Solution & Delivery AG 20. From Adaptation Plans to Investment in Action — Transcript
Full transcript
- 1:08[music]
- 2:07[music]
- 2:14[music]
- 2:19[music]
- 2:37>> This
- 3:18>> [music]
- 3:57[music]
- 4:03[music]
- 4:40>> This
- 5:01>> [music]
- 5:07[music]
- 5:39[music]
- 6:31[music]
- 7:28[music]
- 7:35[music]
- 7:58[music]
- 8:04[music]
- 8:30>> Great. Good morning, everyone.
- 8:33Good morning. We're going to get
- 8:35We're going to get started.
- 8:37Really a privilege to welcome you to
- 8:40today's session.
- 8:41My name is Manish Bapna. I head up the
- 8:43Natural Resources Defense Council, and
- 8:46we're delighted to invite you to
- 8:49today's session from adaptation planning
- 8:52to investment in action.
- 8:55And I want to I want to start by
- 8:56thanking all of you who have come here
- 8:58because we have taken
- 9:00two of the thorniest problems facing
- 9:03climate action and brought them
- 9:04together,
- 9:05right?
- 9:06We're talking about adaptation,
- 9:08resilience, something that we all know
- 9:11we need to do so much more.
- 9:13You look at the UN Overshoot Report, you
- 9:15look at where we are. We look at what
- 9:18the
- 9:19COP, what governments have done on
- 9:20adaptation. Clearly so much more to do.
- 9:23And we know how central finance and
- 9:26private finance is to that challenge.
- 9:30The needs for adaptation finance we know
- 9:33are going up, and yet the response is
- 9:36not commensurate with what is needed,
- 9:39either in quantity or quality.
- 9:42And
- 9:43yet we recognize that there is an
- 9:46opportunity here,
- 9:47an ability to reframe how we think about
- 9:50adaptation and resilience from risk
- 9:54to one of opportunity.
- 9:55We recognize that the economics of
- 9:58making investments in resilience are
- 10:00incredibly strong.
- 10:02But translating economic benefits
- 10:05into bankable projects that unlock
- 10:07finance
- 10:09is the hard work that we need to do.
- 10:12And so we're delighted that during COP
- 10:1430 as part of the action agenda, the
- 10:18the fostering
- 10:20investable national implementation
- 10:23initiative was launched.
- 10:26And this is a initiative that recognizes
- 10:29that no organization, no sector on their
- 10:32own can solve this thorny problem, this
- 10:35thorny problem of adaptation
- 10:37and how we mobilize private finance for
- 10:39adaptation. It is something that the
- 10:41Atlantic Council and
- 10:43and the Natural Resources Defense
- 10:44Council with so many of the people in
- 10:46this room have helped put together.
- 10:49Fin D tries to do three things.
- 10:53It tries to actually catalyze knowledge.
- 10:57How do we take the work that has been
- 10:59done in the national adaptation plans
- 11:02and actually translate those
- 11:06into bankable projects? How do we make
- 11:07sure
- 11:09they lead to private finance being
- 11:12mobilized for these absolutely essential
- 11:16investments?
- 11:17The second thing beyond the knowledge
- 11:19products, how do we catalyze deals?
- 11:22How do we begin to build real deal flow
- 11:26for adaptation finance?
- 11:30And what are the types of conditions
- 11:31that are needed in country?
- 11:34What kind of coalitions need to be put
- 11:36together to help build that deal flow?
- 11:40And then we talk about how we catalyze
- 11:43leadership.
- 11:44How do we bring the private sector
- 11:47to help advocate
- 11:50for greater large-scale capital flows
- 11:54into resilience projects?
- 11:57Knowledge, deals, and leadership.
- 12:00That is the hard work that we all have
- 12:03over the coming couple of years, and
- 12:05today's panel is going to help
- 12:08illustrate some of what is already
- 12:10happening in this space. The first part
- 12:13of the session will focus on solutions.
- 12:17What is actually happening, and the
- 12:18second part will actually provide some
- 12:21reactions to those proof points that we
- 12:24are hearing taking place all around the
- 12:27world.
- 12:28Um again, a lot of gratitude. This This
- 12:31might be
- 12:32the the the most important session at
- 12:34the COP today
- 12:37because it is actually trying to tackle
- 12:41a problem that we all recognize is
- 12:43central
- 12:44to making sure that the most vulnerable
- 12:46communities and countries
- 12:48get the support they needed
- 12:50to withstand increasing climate impacts.
- 12:54Um it's my pleasure now to invite Lara
- 12:57Mongrutti,
- 12:59who is a strategic advisor to the
- 13:00high-level climate champion of Turkey,
- 13:03the CEO of Waste Transformers, and a
- 13:05leader in the private sector. Lara,
- 13:07please join us. Thank you.
- 13:15>> So hi all. I'm absolutely delighted to
- 13:19be here today and to have the
- 13:20opportunity to speak on behalf of our
- 13:23climate high-level champion Samira
- 13:26Samedova Hajiyeva, who unfortunately
- 13:28can't be here today.
- 13:30And
- 13:31listening to the various conversations
- 13:33over the last couple of days, a number
- 13:34of things really stand out for me. And
- 13:37I've really been touched by this new
- 13:39battle cry that I've heard. And the
- 13:41battle cry goes implementalia.
- 13:45And I thought that was actually a pretty
- 13:46nice one. That was a pretty smart one
- 13:48because what it does essentially is it
- 13:50brings together two really vital
- 13:52components, right? On the one hand, it
- 13:54really highlights the need for
- 13:56implementation to go beyond the
- 13:57commitments and the pledges. And on the
- 14:00other hand, it highlights this enormous
- 14:02opportunity we have over the coming days
- 14:05to really bring together this collective
- 14:07vision, the collective power, and the
- 14:09collective execution muscle that we have
- 14:12together to really start making things
- 14:15happen and to start moving things
- 14:17forward. And we know that this is really
- 14:19vital to do because at every single
- 14:21session, what is highlighted and what
- 14:23comes up again and again and again are
- 14:26really the enormous amount of obstacles
- 14:28that we are facing when it comes to
- 14:30implementation. And these obstacles are
- 14:33really quite diverse, right? If you look
- 14:35at an the startup scene and the SMEs and
- 14:39how do we ensure that we go from beyond
- 14:41the demos and beyond the pilot stages
- 14:43and beyond the feasibility studies to
- 14:46really ensuring that there's a framework
- 14:47in place that can make sure that all of
- 14:50this great innovation is really
- 14:52replicable and has access to the kind of
- 14:54finance that it really needs.
- 14:56And on the other hand, when it comes to
- 14:58these large-scale infrastructural
- 15:00projects, how can we ensure that the
- 15:03that the regulatory frameworks are in
- 15:04place and that they really are providing
- 15:06the consistency that so many project
- 15:08developers crave in order to ensure that
- 15:12they're not just staying on
- 15:14under the drawer in a pile of paper for
- 15:16years and years and years, but they
- 15:18really are being implemented and they
- 15:20really are coming into action. And
- 15:22specifically, when it comes to finance,
- 15:25now when it comes to finance, I'm always
- 15:27reminded of something which is
- 15:29a West African proverb.
- 15:32And and the West African proverb goes,
- 15:35if you have extra rice, the best place
- 15:37to store it is in the belly of another.
- 15:40And I think when it comes to finance,
- 15:42what we really have to start figuring
- 15:44out how to do is how to take all these
- 15:46enormous resources that we have and to
- 15:49start storing them into really strategic
- 15:51and effective places so we can really
- 15:53bend the curve, that we can make the
- 15:55transition, and we can really move
- 15:57towards implementaria. And from that
- 15:59perspective, I wish you a fantastic
- 16:02session. I wish you lots of inspiration
- 16:04and I really look forward to hearing all
- 16:06of the input that's coming out of today.
- 16:08Thank you very much.
- 16:21>> Okay. So thanks for being here. I'm
- 16:24excited. I need to
- 16:26agree with Manisha. This is the most
- 16:28relevant event in the whole day. I would
- 16:30argue on the whole two weeks, but uh
- 16:32that gave it too much.
