The Blind Shaker Dilemma — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00what's up everyone Lance hedric here and
- 0:02I think it's finally time to address the
- 0:05controversy now some of you probably
- 0:06know but a few months back I made a
- 0:09series of videos with a lot of data a
- 0:11lot of espresso shots to different
- 0:12Grinders where I was just looking at
- 0:14distribution methods in espresso and it
- 0:17sparked a massive discussion online with
- 0:20many people making all sorts of
- 0:21accusations towards me on brand bias and
- 0:25fake falsifying data and not knowing how
- 0:27to redate all these different weird
- 0:29things anyway what's interesting is
- 0:30someone pointed out recently that chat
- 0:32GPT has a a funny response when you type
- 0:35in the following what is the controversy
- 0:38surrounding Lance pedrick and we let uh
- 0:40chat gbt do its
- 0:42[Music]
- 0:45thing oh here we are Lance hedric a
- 0:48well-known figure in the specialty
- 0:49coffee Community has stirred up some
- 0:51controversy due to probably should have
- 0:53said shaken up some controversy due to
- 0:55his unconventional Brewing techniques
- 0:56Hedrick a YouTuber Bree a coffee
- 0:58professional with a deep interest in the
- 0:59science of coffee brewing gained
- 1:01attention for Innovative methods such as
- 1:03shaking grounds to improve extraction
- 1:05okay the controversy largely centers on
- 1:08the fact that hedrick's methods
- 1:09challenge traditional Brewing norms and
- 1:12sometimes rely on theories that haven't
- 1:13been fully scientifically
- 1:16validated some in the coffee Community
- 1:18appreciate his Forward Thinking approach
- 1:20and willingness to experiment While
- 1:21others are more skeptical questioning
- 1:23the effectiveness and reproducibility of
- 1:25his techniques for instance his shaking
- 1:27method to increase extraction and
- 1:29improve the flow RA in coffee
- 1:30preparation has been met with both
- 1:32interest and criticism as it diverges
- 1:34from conventional wisdom on how coffee
- 1:36should be brewed additionally hedrick's
- 1:38approach to sharing coffee knowledge
- 1:39often bypassing traditional academic
- 1:41coffee training in favor of more
- 1:43accessible online content has been both
- 1:45praised and critiqued some appreciate
- 1:47the democr the democratization of coffee
- 1:50education While others see it as Oprah
- 1:51simplifying or misrepresenting complex
- 1:54coffee science despite the controversy
- 1:56hedri remains a popular and influential
- 1:57figure in the coffee World known for
- 1:58pushing boundaries of father
- 2:00all that good stuff all right well
- 2:02that's an interesting thing to read and
- 2:04it makes me think well if chat GPT
- 2:06thinks it's a big controversy it's um
- 2:08probably still percolating out there and
- 2:09I still hear people talk about it quite
- 2:11frequently in fact I saw on another
- 2:13YouTuber's Channel who did something
- 2:14about coffee prep and how you don't need
- 2:16to prep your espresso Puck and
- 2:18channeling is fake I saw in the comments
- 2:20people were saying that I was some sort
- 2:22of I don't know it was almost like I was
- 2:24a shill to false information or
- 2:26something I don't know it was very
- 2:28weird the data that I gathered and
- 2:31interpreted and showcased in those
- 2:33videos that was never to push anyone
- 2:36into absorbing or utilizing those
- 2:37techniques so a lot of people assumed
- 2:40that there was some sort of um payment
- 2:43from the the I guess winner unofficial
- 2:46winner of my testing which was the Weber
- 2:47blind Shaker and there was not I got my
- 2:50shaker with my eg1 that I paid for
- 2:53that's what you get when you get an eg1
- 2:56and I used it in the testing only
- 2:58because Dr s SM said it's it's all they
- 3:00use in their lab and they testing in
- 3:01Zurich Switzerland so figured I We'll
- 3:03add that if it's good enough for Zurich
- 3:05it's good enough for the testing so when
- 3:07the the the figures came out I was just
- 3:09as shocked as everyone else and I just
- 3:10presented the findings never said you
- 3:12must do this for better tasting coffee I
- 3:14just said I've been incorporating this
- 3:16in a mind sense of testing it's tasted
- 3:18better now the resulting masses that
- 3:20went out and bought a Shaker people want
- 3:22to blame that on me saying that I get a
- 3:23cut if I was getting a cut I would have
- 3:25recommended a more expensive tool where
- 3:26I could get a bigger cut but anyway
- 3:28that's beside the point um there have
- 3:30been a lot of interesting responses to
- 3:32those videos in fact a lot of people
- 3:34have actually gone out and reproduced
- 3:35the testing and with very similar
- 3:37results in fact there was one home
- 3:39Barista out in Denmark named Kenneth who
- 3:42reproduced it using I think eight shots
- 3:44each on the different techniques and had
- 3:46the same exact results as mine and we'll
- 3:48post some graphs here I guess that'll
- 3:51help then of course you have the kma
- 3:53magazine out in Germany they did it in a
- 3:55much more controlled fashion than a lot
- 3:57of people would uh in their
- 3:59reproductions at the home level and they
- 4:01actually found exactly the same thing
