- 50:15running laboratory as a result Sunny
- 50:18exited the company in May 2016. some
- 50:21speculate this was around the time he
- 50:23and Elizabeth broke up but the details
- 50:25around their personal lives will always
- 50:26be a bit fuzzy what we do know is that
- 50:29same month theranos decided to void two
- 50:32years worth of blood tests in what the
- 50:34journal estimated corrected tens of
- 50:36thousands of blood reports with new
- 50:39leaks and information being published
- 50:41every other week things were coming
- 50:43apart fast as far as their value went
- 50:45farados was in a free fall and it didn't
- 50:48look like shake-ups to the board were
- 50:50helping much either by that summer
- 50:52Walgreens closed their 40 theranos
- 50:54locations as Forbes heavily reduced the
- 50:57company's valuation bringing Elizabeth's
- 50:59personal net worth down from 4.5 billion
- 51:03to zero just as it seemed Elizabeth had
- 51:05lost it all CMS officially revoked her
- 51:09license in July 2016. Elizabeth could
- 51:12not run a lab for two years the company
- 51:15became the epitome of a car crash she
- 51:17just couldn't look away from but
- 51:19Elizabeth was convinced she could still
- 51:21turn things around in spite of such
- 51:24public degradation
- 51:27in an attempt to bypass CMS stipulations
- 51:30Elizabeth abandoned the idea of using
- 51:33Labs or clinics at all revealing in
- 51:36August 2016 the mini lab meant to
- 51:39replace the now condemned Edison
- 51:40Elizabeth insisted the new and improved
- 51:434S could handle a range of more varied
- 51:46tests including zika which was pretty
- 51:49widespread at that time Elizabeth
- 51:50presented it as the last Hail Mary to
- 51:53save the company from sure failure
- 51:55claiming it would one day be able to
- 51:57test tiny drops of blood for viral and
- 52:00bacterial infections analyze blood
- 52:03chemistry probe for problems in the
- 52:05immune system and assess crucial blood
- 52:07components that could ideally save
- 52:09Millions this technology that we
- 52:12introduced today is the latest version
- 52:14of our mini lab technology and what we
- 52:16wanted to do was introduce the invention
- 52:18and the capability to run a broad range
- 52:21of assay methods on a single platform
- 52:24but nobody was having it theranos was
- 52:26slammed with law lawsuit after lawsuit
- 52:28their biggest investor partner fund
- 52:30management accusing theranos of Security
- 52:32fraud seeking 96 million dollars in
- 52:36Damages the company was forced to lay
- 52:38off hundreds of employees as Walgreens
- 52:40sued them for 140 million the amount
- 52:43they had initially sunk into theranos
- 52:45years prior while they settled for way
- 52:47less than that a year later the company
- 52:49was on its last legs by 2017. laying off
- 52:53almost half of the remaining staff
- 52:56before failing a second regulatory lab
- 52:59inspection in September forcing them to
- 53:01shut down their last remaining
- 53:03laboratory right then and there after
- 53:05being exposed by the media pummeled by
- 53:08lawsuits and slammed by Regulators
- 53:10theranos had no choice but to dissolve
- 53:13in 2018 but not before Elizabeth and
- 53:16sunny face the music themselves I'm
- 53:19gonna follow my counsel's instructions
- 53:21I'm going to follow my counsel's
- 53:22instructions following his instructions
- 53:27[Music]
- 53:30Shadows walking by you
- 53:35on March 14 2018 the former couple were
- 53:39each personally charged with a massive
- 53:42fraud by the SEC who claimed the two
- 53:44raised money under faulty circumstances
- 53:46or in their words through an elaborate
- 53:48years-long fraud in which they
- 53:50exaggerated or made false statements
- 53:53about the company's technology business
- 53:55and financial performance the complaint
- 53:58also alleged Elizabeth and sunny both
- 54:00knew that the Edison could only carry
- 54:02out 12 of the 200 tested advertised on
- 54:06its patent testing menu which up until
- 54:08this point was only hearsay finally an
- 54:11official government institution was
- 54:13looking at theranos through a more
- 54:15appropriate critical lens as the SEC
- 54:18went on to further insist the company
- 54:20lied about its Revenue projections
- 54:22claimed regulatory approval for their
- 54:25devices was voluntary when it wasn't and
- 54:28they had in fact been using slightly
- 54:30modified third-party Machinery without
- 54:33the public knowing the SECU some of
- 54:36Elizabeth's own public statements
- 54:37against her too citing multiple
- 54:39instances where she lied to make the
- 54:41company seem more legit to the media she
- 54:43would then use that positive attention
- 54:45to get more money from investors not to
- 54:47mention how she'd illegally slap the
- 54:49Pfizer and John Hopkins logos on fake
- 54:52lab reports to make themselves out to be
- 54:54some serious health care entity
- 54:56everything was conducted under a false
- 54:58pretense that the technology was far
- 55:00more advanced than what the chemists
- 55:02engineers and technicians on the inside
- 55:04kept telling Elizabeth the evidence
- 55:07proves she was warned time and time
