SUPERDOTAÇÃO: A verdade que ninguém conta | Ep #11 | Com Dra. Olzeni Ribeiro — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00You who want to have a successful
- 0:07business, you need to know Brain
- 0:09Gymnastics. Brain Gymnastics is a
- 0:11franchise network with an innovative
- 0:14method to stimulate the brain at
- 0:16different stages of life, which already
- 0:18has 43 units and over 15,000 students
- 0:20throughout Brazil. Recommended for
- 0:23typical and atypical children who have,
- 0:25for example, level 1 autism, ADHD,
- 0:27dyslexia, among others. Young people
- 0:30with anxiety, attention difficulties,
- 0:32and seniors who want to keep their
- 0:34minds active. Because I know the
- 0:36competence and seriousness of the
- 0:38doctors behind Brain Gymnastics, I am
- 0:40here recommending it. So, if you are
- 0:42interested and would like more
- 0:44information to bring it to your city,
- 0:46access the QR code here on the screen.
- 0:49And if you want to be a student, visit
- 0:51their Instagram or the website
- 0:53ginasticadocerebro.com.br. Access the
- 0:56QR code and learn more. Hello, welcome
- 0:59to Anima Especial. Here we will talk
- 1:03about neuroscience, neuroeducation,
- 1:06diversities, and challenges of
- 1:08neurodevelopmental disorders. I am
- 1:11Rafael Rangel, a neuropediatrician, and
- 1:13here today we will be hosting a super
- 1:16special person, talking about an
- 1:17extremely important topic that creates
- 1:20many challenges. Welcome, Dr. Ozeni
- 1:23Ribeiro. Thank you for your presence.
- 1:26Thank you very much, Dr. Rafael. It is
- 1:27an honor to be here. Every time we can
- 1:30disseminate information about something
- 1:32so invisible, right? That is very good.
- 1:35Exactly. People are looking for it. So
- 1:37now I have made everyone curious, right
- 1:38? So
- 1:41what would be this term high abilities
- 1:44and giftedness? Is it the same thing?
- 1:48Is it something different? You, who
- 1:50study, publish, and work in this area,
- 1:52please start by defining these two
- 1:54terms a little bit. if it is the same
- 1:56thing, if it is not the same thing so
- 1:59people can understand this set of words
- 2:01,
- 2:01right? Great question to start with,
- 2:04right? Because here in Brazil, there is
- 2:06a confusion between these two terms.
- 2:10You will see throughout our
- 2:12conversation that I only use giftedness
- 2:14because the term high abilities has
- 2:17brought, it refers to something that
- 2:19brings a a confusion of concepts. Why?
- 2:26We have giftedness or high abilities,
- 2:28because first, to say that here in
- 2:31Brazil it is the same thing, still in
- 2:33the legislation, in the guidelines that
- 2:36guide evaluation, guide schools, high
- 2:38abilities or giftedness/means the same
- 2:41thing in Brazil. So, whoever refers to
- 2:44high abilities or giftedness is talking
- 2:46about the same thing. Exactly. If you
- 2:48evaluate, identify a child, make this
- 2:50diagnosis, it doesn't matter if you put
- 2:53high abilities or giftedness or both.
- 2:57It's the same thing, because sometimes
- 2:58there’s a separation, giftedness,
- 3:00what have you, super-gifted, that
- 3:02doesn't exist. But the term "altas
- 3:06habilidades," there was a mix-up almost
- 3:0950 years ago in the translation of "
- 3:12high ability," as if it were "high
- 3:15skills," when in reality, it's high
- 3:18capacity. Because giftedness, or this
- 3:22neurodevelopmental condition, a
- 3:24neurodivergence called "high capacities
- 3:27" in other countries, or "well-endowed,
- 3:30" is always something extra, but here
- 3:33it became "superdotação." So I’ve
- 3:36started using "superdotação"(
- 3:37giftedness) to see if we can change the
- 3:39culture of thinking. Because we say,
- 3:42when you talk about ability, the first
- 3:44question that comes to mind is: in what
- 3:47?
- 3:47In what, what is this?
- 3:48What do you do best? What kind of
- 3:50superpower is that, right?
- 3:51You have it, right? And when you try to
- 3:54see "in what," you don't find this
- 3:56neurodivergent condition. You’ll find
- 3:59a talent, something someone trains to
- 4:02be the best at. But giftedness is a
- 4:04condition, or "high abilities." I’ll
- 4:07speak here so as not to create more
- 4:09confusion. It is a neurodevelopmental
- 4:11condition that is genetic, mostly
- 4:14hereditary. And the child is already
- 4:17born gifted. There is nothing you can
- 4:19do to make them become so. And when we
- 4:22talk about skill or ability, it's
- 4:24something you train. For example, I
- 4:27could become an amazing pianist. If at
- 4:31the age when my brain still absorbs
- 4:34that skill—there’s a childhood age
- 4:37where it’s easier to absorb—I can
- 4:40become highly skilled in piano, in
- 4:43astronomy, in something I dedicate
- 4:45myself to out of passion. And then I
- 4:50can even develop a talent, that is,
- 4:52something you stand out in. And the
- 4:55gifted person isn't always born with
- 4:57this tendency to have a talent or a
- 5:00skill. What they are born with is a
- 5:03high capacity to learn. So giftedness
- 5:07is a potential capacity, meaning it
- 5:10isn't visible. And when you talk about
- 5:14"high abilities" alone, especially in
- 5:17the school environment, among teachers
- 5:19and even parents, they immediately ask:
- 5:21"High ability, what is your ability?
- 5:23What do you do best?" And this puts a
- 5:27very heavy burden on the gifted
- 5:28individual, because for them to do
- 5:29something better, something
- 5:30extraordinary, they need to be doing
- 5:32well. And we see that giftedness today
- 5:36has some little things that we will
- 5:37talk about
- 5:38complicated.
- 5:39I wanted us to take advantage of this
- 5:41start to our chat and have another
- 5:43explanation as well. Take autism, for
- 5:46example; it’s in the DSM, there’s a
- 5:48manual with a chapter and pages that
- 5:50classify it, talking about prevalence,
- 5:52what autism is, and what the
- 5:54communities are. ADHD is there too, as
- 5:57well as depression, anxiety, and
- 5:59giftedness. There’s a chapter in that
- 6:03manual; is it considered by academia
- 6:05and the scientific community a health
- 6:08condition so that people understand us
- 6:10that way: as a disorder, as a disease?
- 6:14How is this term classified today,
- 6:17currently?
- 6:18Right? Giftedness, although it is a
- 6:22neurodivergence, a neurophysiological
- 6:24condition, because it brings about a
- 6:27change in health, including mental
- 6:29health, is not a pathology; it does not
- 6:32have, by its nature inherent to this
- 6:34condition, the development of
- 6:36comorbidities, for example. So, it is
- 6:40not in health manuals. This ends up
- 6:43creating more confusion regarding what
- 6:45the criteria are. And the criteria are
- 6:48multifaceted, multidisciplinary,
- 6:51everything is multi: multiple sources,
- 6:53multiple data, multiple methods. So,
- 6:57it’s not there; you see various
- 6:59theorists in the literature researching
- 7:02, and they take what they’ve
- 7:04researched from specific realities. So
- 7:07everyone takes it in a different
- 7:09direction. There is no consensus. Here
- 7:12in Brazil, since 1972, based on the
- 7:15Marland Report, which is an American
- 7:18report that brought a global definition
- 7:21, it is exactly the definition that I
- 7:24call ableist, because it reduces this
- 7:28condition to five areas. Whoever does
- 7:31not meet a development of extraordinary
- 7:34ability in these five areas is not
- 7:37gifted. So, this leads to
- 7:39underreporting and negligence by the
- 7:41state.
- 7:41What are these five formal areas?
- 7:43Creativity, arts, leadership, music,
- 7:48and academic.
- 7:51Five areas. In other words, if they
- 7:54don’t have a high level of
- 7:56development to show in one of these
- 7:58five areas,
- 7:59they are not, they don't fit the
- 8:01definition.
- 8:02And so you exclude millions of people,
- 8:05children who could have been identified
- 8:08.
- 8:08I’ll take advantage of the fact that
- 8:11we’re on these myths to demystify
- 8:13this issue. We already talked about the
- 8:15concept, right, about the issue of the
- 8:17nosological entity. There is also a
- 8:20concept, right, that people believe
- 8:21that to be gifted you have to have an
- 8:23IQ, an intelligence quotient, above a
- 8:25certain number and that's it.
- 8:28Is it just that, or not? Why? We've
- 8:31known since the last century, when
- 8:34Alfred Binet and others started
- 8:35developing psychometric tests, which
- 8:38are essentially tools created by very
- 8:40intelligent mathematicians who said, "
- 8:42Let's create tests where each one gets
- 8:45a number, a score." So you start to
- 8:48quantify something that couldn't be
- 8:50measured before, which is intelligence.
- 8:52How do I measure intelligence? Is it
- 8:54with a ruler, is it with a scale? So,
- 8:56Binet and other researchers started to
- 8:58create these psychometric tests. And so
- 9:01, IQ became very deeply rooted, right?
- 9:04My IQ is high, or it's low. And then we
- 9:07classify intellectual disability when
- 9:09there is a low IQ. And there is this
- 9:12strong concept that, look, for a person
- 9:14to be diagnosed as gifted, they must
- 9:17have an IQ above a certain number and
- 9:19that's it.
- 9:20Is it only that? Yes or no?
