YouTube2Text

Técnicas y principios de composición fotográfica en cine y series — Transcript

by Luciano Avila sobre cine y series · 4,077 words · 292 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00When we see a shot that we like, it is the result of the combination of several factors and
  2. 0:05how the elements in the frame are organized, this is what we refer to when we talk about composition.
  3. 0:13There are many elements to consider when composing a shot and several
  4. 0:17ways in which it can be done. Therefore, since the methods and possibilities are really very broad,
  5. 0:23in this video we are going to concentrate on those that are seen more frequently, and although everything
  6. 0:28we're going to talk about is applicable to still photography and painting, since this is an audiovisual channel,
  7. 0:33I am only going to focus on those issues that are also applicable to film
  8. 0:37and series, but in any case, I think you will get a fairly solid foundation. Composition
  9. 0:42is an art, and as such, its appreciation is subjective, but based on elements and
  10. 0:48common patterns through which humans perceive images, there are some guidelines
  11. 0:54that it is good to know and take into account to know how a shot is structured and balanced to convey
  12. 0:59a certain idea or feeling.
  13. 1:02Without a doubt, one of the most commonly used methods is the principle of
  14. 1:06figure-ground relationship established by Gestalt psychology, which states that,
  15. 1:10when attention is focused on an element, the image is conceptually separated into a background and
  16. 1:17a figure. The latter being what you want to highlight, the center of interest, which can be
  17. 1:22an object, a person, or a part of the person. However, if the situation were reversed and attention was paid
  18. 1:29to what was previously the background, it would become the figure, as can happen
  19. 1:36when there is, for example, a change of focus. By the way, there is another similar division to figure and
  20. 1:41background that can be made under the name of "positive space", to refer to the point of interest,
  21. 1:47and "negative space", to refer to everything surrounding the point of interest
  22. 1:52within the frame. Sometimes the negative space is expanded to give less room in the
  23. 1:58frame to the subject matter, to convey a sense of loneliness, isolation, or calm through
  24. 2:04the image.
  25. 2:06Our Western eyes, being accustomed to reading and decoding from
  26. 2:10left to right, if the character is composed to the left and to their right there is
  27. 2:15a lot of negative space, the frame can suggest that they have a long way to go. On the
  28. 2:20contrary, it can mean that they have already traveled it if this is reversed and the character is
  29. 2:26situated on the right side of the frame. So, before starting to compose, it is fundamental to know what the
  30. 2:32point of interest in the image will be, you need to know who or what will be the protagonist(s)
  31. 2:37of the frame. Some of the elements you can play with when composing are:
  32. 2:42Attracting attention to a specific center of interest, the texture and tactile sensations that
  33. 2:48the image can evoke, the shape and volume of objects, as well as the sense of depth
  34. 2:53of these in the scene, or the contrast, whether by tone, size, theme, or some other element. There are
  35. 3:01elements of an image that help capture attention or convey the intended message. One can
  36. 3:06draw the viewer's gaze to a specific area of the frame by using essentially
  37. 3:11colors, sizes, and locations. But to understand these elements, it is necessary to know
  38. 3:18through which means they can be highlighted and how they function in relation to human perception.
  39. 3:24For that, we have: focus, framing, the placement of objects within the frame,
  40. 3:30and the lighting and colors of the scene. These are the four main sections that will structure this video.
  41. 3:35Focus is one of the most basic elements when it comes to directing
  42. 3:41the viewer's gaze to where you want it, and it can be divided into two main groups: selective focus and
  43. 3:47total focus. In selective focus, the subject is in focus while the background is out of focus,
  44. 3:54which allows highlighting and concentrating the attention on a specific part of the image.
  45. 3:59And total focus is as simple as it sounds, referring to when everything in the image is in focus,
  46. 4:04both subject and background. While this removes the possibility of drawing attention through focus,
  47. 4:10it is often used for wide shots, like landscapes, where capturing
  48. 4:15all details sharply is desired.
  49. 4:19In this section, we will talk about some small considerations
  50. 4:22and issues that are usually taken into account when choosing how to position the camera.
  51. 4:26For the subject matter to be the center of attention, it is very common to have it occupy
  52. 4:32most of the space in the composition, known as "filling the frame".
  53. 4:36This helps to eliminate possible distracting elements and prevents the subject matter from losing prominence
  54. 4:42if too many elements are included in the composition.
  55. 4:48Using what is known as "frame within a frame" is another way to highlight a point of
  56. 4:54interest by framing it with some border. These can be more pronounced or more subtle, and are generally
  57. 5:00used with doors, windows, or even natural elements, but anything that isolates
  58. 5:06the subject from the rest of the frame will serve to highlight it, draw the viewer's attention
  59. 5:10to it, and increase the sense of depth of the image.
