Synology vs UGREEN in 2026: The Verdict Shifted — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00A year ago, Synology and Ugreen weren't
- 0:02really close, meaning that Synology DSM
- 0:051 on software and it wasn't really much
- 0:07of a debate. But a lot has changed since
- 0:09then. UGOS Pro got a lot of updates.
- 0:12Synology made some changes that pushed
- 0:13people away. And in this video, I'm
- 0:15going to walk you through exactly what's
- 0:17different and who each of these devices
- 0:19makes sense for. But before any of that,
- 0:21I want to be up front that on software
- 0:24alone and on the ecosystem side, DSM is
- 0:27still the winner and that side of it
- 0:29hasn't really changed. Synology been
- 0:31doing this for close to 30 years at this
- 0:33point and Ugreen simply hasn't. So if
- 0:35you came here and you wanted to know
- 0:37straight up if DSM and UGOS are equals
- 0:40at this point, they're not and DSM still
- 0:43leads in that category. With that said,
- 0:45what's actually changed is a little more
- 0:47nuanced than that. The reasons to pay
- 0:50for Synology's premium ended up being
- 0:52weaker than they were a year ago and
- 0:54UGOS Pro has gotten to be good enough
- 0:57that for most home users, you're not
- 0:59really compromising much and we're going
- 1:01to get into exactly why. So the shift is
- 1:03really not that Ugreen has won, it's
- 1:05that Ugreen is no longer something that
- 1:08you have to settle for if you're talking
- 1:10about software. And that comes down to
- 1:12two main things. UGOS Pro has matured
- 1:15over the past year and Synology's own
- 1:17decisions, which mainly came around DSM
- 1:197.3 and 7.4 have changed the equation.
- 1:23So once we get past all of that, we're
- 1:24going to look at the things that
- 1:25actually matter for people, which is
- 1:27photos, Docker and applications as well
- 1:30as things like remote access. Then we're
- 1:32going to get into the hardware side and
- 1:33explain how this drive lock-in still
- 1:36matters today even though things have
- 1:38been walked back. So I think it actually
- 1:40does make sense to take a step back and
- 1:42start with the drive lock-in because
- 1:43it's one of the most confusing topics.
- 1:45So last year, Synology released the
- 1:47DS925+
- 1:49and it shipped with hard drive
- 1:50restrictions. So what that means is that
- 1:53you could not use third-party hard
- 1:55drives in the device. you had to use
- 1:58Synology's first-party hard drives.
- 2:00That, rightfully so, pushed a lot of
- 2:02people away, and many people were upset,
- 2:04and rightfully so. But, here's the part
- 2:06that's changed since then. So, since
- 2:09Synology DSM 7.3, you can use whatever
- 2:12hard drive you want, and note, I am
- 2:14saying hard drive. So, the hard drives
- 2:16themselves, you can use third-party
- 2:19drives, even if they are not verified by
- 2:21Synology. That means that the general
- 2:23drive restrictions have technically been
- 2:26walked back. So, if you were avoiding
- 2:27Synology purely because of the overall
- 2:302025 hard drive controversy that
- 2:33existed, that specific problem is kind
- 2:35of gone, but not entirely. I say not
- 2:38entirely because new features are being
- 2:40announced and released, but you're not
- 2:43really able to use them. So, for
- 2:45example, with Synology DSM 7.4, they
- 2:48introduced a new feature called storage
- 2:50efficiency, which is basically a
- 2:52post-process deduplication that you can
- 2:55run to compress the data that you're
- 2:56storing on your volumes. That's a fancy
- 2:59way of saying that instead of storing
- 3:01the same data multiple times, you're
- 3:03only going to store it once, which then
- 3:05allows you to save storage space. It's a
- 3:07really nice feature, and something that
- 3:09I'm happy that they added, but the
- 3:11feature is locked behind Synology
- 3:13drives. So, we're at this crossroads
- 3:16where technically, you can set up a
- 3:17storage pool and a volume with
- 3:19third-party hard drives, but now there
- 3:21are features that are being released
- 3:23that you can't actually use. So, it's
- 3:25not fair to entirely say that you can
- 3:28use third-party hard drives. It's fairer
- 3:30to say that you can install and use
- 3:33third-party hard drives, but only with
- 3:36most of the functionality, and not all
- 3:38of the functionality. So, while we just
- 3:40talked about third-party hard drives,
- 3:42there are still SSD restrictions. So,
- 3:45there's going to be a lot of features
- 3:46and functionality that people are
- 3:48looking to use that you might not be
- 3:50able to use unless you just purchase
- 3:52Synology drives. So, that's in a
- 3:54nutshell where we stand today with the
- 3:56Synology driver restrictions and we'll
- 3:58say hardware restrictions that exist.