- 9:23No. That is one of the myths that we
- 9:25need to break. IQ is intelligence, and
- 9:28the interesting thing about
- 9:29intelligence is that it is a construct
- 9:31inherent to giftedness. Since
- 9:34intelligence is organic and measurable,
- 9:37IQ tests are very efficient in this
- 9:39regard. For example, when you talk
- 9:43about artificial intelligence, you can
- 9:45create a construct for a computer to
- 9:48work, because there is mathematics
- 9:51behind it. But you cannot create
- 9:53artificial creativity, or talent, or
- 9:56aptitude, but intelligence is possible
- 9:59because it is measurable. The tests are
- 10:03able to extract from a child or a young
- 10:06adult their ability to answer certain
- 10:08questions. When Binet created these
- 10:12tests, he established a relationship
- 10:14between answers and age. Then he coined
- 10:17the term mental age. This mental age is
- 10:21the biggest challenge for the gifted,
- 10:23because their mental age—the age of
- 10:25their mind's development—is always
- 10:27above their chronological age. They are
- 10:30born that way.
- 10:32In other words, just so you understand,
- 10:34it’s a 3-year-old child on paper, but
- 10:36one who has the mental reasoning of a
- 10:38child of six, seven, or 12, or even
- 10:41up to 15. Because we see this a lot
- 10:43sometimes, for exa a 6-year-old child
- 10:47passes an engineering entrance exam.
- 10:51Wait a minute, the boy is 6 years old,
- 10:54so his age on his birth certificate is
- 10:56six, but his mental age is 16 or 18,
- 10:59right? So, this mismatch between the
- 11:01chronological and the mental is what
- 11:04generates these characteristics. about
- 11:07the gifted challenge, because that's
- 11:09already out of sync, the child, the
- 11:11baby is born already out of sync. Why
- 11:14can a 6, 7, 10-year-old child pass a
- 11:17college entrance exam or reach a level
- 11:19outside of Brazil—this happens—of a
- 11:22PhD, MIT, at a child's age, if they
- 11:24haven't gone through that school age,
- 11:27every piece of content,
- 11:30the brain connections, the pace of
- 11:33interconnectivity of the brain regions,
- 11:36is such that they manage to produce
- 11:39knowledge internally. It’s that thing
- 11:43, if you have two, add two more, it
- 11:45makes four. It’s like an algorithm,
- 11:47they have a certain amount of
- 11:49information, they receive other
- 11:51information, the brain immediately
- 11:53cross-references it, and this
- 11:55intersection makes the relationship
- 11:58between information create, emerge, new
- 12:00information. So, often these children
- 12:03learn things that were not taught to
- 12:05them. that's the fluid intelligence
- 12:08part, for example, uh, answering,
- 12:10which is another concept of
- 12:11intelligence. Some people believe that
- 12:13intelligence is just measuring it,
- 12:15right, which is one of the theories,
- 12:17there are several other theories, fluid
- 12:19, crystallized intelligence, multiple
- 12:21intelligences, Gardner's theories,
- 12:23anyway. And that’s where it goes in
- 12:25this context, right? which you touched
- 12:29on, intelligence tests, for example,
- 12:31the Binet ones, throughout their
- 12:34evolution, they are based on creating a
- 12:37general intelligence index within this
- 12:40concept, and those are these two
- 12:42intelligences, crystallized and fluid
- 12:45intelligence. Crystallized is that
- 12:48which is built through knowledge. As
- 12:51you grow, it’s reading so much that
- 12:54with age it increases. Fluid is what
- 12:58you use as a capacity to solve
- 12:59something right there on the spot that
- 13:01you've never seen, never studied, have
- 13:03no mastery of the knowledge, don't need
- 13:05to mobilize what you know, but you
- 13:07manage to do or solve it, regardless of
- 13:09whether it's school-related. And these
- 13:13two types of intelligence are the basis
- 13:15of intelligence tests. So, when you
- 13:19asked that question, ah, IQ, it is part
- 13:22, a part of the identification
- 13:26of this process,
- 13:28extremely important, because it is only
- 13:30this set of data extracted from
- 13:32cognitive index measurements that we
- 13:34know how this brain works inside.
- 13:37It’s like an MRI. how things happen
- 13:43inside that induce highly intense
- 13:45behaviors, a self-awareness, where it
- 13:48functions best, what the best flow is.
- 13:53And these measurements help us
- 13:55understand what the size of the meal
- 13:57they will receive at school is, what
- 13:59the size of
- 14:01the size I'm going for. And so, when we
- 14:03talk about these tests, right, of
- 14:05crystallized and fluid intelligence, we
- 14:07understand that this is one of the
- 14:09models that explains these mechanisms.
- 14:11But there are other theorists, other
- 14:13models too, that over the centuries
- 14:15have explained it a bit, because, for
- 14:17example, many people say: "Oh, but
- 14:19there is a more current concept about
- 14:21multiple intelligences, right, which is
- 14:24artistic intelligence, motor
- 14:25intelligence, mathematical intelligence
- 14:27." Then come the intelligences, right?
- 14:30Those triarchic ones there of
- 14:32intelligence, right? What is the
- 14:34triarchic one that's Sternberg's, right
- 14:37? A little bit of that. What do we use
- 14:39from these multiple intelligence
- 14:41concepts in relation to giftedness? or
- 14:43not. Look, Rafael, when we talk about
- 14:45giftedness, we are talking about this
- 14:47model here by Binet and its refinement.
- 14:48That's it. Rafael, from Binet, because
- 14:52it's a measure, you need to know how
- 14:55much capacity is mastered, how much
- 14:58advanced capacity there is within that
- 15:00age group and how capable they are, and
- 15:03that is what the tests measure, how
- 15:06capable they are of solving questions,
- 15:10problems,
- 15:10problems in any area, not just
- 15:12mathematics. And this concept is the
- 15:16most favorable, because the gifted
- 15:18person's intelligence is this organic
- 15:21intelligence of logic and reasoning.
- 15:24Gardner's intelligence has been highly
- 15:26questioned. A group of researchers has
- 15:29even debunked the theory, calling it a
- 15:31neuromyth. But why? The problem was
- 15:34Gardner using the word intelligence
- 15:36because intelligence is not divided in
- 15:39that way. For example, if I speak of
- 15:41linguistic intelligence, that is an
- 15:42aptitude. Intelligence is not
- 15:45multifaceted in that way,
- 15:46interdependent. These things
- 15:48are interdependent. So his theory has
- 15:51already been called to be proven. He
- 15:54refused. He said he wouldn't get
- 15:57involved with that. There was a great
- 15:59deal of questioning at one time
- 16:00regarding this. He said: "I will not
- 16:02participate." He refused. But this
- 16:04theory is the one I have and that's
- 16:06that. Except his theory is not
- 16:09scientifically proven by the name
- 16:10intelligence, because intelligence does
- 16:13not have parts like that; musical
- 16:15intelligence is not an intelligence
- 16:17linked to music, it's an aptitude. And
- 16:20this aptitude is—we have people with
- 16:22intellectual disabilities who develop
- 16:24an aptitude for music.
- 16:25Talent that goes to a preserved area in
- 16:27the brain there, like that.
- 16:28Ex. So, when you talk about musical
- 16:31intelligence, interpersonal
- 16:33intelligence, the word isn't
- 16:34intelligence, because intelligence is
- 16:37an organic construct that is divided
- 16:39into this, more like this, similar to
- 16:41this aptitude. What you learn, what you
- 16:44know, learning to do it without being
- 16:46taught, which is what comes with being
- 16:48gifted.
- 16:50And there isn't, just to clarify, one
- 16:52single measure that defines giftedness.
- 16:55Since giftedness is a spectrum, just
- 16:57like autism or ADHD, there are measures
- 17:00, meaning what the impact of this
- 17:02condition is on the person. On that
- 17:06spectrum, giftedness begins roughly, if
- 17:09measured and applied correctly, with an
- 17:12IQ of 115 or 110, going up to 160,
- 17:15which is the maximum the tests in
- 17:18Brazil measure. Uh, so these tests, you
- 17:21know, are evaluations performed by
- 17:23qualified professionals, okay?
- 17:26They are psychologists who administer
- 17:28them, so there are standardized and
- 17:30validated tests. Why do I say that?
- 17:32Because sometimes you go on the
- 17:33internet, there's a "test your IQ" link
- 17:35, you start answering a few little
- 17:36questions, and you get a result. "Wow,
- 17:38I'm gifted, right?" So, we need to be
- 17:41careful with that, because
- 17:43unfortunately, we have these issues,
- 17:44tests that,
- 17:46okay? So, for the parents watching us
- 17:49and the adults too, what
- 17:51characteristics should they or teachers
- 17:54, for instance, observe in a child to
- 17:57start considering it? Because as a
- 18:00doctor, I say it's a difficult
- 18:02diagnosis; it's not an easy one,
- 18:04because you're building a picture,
- 18:06observing over time. So, what would be
- 18:08those first signs? You already
- 18:09mentioned something. It's an
- 18:11incompatibility between the age on
- 18:13their birth certificate, so to speak,
- 18:16and their problem-solving age. But what
- 18:20other characteristics or skills should
- 18:23parents and educators observe to start
- 18:26thinking, "This kid might be gifted in
- 18:29the future"? There's an interesting
- 18:33thing, Dr. Rafael, which is, uh, for
- 18:35example, there are conditions you can
- 18:37observe through visual cues. Down
- 18:41syndrome has those characteristic
- 18:44facial features, a physical disability,
- 18:47a wheelchair user, deafness; you can
- 18:49identify neurodevelopmental conditions
- 18:52like ADHD, autism, or giftedness, but
- 18:55they aren't visible. So, what makes a
- 19:00teacher or parents suspicious? They are
- 19:03different. There's something that
- 19:07that word, I think it's the key word
- 19:09when we think about it. "My child is
- 19:12different," right? When he says that,
- 19:15he thinks, he thinks, he thinks right
- 19:17away, if my son is 6, I don't see 6-
- 19:19year-olds the same way he does. So it
- 19:22is different. There is a difference,
- 19:25you need to investigate to understand
- 19:27which way that difference leads.
