Student leadership training3 fixed — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00[Music]
- 0:15and we are back ladies and gentlemen
- 0:18this time um we we felt important that
- 0:20we we look into a a a module that we
- 0:24call political tolerance um it is
- 0:27important that you know from the from
- 0:29the go I explained the importance of why
- 0:31we we thought let let us include
- 0:34political tolerances in as one of the
- 0:36the modules now over the years of of
- 0:39working with a number of student
- 0:41student
- 0:43organizations um and of course with the
- 0:46Advent of of political political
- 0:48organizations within campuses is that we
- 0:51are finding that students over the years
- 0:53have struggled with with if you like
- 0:55sharing power uh and sharing power
- 0:58purely because there are intolerant of
- 1:01of one another and and and when we we
- 1:03try to to to Really hone in on what what
- 1:06the causes of this intolerances and we
- 1:09found it's purely because of different
- 1:11political organizations have very
- 1:14different political dogmas and on the
- 1:16basis of those different political
- 1:18dogmas they tend to to be very very
- 1:21intolerant of one another now this
- 1:24intolerance is not is not is not helping
- 1:26anyone is not helping the individual
- 1:28student leaders it's not helping helping
- 1:30the students that they serve and
- 1:31certainly not helping the institutions
- 1:33that they lead and and so the importance
- 1:35of beginning to to have conversations
- 1:38around around political tolerance how do
- 1:40we get student leaders to share to to to
- 1:43to to be tolerant of one another on
- 1:45campus and so this module is really
- 1:48going to delve into such things as what
- 1:50is this political tolerance that we
- 1:52speak of and then what is the difference
- 1:54between political tolerance and
- 1:56political intolerance
- 2:00ladies and gentlemen we are going to
- 2:01also look at in this module we're going
- 2:02to look at how different political
- 2:07ideologies then then form and not only
- 2:09just form and how they influence the
- 2:12levels of Tolerance in in institutions
- 2:14but you will also notice as we go along
- 2:16that we will begin to speak about such
- 2:18Concepts as as populism and we'll talk
- 2:21about how mob
- 2:23mobilization but in the end we want to
- 2:26be able to locate the role of of
- 2:28Tolerance in a democratic
- 2:30a theory in democratic theory so so that
- 2:33then forms the framework of of this this
- 2:35module that is coming up
- 2:39next political tolerance in it in its
- 2:42very sort of naked sense in its very
- 2:44simplest of of sense just means you you
- 2:47you you are able to accept and respect
- 2:49the basic rights and civil liberties of
- 2:52persons or people that that hold
- 2:55different viewpoints from your own
- 2:57meaning you begin to realize that
- 3:00political party X has got a totally
- 3:04different Viewpoint from political party
- 3:07Y and and and in itself there's nothing
- 3:09wrong with the different political
- 3:12viewpoints which is where now political
- 3:15tolerance comes in political tolerance
- 3:17teaches us the ability to be able to
- 3:19accept and respect those different
- 3:22viewpoints and so as we present this to
- 3:26student leaders we are trying to make
- 3:27the point that it is going to require a
- 3:29lot of political Tolerance on your part
- 3:31to be able to function as a as a
- 3:33structure more so because the nature of
- 3:37our party political system then PS the
- 3:41different members of the different
- 3:43political parties into one structure
- 3:45where you could
- 3:47find I'm Lo to make mention of the
- 3:50specific political parties but we do
- 3:53know that different political parties
- 3:54would exist together in one structure
- 3:58political tolerance then says to us
- 4:00if you have political toor then you are
- 4:02able to respect and to accept the other
- 4:05people's different
- 4:07viewpoints to the extent that we believe
- 4:10that as student leaders and then in fact
- 4:13we go on to say all leaders political
- 4:16leaders have a responsibility to
- 4:17practice political tolerance and and
- 4:20this practice of political tolerance we
- 4:21want to see it in the words that you use
- 4:24in the language that you use and you
- 4:26want to see it in the actions that you
- 4:27then employ as as conduct yourself as a
- 4:31leader so so so so there must be a clear
- 4:34rejection of Might makes
- 4:37right as opposed to political tolerance
- 4:40being a key principle of of democracy
- 4:44right so where where we believe in might
- 4:46makes right is where we believe the one
- 4:48with more power the one with more votes
- 4:50has got the right to dictate the terms
- 4:53of the SRC in actual fact the other
- 4:56should be the other way around it is in
- 4:59and understanding and appreciating the
