The Century of the Self - Part 4: "Eight People Sipping Wine in Kettering" — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:02you're moving through a world in which
- 0:04everything is possible and nothing
- 0:06nothing is beyond you this is the story
- 0:10of the rise of an idea that has come to
- 0:12dominate our
- 0:13society it is the belief that the
- 0:15satisfaction of individual feelings and
- 0:17desires is our highest priority today
- 0:21we're going to tell you how to get
- 0:23whatever you want I wanted to live a
- 0:26different life that wasn't available to
- 0:27me in the image I was born I am here
- 0:30look at me Notice Me previous episodes
- 0:33have shown how this rise of the self was
- 0:36fostered and promoted by
- 0:38business they had used the ideas of
- 0:40Sigman Freud to develop techniques to
- 0:43read the inner desires of individuals
- 0:46and then fulfill them with
- 0:49products this final episode is about how
- 0:53that idea took over
- 0:55politics it tells the story of how
- 0:57politicians on the left in both America
- 1:00and Britain turned to these techniques
- 1:02to regain
- 1:04power they believed that they were
- 1:06creating a new and better form of
- 1:09democracy one that truly responded to
- 1:11the inner feelings of
- 1:14individuals but what the politicians
- 1:16didn't realize was that the aim of those
- 1:18who had originally created these
- 1:20techniques had not been to liberate the
- 1:22people but to develop a new way of
- 1:25controlling them in an age of mass
- 1:27democracy
- 1:29[Music]
- 1:40the roots of the story lie way back in
- 1:42the America of the 1920s with one
- 1:45man he was called Edward bernes the
- 1:48nephew of Sigman
- 1:49Freud bernes had been one of the
- 1:51inventors of the profession of public
- 1:53relations and he was fascinated by his
- 1:56uncle's theory that human behavior was
- 1:58driven by unconscious sexual and
- 2:00aggressive
- 2:02drives many of Bern's clients were large
- 2:05American
- 2:06corporations and he was the first person
- 2:08to show them how they could sell many
- 2:10more products if they linked them
- 2:12through images and symbols to those
- 2:14unconscious desires that Freud had
- 2:18identified the strategy he offered them
- 2:22was that people could now look at the
- 2:25goods that were emerging within this
- 2:27society and not merely view the those
- 2:30goods as things that they needed in
- 2:32order to deal with some specific
- 2:34material want but also as Goods which
- 2:37would stroke and respond to deep
- 2:40emotional
- 2:42yearnings you know how this bar of soap
- 2:46or this bag of flour will make you a
- 2:49happier more successful more sexually
- 2:51appealing less fearful person somebody
- 2:53to be admired rather than
- 2:56reviled the powerful people in that
- 2:59world are those those people who were
- 3:00capable of reading the public mind and
- 3:03giving the public uh what it wants in
- 3:06those
- 3:06terms and bernes was at the heart of it
- 3:09bernes was the guy who was the foremost
- 3:12articulator of the theories which were
- 3:15driving this new
- 3:18system by the 1980s Bern's ideas had
- 3:22come of age a vast industry had grown up
- 3:25in America devoted to reading the inner
- 3:27desires of consumers but its heart was
- 3:30the technique of the focus
- 3:32group previous episodes have shown how
- 3:34the focus group was invented by
- 3:36psychoanalysts employed by us
- 3:39corporations the aim was to allow
- 3:41consumers to express their inner
- 3:43feelings and needs just as patients did
- 3:45in
- 3:47psychoanalysis the information was then
- 3:49used to promote and design new products
- 3:52that would fulfill those
- 3:54desires and Edward bernes who was now
- 3:57nearly 100 years old was celebrated is
- 3:59the founding father of this marketing
- 4:03World hi doctor good to see you come on
- 4:07up over here there you
- 4:09go doctor what uh tell me again what the
- 4:12doctor is what are we dealing with
- 4:13you're the father of public relations
- 4:15with really is the concept that people
- 4:19will believe me more if you call me
- 4:22doctor oh I
- 4:26see so
- 4:30that's a good idea and Bern's ideas and
- 4:33techniques were also about to conquer
- 4:35Britain in the
- 4:361980s unlike America the ruling Elites
- 4:39in Britain had always distrusted the
- 4:41idea of pandering to the
- 4:43masses it was epitomized by the
- 4:46Patrician Elite who ran the
- 4:48BBC even as late as the 60s popular
- 4:51programmers were referred to as
- 4:53groundbait their real job was to lure
- 4:55the viewers into watching the more
- 4:57serious programs the elite knew was good
- 4:59for
- 5:02them and market research reflected this
- 5:05attitude individuals were observed and
- 5:08classified by market researchers
- 5:10according to their social class from a
- 5:13through C2 d and
- 5:16[Music]
- 5:18e probably they might be c2s yes I think
- 5:22uh by the way they carrying their
- 5:24luggage all no taxi and all stuffed in
- 5:27in the bags like that I think the lady
- 5:30possibly sets her own hair which is
- 5:32always an indication the children are
- 5:34nicely dressed yes they are probably are
- 5:37a skilled
- 5:39worker some Des a skilled worker I
- 5:42think served an apprentiship of gam
- 5:45that's qualifying we agree then yes we
- 5:48see we think so yes when people were
- 5:51asked their opinion about both products
- 5:53and politics they were selected by
- 5:55social class and asked only strictly
- 5:57factual questions about what they
- 5:59thought leaving your own party
- 6:01sympathies on one side who do you think
- 6:03will win this forcoming El labor and
- 6:07tell me which you
- 6:11prefer which party do you think you'll
- 6:13be voting for this time this time you'll
- 6:16be waiting for the
- 6:20Liberals and who do you think will be
- 6:22second
- 6:23con this one okay the idea that one
- 6:27might ask people what they themselves
- 6:29felt and desired and then give it to
- 6:31them was seen as alien to the ruling
- 6:33Elites it would challenge their belief
- 6:36that they knew what was best for the
- 6:38public there's evidence in other
- 6:40countries in the United States for
- 6:42example where pollers have been used
- 6:44before elections to interpret the mood
- 6:47of the public and then you give people
- 6:49more they want to have and less what
- 6:51they ought to have but again you this
- 6:53could be alleged to be more democratic I
- 6:55don't know it's very dangerous ground I
- 6:57think though when polls are used uh in
- 7:00that way but then in the economic crisis
- 7:03of the mid '70s British industry was
- 7:05forced to begin to pay attention to the
- 7:07inner feelings of
- 7:09consumers as the recession deepened
- 7:12consumer spending fell dramatically and
- 7:14the advertisers insisted that the only
- 7:16way for companies to survive was to make
- 7:18their advertising more effective and to
- 7:21do this they would have to delve into
- 7:23people's underlying psychological
- 7:24motives for
- 7:26purchasing the advertising industry
- 7:28started to bring in Americans to run
- 7:30focus groups with British
- 7:35Housewives everyone is a unique person
- 7:38and even though you're a group of 10
- 7:40today we don't want a group opinion and
- 7:44we want to know your ideas and your
- 7:46thoughts no matter how crazy it might be
- 7:49please let your imagination run wild