- 19:31The word different will then help us
- 19:33seek an answer. And so we go through a
- 19:37good evaluation, a consultation, tests,
- 19:39and school assessments. In other words,
- 19:42I'm putting together pieces of a puzzle
- 19:44to try to find
- 19:46the reason for this difference.
- 19:48And so we may have autism, we may have
- 19:49ADHD, we may have giftedness
- 19:51and we may have two or all three
- 19:52together.
- 19:53And when there are two of these, there
- 19:56is another term people also use a lot,
- 19:58double exceptionality or perhaps triple
- 20:01exceptionality. What do these terms
- 20:04mean in practice, then, and how do we
- 20:06think about this process? We can call
- 20:09it that—this isn't written anywhere
- 20:11scientifically, but it is a practically
- 20:14obvious thing. Double exceptionality,
- 20:18giftedness, triple exceptionality, are
- 20:22conditions of giftedness. It’s as if
- 20:24they were categories, types of
- 20:26giftedness. For example, giftedness is
- 20:30a condition that is fundamentally
- 20:33characterized by intensity,
- 20:35hypersensitivity, and a worldview
- 20:38completely outside the standard for
- 20:42their age. You notice it right away,
- 20:45wow, this child or young person, they
- 20:47seem like an elder, or a young adult;
- 20:50you perceive this difference in the
- 20:53very way they carry themselves.
- 20:56Sometimes the vocabulary is very
- 20:57refined for their age, very advanced.
- 21:00And for double exceptionality, one of
- 21:03them must be giftedness. If it's not
- 21:06giftedness, this term or concept
- 21:08doesn't exist. So there are two
- 21:11categories of exceptionality:
- 21:13giftedness and a neurodevelopmental
- 21:16disorder or disability. For example, if
- 21:20you have a gifted person who is also
- 21:23identified with autism or ADHD, let's
- 21:25suppose, there you have one condition
- 21:27and two disorders,
- 21:29but giftedness must be attached,
- 21:31it must be there, and it remains double
- 21:33, because they aren't two singular
- 21:35conditions, they are two categories:
- 21:38one is high functioning, which is
- 21:40giftedness, and the other is a
- 21:42comorbidity or a limitation, deficit,
- 21:44or something that impacts that high
- 21:47functioning in some way. And so, with
- 21:50double exceptionality, the other
- 21:52exceptionality might have three: ADHD,
- 21:55OCD, and ASD, for example; it remains
- 21:57double because one of them is
- 21:59giftedness. Triple exceptionality has
- 22:03been researched very little, but the
- 22:06concept brought forward is a child who
- 22:08is a student, let's suppose, who is
- 22:11twice-exceptional, and they are part of
- 22:14a category in society that is among the
- 22:17most vulnerable. Just the socioeconomic
- 22:21part, they are very poor, Black,
- 22:24Indigenous, often the woman, the girl,
- 22:27when she is gifted, she is
- 22:29twice-exceptional and belongs to a
- 22:31social class that is vulnerable, that
- 22:34is already marginalized by society,
- 22:36suffers, that is triple exceptionality.
- 22:40In other words, they have one more
- 22:41challenge. That is, they have a
- 22:43developmental disorder, they have
- 22:45giftedness, and they have a social
- 22:48issue that makes them vulnerable. More
- 22:51vulnerable. And then the challenge
- 22:53triples because they become even more
- 22:55invisible. It is not believed that, for
- 22:58example, if I tell you that in all
- 22:59these years and decades that I have
- 23:01been evaluating, that I have been
- 23:03dealing with the field, I have never
- 23:05evaluated a wheelchair user, I have
- 23:06never evaluated a blind person, I have
- 23:08never evaluated a deaf child. In other
- 23:11words, these children are not seen as
- 23:14someone capable of high functioning.
- 23:17And it is obvious that they have it.
- 23:19Even a child, for example, who may seem
- 23:22to have an intellectual disability, not
- 23:24a disability per se, but who has
- 23:26difficulty learning,
- 23:29they may have it, because giftedness
- 23:31can coexist as a twice-exceptionality
- 23:33with a learning disorder, a learning
- 23:35difficulty. So, they are bad in a
- 23:39specific area, in one way to learn to
- 23:42read, for example, but they have
- 23:44another skill more developed for that
- 23:46age.
- 23:47Exactly. For example, an absurd working
- 23:50memory, a speed of information
- 23:52processing that surpasses other
- 23:53children.
- 23:55Since you mentioned this term here, I
- 23:58really like ADHD.
- 24:01And many people sometimes say the
- 24:02following: "Oh, but they have ADHD,
- 24:04they cannot be gifted, right?" I would
- 24:07like you to explain here a little bit
- 24:09of what I always say: there are two
- 24:11ways for us to solve problems. What is
- 24:13a problem, folks? It's like this: it's
- 24:15in marriage, it's at school. School is
- 24:17a problem; you have to learn to read,
- 24:18to interpret, to solve a math problem.
- 24:20At work, you have to deal with people,
- 24:22make a decision. In traffic, you have
- 24:24them. So, we have problems at every
- 24:26moment. And in the brain, there are two
- 24:30areas, two structures, two concepts to
- 24:32solve problems, which are intelligence
- 24:35and executive functions.
- 24:38Exactly.
- 24:39What is the correlation between
- 24:41executive functions, that set of skills
- 24:43the brain develops, and intelligence?
- 24:46Do they work together? Are they the
- 24:48same thing? Are they mutually exclusive
- 24:50? How does that actually look inside
- 24:52the brain? For example, we have the
- 24:55boss, the CEO, and we have the workers.
- 24:58The workers need to collaborate with
- 25:01the CEO so that he can advance with all
- 25:03the power he has, so he can organize
- 25:06that space, that company, let's put it
- 25:08that way, that organization so that it
- 25:11flows. And the workers that need to
- 25:15collaborate are the executive functions
- 25:17. Executive functions are not a
- 25:21condition for the boss, the CEO, to
- 25:24function. So, the intelligence part is
- 25:28not impacted by executive functions,
- 25:30but it depends.
- 25:32This is where we need to understand
- 25:35that in ADHD, even within the ADHD
- 25:37spectrum, it has a greater impact of
- 25:40this disorder or condition, but it does
- 25:43not prevent the development of
- 25:45intelligence if there is support to
- 25:48help with those executive functions.
- 25:51When we do, the psychologist applies it
- 25:53, for example, in the assessment, there
- 25:55are two parts: there's my part, there's
- 25:57the psychologist's part, and we do the
- 25:59case study. What have we noticed? Most
- 26:03gifted children or adolescents have the
- 26:06pure intelligence part, which is the
- 26:08gold standard test, the WISC, for
- 26:10example, which is VCI and PRI, that is,
- 26:13Verbal Comprehension Index and
- 26:15Perceptual Reasoning Index. These are,
- 26:18just so people understand, we were
- 26:20talking about psychometric tests, right
- 26:22? These are tools that psychologists,
- 26:25and these are professionals, and not
- 26:27just any psychologist, they must have
- 26:30specific training, use to assess these
- 26:32brain functions. We currently use the
- 26:35fourth version, so we call it WISC-IV,
- 26:38right? And within the WISC-IV there are
- 26:40some subcategories, right? Which are
- 26:43the PRI and the VCI, which are verbal
- 26:45comprehension, perceptual, working
- 26:46memory, and at the end, it averages the
- 26:48processing speed, and finally, the IQ
- 26:50emerges through a mathematical
- 26:52calculation, right? Yes,
- 26:55and this calculation, which is done on
- 26:57a platform for the total, goes through
- 27:00around 200 sub-items that add up. And
- 27:05so, in total, the last four categories,
- 27:07the last four subtests, produce these
- 27:10two indices, pure intelligence, which
- 27:12is known in the field as pure
- 27:14intelligence. And there are the other
- 27:18two that aren't cognitive skills, they
- 27:20are executive skills, which are working
- 27:22memory. and processing speed. Gifted
- 27:27individuals tend to have issues,
- 27:29challenges with processing speed. What
- 27:32leads to this? The depth of analysis,
- 27:36the tendency to take time analyzing
- 27:38alternatives, because they cannot get
- 27:41it wrong.
- 27:42You give a command to a person, to a
- 27:44child, to an adult, and then you have a
- 27:47response time. So, something simple,
- 27:49for example, uh, how much? Because 10 +
- 27:5110, then you quickly, oops, 20. So,
- 27:54when you have a speed, I'm giving a
- 27:55very simple example for people to
- 27:57understand, so 10 + 10,
- 28:0120. So, notice that there is a delay in
- 28:03this process, but this adds up. So,
- 28:05when you have more elaborate functions,
- 28:07this starts to cause a deficit, that is
- 28:09, it is a deficit in speed, because
- 28:11they think more,
- 28:12they think more. And then you have more
- 28:14paths to get lost in the middle, for
- 28:16example, which is what happens with
- 28:17ADHD, right? ADHD. With ADHD, it
- 28:20happens that they get lost there.
- 28:21Exactly. This path, this response time
- 28:24they have, they get lost, they forget.
- 28:26A bird passes by,
- 28:27they do something else, it's over,
- 28:29right?
- 28:29In the gifted person, this time, this
- 28:31delay that happens is an excess of
- 28:33alternatives, because they think,
- 28:35but to reach 20, can I do this, can I
- 28:37do that, can I do that other thing? And
- 28:40the processing speed test is timed,
- 28:42they have to do it in one minute. They
- 28:44forget about time, they prioritize
- 28:47precision. So they keep looking for it,
- 28:49they increase the speed, but for the
- 28:51mechanism. The inattentive one forgets
- 28:54in the middle, a butterfly passed by,
- 28:55they saw the butterfly, and the
- 28:56response was finished and gone, right?