- 5:00level of power that you have within the
- 5:02structure that you then you use you able
- 5:05to use it in a more more mature way and
- 5:07the only way to be able to do that is if
- 5:10you are politically
- 5:12tolerant but we speak about this
- 5:15political tolerance within the within
- 5:16the the realm of of of democracy what is
- 5:20this this democracy right as an ideal
- 5:23democracy upholds that different members
- 5:26of society should at the very least
- 5:29there a basic principle treat each other
- 5:31and be treated as equals regardless of
- 5:34of their seniority or minority status
- 5:38underlying democracy is the acceptance
- 5:40and the respect for one
- 5:42another Democratic life is both the
- 5:45right to differ as well the acceptance
- 5:47of such differences by all right and
- 5:50this is a point that is very important
- 5:51that you make it that is democracy
- 5:53allows us the right to differ to hold
- 5:56different political viewpoints but
- 5:58tolerance then comes and says it is in
- 6:01those differences that you begin to
- 6:02accept those differences you begin to
- 6:04respect the differences because in the
- 6:07absence of doing that then you have a
- 6:08very dysfunctional Society you have a
- 6:11very dysfunctional University you have a
- 6:13very dysfunctional SRC
- 6:17structure democracy implies respect for
- 6:19the plurality of of views and the
- 6:22virtues of of dialogue as a means of
- 6:24resolving conflicts there are those who
- 6:26speak about those political theorist
- 6:29political scientist who be who speak
- 6:31about what they call the
- 6:33Marketplace you you you create you turn
- 6:35the SRC into a market place of ideas a
- 6:38market place of ideas is is
- 6:41understanding is you don't have a a head
- 6:43mentality we don't all believe in the
- 6:46same thing but it is in those very
- 6:48different views that we bring them all
- 6:50together in some sort of a parliament
- 6:52where each view is expressed each view
- 6:55is treated with respect each view is
- 6:57accorded its own platform and and and
- 7:00and we we we do this not because we we
- 7:03want to be the same but because we
- 7:05realize that it is in our dividence that
- 7:09lies lies our
- 7:12strengths political intolerance on on
- 7:14the other hand ladies and gentlemen um
- 7:17it will always happen in an institution
- 7:19in a university or in a society where
- 7:22the there is the willingness to restrict
- 7:25the right of disliked person so meaning
- 7:27we identify groups in individuals in
- 7:30society that we dislike for whatever our
- 7:32reasons and and and upon disliking them
- 7:35we then
- 7:37say whatever their rights they become
- 7:40restricted purely because we have we
- 7:42have we have disliked them and that that
- 7:45is when you now you're creating an
- 7:47environment where intolerance T takes
- 7:50root in in your Society what it does is
- 7:53that it represents a threat to democracy
- 7:56right since since you have numbers or
- 7:59individuals or groups in in that society
- 8:02that are discriminated against to the
- 8:04extent that you discriminate against
- 8:07them where you even have to silence them
- 8:11that that you you you you mute their
- 8:13their ideas you mute their
- 8:16voices the problem with intolerance
- 8:18ladies and gentlemen is that it creates
- 8:20a conformist culture where everybody
- 8:22just wants to
- 8:24conform just because so it is not
- 8:26informed by anything that is sensical
- 8:29but purely because I do not want to be
- 8:31silenced therefore I must become a
- 8:34conformist that is a problem with with
- 8:39intolerance the the idea of of silencing
- 8:42others is purely based on the fact that
- 8:44they offer ideologies totally different
- 8:47from the ideologies that that we hold
- 8:49that we hold sacred but what is this
- 8:52ideology perhaps maybe let's let's look
- 8:54at a little bit into the idea of of
- 8:56political ideology in particular as as
- 8:58help student leaders informed by the
- 9:01dogmas of their political parties
- 9:03ideology is a collection of beliefs held
- 9:06by you as a structure or as a society or
- 9:09a group of
- 9:10people it is mainly made up of a set of
- 9:13very conscious and very unconscious
- 9:15ideas about what what makes up one's
- 9:18beliefs what leads to one's goals the
- 9:21expectations that you have of yourself
- 9:23and the motivations that drive you to
- 9:24want to serve students so so it's
- 9:26important that student leaders are very
- 9:28aware of their conscious and unconscious
- 9:30ideas about what they hold hold to be
- 9:34true H we always make the point that
- 9:37particularly if you follow our our our
- 9:40work on on Conflict Management that
- 9:43people's perceptions are their
- 9:45realities but those realities are based
- 9:47on very very falsehoods it it's
- 9:49important that we as an individual as a
