The Boy Crisis Explained - Why America is Producing Weak Men — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00my guest today is dr warren farrell who
- 0:02is a new york times best-selling author
- 0:04written many different books he's been
- 0:06on many different tv shows i'm talking
- 0:07oprah winfrey phil donahue
- 0:10wrote a book called the myth of male
- 0:12power as well as boy the boy crisis he's
- 0:15got millions of views online and he's
- 0:17very comfortable making others
- 0:19uncomfortable and i would even take it
- 0:22as far as he's very comfortable
- 0:24sometimes
- 0:25unintentionally or intentionally pissing
- 0:27other people off so with that being said
- 0:29doc thank you so much for being a guest
- 0:31on valuetainment
- 0:32[Music]
- 0:55why do you think some people get
- 0:56uncomfortable when you talk about
- 0:58you know i i don't know what university
- 1:00was you were speaking at
- 1:01people were writing against you
- 1:03protesting against you they were not
- 1:05happy about you speaking some people
- 1:06just wanted to hear your argument but
- 1:08they tried to silence your message why
- 1:10do you think this message of the boy
- 1:12crisis
- 1:14you know some people have a hard time
- 1:15listening to
- 1:17well to answer that question we're going
- 1:18to have to go deep quickly
- 1:20which is that historically and
- 1:22biologically
- 1:23men were programmed to be disposable
- 1:26and we would be programmed to be
- 1:28disposable to be uh able to save the
- 1:31lives of women
- 1:32so every generation had its war and
- 1:34every generation had some version of
- 1:36uncle sam saying we need you
- 1:38um and and they and we we all knew as
- 1:42males that you know uncle joe who was in
- 1:44the marines was the respected um person
- 1:47in the family and we wanted to be you
- 1:48know we were being criticized by our
- 1:50parents we wanted to be respected so we
- 1:52accept the social bribe what i call the
- 1:54social bribe of being called hero
- 1:57to get that type of respect and then
- 1:59women learn to fall in love with the
- 2:01officer and the gentleman not the
- 2:02private and the pacifist
- 2:04so we knew we would be if we were
- 2:06willing to risk our lives to save women
- 2:08to save children to save other men um
- 2:11save the country uh that we would be
- 2:13more loved we would be uh the person
- 2:16that was you know fallen in love with um
- 2:18by the woman who wanted the officer and
- 2:20the gentleman and not that private in
- 2:22the pacifist uh we learned on some level
- 2:25that lois lane had no interest in clark
- 2:27kent of the same person in superman
- 2:30uniform uh what she fell in love with
- 2:33and so we
- 2:34so when when men complain uh women are
- 2:37programmed to fall in love with alpha
- 2:39men not whining men
- 2:41and so when men complain it spiels to
- 2:44women like
- 2:47let's say a chalk on a blackboard
- 2:50scratching his nails scratching on a
- 2:52blackboard how he feels it doesn't feel
- 2:55right to women women instinctively
- 2:57withdraw from men who express
- 2:59what concerns them
- 3:01they want them to be there to deal with
- 3:04what concerns the women and so
- 3:07in the in the process of becoming
- 3:09successful as a man
- 3:11is inversely related to the process
- 3:14of becoming successful in love and so
- 3:18since we have a lot of entrepreneurs in
- 3:19the line i'll be glad to take that one
- 3:21at a much deeper level but
- 3:23that's the
- 3:24the underlying biological and historical
- 3:27background as to why we don't we're not
- 3:29as empathetic to boys and men
- 3:31complaining or expressing their hurt
- 3:33their pain their feelings their fears
- 3:35now you know to go to go and i want to
- 3:37unpack that but to go back where the
- 3:39audience kind of knows your history
- 3:41you're not somebody that started
- 3:43thinking like this your entire life you
- 3:45were originally part of the
- 3:47uh feminist movement matter of fact i
- 3:49think there's a picture with you and
- 3:51gloria steinem who was the spokes person
- 3:54or spoken or even the leader for the
- 3:56american feminist movement in america
- 3:59and uh you were kind of going in that
- 4:01direction can you kind of walk us
- 4:03through your history and what made you
- 4:05flip and switch
- 4:08yes first of all i don't feel i have
- 4:09flipped and switched but it's definitely
- 4:11true that um i was the only man ever
- 4:14elected three times to the board of
- 4:15directors of the national organization
- 4:17for women in new york city and i spoke
- 4:20all around the world on women's issues
- 4:23and
- 4:23and my income came completely from
- 4:26speaking around the world on women's
- 4:28issues and i i suppose i was probably
- 4:30the um
- 4:32the best known male spokesperson for
- 4:34women's issues and so i guess that was
- 4:36very close to gloria steinem betty
- 4:37friedan and all the initial leaders of
- 4:40the women's movement
- 4:41and i think things began to
- 4:44and so i i never considered i always
- 4:46considered myself i would say
- 4:48a gender a person in favor of a gender
- 4:51liberation movement i never wanted women
- 4:54to be criticizing men or women's
- 4:56movement to be focused on criticizing
- 4:57men i never wanted a men's movement to
- 5:00be focused on criticizing women i always
- 5:02wanted both sexes to understand that for
- 5:04the first time in human history
- 5:06we had an opportunity to not be
- 5:08dominated by not patriarchy but because
- 5:11i don't think we were dominated by
- 5:12patriarchy we were dominated by a need
- 5:14to survive
- 5:15and to survive
- 5:17women and men in most societies played
- 5:19roles women's role was essentially
- 5:21raised children men's role was
- 5:23essentially raised money
- 5:25women didn't feel that they would get
- 5:28much social praise so uh they had social
- 5:31bribes to be mothers and to raise those
- 5:33children and to do that well and men had
- 5:36social bribes that you weren't worth
- 5:38much of anything if you didn't
- 5:40either participate in the possibility of
- 5:42being disposable in war
- 5:44or being disposable in the workplace
- 5:46either by
- 5:47working the hazardous jobs or by
- 5:50working 60 70 80 hours a week where you
- 5:52might die at the desk from stress and
- 5:54overwork uh but your job was to earn
- 5:56enough money to be able to support not
- 5:58just your wife and your children and so
- 6:01you didn't think much of yourself and
- 6:02other people didn't think of much of you
- 6:04if you are an unemployed person living
- 6:06in your family's basement um and hoping
- 6:08that a woman would save you but you were
- 6:10really good looking and uh sweet and
- 6:12kind and had a good emotional
- 6:13intelligence
- 6:16so
- 6:17then maybe let me ask the question
- 6:19differently
- 6:20i'm sorry i didn't
- 6:22do the second part of that question
- 6:23which is how you know what made me
- 6:25evolve from that and i thought but you
- 6:27said you said not much has so let me let
- 6:29me ask the question in a different way
- 6:31so
- 6:32if you've been the same from the 60s and
- 6:3470s till today
- 6:35then it would only be the right question
- 6:37to ask has
- 6:39the movement of feminism changed from
- 6:41what it originally was to what it is
- 6:43today
- 6:45the answer is three answers to that yes
- 6:48yes and yes
- 6:50yeah got it so the the original focus in
- 6:53the women's movement was
- 6:54um that there was that you know helen
- 6:57ready i am woman i am strong um it has
- 7:00increasingly become
- 7:02i am one i've been wronged
- 7:05hashtagged me too i've been wronged um
- 7:08women and then and then uh there was
- 7:11always an anti-male dimension to the
- 7:13feminist movement even in the early days
- 7:15my former wife who was a very wonderful
- 7:18woman
- 7:19said to me you know you don't want to
- 7:21get involved with the women's movement
- 7:22it's really anti a lot of anti-male and
- 7:25my response was well it may be anti-male
- 7:28for a while but i don't think that that
