Systematic Theology I - Lesson 7: The Holy Trinity (Biblical Foundations) — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:01Hello.
- 0:04Hello.
- 0:06Welcome to the continuation of our
- 0:08lesson on the Holy Trinity.
- 0:12Actually, welcome to our systematic
- 0:14theology class, right, everyone?
- 0:17And we're continuing our study of the
- 0:19being of God.
- 0:22And in this lesson specifically, this
- 0:24lesson and the next will be discussing
- 0:27one of the doctrines that is certainly
- 0:30very important to the Christian faith,
- 0:32one of the most important doctrines for
- 0:34our Christianity.
- 0:37Sometimes difficult to understand, and
- 0:39it's no coincidence that we're talking
- 0:40about the being of God.
- 0:43So it would be very strange if we were
- 0:46talking about someone so powerful,
- 0:48someone so great, and it sounded simple
- 0:50to us.
- 0:53So when we talk about God, it's obvious
- 0:56that at some point this will challenge
- 0:59our understanding, it will challenge our
- 1:01way of perceiving, but as Saint
- 1:04Augustine would say, we believe in order
- 1:07to understand.
- 1:08So we believe in God so that we can
- 1:11understand Him, OK?
- 1:15And I want to bring to you here,
- 1:16everyone, the presentation.
- 1:21So, just to recap, in this lesson we're
- 1:23going to talk about the Holy Trinity and
- 1:25its biblical foundations.
- 1:29We'll be showing that God is one in
- 1:32essence, but within that essence of God
- 1:35there are three persons, and the topics
- 1:39we'll be working on in this lesson are
- 1:42these five topics, okay?
- 1:47So, the first topic will be about the
- 1:49greatest mystery of faith.
- 1:54We'll explore the Trinity as a mystery
- 1:56of relationships that often defies human
- 1:59logic.
- 2:03Then we'll talk about the basis of
- 2:06Christian monotheism, showing that God
- 2:09is not a tritheism, not three gods, but
- 2:12one God, one essence.
- 2:15And within this divine being, this
- 2:18essence, we have three persons: Father,
- 2:21Son, and Holy Spirit.
- 2:25Then we'll talk about biblical plurality
- 2:27, identifying the seeds of the Old
- 2:29Testament and the full revelation in the
- 2:32life of Jesus.
- 2:34In other words, we'll see that from the
- 2:37context of the Old Testament we already
- 2:39have evidence of the Trinity, okay?
- 2:44Some people claim that the Trinitarian
- 2:45doctrine is only a New Testament
- 2:47doctrine, but I'm going to show you that
- 2:48, in fact, the doctrine of the Trinity
- 2:53begins in Genesis and goes all the way
- 2:56to Revelation.
- 2:57We're going to study these Trinitarian
- 2:59evidences in the context of the Old
- 3:00Testament, and
- 3:04I'll even leave you with some
- 3:06suggestions for videos you can watch for
- 3:08free on YouTube that will further
- 3:10clarify this very important point.
- 3:15Then we'll talk about God as one in
- 3:17essence, but three in person.
- 3:21We'll define the theological distinction
- 3:23between essence.
- 3:26God's essence is unique, but the person
- 3:29is distinct.
- 3:30There are three distinct persons: Father
- 3:32, Son, and Holy Spirit.
- 3:36And then we'll finish here with the
- 3:37conclusion and practical application,
- 3:39okay?
- 3:41So let's go, everyone.
- 3:44The Trinity is the most challenging
- 3:46concept in Christian theology.
- 3:50I believe that, along with the doctrine
- 3:52of the Trinity, there's only one other
- 3:53concept that's perhaps more difficult,
- 3:55or just as difficult to understand,
- 3:56which is the dual nature of Christ,
- 3:57right?
- 4:01Christ being true God and true man.
- 4:05How can Christ be both divine and human
- 4:07at the same time?
- 4:09This is a very difficult concept to
- 4:12grasp at times.
- 4:15And along with this concept, we have
- 4:17this challenge: How can God be one,
- 4:18right?
- 4:20One in essence, but at the same time
- 4:22three in persons?
- 4:24Christianity often faces
- 4:31accusations of being polytheistic or
- 4:33mathematically irrational because it
- 4:36claims that God is one, yet three
- 4:38persons.
- 4:41And you will see that we are not
- 4:43polytheistic. We affirm that there is
- 4:46only one God, and we are not irrational
- 4:50either, okay?
- 4:52Because we are not saying that God is
- 4:54one and three at the same time.
- 4:57We are saying that God is one in essence
- 5:01, but three persons.
- 5:04We are not creating a mathematical
- 5:07inconsistency here by stating that while
- 5:10God is one in person, He is three in
- 5:13person.
- 5:16Or that God is one in essence and three
- 5:18in essence.
- 5:19No, there is a distinction of categories
- 5:21here.
- 5:22So God is one in essence.
- 5:25The divine essence is only one, but
- 5:27within that essence dwell three persons
- 5:29.
- 5:31I like to give an example that I think
- 5:34makes it easier, in my opinion, perhaps
- 5:37this is the simplest way to understand
- 5:40the Trinity.
- 5:42My family is one, the Zulato family.
- 5:46But within my family there are three
- 5:48people, right?
- 5:49So there's a common surname, Zulato,
- 5:51right?
- 5:52My wife is Zulato, I am Zulato, my
- 5:54daughter is Zulato.
- 5:57So Virginia is Virginia Zulato, I am
- 5:59Vinicius Zulato and my daughter is
- 6:00Valentina Zulato.
- 6:02All three have the surname.
- 6:06We are one family, however, within this
- 6:08family, we have three people. The
- 6:10surname is common, but the person is
- 6:13distinct.
- 6:15God is common in essence.
- 6:18The Son is God, the Spirit is God, the
- 6:21Father is God, however, even though all
- 6:24three are divine, they are distinct
- 6:26persons, right?
- 6:30The Father is not the Son, the Son is
- 6:31not the Spirit and the Spirit is not the
- 6:33Father.
- 6:36Even though the Father is God, the Son
- 6:38is God and the Spirit is also divine,
- 6:41right?
- 6:43Another very simple way to understand
- 6:45this is to think about humanity, right?
- 6:48We are all human.
