THB the West is Right to be Suspicious of Islam - Full Debate — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:04I'm pleased to open this evening's
- 0:05debate.
- 0:06And I'm pleased to call on Mr. Oliver
- 0:08Jones Lyons to open the debate for the
- 0:10proposition. Mr. Jones Lyons.
- 0:13>> [applause]
- 0:18>> Thank you, Mr. Chair. It'd be remiss of
- 0:20me not to begin by noting what an honor
- 0:23it is
- 0:24to be speaking today in what will
- 0:26ultimately prove to be one of those
- 0:28historic debates that shows why this
- 0:31matters.
- 0:33Despite external pressure, internal
- 0:35pressure, political machinations, and
- 0:38every type of motion under the sun,
- 0:41this house
- 0:43voted clearly and decisively
- 0:462 weeks in a row to have this debate
- 0:50and live up to this society's name
- 0:53of being the last bastion of free
- 0:55speech.
- 0:57We are here tonight
- 1:00because that principle matters and this
- 1:01motion matters.
- 1:03I rise to propose the motion that this
- 1:06house believes the West is right to be
- 1:08suspicious of Islam.
- 1:11The rise of Islam in the West
- 1:13has been the most notable and
- 1:14significant demographic change in the
- 1:17West
- 1:18over the course of the last few decades.
- 1:21Its effects, both positive and negative,
- 1:24are well known.
- 1:26But if we are fully honest with
- 1:27ourselves,
- 1:28it is certainly not a secret that the
- 1:31West is in fact suspicious of Islam.
- 1:35Tonight, the proposition will not cower
- 1:37away
- 1:38from the issue being debated here.
- 1:40It is not whether the enlightened West
- 1:42should be suspicious of every religion.
- 1:45It's about Islam.
- 1:47The burden for side proposition will be
- 1:49to prove the good reason exists
- 1:52to find uniquely justifiable reasons
- 1:57uh to be suspicious in the religion of
- 1:59Islam.
- 2:01As my belief, those good reasons exist.
- 2:04It's my hope
- 2:06that this debate won't descend into
- 2:07being a series of increasingly technical
- 2:10theological gotchas,
- 2:13nor the stringing around of anecdotes.
- 2:17This debate, if it is to be honest,
- 2:20will examine how Muslims actually live
- 2:22their lives
- 2:23and in accordance with their beliefs
- 2:25and the teachings of their faith and its
- 2:27leaders.
- 2:29Members of the house, I will set out
- 2:31during my speech the incompatibility of
- 2:33Islam with the values of religious
- 2:35tolerance and pluralism that underpin
- 2:37our society.
- 2:39I will then set out
- 2:41how Islam is more widely irreconcilable
- 2:45with the fundamental principles of
- 2:47Western liberal democratic society.
- 2:50And I will end with a call to action.
- 2:52This discussion should not be as fraught
- 2:56or as, well, frankly, you can hear it,
- 2:58as protested as it has been.
- 3:01And fundamentally, the West must move
- 3:03back to its fundamentally liberal roots
- 3:07and accept that no culture, no religion,
- 3:10no belief may not be subject to the
- 3:12scrutiny of reason and virtue.
- 3:15But with all that, Mr. Chair,
- 3:17it is my obligation to introduce
- 3:18speakers on side opposition to this
- 3:20honorable house.
- 3:22In the union, we have a tradition
- 3:24uh, of introducing
- 3:26uh, the opposition speakers via rows.
- 3:28Given, however, it's the last week of
- 3:30term, and I'm feeling in a very, um,
- 3:32unlike the protesters tonight,
- 3:33constructive mood,
- 3:35I thought I'd say some thank yous.
- 3:38Firstly, you will hear from Aisha Khan
- 3:40Aziz,
- 3:41the union's chief negotiations officer.
- 3:44I'd like to thank Aisha for her work on
- 3:46this debate.
- 3:47She seems to have an extensive amount of
- 3:49contacts in the global Muslim community
- 3:51and some very entertaining anecdotes
- 3:54about every niche Muslim celebrity.
- 3:57However, the way Aisha could be more
- 4:00helpful to any future president she may
- 4:02serve
- 4:03is perhaps by improving her matchmaking
- 4:05skills by finding them a
- 4:08and I must emphasize quote snuggle buddy
- 4:11who would dedicate
- 4:13eight weeks to jettisoning their
- 4:15partner's biggest debate.
- 4:18Next we have Michael Doward. Michael is
- 4:20a podcaster from Luton. I'd like to
- 4:22thank Mr. Doward
- 4:24for being willing to speak in this
- 4:25debate despite all the difficulties and
- 4:27pressures many speakers on this side of
- 4:29face.
- 4:31I also hear though in despite both
- 4:34supporting Luton Town that Mr. Doward
- 4:37may not exactly share many other views
- 4:40with his fellow Hatter on side
- 4:41proposition.
- 4:44Then you will hear from Sir Smog.
- 4:48Uh Sir Jacob, I was corrected I was
- 4:50side.
- 4:51I'd like to thank Sir Jacob for being a
- 4:53tireless defender of both this debate
- 4:56and freedom of speech.
- 4:58My biggest concern
- 5:00having heard Sir Sir Jacob in my first
- 5:04debate as a fresher
- 5:06was that he was debating on side
- 5:08opposition.
- 5:10And that he decided to go woke.
- 5:12But then I realized there is nothing
- 5:14woke about defending the right of all
- 5:16peoples to practice ultra-conservative
- 5:19values that should have been left in the
- 5:2019th century.
- 5:22Something Sir Jacob is famously familiar
- 5:25with.
- 5:27Next we have Abdullah Al-Andalusi.
- 5:30Much like many of the faces on side
- 5:32proposition
- 5:33Mr. Al-Andalusi has been a vocal
- 5:35defender of the president's decision to
- 5:36have this debate.
- 5:39And I want to be absolutely clear
- 5:41that having the balls to defend your
- 5:43faith and put up to scrutiny
- 5:45is something I can literally only have
- 5:48the utmost respect for.
- 5:50However, I was a bit confused why Miss
- 5:52Andalusi is so popular in the Muslim
- 5:55community for being its answer to I hate
- 5:58to say I'm quoting Muslim uh committee
- 5:59members here, who is the Muslim Tommy
- 6:01Robinson?
- 6:03And finally, you will hear from our
- 6:05president, Owolabi Oredein.
- 6:07Most of my job this term has been what
- 6:09we have begun colloquially referring to
- 6:11as Owolabizing.
- 6:14But I'll do it again one last time.
- 6:16Owolabi has faced so much grief for
- 6:18having this important discussion,
- 6:20including most especially from her own
- 6:22community.
- 6:23The bravery and courage she has
- 6:25exhibited to stay steadfast in the face
- 6:28of all from every hourly press request
- 6:30to every daily smear campaign to every
- 6:33weekly motion challenging her authority
- 6:35and her decisions
- 6:36exemplifies exactly what this
- 6:39institution is about.
- 6:42>> [applause]
- 6:49[applause]
- 6:51>> I hate to say she's not getting off that
- 6:54easy.
- 6:55If nothing else, if her desired career
- 6:58as a Green Member of Parliament fails,
- 7:01I'm sure after her term she'll enjoy a
- 7:03safe backstop in Reform UK.
- 7:06Mr. Chair, Madam President, these are
- 7:08your guests and they are most welcome.
- 7:11>> [applause]
- 7:18>> Debates about exclusivism are familiar
- 7:20to any student of philosophy.
- 7:22Islam, as many religions do,
- 7:25has a doctrine that is the final
- 7:28revelation of truth
- 7:30and that all of our revelation is either
- 7:32not divine,
- 7:34not final, or simply wrong.
- 7:37This isn't unusual.
- 7:39But Islam presents a unique challenge to
- 7:42the secular liberal order.
- 7:44While many belief systems engage in
- 7:46internal moral dialogue,
- 7:48Islam encompasses an overarching
- 7:52political and legal framework referred
- 7:54to as Sharia
- 7:55that makes explicit actionable demands
- 7:58on the governance of the state.
- 8:01This system includes a system of
- 8:03taxation called and I'm aware I'm going
- 8:05to butcher this, but jizya,
- 8:07whereby non-Muslims are in Muslim lands,
- 8:10as envisaged by the Quran,
- 8:12required to pay a tax for the extension
- 8:15of freedom of belief and the right to
- 8:17autonomy of life.
- 8:21We talk a lot about how we should be
- 8:22tolerant, how we should be accepting of
- 8:24beliefs, and I'm sure that different
- 8:26presentations of Islamic law will be
- 8:27presented.
- 8:29When you examine concepts like the jizya
- 8:31or specific jurisprudence regarding
- 8:33apostasy,
- 8:35we need not quote trade quotes from
- 8:38scripture.
- 8:40We can debate the more essential tension
- 8:42between a political doctrine
- 8:45that legally categorizes citizens by
- 8:47their faith status
- 8:50under Western liberal system
- 8:52that mandates equality under law
- 8:54regardless of belief.
- 8:57Take jizya.
- 8:59Is not fundamentally liberal?
- 9:02And is it not fundamentally liberal and
- 9:04Western to believe in discriminatory
- 9:06taxes against those of different faiths
- 9:09that are required
- 9:11to be guaranteed the most basic of what
- 9:13we in the West would call human rights?
- 9:16Such as the right to even light up. Feel
- 9:18free.
- 9:19>> Um it's not discriminatory tax taxes.
- 9:22It's that in Islamic state this there's
- 9:25only one level of citizenship.
- 9:27Non-Muslims are the citizens. Muslims
- 9:29are the subjects of the state. We have
- 9:30obligations to the state that
- 9:32non-Muslims are not subject to. And if
- 9:34you go to Pakistan, for example, they
- 9:36have some aspects of Islamic law there
- 9:37in the constitution, Muslims are not
- 9:39allowed to drink alcohol, but Pakistani
- 9:42Christians are actually allowed to drink
- 9:44alcohol and follow their own practices.
- 9:46So, if anything, an Islamic state is
- 9:48more oppressive to Muslims than it is to
- 9:50non-Muslims.
- 9:52>> So, what you're saying is fundamentally
- 9:54there is a discrimination there between
- 9:56Muslim and non-Muslims.
- 9:59>> Not in certain
- 10:00>> This is but one example.
- 10:02Scholars may disagree on the
- 10:04interpretation of various verses of the
- 10:06Quran and Hadiths.
- 10:08From
- 10:09again, I quote, "Kill the polytheists
- 10:12wherever you find them." in Surah 9:5 to
- 10:15quote, "Whoever changes his religion,
- 10:17put him to death." in the words of the
- 10:19Prophet Muhammad in Hadiths.
- 10:22But these verses, even if not literal
- 10:25instructions, go on.
- 10:27>> In the Surah that you mentioned, Surah
- 10:28of verse, in the verse of the Surah,
- 10:30sorry, can you recite the verse that
- 10:31comes before it and then also the verse
- 10:33that comes after it? And are you willing
- 10:34to accept that verse was given in a very
- 10:36specific time regarding a very specific
- 10:37tribe that burned or prevented the
- 10:40treaty that they had signed with
- 10:41Muslims, that is not even a universal
- 10:43command upon all Muslims?
- 10:45>> I found that yet love.
- 10:50But only with these verses,
- 10:52even if not literal instructions,
- 10:57even if not divine law,
- 11:00tell you something about the fundamental
- 11:02difference
- 11:03between Islam and other faiths.
- 11:06Islam is a totalizing religion.
- 11:08Non-believers are expected to convert or
- 11:11remain inferior.
- 11:12Not in the divine realm above, but here
- 11:15on earth.
- 11:16>> What information?
- 11:17>> Polytheists, apostates, and all of the
- 11:20other
- 11:21deserving exclusion or worse.
- 11:24This brings me quite nicely to my second
- 11:26point.
- 11:27Ultimately, I could list countless
- 11:29examples
- 11:31of how Muslim majority countries
- 11:32non-believers.
- 11:34How it is potentially lethal in
- 11:35countries like Syria to be a Jew or
- 11:37religious minority. How Iran hangs
- 11:40homosexuals. How countries like Qatar
- 11:42and Saudi Arabia subjugate women through
- 11:45passport controls moderated by a male
- 11:47guardianship schemes.
- 11:50But it would be the same old tired
- 11:52criticism.
- 11:54I want us to think about this
- 11:55differently and honestly.
- 11:57We can put this down to as I'm sure
- 12:00you've heard side proposition well,
- 12:01local anomalies or distorted
- 12:03interpretations. Yet nearly 80% of the
- 12:06world's Muslim population live in states
- 12:09where these frameworks are not just
- 12:11abstract theory, but the law of the
- 12:13land.
- 12:14We must grapple with this reality.
- 12:18We can observe the outcome of this
- 12:20doctrine where it is empowered to govern
- 12:22through the very same people who profess
- 12:24its teachings.
- 12:27If that practical truth
- 12:30is the standard of governance in the
- 12:32vast majority of the Muslim world,
- 12:35why should we as a liberal society
- 12:38treat the expansion of that system
- 12:41as if the outcome would be any
- 12:42different?
- 12:44Most concerningly, political Islam
- 12:47once dismissed as being crazy and as
- 12:49fringe as the conspiracy of the Epstein
- 12:52files,
- 12:53is now being normalized as a policy end
- 12:56by an insurgent Green Party.
- 12:59The idea of Islam as a political
- 13:01ideology certainly isn't new, but the
- 13:03open pursuit of it by parliamentary
- 13:06hopefuls moving from the streets to the
- 13:08hall of government should concern anyone
- 13:11who values our secular democracy.
- 13:15When the stated goal of a movement is to
- 13:18institutionalize its legal framework to
- 13:20replace existing statutes with an
- 13:23alternative code,
- 13:25we are no longer discussing a religion
- 13:27but a political competitor.
- 13:29Finally, I will leave you a point.
- 13:32Is my choice, as it is your choice,
- 13:35to be suspicious of Islam or not.
- 13:37But let's not act like we really treat
- 13:40it that way.
- 13:42The West has got into this unfortunate
- 13:44habit of thinking tolerance means
- 13:46protection,
- 13:48avoidance of scrutiny,
- 13:50and avoidance of uncomfortable
- 13:52conversations.
- 13:54To be clear, faith is a choice.
- 13:57I faith, I'm certainly not an atheist.
- 14:00But I expect and nor should anyone
- 14:02expect
- 14:03any accommodation, nor safe space.
- 14:06The freedom for faith incurs the
- 14:09liability of criticism.
- 14:12If truly we shouldn't be suspicious of
- 14:14Islam,
- 14:15then why the visceral backlash that you
- 14:17can hear right now to this debate?
- 14:20Why do more Muslims not they see this
- 14:22debate how our president does?
- 14:25Look at the Five Pillars poll as an
- 14:27example of how the Muslim world sees
- 14:29this very important debate. What about
- 14:31how the noble gentleman sitting right
- 14:32there
- 14:34sees it as an opportunity to defend his
- 14:36religion.
- 14:37The UK
- 14:38>> Just for your information,
- 14:39>> Feel free.
- 14:40>> The initial Five Pillars poll suggested
- 14:4166% of Muslims were supportive of this
- 14:44debate going through.
- 14:45And then they found out the speakers and
- 14:47they changed it.
- 14:48>> The UK
- 14:49>> Tommy.
- 14:50>> They knew about Tommy and that was one
- 14:51side.
- 14:54The UK regards, quote, religion or
- 14:56belief as a protected characteristic.
- 14:59But no belief system should be protected
- 15:01from inquiry.
- 15:02You should have the freedom to practice,
- 15:04I should have the freedom to criticize,
- 15:06to scrutinize, or in fact condemn.
- 15:09Religions are systems of propositions,
- 15:12political, philosophical, personal, and
- 15:14ultimately ontological.
- 15:16One can certainly be suspicious of
- 15:18Islam, and I hate to say you are
- 15:20allowed.
- 15:21It's not bigotry, it's not far right.
- 15:25How can a system of belief that demands
- 15:27the discrimination of apostates be
- 15:29compatible with a secular order based on
- 15:31equality and rights? How can a religious
- 15:34order that whose subjugation is morality
- 15:37be compatible with a liberal democratic
- 15:39order?
- 15:41Members of the house, if you, like me,
- 15:44can't answer those questions,
- 15:46then vote for this motion.
- 15:48>> Point of order, Mr.
- 15:49>> Go on.
- 15:50>> On every measure of British values
- 15:51polled last year, democracy, equality
- 15:53before the law, loyalty to this country,
- 15:54opposition to bigotry,
- 15:56British Muslims scored higher than the
- 15:57British average. Will the speaker
- 15:59concede that the community he is asking
- 16:01us to be suspicious of is holding the
- 16:02line on the values he claims to defend?
- 16:06>> I would direct
- 16:09the president
- 16:11to other polls, including the polls
- 16:14about whether October 7th actually
- 16:16happened,
- 16:18the polls about
- 16:20whether
- 16:219/11 was staged by the American
- 16:23government,
- 16:25the polls about
- 16:27the basics of British values, democracy,
- 16:30freedom.
- 16:34And I'll leave it there cuz I'd already
- 16:36finished my speech.
- 16:38>> [applause]
- 16:43[applause]
- 16:46>> I thank the honorable gentleman for
- 16:47opening the debate for the proposition.
- 16:49And I call upon Aisha Khan Aziz to open
- 16:52the debate for the opposition.
- 16:55>> [applause]
- 17:02>> Mr. Chair, thank you for the opportunity
- 17:04to speak tonight.
- 17:06I am a history student. I love digging
- 17:08up the past, though not as much as some
- 17:10people who have studied every terrorist
- 17:12attack since 9/11, and yet somehow
- 17:14missed the 12 centuries of Islamic
- 17:15history that came before.
- 17:17But since we are doing history, let me
- 17:19give you Cato the Elder, since the West
- 17:21likes rooting itself in its Greco-Roman
- 17:23traditions.
- 17:24Cato ended every speech in the Roman
- 17:26Senate on grain prices or foreign policy
- 17:29with the same line, "Carthago delenda
- 17:32est. Carthage must be destroyed." He
- 17:34never argued it or proved it, he just
- 17:37repeated it incessantly and relentlessly
- 17:40until the Senate felt it in their bones,
- 17:42until Carthage felt inevitable.
- 17:45Eventually they went and burnt it to the
- 17:46ground and salted the earth so nothing
- 17:48would grow again.
- 17:49We do not have to go back 2,000 years to
- 17:52see how this ends. We can look at simply
- 17:54last week in Belfast. A stabbing on a
- 17:56street left a man fighting for his life
- 17:59at the hands of a Sudanese refugee here
- 18:01on a legal residence permit. Within 48
- 18:04hours, mobs were going from door to door
- 18:06looking for them.
- 18:0827 people were made homeless overnight.
- 18:11A Ukrainian family burnt out. Muslim
- 18:13parents who were asking their white
- 18:15neighbors to keep their children safe
- 18:17while they stayed in their houses and
- 18:19waited for the inferno to come. A
- 18:212-month-old baby was pulled from a
- 18:23burning house by firefighters.
- 18:25Northern Ireland's Justice Minister said
- 18:27it plainly, "Bad faith actors who could
- 18:29not have found Belfast on a map a week
- 18:31earlier were deliberately stoking people
- 18:33onto the streets and that is the
- 18:35absolute definition of racism."
- 18:38But before I make that case in full, let
- 18:40me acknowledge the distinguished bench
- 18:42in front of me tonight.
- 18:44Oliver J. I begin with you. You dropped
- 18:47out of your GDL course to spend more
- 18:49time unemployed at the Oxford Union.
- 18:53And given how many times a Muslim
- 18:55candidate has stood between you and the
- 18:57position you actually wanted here in the
- 18:59Union, perhaps tonight's motion
- 19:05>> [applause]
- 19:11[applause]
- 19:12>> Perhaps tonight's motion is less about
- 19:14the West's relationship with Islam and
- 19:16more about yours.
- 19:18Stephen Yaxley Lennon, known to his
- 19:20hooligans as Tommy Robinson. Stephen,
- 19:23there is a crowd outside writing against
- 19:26you tonight, and without the protection
- 19:28and generosity of a Muslim Palestinian
- 19:30president and a mostly South Asian
- 19:32executive committee,
- 19:35um you would be quite literally cooked.
- 19:40>> [applause]
- 19:44>> Dan Lawrence Fox, actor, politician,
- 19:46however, I think his most memorable role
- 19:48might be the ex-husband of Doctor Who's
- 19:50Rose Tyler.
- 19:52Founder of the Reclaim Party, which at
- 19:54the last general election reclaimed
- 19:55approximately 0.02%
- 19:58of the British vote.
- 20:00Also a former GB News presenter, former
- 20:02because GB News let him go, which if you
- 20:04know anything about GB News, says
- 20:06something quite specific about the
- 20:08threshold.
- 20:10Finally, Jonathan Sacerdoti, a core
- 20:13memory of my Michaelmas 2024 Oxford
- 20:15Union experience.
- 20:18However, you wrote an article in The
- 20:20Spectator merely 2 days ago. There you
- 20:22insist sharing a panel with Stephen
- 20:24Yaxley Lennon is not a reflection on
- 20:26you, and that guilt by association is
- 20:28beneath serious argument, only spend the
- 20:30rest of the piece asking Muslims to wear
- 20:33the guilt of a minority who share
- 20:34nothing with them but a faith. You
- 20:36cannot demand that logic for yourself,
- 20:37Jonathan, and deny it to everyone else
- 20:39in the room.
- 20:40>> information.
- 20:42My argument was with the ideology of
- 20:44Islam, not with individual Muslims.
- 20:46>> I read the article and it was a bit very
- 20:49self-apologetic about speaking here
- 20:50tonight. Miss
- 20:53>> [applause]
- 20:57>> Mr. Chair, these are Madam Speaker's
- 21:00guests, and in the spirit of free
- 21:01speech, they are most welcome.
- 21:04>> [applause]
- 21:12>> The proposition's argument is seductive.
- 21:14It says, "Look at the threat. Look at
- 21:16these acts. Suspicion is just and
- 21:17prudence." I do not need to deny that
- 21:20Islamist terrorism or an Islamist threat
- 21:21is real. I need to show you that
- 21:23collective suspicion of Islam is
- 21:24irrational, counterproductive, and
- 21:26morally catastrophic. So, let us be
- 21:28inductive. Let us look at what that
- 21:29suspicion actually produces. After 9/11,
- 21:32the West treated Islam as a
- 21:34civilizational enemy and called that
- 21:36suspicion prudence. The result was not
- 21:38safety. It was Abu Ghraib. It was
- 21:40Guantanamo Bay. Men who were held for
- 21:42decades without charge. Men like Ahmed
- 21:44Rabbani, a taxi driver from Karachi,
- 21:46sold to the Americans for $5,000 because
- 21:48they thought he was someone else. 20
- 21:50years in a cage and he never once was
- 21:52charged. His son Jawad grew up on a
- 21:5415-minute phone call a year. A father
- 21:57who would only say he is in jail. At 13,
- 21:59Jawad went on the dark web to watch his
- 22:01father's torture videos. For years, he
- 22:04believed his father must have deserved
- 22:06it because, in his words, "You don't
- 22:07torture anyone for no reason." He did
- 22:10not meet his father until 2023. A grown
- 22:13man meeting a stranger at an airport
- 22:15because suspicion took his father before
- 22:16he was even born. That is what suspicion
- 22:19produces.
- 22:20Not security, but the very monster it
- 22:22claims to defend against. And a
- 22:24childhood stolen from a boy who
- 22:25committed no crime either.
- 22:27When it When it is not states, but
- 22:29ordinary people who act on it, the
- 22:30ledger is just as damning. Two genocides
- 22:33of Muslims in 30 years. Bosnia in 1995,
- 22:35Myanmar in 2017, a pogrom in Delhi in
- 22:382020. All fed by the same elemental
- 22:40claim that the proposition is making
- 22:42tonight. That Muslims are foreign,
- 22:44violent, a threat by nature rather than
- 22:46by individual acts. The motion, at its
- 22:49core, is Samuel Huntington's argument,
- 22:51which is the clash of civilizations.
- 22:53Islam and the West placed as mortal
- 22:56enemies in a stronghold that only one
- 22:57side can win.
- 22:58Published in 1993, it has shaped Western
- 23:01policy for 30 years. So, let us test it
- 23:04against the evidence.
- 23:05The evidence, they say, is ISIS,
- 23:07Palmyra, the Bamiyan Buddhas. Look, here
- 23:10is the clash. Here is why suspicion is
- 23:12rational. All they do is destroy. So,
- 23:15let me take them to Jerusalem. In the
- 23:17Al-Aqsa complex, which is the third holy
- 23:19site in Islam, there are Gothic rose
- 23:21windows, Crusader stonework preserved by
- 23:23Muslim custodians for eight centuries.
- 23:25Saladin Ayyubi took Jerusalem in 1187
- 23:28and left the Christian stonework
- 23:30stonework standing. That is not a clash
- 23:32of civilizations.
- 23:33>> What nation?
