YouTube2Text

The 3 Timeless Rules Shared by 100 Years of Market Wizards · Jack Schwager & George Coyle — Transcript

by Chat With Traders · 13,173 words · 1,850 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00One of the themes that um and I try to
  2. 0:02always at the end of each marker wizard
  3. 0:04book typically talk about what the
  4. 0:06unifying themes are, but it one that has
  5. 0:09been true across all the books until
  6. 0:11this last one and even for some traders
  7. 0:13in this last one as well, but has been
  8. 0:16looking for asymmetric trades. The the
  9. 0:18secret of how these traders have done so
  10. 0:20spectacularly well is one form or
  11. 0:23another their trading methodology is
  12. 0:26find situations where you can make
  13. 0:28three, four, even 10 times what you're
  14. 0:31risking on the trade. We got to see
  15. 0:33these guys returns. They send us their
  16. 0:34material to verify and some of the guys
  17. 0:37that had the best sort of results. So
  18. 0:39their monthly percentage returns are
  19. 0:42just they're wild. you look at them and
  20. 0:43you think, how did they have the
  21. 0:45fortitude to to wake up and trade the
  22. 0:47next month because it was a down 30 or
  23. 0:4950% month
  24. 0:50>> with the next generation here. Is was
  25. 0:52there any interview in there that that
  26. 0:54you think challenged your own kind of
  27. 0:56beliefs or maybe thoughts at all? Yeah,
  28. 1:00I mean the idea of shorting smaller cap
  29. 1:02stocks as a way to get success would
  30. 1:05certainly not have been on my list of on
  31. 1:08my top 100 list of ways to [laughter]
  32. 1:11market. But to succeed and what
  33. 1:15ultimately happens in the process is
  34. 1:17they find they love this thing and they
  35. 1:19just it's like their work is their
  36. 1:21hobby. It has to be that type of
  37. 1:23attitude. If you're only in it, if doing
  38. 1:25all that research is work, uh you're not
  39. 1:28going to be you're not going to succeed
  40. 1:30spectacularly.
  41. 1:31>> One is they're they're usually pretty
  42. 1:32self-aware. They understand who they are
  43. 1:34and what they want. Two is they have
  44. 1:36clear goals. They're not confused about
  45. 1:39what they're trying to achieve. Three is
  46. 1:40they believe in themselves. A lot of
  47. 1:42times they believe in themselves when
  48. 1:44there is no evidence to support that
  49. 1:46belief whatsoever. Whether that's blown
  50. 1:48up trading accounts or family members
  51. 1:50telling them you're not good at this, go
  52. 1:52do something else. Four is that they are
  53. 1:54pretty independent as people. You're not
  54. 1:56going to probably find them working a
  55. 1:57nineto-five as a a cog in the machine.
  56. 2:00Five, they're very passionate about
  57. 2:01trading as we mentioned a minute or two
  58. 2:03ago. Six, they're committed. They're
  59. 2:04they're sticking with this through thick
  60. 2:07or thin. So that leads to persistence.
  61. 2:09They're all very persistent in achieving
  62. 2:11their goals. Uh beyond that, they're
  63. 2:14they're very willing to pursue their
  64. 2:15dreams despite the fear of failure. So
  65. 2:18they press on even if they're afraid
  66. 2:20they might fail. and they really have an
  67. 2:22ability to focus that you don't see so
  68. 2:25much in everyday people.
  69. 2:26>> What would your trading look like if
  70. 2:28capital wasn't the constraint? That's
  71. 2:30the reality for most traders. It's not
  72. 2:32skill holding them back. It's size.
  73. 2:34Trade the pool changes that. Step into
  74. 2:36the US equity markets with up to
  75. 2:38$200,000 in buying power without
  76. 2:41committing your own capital. Full access
  77. 2:43to stocks and ETFs, long or short,
  78. 2:45executed with the precision and freedom
  79. 2:47serious traders expect. Your performance
  80. 2:49is measured by one standard. Disciplined
  81. 2:51risk management and consistent
  82. 2:53execution. Meet that standard and you
  83. 2:55operate at scale. No subscriptions, no
  84. 2:58ongoing obligations, just a clear path
  85. 3:00forward. For those ready to trade beyond
  86. 3:03limitations, this is the next level.
  87. 3:06>> Markets, speculation, and risk. This is
  88. 3:10the Chat with Traders podcast.
  89. 3:15Welcome back to Chat with Traders.
  90. 3:16Today's guests are Jack Schwagger and
  91. 3:18George Coyle. Jack Schwagger is a
  92. 3:20globally recognized authority on trading
  93. 3:22and financial markets renowned for his
  94. 3:24groundbreaking Market Wizard series
  95. 3:27which has educated and inspired
  96. 3:28generations of traders, investors, and
  97. 3:31market professionals around the world
  98. 3:33across titles including the original
  99. 3:35market wizards, the new market wizards,
  100. 3:38hedge fund market wizards, the unknown
  101. 3:40market wizards, and now what's coming
  102. 3:42next, the next generation market
  103. 3:44wizards. So Jack's in-depth interviews
  104. 3:45with elite performers have become
  105. 3:47essential reading for anyone seeking to
  106. 3:49better understand the art and science of
  107. 3:51trading. His career has also included
  108. 3:53senior industry roles such as partner at
  109. 3:55Fortune Group, a London-based hedge fund
  110. 3:57advisory firm, along with director of
  111. 4:00futures research positions at several
  112. 4:02major Wall Street firms. Jack is also no
  113. 4:04stranger to chat with traders, having
  114. 4:06previously joined us on episodes 27,778,
  115. 4:09and 308, and it's a pleasure to welcome
  116. 4:12him back onto the show. Well, joining
  117. 4:14him today is co-author George Coyle.
  118. 4:17George is the founder of Triangulated
  119. 4:19Capital Management and brings more than
  120. 4:21two decades of experience across hedge
  121. 4:23funds, research firms, and family
  122. 4:25offices in roles including chief
  123. 4:27investment officer, portfolio manager,
  124. 4:29systematic strategy designer, macro
  125. 4:32strategist, and trader. George is widely
  126. 4:34respected for his deep study of elite
  127. 4:36traders, market history, and performance
  128. 4:38psychology. Through his writings and
  129. 4:40research, he has focused on identifying
  130. 4:42the timeless principles, common
  131. 4:44patterns, and decision-making frameworks
  132. 4:46shared by exceptional traders across
  133. 4:49generations. Together, Jack and George
  134. 4:51have collaborated on Market Wizards: The
  135. 4:53Next Generation, highlighting a new
  136. 4:55generation of extraordinary traders and
  137. 4:57the lessons they offer in today's
  138. 4:59evolving markets. This is incredible.
  139. 5:02Uh, welcome, Jack and George, to chat
  140. 5:03with Traders. I got to pinch myself here
  141. 5:06because I mean the market wizards books
  142. 5:08these are this is timeless material.
  143. 5:10This material lives on forever. So this
  144. 5:13is incredible to have you both on.
  145. 5:14Welcome to chat with traders.
  146. 5:16>> Hey thanks for having us Kevin and maybe
  147. 5:18you should be doing my PR going forward.
  148. 5:20That was a pretty good introduction.
  149. 5:21[laughter]
  150. 5:21>> I appreciate it. So I want to just dive
  151. 5:23straight in. How did this collaboration
  152. 5:26happen?
  153. 5:27>> Yeah. So um basically what happened was
  154. 5:30we had a mutual acquaintance friend uh
  155. 5:33Marit Sebert uh in Europe and uh I got a
  156. 5:36email from Morates asking me would I be
  157. 5:40willing to read an article from this
  158. 5:42fellow who wrote an wrote an article
  159. 5:45about Michael Marcus who was chapter one
  160. 5:48>> of the first Marcus Wizards book and I
  161. 5:51said well yeah sure send it to me and uh
  162. 5:53I read it was pretty good and uh then I
  163. 5:56got a guess I got a call from George, I
  164. 5:58forget, but just asking to do a call and
  165. 6:00I was more than happy to to accommodate
  166. 6:02him of it because I had seen his work
  167. 6:05and uh we had a we had a talk and George
  168. 6:09was planning to do a book which he can
  169. 6:11describe and uh that I had no intention
  170. 6:16a no intention of uh doing another book
  171. 6:19at that time nor any thought of working
  172. 6:21with George and uh and I was just giving
  173. 6:24him advice uh just my best advice. vice
  174. 6:27and how to go and I even offered to
  175. 6:29introduce him to my editor if you wanted
  176. 6:31and and I'll let George take it from
  177. 6:33there.
  178. 6:34>> Yeah, I I said no to that offer
  179. 6:37initially, which uh seems like a
  180. 6:39bonehead move, but you know, at the time
  181. 6:43I didn't really have a good idea for a
  182. 6:45book. And fast forward about a year, I
  183. 6:47was trying to get my business off the
  184. 6:49ground and struggling like a lot of
  185. 6:50people do. And so I started to study the
  186. 6:53early careers of a lot of really really
  187. 6:56successful people. So Warren Buffett for
  188. 6:58example, he spent about three years as a
  189. 7:00stock broker and didn't do very well at
  190. 7:02it. Uh according to his biography and
  191. 7:04then I found that John Bogle, you know,
  192. 7:06the founder of Vanguard, the the most
  193. 7:08popular investment strategy of all time,
  194. 7:10which is lowcost, you know, passive
  195. 7:13indexing in the S&P 500 essentially. It
  196. 7:15took him eight years to get that going.
  197. 7:18So, when I found all these stories, I
  198. 7:20kept finding more and more great stories
  199. 7:21and I said, "This would make a really
  200. 7:23good book." Um, but I figured I would
  201. 7:25use so much of Jack's material. And Jack
  202. 7:29obviously is is uh very well known and
  203. 7:31I'm not. So, I approached him and said,
  204. 7:32"Hey, what if I wrote a book within the
  205. 7:34Market Wizards universe that isn't a
  206. 7:36traditional wizards book, but really
  207. 7:38focuses on these early stories and uses
  208. 7:40a lot of your material?" And ultimately,
  209. 7:43um, through a series of steps, it
  210. 7:45evolved into what it is now. So, a
  211. 7:48traditional market wizards book.
  212. 7:50>> Wow. I mean, that's just incredible.
  213. 7:51And, you know, doing research for this
  214. 7:54interview really what I came to find out
  215. 7:56is it, you know, Jack, when you first
  216. 7:58had started writing, your first book was
  217. 7:59the complete guide to futures market.
  218. 8:02You wrote that. By the way, I heard you
  219. 8:04say by hand 800 pages.
  220. 8:07>> Yeah.
  221. 8:07>> Which these days you can click a mouse
  222. 8:09and write 800 pages. I can't imagine
  223. 8:11what that was like back then, but you
  224. 8:13were trying to solve a problem is what
  225. 8:15you said. and George, your principles of
  226. 8:17great traders, you were trying to solve
  227. 8:20a problem with that as well. So, it
  228. 8:22almost really feels like the perfect
  229. 8:24collaboration. It's not like you were
  230. 8:25both trying to, you know, your goal
  231. 8:29wasn't I'm to try to be famous, sell
  232. 8:31millions of copies. The goal was really
  233. 8:33I need a I have a problem I need to
  234. 8:35solve. Is that accurate?
  235. 8:36>> So, yeah, first of all, a complete god.
  236. 8:39Congratulations on getting that right.