- 4:03but they added an extra step in theirs
- 4:05or an extra I guess variable that one of
- 4:07their testing markers was using the
- 4:09blind Shaker with the autocom combined a
- 4:12big question that followed my video is
- 4:14well what if you blind shook for the
- 4:15benefits of it and then use the autocom
- 4:17or wdt would that make it even better my
- 4:19speculation is that it wouldn't it would
- 4:21undo some of the benefits that you're
- 4:23getting with blind shaking namely the
- 4:25Dome that is being created when you dump
- 4:26it out and they seem to have gotten the
- 4:29same results in the sense that the
- 4:30highest extraction of all of their
- 4:32methods where they used six to eight
- 4:34shots I can't remember on each method
- 4:35they had two-time German barista
- 4:37champion Erna doing all the shots using
- 4:39um commercial equipment uh and with it
- 4:42they found that the blind Shaker alone
- 4:44was a 2% higher extraction yield than
- 4:47anything else the second highest was a
- 4:49tie between just a leveler and blind
- 4:51Shaker plus autocom and then in last
- 4:54place were the two wdt tools which was
- 4:56the autocom and the Clara some other uh
- 4:58wdt tool that they used for the
- 5:01experiment they do point out that with
- 5:04one coffee they were getting
- 5:06significantly different tastes when they
- 5:07shook for 20 seconds as opposed to 5
- 5:09seconds so that is interesting and the
- 5:11fact that shaking shots do go faster and
- 5:13I had a lot of anecdotal reactions to
- 5:15this statement as well that they're
- 5:17faster when they're shaken uh it also
- 5:19kind of contributes to this idea that
- 5:21something more is going on inside than
- 5:22just Center mouning so anyway the thing
- 5:25that they said that I really did
- 5:26appreciate is you know with all of this
- 5:27you have to go into it with your own
- 5:29skepticism and see what you taste what
- 5:31tastes the best the idea is not higher
- 5:33extraction equals better I've never once
- 5:35said that I've never preached that
- 5:36that's not the case I drink relatively
- 5:38low ey compared to what most people
- 5:40think I drink I'm usually sitting around
- 5:4320 to 21 maybe even 19 for filter coffee
- 5:45and espresso greatly changes depending
- 5:48on the coffee okay folks time for
- 5:50another jayl update and a few comments
- 5:52on some recent Lance Hendrick videos
- 5:54about shaking your ground I know that
- 5:55Jay lover espresso out in Australia
- 5:57found that shaking also had its benefits
- 5:59has a new wdt tool that he believes does
- 6:02add to uh add to help we I can't test
- 6:05that so I can't know it does seem that
- 6:07wdt does negate or or does not improve
- 6:11more so the efficiency of extraction as
- 6:13the blind Shaker but what he has done in
- 6:15his testing does also reflect what I
- 6:18showed a lot of people complain about
- 6:20workflow and that's okay you know same
- 6:23thing happens when you first get into
- 6:24wdt a lot of people have issues with
- 6:26workflow it's once you learn how to do
- 6:28something and you incorporate it
- 6:29actually practice it that it becomes
- 6:31easier so using the Shaker I shake shake
- 6:34shake for 3 to 5 seconds I put it down
- 6:37tap put it on top of the Porta filter
- 6:39done makes it really easy I tap the side
- 6:42of the Porta filter and I'm good to go
- 6:43all with under I think it's like a
- 6:45posted a video on Instagram it took me
- 6:46like 5 seconds or something to do the
- 6:48whole thing so it's all about the
- 6:50workflow you're doing people also
- 6:52complain that it's you know $80 for this
- 6:54I never recommended buying it there are
- 6:55a lot of ways you can shake your coffee
- 6:57the big thing that I like about this
- 6:59however is that it has kind of a
- 7:01funneling uh mechanism that occurs
- 7:03whenever you dump the grounds out which
- 7:05allow for kind of a center Mound inside
- 7:06the Porta filter then when you tap it
- 7:08you still have a bit higher
- 7:09concentration in the center which
- 7:10actually can reduce the effects of edge
- 7:13uh under extraction which does occur
- 7:16even with perfectly distributed coffee
- 7:18or what you think might be a perfectly
- 7:19distributed
- 7:25coffee I just wanted to address kind of
- 7:27this idea that I'm out here pushing a
- 7:29certain thing to be bought which I'm I'm
- 7:30not you do what you want to do you want
- 7:32to do wdt that's cool you want to do you
- 7:35know the the stock FFF okay you're a
- 7:37little outdated but that's cool too you
- 7:39want to do north south east west you
- 7:41want to do horizontal tapping I mean you
- 7:43want to do nothing and just pop it in
- 7:44there and go great that's awesome I
- 7:47don't I don't care that's why I end all
- 7:48my videos with Brew something tasty that
- 7:50takes the absolute top spot with all
- 7:53coffee preparation and everything that
- 7:55you do brw something tasty now I'm still
- 7:57not even arguing that this is
- 7:58objectively the best tasting one I will
- 8:01argue especially with all the backed up
- 8:02you know studies on other Grinders there
- 8:04was this massive study that some friends
- 8:06of mine did um where they tested over
- 8:08four different Grinders eight shots each