- 7:51because that's how very crazy things
- 7:52like instant coffee got born now can we
- 7:56get somebody this lady to be a kitchen
- 7:58sink and kitchen sink how do you feel
- 8:02with these things that are being used to
- 8:04clean you up well I've got to feel clean
- 8:07I've got to be kept clean so I feel that
- 8:10I should hate it if I was all greasy so
- 8:12I've got to be easy to
- 8:14clean okay now the housewife this lady
- 8:18what would you use to clean your kitchen
- 8:21sink um a scaring
- 8:23powder of course a cloth to apply the
- 8:27things on and plenty of water
- 8:31now how do you feel as you're doing this
- 8:32chore um feel satisfied well satisfied
- 8:36when I have done it yes I'm doing my
- 8:38duty I feel it's a job well done the
- 8:41consumers were encouraged to play at
- 8:42being products from household cleaners
- 8:45to car seat belts the aim was not to
- 8:48talk rationally but to act out and
- 8:50reveal their inner emotional
- 8:51relationship to
- 8:55products which
- 8:57firmly and unist stably
- 9:02underlines and then a politician emerged
- 9:05who also believed that people should be
- 9:07allowed to express themselves instead of
- 9:10being controlled by the state the
- 9:11individual should become the central
- 9:13focus of society some socialists seem to
- 9:17believe that people should be numbers in
- 9:19a state
- 9:21computer we believe they should be
- 9:24individuals we're all unequal no one
- 9:27thank heavens is quite like anyone else
- 9:30however much the Socialists May pretend
- 9:33otherwise and we believe that everyone
- 9:35has the right to be unequal but to us
- 9:39every human being is equally
- 9:44important a man's right to work as he
- 9:47will to spend what he earns to own
- 9:50property to have the state as servant
- 9:53and not as Master they are the essence
- 9:57of a free economy and on that freedom
- 10:00all our other freedoms
- 10:03[Applause]
- 10:04depend Mrs st's Vision was of a society
- 10:07in which the wants and desires of
- 10:09millions of individuals would be
- 10:11satisfied through the free market this
- 10:13she believed would be the engine to
- 10:15regenerate Britain and with her Ascent
- 10:18to power the advertising and marketing
- 10:20Industries flourished their task was to
- 10:23find out what the British people really
- 10:25wanted and then sell it to
- 10:27them in this new climate the focus group
- 10:30flourished and those who ran them
- 10:33borrowed from the techniques of
- 10:34psychotherapy to delve ever deeper into
- 10:36people's feelings about
- 10:40products we're trying to understand how
- 10:43people feel about Brands how they relate
- 10:46to brands that is to say what the
- 10:47Brand's personality is as far as
- 10:49consumers are concerned and there are a
- 10:51number of techniques which are very very
- 10:53helpful for getting to that uh to that
- 10:56understanding the consumer has given
- 10:58crayon
- 10:59to Doodle to express their feelings to
- 11:01go inside their own head pull out their
- 11:03feelings and somehow get them onto paper
- 11:05and these are ordinary drinkers uh
- 11:07expressing their feelings about drinking
- 11:09Guinness here you see a rich very female
- 11:13aspect of Guinness so if you were
- 11:15describing a woman who somehow to you
- 11:19had that character what sort of person
- 11:21is it Paula Yates used to lay in bed
- 11:25surrounded with magazines and chocolates
- 11:28like a 50s star
- 11:30out of this research the marketeers
- 11:32began to detect a new
- 11:33individualism in particular among those
- 11:36who had voted conservative for the first
- 11:38time in
- 11:391979 they no longer wanted to be seen as
- 11:41part of social classes but to express
- 11:44themselves and crucial to this were the
- 11:46products they chose to
- 11:48buy we identified that there was this
- 11:51trend towards what might be called
- 11:53individualism where people wanted to
- 11:56still be part of a cried but to express
- 11:58themselves as individual ual within it
- 12:00to have their own personalities to be I
- 12:03suppose their own men I didn't want to
- 12:06be the same as everybody else I wanted
- 12:09it to be little bit different a little
- 12:11bit individual it's quite individual
- 12:14upstairs it's not remarkable but I think
- 12:16it's quite individual it is expensive
- 12:18it's Italian it's Italian it's expensive
- 12:20and it's good quality bit different yeah
- 12:23we want to set our own standards so
- 12:25nobody else has got what we've got we
- 12:27just didn't want it be the same as every
- 12:29El we just want be
- 12:31different business responded eagerly to
- 12:33this new individualism and it soon
- 12:35became one of the main forces driving
- 12:37the growing consumer boom in
- 12:40Britain using the data from the focus
- 12:42groups manufacturers created new ranges
- 12:45of products that allowed people to
- 12:47express their
- 12:51individuality business also
- 12:53recategorized people they were no longer
- 12:55divided by social class but by their
- 12:58inner psychological iCal
- 13:00needs if the primary need is security
- 13:02and belonging we call the groups
- 13:04mainstreamers um if it status and the
- 13:06esteem of others then its aspirers if
- 13:08it's control it's succeeders and if its
- 13:11self-esteem it's
- 13:13reformers and this new marketing culture
- 13:15began to take over the institutions
- 13:17previously dominated by a patrici elite
- 13:20in particular the world of Journalism
- 13:23the assault was led by the profession of
- 13:25public
- 13:26relations in the past PR had been seen
- 13:29as seedy and corrupt but now it became a
- 13:32glamorous business promoting products
- 13:34and
- 13:35[Music]
- 13:37celebrities and one of the Rising Stars
- 13:40was another member of the Freud family
- 13:42Matthew Freud the son of the liberal MP
- 13:46Clement what Freud and other PRS
- 13:49realized was that they could use their
- 13:50celebrities as levers to infiltrate
- 13:53advertising into the editorial content
- 13:55of
- 13:56newspapers the newspapers were offered
- 13:58exclusive interviews with celebrities
- 14:00but only if they also agreed to mention
- 14:03products made by Freud's corporate
- 14:05clients in terms dictated by the
- 14:08company what happened with Freud's was
- 14:11that you effectively got some kind of
- 14:13product placement or even product the
- 14:16manufacturers of the product got some
- 14:18degree of control over how their
- 14:21products would appear in print so if for
- 14:23example you did want to write about
- 14:25Capri's passion for stuffed cross Pizza
- 14:28you would sign a contract which
- 14:30guaranteed that you would mention the
- 14:31firm Pizza Hut uh in at least twice in
- 14:35certain positions in the introductory
- 14:37paragraph of of of the article that you
- 14:38would agree to run the Pizza Hut logo at
- 14:41such and such a size in such and such a
- 14:43place and of course that you would agree
- 14:45to run the enclosed pictures of Caprice
- 14:47eating her stuffed crust pizza there was
- 14:49no choice about how you would run this
- 14:52article in the Press you were
- 14:53effectively told how to run the article
- 14:56in the Press by freuds by freuds
- 14:59it's a rise of the corporate culture and
- 15:01the rise of of business to traditional
- 15:04journalists this infiltration of