  237. 8:40Everybody usually not everybody but most
  238. 8:43people kind of think the first book was
  239. 8:45market wisdom. It wasn't. It was a
  240. 8:47complete guide. And I wrote that I took
  241. 8:49us about it but I didn't think there was
  242. 8:51a good market a good market good book on
  243. 8:53futures markets.
  244. 8:55>> This is back in 1983
  245. 8:57and so I had an opportunity I took a
  246. 8:59sbatical took a year so sbatical. So
  247. 9:01this I mean PCs I think consistent
  248. 9:04existed in their infancy but not really
  249. 9:07not I wasn't using them. So everything
  250. 9:09was by hand. Um I did use my secretary
  251. 9:13from from a previous uh uh dire when I
  252. 9:15was director futures research at at a
  253. 9:18brokerage firm. So I used her to kind of
  254. 9:20trans uh I would record stuff and send
  255. 9:23it to her and she would type it up. So
  256. 9:25that was done. But everything else like
  257. 9:26charts I had to do by hand. Uh
  258. 9:29and this was a book that was analytical.
  259. 9:31So there was some you know math
  260. 9:32involved. I remember literally doing
  261. 9:35multiple regressions on a calc you know
  262. 9:37by calculator which is really tedious uh
  263. 9:40and very easy to make a mistake so you
  264. 9:41got to be careful. Um anyway, so it it
  265. 9:44it took a year uh working really
  266. 9:47intensely uh morning night and my goal
  267. 9:50was simply to write the best analytical
  268. 9:52book on the futures markets at least at
  269. 9:54that time and that was my and I wasn't I
  270. 9:57want to emphasize this I wasn't trying
  271. 9:59to write a book that would sell a lot of
  272. 10:00copies because yeah
  273. 10:02>> I don't know if this is my original
  274. 10:04thought plot or I heard it somewhere
  275. 10:06else but the the sales of a book are
  276. 10:09inversely correlated to the number of
  277. 10:11formulas and I was you know quite aware
  278. 10:14of that and [clears throat]
  279. 10:15uh but like I came to this I you're
  280. 10:18doing fundamental analysis you have to
  281. 10:20get into regression analysis and I
  282. 10:22thought I was going to do one chapter
  283. 10:24turned out well I couldn't started right
  284. 10:26the first chapter well I can't do this
  285. 10:27unless people understand basic
  286. 10:29statistics so I have to write a chapter
  287. 10:30on that and then I said well I can't
  288. 10:32stop at simple regression I have to do
  289. 10:34multiple regression then I you know and
  290. 10:36on and on I ended up with six chapters
  291. 10:37and god knows how many pages so I knew
  292. 10:39the book wasn't geared for mass audience
  293. 10:41ience just because it was it it was had
  294. 10:44some an you know real analysis in it. So
  295. 10:47um that wasn't my goal. I just wanted to
  296. 10:49write the most thorough book.
  297. 10:50>> And is that when market wizard stepped
  298. 10:52in when you were like well actually I I
  299. 10:54know some guys great traders and this
  300. 10:56would be good for a large audience here.
  301. 10:58>> That didn't happen that way. What
  302. 11:00happened was I had no intention like I
  303. 11:02said I took a year. It was a really
  304. 11:04tense work. Uh so I wasn't planning to
  305. 11:06write another book, but I did have the
  306. 11:07idea um that gee, you know, I did know
  307. 11:11some great traders like Marcus and Coner
  308. 11:13and uh and I said, gee, it would
  309. 11:16probably be a fun idea to go around the
  310. 11:18country and interview the world's best,
  311. 11:20you know, the country's best traders. Uh
  312. 11:22but I was a research director. That's a
  313. 11:24full-time job, more than full-time job.
  314. 11:26So I didn't see I could do it. And I got
  315. 11:28invited to lunch by a publisher, another
  316. 11:30publisher, and they wanted me to do a
  317. 11:32series of books. they they had seen the
  318. 11:35complete guide and that did pretty well
  319. 11:37for that type of book and they wanted me
  320. 11:40to do a whole series of books, you know,
  321. 11:43you know, a book on on gold anal gold
  322. 11:45analysis, a book on grain analysis, just
  323. 11:47different books on different types of
  324. 11:48analysis. And I said, look, I've been
  325. 11:50there, I've done it. I don't want to do
  326. 11:52that again, but if I was ever going to
  327. 11:53write another book, I mentioned this
  328. 11:55market wizard idea and he said, great.
  329. 11:57Why don't you do it? So that was the
  330. 12:00catalyst. I didn't have the time, but I
  331. 12:02did think it would be a fun thing to do
  332. 12:05>> and so I agreed and I basically did it
  333. 12:07on nights and weekends and uh
  334. 12:09>> and got it done.
  335. 12:11>> Did you know we would be where we are
  336. 12:12today with now just a huge series? I
  337. 12:15mean at any given time somebody's
  338. 12:17reading a market wizards book. I mean
  339. 12:19it's
  340. 12:19>> never thought of doing a series. I was
  341. 12:21just writing the you know this one book
  342. 12:23market wizards. never thought of of
  343. 12:26doing the additional ones at least not
  344. 12:28before I wrote the first one but the
  345. 12:30first one did extremely well and um I
  346. 12:34knew more traders and I I certainly
  347. 12:37didn't exhaust the idea so um a couple
  348. 12:40few years later I decided to do I would
  349. 12:43do another one and that was the new
  350. 12:45market wizards and then after that like
  351. 12:48every six or seven years
  352. 12:50>> went back to it and did another one. Uh
  353. 12:52so George, you've studied a lot of these
  354. 12:54traders um that have been in the
  355. 12:57original mark uh market wizards. Uh why
  356. 12:59was there that sense of curiosity there?
  357. 13:01What were you trying to solve in doing
  358. 13:02that?
  359. 13:03>> Why are we curious about the things
  360. 13:05we're curious about? You know, that's a
  361. 13:07that's a question we might not be able
  362. 13:08to answer here, but specifically I was
  363. 13:11designing trading systems. I mean, I had
  364. 13:13always read the wizards books and had
  365. 13:14always studied traders, but at one point
  366. 13:16I was
  367. 13:17>> designing systems and I had read the
  368. 13:19work of Ed Sakod on his website over the
  369. 13:21years. and started to see a lot of what
  370. 13:23he said manifesting in the systems that
  371. 13:26I was running in terms of well here's
  372. 13:28what the back test says here's what you
  373. 13:29actually got and that led me to just do
  374. 13:32a deep dive on his website and I
  375. 13:34aggregated everything I could over about
  376. 13:3620 years of his information and I
  377. 13:39categorized it and read it and it made a
  378. 13:40lot of sense and I said well I don't
  379. 13:42want to have to do this again so I'm
  380. 13:43going to write this as a paper and I
  381. 13:45started just writing sort of
  382. 13:47categorically and here are the factors I
  383. 13:49said this doesn't read very well so I'll
  384. 13:51try to make it a Q&A and I wound up
  385. 13:53doing that and sent it to him and he
  386. 13:55published it on his website. It's still
  387. 13:57there so people can can read it. But uh
  388. 13:59once I did that I noticed that a lot of
  389. 14:01the things that he said were inherent to
  390. 14:03robust systems were the same things that
  391. 14:05discretionary guys were saying about
  392. 14:06their trading process. So Martin Zwig
  393. 14:09had talked a lot about the trend as an
  394. 14:11important factor in trading. Um and
  395. 14:13Soros said the secret to his uh success
  396. 14:16was correcting his mistakes which
  397. 14:18essentially is cutting his losses. So I
  398. 14:20said, "Boy, you know, there's so many
  399. 14:22similarities. I'm going to pull this
  400. 14:23string and see where it goes." And I
  401. 14:25read a lot of books and articles and
  402. 14:28went back to as far as I could really. I
  403. 14:30wound up in, I guess, the late 1800s in
  404. 14:32terms of of written work. And I just
  405. 14:34aggregated all of that mainly because I
  406. 14:36wanted to to use it to guide my process.
  407. 14:40Um, but also so when I hit a draw down,
  408. 14:43I'd have something to to go, you know,
  409. 14:45drown my sorrows with essentially like
  410. 14:47got to go back and do the right thing.
  411. 14:49And then once that was done, I just I
  412. 14:51started to enjoy doing it. I said, I've
  413. 14:53always thought Soros is interesting.
  414. 14:55Let's let's do him. And then Dr. Miller
  415. 14:57and Marcus. So, you know, somebody read
  416. 14:59the Marcus paper recently and said, why
  417. 15:01did you do this? You know, this is still
  418. 15:03seems like a ton of work, but I was just
  419. 15:05genuinely curious um about his story for
  420. 15:08one because it was such a great chapter,
  421. 15:10but also just in how he did what he did.
  422. 15:13For whatever reason, I'm just naturally
  423. 15:15curious about how traders do what they
  424. 15:17do. You know, that curiosity led you
  425. 15:20here, though. I mean, for that person
  426. 15:23that asked, "Why'd you do this? It was a
  427. 15:24lot of work." Well, guess what? You're
  428. 15:26co-authoring the Market Wizard's book
  429. 15:29now because of that curiosity, right?
  430. 15:31>> Yeah. And I think people have different
  431. 15:32hobbies. You know, maybe mine are a
  432. 15:34little strange, but I read trading
  433. 15:36books. And for me, you know, when you
  434. 15:38see a a piece of information in one book
  435. 15:41and then something else in an article
  436. 15:43and then something else in an interview
  437. 15:45or what have you and you can put all
  438. 15:47that together and combine it and come up
  439. 15:49with sort of a larger message, it's like
  440. 15:52solving a puzzle. I don't know. I I
  441. 15:54enjoy it.
  442. 15:55>> Well, you said you've you've aggregated
  443. 15:56all this data. You've studied like
  444. 15:58centuries of traders and you've come up
  445. 16:00with a few commonalities. these three
  446. 16:03core trading principles among great
  447. 16:05traders is what you call them. What are
  448. 16:07those three principles? And then Jack,
  449. 16:10I'm curious if if you think those three
  450. 16:12principles have applied to the next
  451. 16:14generation um as well.
  452. 16:16>> Uh so I'll go with the three there. Uh
  453. 16:18respect the price action of the market,
  454. 16:20your winning positions, and cut your
  455. 16:22losing positions. So pretty simple, but
  456. 16:25uh those are the three main things that
  457. 16:26were consistent across a 100 plus years
  458. 16:29of the grades. Well, well, I've heard
  459. 16:30from Jack in a prior interview him
  460. 16:32saying it's better to keep things
  461. 16:34simplistic than complex. Is that right?
  462. 16:37>> What are your thoughts?
  463. 16:38>> It's um to a degree. I mean, it really
  464. 16:41depends. Um I mean, if
  465. 16:45keep things no more complex than they
  466. 16:47need to be would be a better way of
  467. 16:48putting it. Uh because sometimes
  468. 16:50sometimes depending on the approach,
  469. 16:52they need to be complex. So some of the
  470. 16:55people I've interviewed in the course of
  471. 16:56the books uh uh some famous quants like
  472. 16:59D Shaw and Ned Thorp two brilliant minds
  473. 17:03um they they were certainly highly
  474. 17:06highly complex um but that was that was
  475. 17:10the way that was their edge that was
  476. 17:12their their methodology so I wouldn't
  477. 17:14say you should never be complex and in
  478. 17:16fact um when you get down to systems if
  479. 17:19you go to systematic training I think
  480. 17:21it's very difficult to just have a
  481. 17:23simple system that is really
  482. 17:27not that not a simple system that can't
  483. 17:29make money but one that has really good
  484. 17:31return to risk. I think it's difficult
  485. 17:33to would be very difficult to do that in
  486. 17:35a very simplistic fashion. Very simple
  487. 17:37systems. They may make money over time
  488. 17:40but to but with a lot of volatility and
  489. 17:44risk and and to get really good return
  490. 17:46to risk I don't think you can avoid some
  491. 17:48degree of complexity.
