YouTube2Text

The Big Short Partners Reunite: Rates, AI, Gold and Two Stock Picks | The Real Eisman Playbook Ep 75 — Transcript

by Steve Eisman · 10,271 words · 1,599 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:05Hey, it's Steve Eisman and welcome to
  2. 0:06another episode of The Real Eisman
  3. 0:08Playbook. So, when this podcast got
  4. 0:11started April of last year, one of the
  5. 0:13first guests were my former partners,
  6. 0:16Vincent Daniel, Porter Collins, and
  7. 0:18Danny Moses. We had this really great
  8. 0:20conversation. And since last April, I
  9. 0:24mean, to say that the world has changed
  10. 0:27sounds stupid. It's it's just so
  11. 0:29incredible how much things have changed.
  12. 0:31And you know, sometimes it's a good idea
  13. 0:33not to interview someone, but to sit
  14. 0:35down with some old friends and kind of
  15. 0:37hash things out. So that's what we're
  16. 0:39going to do today. Porter Vincent,
  17. 0:41welcome back.
  18. 0:42>> Good to be here.
  19. 0:42>> Thanks for having us.
  20. 0:43>> So let's start. I mean, where could we
  21. 0:46start? We could start with anything
  22. 0:47this. Let's start with Scott Bessant.
  23. 0:50Okay. Um, we'll do a little bit we'll do
  24. 0:52like a lightning round like Porter, what
  25. 0:55do you think about what the hell's going
  26. 0:56on with Scott Besson and the Treasury
  27. 0:58Department buying [laughter] buying
  28. 1:00long-term treasuries?
  29. 1:01>> Well, this is our old sandbox, right?
  30. 1:03This is the Fed. This is monetary
  31. 1:04policy. This is the Treasury.
  32. 1:07I think they're screwed.
  33. 1:10you know, they're they're at a point
  34. 1:13where they have to try these
  35. 1:14extraordinary measures because they're
  36. 1:16at they're out of things to do and
  37. 1:20they're trying to keep a lid on yields,
  38. 1:22but inflation's a problem. It's still
  39. 1:24high and you know, Wars is doing his
  40. 1:28little dance, but they can't do
  41. 1:30anything. And and at this point, you
  42. 1:32know, I I see it as interest expense
  43. 1:35plus entitlements isund and call it 10%
  44. 1:38of tax receipts. There's nothing you can
  45. 1:41do. You can't cut interest unless you
  46. 1:43Well, you certainly can't cut interest.
  47. 1:45I mean,
  48. 1:46>> you can in theory cut entitlements, but
  49. 1:48no one is going to is even talking about
  50. 1:49>> We've been talking about this for how
  51. 1:51long, Steve? And they haven't done
  52. 1:52anything long time.
  53. 1:53>> Yeah.
  54. 1:53>> Long time.
  55. 1:54>> And so I I don't know what you do. You
  56. 1:56either got to raise taxes a lot, which
  57. 1:59>> that's not going to happen.
  58. 2:00>> Not going to do print,
  59. 2:02>> right?
  60. 2:03And so, you know, you can see why,
  61. 2:06>> you know, I think I've had as much
  62. 2:08conviction in this precious metals trade
  63. 2:10as I've had in anything in a long, long
  64. 2:13time. So, explain to viewers who are not
  65. 2:15familiar with precious metals.
  66. 2:18>> What is the relationship between on the
  67. 2:21one hand what you're talking about
  68. 2:23interest rates and on the other hand
  69. 2:25precious metals? Because
  70. 2:27>> it's not intuitively obvious,
  71. 2:29>> no
  72. 2:30>> to most people that they're connected.
  73. 2:32So explain it to people like why do you
  74. 2:34think owning precious metals is is the
  75. 2:37result of everything you just talked
  76. 2:38about with respect to interest rates?
  77. 2:39Well, it goes back, you know, you got to
  78. 2:40take a little history lesson, but in
  79. 2:42terms of um central banks used to own
  80. 2:46assets, right? When you own other
  81. 2:48person, when you own debt, it's a you're
  82. 2:49owning a liability, right? And they own
  83. 2:52US government bonds. I know it's an
  84. 2:54asset, but it's someone else's
  85. 2:55liability, right? And so gold is an
  86. 2:57asset. And that's why you've seen um
  87. 3:00central banks around the world,
  88. 3:01including China, buy more and more of
  89. 3:03it, right? Right. And so I think you've
  90. 3:05crossed or close to crossing depends on
  91. 3:07the gold price obviously um as between
  92. 3:11gold and treasuries as which which is
  93. 3:13bigger as a percent of central banks
  94. 3:16balance sheets.
  95. 3:17>> So you're talking mostly about gold.
  96. 3:18>> Gold. Yes. Gold. And um you know gold's
  97. 3:23nothing. It's just it's an asset but
  98. 3:25it's an asset that's been it's doesn't
  99. 3:27have any debt. Doesn't you know just
  100. 3:29sits there right? And so it's a rock.
  101. 3:31It's a rock. and it's formed in outer
  102. 3:34space, but it's it's a rock and it it
  103. 3:36basically everything else is crashing
  104. 3:39against it, right? And so that's the
  105. 3:41sort of thesis. It just stays there.
  106. 3:42Everything else goes down, right? So is
  107. 3:45it value in dollars goes up because the
  108. 3:47dollar goes down and that's been the
  109. 3:49history. And if you look at the chart of
  110. 3:50it, it the dollar, US dollar has gone
  111. 3:52down and down a lot in the last hundred
  112. 3:55years. And I think that trend continues
  113. 3:57and probably, you know, accelerates at
  114. 4:00this point because they're out of
  115. 4:01arrows. So you like gold as kind of a
  116. 4:03result of all this stuff?
  117. 4:04>> Yeah. I I can't tell you what it's going
  118. 4:06to do today, tomorrow, but like I think
  119. 4:08>> Who could?
  120. 4:08>> Yeah. But I think, you know, if I look
  121. 4:10back in in five years, I think it's
  122. 4:12going to be a lot higher
  123. 4:14>> then. If you put yourself in the shoes
  124. 4:17of Bessant, I like doing this. Like what
  125. 4:19would
  126. 4:19>> you love doing that?
  127. 4:20>> I do. And I would say, well, what would
  128. 4:22I do? Well, the first thing I would do
  129. 4:24is I would go up to
  130. 4:24>> Well, by the way, before you say what
  131. 4:26you would do, you're in Besson's shoes.
  132. 4:29>> Yeah.
  133. 4:30articulate the problem from his
  134. 4:33perspective. What's the problem?
  135. 4:34>> So the problem is is that right now I
  136. 4:37have as Porter said expenses that are
  137. 4:41higher than receipts.
  138. 4:42>> Right?
  139. 4:42>> That's one of the issues
  140. 4:45to the point where 40 trillion times an
  141. 4:48interest rate is a big number and it's
  142. 4:50really eating into all the other things
  143. 4:51the government can do
  144. 4:52>> and going higher.
  145. 4:53>> So you need rates lower,
  146. 4:55>> right? So that so my that's the problem
  147. 4:58my primary agenda my issue is to get
  148. 5:00rates lower because that's the problem
  149. 5:02>> and it helps the economy
  150. 5:03>> of course and of course it helps the
  151. 5:04economy. So the first thing I would do
  152. 5:07>> is go up to my boss which is President
  153. 5:10Trump and say respectfully Mr. President
  154. 5:14can you end this war because if you can
  155. 5:16end the war maybe we could get oil down
  156. 5:19from say 86 to 60. Inflation
  157. 5:23expectations will come crashing down.
  158. 5:25rates will come crashing down. And so
  159. 5:27that gives us time.
  160. 5:29>> And the president just said no.
  161. 5:31>> Well, the president just said, "For some
  162. 5:34reason, I can't." Right? I think he's
  163. 5:36trying to be fair, but it's not working.
  164. 5:39>> Okay?
  165. 5:39>> So then what do you do? Right? Then you
  166. 5:42say, "Well, then we need to cut
  167. 5:44entitlements." No. Then we need to raise
  168. 5:46taxes. No. Like these are all nos. So
  169. 5:49then you start with theatricality and
  170. 5:51deception by playing twist games that
  171. 5:55the three of us when we were in the
  172. 5:57office together and if we saw something
  173. 5:58like this we would start laughing at
  174. 6:00each other and like what's 4 billion
  175. 6:02going to do? Well he said at least 4
  176. 6:04billion which means it's infinite. He's
  177. 6:06trying to have his draggy moment. Um so
  178. 6:08I think he is going to keep trying to
  179. 6:12get rates down because that's what he
  180. 6:14needs to do over the next six months to
  181. 6:16nine months. It has to.
  182. 6:17>> Why do you say 6 to 9 months?
  183. 6:19>> Because I just I think they need time
  184. 6:23for
  185. 6:26inflation expectations to come down. Um
  186. 6:28and I you're trying to make a bet that
  187. 6:32somehow someway
  188. 6:34economic growth will slow a little bit,
  189. 6:37not a lot, to a point where inflation
  190. 6:39can come down to the point where rates.
  191. 6:42But but this is all a bet that they're
  192. 6:43trying to make. And in the interim, I
  193. 6:45think they're playing a lot of games to
  194. 6:47try and pull forward lower rates by
  195. 6:51signaling to the market, this is what
  196. 6:53we're going to do. I'm going to get what
  197. 6:55I want. You better follow my lead so
  198. 6:58rates can come down.
  199. 6:59>> Okay. All right.
