The battle to replace your smartphone has begun — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Every major general-purpose technology
- 0:01has led to a different type of
- 0:03communication. We've had the telegraph,
- 0:04and then in the electricity era, we had
- 0:06the home phone. And then when we step
- 0:08into the internet era, we had the rise
- 0:10of the modern [music] smartphone that we
- 0:11all use. And we're at the beginning of
- 0:13that next general-purpose technology,
- 0:15artificial intelligence. [music] So if
- 0:17history can tell us anything, it's that
- 0:18there should be a new type of
- 0:19communication device. If you look at the
- 0:21investments of all of the major
- 0:23smartphone providers, they are investing
- 0:25in what would eventually cannibalize
- 0:27their own smartphone. That doesn't mean
- 0:28it's going to succeed. It doesn't mean
- 0:30that switch is going to happen anytime
- 0:32soon. But if you look at where the
- 0:34capital is flowing, if you look at the
- 0:36patents that are being filed, and if you
- 0:37look at the AI-first startups [music]
- 0:39and what they're building from a
- 0:40hardware sense, it's all pointing
- 0:42towards a different type of device.
- 0:49>> So Sinead, you think that smartphones,
- 0:51the bane of all our existences, uh are
- 0:55going to go the way of the landline, the
- 0:58Blackberry, the pager. You don't say
- 1:01which way you think the technology will
- 1:03go and what specifically it's going to
- 1:04be, whether it's going to be something
- 1:05wearable around your neck, whether it's
- 1:07going to be something in your ears or or
- 1:08a pair of glasses. But give us a sense
- 1:11of what you think the options are for
- 1:13replacing our smartphone.
- 1:15>> So what we can see so far, and it will
- 1:18be this this kind of gradual transition
- 1:21and both will exist for a while, the
- 1:23glasses are certainly a strong
- 1:24contender. Meta has done pretty well in
- 1:26this space. I think that over 2 million
- 1:28people use Meta's smart glasses, and we
- 1:30can talk about the concerns that I have.
- 1:33Snapchat has stepped into that game as
- 1:34well. Google has their attempt at
- 1:36glasses, and they've demonstrated it at
- 1:38IO a few times. OpenAI is supposed to be
- 1:41releasing something soon. They've
- 1:43partnered up with one of the legendary
- 1:44hardware device makers, Johnny Ive. And
- 1:47the inside scoop there is that it's
- 1:49going to be some type of screenless
- 1:51device that can sit in the home. It
- 1:53could be a pendant, something that we
- 1:55just wear around our neck or something
- 1:56that we wear around our our finger.
- 1:58That's what we can see in the landscape
- 1:59far. But just like the iPhone, it was
- 2:02supposed to fail, and nobody saw it
- 2:03coming. There could be another contender
- 2:05that comes in from the side that
- 2:06nobody's paying attention to.
- 2:08>> So I think a lot of people are going to
- 2:09listen to this and think, oh my god,
- 2:11thank god, you know, I spend way too
- 2:12much time looking at my phone. It's
- 2:14super depressing when you look around
- 2:15and everybody's sitting looking at their
- 2:17phones, whether it's in a restaurant or
- 2:18on the subway or wherever it is. We just
- 2:21seem to have got consumed by them. And
- 2:23we all have this kind of love-hate
- 2:25relationship with our devices. I imagine
- 2:27a lot of people are going to hear this
- 2:28and think, I'm really happy at the idea
- 2:30of getting rid of my smartphones, but
- 2:32just like the smartphone has a downside,
- 2:34I'm assuming all of this new technology
- 2:36will come with its downsides too. So
- 2:38should we be careful what we wish for?
- 2:40>> Absolutely. I think I mean, what would
- 2:43we have done differently had we known
- 2:45the central role the smartphone would
- 2:47have played in our lives and how much of
- 2:49our attention we would give to it? And I
- 2:50don't know if it's the smartphone per se
- 2:52or the apps that we download onto the
- 2:55smartphone, but would we have done
- 2:56different things with schools, for
- 2:58instance, and everything we're trying to
- 2:59do retroactively now?
- 3:01And so when it comes to the AI first
- 3:04devices is what I call them, it's not
- 3:06that I I talk about them so frequently
- 3:09because I'm advocating for them. I'm
- 3:11actually somebody who doesn't even own a
- 3:12television. I have a radio. So I'm very
- 3:14strict with devices. It's because
- 3:17we learned a lot about waiting too late
- 3:20with smartphones and social media and so
- 3:21forth. So what would we do now that
- 3:23we're in the design chapter of what
- 3:25could be coming next? And one thing that
- 3:27seems quite clear to me, any device that
- 3:30has AI embedded into it that doesn't
- 3:32need a screen
- 3:33probably has a 24/7 surveillance aspect
- 3:37to it where your AI would be listening
- 3:39to you.
- 3:40>> The ambient capture of everything that's
- 3:42around you and the privacy implications
- 3:44that come from society with that.
- 3:46>> Completely. So we can see that today.
- 3:48Even with smart glasses, we're now
- 3:49starting to see schools say, oh, what
- 3:51are the limits here? Can people do this
- 3:52in public? What are If they're at the
- 3:54mall, do they have to you know, show
- 3:55people what they're on? So if that's
- 3:57going to become the the dominant device
- 3:59in the future or wherever else, we need
- 4:02to figure out what are the boundaries of
- 4:04that technology and it's not just
- 4:05something that has to happen via
- 4:06regulation. If you build the right
- 4:08incentives today, tech companies could
- 4:11be forced to design that in from from
- 4:14the get go.