- 9:51group you you begin to question your
- 9:55very conscious and unconscious ideas
- 9:57about about your ideologies
- 10:01ideology is the imaginary relation to
- 10:04the real conditions of existence now
- 10:06that that's a bit of a mouthful but I
- 10:08think the key word here is this
- 10:09imaginary it is what what you hold to to
- 10:13be true in your head and and what you
- 10:15hold to be true in your head if if
- 10:18supported by a narrative by other people
- 10:21around you you you you make it to become
- 10:24your reality but all all always has been
- 10:27said and done it's just an imagination
- 10:28it's about it's about what you as a
- 10:30group hold to be true but actual fact
- 10:34it's not necessarily always the case so
- 10:37ideology is formed really around those
- 10:40conscious and unconscious ideas about
- 10:42the beliefs that we have of the
- 10:44world now couple ideology with this
- 10:48concept called populism um a number of
- 10:50leaders I'm sure that as student leaders
- 10:53you would be aware of a number of
- 10:55leaders in in our country in our
- 10:57continent and the world who you would
- 11:00very easily call populist leaders right
- 11:02these are so so so these are leaders who
- 11:04believe that their political stances
- 11:08their political stances are emphasized
- 11:10by the idea of the people now as soon as
- 11:13somebody says for the people of the
- 11:15people what they often is trying to
- 11:18suggest to all of us is that there is
- 11:19always the other group which is the
- 11:22elite considered to be the elite now
- 11:24when when populist populist leaders are
- 11:26very good at mobilizing voters are
- 11:30voting on the grounds of being the
- 11:33the leaders of the people and and we
- 11:37make the point that as soon as you hear
- 11:38a leader say that you must know that
- 11:40they're trying to pit one group of
- 11:41people against another the people
- 11:44against the
- 11:48elite a a common a common sort of common
- 11:51framework this is now trying to
- 11:53interpret populism a common framework
- 11:56suggests that populism as an ideology
- 12:00presents the people which is what this
- 12:03leader stands for the people as a
- 12:04morally as a morally good force and
- 12:06contrast them against the elite who are
- 12:09portrayed as corrupt or self-
- 12:11serving populist differ in how the
- 12:14people are defined but it can be based
- 12:16along class they use they use National
- 12:19lines they use racial lines they use
- 12:21ethnic lines to to identify these people
- 12:25so they segment people for their own
- 12:27benefit if you like
- 12:29and what these populist parties do and
- 12:32socialist Mo social movements do is that
- 12:34often they they are led by very
- 12:36charismatic or dominant leaders or
- 12:38dominant figures who who have a a way
- 12:41and ability of presenting themselves as
- 12:44the voice of the people and as soon as
- 12:46you hear those words ladies and
- 12:47gentlemen we have now now come to learn
- 12:50that it is usually traces of populism be
- 12:53careful of those very charismatic and
- 12:55very dominant leaders who lead some of
- 12:57this this political political parties
- 13:00who could very well in fact exist within
- 13:02our very universities and in particular
- 13:07unisa it is important that within that
- 13:10that understanding trying to explain
- 13:12this concept ladies and gentlemen that
- 13:14we make mention of the concept called
- 13:16mobilization mobilization is is really
- 13:18about how these very populist leaders or
- 13:21any po leader go about garnering votes
- 13:25for themselves or for their for their
- 13:27organizations
- 13:29now in in this module that we have put
- 13:31together we make mention of three forms
- 13:34of political mobilizations this is this
- 13:36is what we have now come to be
- 13:37accustomed to particularly in in a
- 13:39country such as our ours South
- 13:42Africa is that mobilization usually
- 13:44happens on three levels number one it
- 13:46could happen at a level of we use a
- 13:48populist leader I don't know how many
- 13:50times have I seen during the elections
- 13:52national elections provincial elections
- 13:54in our country where there's
- 13:56one particular phase of a leader from
- 14:00one particular party that is used to
- 14:02sell the organization for the benefit of
- 14:04ging votes so the the posters of of that
- 14:07political party will feature only one
- 14:09member of of that of that organization
- 14:11one leader in fact in one in one
- 14:14organization I saw in the last elections
- 14:17one political party used the face of a
- 14:20leader who passed away just to make the
- 14:23point that because the leader was so
- 14:25popular they still needed that that the
- 14:28popularity of of that leader to GA to
- 14:30gather the votes for their
- 14:33party sometimes what they do in