  200. 7:00>> And and the and the war was just a a
  201. 7:03massive strategic error from, you know,
  202. 7:06a interest rate and debt perspective. We
  203. 7:09I think he thought they would be over
  204. 7:11in, you know, two weeks. He did
  205. 7:14>> and he That's a bad miss.
  206. 7:16>> Yeah. Okay. All right. I'm going to
  207. 7:18voice my opinion.
  208. 7:19>> Okay. Go for it.
  209. 7:20>> Here it comes. So, you know, I'm not
  210. 7:22nearly as hung up on the deficit as you
  211. 7:24guys. As as you know, I have this whole
  212. 7:26comedy routine where I go people like
  213. 7:28you are part of the oil the deficit. You
  214. 7:31know, we only talking about this for the
  215. 7:33last 25 years. Um,
  216. 7:36I don't think
  217. 7:38despite how bad it is that it's like
  218. 7:43eminent doom and destruction at this
  219. 7:45point. I don't think I don't think we're
  220. 7:46close, but we're moving in that
  221. 7:49direction.
  222. 7:49>> I mean, the question is defined doom and
  223. 7:51destruction. Like we're not going to
  224. 7:53>> think the rates are going to go 50 basis
  225. 7:55points higher in the end of the day is
  226. 7:56not the worst thing is not to me the
  227. 7:58worst thing in the world. I think the
  228. 8:00the mistake that
  229. 8:03Bessant made is basically putting a line
  230. 8:06in the sand. Now he has to defend it.
  231. 8:08>> Yes.
  232. 8:08>> That's this is what Dr. Miller said. By
  233. 8:10the way, did you read about the scandal
  234. 8:11about JCO Miller?
  235. 8:12>> No,
  236. 8:13>> he wrote it on AI. He wrote
  237. 8:15>> Oh, that that he admitted to it.
  238. 8:17>> He admitted to it. It's like that's why
  239. 8:19it's not a scandal.
  240. 8:20>> My my my response to him is you could
  241. 8:22have just written it yourself. It's not
  242. 8:24that complicated. You know, why would
  243. 8:25you do that? It's lazy. He said he's an
  244. 8:27econ major, not not an English major.
  245. 8:29>> You could still write a stupid editorial
  246. 8:32that's five paragraphs long. It's not
  247. 8:34that complicated. It
  248. 8:35>> was 100% written by
  249. 8:36>> 100% every word. Every word. So
  250. 8:41I think it's a bad sign. I think that
  251. 8:43that doing it is actually the sign of
  252. 8:45weakness. Not the problem is not the
  253. 8:47sign of weakness. Doing it.
  254. 8:50>> You're coming our way.
  255. 8:50>> I'm a little more nervous than I've
  256. 8:52been. And let's leave it at that. So I
  257. 8:55what we would contend always was that
  258. 8:58when you woke up in the morning and you
  259. 9:00turned on CNBC,
  260. 9:02>> right,
  261. 9:02>> and you saw rates benign, Nvidia up,
  262. 9:07>> Apple up,
  263. 9:08>> that made everyone come and said and
  264. 9:11said
  265. 9:12>> nothing's wrong here, right
  266. 9:15underneath the surface, the amount of
  267. 9:18work that they're doing to make sure
  268. 9:20that everyone wakes up in the morning
  269. 9:22and sees calm.
  270. 9:24I think is incredible. And this is the
  271. 9:26first time that people are starting to
  272. 9:28see what we see.
  273. 9:30>> It was just so out in the open that it
  274. 9:32couldn't be hidden anymore. Right.
  275. 9:33Right. And saying like to me it's like
  276. 9:36he's been doing this for about 5 years.
  277. 9:38>> 10 years.
  278. 9:39>> 15 years.
  279. 9:40>> Well, the Fed has the Fed has.
  280. 9:42>> The Fed has correct. The irony here is
  281. 9:43that is that Wars comes in and says, "I
  282. 9:46don't want to do this anymore cuz he's
  283. 9:47in a box."
  284. 9:48>> Right. And Besson says, "I'm going to
  285. 9:50replace you."
  286. 9:50>> I have a theory for that.
  287. 9:51>> Okay. Oh, please share.
  288. 9:53>> So the theory is that let let me provide
  289. 9:56let me just explain because viewers
  290. 9:58understand this.
  291. 9:59>> So the Fed over since basically 2010 has
  292. 10:02done quantitative easing multiple times
  293. 10:05where the Fed goes out and buys
  294. 10:07treasuries with the idea of of bringing
  295. 10:10interest rates down. That's supposed to
  296. 10:11jumpst start the economy. It never
  297. 10:13helped the economy but it did help the
  298. 10:15stock market go up. So Walsh as a new
  299. 10:17head of the Fed has basically said I
  300. 10:20don't want to play that game anymore. I
  301. 10:21don't want to do quantitative easing and
  302. 10:23I don't want and what's more I don't
  303. 10:25want to talk about it. So and so he's
  304. 10:28stepped aside and they're still doing QE
  305. 10:31every day. They just don't call it Q.
  306. 10:34They're printing money every day.
  307. 10:35>> Yes, they're printing money. They're not
  308. 10:37they're not actually going
  309. 10:39but he but in theory he has stepped
  310. 10:41aside. Now Besson comes in and says I'm
  311. 10:43going to do it.
  312. 10:44>> That's so you first off they're playing
  313. 10:46a great good cop bad cop right? I think
  314. 10:50the majority of the market has been
  315. 10:53conditioned to look at the Fed as dovish
  316. 10:56or hawkish and that's their signal right
  317. 10:59so when he's hawkish
  318. 11:01>> wash
  319. 11:02the market can cool off maybe slow down
  320. 11:06maybe market will go down maybe rates
  321. 11:08will go down that's the biggest thing
  322. 11:09right
  323. 11:09>> whereas Besson is wide open
  324. 11:12>> and no one really knows
  325. 11:13>> because no one has focused on him before
  326. 11:14>> kind of no one knows really what the
  327. 11:16Treasury is doing what's this twist
  328. 11:18thing. What's What's
  329. 11:19>> any It's not just It's not just the
  330. 11:22Treasury. It's wide open. The entire
  331. 11:25fiscal uh you know that we're running $2
  332. 11:29trillion deficits or whatever the root
  333. 11:31cause of all of this.
  334. 11:32>> 6% six or seven% budget deficits.
  335. 11:34>> Look, the only the only way that this
  336. 11:37that the government is ever going to do
  337. 11:39anything about this is if we get close
  338. 11:42to the edge.
  339. 11:43>> For sure.
  340. 11:44>> Yeah. They just said, you know, it's not
  341. 11:46just entitlement, it's it's defense. I
  342. 11:48mean, it's the whole budget. So, the how
  343. 11:50you going to how you going to get the
  344. 11:52federal government to you don't even
  345. 11:54necessarily have to cut the budget, but
  346. 11:55you could, let's say, slow the growth
  347. 11:56rate by half. Let's say that's what
  348. 11:59that's what you could do. But they're
  349. 12:00not going to do it
  350. 12:02>> unless things get really bad.
  351. 12:03>> Doge lasted a month.
  352. 12:06>> A month. Remember that? A month. And
  353. 12:09what they cut was nothing. Correct.
  354. 12:12>> So, it has to get bad. There was
  355. 12:13supposed to be all this fraud and you
  356. 12:14know and there probably was but it it's
  357. 12:16nothing.
  358. 12:16>> But that but that's nothing compared to
  359. 12:18what's actually being spent legitimately
  360. 12:20on on social security.
  361. 12:23You can't say that people what's being
  362. 12:25spent on Medicare is illegitimate. It's
  363. 12:26just a lot of money.
  364. 12:27>> Correct. It's probably a lot of fraud
  365. 12:29too. So
  366. 12:29>> I'm sure it is.
  367. 12:30>> But it's a lot of money.
  368. 12:32>> But it's a lot of money and there's
  369. 12:33parts of the government I mean the the
  370. 12:34defense department you know there's
  371. 12:35stuff that the government spends on.
  372. 12:36It's not fraud. It's just they spend a
  373. 12:38lot of money. So would you con would you
  374. 12:40like sort of concede to us that you know
  375. 12:43any part you guys were kind of right
  376. 12:44about calling you the oil the deficit
  377. 12:46[laughter] crowd but I'm not but um but
  378. 12:49I'm not saying it as passionately as I
  379. 12:51use. All right. [laughter]
  380. 12:53>> Just want to put that on record. You
  381. 12:55want to put it on record. You got it on
  382. 12:57the record. Okay.
  383. 12:58>> All right. So let's talk AI. I'm gonna
  384. 13:00So I had on a guy named Ed Zitron. He
  385. 13:04he's like Mr. negative AI and he does
  386. 13:08like the kind of research that that you
  387. 13:10guys do but on AI. So he he put out he
  388. 13:14puts out something every week that's
  389. 13:15like 20 pages long
  390. 13:17>> every week,
  391. 13:18>> right?
  392. 13:18>> And he pointed out something I didn't
  393. 13:20know cuz cuz when he he came in, Nvidia
  394. 13:22had just had literally just reported the
  395. 13:24night before. And so I said to him,
  396. 13:27Nvidia's revenue numbers were up over
  397. 13:28100%.