- 23:34And what did Iran do to I guess here?
- 23:37>> I'm talking about Jerusalem.
- 23:39The evident
- 23:44And denied. The Bamiyan and Bamiyan,
- 23:46when the Taliban first proposed
- 23:48destroying the Buddhas, scholars from
- 23:50Al-Azhar University in Cairo flew to
- 23:51Kandahar to argue against it on
- 23:53theological grounds. Hazara Muslims took
- 23:55up arms to protect them. That tradition
- 23:57tried harder to save those statues than
- 23:59the West ever did, which brings me to
- 24:01Palmyra. The man who died trying to save
- 24:03it was an 81-year-old Muslim man,
- 24:05tortured for a month and beheaded for
- 24:07refusing to talk. So, who is Islamist
- 24:10violence actually killing? Not the West,
- 24:12it's Muslims. 91% of everyone killed by
- 24:15Islamist terrorism is Muslim. The
- 24:17Taliban has killed 69,000 people, ISIS
- 24:2058,000, Boko Haram 25,000 people. All of
- 24:24them, nearly Muslim, killed by men who
- 24:26called themselves the only true Muslims
- 24:28on Earth. For 20 years, the West has
- 24:30pointed at the body count and blamed the
- 24:32corpses for suspicion.
- 24:34Huntington told governments that they
- 24:35were not engaged they were in a
- 24:37civilizational war. They believed him,
- 24:39and in fighting that war, they generated
- 24:40precisely the enemy his thesis required.
- 24:43Yes.
- 24:44>> Um, are you suggesting that Islamic
- 24:47death
- 24:48uh meted out to other Muslims should not
- 24:50make people in the West suspicious
- 24:52because they care about Islam killing
- 24:55its own people?
- 24:57>> I think primarily the West's
- 25:00um argument towards criticism of a
- 25:03Muslim is to do with themselves as
- 25:05opposed to how they treat other Muslims.
- 25:07I don't think that the footing in which
- 25:09we treat other Muslims versus Westerners
- 25:11is equal.
- 25:12That is the paradox of the modern
- 25:13culture war, actually. Offended by
- 25:15everything, shamed by nothing. They take
- 25:17issue with a woman on a head scarf on a
- 25:18bus and feel no shame about the wars we
- 25:20exported or the terrorist regimes we
- 25:22bankrolled. The sensibility that finds
- 25:24Islam offensive cannot locate its own
- 25:26reflection in history. And trust me, the
- 25:28West has plenty of history to locate.
- 25:30The Inquisition, colonialism, slavery,
- 25:32the internment of Japanese Americans,
- 25:33McCarthyism. Every generation has had
- 25:36its carnage. A group cast as a
- 25:38civilizational threat. Every generation
- 25:40told itself it was being reasonable, and
- 25:41every generation was wrong. So, let's
- 25:43just be clear about Western values. The
- 25:45West does not have a settled unified set
- 25:47of values of which a
- 25:49against which Islam can be measured and
- 25:50found wanting. It is a contested,
- 25:53unresolved project, and so is Islam, and
- 25:55so is every intellectual tradition. The
- 25:57question is not whether one perfect
- 25:59civilization can judge another and find
- 26:01it deficient.
- 26:02Denied.
- 26:04But whether two imperfect, contested
- 26:06traditions can coexist, and that is not
- 26:08answered by one of them claiming the
- 26:09right to treat the other as inherently
- 26:10suspect.
- 26:12I agree that Western values are worth
- 26:13defending. So completely that I will
- 26:15show you what they look like when I
- 26:16actually live them. Western critical
- 26:18thinking means I can read a scholar's
- 26:19commentary on a Quranic verse and decide
- 26:21that he might be right or wrong. It
- 26:23means I can hold up my faith to scrutiny
- 26:25without it shattering, because a faith
- 26:27that cannot survive a question probably
- 26:29deserves to be questioned, am I right?
- 26:31But the proposition's argument is not
- 26:32critical thinking should be universal.
- 26:34It is that the West has a right to be
- 26:36suspicious of me
- 26:37before I even open my mouth, before I
- 26:39demonstrate anything at all. Suspicious
- 26:41of who I am, and also what I eat,
- 26:43ironically.
- 26:44MI5's own researchers have said them
- 26:46this have said this themselves. When
- 26:48communities feel pre-convicted, they
- 26:50disengage from the institutions that
- 26:51could intercept real threats.
- 26:54Legitimized I'm trying to get through my
- 26:56speech. Legitimized suspicion does not
- 26:58make us safer. It makes the people we
- 26:59need on side feel like enemies.
- 27:03One more thing about Western values. The
- 27:05proposition speaks of a Judeo-Christian
- 27:07tradition under threat from Islam. That
- 27:09phrase was coined in the 1930s in
- 27:11America to fight fascism. Built against
- 27:14exclusion, then the Cold War came and it
- 27:16was repurposed as a banner against
- 27:17godless communism because nothing says
- 27:19rugged Western freedom quite like
- 27:21reminding the Soviets to go to church.
- 27:23Now it has changed targets again. No
- 27:26longer Jewish people are a risk to the
- 27:27West, but the Muslim person. It is the
- 27:29same machinery, the same sentence
- 27:31structure, the same act of drawing a
- 27:33line around who counts as one of us,
- 27:35just pointed at different people.
- 27:37Islamophobia has become one of the last
- 27:39socially acceptable forms of bigotry in
- 27:42British public life, and the proposition
- 27:44wants to give that bigotry a mandate.
- 27:46My grandfather came to this country in
- 27:48the 1950s. He did not arrive suspicious.
- 27:50He arrived with a particular stubborn
- 27:52hope of someone who believed Britain
- 27:53meant what it had said. He spent his
- 27:55life proving he belonged here, brick by
- 27:58brick, year by year. He even gave up his
- 28:01name, Abdul Aziz, for one that would
- 28:03open more doors. We gave this country
- 28:06our blood to enrich it. That proposition
- 28:08is asking you to tell him that was never
- 28:10going to be enough.
- 28:11Staging suspicion of Islam is not
- 28:13intellectual rigor. It is the same
- 28:15Islamophobia that keeps people like
- 28:17Stephen Yaxley Lennon and Laurence Fox
- 28:19trafficking. And it is a disgrace I'm
- 28:22about to finish my speech. It is a
- 28:23disgrace that Muslims should have to
- 28:25keep performing their humanity to earn
- 28:26belief. I say that is not Western
- 28:28values, that is Western failure, that is
- 28:31a Western disgrace, and this house is
- 28:33better than that.
- 28:34>> [applause]
- 28:35>> I urge you all to vote against the
- 28:37motion tonight. Thank you.
- 28:43>> [applause]
- 28:44>> I thank the honorable lady for opening
- 28:46the case for the opposition
- 28:48and I now call upon Mr. Tommy Robinson
- 28:50to advance the case for the proposition.
- 28:55>> [applause]
- 28:57>> First of all, I'd like to say I'd much
- 28:59rather be watching the England game than
- 29:01in in here tonight.
- 29:04I've simply come here because of the
- 29:06commitment to free speech that I will
- 29:08have for this event. I know you have
- 29:09totally opposite views to me, but I know
- 29:11that people may step into the field of
- 29:12inviting me somewhere without realizing
- 29:14what it's going to face. So, I'm aware
- 29:16of the backlash you would have faced,
- 29:17but I congratulate you on your defense
- 29:18of free speech and that's the reason why
- 29:20I've come tonight.
- 29:23>> [applause]
- 29:25>> I'd also like to congratulate Aisha on
- 29:28her first great speech and I'm sorry
- 29:30that your family aren't here today to
- 29:31have watched that.
- 29:33But it wasn't my supporters that have
- 29:34attacked them outside. It's not my
- 29:36supporters who are causing a rabble or
- 29:38smashing the place up and attacking
- 29:39police officers. It's not supporters on
- 29:41our side of the debate either. It's
- 29:42supporters on your side of the debate
- 29:44who are out there causing mayhem.
- 29:46So, before talking about Islam
- 29:48I'd love to believe what Jacob and the
- 29:50others on this panel believe that we
- 29:52shouldn't be suspicious of Islam.
- 29:54Jacob, there's 480 Muslims who live in
- 29:56your constituency.
- 29:570.5%. You probably can't find a Muslim.
- 30:00There's three mosques, the main one
- 30:01being in Bath University.
- 30:03I'm from Luton Town. We have 80,000
- 30:05Muslims, 45 mosques, 33% of the
- 30:07population.
- 30:08So, I ask myself why would a non-Muslim
- 30:10be telling any of us that we should
- 30:11shouldn't be suspicious of Islam?
- 30:13Well, of course Jacob does not have to
- 30:15live with the consequences of his own
- 30:16disastrous
- 30:17policy government of the Conservative
- 30:19Party and their policies, beliefs only
- 30:21the elite can afford to hold.
- 30:23So, is Islam first, should we, the West,
- 30:26be suspicious of it?
- 30:28I want to be clear
- 30:30what Islam is because it's not what any
- 30:32of you say is. It's not what I say is.
- 30:35It's not what we wish it to be and it's
- 30:37not what your friendly local Imam or
- 30:38your taxi driver or Mr. Andalusia
- 30:40decides is.
- 30:41Islam is defined in the Quran.
- 30:44Muslims that believe the Quran to be the
- 30:46word of Allah written in an eternal book
- 30:48in heaven and revealed to Muhammad in
- 30:50the 7th century.
- 30:52And it's the Sunnah.
- 30:53The excellent pattern of behavior or
- 30:55exalted standard of moral excellence as
- 30:57defined in the Hadiths which record his
- 31:00sayings, actions, and silence approvals
- 31:02or disapprovals of Muhammad and in the
- 31:05biography.
- 31:06And the whole idea by the way is based
- 31:08in on accepting that Muhammad is the
- 31:10final prophet because the Quran says so
- 31:14and the Quran is the word of God
- 31:16because Muhammad says so.
- 31:18So,
- 31:20seeking common ground.
- 31:21I'm not here for a fight contrary to
- 31:23what everyone believes. Everyone thinks
- 31:24everywhere I go I want to fight. I want
- 31:26to find some common ground. Finding
- 31:28common ground with Islam?
- 31:30Muhammad said to the Christians of
- 31:31Najran,
- 31:32"Come to a word that is just between us
- 31:34and you that we worship none but Allah
- 31:37and that we associated no partners with
- 31:40him."
- 31:40So, Islam presents itself as religion
- 31:43that wants to seek common ground with
- 31:44others. Come to a word, Muhammad was
- 31:47saying, "Let's find some common ground."
- 31:50Nothing to be suspicious of there,
- 31:51right?
- 31:52But it's the no partners. That's the
- 31:54key. Islam says it wants common ground,
- 31:57but the common ground must be Islam.
- 32:00Christians must acknowledge Jesus is the
- 32:01son of God
- 32:03a partner.
- 32:04But anyway, let's look for some common
- 32:06ground, okay? That's what we want to
- 32:07find. I'll I'll I've seen how this works
- 32:09and so I'll take as many questions as
- 32:11you want at the end. I'm just going to
- 32:12finish my speech.
- 32:14How many of you in here are gay?
- 32:17You don't actually need to put your
- 32:18hands up, okay?
- 32:20In the Quran, through the story of Lot,
- 32:22homosexuality is homosexuality is
- 32:23condemned and four of the five major
- 32:26schools of Islamic law think it should
- 32:28be punishable by death.
- 32:30Maybe I'm going to I'm going to I'm
- 32:31going to finish my speech. In fact, 24
- 32:33countries where Islam is the state
- 32:35religion have criminal penalties for
- 32:37homosexuality. Eight of them is
- 32:39punishable by death. So, I would want to
- 32:41maybe if you're gay you might maybe be a
- 32:43little bit suspicious of this.
- 32:45That's in Afghanistan, Iran, Qatar,
- 32:47Saudi Arabia, UAE, Yemen. They kill you
- 32:50for being gay.
- 32:52Who's protesting about this? When these
- 32:54countries state legislators or
- 32:56governments visit our country, who
- 32:57protest? Oh, well, I'll just love to
- 32:59finish it here.
- 33:00>> Point of order has been raised,
- 33:02President.
- 33:03>> As per discussions with previous
- 33:05speakers, we did agree that we would
- 33:06take constructive information from
- 33:08fellow speaker, guests, and audience
- 33:10members. If you can respect that as part
- 33:12of a constructive debate, it would be
- 33:13very much appreciated.
- 33:13>> Thank the President for that point of
- 33:15order. Mr. Robinson, I think the idea
- 33:17that the President's putting across is
- 33:19>> Here the question first.
- 33:20>> Take a question every now and then. Take
- 33:22a question every now and then, please.
- 33:23Thank you.
- 33:24>> Can we at least agree killing people
- 33:26because they are homosexuals is never
- 33:28okay? It was never okay then,
- 33:31and it's not okay now.
- 33:33Now,
- 33:34I have to listen more.
- 33:37I see how this works.
- 33:38>> Where does it say in the Quran or the
- 33:40teaching of Prophet Muhammad that
- 33:41someone who has who is homosexual, gay,
- 33:44should be executed?
- 33:45>> You don't need to convince me, mate. You
- 33:47need to reach the eight Islamic
- 33:48countries that are killing them. The
- 33:49people are being thrown off rooftops. Go
- 33:50have your argument with Hamas. Go have
- 33:52your argument with ISIS. You don't need
- 33:53to convince me. Now, please, if I can
- 33:55just finish. Again,
- 33:57again, let's talk about sex, okay?
- 34:01How many of you have had sex since you
- 34:02got here? I want to see your hands up.
- 34:04>> [laughter]
- 34:05>> I knew that was coming, right?
- 34:08You see,
- 34:10you see, the Quran prescribes 100 lashes
- 34:12for the male and the female involved in
- 34:13what Islam considers illegal sexual
- 34:15intercourse. That's the Quran 24:2.
- 34:18But, Islamic scholars have gone all in
- 34:20on this issue, yeah? Not just lashing,
- 34:22all schools of Islamic law prescribe
- 34:25death by stoning if a person is married.
- 34:29And the Shia school, Jafari, prescribes
- 34:32100 lashes before you're stoned to
- 34:34death. So, maybe if you think no one
- 34:37believes in this If you think no one
- 34:38believes in this barbaric stuff, in
- 34:392023, the head Imam of the Green Lane
- 34:42Mosque, the head Imam, you can watch
- 34:43this video, actually gives a seminar to
- 34:45his congregation on how we keep the
- 34:48modesty of the woman before we smash
- 34:50rocks at her head. So, you see, she has
- 34:52to be buried up to a certain level to to
- 34:54preserve her modesty.
- 34:57>> Is what you were discussing not abuse of
- 35:01Islamic scripture and not actually what
- 35:02is discussed in the Islamic scripture?
- 35:03Give me examples from Islamic scripture
- 35:05in Islamic law, not cherry-picked
- 35:07examples that have been taken out of
- 35:08context. Give me examples from the
- 35:10verses of the Quran that back up your
- 35:12arguments.
- 35:13>> Sh- sh- sh- sh- Should the lady
- 35:17Th- This The simple question is, should
- 35:20the gay person who is thrown off the
- 35:22rooftop of Pin Sus should Should the
- 35:24lady buried into the ground having rocks
- 35:26smashed at her head, which is the law
- 35:28which I'll get to?
- 35:30>> Does it matter
- 35:32what the Quran says when Muslims do not
- 35:34practice it? Does it matter when the
- 35:36Muslims who are professing exactly what
- 35:39you just said
- 35:41are the ones who are saying
- 35:42>> Yep.
- 35:43Now, 25 countries 25 countries where
- 35:47Islam is the state religion have
- 35:49criminal penalties for sex outside of
- 35:51marriage. Nine of them is punishable by
- 35:53death. So, again, you No one needs to
- 35:54have this argument with me. You don't
- 35:55need to convince me, okay? You don't
- 35:57need to convince me.
- 35:58Again, who's protesting about this? Can
- 36:00we at least agree as a room? Can we look
- 36:02for some common ground with the Muslim
- 36:03community?
- 36:04Stoning people for having sex outside of
- 36:06marriage is never okay. It was never
- 36:08okay. It's not okay then, and it's not
- 36:10okay now.
- 36:12>> [snorts]
- 36:12>> Uh since Jewish law says the same thing
- 36:15>> here to talk about Jewish law.
- 36:16>> be suspicious of Jewish law equally?
- 36:17Will you be consistent, sir?
- 36:18>> That's not the question we're here for.
- 36:20If you want to have that question
- 36:21debate, have it, yeah?
- 36:23>> [applause]
- 36:24>> Can we at least agree with the Muslim
- 36:26community, okay? In modern Britain,
- 36:28where you're preaching to what now 4
- 36:29million Muslims, we can just put a line
- 36:31through the verses in the Quran, yeah?
- 36:33The parts of Islam's sacred text that
- 36:35says these things are not okay, they're
- 36:36not practiced now, they weren't okay
- 36:38then, and they're not okay now. Can we
- 36:39meet in the middle somewhere and have
- 36:41have you accept the verses in the Quran
- 36:43today?
- 36:43>> Will will you demand that Orthodox Jews
- 36:46put lines put lines through the the
- 36:48Tanakh?
- 36:49Will you demand that Orthodox Jews put
- 36:51lines through the Tanakh as you are
- 36:52requesting Muslims to do?
- 36:53>> I think you're confused at which debate
- 36:54you're at, okay? And the motion of this
- 36:56debate.
- 36:58Now,
- 36:59>> [applause]
- 37:00>> let's turn
- 37:02to good old Muhammad, okay? According to
- 37:04Islam's sacred text, an exalted example
- 37:07of moral excellence.
- 37:08Well, in 2014, ISIS, again, because it
- 37:11this is important cuz they're following
- 37:12scripture.
- 37:13ISIS, when they captured Yazidi
- 37:16>> Sorry?
- 37:17Ask any Muslim whether they believe ISIS
- 37:19is following Islamic scripture, and you
- 37:21will find that no Muslim agrees that
- 37:23they are actually Islamic.
- 37:27>> Once again, once again,
- 37:32>> Let me ask Let me ask you a question.
- 37:33Let me ask
- 37:33>> I'm sorry, Madam President. The point
- 37:35The point has been made. You must allow
- 37:36the speaker to continue.
- 37:37>> 2014, ISIS executed captured Yazidi men
- 37:40and boys. And what they'd done is they
- 37:42pulled their pants down, they
- 37:43surrendered, they pulled their pants
- 37:44down. Anyone who's had any pubic hair
- 37:47was shot in the head, and some of them
- 37:49had their heads cut off with knives. You
- 37:50can watch the videos if you want online,
- 37:51yeah?
- 37:52Okay? They were following the example of
- 37:54Muhammad, who according to Islam's own
- 37:56sacred text presided over the execution
- 37:59of up to 900 men and boys, which was the
- 38:01Jewish tribe who had surrendered, and
- 38:03any male prisoner Any male Let me
- 38:05finish. Any male prisoner who had pubic
- 38:08hair
- 38:09was executed. That is what the practice
- 38:11that the Muslims in 2014 were following.
- 38:13This is why scripture is important and
- 38:15then why we must be suspicious. Now,
- 38:18consider the fact I'll just finish,
- 38:19please. Consider the fact that there are
- 38:21no Jews, none, in any of the 26
- 38:24countries where Islam is a state
- 38:26religion, countries which once held
- 38:28thriving Jewish communities. This is not
- 38:30an accident, and there are precious few
- 38:32Christians in any of these Islamic
- 38:33countries, either, that once had
- 38:35majority Christian populations. You see,
- 38:37one way or another, these countries are
- 38:39following the example of Muhammad. "I
- 38:41will certainly expel the Jews and
- 38:43Christians Excuse me, can I just finish?
- 38:45I will certainly expel the Jews and
- 38:47Christians from the Arabian Peninsula
- 38:49and will not leave any but Muslim."
- 38:51That's a quote of Muhammad, Sahih
- 38:53Muslim, Sahih being the authentic,
- 38:56considered most authentic hadith.
- 38:58Please, can I just finish?
- 39:00>> One more question.
- 39:00>> Thank you.
- 39:02>> On the point On the point On the point
- 39:03On the point, sorry.
- 39:04>> You do not have to accept
- 39:05>> No, it doesn't.
- 39:05>> No, do you like having it?
- 39:07>> Okay. So, of course,
- 39:10put your hands up if you think it's okay
- 39:13for a man older than most of your dads,
- 39:16saying they're 50s, to marry someone in
- 39:18infant school. Let's say 6 years old.
- 39:20And can he consummate that marriage,
- 39:22rape, when the little girl reaches 9? By
- 39:24the way, that's year five doing key
- 39:26stage two.
- 39:27Doing key stage two. No, please, cuz I
- 39:29know many of you gentlemen should have
- 39:30your hands up at this point, no?
- 39:32We're going to get onto it, but you
- 39:33agree that Muhammad was perfect as we as
- 39:35we know. He had He married a 6-year-old,
- 39:37had sex with her when she was 9. We've
- 39:39had We've previously had this
- 39:40discussion, Andalusian.
- 39:42Do you think children should be
- 39:43suspicious of Islam who are studying key
- 39:45stage two?
- 39:46Now, please, can I just finish?
- 39:48And of course, can I please finish this?
- 39:50Please let me finish. You can get
- 39:51>> speaker declined. Please let the speaker
- 39:53continue.
- 39:55>> And I must mention Quran 65:4, where God
- 40:00debatable God spells out the rules for
- 40:03divorcing prepubescent children. Okay?
- 40:06So, let me read it.
- 40:08"And for those who have no courses, not
- 40:10yet started your periods,
- 40:12who are still immature,
- 40:14their iddah, their wait waiting period,
- 40:16is three months." What has happened for
- 40:19child to be married, and this is the
- 40:20Quran telling you what the rules are and
- 40:22obligations to divorce a child before
- 40:25they've started puberty. Yeah?
- 40:27Can we be suspicious on this question?
- 40:29Is this No, please, can I finish then?
- 40:32And to be quite be honest, I'm just
- 40:33here. I'm the extremist apparently.
- 40:36Yeah?
- 40:36I'm the extremist for not wanting
- 40:38homosexuals thrown off rooftops, not
- 40:39wanting women buried in the ground, and
- 40:41not wanting children studying key stage
- 40:42two to be married and raped. So, of the
- 40:4510 countries with the highest rates of
- 40:47child marriage, seven of them are
- 40:49Islamic countries. There's no minimum
- 40:50age in Sudan, Somalia, Saudi Arabia,
- 40:53Yemen, cuz there's no minimum age in
- 40:55Islam.
- 40:56But whatever the state of legal age of
- 40:57marriage is in some Muslim countries,
- 40:59forced marriage of young girls, often to
- 41:01much older men, is prevalent in
- 41:03Afghanistan, in Pakistan, in Bangladesh,
- 41:06Burkina Faso, Yemen, I could go on and
- 41:09on. UNICEF data shows, for all of you
- 41:11ladies who care about women and
- 41:13children's rights, UNICEF data shows
- 41:15child brides are unlikely to finish
- 41:17education, more likely to believe wife
- 41:20beating is justified, and more likely to
- 41:22have experienced intimate partner
- 41:24violence. I'd just like to finish
- 41:26Please, guys, I'm I apologize.
- 41:28Can we at least agree executing
- 41:30prisoners of war, including young boys,
- 41:32carrying out ethnic cleansing of Jews
- 41:34and Christians from the lands, or
- 41:35marrying and having sex with a little
- 41:37child when Muhammad was 53 years old,
- 41:39can we at least agree today
- 41:42Muhammad was not and is not the perfect
- 41:44example for mankind, nor is he an
- 41:46exalted example of moral excellence.
- 41:49Quite the opposite, in fact. Because if
- 41:51we can't agree this, then the West is
- 41:53right to be suspicious of Islam because
- 41:56of what the sacred text says,
- 41:58because of how millions of Muslims
- 42:00interpret the sacred text, because of
- 42:02how Muhammad's life is held up as the
- 42:04perfect example
- 42:06not back then, but now, for all Muslims
- 42:09to follow. That's the problem. They
- 42:10don't recognize any of the problems and
- 42:12see anything wrong with Mohammed done.
- 42:14So ladies and gentlemen, if you care
- 42:16about gay rights,
- 42:17if you care about women's rights, if you
- 42:19care about children's rights, if you
- 42:21care about human rights, or if you care
- 42:23about free speech,
- 42:25I urge you to support this motion.
- 42:28>> [applause]
- 42:32>> I thank the honorable gentleman for
- 42:34advancing the case for the proposition
- 42:36and I call upon Mr. McAward
- 42:38to continue the case for the opposition.
- 42:41>> Okay.
- 42:43So first of all, I'd like to start by
- 42:45thanking Oxford Union for inviting me to
- 42:46speak here. I am truly honored and I'm
- 42:49very grateful to be. I never thought
- 42:51I'd be here to be honest. I've made a
- 42:53new friend of me, Jacob Rees-Mogg. So
- 42:55you know, this is I've had a nice meal,
- 42:57some halal chicken which I'm sure Tommy
- 42:58enjoyed. Um
- 43:00So I'm just thanking the and Liam of
- 43:03course likes a bit of halal chicken now.