- 7:30will um increase um as men start
- 7:34listening to it and men and women men
- 7:36and women's roles tend to change and to
- 7:39modify i think both sexes roles will
- 7:41change and modify however i do think
- 7:43men's roles will change much more slowly
- 7:46than women's roles will change and my
- 7:48former wife um said it was that because
- 7:50you feel men have the power i said no
- 7:52they don't have the power to speak up
- 7:54about the limitations of their roles uh
- 7:57we
- 7:58are we are programmed to protect women
- 8:00and to be able to do what women ask for
- 8:03and right now women are the first ones
- 8:05speaking up um to be able to be more
- 8:07flexible at who they want to be
- 8:09to be able to when children come
- 8:12women express
- 8:13because
- 8:14they have three choices um choice number
- 8:17one is to be full-time with the children
- 8:19if they're married in middle class or
- 8:20above
- 8:22your choice number two is to be
- 8:23full-time with the workplace um choice
- 8:25number three is to be
- 8:27part work part-time
- 8:29and men also have you know say well we
- 8:31have three options too and option one is
- 8:34to work full-time option two is to work
- 8:36full-time option three is to work
- 8:38full-time or if they're working class
- 8:40men to work to um jobs and if they're a
- 8:43a corporate executive it's too um or uh
- 8:47in involved in their middle and upper
- 8:50middle class man it's often to work more
- 8:52hours at the same job or to become more
- 8:54successful so a person who was a local
- 8:58sales person for product x
- 9:00might feel
- 9:01much more inclined to accept a position
- 9:04as national sales person but as a
- 9:06national sales
- 9:07he finds himself um leaving his um
- 9:10experiencing the father's
- 9:12couch 22 and the father's catch 22 is
- 9:14learning to love his family by being
- 9:16away from the love of his family
- 9:18and um and so he um then feels he's he's
- 9:23he's doing this increased amount of
- 9:25money earning to be able to give his
- 9:28families his family options that he
- 9:30never had he wants to buy a better home
- 9:33and a better neighborhood with a better
- 9:35school system for his kids
- 9:37and a better home for both his wife and
- 9:39his kids and and so he gets caught up in
- 9:42that but then spends less and less time
- 9:44for the kids and wife that he really
- 9:46loves and he's working for until
- 9:48sometimes he does things that he learns
- 9:51he learns things to be successful at
- 9:52work
- 9:53that are the opposite of what it takes
- 9:55to be successful in love and he doesn't
- 9:58know that he's doing that and the wife
- 10:00and the wife and children don't know
- 10:01that he's doing that but you know i'll
- 10:03be happy to share with you what that
- 10:05tension is now that often leads to many
- 10:08successful men um ending up getting
- 10:11divorced or not getting divorced because
- 10:14their wife needs the security
- 10:15economically that he provides but he
- 10:17senses underneath uh that his wife is
- 10:20really hanging around to to love the
- 10:22children and have that security rather
- 10:24than feeling loved himself
- 10:26well let me let me ask this do
- 10:29so common reasons why women get a
- 10:31divorce common reasons why men get a
- 10:33divorce it's a different in my family i
- 10:35i've seen both
- 10:36uh my dad filed a divorce against my mom
- 10:39so it was more from that side but from
- 10:40your experience what are reasons why men
- 10:42filed for divorce over women filing for
- 10:44divorce well bigger picture first
- 10:48when
- 10:49women have a college education
- 10:51they are 92
- 10:53of the people who are
- 10:55filed for divorce when they don't have
- 10:57an education much like they've only
- 10:59graduated from high school as opposed to
- 11:00college um they're the percentages are
- 11:03lower um has so
- 11:05why so what
- 11:07was that why so um
- 11:09because when a woman has economic
- 11:12security she
- 11:15needs the man less for economic security
- 11:18she senses that if she sues she if she's
- 11:21a plaintiff she has some advantages
- 11:24legally that
- 11:26that allow her to be to make it
- 11:29likely that she will both get um a
- 11:32significant amount of economic security
- 11:34in the future and will also prompt the
- 11:37children he she basically has the right
- 11:39to the children he has to fight for the
- 11:41children and he has to if he fights for
- 11:43the children it will cost him maybe
- 11:45125 000 to a quarter million dollars to
- 11:48fight for the children
- 11:49and uh that that oftentimes
- 11:52it just breaks his heart so men and
- 11:55women who go who are going through
- 11:57family court
- 11:58men often get so depressed by the
- 12:00process that they're eight times as
- 12:02likely as the mother is
- 12:04to commit suicide
- 12:06and so it's it's a very
- 12:08um challenging process and because the
- 12:11the court system is really designed
- 12:14at its current um
- 12:16state um to um
- 12:19when a woman most judges feel that
- 12:21children do best with both parents have
- 12:23to divorce that's accurate and most
- 12:25judges agree with that however when a
- 12:28woman says i'm afraid of my husband not
- 12:30just physically but you know he might he
- 12:33shouts at me and he raises his voice and
- 12:36she gives a couple of examples of that
- 12:39then the judge often fears um
- 12:42um giving the custody equally to both
- 12:45sexes
- 12:46because if there's one time out of a
- 12:48thousand um that that in fact you know
- 12:51that man um is violent or uh physically
- 12:54abuses the woman or just uh overly
- 12:57shouts at the woman and she records it
- 12:59on a video cam uh that he feel he
- 13:02becomes he or she the judge becomes
- 13:05vulnerable to um being um
- 13:08losing her his position as a judge
- 13:13okay so so why do men file the divorce
- 13:17and you know again
- 13:19you hear stories about women
- 13:21why are some reasons why men follow
- 13:23divorce yeah well first of all both
- 13:25sexes file for divorce largely because
- 13:29neither sex feels heard
- 13:33that is the single biggest problem the
- 13:35achilles heel of all human beings is our
- 13:38inability to handle personal criticism
- 13:40without becoming defensive
- 13:42and that's true of both men and women
- 13:46when men do file for divorce it's often
- 13:49because they um they feel that they just
- 13:52can't take it anymore uh they feel that
- 13:55their alcoholism or their
- 13:58ideations of suicide
- 14:00or
- 14:01the the feeling that the uh the mother
- 14:03really doesn't like him anymore not even
- 14:06just not love him but not like him
- 14:08um and and then often and then usually
- 14:11somewhere along the way particularly if
- 14:13he's an executive or a corporate person
- 14:16and he moves around a lot and owns his
- 14:17own business he might go from branch to
- 14:20branch of his of his business and
- 14:22eventually meet somebody that really he
- 14:24feels respects him oftentimes his own
- 14:26secretary might
- 14:28be much more respectful of him than his
- 14:30wife and um and so he feels like there's
- 14:33somebody else that can love me that does
- 14:35understand me that that is proud of me
- 14:38um and um and verse and then he has an
- 14:41affair with her um and um
- 14:45and that leads uh to him feeling that um
- 14:48and then usually the new woman
- 14:50wants uh wants more than just an affair
- 14:53wants some security wants some lifetime
- 14:55intimacy he does too and so that
- 14:58accounts for the eight percent um of
- 15:00people who are men that file for divorce
- 15:02usually and or the greater percentage of
- 15:05the woman has um
- 15:07um less of a of an education and is less
- 15:11likely to file um then um that starts
- 15:14increasing to about 20 25
- 15:16of males filing for divorce
- 15:18so so doc you know the boy crisis i mean
- 15:22the
- 15:23crisis of education christ of mental
- 15:24health crisis of father and crisis of
- 15:26purpose you know you you talk about this