- 14:35mobilizing ladies and gentlemen is you
- 14:37you do you you so in the one hand you
- 14:40could use a populist leader on the other
- 14:42you could use ideology uh some
- 14:45organizations have got have used
- 14:47africanism as an ideology some have used
- 14:50communism as an ideology socialism as an
- 14:53ideology and there's quite a number of
- 14:55them
- 14:56conservatism as an ideology but then in
- 14:59the end it it could also use social
- 15:02movement as as as as a tool for
- 15:05mobilizing your your voter social
- 15:07movement is identifying what the issues
- 15:09are on the ground such as what you have
- 15:12in our country with the disbursement of
- 15:14food Parcels during elections that is
- 15:17really to get people to it's a it's a
- 15:20social movement in the sense that it's
- 15:22it's solves a a real and an existing
- 15:25problem on the ground but we also do
- 15:27know that it is a way of of G Garin
- 15:30Garin the
- 15:32votes a catalyst for the growth of
- 15:34populism we have
- 15:37found is when When leaders sell sell
- 15:42themselves as the ones who are going to
- 15:44solve all problems because the leaders
- 15:47who are currently in office and are
- 15:49unresponsive to the challenges of the
- 15:51people so so this is the the Mantra that
- 15:54we hear all the time from all leaders
- 15:56when when when it's time for elections
- 15:58we are being promised all manner of
- 16:00things with the suggestion that those
- 16:03who are currently in power have not been
- 16:05responding to our challenges and those
- 16:07who come into power are now going to be
- 16:09Our Saviors now let's bring this
- 16:12conversation back home to the src's um
- 16:15the experience that we have over the
- 16:17years picked up is that a lot of SRC
- 16:20members who come into power they have a
- 16:23belief that by as soon as they come into
- 16:25power they get assume office they're
- 16:27going to solve all of the in institions
- 16:29problems and we know that that is never
- 16:32the case this is just the Mantra to win
- 16:35votes and as soon as you win votes and
- 16:37to be fair to student leaders as soon as
- 16:39you win votes you get into the office of
- 16:41the SRC then you realize that serving at
- 16:43that level is totally different from
- 16:45serving outside of the structures of of
- 16:48of the university and this is the point
- 16:50where we always make the point that
- 16:52there is a huge difference between
- 16:53student activism and student
- 16:56representation now while student
- 16:58activism might have got you the vote to
- 17:01get into the SRC office it is not
- 17:03student activism that is going to keep
- 17:05you in office
- 17:07because in the words of the title of
- 17:10student representative counil it means
- 17:11you are now a representative meaning you
- 17:14are part of the governance structures of
- 17:16the institution so no longer are you
- 17:18going to be banging down down the doors
- 17:20because the door is already open for you
- 17:22and you need to be able to make that
- 17:24transition as as a as a student leader
- 17:26is making the transition from student
- 17:28activist to student representative a lot
- 17:31ofu student leaders we find they only
- 17:34make that realization towards the end of
- 17:36the ATT in office and at that time it's
- 17:39already too late you you've had had a
- 17:42number of months in office where you try
- 17:44to Grapple with the the realities of
- 17:46being an SRC member but you did it at
- 17:48the expense of being a a student
- 17:51activist so it's important that in the
- 17:53process of trying to mobilize you
- 17:55mobilizing so that you get get into the
- 17:57SRC when you get into the SRC the gain
- 17:59changes and the demands are a bit
- 18:01different and so you need to be
- 18:02responsive to the to the new
- 18:05demands now now the role of Tolerance in
- 18:08in a democratic
- 18:10theory um in a simple tense ladies and
- 18:13gentlemen democracy suggest that
- 18:15majority rules right and and so and so
- 18:18it should be majority should rule but
- 18:21the democracy is also a system in
- 18:25which respect for the rights of
- 18:28political mind
- 18:29minorities should also take center stage
- 18:32and then and again you know we will
- 18:34always go back to mature leadership
- 18:36we'll always go back to Discerning
- 18:38leadership we always go back to the big
- 18:41picture kind of leadership where you be
- 18:43realized that even when you do have
- 18:45power there will be those who will be
- 18:48minorities and and it is in your ability
- 18:51to protect the rights of those
- 18:53minorities that will determine the kind
- 18:54of leader and the kind of leadership
- 18:56that that you become the one that
- 18:59student leaders are now confronted with
- 19:01and and this is this is you know we're
- 19:02beginning to realize now is that we've