- 28:59The gifted one, no, they have four
- 29:00doors, they stand there in front like
- 29:02this, do I go in the first, the second,
- 29:04the third, the 14th, time passes and
- 29:06then they take too long to choose the
- 29:08right response door. prevails in the
- 29:10gifted. I cannot be wrong. My stroke
- 29:13has to be perfectionist. They keep
- 29:16erasing. The stroke has to be, they
- 29:19start looking for patterns. Let me see
- 29:22where it is here. I will look for this.
- 29:24Delay in the response. You said it
- 29:27perfectly, it's not information
- 29:28processing speed, it's response speed,
- 29:31of choosing the response. the index for
- 29:33the pattern drops because they exceed
- 29:36the test time and it is often confused
- 29:39with ADHD. That is the level of care
- 29:41required.
- 29:41Look, I'll share a little of my own
- 29:43experience regarding that as well. How
- 29:46many children do I receive? Because
- 29:48sometimes the school tells the parents:
- 29:51"He's not finishing the assignment on
- 29:53time."
- 29:54So the teacher gives the boy a task to
- 29:56do in 10 minutes; the whole class
- 29:57finishes, but he doesn't. And then that
- 29:59starts to repeat itself. And then you
- 30:01start asking, why? The question is, why
- 30:03isn't he finishing? He doesn't finish
- 30:06because he got distracted in the middle
- 30:08of it. Oh, no. Someone walked by, there
- 30:11was construction at the school, a
- 30:12classmate got up, so he gets up, picks
- 30:13something up, and so on. That is
- 30:15usually an inattentive child who is
- 30:17experiencing distraction. Now, there is
- 30:20another profile, and this is the big
- 30:22mistake people make: no, he wants to do
- 30:24it so perfectly, he draws the letters,
- 30:26erases them 10 times, he tries—in
- 30:27other words, he can't finish because
- 30:29his perfectionism hinders him.
- 30:32Exactly.
- 30:32Is that ADHD or something else, Doctor?
- 30:34That would be giftedness. What is the
- 30:36difference between these two children
- 30:38with the same task? The child with ADHD
- 30:40starts doing it and experiences
- 30:42interference, as if there were sound or
- 30:44light distractions. The interference
- 30:48disrupts the continuity. From there, he
- 30:51stalls and loses track of the
- 30:54continuity. The gifted child has two
- 30:57ways of not finishing or finishing.
- 31:00First, if it's repetitive, his brain
- 31:02can't engage because it's just that
- 31:03thing where he looks and thinks, "Oh no
- 31:05, I’ve already mastered this, I'm
- 31:07done."
- 31:07He loses interest and doesn't want to
- 31:08do it.
- 31:09Loses interest. Or else, what you
- 31:11mentioned: it has to be perfect, he
- 31:13can't make a mistake; if there’s
- 31:15tracing involved, he erases it 10,000
- 31:17times. So this delay needs to be
- 31:19carefully evaluated so as not to
- 31:21confuse the diagnoses. And look how
- 31:23important it is, but before I talk, for
- 31:24example, about how to treat this
- 31:24condition and discuss it here with Dr.
- 31:25Eeni, whether that is right or not, I
- 31:26wanted to draw your attention here so
- 31:27you can get to know a franchise network
- 31:28called Brain Gymnastics. Brain
- 31:29Gymnastics is a franchise unit
- 31:30appearing here on the QR code, where
- 31:32you have the possibility to become an
- 31:34entrepreneur in your city and really
- 31:35open a unit there. And in this training
- 31:37center, you work on executive functions
- 31:40, memory, and pleasure, in the sense of
- 31:42developing the minds of children,
- 31:44adults, adolescents, and also seniors.
- 31:47And this training center works on
- 31:49executive functions, memory, and
- 31:52enjoyment, in the sense of developing
- 31:55the minds of children, adults,
- 31:57teenagers, and also the elderly. So,
- 32:00Ginástica do Cérebro is not a
- 32:02treatment center, it is a cognitive
- 32:05training center. You can become a
- 32:07franchisee by accessing this QR code
- 32:09and contacting our sales team; they
- 32:12will be happy to present this model to
- 32:14you. Now, if you want to be a student
- 32:17at Ginástica do Cérebro, you can also
- 32:20find a location near your city or
- 32:22region through social media, Instagram,
- 32:25or our website and become a student. So
- 32:29you have this possibility here with the
- 32:31QR code to either become a franchisee
- 32:33or become a student through our nearest
- 32:35locations. This is Ginástica do
- 32:38Cérebro, one of our supporters here,
- 32:40in other words, training the workers so
- 32:43you can manage to print it.
- 32:45Exactly. In other words, Ginástica do
- 32:47Cérebro is one of the tools that
- 32:48develops and helps with this cognitive
- 32:50training, right, of functions.
- 32:52Exactly. And, getting back to what we
- 32:54were saying about a child getting lost
- 32:56in the middle of an activity due to two
- 32:57mechanisms, right, correct me if I'm
- 32:59wrong. Look how important this is. This
- 33:02totally impacts the treatment, right?
- 33:04Because with ADHD, we know that there
- 33:06is, for example, medication. So there
- 33:09are psychostimulants, the medications
- 33:11we use to improve this attention
- 33:12function, right, to regulate it there.
- 33:16And in the gifted individual, the
- 33:18mechanism, from what you are explaining
- 33:20, is totally different; that is, there
- 33:22is no dysregulation of dopamine or
- 33:23noradrenaline in the frontal cortex. So
- 33:26, if I don't identify this difference
- 33:29in finishing the task and I give
- 33:31medication for, quote-unquote, ADHD, I
- 33:34only cause side effects in this child,
- 33:37because their problem is not ADHD,
- 33:39right? So, look at what this is like in
- 33:41day-to-day life; in your experience,
- 33:43have you seen a lot of this, or is it
- 33:45very rare? this story in the day-to-day
- 33:47life of schools.
- 33:49I have been following this, Dr. Rafael;
- 33:51one is the cases of medication: when
- 33:54medication is confused, it causes great
- 33:56harm to the gifted individual. Because,
- 34:00for example, in ADHD, the chemistry of
- 34:03the medication comes to balance
- 34:05something that is missing; it helps
- 34:07them to manage to solve executive
- 34:09problems, mainly because intelligence
- 34:12works when they are twice-exceptional.
- 34:15Very well, but it doesn't advance
- 34:17enough to match their potential because
- 34:20it needs the executive functions. For
- 34:23the gifted individual, I can make an
- 34:26analogy that their dopamine is the
- 34:28challenge. What is the challenge? Brain
- 34:32connections need a reason to function
- 34:35well. So, a task that is basic, a task
- 34:39that is mechanical, repetitive, it’s
- 34:41as if the brain were saying: "Man, look
- 34:43, I can't do this, there's nothing to
- 34:44do here." It cannot operate on that
- 34:48task because it doesn't allow for any
- 34:49connections. So, if you want a gifted
- 34:53person to be able to imprint this
- 34:56strength of their intellectual
- 34:58potential, they need a school program
- 35:00that is at least minimally compatible
- 35:02with their mental age. For example, a 6
- 35:07-year-old child should be at least 2
- 35:09years ahead of their class. A
- 35:12six-year-old child in Brazil usually
- 35:13follows the age-grade system, they are
- 35:15in the first grade, seven in the second
- 35:16, eight in the third. A gifted child
- 35:19should be advanced back in preschool
- 35:22and enter, for example, the second
- 35:24grade at age five. Or rather, they
- 35:28should go into a class of
- 35:30nine-year-olds with the chronological
- 35:32age of a first or second grader, which
- 35:34is six or seven. Because then, when you
- 35:38move this child up by their
- 35:39chronological age—I liked that.
- 35:43To try and reduce this discrepancy,
- 35:45what do you do? You place this child in
- 35:49a place closer to their own level; they
- 35:52can talk to their peers, they can hold
- 35:54a conversation, they find peers who are
- 35:56closer, with greater maturity.
- 35:59Exactly. Which was what Binet
- 36:01discovered when he created the
- 36:02intelligence test. He said: "Wait a
- 36:05minute, there is a set of cognitive
- 36:07skills that only a 16-year-old, for
- 36:09example, can solve." In a gifted child,
- 36:13a six-year-old can solve it, a 12-
- 36:15year-old can solve it, a 10-year-old.
- 36:18So he went about establishing this
- 36:20compatibility between mental age,
- 36:22chronological age, and developmental
- 36:24age.
- 36:25And then we can't, for example, take a
- 36:26six-year-old child and put them in high
- 36:28school. We could, but we can't do it
- 36:31because it's still not accepted and
- 36:33such.
- 36:34Yeah. And you mentioned throughout your
- 36:37beautiful explanation the importance of
- 36:38challenges, which is one of the ways to
- 36:40treat, care for, and develop giftedness
- 36:41. I usually say the following: if God
- 36:46gave a person a potential for
- 36:47intelligence, we need to know how to
- 36:49develop it. Because what will this
- 36:51person do when they become an adult?
- 36:53Solve our problems. Because that is
- 36:55what intelligence is for: to solve
- 36:57problems, to invent machines, to invent
- 36:58day-to-day solutions. So, by taking
- 37:01good care of a gifted child, in
- 37:03adulthood, they will give back to us by
- 37:05solving problems, right?
