YouTube2Text

The Cambridge Method: Struggle First, Understand Later — Transcript

by Ryan Ward · 2,133 words · 331 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00Everyone tells you just how brilliant
  2. 0:02Cambridge is for studying maths.
  3. 0:05Cambridge has some of the best
  4. 0:06researchers in the world teaching
  5. 0:08undergraduate students topics that
  6. 0:09they've spent their whole career
  7. 0:10studying. But they might be the best at
  8. 0:12research, but they're definitely not the
  9. 0:14best at teaching. The Cambridge lectures
  10. 0:16are fast, definition here, a theorem
  11. 0:18there, and then a proof left as an
  12. 0:20exercise to the reader. Then they move
  13. 0:21on, and they expect you to keep up. And
  14. 0:24not just to cope, but to be the best in
  15. 0:26the world at it.
  16. 0:28That's the teaching. That's it. So why
  17. 0:30do the people who survived that end up
  18. 0:32running maths departments and winning
  19. 0:33Fields Medals? Well, Cambridge have a
  20. 0:36different way of making the best
  21. 0:37mathematicians, and it's not teaching,
  22. 0:39but training. Now, let me be precise,
  23. 0:42because I'm not saying lectures are bad.
  24. 0:43They're probably world-class in their
  25. 0:45field. Some of them have wrote the thing
  26. 0:47that they're actually lecturing on. I'm
  27. 0:49saying the teaching, the actual process
  28. 0:51of moving information from one brain
  29. 0:52into another, in my opinion, is barely
  30. 0:56attempted. And I don't think that's an
  31. 0:57accident. I think it's kind of the
  32. 0:59point. Now, if you know anything about
  33. 1:01maths degree, you're already probably
  34. 1:02objecting to what I'm saying. 12
  35. 1:04lectures a week, uh end-of-year exams,
  36. 1:07proofs left as an exercise. That's
  37. 1:09Warwick, that's Imperial, that's Durham.
  38. 1:11That's every research-heavy maths
  39. 1:13department in the country. And to be
  40. 1:15fair, you're right. So let me be more
  41. 1:17specific about what makes Cambridge the
  42. 1:18extreme case, rather than just another
  43. 1:20example of the same type. It's the pace.
  44. 1:23It's the volume. Material that's a full
  45. 1:25module elsewhere is often half a module
  46. 1:27at Cambridge. The maths Tripos covers
  47. 1:29more ground faster than pretty much
  48. 1:31everywhere else in the world.
  49. 1:33And they test you on some of the hardest
  50. 1:35questions that you've barely been
  51. 1:36taught. It does it while assessing you
  52. 1:38exactly once in May at the end. Now, in
  53. 1:41what way is the teaching bad? Well,
  54. 1:43there's 10 to 12 lectures a week in the
  55. 1:45first year. You get a new definition, a
  56. 1:47new theorem, a proof, next, move on. No
  57. 1:49worked examples in the sense that you
  58. 1:51know from A level, no let's do one
  59. 1:53together. The pace just assumes that
  60. 1:54you've read the content ahead of time.
  61. 1:56It assumes you go home afterwards and
  62. 1:57spend 8 hours understanding the 55
  63. 1:59minutes they just gave you. And if you
  64. 2:01don't, you're behind by Thursday of week
  65. 2:03one. Then, secondly, [music]
  66. 2:05nothing you do actually counts. Example
  67. 2:07sheets aren't assessed, attendance isn't
  68. 2:09tracked, there's no coursework other
  69. 2:11than a bit of cat time in the second
  70. 2:12year.