- 16:34And uh we are going to now have
- 16:37five experts from across the private
- 16:40private ecosystem that will
- 16:42give us a bit of insights on you know
- 16:44how we make
- 16:45this conversation happen in the real
- 16:47economy.
- 16:48And I'm going to introduce them and I
- 16:50ask them if they can join and with that
- 16:52we'll start the panel and
- 16:54I will hopefully and the idea is that we
- 16:56have enough time for people from the
- 16:58audience to actually engage and ask
- 17:00questions. So
- 17:02let me start with um
- 17:06here.
- 17:07So we're starting with Lisi Gerlin who
- 17:10is a Standard Chartered Head of Social
- 17:13Sustainability, Sustainable Finance
- 17:14Products and Frameworks. Please
- 17:16as you hear your name, please feel free
- 17:18to to join.
- 17:20Rachel De Hayes from Convex who is the
- 17:22Chief Sustainability Officer. Rachel,
- 17:24thanks for being with us.
- 17:26We'll have Farhana Altaf from CDP
- 17:29Resilience and Adaptation Lead.
- 17:34Claire Shakya
- 17:36good to see you, Claire, TNC, Director
- 17:37Conservancy Global Managing Director
- 17:39Climate.
- 17:40And finally we have Will Farrow,
- 17:42Federated Hermes Climate Lead.
- 17:47Thank you.
- 17:51Can you hear me here? Excellent. Okay.
- 17:53So
- 17:54since I started working on on on climate
- 17:57finance, I won't say the amount of years
- 18:02I've been hearing that adaptation and
- 18:04resilience
- 18:05is something that only belongs to the
- 18:08public sector.
- 18:09And that it's only through public sector
- 18:12investments that climate that climate
- 18:14adaptation and resilience will be dealt
- 18:15with.
- 18:16I agree with that actually.
- 18:18So I would like you to prove me wrong.
- 18:22So, for him,
- 18:23tell us how they would prove me wrong on
- 18:25that front and indicating, you know,
- 18:27what our actors actually
- 18:29may
- 18:31intervene, participate
- 18:33in that ecosystem.
- 18:38>> Is this Yes, it's on. Hello.
- 18:41Well, that's quite the way to start the
- 18:43panel. [laughter]
- 18:46>> And for you to be the first one, so
- 18:47yeah.
- 18:49>> How can data prove you wrong that
- 18:52adaptation and resilience is only for
- 18:54the public sector? That's your question.
- 18:57Well,
- 18:58I can speak to some of the things that
- 19:00we've looked at recently in some
- 19:01analysis. So, for context, CDP is a
- 19:04global disclosure platform that
- 19:08gets disclosure from cities, states, and
- 19:10regions, corporations, financial
- 19:12institutions, including insurance. And
- 19:15we've always been quite interested in
- 19:17kind of looking at how these different
- 19:19sectors of the society, economy would be
- 19:22looking at the same issues. And
- 19:24recently, we wanted to do that for
- 19:25extreme weather events. So, we analyzed
- 19:29the risk perception of extreme weather
- 19:32from subnational governments, from
- 19:33corporates, and from insurance.
- 19:37And we found an interesting disconnect.
- 19:40And this speaks to your point in a way
- 19:42that, first of all, increasingly the
- 19:44private sector is recognizing physical
- 19:46risk that needs to be adapted to as a
- 19:48financially material issue.
- 19:50That does not mean that they're going to
- 19:52respond to it in the same way that would
- 19:54serve the public sector needs, but it's
- 19:57a first step. And that I think is what
- 20:00brings this issue into the world of the
- 20:03private sector. So, you know, as an
- 20:06example, we had 35% of the disclosing
- 20:09companies who identified extreme weather
- 20:11event as a financially material risk to
- 20:13them.
- 20:15We have 149
- 20:17insurance companies disclosing to us who
- 20:20collectively identified about um 30
- 20:23billion US dollars uh in risk associated
- 20:27with rising insurance premiums. So
- 20:31essentially what I'm saying is
- 20:34physical risks associated with climate
- 20:36change is something that is increasingly
- 20:37financial material for the financially
- 20:39material for the private sector. And I
- 20:41think that is
- 20:43yeah. [laughter] I hope that proves you
- 20:45wrong
- 20:45>> Okay. So uh I'm starting to get what
- 20:47what you're saying. Basically uh
- 20:50you know if the private sector does not
- 20:53uh
- 20:54pay attention to potential physical
- 20:56risks from climate change they might
- 20:59have some financial problems down the
- 21:01road. And it's in their own interest
- 21:03to look into that and figure out the
- 21:05best ways in which they can invest on
- 21:06that.
- 21:07>> Actually not even down the road. I mean
- 21:09I don't have the exact figure off the
- 21:11top of my head right now but around 40%
- 21:13of these identified risks were
- 21:14materializing in the short term. So it's
- 21:17a a risk that they're facing now that
- 21:19they if they don't adapt to is
- 21:21>> Okay. I think I'm starting to get it. Uh
- 21:24thank you.
- 21:25Rachel uh
- 21:27insurance is it just only at a sovereign
- 21:30level? Uh
- 21:31should we look into other
- 21:33you know uh avenues and also who pays
- 21:36for it?
- 21:37In this and you need to convince me by
- 21:39the way that you know private sector
- 21:41actually goes into it.
- 21:43>> Um
- 21:44well uh yes so insurance is is and
- 21:46there's lots of very good stats about
- 21:48how insurance um it helps economic
- 21:51growth projects and
- 21:52stability of of an economy. But the um
- 21:55the you know risk uh relies on data and
- 22:00and we use a lot of modeling in the
- 22:01insurance world. And one of the reasons
- 22:02where you know the basically there's
- 22:04something like 60% of the world is of
- 22:07the of the western world's insured but
- 22:0940% not.
- 22:10The uh that that stat in this of EMG is
- 22:14more like 90 10. So there's a long way
- 22:16to go and one of the organizations I'm
- 22:18chief sustainability officer of a
- 22:20company called Convex Insurance and
- 22:22we're part of the Insurance Development
- 22:23Forum. And the Insurance Development
- 22:25Forum which an institution that's got
- 22:27about 60 insurers and associated
- 22:29companies and behind it, and worse of
- 22:32the World Bank is a tripartite with the
- 22:33World Bank and the UNDP about expanding
- 22:36the footprint of insurance in the rest
- 22:37of the world. And one of the things so I
- 22:40co-chair chair the Risk Modeling
- 22:42Steering Group, and risk modeling relies
- 22:44a lot on data. And there's sort of two
- 22:47ways in which this risk modeling
- 22:48steering group really tries to to to
- 22:51work on that so that we can expand this
- 22:52footprint of insurance that's so needed.
- 22:55So one is which is developing the tools
- 22:57and one is developing the capacity in
- 22:59the country itself. Because when we talk
- 23:01about data, there is a lot of data out
- 23:03there. Tons of dot data everywhere in
- 23:05there's data that can be harnessed in
- 23:06these countries to do to to to expand
- 23:10the resilience measures, right? So we
- 23:12will go so we have gone in for example
- 23:14over the last two years working with
- 23:16Costa Rica, a number of other countries,
- 23:18but Costa Rica is an example where did
- 23:20working with the ministries, working
- 23:21with the local insurance functions
- 23:23there, working with with universities
- 23:25who often and meteorological
- 23:28organizations that have the data. So
- 23:30it's about developing the data and then
- 23:32this sort of hazard risk modeling. So
- 23:34hazard risk modeling sounds super
- 23:35complex. It is super complex, but it's
- 23:38done in in in extensively in for the US,
- 23:41for Europe, for Australia, for Canada,
- 23:43and to a certain extent for Latin
- 23:45America, other parts of Asia and Africa,
- 23:47but it's not as well you know it's not
- 23:50as well developed as it could be. And
- 23:52just to give you a comparison, you know
- 23:54in the 80s prior to the sort of 1980s
- 23:56there was very little of this risk
- 23:57modeling. It then after a few companies
- 23:59went bust in the insurance world, it
- 24:01then sort of advanced through the 90s.