- 6:51Human nature is common to us all, but
- 6:55each of us is a person, right?
- 6:59Each of us is a distinct person.
- 7:03And that's how we should understand the
- 7:05Trinity itself.
- 7:07Regarding humanity, we are all human,
- 7:09but we are not all the same person.
- 7:12God has the same essence, yet there are
- 7:15three distinct persons.
- 7:18Divine mathematics is not about addition
- 7:20, but about perfection and relationship
- 7:22.
- 7:24We don't study the Trinity to understand
- 7:26it exhaustively—that would be impossible
- 7:28, right?
- 7:30We've already talked about that.
- 7:31In fact, we will spend all eternity
- 7:34getting to know the being of God,
- 7:38but the purpose of knowing the
- 7:40Trinitarian doctrine is worship, okay?
- 7:45We know God as He revealed Himself in
- 7:47the Holy Scriptures for the purpose of
- 7:49worshipping Him, okay, my brothers and
- 7:51sisters?
- 7:53Glory to God.
- 7:55So, what is the central thesis when we
- 7:57talk about the Holy Trinity?
- 8:00What is the central thesis? The central
- 8:02thesis is that there is only one God,
- 8:04okay? There is only one God,
- 8:09however, the Father, the Son, and the
- 8:12Spirit are distinct persons, each fully
- 8:14divine.
- 8:16We say that there are seven categorical
- 8:21statements regarding the Trinity.
- 8:25And the first categorical statement is
- 8:27this: there is only one God who subsists
- 8:30in three persons, right?
- 8:32So that is the categorical statement.
- 8:34How many gods are there? There is only
- 8:36one, but in the divine essence there are
- 8:39three persons: Father, Son, and Holy
- 8:42Spirit.
- 8:43And then we have the next six statements
- 8:46, right?
- 8:48So the first statement is: the Father is
- 8:51not the Son, the Son is not the Spirit,
- 8:53and the Spirit is not the Father.
- 8:56So three here.
- 8:59And then we have the other three
- 9:00statements: they are distinct in person
- 9:02, right?
- 9:03The Father is not the Son, the Son is
- 9:06not the Spirit, and the Spirit is not
- 9:09the Father. Distinction in persons: the
- 9:11Father, the Son, and the Spirit are
- 9:13distinct.
- 9:16And we have the next three statements:
- 9:18the Father is God, the Son is God, and
- 9:21the Spirit is God.
- 9:24So each of them is fully divine, even
- 9:26though they are distinct persons, we
- 9:29affirm that there is only one God, but
- 9:31in essence there are three persons, okay
- 9:34?
- 9:37Let's go.
- 9:39Hmm, following here.
- 9:41Let's go, my son.
- 9:43Here.
- 9:45So, when we look at the context of the
- 9:48Old Testament, we have the basis of
- 9:50monotheism, right, Deuteronomy 6: 4,
- 9:52which is the Shema, the confession of
- 9:54Israel, "Hear, O Israel: The Lord our
- 9:57God, the Lord is one."
- 10:01So here we have a very important word,
- 10:03right?
- 10:05Here we have the daily confession of
- 10:07Israel establishing radical monotheism
- 10:10in the face of polytheism. What does it
- 10:13mean to affirm that there is only one
- 10:15God? What does that mean?
- 10:18To affirm that there is only one God is
- 10:21not to say that our God is just one
- 10:24among all the others.
- 10:27That is not monotheism.
- 10:29And it is also not to say that our God
- 10:33is the greatest among all gods, okay?
- 10:37So monotheism is affirming that there is
- 10:41only one God.
- 10:43There is no other.
- 10:46There is no God, right, like our God,
- 10:48who compares to ours.
- 10:51And ours is not the greatest among all
- 10:53gods either, okay?
- 10:55Our God is unique, unique.
- 10:59Hear, O Israel: The Lord your God, the
- 11:02Lord is one, the God of Israel.
- 11:06And I want to remind you here that this
- 11:09word "unique" that appears here
- 11:12is the Hebrew word "errad," okay? Errad
- 11:16.
- 11:18And this word "errad" is important
- 11:20because, despite speaking of God as
- 11:23unity, as unique, it also speaks of God
- 11:25as a composite unity, okay?
- 11:29So the word "unique" here is not
- 11:32singularity, but unique, but within a
- 11:35composite unity.
- 11:38God is unique, but within this
- 11:40uniqueness, this singularity of God,
- 11:43there is community.
- 11:46What do I mean by "isolated"?
- 11:48It would be more or less like this, okay
- 11:49?
- 11:51Think of a bunch of grapes, right?
- 11:54So you have one bunch and you have
- 11:55several grapes.
- 11:57It's just one bunch, but you have many
- 12:00grapes there. God is like that, God is
- 12:03one.
- 12:05He is "errad," he is unity, but within
- 12:07the singularity of God you have
- 12:10diversity.
- 12:13So while other neighboring peoples
- 12:15worshipped multiple gods, were
- 12:18polytheistic, believed in many gods,
- 12:20Israel affirmed the existence of a
- 12:23single living and true God.
- 12:26There is no other, He is not the
- 12:28greatest, He is the only one. He is not
- 12:31one among others, He is unique. Only He
- 12:34is God, okay?
- 12:37In the context of the Old Testament, the
- 12:39Bible makes it very clear that God does
- 12:41not share His glory, right?
- 12:44In Isaiah 45: 5, the Bible declares the
- 12:47absolute sovereignty of God.
- 12:50God declares, "I am the Lord, and there
- 12:53is no other besides me.
- 12:56There is no God besides me, there is no
- 12:58other."
- 13:01This revelation establishes that there
- 13:03is no deity besides the Creator,
- 13:05reaffirming that He does not share His
- 13:07glory with anyone.
- 13:10That is, there is no other deity that
- 13:12can compare to Him.
- 13:15There is nothing and no one like our God
- 13:19, okay?
- 13:21Christianity rejects tritheism. What
- 13:24would tritheism be?
- 13:26It would be the belief in three
- 13:28different gods, right?
- 13:30Three distinct gods, three distinct
- 13:34deities.
- 13:35We don't believe that way; we don't
- 13:37believe that the Father is one God, the
- 13:39Son is one God, and the Spirit is
- 13:41another God—three distinct gods. We
- 13:43believe there is only one.