- 19:05got students who come from from other
- 19:07African countries who come and study in
- 19:09our country and they become our
- 19:10constituencies because they vote as well
- 19:12during elections so so they are they
- 19:15become a minority that needs to be
- 19:17protected by the SRC you also
- 19:21have
- 19:23um persons from from the lgbtqia A plus
- 19:27communities that need need to be taken
- 19:29into consideration that because of their
- 19:32numbers they are lesser in numbers in a
- 19:34number of our campuses it makes them
- 19:37minorities and therefore the SRC at some
- 19:40point needs to begin to Champion some of
- 19:42their issues um a case in point that I
- 19:44found extremely interesting was was
- 19:46around one University that spoke about
- 19:49they they what they did is that they
- 19:51reimagined their positions within the
- 19:53SRC and and and rather than
- 19:56having portfolio of SP and Recreation
- 19:59and portfolio of social this and that
- 20:01they've got what they call universal
- 20:02access now universal access then begins
- 20:05to suggest that they are very clear
- 20:07about protecting the rights of the
- 20:09minorities within campuses such as your
- 20:11lgbtqia plus such as your International
- 20:14students particularly students from the
- 20:16African continent and then of course
- 20:18there's issues students such as persons
- 20:20with disabilities students with
- 20:21disabilities is that at some point or
- 20:23the other somebody's going to have to
- 20:24take care of their needs so a democratic
- 20:27theory suggest that you have the
- 20:29majority but uh maturity on your part
- 20:33will then mean being able to protect
- 20:36your
- 20:39minorities you you you we I spoke
- 20:41earlier on about creating the SRC into a
- 20:44Marketplace of ideas and Market of ideas
- 20:46is where you literally intentionally
- 20:49create spaces for all of these
- 20:50minorities to have a voice in the
- 20:52running of the institution in the
- 20:54running of the
- 20:56SRC so so what we then do is that what
- 20:59what we suggest that you do is that you
- 21:00set up institutions of majority rule now
- 21:04these institutions of ma majority rule
- 21:06are not necessarily based on the numbers
- 21:09but they are really based on ensuring a
- 21:11collectivism of all students involved in
- 21:15in voicing whatever their issues whether
- 21:17you do it via a mass meeting of students
- 21:19whether you do it via a parliament of of
- 21:22of students but there's got to be a way
- 21:23in which the minor minorities rights are
- 21:27protected
- 21:32now without guaranties of the right of
- 21:34all these all these minorities
- 21:36participating in the politics of of the
- 21:38of the institution you can forget about
- 21:41it becoming the marketplace of ideas
- 21:43right so so if we if all that we do is
- 21:47the SRC is to listen to the voices of
- 21:50those who have got more power those who
- 21:52have got more the numbers in terms of
- 21:54the votes then we lose out those who are
- 21:56outside who are on the periphery where
- 21:58we can not begin to speak about the
- 21:59marketplace of ideas of the SRC as the
- 22:01marketplace of ideas the marketpl of
- 22:04ideas ladies and gentlemen suggest that
- 22:06anybody can put forth an idea and these
- 22:10ideas can then formulate what you call
- 22:12the program of action of the
- 22:15SRC it means just before you undertake
- 22:19your processes of developing programs of
- 22:21action it would be perhaps be better for
- 22:24for student leaders to go back to the
- 22:26masses to the students and say what are
- 22:28are your opinions what are your ideas
- 22:30about the sort of programs that you'd
- 22:31like to see on on
- 22:33campuses when all has been said and done
- 22:36and this is very important that that we
- 22:38raise this issue that the the programs
- 22:40that you come up with as the SRC yes you
- 22:43would have conversed your your your your
- 22:45student body but they've got to be the
- 22:48kinds of programs that that that are
- 22:50empowering to students and that can
- 22:52engage students right those two concepts
- 22:55are very important because they're
- 22:56important for the process of GR
- 22:58graduating students right when always
- 23:00it's been certain time these students
- 23:01come here because they want to get a
- 23:03qualification they want to graduate now
- 23:06now the manner in which they're going to
- 23:07graduate will be determined by the
- 23:09quality of life that they experience
- 23:11throughout their study years and the SRC
- 23:13plays a critical role in in that in that
- 23:23discourse a a fairly simple theory is
- 23:26that democracy require free and open
- 23:31debate of political
- 23:33differences right um the the the the the
- 23:37the at any given point where as an
- 23:41individual or as a grouping whatever
- 23:43your political party whatever you call
