Stop Using Active Recall in 2027, Do This Instead — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Active recall is not a learning
- 0:01technique. [music] And if you're using
- 0:03active recall and not getting great
- 0:05results, this is probably why. As a
- 0:07learning coach, when someone tells me
- 0:08that they're using [music] active
- 0:09recall, it means nothing to me. Because
- 0:11the term active recall is just a social
- 0:15media study guru term that means
- 0:17recalling something from memory. But
- 0:19there are several ways that you can
- 0:20recall something from memory, and the
- 0:22method that you use makes a huge
- 0:24difference. If we were to map the term
- 0:26active recall to real learning science,
- 0:29the term active recall could refer to
- 0:31two different categories of techniques,
- 0:34with each category containing [music]
- 0:37several other actual techniques. And
- 0:40each of these techniques is suited for a
- 0:42different kind of learning and memory
- 0:45goal. So, if your goal is over here, but
- 0:48you're using a technique over here,
- 0:50[music]
- 0:51you will need to spend a lot more time
- 0:53than if you were to use a more
- 0:54compatible technique over [music] here.
- 0:57But all of these techniques are
- 0:59technically active recall. So, in this
- 1:01video, I'll teach you how to pick the
- 1:03right [music]
- 1:04active recall technique that actually
- 1:06saves you time and builds high-quality
- 1:08memory. Now, the first question you
- 1:09might ask is, "What is the best active
- 1:12recall technique?" That would be the
- 1:13wrong question to ask, because there is
- 1:16no best technique. It all depends on
- 1:18your goal. And one easy way that we can
- 1:20divide up our goals is as a higher-order
- 1:24versus a lower-order goal. A lower-order
- 1:27goal involves knowledge that is very
- 1:30isolated. It involves recalling specific
- 1:33facts and figures, or explaining how a
- 1:36single concept works, or being able to
- 1:38describe a specific process. And you had
- 1:41a lot of these lower-order goals earlier
- 1:43in school. A lot of memory competitions,
- 1:47where you get these like memory
- 1:48champions, they're almost exclusively
- 1:50lower-order recall. Like, on this page
- 1:53of this book, what is the third
- 1:54paragraph? But for most people,
- 1:56lower-order goals is not really where
- 1:57the value is. Especially if you're a
- 1:59working professional, most of your
- 2:00learning goals are going to be
- 2:02higher-order. So, a higher-order goal is
- 2:05the opposite. Instead of being isolated,
- 2:08the information is very integrated. You
- 2:10have to understand how concepts connect
- 2:13with each other. You have to understand
- 2:15the relationship or the influence that
- 2:18individual facts and concepts have with
- 2:21other facts and concepts. And so, for
- 2:23most people, most of the things that you
- 2:25really struggle with, the things that
- 2:27you think really create a top performer,
- 2:29these are all higher-order goals. Being
- 2:31able to create a really clear narrative
- 2:35on a complex topic, being able to
- 2:37solve a complicated problem, being able
- 2:39to answer tricky questions about a
- 2:42topic, these are all higher-order
- 2:45outcomes. And so, there are different
- 2:46active recall techniques that are more
- 2:48suited for either lower-order or
- 2:50higher-order outcomes. And let's stop
- 2:52calling it active recall. The definition
- 2:55of active recall generally just means
- 2:57when you pull something from your
- 2:58memory. In the research, we call this
- 3:00retrieval. And practicing your
- 3:02retrieval, which improves your memory
- 3:04depth and your fluency and your
- 3:05performance, is called retrieval
- 3:08practice. And doing some kind of
- 3:11retrieval practice is almost always
- 3:13better than not doing it at all. It's
- 3:16also better than doing something that's
- 3:18called recognition practice. So,
- 3:20retrieval practice could be me learning
- 3:23something and then writing an essay
- 3:25about it or answering a question from
- 3:28memory. Recognition practice would be
- 3:31reading the answers to a question or
- 3:35reading someone's essay and asking
- 3:37myself, "Does this make sense to me? Do
- 3:40I feel like I've understood this?"