- 15:28and then i saw one of your speeches
- 15:30where you're talking about at the age of
- 15:31nine
- 15:32boys and girls suicide rate is the same
- 15:35at 10 or 14 boys are twice
- 15:38the chance of committing suicide then
- 15:40the girls do twice the amount of
- 15:41suicides as boys as girls do
- 15:4415 to 19 it's four times the amount boys
- 15:46to girls
- 15:4720 to 25 it's six times the amount boys
- 15:50to girls so if you don't if you don't
- 15:52mind unpacking the boys crisis i have
- 15:55some follow-ups whether anything to do
- 15:57with the upper again has to do with the
- 15:58divorce but i'd like to start with the
- 16:00boy crisis first
- 16:02yes
- 16:03when i first submitted my proposal to
- 16:06my publisher for the boy crisis book
- 16:08i had 10 causes of the boy crisis i was
- 16:11going to write a chapter in each
- 16:13and then the more i studied it the more
- 16:16i realized that the single most
- 16:18important cause by a long shot was that
- 16:20basically the boy crisis resides where
- 16:24dads do not reside
- 16:26um and when boys don't have when when
- 16:29usually
- 16:31when there's one parent
- 16:33in the game um and the other parent
- 16:35minimally involved or not at all
- 16:37involved it's usually the mother that's
- 16:39the primary parent and the the dad
- 16:41that's the secondary parent and in those
- 16:44situations the girls have challenges and
- 16:46more than the daughters have challenges
- 16:48in more than 50 different areas
- 16:50but the boys have challenges in more
- 16:53than 50 different areas also but their
- 16:55challenges are more intense they're more
- 16:58likely to commit suicide than the girls
- 17:00are by the by the data that you just
- 17:02gave they're more likely to move into
- 17:04depression when you remember when you
- 17:06measure depression come by male
- 17:09standards which is almost completely
- 17:11unheard of as opposed to just the female
- 17:14measures of depression almost all of our
- 17:16measures of depression our female
- 17:17measures the boys are much more likely
- 17:19to become addicted to video games uh
- 17:22girls and boys both play video games
- 17:24video games are very healthy at a
- 17:27reasonable proportional amount of level
- 17:29to the rest of life
- 17:30but when it comes to addiction to video
- 17:32games boys are far more likely to be
- 17:34addicted to video games than than girls
- 17:36are
- 17:37um boys are far more likely to be
- 17:39addicted to drugs to alcohol um their
- 17:43depression leads them to feeling that
- 17:44they're they're worthless and they
- 17:46become ashamed of themselves and
- 17:49they fear that they're going to be
- 17:50rejected by girls so they're much more
- 17:52likely to turn into pornography because
- 17:54pornography is basically access
- 17:57to a variety of attractive women without
- 18:00fear of rejection
- 18:02at a price they can afford
- 18:04and so guys as they as they don't do as
- 18:07well in school
- 18:08they don't feel as admired by girls
- 18:10girls tend to date winners not losers
- 18:13and so they feel that they're a loser
- 18:15and that they fear that they can't risk
- 18:17rejection because they know that the the
- 18:19girls they're most attracted to are
- 18:21taking the quarterbacks or the student
- 18:22body president or some other guy that's
- 18:24really sharp
- 18:26and on the basketball team etc
- 18:28and so they start
- 18:30fearing um becoming introspective
- 18:32becoming withdrawn becoming rebellious
- 18:35becoming um
- 18:37very coercive to their parents and their
- 18:40they feel badly about themselves and
- 18:42that leads them into depression into
- 18:43suicide into drinking into drugs into
- 18:46death from opioid overdoses and into
- 18:49addiction to pornography
- 18:51and so and that addiction to pornography
- 18:53is very dangerous because what happens
- 18:55from for boys
- 18:57who are addicted to pornography is that
- 18:59you know the first time
- 19:00they they are watching pornography and
- 19:03just watching a woman
- 19:04an attractive woman take her clothes off
- 19:06is really exciting for them but after
- 19:08they've watched that 15 times it loses
- 19:10the the excitement and so they have to
- 19:13keep upping the ante until uh they're um
- 19:17requiring things like um the only way
- 19:19they can get turned on is a woman doing
- 19:21something like um
- 19:23letting him come in her face and so but
- 19:27then they finally get a woman that is
- 19:29really interested in being with them and
- 19:31the woman um is um and they get together
- 19:34and she and he wants to do that and she
- 19:37goes you know and withdraws because she
- 19:40feels treated like a porn object because
- 19:42she's being treated like a porn object
- 19:44and so that's really um very um
- 19:47challenging um for the woman and
- 19:50therefore is challenging for the
- 19:52guy as well have you ever spoken to
- 19:54pamela anderson
- 19:56i have never spoken to pamela anderson
- 19:59no i think it may not be a bad idea to
- 20:00speak to her because one of the things
- 20:02she talks to her boys about is
- 20:04when she says sometimes when i would go
- 20:06home with a guy they would try to have
- 20:08sex with me as if they watched the porn
- 20:10and she said i taught my boys don't have
- 20:12sex with girls with what you see in porn
- 20:14because that's not how they like it i
- 20:16think it's a very good conversation for
- 20:17the two of you guys to have but that's a
- 20:19completely different subject that's just
- 20:21a suggestion for you so i would agree
- 20:22with her 100 yeah so going back to uh
- 20:25going back to what we're talking about
- 20:26here with porn
- 20:28uh the the visual you gave was very
- 20:30helpful
- 20:31uh i'm sure it inspired a lot of people
- 20:33to make some bright adjustments in their
- 20:35lives uh uh so
- 20:38but uh going back to this so you talk
- 20:40about a fatherless boys okay
- 20:42and statistics we see nowadays and the
- 20:44consequences of it one
- 20:47uh what is the number between fatherless
- 20:49boys and motherless boys is it a 98 to
- 20:52two like the boys that are raised
- 20:53without a mother how small of a
- 20:54percentage is that well we don't even
- 20:56have a lot of data on it
- 20:58yes um boy boys are far more likely to
- 21:00be raised by their mom than their dad
- 21:02it's about a nine to one ratio
- 21:03nine-to-one ratio okay so so let me let
- 21:06me go a little bit more deeper without
- 21:07the question so so boys okay so we know
- 21:09that we know that's going to be taking
- 21:10place is there an event that
- 21:13incentivized
- 21:14incentivized uh
- 21:16you know mothers to say i don't need a
- 21:18man to help me raise my kids i can do it
- 21:20on my own or has this number nine to one
- 21:23been historically the same where we've
- 21:25had a lot of you know fatherless
- 21:28you know homes where boys are raised
- 21:30without a father is there is there a
- 21:31trend that took place
- 21:33very good question and uh the answer is
- 21:36what in the 53 largest developed nations
- 21:40with the emphasis on the word developed
- 21:44in developed nations survival is not as
- 21:47big an issue in the middle and upper
- 21:49middle class as it is in less developed
- 21:51nations
- 21:52when survival is not as big an issue the
- 21:54society starts giving more permission
- 21:56for there to be
- 21:57divorces if you want that because you're
- 21:59moving from
- 22:00survival what you need to what you want
- 22:03and if two people are unhappy most
- 22:05societies that are developed allow some
- 22:08permission for divorce
- 22:09the churches are usually not as
- 22:12significant a role they play a role um
- 22:15but the
- 22:16pressure to to not be just uh to be
- 22:19disgraced at yourself if you uh if you
- 22:22get a divorce is not as great
- 22:25so you have
- 22:26so in the
- 22:28end you have more freedom to raise
- 22:30children um by yourself if you're a
- 22:33woman so in the united states at the
- 22:35present moment 53 percent of