- 24:03And that that figure was about that my
- 24:05figure of 60 40 was more like 90 10. So
- 24:08only about 10% of the world was insured
- 24:10of the rest of the world back in the
- 24:1180s. But with this advance of
- 24:13aggregation of of looking at aggregation
- 24:15of risk, of understanding it. So it's
- 24:16not you know there's one thing about
- 24:18transferring to the insurance world, but
- 24:20actually before that just understanding
- 24:22that risk, that really has made a
- 24:23difference. So that so So we talk about
- 24:27the protection gap actually which is the
- 24:29difference between economic loss and
- 24:30insured loss, yes, that protection gap
- 24:32in some because of some perils and the
- 24:34climate crisis obviously exacerbating
- 24:36it, but it has progressed a lot because
- 24:39we've harnessed the data. So we've just
- 24:41got to do that more expansively. And if
- 24:44I can give you one um one example of a
- 24:46sovereign uh deal where you can really
- 24:49see the difference it makes. So Jamaica
- 24:51has uh bought insurance through the
- 24:53Caribbean pool for a number of years and
- 24:55has also bought a what's called a
- 24:56catastrophe bond. And a catastrophe bond
- 24:59is something that's triggered by what
- 25:00they call a parametric trigger. So in
- 25:02this instance it was because of the the
- 25:04the the wind strength. So if a hurricane
- 25:07came in at a certain strength, then this
- 25:09thing paid out. And when Hurricane
- 25:11Melissa happened last October, this uh
- 25:14this this catastrophe bond paid out 170
- 25:17million within two weeks.
- 25:19And and because of that, these insurance
- 25:22rangers and a a disaster linked credit
- 25:24facility that Jamaica had with the World
- 25:26Bank, they got a Moody's
- 25:28rating sovereign upgrade two months
- 25:30later. So not even in another world that
- 25:33would have been a downgrade, they got a
- 25:34sovereign rating upgrade. So you can see
- 25:36the economic benefit there because these
- 25:38they had these pre-disaster finance
- 25:41arrangements in place. So all the good
- 25:43reason as to why you want to harness
- 25:46this data and modeling and do it to
- 25:48drive pre-disaster finance uh your
- 25:51protection and resilience measures in
- 25:52place.
- 25:54>> So let me get this right. You say you
- 25:56are saying that the insurance sector is
- 25:57willing to engage in this conversation
- 25:59as private sector and help other actors
- 26:02including the public sector
- 26:04deal with these risks in a more
- 26:06efficient, more consistent, more
- 26:08sustainable way.
- 26:09>> And I would say not just willing to
- 26:10actively doing so,
- 26:12hence why I'm here, hence why we have
- 26:14the insurance development for him and
- 26:16and we have we even have an insurance
- 26:18house going on
- 26:19uh COP this year. So actively engaging,
- 26:22but we do need people to engage more
- 26:24with us. The the the the often when
- 26:26people talk about finance, they come to
- 26:28the investment, they come to the banks.
- 26:29They don't tend to come to the insurance
- 26:31first of all. So, please engage earlier
- 26:33with us.
- 26:34>> So you heard there's an invitation to
- 26:35the
- 26:36audience here for engaging more. Uh,
- 26:39happy to facilitate that. Thanks for
- 26:40being here, Rachel, today. Uh, Lizzie,
- 26:44I'm starting to get convinced, but not
- 26:46fully yet.
- 26:49>> Uh, well, I guess I'm here. So,
- 26:52hopefully that goes some way to
- 26:53convincing you to to your comments.
- 26:55Um, so at Standard Chartered Bank, we
- 26:58are predominantly uh have a footprint in
- 27:01Asia, Africa, and the Middle East. So
- 27:03for us, physical risk is a real credit
- 27:06issue for us. We can't ignore it. It is
- 27:10a um
- 27:11going to be a a real challenge in the
- 27:13long-term economic resilience of our
- 27:15business and of our of our um balance
- 27:19sheet. So um from that perspective,
- 27:22absolutely essential. Now, to your
- 27:24question around what is the role of uh
- 27:27the private sector in financing
- 27:28adaptation and resilience?
- 27:30Um, we published something called the
- 27:32Guide for Adaptation and Resilience
- 27:33Finance back in 2024, and this week we
- 27:36released an updated version of it. What
- 27:39this updated version does is we I think
- 27:41we've answered the question of what
- 27:43adaptation and resilience is from an
- 27:45investable activity perspective, and I
- 27:47can see Sean Kidney in the background
- 27:49here doing work on the climate bonds
- 27:50resilience taxonomy as well. So big
- 27:52shout out to to their contribution to
- 27:54this effort. But I think where we need
- 27:56to go now is asking the question of what
- 27:59adaptation and resilience activities can
- 28:02do in terms of augmenting the
- 28:05investability of those activities and
- 28:07where do they sit on the investability
- 28:09pyramid of um commercially financeable?
- 28:13Probably need some sort of blended
- 28:15finance solution, and then actually
- 28:16really they are a public good.
- 28:19And I think we need to think about it
- 28:20across that spectrum. And that bottom
- 28:22bracket, by the way, doesn't not involve
- 28:24the private sector. You look at
- 28:26sovereign bond issuances, they are
- 28:28financing some of this public
- 28:29infrastructure that's going to be needed
- 28:31for adaptive and resilient uh resilience
- 28:33capacity, but they are financed by the
- 28:35public debt capital markets and by um
- 28:38the World Bank and others that by the
- 28:40public debt capital markets as well.
- 28:42Um so I don't think that we can think
- 28:45about what the solution is even for
- 28:47public goods without resolving for what
- 28:49the private sector contribution to that
- 28:51is.
- 28:52>> Excellent. Um let me let me test these
- 28:56three first interventions with Will and
- 28:58Lisa, I want to get back go back to you
- 29:00on that.
- 29:01Will are you
- 29:04do you think this is enough for you as
- 29:05an investor to to put money into
- 29:07additional resilience? You've heard you
- 29:08know from data
- 29:11insurance and and banking investment
- 29:13banking.
- 29:15Is it enough?
- 29:16I I don't know. Try try try to make that
- 29:18case because I'm still struggling with
- 29:20it.
- 29:21>> Yeah it's an excellent question. Um I
- 29:23think certainly we are dependent on all
- 29:26of those um innovative solutions to be
- 29:29able to um allocate capital in this
- 29:31space.
- 29:34There's been plenty of reference to the
- 29:35fact that these these uh
- 29:38risks are most prevalent in emerging
- 29:40markets and of course for institutional
- 29:42investors that presents a whole raft of
- 29:44other um barriers to investment that
- 29:46we're actively working on overcoming.
- 29:49But I think this the power of the the
- 29:51collaboration is key
- 29:53because
- 29:54we're talking about physical risk as as
- 29:56one type of risk, but really um we can
- 30:00portion that and and allocate risk
- 30:01across different actors.
- 30:05I want to also step back a bit because
- 30:08we as an institutional investor we
- 30:10invest directly in infrastructure
- 30:12assets, in real estate assets. We ensure
- 30:15that those are hardened um to a range of
- 30:17different um physical risk scenarios and
- 30:20are dependent on insurance and banking
- 30:23uh to come with us on that journey.
- 30:26But we're also representing ultimately
- 30:28our clients who are long-term asset
- 30:31owners, often pension funds.
- 30:33And we take the view that we are the
- 30:35stewards of that capital um for 30, 40,
- 30:3950 years.
- 30:40And one of the biggest gaps that we see
- 30:43um that remains to be resolved and it is
- 30:45to the point about
- 30:47where something becomes a public good
- 30:48versus being entirely commercial is that
- 30:51systemic resilience.
- 30:53So for example if we have a a warehouse
- 30:55we can make sure that it's entirely
- 30:57storm and flood proof but if the
- 30:58surrounding roads
- 31:00uh are flooded for several weeks a year
- 31:02uh that's going to impair our asset.
- 31:05Uh and so how do we work with partners
- 31:08um
- 31:08in regions there might be a a
- 31:10place-based approach um but also how do
- 31:12we work across value chains?