- 13:46The essence among them is common; there
- 13:48is only one God, but they are distinct
- 13:50in personality.
- 13:53The Father is one person, the Son is one
- 13:55person, and the Holy Spirit is one
- 13:57person.
- 13:58Father, Son, and Spirit do not divide
- 14:00the divinity into parts, right?
- 14:02That's another important point.
- 14:05The Trinity is not what we would call
- 14:08Sabellianism,
- 14:10where the Father, right?
- 14:12There's a God who revealed himself at a
- 14:15certain moment as the Father, then
- 14:17revealed himself as the Son, then
- 14:19revealed himself as the Holy Spirit, or
- 14:22where the Father has one part of the
- 14:24divine, the Son has another, and the
- 14:26Spirit has another—that's not it.
- 14:30Each person of the Trinity is completely
- 14:33divine, possessing the totality of God's
- 14:36essence, maintaining absolute unity of
- 14:39the divine being, okay, my brothers?
- 14:42This is very important, right?
- 14:45So we don't have a little piece of the
- 14:47divine in the Father, a little piece in
- 14:48the Son, a little piece in the Spirit,
- 14:50and when the three come together they
- 14:51form, right, a complete unity. No,
- 14:53that's not it.
- 14:54The Father is completely divine, the Son
- 14:56is completely divine, the Spirit is
- 14:58completely divine.
- 15:00We can perceive this within the sacred
- 15:03text by looking at the titles, right, at
- 15:06the attributes in worship that are given
- 15:09to the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.
- 15:13When you look at Revelation, when you
- 15:15look at the Bible as a whole, in fact,
- 15:18you will realize that the same
- 15:20attributes that are given to the Father
- 15:22are given to the Son and are given to
- 15:25the Holy Spirit.
- 15:28The Father is omniscient, omnipotent,
- 15:30omnipresent; the Son is omniscient,
- 15:32omnipotent, omnipresent; the Spirit is
- 15:34omniscient, omnipotent, omnipresent.
- 15:37The Father receives glory, honor, power
- 15:39, and praise; the Son receives glory,
- 15:41honor, power, and praise; the Spirit
- 15:43receives glory, honor, power, and praise
- 15:44.
- 15:47This shows us that they are fully divine
- 15:50, equally worthy of the same praise,
- 15:53honor, and glory, and possessing
- 15:56complete divinity, okay?
- 16:00Following the limits of tritheism,
- 16:02Christianity categorically rejects
- 16:05tritheism, which defends the existence
- 16:07of three separate gods.
- 16:10The divine essence is unique and
- 16:12indivisible, okay?
- 16:14So there is no division in this essence
- 16:15between Father, Son, and Spirit.
- 16:18The Father, the Son, and the Spirit do
- 16:21not divide divinity into parts or
- 16:22percentages.
- 16:25Each person possesses the totality of
- 16:28God's essence, okay?
- 16:32And here we will see the seeds of this
- 16:34Trinitarian doctrine in the Old
- 16:36Testament.
- 16:41So, is there evidence in the context of
- 16:44the Old Testament that there is
- 16:47plurality within singularity?
- 16:50Yes.
- 16:52Of course, my brothers, we will have a
- 16:55perfect understanding of this plurality
- 16:58within singularity in the incarnation of
- 17:01Christ, right?
- 17:04Christ, through his incarnation, made us
- 17:06, right?
- 17:07He showed us that within the divine
- 17:10being there is a family: Father, Son,
- 17:13and Holy Spirit.
- 17:16This is in John, chapter 1. The biblical
- 17:19text says that the Word became flesh,
- 17:21and when the Word dwelt among us, we saw
- 17:24his glory, the glory as of the only
- 17:27begotten of God, full of grace and truth
- 17:29.
- 17:32So, upon becoming a human being, what
- 17:34did we perceive?
- 17:36We perceived, through the incarnation of
- 17:39the Word, that God the Father has had
- 17:41his beloved Son with him from all
- 17:43eternity, and that the Son is loved by
- 17:46the Father from all eternity through the
- 17:49bond of the Spirit, right?
- 17:51The Spirit is the means, it's what we
- 17:54call the bond, it's the*caritas*, right
- 17:56? The bond of love.
- 17:58Paul speaks about this in Ephesians,
- 18:00chapter 4, that the Spirit is the bond
- 18:03of love between us and God, the Father,
- 18:06Son, and Spirit, but also the Spirit is
- 18:08the bond of love between the Father and
- 18:11the Son.
- 18:13The Father loves the Son by giving him
- 18:15the Holy Spirit, and the Son loves the
- 18:18Father by submitting to him through the
- 18:20work of the Spirit, okay?
- 18:24In Genesis 1:26, a text well known to
- 18:26all of us, the Bible says, "And God said
- 18:27," right?
- 18:29Singular, "And God said," and the text
- 18:32continues, "Let us make man in our image
- 18:35."
- 18:36So you have the verb in the plural
- 18:39applied to a being in the singular, and
- 18:43God said, "Let us make."
- 18:46And it's worth remembering that here in
- 18:49Genesis chapter 1, when God makes a
- 18:52being in his image and likeness, God
- 18:54doesn't make an individual, God makes a
- 18:57community.
- 18:59God created man and woman, in the image
- 19:02of God he created them; male and female
- 19:04he created them. So what is the being
- 19:07created in the image of God?
- 19:09The being created in the image of God is
- 19:13humanity, it is plurality, it is this
- 19:16composition between man and woman who,
- 19:19despite being distinct in person, are
- 19:22common in essence, right?
- 19:25Both are human, in fact, Eve, right,
- 19:27participates in the humanity of Adam,
- 19:30she is formed from Adam, and Adam also,
- 19:32when presenting his wife, says, "She is
- 19:35flesh of my flesh and bone of my bones;
- 19:37she shall be called Woman, for she was
- 19:39taken from me."
- 19:42And he says, "And this one, right?"
- 19:44It's a mystery: a man shall leave his
- 19:45father and mother and be joined to his
- 19:47wife, and the two shall become
- 19:51one flesh.
- 19:54Paul says this is a profound mystery in
- 19:55Ephesians 5, but referring to Christ and
- 19:57the church.