- 15:06advertising into the editorial Pages was
- 15:08a Corruption of their
- 15:10profession but to Mrs s's allies like
- 15:13rert Murdoch who owned the Son and the
- 15:15times it was part of a democratic
- 15:17Revolution against an arrogant Elite who
- 15:20had too long ignored the feelings of the
- 15:23masses they hate to see someone
- 15:25communicating with the masses they feel
- 15:27that newspapers the written word is not
- 15:28for the masses that should be left to
- 15:30television or perhaps to nobody I'm very
- 15:32proud of the sun and the sun was not
- 15:35represented tonight on your film you
- 15:36just took page three which Ione seem so
- 15:38fascinated with about page one page two
- 15:40every other page of the paper it was
- 15:42typical piece of slanting and elitism by
- 15:44the BBC who after all in order to get
- 15:47viewers for this program put on a very
- 15:49sexy episode of Star Trek just which I
- 15:51was watching out in the room there I
- 15:53don't think they put it on to get us
- 15:54viewers I think we just are lucky to
- 15:56follow they try to carry viewers into
- 15:57these show programs you how it's
- 16:01done by the late ' 80s Mrs Thatcher and
- 16:04her allies in advertising and the media
- 16:07had brought the desires of the
- 16:08individual to the center of
- 16:11society as last week's episode showed it
- 16:14was the same transformation that
- 16:16President Reagan had brought about in
- 16:19America both politicians had encouraged
- 16:22business to take over from government
- 16:24the role of fulfilling the needs of the
- 16:26people in the process consumers were
- 16:29encouraged to see the satisfaction of
- 16:31their desires as the overriding
- 16:35priority to thater and Reagan this was a
- 16:38new and better form of
- 16:42democracy but to their opponents in the
- 16:45parties of the left they had summoned up
- 16:47the most selfish and greedy aspects of
- 16:50human
- 16:52nature Ronald Reagan and Margaret thater
- 16:55both embraced an economic philosophy
- 16:57that says the unit of judgement was not
- 16:59only the individual but it was the
- 17:01individual's personal satisfaction the
- 17:04individual's own unique happiness and
- 17:10well-being it was in a sense the Triumph
- 17:12of regarding individuals as purely
- 17:16emotional beings who have needs and
- 17:19wants and desires that need to be
- 17:20satisfied and can be satisfied
- 17:24unconsciously it goes way back to the
- 17:28early part of of the 20th century to
- 17:31Freud to Notions of the
- 17:33unconscious um the assumptions that we
- 17:36are uh in terms of our rational Minds
- 17:39we're little corks bobbing around on
- 17:41this great sea of hopes and fears and
- 17:44and desires of which we are only dimly
- 17:47aware and that the role of a
- 17:50marketer the role of somebody selling
- 17:52something including a politician is to
- 17:55appeal to this Great Swamp of of desire
- 17:59of unconscious
- 18:01[Music]
- 18:04desire the left believed the opposite
- 18:08that the way to create a better Society
- 18:10was not to treat people as emotional
- 18:12isolated
- 18:13individuals but to persuade them to
- 18:15realize that they had common interests
- 18:17with others to help them rise above
- 18:19their individual feelings and
- 18:22Fears let me assert my firm belief that
- 18:27the only thing we have do fear is fear
- 18:32itself nameless unreasoning unjustified
- 18:36Terror which paralyzes needed efforts to
- 18:40convert Retreat into
- 18:43Advance this idea had flourished in
- 18:45America in the depression of the
- 18:471930s President Roosevelt faced with the
- 18:50chaos caused by the Wall Street Crash
- 18:53encouraged Americans to join together in
- 18:55trades unions to set up consumer groups
- 18:58and to pay for a welfare system for
- 19:00those trapped in
- 19:02poverty his aim was to create a
- 19:04collective awareness which would become
- 19:06a powerful weapon against the unfettered
- 19:08power of capitalism which had caused the
- 19:12crisis that idea had driven the
- 19:14Democratic party for 50 years but now
- 19:18Roosevelt's inheritors railed vainly
- 19:20against the effects of the self-interest
- 19:22incouraged by President
- 19:26Reagan there is despair Mr
- 19:29president in the faces that you don't
- 19:31see maybe Mr President if you stopped in
- 19:35at a shelter in
- 19:37Chicago and spoke to the homeless
- 19:41there maybe Mr President if you asked a
- 19:45woman who had been denied the help she
- 19:47needed to feed her children because you
- 19:49said you needed the money for a tax
- 19:52break for a millionaire or for a missile
- 19:54we couldn't afford to
- 19:56use the worst thing Reagan did was to
- 20:00make the denial of compassion
- 20:02respectable he said you've worked hard
- 20:04you've made your money you shouldn't
- 20:07have to feel guilty about refusing to
- 20:10throw it away on people who choose to be
- 20:13homeless and who choose not to work
- 20:16that's what he said he said it with an
- 20:18elegance and a kind of benign aspect
- 20:22that disguised its
- 20:24harshness you think we can do anything
- 20:26about it well why not if we can work
- 20:29together now to look after the lives of
- 20:30the people here I don't see why we
- 20:32couldn't work together afterwards to
- 20:33clear up the mess and help build a
- 20:35better world in which these things can
- 20:37possibly happen the qualities we've
- 20:38learned from comradeship and common
- 20:40suffering are not going to be wasted
- 20:42after this war it's out of experience
- 20:44like ours that the new world will be
- 20:48built that same idea of marshalling the
- 20:51collective force of the masses to
- 20:53challenge the entrenched power of wealth
- 20:55and business but also led the labor
- 20:57party to power in Britain after the
- 21:00war but in the ' 80s labor like the
- 21:03Democrats in America lost election after
- 21:05election as Millions who had once voted
- 21:08for them switched their allegiance to
- 21:10the
- 21:13conservatives There It Is Going blue
- 21:15just about everywhere sweeping the
- 21:17country the rural parts of Britain now
- 21:19have gone blue for they are the party of
- 21:22yesterday and tomorrow is
- 21:25ours in the face of this a growing
- 21:28number within the labor party became
- 21:30convinced that if they were ever to
- 21:31regain power labor would have to come to
- 21:34terms with the new
- 21:36individualism one of them was an
- 21:37advertising executive called Philip G
- 21:40who had been a lifelong labor
- 21:43supporter G believed that Labor's
- 21:45leadership had become corrupted by the
- 21:47same Patrician arrogance that dominated
- 21:49all Britain's
- 21:51institutions they denigrated and
- 21:53disapproved of the new aspirations of
- 21:55workingclass Voters labor stopped
- 21:58listening to these people and I remember
- 22:01uh the best example of this was after
- 22:03the election of 1983 which was the
- 22:06election above all where the people's
- 22:09voices just were not heard and I had
- 22:12dinner with a
- 22:14leading uh labor party figer who'd been
- 22:16involved in the defeat heavily devolved
- 22:18in involved in the defeat and his wife
- 22:20said God these workingclass people these
- 22:22workingclass people they just you know
- 22:25we give them education we give them
- 22:26chances in life what do they do they