  398. 13:30and he said, "Yeah, but and then he he
  399. 13:33pointed out and I I confirmed this later
  400. 13:35in the day that in the 10 Q there's in
  401. 13:38note 7 I actually looked this up
  402. 13:41>> stuff that we used to do to financial
  403. 13:42stock financial stocks. So note 7 says
  404. 13:46that the top five direct customers of
  405. 13:50Nvidia
  406. 13:52accounted for 70% of accounts receivable
  407. 13:56in the quarter. Okay. At the end of the
  408. 13:57quarter.
  409. 13:58>> Yeah. So on the one hand your revenue is
  410. 14:00up over 100%. On the other hand it's
  411. 14:04totally concentrated in a handful of
  412. 14:06names
  413. 14:06>> and a couple of those handful of names
  414. 14:08are not looking so good. Open AI
  415. 14:10certainly
  416. 14:11>> open AI is in trouble. So I'm just
  417. 14:12curious. I mean I we could talk about
  418. 14:14this for the next 10 hours. Give me your
  419. 14:16thoughts about the whole what's going on
  420. 14:18in AI from where from where you guys
  421. 14:20sit.
  422. 14:20>> Morning serving.
  423. 14:22>> I spoke to a friend. He's a friend of
  424. 14:24ours. Yeah.
  425. 14:25>> Yourself included.
  426. 14:26>> Okay. Uh, and he has one of those jobs
  427. 14:28where he would publicly traded company
  428. 14:31name not for attribution.
  429. 14:33>> Let's call him Mr. X.
  430. 14:34>> Mr. X told me that his company's queries
  431. 14:38are up, I'm forgetting the percentage,
  432. 14:4130, 40%. Tokens, the amount of tokens
  433. 14:43he's using for AI,
  434. 14:45>> right?
  435. 14:45>> But his costs are down something like
  436. 14:4760%.
  437. 14:49Because
  438. 14:49>> because what the company has done
  439. 14:52in my words, not his, is centralize all
  440. 14:56the queries that are make in AI
  441. 14:59and rather than sticking everything in
  442. 15:01leading edge trying to figure out what
  443. 15:03are Leaning Age frontier queries that
  444. 15:05require best-in-class
  445. 15:08versus the offtheshelf open source. So
  446. 15:12in other words, they're very careful now
  447. 15:14about what they send to anthropic and
  448. 15:16open AI and everything else they send a
  449. 15:19small percentage of the very very
  450. 15:20important queries to them and everything
  451. 15:22else they let's say they give to the
  452. 15:25Chinese openweight models. So therefore
  453. 15:27the costs have come down a lot. so
  454. 15:28careful that the costs are coming down.
  455. 15:30>> Now,
  456. 15:31>> let's take that. That's just one
  457. 15:33example. So, you can't make a whole
  458. 15:36>> uh mosaic on it, but assuming most
  459. 15:39enterprises are doing this, right?
  460. 15:41Right.
  461. 15:42>> How do we get to the returns on invested
  462. 15:44capital of all the money that we're
  463. 15:46spending uh on artificial intelligence?
  464. 15:49So our view is yeah the funding can
  465. 15:52continue as we've seen but at the end of
  466. 15:56the day are we dealing with a very
  467. 15:58similar and Porter is probably going to
  468. 15:59speak about this
  469. 16:01>> capex boom that history would suggest
  470. 16:03you have boom bust and then
  471. 16:07>> what we get are are good cycles
  472. 16:09afterwards right and that's where we
  473. 16:11stand this is like the topic
  474. 16:13>> yes
  475. 16:14>> I had um Torson Sllock on and he said
  476. 16:18you know GDP PE will grow let's say 2%
  477. 16:20this year at least half of it is AI
  478. 16:23capex.
  479. 16:24So if if all of a sudden open AI failed
  480. 16:29and the whole thing reversed the economy
  481. 16:31would go into recession almost
  482. 16:32immediately. No, you know I'm not making
  483. 16:34the call. Listen, we're not
  484. 16:36>> I'm not making that call yet.
  485. 16:37>> We're we're not AI experts. This is not
  486. 16:38our our expertise, right? But you know I
  487. 16:41look at the balance sheet of open AI or
  488. 16:44anthropic and I look at what you know
  489. 16:46the these hyperscalers have gone from
  490. 16:49huge
  491. 16:50>> uh cash flow machines not machines like
  492. 16:53like like spew out cash like no one's
  493. 16:56ever seen and they were buying back
  494. 16:59their own stocks to to go in the other
  495. 17:01to issuing debt to Google
  496. 17:03>> and in some cases equity. Google issues
  497. 17:05$85 billion in equity, right? Bought by
  498. 17:07Buffett, which is like geez, what that's
  499. 17:09that's not a sure not or I guess it
  500. 17:11wasn't Buffett, but uh sure not a
  501. 17:13distressed purchase, right? So
  502. 17:16>> I think you're in a different paradigm
  503. 17:17here. And um yes, it scares me, right?
  504. 17:21And you know, they're going to they're
  505. 17:25going to force this issue, right?
  506. 17:26They're they're going to let AI come
  507. 17:28public. They're going to they're going
  508. 17:29to let anthropic come public because
  509. 17:31they need to. My contention always is
  510. 17:34that just like SpaceX, it's bad for the
  511. 17:37market
  512. 17:38>> because
  513. 17:38>> it's supply, right? It's it's it's it's
  514. 17:40it's you know, you you
  515. 17:42>> new stock
  516. 17:43>> new stock of supply, right? And that's
  517. 17:45what usually has killed markets, right?
  518. 17:47That's that's in 2000 in 1929. That's
  519. 17:50what killed the market was new supply of
  520. 17:52stock. And so it's just supply demand.
  521. 17:55It's kind of that simple, right? And so
  522. 17:57we've had this machine where, you know,
  523. 17:59everyone's been investing in their 401k
  524. 18:01and you have new supply of buyers every
  525. 18:03day, right? They talk about the S&P.
  526. 18:05It's the dumbest investment uh
  527. 18:09philosophy ever, right? If I get more
  528. 18:10money in, I I buy. If I get money out, I
  529. 18:13sell. There's no other thought to
  530. 18:14anything, right? They they don't think.
  531. 18:16That's that's the two that's the two
  532. 18:17thought process. And so
  533. 18:19>> if you flood a market with capital,
  534. 18:22right, it it's it's problematic. And
  535. 18:24that that's the way I think about it.
  536. 18:25And that's that that's what makes me
  537. 18:26nervous.
  538. 18:28>> Um, you know, look at SpaceX. Where's
  539. 18:31the re, you know, when when everyone who
  540. 18:33made all this money finally sells
  541. 18:35>> asteroid mining? Don't don't poo poo
  542. 18:38asteroid mining.
  543. 18:40[laughter]
  544. 18:41>> Exactly.
  545. 18:43>> I was impressed by that. The Oh, you
  546. 18:46loved it. I loved it because I'm a
  547. 18:48sci-fi guy. I I don't even know what
  548. 18:50you're talking about, but I'm sure Musk
  549. 18:52saying
  550. 18:52>> no, in the in the S1 there's a whole
  551. 18:54section about things that SpaceX will do
  552. 18:58in the future and one of them asteroid
  553. 18:59mining. So I I in my weekly podcast I
  554. 19:02commented I said, you know, it's kind of
  555. 19:04interesting that there's a show on Apple
  556. 19:07right now called For All Mankind, which
  557. 19:09is a sci-fi show where asteroid mining
  558. 19:11is is a major theme.
  559. 19:12>> You know, full self-driving is about a
  560. 19:14decade behind and it's at level three.
  561. 19:16So, you know, he makes a lot of good
  562. 19:18comments that that don't quite come
  563. 19:20true. So,
  564. 19:21>> every financial planning and analysis
  565. 19:23team I talk to is being told to use AI,
  566. 19:26but almost nobody is actually training
  567. 19:28people on how to do it. That's the gap
  568. 19:29the FPNA certificate program from
  569. 19:31Wharton Online and Wall Street Prep is
  570. 19:33built to close. You get hands-on
  571. 19:35training in how to run chat GPT and
  572. 19:37co-pilot through real FPNA workflows,
  573. 19:40forecasting, variance analysis, and
  574. 19:43board decks. It goes beyond AI, too. You
  575. 19:47build the technical skills and the ones
  576. 19:49that decide whether anyone listens, like
  577. 19:52how to present your numbers and hold
  578. 19:54your ground when a CFO or department
  579. 19:55head pushes back. And you're learning
  580. 19:57all of it from people who have actually
  581. 19:59sat in the seat. You get hands-on
  582. 20:02training from Wharton faculty and Wall
  583. 20:03Street preps instructor practitioners,
  584. 20:06professionals who have built forecasts
  585. 20:08and defended budgets under real pressure
  586. 20:10in real companies. The program runs for
  587. 20:128 weeks, about 8 hours a week, and it's
  588. 20:14fully self-paced online, so you can work
  589. 20:16it into your schedule. There are weekly
  590. 20:18live office hours to face time with
  591. 20:20Wharton faculty and your cohort. By the
  592. 20:22end, you'll have a certificate from
  593. 20:24Wharton online, lifetime access to the
  594. 20:26materials, and an MVA level network that
  595. 20:29sticks with you well after the program
  596. 20:31ends. If you're expected to level up
  597. 20:33your FPNA skills from AI to everything
  598. 20:35else the job demands, this program is
  599. 20:37where you do it. Enroll from October 5th
  600. 20:40and use code Eisman to save $300 on
  601. 20:43tuition. The link to enroll is in the
  602. 20:46comments.