- 20:00So when God creates a being to represent
- 20:03Him, God didn't create an individual
- 20:05being, God created a community, because
- 20:08since God is communal, then God also
- 20:10creates a community to represent Him.
- 20:15The Trinity is not a late innovation, as
- 20:17some will say, but a progressive
- 20:19revelation.
- 20:22In the Old Testament we find the seeds
- 20:24of divine plurality, as in Genesis 1:26
- 20:26, where God refers to Himself in the
- 20:28plural, right?
- 20:30And God said, "Let us make..." And
- 20:33furthermore, we have here in the context
- 20:35of the Old Testament, as we will study,
- 20:37the figure of the angel of the Lord.
- 20:42And this angel of the Lord is a very
- 20:44important figure, and I'm going to
- 20:46recommend a video to you here, which I
- 20:48think is very important, from a channel
- 20:50called The Bible Project, okay?
- 20:53You can watch it in both English and
- 20:55Portuguese; I believe it's also
- 20:56available in Spanish.
- 21:00And on this channel you'll find this
- 21:02video, "The Angel of the Lord."
- 21:05And I want you to watch it because it
- 21:08will further clarify what I'm going to
- 21:10talk to you about now.
- 21:13But it's interesting that this angel of
- 21:15the Lord in the context of the Old
- 21:17Testament, despite being distinct from
- 21:20God himself, receives worship as God
- 21:22does, and often qualities,
- 21:23characteristics, and attributes given to
- 21:26God himself in the context of the Old
- 21:28Testament are also attributed to this
- 21:30angel of the Lord.
- 21:32So, the figure of the angel of the Lord
- 21:35demonstrates a personal distinction
- 21:37between God, right?
- 21:39God the Father, and this angel, which we
- 21:42call a Christophany, right?
- 21:44An appearance of Christ already in the
- 21:47context of the Old Testament, pointing
- 21:49to the fullness of Christ's ministry,
- 21:51right?
- 21:53Of Christ himself, which would later be
- 21:55clearly revealed through the incarnation
- 21:57, okay?
- 21:59So, speaking here of the angel of the
- 22:01Lord, this mysterious figure, right? In
- 22:03the context of the Old Testament, the
- 22:05mysterious angel of the Lord appears as
- 22:08a singular figure in various accounts,
- 22:11such as in Exodus chapter 3, right?
- 22:15When Moses approached God at the burning
- 22:18bush, the Bible says that the angel who
- 22:21appeared to him was the angel of the
- 22:23Lord.
- 22:26Let's read this text; I think it's very
- 22:27important for us here.
- 22:30Exodus chapter three.
- 22:34Exodus three, starting from verse one,
- 22:38says this: Moses was tending the flock
- 22:42of his father-in-law, Jethro, a priest
- 22:46of Midian.
- 22:49One day he led the flock to the far side
- 22:51of the desert and came to Horeb, the
- 22:54mountain of God.
- 22:57Verse two: There the angel of the Lord
- 23:01appeared to him in a flame of fire from
- 23:04within the bush.
- 23:07So, look how interesting, the one who
- 23:09appears to Moses in the burning bush is
- 23:11the angel of the Lord.
- 23:14The text says that Moses saw that
- 23:16although the bush was on fire, it was
- 23:18not consumed by the flames, so Moses
- 23:20thought, "I'm going to approach to see
- 23:22this impressive thing, because the bush
- 23:25is not burning."
- 23:28And then the text says that when the
- 23:30Lord saw that he was approaching to
- 23:33observe, God himself spoke to Moses from
- 23:36within the bush.
- 23:38So, look how interesting.
- 23:41The one who appears in the burning bush
- 23:43is the angel of the Lord.
- 23:47But the biblical text says that upon
- 23:49seeing the bush and approaching, God
- 23:51himself speaks to Moses from the midst
- 23:54of the bush.
- 23:58The Lord, right, the Lord, upon seeing
- 24:00Moses approaching, the Bible says that
- 24:03God himself called him from the midst of
- 24:05the bush, saying, "Moses, Moses."
- 24:09And he answered, "Here I am." And then
- 24:12God said to him, "Do not come any closer
- 24:13.
- 24:14Take off your sandals, for the place
- 24:18where you are standing is holy ground."
- 24:23So in various accounts, such as in
- 24:26Exodus 3, the angel of the Lord is like
- 24:30someone sent by God, but who
- 24:32simultaneously speaks as God himself and
- 24:35accepts worship, revealing, people, a
- 24:38personal distinction within the divine
- 24:41unity itself.
- 24:44You have God, you have the angel of the
- 24:47Lord, but you have the angel of the Lord
- 24:50speaking as God and being worshiped as
- 24:53God.
- 24:55Theologically, "Go on, go to Mommy.
- 25:01But Daddy's recording class here, my
- 25:03love. Daddy's recording class.
- 25:10But go on, Daddy's recording class,
- 25:12princess."
- 25:15But Daddy can't be with you right now,
- 25:18daughter.
- 25:303 2 1 So, theologically, there's a
- 25:33distinction here.
- 25:38Uh, let's go over it again.
- 25:413 2 1 Theologically, these
- 25:43manifestations are identified as
- 25:46Christophanies, right, appearances of
- 25:49Christ himself in angelic form in the
- 25:52context of the Old Testament.
- 25:56The term, folks, designates a visible
- 25:58appearance of Christ before his
- 26:00historical incarnation.
- 26:04So, in these moments, the Son of God
- 26:07anticipates his full revelation,
- 26:10interacting with the covenant people in
- 26:13a form that prefigures his saving
- 26:15mission, OK?
- 26:18And then I leave you with the challenge
- 26:21, once again, to watch the video "The
- 26:24Angel of the Lord" on The Bible Project
- 26:27channel, okay?
- 26:29It will be very beneficial for you, okay
- 26:32?
- 26:34Moving on here.
- 26:37And then we have, right, other texts
- 26:39that I'm going to show you here where
- 26:42the angel of the Lord appears and that
- 26:44he is, at the same time, distinct from
- 26:47God, but is called divine and receives
- 26:50worship.
- 26:52So, for example, we have here the first
- 26:55case study, Hagar and the angel of the
- 26:57Lord.