- 22:28read the and they just don't vote for us
- 22:30and there was such a gap
- 22:32between these people just trying to make
- 22:35lies of themselves better Li themselves
- 22:37and the kind of elitism of the labor
- 22:40party that was just such a Chasm that
- 22:43that that that had to be
- 22:45filled G became part of a small group of
- 22:48modernizers centered around Peter
- 22:50mandon their aim was to reconnect labor
- 22:53with the Lost
- 22:55voters to do this G turned to the
- 22:58technique he knew well from his work in
- 23:00advertising the focus
- 23:03group ghoul commission focus groups in
- 23:05Suburban areas across the country with
- 23:08small groups of Voters who had switched
- 23:09to Mrs
- 23:11Thatcher people were encouraged not to
- 23:13talk rationally about policies but to
- 23:16express their underlying
- 23:18feelings and what G discovered was a
- 23:21fundamental shift in people's
- 23:22relationship to
- 23:24politics they no longer saw themselves
- 23:27as part of any group but as individuals
- 23:29who could demand things from politicians
- 23:32in return for paying
- 23:34taxes just as business had taught them
- 23:36to do as
- 23:39consumers and I found that the people
- 23:42had become consumers people now wanted
- 23:44to have you know politics and life on
- 23:47their own terms I mean not just in
- 23:48politics but in all aspects of life too
- 23:51people see themselves as they are as
- 23:54autonomous powerful individuals who are
- 23:57entitled to be respected who are
- 24:00entitled to have the best not just in um
- 24:02you know going to tesos or wherever but
- 24:06the best in terms of health and
- 24:08education too all this was about getting
- 24:11the labor party to understand the people
- 24:14really really really had changed and the
- 24:17labor party had not and unless the labor
- 24:18party changed it would not win Philip G
- 24:21Now set out to try and persuade the
- 24:22labor party that they would have to make
- 24:24concessions to what he called the new
- 24:27aspirational classes
- 24:29that he was going to face implacable
- 24:31opposition in the runup to the 1992
- 24:34election G argued that the only way to
- 24:36win was for Labour to promise not to put
- 24:39up taxes but the shadow Chancellor John
- 24:41Smith angrily refused label would stick
- 24:44to its fundamental policies they would
- 24:47fight the election with the promise of
- 24:48tax increases to create a fairer
- 24:53society and as the campaign began it
- 24:55seemed as if Philip G was wrong
- 24:58the traditional polls consistently
- 25:00showed labor ahead despite the
- 25:02conservative campaign message that labor
- 25:04government would put up
- 25:06[Music]
- 25:10taxes even the conservatives oldest
- 25:12allies in the Press became convinced
- 25:15that by harping on about tax the
- 25:16conservatives were cutting their own
- 25:18throats so the worry about the Tories
- 25:20must be that they're not at the moment
- 25:22conveying a sense of grip and being in
- 25:24control and unless they can do better
- 25:27than that I think think they're going to
- 25:28lose is the other thing is that they
- 25:30still say that they are going to go on
- 25:32and on with this one single message of
- 25:36tax and I think I mean part of the
- 25:38difficulty this morning was that you had
- 25:39a whole lot of uh people who've been
- 25:41going to the same press conference for
- 25:43seven days had virtually the same
- 25:45message thrust at them and kind of
- 25:47getting bored and restless and hitting
- 25:50back on it I think the media sense a big
- 25:53story coming in the Tories being
- 25:55defeated and the labor party too was
- 25:58convinced it would win and finally
- 26:00return to power it's now time to meet
- 26:03the men and women who will form the next
- 26:09government labor Chancellor of the exer
- 26:12John Smith and now it is time time for
- 26:17the next prime minister Neil
- 26:20kinck those running Labor's campaign
- 26:23believ that by modern presentation they
- 26:25would attract back the voters
- 26:28yet keep the old
- 26:30policies but Philip good was convinced
- 26:33that labor were going to lose through
- 26:36his focus groups he knew that the very
- 26:38people who were telling the traditional
- 26:39pollsters they would vote labor were in
- 26:42reality preparing to vote conservative
- 26:44out of
- 26:45self-interest but they were too
- 26:47embarrassed to admit it
- 26:50you and John Major also knew this
- 26:54because his focus groups were telling
- 26:55him the same thing
- 27:00what you make of the poll which puts
- 27:01labor five points
- 27:03ahead daily feel out in the streets that
- 27:06matters it's feeling good on the streets
- 27:08it is feeling good on the streets yes
- 27:10has been feeling surprisingly good on
- 27:12the streets for some time quite
- 27:14surprisingly quite out of line with uh
- 27:17opinion poles don't ask me to explain it
- 27:19but the feels all right anyway come on
- 27:23no Lads you must sit down we waiting to
- 27:26go John Major's victory in 1992 was a
- 27:29disaster for the labor
- 27:32party a small group of reformers
- 27:34centered around Peter mandelson and
- 27:36Philip Gould were convinced that the
- 27:38only way for the party to survive was to
- 27:40change its basic
- 27:41policies but their ideas were rejected
- 27:44by John Smith who had now become
- 27:47leader Philip good left Britain to go to
- 27:50work for the campaign to elect Bill
- 27:51Clinton president in
- 27:53America the 1992 election during it and
- 27:57afterwards People Fell under great
- 27:58strain and really did feel demoralized
- 28:01and dejected and then to go from this to
- 28:03the Clinton campaign it was an
- 28:05extraordinary experience because here
- 28:07suddenly I found articulated many of the
- 28:11ideas that I'd had but not fully myself
- 28:14been able to encapsulate or to
- 28:16articulate if you want a president who
- 28:19will restore the middle class reclaim
- 28:21the future for the middle class and
- 28:23restore the American dream vote for Bill
- 28:26Clinton in New Hampshire and send a
- 28:27signal to to the country that we are
- 28:29coming together what G discovered was
- 28:33that like the labor party the Democrats
- 28:35had also been doing focus groups with
- 28:36swing voters the difference was that
- 28:39Bill Clinton had decided to tailor his
- 28:41policies to fit with these voters
- 28:44desires above all with their ferocious
- 28:46belief that they should only pay tax for
- 28:49things that benefited them not for the
- 28:51welfare of
- 28:53others I have no idea what percentage of
- 28:56my tax dollars go to welfare but
- 28:58even if it's a minuscule percentage you
- 29:00know even if it's a quarter percent you
- 29:03know it's still too much for the people
- 29:06that are receiving these benefits that
- 29:08that are basically
- 29:10nonproductive the Clinton team decided
- 29:12that to win they had to promise tax cuts
- 29:14for these Suburban
- 29:16voters and they also used the focus
- 29:18groups throughout the campaign to check
- 29:21every appearance speech and policy with
- 29:23them for their
- 29:25approval what Clinton called The
- 29:27Forgotten middle class became Central
- 29:29figures in a new type of reactive
- 29:34politics candidates for the presidency
- 29:36in the United States had been
- 29:38prepackaged and designed for many many