  71. 2:13The entire year lands on exams in May,
  72. 2:15which means the system has no mechanism
  73. 2:17for noticing you're drowning in the work
  74. 2:20until it's far too late and there's
  75. 2:21nothing you can do about it. And then
  76. 2:23finally, supervisions. Supervisions are
  77. 2:26the thing that Cambridge sells itself
  78. 2:27on. It sells it the hardest. And to be
  79. 2:29fair, it's a lot more contact time than
  80. 2:30almost any other department in the
  81. 2:32country office. It's one or two students
  82. 2:34with an expert in that field for a full
  83. 2:36hour. And when it's good, it's the best
  84. 2:38teaching, in my opinion, in British
  85. 2:40higher education. But nothing actually
  86. 2:42controls that variance. Sometimes you
  87. 2:43get someone who transforms how you think
  88. 2:45about maths. Sometimes you get a second
  89. 2:47year PhD student who is,
  90. 2:49to be fair, amazing at what they're
  91. 2:51researching,
  92. 2:52but isn't really up to scratch with
  93. 2:54considering how a 19-year-old learns
  94. 2:56maths. Most of the time it's just
  95. 2:58students desperate not to embarrass
  96. 2:59themselves that's forcing them to keep
  97. 3:01up with the course. And even if you get
  98. 3:03a good supervisor, it's 1 hour once a
  99. 3:06fortnight. It's nowhere near enough to
  100. 3:07carry you through an entire course of
  101. 3:09something you're struggling with.
  102. 3:11That hour is the only thing that's
  103. 3:12standing between a really struggling
  104. 3:14student and a year that they just can't
  105. 3:16recover from. And just nobody actually
  106. 3:18checks whether it's any good for the
  107. 3:19student, whether they're actually making
  108. 3:21any progress.
  109. 3:22So, with all this going wrong, why does
  110. 3:25Cambridge end up with such good
  111. 3:26mathematicians even though the teaching
  112. 3:28seems to be absolutely non-existent?
  113. 3:30Well, from what you'd probably expect
  114. 3:32and what I did expect when I went here,
  115. 3:34non-existent teaching should lead to the
  116. 3:36worst students. However, something
  117. 3:39happens when you get no help. When
  118. 3:40nobody explains it to you, then you have
  119. 3:43to explain it to yourself. And
  120. 3:44explaining something to yourself is not
  121. 3:46the same activity as being explained to.
  122. 3:48It's a completely different process and
  123. 3:50a different result.
  124. 3:52With good teaching, the kind we're all
  125. 3:53trained to want and to get from A
  126. 3:55levels,
  127. 3:56it hands you a clean path through the
  128. 3:58material. You follow it, it makes sense,
  129. 4:00you feel the click. The problem is that
  130. 4:02by following somebody else's path, you
  131. 4:03don't actually stray from that path.
  132. 4:06You don't understand why things work and
  133. 4:08why they don't work.
  134. 4:10And don't find alternate paths that
  135. 4:12might just work.
  136. 4:13Change the question slightly and the
  137. 4:15path that you knew and loved completely
  138. 4:16disappears cuz you never built it, you
  139. 4:18just walked down a path that somebody
  140. 4:20else taught you. Now, the reason why
  141. 4:22Cambridge doesn't like teaching is
  142. 4:23because they don't give you the path.
  143. 4:25So, you work out where that theorem came
  144. 4:27from, what breaks if you drop a
  145. 4:29hypothesis, why the proof goes that way
  146. 4:31and not the obvious way.
  147. 4:32When you explain it to yourself, you
  148. 4:34have to critique and understand every
  149. 4:36single angle to truly understand it.
  150. 4:39And the way the example sheets work, you
  151. 4:40can be sat with a question for like 6
  152. 4:42hours. On one specific case, I sat with
  153. 4:44a problem for 4 days, at one point
  154. 4:46contemplating how much gravity will
  155. 4:47affect me if I jump out of the second
  156. 4:49story of the library.
  157. 4:51But, the point is you get absolutely
  158. 4:53nowhere. You learn everything that
  159. 4:54doesn't work. And when you do finally
  160. 4:56get there, you truly understand why it
  161. 4:59does work.
  162. 5:01That 6 hours of getting absolutely
  163. 5:02nowhere is entirely the point.