- 4:01It's not a clean platform where you can
- 4:03use any of the drives you want to use.
- 4:06You could potentially use third-party
- 4:08hard drives. You will lose out on some
- 4:10functionality and you most likely cannot
- 4:12use third-party SSDs. Now, I've been
- 4:14running Synology hardware for close to
- 4:1610 years at this point. I've had various
- 4:18devices like the DS10 19 plus, 923 plus,
- 4:21925 plus. So, I'm not coming at this
- 4:23from the angle of somebody that dislikes
- 4:25Synology. I've always liked Synology,
- 4:28but the restrictions are a problem. So,
- 4:30with those restrictions explained, we
- 4:32then have to talk about the other side
- 4:34of this, which is UGEOS Pro and I'm
- 4:37highlighting the operating system
- 4:39because from a hardware perspective,
- 4:40you'll see later that they don't really
- 4:42compare. So, if you were interested in a
- 4:44Synology, you're interested in it
- 4:46because of Synology DSM. So, how does
- 4:48UGEOS Pro compare to Synology DSM in
- 4:522026? And the truth is it's gotten a lot
- 4:55better. So, it now supports things like
- 4:57BTRFS volumes and it has snapshot
- 4:59support. It has a more mature photos
- 5:01application. You can use their mobile
- 5:03application. It has Docker. It has a
- 5:05really great virtual machine
- 5:06application. It has sync and backup.
- 5:08There's a new surveillance center
- 5:09application that allows you to connect
- 5:11ONVIF cameras and use an NVR style
- 5:14retention for that data. So, we're not
- 5:17looking at a bare-bones operating system
- 5:20at this point. We're looking at a true
- 5:21operating system that has a lot of
- 5:23first-party applications. Those
- 5:25first-party applications still fall
- 5:27behind Synology DSM for the reasons we
- 5:30discussed before. So, while Ugreen is
- 5:32offering these applications, they're not
- 5:34nearly as developed or feature-rich as
- 5:37the Synology versions mainly because
- 5:39Synology's been refining this platform
- 5:41for close to 30 years. Next is security
- 5:44and while there haven't been any major
- 5:46Ugreen security vulnerabilities that
- 5:48have popped up. Security Center is
- 5:50weaker. Their cloud backup destinations
- 5:52are far more limited than they are on
- 5:54the Synology side. And while you get
- 5:56more options, you're syncing data. So,
- 5:59you're syncing your backup data to the
- 6:01cloud, you are not backing it up. And
- 6:03that's a real limitation and something
- 6:05that I need to point out. Because a true
- 6:07backup is something like Hyper Backup,
- 6:09where if you were backing up your data
- 6:11from a Ugreen NAS to the cloud, you're
- 6:13really going to be using Ugreen's sync
- 6:16application, which means that if you
- 6:18were to delete data on the NAS, you're
- 6:20actually deleting data in the backup
- 6:22location as well, because it's a sync.