- 37:08And many parents say the following: and
- 37:09they are afraid, right, of these
- 37:11challenges. For example, you spoke
- 37:13about the issue of chronological age
- 37:14versus mental age, right? Uh, some
- 37:17parents sometimes say: "But that one,
- 37:19he might have a mental age of 10, but
- 37:21has the physical body of a six-year-old
- 37:24child."
- 37:25Exactly.
- 37:26How do you deal with that? What are the
- 37:28challenges, the dangers regarding that?
- 37:30For instance, you take a boy or a girl
- 37:33who is 6 years old,
- 37:34who has a child's body and you put them
- 37:37mentally as an adolescent who already
- 37:39has, in the girl's case, breast
- 37:41development, who is already sometimes
- 37:43talking about sexuality, about dating.
- 37:46Does this 6-year-old child have a level
- 37:49of maturity to deal with, for example,
- 37:51these adolescent issues? What is good
- 37:54about this? What is bad about this? Is
- 37:56this a concern for parents regarding
- 37:57this process? I will give a very
- 37:59practical, real-life example. For
- 38:01example, if you have a typical child,
- 38:03right, not gifted, just typical, what
- 38:05we call that, because there is no
- 38:06normal or abnormal.
- 38:08Yes.
- 38:08A typical child does not learn to read
- 38:11before age 6. You cannot teach a 2, 3,
- 38:14or 4-year-old; when it happens, there's
- 38:18a 99.9%chance they are gifted.
- 38:22But make a cross-section of this,
- 38:23multiply this, scale this up for you to
- 38:25understand. Look at what Dr. En, with
- 38:29all her capacity and expertise, just
- 38:31said: we should not work on literacy
- 38:34before 6 years of age. Exactly, Doctor,
- 38:37I say this because it is something I
- 38:38have been talking about a lot. This
- 38:39generates stress, anxiety, and
- 38:41suffering in the child, this need to
- 38:44want to teach literacy to children
- 38:46before the brain is minimally ready.
- 38:48The tools are not prepared,
- 38:50the executive functions are not
- 38:51developed for this creation. So I need
- 38:53to have a minimum age for function
- 38:56development. That goes technically
- 38:58around the age of 6.
- 38:59Exactly. MEC studies arrived at the age
- 39:02of 6
- 39:03years old so that we can then advance
- 39:05to the literacy process. In other words
- 39:07, when this child develops these skills
- 39:09before that age, we say: "Wow, there's
- 39:12something I need to do differently,
- 39:14right?" That's the word "different"
- 39:15once again appearing here, right? And
- 39:17then you can indeed suspect with 100%
- 39:19probability. There's giftedness there,
- 39:22there's hyperlexia, but it doesn't
- 39:24involve comprehension, so it's easy to
- 39:26distinguish.
- 39:27Hyperlexia is that child who learns to
- 39:30read at 2 or 3 years old, but they are
- 39:32actually playing with words, they are
- 39:35decoding the words. They might read a
- 39:37sign, they walk by at three years old
- 39:39and see "car,""truck,""hospital," but
- 39:41if you ask them what that is, they
- 39:43can't explain it to you. In other words
- 39:44, they don't interpret it. We call this
- 39:46hyperlexia, which is a capacity for
- 39:48reading without stimuli, at a very
- 39:51young age. Now, a child who, before the
- 39:55age of 6, can read and can interpret,
- 39:59break the reading code, that's
- 40:01different. So, for that child, for
- 40:04example, as I’m explaining,
- 40:06practically speaking, you don't teach a
- 40:093, 4, or 5-year-old to read if they are
- 40:11a typical child, right, without any
- 40:13giftedness. A six-year-old with a
- 40:17ten-year-old, the social, psychosocial,
- 40:20motor, and emotional aspects are in
- 40:22asynchronous movement, because it's all
- 40:25, one is higher, one is lower, and
- 40:27cognition is racing ahead. Oh, I'm
- 40:30going, I'm off.
- 40:31And and they stay behind, and they
- 40:32follow me like this, right?
- 40:33Follow me if you can. Regarding issues
- 40:36like sexuality, or seeing, for example,
- 40:39breasts growing, these things, they go
- 40:42a lot
- 40:43into the emotional and social areas,
- 40:45and this child doesn't reach that
- 40:48learning level. So, there's no reason
- 40:51for parents to be afraid, because they
- 40:53can live with it, and just as a
- 40:55three-year-old won't learn to read
- 40:57perfectly even if you try to teach them
- 40:59, they'll find it interesting but
- 41:00boring. No, I have nothing to do with
- 41:03that. What they will like about this
- 41:06ten-year-old is the vocabulary. They
- 41:10will be able to talk about things that
- 41:12the ten-year-old, for example, might
- 41:14want to share about planets, black
- 41:15holes, or something they want to talk
- 41:17about, and the six-year-olds will look
- 41:19and go, "Oh my, I'm out, are you crazy?
- 41:21" And the ten-year-old will find it
- 41:24interesting because they have already
- 41:26reached the mental age level of their
- 41:28chronological age. I like that.
- 41:30Because of their chronological age,
- 41:32having already seen that content and
- 41:34knowledge, they can chat with the
- 41:36six-year-old. That's why gifted young
- 41:38children love to talk to adults. We
- 41:41have many reports of them at parties,
- 41:42just sitting at the adults 'table.
- 41:44talking about the stock market, stock
- 41:46exchange. How does the math work?
- 41:48Minimum wage. What do you mean? They
- 41:51talk about this without having studied
- 41:54it, but the connections help with this
- 41:56self-understanding, yet they can't
- 41:59interact with children their own age.
- 42:03And so, this idea, you know, it came
- 42:06about, a concept back in the 40s, still
- 42:08within twice-exceptionality, which was
- 42:11described, actually described by two
- 42:14researchers back in the 40s, and later
- 42:16named by Lorna Wing regarding
- 42:19Asperger's syndrome, which has since
- 42:21entered and left the DSM. Anyway,
- 42:25that's another discussion, back and
- 42:28forth, but Asperger's syndrome, which
- 42:30is now part of the autism spectrum
- 42:32disorder, was often confused with
- 42:35giftedness, right? Because they were
- 42:37believed to be little professors, great
- 42:39geniuses, based on their
- 42:40characteristics. So, how do we observe
- 42:43these autism characteristics? And here
- 42:46I'll even make an exception to talk
- 42:48about Asperger's syndrome in relation
- 42:50to the giftedness standard. Is every
- 42:52Asperger's individual gifted or not? Is
- 42:55that a myth or not? How does this work
- 42:57now? Not with ADHD, but within autism.
- 42:59Within autism. Since I worked a lot
- 43:02decades ago in resource rooms, I dealt
- 43:05a lot with Asperger's, children with
- 43:08various mixtures of
- 43:10twice-exceptionality. I dealt with
- 43:12Asperger's. Asperger's. I found it
- 43:15interesting when it moved into the
- 43:17autism category in the DSM, because
- 43:19they exhibit rigid behaviors. The
- 43:22rigidity of the individual is desperate
- 43:25.
- 43:25It has to be this way.
- 43:26Wow, the individual, the Asperger's
- 43:28child, plans their wedding, the name of
- 43:31their first child, everything they are
- 43:33going to do in their life. And if that
- 43:36doesn't happen, they become
- 43:37dysregulated. So it's a level of
- 43:39rigidity, of, well, there is a very
- 43:41exaggerated self-centeredness. For
- 43:44example, I never forgot this episode, a
- 43:47teenager I used to talk to, I met him
- 43:50and said: "Good morning, how are you,
- 43:53Augusto?""He stopped, and said:" Good
- 43:56morning, you come and ask me if
- 43:58everything is fine. Have you seen how
- 44:00Africa is? Children being, starving to
- 44:04death. And then he kept bringing up
- 44:06things from the world, and you ask me
- 44:07if everything is fine. I said: "Well
- 44:10then." So it's very much like this, if
- 44:13everything is fine, the world is fine.
- 44:17If you don't, we call it literalness,
- 44:19right? Yeah, I have an example that a
- 44:23father once brought to me, which was
- 44:24the reason he sought care and obviously
- 44:26a diagnosis there. I say that the
- 44:28father noticed it was different. It was
- 44:30one day that he said it was the last
- 44:31straw. It was one day when I said to
- 44:33him: "Son, go there and get your
- 44:34flip-flops at the foot of the orange
- 44:36tree." And the child kept circling a
- 44:38foot and looking for the foot
- 44:40of the orange tree.
- 44:41Of the orange. And he saw the
- 44:42flip-flops and he saw them, he circled,
- 44:43he didn't pick them up, and the father
- 44:45was like, "But what?" He said: "No, dad
- 44:46, you said the flip-flops were on the
- 44:47foot." So that's the literalness. He
- 44:50said: "No, I can't take this anymore,
- 44:52there are too many different things."
- 44:54That was when he sought help and then
- 44:55the diagnosis was made. Anyway, that
- 44:57gave a name to this literature. This
- 45:00this issue of Asperger's is as if it
- 45:02were at the inflection point between
- 45:04giftedness and autism. So it's like a
- 45:07twice-exceptional person who has high
- 45:09functioning and has issues that are
- 45:12very critical to autism, such as social
- 45:15interaction, literalness, and rigidity.