- 43:04So I know you do, mate. So I'll just
- 43:07thank I'll just take this opportunity to
- 43:08thank you guys. So the the real question
- 43:11I believe the first question was is
- 43:12should the West be suspicious of Islam?
- 43:15Was that a question of the debate?
- 43:17You're not in your head so it must be.
- 43:19Hm?
- 43:19Right. So Tommy, you've been
- 43:21Wait, I'm going to know why I'm here but
- 43:22I'm going to answer that. Tommy's been
- 43:23saying the same thing for 15 years and
- 43:25still has to read it.
- 43:27Yeah, but you still have to read it. So
- 43:29obviously you don't know your case that
- 43:30well. So should the West be
- 43:33Proven right. Yeah, well of course you
- 43:34are, mate. So should the West be
- 43:36suspicious
- 43:37>> Point of order. Do you allow people to
- 43:38cut cut in without permission from the
- 43:40speaker?
- 43:41>> Um I think we ask that speeches be heard
- 43:45in some courtesy, gentlemen. If the
- 43:47point of information is declined,
- 43:49then please simply allow the speaker to
- 43:51continue.
- 43:52>> mind taking questions.
- 43:53>> Well
- 43:54it is for the speaker to choose whether
- 43:56a point of information is accepted.
- 43:58With that, Mr. McAward, please continue.
- 44:01>> I haven't started yet. Give me a minute.
- 44:03Right. So
- 44:04should the should the West be suspicious
- 44:06of Islam? Well, the truth of that is
- 44:08it's going to depend. Okay? It's going
- 44:09to depend if you're invested in
- 44:11pornography, if you're invested in
- 44:12alcohol, if you're invested in interest
- 44:14banking, if you're invested in drink,
- 44:16drugs, criminality, then probably you
- 44:18should be suspicious of Islam because
- 44:20Islam has come as an alternative way of
- 44:22life to that. Islam What is it?
- 44:24>> Uh could we add Judaism to that list?
- 44:26>> You can do sure. Okay? But I mean you
- 44:28can't become a Jew. So so so not very
- 44:31easily. So
- 44:33so Islam has come as an Islam has come
- 44:36as a option, an alternative to those
- 44:38vices in this world. Okay? The real
- 44:41question should be The real question
- 44:43should be Should the West be suspicious
- 44:45of Muslims practicing Islam in the West?
- 44:47That's the question. And why? Why would
- 44:49you be? Because Tommy says so? Because
- 44:51Tommy said that you should be suspicious
- 44:53of this religion and suspicious of
- 44:54practicing or I don't know extreme
- 44:56Muslims, okay? So let's talk a little
- 44:58bit about Tommy's credibility because
- 45:00Tommy has spent the last 15 years of
- 45:03building his credibility upon being a
- 45:05white man from Luton. And he's been Go
- 45:08on.
- 45:08>> This debate is not about Tommy Robinson.
- 45:10>> It's it's about it's
- 45:12It's about [cheering]
- 45:13It's I'm getting to it. All right, sit
- 45:14down. Sit down.
- 45:16Sit down.
- 45:17>> The gentleman's made his point. Please
- 45:19take your seat.
- 45:19>> Sit down.
- 45:21And are you in it as well? Are you in it
- 45:23as well?
- 45:23>> The speaker will be heard.
- 45:25>> Are you in it as well?
- 45:26I don't mind taking out the lot of you,
- 45:28mate. I don't mind. It's not a problem.
- 45:29Listen. So
- 45:31the credibility is it's important to
- 45:33base it to credibility, okay? In the
- 45:35debate, of course. In the debate, of
- 45:37course. It's important
- 45:38>> Gentlemen,
- 45:39gentlemen, please take your seats. Both
- 45:42of you gentlemen
- 45:42>> He he just said he doesn't mind taking
- 45:43us out. So we have a Muslim again. Yeah.
- 45:46In the debate, of course. In the debate,
- 45:48of course.
- 45:48>> Can I ask you just to take your seats?
- 45:50Mr. Dawood, can I ask you to stop
- 45:51speaking for 1 second? Speakers will be
- 45:54heard with courtesy. If a point of
- 45:57information is offered and it is in
- 45:59decline
- 46:01can I please ask that you allow the
- 46:02speaker to continue? Equally, may I say
- 46:04to the speaker it is expected
- 46:07that points of information will be taken
- 46:09during your speech.
- 46:10>> I've took about four or five so far.
- 46:11>> that, sir. And with that, I will ask the
- 46:13speaker to continue.
- 46:14Gentlemen, gentlemen, can I can I please
- 46:16ask no interjections
- 46:19other than points of information?
- 46:20>> Point of order, chairman. The point of
- 46:22order is which you briefed us must be
- 46:24taken.
- 46:25A threat to take out people on the other
- 46:27side is unacceptable.
- 46:29>> Totally.
- 46:29>> And should be dealt with
- 46:32>> [applause]
- 46:33>> Mr. Dawud, Mr. Dawud, have you made such
- 46:36a threat? And if so, I must ask you to
- 46:38withdraw it.
- 46:38>> It was a threat within the debate to
- 46:40take them within the debate because
- 46:41we're in a debating forum.
- 46:43>> Mr. Dawud, can I ask you
- 46:45>> [applause]
- 46:45>> Can I ask you in that case to moderate
- 46:47your language?
- 46:48>> I will retract what I said. I will
- 46:49retract what I said. I will retract what
- 46:51I said. If that's a doable thing. Right.
- 46:53So, let me let me get on. He's built his
- 46:55credibility from coming from Luton and
- 46:56telling people that Luton now is now a
- 46:58Muslim run town. Predominantly, it has
- 47:0140-something mosques. It has some
- 47:03extremist Muslim extremist this and
- 47:04that, Sharia run courts. But I'm also
- 47:07from Luton.
- 47:09You know, and I've also been in Luton
- 47:10for 56 years. I was born there and I'm
- 47:12still there. I'm still living on the
- 47:14manner. As far as I know, Tommy hasn't
- 47:15lived there for at least 10 years. I
- 47:17believe now he lives in Spain, like most
- 47:19good patriots do. They move on to Spain.
- 47:21So, let's talk a little bit about
- 47:23Tommy's time in Luton because it's it's
- 47:25I've not going to do any more of you.
- 47:26All right? So, talking about his little
- 47:28bit of time that he had in Luton it's
- 47:30well documented that Tommy was in the
- 47:32Luton firm for the mix.
- 47:33>> Point of information. This debate is not
- 47:36about Tommy Robinson, what he does in
- 47:38his free time, what he thinks about it.
- 47:40It's about whether the West should be
- 47:43suspicious of Islam.
- 47:45>> He's the one telling the West to be
- 47:46suspicious of Islam. So, it's important
- 47:48that I class his I take his credibility
- 47:51about how to say that. Okay? The
- 47:53arguments that he had in Luton while he
- 47:55was in the mix, which is the Luton Town
- 47:56football
- 47:57firm, gang, whatever it is. Most towns
- 47:59and cities have them, okay?
- 48:01That's where he's from. There was other
- 48:02gangs in Luton.
- 48:04Wasn't the only one. No, there was there
- 48:06was other gangs in Luton. One of them
- 48:07was called the Gambinos. One of them was
- 48:09called the Yellows. I know these are
- 48:10ridiculous names, but we are talking
- 48:12ridiculous people in these gangs at the
- 48:13time.
- 48:14Let me finish, please, okay? So, I've
- 48:16taken a few points of information. You
- 48:18just seem to be doing it now just to
- 48:19stifle because No, I'm not taking any
- 48:20from you, okay?
- 48:22Okay? The
- 48:23>> Mr. Robinson, please.
- 48:24>> that these gangs had, as Tommy would
- 48:26say, was either religious and or racial
- 48:28between Pakistanis and his football guys
- 48:31was really not racial. It wasn't racial,
- 48:33it wasn't religious. It was normally,
- 48:35like most gangs, supply and demand of
- 48:37product, okay? That's what it comes down
- 48:39to. Tommy would also Tommy would also
- 48:41say that there was an extremist group in
- 48:43Luton.
- 48:44No, there was an extremist group in
- 48:45Luton called Al-Muhajiroun.
- 48:48I agree with him. It was an extremist
- 48:49group, and I made my opposition to this
- 48:52group vocal at that time when they was
- 48:54there, you know? But even a broken clock
- 48:56can be right twice a day. This group was
- 48:58tiny. It was eight strong at most with
- 49:01maybe eight hangers-on, one foot in, one
- 49:03foot out. They were barred from every
- 49:05mosque I knew. I don't know all of the
- 49:06mosques, but they were barred from every
- 49:07mosque that I knew. Most of the shops in
- 49:09the town
- 49:11the Muslim shops, they didn't want to
- 49:12let them in, either. But the
- 49:13amplification of their message was done
- 49:15by the media. The media would go to the
- 49:18predominantly Muslim populated area in
- 49:19Luton called Bury Park. They'd walk down
- 49:21there with a camera. They'd stick it in
- 49:22front of these guys, and they would be
- 49:23straight in front of it. It wasn't
- 49:26amplified deliberately to cause friction
- 49:28between communities. That small
- 49:30extremist group doesn't exist anymore. I
- 49:32believe they've been disbanded, and they
- 49:34don't they don't even hang around with
- 49:36each other anymore.
- 49:37I I could tell you Yes.
- 49:41Okay.
- 49:42>> If
- 49:44you consume
- 49:46consume drugs, and if you lend money for
- 49:48interest, you should be suspicious of
- 49:49Islam.
- 49:51>> No, I said if you invested in
- 49:52>> Why should we?
- 49:53>> Because Islam has come as an alternate
- 49:55choice to that. Islam is Islam has come
- 49:57as an alternate way of life to that. I
- 49:59think I explained it when I mentioned it
- 50:00the first time.
- 50:01There's a lot more that I want to tell
- 50:02you. Time does not permit me to speak
- 50:04here for an hour. So, obviously, I can't
- 50:06go into detail about everything. I know
- 50:08in detail about this group of
- 50:10Al-Muhajiroun cuz I was one of the
- 50:12trusted go-betweens from mosques in
- 50:14Luton that was trying to get them to
- 50:16stop talking. As he says, a lot of the
- 50:18time that there's not enough calling out
- 50:19of Muslims in the public.
- 50:21But, it is. It does happen. There was
- 50:23500 mosques that wrote an email
- 50:26condemning the grooming gangs, but it
- 50:27never really got out there. And they all
- 50:29done that, okay? They done that years
- 50:31ago. I think it's 2013. Anyway, these
- 50:34these mosques in Luton was go a
- 50:35go-between between the Al-Muhajiroun
- 50:38group and the mosque was me because I
- 50:39was a trusted go-between. Even though I
- 50:40was anti this group, they still trusted
- 50:43me to go between them. And I know that
- 50:44most of Luton didn't want them there. It
- 50:46wasn't the case, okay? Like I said,
- 50:49I would I would love to say more.
- 50:51There's a lot more beans that I could
- 50:52spill, to be quite honest with you. So,
- 50:53let me give you a version of Luton that
- 50:55I recognize. Tommy has a version of
- 50:57Luton that he recognizes. Tommy has a
- 50:59version of Luton that he recognizes. Let
- 51:01me give you a couple of points of the
- 51:03Luton that I recognize, okay? And I'll
- 51:05firstly go back to the first lockdown in
- 51:07COVID
- 51:08where everyone was social distancing and
- 51:10taking it seriously and everything else.
- 51:12There was a Muslim charity in Luton and
- 51:14it's still there, actually. There was a
- 51:16Muslim charity in Luton we were hand I
- 51:17was volunteering for them cuz I was off
- 51:19work for a few weeks, okay? Due to the
- 51:20building sites shutting down. We were
- 51:22handing out food packs.
- 51:24Muslims were coming and handing in food
- 51:26and or giving us money to buy food from
- 51:28supermarkets or whatever.
- 51:30I'm going to say 99%, but it was more
- 51:32realistically 100%, but I'll say 99%.
- 51:36The food packs that I personally handed
- 51:38out were to white old age pensioners
- 51:40that lived in old age pensioner homes or
- 51:42care homes. I never once handed it out
- 51:44to a Muslim family, a Polish family, or
- 51:47any other but it was purely white old
- 51:49age pensioners.
- 51:49>> information. You just asked what was
- 51:50charity. Hm? What charity?
- 51:52>> A crisis aid.
- 51:54Okay? The And it's still there. It's in
- 51:55Sundon Park, okay? Right. So, the it's
- 51:58still there, the charity, okay? So, we
- 52:00was handing out these things. I remember
- 52:02one 90-year-old man. He had to buzz me
- 52:04into his care home, and I put the um
- 52:06bags outside and had to step up the
- 52:07hallway because there was um social
- 52:10distancing. He come out buckled in half.
- 52:12He so I was trying to speak to him. He
- 52:14told me, "I've got cancer. I'm 93 years
- 52:16old, and I'm going to die soon. And none
- 52:18of my family speak to me. None of my
- 52:20family help me." This is the Islam in in
- 52:22Luton that I recognize. Let me give you
- 52:24another one. I was in Farley Hill, not
- 52:26opposite the at the Parrot pub. That
- 52:27Tommy would have remembered, okay? There
- 52:29was a care home. I was working there for
- 52:31BTS the council. What?
- 52:33>> And during the start of this meeting, I
- 52:34was confused about the the motion at the
- 52:36beginning.
- 52:37>> Yeah, I'm not confused. I'm you I'm not
- 52:39confused.
- 52:39>> It's about Islam.
- 52:40>> I know. I'm I'm talking about Islam. If
- 52:41you remember, I've said Islam quite a
- 52:42lot in my talk, okay? Don't stand up for
- 52:44a point of cuz I'm done with you now,
- 52:46yeah? So, listen. So, I was working at
- 52:48this care home. I was working at this
- 52:50care home, and a taxi come pulling in,
- 52:52okay? I noticed that one of the women
- 52:54was in the in the passenger seat. She
- 52:56clearly was distressed. This big fat
- 52:59Pakistani brother with a big black beard
- 53:01jumped out, opened the car door. She had
- 53:03fallen over in the street. He'd picked
- 53:04her up, put her in the car, and he'd
- 53:05brought her back to the uh care home. He
- 53:08was literally in tears. He wanted my
- 53:09number. He wanted to go to the hospital.
- 53:11Why are you suspicious of these people?
- 53:13Who are these people to be suspicious
- 53:14of? Who are these people to be
- 53:16suspicious of, okay? Tommy is desperate
- 53:18to make connections between crime and
- 53:20Islam, especially when it comes to SA
- 53:22crimes. He desperate to make this
- 53:24connection between the crime and Islam,
- 53:26even though nobody that commits these
- 53:27crimes says that they did it because of
- 53:29Islam. But when it comes to Muslims that
- 53:31do good things, NHS workers, doctors,
- 53:33nurses, uh charity care sector workers,
- 53:35which Islam is overrepresented in those
- 53:38in those areas,
- 53:40>> [applause]
- 53:40>> never
- 53:42does he want to make the connection
- 53:43between Muslims doing good deeds and
- 53:45Islam? It's only No, I told you already.
- 53:47I No, never does he make the connection
- 53:49between Muslims doing good deeds and
- 53:51Islam. In fact, actually, when you ask
- 53:53these doctors, nurses, care workers,
- 53:55charity sector workers, why do you do
- 53:57it? They'll say because my religion
- 53:58tells me to be a good person. My
- 54:00religion tells me to be in service of
- 54:01the people. He doesn't want to hear
- 54:02that. He just wants to paint this
- 54:04picture. You
- 54:06You cannot serve two masters.
- 54:08You can only be loyal to one master. And
- 54:10I'll tell you now, without any
- 54:11hesitation, my master is Allah. La ilaha
- 54:14illallah. There is no god worthy of
- 54:16worship except Allah. Okay? But my god
- 54:19tells me how to serve you. My god tells
- 54:22me how to serve you. Okay? So, I don't I
- 54:24can be in service I don't care if you're
- 54:25Muslim, non-Muslim, black, white, fat,
- 54:27thin, short, tall. I don't care. I will
- 54:29serve you because my religion and my
- 54:31master, Allah, tells me how to be in
- 54:33service to my community. No.
- 54:35>> [applause]
- 54:36>> No. No.
- 54:38I will give you many.
- 54:40>> Mr. Jones lines. Thank you.
- 54:42>> I've done more than two. Right. I will
- 54:44give you multiple examples. I will give
- 54:46you multiple examples of Muslims, people
- 54:48that have changed their lives and become
- 54:50better fathers, better husbands, better
- 54:52community members, better people in
- 54:54society, better daughters, better wives,
- 54:56better better people in society because
- 54:58they've accepted Islam. Some of them are
- 55:00sitting in this room today. Maybe I
- 55:01could put myself in that category as
- 55:03well. Why are you suspicious? Why are
- 55:05you suspicious of these people? What
- 55:07they Only Islam has only ever brought
- 55:09good to them and made them better
- 55:10citizens. Why would you be suspicious?
- 55:12And of course
- 55:13And of course
- 55:15Yes, you can yawn. You know, this is
- 55:17this is this is what you do. It's not a
- 55:18problem. I'm not here for you. Yeah, and
- 55:20it's past mine, too. Okay? Of course I
- 55:22want to spread Islam. Who would I be if
- 55:24I had the truth and didn't want to share
- 55:26it with you people? Who would I be if I
- 55:28knew that Islam, or believed at least
- 55:30that Islam was the truth, and I didn't
- 55:31want to share it with you people cuz I
- 55:32thought it was the best thing. If I had
- 55:34a big plate of food and you was hungry
- 55:36and it it cost me nothing to give you
- 55:38food. It cost me nothing. No, it cost me
- 55:40No, it cost me nothing to give you food,
- 55:44why would I not give you food? Why?
- 55:46I don't want to do any more points of
- 55:47call. You You was devoided and you're
- 55:49saying
- 55:49>> have that one, maybe it's Muslims giving
- 55:50charity
- 55:51>> Gentlemen, gentlemen.
- 55:52>> Sorry?
- 55:52>> As long as Muslims giving charity
- 55:54and numbers
- 55:54>> No, there isn't.
- 55:55>> No, there isn't.
- 55:56>> Gentlemen, gentlemen, please. Thank you.
- 55:58>> No, there isn't. There isn't. There
- 55:59isn't.
- 55:59>> Mr. Dowd to finish his decline of point
- 56:01of information.
- 56:02>> That's enough. That's enough.
- 56:04I've said it. That's enough.
- 56:05>> Uh
- 56:06speakers on this side have been
- 56:07egregious in attack on the
- 56:09>> Yes, it's been a constant. It's okay.
- 56:11>> Can the chair, please, take some action?
- 56:14>> [applause]
- 56:15>> Okay. Bro,
- 56:16thank you. I I I work better under
- 56:18pressure.
- 56:19I work better under pressure.
- 56:21>> I can ask you to stop one second. I
- 56:22thank the honorable gentleman for that
- 56:23point of order. I think on both sides
- 56:25there have been unwarranted
- 56:26interjections.
- 56:27>> Yeah.
- 56:28>> Point of order, if declined,
- 56:30please take your seat again. Do not
- 56:32continue to interject. I will say to the
- 56:34honorable gentleman, I have seen that
- 56:35from both sides this evening. It is not,
- 56:38as he puts it on one side only. On both
- 56:40sides. Point of information is declined,
- 56:43please take your seat again. Mr. Dowd,
- 56:45please continue.
- 56:46>> Okay. So, why would I not want to spread
- 56:47Islam? Why would I wish that I could
- 56:49take my heart and give it to you people
- 56:52for a minute so you could taste the
- 56:53sweetness of Iman, and then you would
- 56:55never be suspicious of Muslims again.
- 56:57There is not a single head on anyone's
- 56:59hair, apart from Tufayl's, that I would
- 57:02touch unjustly, and that's inside and
- 57:04outside of this hall. They I mean no
- 57:06harm to anybody. I will defend myself if
- 57:08I have to, but no Muslim that I know
- 57:10thinks like that either. Why wouldn't I
- 57:12want to share that? Where is the problem
- 57:13with that? I want to My friend here, my
- 57:15colleague, is going to deal with the age
- 57:16of Aisha. I dealt with it for 10 or 11
- 57:18minutes on Liam's podcast, so I don't
- 57:20think that I need to
- 57:21go into that again. My friend will deal
- 57:23with that, okay? You mentioned the verse
- 57:24in the Quran about prepubescent women
- 57:26being married. It's not true. Okay, if
- 57:28you knew what you were talking about,
- 57:29you wouldn't have said it. The word
- 57:30that's used for the
- 57:32the for the female in the Quran is a
- 57:33word that's used for women. That ayah of
- 57:35the Quran was revealed because a man
- 57:37come to ask the prophet what how do I
- 57:39divorce my wife if she does not have
- 57:41periods because she is past the age of
- 57:43period. She's a mature woman. That's
- 57:45what that was for. Then the verse is
- 57:47revealed.
- 57:48>> [applause]
- 57:49>> No, that's not that's that's what it is.
- 57:50You're not an expert on the Quran.
- 57:52You're not an expert on Islam. You you
- 57:54present yourself to be an expert to
- 57:55people that don't know any better, but
- 57:57you're not talking to those people
- 57:58today. No. No more points for
- 58:00information.
- 58:01No more points for information. We talk
- 58:03about We talk about I'll be 1 second,
- 58:05yeah, 1 minute. We talk about reform.
- 58:06They talk about want to reform Islam.
- 58:08How dare he? How dare they and they how
- 58:11dare he say a man that is ignorant
- 58:13within the religion of Islam talk about
- 58:15reforming of Islam, okay? His people
- 58:18that come to talk here are people of
- 58:19intelligence, people of professorships,
- 58:21people that are intellects in their
- 58:22field. This man is not an intellect in
- 58:25the field or an authority in the field
- 58:26of Islam and his presence about talking
- 58:28about Islam is a disservice to this
- 58:30place.
- 58:31>> [applause]
- 58:36>> I thank the honorable gentleman for that
- 58:38speech advancing the opposition. I call
- 58:41upon Mr. Lawrence Fox to continue the
- 58:43case for the proposition.
- 58:49>> Do I need to raise this up or is it
- 58:52suitably heightened for the Luton
- 58:54community?
- 58:56Um
- 58:58Before Neville Chamberlain flew to
- 59:00Germany to appease Adolf Hitler,
- 59:03he said European peace is what I'm
- 59:05aiming at and I hope this journey may
- 59:08open the way to get it.
- 59:10And here we are, 87 years later, and
- 59:13European peace and peace in the West is
- 59:16being threatened again.
- 59:18Upon his return from Germany with his
- 59:21piece of paper, Chamberlain said, "We
- 59:24are resolved that the method of
- 59:25consultation
- 59:27shall be the method adopted to deal with
- 59:29any other questions that may concern our
- 59:31two countries. And 338 days later,
- 59:34Britain was at war [clears throat] with
- 59:36Germany.
- 59:37So, this morning I was thinking about
- 59:40this debate and the worthiness of
- 59:41consultation
- 59:43which Chamberlain invoked. And the
- 59:46motion this house believes the West is
- 59:47right to be suspicious of Islam.
- 59:50And then I started thinking about a
- 59:51cartoon
- 59:54that I have here in December night.
- 59:57It's a cartoon which
- 1:00:00I think it instills in me feelings much,
- 1:00:03much more worrying than suspicion.
- 1:00:07But
- 1:00:09you know, in the spirit of consultation,
- 1:00:11I'll just leave it here for the moment
- 1:00:12if we're okay with that.
- 1:00:15So, first let us start with the word
- 1:00:18suspicion.
- 1:00:20There was a minority, going back to
- 1:00:22Chamberlain and that brilliant foreign
- 1:00:23policy, there was a minority who were
- 1:00:26greatly suspicious of fascism
- 1:00:28leading up to the Second World War and
- 1:00:30were very vocal in that suspicion, who
- 1:00:32thought that Chamberlain's appeasement
- 1:00:34policy was just wrong.
- 1:00:35That far from being the peace in our
- 1:00:37time he promised,
- 1:00:39our appeasement would only serve to
- 1:00:40embolden Hitler.
- 1:00:43One of those who faced the most
- 1:00:45criticism for his prescience, suspicious
- 1:00:48prescience perhaps, was Winston
- 1:00:50Churchill. He saw fascism for what it
- 1:00:53was,
- 1:00:54an existential threat to the West.
- 1:00:58No one needs a history lesson from me,
- 1:01:01but it is possibly worth noting now,
- 1:01:04especially here, and thanks to our
- 1:01:06lovely friends outside,
- 1:01:08that it is perfectly acceptable
- 1:01:10and actually encouraged in every school,
- 1:01:12university, TV channel, and media
- 1:01:15organization across the West to be
- 1:01:17suspicious
- 1:01:18of fascism. In fact, if we listen to our
- 1:01:21friends outside, that's not enough.