- 22:38women who have children who are under 30
- 22:4153
- 22:43have have uh children without being
- 22:45married
- 22:46um and
- 22:47in general
- 22:49without the under 30 part put in uh 42
- 22:53of women in the united states at the
- 22:56present moment who have children have
- 22:57children without being married
- 22:59most of the time even among those
- 23:02who who have who are not married but
- 23:05they're living with a man at the time
- 23:06that they have children those
- 23:08relationships last on average about
- 23:10three years
- 23:12and then usually after that three years
- 23:14the children
- 23:16have minimal or no contact with the dad
- 23:18uh when there's a split up and so the
- 23:21boy crisis resides
- 23:23among those boys who have minimal or no
- 23:27contact with the dead and even and
- 23:30they've had that contact for the first
- 23:32few years but then they feel abandoned
- 23:34and lost by that dad and boys you know
- 23:37the girls at least have the role model
- 23:39of a mother as to what it is to be a a
- 23:41female but the boys don't have the role
- 23:44model of a father or if they have a role
- 23:46model the father that father after the
- 23:48mother and father break up or the father
- 23:51is often bad mouthed by the mother he's
- 23:52very narcissistic that's why we broke up
- 23:54he's very self-centered and he's very
- 23:57he's not reliable he's not um
- 24:00you know he's a liar things like that
- 24:02and the boy begins to look in the mirror
- 24:04and worry that maybe he's looking in the
- 24:06mirror because he's a narcissist or he's
- 24:08you know he remembers lying to this a
- 24:10friend of his or he remembers being
- 24:12unreliable in this way or that way and
- 24:14he begins to fear that the qualities
- 24:16that
- 24:17that the father is being condemned for
- 24:19that led to the breakup of the mother
- 24:20and father are also qualities that he
- 24:22has and but he can't talk to the father
- 24:24about that because that'll only
- 24:26destabilize the relationship when the
- 24:28father and mother have a fight can't
- 24:29talk to the mother about that from the
- 24:31same destabilization fear and so he just
- 24:34shuts up about that keeps that inside of
- 24:36himself and it becomes a problem that
- 24:38leads to you know depending on the
- 24:40personality of the boy it either leads
- 24:42to minor problems or very major
- 24:44psychological problems that that
- 24:46oftentimes boys don't go to the
- 24:47psychologist and they don't work those
- 24:49things out
- 24:50and so among divorced families
- 24:53the challenge is even greater
- 24:55because the the children are often
- 24:57seeing the mother and father argue
- 25:00the the arguments are not compassionate
- 25:03arguments where gee i heard you say this
- 25:06tell me more about what you said that i
- 25:08had to sort anything about um here's
- 25:10what i heard you said did i distort
- 25:12anything am i missing anything is there
- 25:13anything more that you want to ask
- 25:14sweetheart
- 25:15tell me more that is not the
- 25:17conversation that the the children of
- 25:19divorce tend to hear
- 25:20and so for the past 30 years i've been
- 25:23conducting couples communication
- 25:24workshops around the country because i
- 25:26wanted to prevent the divorces i wanted
- 25:29children to have
- 25:31parents that had happy relationships
- 25:33positive relationships that that had
- 25:36that had differences of opinion but they
- 25:38knew how to hear each other to work
- 25:40those differences through and so
- 25:42therefore there would as a result of
- 25:44that be fewer divorces and therefore
- 25:46they would as a result of that um be
- 25:48fewer boys that didn't have uh very much
- 25:50father involvement and so um i've sort
- 25:53of gone back to the root cause of the
- 25:55boy crisis which really wasn't um boys
- 25:58alone but it was
- 26:00families breaking up
- 26:02builder boys not having a dad to work
- 26:04with and not having good communication
- 26:06role models
- 26:08in their parents and therefore those
- 26:09boys and the daughters of these of these
- 26:12divorced families are far more likely to
- 26:15have divorces themselves uh when and and
- 26:18bad communication um methods as they
- 26:20grow up
- 26:22do our taxes does our tax system benefit
- 26:26uh
- 26:27single mothers
- 26:28having more kids without relying on a
- 26:31husband just to say you know if i have
- 26:33another kid i'm going to make an
- 26:35additional xyz amount of money per year
- 26:37so i don't need another man because i'm
- 26:39going to get a benefit that's coming
- 26:40from the government
- 26:42does that take into account because
- 26:44again as somebody that's been in the
- 26:45financial industry all i'm looking for
- 26:47is data to show me what flip did a tax
- 26:49incentive flip did a new program flip
- 26:52did a new method of teaching in our
- 26:54educational system flip what was it that
- 26:56caused this to become
- 26:58the number that it is today
- 27:00the main flip was the option of
- 27:04developed nations that didn't have to
- 27:07worry about survival
- 27:09the second flip
- 27:10was the government became a substitute
- 27:13husband
- 27:14when it started to make
- 27:16laws saying that if a woman
- 27:19didn't have a man that she was living
- 27:22with or was not married to a man
- 27:25that she could get money from the
- 27:27government
- 27:28and so the government became a
- 27:30substitute husband and this was
- 27:32institutionalized through many many
- 27:34programs like women infants and children
- 27:37which makes it clear that it's not men
- 27:39infants and children it's not couples
- 27:41infants and children it's not infants
- 27:43whose parents don't make enough money
- 27:46so particularly in inner-city
- 27:48communities where that were poor
- 27:50oftentimes and particularly in
- 27:52african-american black communities uh
- 27:54there was often times the the the black
- 27:56male uh was not making a lot of money
- 28:00and in those cases what he wasn't um the
- 28:03woman and the black male um both usually
- 28:07a black woman and a black male man
- 28:09calculated that there was um a an
- 28:12inadequate amount of money that was
- 28:13coming from the father to support the
- 28:15children effectively so she
- 28:18made sure that the father did not live
- 28:20with her and so then
- 28:23so she could get the money from the
- 28:24government
- 28:25and that money came in multiple forms
- 28:27but not just through the women infants
- 28:29and children forms and um and so the
- 28:31woman felt that the best way to protect
- 28:33her children
- 28:35was to not have the father around but it
- 28:37turned out and that that that was the
- 28:40worst way to protect her children
- 28:41because of the children without children
- 28:44without a dad are most vulnerable now
- 28:47we've known this since
- 28:491965 when the moynihan report came out
- 28:52and
- 28:54daniel patrick moynihan was a
- 28:55sociologist a u.s senator a department
- 28:57of labor
- 28:59a cabinet executive under both
- 29:01republicans and democratic presidents
- 29:04and he
- 29:05was asked because he had such
- 29:07qualifications to do a report of what
- 29:09was created crime in the inner city and
- 29:12everybody was going oh my god this is
- 29:14going to end up you know blaming crime
- 29:16on blacks because we know that in the
- 29:18inner city very frequently blacks commit
- 29:20crimes and
- 29:22what came out was a very different
- 29:23report than many people expected and
- 29:25which was that that crimes were not
- 29:27created by blacks per se
- 29:29that crimes were created by the that
- 29:31those people
- 29:33in the inner city who were being raised
- 29:37uh without debts
- 29:39and that at the time in 1965 was 25
- 29:43of the males in the inner city uh
- 29:46almost all blacks um that that would be
- 29:50among black males
- 29:52among black families uh 25
- 29:55of the children were being raised
- 29:57without their dads in 1965.