- 45:18cognitive, behavioral, emotional,
- 45:20In other words, Asperger's...We are
- 45:22using this term only so that people,
- 45:24you know, who got lost a few minutes
- 45:26ago when I spoke about the change from
- 45:29DSM-4 to 5, we removed it, right...We,
- 45:31the academy, actually removed it and
- 45:33categorized them within Autism Spectrum
- 45:36Disorder, but in there within level one
- 45:38, okay? due to some issues, anyway,
- 45:40there are some issues related to the
- 45:42history of Asperger's regarding war
- 45:44involvement, anyway, so it was kind of
- 45:46taken out of that process, okay? What
- 45:48we are discussing here is that support
- 45:50level one, Asperger's, right, the old
- 45:52Asperger's syndrome, has this pattern
- 45:54of the other criteria: a difficulty
- 45:56with socialization, a difficulty
- 45:58interacting, great rigidity, but they
- 46:00do not have a speech delay, which is
- 46:02often one of the entry points, and they
- 46:05have a very rigid pattern of commands,
- 46:07a literalness, everything taken very
- 46:09literally, right? So that is what we
- 46:11are talking about. But they are very
- 46:13good in some areas. They have
- 46:16highlights, like, oh, the guy is very,
- 46:18very, very good at astronomy, but for
- 46:19other functions he cannot perform. In
- 46:22other words, it is a functioning, once
- 46:24again, a different word, right?
- 46:26And you know something interesting,
- 46:27Rafael? With Asperger's, the perception
- 46:30we have is that you see the gifted
- 46:33person and the autistic person more
- 46:35clearly.
- 46:36Yes. It seems that autism comes through
- 46:39stronger, giftedness comes through
- 46:41stronger. It's as if you were
- 46:43separating them; for example, if I had
- 46:44to give an opinion, I'd say: "He jumped
- 46:46to the right spectrum."
- 46:47Yes.
- 46:48That is indeed where it's better for
- 46:50him, so that he can be worked on
- 46:52regarding the challenges that greatly
- 46:54impact giftedness. But it's clearer for
- 46:56you to see Asperger's than the
- 46:58twice-exceptional, even at a level one
- 46:59spectrum. That seems funny, doesn't it?
- 47:03Yes. It's because he has some
- 47:05particularities. I say the following:
- 47:07for you to do that as a doctor, I
- 47:08always say, to make a diagnosis for
- 47:10this child, you just let him talk in
- 47:11the office.
- 47:12That's it.
- 47:12That's it. He spoke, you already notice
- 47:15a rigidity in his speech, a pattern
- 47:18that is often robotic, right? Speech
- 47:22that is often very eloquent, out of
- 47:23context, very polished Portuguese, with
- 47:25words that sometimes make you look and
- 47:27say: "My God, am I reading a book by
- 47:29Camões?" I'm reading literature like
- 47:31this, you know? Those literature books
- 47:33we study in school, those books, and
- 47:35it's exactly that pattern. So there you
- 47:38listen to him speak: "That's it, here
- 47:39we can already perceive it and you will
- 47:41evaluate."
- 47:42And so, Dr. Eeni, that's what I see in
- 47:45practice too, right? And what we wanted
- 47:48you to talk about a little is the
- 47:50challenges of the school environment
- 47:52and public health policies for this
- 47:54profile of gifted individuals, right?
- 47:57Taking away a bit of the
- 47:58romanticization of the giftedness issue
- 48:00, right? People sometimes take a gifted
- 48:03person and want to frame them as if
- 48:05they have a superpower, right? They
- 48:07have a need, they have supervision,
- 48:10they have, well, you know? That whole
- 48:13issue from theater and cinema. And in
- 48:15real life, we know it's not like that,
- 48:17right? The challenges for schools, for
- 48:19teachers in public health, what is the
- 48:21current context in Brazil, how is it?
- 48:24Perhaps here in Brazil, if you'd like
- 48:26to speak a little about the world too,
- 48:28regarding aspects of public policy
- 48:29associated with the issue of giftedness
- 48:31. Well, Dr. Rafael, two years ago, I
- 48:35had a problem with a mother in a city
- 48:38in Minas, a municipality in Minas, Pato
- 48:41Branco, who went through huge trouble
- 48:43because she came from Uruguay a. Her
- 48:47son was already advanced there, gifted;
- 48:49he arrived here, the system pigeonholed
- 48:51him, he went back 2 years and this boy
- 48:53started having many problems, he
- 48:55reached the point of medication,
- 48:56desperate. When I went to evaluate him,
- 48:59he was a profoundly gifted child, and
- 49:00she started, she just went to court,
- 49:02that whole mess to be able to
- 49:04accelerate him. And this mother, when
- 49:06the judge ordered his acceleration, the
- 49:09school acted in an even unethical way:
- 49:11they wouldn't even let the mother enter
- 49:14the school. She was taken to the police
- 49:16station, anyway, she called me crying.
- 49:18I ended up in the Chamber of Deputies,
- 49:20I said: "Guys, we can't just talk
- 49:22anymore, we're going to have to do
- 49:23something.""The only one who can do it
- 49:25is the state." I can't reach the head
- 49:27of the state, I'll go through here. And
- 49:30that's when I reached this
- 49:31congresswoman who received me and a
- 49:33group of mothers. I always take the
- 49:35mothers with me because their voice...
- 49:36Yes, yes.
- 49:37The first sentence I said to her: "
- 49:40Congresswoman, we have a public health
- 49:42problem today in Brazil, public mental
- 49:45health among gifted students." She said
- 49:47: "What do you mean?""What kind of
- 49:49giftedness is this?""Because what we
- 49:51know is that giftedness is intelligence
- 49:52.""How can intelligence hurt?""How can
- 49:55a country not know how to use this
- 49:57potential?"
- 49:58So, what happens? This mismatch of
- 50:01these children in the system has
- 50:03brought very serious mental health
- 50:05issues for the gifted, which isn't part
- 50:08of the giftedness itself, but
- 50:09giftedness makes them vulnerable to it.
- 50:13Why? The intensity of their feelings.
- 50:16Because, for example, a gifted child,
- 50:18if they feel pain, they say: "Take me
- 50:19to the ICU, take me to the ICU, I'm
- 50:21going to die." Her joy is extreme, it's
- 50:23euphoria, her sadness is very deep,
- 50:25everything is too much, too much, too
- 50:27much. So, their intensity causes them
- 50:30to have behaviors, ah, feelings, ways
- 50:33of reacting that are very exacerbated.
- 50:37And the school cannot accommodate this.
- 50:40Imagine the gifted child with their
- 50:42instrument in an orchestra, the
- 50:44conductor gives the signal, the
- 50:45instruments start playing, forming that
- 50:47beautiful music. He stays here in the
- 50:49classroom, at school, in society, with
- 50:51his instrument. He tries to join in, it
- 50:52doesn't work, the music doesn't flow,
- 50:54the note doesn't fit, he doesn't fit in
- 50:56. What comes to mind? I have a problem,
- 50:59I am different, nobody accepts me. And
- 51:03then self-destruction begins,
- 51:05self-destruction, anxiety, depression,
- 51:07suicide. Then a cascade begins. Suicide
- 51:11, giftedness and suicide have been very
- 51:13high, if we talk about a recent reality
- 51:16. Last night I received, because there
- 51:20are some teenagers I evaluate, that I
- 51:22get so terrified that I hand them my
- 51:24phone and say: "Look, if you feel
- 51:26anything, talk to me." At least during
- 51:28the evaluation process. Yesterday I
- 51:30received one from a...Dr. Zini, it
- 51:32hurts so much, I can't take it anymore.
- 51:34Take this pain away from me, I'm
- 51:35practically dying. Take this pain away
- 51:37from me. How? What can you do to help
- 51:39me? So, by the time they reach around
- 51:4310, 12, 13, up to 16, which is the bulk
- 51:46of those I've evaluated besides adults,
- 51:48they are already very broken from so
- 51:51much denial, from so much invalidation.
- 51:54Why? What is giftedness? It's a high
- 51:57capacity for learning. They learn
- 51:59faster, they have a highly developed
- 52:01self-awareness. This is not their fault
- 52:03; it is physiological, not behavioral.
- 52:06And so they are denied a lot at school
- 52:08because "shut up,""you talk too much,""
- 52:10you won't sit down," they can't sit
- 52:12still, they have sensory issues, "
- 52:15you're challenging the teacher,""you
- 52:16want to be more,""do you want to be the
- 52:17main character?" or
- 52:19exactly, they can't write because this
- 52:22movement doesn't match their thinking.
- 52:25So, writing hurts here, it actually
- 52:27hurts the mind. There are children who
- 52:29say: "My brain hurts." And in fact, it
- 52:31is a subjective pain. And so they start
- 52:34to have problems. Today we have an
- 52:36absurd number of children and
- 52:38adolescents removed from school due to
- 52:41refusal. From school refusal comes
- 52:44social phobia, because there are
- 52:46children, reports like, "Doctor, he
- 52:48gets to the school door and he shakes
- 52:51all over,"
- 52:52which is one of the serious anxiety
- 52:53disorders we have, right? that develops
- 52:57psychiatric disorders, neuropsychiatric
- 52:59conditions have been developed in
- 53:01gifted children and adolescents due to
- 53:03environmental influence. One thing that
- 53:07isn't used in Brazil is epigenetics.
- 53:09The power of epigenetics has been
- 53:11epigenetics. Yes, these, these
- 53:13neurodiversities, right? autism, ADHD,
- 53:16giftedness, as the doctor already said
- 53:18at the very beginning of the podcast,
- 53:20is a genetic condition,
- 53:22but there are environmental factors,
- 53:24that is, things from the environment,
- 53:26that is, epigenetic factors that can
- 53:28make it worse or better. And here she
- 53:31is showing us how environmental factors
- 53:33, that is, the lack of preparation in
- 53:36schools, the lack of preparation in
- 53:38society as a whole, end up triggering
- 53:40anxiety, generating depression, right?