- 6:24So, that means that you need to have
- 6:25some sort of snapshot policy on the
- 6:28destination side to ensure that you're
- 6:30able to recover the data on the
- 6:32destination side if it is deleted. So,
- 6:34that is all to say that UGOS is good
- 6:37enough right now for home users, but
- 6:39it's still behind Synology from an
- 6:41ecosystem perspective. And while they
- 6:44still have alternatives to a lot of the
- 6:46Synology applications, they're not
- 6:48nearly as feature-filled. So, with that
- 6:51out of the way, let's get into some
- 6:52head-to-heads from a software
- 6:54perspective. Now, Ugreen has their photo
- 6:57application, and this is something that
- 6:59most NAS users are interested in. So,
- 7:01can Ugreen Photos be a real Synology
- 7:05Photos replacement? And the answer is
- 7:07mostly yes. The thing that I like most
- 7:09about both of these options is that they
- 7:11have a mobile application that allows
- 7:14you to back up your photos that you take
- 7:16to the NAS device. And that is, in my
- 7:19opinion, the absolute most important
- 7:21feature that they can possibly have,
- 7:24because that ensures your data is being
- 7:26backed up. That's a baseline for me, and
- 7:28both of them do it, and they do it well.
- 7:30Then you could talk about things like AI
- 7:33facial and object recognition, and they
- 7:35both have them. It used to be only a
- 7:38Synology uh feature that Synology
- 7:41offered, but Ugreen added it, and
- 7:43overall, they both work well. I'm not
- 7:45going to say they work great, though,
- 7:47and this is something that is
- 7:48notoriously hard to do. It's compared to
- 7:51things like Google Photos, except for
- 7:53Google Photos tends to be a lot better
- 7:56in that way compared to some of these
- 7:59self-hosted alternatives. But, I say
- 8:01self-hosted alternatives because this is
- 8:03the one area where if you were going to
- 8:05go out of your way to install something,
- 8:07I would, and I would install Image. Now,
- 8:10Image is a third-party photo
- 8:12application, and again, while the setup
- 8:14is going to be a lot harder, it's the
- 8:16path I'd recommend that you go because
- 8:19in my opinion, Image is simply superior
- 8:22to both of these options. So, it's a
- 8:24good thing that you can install them on
- 8:26both if you wanted to because you
- 8:27configure it through Docker. And the key
- 8:29there is Docker because you can run
- 8:31Docker on both of these. The one thing
- 8:34I'll say is that Docker tends to be more
- 8:36important on the Ugreen side because
- 8:39they don't have that first-party
- 8:41ecosystem that Synology has. So, to name
- 8:43a few of those, Hyper Backup, Synology
- 8:46Drive, and Active Backup for Business
- 8:48are genuinely hard to replace even with
- 8:51third-party applications. In my setup, I
- 8:54have replaced those, and I have videos
- 8:56on how I've replaced them. But, if
- 8:58you're trying to replace them, it's not
- 9:00easy, especially if you compare it to
- 9:03something like the actual setup process
- 9:05for those applications on Synology
- 9:07devices because it's in the Package
- 9:09Center, and you basically just install
- 9:10and configure them, and it's drastically
- 9:13harder as soon as you get into
- 9:14third-party tools. So, if you were
- 9:16interested in doing things like that on
- 9:18a Ugreen NAS, their first-party options
- 9:21really have to be compared to the
- 9:23third-party options that you can install
- 9:25on Docker. And that's why I think it's
- 9:27so important to install Docker and a
- 9:30virtual machine application because
- 9:32that's going to allow you to install and
- 9:34configure those third-party apps. So, if
- 9:36you're not interested or if you don't
- 9:39like the Ugreen first-party apps, you do
- 9:41have an alternative, but for complete
- 9:44novices, it's not nearly as easy to use
- 9:47as it is on the Synology side with their
- 9:49first-party applications. So, this is
- 9:51all to say that if you're living in
- 9:53Synology's application ecosystem and
- 9:56you're interested in replacing it with
- 9:58Ugreen application, it's not going to be