  603. 20:48Shopify is an e-commerce platform that
  604. 20:50is responsible for millions of sales
  605. 20:53worldwide. It is an online website
  606. 20:55storefront creator, inventory management
  607. 20:58system, point of sales system, and so
  608. 21:00much more. Shopify handles all facets of
  609. 21:03business that you don't have to use 10
  610. 21:05different systems. One platform is all
  611. 21:08that anyone needs. Leaves aren't the
  612. 21:10only thing that are changing this fall.
  613. 21:12As children go back to school and people
  614. 21:14start preparing for the end of year
  615. 21:16holidays, it seems like a strange time
  616. 21:18to want to start your own business. But
  617. 21:21every entrepreneur knows that you don't
  618. 21:23wait for the right time, you create it.
  619. 21:26I couldn't agree more. Shopify's
  620. 21:28templates and AI tools get you a
  621. 21:30stunning site up and running fast. No
  622. 21:33coding needed. Shopify checkout means
  623. 21:36more customers actually buy and
  624. 21:38returning ones can do it in a single
  625. 21:40click because Shopify handles the setup
  626. 21:43and checkout. You have more time to
  627. 21:45focus on growing your business and the
  628. 21:47tools to do it. If you're ready to hear
  629. 21:50the of your first sale today, head over
  630. 21:54to shopify.com/isman
  631. 21:56to start your free trial today. That's
  632. 21:58right. Start your free trial at
  633. 22:00shopify.com/isman.
  634. 22:02that shopify.com/isman.
  635. 22:08So my thought about the whole AI thing,
  636. 22:11which which is what makes me nervous
  637. 22:13right now,
  638. 22:14>> is that there were some very good
  639. 22:16reports by some Wall Street firms that
  640. 22:18basically said that 70% of hyperscaler
  641. 22:23AI revenue is from just anthropic and
  642. 22:26open AI.
  643. 22:2970%
  644. 22:31of AI revenue.
  645. 22:33>> Correct. That make sense?
  646. 22:34>> Yeah. And then so if you just take that
  647. 22:36math, that equates to about 25 to 35% of
  648. 22:39their total cloud revenue.
  649. 22:41>> Yeah.
  650. 22:43>> That's huge when you think about it.
  651. 22:44>> That's why they need to come public.
  652. 22:46>> Yes. Well, I know they need to come
  653. 22:47public. The problem is that the Open AI
  654. 22:50numbers that have just come out are
  655. 22:51actually quite poor.
  656. 22:52>> Yes.
  657. 22:52>> Compared to Anthropic,
  658. 22:53>> they had huge market share and they just
  659. 22:55they lose it every day.
  660. 22:56>> Well, and they keep losing it. And
  661. 22:57Steve, you're closer to it than we are.
  662. 22:59The sequential growth rates, are they
  663. 23:02slowing, accelerating?
  664. 23:03>> So, Anthropic put out like 11 and a half
  665. 23:07billion in revenue for the June quarter.
  666. 23:09They didn't say anything about costs and
  667. 23:12that was up over 100% in 3 months.
  668. 23:15>> Okay.
  669. 23:16>> Open AI was at 6.5 billion and it was up
  670. 23:19only 18% in 3 months.
  671. 23:22Its costs were 12 billion. But the crazy
  672. 23:26thing was was that if you look at forget
  673. 23:28about these the percentage in increases
  674. 23:31if you just look at the dollar changes
  675. 23:34in three months their revenue went up a
  676. 23:35billion and their cost went up three.
  677. 23:37>> Yeah.
  678. 23:38>> So I I think Open AI is in trouble and
  679. 23:42if Open AI and you know when you're not
  680. 23:45profitable as you know
  681. 23:48>> narrative is everything like our like
  682. 23:51our country
  683. 23:52>> right there narrative is everything like
  684. 23:54our country. Exactly. So like look, if
  685. 23:56you're a really really profitable
  686. 23:57company and somebody writes a bad
  687. 23:59newspaper article about you,
  688. 24:01>> big deal. You know, the stock goes down
  689. 24:03for a day. Who cares?
  690. 24:04>> You buy back stock.
  691. 24:05>> You buy back stock. Who cares? You got
  692. 24:06you're swimming in money. But when
  693. 24:07you're open AI and you're bleeding cash
  694. 24:09every single day and all of a sudden the
  695. 24:11narrative has really started to change
  696. 24:13and got they've lost tremendous number
  697. 24:14of people.
  698. 24:16>> It's bad. Your cost of capital is
  699. 24:18rising. Yes.
  700. 24:19>> And you can't afford that.
  701. 24:20>> And you can't afford that. I make this
  702. 24:21joke that whoever buys open AI at out of
  703. 24:24bankruptcy, it's going to be a fantastic
  704. 24:25deal
  705. 24:26>> probably.
  706. 24:27>> And that that's the history of what
  707. 24:28happens though,
  708. 24:29>> right?
  709. 24:30>> Just like they railroads if the
  710. 24:32railroads failed. Whoever bought WCO,
  711. 24:34you know, when when Wakovia was
  712. 24:35purchased for nothing, you know, it was
  713. 24:37a great deal for Wells Fargo, right?
  714. 24:38Same thing with Bear Sterns. Like that
  715. 24:40that's what happens.
  716. 24:42>> You guys do a newsletter.
  717. 24:43>> Yes.
  718. 24:44>> And you wrote an article about shorting.
  719. 24:46>> Yes. Mhm.
  720. 24:47>> So, why don't you share with people your
  721. 24:50your thoughts from that article because
  722. 24:52it was kind of interesting.
  723. 24:53>> Thanks for reading, by the way.
  724. 24:54>> Yeah. Well, I like to read.
  725. 24:56>> Are you a fan of the Untouchables?
  726. 24:58>> I Yes.
  727. 24:59>> Yes.
  728. 25:00>> So, I was thinking about
  729. 25:02>> team
  730. 25:04team. [laughter]
  731. 25:05>> But really, when you think about a
  732. 25:06movie, whatever movie Shan Connor is in,
  733. 25:09he outshines everybody else
  734. 25:10>> all the time.
  735. 25:11>> All the time. Yeah.
  736. 25:12>> There's got to be I love Finding
  737. 25:13Forester. You must like
  738. 25:15>> love finding he's unbelievable.
  739. 25:17>> He's unbelievable. And anyway, so
  740. 25:19>> it's not a soup question.
  741. 25:20>> I I [laughter]
  742. 25:23go with this.
  743. 25:24>> A great line. It's a great line.
  744. 25:25>> I thought about his arc, right? And his
  745. 25:28character and it's kind of like shorting
  746. 25:29stocks or the way we probably feel right
  747. 25:32now,
  748. 25:32>> right?
  749. 25:32>> Like we just want to go long, you know,
  750. 25:35we'll choose gold, you'll choose
  751. 25:37whatever, be the B cup, but then all of
  752. 25:39a sudden you get like interesting shorts
  753. 25:41that come your way. Right.
  754. 25:43>> Right. And then you got to make a
  755. 25:44decision, right? And then do I do it or
  756. 25:46not?
  757. 25:46>> Do I do it or not? And you know that if
  758. 25:48you decide to do it, and we could talk
  759. 25:49about like one where we decided to to go
  760. 25:53there,
  761. 25:54>> you know, you're aim for a war.
  762. 25:56>> A war, right?
  763. 25:57>> Fighting crazy is hard.
  764. 25:59>> And yes, very hard.
  765. 26:00>> Yes. Most of the people in the investing
  766. 26:03world like you're short, they're long.
  767. 26:05>> Not only that, let's think about the
  768. 26:07people who are short for a living,
  769. 26:09right? When you look at the citadels,
  770. 26:11millenniums, the 72s,
  771. 26:14what is probably not well known is that
  772. 26:16the people that work there, the the pods
  773. 26:18as they're called,
  774. 26:19>> explain what a a pod within a millennium
  775. 26:22or citadel is. What does that mean?
  776. 26:23>> When you work at a millennium or 72,
  777. 26:27their GPS, their the the grand PMs will
  778. 26:31give you an allocation of money, right?
  779. 26:33Call it $2 billion.
  780. 26:34>> So, I could be running a team.
  781. 26:36>> Yes.
  782. 26:36>> And I don't raise any money. The money
  783. 26:39is raised at the parent. Correct. Ken
  784. 26:41Griffin gives you the money.
  785. 26:42>> Or if I'm at Citadel, Ken Griffin says,
  786. 26:44"Oh, I I think this is he's a good guy.
  787. 26:46I'm going to give him
  788. 26:48>> 250 million in capital. Go do go do
  789. 26:52something with it."
  790. 26:52>> Correct.
  791. 26:53>> And so, and if I'm running the
  792. 26:54financials pod
  793. 26:57>> like you guys ran at Citadel for a
  794. 26:58while, then what you're doing is they
  795. 27:00gave you money and you're investing long
  796. 27:02short in financials.
  797. 27:03>> Correct. Now, let's keep it simple. For
  798. 27:07every long that you have in your
  799. 27:09portfolio, you have to have almost
  800. 27:12dollar for dollar a short
  801. 27:13>> at these firms.
  802. 27:14>> At these firms, right? And these firms
  803. 27:16have grown.
  804. 27:17>> They're huge
  805. 27:18>> in huge size and they're highly levered.
  806. 27:21>> Explain that. What do you mean by they
  807. 27:23are highly people don't understand this
  808. 27:25world?