- 26:59So, in the desert, the angel of the Lord
- 27:01finds Hagar. What is happening here?
- 27:05In Genesis 16: 7-13, I won't read the
- 27:07text because of the time constraints of
- 27:10our class, but what do we have?
- 27:14We have Hagar fleeing from Sarah because
- 27:17of the friction that occurred between
- 27:20them because of Ishmael and Isaac, right
- 27:23?
- 27:25Ishmael mocks Isaac for being younger,
- 27:29and then the biblical text says that
- 27:33Sarah asks Abraham to send Hagar away.
- 27:38In fact, at this first moment, Hagar
- 27:39flees because of the disagreements with
- 27:41Sarah.
- 27:44And then the Bible tells me, you, that
- 27:47in the desert the angel of God finds
- 27:49Hagar and assumes the full authority of
- 27:51God.
- 27:52We'll have to read this text just to
- 27:55notice this detail here. Open it with me
- 27:57, please.
- 27:58Genesis 16.
- 28:05Genesis 16,
- 28:13verses 7-13.
- 28:17The text says the angel of the Lord
- 28:20found Hagar near a spring in the desert
- 28:22on the road to Shur and asked her, "
- 28:25Hagar, servant of Sarai, where have you
- 28:28come from?
- 28:30Where are you going?"
- 28:34She answered, "I am fleeing from Sarai,
- 28:36my mistress." Then the angel of the Lord
- 28:39said to her, "Go back to your mistress
- 28:41and submit to her authority."
- 28:44The angel of the Lord also said, "I will
- 28:47multiply your descendants so much that
- 28:49they cannot be counted."
- 28:53The angel of the Lord further said to
- 28:56her, "You are pregnant and will have a
- 28:58son, and you shall name him Ishmael,
- 29:01because the Lord has heard you in your
- 29:03oppression."
- 29:08Verse 12, "He will be like a wild donkey
- 29:11; his hand will be against everyone, and
- 29:14everyone's hand against him.
- 29:17He will live in hostility toward all his
- 29:21brothers."
- 29:23Verse 13. And this was the name, pay
- 29:25attention, this was the name she gave to
- 29:28the Lord who had spoken to her.
- 29:33So, folks, look, this was the name Hagar
- 29:36gave to God, to the Lord Yahweh, the
- 29:38name of God that appears here, who had
- 29:41spoken to her.
- 29:44"You are the God who sees me," she said
- 29:47, "Have I seen the One who sees me?"
- 29:52Therefore, the well that is between
- 29:54Kadesh and Bered was called,
- 30:01which means "well of the One who lives
- 30:04and sees me."
- 30:06Folks, Hagar, look how interesting.
- 30:10Uh, Hagar understands, right? Uh, going
- 30:15back to the text, he not only, right?
- 30:19So Hagar meets the angel, right, with
- 30:22the authority of God, and he not only
- 30:24delivers a message to her, but speaks in
- 30:26the first person, promising that he
- 30:28himself, right, the angel of the Lord
- 30:31here, will multiply her descendants as
- 30:33if he were Yahweh himself.
- 30:38Hagar understands the divine nature of
- 30:41that encounter; she recognizes the
- 30:43authority of God in his words.
- 30:48The text says, and she calls that figure
- 30:52who appeared to her, right?
- 30:57"The God who sees me," identifying the
- 31:00messenger as God himself, as the Lord
- 31:03himself, okay?
- 31:07So, as we've already seen here in Exodus
- 31:093: 2-6, we have Moses encountering God
- 31:12at the burning bush, and there we have
- 31:14the distinction: the angel of the Lord
- 31:17appears to Moses in the midst of a flame
- 31:19of fire, manifesting himself within the
- 31:21burning bush that was not consumed.
- 31:27And then the narrative transmits to the
- 31:29voice of God, who identifies himself as
- 31:31the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac,
- 31:33the God of Jacob, revealing his divine
- 31:36identity.
- 31:38And here we have the reverence before
- 31:40the manifest presence of the Creator in
- 31:42the fire; Moses hides his face in fear,
- 31:44recognizing the holiness of the one who
- 31:46spoke to him.
- 31:48The visible manifestation of Yahweh's
- 31:51presence in the bush was given through
- 31:54the angel of the Lord, okay, folks?
- 32:00And then we have another very
- 32:01interesting text here, which is when the
- 32:03angel of the Lord appears to Gideon's
- 32:05parents.
- 32:09So the biblical text says that the
- 32:11parents appear there to Manoah, to
- 32:13Gideon's parents, promising him a son
- 32:15who will be the liberator.
- 32:18The angel of the Lord then appears to
- 32:19Gideon on horseback, initiating a direct
- 32:21and personal dialogue with him.
- 32:25The Bible says that when Gideon places
- 32:28his offering, the angel accepts it, and
- 32:31the offering is consumed by miraculous
- 32:34fire, revealing the angel's identity as
- 32:37Yahweh himself.
- 32:41The Bible says that, fearing death for
- 32:44seeing God's face, Gideon is reassured
- 32:47by building an altar, calling it Yahweh
- 32:50Shalom, which means "The Lord is God of
- 32:54peace."
- 32:57And now, folks, we have here, right,
- 33:01this other text from Judges 13, verses 1
- 33:05and 2, which is the text I was referring
- 33:09to. You have Gideon seeing the angel of
- 33:11the Lord and also his parents, okay?
- 33:15So, when questioned about his name, the
- 33:17angel appears to Manoah, right, when
- 33:20questioned about his name.
- 33:23In fact, Manoah is Samson's parents,
- 33:26okay? Samson's parents, pardon me.
- 33:29So, when they appear here to Samson's
- 33:31parents,
- 33:34Samson's parents want to know the
- 33:36angel's name so they can worship him
- 33:38properly, right? And then the angel says
- 33:41to them, "Why do you ask for my name?
- 33:45My name is wonderful, my name is too
- 33:47wonderful for your comprehension."
- 33:51And the Bible says that, upon consuming
- 33:54the sacrifice in the flames of the altar
- 33:57, the angel then reveals his identity to
- 33:59Manoah, okay?
- 34:01Manoah realizes that the one who was
- 34:04speaking to him was God himself.
- 34:08So, the biblical text maintains a
- 34:09consistent pattern.