- 31:15And some of the best examples we've seen
- 31:16from some of our portfolio companies in
- 31:18the food and beverage sector is how they
- 31:21are starting to go upstream into their
- 31:24agricultural value chains
- 31:26to uh shore up their resilience. So
- 31:29moving away from a narrative that
- 31:31diversification of supply chains is
- 31:33sufficient because you can't diversify
- 31:35away a systemic risk
- 31:37and instead working with
- 31:39uh local financing partners um but
- 31:42providing sometimes the portfolio
- 31:43companies um credit worthiness and and
- 31:46own balance sheet
- 31:48uh with
- 31:49smallholder farmers so that they can
- 31:50invest in regenerative agriculture and
- 31:52that has a much more systemic um
- 31:54positive adaptation response than simply
- 31:57only asset level measures.
- 32:00>> Thank you Will. Uh so what you're saying
- 32:02is that companies are not all or
- 32:04investors here are not only looking into
- 32:06broad you know in the particular risks
- 32:09at the at the asset level or at the
- 32:11project level but are looking at
- 32:13systemic risks.
- 32:14Um
- 32:15would you say and let me turn to Lisa
- 32:16and then back to you Will. Claire I
- 32:18promise I'll get to you. Um
- 32:20would you say that then companies are
- 32:21moving beyond just looking at risks but
- 32:25also looking at the opportunities that
- 32:26these systemic risks could provide to
- 32:28them in terms of you know engaging
- 32:29different in different ways with
- 32:31stakeholders looking for new
- 32:32technologies that might you know be
- 32:33helpful for the broader supply chain in
- 32:36this in the case that you were putting.
- 32:37Is it this that you're seeing that
- 32:39companies looking just beyond risk and
- 32:42looking into the opportunity as well of
- 32:43this changing climate?
- 32:48>> Yeah, I mean absolutely that's something
- 32:49that we're starting to see. We're a big
- 32:51trade finance bank and supply chain
- 32:52resilience is a huge topic that we see
- 32:54our clients wanting to engage on on a
- 32:56ongoing basis. That looks very different
- 32:58depending on the footprint of that
- 33:00supply chain and how that happens. But I
- 33:03think that what we're starting to see is
- 33:05um adaptation resilience not being
- 33:07considered climate issue but being
- 33:09considered to be a economic viability
- 33:12issue. And I think the clearest example
- 33:14that I can give around that is um
- 33:18we're starting to see in renewable
- 33:20energy projects for example those
- 33:22projects building in resilience features
- 33:25asset hardening to your points um into
- 33:28those to in order to make them bankable
- 33:30in the first place. So we have supported
- 33:32supply chains that for example ship
- 33:34storm resistance solar panels into the
- 33:37US which
- 33:39in order which then ensure the revenue
- 33:41stream on that solar project is
- 33:43resilient in the event of extreme
- 33:44weather events which we know are only
- 33:46going to increase over the coming years.
- 33:48Um and I think that they can't do that
- 33:50without the upstream engagement with
- 33:52their technology providers. Those solar
- 33:54panels are being shipped from China and
- 33:57they need to design something in China
- 34:00that is resilient to an issue that is
- 34:02happening in the US.
- 34:04>> Will any any any other examples that you
- 34:07know built on that you know the business
- 34:09opportunity is out of the equation?
- 34:12>> Yeah, absolutely. Well another um
- 34:15key challenge that we see is for example
- 34:18in the the mortgage books of our
- 34:20portfolio company banks.
- 34:22And there are particular countries in
- 34:24the world that are facing uh
- 34:27immediate heightened physical climate
- 34:28risks over the next few years. Um and
- 34:30that's translating into um
- 34:34those mortgage books no longer being
- 34:35fully covered by home insurance because
- 34:37of the the cost of home insurance in
- 34:39those areas. Um and banks face
- 34:42our portfolio banks really face a
- 34:44serious challenge there because they are
- 34:46operating in a highly competitive
- 34:48environment. Um, the their ability to
- 34:51invest in landscape systemic
- 34:54adaptation measures is limited because
- 34:57of that that competition and because
- 34:59they don't have a monopoly over the
- 35:00market. But we are starting to see
- 35:03collaborations emerge and I think this
- 35:05is where the opportunity for policy
- 35:07makers to step in not necessarily to
- 35:10provide capital or to provide public
- 35:12money, but actually to create the the
- 35:15structures that enable those banks to
- 35:18invest in systemic resilience together
- 35:20together. Um, for example, where
- 35:23mortgage books are concentrated in in
- 35:25particular flood
- 35:26flood prone areas.
- 35:29>> Thank you, Will. Uh,
- 35:31I'm certainly getting excited actually.
- 35:32You know, I I I didn't know there was a
- 35:34business opportunity here in addition to
- 35:36you know dealing with risk only. Claire,
- 35:38uh,
- 35:39you worked for The Nature Conservancy. A
- 35:42disclosure, I worked for The Nature
- 35:43Conservancy for 11 years sometime ago
- 35:45now.
- 35:46Um, and you you have you have innovated
- 35:49in the space of finance for nature and
- 35:52of course you know that overlaps
- 35:55squarely with with resilience
- 35:57adaptation.
- 35:58Can you Can you you know on that line on
- 36:01the same line of thought that I've been
- 36:02starting here, can you give a bit more
- 36:04of thought on you know whether there is
- 36:06a business opportunity for that, whether
- 36:07there is you know private sector finance
- 36:10going into that or is it just still a
- 36:12public and nature is a double whammy
- 36:14because you know nature is usually also
- 36:15seen as a public good only.
- 36:19>> Yeah, thanks. Um,
- 36:20so there are various there are there are
- 36:22sort of three main ways that we're
- 36:24looking at the opportunity to increase
- 36:26resilience. Um, and it's the the role of
- 36:29nature as infrastructure for adaptation
- 36:32is is central. We know that um when
- 36:35ecosystems are degraded, climate impacts
- 36:38just have a much bigger impact. So the
- 36:40first thing we've been doing and and
- 36:42partly what needs to happen to bring the
- 36:44private investment in is for the
- 36:45governments to organize the system of
- 36:47it. So the first thing we've been doing
- 36:49is developing a um a method um the
- 36:52coastal resilience method that got
- 36:54approved by Vera
- 36:56um and it quantifies the economic value
- 36:59that is protected by a natural asset
- 37:02like a mangrove or like a wetland for
- 37:04the flood reduction, storm damage
- 37:07reduction that it offers. Um and in the
- 37:11process of doing that we're we're um oh
- 37:14and the numbers of people that are
- 37:16protected as well. So it gives you an
- 37:18economic value and the numbers of
- 37:19people.
- 37:20Um in using that in in various places
- 37:23from Jamaica to Vanuatu to Charleston in
- 37:26the US
- 37:27we're able to help the government
- 37:29understand the value of that natural
- 37:31asset and then um create the incentives
- 37:34around that. So for example Vanuatu is
- 37:36looking at if a hotel is moving in and
- 37:39going to reduce the amount of mangrove
- 37:41cover
- 37:42what um is the um the what what should
- 37:45the hotel be expected to do in terms of
- 37:47restoration to make sure that the
- 37:50economy beyond the hotel is not also
- 37:53opened up to risk.
- 37:55Um in Charleston they're looking at for
- 37:57very poor households how um what the
- 38:00role of the local government is to
- 38:03protect those poorest households and
- 38:05what might be the role of some of the
- 38:06businesses in that area for restoring or
- 38:09supporting the restoration of protective
- 38:12assets in the in the um wetlands there.
- 38:15So in just by quantifying it you begin
- 38:17to enable the government to have a
- 38:19conversation with the private sector. So
- 38:21that's piece one. Second piece we look
- 38:23at um so with Belize for example we
- 38:26helped refinance their debt and um in in
- 38:31a an agreement where the government
- 38:33itself set out some commitments
- 38:34including protecting its coral reefs and
- 38:37restoring 30% of the mangrove.
