The Breakdown of Women in STEM | Jess Ellis | TEDxCSM — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:02So, I'd like to tell you a story today.
- 0:04During my second year in college, I took
- 0:07a spring break trip to a beautiful
- 0:10country where I was recommended against
- 0:12drinking the water. Um this was my first
- 0:15international travel without adult
- 0:17supervision, and so I really wanted to
- 0:19embrace the identity of world traveler.
- 0:21And I didn't want to be that pretentious
- 0:23American who used bottled water to brush
- 0:26my teeth. So,
- 0:27I drank the water. Inevitably, I became
- 0:30pretty ill. And I went to my university
- 0:32health center, and I told them I had
- 0:34just been in this beautiful country. I
- 0:35drank the water, now I am sick. And they
- 0:37said, "Well,
- 0:39what's most likely happening is you have
- 0:41a stomach flu. You have a bug. Just go
- 0:44on a liquid diet, you'll be fine." And I
- 0:45said, "No, no, no, you don't understand.
- 0:47I was just in this country, I drank the
- 0:49water. I'm feeling really ill." They
- 0:51said, "No, go on a liquid diet."
- 0:53So, I did. And after losing about 15 lb,
- 0:58um
- 0:59I realized that that chicken soup wasn't
- 1:01really soothing my stomach or my soul.
- 1:04And so, I went back to that health
- 1:05center, and I asked them to do some more
- 1:08tests.
- 1:09Um I'll not share the details of those
- 1:11tests with you right now, but once they
- 1:15did those tests, they gave me the
- 1:16diagnosis that I knew was there. Um
- 1:18although I didn't know the word for it
- 1:19at the time, when I heard that word,
- 1:21what it did for me was gave me a
- 1:23confirmation that what I was feeling
- 1:26that wasn't addressed with the word
- 1:29stomach flu or stomach bug. Something
- 1:31else was there. So, that word was
- 1:33Giardia.
- 1:34Um
- 1:35I won't go into details of what that is.
- 1:38Um
- 1:38but with that word, it let me feel like
- 1:42there was a word for this, there was a
- 1:43diagnosis, and I could move forward to a
- 1:45solution.
- 1:47And so, I'm sharing this talk with you
- 1:48because even though I'm not the medical
- 1:50kind of Dr. Ellis, I did have the
- 1:52opportunity this past summer to give a
- 1:54kind of diagnosis or put words to an
- 1:57experience that like Giardia is not a
- 1:59good experience, but an experience that
- 2:01many people across this country have
- 2:03felt.
- 2:04So, along with a team of researchers,
- 2:06this past summer, we identified that
- 2:08women are 50% more likely to switch out
- 2:12of the STEM pathway after taking
- 2:14calculus one when controlling for
- 2:16intended major, um reports of
- 2:18instruction, previous calculus
- 2:20experience, SAT or ACT scores, school,
- 2:23and professor.
- 2:24That means that 50% more of the women
- 2:28who are taking calc one planning to take
- 2:29calc two because they want to be an
- 2:31engineer, they want to be a chemist,
- 2:32whatever,
- 2:33are leaving that after the experience of
- 2:35calc one compared to the men.
- 2:38Um now, this isn't a groundbreaking
- 2:40finding, much like it wasn't so
- 2:43groundbreaking that I contracted Giardia
- 2:45after drinking water in a country for
- 2:46which I hadn't developed the proper
- 2:47immunities in my stomach.
- 2:50But, like Giardia,
- 2:53just by giving the words to this
- 2:55experience, I got to help diagnose
- 2:58something that many people were feeling.
- 3:02Now, when I give this talk, or when I
- 3:03talk about these research findings
- 3:05across the country, um inevitably, there
- 3:07will be some in the audience that says,
- 3:09"Well, what about race and ethnicity?
- 3:11Have you done similar analyses trying to
- 3:13understand the experience of race and
- 3:14ethnicity with or without gender?" So,
- 3:16maybe looking at the intersectional
- 3:17perspective, too.
- 3:19And I say, "Well, that is a wonderful
- 3:20question. Unfortunately, there's such a
- 3:22low percentage of non-white students in
- 3:26our sample that we can't run the same
- 3:28statistical analyses to give the same
- 3:30strong quantifiable results."
- 3:33And then, the person in the audience,
- 3:34like some of you I'm seeing right now,
- 3:36nod your head in understandment. Um
- 3:39the person feels good cuz they asked the
- 3:40right question. I feel good because I
- 3:43gave the right answer.