- 4:15>> Yeah, and you see that the regulation
- 4:16doesn't really work and it takes way too
- 4:17long to get there and we took, you know,
- 4:19whatever it is, 10 15 years with social
- 4:21media and we should have got there much
- 4:22quicker. Do you think though now that we
- 4:25have a league time and you've pointed
- 4:27out that this is going to change, how
- 4:29confident are you that that league time
- 4:31will be used by the designers and
- 4:34potentially the regulators to design
- 4:36something that serves us well and
- 4:39doesn't harm us?
- 4:40>> My confidence is mixed. I mean already
- 4:42today people are ordering neuro devices
- 4:45from, you know, something like Amazon to
- 4:47track their meditation waves and
- 4:49uploading the data onto Facebook and
- 4:51nobody seems to be worried about that
- 4:52and to me that's kind of another pathway
- 4:54to a whole different chapter of data. I
- 4:55think you know what the problem is? It's
- 4:57not that I don't think we're going to
- 4:58move in time, it's that people don't
- 5:00necessarily believe the change that
- 5:04could be coming. When you talk to people
- 5:06about a world without smartphones, it
- 5:08seems impossible to imagine and I think
- 5:10that's what's more likely to get in our
- 5:12way. People saying, oh I would never use
- 5:13smart glasses or I would never use this
- 5:15type of pendant, therefore we don't need
- 5:17to pay attention to it. So I think it's
- 5:19actually more of a a disbelief that our
- 5:22world of devices could change, but I
- 5:23think people are more aware. There's a
- 5:25lot more discussion about the dangers of
- 5:26of smart glasses
- 5:28and hopefully that catalyzes a wider
- 5:30discussion.
- 5:31>> Shinade, you deal with the world of the
- 5:32future, but I'm going to throw you into
- 5:33the role of advisor. What would you say
- 5:36to ordinary people, to parents in
- 5:39particular, that they should watch out
- 5:41for as this
- 5:43technology of the smartphone gets
- 5:45replaced by something we haven't even
- 5:46named yet, but we are rushing towards?
- 5:48What would you advise people to watch
- 5:50for?
- 5:51>> Especially when it comes to children, if
- 5:53we cannot make children the test ground
- 5:57for something for a new type of device,
- 5:59if parents can do their best to try to
- 6:01understand the data that gets captured,
- 6:04where does get stored, where does it go?
- 6:07And then I'd say finally, anytime AI is
- 6:10built into it, which these devices will
- 6:12from the from from from the gecko, there
- 6:14is no reason why a young child should
- 6:17have unsupervised conversations with an
- 6:20AI chatbot ever. We haven't figured out
- 6:23how to do that safely. We haven't
- 6:24figured out how to stop, you know, data
- 6:26being captured and so forth.
- 6:28So depending on how young
- 6:30a child is, there's no reason why they
- 6:31should probably even be alone with that
- 6:33device if AI is embedded right into it
- 6:35from from the gecko.
- 6:36>> What excites you most about the idea of
- 6:40this technology still evolving and
- 6:42something replacing the smartphone and
- 6:44whatever that may look like, whatever
- 6:45it's going to be, what is it that makes
- 6:47you feel this could be a really good
- 6:49scenario for us?
- 6:51>> And I think in an ideal world, I'm not
- 6:54sure how much people love the idea of
- 6:57this the screen. I think in a few
- 7:00decades, the data and their research
- 7:02will probably become more clear on the
- 7:04impact of screens on the brain, on eyes,
- 7:07and so forth. So if we can get this
- 7:10right, right? Like let let's suspend
- 7:12disbelief and imagine, okay, we figured
- 7:14out the data and surveillance and the
- 7:16privacy issues with artificial
- 7:19intelligence and future devices. And
- 7:21instead, we figured out a way that if
- 7:23you need something that's connected to a
- 7:24digital system, maybe that's the
- 7:26internet, maybe that's contacting a
- 7:27friend, you could converse and figure
- 7:30that out without having to leave the
- 7:32moment, open a screen and swipe and go
- 7:35into some virtual world.
- 7:37That to me is an interesting future I'm
- 7:38willing to contemplate
- 7:40if we can figure that out, right? And
- 7:42and and even I mean, it's not just the
- 7:44devices that we can see in the pipeline
- 7:46like rings and pendants. There's also
- 7:48different types of sensors where there
- 7:51could be paper in the future that has
- 7:52sensors
- 7:54built right into the paper. So as you're
- 7:56actually writing, it's uploading
- 7:57immediately to the cloud. So you're kind
- 7:59of getting the best of both worlds. So I
- 8:01encourage and and that's the whole point
- 8:03of foresight, right? You you examine all
- 8:06of the scenarios, the the not so great
- 8:07ones about privacy, surveillance, but
- 8:09also what would it look like if this was
- 8:11designed well and more interesting um
- 8:14and optimized for the things that we all
- 8:15actually crave. Those futures are
- 8:17possible too. Uh so that's something
- 8:19that I'm really curious about.
- 8:21>> Shana, thank you so much for joining me.
- 8:23>> Thanks for having me.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of The battle to replace your smartphone has begun by BBC Global, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,731 words across 254 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.