- 29:59today
- 30:00the percentage is more than 70
- 30:03among black males
- 30:05among caucasian males at the 1965
- 30:09it was only 3.2
- 30:12of caucasian males that were being
- 30:14raised without their dads today
- 30:17it is 35 percent of caucasian males
- 30:21being raised without their dads so the
- 30:23caucasian males being raised without
- 30:25their dens today
- 30:27is higher than it was for black males in
- 30:301965 and we're seeing a huge amount of
- 30:34dysfunction among both black males and
- 30:37caucasian males today
- 30:40and much
- 30:41more among caucasian males than we were
- 30:44seeing among black males in the
- 30:461960s and mid 60s do we know why
- 30:51yes because the lack of father
- 30:54involvement
- 30:55leads many boys to feel that that they
- 30:58um
- 31:00they don't usually have postponed
- 31:02gratification so i'll give i'll give you
- 31:05an example
- 31:06of what happens so
- 31:08moms and dads tend to set boundaries the
- 31:11same way they both care about their
- 31:13children they say sweetie you can't have
- 31:15your ice cream until you finish your
- 31:16peas
- 31:17children intended to test boundaries the
- 31:19same way
- 31:21they want to have as few peas as
- 31:23possible before they get their ice cream
- 31:25the difference between moms and dads on
- 31:27average and sometimes this is reverse
- 31:30the roles are reversed on average the
- 31:32the um difference is that when the child
- 31:36says to mom you know i don't want to
- 31:38have my p's i had a bad day in school
- 31:41today i was bullied by somebody where
- 31:43the mom and dad are divorced and then
- 31:45mom feels guilty about the divorce and
- 31:47that feels this the child must be very
- 31:49stressed
- 31:50her empathy tends to step forward about
- 31:53uh and she says to herself some version
- 31:55of i'm not going to get into a big
- 31:57argument about a few p's this is
- 31:59ridiculous now when they're married and
- 32:01the father does get in
- 32:03in forces they can't have the peace
- 32:04until the um the uh they can't have the
- 32:07ice cream until they have the peas uh
- 32:09the mother feels the dad is being
- 32:11insensitive uh when they're divorced and
- 32:13the thoughts and the children are going
- 32:14over to the father's house the father
- 32:16says i'm sorry we had a deal here now
- 32:18the deal is you can't have your ice
- 32:19cream until you finish your beans and
- 32:21the child says you're so mean you know
- 32:23mom that lets me have my peas when i've
- 32:25had a bad day like this and so with her
- 32:27dad the children learn that they have to
- 32:29focus on finishing their peas
- 32:33in order to get
- 32:34their ice cream
- 32:36and because that's not going to give in
- 32:39and empathy will not
- 32:41the the the child cannot coerce or
- 32:44manipulate the father's emotions in
- 32:46order to get the ice cream uh before he
- 32:50finishes the piece
- 32:51whereas with mom the child is learning
- 32:54ah i can manipulate a better deal here
- 32:57mom says okay i know you're you know
- 32:58you've had a bad day so i'll tell you
- 33:00what just have half the piece and so the
- 33:02child realizes ah this is negotiable so
- 33:05it begins to try to have half the half a
- 33:07piece and um and then and then the mom
- 33:10says okay i'm again the child at least
- 33:12tried it's had they've had a bad day
- 33:14okay so now the child is learning that
- 33:16with mom i can manipulate better deals
- 33:19and so the skill set that the child with
- 33:22mom often learns is that of manipulation
- 33:25but also a lack of respect for the mom's
- 33:27boundaries
- 33:28and so the mom finds herself repeating
- 33:31and repeating the boundaries um
- 33:34and where dad
- 33:36after a while does not have to repeat it
- 33:38because dad's made clear
- 33:39that when the child does not finish the
- 33:41peas
- 33:42there's no ice cream so the child learns
- 33:45to focus on doing what he or she needs
- 33:48to do
- 33:49in order to get what she or he wants the
- 33:52ice cream and so the child is learning
- 33:54with the dad is postponed gratification
- 33:57and as most people know post bone
- 34:00gratification is the single biggest
- 34:02predictor of success or failure so the
- 34:05boy without postponing gratification
- 34:07goes to school uh has homework to finish
- 34:10but is much more likely to get
- 34:11sidetracked by an invitation from a
- 34:13friend to play a video game and so or he
- 34:16has a real great of potential as a
- 34:18basketball or a football player or as an
- 34:20actor or a musician but he doesn't have
- 34:22the discipline um to uh to become one of
- 34:25the best actors musicians basketball
- 34:27players
- 34:28so other is beat him out that are even
- 34:31less talented than he is for that role
- 34:33and he begins to feel ashamed of himself
- 34:35and sometimes depressed and again no
- 34:37girls are interested in the losers
- 34:39they're interested in the winners and so
- 34:41he starts turning in on himself and
- 34:43becoming withdrawn and his own only
- 34:45friends are the online friends that he
- 34:47doesn't have real friends that will help
- 34:49him move or do something when it really
- 34:51counts and so this leads to depression
- 34:54and in worst-case scenarios uh the
- 34:56increase in suicides and a lot of that
- 34:59comes from not having a dad
- 35:01that is there to
- 35:03guide him to help him take risks to help
- 35:06him be disciplined at doing what he
- 35:08wants to do
- 35:09moms are very good at helping their
- 35:11children both girls and boys identify
- 35:14their talents and pursue them but very
- 35:17frequently the children without a dad
- 35:20does not have the discipline to
- 35:21successfully become outstanding at the
- 35:24most fulfilling things you want to be an
- 35:26engineer or um you need um you need that
- 35:30discipline but also if you want to be an
- 35:33artist a writer a musician if you want
- 35:35to ever make a living at it
- 35:37or a basketball player and join the nba
- 35:40you've got to be extremely disciplined
- 35:45uh that was great so on your points
- 35:48you've written here you know in the book
- 35:50the christ of education christ and
- 35:51mental health christ the father christ
- 35:53of fathering purpose
- 35:54all that stuff but
- 35:56how much how much of um
- 35:59the crisis i know you said yeah 10 so i
- 36:00don't know the other six what they were
- 36:02but how much do you think the role of
- 36:04media and movies play
- 36:06in uh who this kid wants to be meaning
- 36:10uh i'm growing up who's the hero if the
- 36:12hero to me was like this strong
- 36:15military general uh you know what when i
- 36:17grow up i want to be general patton or
- 36:19whatever you know when i grow up i want
- 36:21to be like you know uh
- 36:23a john f kennedy i want to be like
- 36:25reagan i want to be like whoever it is i
- 36:27want to be like uh
- 36:28you know um
- 36:30clint eastwood i mean he's a man's man
- 36:33you know i want to be like this guy
- 36:35how much has the media change would
- 36:37portray
- 36:38who the ideal male is
- 36:41that is loved admired and respected and
- 36:45does that have a big influence on how
- 36:47boys adjust
- 36:49to get that necessary attention like oh
- 36:51my gosh today's boys are a little bit
- 36:52more silly i'm going to be silly because
- 36:54that gets the right attention versus man
- 36:56today's men are strong i want to be
- 36:58strong because that gets the respect i
- 37:00want do you think media plays a big role
- 37:01in that
- 37:03you know media does play an important a
- 37:04very important role um and
- 37:07we still have the same basic image of
- 37:10men uh today um
- 37:12on one level uh that is the man that the
- 37:16woman is interested in and attracted to
- 37:20is some version of superman however the
