ماذا لو كان احمد العلواني عراقي شيعي؟ — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00The death of former Iraqi MP Ahmed Alwani caused quite a stir last week. He was killed in
- 0:06Lebanon, and there was a huge uproar on social media. Some people cursed, some rejoiced, some laughed, some
- 0:13gloated [snoring sounds]. I was one of those people who were attacked for writing something like, "
- 0:19Oh, gloating over such an incident is wrong. This is a murdered man; we shouldn't gloat." I remember getting
- 0:28questions from friends—friends who are supposed to be on the same side,
- 0:33the side that advocates for tolerance, freedom, human rights, pluralism,
- 0:38democracy, and so on—and they were surprised. Waseem, how could you write this tweet?
- 0:45Of course, they also shut down my Facebook account. The Iraqi government, as I mentioned in the
- 0:49previous video, told them, "What's the problem?" So, I'm asking why I want to ask
- 0:57this question and try to answer it: Why does the Iraqi intellectual, or the Iraqi civil society
- 1:03activist, or the Iraqi secularist, or the Iraqi atheist [snoring sounds] still view terrorism
- 1:09as exclusively a Sunni act? Sectarianism, as
- 1:17a Sunni act and not a Shiite one, why is Shiite sectarianism socially acceptable
- 1:25while Sunni sectarianism shouldn't be persecuted and insulted? What's going on? What are
- 1:31the reasons? Let's try to talk about this topic, discuss it, and think together. Let's see what these people
- 1:38are doing. What drives this Iraqi intellectual [snoring sounds],
- 1:44or the Iraqi secularist, or even the Iraqi atheist, or the opponent of the
- 1:50Shiite Islamic governments and militias in Iraq that have ruled since 2003, or more specifically from 2000
- 1:56until today, why do these people, in the moment of truth, turn around and become
- 2:02friends of the militias or defend the militias' point of view? Why? What's happening? I
- 2:10want to start with a story that happened to me in 2016. There was a fire at the Al-Laith complex in Karrada,
- 2:18and of course, it was a tragedy, a catastrophe. It happened a few days before Eid, and the world turned upside down. But
- 2:25then the issue was exploited politically; they turned it into The "Atmiyat" (a type of traditional Sudanese clothing) means the pictures
- 2:33of al-Amiri and Abu Mahdi, I don't know who else, and these were everywhere in Karrada back then.
- 2:39So there was a demonstration, or rather a march,
- 2:44by our friends who were active at that time. The civil movement was in 2015, demonstrations
- 2:49and they continued, week after week, and the corrupt officials were exposed. I was one of those
- 2:54[laughs] in these demonstrations.
- 2:58So there was this whole "continuing" and "civil" thing, and all the fuss about the civil struggle
- 3:04against the government at the time [snoring sounds], demanding freedoms, pluralism, democracy, and
- 3:10more space, and corruption, quotas, and so on. We were against all of these things.
- 3:17So our friends and colleagues said, "Let's do a march
- 3:20in Karrada, starting from the beginning of al-Kahraman, I think, and going to
- 3:29the place of the incident, or maybe I think it was from the place that was the bookstore, it wasn't there yet, the one with
- 3:36the colorful bottles, I think. The march started from there.
- 3:42I went in the march and discovered... or... Before the march, calls started on social media. "Hey,
- 3:48we need to have demands for this march. What are your demands?" "And ours, of course." These are
- 3:54our intellectual friends, our secular friends who apparently opposed the government [snoring sounds].
- 3:59But we're portraying the Shia group as such. They said we must demand the hanging
- 4:05of the prisoners at the scene of
- 4:09the incident. The terrorist prisoners at the scene of the incident—their hanging, you know, their killing in that place
- 4:15by the state is a completely barbaric and brutal act. Okay,
- 4:22we know who these people are. Does this include [clears throat] prisoners of the Sadr movement? No. Does it include
- 4:27prisoners of the Ansar? No. We're talking about terrorists. Are these people terrorists? No, they're
- 4:32not terrorists. Why not? Because these people didn't kill Shia. They were killing Sunnis.
- 4:38Or maybe they weren't Sunni. The Sadr movement and the Ansar killed more Shia
- 4:43than Sunnis. But no, these are our people. These are people who defended us. That's our point of view
- 4:52. This view isn't universal, but it's the vast majority. I'm not talking about
- 4:58anything absolute; of course, some people disagree, but there's a prevailing viewpoint we're discussing.