- 29:41years what was new was an attempt to use
- 29:46very sophisticated or pseudo
- 29:48sophisticated techniques to Plum the
- 29:51public psychology to find out precisely
- 29:53what the desires of the individuals were
- 29:56and then to come up with a candidate and
- 29:59a platform and images and words that
- 30:03exactly responded with those deep
- 30:05desires this was packaging at a new
- 30:08level this was polling uh at an extreme
- 30:12I'm not going to raise taxes on the
- 30:13middle class and the middle class needs
- 30:15a break government is in the way it's
- 30:19taking more of your money and giving you
- 30:22less in return in the name of the
- 30:25hardworking Americans who make up our
- 30:27forgot
- 30:28middle class I proudly accept your
- 30:31nomination for president of the United
- 30:34States stay focused talk about things
- 30:36that are matter to people you know it's
- 30:39the economy stupid okay but Clinton's
- 30:43campaign team led by James Carville and
- 30:45George Stephanopoulos did not believe
- 30:47that they were capitulating to the
- 30:49selfish desires of the middle classes
- 30:52tax cuts were the price they had to pay
- 30:54to regain power but once in power they
- 30:57would still fulfill traditional
- 30:58democratic policies and help the poor
- 31:01who had been neglected under Reagan
- 31:04above all with the reform of Health
- 31:06Care they would pay for the tax cuts by
- 31:09cutting defense spending and increasing
- 31:11taxes on the very rich in this way they
- 31:15believe they were forging a coalition of
- 31:17the new and the old voters both of whom
- 31:19could be satisfied probably for the
- 31:22first time in a generation tomorrow
- 31:24we're going to win and that means that
- 31:26more people are going to have better job
- 31:28jobs people are going to pay a little
- 31:30less for healthare get better care and
- 31:33uh more kids are going to go to better
- 31:35schools um so
- 31:41thanks but the Democrats optimism was to
- 31:44be
- 31:46shortlived in November 1992 Clinton was
- 31:49triumphantly elected president but
- 31:51within weeks his administration
- 31:53discovered that the budget deficit was
- 31:55far greater than they had anticipated
- 31:59at a meeting in the White House in
- 32:00January
- 32:011993 the head of the Federal Reserve
- 32:03told them that the deficit was nearly
- 32:05$300
- 32:07billion there was no way they could
- 32:09borrow any more without panicking the
- 32:11markets and causing a
- 32:12crisis the only way to pay for the
- 32:15proposed tax cuts would be to cut
- 32:17government spending not just on defense
- 32:19but on
- 32:23welfare Clinton was faced with a choice
- 32:26between the old politics and the the new
- 32:29and he chose the old the tax cuts were
- 32:31dropped and he tried to inspire the
- 32:34country with the old democratic ideal of
- 32:36government spending to help the poor and
- 32:40disadvantaged tonight I want to talk
- 32:42with you about what government can do
- 32:44because I believe government must do
- 32:46more to put people to work now to create
- 32:48a half a million jobs jobs to rebuild
- 32:51our highways and airports to renovate
- 32:53housing to bring new life to rural
- 32:55communities and spread hope and
- 32:57opportunity among our nation's youth
- 32:59Healthcare reform sounds like a great
- 33:01idea to me well I know but some of these
- 33:03details sure scare the heck out of me
- 33:05like what well like at the start of the
- 33:07Clinton Administration many of us
- 33:10including I believe President Clinton
- 33:13himself reverted back to an older
- 33:15tradition tried to lift the public to
- 33:18talk about genuine ideals uh beyond the
- 33:22individual and that reform agenda being
- 33:24not only Universal Health Care and child
- 33:27care and dealing with the widening
- 33:28inequalities in our society and
- 33:32homelessness many things that
- 33:34many citizens just particularly middle-
- 33:37inome citizens didn't want to deal
- 33:39with but the Suburban voters who had
- 33:42been promised tax cuts were not inspired
- 33:44by Bill Clinton's Vision they felt
- 33:46betrayed and wanted
- 33:51Revenge their opportunity came in 1994
- 33:54with the Congressional elections the
- 33:57Republicans led by n Gingrich promised
- 33:59huge tax cuts and to dismantle the
- 34:02welfare system the voters who had
- 34:04defected to Clinton switch sides yet
- 34:06again and the Republicans won both
- 34:09houses of Congress in a
- 34:11landslide well I think it's a tremendous
- 34:13vote in favor of smaller government
- 34:15lower taxes and in a sense renewal of
- 34:18the fer Reagan tradition and I think in
- 34:20that sense it's pretty decisive it means
- 34:22that the welfare state is going to be
- 34:24less hospitable for people who are not
- 34:26willing to take responsibility for their
- 34:28own situation no question about it I
- 34:30think this is today is the beginning of
- 34:32the end of the welfare
- 34:34state for Clinton it was a disaster
- 34:38faced with a hostile Congress there was
- 34:39no way for him to get his reforms
- 34:41through his personal popularity
- 34:44plummeted and it seem certain he would
- 34:46not be reelected in 2 years
- 34:49time in desperation and without telling
- 34:51his cabinet Clinton turned for help to
- 34:53one of America's most ruthless political
- 34:56strategists Dick Morris
- 34:59what did he want you to do save his
- 35:02butt Clinton was in serious trouble uh
- 35:05he had lost the 94 election he had lost
- 35:08control of Congress and he hired me to
- 35:10come back and help save him uh so he was
- 35:13basically asking me to perform roughly
- 35:15the same role as a life preserver would
- 35:17if you're
- 35:18drowning what Morris told Clinton was
- 35:21that to win reelection he would have to
- 35:23transform the very nature of
- 35:26Politics the group swing voters in the
- 35:28suburbs now thought and behaved like
- 35:31consumers the only way to win them back
- 35:34was to forget all ideology and instead
- 35:36turn politics into a form of consumer
- 35:39business Clinton must try to identify
- 35:42their personal desires and whims and
- 35:45then promis to fulfill them if he
- 35:47followed those consumer rules they would
- 35:50follow
- 35:51him I said that I felt the most
- 35:53important thing for him to do was to
- 35:55bring to the political system the same
- 35:58consumer rules philosophy that we that
- 36:02the business Community has because I
- 36:04think politics needs to be as responsive
- 36:07to the whims and the desires of the
- 36:09marketplace as businesses uh and it
- 36:12should needs to be as sensitive to the
- 36:14bottom line profits or votes as a
- 36:17business is I think that all of this
- 36:19involves really a changed view of the
- 36:23voters so that instead of treating them
- 36:25as targets you treat them as owners
- 36:27instead of treating them as someone
- 36:29something that you can manipulate you
- 36:31treat them as something you need to
- 36:32learn from and instead of feeling that
- 36:35you can stay in one place and you can
- 36:37manipulate the voters you need to learn
- 36:40what they want and move yourself to
- 36:43accommodate it to get inside the minds
- 36:46of the Swing voters Morris brought
- 36:48lifestyle marketing into politics for
- 36:50the first
- 36:51time he went to one of America's most