  60. 5:15In cases where there is a visually very static frame,
  61. 5:18to avoid an undesired flat and two-dimensional appearance,
  62. 5:22it is advisable to enhance the sense of physical depth of the scene, and this can be achieved
  63. 5:27by adding objects in the foreground, middle ground, and background of the composition.
  64. 5:33This sense of depth
  65. 5:34can also be generated by using marked vanishing points, for which we will need
  66. 5:40"leading lines". These are the dominant lines that may be present in a composition, which
  67. 5:45can be physically marked lines or suggested lines that are not so clearly defined.
  68. 5:52They are a powerful ally when it comes to directing the viewer’s attention. If the lines are repeated,
  69. 5:58the effect is reinforced, but at the same time, it becomes more evident as a resource. Horizontal lines
  70. 6:03convey feelings of stability, calm, or rest, as they
  71. 6:09seem to rest on a surface. Vertical lines convey strength, power,
  72. 6:15or growth, and diagonal lines help to create a dynamic image and can be divided
  73. 6:21into two main types: ascending, which according to the context can metaphorically convey a
  74. 6:27sense of effort, slowness, or progress, or, on the contrary, descending,
  75. 6:33as if the character were falling down a ramp, which can convey a sense of speed or decline.
  76. 6:40Diagonal lines can also be ideal for creating depth in
  77. 6:44compositions, especially if they are convergent, meaning when due to the effect of distance
  78. 6:50they seem to converge towards a single point, like train tracks. Curved lines,
  79. 6:56especially "S" shapes, are also very appealing to the eye because
  80. 7:01they have a more erratic structure and invite the eye to follow them. A basic case of a dominant line
  81. 7:07is the horizon line; keeping it straight and horizontal is usually a key visual reference
  82. 7:13for maintaining a stable image. But this can be broken with what is known as a "Dutch angle",
  83. 7:19a concept referring to a tilted frame. Depending on the context, it can convey dynamism,
  84. 7:25unease, or sometimes even be used symbolically,
  85. 7:30although it is advisable not to overuse this technique to avoid overdoing it
  86. 7:35and ending up with a movie like Battlefield Earth.
  87. 7:38Now we move on to the most fundamental part of composition, which is how and where
  88. 7:42to place the elements. This is probably the longest section of the video because there are
  89. 7:48various composition criteria that can be used and many elements to take into account.
  90. 7:53Returning to the horizon, intuitively one might think that
  91. 7:57the logical thing would be to place it in the center of the image,
  92. 8:00however, it is recommended to place it in a third, either the lower or upper third, of the image,
  93. 8:06because this way you choose and prioritize the sky or the ground as the background or even as the subject of
  94. 8:12the image. On the other hand, if you place the horizon in the middle, it is unclear which of the two
  95. 8:16should be highlighted, as both the ground and the sky occupy the same space in the frame. This
  96. 8:22is related to the fact that, to highlight the point of interest and guide the viewer's gaze
  97. 8:27towards it, the most common option is to have the point of interest dominate the frame while ensuring
  98. 8:33that other objects do not draw more attention than it does. For this reason, and to avoid
  99. 8:38discomfort to the eye, it is also usually avoided to have one subject matter obscure another. It
  100. 8:43is important to note that while the main focus is on the placement of the essential part of the object, like
  101. 8:49the face of a character, other directions marked by the rest of the body or objects,
  102. 8:56as well as other elements or characters that have certain prominence in the composition,
  103. 9:01are also important for the composition.
  104. 9:06But once you have an idea of what the point of interest is
  105. 9:09how do you know where to place it? For this, some concepts are usually applied
  106. 9:12such as the "rule of the gaze," which states that if the character or even the
  107. 9:17object is placed at one end of the frame and is looking in that same direction,
  108. 9:22let's say to the left, the space on the right loses importance and leaves an
  109. 9:27unbalanced composition with too much weight on the left and too little on the right. If, on the
  110. 9:33other hand, the character or object is on one side of the frame but is looking
  111. 9:38towards the opposite side, the framing gives importance to the space in front of the character,
  112. 9:44which is important since that's where they are looking and where their interest is focused,
  113. 9:49so it's more relevant to see the space in front of them than the empty space
  114. 9:54behind them, resulting in a more balanced composition. Thus, the rule of the gaze states that,
  115. 10:00depending on where the character is looking, the frame should have one
  116. 10:06third of the space behind them and two-thirds in front. And if we're talking about video,
  117. 10:12it's worth noting that often the character or object is followed, even when they
  118. 10:17turn or change direction, to maintain this composition. But understanding this is no guarantee
  119. 10:23of a good frame, and it’s not very useful if you don’t know how high or low to place the point of interest,
  120. 10:28just as the rule of thirds helps balance the image horizontally, headroom is a criterion
  121. 10:34that can help balance it vertically. Headroom is the space between the top
  122. 10:40of the frame and the head of the character or object,
  123. 10:43the amount of space considered appropriate varies depending on the size of the shot and the figure,
  124. 10:49but the idea is to not leave too much space or too little,
  125. 10:53as a general reference, the eyes are usually placed
  126. 10:56one-third below the top edge of the frame.