  809. 27:25>> Well, and it's amazing. And I'm not
  810. 27:28saying even I think the financial media
  811. 27:31doesn't really understand this world all
  812. 27:32that well. So let's just say make up a
  813. 27:34number that Citadel has
  814. 27:3725 billion in capital that they're
  815. 27:40running
  816. 27:41>> for their investors that investors have
  817. 27:44given them $25 billion. When you say
  818. 27:46it's levered, what does that mean? So in
  819. 27:48order to lever, you have to make sure
  820. 27:50that your annualized volatility
  821. 27:53is statistically below a certain level.
  822. 27:56Call it 6 8 9%. In order to do that, you
  823. 28:00have to have a very low net on your on
  824. 28:03your
  825. 28:03>> your longs and your shorts are roughly
  826. 28:05equal.
  827. 28:06>> And then once you figure out that
  828. 28:08gorgeous science, you can leverage
  829. 28:10yourselves 5 to1, which means
  830. 28:12>> in other words, Citadel would be running
  831. 28:14they have 25 billion in capital, but
  832. 28:17they borrow and they're running 125
  833. 28:19billion in positions.
  834. 28:20>> Correct.
  835. 28:21>> Okay.
  836. 28:21>> Correct.
  837. 28:22>> Got it. And so and if you
  838. 28:24>> and it's all long short and it's roughly
  839. 28:27equal half half of the 125 billion is
  840. 28:30long and roughly half the 25 it depends
  841. 28:33>> at least on the equity side on the
  842. 28:34equity side
  843. 28:35>> then there's they do you know uh energy
  844. 28:38and fixed income and stuff like that but
  845. 28:39on the equities you know they but they
  846. 28:41match it so perfectly on a beta dollar
  847. 28:44you couldn't for every I think they'd
  848. 28:46sweep it every five minutes so you were
  849. 28:47perfectly hedged
  850. 28:49>> right
  851. 28:49>> and this is on a beta adjusted basis
  852. 28:51>> beta a factor neutral basis.
  853. 28:54>> What does that mean? Beta factoring
  854. 28:56ourselves. I apologize. So beta is it
  855. 28:58has to be beta adjusted. So the beta of
  856. 28:59your longs have to equal the beta of
  857. 29:01your shorts. Correct. They also want you
  858. 29:03to be factor neutral. So every stock has
  859. 29:06a personality.
  860. 29:07>> Right.
  861. 29:07>> That's the word I would use.
  862. 29:08>> I can't be long value like or like this
  863. 29:11is the Leupold guy. The whatever his
  864. 29:13name was
  865. 29:14>> Leopold Ashen Brener.
  866. 29:16>> Yeah. So he he was long AI short
  867. 29:18software.
  868. 29:19>> Right.
  869. 29:20>> And he blew up.
  870. 29:20>> Right. Right. Ken would not any of these
  871. 29:23firms would not allow you to have such
  872. 29:24mis mismatches, right? They they want
  873. 29:26you to be long some software and short
  874. 29:29the bad software. And so you're more
  875. 29:31perfectly balanced with
  876. 29:32>> you could be 100% long one sector and
  877. 29:35100 or sub sector and 100% short another
  878. 29:38subsector.
  879. 29:39>> Long growth short value. Can't do that.
  880. 29:41>> Can't do that. You're not supposed to
  881. 29:43long
  882. 29:45neutral factor neutral at least at least
  883. 29:48where we work. But I know the other
  884. 29:50shops are very
  885. 29:51>> probably roughly similar.
  886. 29:52>> So their return thresholds for their
  887. 29:55shorts are very different than ours,
  888. 29:57right? Meaning
  889. 29:58>> meaning if they're long let's let's go
  890. 30:00into our neck of the woods. Okay,
  891. 30:02>> right 100 million of JP Morgan, right?
  892. 30:05>> And they're short a 100 million of Bank
  893. 30:07America
  894. 30:08>> and they would do that something like
  895. 30:09that.
  896. 30:10>> If they made a spread between the two of
  897. 30:13three to 5%,
  898. 30:15>> they're happy
  899. 30:15>> and they're done and they're done,
  900. 30:17>> right? and they have to move on to the
  901. 30:18next
  902. 30:19>> and they have to move on to the next
  903. 30:20trade.
  904. 30:20>> When we're shorting stocks,
  905. 30:22>> we want to make like 150% or whatever.
  906. 30:24They want a big hit.
  907. 30:25>> So, but because they're the predominant
  908. 30:28short in the market and their their size
  909. 30:31market share of the overall market and
  910. 30:33trading is so ubiquitous, it almost
  911. 30:36makes it impossible. They know like
  912. 30:39every short that we would come up with,
  913. 30:41right? They're probably short as well in
  914. 30:43size. And if it doesn't work for them in
  915. 30:463 weeks, they're covering. So, you have
  916. 30:49to contend with all these squeezes, let
  917. 30:51alone that the market just generally
  918. 30:53goes up.
  919. 30:54>> What we used to do for a living is
  920. 30:57brutal,
  921. 30:57>> extremely more difficult.
  922. 31:00>> There are much more shorts in the market
  923. 31:01than there were than there used to be.
  924. 31:03>> Explain that. Why are there more?
  925. 31:04because because this the the these these
  926. 31:07uh firms they lever up and just the
  927. 31:10dollar amount of shorts is so big like
  928. 31:13there just wasn't amount the the the
  929. 31:15amount of shorting that occurred 20 30
  930. 31:17years ago wasn't as big. It was a small
  931. 31:19little
  932. 31:20>> cuz they're bigger.
  933. 31:20>> Cuz they're bigger
  934. 31:21>> and they're levered.
  935. 31:22>> Yes.
  936. 31:23>> I see. And they're not allowed to lose a
  937. 31:26lot of money because when you're levered
  938. 31:28five to one,
  939. 31:29>> you can't.
  940. 31:30>> You can't. Your business model doesn't
  941. 31:32work if you're losing four to 5% per
  942. 31:34month,
  943. 31:34>> right? Cuz multiply that by five.
  944. 31:36>> Correct.
  945. 31:36>> Yeah. And Leopold obviously wasn't as
  946. 31:39sophisticated as these big guys. And
  947. 31:40they they knew it and they blew him up.
  948. 31:42>> They blew him up and and and Kenny G
  949. 31:45cleaned his clock. [laughter] He did
  950. 31:46cleaned his clock.
  951. 31:47>> Cleaned his clock. Unbelievable.
  952. 31:49>> Smart guy, but
  953. 31:51you know what I analogized it to? I
  954. 31:53said, ' imagine if it's like the year is
  955. 31:551905
  956. 31:57and you have a thesis that the
  957. 31:59automobile is going to take over the
  958. 32:01world. So you're long
  959. 32:04every auto and auto parts company and
  960. 32:07you're short every horse carriage
  961. 32:09company and it's working great and
  962. 32:12you're making money on your longs and
  963. 32:14you're making money on your shorts and
  964. 32:15you're levered four, five to one. So you
  965. 32:18look like a genius and then all of a
  966. 32:20sudden on Fifth Avenue a terrible car
  967. 32:22accident takes place and it's on the
  968. 32:24front page of the paper and all of a
  969. 32:25sudden everybody says wait a minute
  970. 32:26maybe this auto thing is is too is
  971. 32:29dangerous and so for two months it all
  972. 32:32reverses when you leverage four five to
  973. 32:34one they matter you're out you're they
  974. 32:36take you out
  975. 32:37>> you know and so shorting [clears throat]
  976. 32:39is and we pointed out shorting is a very
  977. 32:41tough game right especially you know
  978. 32:42when you're you know we've been on and
  979. 32:44off only short or nothing uh Tesla for
  980. 32:47part better part of five or six years
  981. 32:50and fundamentally many could argue that
  982. 32:52we've been right right the earnings have
  983. 32:53been
  984. 32:54>> oh there's no question fundamentally
  985. 32:55you've been right the have gone in one
  986. 32:56direction
  987. 32:57>> down
  988. 32:57>> and the stock has gone up
  989. 32:58>> yes so that's a that's a tough short
  990. 33:02[laughter]
  991. 33:02[gasps]
  992. 33:02>> and so I think the lesson is don't short
  993. 33:04a cult unfortunately it
  994. 33:06>> it is sadly sometimes we don't learn our
  995. 33:09lesson on certain you can't help
  996. 33:10yourself
  997. 33:10>> because we can't and that was the part
  998. 33:12of Connory couldn't help himself right
  999. 33:14he knew better not to do that but He
  1000. 33:17went in anyway. We're just doing it with
  1001. 33:19significantly less capital than we used
  1002. 33:20to.
  1003. 33:21>> So, is there anything short-wise you
  1004. 33:23really like these days
  1005. 33:25>> that you're willing to share?
  1006. 33:26>> Yeah, but it doesn't work. So, so let's
  1007. 33:28let's start [laughter]
  1008. 33:30let's start with a few caveats. I
  1009. 33:32listening to your podcast, I think, you
  1010. 33:35know, circle doesn't make any sense to
  1011. 33:37me.
  1012. 33:39>> Zero.
  1013. 33:39>> Okay.
  1014. 33:40>> And yet the stock has rallied
  1015. 33:41enormously. Every I don't even know why.
  1016. 33:44crypto's going on.
  1017. 33:45>> The crypto the crypto legislation
  1018. 33:47nonsense.
  1019. 33:48>> Let's let's bring something near and
  1020. 33:49dear to our hearts. So, we're back in
  1021. 33:51our neck of the woods cuz circles Finn
  1022. 33:53or Fintech.
  1023. 33:54>> We short a lot of stuff in our neck of
  1024. 33:55the woods. We don't we don't stray too
  1025. 33:57far a field in our shorts
  1026. 33:59>> other than other than
  1027. 34:00>> you short FICO.