- 37:24images of the father on tv
- 37:27are the archie bunkers are the um you
- 37:29know the fathers that are just um that
- 37:32are the that are the goofballs and
- 37:34the
- 37:36analysis of advertising on tv where one
- 37:39parent is focused um uh it looks like a
- 37:41jerk or looks like a bumble you know a
- 37:43well-intended but bumbling um parent
- 37:46is not 90
- 37:48males as dads that are looked at away
- 37:50but 100
- 37:52males when there's only one parent being
- 37:55portrayed as a jerk
- 37:57100 of the time on your advertising
- 38:01it is the male being portrayed as some
- 38:03version of the jerk or a well-intended
- 38:06but bumbling sort of quasi idiot if you
- 38:09will and so we've gone to from father
- 38:12knows best
- 38:13to fathers no less
- 38:16as in our media images of dads and so
- 38:19it's the dad image that has really been
- 38:22um
- 38:24neglected that said
- 38:26there is recently an increasing number
- 38:28of positive father images and
- 38:31advertising
- 38:32and that's uh and that's but there's
- 38:34nothing close to what i feel needs to
- 38:37happen uh when i spoke to when i greece
- 38:39the white house of the the white house
- 38:42but i briefed the white house on the boy
- 38:45crisis book uh one of the things i
- 38:47talked with them about is developing a
- 38:49father warrior program w-a-r-r not
- 38:52worker um but warrior program um to
- 38:56encourage boys to um overcome the social
- 38:59biases uh that it takes uh to become to
- 39:03be valued as a dad uh right now if you
- 39:06if a girl in college or young woman in
- 39:09college uh approaches a male in college
- 39:12at a at a party let's say and she says
- 39:14oh you know let's you know what are you
- 39:16um planning to do when you get out of
- 39:18college and he says oh i want to be a
- 39:19full-time dad
- 39:21uh she's you know she's likely to find a
- 39:23journalist um in the in the room to come
- 39:25back and interview him
- 39:26but she's likely to not come back for a
- 39:28second and drink herself and so the guy
- 39:31gets the hint that you know i'm an
- 39:33aspiration to be a full-time dad or uh
- 39:36while the woman goes off and maybe
- 39:38earns the primary source of income or
- 39:40all the source of income
- 39:42that's the role that would be perfectly
- 39:44fine for her to play and he will be
- 39:46still attracted to her if she said that
- 39:48she wants to be the primary parent
- 39:51but very few he gets it that very few
- 39:53women are going to come back and and
- 39:55want to be with him if that's what he
- 39:58states as his life goal
- 40:00yeah i have a friend who's a full-time
- 40:02dad and the wife works and they've been
- 40:04together for 12 years 13 years
- 40:06and happily married so
- 40:09are you starting to see an increase in
- 40:10that and if yes why
- 40:13yes there is an increase in that
- 40:15fortunately why though
- 40:18why why is that happening
- 40:19because there is an increased amount
- 40:22well first of all um we are now at a
- 40:25place where
- 40:26two out of three
- 40:28of the people who graduate from college
- 40:32are female
- 40:33not
- 40:34not 60 40 60 40 are the ones that enter
- 40:38college but among college graduates the
- 40:40ratio is two female to one male
- 40:44so 60 40 get into college but men
- 40:48males in college are much less likely to
- 40:49graduate from college for a lot of
- 40:52reasons but the emphasis the the end
- 40:55product is uh the woman where we're
- 40:58twice as likely to have young women who
- 41:00are recent college graduates um that we
- 41:03are a male who's a recent college
- 41:04graduate so the the female is oftentimes
- 41:07um
- 41:09as available to her
- 41:10men who
- 41:12may be good-looking maybe taller than
- 41:14she
- 41:15um but she knows that she's going to be
- 41:17earning more money than he
- 41:18and so then a big issue a big issue
- 41:21happens
- 41:23is she wants to be a habitable woman and
- 41:24she's really interested in um you know
- 41:27in developing uh you know breaking a
- 41:29glass ceiling uh she knows that to do
- 41:32that but she usually wants to have to be
- 41:34a habitable woman she wants to be
- 41:35happily married and she wants to have
- 41:37children and children that are well
- 41:38raised
- 41:40so she begins to adjust to say well one
- 41:42way that i can do that is to marry a man
- 41:46who is a nurturer connector type of man
- 41:48as opposed to a provider protector type
- 41:50of man and um but um oftentimes and she
- 41:55does that and the marriage will that
- 41:58type of marriage that is a woman who is
- 41:59the primary breadwinner and a man who's
- 42:02home taking care of the children
- 42:04if she truly respects him
- 42:08that marriage has a high percentage
- 42:10chance of working out very well
- 42:12so two things three things have to be in
- 42:14place she has to really want to be a
- 42:17career person and want to have a lot of
- 42:19her approval and respect for the korean
- 42:21person
- 42:22she has to adjust ahead of time to the
- 42:25fact that the man that she can respect
- 42:27the man who's taking care of the
- 42:29children well
- 42:30taking care of the social schedule
- 42:32cooking the dinner as well and so on and
- 42:35as she loses respect for him and she
- 42:38if she gets attracted to another man at
- 42:41work who's really successful who also
- 42:43seems to be attracted to her
- 42:45that can make her divided in her love
- 42:48and the marriage will very frequently
- 42:50end
- 42:51but if she
- 42:52has the fortitude to know that the
- 42:55reason she has a happy marriage and and
- 42:58the man is raising children that men
- 43:00will only
- 43:02do that
- 43:03with gusto
- 43:05if they feel the respect from their
- 43:07wives
- 43:08because almost every man instinctively
- 43:10knows that a woman who does not respect
- 43:13a man is not able to love that man
- 43:17so so in the case of jeff bezos
- 43:20and mackenzie
- 43:22you have a mckenzie marital guy who
- 43:24who's now the richest man in the world
- 43:26and they get a divorce
- 43:28and she goes and marries a school
- 43:29teacher got him dan i don't know jewett
- 43:31or some some you know
- 43:33you know
- 43:34nice guy i'm sure but he's a school
- 43:36teacher so you go from here to here
- 43:39is there is there also an element of i
- 43:42am so burned out with being with a
- 43:44driven alpha guy that i just want a
- 43:46regular guy like you know how we go
- 43:48through a breakup we're dramatic right
- 43:50we'll go from
- 43:51somebody that is you know driven
- 43:53competitive you're like oh my gosh she's
- 43:56so attractive to me and overbearing like
- 43:58i just want to date a regular girl and
- 43:59then you're like oh my gosh i'm so bored
- 44:01and you go back to this why why do we
- 44:03why do we and the reason why is this
- 44:05question from you is because you brought
- 44:07up your first wife and i think your
- 44:08first wife was a mathematician i may be
- 44:10wrong i think she was a mathematician or
- 44:12either you were a mathematician or she
- 44:14was a mathematician and you guys were
- 44:15married for night for 10 years you spoke
- 44:17very highly about her here on the
- 44:19uh you know
- 44:21interview and then your second wife i
- 44:23think has been together for 20 years now
- 44:25i i want to say it's 20 years give or
- 44:26take a little over 20 years so
- 44:30where do we get
- 44:31marriage wrong like
- 44:33i don't even know if most most men even
- 44:36know like
- 44:37the purpose of getting married like what
- 44:39we're looking for are we confused half
- 44:41the time when we're getting married
- 44:43yes to be fair and honest um both sexes
- 44:46tend to fall in love with the members of
- 44:48the other sex who are the uh who are
- 44:51often opposites and and often the least