- 1:01:23You've got to be an anti-fascist. You've
- 1:01:26got to take direct action against
- 1:01:27fascism.
- 1:01:30Chamberlain today just seems like a
- 1:01:31moronic simpleton to me.
- 1:01:34So, perhaps the deaths of millions of
- 1:01:35people could have been avoided if only
- 1:01:37Churchill's suspicion
- 1:01:39had been heeded.
- 1:01:41That his perspective acknowledged, but
- 1:01:44he stood alone whilst the train
- 1:01:46continued to hurtle towards us because
- 1:01:48we didn't want to upset anybody.
- 1:01:50It is an entirely natural and positive
- 1:01:54human instinct to be suspicious of many
- 1:01:57things.
- 1:01:58From teaching our children not to get in
- 1:02:00cars with strangers
- 1:02:02to friends checking in on each other
- 1:02:03when one is going on a date with a new
- 1:02:05person for the first time, suspicion is
- 1:02:07healthy. It sparks in every single sinew
- 1:02:09of our being. It is the product of
- 1:02:12generational generational caution in
- 1:02:14pursuit of survival.
- 1:02:16It's central to our very fundamentalist
- 1:02:19of instincts. It isn't prejudice, it's
- 1:02:21prudence. Suspicion isn't hatred,
- 1:02:23either.
- 1:02:24It's pattern recognition. And I would
- 1:02:27like to make it clear at this point, I
- 1:02:28would like to thank you so much for
- 1:02:30inviting us to have this debate, and I
- 1:02:31know you've struggled so much with
- 1:02:33people trying to cancel you, and I know
- 1:02:35exactly what that feels like. So, thank
- 1:02:36you so much.
- 1:02:40That's
- 1:02:41>> [applause]
- 1:02:44>> I think I would like to make it very
- 1:02:45clear that I am not here to express
- 1:02:49suspicions
- 1:02:50of individual Muslims at all. There are
- 1:02:52many Muslims, including within my own
- 1:02:55family, who I love deeply. And as a
- 1:02:57Christian, I'm commanded to love my
- 1:03:00neighbor and to pray for my enemy. It is
- 1:03:03my most strongly held belief on this
- 1:03:06planet that every single human life is
- 1:03:08sacred, and all lives matter.
- 1:03:13>> [applause]
- 1:03:16>> But I am not I'm absolutely not and I
- 1:03:19will not
- 1:03:21be commanded to love or submit to ideas
- 1:03:23or ideologies. As was mentioned earlier,
- 1:03:25as Jesus said, render to Caesar what is
- 1:03:27Caesar. Within one directive, he created
- 1:03:30the separation between church and state,
- 1:03:32which is in which in Islam does not
- 1:03:34exist.
- 1:03:35Which literally in well, Islam literally
- 1:03:37means submission. So, there is no
- 1:03:39church. There is no state. There is only
- 1:03:42Islam.
- 1:03:43My suspicion of Islam, therefore, is
- 1:03:45strongly and I think reasonably held.
- 1:03:49Islam is a comprehensive social,
- 1:03:51political, and military doctrine which
- 1:03:52leaves no part of its followers' lives
- 1:03:54untouched. As Andrew Hussey, the British
- 1:03:56historian, says, Islam is more closely
- 1:03:59resembles a ruthlessly efficient war
- 1:04:00machine than a religion. Islam is
- 1:04:03borderless, expansionary, and interested
- 1:04:06only in submission to Allah. And then
- 1:04:09for us, unfortunate well, for some of
- 1:04:12us, unfortunate non-believers, we're
- 1:04:13given three choices.
- 1:04:15>> information.
- 1:04:16Uh when was the last time there was a
- 1:04:17jihad declared against a foreign
- 1:04:19government and the expansion of Muslim
- 1:04:21lands into non-Muslim lands? When was
- 1:04:23the last time?
- 1:04:24>> What are you talking about? What are you
- 1:04:25What are you talking about?
- 1:04:25>> Well, you said that it's a military war
- 1:04:26machine. It's been around for quite a
- 1:04:27long time.
- 1:04:28>> A point of order has been raised,
- 1:04:30>> When you are giving points of
- 1:04:32information,
- 1:04:33you need to be very audible so that the
- 1:04:35microphone picks it
- 1:04:36>> I I I I
- 1:04:37I thank the ex-president for his I I'm
- 1:04:39not sure that's a point of order.
- 1:04:40>> I I I I'm also
- 1:04:42as people may may or may not have
- 1:04:44noticed, I'm not into I'm not an Islamic
- 1:04:46scholar and I'm not into giving you a
- 1:04:47history lesson about the Quran. But, I
- 1:04:50will give you a history lesson into the
- 1:04:51bits of the Quran that I understand and
- 1:04:52the bits of Islam I understand through
- 1:04:54those that I love and from my readings.
- 1:04:56So, Islam gives you three options as far
- 1:04:59as I can tell as a Westerner, submit,
- 1:05:03pay the jizya, the tax, which
- 1:05:04institutionalizes inferior status for
- 1:05:07non-Muslims in Islamic states, or excuse
- 1:05:09me, excuse me, three, war with Muslims.
- 1:05:13Right.
- 1:05:15Notably, within those three options that
- 1:05:17Islam offers you, there is not one
- 1:05:19option which says, "Let's live in
- 1:05:21peaceful coexistence as equals in a
- 1:05:23pluralistic society." Not once. Not once
- 1:05:26does it say that.
- 1:05:29>> I'm certain you are aware that there is
- 1:05:31an entire chapter in the Quran
- 1:05:33chapter called "O Disbelievers".
- 1:05:36The final line of that verse in the
- 1:05:37Quran is to you is your faith and to me
- 1:05:39is mine.
- 1:05:41Are you aware of that chapter in the
- 1:05:42Quran and are you aware of the teachings
- 1:05:44of tolerance the Quran and the Hadith
- 1:05:46and the Sunnah have taught us for
- 1:05:47centuries?
- 1:05:48>> I'm a Christian. All right, thank you.
- 1:05:50And
- 1:05:52I
- 1:05:53The re-
- 1:05:54I'm just going to explain to you one of
- 1:05:55the reasons why I didn't want to start
- 1:05:56quoting Quran verses was because I
- 1:05:59didn't want to come here and start
- 1:06:01talking about it says here that you chop
- 1:06:02people's heads off, it says here that
- 1:06:04you do that, and it says here that you
- 1:06:05do that. I'm sure that that of the
- 1:06:07excuse me, there are very, very, very
- 1:06:09many verses in the Quran that talk about
- 1:06:11peace and love and happiness. It's just
- 1:06:13all we get is the bombs, the running
- 1:06:16over, the knives, and the beheadings.
- 1:06:18So, I'll move on if that's all right.
- 1:06:19Thank you very much. I'm done. Move on.
- 1:06:21Thank you very much. So, I've said
- 1:06:23notably peaceful coexistence with
- 1:06:26with non-Muslims is not an opportunity
- 1:06:29offered. A position which can reasonably
- 1:06:31held to say that it creates not just
- 1:06:33suspicion but tension within a Western
- 1:06:36secular liberal Christian goldfish bowl
- 1:06:39that Tom Holland tells us we all live
- 1:06:40in, right? That's where we live. We do.
- 1:06:43No one knows anything anymore.
- 1:06:44Everyone's feelings matter. So, one
- 1:06:46thing is certain and it is backed up by
- 1:06:47all the data.
- 1:06:49Muslims living in the West
- 1:06:52are pretty suspicious of us.
- 1:06:55So, I'm not going to talk about how I'm
- 1:06:57why the West should be suspicious of
- 1:06:58Islam. Let's talk about how suspicious
- 1:07:00Islam is of the West. The Policy
- 1:07:01Exchange report titled Unsettled
- 1:07:03Belonging, published in 2016, which
- 1:07:05claims to be the most extensive research
- 1:07:07of British Muslims ever conducted
- 1:07:09revealed that let's do it. 43% of
- 1:07:12British Muslims supported the
- 1:07:13introduction of Sharia, not British law,
- 1:07:15Islamic law. 53%
- 1:07:17preferred to send their children to
- 1:07:18school with strong Muslim values,
- 1:07:20suspicious perhaps of Western ones,
- 1:07:22maybe? I don't know.
- 1:07:24Um
- 1:07:2644% of schools should be able to insist
- 1:07:28on face coverings. Does this sound like
- 1:07:30a community which seeks integration? Do
- 1:07:31we have a right to be suspicious of
- 1:07:33those who reject our values and the
- 1:07:35societal and the societal norms of their
- 1:07:37host country? 24% sympathized with
- 1:07:40violence organized by uh groups to
- 1:07:43protect their religion.
- 1:07:45That's what the Muslims say.
- 1:07:47And 31%
- 1:07:49thought it was more it would that it was
- 1:07:50acceptable to keep more than one wife,
- 1:07:52illegal in Britain but fine in Sharia
- 1:07:54apparently. And 35% believe that the
- 1:07:56Jews have too much power in the UK. 52%
- 1:07:58compulsory halal. I could go on and on
- 1:08:01and on and on. But most important to me
- 1:08:03and most important to me is the free
- 1:08:04speech of this.
- 1:08:07So, let's get this out, shall we?
- 1:08:1078%
- 1:08:13of British Muslims
- 1:08:14believe that no publication
- 1:08:17should publish pictures of Muhammad.
- 1:08:20An overwhelming majority. That rises
- 1:08:23That rises to 87%. That's one That's
- 1:08:26nine out of every 10 Muslims that are
- 1:08:29walking the streets today in a country
- 1:08:31which absolutely abandoned blasphemy
- 1:08:34laws.
- 1:08:35Suspicion is not strong enough word.
- 1:08:38The West should resist Islam in the
- 1:08:40strongest terms on free speech grounds
- 1:08:43alone. So, here we are with this
- 1:08:45cartoon, right?
- 1:08:47And um
- 1:08:50it's time
- 1:08:52to show that I will not submit.
- 1:08:55I will not adhere to the religious laws
- 1:08:57of far-off places. Now, my wife asked me
- 1:09:00not to show this for fear of
- 1:09:01repercussions in in my family, but I
- 1:09:03told her that if I did not, then I would
- 1:09:05already submitted to Islam. So, here we
- 1:09:07are.
- 1:09:09>> Is it not enough that half the team that
- 1:09:11invited you to this debate were Muslim
- 1:09:14women who wanted to hear out your your
- 1:09:16expression and your arguments? Is it not
- 1:09:18enough that I as the Muslim president
- 1:09:19have invited you to this chamber to give
- 1:09:21your arguments?
- 1:09:22Is that not enough justification and
- 1:09:24evidence for you to believe that we do
- 1:09:25believe in free speech? I would not
- 1:09:26become the president of a free speech
- 1:09:27society if I did not.
- 1:09:28>> Thank you [applause] very much.
- 1:09:30All right. May May May I May I In the
- 1:09:33Thank you very much. May May I finish
- 1:09:35May Excuse me.
- 1:09:36>> Order.
- 1:09:37A point of order having been raised, I
- 1:09:38will hear the ex-librarian.
- 1:09:40>> It's a long time since I've been in this
- 1:09:42chamber and knew the rules off by heart,
- 1:09:43but in the House of Commons, and we
- 1:09:45model ourselves on the House of Commons,
- 1:09:47props are not allowed. I wonder whether
- 1:09:50the rule on props is the same in the
- 1:09:53Oxford Union.
- 1:09:55>> I thank the honorable gentleman for his
- 1:09:56point of order.
- 1:09:57>> Um In the In the Excuse me.
- 1:10:00>> So, what for 1 second?
- 1:10:01>> One one moment, Mr. Speaker. This is a
- 1:10:02point of order.
- 1:10:03One One moment, Mr. Speaker. I The
- 1:10:05ex-president is also raising a point of
- 1:10:06order, I think.
- 1:10:07>> I just thought it was helpful to inform
- 1:10:09the ex-librarian that at least my
- 1:10:11political society that banner was not
- 1:10:14extended and didn't seem to provide a
- 1:10:16Israel outside flag.
- 1:10:19>> Thank you. So, right. Um I just want to
- 1:10:21wrap this up.
- 1:10:22>> I am going to rule on the point of
- 1:10:23order. There is no bar in the forms of
- 1:10:26the house against the use of props.
- 1:10:28However, I would encourage Mr. Fox to
- 1:10:30make the point and move on.
- 1:10:31>> I I I I was until points of order. So,
- 1:10:34it is in that spirit that I will not
- 1:10:35submit that I show you this
- 1:10:39as an Englishman who believes in free
- 1:10:40speech.
- 1:10:46I will not submit.
- 1:10:48I WILL NOT BOW DOWN.
- 1:10:51>> [applause]
- 1:10:54>> RIGHT.
- 1:10:55SO,
- 1:10:57I THINK which um rather proves the point
- 1:11:00of
- 1:11:01the point I was trying to make.
- 1:11:03That in this envelope
- 1:11:05lived your fear.
- 1:11:07And your fear of Islam and what Islam
- 1:11:09will do to you that when you when you
- 1:11:12upset it's
- 1:11:14very oversensitive sky wizard. And um
- 1:11:17what lived in this room is a healthy and
- 1:11:19brilliant and noble British tradition of
- 1:11:22suspicion of Islam. I encourage you to
- 1:11:24pass the motion. Thank you very much.
- 1:11:27>> [applause]
- 1:11:30>> I thank the honorable gentleman for that
- 1:11:32speech advancing the proposition.
- 1:11:35And indeed for his uh
- 1:11:37We probably have some pens if you want
- 1:11:38it signed. We can arrange that later on.
- 1:11:41>> It's Hamark.
- 1:11:42>> And I and I now call upon the president
- 1:11:45to continue the case for the opposition.
- 1:11:49>> [applause]
- 1:11:56>> Right.
- 1:12:00There is anger in this room tonight.
- 1:12:04There is anger in homes and on streets
- 1:12:06and throughout communities that no
- 1:12:08longer feel safe
- 1:12:09and no longer feel like they matter.
- 1:12:13Anger from people who feel that no
- 1:12:14government in any party in a generation
- 1:12:17has told them the truth about why their
- 1:12:19lives are the way that they are. Why
- 1:12:21their rent is unpayable, why they cannot
- 1:12:23get a GP appointment, why the country
- 1:12:24they knew is not the country their
- 1:12:26children
- 1:12:27are inheriting.
- 1:12:29I'm not going to stand here tonight and
- 1:12:30tell you your anger is wrong.
- 1:12:32I'm not going to dismiss you as a racist
- 1:12:34for asking honest questions about a
- 1:12:36country that has stopped working for
- 1:12:39you.
- 1:12:40And that is why I wanted this debate to
- 1:12:42be held because we have seen what
- 1:12:44happens when people's anger goes
- 1:12:46unaddressed. It does not disappear.
- 1:12:48It looks for somewhere to go.
- 1:12:50And there are people in this country,
- 1:12:51people on side of the argument, who have
- 1:12:54made it their business to be standing
- 1:12:57there when that anger arrives, ready to
- 1:12:59point it in a direction that serves
- 1:13:01them, and believe me, hurts you.
- 1:13:04The proposition does not have a monopoly
- 1:13:06on that anger.
- 1:13:07Mr. Robinson and Mr. Fox have built
- 1:13:09careers directing that anger at easier
- 1:13:10targets, scapegoating Islam and Muslim
- 1:13:13communities, not because we are the
- 1:13:14cause of your suffering, not because we
- 1:13:17are a direction of your suspicion,
- 1:13:19but because when you are profiting from
- 1:13:21a hollowed-out country, it is safer to
- 1:13:24scapegoat a minority, to set its
- 1:13:25citizens against one another, than it
- 1:13:28ever would be to finally let them ask
- 1:13:30who hollowed their country out in the
- 1:13:32first place.
- 1:13:34But first, let me do what I believe side
- 1:13:36proposition has missed the mark on when
- 1:13:39this discussion is being held. Let me
- 1:13:41reiterate what this motion is and what
- 1:13:43it is not.
- 1:13:44The motion is not "The West is right to
- 1:13:46be suspicious of Salman Abedi, the
- 1:13:48Manchester Arena bomber." The motion is
- 1:13:50not "The West is right to be suspicious
- 1:13:51of jihadist ideologies, of Al-Qaeda, of
- 1:13:54of ISIS, of the examples that you
- 1:13:55presented." I, as a Muslim, and I am
- 1:13:58certain and I can assure you, as many,
- 1:14:00many, many, the vast majority of Muslims
- 1:14:02are equally as suspicious of those
- 1:14:03people, of those organizations, as
- 1:14:05anyone in this room.
- 1:14:07When when let me let me let me get to my
- 1:14:09introduction.
- 1:14:10Let me get to the motion.
- 1:14:12The motion
- 1:14:13is the suspicion of Islam itself, not
- 1:14:15some caricature that has been painted by
- 1:14:18Lawrence or by Tommy, or from selected
- 1:14:20verses in the scripture without context,
- 1:14:22without understanding, without reference
- 1:14:24to any of the verses that preceded it or
- 1:14:25came after it. It is not selective
- 1:14:27understanding by people who do not
- 1:14:29believe in Islam.
- 1:14:31The people who behead, the people who
- 1:14:32wage wars, the people who attack, and
- 1:14:34the people who stone and behead, these
- 1:14:36are not followers of Islam. The motion
- 1:14:38is about Islam.
- 1:14:41>> [applause]
- 1:14:44>> The motion is about the body of the
- 1:14:45teaching,
- 1:14:46the 1,400 year tradition of the faith
- 1:14:49carried by 1.9 billion people, almost
- 1:14:51all of whom could not have been further
- 1:14:53removed in their faith and my faith from
- 1:14:56the abhorrent crimes committed
- 1:14:57supposedly in their name. And this is
- 1:14:59the important bit that I think you all
- 1:15:00miss.
- 1:15:01>> What do you mean by it?
- 1:15:02>> Yes.
- 1:15:02>> So, the people who killed the cops and
- 1:15:04Christians, the people who killed
- 1:15:06the ISIS,
- 1:15:08were they not part of that 1.9 billion?
- 1:15:10Were they just not part of that 1.9?
- 1:15:11>> They were not following the teachings of
- 1:15:12Islam, and I will get to exactly why.
- 1:15:14They were not They were They were not
- 1:15:15following the teachings of Islam, and I
- 1:15:16will get to why. I will get to why. The
- 1:15:18motion is about Islam, not about people
- 1:15:20who claim to believe in Islam and then
- 1:15:22misrepresent and denigrate our religion.
- 1:15:28The motion
- 1:15:30is that the body of teaching itself is
- 1:15:31the cause of those atrocities in a way
- 1:15:33that Christianity, Judaism, Hinduism,
- 1:15:35and even secular ideologies are not the
- 1:15:36causes of their own, that our faith is
- 1:15:39inherently incompatible with and in fact
- 1:15:40are a danger to British society, its
- 1:15:43values, its traditions, and its culture.
- 1:15:45Every Muslim, therefore, warrants a
- 1:15:46presumption of suspicion, and I am going
- 1:15:48to, point by point, take your arguments
- 1:15:50at their highest and tell you why they
- 1:15:51are wrong.
- 1:15:53First, given that there were arguments
- 1:15:54presented by Lawrence I'm not too sure
- 1:15:56where he's gone. Lawrence and Tommy,
- 1:15:58there you are. Law- Lawrence and Tommy
- 1:15:59about presumed and supposed scriptures
- 1:16:02and points in the Quran and verses, I
- 1:16:04want to take you through what they
- 1:16:05actually say, what the teachings
- 1:16:07actually say, what Islam actually says,
- 1:16:09not the caricature you've been painting.
- 1:16:13And then, I'd like to ask you whether
- 1:16:14you are suspicious of those values and
- 1:16:16those cultures.
- 1:16:18The claim that the Quran is a manual of
- 1:16:20violence and that mainstream Islam is
- 1:16:21therefore inherently at war with and in
- 1:16:23contradiction with Western values is
- 1:16:24what I've heard tonight.
- 1:16:25You will have heard, for example, both
- 1:16:27from JL and Tommy Robinson, that the
- 1:16:28proposition called the sword verse,
- 1:16:31"Kill the unbelievers wherever you find
- 1:16:32them."
- 1:16:34What you will not have heard is the
- 1:16:35verse immediately before it, which
- 1:16:37exempts anyone who has kept a peace
- 1:16:38treaty with the Muslims. You would not
- 1:16:40have heard the verse immediately after
- 1:16:42it, which orders Muslims to grant safe
- 1:16:44passage to any non-Muslim who asks for
- 1:16:46it and to escort them to safety. You
- 1:16:47will not have heard that every major
- 1:16:49classical commentator on the Quran
- 1:16:51across 1,400 years and every Muslim that
- 1:16:54actually follows the scripture agrees
- 1:16:56that the verse was about a very specific
- 1:16:57group of Arab tribes who had signed a
- 1:16:59peace agreement with the early Muslim
- 1:17:00community and then broke it in the
- 1:17:02middle of war in 17th century Arabia. It
- 1:17:04is dishonest.
- 1:17:05>> [cheering]
- 1:17:05>> It is dishonest to stand here. No, let
- 1:17:08me finish. It is is dishonest to stand
- 1:17:10here and selectively and misrepresent
- 1:17:12and misquote. Let me let me get to the
- 1:17:13end of my point and I'll get to you.
- 1:17:15And let me get to the end of my point
- 1:17:16and then I'll get to you. Um let me get
- 1:17:18to the end of my point and then I'll get
- 1:17:19to you. That's good.
- 1:17:20>> of the information has been declined,
- 1:17:21Mr. Jones Lyons.
- 1:17:22>> It is not and has never been read by the
- 1:17:23scholarly tradition as a standing order
- 1:17:25for all Muslims in all centuries against
- 1:17:27everyone who does not share their faith.
- 1:17:28It has never been the case. And anyone
- 1:17:30who says that they follow Islam and have
- 1:17:32committed those crimes in that name in
- 1:17:34that verse is a liar and not a follower
- 1:17:36of our religion.
- 1:17:37>> [applause]
- 1:17:40>> You're fine.
- 1:17:42>> We have that. That's good. I think the
- 1:17:43heading we need
- 1:17:45is "Can women persecute non-Muslims?"
- 1:17:47>> Yeah.
- 1:17:47>> Justified waiting for it. Don't
- 1:17:49interrupt me, please.
- 1:17:50>> Get it.
- 1:17:50>> We can talk about it in a minute.
- 1:17:52I get I get I get I get I get I get your
- 1:17:53I get your point.
- 1:17:55>> I have just given you the exact
- 1:17:56quotation from the religious scripture
- 1:17:58upon which that person claimed to have
- 1:18:00followed. I have shown you that that is
- 1:18:02not what the verse says. Let me finish,
- 1:18:03Jail. I've shown you that that is not
- 1:18:04what the verse said. I have shown you
- 1:18:06that that is not what the teachings
- 1:18:07ascribed to us and tell us to follow.
- 1:18:08Let me finish. If somebody wants to pick
- 1:18:10out any verse from the from the from the
- 1:18:12Bible from the Old Testament from the
- 1:18:14Torah
- 1:18:15any selective verse, a verse where Moses
- 1:18:17is discussed killing innocent civilians
- 1:18:19or Solomon taking up tens of dozens of
- 1:18:21wives, and then I tell you that that
- 1:18:23must justify anyone who then claims that
- 1:18:25that text is referenced to or in in is
- 1:18:28presented to
- 1:18:30be a defense of their actions, you would
- 1:18:31tell me that is unjustified. You would
- 1:18:32tell me that is not the correct reading
- 1:18:33of the scripture.
- 1:18:36>> [applause]
- 1:18:38>> Can I
- 1:18:40>> I've accepted a point of information.
- 1:18:41>> Gentlemen, gentlemen, can I ask you both
- 1:18:43to take your seats, please?
- 1:18:45Mr. Andrew Lucy,
- 1:18:48thank you.
- 1:18:48>> I've accepted a point of information.
- 1:18:50>> Well, can I can I encourage you to make
- 1:18:52a little progress since we seem to have
- 1:18:54points on both sides, and then perhaps
- 1:18:56return to the point.
- 1:18:57>> Yeah.
- 1:18:58Let me let me finish, please.
- 1:19:00>> No, a point of order having been raised,
- 1:19:02Mr. Jones Lines.
- 1:19:03>> I'd like to ask a point
- 1:19:04>> You did.
- 1:19:05>> Mr. Speaker, I asked that people be
- 1:19:07forbidden as the first house bit from
- 1:19:09doing individual photography at the
- 1:19:10hall.
- 1:19:14>> You will not have heard that
- 1:19:16>> Madam President, one moment. I will
- 1:19:17remind those in the chamber
- 1:19:20that with the exception of those with
- 1:19:22prior arrangements with the society and
- 1:19:25the society's own videographers and
- 1:19:26photographers,
- 1:19:28there is to be no recording in the
- 1:19:29chamber.