  1028. 34:01>> Yes,
  1029. 34:01>> we are short FICO.
  1030. 34:02>> Me too.
  1031. 34:03>> So, you know the reason.
  1032. 34:03>> I had two shows on FICO when I've
  1033. 34:06listened. We we shorted it the day that
  1034. 34:09Bill Py came out and said something
  1035. 34:11which was like I was around then which
  1036. 34:12was like $2,500.
  1037. 34:14I was I agree. It was it's bad.
  1038. 34:17>> It's by the way it goes back to the same
  1039. 34:19stuff that we used to be pissed off
  1040. 34:20about is basically companies gouging
  1041. 34:23customers.
  1042. 34:23>> Yes.
  1043. 34:24>> Yes.
  1044. 34:25>> If if he if if FICO had raised prices
  1045. 34:28over the last 5 years like call it
  1046. 34:31inflation plus 2% Mastercard, right?
  1047. 34:34like Visa, Mastercard, like nobody would
  1048. 34:36even have paid attention and said they
  1049. 34:38they raised prices 1,600%.
  1050. 34:41>> It was pigish. And not only that,
  1051. 34:43they're pulling credit files and
  1052. 34:45mortgages and charging I think it's 3 to
  1053. 34:475x what you're doing on credit card and
  1054. 34:50auto loans. So imagine if you're Fanny
  1055. 34:52May or some big rocket, right?
  1056. 34:54>> Just because they can.
  1057. 34:54>> Just because they can because of the law
  1058. 34:57and like if I was Rocket or Fanny and
  1059. 34:59Freddy, I'd be like, you're going to
  1060. 35:00lower your price now, right? But
  1061. 35:03everyone's like, "Oh, it's such a small
  1062. 35:04piece of the the loan." It's like,
  1063. 35:06"Well, that's small anymore."
  1064. 35:07>> No.
  1065. 35:08>> So, the other name which is near and
  1066. 35:10dear to all of our hearts is Carvana and
  1067. 35:13the mystery and the mystery buyer of
  1068. 35:15paper north of 110.
  1069. 35:17>> Okay. Go explain that.
  1070. 35:18>> This will be this will be that's a
  1071. 35:20cryptic comment.
  1072. 35:20>> I will explain. So, what does Carvana do
  1073. 35:23for a living? Okay. They sell used cars,
  1074. 35:24right? Right. In addition to
  1075. 35:26>> online online in addition to used cars
  1076. 35:29selling the used car they provide the
  1077. 35:31financing for it.
  1078. 35:32>> Okay.
  1079. 35:33>> Okay.
  1080. 35:33>> Which at this point
  1081. 35:34>> by the way I just wanted to say that the
  1082. 35:37father who had a company called Ugly
  1083. 35:39Duckling I know
  1084. 35:40>> I actually went and visited the company
  1085. 35:42in the 90s when you and I were working
  1086. 35:44together and as as part of the trip I
  1087. 35:46got an Ugly Duckling towel
  1088. 35:49>> which I loved and used all the time. Do
  1089. 35:52you still have it? I it it I used it so
  1090. 35:54much it it became like like like like a
  1091. 35:57rag but but it was one of the best
  1092. 35:58towels I ever had. So So all due respect
  1093. 36:01to Ugly Duckling, they had a great
  1094. 36:02towel.
  1095. 36:03>> By the way, when I when I [laughter]
  1096. 36:04when I first came to work for you and
  1097. 36:06call it 2001, I looked on the sheets and
  1098. 36:08I was like, "What the hell is this Ugly
  1099. 36:10Duckling that you're short?" [laughter]
  1100. 36:13>> And that was Ernie Garcia Senior.
  1101. 36:14>> Ernie Garcia Senior. So So they they
  1102. 36:18sell used cars. They finance the sale of
  1103. 36:20those cars. a good portion of those
  1104. 36:23loans are subprime in nature.
  1105. 36:25>> Okay.
  1106. 36:26>> Um and and the the majority of their
  1107. 36:28profits, almost all of their profits,
  1108. 36:30>> a good portion of their pre-tax income
  1109. 36:33between 75 and 100% from gain on sale.
  1110. 36:37>> Explain
  1111. 36:39how gain on sale works here. What does
  1112. 36:41it mean?
  1113. 36:42>> So, when you originate a loan or you
  1114. 36:44create a loan, you could either hold it
  1115. 36:46on your books and earn the spread,
  1116. 36:47>> right?
  1117. 36:48>> Or you're going to sell it to a third
  1118. 36:49party. Are they selling it or are they
  1119. 36:51securitizing it?
  1120. 36:52>> Well, selling it and securitizing it are
  1121. 36:54similar things. They're doing both,
  1122. 36:56right? So, they're securitizing it, but
  1123. 36:58blowing out even the residuals, meaning
  1124. 37:00the last piece of the securization. So,
  1125. 37:03they're not really
  1126. 37:03>> They're actually selling the loans.
  1127. 37:05>> Correct. They also sell loans on a whole
  1128. 37:07loan basis that meaning the whole loan,
  1129. 37:09not securitizing it
  1130. 37:11>> to third parties like Ally. Ally is one
  1131. 37:14of their biggest finance years. An ally
  1132. 37:15probably pays I'm going to give a wide
  1133. 37:17range because I don't know exactly what
  1134. 37:19it is between 102 and 104. That means if
  1135. 37:22I originated a loan for $100, I get to
  1136. 37:25sell it for $102 or $104.
  1137. 37:27>> Okay. So far everything you've said
  1138. 37:29sounds legit.
  1139. 37:30>> Correct. Their average gain on sale over
  1140. 37:33the last two years has been 109 110.
  1141. 37:36>> Okay. So if we do some simple math and
  1142. 37:38say if Alli's 20% at 102 103 that means
  1143. 37:42somebody in the world is paying north of
  1144. 37:45110 meaning I originate a loan for 100
  1145. 37:47selling it at 112 113.
  1146. 37:49>> Okay.
  1147. 37:50>> So there's a mystery buyer out there and
  1148. 37:52no one knows who the mystery buyer is.
  1149. 37:53They won't disclose it, but I think like
  1150. 37:57eight years ago, they said it wasn't
  1151. 38:00Mark Walter. And Mark Walter was is the
  1152. 38:02guy who just is attempting to sell the
  1153. 38:04the Lakers and the Dodgers and all this
  1154. 38:07other stuff
  1155. 38:08>> cuz his insurance company is in trouble.
  1156. 38:10>> Yes. And allegedly,
  1157. 38:11>> that's the only thing they said. Did it
  1158. 38:13>> was not Mark Wal.
  1159. 38:15>> Who is the number five holder of
  1160. 38:16Carvana?
  1161. 38:17>> Oh, that's right. He is the number five
  1162. 38:18holder of the stock. It's a it's a it's
  1163. 38:20a it's a it's a it's a one-sto multi
  1164. 38:25special purpose vehicle called called C
  1165. 38:27van that's owned by him owned by him.
  1166. 38:30>> And allegedly Delaware Life owns a heck
  1167. 38:32of a lot of Carvana paper.
  1168. 38:36>> And Delaware Wife is who?
  1169. 38:38>> Mark Walter.
  1170. 38:39>> Insurance company.
  1171. 38:40>> Yes. So
  1172. 38:42did we find the mystery buyer?
  1173. 38:44>> We've kn people have known the shorts
  1174. 38:46have known this for a long time. This is
  1175. 38:47nothing new.
  1176. 38:48>> Okay. Because that's why they came out
  1177. 38:50the Mark Walter connection.
  1178. 38:51>> Yes. Because they came out, you know, I
  1179. 38:53think eight years ago and they said it
  1180. 38:55wasn't Mark Walter who's buying it, but
  1181. 38:58everyone still thinks it's Mark Walter.
  1182. 39:00And now
  1183. 39:00>> it could be Delaware Life, who's not
  1184. 39:02technically Mark Walter.
  1185. 39:03>> And apparently in the court filings,
  1186. 39:07Delaware Life had to increase the
  1187. 39:10disclosure of how much counterparties
  1188. 39:12they've had uh related party
  1189. 39:13transactions they had something
  1190. 39:15substantially. uh like I I think they
  1191. 39:18said that that the related party
  1192. 39:20transactions of the Delaware life and
  1193. 39:23its related party like Mark Walter and
  1194. 39:26such went from like three to something
  1195. 39:28like 30 or 40%. So oops that's a big uh
  1196. 39:32Yeah. Okay.
  1197. 39:33>> And also listen Mark Walter came out and
  1198. 39:36said publicly there is no fraud here.
  1199. 39:37>> Yeah.
  1200. 39:38>> There is no fraud here
  1201. 39:39>> and the market believes it. So I got
  1202. 39:40squeezed.
  1203. 39:41>> You got squeezed?
  1204. 39:41>> Yes. Yes.
  1205. 39:42>> So which hence why it's so difficult to
  1206. 39:45short sell. What has the stock Carvana
  1207. 39:47done of late?
  1208. 39:48>> It was
  1209. 39:49>> a lot of nothing for the past year.
  1210. 39:51>> Yeah, a lot of nothing. Yeah,
  1211. 39:53>> it's expensive. It's like 30 or 40 times
  1212. 39:55earnings and you know it's a lot for a
  1213. 39:57used car. I mean like I guess they are
  1214. 39:58changing the way that used cars are
  1215. 40:00bought and sold but it's expensive for a
  1216. 40:02used car company that's and they have a
  1217. 40:04great service apparently but a lot of
  1218. 40:07their profits are
  1219. 40:09probably artificial or or enhanced
  1220. 40:11steroid enhance
  1221. 40:12>> but but proving that is going to be
  1222. 40:14impossible. that has proven to be
  1223. 40:16impossible for eight years.