- 38:40We're now able to show that their debt
- 38:43sustainability is greater because of the
- 38:46mangrove restoration. So, in the case of
- 38:48a category four hurricane, um, their GDP
- 38:52loss will be um reduced by 2%. Their
- 38:57ability to um the the cost of loans to
- 39:00the government will be improved by 10
- 39:03basis points. So, there's a number of
- 39:05different ways that we can show to the
- 39:06Ministry of Finance the value of that
- 39:09restoration and the value to the cost of
- 39:12debt to the country. So, it's sort of
- 39:13macroeconomic analytics. And then the
- 39:16third way is by setting up um insurance
- 39:20mechanisms around those natural assets.
- 39:22So, we've done that in
- 39:24coral reefs. We're exploring that
- 39:26currently with mangroves in in the
- 39:28number of countries.
- 39:30Um, and by protecting the assets, you're
- 39:33protecting the economy within the
- 39:35numbers of people within, but you're
- 39:36also able to provide protection to or
- 39:39some
- 39:39business interruption support to the um
- 39:43the households that are actually living
- 39:45in that ecosystem to create an incentive
- 39:47for them to also protect that and
- 39:49protect the um their livelihoods within
- 39:52that system.
- 39:53>> Oh, that's fascinating. I you know, I
- 39:55have to say that I you've done a great
- 39:58job of convincing me. I fully believe
- 40:00now that both private sector has an
- 40:02interest, a strong interest on their own
- 40:04physical risk, systemic risk, and how
- 40:06they can become a better neighbor, a
- 40:08better community member, uh, but also
- 40:10looking to the opportunities that they
- 40:12should uh, you know, be investing on in
- 40:15changing climate. So, uh,
- 40:17I may ask you know for a round of
- 40:18applause for this panel because it was
- 40:19brilliant. I really appreciate your
- 40:21time. Don't don't don't don't move.
- 40:23Don't move.
- 40:24We have about 20 more minutes and I
- 40:26would love to focus those 20 minutes in
- 40:28questions from the audience.
- 40:30Uh,
- 40:30before before opening up to the to the
- 40:33floor, I just wanted I didn't want to be
- 40:34remiss of of thanking both IIEC
- 40:38and the Inter Conservancy for your
- 40:40collaboration on organizing this event.
- 40:43And of course, you know, NRDC as Manish
- 40:45said before, you know, as a partnership
- 40:47in Finny, Yamit, my partner in crime is
- 40:50here sitting in the in the audience.
- 40:52Finni has been a labor of love. Uh, you
- 40:54know, I see so many faces. This feels
- 40:56like a reunion even though we haven't
- 40:58yet fully launched the
- 41:00the the effort, but it's been such a
- 41:01hard work over the past two years with
- 41:03so many contributors from all across
- 41:05this ecosystem including the COP 30
- 41:06presidency, Alisi and uh
- 41:09and so I just now wanted to open it to
- 41:11the floor. Uh uh
- 41:13Manish had said in the beginning uh in
- 41:15his opening remarks that you know Finni
- 41:17is looking to break that uh build a
- 41:19bridge between what the private sector
- 41:21is thinking of the role that they could
- 41:23bear in adaptation resilience and what
- 41:24the public sector actually needs to here
- 41:27and whether that bridge could be built
- 41:29and how we can also look into the public
- 41:32sector and help them enhance not only
- 41:34the understanding of the private sector,
- 41:36but also and the role that they could
- 41:37play
- 41:39but also what are the kind of things
- 41:40that the public sector could be doing.
- 41:42Will uh Claire you mentioned some of
- 41:44those that could create policy
- 41:46environments to
- 41:48create markets
- 41:50uh and to not only ensure people ensure
- 41:53and ensure that people have the right
- 41:55mechanisms to uh to adapt to climate
- 41:57change, but also uh
- 41:59uh
- 42:00and reacting to that and the physical
- 42:02risks, but also the opportunities and
- 42:03the technology, the new wave of
- 42:04technology that should be out there. So
- 42:06with that
- 42:08any
- 42:09please sir uh I don't know if there's a
- 42:11mic and if there are all work as a
- 42:15maybe Niti
- 42:20>> Sure.
- 42:21Thank you very much. Thank you for the
- 42:22panel. Uh my name is Stefan Niccolo. Uh
- 42:24I do a lot of work in and around methane
- 42:26mitigation. Um obviously methane has
- 42:29been a big conversation at this COP, but
- 42:31really this is only the fifth or sixth
- 42:32year where we're got starting to get
- 42:33into the uh what we call the nitty
- 42:35gritty, right? The how of how we do uh
- 42:38the asset transformation necessary to
- 42:40transform waste assets to plug the leaks
- 42:43in the oil and gas infrastructure and to
- 42:45make agricultural transformations that
- 42:47reduce methane emissions. I'm wondering
- 42:49uh for anyone on the panel perhaps uh
- 42:51Will and perhaps um one of you who has
- 42:53has a portfolio role, how are you
- 42:56thinking about the order of operations
- 42:58in terms of the asset transformation
- 43:00that needs to happen, the relationship
- 43:02between say capping a landfill or
- 43:06creating a sanitary conditions around
- 43:08landfill and the adaptation efforts of
- 43:12kind of working around
- 43:14the ecosystem
- 43:15that you had mentioned earlier kind of
- 43:17going up the supply chain and making
- 43:18sure that the the systems around the
- 43:21asset are also hardened. How are you
- 43:23thinking about methane as a priority and
- 43:25these assets as a priority to deploy
- 43:28capital? And then perhaps a small offer,
- 43:31there was a asset owners round table
- 43:34yesterday, a methane ministerial the day
- 43:36before. We're trying to do what we might
- 43:39call a crossover episode next week,
- 43:41right? What is that is to say to find
- 43:43those country ministers making methane
- 43:45mitigation
- 43:46commitments and the asset owners who
- 43:48don't necessarily have the order of
- 43:50assets that they would transform in
- 43:52place so that those two counterparties
- 43:54can speak and start to create the
- 43:56conditions for for shared success. So a
- 43:59question and an offer and and thank you
- 44:00for the information really appreciate
- 44:02it.
- 44:04>> I can start off.
- 44:07So firstly methane, massive priority
- 44:10not only because it's
- 44:12such a high impact greenhouse gas, but
- 44:15also because there is the immediate
- 44:17commercial risk
- 44:18that plenty of companies face and that
- 44:20we as investors want to see managed well
- 44:23both from the policy environment, but
- 44:25also more broadly. So often
- 44:28fixing methane leaks is also a precursor
- 44:30to improving safety practices,
- 44:33improving governance, etc.
- 44:35I think the connection to adaptation
- 44:38is an is a really interesting one. I'd
- 44:39be keen to take up your offer.
- 44:43I I think it represents one of the the
- 44:46challenges that we as an investor
- 44:48face and that we seek to voice to to
- 44:51policy makers as they look at how to
- 44:53different opportunities such as methane
- 44:56mitigation.
- 44:57It is how do you ensure that this work
- 44:59doesn't happen in in silos. So for
- 45:01example, many of the nature-based
- 45:03solutions also have methane and emission
- 45:06other emissions benefits
- 45:07um as well as their immediate nature and
- 45:09adaptation benefits. And if you can
- 45:12quantify those together, consider them
- 45:14together, and also derive different um
- 45:18financial returns from those different
- 45:20components,
- 45:21that can add up to something that would
- 45:23not be commercial or add up adds up to
- 45:25something commercial that would
- 45:26otherwise not be commercial looking at
- 45:28only one of those
- 45:29um those elements.
- 45:33>> Yeah, and I think just very quick answer
- 45:34from my side is that I don't see them as
- 45:36separate issues. I think uh addressing
- 45:39the methane abatement issue is going to
- 45:40involve new infrastructure. That new
- 45:42infrastructure needs to be resilient to
- 45:44the the respective um like climatic
- 45:47risks or physical risks that might occur
- 45:49in the in the location in which it's
- 45:51being installed. So I don't see them as
- 45:52separate.