- 8:10using blind Shaker then blind Shaker
- 8:13plus wdt then blind Shaker plus OCD and
- 8:16there are results of that too so there
- 8:17have been people who have been finding
- 8:18the efforts of this and the effects of
- 8:20this to be superior than other ways and
- 8:23so they've been now testing not just
- 8:25whether blind Shaker is better but what
- 8:27is the best way to use the blind Shaker
- 8:29and it's still seems that the most
- 8:30consistent way of doing it is just
- 8:32shaking and dumping and anything on top
- 8:34of it is either going to take away from
- 8:36it or is going to just make things a
- 8:37little bit more difficult to
- 8:40reproduce the only thing that is
- 8:41objective is on the studies that have
- 8:43been released you have a higher
- 8:45extraction consistency and yield with
- 8:48blind Shaker and it's always it's pretty
- 8:49much always statistically
- 8:53significant the thing for me with
- 8:55espresso specifically is I found that
- 8:57the more even or efficient the
- 8:59extraction is the more tasty it tends to
- 9:02be so if we have two coffees same
- 9:05recipes and one of them is extracting
- 9:07higher than the other at the same grind
- 9:09size then obviously logic will tell us
- 9:12it is a higher efficiency of extraction
- 9:15now that's not proven I guess you could
- 9:17argue that it could be more inefficient
- 9:19and one part of it is extracting so much
- 9:21more than the rest that it's boosting
- 9:23the extraction but the likelihood of
- 9:24that is probably low instead the
- 9:27likelihood is it's extracting more f
- 9:30and I found with espresso due to its
- 9:31such fine grind size that the more even
- 9:33you can get that extraction then at a
- 9:36given ratio it probably taste a little
- 9:38bit better what I recommend doing is
- 9:40getting them all to the same extracting
- 9:42extraction yield and tasting them side
- 9:44by side by side with a Shaker you will
- 9:47be able to go coarser than you can
- 9:50without a Shaker or with something that
- 9:51gives you less extraction yield in order
- 9:54to match extraction with this you have
- 9:56to go finer with something else so let's
- 9:58say that in my tests I was getting 23%
- 10:01with this and 21% with wdt to match them
- 10:04I probably wouldn't go finer on the wdt
- 10:06to match 23 I'd probably go coarser with
- 10:09the Shaker to match 21 my bet is because
- 10:12you're going coarser you're getting even
- 10:13more even extraction the coer you go in
- 10:16espresso the more even it is regardless
- 10:17of how ugly it looks just the pathways
- 10:20are more easy it's easier for water to
- 10:21make it through
- 10:23evenly that is a better way of doing it
- 10:25as kerma said is is matching the
- 10:27extractions tasting it for yourself and
- 10:29and deciding what you want to do now I
- 10:31have nothing against wdt and in fact I
- 10:33think it's very funny when I see Matt
- 10:35perer walking around expose with his wdt
- 10:38hat like I get it he sells a wdt
- 10:41mechanism and it makes sense and I have
- 10:43nothing against it in fact I still will
- 10:44recommend from time to time and autocom
- 10:46on bars because sometimes Baristas are
- 10:48so inconsistent from person to person
- 10:50that some sort of standard makes sense
- 10:52and due to the fact that autocom is
- 10:54pretty indestructible that's a great
- 10:56option
- 10:59are people who I who I've chatted with
- 11:01that have implemented this into their
- 11:02barf flow and they say it's been
- 11:03incredible but I would imagine they're
- 11:06not super high volume because I I can't
- 11:08imagine it being very easy to shake
- 11:09every shot in a in a and baras would
- 11:12probably hate you whereas two or three
- 11:14little turns of an auto comb if you have
- 11:16if you have it down because it's a
- 11:17difficult workflow to learn then that
- 11:19that's a much easier thing you do reduce
- 11:21the consistency in the extraction but if
- 11:24you dial it in to where it's tasting
- 11:25good most coffees can taste pretty good
- 11:27even with uneven extraction then you're
- 11:29good to
- 11:30[Music]
- 11:32go anyway if you are watch this whole
- 11:35video just cuz you watch my videos and
- 11:36you're new to the channel and you have
- 11:37no idea what I'm talking about the
- 11:39original videos are linked down below
- 11:41but essentially I was just testing out
- 11:42different distribution
- 11:46methods all that to say I'm still
- 11:49curious about the densification that's
- 11:51going on in here or if it's even
- 11:52happening according to like Dr Mark Al
- 11:54shamarie and the other theories that are
- 11:55out and about I don't think we truly
- 11:57understand all that might be going on I
- 11:59do think that a big thing that's helping
- 12:00it is the center mounting and I do think
- 12:02that there is something going on with
- 12:04shaking that's causing fines to go to
- 12:06Boulders anyway I hope that you brew
- 12:08something tasty today whether that would
- 12:10be shaken or stirred cheers
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of The Blind Shaker Dilemma by Lance Hedrick, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,500 words across 359 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.