YouTube2Text

T137 PU Schrauben — Transcript

by Physik der Elektrogitarre · 1,713 words · 253 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:09You can adjust pickup screws to change
  2. 0:11the sound. Let's take a closer look at
  3. 0:15how that works. On a humbucker, you
  4. 0:21typically have one row of screws,
  5. 0:23depending on the model. Or sometimes
  6. 0:26two rows; you can turn the screws to
  7. 0:29make string-specific adjustments. Some
  8. 0:33single coils, like this P90, allow for
  9. 0:36this, while others do not. You might
  10. 0:41read that you just need to tap the
  11. 0:44magnet to shift the pole pieces. That
  12. 0:49might work, or it might not, because
  13. 0:53early on, the wire—you can see the
  14. 0:56thin wire here—was wound directly
  15. 0:59onto the magnets, and if you shift them
  16. 1:02, it is very likely that the thin wire
  17. 1:06will snap. Then the pickup is ruined.
  18. 1:13According to the booklet by Dusch, from
  19. 1:17the years '54 to '70, whatever that
  20. 1:21implies, the bobbin supports—those
  21. 1:24two flanges—were black, light gray,
  22. 1:28or dark gray, but in any case, the coil
  23. 1:32was wound directly onto the magnets, so
  24. 1:36I would not move the magnets. It wasn't
  25. 1:43until around 1980 that a one-piece
  26. 1:45bobbin was used. Only then can you move
  27. 1:49the magnets. Everyone has to judge the
  28. 1:52level of risk for themselves. I assume
  29. 1:56no liability for that. If you have a
  30. 2:02pickup from that famous early period,
  31. 2:06which lasted for several years as seen
  32. 2:09here, you can only turn the mounting
  33. 2:13screws to raise or lower the entire
  34. 2:16pickup, moving it closer to or further
  35. 2:20from the strings. A quick look at the
  36. 2:26varying lengths of magnets. There are
  37. 2:30pickups where all magnets are the same
  38. 2:32length, but there are also ones where
  39. 2:35they vary. One reason for these
  40. 2:39differences: Fender tried to balance
  41. 2:42string volume. However, it also depends
  42. 2:46on whether the G-string is wound or
  43. 2:50plain. P.L. I won't go into more detail
  44. 2:53on that here. It is described in more
  45. 2:55detail in the book, for example. Some
  46. 2:58musicians say it's very important, many
  47. 3:00others say it doesn't matter at all.
  48. 3:03What matters is how you play. Everyone
  49. 3:06has to judge these small height
  50. 3:08differences for themselves. What
  51. 3:11happens when you turn the screws? Here
  52. 3:14is a P90 as an example with the screws
  53. 3:17turned in. 2.764 Henries; screws turned
  54. 3:23out a bit, 2.859 Henries. Well, a 3.4%
  55. 3:27difference—it's a difference, but not
  56. 3:32a particularly large one. The magnetic
  57. 3:37field changes a bit, which is why the
  58. 3:39inductance changes by a few percent.
  59. 3:43Something else is more important: when
  60. 3:46you turn the screws out, they are
  61. 3:49closer to the string. The output
  62. 3:52voltage increases, all other conditions
  63. 3:55being equal. That means the pickup is
  64. 3:57louder, to put it simply. I measured
  65. 4:01this for the pickups. A Jazzmaster
  66. 4:05pickup, a P90, the familiar
  67. 4:08Stratocaster pickup, Telecaster bridge,
  68. 4:12and an SDS1, a pickup with quite a lot
  69. 4:15of windings, screws in the coil,
  70. 4:18magnets underneath; very different
  71. 4:22construction principles, and ultimately
  72. 4:26, you can see here a 3 mm distance
  73. 4:30between the string and the pole piece,
  74. 4:34this face of the magnets. With a larger
  75. 4:39distance, the level drops a bit. With a
  76. 4:41smaller distance, well, the black
  77. 4:44Jazzmaster stands out a bit here. One
  78. 4:49reason could be that the magnets are
  79. 4:51significantly shorter and the coil is
  80. 4:53larger; well, that would be it here,
  81. 4:55the magnetic field plays the main role.
  82. 4:59I haven't investigated that in detail.