- 45:55>> Can can I just add actually as it
- 45:56happens I'm going to a round table the
- 45:58we
- 45:59on methane methane and the future of
- 46:01insurability
- 46:02in in 20 minutes so 12:30. So we are
- 46:05engaged in it. Um I would only liken it
- 46:07and sorry this business of insurability.
- 46:10So this is organized by the University
- 46:11of Cambridge has a an insurance
- 46:13association called ClimateWise and
- 46:15they've developed a really good um paper
- 46:18in the last in the was published this
- 46:20year called and it's called the
- 46:21insurability readiness matrix and it's a
- 46:24tool in fact that basically takes you
- 46:25through how do you break down something
- 46:27that would otherwise be really difficult
- 46:29to ensure or where it looks like it's
- 46:31becoming it it you know for whether it's
- 46:33a natural disaster or whether it's it's
- 46:35you know a technology or whether it's uh
- 46:37you know sort of chemicals. How is it
- 46:39how how can we make sure that we can
- 46:41continue the role of insurance, right?
- 46:43So sort of so anyway Google um the
- 46:46insurability readiness matrix from
- 46:48ClimateWise which we are a backer at
- 46:50which we you know we are a member of as
- 46:52are others. The only thing I'd liken it
- 46:54to is we for example insured carbon
- 46:56capture and storage now that's super
- 46:58difficult okay so this is taking the
- 47:00emissions from two plants and the
- 47:02in in in the UK and it's sort of it's
- 47:05you what you're doing is ensure you're
- 47:06ensuring the capture of that and it's
- 47:08going into a saline aquifer under the
- 47:10sea so and then ensuring the the
- 47:12long-term containment risk of that for
- 47:1410 years so that's an example of
- 47:17something that wasn't even heard of you
- 47:18know three three or four years ago in
- 47:20terms of of of getting your head around
- 47:22the insurance of that that we even and a
- 47:24number of other
- 47:25insurers have done so let's try and
- 47:27solve is what I would say.
- 47:39>> Thank you.
- 47:40Any other questions for the panel?
- 47:46Here.
- 47:51>> Thank you very much I'm Vinnie I'm from
- 47:53the COP 32 presidency I'm supposed to
- 47:55make a closing statement but I couldn't
- 47:57wait to ask a question so
- 47:59it's it's about insurability and my
- 48:02question is
- 48:04sometimes people get worried about
- 48:06affording the insurance
- 48:09more than the risk of flood or the the
- 48:12climate impact
- 48:14particularly in in countries like where
- 48:16I come from where we don't not have
- 48:17mortgages and people have to pay
- 48:19outright to own their their house for
- 48:21example insurance is not something they
- 48:24consider so how do we
- 48:27see this from a from the public service
- 48:30perspective
- 48:32yes private sectors they have the
- 48:34profitability angle to to insurance for
- 48:37example they have to serve their
- 48:38shareholders how do we ensure that from
- 48:41adaptation perspective it serves the
- 48:43public.
- 48:46>> I think there are a number of examples
- 48:48of countries where that has worked so at
- 48:50the moment Thailand is buying two
- 48:52billion it's a very big limit two
- 48:53billion of insurance that is going to go
- 48:56directly to its uh to its households so
- 49:00and there's a sort of it's it's been
- 49:01from what I understand it's been
- 49:02structured pretty efficiently. So it's a
- 49:04sort of fixed amount if a flood it's
- 49:07coming flood, storm and I think one
- 49:09other
- 49:10peril, but basically it gives an amount
- 49:13of $10,000 something for for a a a
- 49:16specific uh for a certain certain if the
- 49:19event happens for almost unquestionably,
- 49:21right?
- 49:22And this has been being bought at
- 49:23government level. And then if it's a
- 49:25sort of more
- 49:26uh if it's a sort of bigger loss than
- 49:27that then they would take sort of longer
- 49:29to to do the usual process of adjusting
- 49:32for the loss. But it's a but it's it's
- 49:33been structured in such a way that that
- 49:35the money gets very quickly to the
- 49:37householders. But I think
- 49:39you know it has to be done that if often
- 49:41it has to be done at national level and
- 49:42it has to be done at at and and in terms
- 49:44of um sort of financing the premium to
- 49:47help get it going. But then I do think
- 49:49that in the long term it then has to
- 49:51become part of the economics of
- 49:54of of of the of of that country and and
- 49:56of the and of the people and the
- 49:58businesses as well. So it can be very
- 49:59difficult to get going and it needs some
- 50:02some you know some some support. But
- 50:04once it's got that it can then get
- 50:06going.
- 50:08>> And I'll just add
- 50:10that at a landscape level there are a
- 50:12number of different ways you can reduce
- 50:14the risk. And um if you take out a
- 50:16parametric insurance mechanism that
- 50:18actually looks at the risk reduction
- 50:20value of a wetland or of a forest um for
- 50:25that peril, then you can begin to make
- 50:27it much more affordable. So that's what
- 50:28we're finding with Mexico for example or
- 50:31with Hawaii where they have certain
- 50:33perils that are really hard to um
- 50:36finance. But governments are always the
- 50:39the providers of um ultimately the
- 50:41insurers because the uh anyone that
- 50:43doesn't have insurance ends up their
- 50:46their cost of disaster is held by the
- 50:48government. So actually creating
- 50:49parametric insurance mechanisms around
- 50:51the landscape gives the opportunity for
- 50:54de-risking the government's the um risk
- 50:57that they own, but also incentivizing a
- 51:00more risk reduction approach to that
- 51:02landscape.
- 51:03>> Just a quick comment from the finance
- 51:05side, finance sector side as well, is
- 51:07that we are increasingly working with
- 51:09insurance companies to figure out how we
- 51:11can collaborate on financial structures
- 51:14that embed an insurance product and the
- 51:16premium, the cost of the premium is
- 51:18considered as part of the package of the
- 51:20financing solution. We're also looking
- 51:22at how innovative structures that can
- 51:25leverage the capital markets to support
- 51:27the payment of insurance premiums. So
- 51:29we're working at the moment on a on a
- 51:31transaction that is related to helping
- 51:33humanitarian aid agencies cover the cost
- 51:36for a premium that would pay out in the
- 51:38event that draws on their funding were
- 51:40in excess of their planned expenditure
- 51:42as a result of an extreme weather event.
- 51:45So we are starting to collaborate across
- 51:48the financial sector to to address that
- 51:51specific issue.
- 51:54>> Thank you so much. Thanks for the
- 51:56answers. And
- 51:58this I know this is an event and it's a
- 52:00panel, but I'm going to treat it as a
- 52:02round table.
- 52:03If there are no more questions, I want
- 52:04to start calling people.
- 52:06But there's a question. I don't see the
- 52:08hands.
- 52:17>> Hi, good morning. My name is Emiliano.
- 52:19I'm from Zero Hunger Institute from
- 52:21Brazil. Nowadays we are working with our
- 52:23government to connect the social
- 52:25protection network
- 52:27to the insurance through this
- 52:30climate-related
- 52:31insurances. And we are willing to have
- 52:34the anticipatory social protection
- 52:36network.
- 52:37So would like to hear more from you
- 52:41about this challenge to convince the
- 52:43government to invest in the social side
- 52:46through insurances and therefore
- 52:49reducing the price for the insurance in
- 52:52the in the private market.
- 52:55So no one specifically, but
- 52:57thank you.
- 53:00>> I can have a first go. I guess I think
- 53:02part of the issue is that um the link
- 53:05between uh
- 53:07adaptation and resilience benefits and
- 53:10some of these broader uh societal
- 53:12outcomes has not yet being clearly
- 53:14drawn. And so for example in the
- 53:17resilient health space uh the challenge
- 53:19is the forward-looking potential cost
- 53:23that is based on the the changing
- 53:26disease profile that is going to arise
- 53:29as a result of different physical risk
- 53:31scenarios. Now that's a lot of uh
- 53:34sort of causal links that you need to
- 53:36get to before you can get to a a price
- 53:40and that is one of the or a cost and
- 53:42that's one of the potential issues.