- 34:13Folks, I'd like to read all the texts
- 34:15with you, but we can't do that because
- 34:17of time constraints, but all the
- 34:19references are here in the presentation
- 34:22so that you can...Going back here, folks
- 34:24, so the texts will be here so that you
- 34:27can
- 34:31read them and have a deeper
- 34:34understanding of this subject, okay?
- 34:40So, remembering here, the biblical text
- 34:42maintains a consistent pattern.
- 34:44The angel is presented, right, as
- 34:46distinct from God the Father, but speaks
- 34:49in the first person as Yahweh himself.
- 34:54Human beings react with fear before this
- 34:57angelic being because they perceive that
- 35:00they are seeing God himself and they
- 35:02worship him.
- 35:05People, if this angel were not a divine
- 35:08person distinct from God the Father,
- 35:11this would be considered idolatry in the
- 35:14context of the Old Testament, right?
- 35:18God the Father himself would condemn
- 35:20this act as idolatrous, because God the
- 35:23Father says that anything in heaven, on
- 35:25earth, under the earth, in Exodus 20,
- 35:27right, which is the text of the
- 35:29Decalogue,
- 35:35these creatures should not be worshiped
- 35:38, and if this happens, it is idolatry.
- 35:41But in the case of the angel of the Lord
- 35:44, even though he is a figure distinct
- 35:46from God the Father himself, he receives
- 35:48titles, divine attributes, is worshiped
- 35:51as God, but this is not considered
- 35:53idolatry, and his own worshipers
- 35:55recognize that they are before God
- 35:57himself, OK?
- 35:59The narrative never corrects this
- 36:01identification, validating the
- 36:04recognition that the figure of the angel
- 36:07of the Lord, right, whom they are before
- 36:10, is God himself there, in some angelic
- 36:13form, and they are therefore
- 36:15contemplating the presence and authority
- 36:19of God himself, okay?
- 36:23And then, moving on to the analysis of
- 36:26this theme in the context of the New
- 36:28Testament, I could point out, in the
- 36:31book of Genesis, in addition to the text
- 36:34of Genesis 1:26, where you have God
- 36:36saying, "Let us make," so you have the
- 36:39plural verb applied to a singular being
- 36:42.
- 36:44When man sins, you have God, right?
- 36:49Walking towards the human being, and the
- 36:52word that appears there in the original
- 36:54, right?
- 36:56For man hiding from God, it says that
- 36:58man hid himself from the face of the
- 37:00Lord, right?
- 37:02As if there were, right, plurality in
- 37:04God. Man hid himself from the face of
- 37:07God.
- 37:09Then, when God appears on the scene and
- 37:12is about to deliver his judgment, God
- 37:14says, "Now man has become like one of us
- 37:17, okay?
- 37:18Like one of us."
- 37:21And here, it's not possible to say,
- 37:22right?
- 37:23That it's in Genesis 3, it's not
- 37:24possible to say he became like one of us
- 37:26here, so it's talking about God and the
- 37:28angels.
- 37:29No, because man was in a fallen state,
- 37:31in a state of rebellion.
- 37:34So, in what sense did man become like
- 37:37one of us?
- 37:39The text says he knew good and evil, but
- 37:42that community, right?
- 37:45Had known good and evil, just as the
- 37:47divine community, Father, Son, and
- 37:49Spirit, knew, right?
- 37:51They know good and evil.
- 37:53The difference is that man, upon knowing
- 37:54good and evil, becomes contaminated with
- 37:56wickedness, becoming wicked, and God
- 37:58knows good and evil without necessarily
- 37:59becoming wicked because of it.
- 38:02Right?
- 38:03I already told you, you have the text of
- 38:05Deuteronomy 6: 4, "Hear, O Israel: The
- 38:07Lord your God is wrong," it's a
- 38:08community.
- 38:11You have Genesis 11 when God goes down
- 38:13to confuse languages, and there at the
- 38:16Tower of Babel, you have the text saying
- 38:19, "Let us go down and confuse their
- 38:22languages."
- 38:23So you have a lot of evidence that there
- 38:26is plurality in God's being, even in the
- 38:28context of the Old Testament.
- 38:31But when we get here to the New
- 38:33Testament with the incarnation of the
- 38:34Lord Jesus Christ, then, brothers and
- 38:36sisters, this becomes very clear, right
- 38:38?
- 38:40So in Matthew 3:16 and 17, which is the
- 38:43baptism of Jesus, the Bible says that
- 38:46when Jesus goes down into the waters
- 38:48being baptized by John the Baptist, the
- 38:51heavens open, and the Spirit of God
- 38:53descends upon him in bodily form like a
- 38:56dove, and this directly refers to the
- 38:59text of Genesis chapter 1 where the
- 39:01spirit hovered,
- 39:04and the word "hovered" in the original
- 39:06speaks of a bird flying over the waters
- 39:09.
- 39:10So you have the Spirit of God descending
- 39:13upon the Son, just as in the beginning,
- 39:16upon the waters, right, from chaos.
- 39:21So you have the son going down into the
- 39:23water, the spirit coming upon him, and
- 39:26the Bible says there is a voice, a voice
- 39:28from heaven proclaiming about the son, "
- 39:31You are my beloved Son, in whom I am
- 39:33well pleased."
- 39:36So the scene reveals simultaneous
- 39:37interaction between the three persons.
- 39:40While the son is being baptized, the
- 39:43spirit descends upon him like a dove,
- 39:45and the father speaks from heaven, right
- 39:47?
- 39:48In the context of the Old Testament, the
- 39:50voice that guides the people of Israel,
- 39:52right? God always appears as the voice;
- 39:55he is the voice that echoes from Sinai,
- 39:57the voice that guides the people, the
- 39:59voice that directs.
- 40:01So once again here, even in the context
- 40:03of the New Testament, right?
- 40:05In Matthew 17, when God speaks again
- 40:07about the identity of the son, God
- 40:09appears there as the voice.
- 40:13He is the one who speaks.
- 40:15So we have the father's voice echoing
- 40:17the identity of the son, "You are my
- 40:18beloved Son, in whom I am well pleased.
- 40:20"
- 40:21So you have the son in the water, the
- 40:23spirit coming in the form of a dove, and
- 40:24the father's voice echoing from heaven.