- 55:09again about the status of their
- 55:11technology but her willful ignorance got
- 55:14the best of her as she continued to
- 55:16deceive everyone on the outside
- 55:17Elizabeth had even doubted her
- 55:19relationship with Jim Mattis to make it
- 55:21seem Thera knows how to track record of
- 55:24working with the Department of Defense
- 55:25while it's true Elizabeth had hoped to
- 55:28eventually use Edison devices to test on
- 55:31soldiers overseas this never would have
- 55:33happened given the FDA guideline times
- 55:35they needed to have met together the
- 55:37charges involved over 700 million
- 55:40dollars and in June 2018 Elizabeth and
- 55:43sunny were both indicted on criminal
- 55:45wire fraud charges over engaging in a
- 55:48multi-million dollar scheme to defraud
- 55:50investors patients and doctors delayed
- 55:53by covid and more than one possible
- 55:56strategic pregnancy Elizabeth's trial
- 55:58found her guilty on four of the 11
- 56:00federal charges what's interesting is
- 56:03that she was actually found not guilty
- 56:04on four other charges related to
- 56:06defrauding patients but regardless in
- 56:09November 2022 Elizabeth was sentenced to
- 56:1311 years and three months in federal
- 56:15prison with sunny getting almost an
- 56:17identical sentence in December ensuring
- 56:19the two will live out the next decade of
- 56:22their lives behind bars for swindling
- 56:24hundreds of millions of dollars from
- 56:26unsuspecting investors and putting the
- 56:29lives of countless Innocents in Jeopardy
- 56:31all in the name of careless arrogance
- 56:33and false Innovation every person should
- 56:36have the ability to get that type of
- 56:37test because if you understand that
- 56:40early that you're at risk there's a lot
- 56:43more that you can do about it and we'd
- 56:45like to see a world in which every
- 56:47person
- 56:48gets access to this type of basic
- 56:51testing and the types of tests that are
- 56:53done or ones that provide insight into
- 56:56the onset of disease in time to do
- 56:59something about it we may never know
- 57:01whether or not Elizabeth truly believed
- 57:03in theranos's Mission while her initial
- 57:06goal after dropping out of college may
- 57:08not have been to endanger patients and
- 57:10to bark on a decades-long fraud to
- 57:12Swindle the country's richest people out
- 57:14of hundreds of millions of dollars it's
- 57:16just kind of what happened if you ask me
- 57:18the tragedy of Elizabeth Holmes is a
- 57:20combination of unrealistic ambition and
- 57:23unrelenting ego Elizabeth took fake it
- 57:26till you make it to a whole new level
- 57:28and ended up Landing herself in jail
- 57:30when her technology failed to live up to
- 57:32her incredibly lofty Vision at the
- 57:35beginning she figured she could just
- 57:36make certain promises and to iron out
- 57:38the details later on but before she knew
- 57:40it all those little white lies began to
- 57:43pile up into a massive fraud her goal
- 57:46may have been to revolutionize an
- 57:48industry and become a cultural Pioneer
- 57:50in the meantime but the problem is she
- 57:52put more effort into the latter than
- 57:54perfecting what would have actually
- 57:55gotten her there inside her
- 57:57paranoia-ridden mind she had all the
- 58:00answers and anyone who said differently
- 58:02was only trying to deter her from
- 58:04whatever pipe dream she had conjured up
- 58:06she'd rather fix on the trivial nature
- 58:08of theranos's branding then wastes time
- 58:10on the boring difficult and confusing
- 58:13details of what would actually breathe
- 58:15life into her idea but as we've seen you
- 58:18can't afford to do that when the
- 58:20well-being of patience is at the heart
- 58:22of your idea why so many people continue
- 58:24to have faith in her vision I think
- 58:27comes down to human nature with the way
- 58:29our brains work it's often we see
- 58:31someone speaking with enough Charisma
- 58:33and conviction that we just kind of
- 58:35assume whatever they're saying is legit
- 58:37plus it's not like anyone wanted it to
- 58:39be false people unfortunately lose loved
- 58:41ones to infectious diseases and Cancers
- 58:44all the time and the prospect that maybe
- 58:46we don't have to say goodbye too soon is
- 58:49a powerful one maybe it's some form of
- 58:51what Elizabeth envisioned can still
- 58:53happen one day but I just don't think
- 58:55we're there the plan was always too
- 58:58ambitious from the start but Elizabeth
- 59:00would rather stop at nothing to pursue
- 59:03an idealistic reality where she wins
- 59:05then listen to the more Xperia against
- 59:07grounded voices around her proving the
- 59:10story of Elizabeth Holmes to be one of
- 59:13extraordinary aspiration followed by
- 59:15crushing defeat in the form of a
- 59:17devastating reality check and bounce
- 59:20houses
- 59:24[Music]
- 59:33keep on keep running
- 59:37[Music]
- 59:41foreign
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of The Crimes of Elizabeth Holmes | A 10 Billion Dollar Fraud by j aubrey, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 9,591 words across 1,497 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.