- 3:42Recognition practice is significantly
- 3:45easier and significantly faster than
- 3:48retrieval practice or active recall.
- 3:51Unfortunately, it's also borderline
- 3:54useless. It creates what's known in the
- 3:56research as the illusion of fluency,
- 3:59which is that you feel like you
- 4:01understand and you feel like you're
- 4:03learning, but actually that does not
- 4:05mean that you could generate those same
- 4:08answers or that same essay yourself
- 4:11without having any prompts. And so
- 4:12compared to doing nothing at all or
- 4:15doing recognition practice, doing any
- 4:18kind of retrieval practice, aka active
- 4:21recall, is going to be better. But let's
- 4:22now get into the different types of
- 4:25retrieval practice because again, there
- 4:27is a huge difference in effectiveness.
- 4:29Now FYI, I'm only going to be able to go
- 4:30into a few examples. This is not an
- 4:33exhaustive list of all the different
- 4:35types of retrieval practice that you can
- 4:36do. If you are looking for a more
- 4:39complete list where you can learn a
- 4:40little bit more about the nuances of
- 4:42retrieval practice, how to schedule your
- 4:44retrieval practice, how that fits into
- 4:46all the other learning methods that you
- 4:47might be using, what to do when your
- 4:49learning goals start changing. These are
- 4:51all important nuances, but I'm not going
- 4:53to be able to cover them in this video.
- 4:55You can either check out some of my
- 4:56other videos on this or you can learn
- 4:58more in my free weekly newsletter. For
- 5:01me, the newsletters are a place where I
- 5:04get to teach on more nuanced practical
- 5:07points based on either things that I've
- 5:09taught in the video or things that don't
- 5:11make it into the video. They take just a
- 5:13few minutes to read and there's a
- 5:15practical takeaway for you to work on
- 5:17during that week. At this point, there
- 5:18are over 500 thousand people receiving
- 5:20the newsletters, which is awesome. And
- 5:22based on the comments and the feedback
- 5:24that I get, people will seem to really
- 5:25love them. So if you're interested, I'll
- 5:27leave a link in the description below
- 5:28for you to sign up. And of course, you
- 5:29can unsubscribe at any time if you want.
- 5:31But moving on to the two categories. The
- 5:34first type of retrieval I broadly
- 5:36classify as reproductive retrieval.
- 5:39Reproductive retrieval is when you are
- 5:41simply trying to reproduce the
- 5:43knowledge. You learn that the definition
- 5:45of mitochondria is that it is the
- 5:47powerhouse of the cell. And then you get
- 5:50asked, what is the definition of
- 5:51mitochondria? The mitochondria is the
- 5:53powerhouse of the cell. That's
- 5:55reproductive. You're just taking the
- 5:56knowledge as is and almost one-to-one
- 6:00simply reproducing it. And there are
- 6:01lots of ways that we can do this
- 6:02reproductive recall. Uh one of the most
- 6:04common ways of doing this is using
- 6:06flashcards. Another example would be a
- 6:09fill-in-the-blanks, doing simple
- 6:12quizzes, and even solving simple
- 6:15problems where the solution to the
- 6:17problem is applying just usually one or
- 6:20at most two concepts. Sometimes we call
- 6:23uh this type of retrieval cued recall as
- 6:26well because there is a cue, like a
- 6:28question or a flashcard or a blank to
- 6:31fill in, that we are responding to. And
- 6:33cued recall is uh often much easier than
- 6:37the alternative, which is called free
- 6:38recall, where there is no cue at all and
- 6:41we sort of have to just summon that
- 6:43knowledge from a blank slate. Now, this
- 6:45is not to say that cued recall or that
- 6:48reproductive retrieval is
- 6:51useless. This is a type of retrieval
- 6:53that is very well suited if you have
- 6:56lower-order
- 6:58learning goals. But these methods often
- 7:00are quite repetitive and tedious.