  164. 5:04Everything else is just scaffolding to
  165. 5:06help you build towards the answer. And
  166. 5:08I'm trying not to be romantic about
  167. 5:10suffering. I'm not a masochist, but
  168. 5:12there is a name for it in science. It's
  169. 5:13called desirable difficulties. But, the
  170. 5:15short version is conditions that make
  171. 5:17learning feel slower and worse while
  172. 5:20it's actually happening, produce
  173. 5:21knowledge that lasts longer and
  174. 5:23transfers to more things.
  175. 5:26Struggling to understand something
  176. 5:27before you're told it beats just being
  177. 5:29told. Failing at a problem before you
  178. 5:31see the solution always beats just
  179. 5:34looking at the solution and going, "Ah,
  180. 5:35that's the answer." Now, on the back of
  181. 5:37this, there's probably two questions you
  182. 5:38might ask. One, are students failing in
  183. 5:41school because of bad teaching, whereas
  184. 5:42I've just claimed that bad teaching
  185. 5:43leads to good students? And secondly,
  186. 5:46does Cambridge actually produce good
  187. 5:47mathematicians or they just have such
  188. 5:49high standards that they only let in
  189. 5:52good mathematicians and then just take
  190. 5:53the credit? And to be fair, you're
  191. 5:55asking the right questions. But the
  192. 5:58second question actually answers the
  193. 5:59first. Cambridge does have pretty much
  194. 6:01the highest requirements to get in. I
  195. 6:03mark STEP papers. I I know it is a
  196. 6:05really hard exam. It's the hardest one
  197. 6:07A-level students have to go through. It
  198. 6:09really pushes students to think
  199. 6:10differently and understand the math that
  200. 6:11they're doing. So yes, Cambridge does
  201. 6:14admit some of the best. Well, that's
  202. 6:15exactly why this method works. Put a few
  203. 6:17hundred students like that in one place
  204. 6:19and they start trying to outwork each
  205. 6:21other. Most of their working hours go
  206. 6:23into the course because everyone around
  207. 6:25them is doing the same. That peer
  208. 6:27pressure doesn't exist if you don't
  209. 6:28admit those people in the first place.
  210. 6:31Does that mean it's selection rather
  211. 6:32than training? Well, partly, yes. I'm
  212. 6:35not going to pretend otherwise. But I
  213. 6:37think the honest version is that it's
  214. 6:38both. The system selects the best
  215. 6:39students and then it forces those best
  216. 6:41students to develop and really learn as
  217. 6:44quickly as a skill that nobody would
  218. 6:46choose to do voluntarily.
  219. 6:48A lot of people put themselves through
  220. 6:49quite a lot at Cambridge. A lot of them
  221. 6:51arrive able to sit with a hard problem
  222. 6:52for maybe an hour. But when they leave,
  223. 6:54they're able to sit with a hard problem
  224. 6:55for like over a week. That's really
  225. 6:57important because that's what research
  226. 6:59math is. You sit in front of a problem
  227. 7:01nobody has ever solved before. There are
  228. 7:03no lecture notes, there's no supervisor
  229. 7:04who knows the answer because there is no
  230. 7:06answer. You just sit with a problem for
  231. 7:08days and days trying to understand it.
  232. 7:10And the math Tripos is essentially a
  233. 7:12three-year rehearsal for exactly that.
  234. 7:14It isn't badly designed teaching, it's
  235. 7:16well-designed training that happens to
  236. 7:18look identical to badly designed
  237. 7:20teaching from the outside. The people
  238. 7:21who come out at the end have spent three
  239. 7:23years building [music] the specific
  240. 7:24muscle that a researching job requires.
  241. 7:27Tolerance for not knowing and the habit
  242. 7:29of sticking with a problem to find out
  243. 7:30that solution.
  244. 7:32You can't get that from being spoon-fed
  245. 7:33answers. There is no version of being
  246. 7:35taught well that also teaches you to
  247. 7:37work without knowing anything.