- 53:43We know that in neurodiversity, it
- 53:45naturally increases due to factors like
- 53:47brain structure and executive functions
- 53:49. There is already a set of things they
- 53:52are much more prone to having as
- 53:53comorbidities. Then I add this lack of
- 53:56preparation, this lack of care, of tact
- 53:59, and then you start to trigger this,
- 54:01often culminating in suicide, right? In
- 54:04suicide or self-harm. Self-harm—
- 54:08I’ve evaluated children with holes in
- 54:10their heads, pulling out hair, nails
- 54:12bleeding, they tear little pieces here
- 54:14from their mouth, dermatitis,
- 54:17that's why this suffering, right? In
- 54:19other words, it's not just the brain,
- 54:20it starts screaming for help, right?
- 54:22Screaming is the somatization of
- 54:24emotion in the gifted person's body;
- 54:26it's very high. It
- 54:27and it causes pains they don't know
- 54:29what to do with. One of the areas of
- 54:31neurodiversity I study a lot is
- 54:33psychopharmacology, right? The part
- 54:35about medications there.
- 54:37And it has scared me, the number of
- 54:39patients with wrong diagnoses I've been
- 54:41receiving in my office, with ADHD, with
- 54:44autism, but mainly ADHD. And the story
- 54:47is always like this. He arrives there
- 54:49at 12, 13, 14 years old, ultra mega
- 54:52anxious, some already with suicidal
- 54:54ideation, with self-harm, and with an
- 54:57ADHD diagnosis made back at 6, 7, 8
- 54:59years old. Then he spends 4, 5 years
- 55:02taking all the ADHD medications,
- 55:05all with side effects, it doesn't work.
- 55:08And the mother goes crazy, the school
- 55:09goes crazy, and he arrives there
- 55:11desperate. And then, when you quickly
- 55:13realize, I say: "Wait a minute, if that
- 55:15really were ADHD, with medication, it
- 55:18gets resolved, the medication part will
- 55:20resolve it.""Oh, there might be some
- 55:21particularities." It's rare; it usually
- 55:23gets resolved there. Now, when you hear
- 55:25this recurring story that the kid took
- 55:27the right dose at the right time of all
- 55:29the medications, has a therapist, the
- 55:30family understands everything, and it
- 55:32doesn't resolve. You say: "Wait a
- 55:34minute, there's something here that
- 55:35isn't ADHD." You often have to
- 55:37deconstruct this diagnosis. Then when
- 55:39you evaluate, this patient is gifted,
- 55:41and is there with an anxiety condition,
- 55:44often with absurd depression. And what
- 55:46does that draw attention to? Why? For
- 55:49ADHD, we use medications like Ritalin,
- 55:52Vyvanse, the psychostimulants. If you
- 55:55have a case of anxiety, which is a
- 55:58comorbidity frequently associated with
- 56:00ADHD, and you use a psychostimulant,
- 56:02you get absurdly worse, because that
- 56:05brain doesn't need dopamine adjustments
- 56:07, it doesn't need adjustment with
- 56:09psychostimulants, it needs to treat
- 56:11paths
- 56:14of anxiety, the emotion system with
- 56:16medication, with therapy, in other
- 56:18words, once again, the wrong diagnosis
- 56:20increases the risk of side effects from
- 56:22medications. And what I see in practice
- 56:25is a lack of preparation among many
- 56:27professionals, including in the medical
- 56:29field, who don't know, who don't have
- 56:32this knowledge to differentiate ADHD,
- 56:34autism, from giftedness. Then they
- 56:36start giving medicine and then it turns
- 56:37into this chaos, right? As you said,
- 56:39whether in an evaluation and you
- 56:40receive a message like that, you just
- 56:42think: "My God, what am I going to do?"
- 56:44That despair,
- 56:46right? We wake up and wonder what
- 56:47happened and how that family, that
- 56:49teenager, that child will be. Then what
- 56:51do I tell them? I said: "Hey, stay calm
- 56:53, I'll help you, we'll figure it out
- 56:54and the next day I'm already looking
- 56:56for". So they enter this state and what
- 56:59I really ask, especially the medical
- 57:02field, is this: include giftedness in
- 57:04the account. It is not a disease, but
- 57:08the environment has modified the
- 57:10manifestation, the expression of this
- 57:13gene, because the environment comes
- 57:15with so much hostility, it's that thing
- 57:18, the amygdala comes, right, it's there
- 57:21, it's the smoke signal, the
- 57:23hippocampus catches that smoke signal.
- 57:26Wait a minute, let me store this here
- 57:28for you to defend yourself when the
- 57:30enemy appears. So it puts itself in a
- 57:33state of hypervigilance that you can
- 57:35imagine all gifted people like that,
- 57:37he's in a war trench with his rifle all
- 57:39the time.
- 57:41It's a soldier who doesn't rest, right?
- 57:43He reaches a level of stress. And you
- 57:45mentioned an age that is impressive. 10
- 57:48, 12, 13 is the age of chronic stress.
- 57:53They are already in stress and nothing
- 57:55was done
- 57:56for a decade of suffering.
- 57:58And then many times they reach this age
- 58:00, we give more autonomy to the teenager
- 58:02, he goes to a birthday party alone,
- 58:03goes to parties alone. a set of social
- 58:05skills that he has difficulty with, he
- 58:07is already tired, because that soldier
- 58:09who doesn't rest, is on 24 hours a day
- 58:11and the chance of
- 58:13He has no one to talk to and can't find
- 58:15peers; everyone drifts away, kids his
- 58:17age drift away, he looks around, where
- 58:19is everyone? And the older ones say, "
- 58:21Oh, he's just a kid, no way, he won't
- 58:23understand us." In other words, he ends
- 58:25up completely alone. His peers can't
- 58:27handle his conversation, and he can't
- 58:29seem to interact with them either. The
- 58:31older ones think he's just a boy, and
- 58:34he's left there with no one in the
- 58:36world.
- 58:37This leads to very serious mental
- 58:39health problems in gifted individuals.
- 58:42Since I evaluate children up to 16, I
- 58:44see that this age range between 13 and
- 58:4716 is very critical,
- 58:49which is the age group I also work with
- 58:50, during childhood and adolescence as
- 58:51well. And as you said, when it comes
- 58:53from a wrong diagnosis, it's like that.
- 58:56I really like a phrase I always say:
- 58:58what is seen is cared for. If you don't
- 59:01see it, what isn't seen gets lost. So,
- 59:04if you view it as a disorder, you'll
- 59:06treat it as a disorder. And if it's
- 59:09giftedness, this boy just keeps
- 59:10breaking down more and more. And what
- 59:13happens is exactly what is happening in
- 59:14your reality. Medications, doctors,
- 59:17switching psychiatrists, all of it.
- 59:19Then he reaches 10. I have a recent
- 59:20case of a family, a very studious
- 59:23mother, she's not a doctor, not from
- 59:25the health field, but watching her son
- 59:27there. And this family came to me when
- 59:30he was 13, 14, because she wanted a
- 59:32genetic test for medication.
- 59:33Hmm.
- 59:34So she started the consultation like
- 59:36this: "Look, I don't want a lot of
- 59:37beating around the bush, I want you to
- 59:38order a genetic medication test for me,
- 59:40because my son has already taken this,
- 59:42this, and this for ADHD." He's had an
- 59:43ADHD diagnosis since he was 7 years old
- 59:45and has already taken all the
- 59:47medications. I've even imported
- 59:49medication, he used low doses, high
- 59:51doses of Ritalin, Concerta, the whole
- 59:52arsenal, and all the medications were
- 59:54very harmful to him. And I don't know
- 59:56what else to do, and he's causing
- 59:58trouble at school, he's refusing to go
- 1:00:00to school, and it's chaos.
- 1:00:01It's his history.
- 1:00:03And then I asked quickly, I said: "But
- 1:00:05what is his diagnosis?" I said: "ADHD,
- 1:00:07doctor." I asked: "Are you sure it's
- 1:00:09ADHD?""And we were talking, and
- 1:00:10actually, the giftedness diagnosis
- 1:00:12created this, it shed a light for her
- 1:00:14on the future, and she started to
- 1:00:15understand, she said:' Look, forget
- 1:00:17medicine, we are going to focus on
- 1:00:19something else '." But he is already a
- 1:00:21teenager,
- 1:00:2214 years old, who really suffered a lot
- 1:00:24in school,
- 1:00:24the rigidity increases a lot.
- 1:00:26And so, what do you, what I always say,
- 1:00:29you take a brain that has potential and
- 1:00:31is a percentage like
- 1:00:34a minimal part of the population that
- 1:00:36has this quality, this gift, right,
- 1:00:38this brilliant mind,
- 1:00:40and not use it to, once again, solve
- 1:00:42problems.
- 1:00:43This Ferrari was trapped in a garage
- 1:00:45for a decade. And didn't get to show
- 1:00:47its power. Exactly, right? That's it.
- 1:00:51Yeah, I say it's like driving with the
- 1:00:52handbrake pulled your whole life, right
- 1:00:53? Ruining the engine, wasting oil,
- 1:00:55wasting energy. You push the energy
- 1:00:57forward, it pulls back, and from
- 1:00:59pulling the brake so much for families,
- 1:01:01so, now bringing a little light, a hope
- 1:01:03: what’s coming in this future? What
- 1:01:06does the research say? What can society
- 1:01:08do and what is being done in practice
- 1:01:10for us to perhaps change this
- 1:01:12perspective a bit regarding the future,
- 1:01:14so that families can understand a
- 1:01:16little of what this journey has been
- 1:01:18like, this path for the gifted.
- 1:01:20What do we need to do? Cut Samson’s
- 1:01:23hair. Because Samson’s hair in
- 1:01:25giftedness is our Brazilian definition.