- 40:28This event, the baptism of Christ,
- 40:31personally, demonstrates that God is not
- 40:34a single person wearing distinct masks,
- 40:37but an eternal communion between three
- 40:39distinct persons, okay?
- 40:46So there are three persons, but the same
- 40:50divine essence.
- 40:54Another very interesting thing in
- 40:57Matthew 28:19, when Jesus is releasing,
- 41:00right, the text here of the Great
- 41:03Commission, Jesus commands that baptism
- 41:07be done in the name.
- 41:10So it's not in the names of the Father,
- 41:13the Son, and the Spirit, but it's in the
- 41:15name.
- 41:16The name.
- 41:18So God the Father has a name.
- 41:22So, right, God the Father, the Son, and
- 41:24the Spirit, right, are three distinct
- 41:26persons, but God has only one name.
- 41:30The name. Name, not names.
- 41:32What is the name of God? The name of God
- 41:36is Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.
- 41:40So in Matthew 29:19 Jesus commands
- 41:43baptism in the singular name of the
- 41:45Father, one person, the Son, another
- 41:48person, and the Spirit, another person.
- 41:52This formula reveals, personally, the
- 41:54unity of the divine essence
- 41:56simultaneously with the distinction of
- 41:58persons, of the three persons of the
- 42:01Trinity.
- 42:03The apostolic blessing that appears in
- 42:06Second Corinthians, chapter 13, appears
- 42:08in practically all the Pauline letters,
- 42:11in the Petrine and Johannine letters, in
- 42:14the general letters.
- 42:16The apostolic blessing is a Trinitarian
- 42:19blessing, right?
- 42:22The apostolic blessing synthesizes
- 42:24Christian life in the communion of the
- 42:26Trinity: the grace of Christ, the love
- 42:29of God the Father, and the communion
- 42:31that comes from the Holy Spirit.
- 42:34The communion that is given through the
- 42:36work of the Spirit. So you see why the
- 42:38Spirit is the bond, the charity, the
- 42:40bond of love?
- 42:41Because the communion of the saints is
- 42:43through the work of the Spirit, in the
- 42:45love of the Father and in the grace of
- 42:47the Son.
- 42:49So each of the persons reveals, right?
- 42:53A face, reveals an aspect of the being,
- 42:56the character, the attributes of God,
- 42:59right?
- 43:00The Son reveals grace, the Father
- 43:03reveals love, and the Spirit, the
- 43:06communion that is given through His work
- 43:09, okay?
- 43:12Although grace, love, and communion
- 43:15belong to the three—love, grace, and
- 43:18communion belong to the Father, the Son
- 43:21, and the Spirit—each plays a role in
- 43:24the work of salvation, revealing
- 43:27distinct realities.
- 43:32A very important point we're discussing
- 43:34here, moving on to point three, is the
- 43:36distinction between essence and person.
- 43:40What is the difference between essence
- 43:42and person?
- 43:44Essence, folks, is what...Essence
- 43:47corresponds to what God is.
- 43:51Essence refers to the divine nature,
- 43:54which is unique and indivisible, fully
- 43:56shared by the Father, the Son, and the
- 43:59Spirit.
- 44:03God is the only being without division
- 44:06or fragmentation.
- 44:10So, for example, if I were to say in
- 44:12this lesson, let's imagine we could do
- 44:15this: put a table, I'd be on this side,
- 44:17put a table between me and you, and
- 44:20you'd be on the other side.
- 44:23So there's me, a table, and you.
- 44:27And then I'll start talking, look, every
- 44:30time you feel mentioned, okay?
- 44:34You raise your hand.
- 44:36So I say, "Women, raise your hands."
- 44:39"Men, raise your hands.""Brazilians,
- 44:42raise your hands."
- 44:44So, as you feel called, you raise your
- 44:47hand.
- 44:49But you agree with me that if I say "
- 44:52human,""humanity," you would all raise
- 44:54your hand, maybe not all the students
- 44:57would raise their hands when I said "
- 44:59man," right?
- 45:01The women wouldn't raise their hands.
- 45:03If I say "woman," the men won't raise
- 45:05their hands.
- 45:06If I say "Brazilian," the Hispanics,
- 45:09Indians, Americans, students of other
- 45:11nationalities won't raise their hands.
- 45:15But when I say "human," it doesn't
- 45:17matter if you are Brazilian, man, woman
- 45:19, Indian, American, Hispanic, it doesn't
- 45:21matter, we will all raise our hands, why
- 45:24?
- 45:25Because the human essence is common to
- 45:27all of us, to all of us.
- 45:31So when I say, "Father," it's the Father
- 45:33.
- 45:35When I say "Son," it's the Son.
- 45:38When I say "Holy Spirit," it's the Holy
- 45:41Spirit.
- 45:42But when I speak of the divine, when I
- 45:44speak of God, then we are speaking of
- 45:47the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit
- 45:49, okay?
- 45:51The essence is common, even though the
- 45:54persons are distinct.
- 45:56Person is the "who."
- 45:58The person corresponds to who God is.
- 46:01The one divine being exists eternally as
- 46:04three distinct subjects: the Father, the
- 46:07Son, and the Holy Spirit.
- 46:10And it's worth remembering that the
- 46:11Father is not the Son, the Son is not
- 46:13the Spirit, and the Spirit is not the
- 46:15Father, even though the Father is God,
- 46:17the Son is God, and the Spirit is God.
- 46:20They maintain personal and relational
- 46:23distinction, acting in perfect unity,
- 46:26okay?
- 46:30So, a very interesting way for us to
- 46:33understand the distinction of persons,
- 46:36even though the essence is common, is to
- 46:39look at the work of the Trinity, what we
- 46:43call the economic Trinity, right?
- 46:47Trinitarian economy.
- 46:50There are two ways for us to understand
- 46:52the Trinity, which is the ontological
- 46:54Trinity, right?
- 46:56The Trinity before time, and the
- 46:59economic Trinity, which are the roles
- 47:01that each person of the Trinity plays in
- 47:04the work of salvation.
- 47:08So the Trinity before time is understood
- 47:10in the relationship that each of the
- 47:12persons has with one another before the
- 47:14foundation of the world.