- 36:53prominent market research firms called
- 36:55pen and shern and commissioned what they
- 36:57called a neuro personality
- 37:01pole it was a massive survey of hundreds
- 37:04of thousands of Voters but the only
- 37:06political questions it asked were to
- 37:08find out whether someone was a swing
- 37:10voter or
- 37:12not all the other questions were
- 37:14intimate psychological ones designed to
- 37:17see whether swing voters fell into
- 37:19identifiable psychological
- 37:21types well we were asking people like um
- 37:24you know do you think you're the life of
- 37:25the party um uh do you think uh when you
- 37:29when you see things that uh you like to
- 37:31have a list and organize them uh do you
- 37:34uh do you typically uh you know try to
- 37:37plan things ahead or do you like to be
- 37:39more
- 37:40spontaneous uh where do you like to go
- 37:43what sports do you like to play what
- 37:45would you do with your spouse in a
- 37:47romantic uh weekend so we were asking
- 37:49people some very personal questions
- 37:51about their own lives to try to see were
- 37:53the kinds of people that were likely to
- 37:55change their vote all also possessing of
- 37:59certain kinds of personality traits and
- 38:03in fact they
- 38:05were the neuro personality poll allowed
- 38:08the Clinton team to segment swing voters
- 38:10into different lifestyle types they were
- 38:13given names like pools and patios or
- 38:16caps and gowns who were Urban
- 38:18intellectuals living in University
- 38:21towns from this the team could identify
- 38:24ways in which they could make
- 38:25individuals feel more secure in their
- 38:27their chosen Lifestyles just as business
- 38:30had learned to do with
- 38:32products Dick Morris called it small
- 38:34bore politics tiny details of people's
- 38:37lives and personal anxieties which
- 38:39politics had never even thought about or
- 38:41noticed before but which now have become
- 38:44the key to winning
- 38:46[Music]
- 38:47power it was an America that focused on
- 38:51day-to-day practical concerns should I
- 38:54wear seat belts should I stop smoking uh
- 38:58should I wear a school uniform uh is my
- 39:01neighborhood being protected it was a
- 39:05not so much a new individualism as the
- 39:08social order as we had known it had
- 39:10broken down so we got into people's
- 39:12heads understood their psychology about
- 39:15lifestyle about values what they thought
- 39:17was important what issues they wanted
- 39:20politicians and particularly the
- 39:22president to address and these issues
- 39:23proved to be very very different from
- 39:25what the conventional wisdom had
- 39:26suggested
- 39:28as the election campaign began Clinton
- 39:30revealed Morris's new approach to a
- 39:32shocked White
- 39:33House all traditional policies were to
- 39:36be dropped instead he would concentrate
- 39:38exclusively on policies that targeted
- 39:40the worries of the Swing voters V chips
- 39:43would be fitted into televisions to
- 39:45prevent children from watching
- 39:47pornography and mobile phones would be
- 39:49fitted into school buses to make parents
- 39:52feel more
- 39:53secure Dick Morris also persuaded the
- 39:56president to spend his leure time in the
- 39:58same way as particular groups of Swing
- 40:00voters he sent Clinton on a hunting
- 40:03holiday dressed in exactly the GX
- 40:05outfits a group called Big Sky families
- 40:08liked the aim was to reflect swing
- 40:10voter's Lifestyles back to them the
- 40:13Liberals in Clinton's cabinet hated this
- 40:16approach and I would say well dick why
- 40:18have a campaign this was the 1996
- 40:21campaign if all the president is going
- 40:23to do is offer up these little bite-size
- 40:25miniature initiatives that appeal to
- 40:27people's uh desires uh like consumers
- 40:31buying soap uh a v chips that you could
- 40:33put in your tele televisions so you can
- 40:36make sure that your children did not
- 40:38have pornography and and school uniforms
- 40:41why talk about them they're they're
- 40:43they're so mundane and they're so tiny
- 40:45and he would say back if we don't do
- 40:47this we may not get
- 40:49reelected uh and I would say what's the
- 40:51point of get getting reelected if you
- 40:52have no mandate to do anything when
- 40:54you're reelected and he'd say what's the
- 40:56point of having a mandate if you can't
- 40:57get
- 40:58reelected isn't the ultimate goal
- 41:00getting
- 41:03reelected but Morris's New Politics were
- 41:05an extraordinary success Clinton's
- 41:08ratings among the swing voters began to
- 41:10soore and Dick Morris along with the
- 41:13marketeer mark Penn took effective
- 41:15charge of making White House
- 41:17policy Mark Penn set up a huge call
- 41:20center in an office Block in Denver and
- 41:23every night hundreds of telephone
- 41:25operators called swing voters in suburbs
- 41:28across the country to check with them
- 41:30every detail of policies that Clinton
- 41:33was
- 41:34proposing the policy was made by a group
- 41:37of people manning telephones in Denver
- 41:40Colorado placing calls to voters in
- 41:42places like Westchester and uh Pasadena
- 41:46and asking them what they wanted from
- 41:48their government um and asking them very
- 41:50specifically about specific policies
- 41:53that Bill Clinton was considering would
- 41:55you be more likely to support him if he
- 41:57offered this particular government
- 41:59service or if he offered that one those
- 42:01people told them what they thought Mark
- 42:02Penn transmitted that to Bill Clinton
- 42:04and it came out of his mouth so
- 42:07essentially it was suburbanite voters
- 42:09Suburban voters in the 9s were creating
- 42:13American domestic policy and some of its
- 42:16foreign policy as
- 42:18well yeah Mark Penn was polling on
- 42:21questions like whether we should bomb in
- 42:23Bosnia things like that Morris also
- 42:26insisted that Clinton make a symbolic
- 42:28sacrifice of the old politics to
- 42:30convince the swing voters to trust him
- 42:33in August 1996 Clinton signed a bill
- 42:35which ended the system of guaranteed
- 42:37help for the poor and
- 42:39unemployed welfare would be cut back
- 42:42after 2 years in order to force people
- 42:44into work the new system was called
- 42:47welfare to work and would he said be a
- 42:50hand up not a
- 42:54handout it was the effective end of the
- 42:56guaranteed welfare system created by
- 42:58President Roosevelt 60 years
- 43:01before for many in Clinton's cabinet it
- 43:04was also the end of the progressive
- 43:06political ideal that Roosevelt had
- 43:09represented the belief that one used a
- 43:11position of leadership to persuade the
- 43:13voters to think and behave as social
- 43:16beings not as self-interested
- 43:20individuals Dick Morris and the
- 43:21pollsters had won and by that I mean
- 43:25that the people who ultimately got to
- 43:28the president shaped the president's
- 43:30mind were those who viewed the voters as
- 43:36just a collection of individual desires
- 43:38that had to be catered to and pandered
- 43:40to it suggests that democracy is nothing
- 43:43more and should be nothing more than
- 43:47pandering to these unthought about very
- 43:51primitive desires primitive in the sense
- 43:54that they are not even necessarily
- 43:56conscious just what people want in terms
- 43:59of satisfying
- 44:01[Music]