  492. 17:50>> Right. You know what I find fascinating
  493. 17:51too is you've mentioned there's really
  494. 17:53no single approach to the market. So
  495. 17:56maybe with that too like some maybe
  496. 17:59simple some complex some focus for
  497. 18:01example fundamentals some technical some
  498. 18:03scalp some day trading it's swing
  499. 18:06trading you know it's there's so many
  500. 18:07different approaches and I want to ask
  501. 18:09you both too with that because the next
  502. 18:11generation there are a few different
  503. 18:13approaches as well in fact there was an
  504. 18:16approach that we haven't seen yet in a
  505. 18:17market wizards book. Is that correct?
  506. 18:19>> Yeah. So you're you're you're quite
  507. 18:21right on that. So one of the themes that
  508. 18:24um and I try to always at the end of
  509. 18:26each market wizard book typically talk
  510. 18:29about what the unifying themes are but
  511. 18:31it one that has been true across all the
  512. 18:34books until this last one uh and even
  513. 18:36for some traders in this last one as
  514. 18:38well but has been uh looking for
  515. 18:41asymmetric trades. The the secret of how
  516. 18:44these traders have done so spectacularly
  517. 18:46well is one form or another their
  518. 18:50trading methodology is find situations
  519. 18:53where you can make three, four, even 10
  520. 18:55times what you're risking on the trade.
  521. 18:58That's that's where they get their uh
  522. 19:01really good performance because their
  523. 19:03whole methodology is geared to when they
  524. 19:06win they or they're looking for spots
  525. 19:09and situations where they can win a lot
  526. 19:13relative to the amount of risk required
  527. 19:15to prove that trade is wrong. That in a
  528. 19:17nutshell is the essence. Even for
  529. 19:19traders with completely different
  530. 19:21approaches, when you get down to it in
  531. 19:23their own way, they're trying to do
  532. 19:25that. They're trying to find the spot
  533. 19:28where they can have an opportunity to
  534. 19:31make as I said three, four, five, 10
  535. 19:33times what they'll lose if they're wrong
  536. 19:36on the trade. So, uh that is a big
  537. 19:38unifying theme in this book. There were
  538. 19:41few traders who at least at one point in
  539. 19:45their career, usually the earlier part
  540. 19:47did come up with methodologies where
  541. 19:49they made their initial millions which
  542. 19:52which really defied that. in fact was
  543. 19:54just the opposite. They were doing they
  544. 19:56were doing a strategy which
  545. 19:58theoretically could lose multiples what
  546. 20:02what they were could make and that was
  547. 20:05specifically uh a few of these traders
  548. 20:08started out by selling small cap uh
  549. 20:11going short small cap stocks which I
  550. 20:14mean the best you can do is it goes to
  551. 20:15zero and some of these small cap stocks
  552. 20:18when they're in these pump and dump
  553. 20:20phases they could go to extreme extreme
  554. 20:23levels I mean not
  555. 20:24unheard of for them to go up a thousand%
  556. 20:26in a day even. So there is there is a
  557. 20:29lot of risk there and a limited
  558. 20:32potential. So yet they made it work and
  559. 20:34we could talk about how they made it
  560. 20:36work but uh so you have that and you
  561. 20:38also had one trader who
  562. 20:41second half of his career went uh a
  563. 20:44large part of his trading was uh
  564. 20:47shorting options. And shorting options
  565. 20:49is the kind of poster child for a uh uh
  566. 20:54you know the the old phrase is what
  567. 20:56picking up nickels in front of a
  568. 20:58bulldozer. Um you you you know there if
  569. 21:01you see the if you see the charts the
  570. 21:04equity charts of traders who sell out of
  571. 21:07the money options pretty much looks like
  572. 21:09an mountain chart until they step on a
  573. 21:13mine otherwise known as a sharp quick
  574. 21:16selloff in the market. Um and and it all
  575. 21:20evaporates because that type of strategy
  576. 21:23the more the market the market
  577. 21:25volatility starts going up the more it
  578. 21:27goes up your your position not only you
  579. 21:30losing your your the key is not that
  580. 21:32you're losing on your position is your
  581. 21:34position grows exponentially larger as
  582. 21:37as the market in this case volatility
  583. 21:40moves against you. So it's it's a
  584. 21:42radically uh opposite uh type of
  585. 21:45strategy. Uh again he made it work very
  586. 21:48well and but he had ways of controlling
  587. 21:51the risk and characteristics
  588. 21:53how he made that work without stepping
  589. 21:56on the landmines.
  590. 21:57>> Yeah those landmines seem inevitable.
  591. 22:00You know there there's maybe one or two
  592. 22:02in the field. I was George I heard you
  593. 22:03say that in an interview. There might
  594. 22:05you know the field might be pretty clear
  595. 22:06and empty for the most part but one or
  596. 22:08two are kind of sitting out there. It's
  597. 22:11going to it may happen at one point. So
  598. 22:13certainly risk has to be managed. But
  599. 22:16George, how important do you think it is
  600. 22:18to that your trading system or strategy
  601. 22:22needs to be congruent with who you are
  602. 22:24like your personality? Uh because again,
  603. 22:27there were a lot of different traders in
  604. 22:29the book. In fact, I interviewed your
  605. 22:31oldest um next generation market. He's
  606. 22:35not going to like I said that. Uh I
  607. 22:37think he's only 40. You're only 40,
  608. 22:39Jason. Uh but what he would say too, I
  609. 22:42mean he was Mr. Consistent in the book,
  610. 22:44right? Mr. Consistency and then you had
  611. 22:46those that were shorting the small caps,
  612. 22:48you know, as well. So there's so many
  613. 22:50different paths. There's no singular
  614. 22:52path. But how important is it, George,
  615. 22:54that it remain consistent with your
  616. 22:57personality?
  617. 22:58>> Well, I think it's very important, but I
  618. 23:00I think there's shades of gray, right?
  619. 23:02inherently as people with with very few
  620. 23:05exceptions, we want to
  621. 23:07>> buy something cheap and sell it dear,
  622. 23:09right? I I think most people including
  623. 23:11myself come to the markets and say,
  624. 23:13"Well, that stock's too expensive. I'll
  625. 23:15wait till it gets cheaper. That stock's
  626. 23:17too pricey. I'll short it because it's
  627. 23:19going to go down." And that tends to be
  628. 23:21wrong. So, I think it was Bill Eckard in
  629. 23:24New Market Wizards who said something to
  630. 23:26the effect of
  631. 23:28average human tendencies are not good
  632. 23:30for trading. Um, and I think that's
  633. 23:32true. So, in some sense, I think what
  634. 23:34would make any of us comfortable would
  635. 23:36not lead to profits potentially long
  636. 23:38term. Now, that said, I think within
  637. 23:41that, there are a lot of, as you said,
  638. 23:44uh, Kevin, ways to succeed and ways to
  639. 23:48peel the onion, and I think you need to
  640. 23:50find what works for you in terms of
  641. 23:52personality,
  642. 23:54um, within that. And so, for example,
  643. 23:56some guys like to day trade. they can't
  644. 23:59stand holding positions and allowing
  645. 24:01unrealized losses or or big changes in
  646. 24:04equity. Other guys think day trading
  647. 24:06sounds absolutely miserable. Uh we
  648. 24:08interviewed one guy uh for actually a
  649. 24:11book that's going to be coming up, but
  650. 24:13he more or less said that nobody could
  651. 24:15pay him enough money in the world to
  652. 24:17spend his life in front of a screen. So
  653. 24:19you've got sort of diametrically opposed
  654. 24:22views on that. And I think that people
  655. 24:24need to find within the reality that
  656. 24:26what they're doing is probably not going
  657. 24:28to be comfortable. They need to find
  658. 24:29relative comfort within the discomfort.
  659. 24:31Otherwise, it just won't work.
  660. 24:34>> Yeah. I believe Michael Marcus even said
  661. 24:37that you if you try to combine two
  662. 24:40traders, even if they're highly
  663. 24:41successful, but you try to combine two,
  664. 24:44you're going to get the worst of both of
  665. 24:46them. Well, I wonder why do why do you
  666. 24:48think that is, Jack?
  667. 24:49>> Yeah. Um because everybody has their own
  668. 24:54psychological makeup and what they're
  669. 24:56comfortable and beliefs and what they're
  670. 24:58comfortable with. So I mean if I think
  671. 25:00back to that first book you have uh you
  672. 25:03have uh Jim Rogers I ask him about uh uh
  673. 25:06whether he ever looks at charts because
  674. 25:08he's such a pure fundamentalist. He says
  675. 25:11well if you mean like to look at the
  676. 25:13history of where it's been. Yeah. But do
  677. 25:16I believe in any of this head and
  678. 25:18shoulders mumbo jumbo whatever you know
  679. 25:20term he used I forget the exact phrase
  680. 25:22it's all a bunch of nonsense and says
  681. 25:25then he says the only uh I never met a
  682. 25:28rich technician except those that sell
  683. 25:31their services. So that's his cynical
  684. 25:33view of tech of of technical analysis.
  685. 25:35Then you get somebody like Marty Schwarz
  686. 25:37who who was on the fundamental side for
  687. 25:40over a decade, lost money in his
  688. 25:42trading, I think he said every year,
  689. 25:45turned to chart analysis and became
  690. 25:47spectacularly successful. Um, and so,
  691. 25:51uh, you know, and he he talks about
  692. 25:53people, not that I mentioned my
  693. 25:54interview with Rogers, but he talks
  694. 25:56about that. Yeah, I think somewhere in
  695. 25:58the interview he says something like,
  696. 26:00uh, uh, you know, people who criticize
  697. 26:03chart analysis and what, you know, what
  698. 26:05what a stupid attitude. I mean, I grew
  699. 26:06rich as a technician. So, you've got,
  700. 26:09you couldn't be more different. So,
  701. 26:10they're core beliefs. Jim Rogers if he
  702. 26:13if he went to explore Charles and he
  703. 26:15could never be successful because he's
  704. 26:16such built-in cynical attitude towards
  705. 26:19it and and Schwarz just whatever it is
  706. 26:23about it fundamental analysis didn't
  707. 26:25work for him but but technical analysis
  708. 26:29>> you everybody has their own kind of
  709. 26:31thing and also in terms of risk you've
  710. 26:33got in this upcoming book uh you've got
  711. 26:35one fellow well like one who one of the
  712. 26:38guys who never had a losing month or at
  713. 26:40least not back. Well, we could we could
  714. 26:43verify 11 years and before that he was
  715. 26:45with a prop firm, not a prop firm, a
  716. 26:47family office. He still hadn't didn't
  717. 26:49have losing months, but we couldn't
  718. 26:50verify that. But any case, just every
  719. 26:52month he makes money. Uh, but he his
  720. 26:55really he is so riskaverse. I mean,
  721. 26:58forget about having a losing month,
  722. 27:00which he never had. I mean, for him a
  723. 27:02losing day is a really, you know,
  724. 27:05hopefully rarish event. So, um, you have
  725. 27:08that attitude. Then you have people who
  726. 27:11a couple of people in the book who kind
  727. 27:14of went from a accounts relatively small
  728. 27:17accounts to uh two of them got up to
  729. 27:20like literally a half a billion dollars
  730. 27:21approximately. Uh and they didn't do
  731. 27:23that by by keeping the risk down to a
  732. 27:26fraction of 1% per day, you know. So
  733. 27:29they had a much bigger risk appetite
  734. 27:31which uh led to some significant draw
  735. 27:34downs along the way. But it also made it
  736. 27:37possible for them to get to the
  737. 27:38spectacular uh uh amount of money they
  738. 27:41made. So again, you have to have the
  739. 27:44right attitude about risk to do it that
  740. 27:47way. And and the one who the trader who
  741. 27:50never had a losing month, he would not
  742. 27:52be he couldn't trade that way. He asked
  743. 27:54the guy to keep it super and he he
  744. 27:56doesn't hold positions. He does not hold
  745. 27:58positions overnight either. So again,
  746. 28:01different personalities, different
  747. 28:02psycholog psychologies, different
  748. 28:04talents, different interests, different
  749. 28:06beliefs, etc., etc., etc. So, which
  750. 28:09means that you you to be successful,
  751. 28:12you've got to find the approach that
  752. 28:13works for you.