- 10:00a one-to-one. But with that said, if you
- 10:03were to self-host everything in
- 10:05containers, it's basically a wash
- 10:07because you're going to be able to do
- 10:08the same on both of them. So,
- 10:10applications are what I consider to be
- 10:12the most important feature, but the
- 10:14second most important feature is remote
- 10:16access. And this is where Ugreen is
- 10:18actually a little better, and I say
- 10:21better, but it's mainly from a
- 10:23performance side because the Ugreen link
- 10:25service, in my experience, has been
- 10:28slightly faster than Synology's
- 10:30QuickConnect. Now, the point here is
- 10:32that it's not drastically faster. You're
- 10:34talking about two to four times faster
- 10:37in my testing, but that doesn't really
- 10:39mean much. And I say that it doesn't
- 10:41really mean much because the way they
- 10:43work is they basically use relay
- 10:45services. So, you're routing some of
- 10:47that traffic through their servers,
- 10:50which is not really a security concern,
- 10:54even though it potentially sounds that
- 10:55way, and there haven't been any major
- 10:57security vulnerabilities on either side
- 10:59that have been discovered, but it leads
- 11:01to a lot of performance issues. So, if
- 11:03you're downloading data, you're going
- 11:05from your NAS to their cloud to your
- 11:07client device. So, you're adding an
- 11:09intermediary there to broker that
- 11:12connection. For that reason, the
- 11:13recommendation is to remove that
- 11:16intermediary and use something like a
- 11:18VPN. So, that would be something like
- 11:20WireGuard, OpenVPN, or if you didn't
- 11:23want to configure either of those, you
- 11:24could use Tailscale. And this is where
- 11:26they differ again. So, Synology has a
- 11:29kernel limitation, which means that you
- 11:32can't actually run WireGuard on Synology
- 11:35devices. You can run Tailscale, but
- 11:38Tailscale, while technically being
- 11:40WireGuard under the covers, requires a
- 11:43third party to basically manage that
- 11:46connection. So, you're using Tailscale,
- 11:48which is technically WireGuard, but it's
- 11:50not a true WireGuard implementation the
- 11:53way it would be on the UDM side. So, if
- 11:56you wanted to run a first-party VPN on
- 11:58the Synology side, you have to use their
- 12:01VPN server application, which I've used
- 12:04for many years in the past, and it works
- 12:06well, but you're limited to their
- 12:08options, and you cannot use WireGuard,
- 12:10which in my testing is drastically,
- 12:13drastically faster than OpenVPN is. So,
- 12:15that is a potential downside if you were
- 12:19interested. Now, I say potential
- 12:20downside because the truth is that in my
- 12:23opinion, if you wanted to run a VPN, you
- 12:26should buy the dedicated hardware that
- 12:28you need. So, I'd look into something
- 12:30like a UniFi Cloud Gateway, which allows
- 12:33you to basically configure a pretty
- 12:35powerful network as a beginner or novice
- 12:39because they just make everything easy
- 12:40to use. So, I have a full UniFi network
- 12:43buying guide that I will leave a pop-up
- 12:45for now, but if you were interested in
- 12:48running a VPN, and you didn't really
- 12:50want to run it on your NAS, which a lot
- 12:52of people don't, that is the path that
- 12:54you can go down. Now, I spent a lot of
- 12:56time on the software, but it's important
- 12:58to highlight the hardware, too. And this
- 13:00is where things have shifted, as well.
- 13:02So, the Synology DS925+
- 13:05is the latest four-bay NAS device that
- 13:07Synology has. And with those hard drive
- 13:10restrictions removed, if we completely
- 13:12remove them from the equation, it's
- 13:14still genuinely one of the best, if not
- 13:17the best pre-built NAS device that you
- 13:19can buy. But the hard drive
- 13:20restrictions, or I should say drive
- 13:22restrictions, are the real issue. And
- 13:25with that in mind, now you have to start
- 13:27comparing hardware versus hardware. And
- 13:29as soon as you do that, you start to see
- 13:32where QNAP really starts to pull ahead.