- 1:19:30There will be one warning given, and on
- 1:19:31the second warning people will be
- 1:19:32removed. The only exceptions are the
- 1:19:35society's videographers and those that
- 1:19:36have already arranged recording. Thank
- 1:19:38you.
- 1:19:38>> Matthew.
- 1:19:40This motion is not about non-believers,
- 1:19:43people who say they believe in Islam but
- 1:19:45don't actually follow its teachings. It
- 1:19:46is about Islam, and I would urge you all
- 1:19:48to follow through with that motion, with
- 1:19:49that wording, and actually scrutinize
- 1:19:51the religious teachings for what they
- 1:19:53actually are and not for what you want
- 1:19:54them to be to fit your narrative. Let me
- 1:19:56get to my point. Thank you.
- 1:19:58You will not have even heard that the
- 1:19:59verses that you are quoting come from a
- 1:20:02from a from a chapter in the Quran
- 1:20:04called Repentance. Not conquest, not
- 1:20:07war, repentance. That it is the name the
- 1:20:09book itself gives to the chapter the
- 1:20:11proposition will tell you is a manual
- 1:20:12for killing you.
- 1:20:14Another claim we have heard tonight from
- 1:20:16Tommy Robinson is this, "Whoever changes
- 1:20:18his religion, kill him."
- 1:20:20from Bukhari.
- 1:20:22That sounds absolute, but it is not.
- 1:20:25The Hanafi school followed by most
- 1:20:27British Muslims, in fact most Muslims
- 1:20:28across the world has long held that this
- 1:20:30only applies to those who leave Islam
- 1:20:32and wage war against communities. Wage
- 1:20:35war.
- 1:20:36It is not just It is not honest. It is
- 1:20:39not just and it is not honest to
- 1:20:40cherry-pick quotes and verses. I will
- 1:20:42get to you. Let me get some progress,
- 1:20:43please.
- 1:20:44Let me get to some make make some
- 1:20:45progress, please.
- 1:20:46And then when it comes to the verse
- 1:20:48supposedly enabling violence against
- 1:20:49women, actually let me I'll leave that
- 1:20:51for you haven't mentioned it, so I won't
- 1:20:54bring it up, but if you were if somebody
- 1:20:56were to mention the verse on the
- 1:20:57supposedly enables women violence
- 1:20:59against women,
- 1:21:00all that verse is hung on is one word in
- 1:21:03Arabic which commentators like
- 1:21:05yourselves have latched on to mean beat
- 1:21:07them.
- 1:21:09That word has 20 different meanings in
- 1:21:11Arabic.
- 1:21:12Major scholars do not interpret that
- 1:21:14word to mean the worst and harshest
- 1:21:16possible interpretation. The prophet
- 1:21:17himself, whom you say we believe is
- 1:21:20rightful and we must follow in his
- 1:21:21example, said himself that he disliked
- 1:21:23men who hit their wives. So, just
- 1:21:25preempting any arguments that would be
- 1:21:27put in that direction.
- 1:21:29Let me Let me please finish. Let me
- 1:21:31please finish. Yeah.
- 1:21:32The same pattern shows up with the
- 1:21:34Hadith you mentioned about Aisha and the
- 1:21:36marriage.
- 1:21:37The claim that she was six at marriage
- 1:21:39and nine at consummation. Except what
- 1:21:41they don't tell you is that the source
- 1:21:42who provided that recollection is not
- 1:21:44seen as concretely reliable. That the
- 1:21:46author of one of the earliest and most
- 1:21:47revered collections of Hadith in Islamic
- 1:21:49law, Imam Malik, did not accept this
- 1:21:51narrator's report and that various
- 1:21:52reconstructions, including from the
- 1:21:54Yaqeen Institute, put her age as far far
- 1:21:56older. English common law, however, set
- 1:21:59the age of consent at 12 until 1875.
- 1:22:01Canon law permitted marriage from
- 1:22:03puberty. The marriage practices Mr.
- 1:22:05Robinson is condemning condemn the whole
- 1:22:07of pre-modern civilization, including
- 1:22:09Christian Europe, if we were to take his
- 1:22:10arguments at their highest tonight.
- 1:22:12>> Point of information.
- 1:22:13>> Let me get through my speech. I'm not
- 1:22:14being able to get
- 1:22:14>> You haven't taken one point from me. Are
- 1:22:16you afraid? Um there are still Muslim
- 1:22:19countries in this world which say that
- 1:22:22their legal system is based on Sharia,
- 1:22:23which allow the marriage of children
- 1:22:26because of their belief in those verses.
- 1:22:28Are you saying they are not Muslims,
- 1:22:30too?
- 1:22:32>> [applause]
- 1:22:34>> Again, and I do not understand why it is
- 1:22:36so difficult for proposition to rub
- 1:22:37their heads around this. People can take
- 1:22:39any text, and they can misinterpret it,
- 1:22:41and they can misapply it, and they can
- 1:22:42believe that what they're doing is
- 1:22:44Islamic Wait, and sit down. They can
- 1:22:46believe that what they are doing is
- 1:22:47Islamic and within accordance with
- 1:22:49Islamic principles. I am asking you to
- 1:22:51scrutinize Islam and its teachings. Let
- 1:22:53me get to his point. The people who
- 1:22:55misquote, misrepresent, and take Islam
- 1:22:57at its worst and then try and purport
- 1:22:59that they are Muslims and they are
- 1:23:00following the teachings of Islam are
- 1:23:02people you should be suspicious of. I
- 1:23:03have no doubt. But, that is not
- 1:23:04suspicious of Islam.
- 1:23:05>> Return back to our nations.
- 1:23:07>> Can I Can I Can I finish, please?
- 1:23:09We are also told Muslims are meant to
- 1:23:10follow the prophet's example. Fair
- 1:23:12enough. But, then key parts of that
- 1:23:14example quietly disappear in the
- 1:23:16arguments presented by Tommy and
- 1:23:17Lawrence and the rest of the the bench.
- 1:23:19The Constitution of Medina, drafted and
- 1:23:21delivered by the prophet, set up a
- 1:23:23community of Muslims, Jews, and pagans
- 1:23:25living together with mutual obligations
- 1:23:27and religious freedoms. Quote, "The Jews
- 1:23:29are a community along with the
- 1:23:31believers. To the Jews, their religion.
- 1:23:32To Muslims, theirs."
- 1:23:34It is right there. It is right there.
- 1:23:37>> [applause]
- 1:23:37>> Another treaty was with the Christians
- 1:23:39of Yemen, protecting their churches and
- 1:23:41clergy.
- 1:23:42Not mentioned anywhere. The prophet's
- 1:23:45final sermon, 2 months before he died,
- 1:23:48went as such, "There is no superiority
- 1:23:51of an Arab over a non-Arab, or a
- 1:23:53non-Arab over an Arab, or a white over a
- 1:23:55black, or a black over a white, except
- 1:23:57in piety." Not mentioned anywhere in any
- 1:24:00of the ARGUMENTS THAT YOU ARE GOING TO
- 1:24:01PRESENT because it does not fit your
- 1:24:03narrative.
- 1:24:05Then let me I'm going to run out of
- 1:24:06time. Please bear with me.
- 1:24:07From the Quran's own lines in that
- 1:24:09chapter that I quoted to you, which is
- 1:24:10called "O Disbelievers", "For you, your
- 1:24:13religion, and for me, mine." Somehow,
- 1:24:15that does not make the cut. After a
- 1:24:17while, the pattern becomes obvious. The
- 1:24:19case works best when certain texts stay
- 1:24:20are the page. You can do the exact same
- 1:24:22thing with other scriptures. Deuteronomy
- 1:24:2420, when you take a city, save alive
- 1:24:26nothing that breathe.
- 1:24:28Numbers 31, kill all the boys and kill
- 1:24:30every woman who has slept with a man,
- 1:24:31but save for yourselves every girl who
- 1:24:33has not. Let me finish. You can build a
- 1:24:35very dark picture that way. But that is
- 1:24:37not how Jews and Christians read their
- 1:24:39scriptures. I extend that generosity to
- 1:24:41my Muslim to my Christian brothers and
- 1:24:43my Jewish brothers and Jewish neighbors.
- 1:24:44I'm simply asking that it be extended
- 1:24:46tonight to mine. Can I please Can I
- 1:24:47please get through my speech? I will get
- 1:24:49back to you.
- 1:24:50So let's actually see because you've
- 1:24:51said, how do people take that religion
- 1:24:53and that scripture and how do they apply
- 1:24:55it in their day-to-day lives? I'm not
- 1:24:56going to deny that there are people who
- 1:24:58tell try to understand that fail and try
- 1:25:00to use that as a cover-up for atrocious
- 1:25:02and abhorrent actions. Those are not
- 1:25:04Muslims latent for God's sake.
- 1:25:07So let's see how those religious
- 1:25:09teachings translate into actual Muslim
- 1:25:11attitudes. Opium last year, 85% of
- 1:25:14British Muslims back democracy as the
- 1:25:16best system of government.
- 1:25:17The general public, 71%.
- 1:25:2094% back equal treatment under the law
- 1:25:22for all faiths and none. The general
- 1:25:23public, 80%.
- 1:25:26Seven in 10 say they feel loyal to the
- 1:25:27United Kingdom. The general public, one
- 1:25:29in two.
- 1:25:31Eight in 10 interact with non-Muslims at
- 1:25:33least weekly. Nine in 10 say standing
- 1:25:35against bigotry including anti-Semitism
- 1:25:36matters to them. Four in 10 have served
- 1:25:38themselves or through family in public
- 1:25:40service. On every single one of those
- 1:25:42measures, British Muslims are more
- 1:25:44committed to British values than the
- 1:25:46British average.
- 1:25:50>> [applause]
- 1:25:51>> These are not numbers from a community
- 1:25:54at war with this country. These are
- 1:25:55numbers from a community holding the
- 1:25:56line on the values this country claims
- 1:25:59to believe in.
- 1:26:00While the proposition tells you we are a
- 1:26:01threat to them.
- 1:26:03And exactly the same pattern shows up
- 1:26:04when we turn from opinion polls to crime
- 1:26:06statistics. The story you are being sold
- 1:26:07about Muslim crime looks very different
- 1:26:09when you see the whole picture is
- 1:26:10including for example grooming gangs.
- 1:26:12And please do bear with me, I've been
- 1:26:13interrupted for quite a bit.
- 1:26:15For the grooming gangs, the abuse
- 1:26:17happened, the girls were real, the
- 1:26:18failures were real. I will not minimize
- 1:26:20any of it. And as a Muslim woman, I'm
- 1:26:21not here to do so. In Rotherham,
- 1:26:23Rochdale, Telford, the offender public
- 1:26:25profiles on the headlines were dominated
- 1:26:26by British Pakistani Muslim men, that is
- 1:26:28true, that must be spoken about. But
- 1:26:29there is another truth that must be
- 1:26:31named alongside it. Those girls were
- 1:26:33working class. Working class girls in
- 1:26:35towns that had already been told their
- 1:26:36problems did not matter. Failed by
- 1:26:38police officers who did not come,
- 1:26:39councils who looked away, institutions
- 1:26:40that decided their suffering was not
- 1:26:41worth the paperwork. Class contempt is
- 1:26:44what allowed this to continue for
- 1:26:45decades and no girl, no working class
- 1:26:47girl, no girl of any background should
- 1:26:48ever have to learn that her pain is an
- 1:26:50administrative inconvenience. What Mr.
- 1:26:52Robinson never shows you and what the
- 1:26:53rest of the bench will never tell talk
- 1:26:55to you about is that 81% of child-based
- 1:26:58sexual offenses were most commonly
- 1:26:59committed by white men.
- 1:27:01The government's own 2020 review of
- 1:27:02group-based child sexual exploitation
- 1:27:04said two things very clearly. First,
- 1:27:06that group-based child sexual
- 1:27:07exploitation offenders, let me please
- 1:27:09land, are most commonly white. I'm
- 1:27:11getting to that point. And second, that
- 1:27:12the data are too poor poor to show that
- 1:27:14any ethnic group is uniquely predisposed
- 1:27:16to offending or overrepresented as
- 1:27:17perpetrators. That answers your point, I
- 1:27:18hope you heard it.
- 1:27:20In other words, there is no evidence
- 1:27:21that so-called grooming gangs involving
- 1:27:22Muslim men are disproportionate once you
- 1:27:24step back and look at the whole picture
- 1:27:26rather than a handful of high-profile
- 1:27:27cases.
- 1:27:32I didn't Let take it Please go ahead and
- 1:27:34please stop talking.
- 1:27:35Go for it.
- 1:27:47Under under a conservative under a
- 1:27:49conservative No, no, no, cuz you made
- 1:27:50your point. I you made your point.
- 1:27:51You've made your points. You've made
- 1:27:52your point and I've heard it. You've
- 1:27:53made your point and I've heard it. I've
- 1:27:54asked I asked the I asked You made your
- 1:27:56point and I've
- 1:27:56>> can I ask you to take your seat again,
- 1:27:57please? Thank you.
- 1:28:02>> A conservative government inquiry into
- 1:28:05Can I please a conservative government
- 1:28:07inquiry into the proportion of grooming
- 1:28:10gang-related crimes committed by all
- 1:28:12groups by all groups found found found
- 1:28:14found
- 1:28:14>> Mr. Robinson, I must ask you to take
- 1:28:15your seat. The point has been taken. The
- 1:28:17president is responding.
- 1:28:20>> Please do check the facts after this.
- 1:28:21Everyone here in the chamber is more
- 1:28:22than welcome to do so.
- 1:28:23I'm asking I'm asking I'm asking for 2
- 1:28:24more minutes if you'll allow me that.
- 1:28:28There are some other facts that the our
- 1:28:30proposition will not give you. The first
- 1:28:32that Muslims were among the dead in
- 1:28:33terrorist attacks supposedly committed
- 1:28:35under the name of Islam. Muslims were
- 1:28:36among the doctors who treated the
- 1:28:37wounded, the paramedics who ran towards
- 1:28:39the smoke, the first responders who held
- 1:28:40the dying. Ask you to condemn a
- 1:28:42community it will not acknowledge was
- 1:28:43also grieving.
- 1:28:45The second that Muslims are
- 1:28:45disproportionately represented among
- 1:28:47those who flag concerns to counter
- 1:28:49terror or programs. It is Muslim mothers
- 1:28:51who call the hotline, Muslim fathers who
- 1:28:53sit with police officers and say that
- 1:28:54something is wrong. The community the
- 1:28:56proposition frames as a threat is in
- 1:28:58practice one of our most reliable lines
- 1:28:59of defense.
- 1:29:01And then there's what the proposition
- 1:29:02will not say at all.
- 1:29:04In 2019 a man walked into two mosques in
- 1:29:05Christchurch during Friday prayers and
- 1:29:07murdered 51 Muslims. Among them a
- 1:29:093-year-old boy he manifesto named Mr.
- 1:29:10Robinson directly. It thanked him.
- 1:29:14If we are tallying the dead tonight and
- 1:29:15the proposition has made very clear that
- 1:29:16we are, then the dead of the
- 1:29:18Christchurch belong on that tally, too.
- 1:29:22He thanked you on on the card. I I
- 1:29:24haven't actually seen the information.
- 1:29:25>> Mr. Robinson, please. Thank you.
- 1:29:27>> Suspicion of Muslims as a category has
- 1:29:29also been tried as a policy. Over 83,000
- 1:29:31men from 25 mainly Muslim majority
- 1:29:32countries were forced to register with
- 1:29:33US authorities under special
- 1:29:34registration. More than 13,000 were put
- 1:29:36into deportee deportation proceedings.
- 1:29:38The number of terrorism convictions
- 1:29:40produced was zero. In the United Kingdom
- 1:29:43between 2001 and 2011 fewer than 1% of
- 1:29:46terrorism related arrests resulted in a
- 1:29:47conviction for a terrorism offense.
- 1:29:50It broke up thousands of families and
- 1:29:51consumed billions in resources catching
- 1:29:52almost nothing. That is what suspicion
- 1:29:54of an entire community, of entire
- 1:29:55category of people gets you. Nothing.
- 1:30:02I'm going to skip over to my ending.
- 1:30:05So when the proposition tells you that
- 1:30:06more suspicion makes Britain safer, I
- 1:30:08would like to ask them to look at the
- 1:30:10record. Not the theory, the record.
- 1:30:12And look to at who they are telling you
- 1:30:14to trust.
- 1:30:15And this is important because these are
- 1:30:17the people who are advocating for these
- 1:30:18points most. And it is important to know
- 1:30:20where they come from.
- 1:30:22In 2018, Mr. Robinson published videos
- 1:30:24claiming that Jamal Hijazi, a Syrian
- 1:30:25refugee schoolboy in Huddersfield whose
- 1:30:27assault on a playground had gone viral,
- 1:30:28was himself a violent bully. In fact,
- 1:30:31the video showed him being throttled and
- 1:30:32waterboarded by other people. Please
- 1:30:33give me a minute.
- 1:30:35Mr. Hijazi sued for libel. Mr. Justice
- 1:30:37Nicklin found Mr. Robinson's allegations
- 1:30:39were fake and highly defamatory and
- 1:30:41ordered him to pay 100,000 pounds in
- 1:30:42damages. He did not go to prison for
- 1:30:44telling the truth about Muslim grooming
- 1:30:45gangs. He went to prison for lying about
- 1:30:47a vulnerable refugee child. Let me
- 1:30:48finish. Let me finish. Let me finish.
- 1:30:50Let me finish.
- 1:30:51>> [applause]
- 1:30:53>> Each generation of British Muslims is
- 1:30:56more educated, more politically engaged,
- 1:30:58more invested in this country's future.
- 1:31:00THERE ARE SERIOUS issues within some
- 1:31:01Muslim communities and some of the most
- 1:31:03courageous people fighting those battles
- 1:31:04are Muslim women. Doing it quietly
- 1:31:07without a platform, without a hedge fund
- 1:31:08manager paying their legal fees. So let
- 1:31:10me end where I began, with my faith and
- 1:31:12with this country.
- 1:31:13The Prophet Muhammad hosted the
- 1:31:14Christians of Najran in his own mosque
- 1:31:17and invited them to pray there after
- 1:31:18debating them on a religion that they
- 1:31:20ultimately did not pick up. They did not
- 1:31:21convert to Islam.
- 1:31:23He guaranteed the Jews of Medina the
- 1:31:24protection of their religion and their
- 1:31:26descent.
- 1:31:27The book I believe to be the word of God
- 1:31:29says in plain Arabic, "There is no
- 1:31:30compulsion in religion." For you, your
- 1:31:33religion, and for me, mine. That is a
- 1:31:35tradition that built me. That is a
- 1:31:36tradition that proposition is asking you
- 1:31:38to declare suspect.
- 1:31:39Free speech and debate is not something
- 1:31:41I do despite being a Muslim. It is
- 1:31:42something I do because of it.
- 1:31:44>> [applause]
- 1:31:46>> One a second.
- 1:31:49So So So when I So when I defend So when
- 1:31:52I defend your right to read from my holy
- 1:31:54book in a voice dripping with contempt
- 1:31:55to contempt, when I sit through speeches
- 1:31:57calling my faith a danger and rise to
- 1:31:59them with evidence rather than threats,
- 1:32:01I'm not betraying my religion, I am
- 1:32:02practicing it. Half the team that built
- 1:32:04this debate are Muslim women.
- 1:32:06Do not let anyone sell you a false
- 1:32:08England, an England that was pure until
- 1:32:10the day your Muslim neighbor moved in.
- 1:32:11That England never existed. The real
- 1:32:13England is messier, it's kinder, it's
- 1:32:15more mixed. It is England where a Syrian
- 1:32:16schoolboy in a school playground
- 1:32:18deserves protection from lies, where
- 1:32:20four young people in Filton can oppose a
- 1:32:22weapons factory without being branded as
- 1:32:23terrorists, where Muslim girl can walk
- 1:32:25to class without being treated as
- 1:32:26suspect. This That England is still
- 1:32:28here. It is worth fighting for.
- 1:32:30So, look at who is on which side of this
- 1:32:31argument tonight. Look at who is
- 1:32:32defending free speech
- 1:32:34and who is suing journalists. Look at
- 1:32:36who only a week ago was in his abode in
- 1:32:38Spain telling you that immigrants are
- 1:32:40the problem.
- 1:32:41And ask yourself the only question this
- 1:32:43motion has ever really cared about, not
- 1:32:44whether Islam is a danger to the West,
- 1:32:45but whether a handful of rich men get to
- 1:32:48convince you that your own neighbors are
- 1:32:50your enemy.
- 1:32:51Vote against this motion. My faith has
- 1:32:53survived empires, it will survive this
- 1:32:55evening. Vote against it to protect what
- 1:32:57is best in your own tradition, the right
- 1:32:58of every person in this country to be
- 1:33:00seen as a human being before they are
- 1:33:02seen as a category.
- 1:33:06They are not trying to fix this country,
- 1:33:08they are trying to own it. Do not let
- 1:33:10them own your anger or your England. We
- 1:33:12not We are not and we never were your
- 1:33:14enemy.
- 1:33:17>> [applause]
- 1:33:21[applause]
- 1:33:37>> No, but I read about the legal
- 1:33:38proceedings.
- 1:33:41I read about the legal proceedings. I
- 1:33:42read I read about the legal proceedings.
- 1:33:44So, you distrust the court.
- 1:33:46You distrust one of the institutions
- 1:33:48that has been found guilty of racism.
- 1:33:51>> Order.
- 1:33:52Order. Thank you. Thank you. Madam
- 1:33:55President, I think I think
- 1:33:57I'm going to ask you to take your seat.
- 1:33:58Mr. Robinson, I can to you to take
- 1:33:59yours. And I call upon Mr. Jonathan
- 1:34:01Sacerdoti to continue the case for the
- 1:34:03proposition.
- 1:34:10>> Thank you. Well,
- 1:34:11it's very uh good to be back in the
- 1:34:14Oxford Union. Um
- 1:34:17I just want to take up a few points that
- 1:34:19we've heard from the other side,
- 1:34:21which is
- 1:34:22really their strongest argument appears
- 1:34:24to be that
- 1:34:25anybody that's done something bad in the
- 1:34:27name of Islam actually wasn't really
- 1:34:30Muslim or wasn't really carrying out the
- 1:34:34true scripture of Islam. Uh and indeed
- 1:34:37they are non-believers, but even those
- 1:34:39people Islam has some pretty vile
- 1:34:41treatments in store for. So, on that
- 1:34:43basis alone for non-believers of Islam,
- 1:34:46I would query uh whether or not we
- 1:34:48should be suspicious of it. And and I I
- 1:34:50must say again, I must echo the thanks
- 1:34:52to the President for her hospitality in
- 1:34:54bringing us here tonight. I have
- 1:34:55admiration for her holding this debate.
- 1:34:58Um she was also a wonderful host at the
- 1:34:59dinner. Last time they sat me almost
- 1:35:01outside. Um but she had me on the high
- 1:35:04table. Indeed, she offered me some wine.
- 1:35:06Um
- 1:35:07but I thought that Allah had cursed
- 1:35:08wine, its drinker, its server, its
- 1:35:10seller, its buyer, its presser, uh and
- 1:35:13the one for whom it's pressed, the one
- 1:35:15who carries it, and the one to whom it
- 1:35:17is carried. So, I hope that she still
- 1:35:19counts as a Muslim given that her
- 1:35:21version of Islam is one that sounded
- 1:35:23much nicer than the one that many of us
- 1:35:25are familiar with.
- 1:35:26Five minutes before Salman Ramadan
- 1:35:29detonated his bomb, killing 22 people
- 1:35:33at an Ariana Grande concert in
- 1:35:35Manchester Arena, he was spotted by Kyle
- 1:35:38Lawler, an 18-year-old security guard.
- 1:35:41And after the bombing, Kyle told the
- 1:35:43inquiry, "I just had a bad feeling about
- 1:35:45him."
- 1:35:46Kyle had been suspicious,
- 1:35:49but he didn't act. He didn't raise the
- 1:35:51alarm. Why?
- 1:35:53Here's what he said. "I felt unsure
- 1:35:56about what to do." That's what he told
- 1:35:57the inquiry. "I'm being branded a
- 1:35:59racist. It made me hesitant."
- 1:36:0322 people were killed.
- 1:36:06This is a lesson in ignoring suspicion.
- 1:36:09And it's one that the West needs to
- 1:36:11learn urgently.
- 1:36:12No, thank you.
- 1:36:14I've had phone calls this week from
- 1:36:15friends, family, colleagues. Some called
- 1:36:18to praise me for my courage, others to
- 1:36:21question my sanity for coming back here.
- 1:36:23And one or two who begged me not to
- 1:36:25speak with you tonight. Why?
- 1:36:29In what way does it take courage to come
- 1:36:31and speak at a student debating society?
- 1:36:33Why would it be foolish for my safety
- 1:36:37to debate at the invitation of a Muslim
- 1:36:39woman with two Muslim men and a mock
- 1:36:43Victorian Catholic knight?
- 1:36:45We all know why.
- 1:36:48>> Which bit is mock?