- 44:03themselves and the same Triumph of the
- 44:06politics of the sou was about to happen
- 44:08in Britain
- 44:11too in 1994 Tony Blair had become the
- 44:14leader of the labor party and the
- 44:16reforming group centered around Peter
- 44:17mandon became all
- 44:21PA almost every night Philip G ran focus
- 44:24groups with swing voters in the suburbs
- 44:27but this time he was listened to and the
- 44:30desires and the fears of the new
- 44:31aspirational classes became the central
- 44:33Force shaping Labour party
- 44:36policies in that period I was talking to
- 44:39people who used to vote conservative and
- 44:42were considering voting labor and they
- 44:43wanted understood that they are
- 44:45financially pressed and that there are
- 44:47limits to uh the extent to which
- 44:49taxation can be improved they they think
- 44:51that crime is initial That Matters to
- 44:53them and should be uh respected they you
- 44:56know they want welfare to go to people
- 44:58who deserve welfare not to people um who
- 45:01do not this was seen of by many in the
- 45:03labor party as selfish I never saw that
- 45:06it was selfish I believe that you know a
- 45:09dad or a mom doing the best for their
- 45:11family isn't selfish that it's doing the
- 45:12best of their family and that's what
- 45:14people do a Crackdown on those who make
- 45:16life hell in their local neighborhoods
- 45:18through noise or disturbance Law and
- 45:20Order is a labor issue
- 45:23today philosophy of campaigning is let's
- 45:28concentrate on swing voters let's focus
- 45:31group them to find out what they want
- 45:32and what will appeal to them and let's
- 45:34just relentlessly push those themes in
- 45:36the
- 45:38election something is happening to
- 45:42you after promising to put money in your
- 45:46pocket the conservatives are quietly
- 45:49taking it away Philip G was was crucial
- 45:53because he gave the raw material if you
- 45:57like for these politicians to do uh this
- 46:01kind of politics in that when he came up
- 46:04with stuff they'd follow it you know
- 46:06pretty much without exception blur
- 46:09himself would pour over these sort of
- 46:1112-page memos and say well this is what
- 46:14we must do we want people to earn more
- 46:18to consume the good things of life we
- 46:20want people to pay lower
- 46:22taxes Gordon Brown says a labor
- 46:24government would hold the main tax rates
- 46:26under change the labor government will
- 46:29not increase the basic rate of
- 46:31tax I want to make it clear that I will
- 46:34not increase tanks in fact the labor
- 46:36party does stand for Middle England
- 46:39those that aspire to do better to get on
- 46:41in life and be ambitious to themselves
- 46:43and their families will do better with
- 46:44labor groups of eight people drinking
- 46:47wine and nibbling you know Cheerios um
- 46:50what they thought determined effectively
- 46:54everything that the labor party did
- 46:57and although those running the campaign
- 46:59like to portray the new approach as
- 47:00their invention it was in fact copied
- 47:03from the Americans even down to the
- 47:06phrases that the American marketeers had
- 47:08tested on their swing voters Peter
- 47:10mandon and his team were in the United
- 47:12States watching what we did and copied
- 47:15almost verbatim our approach in their
- 47:181997 campaign the benefit system should
- 47:21be about giving people a hand up not
- 47:25just a hand out
- 47:27melson's not a fool if he's anything
- 47:30he's saw something that work so why not
- 47:31do
- 47:32it and I can remember reading their
- 47:35Manifesto and say to myself they just
- 47:37took it Lock Stock and
- 47:39Barrel you know on one hand you're proud
- 47:41and on another hand [ __ ] and as in
- 47:45America labor was forced to drop
- 47:47policies that would not directly benefit
- 47:49the swing voters even if it meant
- 47:52sacrificing its fundamental principles
- 47:54the commitment to public control of
- 47:56Industry which was enshrined as Clause 4
- 47:59of the party Constitution was
- 48:01dropped the aim of clause 4 had been to
- 48:04use the collective power of the people
- 48:07to challenge the unfettered greed of
- 48:09business but now Tony Blair was faced
- 48:11with crucial voters who no longer saw
- 48:14themselves as exploited by the free
- 48:16market they saw themselves as individual
- 48:19consumers who were fulfilled and given
- 48:21identity by what business delivered them
- 48:25the new Clause 4 promised not to control
- 48:27the free market but to let it flourish
- 48:30business is more powerful than
- 48:31government it is quicker it is more
- 48:34creative business is the lifeblood of
- 48:38the country from this come all the
- 48:40benefits that Society needs employment
- 48:43investment I think frankly there is only
- 48:45one part is getting business right and
- 48:47that's new
- 48:49labor what new labor did it suits people
- 48:52who exert power in
- 48:54society not through
- 48:57the political system or or not through
- 49:00the Democratic political system so it
- 49:01suits big business and it suits
- 49:03entrenched interests and it ensuites the
- 49:05status quo um you know those three
- 49:08things of course just off the top of my
- 49:10head being the things that the labor
- 49:11party is supposed to be you know a
- 49:13counterforce too what that means is Big
- 49:16Business get to carry on exerting their
- 49:19power behind the scenes getting their
- 49:22way because there's no counterveiling
- 49:23pressure counterveiling pressure isn't
- 49:25going to come from you know
- 49:27eight people sipping wine in ketering
- 49:29here he goes Turing an awful lot of
- 49:31other blue seats red as
- 49:37well very happy very rened very
- 49:41exhilarated but those who masterminded
- 49:43Labour's victory in 1997 saw it as a
- 49:46triumphant Vindication of a new form of
- 49:49democracy by understanding and
- 49:51fulfilling people's inner desires
- 49:53through the focus group they were giving
- 49:55power to individuals not treating them
- 49:57as faceless groups who were told by
- 50:00politicians what was good for
- 50:04them I don't believe I don't see the
- 50:07focus group as some marketing tool I see
- 50:09the focus group as a way of hearing what
- 50:13the people have to say and I see the
- 50:15focus group as a way to a new form of
- 50:20politics what the people give the people
- 50:23can take away we are the
- 50:27they are the Masters
- 50:29now 1997 was I think fundamentally
- 50:33important in that I think it is the end
- 50:36the end of the uh elitist politics
- 50:39that's dominated Britain for so much of
- 50:42the last uh 100
- 50:47[Music]
- 50:50years in 1939 Edward bernes Sigman
- 50:54Freud's nephew created a vision of a
- 50:57future world in which the consumer was
- 51:01King it was at the World's Fair in New
- 51:04York and bernes called it democrac City
- 51:08it was one of the earliest and most
- 51:10dramatic portrayals of a consumerist
- 51:12democracy a society in which the needs
- 51:15and desires of individuals were read and
- 51:17fulfilled by business and the free
- 51:21market the World's Fair created a
- 51:24spectacle in which all of these concerns
- 51:27were met and they were met by
- 51:28Westinghouse and General Motors and the
- 51:31American cash register company and
- 51:34Company after company presented itself