- 13:35So, unlike Synology, where they have one
- 13:37or two four-bay NAS devices, QNAP has an
- 13:40entire lineup and you're going to be
- 13:42able to find just about whatever you
- 13:43want. So, the three devices I think most
- 13:45people would naturally land on are the
- 13:48DXP 4800 Plus, the DXP 4800 Pro, and the
- 13:53DXP 4800 GT. Now, while they're all very
- 13:56similar, they are also very different.
- 13:59So, the DXP 4800 Plus is Intel-based, it
- 14:03has DDR5 RAM, it has two networking
- 14:05ports, one is 10 gig and one is two and
- 14:08a half. But, it has Intel's Quick Sync
- 14:10if you wanted it for Jellyfin or Plex.
- 14:12And that's important because the GT
- 14:14model does not have that. Before we get
- 14:16to that GT model, the DXP 4800 Pro
- 14:19basically just a slightly more superior
- 14:22version of the DXP 4800 Plus. So, in
- 14:25general, if you wanted the Plus, the Pro
- 14:28is going to be roughly the same, mainly
- 14:29from a performance perspective. But, the
- 14:31GT is where things get interesting
- 14:33because it's their latest model and it
- 14:36has an AMD processor instead of Intel.
- 14:39But, that allows it to support things
- 14:41that the Intel model doesn't support.
- 14:43So, for example, you can use ECC RAM in
- 14:46it. And ECC RAM is error correcting.
- 14:49Now, it's important to highlight that
- 14:50the Synology device comes with dedicated
- 14:53ECC RAM. So, while this device is
- 14:56technically ECC-capable,
- 14:58it does not actually ship with it. So,
- 15:00you'd have to go out of your way to buy
- 15:02it. It also has other features like two
- 15:0410 gig ports. It has U.2 support, which
- 15:07is going to be rather niche for most
- 15:09people. But, for the most part, you're
- 15:11going to be comparing Intel versus AMD
- 15:14and if you do or do not want to use
- 15:17Intel's Quick Sync. If you do, go Intel.
- 15:20If you don't and you want ECC support,
- 15:22you can go on the AMD side. Which leads
- 15:25us to the last point, which is that if
- 15:26you hated absolutely everything that I
- 15:29said about Ugreen's operating system,
- 15:32you can install TrueNAS or Unraid on any
- 15:35of the Ugreen devices, and you don't
- 15:37have to run Ugreen OS at all. Now, the
- 15:40one thing in specific is that the GT
- 15:42line uses eMMC storage for the operating
- 15:45system. So, if you really wanted to run
- 15:48TrueNAS or Unraid, you should install it
- 15:51on one of the two dedicated M.2 slots,
- 15:54so where you can wipe the plus or pro
- 15:57M.2 NVMe SSD and install TrueNAS or
- 16:00Unraid on it, even though it's not
- 16:02something I would technically recommend
- 16:04that you do. You could do that, where on
- 16:06the GT line, you really have to get your
- 16:09own dedicated one and install it on
- 16:11that. But, that's a long-winded way of
- 16:12saying UGOS is an option, it is not a
- 16:16requirement. You can use it, but if you
- 16:18don't like it, you can also use Unraid
- 16:20or TrueNAS, and I have personally been
- 16:23running TrueNAS on two Ugreen devices
- 16:26for close to a year at this point, or I
- 16:28should say one for close to a year, and
- 16:29one I recently added, and it's worked
- 16:32very well. So, the last point on that is
- 16:34that if you were buying a Synology NAS,
- 16:37you are buying it to run Synology DSM.