- 23:44yourselves you feel threatened by ideas
- 23:48from a different political parties what
- 23:50you need to know is that you are not fit
- 23:52for purpose you're not ready for the
- 23:54maturity required to become SRC members
- 23:57because because again Simple Theory of
- 24:00democracy says to us you've got to have
- 24:02free and open debate whether it is we do
- 24:05it face to face whether we do it in a
- 24:08meeting whether we write we publish
- 24:10articles however way that we do it but
- 24:12there's got to be the the willingness to
- 24:15be open to free and open debate across
- 24:18the different political part political
- 24:20parties now this this this such debates
- 24:23can only take place in an environment
- 24:26where there is political to to an now
- 24:29political tolerance requires that all
- 24:32the ideas get the same access to the
- 24:34marketpl of ideas now to to to retrace
- 24:39to to retrace our steps we we we speak a
- 24:42lot about political tolerance and we
- 24:43speak a lot about political intolerance
- 24:45and of course what we do know is that we
- 24:47want to get to a point where we are
- 24:49tolerant as a society or as an
- 24:51institution perhaps the question that we
- 24:53need to be asking is what makes people
- 24:56intolerant right we we found that it
- 24:59this this intolerance happens largely
- 25:02because again leaders who fail to see
- 25:06the big
- 25:07picture two leaders Who Remain
- 25:11immature three leaders who fail to make
- 25:14the transition from student activism to
- 25:16student representative now this is a
- 25:18matter that I think as the SRC of unisa
- 25:21we need to begin to you know literally
- 25:22throughout the term of office to engage
- 25:25in in some of these these issues to what
- 25:27extent are
- 25:29we tolerant as a structure of this
- 25:32SRC measuring political tolerance now
- 25:35tolerance requires that student leaders
- 25:37you know you you you are able to accept
- 25:40ideas even those that you find
- 25:41objectionable even those that you find
- 25:43repulsive and you develop the maturity
- 25:45to accept and listen as one as one
- 25:48leader once said
- 25:50that I might I disagree with you but I
- 25:54will protect your right to State your
- 25:57case however repulsive I find it I
- 26:00believe it was the late desm Bishop desm
- 26:05this LS to to pertinent questions which
- 26:08ideas must be put up with in an
- 26:10institution or put differently what
- 26:13kinds of activities should we pursue as
- 26:15the SRC of a university such as such as
- 26:18unisa with with with the numbers that
- 26:20you deal with the diversity that you
- 26:22deal with what sort of activities should
- 26:24be embraced what sort of ideas should be
- 26:26embraced and only you the leaders of
- 26:28this institution can answer that
- 26:30question but to answer this question
- 26:32you're going to have to mobilize the
- 26:34entire student body around a discussion
- 26:37on what what becomes a functioning
- 26:39Institution for
- 26:42us it is about identifying a group that
- 26:45you dislike and still put up with it is
- 26:48about pluralistic intolerance achieving
- 26:51consensus on who the enemy is if that
- 26:53consensus cannot be reached it means we
- 26:56don't actually dislike them and there's
- 26:58a point being made here is that
- 27:00sometimes what you call dislike in
- 27:01another person is really just
- 27:03misunderstanding of the difference that
- 27:06they present to you and if you could
- 27:08understand the difference maybe we'll
- 27:10get to a point where we accept each
- 27:12other and there will be no more the
- 27:14disliking of of
- 27:17others what causes tolerance and what
- 27:19causes intolerance again let's go back
- 27:21to that question to answer this Focus
- 27:24must be on the
- 27:25individual we again I spoke at on about
- 27:29what we call political Dogma it is
- 27:31people Believing on what they believe on
- 27:34the basis of it is it is generally
- 27:37widespread a
- 27:38widespread notion H by by a number of
- 27:41people but if we hone in on the
- 27:43individual student leader and we ask
- 27:45that person what as an individual do you
- 27:48perceive to be a
- 27:50threat because we know that we know that
- 27:52predictors of in intolerance ladies and
- 27:54gentlemen include such things such as
- 27:56social esteem it self-esteem my
- 27:59apologies it is your self-esteem that is
- 28:01on the line we also know that it
- 28:03includes such things as social learning
- 28:05the man in which you are socialized it
- 28:08includes Democratic Values those values
- 28:11that you've hold dear to you it includes
- 28:14your psychological
- 28:16insecurity and largely it includes your
- 28:19personality trait so so the point that
- 28:21we're trying to make here is that maybe
- 28:23rather than aggregating the problem let