- 5:03The prevailing viewpoint is that we're talking about the Western region, the Diyala region,
- 5:11the Mosul region, and the places where al-Qaeda was present, and later ISIS in its early stages. These are
- 5:18the people we need to address. I wrote a post—honestly, I don't
- 5:24want to criticize anyone—I'm against the idea of killing people absolutely, regardless of who the killer is,
- 5:32whether it's a state or an individual. I wrote a post on my page at the time, saying
- 5:40I was sad. I don't remember the exact content of the post now, but I'll post it if I find it on my old page.
- 5:47I remember writing a post where I told them I had nothing to do with it, that I wasn't calling for the killing of people, that I
- 5:53was going on a march because people had been harmed in that place. Then, when I got there, I discovered I'd been
- 5:58tricked. I went and found pictures of these people. Al-Amiri, in the end, I won't be
- 6:04affected. I'm just one of thousands of people standing by, but ultimately, I'm here to support Hadi
- 6:10al-Amiri's image. I'm here to support Abu Mahdi's image. I'm here to support the image of... I don't know what else. The event was exploited
- 6:14by those who are themselves responsible for this security breach. They couldn't even provide a government
- 6:20to prevent terrorism from bombing shopping malls and killing people.
- 6:25People in a horrible way inside the place, in the end they exploited it and became the protectors of the
- 6:32important issue. So how was it when I was there, despite the amount of sadness that was there, it was from a catastrophic place, I mean,
- 6:39this is a disaster. [Snoring sounds] You're making fun of me. What happened in this incident is that I wrote this post about
- 6:47Alwani, going back to Alwani, meaning that the same friends who went out, I mean, in demonstrations,
- 6:54demanded that people be hanged at the scene of the incident. It seems that they haven't reconsidered themselves despite the passage of all these
- 7:01years. On the contrary, this camp that was demanding the hanging has increased a lot of people.
- 7:07They moved from being, I mean, being tolerant, being calling for democracy and freedom, as if they are not
- 7:13sectarian, being not sectarian, I mean, [Snoring sounds] they have no face, I mean, he doesn't differentiate between
- 7:19Abu Deraa and what's his name, this one in Al-Qaeda, I forgot his name,
- 7:24who was in Ramadi, [Snoring sounds] robbing trucks on the road, I forgot his name, anyway,
- 7:30he doesn't have a difference between Abu Deraa and Zarqawi, for example. Both of them, for me,
- 7:35are terrorists. These are the ones who said, why did they say, because of the increase The polarization in the region, the Iran -Israel-America
- 7:43war , the world is upside down [snoring sounds]. These people, who were once in the camp
- 7:49of tolerance and civility, who viewed humanity as humanity, who saw
- 7:54Iraqis in general as Iraqis, human beings, citizens—meaning, a citizen, whether
- 8:00Sunni or Shia, it makes no difference—these people have shifted. The camp of those who called for
- 8:06the suspension of the Al-Laith complex has grown, and frankly, they have become an overwhelming majority,
- 8:14to the point that no other voices remain. When you write something, you feel alone.
- 8:21I don't mean that I'm alone; I mean that
- 8:28we have become so few within this cultural space. Activists, journalists, and writers
- 8:35have all turned to the side of savagery. So how can you say, "Don't accuse
- 8:44Ahmed Al-Awani," when this man was killed? I don't know
- 8:49what standard in the world is being used to resolve political disputes, or because I don't like this person,
- 8:57his speech, or his words, to go and kill him. No, there's no state, my dear. You
- 9:02have a problem with the state. The judiciary, for example, should have a problem with Ahmed Al-Alwani's
- 9:08sectarian speech. Fine, he should be tried. But at the same time, Muqtada al-Sadr should be tried for his sectarian speech
- 9:14and his militias that wreaked havoc on the land. He should address Qais al-Khazali. He should try
- 9:20Nouri al-Maliki. This judiciary is supposed to be fair. Why is
- 9:25Ahmed Al-Alwani sectarian and Nouri al-Maliki not? Why are you okay? Let's suppose this happened. Let's
- 9:32say the murder, the crime of murder, happened to Muqtada
- 9:39al-Sadr, for example. [Snoring sounds] It happened to Nouri al-Maliki. It happened to Nouri al-Maliki's cousin.
- 9:47He was killed in his apartment. If we [clear our throats] wrote the same opinion, that we shouldn't
- 9:53gloat, would you tell us not to talk like that? Or because these are Shiites, would you say we're
- 9:58being fair? Someone would come and tell you, "By God, you have honor in your opposition, my brother. By God, you're fair, my brother.