  127. 10:59With a balanced composition horizontally and vertically, you ensure
  128. 11:03having a good amount and well-balanced negative space, while giving
  129. 11:08the image and the viewer room to breathe, avoiding an undesirable feeling of confinement.
  130. 11:15The guidelines for leaving enough space above and to the sides
  131. 11:18of the image may seem a bit intuitive and inexact, but luckily to help simplify
  132. 11:24and organize this, there is the most commonly used technique of all, especially in cinema,
  133. 11:29which is "the rule of thirds" and it’s the first method we will see for
  134. 11:34composition. The rule of thirds is a visual composition technique designed to create
  135. 11:40a balanced and pleasing image to the eye,
  136. 11:44avoiding the point of interest splitting the image
  137. 11:46in half or being in the center of the frame, giving a sense of symmetry that is not intended.
  138. 11:51This technique consists of dividing the frame into three equal vertical thirds and three horizontal thirds,
  139. 11:57thus creating nine rectangles of the same size and four intersection points. On these lines,
  140. 12:03and especially at the intersection points, is where we should place what we want
  141. 12:07to highlight in the image.
  142. 12:10In case of having two centers of interest, they are usually placed each at
  143. 12:14an intersection point and ideally diagonally, to distribute the weight evenly between
  144. 12:19the lower and upper halves of the composition. It can also be possible to group
  145. 12:25two or more centers of interest and treat them as one when composing the
  146. 12:30frame. However, it should be noted that these lines are guides, and while it's necessary for
  147. 12:36the character or object to be relatively close, it doesn’t need to be perfectly on
  148. 12:42the line because, since the viewer doesn’t have a grid of thirds marked with precision
  149. 12:47on their retina, everything becomes a matter of relative perception. However,
  150. 12:53some consider that the structure of the rule of thirds is too stable and static,
  151. 12:58which is why they choose to use another composition criterion called "dynamic symmetry,"
  152. 13:04for which you first draw a line between the corners of the frame, and then
  153. 13:10intersect it with a perpendicular line, that is, at 90 degrees, connecting it with
  154. 13:16a corner of the frame. The result, like with the rule of thirds,
  155. 13:20is a point of interest at the intersection of both lines. By doing the same with the remaining corner,
  156. 13:26you get a new point of interest, and then it's a matter of repeating the same operation with
  157. 13:31the opposite main diagonal, thus obtaining the 4 key points of the image. The points of
  158. 13:37interest are slightly shifted in relation to the points obtained from the
  159. 13:43rule of thirds, but the main difference is in the lines, as they are not as
  160. 13:48perfect and stable, and by relying entirely on diagonal directions, they attract more attention,
  161. 13:53better mark the perspective, and are more dynamic in indicating the direction
  162. 13:59of the elements in the composition. Very briefly touching on other compositional methods,
  163. 14:05there's also the "golden composition," created from a pattern of numbers and measurements based
  164. 14:10on the golden spiral or Fibonacci spiral, which is associated with a beautiful image and can
  165. 14:16be found in various objects in nature. However, since the rule of thirds is a
  166. 14:21simplification of the golden ratio, unless you follow the Fibonacci spiral pattern
  167. 14:26very strictly, broadly speaking, the truth is that the golden composition usually doesn’t yield very
  168. 14:32different results or ones that cannot be achieved through the rule of thirds.