  753. 28:14>> Yeah, it may like what I'm hearing is
  754. 28:16maybe you don't necessarily have to
  755. 28:17look, you need to look within, you know,
  756. 28:19you need to look within because a lot
  757. 28:21start out and they want to look
  758. 28:22outwardly or try to emulate somebody
  759. 28:24else. But a couple things I want to
  760. 28:25touch on there. George, you had written
  761. 28:27this in in the book as well. You said
  762. 28:29there's two types of profitable traders
  763. 28:32and Jack was discussing this as far as
  764. 28:34you have those who there was a lot of
  765. 28:36volatility on the equity curve but then
  766. 28:38you had Mr. Consistency who's just not
  767. 28:41not very large draw downs at all. You
  768. 28:43said there's two types of traders. Those
  769. 28:45who generate
  770. 28:47exceptional returns and those who excel
  771. 28:49at capital preservation. I was I'm
  772. 28:52curious with that. Do you think there's
  773. 28:54a way to balance both of those into a
  774. 28:57trader or you're one or the other?
  775. 28:59>> Um, you know, that was in my preface and
  776. 29:02I don't know that the capital
  777. 29:04preservation types were really what we
  778. 29:05were thinking about with the wizards.
  779. 29:07Just to be clear, I was more speaking
  780. 29:09about myself. I'm better at protecting
  781. 29:12money as opposed to making tons of it.
  782. 29:14Uh, can you balance somebody who makes
  783. 29:18money? It's funny. I listen to the uh
  784. 29:20the reminiscences of a stock operator.
  785. 29:22uh audio book on my morning walks and
  786. 29:25there's a line and I don't remember the
  787. 29:27specifics, the names wouldn't matter
  788. 29:29because these guys are a hundred years
  789. 29:30dead if they were ever real. But uh the
  790. 29:33main character who's essentially
  791. 29:35Livermore is saying some people have the
  792. 29:38money-making instinct and they often
  793. 29:40have big swings. Other people have the
  794. 29:42hoarding instinct and sometimes you'll
  795. 29:44get people with both and they die
  796. 29:46disgustingly rich. So, uh I think
  797. 29:49they're out there. I think it's just
  798. 29:51rare because for the most part I think
  799. 29:54what it takes to have gigantic compound
  800. 29:58annual growth rate returns that are also
  801. 30:00scalable requires you to take big ups
  802. 30:03and downs and that's sort of the
  803. 30:05antithesis of let's protect capital that
  804. 30:08we got to see these guys returns. They
  805. 30:10send us their material to verify and
  806. 30:12some of the guys that had the best sort
  807. 30:14of results. So their monthly percentage
  808. 30:17returns are just they're wild. you look
  809. 30:19at them and you think, how did they have
  810. 30:20the fortitude to to wake up and trade
  811. 30:23the next month because it was a down 30
  812. 30:25or 50% month. Um, so anyway, to your
  813. 30:27question, I'm sure some exist, but I
  814. 30:30think it's tough. People tend to usually
  815. 30:32either be in a make tons of money and
  816. 30:35experience lots of volatility better at
  817. 30:38protecting.
  818. 30:40Just to be clear, there's shades of
  819. 30:42gray. So, if you think of Jason Barry,
  820. 30:44who you interviewed, he has almost no
  821. 30:46down lines at all. So that's
  822. 30:48exceptional. And and Rick Bandazian is
  823. 30:50the other one. Yeah.
  824. 30:52>> We really never have down months. These
  825. 30:53guys are like cash registers. It's like
  826. 30:55having a WT.
  827. 30:56>> I know. It's it's incredible. But then
  828. 30:58you'll have those that take $5,000 and
  829. 31:01turn it into what a hundred million. I
  830. 31:03mean, high volatility. Um
  831. 31:07>> Kevin, I would say there were I think in
  832. 31:09in this last book as well as in the
  833. 31:12previous market wizard books, there are
  834. 31:13people who kind of blended. uh they do
  835. 31:17they do very well. I'll give one example
  836. 31:19of his current book uh Lance Brightstein
  837. 31:23um I mean well he was a prop firm
  838. 31:25originally trading started out with
  839. 31:26small amounts but then went on to trade
  840. 31:29left at after 10 years and traded his
  841. 31:32own account but ultimately ended up like
  842. 31:34at 100 million and along the way I don't
  843. 31:36believe he had any large draw downs. He
  844. 31:38certainly wasn't making money every
  845. 31:40month uh uh like some of the a couple of
  846. 31:43the other guys, but he made a ton more
  847. 31:45money. So, uh I think there are people
  848. 31:48who kind of blended blended the two.
  849. 31:50They they didn't make really good sums
  850. 31:52of money and still had reasonable draw
  851. 31:55downs.
  852. 31:55>> Or do you think even too as they get
  853. 31:57older? Is it Ed Dakota um that says
  854. 32:01there are those who are bold and those
  855. 32:03who are old, but you're you can't blend
  856. 32:06the old and bold together?
  857. 32:08Is that the one?
  858. 32:10>> That's a typical Dakota line, man.
  859. 32:12>> Yeah. Yeah. So, with u today's the the
  860. 32:15young traders you guys have have
  861. 32:16interviewed,
  862. 32:18do you think that there's a certain edge
  863. 32:21that may exist in today's I guess the
  864. 32:23landscape of today that I mean certainly
  865. 32:25didn't exist back with the original
  866. 32:27market wizards where with technology and
  867. 32:30access maybe the speed. Do you think can
  868. 32:32you identify certain edges?
  869. 32:34>> You know, I I don't know if the edges
  870. 32:35have changed. I mean, they're always
  871. 32:37different. Um, I I think of a couple of
  872. 32:40traders in this book who, let's say,
  873. 32:42made good use of uh 13D reports, you
  874. 32:45know, really really getting into the
  875. 32:48thick thick of it and and finding
  876. 32:50situations where they had information,
  877. 32:53not information that is available to the
  878. 32:55public. It's just the public doesn't dig
  879. 32:59into it like they did. And uh so
  880. 33:03I but that existed all along. It's just
  881. 33:06you know in this case some of these
  882. 33:08traders that's type of information that
  883. 33:10was instrumental in making their initial
  884. 33:13millions. So uh I wouldn't say it's so
  885. 33:16much a result of technology. Uh I mean
  886. 33:19the technology comes in of course
  887. 33:20naturally uh you're going to review a
  888. 33:23thousand charts or something like that.
  889. 33:25It wouldn't have been practical uh when
  890. 33:27you had to chart them by paper or
  891. 33:29something like that. So that's that's a
  892. 33:32consequence of just technology, but it's
  893. 33:34nothing unique really. It's uh I think
  894. 33:37that would have been true for for 20
  895. 33:39years now.
  896. 33:40>> And George, do you think with the the
  897. 33:42three principles you've laid out, do you
  898. 33:44think they apply in a like a AIdriven
  899. 33:47world? Do you think they apply
  900. 33:49universally?
  901. 33:49>> I do. I mean, there's exceptions. Chris
  902. 33:52Camilillo from Unknown Market Wizards
  903. 33:54didn't use
  904. 33:56really cut his losses. Although I read
  905. 33:58his book and he bought options. So in
  906. 34:00theory, he's limiting his risk in some
  907. 34:02capacity. But I think it's uh the
  908. 34:05principles are more the rule than the
  909. 34:06exception. And one thing I found from
  910. 34:09from studying all of the traders and
  911. 34:11doing these interviews is there are
  912. 34:13always going to be exceptions. There's
  913. 34:15always going to be almost every rule.
  914. 34:17But I I think for me personally and for
  915. 34:20the masses, we would probably be better
  916. 34:22served to find out what's more common
  917. 34:24and more prevalent and go with that
  918. 34:27because the exceptions are the
  919. 34:29exceptions, right? Um so yeah.
  920. 34:31>> Did did you think that when going
  921. 34:35through all the the wizards over the
  922. 34:36years, Jack, do do you think there's
  923. 34:40that traders have to experience
  924. 34:43losses, draw downs? Even in this book
  925. 34:45there were some level of uh you know
  926. 34:48blowups of early accounts. Can can a
  927. 34:51trader start their journey and just kind
  928. 34:54of smooth sail or do they need do they
  929. 34:56have to learn those three principles
  930. 34:58George points out to respect the trend
  931. 35:01to cut your losses? Let your winners
  932. 35:02run. Is that something that's learned or
  933. 35:04is it more like innate? Well, it's well,
  934. 35:07first of all, some the there the number
  935. 35:11of these market wizards who obviously by
  936. 35:14there being in a book have performed
  937. 35:17spectacularly well. Um the number of
  938. 35:19them that experienced early failures in
  939. 35:22in many cases multi complete failure,
  940. 35:25complete blowouts and in some cases
  941. 35:27multiple complete blowouts is is much
  942. 35:30higher than one would think. So uh that
  943. 35:34that is true. Uh however not all not all
  944. 35:39of them had that experience. I think um
  945. 35:42there there are number of ones who were
  946. 35:45successful kind of out the bat never had
  947. 35:47a really um really really like I think
  948. 35:50Michael Platt of Blueest is a good
  949. 35:52example of that. I think he was just
  950. 35:54successful from the beginning and just
  951. 35:56never had that experience. But that's
  952. 35:58the exception. I mean there for the most
  953. 36:00part most of them did experience some
  954. 36:03some episode early on that was uh that
  955. 36:06was a if not a wipeout completely a draw
  956. 36:10down that took them to the edge. Uh for
  957. 36:12example, Paul Tudtor Jones never
  958. 36:14literally completely wiped out, but as I
  959. 36:17tell the story in in uh market the
  960. 36:20original market wizards, uh he had one
  961. 36:23trade uh where he literally after doing
  962. 36:27quite well literally lost twothirds of
  963. 36:30his assets on one trade in a few days.