- 53:44There's then a counterfactual of what
- 53:46the what the potential cost is if you
- 53:48don't invest in all of those things. So
- 53:50what is the cost of that disease burden
- 53:52to your economy from a worker
- 53:54productivity perspective for example.
- 53:57What we're trying to do at the moment is
- 53:59work with some of the insurance
- 54:01providers that provide health insurance
- 54:03cover to design a product that would
- 54:06address a specific health health need
- 54:09that is going to be forward projected
- 54:11based on the physical risks that exist
- 54:13in that in that specific location that
- 54:16can then be adopted by employers as part
- 54:18of their private worker health coverage.
- 54:21So I don't have a solution from the
- 54:23public sector side but from the private
- 54:25sector where there's that clear link to
- 54:27worker health and there's good evidence
- 54:30around healthier workers leading to
- 54:32higher productivity at an organisational
- 54:34level. Can we start to tie some of that
- 54:37into
- 54:38the forward-looking health issues that
- 54:39are going to arise as of results of
- 54:41these climatic shifts.
- 54:43>> Yeah I I I'd just add that the that's
- 54:45this forward-looking um
- 54:47cost of climate uh issues of of the
- 54:50climate impact on on a on an investment
- 54:53for the and and and you could speak from
- 54:55a public entity as well as from a
- 54:57private.
- 54:58That is now as you were described that's
- 55:00getting better understood. So this this
- 55:02sort of hazardous modelling that the
- 55:04insurance world does is now sort of
- 55:07finding its way into uh investment
- 55:09thesis.
- 55:10So and and there's quite a good New York
- 55:12climate week. The Broken Marsh and
- 55:14Carlyle group announced a pretty useful
- 55:17tool that actually is for everyone to
- 55:19use just it's called Marsh Carlyle
- 55:21investment resilience framework.
- 55:23And what that's doing is saying you know
- 55:25the way when when when the insurance
- 55:27world looks at risk it says okay there's
- 55:28a probable maximum loss of a very big
- 55:30number and there's a kind of medium term
- 55:33loss of an a smaller number and then
- 55:34there's you can average that out and
- 55:36arguably your sort of average amount is
- 55:39is kind of the the is is the cost and if
- 55:41you look at what the climate the future
- 55:43looking climate impact is that number is
- 55:45generally going up right? So if you so
- 55:47if you're expecting to make a 10% return
- 55:49on something actually it it might be
- 55:51that you're only going to be making 8%
- 55:53because of the resilience measures that
- 55:55you may have to bring in but if you if
- 55:57you build in adaptation if you build in
- 55:59so you can sort of the object of this
- 56:01tool is to be able to say okay if we put
- 56:03in the cost of adaptation then okay
- 56:05that's a small cost but that is actually
- 56:07saving us so we're sort of back up
- 56:08nearer to our 10% and whether you're a
- 56:10public or a private institution you
- 56:12could be using that and that doesn't to
- 56:14that that speaks to natural assets as
- 56:16well so I think you know it's a very
- 56:18poignant extremely well made that you
- 56:19know
- 56:20the the the the sort of cost and the
- 56:21benefits of doing things like protecting
- 56:24your coral reefs if you're a chain of
- 56:25hotels on the Mexican coast is really
- 56:28important and just lastly I would say
- 56:30that the insurance world is listening
- 56:31very hard to the concerns of extreme
- 56:34heat and how that's impacting
- 56:36particularly cities and countries and
- 56:38there is work being done on that so
- 56:40that's um something that we would sort
- 56:42of love to engage further with um with
- 56:45with cities on if if if if that's a sort
- 56:47of area of interest.
- 56:50>> Will
- 56:51and just to to build on that some more
- 56:53last year at COP 30
- 56:54uh Brazil was
- 56:56attempting to to lead in in how it
- 56:58overcame some of the barriers to EM
- 57:00investment that I alluded to earlier and
- 57:03eco invest I think is a very good
- 57:04example of taking that more systemic
- 57:07view about avoiding future losses uh
- 57:09because a lot us included, institutional
- 57:11investors were asking the Brazilian
- 57:13government, why are they willing to
- 57:15provide this currency facility because
- 57:18FX risk is a a major barrier to EM
- 57:20investment.
- 57:21Uh and what really impressed me was the
- 57:24the level of systemic thinking. So
- 57:26actually that if you are better able to
- 57:28invest in a resilient food supply chain
- 57:31domestically in in Brazil through
- 57:33nature, through other um adaptation
- 57:36measures,
- 57:37that should contribute to a more
- 57:38resilient food supply chain. That
- 57:41in turn contributes to price stability
- 57:43uh and in turn to currency stability. So
- 57:45actually for the government able to take
- 57:47a much broader systemic view,
- 57:50that's where that that's a perfect
- 57:51example of where blending can work
- 57:53really well because the public piece
- 57:54comes in uh to to take the the policy
- 57:57risk at the systemic level which
- 57:59investors struggle to take a bet on. And
- 58:01then the the private capital can come in
- 58:03and take the other risks about around
- 58:05development and and classic investment
- 58:07risks which we want to take because
- 58:08that's where we um attract our return.
- 58:13>> Thank you so much for that very
- 58:14comprehensive set of answers for that
- 58:16very complicated question as well. Uh
- 58:18Alisi, I'll give you the last uh the
- 58:21last question of the day.
- 58:23Um
- 58:25I can give you my phone my mic.
- 58:28Here.
- 58:30>> Thank you. Thank you. Very interesting
- 58:32panel. I want to come from a different
- 58:33perspective uh
- 58:35which is on communications because uh
- 58:38one of the challenges that we see we
- 58:40have faced uh throughout last year to to
- 58:43engage people on adaptation and and make
- 58:46it appealing was to explain what do we
- 58:48really mean by it? What do we need
- 58:50people to do? And talking about
- 58:52resilience and communication and and
- 58:54adaptation is usually seen as overly
- 58:57complex and not concrete.
- 58:59What would you be your one piece of
- 59:01advice to engage more private sector
- 59:04investors in terms of communication
- 59:07infrastructure that needs to exist?
- 59:10>> Brilliant question. Will.
- 59:12>> Sorry to jump in
- 59:13>> straight away. I have quite a short
- 59:15answer, which is
- 59:16engage investors in industry very
- 59:18closely in the national adaptation
- 59:20planning process
- 59:21with a specific focus on how to make
- 59:23that investable. And so create the the
- 59:26right fora
- 59:28that that has emerged for example on
- 59:29transition planning in other markets.
- 59:33Create the right fora to have that
- 59:34continuous dialogue
- 59:36to refer to the point earlier made about
- 59:38where different measures that are
- 59:39required fit in that pyramid.
- 59:42And then also to diagnose the specific
- 59:44solutions that we've spoken about today.
- 59:48That that won't apply in in absolutely
- 59:50every case and need need to be tailor
- 59:52made.
- 59:52>> You you just described Finity.
- 59:54That's what Finity is going to do. So
- 59:56thank you.
- 59:58Rachel.
- 1:00:00>> I I would just say don't get the
- 1:00:01insurance world as capital investors,
- 1:00:03right? And and their risk appetite that
- 1:00:05that that they can be extremely capital
- 1:00:08can clearly be helpful, but their risk
- 1:00:10appetite needs to be sort of judged
- 1:00:12and and needs to be targeted in that
- 1:00:13way. So I would just give
- 1:00:15an illustration of there's something
- 1:00:16called the Infrastructure Resilience
- 1:00:17Development Fund, which a number which
- 1:00:19was instigated and put together by the
- 1:00:21the the Insurance Development Forum that
- 1:00:23I mentioned earlier. It's being run by
- 1:00:25BlackRock. It's backed by half a dozen
- 1:00:27insurers, but it's been structured and
- 1:00:29and it's sorry, it's focused on emerging
- 1:00:30market infrastructure debt. And this,
- 1:00:33you know, this investment from a bunch
- 1:00:35of insurers who have to be pretty
- 1:00:36conservative in the way they invest
- 1:00:38wouldn't necessarily get to that to that
- 1:00:40type of investment otherwise. So this
- 1:00:42has been structured away the IFC, the
- 1:00:44World Bank's investment arm IFC does the
- 1:00:46sort of junior tranche and the insurers
- 1:00:48take on the senior tranche. And that's a
- 1:00:50way of allowing that capital to in a
- 1:00:52blended finance way to get to the the
- 1:00:55the infrastructure opportunities in in
- 1:00:57the emerging markets globally. It's it's
- 1:00:59it's targeting Latin America, Asia and
- 1:01:01Africa that it that it that it wouldn't
- 1:01:03otherwise get to.