- 44:53capable of loving them uh so men fall in
- 44:56love with beautiful younger women who
- 44:58are less mature uh than they are and end
- 45:01up um being very highly you know look up
- 45:04looking up to the man at the beginning
- 45:05and we feel really proud and approved of
- 45:08and so on um but then it turns out that
- 45:11we're a little bit disgusted in their
- 45:12lack of maturity and they're disgusted
- 45:14at our uh propensity for dominating and
- 45:18and having all the answers and the more
- 45:19mature she becomes the more she wants to
- 45:21have an equality in the relationship
- 45:23which was different from the dynamic
- 45:25that attracted the two of them
- 45:27but there's a lot of bigger issues that
- 45:29often happen here too so the jeff bezos
- 45:31case i don't know the situation
- 45:33personally but normally speaking or very
- 45:35frequently as a sort of model um the the
- 45:39woman will initially be attracted to a
- 45:40man who is very successful powerful dumb
- 45:43confident in himself able to be has a
- 45:46sense of efficacy um and so um but she
- 45:50doesn't realize that it's ex
- 45:52but that it's exactly those
- 45:54characteristics that will lead to their
- 45:57divorce here's why
- 45:59so
- 46:01what both sexes have an equal need for
- 46:03is a need to feel heard and understood
- 46:06but as the male
- 46:08who is successful becomes more and more
- 46:10successful he often learns a series of
- 46:13behaviors that are
- 46:16that are that help him become successful
- 46:18at work
- 46:20that is are exactly the behaviors that
- 46:23lead him to be unsuccessful in love so
- 46:25for example let's say you're a ceo and
- 46:28you're looking for a a new type of plane
- 46:32and you get a sales person trying to
- 46:34sell you a special engine um that they
- 46:37have for a new plane that will that they
- 46:39say will be perfect for you well as as a
- 46:41ceo you're listening to that sales
- 46:44person speak and you're thinking to
- 46:46yourself okay is this salesperson as
- 46:49convincing as another salesperson i had
- 46:51before and should i also interview
- 46:53somebody else will this work for my
- 46:55chinese market well will this work for
- 46:57these infrastructure that i already have
- 46:59set up for my chinese market uh will
- 47:01this um you know and and is asking a
- 47:04hundred questions like this
- 47:05while the person is talking
- 47:08um and so that person the a good ceo has
- 47:13learned to self listen
- 47:15um to be juggling the listening process
- 47:18with the uh with the yes but process or
- 47:21what about process and the
- 47:23cross-examination process
- 47:25that skill set for the good ceo becomes
- 47:28so ingrained
- 47:30that when he takes that that skill set
- 47:32home and by the way this can sometimes
- 47:35be happened to women as well
- 47:37not as frequently but i'll explain why
- 47:39both frequently and not frequently so
- 47:41that the male sales of the male ceo
- 47:43comes home
- 47:44and his wife says you know i've had a
- 47:46really difficult day at work or i've had
- 47:48a difficulty with the children but
- 47:50something's happened in the family and
- 47:52um and the male
- 47:54sees his wife the woman he loves the
- 47:56woman he'd probably die for
- 47:58um to is having a problem and so our
- 48:01instinct when our wife is having a
- 48:03problem is to while she's talking to
- 48:05figure out a solution because
- 48:07instinctively when our wife who i we
- 48:10love is bleeding to death the only way
- 48:13to handle that is to solve the problem
- 48:15to get the band-aids on her quickly to
- 48:17get it to the emergency room quickly and
- 48:20so um we we're we're behaving with our
- 48:22wife in a way that is looking for the
- 48:25solution while she's talking
- 48:27very few ceos or top level entrepreneurs
- 48:31realize that there is a solution for
- 48:33your wife's complaints and challenges
- 48:37and that is to listen
- 48:39not only listen by keeping your mouth
- 48:42shut
- 48:43but also listen by when she's finished
- 48:46the complaining not coming up with a
- 48:49solution
- 48:50but rather saying so sweetie what i
- 48:53heard you say was was this is and then
- 48:55asking is that accurate and then if she
- 48:58says no actually it's mostly accurate
- 49:00thank you for listening but i i think
- 49:02you got this wrong not saying no no i
- 49:04said that
- 49:05not becoming defensive about what she
- 49:07feels we got wrong but being right in
- 49:10there saying so it's not what i said but
- 49:12it's this is that correct and then she
- 49:15goes yes that's correct okay did i miss
- 49:17anything and uh understanding what
- 49:20you're saying
- 49:21um yes i think you've missed this no no
- 49:23no i think i got that i said that
- 49:24because this no
- 49:26shut your mouth listen
- 49:28work on what she feels you miss because
- 49:30the only thing that counts
- 49:33is what she feels that you've missed and
- 49:35then when she begins to feel safe
- 49:37because you didn't distort anything you
- 49:39didn't miss anything say is there
- 49:41anything new that you'd like to add
- 49:43that leads to a woman or when a woman
- 49:46does the same thing for a man in reverse
- 49:49that leads to your partner feeling heard
- 49:52but the great majority of men
- 49:55move to fixing the problem
- 49:58as opposed to understanding that you can
- 50:02fix the problem by not fixing the
- 50:05problem the fixing of the problem is the
- 50:07listening process
- 50:09hearing
- 50:11and then letting your wife or your
- 50:13daughter or your son
- 50:15say
- 50:16here's what i heard you say son
- 50:18daughter wife
- 50:20uh mom dad
- 50:22um and then mom and dad daughter wife
- 50:25uh she a son feels really hurt
- 50:28and then
- 50:29and being open to anything you distorted
- 50:32open anything that you missed
- 50:34and so this is what i teach in my
- 50:36couple's communication courses in much
- 50:38greater depth than i've explained here
- 50:41and invariably one of the men in the
- 50:42chorus will say well no i'm not really
- 50:45fixing it then i'm not really attending
- 50:47to
- 50:47her real need she's hurting why am i not
- 50:50solving the problem for her and i have
- 50:52to work with him that hearing the
- 50:54listening process
- 50:56in the way i just described it is the
- 50:59solution
- 51:01the fixing of it leaves your wife
- 51:04children or parents feeling unheard
- 51:07people need to be heard
- 51:09before they are asking for a solution
- 51:12beyond being heard
- 51:14so let me let me ask you a question i
- 51:15think i'm getting a read on what you're
- 51:17saying are you insinuating that we
- 51:19should add term limits to marriage
- 51:22absolutely not um the term limits to
- 51:25marriage should be
- 51:28there should be no term limit to
- 51:29marriage like i'm talking like you get
- 51:31married four years and you campaign with
- 51:32all the family i think we should go one
- 51:34more four years
- 51:35you are you saying that's a good idea
- 51:37term limits
- 51:38yeah so you can do it that way but i
- 51:41think the the um i i think it's the
- 51:43second best way of doing it i think
- 51:45that's giving you a hard
- 51:49let's this time i was i was involved
- 51:51with my wife for 27 years and we took
- 51:53eight years before we decided to we
- 51:56actually got married and during those of
- 51:58um first eight years it was sort of like
- 52:01you know re-examining whether this was
- 52:03the right person for us we were very
- 52:05different people and so we really needed
- 52:07my couple's communication course to
- 52:09really hear each other really well
- 52:11in order to see that the differences
- 52:13made much less differences the
- 52:15difference in the love we had
- 52:17then um 17 years ago we got married
- 52:19married and my attitude when i got