- 1:01:28Every country has a definition of
- 1:01:30giftedness. This definition shapes
- 1:01:33public policy, everything. Our public
- 1:01:38policies, with the definition we have,
- 1:01:40they look at it and say: "What does
- 1:01:42that need?" What great support for the
- 1:01:45psychomotor part, he’s a genius at
- 1:01:48that. He is wonderful. I’m going to
- 1:01:50look at the poor boy who is there
- 1:01:52hungry, the ADHD child who can't stay
- 1:01:54in school, the autistic children, level
- 1:01:56three support, I need to provide that.
- 1:01:59And the gifted child is left,
- 1:02:00leave him in his lamp, right? He has
- 1:02:02his lamp, he's a genie in a lamp, right
- 1:02:04? This lamp is turned off, it’s off
- 1:02:06due to the impact of the hostility of
- 1:02:09the environment, because we have a
- 1:02:11Brazilian mentality that sees the
- 1:02:14gifted in a place where they are not.
- 1:02:17Because you look for the gifted and say
- 1:02:18: "What do you do best? What is your
- 1:02:21extraordinariness?" And that is not
- 1:02:23giftedness.
- 1:02:24What is your super power, right?
- 1:02:25What is your super power? And there is
- 1:02:28a super pain, because he grows up being
- 1:02:31invalidated. And do you know what we
- 1:02:33have today that is very serious?
- 1:02:35Giftedness is genetically hereditary.
- 1:02:37For every gifted child, usually, the
- 1:02:39siblings are too. When there is
- 1:02:41neurodivergence in the family, a mother
- 1:02:44described this very well. In the family
- 1:02:46, there is,
- 1:02:47well, a mother said: "Here, we're all
- 1:02:49weird together, so we're all different
- 1:02:51together."
- 1:02:52When this happens, the parents, usually
- 1:02:54—or if not 100%, often—are also
- 1:02:56gifted, one or both, because studies
- 1:02:58show they are even attracted to each
- 1:03:00other for marriage because they find a
- 1:03:02peer, they understand each other, and
- 1:03:04so on. Parents of our generation,
- 1:03:07unintentionally, out of love and
- 1:03:10self-protection, are making their
- 1:03:12gifted children suffer a lot. Why? They
- 1:03:16come from a generation where that
- 1:03:18potential was invalidated. In other
- 1:03:20words, they don't believe they have it.
- 1:03:22And they remain more or less in the
- 1:03:24same parameters as their child:
- 1:03:26self-demand, perfectionism,
- 1:03:27self-criticism, and low self-esteem.
- 1:03:30And they think: "I need to save my
- 1:03:32child so they don't go through what I
- 1:03:33went through." Then they bring all that
- 1:03:37old history to project onto the child,
- 1:03:40and they build a fence around them.
- 1:03:43Regarding the study of epigenetics, it
- 1:03:46says the following: "Even trauma is
- 1:03:49hereditary." The child acquires the
- 1:03:52parents' trauma without having lived it
- 1:03:54, through the projection that occurs.
- 1:03:57There is an American psychologist, John
- 1:03:59Houseman, who says the following: there
- 1:04:01is a psychic osmosis, an exchange of
- 1:04:03anxiety, of—
- 1:04:05Technically, we say it's damage to that
- 1:04:08DNA, it's a process of methylation that
- 1:04:11happens, you see, and you end up
- 1:04:13damaging it. That's why when you have
- 1:04:17the possibility of making an early
- 1:04:19diagnosis of neurodivergence in general
- 1:04:21, and using medication correctly,
- 1:04:23studies show there is less damage to
- 1:04:25this DNA, less of that methylation
- 1:04:27process, and less damage that occurs in
- 1:04:29that sense. And trauma is an epigenetic
- 1:04:32factor that contributes to this.
- 1:04:34Ex. Trauma in giftedness is very
- 1:04:37present because there is something
- 1:04:39called long-term memory. A little thing
- 1:04:43we have here called the hippocampus
- 1:04:44stores everything. Let's store it,
- 1:04:46because when the trigger comes, we—
- 1:04:48Instead of storing everything, it says:
- 1:04:50"Let's stay here so we can recognize
- 1:04:52the enemy." So the child becomes
- 1:04:54totally helpless in the face of this.
- 1:04:57And the parents, in trying to avoid it,
- 1:04:59end up consolidating that pain in the
- 1:05:01child, and it becomes a "shuttlecock"
- 1:05:03within the neurodivergence at home—
- 1:05:05everyone is weird together, just as
- 1:05:07that mother said. So, we have a
- 1:05:11generation of parents who need to study
- 1:05:13, learn, and take better care of
- 1:05:15themselves than the kids do, so they
- 1:05:17can become a positive reference—one
- 1:05:19that's less painful, because they have
- 1:05:21so much hidden pain.
- 1:05:24It all starts with a good definition, a
- 1:05:26good diagnosis, right? end it. If we
- 1:05:28change the definition, we cut off the
- 1:05:30source of the punishment. Then, through
- 1:05:33that definition, the state starts to
- 1:05:35look at who that child is, who those
- 1:05:37students are—because the state
- 1:05:39handles health, education, and security
- 1:05:41—so it will look at them properly and
- 1:05:44take care of them in the right way. So,
- 1:05:47the first step is changing the
- 1:05:49definition.
- 1:05:50So, events like this podcast give us
- 1:05:52the possibility of being a voice for
- 1:05:55many of these families so it can
- 1:05:57reverberate throughout society. So, to
- 1:06:02help this reach more people, like and
- 1:06:04share this podcast so many others can
- 1:06:07understand giftedness, high abilities,
- 1:06:10their concepts, and their challenges.
- 1:06:14Once again, I’d like to thank
- 1:06:16Ginástica do Cérebro for also
- 1:06:17supporting this episode. If you’d
- 1:06:21like to become a franchisee of
- 1:06:22Ginástica do Cérebro, just scan the
- 1:06:24QR code on the screen to get in touch
- 1:06:26with the sales team. They will present
- 1:06:29this business model to you. If you want
- 1:06:32to be a student at Ginástica do
- 1:06:34Cérebro, just search our social media,
- 1:06:37Instagram, or website to find the
- 1:06:39nearest location to enroll, book a
- 1:06:41trial class, and discover a methodology
- 1:06:44and cognitive training center where
- 1:06:46they develop memory, attention, and
- 1:06:48concentration skills; in other words,
- 1:06:51where you will be training and saving
- 1:06:53your mind.
- 1:06:55Perfect. Well, we're reaching that
- 1:06:57moment of, "Oh, is it over already?"
- 1:06:59There's still so much we could talk
- 1:07:00about, right? It’s infinite.
- 1:07:02That's right. I’d like you to leave a
- 1:07:04final message, your closing thoughts,
- 1:07:07so we can wrap up our podcast.
- 1:07:10right? Well, as a final message,
- 1:07:13awareness that giftedness isn’t a
- 1:07:16superpower; it’s a super intensity, a
- 1:07:19super sensitivity, a super capacity—
- 1:07:21in other words, this capacity isn't
- 1:07:24always visible. So, parents and
- 1:07:27teachers shouldn't try to force what
- 1:07:29they want to see or think about
- 1:07:31giftedness. But I don't see all this "K
- 1:07:33," the boy with a K of 140, for example
- 1:07:35, and all the characteristics screaming
- 1:07:37: "Oh, but I don't see all that because
- 1:07:39his notebook isn't pretty, because he
- 1:07:41can't stay seated in the classroom, he
- 1:07:43doesn't look at the teacher because his
- 1:07:45attention is diffuse." For them to be
- 1:07:48able to listen and learn that new
- 1:07:49content, they have to occupy other
- 1:07:51regions by moving, walking, sitting,
- 1:07:53and...because some say: "I listen with
- 1:07:56my ears, not with my eyes, so I don't
- 1:07:58need to be looking." So we need to
- 1:08:01understand, we need to understand this
- 1:08:02condition. Yeah. And today in Brazil
- 1:08:05it's so serious, for example, just this
- 1:08:08Saturday I created a lecture, a meeting
- 1:08:10with parents to learn how to save their
- 1:08:12child's mental health, because I
- 1:08:14already suffer a lot with the pain they
- 1:08:16are having. We need to take care of the
- 1:08:19child so the adolescent doesn't get to
- 1:08:21where I'm receiving them now. And what
- 1:08:24makes me suffer most is thinking: "Wow,
- 1:08:26so much could have been avoided." So we
- 1:08:29need to start knowing this condition as
- 1:08:31a neurophysiological condition, it's
- 1:08:34not behavioral, it's not a behavior
- 1:08:36that appears and goes away. It is the
- 1:08:39person, it is what they
- 1:08:41give a name to that word, right?
- 1:08:43Different.
- 1:08:44Different. That's the word.
- 1:08:45That is the warning word, right? For
- 1:08:47all parents, teachers, and educators,
- 1:08:49right? Doctor. Thank you so much for
- 1:08:52your presence, for your very rich
- 1:08:54contribution to such a challenging
- 1:08:56topic, one where we need to advance so
- 1:08:58much from the point of view of science,
- 1:09:00of treatment in health, in education,
- 1:09:02and which creates many challenges, but
- 1:09:04with information, like from people like
- 1:09:07you, I'm sure we have a very prosperous
- 1:09:09future so that we can implement true
- 1:09:11public and private health measures, in
- 1:09:13education, which is where these
- 1:09:15problems often start to scream in
- 1:09:17childhood, right? Save the child.
- 1:09:20Exactly, guys. So, once again, I ask
- 1:09:23that you like, forward this podcast so
- 1:09:25that so many other people have access.
- 1:09:28My thanks and God bless you all.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of SUPERDOTAÇÃO: A verdade que ninguém conta | Ep #11 | Com Dra. Olzeni Ribeiro by Anima Podcast, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 11,150 words across 1,813 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.