  964. 36:33Uh and he did come to the brink of
  965. 36:35quitting. Um he just they it could have
  966. 36:38gone either way. there might not have
  967. 36:40been a ball to the Jones of that we
  968. 36:42know. Uh so [clears throat] so it was a
  969. 36:45very close call. So even if they didn't
  970. 36:48blow out completely, most of them did
  971. 36:50experience some traumatic trade early on
  972. 36:53or along the way. There are a few
  973. 36:55exceptions.
  974. 36:57>> Can I chime in on that for a sec? Um
  975. 37:00>> Phil Geter, if I pronounced his name
  976. 37:02right. To me personally, it's probably
  977. 37:04one of the closest things I've ever seen
  978. 37:06to a natural-born trader, if there is
  979. 37:08such a thing. And there's just something
  980. 37:11in his mindset. He w he still wiped out
  981. 37:13twice. So, so let's keep that in mind
  982. 37:15before he went on to to huge success.
  983. 37:18But his mindset was just this isn't
  984. 37:21working. I should stop. And you for me
  985. 37:24as a trader, not that I'm a market
  986. 37:25wizard, I'm not, but it took years to
  987. 37:28get to that level. And I think for a lot
  988. 37:30of people it takes months or or years if
  989. 37:32they ever do it. So the fact that he got
  990. 37:34there very quickly I just found
  991. 37:37interesting and I think it was just
  992. 37:38inherently the way his mind thinks about
  993. 37:40things that sort of differed from most
  994. 37:43other people. So but even the guys that
  995. 37:46I believe are sort of born with a a
  996. 37:48temperament that's suited to the
  997. 37:49principles still lose money early on for
  998. 37:53whatever that's worth.
  999. 37:55>> Yeah. So with with the next generation
  1000. 37:57here, is was there any interview in
  1001. 37:59there that that you think challenged
  1002. 38:01your own kind of beliefs or maybe
  1003. 38:04thoughts at all?
  1004. 38:07>> Yeah, I mean the idea of the idea of
  1005. 38:10shorting smaller cap stocks as a way to
  1006. 38:12get success would certainly not have
  1007. 38:14been on my list of on my top 100 list of
  1008. 38:18ways to [laughter]
  1009. 38:20market.
  1010. 38:22>> And you George.
  1011. 38:23>> Yeah, I would agree. I I talk about the
  1012. 38:25the trading literature or scripture
  1013. 38:27since I read so much about trading. And
  1014. 38:30if somebody came and said, "Hey, I got
  1015. 38:32this great idea on how to make money.
  1016. 38:33We're going to short small caps for day
  1017. 38:36trades and we're going to make a
  1018. 38:38fortune." I just said, "Hey, you read it
  1019. 38:40wrong. You're not supposed to do that."
  1020. 38:42So the fact that not one but multiple of
  1021. 38:46them made a lot of money doing that was
  1022. 38:48very surprising and kind of taught me
  1023. 38:50that there's there was another guy too
  1024. 38:53um who made a bunch of money in
  1025. 38:55agriculture and I had never really seen
  1026. 38:56anybody make a lot of money in
  1027. 38:58agriculture
  1028. 38:59>> and so those two things in particular it
  1029. 39:02was like these are things that I thought
  1030. 39:04maybe weren't impossible but close and
  1031. 39:06yet here they are succeeding at it. So
  1032. 39:08the the exercise of writing the book and
  1033. 39:10doing the interviews was certainly eye
  1034. 39:11opening and taught me that there's
  1035. 39:14probably somebody out there doing
  1036. 39:15something that you don't think is po
  1037. 39:17possible and they're doing it very well.
  1038. 39:20>> Yeah. Go
  1039. 39:22>> mentioned the trader. This is
  1040. 39:23interesting. The trader he's talking
  1041. 39:25about the A. Uh this is one of the two
  1042. 39:28guys who got to around a half a billion
  1043. 39:30and uh he literally made his early for
  1044. 39:33you know early years first four five six
  1045. 39:35years uh trading not not only a futures
  1046. 39:39but a future spreads so you know if you
  1047. 39:43told me somebody's going to start out
  1048. 39:45with with a you know uh well he he had
  1049. 39:49save I think he did in this case he did
  1050. 39:51save up $7 million that he made while he
  1051. 39:54was trading for a prop firm. So, but if
  1052. 39:57you could tell me that somebody was
  1053. 39:58going to parlay that into a half billion
  1054. 40:01uh and trading agricultural future
  1055. 40:04spreads uh predominantly until the later
  1056. 40:07years, I would have not thought that
  1057. 40:10made would be possible.
  1058. 40:11>> Yeah, that's that's incredible. U so
  1059. 40:14with this the next generation here, what
  1060. 40:16what was the criteria, if you will? Uh
  1061. 40:20did did they need to be under 40? What
  1062. 40:23what was the criteria when it's like
  1063. 40:24who's who's going to be in the the next
  1064. 40:26generation?
  1065. 40:27>> Yeah. Age wasn't a criteria. Uh it was a
  1066. 40:30preference. Uh
  1067. 40:31>> yeah. Yeah.
  1068. 40:32>> We came across somebody who was
  1069. 40:33absolutely perfect but didn't fit the
  1070. 40:34age. So I I think the oldest guy turned
  1071. 40:3850 uh after we we did the interview. So
  1072. 40:42uh if you were going strictly by keeping
  1073. 40:44people in their 30s and 40s um it would
  1074. 40:48not have been possible. Then of course
  1075. 40:49since we're looking for people with
  1076. 40:51track records of at least 10 years,
  1077. 40:53there's a limit to how young they can
  1078. 40:54be. Although I think at least one trader
  1079. 40:57was in the 20s though. Uh so um so age
  1080. 41:01wasn't the criteria. It like it it was
  1081. 41:03no different than all the other market
  1082. 41:04wizard books. There are two ways
  1083. 41:06somebody gets chosen. One they take a
  1084. 41:10relatively moderate amount of money and
  1085. 41:12turn into a large fortune. That's always
  1086. 41:14a good story.
  1087. 41:15>> And two is they have phenomenal return
  1088. 41:17risk. So yeah, the two people in the
  1089. 41:19book who have this, you know, almost
  1090. 41:22even no losing months or almost no
  1091. 41:24losing months, their returns are not in
  1092. 41:27terms of dollars are not spectacular by
  1093. 41:29any means, but the fact that they just
  1094. 41:32turn the markets into a money machine
  1095. 41:34that they live off of, that's the story.
  1096. 41:36So it's one of those.
  1097. 41:38>> Wow, that's incredible. And George, your
  1098. 41:40thoughts on that?
  1099. 41:41>> We didn't set out to write this book. So
  1100. 41:44it's
  1101. 41:45>> they just kind of came to you. Is that
  1102. 41:46what you say? they just kind of came to
  1103. 41:48you.
  1104. 41:48>> Well, you know, um, so we, and this is
  1105. 41:51in the preface, people can pre-order now
  1106. 41:54and get the first two prefaces in the
  1107. 41:55first chapter, but we're going to write
  1108. 41:57a second book that's going to come out
  1109. 41:59in about a year and a half, two years,
  1110. 42:01something like that. And when we
  1111. 42:03originally started doing interviews, we
  1112. 42:05were focused on hedge fund guys as well.
  1113. 42:08So, we um ultimately decided that we
  1114. 42:10were going to do this book on
  1115. 42:12independent traders, most of whom wound
  1116. 42:13up being younger. And then the second
  1117. 42:16book is going to be hedge fund guys. But
  1118. 42:18essentially because of that it's not
  1119. 42:20like we said hey let's set out and let's
  1120. 42:22find traders who are under 50 who have
  1121. 42:25achieved great things.
  1122. 42:27>> So it just sort of worked out when
  1123. 42:28sifting through the big volume of
  1124. 42:30different people that we were looking
  1125. 42:31at. And as I said earlier the original
  1126. 42:34idea wasn't even to write a wizards
  1127. 42:35book. It was early struggle. So it it it
  1128. 42:39kind of evolved. One thing Jack told me
  1129. 42:40is that the wizards books are sort of
  1130. 42:43Jack, correct me if I'm paraphrasing
  1131. 42:44this wrong, but they're like a dragon
  1132. 42:46and you're riding the dragon and you're
  1133. 42:47kind of steering it, but it's kind of
  1134. 42:49going where it goes. If you want to
  1135. 42:51speak to that, Jack, but it's uh
  1136. 42:53>> Yeah, I mean, basically, that's right.
  1137. 42:56>> So, so yeah, it kind of evolves and it
  1138. 42:58becomes what it becomes throughout the
  1139. 43:00process. So, we didn't set out and say
  1140. 43:02we're looking to capture traders that
  1141. 43:05are plus or minus 25 to 30 and and
  1142. 43:07that's it. It just went that way over
  1143. 43:10time.
  1144. 43:10>> Got it. Got it. What What do you think
  1145. 43:12that the the young people in this book
  1146. 43:15have that impresses you or maybe they do
  1147. 43:19really well at that some of maybe some
  1148. 43:21older market wizards don't don't do
  1149. 43:23well? I mean, is there something that
  1150. 43:25you can see with the younger generation
  1151. 43:27where they really succeed?
  1152. 43:29>> I think it's still the same things as my
  1153. 43:31books. take uh quite a majority of them
  1154. 43:35are super hard workers. Uh
  1155. 43:37>> the fault of in my mind not the way I
  1156. 43:39want to live want to live my life. uh uh
  1157. 43:43the the fellow of no losing months uh
  1158. 43:46gets up at like 4:30 a.m. to check the
  1159. 43:49the pre-market situation and uh his last
  1160. 43:53look at the markets is around 8:00 p.m.
  1161. 43:55Yeah, he takes a couple of breaks during
  1162. 43:56the day, but that's you know that's
  1163. 43:59that's your life in front of the screen.
  1164. 44:02So uh that's an example of hard work but
  1165. 44:04it's by no means the only one that uh
  1166. 44:07that I mean you read this book and you
  1167. 44:10will see that a number of these traders
  1168. 44:13just
  1169. 44:14lived uh market analysis and trading. I
  1170. 44:18mean their life was that was their life.
  1171. 44:20They just they just were constantly
  1172. 44:22researching and uh constantly working
  1173. 44:25and including weekends including
  1174. 44:27holidays. uh um and they would come in
  1175. 44:31they would if they they worked at a prop
  1176. 44:32shop they would even come in on weekends
  1177. 44:35uh to sort of go over their trades and
  1178. 44:37so there was no there was very little
  1179. 44:40free time and sometimes no vacations and
  1180. 44:43so this this this hard work ethic was
  1181. 44:45very prominent in this book but it's
  1182. 44:47been there from the very first book as
  1183. 44:49well. So, do you think there needs to be
  1184. 44:51a level of of passion? That's a common
  1185. 44:53theme I've heard in a lot of the
  1186. 44:54interviews. Like a lot of these guys who
  1187. 44:57succeed in this industry, they have
  1188. 45:00passion. Um,
  1189. 45:02>> this has to be this has to be something
  1190. 45:04you really enjoy and and you get that
  1191. 45:06you get that message from these people.