  83. 5:03I measured the distance dependency, and
  84. 5:05one can say, well, about 2 to 3 dB per
  85. 5:08millimeter when you adjust the screws.
  86. 5:12So, the main effect is the volume. Did
  87. 5:16you already know that? Well, enjoy.
  88. 5:20With the humbucker, similar curves.
  89. 5:23Tony Iommi, the typical Gibson pickup,
  90. 5:27a Gretsch pickup, and here a DP140,
  91. 5:31also a humbucker, but in a small format
  92. 5:35, and here too, a similar tendency.
  93. 5:40Tony Iommi is quite special. You can
  94. 5:44find a picture of its inner workings.
  95. 5:47It is a rail pickup, a blade pickup
  96. 5:51with different magnets. The distance
  97. 5:56dependency for the red Tony Iommi is a
  98. 5:58bit different, but by and large, you
  99. 6:01can say 2 to 3 dB per millimeter;
  100. 6:03that’s something. If you turn it down
  101. 6:07by 2, 3, or 4 mm, you definitely have
  102. 6:10an audible effect. But it is primarily
  103. 6:15the volume. Who says, wasn't there
  104. 6:19something about the aperture? Yes,
  105. 6:21small effect, I'll leave it out here.
  106. 6:24There is more about that in the book.
  107. 6:26Now for the humbucker. The situation
  108. 6:29there is a bit more difficult. Two
  109. 6:32examples, the string, the pickup, the
  110. 6:36screw turned in a bit further, turned
  111. 6:39out a bit further. Here is a
  112. 6:43measurement. How sensitive is the
  113. 6:46pickup to movements of the string at
  114. 6:48different positions? And clearly, when
  115. 6:53you turn the screw out, it is sampled
  116. 6:57more sensitively, about 6 to 7 dB more
  117. 7:00sensitively. And we have to take a
  118. 7:05closer look at that, because there are
  119. 7:08comb filter effects that change when
  120. 7:11you turn the screw out. I measured
  121. 7:15these curves with a special test bench,
  122. 7:17a steel wire with a crank, which
  123. 7:19rotates over the pickup; you can move
  124. 7:22it and measure this sensitivity. Result
  125. 7:26: there are comb filters that are
  126. 7:29string-dependent. Low E string, A, D, G
  127. 7:33, B, and the high E string. The effect
  128. 7:37is mainly noticeable on the low strings
  129. 7:40. For the high E string, for example,
  130. 7:43this interference dip is at such a high
  131. 7:46frequency that it no longer plays a
  132. 7:48role. But for the low E string, it's a
  133. 7:52very clear matter. Where you would
  134. 7:55typically find the resonance peak on a
  135. 7:58Fender single-coil, a standard Gibson
  136. 8:00humbucker shows a minimum for the low E
  137. 8:03string. A very clear effect can be
  138. 8:07heard. And there are differences in
  139. 8:10these interference curves when you turn
  140. 8:14the screw in or out. Hey. A very brief
  141. 9:07look at the theory; I won't go into too
  142. 9:09much detail. You can model a string
  143. 9:14with a pickup as a filter using signal
  144. 9:18transit times. Tau 1, T2, T1, T2 are
  145. 9:22transit times. The string is stretched
  146. 9:24between two supports. The pickup is
  147. 9:27placed here, using a single-coil as an
  148. 9:30example again. Plucking happens here.
  149. 9:33In calculations, this plucking can be
  150. 9:36interpreted as an excitation pulse
  151. 9:38traveling to the right and to the left.
  152. 9:41It requires certain amounts of time,
  153. 9:42which are these transit times here. You
  154. 9:44can create filters from this, rearrange
  155. 9:48them, and end up with a mix of FIR and
  156. 9:52IIR filters; it's described in detail
  157. 9:55in the book. This would be the loop for
  158. 10:02the recursive part. The excitation
  159. 10:06pulse enters here and then travels in
  160. 10:08two directions, which are two pulses in
  161. 10:10this loop. That suffices for this brief
  162. 10:14overview. With a humbucker, the string
  163. 10:18vibration is sampled at two points.
  164. 10:23Then there is this additional transit
  165. 10:25time Delta T and a corresponding
  166. 10:28additional filter, detailed in the
  167. 10:30physics of the electric guitar. So, now
  168. 10:35we turn the screws. E2, that is the low
  169. 10:40E string. Bridge pickup, the one here.