  1224. 40:17>> Well, I guess if Delaware Life goes
  1225. 40:19under, then then it's not going to be so
  1226. 40:21hard to prove because then the the buyer
  1227. 40:22of the paper is gone.
  1228. 40:23>> If they are the buyer,
  1229. 40:24>> if they are the buyer of the paper.
  1230. 40:25>> Yeah. So, the the only way, you know,
  1231. 40:27the again the only way that you get paid
  1232. 40:30on a on a short is usually if you bring
  1233. 40:32light,
  1234. 40:34>> you know, or truth to to what happens,
  1235. 40:36right? Oh, I knew it all along, right?
  1236. 40:39just, you know, like just that they they
  1237. 40:41finally couldn't
  1238. 40:42>> u bury the the subprime losses, right?
  1239. 40:45Or in in the in the in the big short
  1240. 40:47like, oh, this is where, you know, we
  1241. 40:49were faking the prices all along, right?
  1242. 40:51So that that's what finally happened.
  1243. 40:53>> So you need a moment like that to to
  1244. 40:55really get paid on the on the short.
  1245. 40:56Whether that happens or not, I don't
  1246. 40:58know.
  1247. 40:58>> So besides gold,
  1248. 41:00>> yes, you guys like anything
  1249. 41:03>> very idiosyncratic
  1250. 41:05odd things.
  1251. 41:06>> Okay.
  1252. 41:07>> Which kind of makes fits us. Well,
  1253. 41:08that's that that's that you're you guys
  1254. 41:09are weirdos. So, you know,
  1255. 41:11>> we have about that's what you
  1256. 41:13>> we probably have about 10 weird names
  1257. 41:16and a lot of gold.
  1258. 41:18>> Okay. Would you be willing to share two?
  1259. 41:21>> Sure.
  1260. 41:22>> Where you going first?
  1261. 41:23>> Two weird names. One you put, you speak
  1262. 41:25one, Vinnie, you speak one.
  1263. 41:26>> Well, we we own a lot of um a company
  1264. 41:29[clears throat] called Golar.
  1265. 41:31>> Golar.
  1266. 41:31>> Golar. G L A R.
  1267. 41:33>> Yep. G L N G is a ticker. And what and
  1268. 41:36what Golar does is they have they first
  1269. 41:40were in shipping a long time ago and
  1270. 41:41they kind of got out of shipping, but
  1271. 41:42they have these boats. They right now
  1272. 41:44they have four boats. And what these
  1273. 41:45boats do is they pull up to a country
  1274. 41:49like Argentina
  1275. 41:51and convert the uh natural gas into
  1276. 41:55liquid natural gas. So then that the gas
  1277. 41:57can then go to the buyers around the
  1278. 41:59world. And so, you know, you can either
  1279. 42:02build a huge project like Shener does in
  1280. 42:06Louisiana, which cost them probably
  1281. 42:08between
  1282. 42:09>> gab billions of dollars.
  1283. 42:10>> Yes. I I think it's
  1284. 42:11>> LNG is a symbol.
  1285. 42:12>> Yes. Uh I think that they said that YPF
  1286. 42:15in Argentina is going to spend 30 to50
  1287. 42:18billion dollars building that. But in
  1288. 42:20the meantime, they're buying these boats
  1289. 42:22and, you know, they're going to take a
  1290. 42:24toll. But the the capex is minimal. It's
  1291. 42:26like three and a half or two and a half
  1292. 42:28billion. How do they convert it though
  1293. 42:30into liquid natural?
  1294. 42:31>> Well, they they have a a it's a
  1295. 42:33converter. It's the ship on the ship.
  1296. 42:35>> I see.
  1297. 42:35>> And so it's basically a 20-year
  1298. 42:38contract, a toll road. And one of the
  1299. 42:39things that we've been bullish on is
  1300. 42:40Argentina. And
  1301. 42:43>> Argentina finally, you know, figured out
  1302. 42:45under Malay kind of figured out their
  1303. 42:47their uh fiscal situation and balance
  1304. 42:50the budget. But what they have is a lot
  1305. 42:53of uh natural resources in terms of uh
  1306. 42:57uh oil and gas and it's been trapped
  1307. 42:59gas. They couldn't get it. It's there.
  1308. 43:01They can find it, but how do you
  1309. 43:03transport it out?
  1310. 43:04>> Right.
  1311. 43:04>> And the big thing for them is they're
  1312. 43:06going to move these Golar ships in, two
  1313. 43:07of them, and pull the gas out starting
  1314. 43:10next year. And then eventually more gas
  1315. 43:12and more oil comes out. And we think
  1316. 43:14because of that um budget surplus go
  1317. 43:18wild and interest rates which have gone
  1318. 43:20from down from 100 plus% to uh 30 come
  1319. 43:26down a lot more. So there's a lot margin
  1320. 43:28is a big theme for us as um he probably
  1321. 43:30don't know but Peter Teal moved there
  1322. 43:33and has a big uh
  1323. 43:34>> he plays chess with the president.
  1324. 43:36>> Yes. And has a couple investments that
  1325. 43:37we we have similar investments in but
  1326. 43:39Golar is part of that that uh thought
  1327. 43:42process.
  1328. 43:44We own a farm. Uh, do you work on the
  1329. 43:47farm, Vincent?
  1330. 43:47>> No, but I've seen the farm. Do
  1331. 43:48>> you wear a hat? I've seen the farm.
  1332. 43:51>> He has a cool stylish trucker hat that
  1333. 43:53you like you can wear and a shirt. Yes.
  1334. 43:56Shirt.
  1335. 43:57>> So, the farms in California.
  1336. 43:58>> This a public company.
  1337. 43:59>> Yeah. um farms in California in in
  1338. 44:04vegetable, tomato, blueberry uh country
  1339. 44:06where almost all of the product a lot of
  1340. 44:09the products of America that are made
  1341. 44:11your fruits and produce is made there.
  1342. 44:13This just happens to be cannabis that
  1343. 44:15they that they produce rather than
  1344. 44:17fruits and vegetable.
  1345. 44:18>> Full disclosure, the last time that I
  1346. 44:20smoked weed, May 1984.
  1347. 44:23>> Wow. Wow. [laughter]
  1348. 44:27which is I think it's safe to say a long
  1349. 44:30time ago. A long time ago. So this
  1350. 44:32company Glass House, you own it. I own
  1351. 44:34it too. So go ahead.
  1352. 44:35>> So the ticker
  1353. 44:36>> and none of us use the product. Correct.
  1354. 44:37We do not use product. We do not use
  1355. 44:39[laughter] the funniest thing
  1356. 44:41>> couple sleep gummies every once in a
  1357. 44:42while but that's about it
  1358. 44:43>> is that I none of us use the product but
  1359. 44:45what they what I do like about it is
  1360. 44:47that they are the lowcost provider but
  1361. 44:50that's not enough right? whatever that
  1362. 44:52means in California that in proforma
  1363. 44:55they could produce it for call it 90 to
  1364. 44:58100 bucks a pound. These guys basically
  1365. 44:59bought a huge vegetable glass house and
  1366. 45:02and gut
  1367. 45:03>> and gut it in May and they they they
  1368. 45:06grow weed.
  1369. 45:06>> Yep. The the opportunity here is
  1370. 45:09recently last December and then
  1371. 45:12eventually finalized they rescheduled
  1372. 45:14>> the government federal government
  1373. 45:16>> federal government rescheduled the
  1374. 45:18classification of medical cannabis from
  1375. 45:20schedule one to schedule three.
  1376. 45:22>> Right.
  1377. 45:22>> Which really reduces the restrictions.
  1378. 45:25So a schedule one drug is heroin or
  1379. 45:27fentinyl. Right.
  1380. 45:28>> Right. Schedule
  1381. 45:29>> which is a no no.
  1382. 45:30>> Which is a no no. But cannabis was under
  1383. 45:33the same rules as as something such as
  1384. 45:35heroin.
  1385. 45:36>> And you can't you can't die from you
  1386. 45:38can't OD on on marijuana.
  1387. 45:40>> No. Right.
  1388. 45:40>> I assume you can. I can. But so in
  1389. 45:44>> but because it's for medicinal purposes.
  1390. 45:47The whole story is can they and right
  1391. 45:49now the answer is not yet but we believe
  1392. 45:52it will be the case produce cannabis and
  1393. 45:55hemp in California
  1394. 45:57>> and sell it elsewhere
  1395. 45:58>> and sell it elsewhere. And the margins
  1396. 46:00of selling it elsewhere are ginormous.
  1397. 46:02>> So everybody should know in California
  1398. 46:04they they say they sell it for $200 a
  1399. 46:06pound
  1400. 46:06>> and if they were able to sell it in
  1401. 46:08Germany
  1402. 46:09>> it's 600 700 bucks a pound.
  1403. 46:10>> It could be a thousand but but what else
  1404. 46:13will come down it's a lot more.
  1405. 46:14>> You know I run conservative so I'm so
  1406. 46:17but the that is 50 to 65% IBIDA margins
  1407. 46:23if they can do that on higher revenues.
  1408. 46:25>> How close do you think we are to this?