  169. 14:37Another method is the
  170. 14:38"rule of odds," having a single element in the image can convey a sense of
  171. 14:43loneliness or isolation, and two elements can create a composition that is too balanced
  172. 14:48and static, where both have almost identical weight and neither stands out over the other,
  173. 14:53but if there are three elements, a center is created among them. A greater number of even elements
  174. 14:59can be complicated to distribute, as it will always be a divisible number and thus
  175. 15:05the brain will probably form patterns and segmentation, providing an image
  176. 15:10that is divided and conceptually organized in a way the creator might not want,
  177. 15:16whereas if the number of elements remains odd, even if it is more than 3,
  178. 15:22this conceptual division won't happen and the image will look a bit more organic. And now let's move on to
  179. 15:27the last compositional method we will see: symmetry. The different methods of composition,
  180. 15:33including symmetry, can be used in various ways. For example, while Wes
  181. 15:39Anderson keeps it present throughout the entire film and uses it as an aesthetic and stylistic resource,
  182. 15:44Kubrick chooses to use it only for those shots that are prominent for the story. One of
  183. 15:51the studies developed by Gestalt psychology talks about the principle of symmetry, which
  184. 15:57states that the human mind finds a symmetrical image more attractive and balanced. This is
  185. 16:03enhanced if the motifs placed on both sides of the axis of symmetry have the same visual weight, and if
  186. 16:09the composition is centered around a vanishing point, even better. But,
  187. 16:15even if a symmetrical composition is not being used, it may be necessary to place the object
  188. 16:20of interest in the center anyway. This applies especially to video because it may be necessary for
  189. 16:26the viewer's eye to find the point of interest almost immediately without having
  190. 16:32to search for it in the frame, so the viewer will always have what they need to see right in front
  191. 16:37of their eyes. This allows for creating a fast and dynamic montage that is easy to understand and where
  192. 16:43the viewer's eye doesn't have to jump from side to side following the
  193. 16:47point of interest, because it will always be right in the center. Examples of this are the montage sequences
  194. 16:53by Edgar Wright, and even Mad Max: Fury Road follows this criterion throughout
  195. 16:58almost the entire film. The principle of symmetry shows us that the mind always wants
  196. 17:04to find visual balance, especially to understand how important balance and
  197. 17:10proportion are in distributing the elements in the composition.
  198. 17:15And so now we move on to talk about the different factors that influence
  199. 17:18whether an element has more or less weight within the frame.
  200. 17:22If a point of interest is too far from other elements in the frame, it can leave an
  201. 17:27empty space in the scene. In that case, one option is to balance the image with other objects
  202. 17:33filling the space or air that is creating that unwanted feeling of emptiness. On the other hand,
  203. 17:39it can also happen that another element in the image is attracting more attention than necessary,
  204. 17:45diminishing the subject matter a bit. That's when the composition's weight should be balanced
  205. 17:49so that the desired point of interest has the strength and presence it needs
  206. 17:55to stand out in the frame. Balancing the weight of an image has to do with the attention that each
  207. 18:00of the elements in the composition attracts. Although it must be remembered that compositional balance
  208. 18:05is something relative, these are some of the elements that influence the visual weight of objects:
  209. 18:12Light elements on a dark background
  210. 18:14weigh more than dark elements on a light background.
  211. 18:18Against a uniform background, the tone that contrasts the most with the background color will be heavier.
  212. 18:24Warm colors weigh more than cool colors.
  213. 18:28The larger the size, the heavier the
  214. 18:30object in the image and, consequently, it will attract more attention, and as an extra, size can also
  215. 18:37demonstrate in a shot a power relationship between characters, either to show that one
  216. 18:43has superiority over another or to show equality. But nevertheless,
  217. 18:48Not all composition schemes are based on the figure-ground relationship,
  218. 18:52the psychologist Rudolf Arnheim distinguished four different methods of composition: central,
  219. 18:57binary, hierarchical, and atonal. The central ones have a single strong point,
  220. 19:03this is the scheme most similar to figure-ground and can refer to something as simple as a portrait.
  221. 19:10Binary schemes present a duo of figures or groups
  222. 19:14and are typical of symmetric compositions.
  223. 19:17In atonal schemes, we can find many elements of
  224. 19:20equal weight that homogenize to create a unit centered on texture.
  225. 19:26And finally, hierarchical schemes are constituted by accents
  226. 19:30that range from strong to weak, related in a subordinate way.
  227. 19:34As we mentioned earlier, Gestalt psychologists studied minutely
  228. 19:38the different stimuli that create sensations and perception in the mind, thus forming the
  229. 19:44so-called "Principles of perception" which, in addition to the figure-ground law and the symmetry law that
  230. 19:49we mentioned earlier, here are some other Gestalt laws:
  231. 19:54Principle of proximity, which says that the mind perceptually groups elements that remain close
  232. 20:00to each other. Principle of continuity, where elements that are grouped continuously,
  233. 20:06whether straight or curved lines, tend to be perceived as a unit. Principle of identity or
  234. 20:12similarity, where elements are grouped by analogous characteristics, that is, based
  235. 20:18for example on color, size, shape, or other visual elements. And it's worth noting that in
  236. 20:26all these cases repetition is a fundamental unifying element that is attractive
  237. 20:31to the eye, as our brain often tends to want to group by finding patterns.