  1192. 45:09It's not that, you know, they're they're
  1193. 45:12doing all this work and it's trudger,
  1194. 45:14you know, it's drudgery. Even if it's
  1195. 45:16going through, you know, 13D reports,
  1196. 45:18which would not be most people's idea of
  1197. 45:20a fun time, but for them it's like a
  1198. 45:22treasure hunt on finding the pieces of
  1199. 45:24information. And so, yeah, to to have
  1200. 45:27that type of devotion, to be willing to
  1201. 45:29commit that much energy and time and a
  1202. 45:32large chunk of your life to this, you
  1203. 45:35have to actually love the the actual
  1204. 45:38endeavor. It's not about the money. I
  1205. 45:40mean they may in in some cases people
  1206. 45:42are motivated to to get into markets
  1207. 45:45because it seems like a path to possible
  1208. 45:48fortunes but but to succeed and what
  1209. 45:52ultimately happens in the process is
  1210. 45:54they find they love this thing and they
  1211. 45:56just it's like their work is their
  1212. 45:58hobby. It has to be that type of
  1213. 46:00attitude. If you're only in it if if
  1214. 46:03doing all that research is work uh
  1215. 46:06you're not going to be you're not going
  1216. 46:07to succeed spectacularly. And that's
  1217. 46:09your experience too, George, right? I
  1218. 46:10mean, your hobby is is your work, vice
  1219. 46:14versa. And was that your experience with
  1220. 46:16um the market wizards as well?
  1221. 46:18>> Yeah.
  1222. 46:19>> Yeah.
  1223. 46:19>> Jack made me think of a Ed Sakakota
  1224. 46:21quote, which I think came from the first
  1225. 46:23book, but it's uh great traders don't
  1226. 46:26have the talent, the talent has them,
  1227. 46:28which I think is pretty accurate. And
  1228. 46:30this is this is I think what these guys
  1229. 46:33while they're trading some of them are
  1230. 46:35walking away from it but um while
  1231. 46:36they're trading it's really what they're
  1232. 46:38living for. And it's you know people say
  1233. 46:42like god country core I think trading
  1234. 46:44would be very high up on their hierarchy
  1235. 46:48of priorities in life if you were to ask
  1236. 46:50them.
  1237. 46:51>> Wow. Yeah. So what's a what do you think
  1238. 46:54there's there's a critical quality
  1239. 46:56amongst the market wizards. What what is
  1240. 46:58it that one quality that you think of
  1241. 47:00off the top of your head stands out to
  1242. 47:02you, Jack? What's that quality that they
  1243. 47:03possess?
  1244. 47:05>> There are a few exceptions, very few. Uh
  1245. 47:08but if you had to name the single most
  1246. 47:11important unifying theme, it would be
  1247. 47:14risk management. So not the methodology,
  1248. 47:17not the trading, not the research, but
  1249. 47:20risk management. I I would say if you
  1250. 47:23asked every person I've interviewed what
  1251. 47:25is the most important thing about
  1252. 47:26trading, I would put money on the single
  1253. 47:30answer that would turn up the most would
  1254. 47:31be risk management.
  1255. 47:32>> Okay. I want to follow up on that, but
  1256. 47:34George, go ahead.
  1257. 47:35>> I thought you were asking more about
  1258. 47:36their personality traits as opposed to
  1259. 47:39trading methods. So maybe I
  1260. 47:40misunderstood your question.
  1261. 47:42>> Yeah, go either direction. Give us one
  1262. 47:44of each. I think if you're thinking of
  1263. 47:46personality traits, I have a list that
  1264. 47:49uh is in the book and I have it here,
  1265. 47:51but I don't think it's um one thing. It
  1266. 47:55reminds me of another Sakola quote. I'm
  1267. 47:56like a parrot of Sakakota, but a lot of
  1268. 47:58what he says is is true. But somebody
  1269. 48:00said, "What's the most important part of
  1270. 48:02a trading system?" And he said, "I don't
  1271. 48:04view a single part as the most important
  1272. 48:06just as what's more important, your
  1273. 48:08liver, your heart, or your spleen." I
  1274. 48:10mean, uh, so I think they all function
  1275. 48:12together, but these guys and and prior
  1276. 48:16wizards have a lot of sort of common
  1277. 48:18personality traits, and I could go
  1278. 48:20through them if you'd like or you tell
  1279. 48:22me.
  1280. 48:23>> Yeah, go for it. Well, I had that quote
  1281. 48:25here, too. It's fascinating. There's no
  1282. 48:27best car. There's no best spouse. It
  1283. 48:29depends on the individual. And, uh,
  1284. 48:31Sakakota also has right here about the
  1285. 48:34only one thing is for sure is that there
  1286. 48:36isn't a sure thing. I mean, he he was
  1287. 48:40brilliant. I mean, with the quotes and
  1288. 48:42um just absolutely
  1289. 48:44brilliant guy, but go for it, George.
  1290. 48:46Yeah, let's dive into that a little bit.
  1291. 48:47>> I guess the same way that the principles
  1292. 48:49are inherent to most wizards, there's
  1293. 48:52always exceptions, but they're
  1294. 48:54personality things, and they are one is
  1295. 48:56they're they're usually pretty
  1296. 48:58self-aware. They understand who they are
  1297. 49:00and what they want. Two is they have
  1298. 49:02clear goals. They're not confused about
  1299. 49:04what they're trying to achieve. Three is
  1300. 49:06they believe in themselves. Um, a lot of
  1301. 49:09times they believe in themselves when
  1302. 49:10there is no evidence to support that
  1303. 49:12belief whatsoever. Whether that's blown
  1304. 49:15up trading accounts or family members
  1305. 49:17telling them you're not good at this, go
  1306. 49:18do something else. Uh, four is that they
  1307. 49:21are pretty independent as people. You're
  1308. 49:23not going to probably find them working
  1309. 49:24a 9 to5 as a a cog in the machine. Um,
  1310. 49:28five, they're very passionate about
  1311. 49:29trading as we mentioned a minute or two
  1312. 49:31ago. Six, they're committed. they're
  1313. 49:33they're sticking with this through thick
  1314. 49:35or thin. So that leads to persistence.
  1315. 49:38They're all very persistent in achieving
  1316. 49:40their goals. Uh beyond that, they're
  1317. 49:43they're very willing to pursue their
  1318. 49:45dreams despite the fear of failure. So
  1319. 49:47they press on even if they're afraid
  1320. 49:49they might fail. And they really have an
  1321. 49:51ability to focus uh that you don't see
  1322. 49:55so much in everyday people. So I think
  1323. 49:58those as far as my research are the most
  1324. 50:01common personality traits of really
  1325. 50:05traders, market wizards or or other.
  1326. 50:07>> Jack, your thoughts?
  1327. 50:09>> Yeah, I mean I would also I mean there
  1328. 50:11there are quite a number of others but
  1329. 50:13one I think that is really critical and
  1330. 50:16I think it's true of just about uh all
  1331. 50:18market wizards is they have flexibility
  1332. 50:23uh in their thinking. uh they're not
  1333. 50:27tied to the idea. I mean, yes, they put
  1334. 50:31on a they I what is the u I'm trying to
  1335. 50:34think Peter Brent has a good way of
  1336. 50:36putting it. Um and um uh I I'm
  1337. 50:41forgetting the phrase exactly now, but
  1338. 50:43>> I think I remember it's
  1339. 50:45>> strong opinions weakly held.
  1340. 50:47>> Yeah, that's it. Strong opinions weakly
  1341. 50:49held. See, George knew it just from the
  1342. 50:52vague description I was giving. uh
  1343. 50:54that's exactly the the the the key to
  1344. 50:56it. So uh they uh they have an idea,
  1345. 51:01they really believe in it, they put on a
  1346. 51:03trade, but if the market action or news
  1347. 51:06or whatever dictates that the idea is
  1348. 51:09wrong, uh they're quite quite able to to
  1349. 51:14abandon it. Uh they don't continue to
  1350. 51:16hope. uh they're they have this uh
  1351. 51:20incredible flexibility to to change
  1352. 51:23including going the other way. So you'll
  1353. 51:26find a number of stories in the market
  1354. 51:27wizard books where where a trader
  1355. 51:30thought one way and then comes up
  1356. 51:32repeatedly and then ends up going
  1357. 51:35realizing they're wrong and doing the
  1358. 51:37exact opposite and that being one of the
  1359. 51:39best trades they've ever had. They wow.
  1360. 51:41>> So that becomes that's a common that's a
  1361. 51:43common occurrence. So this is very very
  1362. 51:46important and that's why a lot of people
  1363. 51:47just by their psych [snorts]
  1364. 51:50psychological makeup would make uh would
  1365. 51:53not would not make good traders. Uh so
  1366. 51:56because they're not willing to admit
  1367. 51:58they're wrong when they're wrong.
  1368. 52:00>> So remaining unbiased, you know,
  1369. 52:02objective. That's what I wanted to touch
  1370. 52:04on with you, Jack. This you said strong
  1371. 52:07opinion, weakly held. And you were
  1372. 52:09speaking on fundamentals earlier and I I
  1373. 52:13had heard you in another interview. It
  1374. 52:14really resonated me when you said this
  1375. 52:16you because you had started out of
  1376. 52:18course when you your journey with you
  1377. 52:20you started out more fundamental because
  1378. 52:22that was your background at that time
  1379. 52:23but then you said you kind of went like
  1380. 52:25you started to lean towards technicals
  1381. 52:27and the reason for that which I want you
  1382. 52:29to dive into is like you think about
  1383. 52:33like a company you're saying you have a
  1384. 52:35strong opinion or a company has great
  1385. 52:36intrinsic value and it to you almost to
  1386. 52:40the trader it feels like well I'm
  1387. 52:42getting a better bargain price so you
  1388. 52:44can just constantly add add uh as the as
  1389. 52:48the value you know drops because in your
  1390. 52:50mind well this is going to gravitate
  1391. 52:52towards that intrinsic value over time
  1392. 52:54and be worth more. What are your I want
  1393. 52:56to hear your story and your thoughts on
  1394. 52:57that fundamentals, risk management tied
  1395. 52:59to technicals versus
  1396. 53:01>> Exactly. That's exactly and I think it's
  1397. 53:03a very important point and it's not I
  1398. 53:05want to preface it here by saying that
  1399. 53:07I'm not knocking fundamentals. I'm just
  1400. 53:09stating what I think are is the reality
  1401. 53:12of the structure of the markets. Uh and
  1402. 53:14there are plenty of people I've
  1403. 53:15interviewed who used only fundamentals
  1404. 53:17were very successful. However,
  1405. 53:19fundamental analysis by its very nature
  1406. 53:22is almost difficult to um to risk
  1407. 53:26management. So, as you kind of alluded
  1408. 53:28because you talked about it. So, you
  1409. 53:30have a company, let's say a company's
  1410. 53:32trading at $50 and and you're you go
  1411. 53:36through for fundamentals and this
  1412. 53:39company should be worth $80, right? So,
  1413. 53:42you go long at 50 looking for it to go
  1414. 53:44at 80, let's say. Okay. Uh then it goes
  1415. 53:46down to 45 for 40. Uh nothing has
  1416. 53:50changed fundamentally, but it's down to
  1417. 53:5240. So hey, if [clears throat] it was a
  1418. 53:54good price, if the fundamentals said it
  1419. 53:57was worth 80, now you know when it's 40
  1420. 54:01instead of 50, it's an even better
  1421. 54:03upside potential. So the the irony is
  1422. 54:07with pure fundamental analysis if
  1423. 54:09nothing fundamentally changes the more
  1424. 54:11the market goes against you the more you
  1425. 54:14should want to put on which is exact
  1426. 54:15opposite of risk management. Whereas
  1427. 54:19most if not almost all technical
  1428. 54:21analysis if the market goes against you
  1429. 54:24it sort of automatically negates the
  1430. 54:27reason for being in the trade. If take a
  1431. 54:29very simple example, if you're a trend
  1432. 54:30follower and you know market breaks out
  1433. 54:33on the upside and you go long or the
  1434. 54:36market has a crossover or whatever and
  1435. 54:38you go long then if it goes against you
  1436. 54:42that crossover goes the other way the
  1437. 54:44breakout turns out to be a false
  1438. 54:46breakout. The the the methodology itself
  1439. 54:49argues that you're wrong but fundamental
  1440. 54:52analysis exactly opposite. So there's a
  1441. 54:54built-in difficulty with that. And so
  1442. 54:56from my own experience I found that
  1443. 54:58because of that it was very difficult
  1444. 55:01for me to use fundamental analysis
  1445. 55:02because I had no way of telling you you
  1446. 55:05know when to get out and when I started
  1447. 55:08using chart analysis uh and this is a
  1448. 55:11this is kind of I remember people ask me
  1449. 55:14sometimes what was your best trade
  1450. 55:17and it's never it's not a trade and I
  1451. 55:19think back my best trade I remember back
  1452. 55:21a trade way back when I just early and
  1453. 55:25then you know just started trading very
  1454. 55:26small amounts of money but when I
  1455. 55:29started this was when I switched over to
  1456. 55:30chart analysis and I remember it was the
  1457. 55:33back then it was the D mark it wasn't
  1458. 55:35the euro and uh the euro didn't come on
  1459. 55:37for decades later um and uh the D mark
  1460. 55:41had sort of had a long slide had gone
  1461. 55:43into like a six-month base it looked
  1462. 55:46like a bottom and sort of I kind of
  1463. 55:48looked at that I said yeah you know kind
  1464. 55:50of this should be enough and it's been
  1465. 55:52building a base and I kind of anticip
  1466. 55:54ipated would break out on the upside. So
  1467. 55:56I went long and I put a stop in like you
  1468. 55:59know 15 20 ticks below the low of the
  1469. 56:02base and then one day the market went
  1470. 56:04down sharply hit my stop I was knocked
  1471. 56:06out and then the great thing was that
  1472. 56:09after that for the next few weeks it
  1473. 56:11just kept on going down and that is that
  1474. 56:14I always think back is kind of my best
  1475. 56:16trade because I I was dead wrong. I lost
  1476. 56:19only a small amount of money and if I
  1477. 56:21hadn't had you know the risk management
  1478. 56:23it would have been a large loss. So uh
  1479. 56:26that's like a personal example.