- 51:36as the sort of centerpiece of a society
- 51:39in which human desire and human want and
- 51:41human anxiety would all be responded to
- 51:44and would be all be met purely through
- 51:47the free enterprise system there was
- 51:50this sort of notion that the free market
- 51:52was something that was not Guided by
- 51:54ideologies or by political power it was
- 51:57something that simply was Guided by The
- 51:59People's
- 52:01will this was the model of democracy
- 52:03that both new labor and the American
- 52:06Democrats had bought into in order to
- 52:08regain
- 52:10power they had used techniques developed
- 52:12by business to read the desires of
- 52:14consumers and they had accepted Bern's
- 52:17claim that this was a better form of
- 52:22democracy but in reality the World's
- 52:25Fair have been an elaborate piece of
- 52:27propaganda designed by bernes for his
- 52:30clients the giant American
- 52:33corporations privately bernes did not
- 52:36believe that true democracy could ever
- 52:39work he had been profoundly influenced
- 52:41in this by his uncle's theories of human
- 52:45nature Freud believed that individuals
- 52:47were not driven by rational thought but
- 52:49by primitive unconscious desires and
- 52:52feelings and bernes believed that this
- 52:55meant it was too dangerous to let the
- 52:57masses ever have control over their own
- 53:00lives and consumerism was a way of
- 53:03giving people the illusion of control
- 53:05while allowing a responsible Elite to
- 53:08continue managing
- 53:13Society it's not that the people are in
- 53:16charge but that the people's desires are
- 53:18in
- 53:19charge the people are not in charge the
- 53:22people exercise no decision-making power
- 53:24within this environment so
- 53:28democracy is reduced from something
- 53:30which assumes an active
- 53:33citizenry to something which now
- 53:35increasingly is predicated on the idea
- 53:38of the public as passive
- 53:40consumers the public as people who
- 53:42essentially what you're delivering them
- 53:44are doggy
- 53:46treats the problem for new labor was
- 53:49that it believed the
- 53:51propaganda they took at face value the
- 53:54idea promoted by business that the the
- 53:56systems invented to read the consumer's
- 53:58mind could form the basis for a new type
- 54:00of
- 54:02democracy once in power new labor tried
- 54:05to govern through a system that Philip G
- 54:07called continuous
- 54:09democracy but what worked for business
- 54:11in designing products led the labor
- 54:14government into a bewildering Maze of
- 54:16contradictory whims and
- 54:19desires for much of Labor's first term
- 54:22the focus group said that the railways
- 54:23were not a high priority and Labor's
- 54:26policy has Faithfully reflected this but
- 54:29now those same groups are blaming the
- 54:31government for not having invested more
- 54:33money sooner in the
- 54:36railways the point about focus group
- 54:38politics is that there isn't one because
- 54:40people are contradictory and irrational
- 54:42and so you have a problem in terms of
- 54:46deciding what you're going to do if all
- 54:48you do is actually listen to a massive
- 54:50individual opinions that are forever
- 54:51fluctuating and don't really have any
- 54:53coherence and crucially are not set in
- 54:55context so that's why people can say you
- 54:57know um I want lower taxes and better
- 55:00Public Services of course they do you
- 55:03know you say um do you want to pay more
- 55:06taxes to get better Public Services
- 55:08people are less sure they then don't
- 55:10believe that if they do pay more taxes
- 55:12they will be spent on better public
- 55:14services so you end up in this Quagmire
- 55:16where the TR is a politician has to say
- 55:18look this is what I believe I believe
- 55:20that you should pay slightly more taxes
- 55:22to to make better public services and I
- 55:24pledge that I'm competent enough to
- 55:25actually use that money wisely do you
- 55:27want that vote for me yes or no and
- 55:30that's what blur has failed to do Tony
- 55:32blur turn around and sort of tries to
- 55:33feed back to them what they already
- 55:35believe and given what what they believe
- 55:37is sort of a load of individual um in
- 55:40incoherent contradictory nonsense that's
- 55:42all he has to offer and then he wonders
- 55:44why people don't get him you know the
- 55:46answer they don't get him is because
- 55:47they're looking for someone to do
- 55:49something that they can't do themselves
- 55:50which has actually come up with a
- 55:52coherent political opinion that they
- 55:53might have faith in new labor a with a
- 55:57dilemma the system of consumer democracy
- 55:59that they have embraced has trapped them
- 56:02into a series of short-term and often
- 56:03contradictory
- 56:05policies there are now growing demands
- 56:08that they fulfill a grand division that
- 56:10they use the power of government to deal
- 56:12with the problems of growing inequality
- 56:14and the decaying social fabric of the
- 56:17country but to do this they will have to
- 56:20appeal to the electorate to think
- 56:22outside their own
- 56:23self-interest and this would mean
- 56:25challenging the now dominant Freudian
- 56:27view of human beings as selfish Instinct
- 56:30driven individuals which is a concept of
- 56:33human beings that has been fostered and
- 56:35encouraged by business because it
- 56:37produces ideal
- 56:41consumers although we feel we are free
- 56:44in reality we like the politicians have
- 56:47become the slaves of our own
- 56:51desires we have forgotten that we can be
- 56:53more than that that there are other
- 56:56decides to human
- 56:59nature fundamentally here we have two
- 57:02different views of human nature and of
- 57:04democracy you have the view that people
- 57:08are irrational that they are bundles of
- 57:12unconscious emotion uh that comes
- 57:15directly out of flud and businesses are
- 57:18very able to respond to that that's what
- 57:20they have honed their skills doing
- 57:22that's what marketing is really all
- 57:24about what are the symbols the music the
- 57:26images the words that will appeal to
- 57:29these unconscious
- 57:32feelings politics must be more than that
- 57:36politics and
- 57:38leadership are about engaging the public
- 57:41in a rational discussion and
- 57:44deliberation about what is
- 57:47best and treating people with
- 57:49respect in terms of their rational
- 57:52abilities to debate what is best if it's
- 57:55not not that if it is Freudian if it is
- 57:59basically a matter of appealing to the
- 58:01same basic unconscious feelings that
- 58:04business appeals to then why not let
- 58:06business do it business can do it better
- 58:08business knows how to do it business
- 58:10after all is in the business of
- 58:12responding to those
- 58:14[Music]
- 58:19feelings I see trees of
- 58:23green red roses
- 58:27you I see them
- 58:30bloom for me and you and I think to
- 58:37myself what a wonderful
- 58:41[Music]
- 58:43word I think to
- 58:49myself what a
- 58:52[Music]
- 58:55wonderful h
- 58:58[Music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of The Century of the Self - Part 4: "Eight People Sipping Wine in Kettering" by JustAdamCurtis, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 8,928 words across 1,419 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.