  238. 20:38And now we go to the last section of this video, which is "Lighting and Color."
  239. 20:44The different types of lights and colors can produce various shadows and shades affecting
  240. 20:50perception. To address lighting and colors from a composition aspect,
  241. 20:55it's necessary to know that these can be used to highlight a point of interest.
  242. 21:01Color is also used to achieve a harmonious image, for this it's advisable to simplify
  243. 21:06the composition, look for uniform backgrounds, and not use too many very marked colors to
  244. 21:12avoid backgrounds full of details that can distract attention. In general
  245. 21:17an image with few elements and few very contrasting colors is more impactful,
  246. 21:23than a composition with many elements where none stand out from the rest.
  247. 21:28The black and white image helps to better highlight the contrasts and prevents the color from
  248. 21:34distracting from other elements, like shape or texture. Saturated colors evoke intensity
  249. 21:40and soft tones, tranquility. The amount of colors and their range also affect the perception
  250. 21:46and sensations of the viewer, because each color can evoke specific feelings based
  251. 21:53on what is called "color psychology," but that's another topic I might cover
  252. 21:58in a future video.
  253. 22:00We can distinguish different types of contrasts, some of the
  254. 22:04most used are: Tone contrast, where saturated or intense colors are combined, with
  255. 22:10the contrast increasing the further apart the colors are on the color wheel,
  256. 22:15creating a striking and energetic effect. A subset of tone contrast
  257. 22:21is complementary color contrast, where this becomes more specific by juxtaposing
  258. 22:27two diametrically opposed colors on the color wheel. Temperature contrast,
  259. 22:33which occurs when a warm color is paired with a cool color.
  260. 22:38And while for the types of contrast just mentioned
  261. 22:40greater color saturation maximizes the effect of the contrast,
  262. 22:44one can also opt for "saturation contrast," where vivid colors are set against muted ones.
  263. 22:50And another type of contrast is brightness or chiaroscuro contrast,
  264. 22:56which occurs when a dark color is paired with a light one. In these cases, we usually say
  265. 23:02that the image has "high contrast," thus guiding attention through the juxtaposition of
  266. 23:08dark and light areas. It should be noted that this type of contrast is independent of color,
  267. 23:14so it works even in black and white images.
  268. 23:20And these are the basic (and some not so basic) principles
  269. 23:22of composition applied to cinema. As you can see, there are many things
  270. 23:27to keep in mind and, in the best cases, many of these elements manage to combine simultaneously
  271. 23:32to achieve a composition rich on various levels. And finally, considering that
  272. 23:38in video, the camera position can be changed at any time during the shot, this gives cinema
  273. 23:43and series a new possibility that no other (visual) art has,
  274. 23:47which is that the composition evolves over time. In this way, framing is generated along the shot itself,
  275. 23:54From very small things, like a slight camera movement,
  276. 24:00to sequence shots where the camera usually moves constantly, the framing
  277. 24:05changes. It can even happen that as a shot progresses, the composition
  278. 24:11criteria need to be changed if required. An example of this is
  279. 24:17Spielberg's sequence shots, which usually include clearly differentiated compositions. And now
  280. 24:23that you know all this, looking for and observing these aspects is a great way to rewatch
  281. 24:29a film you already know, to train your eye by paying attention to all these details
  282. 24:33and, who knows, maybe even putting them into practice yourself. Although many of
  283. 24:40the concepts we've seen are presented as "laws" or "rules," it's not mandatory to follow them,
  284. 24:45in fact, some of the best cinematographers in history often choose not to,
  285. 24:51mainly because experimentation is essential to discovering new possibilities,
  286. 24:56and besides, all this applies to achieving a balanced composition that's pleasant to view,
  287. 25:02pleasant to view, but what about when you want to create a different or more unsettling effect
  288. 25:09for the viewer through composition and move away from the tranquility of
  289. 25:13a balanced image? Well, for that, you'll have to wait for the next video where we'll see
  290. 25:20how these patterns can be broken by analyzing the compositions in Mr. Robot. So if you don't
  291. 25:26want to miss it, I suggest you subscribe and turn on notifications if you haven't already.
  292. 25:30As always, thank you very much and see you in the next video.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Técnicas y principios de composición fotográfica en cine y series by Luciano Avila sobre cine y series, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,077 words across 292 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.