- 10:05You're honorable, by God, you're this and that." Of course, why? Because this is what we're talking about. Regarding the Shia, here
- 10:13you are, against this Shia. If you say, "Don't associate with him," even if he's a corrupt politician
- 10:20and part of a group of murderers, ultimately,
- 10:26the culture of killing won't become prevalent in society, the state, or in the way people think.
- 10:32[Snoring sounds] That the first solution in life is killing? No, this should never be on the table, neither as a final
- 10:37solution nor as a first solution. The solution is to have a dialogue. The solution is for the law to be
- 10:44the arbiter between us. The solution is for the judiciary to rule if we are breaking the law, inciting murder
- 10:49and terrorism, and committing crimes. This is the solution, not killing, of course. And then they showed me a picture
- 10:56claiming I was gloating over Khamenei's death, which is incorrect. The picture they published
- 11:02shows me saying that the religious figure is like an insect or a rodent,
- 11:07feeding off people. In secular societies, the context of the picture, for me, is that
- 11:13in secular societies, he would be hunted down so he wouldn't feed like a rodent on
- 11:21people's stupidity and foolishness. I apologize for these terms, but that was the point of my statement. By the way, this is the point.
- 11:27The picture was posted in 2023, I think, or 2022, and I reposted it. It's on my account [Snoring Sounds]
- 11:3420232, on the same day as November 1st.
- 11:39So, the picture has nothing to do with Khamenei or anyone else. By the way, any
- 11:45posts I make are about myself, justifying my own actions. I'm talking to people who might not be interested
- 11:50in this, but it's gotten out of hand. You're contradicting yourself. Many people know that I and my page exist
- 11:59because I'm against war with Iran. I don't want war because, as an Iraqi who lived through the experience
- 12:07of war with regimes, I know it comes at a huge cost. In the end, war means destruction.
- 12:14For me, war means... my memory of war is tied to an event
- 12:21I might not have the right to talk about, but I want to. This event, in the end, represents war for
- 12:26me. In 2003, we were in Khan Bani Saad, in the village of Al-Muradiya, and the American forces bombed an ammunition depot
- 12:35near our house. We stayed there for four hours until morning, each of us standing. He's in a corner of the house, afraid
- 12:42that if the house collapses, it will collapse on all of us and we'll die inside.
- 12:48My brother, excuse the expression, is ten years old and wet himself from fear. He's under ten years old, a child.
- 12:56[Snoring sounds] This war, for me, in short, I'll keep it
- 13:02simple. [Snoring sounds] This is the war. The rest of the details aren't important to me. You'll
- 13:08tell me that the regime can only be overthrown this way or that. I don't think Trump is
- 13:13an angel compared to Khamenei.
- 13:18That's my point of view. I mean, I'm not for the war. I mean, by the way, to be one of
- 13:25those gloating [Snoring sounds] isn't ethical for me. I mean, I don't need to be gloating. Does that mean I
- 13:30think Khamenei is good? No, I think Khamenei is a criminal and a murderer
- 13:36, and he deserves to be tried, condemned, and condemned historically, and so on. And on the other hand, Trump is the same
- 13:43for me, and Netanyahu is the same. So, this is my point
- 13:47of view. Okay, but if they catch Khamenei one day and put him in a room and a bathroom
- 13:55and kill him in this horrific way, will I be happy? No, at that moment I'll lose my soul. I'll
- 14:00be a monster, a monster. So, for me, it doesn't matter who is killed,
- 14:06and I think for many people, and I should think, that's normal. It doesn't matter if
- 14:12the murdered person was Sunni or Shia for me to decide whether to sympathize with him or not. It doesn't matter if I say, "Wow, what is this? What is this
- 14:18person who died? Wait a minute, let me see if he's Sunni or from our group—I mean, our group, I mean Shia—
- 14:24[snoring sounds] or Kurdish or Arab. Okay, stop, let me look at him, what did he say in his life, so I can see
- 14:31if killing him is permissible or not, or legitimate or not." No, my friend, killing is wrong,
- 14:37no matter who the murdered person is, no matter who they are, without exception.
- 14:41Killing is wrong
- 14:44and must be condemned. Don't rejoice that you're spreading a culture of killing among people and that it's part of
- 14:51the solutions to our problems in life—our social problems, our political problems, our
- 14:56cultural problems, and any other problem. The day you call for the killing of others, I expect that day
- 15:02will come when you will be killed, and that's it.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of ماذا لو كان احمد العلواني عراقي شيعي؟ by وسيم سيزيف waseem Sisyphus, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,399 words across 145 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.