- 3:45And then, we move on. So, this has
- 3:46happened for years. I've been presenting
- 3:48on this data for years and been giving
- 3:50these answers for years, and it's been
- 3:52fine. And it struck me that it was
- 3:54similar to when I went to the health
- 3:56center and said
- 3:58I'm having these symptoms, and they said
- 3:59most likely you just have a stomach flu.
- 4:01Here's a remedy. And that remedy had no
- 4:04bearing. It didn't help me at all cuz it
- 4:06wasn't what I was experiencing.
- 4:08That by not actually looking at the
- 4:10experiences
- 4:11of these students of color in our
- 4:13calculus classes, even though they're a
- 4:15smaller percentage, that we're making
- 4:17their experiences invisible. Much like
- 4:19the doctors made my giardia invisible by
- 4:21not testing for it. And so what we're
- 4:23doing is not understanding the actual
- 4:25experiences of these students in the
- 4:26same way that we can in order to provide
- 4:29a solution.
- 4:33So,
- 4:34we have two problems here. We have the
- 4:36problem of diversity in STEM that we're
- 4:38all well aware of. It's being published
- 4:40all over and talked about in the news.
- 4:42But we also have the problem among
- 4:43researchers that when we
- 4:45write these findings, when we talk about
- 4:47them, when we answer these questions,
- 4:49we're not really looking deeper into
- 4:52what's happening with our answers. So,
- 4:53although my answer has been accepted as
- 4:56correct, it is correct, it's expect or
- 4:59um accepted by the research community,
- 5:01it doesn't tell the full story.
- 5:03And so, I was recommended to not just
- 5:05come up here and tell you some problems,
- 5:07but also try to understand some
- 5:09solutions. Now, certainly the problem of
- 5:12diversity in STEM and representation of
- 5:14women and students of color and
- 5:16persistence is not so easy to solve as
- 5:19the pill that they gave me to solve my
- 5:21giardia.
- 5:23But,
- 5:25we can think about ways to go about it
- 5:27by just trying to actually understand
- 5:28what's happening. So, here we are. We're
- 5:30at Colorado School of Mines. Many of you
- 5:32are students. Um and so I understand
- 5:34that you probably get the situation
- 5:36that's going on here. But I'm just going
- 5:37to share some numbers really quick. So,
- 5:38Colorado School of Mines is almost
- 5:40entirely a STEM school. There's some
- 5:42economics majors, but we'll just group
- 5:44them into STEM for now. Um in 2014,
- 5:47there were about 900 students graduated
- 5:49with STEM degrees. Of those 900-ish
- 5:52students, around 25% were earned by
- 5:54women.
- 5:55Um, less than 10% were earned by
- 5:57Hispanic and Latinx students. And less
- 6:00than 1% were earned by black or
- 6:01African-American students. So, I imagine
- 6:04that the classes here at Colorado School
- 6:05of Mines, the calculus classes, which
- 6:07are feeding into these STEM majors, look
- 6:09fairly similar if not even more
- 6:11homogeneous than the sample that I
- 6:13looked at in my study.
- 6:15And so,
- 6:16what can you do? As students, as
- 6:18faculty, as parents, whatever your
- 6:20relationship is to this university.
- 6:22As students, I want you to be asking
- 6:24more questions. I recommend that you
- 6:26think about why do your classes look the
- 6:28way that they do? Or if you read
- 6:29research, try to understand why is there
- 6:31too few students to be able to do a
- 6:33similar analysis. What's put in the
- 6:35footnote of multiple of my studies right
- 6:37now.
- 6:38And if you're in the position to be
- 6:40giving answers to people,
- 6:42which is a wonderful place to be in, I
- 6:43want you to question those answers that
- 6:45you're really comfortable giving.
- 6:46Because although they might be right,
- 6:48that might might not be the full story.
- 6:50So, we need to do better at looking into
- 6:52what's actually going on.
- 6:54So, for me, this talk is a public coming
- 6:55out and acknowledging that when I gave
- 6:57that answer so many times, that I was
- 7:00missing the whole story. And I'm asking
- 7:03of you today to be curious, like we just
- 7:06heard in the past talk.
- 7:08Um, ask more of those questions and
- 7:09question the answers that you're
- 7:10getting. Thank you.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of The Breakdown of Women in STEM | Jess Ellis | TEDxCSM by TEDx Talks, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,341 words across 213 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.