- 28:25let us disaggregate it and look at the
- 28:27individual consider the individual and
- 28:29when you look at the individual as I
- 28:31said let's look at their self-esteem
- 28:33let's look at their social learning
- 28:35let's look at their Democratic Values
- 28:36let's look at their psychological
- 28:38insecurity let's look at their
- 28:39personality traits looking at that put
- 28:43together will tell us a lot about the
- 28:45individual and how that individual
- 28:47influences those individuals those
- 28:49others around around them we know
- 28:53that
- 28:55close-mindedness and psychological regid
- 28:58are also causes of intolerance is that
- 29:01you have such a a limited world view you
- 29:04have very very you're very rigid in in
- 29:07your psychological makeup that you are
- 29:09not able to to see beyond the lenses
- 29:12that that that form the your
- 29:15understanding of the world and because
- 29:16of that your intolerance then spikes
- 29:20because you know again you you lack the
- 29:22big picture thinking that I speak
- 29:25of but but the strongest of of all of
- 29:28these ladies and gentlemen around
- 29:30tolerance and intolerance the strongest
- 29:32of them all is this thing called
- 29:34perceptions now I'm going to sound like
- 29:36a broken record but I'll go back and say
- 29:38people's perceptions are their realities
- 29:40and I accept that but I've also come to
- 29:42learn that it is those very perceptions
- 29:45that are based on falsehoods you know
- 29:46somebody once said um somebody said the
- 29:49problem with trying to express
- 29:51everybody's world view is that sometimes
- 29:53people without a view of the world are
- 29:56allowed to express a world view
- 30:00those who are threatened by their
- 30:01political enemy are less likely to
- 30:02tolerate them and I suppose that that
- 30:05that goes without that goes without
- 30:07saying while threat perceptions cause
- 30:09intolerance it may also be the case that
- 30:12intolerance causes threat perceptions so
- 30:15one feeds off of each other so what are
- 30:17we saying here we're saying we it is
- 30:19important that we understand the causes
- 30:21of Tolerance and intolerance but in
- 30:23order for us to be able to do that
- 30:24perhaps let us look at the individual
- 30:26and not so much the whole as a
- 30:28collective maybe understanding the
- 30:31individual will help us understand the
- 30:33whole and understanding the whole will
- 30:35help us understand the beliefs that they
- 30:37hold and understanding their beliefs
- 30:39will understand why they become tolerant
- 30:41or intolerant of views that are
- 30:43different from their
- 30:46own environmental conditions have a way
- 30:49of of of exacerbating the problem right
- 30:54or sometimes ameliorating the problem by
- 30:56by environmental conditions we talk
- 30:58about such things as to the the level to
- 31:01which our student leaders are exposed um
- 31:03how big is your world um what have you
- 31:06been exposed to what have you been
- 31:07socialized to we have we are finding
- 31:10that and there's a there's a thinker who
- 31:12makes a point
- 31:14around read and read and read as student
- 31:17leaders right we have problems of
- 31:18student leaders who all that you read Is
- 31:22What You by either your your field of
- 31:24study or by your political party but we
- 31:27would like a situation where student
- 31:29leaders are able to broaden their
- 31:31Horizon to read as widely as they
- 31:34possibly can because it is in reading
- 31:36that your your you know your world
- 31:39becomes becomes a little bit bigger
- 31:41right and and that goes with your
- 31:43environmental conditioning what is
- 31:45important for us is understanding that
- 31:46these environmental conditions have the
- 31:48ability to to either make the problem
- 31:50worse or reduce the
- 31:53problem we also need to look at such
- 31:55things as as you know what we call core
- 31:58values core attitudes of people and and
- 32:00just how fairly resistant they are to
- 32:02change right and fairly resistant to
- 32:05they are to change if if you want to be
- 32:07able to embrace the change from those
- 32:09core values and core attitudes it is
- 32:12perhaps again a bit better to to expose
- 32:14yourself to the to the bigger World
- 32:16realize that there's more to the world
- 32:18than just your your personal personal
- 32:22beliefs here's some some sobering
- 32:25thoughts right here's some some sobering
- 32:27thoughts perhaps as I as I as I begin to
- 32:29taper down is that the tolerance is a
- 32:33difficult and cognitively demanding
- 32:35position to
- 32:37adopt tolerance requires
- 32:41deliberation when people take the time
- 32:43and energy to deliberate they often can
- 32:45descend the cost of intolerance and I
- 32:48think for me this is the the important
- 32:50until such time student leaders begin to