  248. 7:39Okay, so getting on to probably the most
  249. 7:41important part of this video. You don't
  250. 7:43need to be at Cambridge to benefit from
  251. 7:45this system. You can incorporate these
  252. 7:47habits into your own studies. So, before
  253. 7:50you seek for the solution, sit on it for
  254. 7:51a while and fail properly. Don't just
  255. 7:54give up and then look for the answer.
  256. 7:56>> [music]
  257. 7:56>> You need to give yourself time to make
  258. 7:57mistakes, try different methods, and
  259. 8:00struggle. That's the important part. 10
  260. 8:02minutes, half an hour, on paper actually
  261. 8:05attempting it. The failure is what makes
  262. 8:07you fully understand. The instinct to go
  263. 8:09and check the answer as soon as
  264. 8:10something goes wrong is the exact
  265. 8:11instinct that's just costing you.
  266. 8:14Cuz it feels like efficiency. It feels
  267. 8:15like you're being super efficient,
  268. 8:16finding the answer, understanding really
  269. 8:18quickly.
  270. 8:19But you're just memorizing their
  271. 8:20solution. You're not understanding why
  272. 8:22the solution works.
  273. 8:23>> [music]
  274. 8:23>> And secondly, a bit more of a
  275. 8:24controversial one, hold yourself to a
  276. 8:26very high standard. And I'm not saying
  277. 8:28do loads and loads and loads of problems
  278. 8:30just so that you you've done everything
  279. 8:31and you've you've worked really really
  280. 8:33hard. I'm saying hold yourself to a high
  281. 8:35standard when it comes to your
  282. 8:36understanding. See yourself as a
  283. 8:38researcher, not just a student. When you
  284. 8:41start to learn something new, don't just
  285. 8:43accept it because you've been taught it.
  286. 8:45Push yourself to develop a deep
  287. 8:46understanding of why things work and why
  288. 8:49they don't.
  289. 8:51That's the entire Cambridge method. It
  290. 8:53costs you nothing to implement yourself
  291. 8:55and nobody has to teach it to you, which
  292. 8:57is kind of more or less the point of
  293. 8:58this video.
  294. 9:00But this is the exact method I used back
  295. 9:02when I was in A level to get the highest
  296. 9:04grades, five A stars. I did every module
  297. 9:07on the further maths and back then the
  298. 9:09further additional maths back. And my
  299. 9:11school at the time just didn't have
  300. 9:12anyone who knew the content to be able
  301. 9:14to teach it to me. So, I had to learn it
  302. 9:15myself and I had to go through this
  303. 9:17exact method because I just didn't have
  304. 9:19the solutions. I couldn't look anything
  305. 9:21up. I just had to struggle with the
  306. 9:23problem until I understood them and
  307. 9:25until I got the answers right. So, yeah,
  308. 9:27Cambridge might not have the best
  309. 9:28teaching. But the Cambridge method of
  310. 9:30training, rather than simply teaching,
  311. 9:32produces not only the best
  312. 9:33mathematicians in the world, but also of
  313. 9:35best thinkers. People who go on to not
  314. 9:37just study maths, but maybe philosophy
  315. 9:40or law.
  316. 9:41Now, if you're applying for Cambridge or
  317. 9:43any other university for maths, or even
  318. 9:44if you're just sitting in first year
  319. 9:46right now, quietly wondering whether
  320. 9:47everyone else is finding it as hard as
  321. 9:49you, they are. It's just nobody wants to
  322. 9:51say so. Try and implement some of these
  323. 9:53ideas. See if they can help you level up
  324. 9:55your maths game. See if it helps you
  325. 9:56with your university maths. And if
  326. 9:58you've already been through the Tripos
  327. 9:59and have a different view than me, put
  328. 10:01it in the comments. I'd actually really
  329. 10:02like to read it. See what you thought of
  330. 10:03being at Cambridge. But yeah, I'll see
  331. 10:05you in the next one. Bye.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of The Cambridge Method: Struggle First, Understand Later by Ryan Ward, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,133 words across 331 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.