- 7:03Because they are lower-order in nature,
- 7:05it also means that your brain is not as
- 7:08active. And so we find these techniques
- 7:10to often be a little bit more boring and
- 7:12monotonous. But like I said, uh most
- 7:15people don't actually have lower-order
- 7:17learning goals and lower-order learning
- 7:19problems. Most people, especially as you
- 7:22get older in life and in the
- 7:23professional workforce, have
- 7:25higher-order learning goals. And so here
- 7:27we need the second category of active
- 7:29recall, which I call reconstructive
- 7:33retrieval. Actually, let me just write
- 7:34that out again because a lot of you guys
- 7:35complain about my handwriting. Uh so
- 7:37reconstructive retrieval is more
- 7:40effortful, often more engaged than
- 7:43reproductive, and it involves
- 7:44manipulating groups of concepts
- 7:47together. And so, some examples of this
- 7:50uh
- 7:50brain dumps, which is probably the most
- 7:53uh simple and uh
- 7:56partially effective form of
- 7:58reconstructive retrieval. A brain dump
- 8:00is basically when you just take
- 8:01everything that you've learned and you
- 8:03just dump it as much of it as you can
- 8:05and as much detail as you can uh in a
- 8:07single go. This is like a very raw,
- 8:10unfiltered type of free recall. The
- 8:13reason that is varied in effectiveness
- 8:15is that if you haven't learned anything
- 8:17very deeply, then you just don't really
- 8:20find where the gaps are. So, you're able
- 8:22to recall what you remember, but the way
- 8:24that you actually communicate it may not
- 8:26be very accurate, it may not be very
- 8:27nuanced, and there's no feedback from
- 8:30doing this that tells you that the way
- 8:32that you're thinking about things is not
- 8:33very nuanced. Now, to combat that, uh
- 8:36one strategy that I recommend these days
- 8:38is doing a brain dump with an LLM
- 8:42challenge. So, you're actually going to
- 8:43brain dump it into an LLM, and then
- 8:46you're going to get the LLM to challenge
- 8:47you to find areas where you're missing
- 8:50nuance or there's uh errors or or
- 8:52incorrect perspectives that you've typed
- 8:54out. And this helps brain dumps become
- 8:56much more effective. So, I'll add plus
- 8:59LLM challenge. Another example of this
- 9:01is unprompted teaching. This is very
- 9:04similar to a brain dump, but it involves
- 9:06a little bit more uh organization and
- 9:08higher-level thinking because you have
- 9:11to make decisions about how you're going
- 9:12to teach this. What is the best way?
- 9:14What is the best order? What is the best
- 9:16structure? That involves a lot of
- 9:18evaluation and judgment, which isn't
- 9:20always necessary when you're doing a
- 9:21simple brain dump. And the reason that
- 9:23we do this unprompted, without a cue, is
- 9:26because it's easier to find gaps in our
- 9:28knowledge if it's unprompted. Whereas,
- 9:29if you're prompted with something like a
- 9:31question, "Hey, can you teach me about
- 9:32this particular concept and how it
- 9:34relates to this this concept?" Then
- 9:35you're not going to miss anything
- 9:37because all the cues are in the question
- 9:39or the prompt that you're getting. So,
- 9:40by leaving it unprompted and giving
- 9:42ourselves less scaffolding, it increases
- 9:45the risk of errors in the way that we
- 9:48retrieve it, which is more valuable
- 9:50feedback for us to learn from. Another
- 9:52example that's very similar is just
- 9:53spontaneous self-explanation.
- 9:56This is when you take a group of
- 9:58concepts or a topic and you just try to
- 10:01almost teach it to yourself and explain
- 10:03it to yourself in a way that feels more
- 10:04intuitive, is a little bit simpler,
- 10:06makes more sense. This involves things
- 10:08like creating analogies and finding
- 10:10metaphors, thinking about how you can
- 10:11apply this knowledge in real contexts.