- 16:40With a Ugreen NAS, you can run UGOS,
- 16:42TrueNAS, Unraid, or just about any other
- 16:45operating system that you want. So, the
- 16:47main point in that is that you have a
- 16:48lot of flexibility. So, with that said,
- 16:51who should actually buy what device in
- 16:542026? And the answer is that if you're a
- 16:57home user, and you want it to just work,
- 17:00and you value the app ecosystem that
- 17:02Synology has, if you don't mind paying a
- 17:04premium for pretty outdated hardware,
- 17:07you should just get a Synology device.
- 17:09Just keep in mind, you're going to have
- 17:11drive limitations, and over time, those
- 17:13drive limitations are going to rear
- 17:15their ugly head. But, something like the
- 17:17DS925 plus is a genuinely good device.
- 17:21Well, with that said, if you want
- 17:22drastically better hardware for the
- 17:24money, and I stress hardware for the
- 17:26money because they're not drastically
- 17:28different in price, but they are when
- 17:30you start to compare the hardware
- 17:31because the Ugreen devices are superior
- 17:34in literally every single way from a
- 17:36hardware perspective. If you're one of
- 17:38those people, then a Ugreen NAS device
- 17:40is the way to go. But, keep in mind
- 17:42there are limitations, and you're going
- 17:44to have to get into some self-hosting,
- 17:47especially using Docker. The first-party
- 17:49applications are going to be a little
- 17:52bit more limiting than they are on the
- 17:53DSM side. And if you're interested in
- 17:56running any of them, it's going to be a
- 17:58little bit more of a learning curve than
- 18:00it would be on Synology DSM. But, none
- 18:02of that is to say that you can't get
- 18:04everything working. It's just to say
- 18:06that you might have to put a little more
- 18:08effort into it. If you're one of those
- 18:09people, basically decide now if you want
- 18:13to use Plex or Jellyfin trans coding. If
- 18:15you do want to use Plex or Jellyfin
- 18:17trans coding, go with something like the
- 18:19plus or pro line because they come with
- 18:21Intel-based CPUs. But, if not, you can
- 18:24look at the GT model as well. I have a
- 18:26full video that compares all three of
- 18:28those devices that I will leave a pop-up
- 18:31for now. So, to summarize all of this,
- 18:33while a lot has changed, a lot is still
- 18:35the same. Synology DSM is still the
- 18:38better operating system. But, there is
- 18:40one big flip, and the big flip is that
- 18:42for most home users, Ugreen is no longer
- 18:45going to be a compromise, and Synology
- 18:48really has to earn the premium that
- 18:50you're going to end up paying for it.
- 18:52Where in the past, it was easy to just
- 18:53say, "Ah, just pay the premium because
- 18:56Synology is better." It's not really the
- 18:58case in 2026. So, for better hardware,
- 19:01for a good, we'll say, operating system
- 19:04experience, Ugreen is a perfectly
- 19:07legitimate option in 2026. But, if
- 19:10you're somebody that wants that
- 19:11appliance-like functionality, where you
- 19:13just want a NAS device that's going to
- 19:15work, you don't want to worry about any
- 19:17of the applications having problems, you
- 19:19don't want to spend a lot of time on
- 19:21that, Synology is still probably the
- 19:23path that you should go down. The key is
- 19:25that in 2026, this is far more of a
- 19:29personal decision than it was in the
- 19:31past. Meaning that some people are going
- 19:33to be better off going down the UGREEN
- 19:34path, and some people would be better
- 19:36off going down the Synology path. Where
- 19:38at one point, almost everyone was better
- 19:41going down the Synology path. And that
- 19:43is the main point in this video. It's
- 19:46far more of a comparison now than it's
- 19:49ever been in the past. So, I hope you
- 19:51got some value out of this video. I know
- 19:53we went over a lot today. So, if you
- 19:54have any questions, feel free to leave
- 19:56those in the comments. But, other than
- 19:58that, if you made it this far, thank you
- 19:59very much for watching. I'll see you
- 20:00guys next time.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Synology vs UGREEN in 2026: The Verdict Shifted by WunderTech, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,660 words across 529 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.