- 47:17As I told you, the Father loving the Son
- 47:19through the bond of the Spirit, and the
- 47:22Son honoring and submitting to the
- 47:24Father through the bond of the Holy
- 47:27Spirit, okay? So we have
- 47:31this reality before the existence of all
- 47:34things.
- 47:36However, upon creating all things and
- 47:38beginning to manifest His grace, through
- 47:41creation and, of course, also through
- 47:43the fall of human beings, we have the
- 47:46economic Trinity, which are the roles
- 47:48that each of the persons plays in the
- 47:50work of salvation.
- 47:52So, in the work of salvation, it's in
- 47:54Ephesians 1, okay?
- 47:56We don't have time to read the text, but
- 47:59in Ephesians 1, the divine persons act
- 48:02with distinct functions.
- 48:06Although they play different roles, each
- 48:09of the three shares the same dignity,
- 48:12the same power, the same essence, and
- 48:15they act in perfect unity.
- 48:19So, in Ephesians chapter 1, what is the
- 48:21Father's function?
- 48:23The Father is responsible for planning,
- 48:26for planning and electing.
- 48:31The Son is the one who incarnates and
- 48:34dies for the Father's plan and election
- 48:37, okay?
- 48:38That's what's in Ephesians.
- 48:40And the Holy Spirit is the one who
- 48:43applies the election and the power of
- 48:46salvation given by the merits of the Son
- 48:49to those who have been called and
- 48:52elected by God, okay?
- 48:56So each of the persons plays a distinct
- 48:58role.
- 49:00The Father is the one who plans and
- 49:02elects, the Son becomes a human being
- 49:04and dies for those who have been elected
- 49:06by the Father, and the Holy Spirit is
- 49:08the agent, the one who seals and applies
- 49:10the work of salvation that was given to
- 49:12us through the merits of Christ.
- 49:16Okay, so, folks,
- 49:20what are the applications we can find in
- 49:23this topic for our lives?
- 49:25What can we learn here?
- 49:30How is the doctrine of the Trinity
- 49:32useful, how does it apply to our life
- 49:35context?
- 49:38The Trinity reveals that love is the
- 49:40very essence of God.
- 49:44If God were a solitary person before
- 49:46creation, He could not be love, because
- 49:49love requires someone to love.
- 49:53Like the Trinity, the Father, right?
- 49:56Because there is a plurality in God's
- 49:59being, even though it is one God, but
- 50:01three persons, the Father loves the Son
- 50:04and the Son loves the Father through the
- 50:06Spirit from all eternity.
- 50:10And we were created to participate in
- 50:13this relational and perfect communion,
- 50:16okay?
- 50:19A second application we can find in the
- 50:22doctrine of the Trinity is how this
- 50:24doctrine teaches us, influences our way
- 50:26of praying.
- 50:28The Trinity makes prayer possible and
- 50:32relational.
- 50:34According to Ephesians 2:18, we have
- 50:37access to the Father through the Son in
- 50:40one Spirit.
- 50:42This divine dynamic ensures that all our
- 50:45communion with God is sustained by the
- 50:47intercession of Christ and the
- 50:49indwelling of the Holy Spirit within us
- 50:51.
- 50:53Jesus himself taught us that we should
- 50:55pray to the Father in his name through
- 50:57the power of the Holy Spirit.
- 50:59So what guarantees us
- 51:03access to communion with the Father,
- 51:05with his family, is the work of the Son
- 51:06.
- 51:08And who gives us the power, the right,
- 51:11who applies these categories, let's put
- 51:13it this way, to our hearts so that we
- 51:15can, in the name of the Son, approach
- 51:17the Father?
- 51:19It is the person of the Holy Spirit.
- 51:22And so, moving towards the conclusion,
- 51:25let us worship the triune God.
- 51:27I like talking to you all, right?
- 51:30I think I've already said this to you a
- 51:32few times, but my brothers and sisters,
- 51:35I had this lesson in the courses I took
- 51:37, seminars, college, but something I
- 51:39really like, right?
- 51:42I had a professor I really liked when he
- 51:44taught this lesson, because he said that
- 51:46when we talk about the Trinity, we are
- 51:48talking about the being of God, about
- 51:50the essence of God.
- 51:52And it's like an invitation, right?
- 51:55For me, for you, as it was for Moses,
- 51:57take off your sandals because the place
- 51:59you're standing on is holy ground, it's
- 52:02holy soil.
- 52:05So when we speak of God, brothers and
- 52:07sisters, we need, when we speak of God,
- 52:10we need to have this reverence, this
- 52:12reverence, right?
- 52:14We are standing on holy ground here. We
- 52:17are speaking here about the character of
- 52:20God.
- 52:21So what is the greater purpose, besides
- 52:24learning to pray, besides understanding
- 52:27here, right?
- 52:29The being of God, this essence of love
- 52:32that exists between Father, Son, and
- 52:35Spirit, what can we apply to our lives?
- 52:41Our worship should reflect this
- 52:43revelation of God's family, of the
- 52:45Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit.
- 52:49We worship the one God in His perfect
- 52:52communion, and this invites us to dwell
- 52:55in this eternal love that the Father,
- 52:58Son, and Spirit have enjoyed since
- 53:01before the creation of the world, okay?
- 53:05So let our worship reflect this
- 53:08understanding of the Father, the Son,
- 53:11and the Spirit, that we may worship the
- 53:14one God who, in His perfect communion,
- 53:17invites us to dwell in His eternal love
- 53:20, OK?
- 53:22As an old church song would say, the
- 53:24doxology says to the supreme benefactor
- 53:27God, you angels and men give praise.
- 53:32To God the Son, to God the Father, to
- 53:35God the Holy Spirit, give glory, OK?
- 53:40God bless you.
- 53:42In our next meeting we will continue
- 53:44discussing this doctrine of the Trinity
- 53:47, but talking about the deviations, the
- 53:49Trinitarian errors, and I believe that
- 53:52this will further clarify this point so
- 53:54that we can have understanding and
- 53:56worship God as He deserves to be
- 53:58worshipped.
- 54:01God bless you and until then, God
- 54:03willing.
- 54:04Goodbye.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Systematic Theology I - Lesson 7: The Holy Trinity (Biblical Foundations) by Living Water University, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,248 words across 1,229 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.