- 32:52realize the cost of intolerance on
- 32:55themselves on their structures on their
- 32:57students that they leave lead on the
- 32:58institutions that they lead they will
- 33:00perhaps begin to to to to move towards
- 33:03towards
- 33:04tolerance tolerance is considering more
- 33:07pliable than
- 33:10intolerance the tolerant can be more
- 33:12readily persuaded to abandon their
- 33:14tolerance than can the intolerant be
- 33:17convinced to become tolerant again a bit
- 33:20of a mouthful but what it says and I'd
- 33:22like to repeat the tolerant can be more
- 33:25readily persuaded to abandon their
- 33:27tolerance then the intolerant can be
- 33:29convinced to become tolerant meaning
- 33:31people who are intolerant find it very
- 33:33difficult to move towards tolerance and
- 33:35that is the challenge that Society sits
- 33:37with today is that people who are
- 33:38intolerant are very difficult to
- 33:40convince to become tolerant whereas
- 33:42people who are tolerant very easily can
- 33:45abandon their tolerance and that for us
- 33:47ladies and gentlemen is a challenge that
- 33:49that Society has and certainly as
- 33:51student leaders it will have to be a
- 33:52challenge that that you take up first
- 33:54with yourselves as individuals and of
- 33:57course with the larger
- 34:01group in closing and and this is perhaps
- 34:04something for student leaders to begin
- 34:05to think about um you know these are
- 34:08these are these are questions that I
- 34:09will ask but there will be rhetoric
- 34:12questions um can you think of as a
- 34:15student leader can you think of any case
- 34:18studies of political intolerance in the
- 34:21world anyway in the world you know take
- 34:22your time to think about it can you
- 34:24think
- 34:26about I don't want to be descriptive but
- 34:29from from the African continent to to
- 34:32the to the Middle East to to Europe to
- 34:36Eastern Europe today another I want to
- 34:39think about is can you think about
- 34:42examples of political
- 34:44ideas in in South Africa political
- 34:48ideologies in our country right this is
- 34:50something that as you think about you
- 34:52must think about it in relation to your
- 34:54own ideologies and the ideologies that
- 34:56that you pursue
- 35:00how do how do political parties in our
- 35:02country in particular in our country
- 35:04mobilize voters what are the things that
- 35:06get students voting for you and this is
- 35:09something that I was thinking about in
- 35:11fact just this weekend is that to to to
- 35:13to a very large extent students vote if
- 35:17a student votes for a particular party
- 35:19outside of campus and that party then
- 35:22exists within their campus they highly
- 35:24likely to vote for that
- 35:26party even though the demands are a
- 35:28little different but there's this this
- 35:30Affinity that we find with our political
- 35:32parties that we do not lose those
- 35:34parties we do not divorce our parties
- 35:35doesn't matter where we find ourselves
- 35:37so so as student leaders I think it's
- 35:39important that you begin to think about
- 35:41as as you mobilize students you know
- 35:43what what is the what is what what what
- 35:45is what is your sale what is it that
- 35:46you're offering them versus what they
- 35:48get outside of their
- 35:51campuses as you think about your term of
- 35:53office student leaders think about
- 35:55sections of the sections of the
- 35:58the the
- 35:59unisa
- 36:01community that that you would
- 36:03call minorities right how do you define
- 36:07them how do we Define Minority is it on
- 36:09the basis of the numbers is it on the
- 36:10basis of the lack of voice is it on the
- 36:12basis of their emerging but how do you
- 36:15who do you who would you consider the
- 36:18the the sections of communities of this
- 36:19institution that you would consider
- 36:21minorities because understanding that
- 36:24then the challenge becomes how do you
- 36:26then get them to to become to become
- 36:28part of this Marketplace of ideas right
- 36:31how do you mobilize them to come and
- 36:33join in the table of of ideas because as
- 36:36I said The more powerful that you are as
- 36:39a structure whether you National SRC
- 36:41whether you Regional SRC is that you
- 36:43hold a level of power that has got the
- 36:46ability to draw in the other minorities
- 36:48onto the table of Market of of ideas
- 36:51right so it's important that you are
- 36:53able to protect the the rights of of
- 36:55your minorities
- 36:58and with that ladies and gentlemen I'd
- 36:59like to come to an end and thank you
- 37:03good luck
- 37:10[Music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Student leadership training3 fixed by Academic Development Open Virtual Hub (ADOVH), generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,091 words across 911 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.