  1409. 46:28That's the $64,000 question. We believe
  1410. 46:32it's probably evolving slowly
  1411. 46:36and probably in my opinion might get
  1412. 46:38yelled at right now by Porter a 2027
  1413. 46:41event that we start seeing progress uh
  1414. 46:44whether it's interstate or overseas.
  1415. 46:47>> They sold hemp overseas this this
  1416. 46:49quarter.
  1417. 46:50>> Yes. and small amount small but then but
  1418. 46:52then they're trying to get sell
  1419. 46:53obviously the cannabis and then the
  1420. 46:55question is is can they get into selling
  1421. 46:57you know they have bombs that that um
  1422. 47:00you know that that fix like icy hot but
  1423. 47:02it actually works
  1424. 47:03>> right
  1425. 47:04>> and so c can you get into and can they
  1426. 47:07you know find a distribution partner and
  1427. 47:09get into the wellness business there's a
  1428. 47:10lot of
  1429. 47:11>> there's a lot they could do a lot they
  1430. 47:12can do and so is it's a small cap
  1431. 47:14company
  1432. 47:15>> it's like a 500 million what is it a
  1433. 47:17billion billion it's a billion in
  1434. 47:205 800 million something.
  1435. 47:21>> So we play we play we have a lot of
  1436. 47:23companies that were long and these small
  1437. 47:25cap stuff that we can find that no one
  1438. 47:27else really traffics in and we we like
  1439. 47:29it. You know we don't we've owned Google
  1440. 47:31for years but that's basically the only
  1441. 47:33household name that you
  1442. 47:34>> the only time we we go into what I would
  1443. 47:37call the mainstream media neck of the
  1444. 47:39woods is when there's something's for
  1445. 47:42sale, right? So for example when SAS
  1446. 47:46apocalypse or whatever we call it was
  1447. 47:48there and they were destroying some of
  1448. 47:50these names you know we bought into it
  1449. 47:53and service now uh on the cheap
  1450. 47:56>> uh when Google was allegedly being
  1451. 47:59disrupted
  1452. 48:00>> we bought Google.
  1453. 48:01>> Okay.
  1454. 48:01>> But but we typically don't play the you
  1455. 48:04don't play the standard game.
  1456. 48:05>> We don't play the stand
  1457. 48:05>> we don't own Amazon or this other stuff.
  1458. 48:09>> All right. We only have a few minutes.
  1459. 48:10Let's I'll give you guys the last word.
  1460. 48:12reporter say something. Again, I'll go
  1461. 48:14back to what I started with in that I
  1462. 48:18think that they're going to have to
  1463. 48:19print a lot of money. I I I just think
  1464. 48:22that and it's not going to it's not a
  1465. 48:24big disaster, but I think that just it's
  1466. 48:27not like the the world's going to blow
  1467. 48:29up because they can't do it, right?
  1468. 48:31>> So, but but what they when there is a
  1469. 48:32problem, what do they do? Come in they
  1470. 48:34come in and and helicopter print lots of
  1471. 48:37money,
  1472. 48:37>> right? And so I think that if something
  1473. 48:40really goes bad, I know they're going to
  1474. 48:41helicopter print money. And if status
  1475. 48:43quo happens, I know they're going to
  1476. 48:45keep continue printing money. And so
  1477. 48:47therefore, I think that the, you know,
  1478. 48:50gold continues to do well. And I think
  1479. 48:52that that's where the majority of our
  1480. 48:54capital sits. And I'm pretty bullish on
  1481. 48:56it.
  1482. 48:57>> And Steve, I want to say just thank you.
  1483. 49:00You're doing a great job. You look
  1484. 49:02great. Thank you. People love your
  1485. 49:04podcasts. It's uh you know it's
  1486. 49:07interesting. Thank you. Thank you for
  1487. 49:08saying that. Um
  1488. 49:11it's like
  1489. 49:13being part of a of like a dialogue
  1490. 49:16debate, you know, the AI, private
  1491. 49:19credit, all I mean you guys are
  1492. 49:20involved, too. It's it's like being
  1493. 49:24front and center on like the most
  1494. 49:25important questions of our of the age.
  1495. 49:28and and the the new media that we're
  1496. 49:30involved with deals with this much
  1497. 49:33better than old media.
  1498. 49:35>> What you do a great job of is is doing
  1499. 49:37the whole what do you mean? Right. You
  1500. 49:39you you know it's like cuz people like
  1501. 49:41to talk fancy and and
  1502. 49:43>> Oh, it was like when Vinnie was talking
  1503. 49:44the leverage. I know that most most
  1504. 49:46viewers it's not a criticism to viewers.
  1505. 49:48Why would they know how a hedge fund
  1506. 49:50lever the book?
  1507. 49:51>> So I I I've sort of learned that from
  1508. 49:52you over the years and you know I asked
  1509. 49:53a question on a call recently and
  1510. 49:55someone's like god that was a good
  1511. 49:56question. I was like, "Yeah, it was a
  1512. 49:57Steve question." [laughter]
  1513. 49:59>> Thank you.
  1514. 49:59>> Go, hold on. Go back and say that again.
  1515. 50:01What do you mean? What do you mean? What
  1516. 50:02do you mean? Explain that.
  1517. 50:04>> Yeah.
  1518. 50:04>> So,
  1519. 50:04>> and it's a lot of fun to like for us,
  1520. 50:06you're right. I mean, our jobs are never
  1521. 50:08boring now. Like, you're waking up.
  1522. 50:10>> You wake up every day something is
  1523. 50:12interesting has happened and you learn
  1524. 50:13about it. And I mean, I've learned more
  1525. 50:15about tech in the last year than I ever
  1526. 50:17learned.
  1527. 50:18>> Yeah. I mean, if if you said to us, you
  1528. 50:21know, five years ago, hey, you know,
  1529. 50:23Porter and Vinnie, you're gonna you're
  1530. 50:24going to start this Substack, like,
  1531. 50:27what? No way would I ever do that.
  1532. 50:28>> Yeah. Yeah.
  1533. 50:29>> And so, it's been it's been fun. We we
  1534. 50:32enjoy educating, you know, our
  1535. 50:34subscribers and, you know, our own
  1536. 50:36little pocket of crazy. And it's it's
  1537. 50:37fun, you know, we enjoy it and we get a
  1538. 50:40lot of feedback from them and we have
  1539. 50:41this little Discord that we use and and
  1540. 50:44so people ask us questions all day, all
  1541. 50:46the time. Funniest comment I got was I
  1542. 50:49always and not today but I usually wear
  1543. 50:51this jacket with a hoodie.
  1544. 50:52>> Yep.
  1545. 50:53>> Yeah.
  1546. 50:53>> So few months ago I wore it and there
  1547. 50:57was a comment from someone that says is
  1548. 51:00he wearing a jacket with a hoodie and
  1549. 51:02somebody one of the other viewers
  1550. 51:04replied saying you must be new here.
  1551. 51:06[laughter]
  1552. 51:08>> I make fun of uh Vinnie's wife and I
  1553. 51:11like to make fun of V usually Vinnie's
  1554. 51:13clothing attire.
  1555. 51:14>> Oh yeah. all the time like he likes his
  1556. 51:16cargo shorts and you look good today
  1557. 51:17though.
  1558. 51:18>> You look good.
  1559. 51:19>> I I was I was in the middle of Penn
  1560. 51:20Station and they were soliciting me but
  1561. 51:23uh people were soliciting me and one
  1562. 51:25called me GQ and CEO so I had to give
  1563. 51:27them money, right? [laughter] Like like
  1564. 51:29whether it's true or not, it just felt
  1565. 51:30good. I was like I got to give you
  1566. 51:32money. Don't sign me up for anything.
  1567. 51:33Here's here's here's 20. So
  1568. 51:35>> that's great.
  1569. 51:36>> Remember we we would uh Stew the H had
  1570. 51:39this uh exchange company that we owned.
  1571. 51:41Remember back in the day?
  1572. 51:42>> Sure. And uh it was a big meeting and uh
  1573. 51:45they're like, "Well, okay. Just come
  1574. 51:46down to our offices right now." And
  1575. 51:47Vinnie's like, "I'm not dressed for
  1576. 51:48this." So you went out into uh Paul
  1577. 51:50Stewart.
  1578. 51:51>> Paul Stewart and he had like this he got
  1579. 51:55a nice bright pink uh button-down and
  1580. 51:58like a like a socks.
  1581. 52:01>> Oh my god. And blue sweater. I was like,
  1582. 52:04"Oh my god, [laughter] what the hell is
  1583. 52:05going on?"
  1584. 52:07>> Like when in Rome, you
  1585. 52:08>> look great. You look great.
  1586. 52:09>> When in Rome, you got to dress the part.
  1587. 52:10>> Got to dress the part. All right, guys.
  1588. 52:12Thank you. That was great. Thank you for
  1589. 52:13coming in.
  1590. 52:16[music]
  1591. 52:19>> This podcast is forformational purposes
  1592. 52:21only and does not constitute investment
  1593. 52:23advice. A host and guests may [music]
  1594. 52:25hold positions in stocks discussed.
  1595. 52:27Opinions expressed are their own and not
  1596. 52:29recommendations. Please do your own due
  1597. 52:31diligence and consult a licensed
  1598. 52:32financial adviser before [music] making
  1599. 52:34any investment decisions.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of The Big Short Partners Reunite: Rates, AI, Gold and Two Stock Picks | The Real Eisman Playbook Ep 75 by Steve Eisman, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 10,271 words across 1,599 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.