- 1:36:50>> Well, the Victorian.
- 1:36:54We all know why.
- 1:36:56It's why there's quite a lot of security
- 1:36:57here. It's why there's a bit of
- 1:36:59electricity in the air.
- 1:37:02It's why this
- 1:37:03debate generated news coverage before it
- 1:37:05even happened.
- 1:37:07It is because of Islam.
- 1:37:09Now, I'm not a Muslim. For the purposes
- 1:37:11of full disclosure, I'm a Jew and a
- 1:37:14Briton.
- 1:37:15So, I'm not here to speak for Muslims
- 1:37:17and what individual Muslims do or don't
- 1:37:19think or feel or believe.
- 1:37:22I'm not here to argue over Quranic
- 1:37:24verses and Hadith.
- 1:37:26I'm here tonight to represent the other
- 1:37:28side of this debate, Western values. I'm
- 1:37:31here to talk about how Islam has
- 1:37:34encroached on our lives.
- 1:37:38I would love not to be here,
- 1:37:40especially at this time. I would love
- 1:37:43never to talk about this topic again,
- 1:37:45never to talk about Islam.
- 1:37:48It's not my faith. It's not my ideology.
- 1:37:52But over and over again, it has
- 1:37:55confronted me, coming for my life, for
- 1:37:58your lives.
- 1:38:01I am not motivated by hate, whatever
- 1:38:03those people outside say.
- 1:38:06The only person in this debate who has
- 1:38:07made physical threats was over there.
- 1:38:11No, thank you.
- 1:38:13I am motivated by love.
- 1:38:16Love for freedom, love for life, love
- 1:38:19for debate, for discussion, love for the
- 1:38:22West.
- 1:38:23The West is a civilization of defiant
- 1:38:26liberty and fearless truth-telling, and
- 1:38:28that is why I'm here now.
- 1:38:31Now, I often ask people what their first
- 1:38:33conscious memory of Islam was. For me,
- 1:38:36it was as a child of eight or nine when
- 1:38:38Salman Rushdie published The Satanic
- 1:38:40Verses.
- 1:38:42What followed was a global eruption of
- 1:38:45Islamic fury.
- 1:38:47Book burnings in the streets, a death
- 1:38:49fatwa from Ayatollah Khomeini, and a
- 1:38:52trail of terror that crossed decades and
- 1:38:55borders. My own father, a bookseller,
- 1:38:58who believed in the fundamental Western
- 1:39:00right to read and write even offensive
- 1:39:02ideas, was forced to sell copies from
- 1:39:05behind the counter for fear of his own
- 1:39:08life.
- 1:39:09Translators were stabbed, publishers
- 1:39:12shot.
- 1:39:14And over 30 years later, in 2022, a
- 1:39:17young Muslim assassin, Hadi Matar,
- 1:39:20nearly murdered the elderly Rushdie on
- 1:39:22stage in New York, blinding him in one
- 1:39:25eye
- 1:39:26because he wrote a story.
- 1:39:31Yet, in the face of this medieval
- 1:39:33intolerance,
- 1:39:35Rushdie struck back with the West's
- 1:39:38greatest weapons,
- 1:39:40his pen and his mind
- 1:39:43writing a new book Knife.
- 1:39:46He fought violence with art.
- 1:39:49Western.
- 1:39:51They fought art with violence. Islamic.
- 1:39:58But you don't need to be a writer to
- 1:40:00have suffered the violent intrusion of
- 1:40:03Islam into your life.
- 1:40:05On September the 11th, 2001, 19
- 1:40:08hijackers cried Allahu Akbar as they
- 1:40:11murdered nearly 3,000 people in the name
- 1:40:14of Islam flying planes into the Twin
- 1:40:17Towers.
- 1:40:18On the 7th of July, 2005,
- 1:40:21four British Muslim suicide bombers
- 1:40:23slaughtered 52 commuters on London's
- 1:40:26Tube and a bus declaring, "We are at war
- 1:40:30and I am a soldier."
- 1:40:32In 2013, Michael Adebolajo beheaded the
- 1:40:36young British soldier Lee Rigby
- 1:40:39in broad daylight on a Woolwich street
- 1:40:41and then proudly told police and
- 1:40:43cameras, his hands dripping in blood,
- 1:40:46"I'm a soldier of Allah."
- 1:40:48Theo van Gogh
- 1:40:50stabbed, shot, nearly decapitated in
- 1:40:52Amsterdam for criticizing Islam. His
- 1:40:55killer
- 1:40:56pinned a note to the body declaring it
- 1:40:59was done, {quotes}
- 1:41:01"by the law that commands me to cut off
- 1:41:03the head of anyone who insults Allah and
- 1:41:06his prophet."
- 1:41:09>> Can you give me examples from the
- 1:41:10scripture directly in context, properly
- 1:41:14that would advise or point to the
- 1:41:16actions of any of these specific people?
- 1:41:19>> This is the crux of this point. I don't
- 1:41:21need to give you those examples because
- 1:41:23all of these men who slaughtered
- 1:41:25Westerners, who slaughtered other
- 1:41:27Muslims, gave their quotes from your
- 1:41:30holy book. Ayaan Hirsi Ali, no, thank
- 1:41:32you, who worked with van Gogh, she's
- 1:41:35lived with round-the-clock protection
- 1:41:37ever since. She was a Muslim who
- 1:41:40committed the crime of leaving that
- 1:41:42faith and criticizing it.
- 1:41:44Are you starting to see the pattern yet?
- 1:41:47In 2006, Ilan Halimi, a French Jew, was
- 1:41:51kidnapped, tortured for 24 days, and
- 1:41:53burnt alive by a gang who shouted, guess
- 1:41:55what? Allahu Akbar.
- 1:41:58A rabbi and three small Jewish children
- 1:42:00gunned down at a school in Toulouse.
- 1:42:03A kosher supermarket in Paris, four Jews
- 1:42:06executed.
- 1:42:08A teacher at Batley Grammar School here
- 1:42:11hounded into hiding by Muslim mobs
- 1:42:15baying for his death for showing a
- 1:42:17cartoon.
- 1:42:21Charlie Hebdo, three gay friends in
- 1:42:24Reading, David Amess MP, Streatham,
- 1:42:27London Bridge, Westminster Bridge,
- 1:42:29Parsons Green, Manchester Victoria
- 1:42:31Station, journalists, gay men, Jews,
- 1:42:34MPs, commuters, police, ordinary
- 1:42:37citizens. The list goes on and on.
- 1:42:41Dishonest people will tell you that this
- 1:42:44is not Islam, but extremism. Extreme
- 1:42:46what?
- 1:42:47Extreme Jainism? Extreme Quakerism?
- 1:42:50The two converts to Islam opposite
- 1:42:53cannot deny that those killers were
- 1:42:55Muslim
- 1:42:57following their Islamic beliefs. They
- 1:42:59said it themselves. The list of Islamic
- 1:43:01contributions to our Western life
- 1:43:04demonstrates that human cost.
- 1:43:07The human cost that makes people in here
- 1:43:10afraid to even talk about Islam. That's
- 1:43:13why we're suspicious of Islam.
- 1:43:17>> [applause]
- 1:43:19>> And don't worry, I know that Islam is
- 1:43:20not all violence. It's also political.
- 1:43:23In 1928, Hassan al-Banna founded the
- 1:43:25Muslim Brotherhood, a disciplined
- 1:43:27movement to reverse the fading of
- 1:43:29traditional Islamic life in Egypt.
- 1:43:32Building an entire alternative Islamic
- 1:43:35society. I have another couple of pages
- 1:43:37which I hope you'll give me the courtesy
- 1:43:39of.
- 1:43:40Building an an entire Islamic society.
- 1:43:43Mosques, schools, charities, youth
- 1:43:45groups, businesses, institutions, which
- 1:43:48they then spread to the West.
- 1:43:51And their devised strategy was one of
- 1:43:53patient Islamic transformation from
- 1:43:56within.
- 1:43:57A civilizational jihad. Don't worry,
- 1:44:00that is not a far-right name made up by
- 1:44:02Tommy Robinson or me. That's actually
- 1:44:04what they called it, and we know that
- 1:44:06because the FBI seized their 1991
- 1:44:09explanatory memorandum setting out the
- 1:44:12plan to settle in the West, build
- 1:44:14Islamic centers and spaces, infiltrate
- 1:44:17institutions, and work until, quote,
- 1:44:19Allah's religion is made victorious over
- 1:44:22all other religions.
- 1:44:25No, thank you. Nearly a century later,
- 1:44:27they are widely accepted across Europe
- 1:44:29and in the US and much of the West as a
- 1:44:32dangerous
- 1:44:33threat to democracy.
- 1:44:36So, Islam doesn't only attack with
- 1:44:38bombs. Sometimes, it uses our own
- 1:44:41freedoms and our own land and our own
- 1:44:42institutions against us.
- 1:44:45And Islam's ambition to spread is not
- 1:44:47always so subtle. Historically, Islam is
- 1:44:49an ideology of conquest and
- 1:44:52expansionism. After Muhammad's death in
- 1:44:54632,
- 1:44:55its armies burst out of Arabia and
- 1:44:59within a century conquered much of the
- 1:45:01ancient Christian world, the Middle
- 1:45:03East, North Africa, Egypt, Syria. They
- 1:45:07pushed into Spain, Al-Andalus. Where's
- 1:45:10that name from? They reached France,
- 1:45:12halted at Tours in 732.
- 1:45:21Thank you for the reminder.
- 1:45:22Um
- 1:45:27They were
- 1:45:28>> indeed.
- 1:45:28>> These sorts of wrongs have happened
- 1:45:30between all religions throughout
- 1:45:31[snorts] history.
- 1:45:32>> And 14th century Sorry, excuse me.
- 1:45:35Absolutely. And And if you would like to
- 1:45:36invite me back, sir Rees-Mogg, I would
- 1:45:40be delighted to debate your religion and
- 1:45:42your faith and the wrongs that it has
- 1:45:43done my people as well. But that is for
- 1:45:45another evening.
- 1:45:52Wherever they've conquered, Jews and
- 1:45:53Christians
- 1:45:55were reduced to dhimis, defeated peoples
- 1:45:58living under submission, tax, and
- 1:46:00Islamic supremacy. Because at Islam's
- 1:46:03core is
- 1:46:05political, theological dominance, not
- 1:46:07private, internal faith.
- 1:46:10They may try to hide it, but it is
- 1:46:12written in blood across the centuries
- 1:46:15until today.
- 1:46:17For every other ideology, we can be
- 1:46:20proud of the positives and still
- 1:46:22suspicious of the negatives. But some
- 1:46:24people are so quick to list all the
- 1:46:26great things they say Islam's
- 1:46:27contributed. The second speaker that he
- 1:46:29gave some money once to an old man who
- 1:46:31was in need.
- 1:46:33But they utterly reject any Islamic
- 1:46:35connection to all the dreadful things
- 1:46:38that I've mentioned tonight. The bits
- 1:46:40they like, those are all Islam. But the
- 1:46:42bits they don't like, well, not Islam.
- 1:46:44Totally binary in an era when being
- 1:46:47non-binary is all the rage.
- 1:46:51Everything today is on a spectrum except
- 1:46:55Islam.
- 1:46:57So, I'm asking you
- 1:47:00to believe your own eyes, to accept your
- 1:47:02own survival instincts, apply the same
- 1:47:05rational thought to Islam that you would
- 1:47:07and should
- 1:47:08to any other set of ideas and behaviors.
- 1:47:11Kyle Lawler, that Manchester Arena
- 1:47:13security guard,
- 1:47:15will live forever
- 1:47:17with the heavy weight of ignoring his
- 1:47:19suspicion.
- 1:47:22Don't be Kaya Lawler.
- 1:47:24Don't be afraid to call out an urgent
- 1:47:27danger
- 1:47:28that you instinctively identify
- 1:47:32just because you're afraid.
- 1:47:34What we have in the West is worth
- 1:47:36protecting. Our freedoms, our culture,
- 1:47:40our ethics, this university, this
- 1:47:42country, all of it. And it can compete,
- 1:47:45it can win.
- 1:47:47But only if you stay curious, stay
- 1:47:50intelligent,
- 1:47:52stay suspicious,
- 1:47:54especially of Islam.
- 1:47:57>> [applause]
- 1:48:02>> I thank the honorable gentleman for his
- 1:48:03speech advancing the proposition, and I
- 1:48:05call upon Abdullah Andalusi to advance
- 1:48:08the case for the opposition.
- 1:48:28>> Thank you.
- 1:48:37Greetings to you all. As-salamu alaykum.
- 1:48:40Peace be with you. Pax vobiscum to the
- 1:48:43Catholics.
- 1:48:44Ladies and gentlemen,
- 1:48:46um Mr. President
- 1:48:48>> [laughter]
- 1:48:49>> Not quite yet.
- 1:48:50>> Yeah.
- 1:48:51Members of Oxford Union, friends, I know
- 1:48:54you're tired after a long debate. I'll
- 1:48:57try to bring some clarity to a lot of
- 1:48:59these discussions. Unfortunately, as
- 1:49:01Brandolini's law states, it takes a
- 1:49:03disproportionate amount of time to
- 1:49:04explain something that is false, which
- 1:49:06was said in a few words.
- 1:49:08So, I'll try to cover as much as
- 1:49:10possible.
- 1:49:11My background is Portuguese.
- 1:49:14So,
- 1:49:15uh I might have unpatriotic thoughts
- 1:49:17when it comes to the World Cup.
- 1:49:18>> Forca Portugal.
- 1:49:20>> But, I will say that uh my background is
- 1:49:23actually more fascinating than this. Uh
- 1:49:25from my mother's side of the family, I
- 1:49:27discovered that we descend from a Jewish
- 1:49:28family
- 1:49:30uh that was couple centuries ago
- 1:49:33persuaded to be Catholic and wasn't able
- 1:49:36to escape uh Spain.
- 1:49:39Uh
- 1:49:39and if they were trying to hide their
- 1:49:42faith, there was the Portuguese
- 1:49:44Inquisition around to give some very
- 1:49:46sharp arguments.
- 1:49:48Now, I know you were you're say you're
- 1:49:50thinking the Portuguese had an
- 1:49:52Inquisition? Yes. No one expects the
- 1:49:54Portuguese Inquisition.
- 1:49:57So, this time was a funny one and I'm
- 1:50:00going to try to deal with as many points
- 1:50:02as possible.
- 1:50:04I think that if we looked at
- 1:50:07uh
- 1:50:07Helmut Ebbing, the German member of the
- 1:50:11Free Democratic Party, who argued when
- 1:50:14he was found with child photos that if
- 1:50:17he was prosecuted publicly, it would be
- 1:50:19it would increase anti-Semitism and his
- 1:50:22sentence was reduced.
- 1:50:24Uh Tom Artion Alexandrovich,
- 1:50:28again someone caught in Las Vegas, left
- 1:50:30to Israel and very quietly allowed to
- 1:50:33escape bail.
- 1:50:35And of course, well, Jeffrey Epstein,
- 1:50:37Weinstein. If we said, "Wait a second,
- 1:50:40what did they all have in common? Should
- 1:50:42we stop being suspicious of what they
- 1:50:44all have in common?" You'd say, "That's
- 1:50:48anti-Semitic
- 1:50:49and rightly so." So, could we not extend
- 1:50:52perhaps the same latitude to criminals
- 1:50:56in every other community on planet
- 1:50:58Earth?
- 1:50:59Please.
- 1:51:00>> Uh none of those people used the Torah
- 1:51:02to justify sexual abuse, for example, or
- 1:51:05any of those things because it's not in
- 1:51:06there. Uh they did it because they're
- 1:51:08bad people, not because they're Jews.
- 1:51:10>> Uh
- 1:51:11some actually that there's been some
- 1:51:13quirky rabbis, not actually part of the
- 1:51:15mainstream, but have argued for
- 1:51:17permissibility to have sexual relations
- 1:51:20with a child over 3 years old. Uh, would
- 1:51:23we say, "Oh, that means that all Jews
- 1:51:25are allowed to do that and that's
- 1:51:27allowed for Jews?" No, it's not, right?
- 1:51:29So, anyone can as the saying goes by
- 1:51:31Shakespeare, the devil can quote
- 1:51:32scripture.
- 1:51:33Okay.
- 1:51:35A bit Well, I'm going to go into
- 1:51:37Pay Pay Patience, sir.
- 1:51:39>> Gentlemen, gentlemen, can I remind you
- 1:51:40of the forms of the house, please?
- 1:51:41>> I think I've made him a little irate.
- 1:51:43It's okay. Please, just No, I'm I'm
- 1:51:46trying to talk about the principle.
- 1:51:47>> Sir,
- 1:51:48can I ask you to please refrain from
- 1:51:50interrupting the speaker? We have
- 1:51:51discussed the forms of the house. If you
- 1:51:53wish to make a point of information,
- 1:51:54please rise and do so. Otherwise, please
- 1:51:56allow the speaker to continue. Thank
- 1:51:58you.
- 1:52:00>> So,
- 1:52:01um, let's discuss as many things as
- 1:52:03possible and I'm going to speed up a
- 1:52:04little bit. So, people talk about what
- 1:52:06ISIS did to Yazidis. Where were the
- 1:52:08Yazidis, by the way? Oh, in the Middle
- 1:52:09East. For for how long?
- 1:52:111,400 years. And who were their
- 1:52:14neighbors for 1,400 Muslims? So, did
- 1:52:17Muslims only after 1,400 years say,
- 1:52:19"Wait a second, those look a bit funny.
- 1:52:22Yazidis, let's persecute them and kill
- 1:52:24them." That's how ridiculous the
- 1:52:26argument is. You know, I find it a shame
- 1:52:29that people only realized despite all
- 1:52:31the rhetoric that Iran wants to kill all
- 1:52:33Jews, that the only
- 1:52:35the only time Wait a second, the only
- 1:52:36time we realized that Jews were actually
- 1:52:38in Iran was when Israel blew up a
- 1:52:40synagogue in Tehran. Tehran has 30
- 1:52:42synagogues, by the way. 6,000 Jews live
- 1:52:46in Tehran.
- 1:52:48Um,
- 1:52:49other issues. Let's even go for even
- 1:52:51quicker.
- 1:52:53The
- 1:52:54the Okay, the Quran says very clearly
- 1:52:57there's no compulsion in religion. It
- 1:53:00has There's actually four mentions of
- 1:53:02the word compulsion in the Quran,
- 1:53:04and every single one, it's always not to
- 1:53:07compel. Every single one. There's not a
- 1:53:09verse that's not out that's not
- 1:53:11mentioned one one second. There's not a
- 1:53:12verse that's not mentioned often, which
- 1:53:15is it said if God so willed, he would
- 1:53:18have created the whole world following
- 1:53:19one religion.
- 1:53:21So, if that's the case, who are you to
- 1:53:23compel when basically religion should be
- 1:53:26only for God? I.e. God decides who is
- 1:53:28guided and who is not. That's not a
- 1:53:30verse of the Quran.
- 1:53:31Right? We're not allowed to compel
- 1:53:33anyone to become Muslim.
- 1:53:37But also
- 1:53:38uh
- 1:53:40Sure.
- 1:53:40>> Why can't you buy alcohol in Riyadh?
- 1:53:43>> Well, you can if you probably say you
- 1:53:44I'm not I'm not sure about Riyadh, but
- 1:53:45in Pakistan, which is an Islamic
- 1:53:47Republic, you can. Just say you're
- 1:53:49Christian and you get if you get beer.
- 1:53:51Right? That's the point is that let's
- 1:53:53pick the worst country we can find out
- 1:53:56of 50 countries and judge all Muslims by
- 1:53:59it when the vast majority clearly go
- 1:54:01against your argument.
- 1:54:04Um
- 1:54:05>> [clears throat]
- 1:54:05>> Oh, yes. It was said, "Doesn't Islam say
- 1:54:08you must kill gays, people who are
- 1:54:10homosexual?"
- 1:54:12No, it doesn't. Not in a single verse,
- 1:54:14not in a single Hadith. Brother, please
- 1:54:17tell me how many gays did the Prophet
- 1:54:18Muhammad kill then?
- 1:54:20Can you
- 1:54:20Why are you silent now?
- 1:54:22Right? How many How many gays did he
- 1:54:24kill?
- 1:54:25>> Um does the Quran actually not preach
- 1:54:27death for people who engage in
- 1:54:29homosexual sexual acts?
- 1:54:31>> The Quran doesn't say Does the Quran
- 1:54:32actually doesn't talk about that. It
- 1:54:33talks about people who have sex outside
- 1:54:36of marriage. But the point is let me let
- 1:54:38me let me correct you, sir.
- 1:54:40The the Like
- 1:54:42Look, I I know you're getting anxious,
- 1:54:44but like please let me finish my point,
- 1:54:46sir. You know, freedom of speech.
- 1:54:49So,
- 1:54:50um So, the Let me
- 1:54:53>> You said you have freedom of speech, so
- 1:54:54I'm assuming
- 1:54:55>> Sorry?
- 1:54:56>> You keep saying
- 1:54:57>> Yeah, but you have to let me speak first
- 1:54:58and then I can give way to you. I
- 1:54:59haven't didn't started speaking, sir.
- 1:55:02Okay.
- 1:55:03All right. Um
- 1:55:05I think you have to judge you have to
- 1:55:06judge religion based on uh on the
- 1:55:08teachings on the text because that's
- 1:55:10where the religion comes from. If we
- 1:55:12judged religion or any moral ideology or
- 1:55:16belief system by the it's adherence, we
- 1:55:19would basically condemn all morality in
- 1:55:21humanity actual cuz there's always
- 1:55:22criminals, always someone that are
- 1:55:24self-centered despite their high-minded
- 1:55:27claims.
- 1:55:28Um also, the laws that do exist on some
- 1:55:31of the the books in Muslim world,
- 1:55:33unfortunately, were taken from
- 1:55:35somewhere. The idea of the homosexuals
- 1:55:37invented in the 19th century as in the
- 1:55:39the top the idea that you can classify
- 1:55:41people by sexuality, homosexualities
- 1:55:43heterosexuality and so on. Krafft-Ebing
- 1:55:46was the person. And then the Victorians
- 1:55:48developed an idea that you should be
- 1:55:49intolerant about these people. It was a
- 1:55:50mental disease. And then they imported
- 1:55:53it or exported it into the Muslim world
- 1:55:55when we never had the concept of the
- 1:55:57heterosexual, bisexual, homosexual.
- 1:55:59Everyone was just people.
- 1:56:01All right. So, and then we're blamed for
- 1:56:04basically adopting an older version of
- 1:56:06the West. We have to update it to West
- 1:56:082.0 and we're being blamed for still on
- 1:56:10West 1.0. I should I would argue we
- 1:56:12should be in West 0.0, but it's because
- 1:56:15in Islam, we didn't have such
- 1:56:18persecutions that the West encountered.
- 1:56:20Um
- 1:56:21let me just let me finish that then I'll
- 1:56:22take it. I'll take it in a second. I'll
- 1:56:24take it in a second.
- 1:56:25>> I didn't mention
- 1:56:26>> All right. I'll take it in a second.
- 1:56:27>> I didn't
- 1:56:27I didn't accept it.
- 1:56:28>> I didn't accept it.
- 1:56:30>> I'll take one in a moment. Please allow
- 1:56:31him to continue. Thank you.
- 1:56:34>> So, basically, if the Muslim world
- 1:56:35doesn't
- 1:56:36accept the forcefully imposed ideas and
- 1:56:40concepts from from the West, we're
- 1:56:42somehow being intolerant of the West?
- 1:56:44That's kind of how you've been sounding
- 1:56:45throughout this entire discussion today,
- 1:56:46actually. Um
- 1:56:48I think that the second thing is Sharia
- 1:56:50can't be imposed on non-Muslims. The
- 1:56:54Quran says regards those Jews and
- 1:56:56Christians who Jews come to the Prophet
- 1:56:58Muhammad to seek uh his judgement and
- 1:57:01then they didn't accept it. So, what
- 1:57:02does the Quran say? If they don't accept
- 1:57:03it, then turn away from them. Say, you
- 1:57:04go judge by your own book. It says,
- 1:57:06judge the people of the book should
- 1:57:08judge by their own book. It's actually
- 1:57:10in the Quran. Okay, I'll take it one
- 1:57:11from you.
- 1:57:12>> So, few points. There's more actually
- 1:57:14responsible for this.
- 1:57:15>> So, what?
- 1:57:16>> Mr. Jones lines, Mr. Jones lines, please
- 1:57:19sit down. Thank you. Mr. Jones lines,
- 1:57:21please sit down. Thank you very much.
- 1:57:25>> Okay, if I if I may continue, um
- 1:57:29Look, you know, uh
- 1:57:32I
- 1:57:32The thing is, one of the issues that as
- 1:57:34Muslims face is that we are constantly
- 1:57:36on trial for our own existence.
- 1:57:40Like the the stakes today is not an
- 1:57:42academic
- 1:57:43uh stake.