- 52:22married
- 52:23i'm in this forever
- 52:24um you know there's no
- 52:26i may find another woman attracted but
- 52:29i've made my commitment and
- 52:31and that
- 52:33level of commitment that i made when i
- 52:35got married really was meaningful to me
- 52:38and there's there are things that
- 52:39happened in the ceremony of marriage in
- 52:41the ceremony of marriage you bring the
- 52:42people you love and care for around you
- 52:45they see you make that commitment when
- 52:48you make that commitment and you see the
- 52:50people you love
- 52:51see you make that commitment something
- 52:53changes in your brain your r c z your
- 52:56rostral cingulate zone in your brain
- 53:00is is special knowing that the people
- 53:03who you love are approving of you
- 53:06getting married and they will approve of
- 53:08you more when you remain married and
- 53:11that gives you a little extra oomph to
- 53:13go through the hard times um to um to to
- 53:16work things through that are that are
- 53:18challenging and then we had the couple's
- 53:20communication course where
- 53:22the the
- 53:24the the very
- 53:26disciplined process of teaching men and
- 53:29women how to listen to each other uh
- 53:31that goes beyond anything that i've seen
- 53:33um so far so let me um is if you don't
- 53:36mind going to the the the because i only
- 53:39have like seven minutes and i want to
- 53:40make sure i get these two other
- 53:41questions in there as well uh in on in
- 53:44the area of pay gap
- 53:46so you know it's a very common debate
- 53:48that you always hear on the political
- 53:50side that happens well women are not
- 53:52getting paid it's not fair it's not this
- 53:53so one side says female athletes should
- 53:56get paid as much as male athletes and
- 53:58then the argument will be made as female
- 53:59athletes in certain sports like
- 54:01gymnastics is more but maybe in
- 54:03basketball it's not more doesn't get as
- 54:05many viewership as male athletes do
- 54:08where did this pay gap argument come in
- 54:10and does it have any credence uh and if
- 54:13it does in certain industry is there
- 54:15some areas where it has no credence in
- 54:18yes well first of all this is such an
- 54:21important question that i literally
- 54:22wrote an entire book to answer this
- 54:24question
- 54:25called why men earn more the startling
- 54:27truth behind the pay gap and what women
- 54:29can do about it and the most important
- 54:31part of why men earn more i think is my
- 54:34discussion of the 25 differences between
- 54:38what men do
- 54:40in the workplace
- 54:41and in their work life balance and what
- 54:44women do in their work life balance
- 54:47so
- 54:48some quick insights
- 54:50never married men
- 54:52and never married women
- 54:54who have never had children
- 54:57that never married women out earn and
- 55:00their married men
- 55:02by 17
- 55:05and the never married women who have
- 55:07never had children
- 55:09have out earned the never married men
- 55:12who have never had children
- 55:14since the 70s wow
- 55:16that gives you some sense that
- 55:18the pay gap predominantly
- 55:21is not just about these 20 is about
- 55:23these 25 different um decisions
- 55:26that men and women make but it's usually
- 55:29not just men and women or single men and
- 55:31women
- 55:32it is rather
- 55:33married men and women with children the
- 55:36pay gap is much much less about men and
- 55:39women than it is about dads versus moms
- 55:42when dads become dads
- 55:44they tend to
- 55:46um
- 55:47give up jobs that they are fulfilling
- 55:49that pay less
- 55:51they love being an elementary school
- 55:53teacher but they realize that being a
- 55:55superintendent of schools or a principal
- 55:57will pay them twice as much even though
- 55:59they hate administration
- 56:01so they give up becoming that passionate
- 56:03elementary school teacher to do
- 56:05something that will support their family
- 56:06better they love being a musician an
- 56:09artist a writer or an actor
- 56:11but they all pay very little and
- 56:13starving artists so they give up those
- 56:16gigs and that those passions of
- 56:18fulfillment to pace to get something
- 56:21that pays more
- 56:22but the more fulfilling the job the less
- 56:25it pays on average the road to high pay
- 56:28is a toll road men when they become
- 56:32when they're just men who are who don't
- 56:34have children they they want to do
- 56:36what's fulfilling like women do but when
- 56:38they have children they're willing to
- 56:40give up doing what's fulfilling to and
- 56:42look at the things that pay more that
- 56:44they may like a lot less that they
- 56:46usually do like a lot less work more
- 56:48hours than they want to work because
- 56:50their job is no longer to please
- 56:52themselves their job is to make sure
- 56:55that their wife and children are secure
- 56:57and move to good neighborhoods with good
- 56:59schools and that their wife that their
- 57:01children have opportunities that they've
- 57:03never had as a result of those
- 57:05sacrifices and so that's where the pay
- 57:08gap resides
- 57:09and if you wish to really understand the
- 57:12pay gap look at those 25 differences and
- 57:15work life choices and i'll explain
- 57:17explain in the white men and learn more
- 57:18book exactly what those differences are
- 57:21worth financially and why the great
- 57:24majority of men do work that they like
- 57:27less that earns more and the great
- 57:29majority of women are more likely to do
- 57:31more fulfilling jobs that earn less and
- 57:34if you really do want to earn more
- 57:37you could look at any of those 25
- 57:39careers and jobs and decisions that men
- 57:42and women make
- 57:43that lead to earning more money but
- 57:46usually the earning of more money leads
- 57:48to less fulfillment
- 57:51so i asked i asked you earlier i said
- 57:53our goal on today's zoom is to be able
- 57:56to solve the boy crisis in 59 minutes
- 57:58i think we're making some progress i
- 58:00don't know what you say about that but i
- 58:01think we made some progress today doc i
- 58:03appreciate you for uh getting on the
- 58:06zoom here i've really enjoyed talking to
- 58:07you we're gonna put the link below to
- 58:09your book
- 58:10uh the boy crisis uh below for people to
- 58:13be able to find it we'll also put the
- 58:14link to your website where folks can go
- 58:15and find you but with that being said
- 58:17thank you so much for your time and
- 58:19being a guest on valuetainment
- 58:21it's a total pleasure i also want to say
- 58:23that a lot of men tell me that they
- 58:25commute or they're working out of the
- 58:27gym and the audible version is really
- 58:29more helpful for them to take in the um
- 58:31the um the boy crisis book fantastic
- 58:33we'll put the link below thank you very
- 58:35much great to take care real life
- 58:38so do you think there's a boy crisis yes
- 58:40there is thumbs up no i don't think
- 58:42there's a boy crisis thumbs down uh but
- 58:45i thought it was very interesting cena's
- 58:46perspective if you want to get his book
- 58:47we'll put the link below if you enjoyed
- 58:49this interview i did another interview
- 58:50with jordan peterson
- 58:52this was uh at the same event when i
- 58:55interviewed kobe the late kobe bryant
- 58:56and george bush if you've never seen
- 58:58this interview with jordan peterson it's
- 58:59a must-watch click over here to watch it
- 59:02and if you haven't subscribed to the
- 59:03channel please do so thanks for watching
- 59:04everybody take care bye
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of The Boy Crisis Explained - Why America is Producing Weak Men by Valuetainment, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 10,275 words across 1,593 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.