- 10:13And again, we want to do this without
- 10:15much scaffolding or prompting because we
- 10:17want to feel where it's more difficult
- 10:19to explain it. When we really struggle
- 10:21to explain a certain thing, that's a
- 10:23compass pointing to a weak point in your
- 10:25knowledge. Another example of
- 10:28reconstructive retrieval is case
- 10:30applications or simulations, and you
- 10:33need to draw on your knowledge diversely
- 10:35to work through this case. Or, the last
- 10:37example of reconstructive retrieval,
- 10:39which is complex problem solving. So,
- 10:41this is different to the
- 10:43simple problem solving that was up here
- 10:45in the reproductive retrieval part
- 10:47because instead of just needing to draw
- 10:50on one or two concepts, complex problem
- 10:53solving requires you draw on multiple
- 10:54concepts simultaneously. And so, these
- 10:57would be examples of technically cued
- 11:00recall, but still at a more
- 11:02reconstructive level and still very
- 11:04valuable, especially if you know that
- 11:06when you are performing with your
- 11:07knowledge, you are actually going to
- 11:09need to respond to certain cues. So, for
- 11:11example, if you know that you're going
- 11:14to have an oral examination where
- 11:15someone is questioning you, then you may
- 11:17want to practice responding to those
- 11:20cues. Whereas, if you know that it's
- 11:22going to be more of a free recall style
- 11:25of performance that you need, then you
- 11:27may want to do more of these, which are
- 11:29free recall. And often, it's useful to
- 11:31have a combination of both. Uh but these
- 11:34techniques are ones that help you with
- 11:37achieving higher order goals. Now,
- 11:39what's really interesting about this,
- 11:41though, is that using reconstructive
- 11:43retrieval has a moderate level of
- 11:46crossover to lower order outcomes. Which
- 11:50means if you get really good at this
- 11:52stuff, it also automatically helps you
- 11:56with some of the lower order outcomes.
- 11:58Because after all, you cannot really uh
- 12:00solve a complicated problem with
- 12:02multiple concepts if you're not able to
- 12:04just
- 12:05describe or explain what that concept
- 12:07is. But you get very poor transfer the
- 12:09other way. So, reproductive retrieval
- 12:12does not translate very well to higher
- 12:15order outcomes. Sometimes not at all.
- 12:18So, you can be very, very good at your
- 12:20isolated uh reproductive cued recall,
- 12:23but when it comes to uh doing unprompted
- 12:26teaching or writing in a big narrative
- 12:28or an essay or complex problem-solving
- 12:30or applying it in in complex cases, you
- 12:33may really, really struggle. And so,
- 12:34while there is no best technique and it
- 12:37really depends on, you know, what your
- 12:39goal is, my rule of thumb is figure out
- 12:42your higher order goals first, build a
- 12:44reconstructive retrieval system using
- 12:47these techniques as your base, and then
- 12:49see where the gaps are that you need to
- 12:52fill at the lower order, and then add
- 12:54whatever techniques you need from this
- 12:56list into that. Don't do it the other
- 12:59way around where you start with
- 13:00reproductive retrieval and then try to
- 13:02add reconstructive on top of it because
- 13:05reconstructive retrieval is more
- 13:07energy-consuming, it's more difficult,
- 13:09it can be more time-consuming, and you
- 13:10run the risk of spending all of your
- 13:12time just doing the lower order stuff
- 13:14and not having enough time for the
- 13:16reconstructive retrieval. When actually,
- 13:19if you spent that time on the
- 13:20reconstructive retrieval, you would
- 13:21maybe cover 50% of what you need on the
- 13:23lower order anyway. So, stop calling it
- 13:26active recall, start talking about the
- 13:27actual techniques that you're using, and
- 13:29be strategic about the technique that
- 13:31you use, not just the one that's the
- 13:32most common or the one that feels the
- 13:34easiest. Now, all of this stuff about
- 13:35retrieval practice is one part of a
- 13:38larger learning system. So, if you're
- 13:40wondering how this fits with everything
- 13:42else you need to do in your learning,
- 13:44then I would recommend checking out this
- 13:46video here where I break down the way
- 13:47that I, as a learning coach, think about
- 13:49building learning systems. But,
- 13:51otherwise, thanks so much for watching,
- 13:53and I'll see you in the next video.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Stop Using Active Recall in 2027, Do This Instead by Justin Sung, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,473 words across 383 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.