  1480. 56:28>> Ever watch a stock rip and think I could
  1481. 56:30have nailed that if I had real capital.
  1482. 56:33The truth is many capable traders never
  1483. 56:35reach their potential. Not due to lack
  1484. 56:37of skill but lack of scale. Trade the
  1485. 56:40pool was built to solve exactly that. A
  1486. 56:42firm designed for serious individuals
  1487. 56:44who want access to the US equity markets
  1488. 56:46with meaningful buying power up to
  1489. 56:49$200,000 without committing their own
  1490. 56:51capital. Get access to virtually every
  1491. 56:53stock and ETF. Go long or short freely
  1492. 56:56with the flexibility professional
  1493. 56:57traders expect. You're evaluated on one
  1494. 57:00thing, your ability to manage risk and
  1495. 57:02execute with consistency. Meet the
  1496. 57:04standard and you trade at scale. No
  1497. 57:07subscriptions, no ongoing commitments.
  1498. 57:09Whether you're still refining your
  1499. 57:10strategy, a trader with experience who
  1500. 57:12hasn't yet broken through, or a seasoned
  1501. 57:15professional simply looking for more
  1502. 57:17capital, trade the pool is built to meet
  1503. 57:19you where you are and take you that next
  1504. 57:22step further. The markets have evolved.
  1505. 57:24Access has evolved. Now, so has the way
  1506. 57:27traders operate within them. Trade the
  1507. 57:29pool. I love that because I mean, the
  1508. 57:31best trade you're thinking of is is that
  1509. 57:34that is the loser, not necessarily what
  1510. 57:36most would think is the winner. Um,
  1511. 57:38George, do you have a take on that? The
  1512. 57:40fundamentals versus technical risk
  1513. 57:42management applied.
  1514. 57:43>> Yeah, I mean, I don't want to repeat
  1515. 57:45what Jack just said, but I I agree
  1516. 57:47mostly with what he said. Actually,
  1517. 57:50Kelvin uh in the book, Kelvin Chu, he
  1518. 57:53says essentially the same. He says that
  1519. 57:56fundamentals can be helpful, but they
  1520. 57:58have no risk management. So, I think
  1521. 58:00that's the right take. you if you're a
  1522. 58:02fundamental guy and it drops logically
  1523. 58:06you should buy more if the reasons you
  1524. 58:07own it haven't changed so but what do
  1525. 58:10you do if it just keeps going down and I
  1526. 58:12guess people could limit their risk by
  1527. 58:13saying position sizing but that opens a
  1528. 58:16whole can of worms of sort of Wall
  1529. 58:18Street versus Lal Street how do you look
  1530. 58:20at risk how do you size positions and
  1531. 58:22probably more than we want to get into
  1532. 58:24today so I'll support what Jack said
  1533. 58:26>> do yeah I'd like to add sort of to be
  1534. 58:28fair here I was thinking the other side
  1535. 58:30while George was answering. So about on
  1536. 58:33the fundamentals like think of a pure
  1537. 58:35fundamental one of the pure
  1538. 58:36fundamentalist I I interviewed
  1539. 58:38predominantly pure fundamentalist Martin
  1540. 58:40Taylor who started out as an emerging um
  1541. 58:44market type of uh stock trader and
  1542. 58:47eventually uh branched out to also trade
  1543. 58:50uh uh trade uh regular larger cap
  1544. 58:54stocks. Um but so I I remember when I
  1545. 58:57interviewed him uh and he but just
  1546. 59:00enormously successful. He he built his
  1547. 59:03various funds into about seven eight
  1548. 59:05billion and decided to give the money
  1549. 59:06back because he didn't want to bother
  1550. 59:08investors and just kept a billion of his
  1551. 59:10own money and a few clients or friends
  1552. 59:13that he allowed in. Anyway, so at the
  1553. 59:15time I interviewed him u and he was a
  1554. 59:18trader just to put to give the context
  1555. 59:21he was a trader who um a bad draw down
  1556. 59:24for him would be like high teens teens
  1557. 59:27those were like his worst draw downs and
  1558. 59:29at the time I interviewed him
  1559. 59:30interestingly he was in one of those
  1560. 59:32draw downs and he had he had one
  1561. 59:34position uh on that was responsible for
  1562. 59:37most of the draw down and he was long he
  1563. 59:40was long Apple u at that time before the
  1564. 59:42circuit splits I think it was like maybe
  1565. 59:45350 going down to 350 or something like
  1566. 59:47that. And um he was so convinced on the
  1567. 59:52fundamentals and he he like say he was a
  1568. 59:54pure fundamentalist and he really did
  1569. 59:56his work. But to him it was clear as
  1570. 1:00:00could be that Apple could have to would
  1571. 1:00:02have to go up because uh he at that this
  1572. 1:00:06was back in 2012 and he kind of foresaw
  1573. 1:00:09that the earnings the the forward
  1574. 1:00:11earnings that people were projecting
  1575. 1:00:13were basically based on their growth in
  1576. 1:00:15largely US and so forth was not taking
  1577. 1:00:17account that Apple was going to explode
  1578. 1:00:20globally particularly in China and other
  1579. 1:00:22places and uh he saw that those
  1580. 1:00:25estimates were just woefully fully
  1581. 1:00:27inadequate relative to to the true
  1582. 1:00:29global growth Apple was going to see. So
  1583. 1:00:31not only he was not concerned about that
  1584. 1:00:33opposition at all. I think he might have
  1585. 1:00:35even been adding. So that sounds like
  1586. 1:00:37the antithesis of of uh of risk
  1587. 1:00:40management in a way it is. But the only
  1588. 1:00:42way he controlled that is by limiting
  1589. 1:00:45the the position to a certain
  1590. 1:00:47percentage. I think the extreme percent
  1591. 1:00:49he would put in the position would have
  1592. 1:00:51been Apple at that time which might have
  1593. 1:00:52been around 15%. So he had to be, you
  1594. 1:00:55know, it's not going to go to zero. So
  1595. 1:00:58he has to just keep his risk manager.
  1596. 1:01:00The idea, well, this one position, I
  1597. 1:01:02really totally believe in it. Uh, I've
  1598. 1:01:04got 15% of my money in it, but it's not
  1599. 1:01:07going to go to zero. It's not even going
  1600. 1:01:08to go down 50%. So the position can only
  1601. 1:01:12lose a certain percentage from that
  1602. 1:01:14realistically, and I'm willing to hold
  1603. 1:01:16it. That that's the way he achieved the
  1604. 1:01:18risk match. And by the way, six months
  1605. 1:01:20after that interview, I think Apple had
  1606. 1:01:23maybe even doubled. It had just gone. He
  1607. 1:01:26was totally he was 100% right. He was
  1608. 1:01:28also incidentally short rim at the same
  1609. 1:01:31time. The Blackberry company
  1610. 1:01:33>> rim at the time was 50. And I remember
  1611. 1:01:35these things, you know, eventually went
  1612. 1:01:37went
  1613. 1:01:39uh I believe. Uh so, you know, you
  1614. 1:01:42that's a long and a short and completely
  1615. 1:01:45convinced of both and you know, couldn't
  1616. 1:01:46be more right. Well, it sounds like you
  1617. 1:01:48just need to have a high level of
  1618. 1:01:50conviction, right?
  1619. 1:01:51>> Yeah. Yes. I'm g that. Yeah. I don't
  1620. 1:01:53want to come off sounding like you can't
  1621. 1:01:54use fundamentals. There are, you know,
  1622. 1:01:56here's an example of a guy that does
  1623. 1:01:58fundamentals uh doesn't have risk
  1624. 1:02:00management of a sense of we typically
  1625. 1:02:03talk about it, but he achieves it
  1626. 1:02:05through limiting the position to certain
  1627. 1:02:08a certain maximum amount of his
  1628. 1:02:11portfolio.
  1629. 1:02:11>> Well, it comes back to this quote I've
  1630. 1:02:13heard you say, Jack, which the 10 words
  1631. 1:02:15of advice. Do you want to say uh it's
  1632. 1:02:18just knowing where you're getting out
  1633. 1:02:21before you get in and if you know that
  1634. 1:02:22you know fundamentally or technically I
  1635. 1:02:25mean that you're going to be managing
  1636. 1:02:27risk, right? Um so one of the quotes
  1637. 1:02:29that came to mind too in regards to this
  1638. 1:02:31was William O'Neal. So he said the
  1639. 1:02:33secret to winning is not being right all
  1640. 1:02:34the time. It's losing the least amount
  1641. 1:02:37of money when wrong. Uh love that quote.
  1642. 1:02:41So, George, I wanted to ask both of you
  1643. 1:02:44uh really, but just if you can think
  1644. 1:02:46back on all the interviews from the next
  1645. 1:02:48generation, is there just the most
  1646. 1:02:51memorable moment for you in it?