- 1:01:05>> Claire, you have the last intervention
- 1:01:06before we move to COP 32. Thank you.
- 1:01:08>> Okay. Um so very quickly, I would just
- 1:01:10say really investing time in that
- 1:01:12communication piece for exactly the
- 1:01:14reasons that everyone's talking about.
- 1:01:16It takes real time to translate what is
- 1:01:19needed for the government to understand
- 1:01:21what they need to do, for the investors
- 1:01:23to understand what the opportunity is.
- 1:01:25And the water bond in South Africa is a
- 1:01:28really good example of that. I think it
- 1:01:29took two and a half years to to build
- 1:01:31the understanding across the different
- 1:01:33pieces around the KPIs that would work
- 1:01:35for the different actors to structure
- 1:01:37something that could really bring the
- 1:01:38finances needed.
- 1:01:41>> Thank you Uh
- 1:01:43Last word.
- 1:01:52>> Hello. Yes.
- 1:01:53Um
- 1:01:54I think I'd also like to add on the
- 1:01:56communication point that
- 1:01:58everything that I learned so much on
- 1:02:00this panel as well, and I think hearing
- 1:02:02more and more examples of the fact that
- 1:02:05the private sector does and can think
- 1:02:08about resilience and adaptation at at
- 1:02:10that systemic level
- 1:02:12is I think also a key part of the
- 1:02:14communication suite, you know, making
- 1:02:16the fact that it's being done more
- 1:02:18visible to catalyze the frequency at
- 1:02:22which it happens. I think that would be
- 1:02:23great.
- 1:02:24>> Thank you,
- 1:02:25And with that,
- 1:02:27I'll like to invite
- 1:02:29Thank you again.
- 1:02:31Round of applause for
- 1:02:33for the panelists. Thank you. Please
- 1:02:36if you want, now you are released
- 1:02:39to go back to your seats. And [snorts]
- 1:02:41I wanted to
- 1:02:43You want to do a picture at the end,
- 1:02:45better?
- 1:02:47Okay, because we're running out of time.
- 1:02:50We're going to be kicked out of this. I
- 1:02:52think already looking at me and
- 1:02:54[laughter]
- 1:02:56We'll we'll do it right after that.
- 1:02:58Right when we're done. We're we're just
- 1:02:59two minutes away.
- 1:03:01I wanted to invite
- 1:03:04for the Minister of Foreign Affairs of
- 1:03:05Ethiopia and
- 1:03:07Just wanted to mention that this is a
- 1:03:09unique event, not only because of the
- 1:03:11amazing topic that we discussed, but
- 1:03:13also because we have the Troika present
- 1:03:15here. COP 30, COP 31, COP 32. That is
- 1:03:18unique. Doesn't happen that often, so
- 1:03:19thank you.
- 1:03:21>> Thank you. Thank you very
- 1:03:25Can you hear me? Yes. Thank you very
- 1:03:26much for the invitation and very
- 1:03:29interesting panel. I was really
- 1:03:31interested in taking notes as well
- 1:03:34into the insights.
- 1:03:35Very briefly,
- 1:03:38we've heard about solutions. We've We've
- 1:03:39heard about risks. We've heard about
- 1:03:41insurance. We've heard about bankable
- 1:03:44projects.
- 1:03:46I think we really need to see adaptation
- 1:03:48finance as an ecosystem,
- 1:03:50as an ecosystem where the source of
- 1:03:53finance, different instruments,
- 1:03:54different institutions play distinct but
- 1:03:58complementary roles. So the question on
- 1:04:00how that works, I think the panel has
- 1:04:02given us certain ideas of how certain
- 1:04:05financial sources and instruments do
- 1:04:08work better. So
- 1:04:10how public and concessional finance can
- 1:04:12provide the foundation? How better data
- 1:04:15can help us understand risks? And how
- 1:04:18And where does the additional capital
- 1:04:21can genuinely complement public resource
- 1:04:24and expand the overall pool of climate
- 1:04:26finance
- 1:04:27has been a key priority for for the COP
- 1:04:3132 presidency as well. So our objective
- 1:04:34is to mobilize the scale and range of
- 1:04:36finance needed to deliver country
- 1:04:38adaptation priorities. So as we talk
- 1:04:41about translating adaptation plans and
- 1:04:44into investments and action, it's really
- 1:04:46important to understand that the
- 1:04:48foundation for us is international grant
- 1:04:50finance becomes quite central. The
- 1:04:52commitments and responsibilities under
- 1:04:54the UNFCCC and the Paris Agreement
- 1:04:56remain clear,
- 1:04:58and they need to be delivered.
- 1:05:00There There There are innovation
- 1:05:03innovative sources around that ecosystem
- 1:05:06that are also complementary and are not
- 1:05:08competing or replacements of. So I think
- 1:05:12we really need to move away from that
- 1:05:14competing narrative to a
- 1:05:16complementarity narrative. Seeing the
- 1:05:19conversation about the premiums. Um it's
- 1:05:21really uh if it's going to be up to
- 1:05:24governments to meet those demands, of
- 1:05:26course, then there needs to be support
- 1:05:30for developing countries in line with
- 1:05:32the principles of the convention and the
- 1:05:34Paris Agreement. So we also need to be
- 1:05:36very realistic of the finance that's
- 1:05:38available, of what can be sourced, and
- 1:05:40in terms of time because sometimes the
- 1:05:44time we take to mobilize those resources
- 1:05:46really take away the time that we need
- 1:05:49to adapt from. And by the day as as
- 1:05:52we're talking about overshoot, uh we're
- 1:05:56putting our community into an even more
- 1:05:58risk
- 1:05:59uh and at a higher cost of meeting their
- 1:06:02adaptive capacity. So to make it very
- 1:06:04brief, um
- 1:06:07what we see in the road to Addis is we
- 1:06:10would like to see all these
- 1:06:11complementary financings enhanced,
- 1:06:14better understood, and better mobilized
- 1:06:17so that we can meet the needs and
- 1:06:19priorities of the communities. So as we
- 1:06:22convene um in the road from Antalya to
- 1:06:26to Addis, we would like this
- 1:06:27conversation on what role does the
- 1:06:29public and concessional finance play?
- 1:06:32Who carries risks? Where who covers the
- 1:06:35cost?
- 1:06:36Can successful approaches move beyond
- 1:06:38pilots? Can they be replicated and
- 1:06:40scaled? These are the conversations we
- 1:06:43would like to be enhanced. And there
- 1:06:44were some interesting points around
- 1:06:47investments, MDBs being pulled into
- 1:06:49conversation on national adaptation plan
- 1:06:51priorities. I think that's a very
- 1:06:53critical point. They need to go hand in
- 1:06:56hand in conversations as governments put
- 1:06:58in their policy.
- 1:07:00We and finally I would like to uh
- 1:07:02invite you all to Addis. Uh we have a
- 1:07:05pavilion to show you the coffee that we
- 1:07:07are going to have, but to get the real
- 1:07:10thing, please come to Addis. Thank you
- 1:07:11very much.
- 1:07:14>> [applause]
- 1:07:20>> Can I invite the panelists if you don't
- 1:07:21mind at all that you're running around
- 1:07:23uh a new project you're going somewhere
- 1:07:24else Vanish if you'll mind also to join
- 1:07:27Yamit uh
- 1:07:29and can we have
- 1:07:30and TNC also uh
- 1:07:33the two
- 1:07:35please Lara so we have a little bit room
- 1:07:37>> Yeah
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Solution & Delivery AG 20. From Adaptation Plans to Investment in Action by UNFCCC Global Climate Action, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 9,862 words across 1,618 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.