- 1:57:44The stakes are something much greater
- 1:57:46cuz these people have proposed certain
- 1:57:48policies
- 1:57:49uh such as, you know,
- 1:57:51religious tests and ethnic cleansing.
- 1:57:53Sorry, sorry. Remigration. Sorry.
- 1:57:56Um as and this is the This is the threat
- 1:57:59that is basically upon a religious
- 1:58:02minority
- 1:58:03in the West. We we all we constantly on
- 1:58:06in judgement.
- 1:58:07>> A point of order has been raised, Mr.
- 1:58:08Fox.
- 1:58:09>> You
- 1:58:10Who has advocated for ethnic cleansing
- 1:58:12>> Hear, hear.
- 1:58:13>> at any point this evening? If the whole
- 1:58:16point of having a decent debate is in
- 1:58:17good faith.
- 1:58:18>> This is a point of order or a point of
- 1:58:19information?
- 1:58:20>> Mr. Fox, I hear I hear I hear your point
- 1:58:22of order. I hear your I hear your point
- 1:58:25of order.
- 1:58:26Mr. Anne Marie Lucy, could I ask you to
- 1:58:27clarify who has advocated for ethnic
- 1:58:29cleansing?
- 1:58:30>> Uh oh, um
- 1:58:33Uh
- 1:58:34Britain First. Members I've encountered
- 1:58:36of the store of the store of the store
- 1:58:38party
- 1:58:39Uh some of some some of the some of the
- 1:58:42friends of the individuals I will bring
- 1:58:44Yeah.
- 1:58:44>> I must ask you to withdraw the remark as
- 1:58:46it relates to the opposition bench
- 1:58:48simply because the people you are citing
- 1:58:50are not at this debate. Are you able to
- 1:58:52say that any of the gentlemen have made
- 1:58:54that comment?
- 1:58:55>> That's fine. I retract. I'll say members
- 1:58:58of the far right.
- 1:58:59>> [applause]
- 1:59:02>> Members
- 1:59:03members of the far right.
- 1:59:06For example, there was a case where
- 1:59:08a black person
- 1:59:10a with the United Kingdom March. There
- 1:59:11was Britain First guy there. The the guy
- 1:59:13was there to support it and Britain
- 1:59:15First said it's good. We'll get rid of
- 1:59:16the bad migrants first and we'll save
- 1:59:19the good one for last. Basically, if I
- 1:59:21if I if if I remember. Anyway, there's a
- 1:59:24video on it online you can you can see
- 1:59:26it's been doing the rounds. Okay.
- 1:59:28Okay.
- 1:59:30So, if Sharia can't be imposed on
- 1:59:32non-Muslims, what about the command
- 1:59:35is there a command or the alleged
- 1:59:37command to kill all non-Muslims where
- 1:59:40where you find them or anything like
- 1:59:41this?
- 1:59:42And this is
- 1:59:43wrong and I will quote to you classical
- 1:59:47medieval Islamic scholar Ibn Taymiyyah.
- 1:59:49I quote Ibn Taymiyyah because Ibn
- 1:59:51Taymiyyah was actually been praised by
- 1:59:53ISIS, been praised by Al-Qaeda. He's
- 1:59:55looked up to before them, but let's see
- 1:59:57what he says. He's a medieval scholar,
- 1:59:59so he's not pandering to any liberal
- 2:00:01current
- 2:00:02day.
- 2:00:03So, he says
- 2:00:05the foundation is that the blood of Bani
- 2:00:07Adam, which is the tribe of Adam, which
- 2:00:09is all human beings, is sanctified and
- 2:00:11inviolable and no one is killed except
- 2:00:13by a right.
- 2:00:15Killing due to disbelief in Islam is not
- 2:00:18something which the legislations have
- 2:00:20agreed upon at any one time of Sharia
- 2:00:22such as killing the one who sits out of
- 2:00:24combat for this is something that the
- 2:00:26legislators have
- 2:00:28and and the intellect do not differ
- 2:00:29over. The blood of a non-Muslim during
- 2:00:32the time since early Islam was
- 2:00:34sanctified and inviolable just like the
- 2:00:37original sanctity of the person from
- 2:00:39Bani Adam.
- 2:00:41So, as Allah prevented Muslims from
- 2:00:43killing such a
- 2:00:45anyone who's non-Muslim considering a
- 2:00:47non-Muslim.
- 2:00:49This is
- 2:00:50a medieval classical scholar. It's
- 2:00:51pretty straightforward.
- 2:00:53But then the question arises,
- 2:00:56why then does the Al-Qaeda exist? What
- 2:01:00did the killers of Lee Rigby say they
- 2:01:02were doing it for? Right?
- 2:01:05So.
- 2:01:07>> A point of order has been raised. I hear
- 2:01:08the gentleman.
- 2:01:09>> Just as a question for clarification,
- 2:01:11has the remark on the remark on
- 2:01:13remigration has been withdrawn, yes? Uh
- 2:01:17I actually have a quote here uh from
- 2:01:20Tommy Robinson. "I would have
- 2:01:21remigration. It's time for many Muslims
- 2:01:23to leave this country if they're not
- 2:01:24going to integrate or assimilate. It's
- 2:01:26time to go home."
- 2:01:27>> Yeah.
- 2:01:27>> I hear the honorable gentleman. I hear
- 2:01:29the honorable gentleman.
- 2:01:31Mr. Anderson, I hear the honorable
- 2:01:32gentleman's point of order. However, we
- 2:01:34are concerned with the comments in this
- 2:01:36chamber.
- 2:01:38>> Okay.
- 2:01:38>> I believe you're reading a quote from
- 2:01:40outside this chamber.
- 2:01:41>> Okay.
- 2:01:41>> Is that the case?
- 2:01:43>> Yes, but
- 2:01:44I would leave but I would leave
- 2:01:46>> I'm going to ask everybody to take their
- 2:01:48seats. I've ruled on the point of order.
- 2:01:50I will remind the gentleman that a point
- 2:01:52of order is not for simply reading
- 2:01:54quotes from outside the chamber. It must
- 2:01:56be to raise a matter concerned with the
- 2:01:58debate that is going on. Thank you. Mr.
- 2:02:00Anderson.
- 2:02:01>> [cough]
- 2:02:05>> I haven't even started speaking yet,
- 2:02:06sir.
- 2:02:07And then no, I I haven't accept I
- 2:02:08haven't accepted it because my time is
- 2:02:09limited now, right? And uh
- 2:02:15Um I'll leave it to the imagination of
- 2:02:16everyone um who here will be on his list
- 2:02:20of Muslims he will remigrate.
- 2:02:22Um so,
- 2:02:24what what about free speech?
- 2:02:26Uh sir, excuse me. You can't do this.
- 2:02:30>> I I can. It's called Gentlemen, it's
- 2:02:32called my time to speak, sir.
- 2:02:33>> Can I Can I ask Mr. Anderson to make to
- 2:02:36make some progress? Mr. Fox, I
- 2:02:37understand the point you're raising. Mr.
- 2:02:38Anderson, can I ask you to continue? And
- 2:02:40can I ask you
- 2:02:41Can I, Mr. Fox? Thank you. Mr. Lucy, can
- 2:02:45I ask you not to repeat that remark? We
- 2:02:47have already dealt with this point.
- 2:02:49>> I need more than that.
- 2:02:51All right, okay.
- 2:02:53Um [gasps] what about free speech? We've
- 2:02:54heard a lot about free speech.
- 2:02:56Well, I'll just give you an example of
- 2:02:59medieval Islamic free speech. Perhaps
- 2:03:01that would give you the best example cuz
- 2:03:03you might say maybe Muslims here
- 2:03:05these in this day and age in many
- 2:03:07countries don't fully understand what
- 2:03:08Islam requires them to do {quote} and
- 2:03:10{unquote} vis-a-vis people who
- 2:03:12attack the Prophet Muhammad or criticize
- 2:03:14him. Well, firstly, the example of the
- 2:03:16Prophet Muhammad
- 2:03:17was he had a neighbor who was a woman
- 2:03:18who hated him, hated his message. And
- 2:03:20every day he'd come out, when he'd come
- 2:03:22back she'd throw rubbish on his head.
- 2:03:24And he didn't do anything to her. Except
- 2:03:27there was one day when he came back and
- 2:03:29the woman didn't throw rubbish on his
- 2:03:31head. And what did he do? He went to her
- 2:03:33door, knocked on it. She opened it and
- 2:03:35she was shocked to see him there.
- 2:03:37And he he said, "Are you okay?
- 2:03:40I noticed that today you didn't throw
- 2:03:41rubbish on my head, so I was concerned
- 2:03:43about about you." And she said, "No one
- 2:03:46in all of the the town has come to see
- 2:03:49me about cuz I'm ill except you."
- 2:03:52And then she embraced Islam. She was
- 2:03:53amazed at the person's morals. This is
- 2:03:56the example that Muslims
- 2:03:58follow. And I'll give you an example
- 2:03:59from Islamic history. Please let me let
- 2:04:01me just
- 2:04:02at least quote them an example.
- 2:04:04So, you've probably heard maybe you've
- 2:04:06heard of someone
- 2:04:07a saint called Saint John of Damascus.
- 2:04:10Why is he called Saint John of Damascus?
- 2:04:14Well, firstly, let me talk about his
- 2:04:16book. So, he published a book attacking
- 2:04:17Islam
- 2:04:19uh quite specifically calling the
- 2:04:20Prophet a false prophet who wrote
- 2:04:22ridiculous compositions, randomly
- 2:04:24accused him of committing adultery, and
- 2:04:26and wrote how he
- 2:04:28how that Muslims are like beasts who are
- 2:04:31destined to hell. Where did he publish
- 2:04:33this book?
- 2:04:34He published this book under the Umayyad
- 2:04:37Caliphate, Syria.
- 2:04:39During Islamic times. And then he had
- 2:04:42a student, Theodorus Abu Qurrah, who
- 2:04:46wrote 15 more books criticizing
- 2:04:5115 more books attacking Islam. And he
- 2:04:54was invited to the court of Caliph
- 2:04:56Marwan to have a debate with Muslim
- 2:04:58scholars in front of the Caliph. And at
- 2:05:00the end, by his own account, he was
- 2:05:02given gifts and a mantle for his good
- 2:05:06debating skills, even though he had not
- 2:05:09embraced Islam and he had kept on
- 2:05:11attacking. And what happened to him?
- 2:05:14The Muslim scholar Isa bin Sabih
- 2:05:16al-Murta published a book refuting him.
- 2:05:19And that was it.
- 2:05:20This is Islamic free speech. And I'll
- 2:05:23leave it with one final point, cuz my
- 2:05:27time has been heavily limited,
- 2:05:29unfortunately.
- 2:05:30Um, have Does anyone know the quote,
- 2:05:32"Live and let live"?
- 2:05:34You heard of it? Does anyone know a
- 2:05:36famous person or infamous person that
- 2:05:37said it?
- 2:05:39You don't know?
- 2:05:40Oh, you're not going to like what I say
- 2:05:41next. I'm going to give you someone
- 2:05:43that's You won't be able to get out of
- 2:05:44your head.
- 2:05:46There was a guy that said it rather
- 2:05:48relatively recently.
- 2:05:50His name is
- 2:05:52Osama bin Laden.
- 2:05:54He said it and you can check in the book
- 2:05:56by Dr. Bruce Lawrence, the the
- 2:05:59composition composition of the
- 2:06:01statements by Osama bin Laden
- 2:06:02when he said, "And let me explain Let me
- 2:06:05explain the context."
- 2:06:07All right, it's easy to scoff, but it's
- 2:06:09even it's harder to actually investigate
- 2:06:10the nuances of reality.
- 2:06:13The issue is Yes. Yes.
- 2:06:16Osama bin Laden was asked in an Al
- 2:06:19Jazeera interview, "Why are you fighting
- 2:06:22the West? And also you have declared
- 2:06:25that non-combatants can be attacked."
- 2:06:27So, he said
- 2:06:29that because the West kills our women
- 2:06:31and children, and I want to show I want
- 2:06:34to protect our women and children by
- 2:06:37making the West pay price to feel our
- 2:06:39pain in the same way to stop them from
- 2:06:41bombing us. This is not an Islamic logic
- 2:06:43by the way. And then the person asked
- 2:06:45him, but does not the Prophet Muhammad
- 2:06:46forbid the targeting of non-combatants?
- 2:06:48And you know what some bin Laden said?
- 2:06:49You're right. It is forbidden in the
- 2:06:51Quran and Sunnah. But then he says, but
- 2:06:53this prohibition he believes, let me
- 2:06:55finish there, this prohibition he
- 2:06:57believes is not absolute because he says
- 2:07:00in the modern world, which is not an
- 2:07:02Islamic text or or something, he says,
- 2:07:04we should we should reciprocate how the
- 2:07:07enemy fights us.
- 2:07:09And then he claims that Islamic scholars
- 2:07:12have permitted this. I will I will
- 2:07:14finish you right now.
- 2:07:14>> I must ask you to conclude. I must ask
- 2:07:15you to conclude. I must ask you to
- 2:07:16conclude.
- 2:07:16>> Yes. Okay. One last One last quote.
- 2:07:19>> Gentlemen, please. Thank you. Mr.
- 2:07:22Sachedoti, you raised a point of order.
- 2:07:23What is your point of order?
- 2:07:24>> We'd all like him to carry on. It's
- 2:07:25really funny.
- 2:07:26>> Thank you, Mr. Sachedoti. That's not a
- 2:07:28point of order, Mr. Styles. Yes, what is
- 2:07:30your point of order?
- 2:07:31>> Thank you. Let me
- 2:07:33>> Can Can the gentleman opposite confirm
- 2:07:35whether he condemns
- 2:07:37>> That is not a point of order, Mr.
- 2:07:39Styles.
- 2:07:39>> Mr. Osama bin Laden
- 2:07:41>> I've asked you to
- 2:07:42>> Do not take it.
- 2:07:43>> Sit down. That is not a point of order.
- 2:07:46Mr. Andalusi, Mr. Andalusi, I'm going to
- 2:07:48give you 30 seconds to conclude your
- 2:07:50remarks. Thank you.
- 2:07:51>> Okay. Yes, I do condemn Osama bin Laden
- 2:07:53and his methods because as the classical
- 2:07:56medieval Islamic scholar Ibn Khurtubi
- 2:07:59says, it is not permissible for us to
- 2:08:01retaliate in the same manner even if the
- 2:08:03enemy kill our women and children and
- 2:08:05cause sorrow to befall us, it is not
- 2:08:07permissible for us to act likewise with
- 2:08:09the intention of making them feel grief
- 2:08:10and sorrow. Medieval Islamic scholars
- 2:08:12understood the rules of war. Osama bin
- 2:08:15Laden wants to change it to become part
- 2:08:17of the modern world to imitate the West
- 2:08:19and he cites Winston Churchill's bombing
- 2:08:21of Germany. They can bomb civilians, why
- 2:08:23can't we? In Islam, this is a rejected
- 2:08:26argument. We don't copy monstrous
- 2:08:29actions. We don't become the monsters
- 2:08:31who fight us. But but I will I will
- 2:08:34>> and I must ask you to conclude. I'm
- 2:08:36sorry, but I must ask you to conclude.
- 2:08:38Sorry,
- 2:08:41>> Okay, but I will.
- 2:08:43So when I said when I said
- 2:08:47when I said live and let live, what was
- 2:08:48what was I referring to? The actual his
- 2:08:50full phrase. He said
- 2:08:53if the West stop attacking us, we'll
- 2:08:55stop attacking them. Live and let live.
- 2:08:58He did not say the Quran tells us to
- 2:09:01kill all non-Muslims and massacre them.
- 2:09:03He did not say it. So the issue is this.
- 2:09:05We talk We talk a lot about what
- 2:09:07motivates terrorists.
- 2:09:09We talk a lot about what motivates
- 2:09:11terrorists, but at least quote them. Cuz
- 2:09:13Osama bin Laden never himself uses the
- 2:09:15argument that the Quran says to kill
- 2:09:17non-Muslims. So So the only people that
- 2:09:19believe that Muslims can kill
- 2:09:21non-Muslims is are the those standing in
- 2:09:23proposition.
- 2:09:24Thank you.
- 2:09:26>> I thank the honorable gentleman. I thank
- 2:09:29the honorable gentleman for his speech
- 2:09:30in opposition [snorts]
- 2:09:31of the motion.
- 2:09:33And I call upon Mr. Layton Styles to
- 2:09:35close the case for the proposition.
- 2:09:39>> [applause]
- 2:09:44>> Thank you, Mr. Chair. I mean, I must say
- 2:09:47I'm not sure how I can top that. And I'm
- 2:09:50not referring
- 2:09:51I'm not referring to the duration.
- 2:09:54Uh
- 2:09:56Yes.
- 2:09:58>> So the album by bin Laden live and let
- 2:10:00live, I hear it's great for side
- 2:10:02proposition.
- 2:10:03>> Uh he talks about live live and let live
- 2:10:05and then uh continues to quote Mr. bin
- 2:10:08Osama bin Laden on all kinds of
- 2:10:09different aspects. Uh what the question
- 2:10:12I was going to ask you, Mr. Chair, was
- 2:10:13whether he condemns him. Because if he
- 2:10:15does, I'm not sure why he quoted him so
- 2:10:17very much. I suppose that's a question
- 2:10:19for the gentleman, and you never took
- 2:10:21many of mine, so I'm going to wait.
- 2:10:23Now, I must say Mr. Chair, when I first
- 2:10:26accepted to speak in this debate, I
- 2:10:28assumed I would be the most right-wing
- 2:10:31individual in the chamber.
- 2:10:33However, looking at the speakers
- 2:10:35alongside me, I'm pleased to report this
- 2:10:37is no longer the case.
- 2:10:40Instead, this debate has already
- 2:10:41achieved something I previously thought
- 2:10:43impossible.
- 2:10:44In fact, we've encouraged Mr. Jacob
- 2:10:47Rees-Mogg and Mr. Tommy Robinson to
- 2:10:49finally disagree on something.
- 2:10:51If anything,
- 2:10:52Mr. Chair, at least the Oxford Union
- 2:10:55still performs miracles.
- 2:10:57But, that observation points to
- 2:10:59something quite important.
- 2:11:01The easiest mistake this house could
- 2:11:03make would be to assume that our
- 2:11:05argument belongs to one political tribe.
- 2:11:09That is not true. The argument I make
- 2:11:11tonight is not necessarily a
- 2:11:13conservative one, believe it or not.
- 2:11:16It is actually a liberal one. So, yes,
- 2:11:19Mr. Chair, I rise to propose the motion
- 2:11:22that the West does in fact have the
- 2:11:24right to be suspicious of Islam and Mr.
- 2:11:26Osama bin Laden.
- 2:11:30>> Hear, hear.
- 2:11:32>> Before anybody rushes to outrage,
- 2:11:34however, let us be absolutely clear
- 2:11:37about what we are and what we are not
- 2:11:39arguing.
- 2:11:40We are not arguing that Muslims are
- 2:11:43lesser citizens. We are not arguing that
- 2:11:46Muslims deserve fewer rights.
- 2:11:50We are not arguing that Muslims deserve
- 2:11:52less dignity, less freedom than anybody
- 2:11:55else. Indeed, one of the defining
- 2:11:58achievements of Western liberal
- 2:11:59democracy is the principle that as
- 2:12:02Martin Luther King said, and I'm sure
- 2:12:04you're a fan of him, sir, as well as
- 2:12:06Osama bin Laden, is that individuals
- 2:12:09as that individuals
- 2:12:10>> order. A point of order has been raised.
- 2:12:13Mr. Anlaby.
- 2:12:14>> He said I'm a fan of Osama bin Laden and
- 2:12:15in no way did I ever say that at all.
- 2:12:19>> I hear the point of order.
- 2:12:21>> I I actually what I said, I'm sure he's
- 2:12:23a fan of him as well as Osama bin Laden.
- 2:12:26>> Which does suggest that you think he's a
- 2:12:28fan of Osama bin Laden.
- 2:12:30I I'm
- 2:12:31I'm no English language graduate, but I
- 2:12:33think that's
- 2:12:34>> I'm willing I'm
- 2:12:35I'm willing to retract.
- 2:12:36>> Styles, can I invite you to withdraw the
- 2:12:38accusation
- 2:12:38>> Of course. Of course. Of course,
- 2:12:40I'm willing
- 2:12:41>> Laden.
- 2:12:41>> Mr. Chair. I'm willing to
- 2:12:43withdraw, but I will leave that uh
- 2:12:45judgment to to the audience.
- 2:12:47Um indeed, one of the defining
- 2:12:49achievements of Western liberal
- 2:12:50democracy is the principle, as I said,
- 2:12:53as Martin Luther King said, that
- 2:12:54individuals are judged based on the
- 2:12:56content of their character, not their
- 2:12:58religion, and not their race.
- 2:13:01The Muslim citizen deserves the same
- 2:13:03rights as the Christian, the Jew, and
- 2:13:05the atheist who lives alongside them.
- 2:13:08What we are arguing is something much
- 2:13:11more simple, that ideas have no right to
- 2:13:14immunity from scrutiny.
- 2:13:16Religions have no right to exemption
- 2:13:19from criticism.
- 2:13:21Ideologies have no right to deference.
- 2:13:24The West has long been suspicious of
- 2:13:27numerous forms of ideas, monarchism,
- 2:13:30fascism, communism,
- 2:13:33Islamism, to name a few.
- 2:13:36And if we have the right to be
- 2:13:38suspicious of every other major belief,
- 2:13:40why should Islam be uniquely exempt?
- 2:13:43One may criticize the authority of the
- 2:13:46pontiff, the Pope. One may criticize the
- 2:13:49authority of the Quran. There is no
- 2:13:51double standard.
- 2:13:53Of course.
- 2:13:54>> On that basis, when someone criticizes
- 2:13:56the Pope, when someone criticizes
- 2:13:58Catholic teachings, is it a threat
- 2:14:00against the dignity of Catholics?
- 2:14:02>> No. Of course not. No. No. No. No.
- 2:14:09>> Point of information.
- 2:14:09>> Of Of
- 2:14:10>> But are we not We're not arguing about
- 2:14:12whether you have a right to be
- 2:14:14suspicious of Islam, but whether you are
- 2:14:16right to be suspicious of Islam. There
- 2:14:18are There is a difference, I'm sure you
- 2:14:20agree.
- 2:14:20>> The motion is we we have a right to be.
- 2:14:23So,
- 2:14:24the the way the the way the
- 2:14:26Sure. The west The west is right to to
- 2:14:28be suspicious of Islam. That's
- 2:14:29absolutely fine. I think we're we're
- 2:14:31right to be suspicious of all sorts of
- 2:14:33ideologies, including, as I mentioned,
- 2:14:35of Christianity, of Mormonism,
- 2:14:36communism, fascism, which we have been
- 2:14:38historically. We We're also right to be
- 2:14:41skeptical of Islamism, which Osama bin
- 2:14:43Laden seems to be a big fan of. Now,
- 2:14:45the opposition The opposition,
- 2:14:48Mr. Chair,
- 2:14:49have attempted to blur the distinction
- 2:14:52between criticism of Islam and prejudice
- 2:14:55against Muslims.
- 2:14:57But, these are not the same thing.
- 2:14:58Suspicion of an idea is not hatred of a
- 2:15:01person.
- 2:15:03To question a doctrine
- 2:15:04is not to persecute its followers. Of
- 2:15:06course, I give way.
- 2:15:07>> So, you would vote
- 2:15:09Martin Luther King. If we accept Dr.
- 2:15:12King's principle that people should be
- 2:15:14judged on the content of their
- 2:15:15character, why should we judge nearly 2
- 2:15:17billion Muslims by the actions of a
- 2:15:20French minority?
- 2:15:23>> [applause]
- 2:15:28[applause]
- 2:15:28>> Uh
- 2:15:29I'll refer the lady opposite to my most
- 2:15:32previous sentence, quote, "But, these
- 2:15:34are not the same thing. Suspicion of an
- 2:15:36idea is not hatred of a person. To
- 2:15:38question a doctrine is not to persecute
- 2:15:40its followers."
- 2:15:41>> [applause]
- 2:15:46>> Our suspicion is particularly justified
- 2:15:48in Islam.
- 2:15:49Unlike many modern interpretations of
- 2:15:51religion, it is not always presented
- 2:15:54merely as a private spiritual faith.
- 2:15:57Many interpretations of Islam contain
- 2:15:59legal, political, and social
- 2:16:01prescriptions.
- 2:16:02They make claims about not only how
- 2:16:04individuals should live their lives, but
- 2:16:06how society should be organized and
- 2:16:08governed.
- 2:16:09When any belief system seeks influence
- 2:16:12over law, education, public morality, or
- 2:16:15political institutions, citizens don't
- 2:16:17only have a right, but a responsibility
- 2:16:20to question those ideologies.