  170. 10:44You can turn these screws. In the
  171. 10:49normal state, when these screws are
  172. 10:51turned in, there is this comb filter. A
  173. 10:56very distinct spectral hole in the area
  174. 10:59around 3-4 kHz. As I said, with a
  175. 11:03single-coil, there would be a peak here
  176. 11:05. A very clear effect, especially on
  177. 11:10the low E string. You can still notice
  178. 11:14something on the A string, but the
  179. 11:15higher you go, the thinner the strings
  180. 11:17get, the smaller this effect becomes
  181. 11:19because it shifts to higher frequencies
  182. 11:21. What happens now if you turn the
  183. 11:24screws out, normalized to this point
  184. 11:29here? Then you can see this
  185. 11:31interference hole changing here. A 6dB
  186. 11:35difference between the sensitivity of
  187. 11:37the two coils is assumed here. If you
  188. 11:41turn them out very far, a rather
  189. 11:43theoretical case, you end up with the
  190. 11:46transmission behavior of a single-coil.
  191. 11:49Then the string is practically only
  192. 11:51sampled at the screws. As mentioned,
  193. 11:54such an extreme is a theoretical case.
  194. 11:58The second possibility, slugs, changing
  195. 12:01these poles. That works here if the
  196. 12:04pickup is open; if there is a metal
  197. 12:06cover over it, it doesn't work at all.
  198. 12:09But here you could also push these
  199. 12:12metal poles out. A bit of effort, then
  200. 12:16it looks like this. Here, too, the
  201. 12:20interference hole gets weaker and, in
  202. 12:22the end, there's a different comb
  203. 12:24filter because the string is now being
  204. 12:27sampled at a different position. Slugs
  205. 12:31pushed out. The alternative is that you
  206. 12:35can also turn the pickup around. This
  207. 12:38is how it is regularly, if you turn it
  208. 12:40around, it looks like this. And no,
  209. 12:43that doesn't change anything. The
  210. 12:45polarity is not out of phase, because
  211. 12:47the winding direction of the coils is
  212. 12:49not changed by that. So, this would be
  213. 12:53conceivable, unscrew the screws, then
  214. 12:55it goes in this direction. Clear effect
  215. 12:59. Quite clearly. Another question is,
  216. 13:02is it important how the screw slot is
  217. 13:05positioned, whether it is parallel to
  218. 13:07the string or perpendicular to it. I've
  219. 13:11already heard quite a bit of nonsense
  220. 13:12about that on the internet. Here are
  221. 13:15magnetic field calculations, and you
  222. 13:17can see that as soon as you are a few
  223. 13:19millimeters above the screw, the
  224. 13:21magnetic field is completely unaffected
  225. 13:24by such a screw slot. Only when you are
  226. 13:27very close are there any effects. I
  227. 13:30have described this in detail in the
  228. 13:32book "Physics of the Magnetic Pickup".
  229. 13:34It's out of print, no longer available.
  230. 13:38Here are representations of the scalar
  231. 13:40potential. You can see there too that
  232. 13:42one of the curves happens to run just
  233. 13:45barely over the screw. There are
  234. 13:47differences there, but as soon as you
  235. 13:49are a bit above it, there is no
  236. 13:51significant effect. And you can see it
  237. 13:54there too, that's already quite old
  238. 13:56from the book "Physics of the Electric
  239. 13:58Guitar". Magnetic field measurements
  240. 14:01over a humbucker. If the slot had an
  241. 14:05influence, you would see a color change
  242. 14:08here in the magnetic field. That is not
  243. 14:11the case. It doesn't matter as soon as
  244. 14:15the strings have the usual distance
  245. 14:17from the pickup. The book is still
  246. 14:22available at gitarristentechnik.de,
  247. 14:25where you can order it. Information can
  248. 14:28be found under this link. Attention,
  249. 14:31the character at the end is a capital I
  250. 14:33and not a lowercase L. It's always a
  251. 14:35bit difficult. Depending on the font,
  252. 14:38you can't always distinguish them well.
  253. 14:40M. O.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of T137 PU Schrauben by Physik der Elektrogitarre, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,713 words across 253 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.