  1647. 1:02:53>> There's something in this there's a
  1648. 1:02:55number of things in this book which
  1649. 1:02:56haven't in many other books Mark before,
  1650. 1:03:00but one of them is an anonymous
  1651. 1:03:02interview. I did. In another case, we'll
  1652. 1:03:05have an interview where uh if you want
  1653. 1:03:08to get an attention, we can, but I ended
  1654. 1:03:10up not being able to use the interview.
  1655. 1:03:12Uh but I kind of pleaded or just asked
  1656. 1:03:17the uh trader if I could just use one
  1657. 1:03:19little section. So, which he agreed to
  1658. 1:03:21and it's like two pages uh called Trader
  1659. 1:03:24X or something like that. So, I did have
  1660. 1:03:26a little snippet of an anonymous
  1661. 1:03:28interview, but I never had a full
  1662. 1:03:29interview, an anonymous uh in in the
  1663. 1:03:32book. And uh in this book, we do have
  1664. 1:03:36one because uh the story is so
  1665. 1:03:38spectacular and so compelling and
  1666. 1:03:41interesting. And I figured, look, uh
  1667. 1:03:43nobody would know if I had his real
  1668. 1:03:45name, nobody would know him anyway
  1669. 1:03:47because he's completely under the radar
  1670. 1:03:49and he's just a private individual,
  1671. 1:03:51right? So, nobody would know. So, what
  1672. 1:03:53what difference does a name make? It's a
  1673. 1:03:54story that counts. Uh it's, you know,
  1674. 1:03:57the story is accurate. The story is
  1675. 1:03:58true. And and uh this is this is a
  1676. 1:04:01fellow who u was a musician and uh was
  1677. 1:04:05in one of the country's top music
  1678. 1:04:07schools and uh dropped out then found
  1679. 1:04:11discovered he passionate about music but
  1680. 1:04:14then discovered trading. he was
  1681. 1:04:16passionate about trading and decided and
  1682. 1:04:19dropped out like a year before he
  1683. 1:04:21graduated uh from music conservatory uh
  1684. 1:04:24to just focus on trading and uh the
  1685. 1:04:28story goes on from there and it's uh uh
  1686. 1:04:31he ends he's one of the two people who
  1687. 1:04:33who kind of got to that near half
  1688. 1:04:35billion mark. So, uh, that that is to me
  1689. 1:04:39that story to me was the it's it's also
  1690. 1:04:42if not the longest chapter in any market
  1691. 1:04:45wizard book, uh, it's close. I think
  1692. 1:04:49Mark Marcus was a very long chapter, but
  1693. 1:04:51it's it's up there in one of the longest
  1694. 1:04:54chapters ever because the story is very
  1695. 1:04:56interesting. has a lot of ups and downs
  1696. 1:04:59and um and he ends up with a philosophy
  1697. 1:05:02that I find quite interesting uh which
  1698. 1:05:05is looking to ba basically give back
  1699. 1:05:08money uh for his various philanthropies.
  1700. 1:05:11>> Was it challenging to get that interview
  1701. 1:05:13or was he reluctant at all?
  1702. 1:05:15>> He was clearly well for one thing kind
  1703. 1:05:19of had his lawyer draw up like a
  1704. 1:05:21ninepage document which we
  1705. 1:05:23[clears throat] had to change.
  1706. 1:05:24>> Oh wow.
  1707. 1:05:26Yeah,
  1708. 1:05:27>> incredible.
  1709. 1:05:27>> You know, for the for the secrecy I'm
  1710. 1:05:31>> uh I thought of mine um just sorry it
  1711. 1:05:34took me a minute to think of it, but
  1712. 1:05:36Lance, who's chapter 2, he was
  1713. 1:05:38describing one of his mentors, and I
  1714. 1:05:40don't want to name this guy, but he
  1715. 1:05:42talked about the guy and where he had
  1716. 1:05:44worked and where he had gone to college
  1717. 1:05:45and he had lived in Asia. And as he's
  1718. 1:05:48describing this guy, I'm like, I know
  1719. 1:05:50this guy. I sat next to this guy for
  1720. 1:05:51five years. So at one of our breaks I
  1721. 1:05:54said, "Was this this guy?" And he's
  1722. 1:05:55like, "Yeah." And it was like, "Holy
  1723. 1:05:56smokes, small world." You know, we
  1724. 1:05:59>> the guy that was his mentor is the guy
  1725. 1:06:00that I sat next to for 5 years. So that
  1726. 1:06:02was probably the biggest uh coincidence
  1727. 1:06:05and that's memorable thing from the
  1728. 1:06:08>> the book in terms of just came to mind
  1729. 1:06:10right now.
  1730. 1:06:12>> Well, you [sighs and gasps] both have
  1731. 1:06:13studied elite performers uh over the
  1732. 1:06:16years and it's led us to this book. I'm
  1733. 1:06:18so excited for it. Been uh reading it
  1734. 1:06:20myself. It's incredible. It u comes out
  1735. 1:06:23June 9th uh 2026 here. Well, I wanted to
  1736. 1:06:28ask too, George, because you got a lot
  1737. 1:06:29of really great papers out out there.
  1738. 1:06:31Where can they find your work, George?
  1739. 1:06:33>> I think the best place to start is to go
  1740. 1:06:34to X, formerly Twitter. Uh my handle is
  1741. 1:06:37GFC4,
  1742. 1:06:39and I've got a link tree there that
  1743. 1:06:41links to a lot of the different things
  1744. 1:06:42I'm doing, including the the papers and
  1745. 1:06:45other materials and the book. So that's
  1746. 1:06:47the best place I think to go to find the
  1747. 1:06:50central hub for for George.
  1748. 1:06:52>> Okay, perfect. And then of course you
  1749. 1:06:55guys are already working on the next uh
  1750. 1:06:58market wizards book. Is that correct?
  1751. 1:06:59>> No, we didn't start yet, but uh
  1752. 1:07:01>> haven't started. So what happened as
  1753. 1:07:03George said before we had uh too much
  1754. 1:07:06material for one book and sort of
  1755. 1:07:08thought about well how do we divide them
  1756. 1:07:10in a lot some logical way and the most
  1757. 1:07:12logical way seemed to be solo traders
  1758. 1:07:15versus hedge funds and so we've had a
  1759. 1:07:17few of these hedge fund uh interviews
  1760. 1:07:19that we've done uh and uh we'll
  1761. 1:07:23obviously have to do more to fill out
  1762. 1:07:24that book but we have you know uh I
  1763. 1:07:27don't know a third or a half of the
  1764. 1:07:30potential raw material
  1765. 1:07:31there. Uh, in some cases, we've actually
  1766. 1:07:34written chapters. In the other cases,
  1767. 1:07:36we've got the interview, which hasn't
  1768. 1:07:38been transformed yet into chapters.
  1769. 1:07:40Well, Jack, every time you think it's
  1770. 1:07:42the last market wizards book, there's
  1771. 1:07:44another one on the way. So, maybe we'll
  1772. 1:07:46get another what, five or six more
  1773. 1:07:49over the next 10 to 20 years or so. So,
  1774. 1:07:51hey gentlemen, this has been excellent.
  1775. 1:07:53I mean, just last words over to you
  1776. 1:07:55guys. What's if someone for for the
  1777. 1:07:58person reading this book, you know,
  1778. 1:08:00what's one lesson you really want them
  1779. 1:08:02to to grab from this book when reading
  1780. 1:08:04it? Start with you, Jack.
  1781. 1:08:06>> Well, uh I'm going to be unconventional
  1782. 1:08:09here. uh let's take it kind of in the
  1783. 1:08:11opposite direction is one thing you'll
  1784. 1:08:13see in this book is that a number of
  1785. 1:08:15these traders ca ultimately came to the
  1786. 1:08:18conclusion that as a successful they've
  1787. 1:08:21been that they just didn't want to even
  1788. 1:08:23though they continue to churn out money
  1789. 1:08:26just by and it seems like a loss not to
  1790. 1:08:28keep trading because they're not trading
  1791. 1:08:30or devoting time to other things is
  1792. 1:08:32going to take away from their making uh
  1793. 1:08:35highly likely making more money. uh they
  1794. 1:08:38still decide that they want to use their
  1795. 1:08:40life in some other direction. They've
  1796. 1:08:42done the trading bit. They've been
  1797. 1:08:43successful. They got more money than
  1798. 1:08:45they need to live on for the rest of
  1799. 1:08:46their lives. They want to do something
  1800. 1:08:48else. So, uh you know, I think an
  1801. 1:08:50important lesson is there's more to life
  1802. 1:08:52than trading. I mean, as long as it's
  1803. 1:08:54your passion, what you want to do, go
  1804. 1:08:56for it. But keep in mind that that's not
  1805. 1:08:59all of life. and uh you for your
  1806. 1:09:02whatever your case may be uh that may
  1807. 1:09:05not be the direction you necessarily
  1808. 1:09:07want to go or if you've gone that way
  1809. 1:09:09you may not want to stay that way. So I
  1810. 1:09:12think it's important to have overall
  1811. 1:09:13perspective there's more to life than
  1812. 1:09:15trading.
  1813. 1:09:17And over to you, George.
  1814. 1:09:19>> If you incorporate the consistent
  1815. 1:09:22principles into your process, whether
  1816. 1:09:24it's discretionary or systematic, I
  1817. 1:09:26think you have a much greater chance of
  1818. 1:09:28survival and [clears throat]
  1819. 1:09:30and that's what it's about. So, I would
  1820. 1:09:32say find a way to cut your losses uh as
  1821. 1:09:35you learn and you'll save your money.
  1822. 1:09:37You won't lose it all.
  1823. 1:09:39>> Cut your losses and stick with the
  1824. 1:09:41principles.
  1825. 1:09:42>> Stick with the principles. Uh I love it.
  1826. 1:09:44That's a consistent theme here. And also
  1827. 1:09:46something I took away from the interview
  1828. 1:09:48as well is there's no singular approach.
  1829. 1:09:50I mean so many of these market wizards
  1830. 1:09:51had different approaches and found their
  1831. 1:09:53own success while sticking to George's
  1832. 1:09:56three principles. So thank you so much
  1833. 1:09:59for coming on. I mean the the market
  1834. 1:10:01wizards timeless material that's going
  1835. 1:10:03to live on for generations. Um and
  1836. 1:10:06hopefully this video as well that
  1837. 1:10:08traders can go back and watch and learn
  1838. 1:10:09from. So again, thank you Jack, thank
  1839. 1:10:12you George so much for taking the time.
  1840. 1:10:14Thanks again.
  1841. 1:10:15>> You've reached the end of this episode
  1842. 1:10:17of Chat with Traders, but rest assured,
  1843. 1:10:19there are more episodes loaded with real
  1844. 1:10:22market insight and zero hype on the way
  1845. 1:10:25soon. So, to stay updated [music] with
  1846. 1:10:27each great new release, subscribe to the
  1847. 1:10:29podcast, and we'd love it if you'd leave
  1848. 1:10:31a rating and review. We'll catch you
  1849. 1:10:33next time on Chat with Traders.
  1850. 1:10:42>> [music]

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of The 3 Timeless Rules Shared by 100 Years of Market Wizards · Jack Schwager & George Coyle by Chat With Traders, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 13,173 words across 1,850 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.