- 2:16:23In addition to concerns regarding
- 2:16:25fundamentalist Islam abroad, for example
- 2:16:28in Iran and Afghanistan,
- 2:16:30we have witnessed, Mr. Chair,
- 2:16:32within our own society, serious
- 2:16:35challenges posed by Islamist extremism.
- 2:16:38The United Kingdom has spent decades
- 2:16:40confronting terrorist threats inspired
- 2:16:43by extreme interpretations of Islam.
- 2:16:46I direct all members to take a look at
- 2:16:48the MI5 terror watch list, made up
- 2:16:51overwhelmingly of Islamist terrorists.
- 2:16:55>> Point
- 2:16:56Is the speaker aware that Islamism is
- 2:16:58not Islam?
- 2:16:59>> Of course. Of course. There was no
- 2:17:01indication There was no indication that
- 2:17:03Islamism is the same as Islam. What I'm
- 2:17:06The point I'm making is many followers
- 2:17:08of Islam take it to the extreme
- 2:17:10disproportionately compared to other
- 2:17:13religions.
- 2:17:14Of course.
- 2:17:17Well, I'm sure you know more about that,
- 2:17:18Tommy, than I would.
- 2:17:20Um
- 2:17:22We have also seen instances in which
- 2:17:25public authorities were reluctant to
- 2:17:26investigate or discuss pattern
- 2:17:29No, I I I didn't I did not give you
- 2:17:31permission. Please sit down.
- 2:17:34We have also seen instances in which
- 2:17:36public authorities were reluctant to
- 2:17:38investigate or discuss patterns that
- 2:17:40emerged in certain criminal networks for
- 2:17:43fear of causing offense or appearing
- 2:17:46prejudiced.
- 2:17:47Whatever conclusions one draws from
- 2:17:49those cases, Mr. Chair,
- 2:17:52the lesson is clear. Fear of criticizing
- 2:17:55ideas, cultures, or communities cannot
- 2:17:57be permitted in the pursuit of the
- 2:18:01A liberal society must be willing to
- 2:18:03examine uncomfortable facts wherever
- 2:18:05they may lead.
- 2:18:07Of course, Mr. Chair, I'm talking about
- 2:18:09the rape gangs.
- 2:18:11One of the greatest domestic atrocities
- 2:18:14in decades.
- 2:18:16Thousands and thousands of young white
- 2:18:19working class girls raped and abused.
- 2:18:22Yet the authorities
- 2:18:24they were afraid to ask the difficult
- 2:18:26questions about the perpetrators.
- 2:18:29The vast and overwhelming majority of
- 2:18:31whom were Pakistani Muslim men.
- 2:18:34>> Point of information.
- 2:18:35>> I give way.
- 2:18:35>> That's factually not That's factually
- 2:18:37not correct. Uh according to the VKPP
- 2:18:40national analysis reports, only 2.2%
- 2:18:44of Pakistanis are involved Sorry, of the
- 2:18:46those who are committing
- 2:18:48um child sex exploitation
- 2:18:50at of the of the total amount of
- 2:18:52perpetrators, 2.2% are Pakistanis. How
- 2:18:54are they the majority? How are they the
- 2:18:56majority, sir?
- 2:18:57>> That That's fine. The rape gangs I'm
- 2:18:59referring to were mentioned in the Jay
- 2:19:01report. Were mentioned Were mentioned in
- 2:19:03the rape gang report published yesterday
- 2:19:05by Rupert Lowe. You may be a fan of him,
- 2:19:07I'm not sure. Of course, I give way.
- 2:19:10>> Um
- 2:19:13On a point Across all child sexual
- 2:19:15offenses in this country, around 88% of
- 2:19:17convicted offenders are white. And only
- 2:19:19a very small minority are from mixed or
- 2:19:21ethnic backgrounds. If we do not call
- 2:19:22that a white sex offender epidemic, why
- 2:19:24is the speaker entitled to call a far
- 2:19:26smaller subset a Muslim one? The Home
- 2:19:28Office's own December 2020 review of
- 2:19:30group-based child sexual exploitation
- 2:19:31found that offenders are most commonly
- 2:19:32white. Will the speaker tell the house
- 2:19:34he is equally suspicious wholesale of
- 2:19:36white men as a whole?
- 2:19:37>> Thank you, Madam President. I was not
- 2:19:39referring to anybody's race. What I was
- 2:19:40referring to is the religion of Islam
- 2:19:43and how culturally is proven very, very
- 2:19:45prominent in these rape gangs.
- 2:19:49I I No, thank you. I I would direct the
- 2:19:52members of the house to the rape gang
- 2:19:54report published yesterday by the member
- 2:19:57of Parliament for Great Yarmouth.
- 2:19:59Particularly to page 18, where the most
- 2:20:02egregious testimonies of all begin.
- 2:20:05Those of the survivors.
- 2:20:08To recognize this fact is not to condemn
- 2:20:10ordinary Muslims. Indeed, many of the
- 2:20:13victims of Islamist extremism around the
- 2:20:15world are themselves Muslim.
- 2:20:18But a particular ideology
- 2:20:20giving rise to movements that reject
- 2:20:24pluralism, individual liberty,
- 2:20:26democratic governance, and freedom of
- 2:20:27expression.
- 2:20:29Citizens must be able to ask questions
- 2:20:31about those ideas.
- 2:20:33Indeed, every scientific advance and
- 2:20:36every philosophical breakthrough begins
- 2:20:39with the willingness to ask difficult
- 2:20:41questions.
- 2:20:42A society that loses this ability and
- 2:20:45the right to be suspicious loses the
- 2:20:47capacity to think critically.
- 2:20:50Ultimately, Mr. Chair,
- 2:20:52this debate is not alone about Islam. It
- 2:20:55is about whether any set of ideas should
- 2:20:58be protected from scrutiny because
- 2:21:00criticism may offend, of course.
- 2:21:02>> is not actually about whether the West
- 2:21:03has a right to be suspicious of Islam.
- 2:21:05It is very specifically if the West is
- 2:21:06right.
- 2:21:06>> And I pointed to uh
- 2:21:08>> A bit of a distinction there. We're not
- 2:21:09saying you don't have a right.
- 2:21:10>> Thank you, Madam President. I I I've
- 2:21:11pointed to many examples as to why we
- 2:21:13would be right to. For example, the rape
- 2:21:15gangs. Um uh so so if the answer is yes,
- 2:21:19that we should allow these ideas to be
- 2:21:22sheltered from scrutiny, then liberal
- 2:21:24democracy has fallen face first. It has
- 2:21:26failed. If the answer is no and we
- 2:21:29should question these uh ideas,
- 2:21:32then the motion will stand and you all
- 2:21:34must vote in proposition.
- 2:21:37We ask for no special suspicion of
- 2:21:39Islam. We ask for no lesser rights for
- 2:21:41Muslims. We ask only for the equal
- 2:21:44application of a principle at the heart
- 2:21:46of Western civilization.
- 2:21:49That every idea, however ancient,
- 2:21:51however influential, however sacred,
- 2:21:54must be questioned and is right to be
- 2:21:56criticized.
- 2:21:58Islam is a powerful and influential set
- 2:22:00of ideas. Like with every other powerful
- 2:22:03set of ideas, it may be examined,
- 2:22:05criticized, and yes, regarded with
- 2:22:08suspicion.
- 2:22:09And if there is one thing everybody in
- 2:22:11this room can agree with,
- 2:22:13it is that being suspicious of
- 2:22:14propositions is entirely reasonable.
- 2:22:17After all, you've spent the last 10
- 2:22:19minutes being suspicious of mine.
- 2:22:21So,
- 2:22:22of course.
- 2:22:23>> So, the motion is actually this house
- 2:22:25believes the West as a whole um it is
- 2:22:29right to be suspicious of Islam. You're
- 2:22:31referring to individual suspicions and
- 2:22:33individual lines of inquiry. What this
- 2:22:35motion is referring to and what I hope
- 2:22:38what what I would
- 2:22:38>> I think we have the point, sir. Please
- 2:22:40allow the speaker to respond.
- 2:22:41>> Uh is it a systemic
- 2:22:42>> Sir, sir, please allow the speaker to
- 2:22:44respond. Thank you.
- 2:22:44>> Well, there was about four questions in
- 2:22:46there. I'm not sure which one to respond
- 2:22:47to. Um I'll go with the second or the
- 2:22:49third or maybe the fifth, I'm not sure.
- 2:22:51Um what I would say to you is uh in
- 2:22:54America, they're very suspicious of
- 2:22:55Islam and they've had a very successful
- 2:22:57immigration policy. Over here, we're
- 2:22:59increasingly as a society suspicious of
- 2:23:02Islam for some of the reasons I've
- 2:23:03mentioned, including the rape gangs,
- 2:23:05including the MI5 terror watch list made
- 2:23:08up of overwhelmingly of Islamist
- 2:23:11terrorists. So, I hope that answers one
- 2:23:13of your vast array of questions. Now,
- 2:23:16for those reasons, Mr. Chair, including
- 2:23:18the fact that most of this room have
- 2:23:20probably been very suspicious of my
- 2:23:21propositions for the last 10 minutes,
- 2:23:23and maybe rightly so.
- 2:23:25I am also suspicious of Islam. And for
- 2:23:27those reasons, Mr. Chair, I beg the
- 2:23:29house to vote in proposition. Thank you
- 2:23:32very much.
- 2:23:33>> [applause]
- 2:23:37>> I thank the honorable gentleman for that
- 2:23:39speech closing the case for the
- 2:23:40proposition, and I call upon the
- 2:23:42ex-librarian Trinity, Sir Jacob, to
- 2:23:45close the case for the opposition.
- 2:23:47>> [applause]
- 2:23:57>> Mr. Chairman, may I begin by adding my
- 2:24:00congratulations to the president for
- 2:24:03being incredibly steadfast and stalwart
- 2:24:07against extraordinary pressure and
- 2:24:09hostility from people who ought to have
- 2:24:11known better and should have supported
- 2:24:12her in defending free speech. And I
- 2:24:16thank Mr. Robinson for accepting the
- 2:24:17invitation to come to an audience that
- 2:24:20he didn't necessarily expect to be
- 2:24:23favorable. Free speech requires both
- 2:24:25sides of the argument to be put.
- 2:24:29I also congratulate the member who just
- 2:24:31spoke from Christchurch for his elegant
- 2:24:34speech, which unfortunately elegantly
- 2:24:36spoke about a different motion. And that
- 2:24:39is often a problem with the Oxford Union
- 2:24:40Society that when a motion says one
- 2:24:42thing and a speaker thinks something
- 2:24:44else, he tries and talk around the
- 2:24:46subject. Now, we've had quite a bit from
- 2:24:47you already, but we might come back to
- 2:24:49you later.
- 2:24:50We might come back to you later.
- 2:24:53>> [applause]
- 2:24:55>> And
- 2:24:56I want to speak strictly to the motion.
- 2:25:01The West is right to be suspicious of
- 2:25:03Islam.
- 2:25:05And here, Mr. Chairman, I'm
- 2:25:06disappointed.
- 2:25:07Because I thought I was coming up
- 2:25:09against the hard men of the right of
- 2:25:12British politics. The people who have a
- 2:25:15reputation for being tough and
- 2:25:18forthright and powerfully patriotic.
- 2:25:22And it turns out that they are wee,
- 2:25:25sleekit, cowering, timorous beasties
- 2:25:27because they have no confidence in the
- 2:25:30West, in their nation, in the religion
- 2:25:32that has made our nation fine and great
- 2:25:35and strong. Instead, they're sitting
- 2:25:38there in their homes at night
- 2:25:41fretting that we're suddenly going to be
- 2:25:43converted to Islam.
- 2:25:46Well, I'm not. Let me be quite clear
- 2:25:48about this.
- 2:25:50>> [applause]
- 2:25:50>> I'm gay.
- 2:25:54Because I believe in the enormous
- 2:25:57strength of the West and of Western
- 2:26:00values. And one of those Western values
- 2:26:03is that we believe in freedom of
- 2:26:05religion.
- 2:26:06But we partly believe in that because
- 2:26:08freedom of religion, freedom of ideas,
- 2:26:11freedom of speech, of which freedom of
- 2:26:13religion must be a sub-step,
- 2:26:16has made us strong.
- 2:26:18We have,
- 2:26:20whisper it quietly in the West,
- 2:26:22benefited from Islam during our history.
- 2:26:26What about
- 2:26:27al-Khwarizmi?
- 2:26:29Say we're in 820,
- 2:26:31even a bit before my time,
- 2:26:33who gave us the advantage of numbers. It
- 2:26:35took us 300 years
- 2:26:38to get his numbering system into Latin,
- 2:26:41but even into English.
- 2:26:44But that has been the foundation of
- 2:26:45capitalism.
- 2:26:47Without the numbering system that has
- 2:26:48come to us from Islam, we would not have
- 2:26:51the strength of capitalism that has made
- 2:26:53us strong and rich and prosperous and
- 2:26:56successful.
- 2:26:58But what about the Laffer curve?
- 2:27:00Now, there may be some people here who
- 2:27:02like the Laffer curve. But I love it. I
- 2:27:03love this idea that lower taxes are a
- 2:27:05jolly good thing. I want them to be a
- 2:27:07good deal lower.
- 2:27:10But Arthur Laffer himself
- 2:27:13recognizes the value of Ibn Khaldun,
- 2:27:16who wrote 600 years before Arthur
- 2:27:20Laffer,
- 2:27:21in 1377,
- 2:27:23beginning to come into my time. I think
- 2:27:25I was probably at school by then. But I
- 2:27:27hadn't
- 2:27:27hadn't come up to Oxford yet.
- 2:27:301377, 600 years. What did he say? It's
- 2:27:33rather wonderful how he put it.
- 2:27:35He said that when a
- 2:27:37Sultan comes to the throne, he has low
- 2:27:40taxes and lots of income.
- 2:27:42And when he's old, he has high taxes and
- 2:27:44no income. That is a beautiful
- 2:27:47encapsulation
- 2:27:48of the Laffer curve. And it comes from
- 2:27:51an Islamic scholar. If only the West had
- 2:27:54the wisdom to be a little bit less
- 2:27:56suspicious of some things that come from
- 2:27:57Islam, we might have lower taxes and a
- 2:28:00stronger growing economy.
- 2:28:02And I go on, I'll give way to you.
- 2:28:04>> Could you maybe come up with something a
- 2:28:05little more current from an Islamic
- 2:28:06scholar like say Osama bin Laden or
- 2:28:09someone?
- 2:28:09>> Well, I know the side opposite of
- 2:28:11friendly session with
- 2:28:14of Mr. bin Laden.
- 2:28:16I'm not a fan of his, let me make that
- 2:28:17absolutely clear.
- 2:28:19I think he's one of the most evil men to
- 2:28:22have come into the world in the last 100
- 2:28:24years.
- 2:28:26No, yes, to come into the world in the
- 2:28:28last 100 years. A fundamentally evil,
- 2:28:31bad man.
- 2:28:33But, if we go through the history of
- 2:28:36evil and bad men,
- 2:28:38are they all Muslim?
- 2:28:41Or dare I say that there are some
- 2:28:44Christians who have committed great and
- 2:28:46evil acts?
- 2:28:48There are people of all faiths. There
- 2:28:50are particularly atheists who are very
- 2:28:53dangerous. Stalin was an atheist, one of
- 2:28:55the great killers. Mao was an atheist,
- 2:28:58one of the great killers. You can't
- 2:29:00blame Mao and Stalin on Islam.
- 2:29:04And those are the risks we should be
- 2:29:05worried about.
- 2:29:07We should be worried about China and
- 2:29:09about Russia, people who threaten our
- 2:29:11safety. One a totalitarian atheist state
- 2:29:14and one
- 2:29:16probably an Orthodox state. The Orthodox
- 2:29:18Church's relationship with the Russian
- 2:29:20state is pretty close. But do I dismiss
- 2:29:23all Orthodoxy? Or do I in fact want it
- 2:29:26to come into union with Rome?
- 2:29:29And what about other people
- 2:29:31who have been important? I'm going to
- 2:29:32make the comparison and I know my
- 2:29:34honorable friend opposite doesn't like
- 2:29:36to have historical comparisons, but they
- 2:29:38matter.
- 2:29:39We learn from our history.
- 2:29:41But the Christians
- 2:29:43in 1204
- 2:29:45sacked and pillaged and destroyed
- 2:29:48Constantinople. They stole things, they
- 2:29:50took things, some of them you can still
- 2:29:52see in Venice today.
- 2:29:55But in 1453, the 21-year-old Mehmet II
- 2:29:59took Constantinople. Do you know what he
- 2:30:00did?
- 2:30:02He wrote down some of the great works of
- 2:30:05Western literature, scholarship, and
- 2:30:08philosophy so that they were preserved.
- 2:30:11He had ancient manuscripts copied for
- 2:30:13their preservation. These are documents
- 2:30:16that might otherwise have been lost to
- 2:30:18us and to Western civilization. So, my
- 2:30:21starting point on this suspicion is we
- 2:30:23should of course not be suspicious
- 2:30:25because there are times when freedom of
- 2:30:28religion, recognizing what other people
- 2:30:30can do, has benefited our way of life.
- 2:30:34And I am a great and unapologetic
- 2:30:37advocate for our way of life because
- 2:30:40when you go back to Mehmet II and you
- 2:30:43roll on for the next 100 and 150 years,
- 2:30:46Constantinople was the greatest, the
- 2:30:48richest, the cleanest, the most
- 2:30:49civilized city in the world.
- 2:30:52We were a backwater in comparison.
- 2:30:54But how did we succeed? What made us
- 2:30:57work?
- 2:30:58What made us work is that we developed a
- 2:31:00constitutional system of which we should
- 2:31:03be immeasurably proud and which is so
- 2:31:05strong
- 2:31:06that we can afford to have 6% of the
- 2:31:09country being Muslims without worrying
- 2:31:10about it at all. They are welcome fellow
- 2:31:12citizens. They are not going to take us
- 2:31:15over because our constitution will not
- 2:31:17allow Sharia law to become the law of
- 2:31:20the land. A democratic Westminster
- 2:31:22Parliament will not vote for that.
- 2:31:25So, fear not. And what goes on in Iran
- 2:31:28is not what is going to happen in
- 2:31:30Westminster. So, all these things we've
- 2:31:32heard about terrible punishments that
- 2:31:34apply in Islamic countries is for the
- 2:31:36birds. That is not going to be applied
- 2:31:39in the United Kingdom or in the United
- 2:31:41States or across Europe.
- 2:31:44We're going to be able to keep our way
- 2:31:46of life. Have confidence. Have faith.
- 2:31:48Now, confidence and faith, I give way to
- 2:31:50the honorable gentleman.
- 2:31:55There is no legality of Sharia law in
- 2:31:59this country as law. And did you know
- 2:32:01this is one of our most ancient statutes
- 2:32:04that is still on the statute book. The
- 2:32:061267 statute of Marlborough makes it
- 2:32:09illegal for justice to be given out in
- 2:32:12this land by any court other than the
- 2:32:14king's courts. It is still the law of
- 2:32:17the land. It is one of the shortest act
- 2:32:19of Parliament. It is our law. It makes
- 2:32:21our law equal for everybody in this
- 2:32:24country. And anyone who has Sharia law
- 2:32:26applied to them may apply to the king's
- 2:32:28court to have it disapplied. I'll give
- 2:32:30way again.
- 2:32:46I know the point. I will happily answer
- 2:32:48this.
- 2:32:49They are tribunals. That's the point.
- 2:32:51They are not compulsory law. The Holy
- 2:32:54Catholic and Apostolic Church judges on
- 2:32:58marriages.
- 2:33:00It is allowed to. The Act Against
- 2:33:02Appeals was repealed in the 1960s. There
- 2:33:05are other churches and other places that
- 2:33:08have their own internal laws, but they
- 2:33:11do not overtake I won't give way again.
- 2:33:13It's getting late. I think everyone's
- 2:33:15probably quite keen to go home, but
- 2:33:16we've outlasted the protesters, haven't
- 2:33:18we? Which is I think a very What a to be
- 2:33:20done.
- 2:33:22Huh.
- 2:33:23>> [applause]
- 2:33:24>> Oh.
- 2:33:25I've been having a go. I've been having
- 2:33:27a go at this lot for being wet wipes,
- 2:33:29but they're the serious wet wipes. Come
- 2:33:31on. I'll give it a quick go.
- 2:33:32>> Eight quick wipes women's institutions
- 2:33:34in the UK wrote to the government during
- 2:33:36their investigation to be suspicious.
- 2:33:38Eight eight international organizations,
- 2:33:40many of them from the
- 2:33:41>> I admire the Women's Institute
- 2:33:42marvelously. I think it's a fantastic
- 2:33:44organization, but I don't particularly
- 2:33:45need to take my political opinions from
- 2:33:47the Women's Institute. That a few
- 2:33:49institutes right to say they're
- 2:33:50suspicious of something is not wholly
- 2:33:52right, it has to be said. Um,
- 2:33:54it's the question I won't won't give
- 2:33:56away any further because I do need to
- 2:33:58allow people to go home and to bed to
- 2:33:59sleep perchance to dream. Um, but I wish
- 2:34:03chair
- 2:34:04in some cases they have other
- 2:34:05intentions, but I won't go into that.
- 2:34:08They may worry it's not allowed under
- 2:34:09some laws or another and it's probably
- 2:34:11not allowed by Holy Mother Church
- 2:34:12either. So, anyway, I'm expecting
- 2:34:15everyone to behave very well. Um, I want
- 2:34:17to stick to this constitutional point
- 2:34:19because we should be so proud of our
- 2:34:21constitution and what is it? It is
- 2:34:23democracy, it is the rights of property,
- 2:34:25it is the rule of law, it is freedom of
- 2:34:27speech. If you go back to my great hero
- 2:34:30Sir John Fortescue, he sets this out set
- 2:34:32this out in the 15th century saying why
- 2:34:35it works in this country, why we are
- 2:34:36prosperous is because the king is under
- 2:34:38the law not the law. And that's why over
- 2:34:41hundreds of years we have reached and
- 2:34:43countries like us have reached this
- 2:34:45level of prosperity which Constantinople
- 2:34:47failed to do because in total
- 2:34:50totalitarian despotic regimes, what you
- 2:34:52make can be stolen. This isn't Islam, it
- 2:34:55was the way Constantinople was run and
- 2:34:58if you look at the Islamic countries,
- 2:34:59most of them have very corrupt and bad
- 2:35:02governments. And that has led to serious
- 2:35:05problems for them. And the ones that
- 2:35:07have money are beginning to try and copy
- 2:35:09us. So, the UAE and very slowly Saudi
- 2:35:12Arabia are trying to develop to be more
- 2:35:14like us. If I were in Saudi Arabia, I
- 2:35:16would be saying I'm very suspicious of
- 2:35:18Christian values because that's what
- 2:35:19they're beginning to have imposed on
- 2:35:21them. Why? Because our values work. Our
- 2:35:25values have led to prosperity and they
- 2:35:27support freedom of religion.
- 2:35:31But I'm going to upset all my friends
- 2:35:33who I've been supporting this evening
- 2:35:35at this point because fundamental to our
- 2:35:38values
- 2:35:39is of course our Lord and Savior.
- 2:35:41The reason the West is strong
- 2:35:44is because of Christ
- 2:35:46and because
- 2:35:48>> [applause]
- 2:35:49>> and because
- 2:35:51of the resurrection.
- 2:35:53And the resurrection
- 2:35:55is born witness to in the Gospels.
- 2:35:59It is born witness to by the deaths of
- 2:36:01the apostles who were martyred having
- 2:36:03seen the resurrection.
- 2:36:07And that underpins the values of our
- 2:36:11society.
- 2:36:12And as our Lord himself said to St.
- 2:36:14Peter, "You are the rock on which I
- 2:36:16build my church and the gates of hell
- 2:36:19shall never prevail." Nothing will
- 2:36:22prevail against our values because our
- 2:36:25values are underpinned by that
- 2:36:27underlying truth
- 2:36:29that is Christ.
- 2:36:30And that is why I object to this motion
- 2:36:33so strongly. I think it is misplaced. I
- 2:36:35think it's basically cowardly. I think
- 2:36:36it is weak. I think it accuses
- 2:36:38individuals of having a collective guilt
- 2:36:41which is Marxism and they're not hard
- 2:36:43right at all over there. They're just a
- 2:36:45little pinkos it turns out.
- 2:36:47But it comes fundamentally down to what
- 2:36:51our values are built on.
- 2:36:54And Mr. Chairman, I'm very glad you
- 2:36:56ruled in favor of objects because I have
- 2:37:00an object in my pocket.
- 2:37:03I have an object which is a cross.
- 2:37:05The cross
- 2:37:07literally
- 2:37:08on which our Lord and Savior died
- 2:37:10because inside
- 2:37:11there is a piece of the true cross.
- 2:37:16Christus vincit.
- 2:37:18Christus regnat.
- 2:37:20Christus imperat.
- 2:37:23>> [applause]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of THB the West is Right to be Suspicious of Islam - Full Debate by OxfordUnion, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 27,270 words across 4,594 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.